Lords day on neither whereof they fasted Neverthelesse in other places this reason prevailed not By Tertullian it appeareth De Orat. C. xiiii that in his time and the parts where he lived the Eucharist was celebrated on dayes of Fasting And in the same place he disputeth against those that forbore the Kisse of Peace used in some places afore receiving the Eucharist in some places after it Conc. Laod. Can. xix Innocent I. ad Docent 1. upon dayes of Fasting which was an observance of Fasting-dayes derived from the Synagogue where their fashion was not to salute one another when they fasted Maimoni Taanioth C. iii. n. 8. C. v. n. 11. And S. Basil Epist cclxxxix 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Yet we communicate foure times a week Lords dayes Wednesdayes Fridayes and Sabbaths and on other dayes if the memory of a Martyr fall out In fine certain it is which S. Augustine delivereth in this point Epist cxviii Alia quae per loca terrarum regionésque variantur sicuti est quòd alii jejunant Sabbato alii non alii quotidie communicant corpori sanguini Dominico alii certis diebus communicant alibi nullus dies intermittitur quo non offeratur alibi Sabbato tantùm Dominico alibi tantùm Dominico siquid aliud hujusmodi animadverti potest totum inquam hoc genus rerum liberas habet observationes Other things which change according to places and countreys of the world as that some fast on Saturday some not some participate every day of the Lords body and bloud some receive on certain dayes in some places no day is intermitted but it is celebrated otherwhere onely on the Sabbath and Lords day otherwhere on the Lords day alone and if any thing else of this sort can be observed all matters of this kind I say are of free observance This indifference or this difference notwithstanding we shall perceive the whole custome of the Ancient Church was to celebrate the Eucharist if not every day yet upon all Lords dayes if not rather by consequence upon all Festivals or all dayes of more solemn Assemblies as the Crown of the Service for which they assembled both upon example of the Primitive time The practice of them that celebrated and received the Eucharist every day standeth upon the example of the Primitive Christians at Jerusalem Of whom when it is said that they continued constant in the doctrine of the Apostles and communion and in breaking bread and prayers and that continuing with one mind in the Temple and from house to house they did eat their meat with gladnesse and singlenesse of heart to what purpose shall we imagine that Breaking bread and Communion is mentioned besides the Service of the Temple but to signifie the Service of the Eucharist proper to the Faith of Christians in which they communicated among themselves as with the Jews in the Service of the Temple knowing that at the first it was used at meals as it was instituted among Christians This notwithstanding in other places it seemeth the Eucharist was celebrated but upon Lords dayes as well in the times of the Apostles as in the Church that succeeded Acts xx 7. On the first day of the week the Disciples being assembled to break bread that is to celebrate the Eucharist as the Syriack translateth it Here the first day of the week seemeth to stand against the rest in terms of difference as if upon other dayes they did it not And that is the day which S. Paul appointeth the Church of Corinth as he had done the Churches of Galatia to make their Collections for the poore which Tertullian sheweth was done at their Assemblies 1. Cor. xvi 2. Tertull. Apolog. C. xxxix and in Plinie's Epistle concerning the Christians of his Government Quòd essent soliti stato die ante lucem convenire That they were wont on a set day to assemble before light What day but the Lords day can we think might be Set for this purpose Justice Martyr for certain mentioneth no other Assemblies of Christians but on the Lords day in the place aforenamed And in the Constitutions of the Apostles ii 58. where he exhorteth to Assemble every day morning and evening as was said afore the Eucharist is mentioned to be celebrated but upon Lords dayes as it followeth afterwards Plinie's words in that place are these at large Epist xcvii l. x. Quòd essent soliti stato die ante lucem convenire carménque Christo quasi Deo dicere secum invicem séque Sacramento non in scelus aliquod obstringere sed nè furta nè latrocinia nè adulteria committerent nè fidem fallerent nè depositum appellati abnegarent His peractis morem sibi discedendi fuisse rur súsque coeundi adcapiendum cibum promiscuum tamen innoxium The Christians confessed that they were wont to assemble on a set day before light and to sing praise among themselves to Christ as to God and to tye themselves upon a Sacrament not to any wickednesse but not to commit thefts robberies or adulteries not to falsifie their trust or deny a thing deposited being demanded This done that their custome was to depart and meet again to eat together but in a vulgar and innocent sort Grotius of late upon Matth. xxvi 25. seemeth to conceive that at the beginning the Eucharist was not celebrated but at meals as it was instituted by our Lord. And that so it was celebrated not onely under the Apostle as Acts xx 11. 1. Cor. xi or under Ignatius but in Justine Martyr and Tertullians time appeareth by their words Justin Dial. cum Tryph. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Therefore that Prayers and Thanksgivings made by the worthy are the onely complete Sacrifices and acceptable to God I also affirm for these alone Christians also have received order to perform and that upon remembrance both of their dry and moist nourishment at which there is also remembrance of the Passion which God by God himself suffered The like Apol. ii the words shall follow afterwards Tertullian de Cor. c. 3. Eucharistiae Sacramentum in tempore victûs omnibus mandatum à Domino etiam antelucanis coetibus nec de aliorum manu quà m Praesidentium sumimus The Sacrament of the Eucharist commanded by our Lord both to all and at meat time we receive also at our Assemblies afore day but at no mans hands but our Presidents They are the words whereupon he groundeth For Tertullian reckoneth it among Traditions that is Customes of the Church not commanded in Scripture Which notwithstanding nothing hindereth but the same might be practised in the Apostles time and remembred in the Scriptures To which opinion I rather incline Otherwise whence should the Custome rise in Justine and Tertullians time to celebrate the Eucharist at their Morning Assemblies when it was still in use at Supper time in their Feasts of Love That is it which Ignatius calleth 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 in the ancient translation
may please to consider S. Cyprians Order which alloweth their presence for their satisfaction not their voices to decide As they are present at Councels but not called to give sentence But since Kingdomes and Commonwealths are become Christian the Laws of those Kingdomes and Commonwealths as they inforce the Ministers of the Church to execute their office according to such Rules as they inforce so they constrain the people to yield outward effect to the same The good order and peace of the Church cannot be preserved otherwise All this while the Office of Ministers continueth the same No part of it accrueth to the Secular powers By becoming Christians they purchase themselves no more right then the Charge of maintaining the Ministers of the Church in doing their Office containeth Onely as all Christians have the judgement of particular discretion to discharge unto God even in matters of Religion the account of what themselves do so is this judgement of particular discretion by publick persons but most by the Sovereigne of right imployed in all that in which they lend or refuse their assistance to the Ministers of the Church in their Office alwayes under the account due to God and to the Sovereigne What is then the meaning of that which we reade in these dayes That all Jurisdiction of the Church exercised by the Ministers of it even that of Excommunicating call it Jurisdiction for the present though the term be proper where there is power to constrain is inherent and derived in and from the Common-wealth that is in our particular from the Crown of this Kingdome From whence it will follow by just and due consequence that the Office charged upon the Ministers of the Church by the Scriptures cannot be executed by them of right so long as Kingdomes and Commonwealths are enemies of the Faith So that whatsoever the Church did under the Empire before it was converted to the Faith was an attempt upon the Laws of it And the Church must of necessity die and come to nothing for want of right to execute and propagate the Ministeries which it standeth incharged with by the Scripture The Canonists have done well to distinguish between Order and Jurisdiction in the Ministeries of the Church provided that the ground be right understood upon which these terms are distinguishable according to the Scriptures That will point the effect of it to a farre other purpose but we must not be beholden to the Canonists for it being indeed this Because he that receiveth the Order of Presbyter in the Church for example is not of necessity by the same Act deputed to the exercise of all that his Order importeth and inableth to exercise without receiving the Order anew I say by the Scriptures he is not confined when he receiveth the Order when where how what part of those things he shall exercise which the Order inableth to do True it is when the Canon that prohibited Ordinations without Title of Office was in force to the true purpose of it by receiving the Order a man was deputed to the Service of the Church in which he received it as a Bishop is now when first he is ordained And the nearer the Course of Law cometh to this Canon the better I conceive it is in that regard But as this deputation was alterable so was the execution of it of necessity limitable in them that received it What Law of God what Command of Scripture what Rule or Practice of the whole Church is there to hinder him that is deputed to one Service to undertake another for the good of the Church Or to inable all that have received the Order of Presbyter for example indifferently to exercise the power of the Keys and of Ordaining so farre as it belongeth to that Order of right much lesse to exercise it according to their own sense and not according to Rules prescribed by the Church Therefore when the Order is given if you please to call the right of exercising that which it importeth in such time and place and sort as he that receiveth it is or may be deputed to do without receiving the Order anew the power of Jurisdiction this power of Jurisdiction may be given or limited by other acts besides though habitually and afarre off it be contained in the Order of Presbyters and exercised without receiving the Order anew so soon as a man is deputed to the exercise of it If further the question be made From whom this power of Jurisdiction that is the right of exercising that which the Order thus inableth to do is derived and in whom the power of Jurisdiction that is the right of giving this right resideth which the Canonists derive from the Pope upon the whole Church The answer is plain that it must rest in them and be derived from them upon whom the Government of particular Churches and that which falleth under them is estated according to the Scriptures In as much as no Law of God inforceth the rest of Churches to be Governed by one further then the Law of Charity inforceth all to concurre to the unity of the whole In the outward Jurisdiction of the Church in charitable causes settled here upon Bishopricks the matter is somewhat otherwise in as much as it is not so settled by expresse provision of Scripture And yet not so strange from the Scripture and that which is provided there but that it may seem originally to have been derived from thence 1. Cor. vi The Apostle reproving them for impleading one another in the Courts of unbelievers sheweth that the Church was disparaged in that course as if it had none fit to decide their controversies whereas it had been better to referre their causes to the meanest of the Church then to sue before Infidels That is the meaning of his words there vers 4. If ye have causes concerning matters of this life set them to judge who are least esteemed in the Church Not spoken by way of precept commanding them to let the simplest of the brethren judge their causes that were a strange course where there were abler men to do it but by way of Concession that it were better so to do then as they did do For the practice of the Church argueth that the Custome grew upon this Order of the Apostle to referre their causes to the chief of the Church as the Church that is to the Bishop and Presbyters In the Constitutions of the Apostles ii 47. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Let your Consistories be upon the Mundayes that if there arise opposition to your sentence having leisure till the Sabbath you may set the opposition straight and make them friends that are at variance among themselves against the Lords day And the Deacons also an◠Presbyters be present at the Consistory judging without respect of persons as men of God c. 45. afore 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 But suffer not the Magistrates of the world to give sentence on ours Not withdrawing obedience
down their throat the form of the Masse was related afore Vt nobis Corpus Sanguis fiat dilectissimi filii tui Domini nostri Jesu Christi and it was shewed that Transubstantiation is not contained in these words Neverthelesse because there might be offense taken at the words upon the sense of those that use them we see them altered into those terms wherein the truth of that which is done is most excellently expressed to the intent of the Scripture and true sense of the Primitive Church in these words Heare us O mercifull Father and those which follow In like sort because the very term of Offering and Sacrifice though used with a farre other meaning then the Church of Rome professeth seemeth to sound their meaning it is not onely removed out of the Prayer for the whole state of Christs Church but the prayer it self removed to stand afore the Consecration as we conjectured it did stand in the Africane Churches and not after it to give opinion that Christ present by Consecration was sacrificed then for the quick and dead as the Church of Rome imagineth Of the rest of the Service of the Eucharist I shall need to say nothing having shewed that in the ancient Church as with us the time of communicating was transacted with Psalmes after that Thanksgiving the dismission upon that The people is dismissed with the blessing in our Service as in the most ancient form related in the Constitutions of the Apostles and so in the Reformed Churches of France though they use that of Moses still frequented by the Synagogue In the Service prescribed for Lords dayes and Festivalls when the Eucharist is not celebrated it is not strange if something be added above the ordinary course to make it more solemn though it had been rather to be wished that the world were disposed for the true solemnity of it Is the voice of the Law calling us to mind our offenses and moving to crave pardon and grace for the future nothing to the Service of God The Lessons of the Epistles and Gospels belong indeed to the first part of the Service as hath been shewed but shall we take them to come from the Masse where they are last found or from S. Hierome from whom they seem first to have come And was it not convenient in them to remember what the Church celebrateth at severall seasons and solemnities of the yeare and to promote the edification of the Church and instruction of the people in the mysteries of the faith by giving Preachers a subject of their Sermons sutable to those solemnities Last of all though the world is not disposed to the continuall celebration of the Eucharist yet was it requisite in reverence to the Apostles Order and the universall practice of the Church that the prayer for all states of the same should be used at almost all solemn Assemblies which because it alwayes went along with the Eucharist as it is used serves to put us in mind what is wanting In fine though all Forms of Service devised by men must needs remain disputable and happy it is when so they are but upon slight matters so my hope is that from hence will appear that the form which we use deserves this commendation that it is possible to alter it for the better but easie to alter it for the worse Thus farre upon the Principles propounded in the beginning of things remembred in the Scripture concerning the publick Service of God and the most ancient and generall practice of the Church to expound them I have discoursed the substance and form of Gods Publick Service at solemn Assemblies for that purpose the circumstances of it and the particular form which we use Of the rest of Ecclesiasticall Offices and the Course we use in them it was not my purpose to say any thing at the present In which neverthelesse the reasons hitherto disputed will easily take place to show both that it is for the edification of the Church that the performance of them be solemn and by prescript form and that the form which we use is exceeding commendable CHAP. XI How the Form of Publick Service is ordered Dependance of Churches is from the Apostles for that and other purposes How the preaching of Lay men imports Schisme The good of the Order of Publick Service ANd now without further dispute it is to be seen what is prescribed concerning the Publick Service of God in the Scriptures and what is left to be ordered by humane appointment The particular Offices whereof it consisteth of Publick Prayers and the Praises of God of reading and expounding the Scriptures of the Celebration of the Eucharist and the rest are prescribed and recommended to the Church in the rules and practice of holy Scripture The Order and Form in which they are to be performed is acknowledged on all hands that it ought to be prescript yet is it no where prescribed in the Scriptures but left to humane Ordinance That which is to be Preached is acknowledged on all hands to be referred for the most part to the private endeavours of particular persons not in respect to any immediate inspiration of the holy Ghost otherwise to be quenched but because it is the ordinary means to instruct and admonish whole Congregations in that which most concerneth them of the knowledge and doctrine of the Scriptures Publick Prayers some think are to be ministred according to the disposition and discretion of particular guides of particular Congregations by virtue of the Apostles Ordinance forbidding to Quench the spirit Here it is proved that because it is confessed that the Grace of praying by immediate inspiration is not now extant therefore the purpose of this Ordinance ceaseth and that the ordinary rule of the edification of the Church to be attained by the Order and Comlinesse of these things which are done at publick Assemblies is followed to farre more purpose in the use of a form prescript and uniform It is further here to be observed that whatsoever may concern the honour of God the unity of the Church the truth of Religion and the recommendation of it is most effectually to be procured as procured it was from the beginning of our Faith by the dependance of Churches visibly derived from the appointment and ordinance of the Apostles It hath been declared that according to that which was done by Barnabas and Paul ordaining Presbyters through the Churches Acts xiv 22. according to that which Titus is instructed to ordain Presbyters through the Cities Titus 1 3. that is Colledges of Presbyters to order the Churches founded in populous Cities so throughout the whole Christian world were all Churches of Cities thought meet for their greatnesse whether instituted by the Apostles or propagated thence governed by Presbyteries or Colledges of Presbyters the Heads whereof were Bishops in Succession to the Apostles We know the Gospel attained to the Countreys and Territories lying under these Cities upon the preaching of
temporibus causis uniuscujusque Sic Apostolos observasse nullum aliud imponentes jugum certorum ab omnibus obeundorum jejuniorum proinde nec stationum quae ipsae suos dies habeant quartae feriae sextae passivè tamen currant neque sub lege praecepti Therefore otherwise beside the dayes on which the Bridegroom was taken away they say we are to fast indifferently arbitrarily not upon command of the new discipline according to each mans times and occasions And that so the Apostles observed imposing no other yoke of certain Fasts to be performed of all neither by the same reason of Stations which they say have also their dayes of Wednesday and Friday but of ordinary course under the law of no precept For which cause he calleth these Stations semijejunia or half Fasts c. 13. of that book The Wednesday and Friday Assemblies of the Primitive Christians with Fasting were not of such strict and solemn observance No more were those of Mundayes and Thursdayes in the Synagogue and therefore taken up in imitation of the Synagogue and upon the like reasons The generall whereof is well laid down by S. Hierome upon Gal. iiii 10. His question is how the Church appointing Festivals and set times of Fastings is clear of the Apostles charge upon the Galatians there Ye observe dayes and moneths and years I fear lest I have laboured upon you in vain His answer is first Et nè inordinata congregatio populi fidem imminueret in Christum propterea dies aliqui statuti sunt ut in unum omnes pariter veniremus non quòd celebrior sit dies illa quâ convenimus sed quòd quacunque die conveniendum sit ex mutuo conspectu laetitia major oriatur And lest the disorderly assembling of the people should â—ate faith in Christ therefore certain dayes are appointed for all to assemble at once not because the day on which we assemble is more not able then others but because on what day soever we assemble by seeing one another more gladnesse ariseth Meaning that gladnesse wherewith they celebrated their Festivals So his mind is that all difference of dayes among Christians is in respect to the Order of their Assemblies and that in respect to the work of those Assemblies Again Qui subtiliùs respondere conatur dies omnes aequales esse ait Jejunia autem Congregationes inter dies propter eos à viris prudentibus constitutos qui magis saeculo vacant quà m Deo nec possunt imò nolunt toto in Ecclesia vitae suae tempore congregari ante humanos actus Deo orationum suarum offerre Sacrificium One that indeavoureth to make a more subtle answer saith that all dayes are equall but that Fasts and Assemblies are appointed among other dayes by discreet men for those that spend more time in the world then on God and can not nay will not assemble all dayes of their life in the Church to offer unto God the Sacrifice of their Prayers before humane actions Adding that whereas the Jews Service was confined to certain times that of Christians is alwayes seasonable The Primitive Christians were alwayes assembled alwayes in posture for the Service of God as we reade in the Acts when the number increased there was no expectation of humane reason that they could continue so unanimous in frequenting their Assemblies for that purpose The neglect of them must needs prove an abatement the disorder of them a scandall to the Faith Here the wisdome and the authority of the Church-guides behoved to take place by customing certain times whereof the occasion was justest to confine men from Secular imployments to better purposes And how this course prevailed in matter of Festivals I referre to those well known words of S. Augustine Ep. cxviii where being to instance in some universall custome of the whole Church Sicuti saith he quòd Domini Passio Resurrectio Asscensio in Coelum Adventus de Coelo Spiritûs sancti anniversariâ solennitate celebrantur siquid aliud tale occurrit quod servatur ab universa quacunque se diffundit Ecclesia As that the Passion the Resurrection and Ascension of our Lord into Heaven and the Coming of the Holy Ghost from Heaven is celebrated with yearly solemnity and if there be any thing else which all the Church wheresoever dispersed observeth As for times of Fasting the answer of our Lord importeth two things First that his purpose was that the outward freedome which he allowed his Disciples for the time should symbolize with the inward comfort which the Gospel professeth and conduct and train them as trained they were by his Doctrine in divers particulars by corporall to spirituall things to understand it The second the reason of this purpose because they were old vessels for the present which a strict discipline for the present might cause to flie in pieces but when the new wine of the Holy Ghost should make the vessels new into which it was put on the day of Pentecost then should they Fast then should they be willing to undertake the discipline which their Profession suited with Accordingly we may find them serving God with Prayer and Fasting Acts xiii 3 4. xiiii 23. But because disorder or coldnesse in this voluntary performance might disadvantage the Faith it soon proved time to bring those voluntary observances to set rules of practice These causes thus disposing the Church and the President of the Synagogue directing not to do lesse what course should it observe but in stead of Mundayes and Thursdayes used in the Synagogue to practice Wednesdayes and Fridayes for this purpose holding in them a convenient distance from the Lords day as those other did from the Sabbath Their Writers tell us besides the reason specified out of Maimoni afore that they might not rest three dayes from hearing the Law that they made choice of Mundayes and Thursdayes in regard of some great calamities that befell their nation upon those dayes What marvell is it if the Church had regard to those which befell our Lord on the Wednesday and Friday the other Morall reason of assembling once in three dayes for Gods Service concurring Those ancient Christians of Tertullians time conceived that the Fast afore Easter is appointed in the Scripture which saith The dayes will come that the Bridegroom shall be taken from among you and then shall ye Fast in those dayes and Tertullian is content to have it believed because Montanus required that and more But S. Augustine found that there is a command in Scripture to Fast but no time commanded when it shall be done Ep. lxxxvi So he would have accepted their reason as an allusion handsomely symbolizing with the nature of Fasting but the appointment he must needs referre to the Custome of the Church and the Ordinance of the Guides of it It is not much otherwise with those other dayes wherewith some inlarged the Fast afore Easter even afore Ireneus his