after him in wayes of Gospell Obedience Doth this I say incourage any of them to continue in sinne that this Grace may abound Or are any Doctrines of the Gospell to be measured by the rules and lines of the use or abuse that the flesh is apt to make of them Or rather by their suitablenesse to the Divine nature whereof the Saints are made partakers and servicablenesse to their carrying on to perfection in that Attainment Or is this an Argument of validity against an Evangelicall Truth that the carnall unbelieving part is apt to turne it into wantonesse And whether Believers walking after the Siprit in which frame the Truthes of God in the Gospell are savory and sweet to them Rom. 8. 1 14. doe experience such attendancies of the Doctrine under consideration as are here intimated I am perswaded Mr Goodwin will one day finde that he hath not a little grieved the holy Spirit of God by these reproaches cast upon the worke of his Grace Further Doth this perswasion assure men that they shall injoy the Love Favour of God under the practises of all manner of sinne Or can this be wrested by any racks or wheeles from this Assertion that none indeed injoy the love and favour of God but only they towards whom it is effectuall to turne them from the practises of all manner of sinne and wickednesse to translate them from Darknesse into marvelous light and from the power of Satan into the Kingdome of Jesus Christ whom the Grace that appears unto them teacheth to deny all ungodlinesse and worldly lusts to live soberly righteously and Godly in this present world whom that Love constraines not to live vnto them selves but unto him that dyed for them Doth it promise the love and favour of God to doggs turning to their vomit swine wallowing in their mire when the very discriminating difference of it from that Doctrine which advanceth it selfe into Competition with it is that such returning doggs and wallowing Swine did indeed in their best estate and Condition never truly and properly partake of the Love and favour of God but notwithstanding their disgorging and washing of themselves they were doggs and swine still But to what end should I longer insist on these things I am fully perswaded Mr Goodwin himselfe cannot make roome in his understanding to apprehend that this is indeed the true notion of the Doctrine which he doth oppose Something hath been spoken of it already and more the Lord asslisting will be discussed in the progresse of our Discourse abundantly sufficient to manifest to the consciences of men not possest with prejudice against the Truth that it is quite of another nature consistency of another Complexion and usefullnesse then what is here represented I cannot but adde that this way of handling Controversies in Religion namely in proposing Consequences and Inferences of our owne framing wierdrawne with violence and subtility from Principles farr distant from them disowned disavowed and disclaimed by them on whom they are imposed as the Judgment of our Adversaries loading them with all manner of reproaches is such as beeing of all men in the world most walked in by the Arminians I desire not to be Competitor with any in haud defensoribus istis c. Let us now a little in the next place consider what Mr Goodwin gives in for that Perswasion § 32. which in Opposition to the other before by him displayed he contendeth with all his strength to advance I doe not doubt but all that are acquainted with his way of expression elato cothurno will as they may reasonably expect to have it brought forth 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 adorned with all the Gallantry and Ornaments that Words can contribute thereunto for of them there is with him store to be used on all occasions 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 The summe of the Doctrine he is so inamoured on §. 33. he gives us Chap. 9. Sect. 21. Pag. 115. Longa est Fabula longae Ambagis this is Caput reir * Quidam sunt qui jam aliquamdia luce veritatis collustrati fuerunt in ejus cognitione pietatisque studio tantùm profecerunt ut habitum tandem credendi sanctèque vivendi comparaverint Hos non tantum ad finem usque vitae perseverare posse sed facile posse ac libenter cum voluptate perseverare velle credimus adeó ut non nisi cum luctâ molestiâ ac difficultate desicere possint Act. synod Decl. Sen. A. 5. p. 189 190. It is not any danger of falling away in them that are Saints and Believers or probability of it that he mainetaines but only possibility of it such as there is that sober and carefull men may voluntarily throw themselves downe from the topps of Houses or Steeples though perhaps they never come there or runne into the fier or water and be burned or drowned having the use of their reason and understanding to preserve them from such unusuall and dismall accidents which seemes to be an instance of as remote and infirme a possibility as can likely be imagened Yea he tells you farther Sect. 22. That the Saints have as good security of their Perseverance as he could have of his life to whom God should grant a lease of it for so long upon condition that he did not thrust a sword through his bowells or cast himselfe headlong downe a Tower so that his Doctrine indulgeth to the Saints as much assurance as that of Perseverance but only it grants them not a liberty of sinning which I presume his owne Conscience told him that neither the other doth But is this inded Mr Goodwins Doctrine §. 34. Is this all that he intends his Arguments and proofs shall amount unto Ad populum phaleras strange that when there is not so much as a probabillity or danger of falling away yet so many and so Eminent Saints should so fall How seldome is it that we heare of wise and sober men running into the fier throwing themselves headlong from Towers thrusting swords through their owne bowels and nothing more frequent then the Apostacy of Saints If these things stood upon equall tearmes of unlikelyhood and improbability Math. 13. The stony field in the Parable seemes to be every whit as large as the good ground whose fruit abideth That Ground in Mr Goodwins sence is true Believers so that a moyety at least must be granted to fall away and never come to perfection Doubtlesse this is not easy to be received that one halfe of a Company of men in succession should constantly from one Generation to another fall into ruine in such a way as wherein there is no Danger of it or probability that it should so come to passe Methinks we should scarce dare to walke the streets least at every steppe we be strucken downe by sober men voluntarily tumbling themselves frō the topps of houses and hardly keepe our selves from being wounded with the swords wherewith
them that are concerned therein And this I shall do in the Order that I have named giving the Preeminence unto their Obedience which more immediately respecting the Glory of God the honour of the Gospell is to be preferred before their Consolation yea though God should never afford his Saints any drop of that Consolation which we affirme to streame from the Truth discussed yet it is Honour unspeakable for them that he is pleased to admit them and inable them to do him Service in this life and it will be their infinite Consolation that they have done so to Eternity For the making our way cleare to the demonstration of that influence which the Doctrine of the Perseverance of the Saints hath into their Obedâ—ence and close-walking with God and so to manifest what weight is to be lay'd upon it on that Consideration I shall give some previous Observations which may direct and give us light in our passage both concerning Gospell Truths Gospell Obedience and Gospell Motives thereunto I hope it will not be thought amisse if I looke a little backwards to fortify and cleare this part of our progresse there being no concernement of our Doctrine that is more clamoured by the Adversaries of it nor can any respect of it or any Truth of God more causelessly meet with such entertainement as I hope will abundantly in the progresse of our businesse be evinced to the consciences of all who know indeed what it is to walke before God in a course of Gospell Obedience and who have their communion with the Father and his Sonne Jesus Christ. For the first 1. Every Truth revealed from God is to be received not only with Faith and Love but with equall Reverence to any that is revealed though we are not able to discerne such an immediate tendency unto usefullnesse in our Communion with him as in some others we may The formall Reason whereunto our Faith Love and Reverence unto the Word of God is resolved is that it is His Now this is common to the whole for he is the Author of every part and portion a like And though perhaps we may want some part of it at a lesse fatall price then some other yet to reject any one title or jot of it as that which is revealed of God is a sufficient demonstration that no one jot or title of it is received as it ought upon whatever this Title Inscription is Verbum Jehovae there must we stoope and bow downe our soules before it and captivate our Understandings to the obedience of Faith Whatsoever then may hereafter be spoken concerning the usefulnesse of the Truth under Consideration and that comparative regard which in respect of others ought on that account to be had thereunto doth not in the least exalt it as it is in it selfe in respect of Faith and Reverence due thereunto above any other Truth whatsoever that is in Scripture revealed 2. That next to the Revelation of God his Will and his Grace the grand immediate tendency of the whole Scripture is to worke them to whom the Revelation is made into a conformity to himselfe and to mould them into his owne Image All Scripture the Apostle tells us 2 Tim 3.16 is given by inspiration of God and is profitable for Doctrine for reproofe for correction for instruction in righteousnesse that the man of God may be perfect throughly furnished unto all Good workes Hereunto all Scripture tends and is usefull profitable for this end And the Gospell is called the Truth that is according to Godlinesse Titus 1. 1. As the end of the Law is Charity out of a pure heart and a Faith unfained 1 Tim. 1. 5. That which in respect of the prime Author of it is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the Word of God 1 Thess. 2 13. and in respect of the principall matter of it is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the Word of the Crosse 1 Cor. 1.18 in respect of its end and tendency towards us is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the Word or Truth that is according to Godlinesse The Word is that revealed Will of God which is our Sanctification 1 Thess. 4. 3. and the Instrument whereby he workes our Holinesse according to that prayer of our Saviour Sanctifie them by thy Word thy Word is Truth John 17. 19. And that which when we are cast into the mould of our Obedience is in some measure wrought Rom. 6. 17 the substance also or matter being written in our hearts is the Grace and Holinesse promised unto us in the Covenant Jere. 31.33 And that this is the Improvement which ought to be made by Believers of every Gospell Truth or rather that it hath an Efficacy to this purpose the Apostle tells us 2 Cor. 3. 18. We all with open face beholding as in a glasse the Glory of the Lord are changed into the same Image from Glory to Glory even as by the Spirit of the Lord By apprehensions of the glorious Truths discovered in the glasse or mirror of the Gospell we are changed and moulded into the frame and Image therein discovered by the power of the Spirit effectually accompanying the Word in the dispensation thereof And unlesse this be done whatsoever we may pretend we have not received any Truth of the Gospell as it is in Jesus in the power of it Eph. 4. 20 21 22 23 24. Ye have not saith the Apostle so learned Christ If so be that ye have heard him and have been taught by him as the Truth is in Jesus That ye put of as concerning the former conversation the old man which is corrupt according to the deceitfull lusts And be renewed in the spirit of your mind and that ye put on the new man which after God is created in Righteousnesse and true Holinesse Whatsoever men may professe if we have learned the Truth as it is in Jesus it will have these Effects in us even universall relinquishment as to sinceritie of all ungodlinesse and a through change both as to principles and practices unto Holinesse and to Righteousnesse which the Gospell teaches us which if we have not learned we have not yet learn't it as it is in Jesus Tit. 2. 11 12. The Grace of God that bringeth Salvation hath appeared to all men teaching us that denying ungodlinesse and worldly lusts we should live Soberly Righteously and Godlily in this present evill world 3. Some Truths have a more immediate direct and effectuall tendency to the promotion of Godlinesse and Gospell Obedience then others This the Apostle emphatically ascribes as a priviledge to that Doctrine that reveales the Love of Christ unto us 2 Cor. 5. 14. the Love of Christ constraines us other things effectually perswade but the Love of Christ constraines us to live to him it hath an importunity with it not to be denied an efficacy not to be put off or avoided and what is in the things themselves as in the love of Christ that is in its manner in the
are suited to the cherishing of that Principle of the new or inner man in the heart to the nourishing and strengthning of the new creature such as are apt to ingenerate Faith and Love in the heart unto God such as reveale and discover those things in his nature mind and will as are apt to endeare and draw out the heart to him in Communion discouraging perplexing Doctrines doe but ill manure the soyle from whence the fruits of Obedience are to spring and grow Look then I say whatsoever Gospell Truth is of eminent usefulnesse to warme foment stirre up and quicken the Principle of Grace in the heart to draw out increase and cherish Faith and Love that Doctrine lies in a direct immediate tendency to the promotion of Holinesse Godlinesse and Gospell Obedience Yea and whereas to the carrying on of that course of Obedience it is necessary that the contrary Principle unto it which we mentioned before be daily subdued brought under crucified and mortified there are no Doctrines whatsoever that are of such and so direct and eminent a serviceablenesse to that end and purpose as those which inwrappe such discoveries of God and his good will in Christ as are fitted for the improvement also of the principle of Grace in us Hence the worke of Mortification in the Scripture Rom. 6. 2 3 4 5 6. is every where assigned peculiarly to the Crosse and death of Christ Rom. 8. 13. his Love manifested therein and his Spirit flowing therefrom Rom. 7. 7. The Doctrine of the Law indeed humbles the soule for Christ Gal. 3. 23. but it is the Doctrine of the Gospell that humbles the soule in Christ It is the Grace of God that hath appeared 2 Cor. 5. 15. that teaches us effectually to deny all ungodlinesse and worldly lusts to live soberly and righteously and Godly in this present world Tit. 2. 12. He that will but with a little heed read Cap. 6. to the Romans will know from whence Mortification flowes which truly by the way makes me admire at the extreame darknesse and blindnesse of some poore men who have of late undertaken to give directions for Devotion and walking with God who indeed sutably to the most of the rest of their discourses all manifesting an Ignorance of the Righteousnesse of God Rom. 10. 4. and a zealous endeavour to establish their owne coming to propose waies and meanes for the mortifying of any sinne or Lust tell you stories of biting the tongue thrusting needles under the nailes with such like Trash as might have befited Popish devotions five hundred years agoe Were not men utterly ignorant what it is to know the Lord Jesus Christ Phil. 3. 10. and the power of his Resurrection and the fellowship of his sufferings Gal. 6. 14. and being made conformable to his death they could never feed on such huskes themselves nor make provision of them for those whose good they pretend to seeke Unto what hath been spoken adde 4. Fourthly §. 8. who are the Persons that are to be provoked to Holinesse and Godlinesse by the Doctrine insisted on Now they are such as doe believe it and are concerned in it We say the Truth under consideration is of an excellent usefulnesse to farther Gospell Obedience in the hearts of Believers and Saints of God who are taught of God not to turne the Doctrine of Grace into wantonnesse What use or abuse rather men of corrupt mindes and carnall principles who stumble at Jesus Christ and abuse the whole Doctrine of the Gospell by their prejudices and presumptions will make of it we know not nor are sollicitous 2 Cor. 4. 3 4. If the Gospell be hid it is hid to them that perish it is sufficient that the food be good and wholsome for them for whom it is provided If some will come and steale it 2 Cor. 2. 16 27. that have no right to it and it prove through their own distempers gravell in their mouthes or poyson in their bowells they must blame themselves and their own wormewood Lusts and not the Doctrine which they doe receive It is provided for them that feare God and love the Lord Jesus Christ in sincerity not for doggs swine unbelievers we shall not marvaile if they trample on this pearle and rend them that bring it To such as these then I say the Doctrine of the Perseverance of the Saints or the stability or unchangeablenesse of the Love of God unto Believers and of their continuation in Faith and Obedience is full of exceeding effectuall motives and provocations unto Holinesse in all manner of Gospell Obedience and holy conversation exceedingly advantaging the soules of men in a course thereof Now the influence it hath into the Obedience of the Saints floweth from it upon a twofold account 1. By removing all discouragements whatsoever §. 9. that are apt either to turne them aside from their Obedience or to render their Obedience servile slavish or unacceptable to God it setts them through Christ at perfect liberty thereunto 2. By putting unconquerable and indissoluble Obligations upon them to live unto God and the praise of his glorious Grace and evidently drawes them forth unto the Obedience required 1. It removeth and taketh out of the way all discouragements whatsoever all things which are apt to enterpose to the weakning of their Faith in God or their Love to God which as hath been said are at the bottome of all Obedience and Holinesse that is acceptable to God in Christ Now these may all be referred unto two heads 1. Of perplexing anxious fears §. 10. which are apt to impaire and weaken the Faith of the Saints 2. Of hard thoughts of God which assault and shake their Love That slavish perplexing troublesome feares are contrary to the free and ingenuous state of Children whereunto the Saints are admitted and however sometimes yea oftentimes they are at the bottome and the occasion of burthen some servile and superstitious Obedience Impairers of their Faith I suppose I need not labour to prove That kind of Feare whereof we speake of which more afterwards is the greatest Traytor that lurkes in the soule To feare the Lord and his Goodnesse Hos. 3. 5. is the soules Keeper but this servile perplexing feare is the Betrayer of it in all its waies and that which sowres all its duties A thing which the Lord sets himselfe against in rebukes reproofes dehortations as much as any failing and miscarriage in his Saints whatever It is the opposite of Faith hence the fearefull and unbelieving are put together in their exclusion from the new Jerusalem Rev 20. 8. it is that which is direct contrary to that which the Apostle adviseth the Saints unto Heb 10. 19 20 21 22. it is that which mixeth Faith with staggering Rom 4. 20. Prayer with wavering making it ineffectuall Iames 1. 6. 7. Let us now suppose a man to have attained some assurance of the Love of God
asserts against the Jewes Rom 9. 31. They â—ought for righteousnesse but as it were by the workes of the Law and therefore he tells them Chap. 10. 3. That being ignorant of Gods Righteousnesse and going about to establish their own Righteousnesse they did not submit to the Righteousnesse of God And the Papists will one day find a fire proceeding out of their Doctrine of merits consuming all their good Workes as hay and stubble There are also many other waies and principles whereby Obedience is vitiated and rendred an abomination instead of Sacrifice wherein our Doctrine is no sharer But this I must not enter into because it would lead me into other Controversies which with this I shall not intermixe 5. It naturally and sweetly mixeth with all the Ordinances of Christ §. 19. instituted for the end under Consideration In particular with that great Ordinance The Ministry of the Gospell in reference to the great fruit and effect of it mentioned Eph. 4. 12 13. The perfecting of the Saints the edifying of the Body of Christ till we all come in the unity of the Faith and of the knowledge of the sonne of God unto a perfect man unto the measure of the stature of the fulnesse of Christ. That which the Lord Jesus aimed at and intended principally in giving Pastors and Teachers to his Church was that they might carry on the worke of the Ministry for the Perfecting of the Saints and their filling up the measure alotted unto them And this they do by revealing the whole Councell of God unto them keeping back nothing that 's proâ—itable for them as was the practice of Paul Act. 20. 27. Of this Councell or Will of God as by them managed there are two parts 1. The discovery of God to them and his Will as to the state and Condition whereto he calls them and which he requires them to come up unto And this consists in doctrines revealing God and his Will which contain Rules and Precepts for men to walke by and yeild Obedience unto 2. That which is suited â—o the carrying on of men in the state and Condition whereunto they are called according to the mind of God as also to prevaile with them to whom the Word doth come to enter into the state of Obedience and walking with God and this is usually branched into three generall heads of Promises Exhortations and Threatnings The management of these aright with power and efficacy with Evidence and demonstration of the Spirit is no small part yea it is the greatest part of the worke of the Ministry the greatest portion of what is Doctrinall in the Word or Booke of God relating to these heads And of this part of that Ordinance of Christ the Ministry of the Word the pressing of men into a state of Obedience and to a pogresse in that estate by Promises Exhortations Threatnings I shall briefely speake either by way of Demonstration and proofe of what lieth before me or vindication of what is affirmed in the same kind from the Objections and Exceptions of Him in particular with whom I have to doe aiming still at my former Assertion that the Doctrine I have insisted on naturally and clearly closeth with those Promises and Exhortations to help on their efficacy and energy for the accomplishment of the work intended For the first let us take a tast of the Promises which are as it were §. 20. the very life beauty of the Covenant of Grace and the Glory of the Ministry committed unto men and they are of two sorts both of which have their effectuall influence into the obedience of Saints 1. There are promises which expresse only the worke of Gods grace and what he will freely doe in upon the hearts of his thereby as to the working Holinesse and Obedience in them as also of his pardoning mercy in his free acceptance of them in Jesus Christ And these are in a peculiar manner those better Promises of the Covenant of Grace upon the account whereof it is so exceedingly exalted above that of Workes which by sinne was broken and disanulled Heb 8. 6 7 8 9 10. 2. There are Promises of what Good and great things God will farther doe unto and for them who obey him As that he will keepe them and preserve them that they shall not be lost Heb. 9. 10. that their labour and Obedience shall end in the enjoyment of God himselfe with an immortall Crowne of Glory which shall never fade away Now the Doctrine of the Saints Perseverance and the stability of the Love of God unto them closeth with the Promises of both these sorts as to the end of carrying on increasing Obedience Holinesse in them Take an instance in the first The Promises of the worke of Gods Grace in us and towards us are effectuall as appointed to this end so in that Great word Gen 17. 1. which the Apostle calls the Promise Gal. 4. I am God Almighty I am so and will be so to thee and that for and to all ends and purposes of the Covenant whatsoever The inference is walke before me and be thou perfect Walking with God in uprightnesse and sincerity is the proper fruit in us of the Promise of God to us to be our all sufficient God in Covenant As Ier. 31. 33. our becoming the People of God in walking with him in all waies of Obedience is the effect of his Promise to be our God and to write his Law in our hearts not only because by the Grace of the Promise we are brought into a state of Acceptance and made the People of God but also upon the account of the ingagement that is put upon us by that gracious Promise to live unto him Whence in the close it is affirmed we shall be his People The word of the Gospell or the word of Faith doth mainly consist in this And what the aime of that is the Apostle declares Titus 2. 11 12. The Grace of God which appeareth unto us teacheth us to deny all ungodlinesse and worldly lusts and to live soberly righteously and Godly in this present world Which generall purport of the Promises in this way is farther asserted 2 Cor. 7. 1. Having then saith he these Promises Let us cleanse our selves from all silthinesse of flesh and spirit perfecting Holinesse in the feare of the Lord. And most eminently is this assigned to the Promises of that sort which we now peculiarly insist upon 2 Pet 1. 3. 4. To know the way whereby these or any other Promises are effectuall to the end and purpose intimated two things are considerable First what is required to make them so effectuall Secondly wherein and how they doe exert that efficacy that is in them For the First the Apostle acquaints us on what account alone it is that they come to be usefull in this or any other kind Heb 4 2. the word of the Gospell the Promise Preached to them of old did not profit
of mankind not at all to any of those whereby they are distingunished as such This they professed to have a powerfull Efficacy to prevaile with them for that exactnesse in walking with God which by his Grace they attained unto And why they should not be believed herein as farre a sany men whatever bearing the like Testimony to any Doctrine whatever I know not Besides the intendment of this instance of the Persons and their Piety who formerly Believed and spake forth this Doctrine was to manifest by an eminent experiment that there was not in it nor is any tendency to a contrary frame unto Piety Holines which it is injuriously charged withall if by the consideration thereof we do not obtaine that it hath a proper and direct serviceablenesse to the promotion of Godlinesse yet at least we have a convincing demonstration that it is no way obstructive to it Nextly §. 15. Sect. 26. Mr Goodwin entreth upon his defensative to the charge against his Doctrine whose Foundation is laid in the unworthinesse of its Authors in this Nation before it fell upon his hand These he confesseth to be the worst of our late Bishops with such as Romanized â—yrannized among them with their Clergie creatures favorites Persons many of theÌ„ of superstition loosenes much profanenes Of the Apologie shaped for the clearing of the Doctrine he maintaineth from aparticipation with them in their unworthinesse there are three parts In the 1. whereof he denieth that this Doctrine did any way induce them to the loosenesse that was found upon them In the other two giveth as many Reasons of their receiving of it and cleaving to it As for the first part I shall willingly assent to him that the Holinesse or unholinesse of Professors is not to be charged on the Religion they professe I meane appearing Holinesse in the profession of it unlesse there be an evidence of a connexion betwixt their principles practises which in this case to us our apprehension of them who charge this Doctrine with the miscarriages of those men there is At least we may insist on this that there is a suitablenesse in the whole Systeme of the Doctrine whereof the Apostacy of the Saints is an eminent parcell to that frame of Spirit which is in men of loose and superstitious wayes enemies of the Grace of God and power of Godlinesse Neither can there any other reason be tollerably assigned or alledged for the embracement of that Doctrine by those Persons formerly mentioned but only their ignorance of envy to the great Misteryes of the Gospell the Covenant of Grace with union communion and close walking with God A designe was upon them written with the beames of the Sunne to cry up a barren outside light and loose profession with a vaine superstitious selfe-invented Worship of God instead of the Power of a Gospell-conversation and Ordinances of Christ according to his appointment Seeking after a Righeousnesse as it were by the workes of the Law and being ignorant of the Righteousnesse of Christ they found the whole Doctrine whose defence M. G. hath lately undertaken suited to their principles and aimes and therefore with greedinesse drunke it downe like water untill they were swelled with the Dropsy of Pride and selfe conceit beyond what they could beare whatever be now pretended it was little disputed then and in those dayes which Mr Goodwin pointeth unto but that loosenesse of Life inclination to Popery enmity to the power of Godlinesse were at the bottome of the entertainement of the Arminian Principles by that generation of men But Mr G. proceedeth to alleviate this charge §. 16. informes us thus That if the soundnes rottennes of Opinions should be esteemed by the goodnes or badnes of the Lives of any parcell or number of Persons professing the same as well the Opinion of Atheisme which denyeth the being of any God as the opinion of Polytheisme which affirmeth a plurality of Gods must be esteemed better and more sound than that which maintaineth the being of one God and of one only for certaine it is that there have been many Heathens Professours some of the one some of the other of those Opinions who have quitted themselves upon fairer tearmes of honour and approbation in their lives than many Christians professing of the last opinion have done I am not willing to wring this Nose too farre least bloud should follow The lives of many Atheists and Pagans are preferred before the lives of many professing Christianity By Professors of Christianity Mr Goodwin intendeth those who are so indeed and seasoned with the Power of the Principles of that Religion or such only as making an outward profession of it are indeed acted with Principles quite of another nature which notwithstanding all their Profession rendreth them in the truth of the thing it selfe enemies of the crosse of Christ their God being their belly their glory being in their shame and their end being destruction Philip. 3. 18 19. If the former be intended as the Assertion is most false the Gospell only effectually teaching men to deny all ungodlinesse and to live soberly righteously and Godly in this present world so it tendeth directly to the highest derogation from the honour of our Lord Jesus Christ and of his glorious Gospell He that would be throughly acquainted with the notorious untruth of this insinuation let him a little consult Tertullian Arnobius Lactantius Austin others handling the Lives Conversations of the best of the Polytheists and Heathens before in their dayes if he be not contented to take a shorter course and rest in the Authority of the Apostle or rather of the Holy Ghost describing them and their conversations to the Life as they lay under the just hardening Judgements of God Rom. 1. 18. to the end If the latter sort of men called Christians be intended the comparison instituted between them and Atheists is to no purpose they themselves being disclaimed and disowned by Christ his Gospell and reckoned among them with whom they are compared So that upon the matter this is but the comparing one sort of Atheists with an other and giving in a Judgement that of all those are worst whose practises are so and yet pacifie their owne Consciences and deceive the world with a pretence flowrish of a glorious profession I shall not now enter upon any long enquiry what influence the ungodly and profane lives of any ought to have upon the Judgements of men in discovering and discerning of the Doctrines that they bring especially if such as consent in any Doctrine do also concurre in a dissolutenesse of conversation That it will be of no small consideration the experience of all Ages hath evinced The Athenians refused a virtuous Law because the Person was vicious who proposed it and it is generally esteemed that there is a correspondency betwixt the principles practices of those men who earnestly
their thoughts as to particulars in great variety according as their concernments may be yet the Reasons which are generally pleaded as directions for the choise of them to whom with their labours and writings they so address themselves are for the most part uniforme and in their various course transgress not the Rules of certaine heads from whence they flow To express a gratitude for respects and favours received by returning things in their kind eternal for those which are but temporal to obtaine Countenance and Approbation unto their endeavours in their breaking forth into the world from names of more esteem or at least more knowne then their own to advance in repute by a Correspondency in Judgment with men of such esteem intimated thereby are the more ingenuous aimes of men in the dedications of their writings Though these and sundry other pretences of the same kind might justly be drawn into my plea for this address unto you yet your peculiar designation and Appointment through the good hand of the providence of God to the defence of the Gospel and your eminent Furnishment with Abilities from the same hand for the performance of that glorious duty is that alone upon the account whereof I have satisfied my selfe and hope that I may not dissatisfie others as to this present Application What there is of my own peculiar concernment wherein I am like to obtaine a more favourable Condescention in Judgment as to my present undertaking from you then from other men will in the close of my address crave leave to have mention made thereof Brethren the outward obligations that are upon you from the God of truth with the Advantages which he hath intrusted you withal for the defence of his Truth above the most of men in the world are evident even to them that walke by the way and turne little aside to the consideration of things of this nature importance and Condition And it is to me an evidence of no small incouragement that God will yet graciously imploy you in the work and labour of his Gospel by his constant giving a miscarrying wombe to all them who have attempted to defraud the Nation and the Churches of God therein of those helpes and furtherances of Piety and Literature with whose management for their sevlice you are at present intrusted Of the Jewels of Silver and Gold whereof by the Lord's appointment the Children of Israël coming out from amongst them spoiled the Egyptians did they dedicate to the Tabernacle in the wilderness when the Lord planted the Heavens and laid the foundations of the Earth and said to Sion Thou art my people Though some outward provisions and furnitures of Literature now through the good hand of God made serviceable to you in your Attendance upon the great Worke and imployment committed to you were first deposited when thick darkness was over the land Yet that they may be made eminently subservient to the will of God in raising up againe the Tabernacle of David that was falne down the Experience of a few yeares I no way doubt will abundantly reveale and manifest That in the vicissitude of all things given them by the mysterious and dreadful wheeles of providence your good things also as every thing else that is pleasant and desirable or given of God unto the Sons of men hath done have fallen into the possession and disposal of men some enemies others utterly useless and unfruitful to the Lord in their generations cannot be denyed But what is there in his waies or worship in his workes or word that God hath not at some season or other delivered into the power of the men of the world though they have abused and perverted them to their own destruction Neither is there any other use of this Consideration but only to informe them of the Obligations they lye under to a due and zealous improvement of them to whose Trust and Cate the Lord committe any of his mercyes when he rescues them from the Captivity under which they have been detained by ungodly men This is now your lot and condition in reference to many who for sundry generations possessed those places and advantages of eminent service for the house of our God which you now enjoy What may justly be the Expectation of God from you under this signal dispensation of his goodness what is the hope prayer expectation of very many that feare him concerning you in this nation what are the designes desires aimes and endeavours of all sorts of them who beare ill will at whatsoever is comely or praise worthy amongst us you are not ignorant Whatever consideration at any time or season may seem to have had an efficacy upon the minds and wills of men under the like Sacrament and designement to the service of truth with your selves to incite and provoke them to a singularly industrious and faithful discharge of their duty is eminently pressing upon you also and you are made a spectacle to men and Angells as to the acquitment of your selves The whole of your imployment I confess both in the General intendment of it for the promoting and diffusing of light knowledge and Truth in every kind whatever and in the more special designe thereof for the defence furtherance and propagation of the Antient inviolable unchangeable truth of the Gospel of God is in the dayes wherein we live exposed to a Contention with as much opposition contempt scorne hatred and reproach as ever any such undertaking was in any place in the world wherein men pretended to love light more then darkness It is an hellish darkness which the light of the Sun cannot expel There is no ignorance so full of Pride folly and stubborness as that which maintaines it selfe in the midst of plentiful meanes of light and knowledge He that is in the darke when the light of the Sun is as seven dayes hath darkness in his eye and how great is that darkness Such is the Ignorance you have to contend withal stubborne affected prejudicate beyond expression maintaining it's darkness at noon-day expresly refusing to attend to the Reason of things as being that alone in the thoughts of those men if they may be so called who are possessed with it wherewith the world is disturbed From those who being under the power of this enthralment do seem to repine at God that they are not beasts and clamorously traduce the more noble part of that kind offspring whereof themselves are which attempts do heighten improve the difference between Creatures of an intellectual Race and them to whom their perishing Composition gives the utmost Advancement whose eternal seeds and principles are laid by the hand of God in their respective beings you will not I am sure think it much if you meet with Oppositions Those who are in any measure acquainted with the secret triumphing exaltations of wisdome and knowledge against folly and ignorance with the principles and conditions wherewith they advance themselves in their
is a weighty observation yet withall it is evident that he opposeth the abiding of the Spirit with them as a Comforter to his owne bodily presence with them for that end His was for a season the other to endure for ever And I desire to know how our Saviour Christ comes or enters into the soules or hearts of men but by his Spirit and how these things come here to be distinguished But 2. He saies By the abiding of the Comforter with them for ever he doth not meane his perpetuall abode in their hearts or the hearts of any particular man but his constant abiding in the world in and with the Gospell and the Children thereof in respect of which he saith of himselfe elswhere I am with you alwaies even to the end of the world as if he should have said This the purpose of my Father in sending me into the world requiers that I should make no long stay in it I am now upon my returne but when I come to my Father I will intercede for you and he will send you another Comforter upon better termes for staying and continuing with you then those on which I came for he shall be sent not to be taken out of the world by death but to make his residence with and among you my friends and faithfull ones for ever Now from such an abiding of the Holy Ghost with them as this cannot be inferd his perpetuall abiding with any one person or Believer determinately much lesse with every one Ans. 1. §. 29. It was evident before that this Promise was made to the Disciples of Christ as Believers to quicken and strengthen their failing drooping Faith in and under that great Tryall of loosing the presence of their Master which they were to undergoe and being made unto them as Believers though upon a particular occasion is made to all Believers for à quatenus ad omne valet argumentum 2. It is no lesse evident that according to the interpretatiō here without the least attempt of proofe importunately suggested the Promise is no way suited to give the least Incouragement or Consolation unto the Disciples in reference to the Condition upon the account whereof it is now so solemnly given thē It is alone as if our Saviour should have said you are sadly troubled indeed yea your hearts are filled with trouble fear because I have told you that I must leave you be not so dejected I have kept you whilst I have been with you in the world now I goe away and will send the Holy Spirit into the world that whatsoever becomes of you or any of you whether yee have any Consolation or no he shall abide in the world perhaps with some or other that is if any doe believe which it may be some will it may be not untill the end and consummation of it 3. Is this Promise of sending the Holy Spirit given to the Apostles or is it not If you say not assigne who it is given or made unto Christ spake it to them and doubtlesse they thought he intended them and it was wholly suited to their Condition If it were made unto them is it not in the letter of the Promise affirmed that the Spirit shall abide with them for ever to whom it was given If there be any subject of this Promise in receiving the Spirit he must of necessity keepe his residence and abode with it for ever The whole designe of this Section is to put the persons to whom this Promise is made into the darke that we may not see them yea to deny that it is made to any persons at all as the recipient subject of the Grace thereof He tells yee that he abides in the world how I pray Doubtlesse not as the uncleane Spirit that goes up and downe in dry places seeking rest and finding none Christ promiseth his Spirit to his Church not to the world to dwell in the hearts of his not to wander up and downe Nay he abides with the Apostles and their Spirituall posterity that is Believers in our Saviours interpretation John 17. 20. Are they then and their posterity that is Believers the persons to whom this Promise is made and who are concerned in it with whom as he is promised he is to abide This you can scarcely finde out an Answer to in the whole Discourse He tells you indeed the Holy Ghost was not to dye with such other rare notions but for any persons particularly intended in this Promise we are still in the Darke 4. He tells us That from such an abiding of the Holy Ghost with them as this cannot be inferred his perpetuall abiding with any one person determinately But 1. What kind of abiding it is that he intends is not easily apprehended 2. If on the account of this Promise he is given to any person on the same account he is to abide with the same person for ever 3. That which he seemes to intend is the presence of the Spirit in the Administration of the Word to make it effectuall unto them to whom it is delivered when the Promise is to give him as a Comforter to them on whom he is bestowed But he adds Sect. 14. 4. And lastly This particle 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 doth not alwayes import the certainty of the thing spoken of by way of event no not when the speech is of God himselfe but oft times the intention only of the Agent so that the words that he may abide with you for ever doe not imply an absolute necessity of his abiding with them for ever but only that it should be the intent of him that should send him and that he would send him in such a way that if they were true to their own interest they might retain him and have his abode with them for ever Turne the words any way with any tolerable congruity either to the scope of the place manner of Scripture expression principles of Reason and the Doctrine of Perseverance will be found to have nothing in them Ans. 1. This is the 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 that when all Medicines will not heale must serve to skinne the wound given our Adversaries cause by the Sword of the Word The Promise is made unto Believers indeed but on such and such conditions as on the account whereof it may never be accomplisht towards them 2. This no way sutes Mr Goodwins interpretation of the place formerly mentioned and insisted on If it be as was said only a Promise of sending his Spirit into the World for the end by him insinuated doubtlesse the word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 must denote the Event of the thing and not only an Intention that might faile of Accomplishment For let all or any individualls behave themselves how they will it is certaine as to the Accomplishment and event that the Spirit of God shall be continued in the World in the sence pleaded for But it is not what is congruous to his
own thoughts but what may oppose ours that is the plaine and obvious sence of the words that he is concerned to make use of It being not the sence of the place but an escaping our Argument from it that lies in his designe he cares not how many contrary and inconsistent Interpretations he gives of it haec non successit aliâ aggrediemur viâ The word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 denotes as is confessed the intention of Christ in sending the Spirit that is that he intends to send him to Believers so as that he should abide with them for ever Now besides the impossibility in generall that the intention of God or of the Lord Christ as God and man should be frustrate whence in particular should it come to passe he should faile in this his intention I will send ye the holy spirit to abide with you for ever that is I intend to send you the Holy Spirit that he may abide with you for ever what now should hinder this Why it is given them upon condition that they be true to their own interest and take care to retaine him what is that I pray Why that they continue in Faith Obedience Repentance and close walking with God but to what end is it that he is promised unto them Is it not to teach them to worke in them Faith Obedience Repentance and close walking with God to Sanctifie them throughout and preserve them blamelesse to the end making them meet for the inheritance with the Saints in Light In case they Obey Believe c. the Holy Ghost is promised unto them to abide with them to cause them to Obey Believe Repent c. 4. The Intention of Christ for the sending of the Spirit and his abiding for ever with them to whom he is sent is but one and the same And if any frustration of his intention do fall out it may most probably interpose as to his sending of the Spirit not as to the Spirits continuance with them to whom he is sent which is asserted absolutely upon the account of his sending him He sends him 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 his abode is the end of his sending which if he be sent shall be obtained Upon the whole doubtlesse it will be found that the Doctrine of Perseverance findes so much for its establishment in this place of Scripture and Promise of our Saviour that by no Art or cunning it will be prevailed withall to let goe its interest therein And though many attempts be made to turne and wrest this Testimony of our Saviour severall wayes and those contrary too and inconsistent with one another yet it abides to looke straight forwards to the proofe and confirmation of the Truth that lyes not only in the wombe and sence of it but in the very mouth and literall expression of it also I suppose it is evident to all that Mr Goodwin knowes not what to say to it nor what sence to fixe upon At first it is made to the Apostles not all Believers then when this will not serve the turne there being a Concession in that Interpretation destructive to his whole cause then it is made as a Priviledge to the Church not to any individuall Persons but yet for feare that this priviledge must be vested in some individualls it is denyed that it is made to any but only is a Promise of the Spirits abode in the world with the Word but perhaps some thoughts coming upon him that this will no way suit the scope of the place nor be suited to the intēdmēt of Christ it is lastly added that let it be made to whom it will it is conditionall though there be not the least intimation of any condition in the Text or Context and that by him assigned be coincident with the thing it selfe promised But hereof so farre And so our second Testimony the Testimony of the Sonne abides still by the Truth for the confirmation whereof it is produced and in the mouth of these two witnesses the abiding of the Spirit with Believers to the end is established Adde here unto thirdly the Testimony of the third that beares witnesse in Heaven §. 29. and who also comes neere and beares witnesse to this Truth in the hearts of Believers even of the Spirit it selfe and so I shall leave it sealed under the Testimony of the Father Sonne and Holy Ghost As the other two gave in their Testimony in a word of Promise so the Spirit doth in a reall worke of Performance wherein as he beares a distinct Testimony of his owne the Saints having a peculiar Communion and fellowship with him therein so he is as the common seale of Father and Sonne set unto that Truth which by their Testimony they have confirmed There are indeed sundry things whereby he confirmes and establisheth the Saints in the Assurance of his abode with them for ever I shall at present mention that one eminent worke of his which being given unto them he doth accomplish to this very end and purpose and that is his Sealing of them to the day of Redemption A worke it is often in the Scripture mentioned and still upon the account of assuring the Salvation of Believers 2 Cor. 1. 22. by whom also ye are sealed Having mentioned the Certainty Unchangeablenesse and efficacy of all the Promises of God in Christ and the end to be accomplished and brought about by them namely the Glory of God in Believers v. 20. all the Promises of God are yea and Amen in him to the Glory of God by us the Apostle acquaints the Saints with one Foundation of the security of their interest in those Promises whereby the end mentioned the Glory of God by them should be accomplished This he ascribes to the efficacy of the Spirit bestowed on them in sundry workes of his Grace which he reckoneth v. 21 22. Among them this is one that he seales them As to the nature of this sealing and what that Act of the Spirit of Grace is that is so called I shall not now insist upon it The end and use of Sealing is more aimed at in this expression then the nature of it what it imports then wherein it consists Being a terme forensicall and translated from the use and practice of men in their Civill Transactions the use and end of it may easily from the originall rise thereof be demonstrated Sealing amongst men hath a two fold use First to give secrecy and security in things that are under present consideration to the things sealed And this is the First use of Sealing by a seale set upon the thing sealed Of this kind of sealing chiefely have we that long Discourse of Salmasius in the vindication of his Jus Atticum against the Animadversions of Heraldus And 2 ly to give an assurance or faith for what is by them that seale to be done In the first sence are things sealed up in Baggs and in Treasuries that they may be kept safe none daring to
the consideration of what hath been from a like disposition of Causes to an Answerablenesse of Events What Mr Goodwin hath to plead in this Case he insists on §. 4. Chap. 9. Sect. 24 25 26 27. Pag. 167 168 169 170 171 172. The summe and aime of his Discourse is to Apologize for his Doctrine against sundry Objections which in the Observations of men it is lyable and obnoxious unto Now these are such as whatever the Issue of their Consideration prove doubtlesse it can be of no Advantage unto his Cause that his Doctrine is so readily exposed to them The first of these is §. 5. that the Doctrine he Opposeth and in Opposition whereunto that is set up which he so industriously asserts hath generally been received and imbraced by men eminent in Piety and Godlinesse famous on that account in their Generations with the generality of the People of God with them And this is attended with that which naturally insues thereon viz. The Scandalousnesse of the most of them yea of them all of this Nation is it spoken who have formerly asserted the Doctrine which Mr Goodwin hath lately espoused Whereunto in the third place an Observation is subjoyned of the Ordinary defection of men to loose and unsavory practises after they have once drunke in the principles of that opinion which he now so industriously mixeth and tempereth for them It is usually said there is no smoake but where there is some fire It would be strange if such Observations as these should be readily and generally made by men concerning the Doctrine under Contest unlesse there were some evident occasion Administred by it thereuto And I must needs say that if they prove True and hold under Examination they will become as urging a prejudice as can lightly be laid against any cause in Religion whatsoever The Gospell being a Doctrine according unto Godlinesse severall perswasions pretending to be parts and portions thereof if one shall be found to be the constant Faith and profession of those who also have the life and power of Godlinesse in them the other to be maintained by evill men aud seducers who upon their receiving it doe also wax worse and worse it is no small advantage to the first in its plea for admittance to the right and title of a truth of the Gospell To Evade this charge Mr Goodwin premises this in Generall §. 6. The experience Asserted in the Objection is not so unquestionable in point of Truth But that if the Asserters were put home upon the proofe they would I seare doubtlesse he rather hopes it accompt more in presumption than in reasonablenes of Argument For if Persons of the one judgement of the other were duly compared together I verily believe there would be found every whit as full a proportion of men truly Conscientious and Religious amongst those whose judgements stand and have stood for a possibility of falling away As on the other side but through a foolish and unsavoury kind of partiality we are apt on all hands according to the Proverb to account our own Geese for Swannes and other mens Swannes Geese Certaine I am that if the writings of men of the one judgement and of the other be compared together and an estimate made from thence of the Religion Worth and Holinesse of the Authors respectively Those who oppose the common Doctrine of Perseverance doe account it no Robbery to make themselves every way equall in this honour with their opposers The truth is If it be lawfull for me to utter what I really apprehend and judge in the case I doe not find that spirit of holinesse to breath with that Authority height or Excellency of power in the writings of the latter which I am very sensible of in the writings of the former These call for Righteousnesse Holinesse and all manner of Christian conversation with every whit as high a hand as the other and adde nothing to check obstruct or infeeble the Authority of their demands in this kind when as the other though they before many times in their exhortations and conjurements unto holinesse yet other while render both these and themselves in them contemptible by avouching such principles which cut the very sinews and strength of such their exhortations and fully ballance all the weight of those motives by which they seek to bind them upon the Consciences of men And for men truly holy and Conscientious doubtlesse the Primitive Christians for three hundred years together and upwards next after the times of the Apostles will fully ballance with an abundant surplusage both for numbers and truth of Godlinesse All those in the Reformed Churches who since Calvins daies have adhered to the common Doctrine of Perseverance And that the Churches of Christ more generally during the said space of three hundred years and more held a possibility of a totall and finall defection even in true and soun◠Believers is so cleare from the Records yet extant of those times that it cannot be denied Ans. To let passe M. Goodwins Proverb with its Applycation it being very facile to returne it to its Author there being nothing in the World by him proposed to induce us to such an estimation of his associates in the work of teaching the Doctrine of the Saints Apostasy and their labours therein or any other undertaking of theirs as he labours to beget in guilding over their Worth and Writings but only his own judgment an overweening of their Geese for Swans Let us see what is offered by him to evince the Experience Asserted not to be so unquestionable as is pretended He offers First his own Affirmation That if an estimate may be made of mens Worth and Holinesse by their writings Those who oppose the Doctrine of the Saints Perseverance will be found in the promotion of Holinesse and the practice of it to out goe their Adversaries Their writings he tells us breath forth a spirit of holinesse such as he cannot find in the writings of others But first for this you have only M. Goodwins naked single Testimony And that opposed to the common experience of the people of God What weight this is like to beare with men the event will shew It is a hard thing for one man upon his bare word to undertake to perswade a multitude that what their eyes see and their eares heare is not so M. Goodwin had need have Pythagorean Disciples for the imbracing of these dictates of his The experience of Thousands is placed to confirme the observation insisted on saith M. Goodwin It is not so they are in my judgement all deceived But Secondly § 7. who are they in whose writings Mr Goodwin hath found such a Spirit of Holinesse breathing with Authority as is not to be found out nor perceived in the writings of them that assert the Doctrine of the Perseverance of the Saints Calvin Zanchius Beza c. and to confine our selves home Reynolds Whitaker Perkins Greenham
of the consistency of Effectuall Grace and Gospell Exhortations A Third Argument is proposed Sect. 18. Cap. 13. in these words §. 1. That Doctrine which representeth God as weake Incongruous and In coherent with himselfe in his applications unto men is not from God and consequently that which contradicteth it must needs be the truth but the Doctrine of Perseverance opposed by us putteth this great dishonour upon God representeth him weake Incongruous c. Ergo. For the proofe of the Minor Proposition to make good the charge in it exhibited against the Doctrine of Perseverance there is a Drammaticall scheme induced to whose framing and Application M. Goodwin contributed no more but the paines of a Translator taking it from the Anti-Synod p. 276. 277. in these words You that truly Believe in my Sonne and have beene once made partakers of my Holy Spirit and therefore are fully perswaded assured from my will and command given unto you in that behalfe yea according to the infallible word of Truth which you have from me that you cannot possibly no not by all the most horrid sinns and abominable practices that you shall or can commit fall away either totally or finally from your Faith for in the midst of your foulest actions courses there remaines a seed in you which is sufficient to make you true Believers to preserve you from falling away finally that it is impossible you should dye in your sinnes you that know are assured that I will by an irresistible hand worke Perseverance in you consequently that you are out of all danger of condemnation and that Heaven and Salvation belong unto you and are as good as yours already so that nothing but giving of thankes appertaines to you which also you know that I will do what you will in the meane time necessitate you unto you I say that are fully and throughly perswaded and possessed with the truth of all these things I earnestly charge admonish exhort and beseech that yee take heed to your selves that yee countinue in the Faith that there be not at any time an evill heart of unbeliefe in any to depart from the Living God that you fall not from your owne stedfastnesse yea I declare and professe unto you that if you shall draw back my soule shall have no pleasure in you that if you shall deny me I will deny you that if you be againe overcome of the lusts of the world and be intangled here with that your latter end shall be worse than your beginning that if you shall turne away all your former Righteousnes shall not be remembred but you shall dye in your sinnes and suffer the veugeance of Eternall fire On the other hand if you shall continue to the end my Promise is that you shall be Saved therefore strive to enter in at the straite gate quit your selves like men labour for the meat that indureth unto Everlasting Life and be not sloathfull but followers of them who through Faith and Patience inherit the Promises He that shall duly weigh and consider what a sencelesse and indeed ridiculous incongruity there is between these Exhortations Adjurations Threatnings and latter Promises and those Declarations Applications and former Promises doubtlesse will confesse that either the one or the other of them are not from God or according to the mind of God Ans. §. 2. The incongruity of this fiction with the Doctrine it is framed against is so easily manifested that it will not much concerne us to consider the incongruity that the severall parts of it have one with an other For First the whole Foundation of this fanatick Fabrick is ridiculous in it selfe and ridiculously imposed on the Doctrine of Perseverance For whereas it sayes not that all Saints have any comfortable Assurance of their Perseverance and so may by all Gospell wayes whatever by Promises and Threatnings be stirred up to the use of those meanes whereby Perseverance is wrought and Assurance obtain'd so it saies that no one Saint in the world ever had can have or was taught to expect his Perseverance or the least sence or Assurance of it under such an uncouth supposition as falling into continuing in sins Abominations the Promises they have to assure thē of their inseparable abode with God to the end are that he will write his Law in their hearts put his Feare in their inward parts that they shall never depart from him and they shall be kept up thereto by the use of meanes suitable as appointed of God for the attaining of the end proposed being kept by the power of God but throngh Faith unto Salvation God doth not call nor doth the Doct of Perseverance of the Saints or of the stability and Unchangeablenesse of his Promises in Christ to Believers assert it any to Believe that they shall never fall away from him what sinnes and Rebellions so ever they fall into neither hath he promised any such things unto thē but only that he will through his Grace preserve them in the use of meanes from such Rebellions as are inconsistent with his Love and free acceptation through Christ according to the Tenor of the Covenant of Grace so that instead of the first part of this fiction whose inconsistency with the latter is after Argued let this acording to the Analogy of our Doctrine be instituted You that truly Believe in my Sonne Jesus Christ § 3. and are made partakers of my Holy Spirit who being heirs of the Promises and so have a Right to that abundant Consolation that Joy in believing which I am willing all of you should receive I know your Feares doubts perplexityes and Temptations your failings sinnes and back-slidings and what sad thoughts on the account of the evill of your owne hearts and wayes you are exposed to as that you shall never abide nor be able to continue with me and in my Love to the end let the feeble knees be strengthned and the hands that hang downe be lifted up behold I have ordained goodworkes for you to walke in as the way wherein you are to walke for the attainement of the end of your Faith the Salvation of your soules And to quicken you and stirre you up hereunto I have provided and established Effectuall Ordinances revealed in the Word of my Grace whereunto you are to attend and in the use of them according to my mind to grow up into Holinesse in all manner of holy conversation Watching Fighting Resisting Contending with and against all the Spirituall Enemy's of your soules And as for me this is my Covenant with you that my Spirit which gives Efficacy to all the meanes Ordinances and Advantages of Gospell Obedience which I have afforded unto you by whom I will fulfill in you all the good-pleasure of my Goodnesse and the worke of Faith with Power so making you meet for the Inheritance of the Saints in Light and Preserving you to my Heavenly Kingdome shall never depart
Christ imputed if ever he were invested with it before because no man with that Righteousnesse upon him can be in such an estate Now we have upon severall grounds proved that the Righteous man under that Apostacy wherein Ezechiel describes and presents him is pronounced by God a child not of a temporall but eternall death and condemnation This indeed the Doctor denyes but gives no reason of his denyall for which I blame him not Only I must crave leave to say that the Chair weigheth not so much as one good Argument with me much lesse as many So that all this while he that spake and still speakes unto the world by Ezekiel is no friend to that Doctrine which denyeth a possibility of a righteous mans declining even unto death Ans. If this be all that Mr Goodwin hath to say for the removall of this Answer that cuts the throat of his Argument if it be not removed he hath little Reason for the confidence wherewith he closeth it concerning Gods speaking in this place of Ezechiel against that Doctrine which in innumerable places of his Word he hath taught us as a Doctrine enwrapping no small portion of that Grace which in a Covenant of Mercy he dispenseth to his Chosen Redeemed Justifyed Sanctifyed ones neither is here any need to adde the weight of the Chair wherein yet that person spoke of behaved himselfe worthily in his Generation and was in his Exercises herein by no meanes by Mr Goodwin to be despised be laid upon the Reasonings of the Doctor in this case they proving singly of themselves too heavy for Mr Goodwin to beare In briefe that the substance of the reply in hand is meerely a begging of the thing in Question any one that hath but halfe an eye in the businesse of this nature may easily discerne that it is supposed that a man truly Righteous and Justifyed in the bloud of Christ may so fall away as to be pronounced of God to be in a state of damnation and so fallen really from his former condition Rom. 8. 1. is the thing that Mr Goodwin hath to prove Now saith he this must needes be so because God here upon such a supposall pronounceth such a man to be in the estate of condemnation what this is with other men I know not but to me it is no proofe at all nor should I believe that to be the sence of the place though in variety of expressions he should significantly affirme it a thousand times the Reader also is misinformed that the Doctor attempts not any proof that by death eternall death is not in this place intended he that shall consult the plaee will finde himselfe abused but we must speake more of this anon And this is all our Authour offers as to the persons spoken of in the place of Scripture under consideration wherein though he hath taken some paines to little or no purpose to take off the exposition of the words the description of the person given by others yet he hath not attempted to give so much as one Argument to confirme the sence he would impose on us concerning the condition of the person spoken of And I must crave leave to say that naked assertions be they never so many in the Chaire or out weigh not so much with me as one good Argument much lesse as many There is nothing remaines to consideration §. 17. but only the Comminatory part of the words or the expression of the punishment allotted of God to such as walke in the wayes of Apostasy here expressed in his trespasse that he hath trespassed and in his sinne that he hath sinned in them shall he dye that is He shall be dealt withall as many of their Nation were in the Land of Israel my judgements shall overtake him it shall not advantage him that either he had Godly Parents that have walked with mee or that he himselfe had so behaved himselfe in a way of Righteousnesse as before described if he turne to the profanenesse and abominations which are laid downe as the waies of wicked men or into any paths like them he shall even dye or be punished for his sinnes according to the tenour of the truth laid downe in the entrance of the Chapter and repeated againe v. 20. the soule that sinneth it shall dye But now whereas it might be replied that such an one notwithstanding his degeneracy might yet perhaps recover himselfe to his former way of walking obedience and righteousnesse in conversation And is there then no hope nor helpe for him but having once so Apostatised he must suffer for it To prevent any such misprision of the mind of God there is added the termes of his duration in that state of Apostasy that is even unto death if he commiteth iniquity and dyeth in it that is repents not of it before his death the judgements of God shall find him out as was before expressed If by his Repentance he prevent not his calamities he shall end his sinning in destruction in which expressions of the persons continuance in his Apostatised condition and of the judgements of God falling on him on that account there is not the least appearance of any Tautology or incongruity in the sence the same word is used to expresse diverse concernements of it which is no Tautology though the same word be used yet the same thing is not intended Tautology reflects on things not words otherwise there must be a Tautology where ever there is an 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 as John 1. 4. % to commit iniquity and to dye therein is no more but to continue in his iniquity impenitently untill death now to say that a man was put to death for his fault because he committed it and continued impenitent in it even unto the death which he was adjudged to and which was inflicted on him for his fault is an incoherent expression it seems will puzle as great a master of Language as M.G. to make good M.G. endeavours to make the punishment threatned in the words he shall dye for his iniquity precisely and exclusively to signify eternall death which the former interpretation doth not exclude which he is no way able to make good what he offers Sect. 3. concerning the incongruity of the sence and tautology of the expression of it be not so understood hath been already removed the comparison ensuing instituted between these words and those of 1 Cor. 9. 10. Should have been enforced with some consideration of the coincidence of the scope of either place with the expressions used in them and though Repentance which is also added will not deliver them from temporall or naturall death yet it will and may as did Ahab in part from having that death inflicted in the way of an extraordinary Judgement Sect. 4. Mr Goodwin offers sundry things all of the same importance and tendency all animated by the same fallacyes or mistakes to make good the sence he insists on exclusively to all others