design being resolved upon he necessarily chuses those general ways which are most worthy of his wisdom greatness and goodness for since he does not resolve upon any thing but by the knowledge he has of the ways of executing it the choice of the design contains the choice of the ways L. When I say that God freely forms his design I do not mean as if he cou'd chuse another which is less and reject that which is more worthy of his wisdom for supposing that God will make any outward work worthy of himself he is not indifferent in his choice he must produce that which is the most perfect in respect of the simplicity of the ways by which he acts he owes this to himself to follow the rules of his wisdom he must always act after the most wise and perfect manner But I say God freely takes up his resolution because he invincibly and necessarily loves nothing but his own substance Neither the Incarnation of the Word much less the Creation of the World are necessary Emanations of his Nature God is altogether sufficient to himself For a Being infinitely perfect may be conceiv'd alone without having a necessary relation to his Creatures LI. Since God necessarily loves himself he also necessarily follows the Rules of his Wisdom But seeing the Creatures make no part of his Being he is so self-sufficient as that nothing can oblige him to produce them he is very indifferent or free in respect of them And it is upon this account that he made the World in time for this circumstance makes it evident that the Creatures are not necessary Emanations of the Divinity but do essentially depend upon the Free-will of a Creator LII Nevertheless behold an Objection which at first does surprize the mind If it be true That God necessary follows the Rules of his Wisdom the World wou'd not have been created in time For either the World is worthy or unworthy of God If it was better the World shou'd have been brought out of nothing it ought to have been eternal if better it shou'd have remain'd in nothing it ought not to have been made at all God therefore is not obliged to follow the Rules this Wisdom prescribes seeing the World was created in time But the Answer to this Objection is not difficult It is better the World shou'd be than not but it is better it shou'd not have been at all than be eternal The Creature must carry in it the essential mark of its dependance If Spirits had been eternal they might have had some reason to have look'd upon themselves as Gods or necessary Beings or at least capable to contribute something to the greatness and happiness of God imagining that he cou'd not but have made them they might likewise in some sort have compar'd themselves to the Divine Persons thinking they were like them produc'd by a necessary emanation Thus God was oblig'd according to the Rules of his Wisdom to leave unto the Creatures the character of their dependance assuring them nevertheless that he has not made them to annihilate them and that being constant to his designs as his infinite Wisdom requires they shall subsist eternally LIII This Difficulty may be further urg'd after this manner God necessarily follows the Rules of his Wisdom he necessarily does what is the best Now it was better at least that the World shou'd have been created in time than that it shou'd not have been created at all Certainly it was expedient according to the Rules of Divine Wisdom that the World shou'd have been produced with those circumstances according to which God had made it Therefore the Creation of the World in time is absolutely necessary God is not at all free in this respect he cou'd not but have made it To resolve this Difficulty it ought to be observed That tho' God follows the Rules which his Wisdom prescribes unto him yet he doth not necessarily do that which is best because he might do nothing To act and not exactly to follow the Rules of Wisdom is a defect Thus supposing that God will act he necessarily acts after the wifest manner that can be But to be free in the production of the World is a mark of abundance of fulness and self-sufficiency It is better the World shou'd be than not be the Incarnation of J. C. renders the Work of God worthy of its Author This I grant But seeing God is essentially happy and perfect seeing nothing but himself can be good in relation unto him or the cause of his perfection and happiness he invinsibly loves only his own substance and all that is without him must indeed be made by an eternal and immutable action but which has no other necessity but upon supposition of the Divine Decrees See yet another Principle of which I have already spoken which may give some light to the Difficulties which may be made about the Circumstances of the Incarnation of J. C. and the Creation of the World LIV. Reason and the Authority of the H. Books teach us that the first and principal of God's Designs is the Establishment of his Church in J. C. The present World is not created to continue such as it is The Lies and Errours the Unrighteousness and Disorders which we see sufficiently shew it must have an end The future World where Truth and Righteousness inhabit is that Land whose Foundations cannot be shaken and which being the external Object of the Divine Love shall subsist eternally God has not created this visible World but by little and little to form thereof that invisible City of which S. John tells us so many Wonders And seeing J. C. shall be the chief Beauty thereof God always has had J. C. in view in the production of his Work He hath made all for Man and with respect to Man Heb. ch II. as the Scripture teacheth us but this Man for whom God has made all is according to S. Paul J. C. 'T is to teach Men that they are created that they do not subsist but in J. C. 't is to bind them closely to J. C. 't is to engage them to become like unto him that God has represented J. C. and his Church in the chiefest of his Creatures For it was necessary God shou'd find J. C. in all his Work that this Work might be the object of his Love and worthy of the Action by which it is produc'd LV. If the manner after which the H. Scripture relates the Creation of the first Man be considered how his Wife was form'd of his Flesh and Bone the Love he had for her and even the Circumstances of their Sin it will doubtless be granted that God thought of the second Adam when he made the first that he considered the Father of the World to come when he created the Father of the present and that he intended to make the first Man and the first Woman express Figures of J. C. and his Church S. Paul
infinite Wisdom of its Author Additions I use the example of the irregularity of ordinary rain to prepare the mind for another rain which is not given to the merits of men no more than the common rain which falls equally upon Lands that are Sown as well as those that lie Fallow I suppose it to be easily comprehended that it is because the rain falls in consequence of natural Laws that it is so ill distributed in relation to the necessities of the Earth But I think I ought to advise that they who don 't distinctly remember the proofs which I have given in the Search after Truth that it is God who does all that he does not communicate his power unto Creatures but by making them the occasional causes of determining the efficacity of the general Laws by which he executes his designs in a way worthy of him I think I say I ought to advise these persons to read and meditate upon at least the first explication which is at the end of the third discourse for to do it well recourse ought to be had to those places wherein I demonstrate my Principles XV. In truth I am perswaded that the Laws of motion necessary to the production and conservation of the EARTH and of all the STARS in the HEAVENS are reduced to these two The first that Bodies in motion endeavour to continue their motion in a right Line The second that when two Bodies meet one another their motion is distributed from one to another proportionably to their bulk so that afterwards they may be mov'd with an equal celerity These two Laws are the cause of all the motions which make that variety of form which we admire in nature XVI I confess nevertheless Search after Truth in the last C. of Method that the second does not always seem to be observ'd in the experiments which may be made upon this subject but this is because we see only that which happens to Bodies that are visible and that we think not at all upon the Invisible that surround them which by the efficacy of the same Law make the spring of visible Bodies thereby obliging them to recoil and not observe this same Law I must not in this place explain this any further XVII Now these two Laws are so simple so natural and at the same time so fruitful that tho there were no other reasons to judge that nature observes them yet we should have cause to believe that they are appointed by him who always acts by the most simple wayes in whose Action there is nothing irregular and who proportions it so wisely with his Work that he does infinite marvels by a very few Practical Resolutions Additions It would require a whole Book to prove that which I say here concerning the fruitfulness of these two general laws of the communication of motion It will be easily seen that I speak not at all adventures by those who are exactly well acquainted with the Physical principles of Mon. des Cartes But this is not essential to my subject It is sufficient that the Laws of Nature are general These three Articles may be looked upon as a kind of parenthesis XVIII We must not judge of the general cause as of particulars of the Infinite Wisdom as of limited understandings God foreseeing all that should follow the natural Laws even before their establishment could not have established them to overturn them The Laws of Nature are constant and Immutable they are general for all times and all places Two Bodies of such a magnitude and such a swiftness striking upon one another will be reflected after the same manner now as heretofore If the rain falls upon certain grounds and the Sun burns up others if a season favourable to the Fruits of the Earth be succeeded by a Prost which destroys them if a Child comes into the world with a monstrous and useless head which grows out of his breast and makes him miserable it is not because God intended to produce these effects by particular wills but because he has established the Laws of the communication of motions of which these effects are necessary consequences Laws otherwise so simple and withal so fruitful that they produce all that we see beautiful in the world and in a little time repair the greatest Mortality and Dearth XIX He that having built an house and then undermines the Foundation discovers his ignorance he that plants a Vineyard and immediately pulls up that which had taken root shews his folly Because he that wills and wills not wants either understanding or constancy of mind But it can't be said that God acts either by caprice or thro' Ignorance when an Infant comes into the world with superfluous members which hinder him from living or when an Hail-Storm destroys the Fruit almost ripe Thus if God makes the Fruit to fall by a Storm before it is ripe it is not because he wills and wills not For God acts not by particular wills as particular causes do He has not established the Laws of communication of motions with a design to produce Monsters or to make the Fruits Fall before they be ripe he appointed these Laws by reason of their Foecundity and not their Barrenness Thus that which once he willed he wills still and in general the world for which he made these Laws shall subsist eternally Additions I have not here proved a Posteriori or by the effects that the general cause acts by general Wills or Laws whose efficacy is determined by the action of occasional or particular causes tho' these sorts of proofs are very many and undeniable 1. Because I supposed in the Advertisement to the Reader that he had read what I have written against the pretended efficacy of second causes 2. Because none can want these sort of proofs for every one knows that a body is never mov'd before it be struck and that it is never stricken without being mov'd Every one knows it is day when the Sun is risen and that it is night when it is set and that thus God produces the motion and the light in consequence of the general laws of nature 3. To conclude because the proofs a priorit taken from the nature of the cause tho more abstracted appear to me clearer stronger and more proper to the subject I Treat of For if I had not proved only by the effects that God does all that we see in nature by simple general uniform and constant ways it might be answered 'T is true but in grace he does quite otherwise he there does all by particular wills Whereas having proved by the Idea of a Being infinitely perfect that he does all that we see by simple ways since God does not bely himself this proves that he does by the like wayes all that we do not see Thus men begin to reflect that God must act after such a manner as comports with his Divine Attributes Nevertheless at the end of this first Discourse
A Treatise OF NATURE AND GRACE To which is Added The AUTHOR's Idaea of Providence AND His Answers to several Objections against the foregoing Discourse By the Author of The Search after Truth Translated from the Last Edition Enlarged by many Explications LONDON Printed and are to be Sold by John Whitlock near Stationers Hall 1695. MVNIFICENTIA REGIA 1715. GEORGIVâ— D.G. MAâ— BRâ—â—ET HI◠〈◊〉 F.D. Advertisement I Intreat those into whose hands this writing shall fall to believe that I chiefly undertook it to satisfie the difficulties of some Philosophers who had not as I thought all those Sentiments which Religion teaches to have of Gods goodness and were not sufficiently acquainted with the obligations which we have to Jesus Christ I desire it may be lookt upon only as an Essay that none will judge of it before they have examined it without prejudice and that they will not suffer themselves to be surprized by those motions of fear and suspition which every thing which seems to be new is apt naturally to excite in us Seeing I wrote for such Philosophers as pretend to be very just and exact in their Reasonings I was obliged to avoid those general terms which are ordinarily used for I could not content them but by using such terms as raise in their minds distinct and particular Ideas as far as the subject will permit it I presume that all Candid Readers will judge that I have no other design but to prove all ways possible those truths which Faith teaches and that I am not so rash as to doubt of that which is look't upon as certain in the Church and which Religion obliges us to believe But it has always been allowed to give new proofs of old truths to represent God Amiable to Men and to make it plain that there is nothing hard or unjust in the order which he observes for the establishment of his Church This Work is divided into Three Discourses In the First I represent God as doing all the good to his Creatures which his Wisdom permits In the Second I shew how the Son of God as incarnate Wisdom and Head of the Church communicates to his Members those Graces which he could not grant unto them as Eternal Wisdom And thus I do endeavour to represent the obligations and relations which we have to Jesus Christ Lastly In the Third I explain what is Liberty and how Grace acts in us without hurting it Seeing there are some Persons of so little Candour as to draw invidious Consequences even from Principles the most advantageous to Religion I beg that I may not be condemned upon their word and that before I be Judged Men will do me so much Justice as to understand me Certainly I ought not to be necessitated to make this request A TABLE OF The Treatise of Nature and Grace The First Discourse OF the Necessity of the General Laws of Nature and Grace Part I. Of the Necessity of the General Laws of Nature pag. 1. Part II. Of the Necessity of the General Laws of Grace p. 32. The Second Discourse Of the Laws of Grace in particular and of the occasional causes which govern and determine their efficacy Part I. Of the Grace of Jesus Christ. p. 63. Part II. Of the Grace of the Creator p. 101. The Third Discourse Of Grace and the manner by which it acts in us Part I. Of Liberty p. 123. Part II. Of Grace p. 140. The First Explication What it is to act by General Wills and what by Particular p. 160. Marks by which it may be judged whether an effect is produced by a General or by a Particular Will p. 162 163. Objection 1. and Answer p. 173. Object 2. and Answer p. 178 179. The Second Explication Where 't is proved that J. C. is figured every where in the Scriptures and that even by the events which were before the Sin of the first Man to teach us that the principal of God's Designs is the Incarnation of his Son p. 190. The Third Explication Where 't is proved that the chief of Gods Designs is J. C. and his Church and that God truly loves Men that he sincerely desires to save all that his Conduct is worthy of his Wisdom Goodness Immutability and other Attributes What is the order of the decrees which contain the Predestination of Saints p. 197. Object and Answer p. 206 207. The Last Explication The frequent Miracles of the Old Law do by no means shew that God often acted by particular Wills p. 217. The Author's Idea of Providence p. 228. Objections against the foregoing discourse with the Author's Answers Objection 1. and Answer p. 238. Object 2. and Ans p. 242. Object 3. and Ans p. 246 247. Object 4. and Ans p. 255 256. Object 5. and Ans p. 263 264. Object 6. and Ans p. 269 270. Object 7. and Ans p. 275. Object 8. and Ans p. 278 279. CORRECTIONS Page Line  5 4 AFter image ad of ib. 7 For there Lege their 10 13 For creation L. Incarnation 14 12 After absit add the Period stop 16 7 For capit L. cupit 17 28 For they L. men 23 17 For form L. forms 26 15 Dele not 33 26 For principle L. principal 38 10 The Comma after it 43 3 D. to after obliges 45 31 For all those L. any ib. 18 After proceedings this Punctation 81 13 D. of after think 85 19 After wisdom a Comma 87 11 For real manner L. sure way 89 23 D. the before order 93 33 After God add they 95 4 L. men's for men ib. ult L. efface for effuse 97 4 L. motions for motion 104 32 L. speak for speaking 106 ult After and add another 108 16 17 For God is just and would by a particular c. ib.  L. this Man is just God would by a particular c. 131 ult For whilst we love L. when we enjoy c. 134 4 After carries add him 138 6 For unusual L. unuseful 143 20 21 For pleasures L. pleasures 153 3 4 After and add it After sweetness and desolation this Punctation ib. 5  158 10 After besides add that ib. 12 After infinite only a Comma 162 19 Only a Comma after others For but L. that ib. 20 This Punctation after them 192 16 For but L. that 202 28 D. not 215 6 For pravisiones L. praevisione ib. 16 After fidei add regula In the Margin instead of Cap. 23. L. c. 13. 223 22 For Manada L. Mandata The First Discourse Of the Necessity of the General Laws of Nature and Grace First Part. The Necessity of the General Laws of Nature Advertisement I Think I ought to Advertise That they who are well acquainted with the Principle which I have proved in the Search after Truth and elsewhere need not to read the following Additions nor even the Explications which are at the end of this Treatise without which my Meaning may be very well understood But they may perhaps be usefull unto
may be inferred from these Truths XLV It must be observed that J. C. who alone is the meritorious cause of the good things which God gives us according to the order of Nature is sometimes the occasional cause of knowledge as well as of sentiment Nevertheless I believe that this is very rare because in truth it is not necessary J. C. as much as is possible makes Nature serve Grace For besides that Reason teaches us that order requires this as being the most simple way this sufficiently appears by his management upon Earth and by that order which he has founded and still preserves in his Church J. C. made use of preaching the Word for to enlighten the World and sent forth his Disciples two by two to prepare the people to receive him Luke X. 1. Eph. IV. 12. 12. He hath appointed Apostles Prophets Evangelists Doctours Bishops Priests for the Edification of the Church Is not this to make Nature serviceable to Grace and to communicate the knowledge of Faith to the minds of Men by the most simple and natural ways In truth it did not become J. C. upon Earth to enlighten Men by particular wills since he might instruct them as inward Truth and eternal Wisdom by the most simple and most fruitful Laws of Nature XLVI That which seems most dark in the order which God hath observed in founding his Church is doubtless the times the place and other circumstances of the Incarnation of his Son and the preaching of the Gospel For why should J. C. for whom the world was created be made man 4000. years after its creation Why should he be born among the Jews who was to reprove this miserable Nation Why chosen to be the Son of David when the House of David was fall'n from its Glory and not the Son of any of the Emperours who commanded all the Earth since he came to convert and enlighten all the World Why did he chuse low mean and ignorant persons for his Apostles and Disciples Preach to the Inhabitants of Bethsaida and Corazin who were resolved to continue in their incredulity and pass by Tyre and Zidon who would have been converted if they had had the same favour Hinder St. Paul from Preaching the word of God in Asia and command him to pass into Macedonia These and a thousand other circumstances which attended the preaching of the Gospel doubtless are Mysteries whereof 't is not possible to give clear and evident reasons neither is this my design I would only lay down some principles which may give some light to these and such like difficulties or at least make it appear that from them nothing can be concluded against what I have hitherto said concerning the Order of Nature and of Grace XLVII It is certain that natural effects are combined and mixed after infinite ways with the effects of Grace And that the order of Nature encreases or lessens the efficacy of the effects of the order of Grace according to the different manners by which these two orders are mixed one with another The Death which according to the general Laws of Nature sometimes happens to a good or evil Prince to a good or an evil Bishop causes a great deal of good or evil to the Church because such like accidents make great change in the consequence of effects which depend upon the order of Grace Now God would save all men by the most simple ways Therefore it may and it ought to be said in general that he hath chosen the times the place the manners which in succession of time and according to the general Laws of Nature and Grace will caeteris paribus cause the greatest number of the Predestinated to enter into the Church God does all for his Glory Therefore amongst all the possible combinations of Nature with Grace he by the infinite extension of his knowledge has chosen that which must make the Church most perfect and most worthy of his Majesty and Wisdom XLVIII It seems to me this already suffices to answer all difficulties relating to the circumstances of our Mysteries For if it be said that J. C. ought to have been born of a Roman Emperour and have wrought Miracles in the Capital City of the World that so the Gospel might have been more easily spread in the farthest distant Countries to this it may be answered boldly that whatsoever men think thereof this combination of Nature with Grace would not have been so worthy of the Wisdom of God as that which he hath chosen I grant that Religion would thus at first have been spread with more ease but its establishment would not have been so divine and so extraordinary and consequently not such an invincible proof of its solidity and certainty Thus according to this combination Religion perhaps would have been at present either destroyed or less spread in the World Moreover when it is said that God acts by the most simple ways an equality is always supposed in all things else especially in the glory which must redound to God by his Work Now the Church would not have been so perfect nor so worthy of the greatness and holiness of God if it had been form'd with so much ease For the Beauty of the Heavenly Jerusalem consisting in the different rewards due to the different combate of Christians it was expedient that the Martyrs should shed their Blood as well as J. C. to enter into the glory which they possess In a word this principle that amongst all the infinite combinations of the orders of Nature and Grace God has chosen that which would produce an effect most worthy of his Majesty and Wisdom is sufficient in general to answer all the difficulties which may be made concerning the circumstances of our Mysteries In like manner to justify the orders of Nature and Grace in themselves it s enough to know that God being infinitely Wise he does not form his designs but upon the admirable relation of Wisdom and fruitfulness which he sees in the ways capable to execute them as I have already shewn in the first Discourse XLIX Since the generality of men judge of God by themselves they imagine that he first resolves upon a design and afterwards consults his Wisdom how to bring it to effect for our wills every moment go before our reason so that our designs are scarce ever perfectly reasonable For God does not act as Men do Behold how he acts if I have well consulted the idea of an infinitely perfect being God by the infinite knowledge of his wisdom and in the same wisdom sees all possible works and at the same time all ways of producing each of them He sees all the relation of the means to their ends he compares all things by an eternal immutable necessary foresight and by the comparison which he makes of relations of the wisdom and fruitfulness which he discovers betwixt his designs and the ways of executing them he freely forms the design But the
suffers us not to doubt of this truth when he assures us that we are made of the Bone and Flesh of J. C. and that we are his Members and that the Marriage of Adam and Eve was the Figure of J. C. and his Church LVI God might have form'd Men and Animals by ways as simple as the ordinary Generation is But seeing this way figured J. C. and his Church since it bore the Character of the Chief of God's Designs since it represented as I may say the well-beloved Son of his Father that Son by whom the whole Creation subsists God was obliged to prefer it before all others whereby to teach us that as intelligible Beauties consist only in the relation they have to eternal Wisdom so sensible Beauties must in some manner much unknown to us have some relation to the Truth incarnate LVII Doubtless there are many relations between the principal Creatures and J. C. who is their model and end For all is full of J. C. all expresses and figures him as far as the simplicity of the Laws of Nature will permit them but I dare not enter into the particulars of this For besides that I am afraid of deceiving my self and that I don 't sufficiently know either Nature or Grace the present or the future World to discover the relations thereof I am sensible that Mens Imaginations are so witty and delicate that one cannot by Reason lead them to God much less to J. C. without tyring them and exciting their railery The greatest part of Christians are accustom'd to a Philosophy which rather loves to shelter its self in fictions as extravagant as those of the Poets than have recourse to God and some are so little acquainted with J. C. that a Man shou'd pass with them for a visionary if he shou'd say the same things with S. Paul and not quote his words For 't is rather this great Name than the Sight of the Truth which engages them The Authority of the Scripture hinders them from blaspheming against that which they are ignorant of but seeing they think but little of it they can't thereby be much enlightned LVIII It is certain the Jews were a figure of the Church and the most holy and famous amongst the Kings Prophets and Patriarchs of this People did represent the true Messias our Saviour J. C. This truth can't be denied without undermining the Foundations of Christian Religion and making the most learned of the Apostles pass for the most ignorant of Men. J. C. not being yet come it was necessary he shou'd at least be prefigured He ought to be expected he ought to be desired he ought to disperse by his Figures some sort of Beauty in the World to make it pleasing to his Father Thus it was necessary he shou'd have been in some sense as ancient as the World it was necessary he shou'd die presently after Sin in the person of Abel Agnus occisus ab origine Mundi principium finis Alpha Omega heri hodie est erat venturus est These are the Qualifications which S. John gives to the Saviour of Men. LIX Now supposing that J. C. ought to be presigured it was expedient he shou'd chiefly be so by his Ancestors and that their History dictated by the H. Spirit shou'd in all times be preserv'd to the end that J. C. may still be compar'd with his Figures and acknowledg'd as the true Messias Of all the Nations of the Earth God loving that best which had most relation with his Son the Jews were to have been the Ancestors of J. C. according to the flesh and to have received this favour of God since they were the most lively and most express Representations of his Son LX. But if this Difficulty be further urg'd so as to demand a reason of the choice which God made of the Jews to be the principal Figures of J. C. I think I may and ought to affirm first That God always acting by the most simple ways and discovering in the infinite Treasures of his Wisdom all the possible Combinations of Nature with Grace chose that which wou'd make the Church most ample most perfect and most worthy of his Majesty and Holiness as I have already said In the second place I think I ought to answer That God foreseeing what wou'd happen to the Jews by a necessary consequence of natural Laws had more relation to the design which he had of representing J. C. and his Church than any thing which cou'd happen to any other Nation it was expedient that he shou'd chuse this People rather than any other For in conclusion the predestination to the Law is not like the predestination to Grace and tho' there is nothing in Nature which may oblige God to dispense his Grace equally to all People it seems to me that Nature might merit the Law in the sence wherein I here understand it LXI It is true that all that happen'd to the Jews who represented J. C. was not a necessary consequence of the order of Nature Miracles were necessary to render them the lively and express Images of the Church but Nature must have furnish'd the Fund and the Matter and perhaps the principal Stroaks in several things Miracles finish'd the rest But no other Nation wou'd have been so proper for so just and high a Design LXII It appears to me that we are oblig'd to think that God's Wisdom foreseeing all the Consequences of all the possible Orders and all their Combinations never works Miracles when Nature suffices and that thus he was oblig'd to chuse the Combination of Natural Effects which saving him as I may say the expence of Miracles might nevertheless very faithfully execute his Intentions For example 'T is necessary that all Sins shou'd be punish'd but not always in this World Supposing nevertheless that it was expedient for the glory of J. C. and the establishment of Religion that the Jews shou'd be punish'd in the face of the whole Earth for putting to death the Saviour of the World it was convenient that J. C. came into the World towards the end of Herod's Reign supposing that according to the necessary consequence of the Order of Nature that People shou'd be divided amongst themselves about that time that Civil Wars and continual Seditions shou'd weaken them and that lastly the Romans shou'd destroy and scatter them abroad after the total destruction of their City and Temple It is true there seems to have been something extraordinary in the desolation of the Jews But since it argues more Wisdom in God to produce such surprising Effects by the most simple and general Laws of Nature than by particular Wills I know not whether on this occasion we ought to have recourse to a Miracle For my part I don't dispute of it here this is a thing which is not easie nor indeed very necessary to be cleared I give this Example for to make some application of my Principles and to make them the
distributes to his Members those Graces which by his sacrifice he hath merited for his Church For my part I cannot comprehend how any one can doubt of these Reasons nor upon what foundation a Truth so very edifying and as ancient as the Religion of J. C. can be treated as a dangerous Novelty I grant my Expressions may be new but this is because they appear'd to me very proper distinctly to explain a truth which I could only have confusedly demonstrated by too general terms The words Occasional Causes and General Laws appear to me necessary to make those Philosophers for whom I wrote the Treatise of Nature and Grace distinctly comprehend that which the generality of Men are content to know only confusedly Since new Expressions are not dangerous but when they cover something which is equivocal or may occasion some thought contrary to Religion to arise in the mind I do not think that any candid persons and who are skill'd in St. Paul's Divinity will be offended because I explain my self after a particular manner since it tends only to make us adore the Wisdom of God and to unite us strictly unto J. C. Objection I. XIII It is objected against what I have said That neither Angels nor Saints of the Old Testament received Grace in consequence of the desires of the Soul of Jesus since this Holy Soul was not as yet and thus tho J. C. be the meritorious cause of all Graces he is not the occasional which distributes them to Men. Answer In respect of Angels I answer That there is some probability that Grace was given to them once only So that if we consider things in this respect I confess that nothing oblig'd the Wisdom of God to establish an occasional cause for the sanctification of Angels But if these blessed Spirits be considered as Members of the Body whereof J. C. is Head or if it be supposed that they were unequally assisted I believe there is reason to think that the diversity of their Graces came from him who-is Head of Angels as well as Men and that in this capacity he by his sacrifice not only merited all Graces which God gave to his Creatures but also diversly applied these same Graces to them by his different desires Since it cannot be denied that J. C. along time before he was born or could merit was the meritorious cause of Graces which were given to the Angels and Saints of the Old Testament it must in my opinion be granted that by his Prayers he might have been the occasional cause of the same Graces a long time before they were ask'd For there is no necessary relation between occasional causes and the time of their producing their effects and tho ordinarily these sorts of causes do produce their effects at the very time of their action nevertheless since their action is not efficacious in its self seeing its efficacy depends upon the will of the universal cause it is not necessary that it should actually exist that they may produce their effects Suppose for example That J. C. to day asks of his Father that such an one may receive such an assistance at certain times of his life the Prayer of J. C. will infallibly determine the efficacy of the general Will of God which is to save all Men in his Son This person shall receive these assistances tho the Soul of J. C. actually thinks of quite another thing and tho it should never more think of that which it desired for him Now the Prayer of J. C. which is already pass'd is not more present to his Father than the future for whatsoever happens in all times is equally present to God Thus since God loves his Son and knows that his Son will have such desires in respect of his Ancestors and the People of his own Nation and also in respect of Angels who were to enter into the Spiritual Edifice of his Church and compose the Body of which he is the Head he seems to have been obliged to accomplish the desires of his Son before they were made to the end that the Elect who were before his birth and whom he purchased by the merit of his sacrifice should as particularly belong to him as others and he should be their Head as truly as he is ours I confess it is convenient that meritorious and occasional causes should go before their effects rather than follow them and even order its self requires that these causes and their effects do exist at the same time For 't is clear that all merit should be presently rewarded and that every occasional cause should actually produce its effect provided that nothing hinder but that this may and ought to be so But since Grace was absolutely necessary to the Angels and to the Patriarchs it could not be differ'd As for the Glory and Reward of the Saints of the Old Testament seeing it might be delay'd it was expedient that God should suspend its accomplishment till J. C. was ascended into Heaven and made an High-Priest over the House of God and began to use the soveraign power of an occasional cause of all Graces which he had merited by his Labours upon Earth Thus we believe that the Patriarchs did not enter into Heaven till J. C. himself their Head their Mediator and their Fore-runner was therein entred Nevertheless tho it should be granted that God should not have appointed an occasional cause for all Graces given to the Angels and the Patriarchs I do not see how it can be concluded that at present J. C. does not dispense to the Body of the Church that Spirit which gives it increase and nourishment that he prays not for it or that his Desires or Prayers do not infallibly obtain their effect or in a word that he is not the occasional cause which applies those Graces to to Men which he has merited for them Before J. C. God gave Grace by particular Wills This I grant if it be desired the necessity of Order requires it the occasional Cause could not regularly be so soon establish'd the Elect were but very few But at present when the rain of Grace is generally sent upon all the World when it falls not as heretofore upon a very few Men of one chosen Nation when J. C. may or ought to be establish'd the occasional cause of the goods which he has merited for his Church what reason is there to believe that God should still work Miracles as often as he gives good Sentiments For certainly all that God does by particular Wills is a Miracle since it happens not by the general Laws which he has established and whose efficacy is determin'd by occasional causes But how can we think that to save Men he should work all those Miracles which are useless to their salvation I mean that he should give all those Graces which they resist because they are not proportioned to the actual strength of their concupiscence St. John teaches us that Christians receive
of J. C. John 1.17 abundant Graces because says he the Law was given by Moses but true Grace by Jesus Christ. For in truth the Graces which were before J. C. ought not to be compared to those which he distributed after his triumph If they were miraculous it must be thought they were very rare Even the Grace of the Apostles before the Holy Spirit was given to them was not to be compared with those which they received when the Soveraign Priest of good things to come being entred by his Blood into the Holy of Holies by the strength of his Prayers obtain'd and by the dignity of his Person sent the Holy Spirit to animate and sanctifie his Church The strange Blindness of the Jews their gross and carnal Sentiments their frequent relapses into Idolatry after so many Miracles do sufficiently shew they had scarce any love for true goods and the fearfulness of the Apostles before they received the Holy Spirit is a sensible mark of their weakness Thus Grace in this time was very rare because as yet our Nature was not made in J. C. the occasional cause of our Graces as yet J. C. was not fully consecrated a Priest according to the Order of Melchisedech and his Father had not yet given him that immortal and glorious Life Heb. 5.5 10. Heb. 7.16 17. which is the particular character of his Priesthood For it was necessary that J. C. should enter into the Heavens and receive the glory and power of being the occasional cause of all goods before he sent the Spirit according to the words of St. John John 7.39 John 16.7 The Spirit was not yet given because J. C. was not yet glorified And according to these words of Christ himself It is expedient for you that I go For if I go not the Comforter will not come But if I go I will send him unto you Now it is not to be imagined that J. C. considered as God is the Head of the Church He has obtain'd this honour as Man the Head and the Members ought to be of the same nature It is as Man that J. C. interceeds for Men it is as Man that he has received of God soveraign power over his Church For since God does not interceed at all he as God has not received that Name which is above every Name he is equal to the Father and absolute Master of all things by right of his birth These Truths are evident and J. C. himself assures us of them John 5.22 to 27. since he says that his Father gave him power to judge Men because he was the Son of Man Thus we must not think that those Expressions of Scripture which teach us that J. C. is the Author of Grace ought to be understood of J. C. considered according to his Divine Person For if this was so I confess I should not have demonstrated that he is the occasional cause of it he would have been only the true cause thereof But since it is certain that the three Persons of the Trinity are equally the true causes of Grace seeing all the outward Operations of God are common to the three Persons my Arguments cannot be denied since the Holy Scripture says of the Son and not of the Father nor of the Spirit that he is the Head of the Church and that under this character he communicates Life to all the Members which compose it Object II. XIV It is God who gives to the Soul of J. C. all Thoughts and Motions which it has in the formation of his Mystical Body So that if on one hand the Wills of J. C. as natural and occasional Causes determine the efficacy of God's general Will on the other hand it is God himself who determines the divers Wills of J. C. Thus it comes to the same thing for assuredly the Wills of J. C. are always conformable to those of his Father Answer I confess that the particular wills of J. C. are always conformable to those of the Father but this is not because the Father has particular wills which answer to those of the Son and determine them This is only because the wills of the Son are always conformable to Order in general which is necessarily the rule of the divine wills and of those which love God For to love Order is is to love God it is to will what God wills it is to be Just Wise Regular in his love The Soul of J. C. would form to the Glory of his Father the most Sacred Magnificent and Perfect Temple that can be Order requires this for nothing can be made too great for God All the divers desires of this Soul ever intent upon the Execution of its design come also to it from God or the Word to which it is united But the occasional causes of all these thoughts most certainly are its divers desires for it thinks on what it will Now these divers desires are sometimes altogether free probably the thoughts which excite these desires do not always invincibly determine the Soul of J. C. to form and resolve to execute them It is equally advantagious to the design of Jesus Christ whether it be Peter or John who does that which the regularity of his work requires It is true that the soul of Jesus Christ is not indifferent as to what respects the glory of his Father or that which Order necessarily requires but it is altogether free in every thing else nothing out of God invincibly determines its love Thus it ought not to be wonder'd if it have particular wills tho there are no such wills in God which determine those of the soul of Jesus Christ But I grant that the wills of Jesus Christ are not free I grant that his knowledge determines him to will and always to will after a certain manner in the construction of his Church But it must be Eternal Wisdom to which his soul is united which determines these wills if it is not necessary for this end to suppose particular wills in God It must be observ'd that the wills of the soul of J. C. are particular or have not any occasional cause which determines their efficacy no not the will of God For the soul of J. C. not having an infinite capacity of thinking his knowledge and consequently his wills are limited Thus 't is necessary that his wills be particular since they change according to his divers thoughts and applications For it seems to me that the soul of J. C. otherwise employ'd in contemplating the beauties and tasting the infinite sweetness of the true good ought not according to the rule of Order to think at the same time upon all the Ornaments which it designs to bestow upon his Church and the different means of executing each of his intentions J. C. desiting to render the Church worthy of the infinite Majesty of his Father he desires also to adorn it with infinite beauties and that by such means as are most
an invincible manner by particular and practical wills to the end that he may leave to him more of the glory of his work and make the infinite Wisdom of his Father shine more brightly as he is the Searcher of Hearts that glorious attribute which no spirit can comprehend Now if God acts by general Laws it is visible that we ought to ascribe unto occasional causes to the limitation the dispositions and sometimes the malice of Creatures all those mischievous effects which Piety and the Idea we have of a good wise and just God oblige us to say that he rather permits than has any design to effect For example if a Woman brings forth a Monster or a dead Child or if she lets her Child fall and kills it carrying it to the Church to make it a Christian it is because God observes the general Laws which he hath prescribed We ought to ascribe this dismal effect to natural or occasional causes Super defectum causarum secundarum says St. Thomas God hath permitted this evil since there is none but he can be the true cause of it it may be said in some sence that he hath not done it because it is not for such like effects but for better that he hath established natural Laws and if he follow these Laws it is because he owes this to himself that his Conduct may be uniform and carry the character of his Attributes This is not in the least to blaspheme against the Divine Power as some ignorantly object but it is rather to blaspheme against the Divine Wisdom and Goodness of God to maintain that he wills directly and positively these dismal effects A Man whose Arm is cut off feels grief in his Arm We all of us sleeping have a thousand thoughts in relation to objects which are not at all before us This is because God always acts in consequence of his Laws and gives to the Soul the same thoughts and the same sentiments when there are the same motions in the brain whether we have an Arm or no whether objects are present or absent The DEVIL tempts just Men the wicked solicite good Men to evil Thieves and Soldiers Pillage and Massacre the innocent as well as the guilty God permits this this therefore ought to be attributed to the malignity of occasional causes For tho God doth often from thence draw great advantages by the Grace of J.C. since injustice it self enters into the order of his providence Ordinat peccata says St. Augustine yet these sad effects considered in themselves are unworthy of his goodness There is nothing but good which he wills positively and directly And if he makes use of the injustice of Men to speak as Scripture doth it is because it becomes him to obey his own Laws which were not at first established for such effects In short the greatest number of Men are damned and yet God would save all for he would and can hinder them from offending him God wills the conversion of sinners and certainly he can give them such grace that they shall infallibly be converted Whence is it then that sinners dye in their sin Infants without Baptism whole nations in the ignorance of truths necessary to their Salvation should we rather maintain that God would not save all meerly because of these things Or rather should we not in general seek out the reason in that which he owes to himself to his wisdom and his other attributes Is it not visible or at least is it not a sentiment agreeable with Piety that those ruful effects ought to be attributed to the simplicity in a word to the divinity of his ways and limitation of occasional causes For seeing that God acts by general Laws since he makes use of his Creatures in bringing about his purposes and that he doth not communicate to them his Power but by the establishment of his Laws it is clear that all this proceeds from the nature and action of occasional causes But why has not God established other general Laws or given to the finite action of J.C. an infinite Virtue The Reason is he ought not because his Wisdom exacts from him that he do great works by the most simple ways and that he proportion the action of causes to the beauty of the works And I fear not to say that the Eternal Temple which is the great design of God and the end of all his works is the most beautiful that can be produced by ways so simple and so wise as those are which God makes use of to effect it For I am certain that God loves Men that he would save all and therefore if he doth not so it is because he loves all things in proportion to their amiableness it is because he loves his Wisdom more than his Work 'T is because he does more honour to his attributes by the divinity of his ways than the Perfection of his Creatures In a word 't is because he has the Reason of his Conduct in himself for there is nothing out of God which can hinder him from executing his will And if he should have a will absolutely to save all Men without having respect to the simplicity of his ways 't is certain that he would save all because it is certain that there is an infinite number of means to execute all his designs and that likewise he can execute them by the absolute efficacy of his will without the help of his Creatures I thought my self obliged to represent in few words the Idea which I have of the Divine Providence to the end that it may be easily judged whether it is not more worthy of the Wisdom of God more agreeable to all that experience teaches more useful to answer the Objections of the Libertines better fitted to make us love God and unite us to J.C. our Head and Lastly more according to the Scripture taking it in its full meaning than that humane providence which supposes that God acts always by particular wills and would only save the lesser part of mankind and this simply and precisely because his will is so Objections against the foregoing Discourse With the Author's Answers Objection I. THat cannot evidently be seen in the Idea of GOD which has no necessary relation to him Now there is onely an Arbitrary and not any necessary relation betwixt God and the observation of the general Rules of nature This is one of the Author's Principles Therefore it is not evident that the general cause ought not to produce its effect by particular Wills Now according to this Author we ought not to believe any thing that he says if evidence doth not oblige us thereunto Therefore we may stop here This overturns his new System Answer 'T is true I have said that the general Laws by which God executes his designs are Arbitrary and this is true in two senses First Because God might have produc't nothing For the World is not a necessary Emanation of the Divinity Secondly