Guilty in any kind of such a breach or the breach of such an Vnity This then now insisted on being the union of the Church of Christ as visibly professing the word according to his own minde when I have laid down some generall foundations of what is to ensue I shall consider whether we are guilty of the breach of this Vnion and argue the severall pretensions of men against us especially of the Romanists on this account 1. I confesse that this union of the generall visible Church was once comprehensive of all the Churches in the world the Faith once delivered to the Saints being received amongst them From this unity it is taken also for granted that a separation is made and it continnes not as it was at the first institution of the Churches of Christ though some small breaches were made upon it immediately after their first planting The Papists say as to the Europaean Churches wherein their and our concernment principally lyes this breach was made in the dayes of our forefathers by their departure from the common faith in those Ages though begunne by a few some Ages before We are otherwise minded and affirme that this secession was made by them and their Predecessors in Apostacy in severall generations by severall degrees which we manifest by comparing the present profession and worship with that in each kind which we know was at first embraced because we find it Instituted At once then we say this Schisme lyes at their doors who not only have deviated from the common faith themselves but do also actually cause and attempt to destroy temporally and eternally all that will not joyne with them therein For as the mystery of iniquity began to worke in the Apostles dayes so we have a testimony beyond exception in the complaint of those that lived in them that not long after the operation of it became more effectuall and the infection of it to be more diffused in the Church This is that of Hegesyppus in Eusebius Eccles Hist lib. 3. cap. 26. who affirmes that the Church remained a Virgin whilst the Apostles lived pure and uncorrupted but when that sacred Society had ended it's pilgrimage and the generation that heard and received the word from them were fallen asleep many false doctrines were preached and divulged therein I know who hath endeavoured to elude the sence of this complaint as though it concerned not any thing in the Church but the despisers and persecutors of it the Gnosticks But yet I know also that no man would so doe but such a one as hath a just confidence of his own ability to make passable at least any thing that he shall venture to say or utter For why should that be referred by Hegesyppus to the Ages after the Apostles and their hearers were dead with an exception against its being so in their days when if the person thus expounding this testimony may be credited the Gnosticks were never more busie nor prevalent then in that time which alone is excepted from the evill here spoken of Nor can I understand how the opposition and persecution of the Church should be insinuated to be the deflowring and violating of its chastity which is commonly a great purifying of it so that speaking of that broaching and preaching of errors which was not in the Apostles times nor in the time of their Hearers the chiefest time of the rage madnes of the Gnosticks such as spotted the pure incorupted Virginity of the church which nothing can attaine unto that is forraigne unto it that which gave originall unto sedition in the Church I am of the mind so I conceive was Eusebius that recited those words that the good man intended corruptions in the Church not out of it nor oppositions to it The processe made in after Ages in a deviation from the unity of the faith till it arrived to that height wherein it is now stated in the Papall Apostacy hath been the work of others to declare therein then I statet the rise and progresse of the present Schisme if it may be so called of the visible Church 2. As to our concernment in this businesse they that will make good a charge against us that we are departed from the Vnity of the Church Catholick it is incumbent on them to evidence that we either doe not believe and make profession of all the Truths of the Gospell indispensably necessary to be known that a man may have a communion with God in Christ and be saved Or 2. That doing so in the course of our lives we manifest and declare a principle that is utterly inconsistent with the belief of those Truths which outwardly we professe or 3. That we adde unto them in opinion or worship that or those things which are in very deed destructive of them or doe any way render them insufficient to be saving unto us If neither of these three can be proved against a man he may justly claime the priviledge of being a member of the visible Church of Christ in the World though he never in all his life be a member of a particular Church which yet if he have fitting opportunity and Advantage for it is his duty to be And thus much be spoken as to the state and condition of the visible Catholick Church and in this sence we grant it to be and the unity thereof In the late practice of men that expression of the Catholick Church hath been an Individuum Vagum few knowing what to make of it A Cothurnus that every one accommodated at pleasure to his own principles and pretensions I have no otherwise described it then did Irenaeus of old said he judicabit omnes eos qui sunt extra veritatem id est extra Ecclesiam Lib 4. cap. 62. and on the same account is a particular Church sometimes called by some the Catholick Quandoque ego Remigius Episcopus de hâc luce transiero tu mihi Haeres esto Sancta venerabilis Ecclesia Catholica urbis Remorum Flodoardus lib. 1. In the sence insisted on was it so frequently described by the Ancients So again Irenaeus Etsi in mundo loquelae dissimiles sunt sed tamen virtus traditionis una eadem est neque hae quae in Germania sunt â—undatae Ecclesiae aliter credunt aut aliter tradunt neque hae quae in Hibernis sunt neque hae quae in Celtis neque hae quae in Oriente neque hae quae in Aegypto neque hae quae in Lybia neque hae quae in medio mundi constitutae Sed sicut sol Creatura Dei in universo mundo unus idem est siâ— lumen praedicatio veritatis ubique lucet lib. 1. cap. 3. to the same purpose Jusâ—in Martyr 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Dialog cum Tryphone The generality of all sorts of men worshipping God in Jesus Christ is the Church we speak of whose extent in his daies Tertullian
of his institutions ceaseth or that he doth not now dispense the gifts and graces of his Spirit to render them usefull is a difficult taske for any man to undertake to evince There is indeed in the institutions of Christ much that answers a naturall principle in men who are on many accounts formed and fitted for society A Confederation and consultation to carrie on any designe wherein the concernment of the individualls doth lye within such bounds and in such order as lyes in a ready way to the end aymed at is exceeding suitable to the principles whereby we are acted and guided as men But he that would hence conclude that there is no more but this and the acting of these principles in this Church constitution whereof we speake and that therefore men may be cast into any prudentiall forme or appoint other wayes and formes of it then those mentioned in the Scripture as appointed and owned takes on himselfe the demonstrating that all things necessarily required to the Constitution of such a Church society are commanded by the Law of nature and therefore allowed of and approved only by Christ so to be wholy morall and to have nothing of instituted worship in them and also he must know that when on that supposition he hath given a probable Reason why never any persons in the world fixed on such societies in all Essentiall things as those seeing they are Naturall that he leaves lesse to the Prudence of men and to the ordering and disposing of things concerning them then those who make them of pure institution all whose circumstances cannot be derived from themselves as those of things purely morall may But this is not of my present consideration 2. Nor shall I consider whether perpetuity be a property of the Church of Christ in this sence that is not whether a Church that was once so may cease to be so which it is known I plead for in the instance of the Church of Rome not to mention others but whether by vertue of any promise of Christ there shall alwayes be somewhere in the world a visible Church visibly celebrating his Ordinances Luc. 1. 33. He shall raigne over the house of Jacob for ever and of his Kingdome there shall be no end is pleaded to this purpose But that any more but the spirituall raigne of Christ in his Catholick Church is there intended is not proved Mat. 16. 18. upon this Rock will I build my Church is also urged but to intend any but true Believers and that as such in that promise is wholly to enervate it and to take away its force and efficacy Mat. 18. 18 20. declares the presence of Christ with his Church where ever it be not that a Church in the regard treated of shall be To the same purpose are other expressions in the Scripture As I will not deny this in Generall so I am unsatisfyed as to any particular instance for the making of it good It is said that true Churches were at first planted in England how then or by what means did they cease so to be How or by what Act did God unchurch them They did it themselves Meritoriously by Apostacy and Idolatry God Legally by his Institution of a Law of rejection of such Churches If any shall aske How then is it possible that any such Churches should be raised a new I say that the Catholick Church mysticall and that visibly professing being preserved entire he that thinketh there needs a miracle for those who are members of them to joyne in such a Society as those now spoken of according to the Institution of Christ is a person delighting in needlesse scruples Christ hath promised that where two or three are gathered together in his name he will be in the midst of them Mat. 18. 20. It is now supposed with some hope to have it granted that the Scripture being the power of God to Salvation hath Rom. 1. 16. a sufficient efficacy and energie in it selfe as to its own kind for the conversion of Soules yea let us till opposition be made to it take it for granted that by that force and efficacy it doth mainly and principally evince its own Divinity or divine Originall Those who are contented for the honour of that word which God delighteth to magnify to grant this Supposition will not I hope think it impossible that though all Church state should cease in any place and yet the Scripture by the providence of God be there in the hand of individualls preserved two or three should be called converted and regenerated by it For my part I think he that questions it must doe it on some corrupt principle of a secondary dependent Authority in the word of God as to us with which sort of men I doe not now deale I aske whether these converted persons may nor possibly come together or assemble themselves in the name of Jesus may they not upon his command and in Expectation of the accomplishment of his promise so come together with Resolution to doe his will and to exhort one another thereto Zech. 3. 10. Mal. 3. 10. Truly I believe they may in what part of the world soever their lot is fallen Here lye all the difficulties whether being come together in the name of Christ they may doe what he hath commanded them or no whether they may exhort and stirre up one another to doe the will of Christ Most certain it is that Christ will give them his presence therewithall his Authority for the performance of any duty that he requireth at their hands Were not men angry troubled and disappointed there would be little difficulty in this businesse But of this elsewhere 3. Upon this supposition that particular Churches are Institutions of Jesus Christ which is granted by all with whom I have to doe I proceed to make enquiry into their Vnion and Communion that so we may know wherein the bonds of them doe consist 1. There is a double foundation fountain or cause of the Vnion of such a Church the one externall procuring commanding the other internall inciting directing assisting The first is the Institution of Jesus Christ before mentioned requiring Peace and Order Vnion Consent and Agreement in and among all the members of such a Church all to be regulated ordered and bounded by the Rules Laws Prescripts which from him they have received for their walking in those Societies The Latter is that Love without dissimulation which alwaies is or which alwaies ought to be between all the members of such a Church exerting it selfe in their respective duties one towards another in that holy combination whereunto they are called and enter'd for the Worship of God whether they are those which lye in the levell of the equality of their common interest of being Church-members or those which are required of them in the severall differences whereby on any account whatever they are distinguished one from another
which at the same time is sub Iudice in its own The like also may be said of the Church of Ephesus Act. 20. 17. Rev. 2. 1. Nor is it about a meer denomination that we contend but the Vnion forme of such a church and if more Churches then one were together called a Church it is from their participation of the nature of the generall visible Church not of that which is particular and the seate of Ordinances So where Paul is said to persecute the Church of God Gal. 1. 13. it is spoken of the Professors of the Faith of Christ in generall and not to be restrained to the Churches of Iudaea of whom he speakes v. 22 23. seeing his rage actually reached to Damascus a City of another Nation Act. 22. 5 6. and his desigue was 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 That by the Church mentioned 1 Cor. 12. 28. 1 Cor. 10. 32. Eph. 3. 21. is intended the whole visible Church of Christ as made up into one body or Church by a collection of all particular Churches in the world by lesser and greater Assemblies a thing that never was in the world nor ever will be is denyed and not yet by any that I know proved not that I am offended at the name of the Church of England though I think all professors as such are rather to be called so then all the Congregations That all professors of the truth of the Gospell throughout the world are the visible Church of Christ in the sence before explained is granted So may on the same account all the professors of that truth in England be called the Church of England But it is the institution of lesser and greater Assemblies comprising the representatives of all the Churches in the world that must give Being and Union to the visible Church in the sence pleaded for throughout the world or in this Nation that bounded to this relation by vertue of the same institution that is to be proved But of what there is or seemes to be of Divine Institution in this order and fabrick what of humane Prudent Creation what in the matter or manner of it I cannot assent unto I shall not at present enter into the consideration but shall only as to my purpose in hand take up some principles which lye in common between the men of this perswasion and my selfe with some others otherwise minded Now of these are the ensuing Assertions 1. No man can possibly be a member of a Nationall Church in this sense but by vertue of his being a member of some particular Church in the Nation which concurrs to the making up of the Nationall Church As a man doth not legally belong to any County in the Nation unlesse he belong to some Hundred or Parish in that County this is evident from the nature of the thing it self Nor is it pleaded that we are one Nationall Church because the people of the Nation are generally baptized and doe professe the true faith but because the particular Congregations in it are ruled and so consequently the whole by lesser and greater Assemblies I suppose it will not be on second thoughts insisted on that particular congregations agreeing solemnely in Doctrine and worship under one civill Government doe constitute a nationall Church for if so its forme and unity as such must be given it meerly by the civill Government 2. No man can recede from this Church or depart from it but by departing from some particular Church therein At the same door that a man comes in he must goe out If I cease to be a member of a Nationall Church it is by the ceasing or abolishing of that which gave me originall right thereunto which was my relation to the particular Church whereof I am 3. To make men members of any particular Church or Churches their owne consent is required All men must admit of this who allow it free for a man to choose where he will fix his habitation 4. That as yet at least since possibly we could be personally concerned who are now alive no such Church in this Nation hath been formed It is impossible that a man should be guilty of offending against that which is not We have not separated from a Nationall Church in the Presbyterian sence as never having seen any such thing unlesse they will say we have separated from what should be 5. As to the state of such a Church as this I shall only adde to what hath been spoken before the judgement of a very Learned and famous man in this case whom I the rather name because professedly engaged on the Presbyterians side It is Moses Amyraldus the present professor of Divinity aâ— Saumur whose words are these that follow Scio nonnunquam appellari particulareÌ„ Ecclesiam communionem ac veluti confoederationem plurium ejusmodi societatum quas vel ejufdem linguae usus vel eadem Rei-pub forma the true spring of a Nationall Church unà cum ejusdem disciplinae regimine consociavit Sic appellatur Ecclesia Gallicana Anglicana Germanica particularis ut distinguatur ab Vniversali illa Christianorum societate quae omnes Christiani nominis nationes complectitur At uti supra diximus Ecclesiae nomen non proprie convenire societati omnium Christianorum eo modo quo convenit particularibus Christianorum coetibus sic consequens est ut dicamus Ecclesiae nomen non competere in eam multarum Ecclesiarum particularium consociationeÌ„ eodem plane modo Vocetur ergo certe Ecclesiaâ—uÌ„ quae sunt in Gallia Communio inter ipsas Ecclesia si Ecclesia est multarum Ecclesiarum confoederatio non si nomen Ecclesiae ex usu Scripturae sacrae accipiatur Paulus enim varias Ecclesias particulares quae erant in Achaia Ecclesia Achaiae nuncupat non Ecclesiam Achajae vel Ecclesiam Achaicam Amyral Disput de Ecclesiae Nom. Defin. Thes 28. These being if I mistake not things of mutuall acknowledgenent for I have not laid down any principles peculiar to my selfe and those with whom I consent in the way of the worship of God which yet we can justly plead in our own defence this whole businesse will be brought to a speedy issue Only I desire the Reader to observe that I am not pleading the right liberty and duty of gathering Churches in such a state of professors as that of late and still amongst us which is built on other principles and Hypotheses then any as yet I have had occasion to mention but am only in generall considering the true notion of Schisme and the charge mannaged against us on that single account which relates not to gathering of Churches as simply considered I say then 1. Either we have been members by our own voluntary consent according to the mind of Christ of some particular congregations in such a Nationall church that as de facto part of such a church or we have not If we have not
the Church-Catholick visible 3. For a particular Church of some place wherein the instituted worship of God in Christ is celebrated according to his minde From the Rise nature of the things themselves doth this distinction of the signification of the word Church arise for whereas the Church is a society of men called out of the world It is evident there is mention of a twofold call in Scripture one effectuall according to the purpose of God Rom. 8. 28. the other only externall The Church must be distinguished according to its answer and obedience to these calls which gives us the two first states and considerations of it And this is confessed by the ordinary glosse ad Rom. 8. Vocatio exterior fit per Praedicatores est communis bonorum malorum interior vero tantum est Electorum And whereas there are Lawes and externall rules for joynt communion given to them that are called which is confessed the necessity of Churches in the last acceptation wherein obedience can alone be yeilded to those Laws is thereby established In the first sence the Church hath as such the properties of perpetuity invisibility infallibility as to all necessary meanes of Salvation attending of it not as notes whereby it may be known either in the whole or any considerable part of it but as certaine Adjuncts of its nature and existence Neither are there any signes of lesse or more certainty whereby the whole may be discerned or known as such though there are of the Individualls whereof it doth consist In the second the Church hath perpetuity visibility infallibility as qualifyed above in a secondary sence namely not as such not as visible and confessing but as comprizing the individualls whereof the Catholick Church doth consist For all that truely believe professe though all that professe doe not truely believe Whether Christ hath had alwayes a Church in the last sence and Acceptation of the word in the world is a most needlesse enquiry nor are we concerned in it any farther then in other matters of fact that are recorded in story though I am apt to believe that although very many in all Ages kept up their station in Relation to the Church in the two former acceptations yet there was in some of them scarce any visible Society of worshippers so far answering the institution of Christ as to render them fit to be owned and joyned withall as a visible particular Church of Christ but yet though the notions of men were generally corrupt the practice of all professours throughout the world whereof so little is recorded at least of them that did best is not rashly to be determined of Nor can our Judgement be censured in this by them who think that when Christ lay in the Grave there was no Believer left but his Mother and that the Church was preserved in that one person So was Bernard minded Tractat. de pass Dom. ego sum vitis sâ—la per illud triste sabbathum stetit in fide salvata fuit Ecclesia in ipsa sola Of the same minde is Marsilius in Sent. Quaest 20. Art 3. as are also others of that sort of men see Bannes in 2. 2. Thom. Quaest. 1. Art 10. I no way doubt of the perpetuall existence of innumerable Believers in every age and such as made the profession that is absolutely necessary to salvation one way or other though I question a regular association of men for the celebration of instituted worship according to the mind of Christ The 7000 in Israel in the dayes of Elijah were members of the Church of God and yet did not constitute a Church state among the ten Tribes But these things must be farther spoken to I cannot but by the way reminde a learned Person with whom I have formerly occasionally had some debate in print about Episcopacy and the state of the first Churches of a mistake of his which he might have prevented with a little enquiry into the judgement of them whom he undertook to confute at a venture I having said that there was not any ordinary Church Officer instituted in the first times relating to more Churches in his Office or to any other Church then a single particular Congregation He replyes that this is the very same which his memory suggested to him out of the Saints Beliefe printed 12 or 14 yeares since where instead of that Article of the Apostolick Symbole the holy Catholick Church this very Hypothesis was substituted If he really believed that in professing I owned no instituted Church with Officers of one denomination in Scripture beyond a single sence v. 24. saith the Apostle I fill up that Congregation I renounced the Catholick Church or was any way necessitated so to doe I suppose he may by what hath now been expressed be rectifyed in his Apprehension If he was willing only to make use of the advantage wherewith he supposed himselfe accommodated by that expression to presse the perswasion owned in the minds of ignorant men who could not but startle at the noyse of denying the Catholick Church it may passe at the same rate that most of the reports in such discourses are to be allowed at But to proceed In the first sence the word is used Mat. 16. 28. upon this rock will I build my Church and the gates of Hell shall not prevaile against it this is the Church of the Elect redeemed justifyed sanctifyed ones that are so built on Christ and these only and all these are interested in the promise made to the Church as such in any sence but is peculiarly made therein to every one that is truely properly a part member of that Church Who and who only are interested in that promise Christ himselfe declares Joh. 6. 40. Joh. 10 28 29. Joh. 17. 20 24. they that will apply this to the Church in any other sence must know that it is incumbent on them to establish the promise made to it unto every one that is a true member of the Church in that sence which whatever be the sence of the promise I suppose they will find difficult worke of Eph. 5. 25 26 27. Christ loved the Church and gave himselfe for it that he might sanctify and cleanse it with the washing of water by the word that he might present it to himselfe a Glorious Church not having spot or wrinkle or any such thing He speakes only of those whom Christ loved antecedently to his dying for them whereof his love to them was the cause who they are is manifest Joh. 10. 15. Joh. 17. 17. And those on whom by his death he accomplished the effects mentioned of washing cleansing and sanctifying bringing them into the Condition promised to the bride the Lambs wife Rev. 19. 8. which is the new Jerusalem Rev. 21. 2. of elected saved ones v. 27. Col. 1. 18. containes an expression of the same light and evidence Christ is the head of the body the
Church not only a governing head to give it Rules and Lawes but as it were a Naturall head unto the body which is influenced by him with a new spirituall life which Bellarmine professeth against as any requisite condition to the members of the Catholick Church which he pleadeth for In that same which is behind of the afflictions of Christ in my flesh for his bodies sake which is the Church which assertion is exactly paralell to that of 2 Tim. 2. 10. Therefore I endure all things for the Elects sake that they may obtaine Salvation so that the Elect and the Church are the same persons under severall considerations and therefore even a particular Church on the account of its participation of the nature of the Catholick is called Elect 1 Pet. 5. 13. and so the Church Mat. 16. 18. is expounded by our Saviour himselfe Mat. 22. 24. But to prove at large by a multiplication of Arguments and testimonies that the Catholick Church or Mysticall body of Christ consists of the whole number of the Elect as Redeemed Justifyed Sanctifyed Called Believing and yeilding obedience to Christ throughout the world I speake of it as Militant in any one Age and of them only were as needlessly actum agere as a man can well devise It is done already and that to the purpose uncontroulably terque quaterque And the substance of the doctrine is delivered by Aquinas himselfe p. 3. Q. 8. A. 3. In briefe the summe of the inquiry upon this head is concerning the matter of that Church concerning which such glorious things are spoken in Scripture namely that it is the Spouse the Wife the Bride the Sister the only one of Christ his Dâ—ve undefiled his Temple Elect Redeemed his Sione his Body his new Jerusalem concerning which inquiry the Reader knowes where he may abundanly find satisfaction That the asserting the Catholick Church in this sence is no new Apprehension is known to them who have at all looked backward to what was past before us Omnibus consideratis saith Austin puto me non temere dicere alios ita esse in domo dei ut ipsâ— etiam sint eadem domus Dei quae dicitur aedificari supra petram quae unica columba appellatur quae sponsa pulchra sine macula ruga hortus conclusus fons signatus patens aquae vivae paradisus cum fructu pomorum alios autem ita constat esse in domo ut non pertineant ad compagem domus Sed sicut esse palea dicitur in frumentis de Bapt. lib. 1. cap. 51. who is herein followed by not a few of the Papists hence saith Biel. accipitur etiam Ecclesia pro tota multitudine praedestinatorum in Canon Miss Lec 22. In what sence this Church is invisible was before declared Men elected redeemed justifyed as such are not visible for that which makes them so is not But this hinders not but that they may be so upon other Consideration sometimes to more sometimes to fewer yea they are so alwayes to some Those that are may be seen and when we say they are visible we do not intend that they are actually seen by any that we know but that they may be so Bellarmine gives us a description of this Catholick Church as the name hath of late been used at the pleasure of men and wrested to serve every designe that was needfull to be carryed on to the interest which he was to contend for but in it self perfectly ridiculous He tells us out of Austine that the Church is a living Body wherein is a body and a soule thence saith he the soule is the internall graces of the spirit Faith Hope and Love the body is the externall profession of Faith some are of the soul and body perfectly united to Christ by faith and the profession of it some are of the soule that are not of the body as the Catechumeni which are not as yet admitted to be members of the visible Church but yet are true believers Some saith he are of the body that are not of the soul who having no true grace yet out of hope or temporall feare doe make profession of the faith and these are like the haire nailes and ill humours in an humane body Now saith Bellarmine our definition of a Church comprizeth only this last sort whilst they are under the head the Pope which is all one as if he had defined a man to be a dead creature composed of haire nailes and ill humours under an hat but of the Church in this sence so farre It remaineth then that we enquire what is the Vnion which the Church in this sense hath from the wisdome of its head Jesus Christ That it is one that hath an union with its head and in it selfe is not questioned It is one sheepfold one Body one spouse of Christ his only one as unto him and that it might have onenesse in it selfe with all the fruits of it our Saviour praies Joh. 17. 19 20 21 22 23. the whole of it is described Eph. 4. 15 16. may grow up into him in all things which is the head even Christ from whom the whole body fitly joyned together and compacted by that which every joynt supplieth according to the effectuall working in the measure of every part maketh increase of the body to the edifying it selfe in love And of the same importance is that of the same Apostle Col 2. 19. not holding the head from which all the body by joynts and bands having nourishment ministred and knit together increaseth with the increase of God Now in the union of the Church in every sense there is considerable both the formalis ratio of it whence it is what it is and the way and meanes whereby it exerts it selfe and is usefull and active in communion The first in the Church as now stated consists in its joynt holding the head and growing up into him by vertue of the communication of supplies unto it therefrom for that end purpose That which is the formall Reason and cause of the Union of the members with the Head is the formall Reason and Cause of the Union of the members with themselves The Originall Vnion of the members is in and with the Head and by the same have they union with themselves as one body Now the inhabitation of the same Spirit in him and them is that which makes Christ Personall and his Church to be one Christ mysticall 1 Cor. 12. 12. Peter tells us that we are by the promises made partakers of the Divine Nature 2 Pet. 1. 4. we are 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 we have communion with it that 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 is no more but 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 I cannot easily consent Now it is in the person of the Spirit whereof we are by the promise made partakers he is the Spirit of promise Eph. 1. 13. promised by God to Christ Act. 2. 33. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉
the Gospell and communion thereof CHAP. V. Of the Catholick Church visible Of the Nature thereof In what sense the Vniversality of Professors is called a Church Amiraldus his Judgement in this businesse The Vnion of the Church in this sense wherein it consists Not the same with the Vnion of the Church Catholick Nor that of a particular instituted Church Not in relation to any one officer or more in subordination to one another Such a subordination not proveable 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 of the Nicene Synod Of generall Councells Vnion of the Church visible not in a generall Councell The true Vnity of the Vniversality of professors asserted Things necessary to this union Story of a Martyr at Bagdat The Apostacy of Churches from the unity of the Faith Testimony of Hegesippus Vindicated Papall Apostacy Protestants not guilty of the breach of this Vnity The Catholick Church in the sence insisted on granted by the Ancients Not a Politicall body THe Second generall notion of the Church as it is usually taken signifies the Vniversality of men professing the Doctrine of the Gospell and obedience to God in Christ according to it throughout the World This is that which is commonly called the visible Catholick Church which now together with the union which it hath in its selfe and how that Unity is broken falls under consideration That all Professors of the Gospell throughout the World called to the knowledge of Christ by the Word doe make up and constitute his visible Kingdome by their professed subjection to him and so may be called his Church I grant That they are precisely so called in Scripture is not unquestionable What relation it stands in to all particular Churches whether as a Genus to its Species or as a Totum to its parts hath lately by many been discussed I must crave leave to deny that it is capable of filling up or of being included in any of these denominations and Relations The Vniversall Church we are speaking of is not a thing that hath as such a specificative forme from which it should be called an Vniversall Church as a particular hath for its ground of being so called It s but a collection of all that are duely called Christians in respect of their profession nor are the severall particular Churches of Christ in the world so parts and members of any Catholick Church as that it should be constituted or made up by them and of them for the order and purpose of an instituted Church that is the cellebration of the worship of God and Institutions of Jesus Christ according to the Gospell which to assert were to overthow a remarkable difference between the oeconomy of the Old Testament the New Nor do I think that particular Congregations doe stand unto it in the Relation of Species unto a Genus in which the whole nature of it should be preserved and comprized which would deprive every one of membership in this Vniversall Church which is not joyned actually to some particular Church or Congregation then which nothing can be more devoid of truth To debate the thing in particular is not my present intention nor is needfull to the purpose in hand The summe is the Vniversall Church is not so called upon the same account that a particular Church is so called The formal Reason constituting a particular Church to be a particular Church is that those of whom it doth consist doe joyne together according to the minde of Christ in the excercise of the same numericall Ordinances for his worship And in this sence the Vniversal Church cannot be said to be a Church as though it had such a particular forme of its own which that it hath or should have is not only false but impossible But it is so called because all Christians throughout the world excepting some individuall persons providentially excluded do upon the enjoyment of the same preaching of the word the same Sacraments administred in specie profes one common faith and hope but to the joynt performance of any exercise of Religion that they should heaâ—e one Sermon together or partake of one Sacrament or have one Officer for their Rule and Government is ridiculous to imagine nor doe any professe to think so as to any of the particulars mentioned but those only who have profit by the fable As to the description of this Church I shall acquiesce in that lately given of it by a very learned Man Saith he Ecclesia Vniversalis est communio seu societas omnium coetuum I had rather he had said and he had done it more agreeable to principles by himselfe laid down omnium Fidem Christianam profitentium sive illi ad Ecclesias aliquas particulares pertineant sive non pertineant qui Religionem Christianam profitentur consistens in eo quod tametâ—â— neque exercitia pietatis uno numero frequentent neque Sacramenta eadem numero participent neque uno eodemque omnino ordine regantur gubernentur unum tamen corpus in eo constituunt quôd eundem Christum Servatorem habere se profitentur uno in Evangelio propositum iisdem promissionibus comprehensum quas obsignant confirmant Sacramenta ex eadem institutione pendentia Amyrald Thes de Eccles nom defin The. 29. There being then in the World a great multitude which no man can number of all Nations Kindreds people and languages professing the doctrine of the Gospell not tied to mountaines or hills Joh. 4. but worshipping 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 1 Cor. 1. 2. 1 Tim. 2. 8. Let us consider what union there is amongst them as such wrapping them all in the bond thereof by the will and appointment of Jesus Christ and wherein the breach of that union doth consist and how any man is or may be guilty thereof I suppose this will be granted That only Elect believers belong to the Church in this sense considered is a Chimaera feigned in the braines of the Romanists and fastened on the Reformed Divines I wholly assent to Austins dispute on this head against the Donatists and the whole entanglement that hath been about this matter hath arisen from obstinacy in the Papists in not receiving the Catholick Church in the sense mentioned before which to doe they know would be injurious to their interest This Church being visible and professing and being now considered under that constituting difference that the union of it cannot be the same with that of the Catholick Church before mentioned it is cleare from hence that multitudes of men belong unto it who have not the Relation mentioned before to Christ and his body which is required in all comprehended in that union seeing many are called but few are chosen Nor can it consist in a joynt Assembly either ordinary or extraordinary for the celebration of the Ordinances of the Gospell or any one of them as was the case of the Church of the Jewes which met at set times in one place
for the performance of that worship which was then required nor could otherwise be accomplished For as it is not at all possible that any such thing should ever be done considering what is and shall be the estate of Christs visible Kingdome to the end of the World so it is not that I know of pleaded that Christ hath made any such appointment yea it is on all hands confessed at least cannot reasonably be denyed that there is a supersedeas granted to all supposalls of any such duty incumbent on the whole visible Church by the Institution of particular Churches wherein all the Ordinances of Christ are duely to be administred I shall only adde that if there be not an institution for the joyning in the same numericall Ordinances the Vnion of this Church is not really a Church Vnion I mean of an Instituted Church which consists therein but something of another nature Neither can that have the formall Reason of an instituted Church as such which as such can joyne in no one act of the worship of God instituted to be performed in such societies So that he that shall take into his thoughts the condition of all the Christians in the world their present state what it hath been for 1500 years and what it is like to be 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 will easily understand what Church state they stand in and relate unto 3. It cannot possibly have its union by a Relation to any one Officer given to the whole such an one as the Papists pretend the Pope to be For though it be possible that one Officer may have Relation to all the Churches in the World as the Apostles severally had when Paul said the care of all the Churches lay on him who by vertue of their Apostolicall commission were to be received and submitted to in all the Churches in the World being antecedent in office to them yet this neither did nor could make all the Churches one Church no more then in one man were an Officer or Magistrate in every Corporation in England this would make all those Corporations to be one Corporation I doe not suppose the Pope to be an Officer to the whole Church visible as such which I deny to have an union or order capable of any such thing but suppose him an Officer to every particular Church no union of the whole would thence ensue That which is one Church must joyne at least in some one Church act numerically one So that though it should be granted that the Pope were a generall Officer unto all and every Church in the World yet this would not prove that they all made one Church and had their Church-union in subjection to him who was so an Officer to them all because to the constitution of such an Vnion as hath been shewed there is that required which in reference to the universall society of Christians is utterly and absolutely impossible But the non-institution of any such Officer ordinarily to beare rule in and over all the Churches of God hath been so abundantly proved by the Divines of the Reformed Churches and he who alone puts in his claime to that prerogative so clearly manifested to be quite another thing that I will not needlessely goe over that work again something however shall afterwards be remarked as to his pretensions from the principles whereon I proceed in the whole businesse There is indeed by some pleaded a subordination of Officers in this Church tending towards an union on that account as that ordinary Ministers should be subject to Diâ—cesan Bishops they to Arch-Bishops or Metropolitans they again to Patriarchs where some would bound the processe though a parity of Reason would call for a Pope Nor will the Arguments pleaded for such a subordination rest untill they come to be centred in some such thing But 1 before this plea be admitted it must be proved that all these Officers are appointed by Jesus Christ or it will not concerne us who are enquiring solely after his will and the setling of conscience therein To doe this with such an evidence that the Consciences of all those who are bound to yeild obedience to Jesus Christ may appeare to be therein concerned will be a difficult task as I suppose And to settle this once for all I am not dealing with the men of that lazy perswasion that Church affairs are to be ordered by the prudence of our Civill Superiors and Governors and so seeking to justify a non submission to any of their constitutions in the things of this nature or to evidence that the so doing is not Schisme nor do I concerne my selfe in the order and appointment of Ancient times by men assembled in Synods and Councells wherein whatever was the force of their determinations in their own Seasons we are not at all concerned knowing of nothing that is obligatory to us not pleading from Soveraigne Authority or our own consent but it is after things of pure Institution that I am enquiring With them who say there is no such thing in these matters we must proceed on other principles then any yet laid downe Also it must be proved that all these Officers are given and do belong to the Catholick Church as such and not to the particular Churches of severall measures and dimensions to which they relate which is not as yet that I know of so much as pretended by them that plead for this order They tell us indeed of various arbitrary distributions of the World or rather of the Roman Empire into Patriarchats with the dependent Jurisdictions mentioned and that all within the precincts of those Patriarchats must fall within the lines of the subordination subjection and communication before described but as there is no subordination between the Officers of one denomination in the inferior parts no more is there any between the Superior themselves but they are independent of each other Now it is easily discernable that these Patriarchats how many or how few soever they are are particular Churches not any one of them the Catholick nor altogether comprising all that are comprehended in the precincts of it which none will say that ever they did and therefore this may speak something as to a combination of those Churches nothing as to the union of the Catholick as such which they are not Supposing this Assertion to the purpose in hand which it is not at all it would prove only a combination of all the Officers of severall Churches consisting in the subordination and dependance mentioned not of the whole Church it selfe though all the members of it should be at once imagined or fancied as what shall hinder men from fancying what they please to be comprised within the limits of those distributions unles it be also proved that Christ hath instituted severall sorts of particular Churches Parochiall Diocesan Metropoliticall Patriarchall I use the words in the present vulgar acceptation their signification having bin somewhat
of Faith Rom 12. 6. an Vnity of Faith and of knowledge of the Sonne of God Eph 4. 13. a measure of saving Truths the explicite knowledge whereof in man enjoying the use of Reason within and the means of grace without is of indispensible necessary to Salvation without which it is impossible that any soule in an ordinary way should have communion with God in Christ having not light sufficient for converse with him according to the tenour of the Covenant of Grace These are commonly called Fundamentalls or first Principles which are justly argued by many to be clear perspicuous few lying in an evident tendency to obedience Now look what truths are savingly to be believed to render a man a member of the Church Catholick invisible that is whatever is required in any one unto such a receiving of Jesus Christ as that thereby he may have power given to him to become the Son of God the profession of those Truths is required to enstate a man in the unity of the Church visible 2. That no other internall principle of the mind that hath an utter inconsistency with the reall beliefe of the Truths necessary to be professed be manifested by the Professors Paul tells us of some who though they would be called Christians yet they so walked as that they manifested themselves to be Enemies of the crosse of Christ Phil 3. 18. certainly those who on one account are open and manifest enemies of the Crosse of Christ are not on any members of his Church there is one Lord and one Faith required as well as one Baptisme And a protestation contrary to evidence of fact is in all Law Null Let a man professe 10000 times that he believes all the saving truths of the Gospell and by the course of a wicked and prophane conversation evidence to all that he believes no one of them shall his protestation be admitted shall he be accounted a servant in and of my family who will call me Master and come into my house only to doe me and mine a mischiefe not doing any thing I require of him but openly and professedly the contrary Paul saies of such Tit. 5. 15 16. They professe that they know God yet in works they deny him being abominable disobedient and unto every good work reprobate which though peculiarly spoken of the Jewes yet contains a generall Rule that mens profession of the knowledge of God contradicted by a course of wickednesse is not to be admitted as a thing giving any priviledge whatever 3. That no thing opinion error or false doctrine everting or overthrowing any of the necessary saving Truths professed as above be added in with that profession or deliberately be professed also This principle the Apostle layes downe and proves Gal. 5. 3 4. notwithstanding the profession of the Gospell he tells the Galatians that if they were bewitched to professe also the necessity of Circumcision and keeping of the Law for Justification that Christ or the profession of him would not profit them On this account the Ancients excluded many Hereticks from the name of Christians so Justin of the Marcionites and others 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 We are at length then arrived to this issue the belief profession of all the necessary saving truths of the Gospell without the manifestation of an internall principle of the mind inconsistent with the beliefe of them or adding of other things in profession that are destructive to the truths so professed is the bond of the unity of the visible professing Church of Christ Where this is found in any man or number of men though otherwise accompanied with many failings sinns and errors the unity of the faith is by him or them so farre preserved as that they are thereby rendred members of the visible Church of Christ and are by him so esteemed Let us suppose a man by bare Reading of the Scriptures brought to him by some providence of God as finding the Bible in the high way and evidenâ—ing their Authority by their own light instructed in the knowledge of the Truths of the Gospell who shall thereupon make profession of them amongst them with whoÌ„ he lives although he be thousands of miles distant from any particular Church wherein the Ordinances of Christ are administred nor perhaps knows there is any such Church in the world much lesse hath ever heard of the Pope of Rome which is utterly impossible he should supposing him instructed only by reading of the Scriptures I aske whether this man making open profession of Christ according to the Gospell shall be esteemed a member of the visible Church in the sence insisted on or no That this may not seem to be such a fiction of a case as may involve in it any impossible supposition which being granted will hold a doore open for other absurdities I shall exemplifie it in its most materiall postulata by a story of unquestionable truth Elmacinus who wrote the story of the Saracens being Secretary to one of the Caliphs at Bagdat informes us that in the yeare 309 of their Hegira about the year 921 of our account Muctadinus the Caliph of Bagdat by the Counsell of his wise men commanded one Huseinus the son of Mansor to be crucified for certaine Poems whereof some verses are recited by the Historian and are thus rendred by Erpenius Laus â—i qui manifestavit humilitatem suam celavit inter nos divinitatem suam permeantem donec coepit in creatura sua apparere sub specie edentis bibentis Jamque aspexit cum Creatura ejus sicuti supercilium obliquum respiciat supercilium From which remnant of his worke it is easily to perceive that the crime whereof he was accused and for which he was condemned and crucifyed was the confession of Jesus Christ the Son of God As he went to the crosse he added says the same Author these that follow Compoâ—ur mens nihil plane habet in se iniquitatis bibendum mihi dediâ— simile ejus quod bibit secit hospitem in hospite And so dyed constantly as it appears in the profession of the Lord Jesus Bagdat was a City built not long before by the Saracens wherein it is probable there were not at that time any Christians abiding Adde now to this story what our Saviour speakes Luck 12. 8. I say unto you whosoever shall confesse me before men him shall the Sonne of man confesse before the Angells of God and considering the unlimitednesse of the expression as to any outward consideration and tell me whether this man or any other in the like condition be not to be reckoned as a subject of Christs visible Kingdome a member of this Church in the world Let us now recall to minde what we have in designe granting for our processe sake that Schisme is the breach of any unity instituted and appointed by Christ in what sence soever it is spoken of our inquiry is whether we are
OF SCHISME The True Nature of it Discovered and Considered With Reference to the present Differences in Religion By JOHN OWEN D. D. OXFORD Printed by L. L. for T. ROBINSON Anno Dom. M. DC.L.VII OF SCHISME CAP. I. Aggravations of the Evil of Shisme from the Authority of the Antients Their incompetency to determine in this case instanced in the sayings of Austine and Hierome The saying of Aristides Judgement of the Antients subjected to disquisition Some mens Advantage in charging others with Schisme The Actors part priviledged The Romanists interest herein The charge of Schisme not to be despised The iniquity of Accusers justifys not the Accused Severall Persons charged with Schisme on severall accounts The designe of this discourse in reference to them Justification of differences unpleasant Attempts for peace and reconciliation considered Severall perswasions hereabouts and endeavours of men to that End Their Issues IT is the manner of men of all perswasions who undertake to treat of Schisme to make their entrance with Invectives against the evills thereof with aggravations of its heinousnesse All men whether intending the Charge of others or their own acquitment esteem themselves concerned so to doe Sentences out of the Fathers determinations of Schoolemen making it the greatest sinne imaginable are usually produced to this purpose A course this is which mens Apprehensions have rendred usefull and the state of things in former dayes easy Indeed whole volumes of the Ancients written when they were Actors in this Cause charging others with the guilt of it consequently with the vehemency of men contending for that wherein their own interest lay might if it were to our purpose be transcribed to this end But as they had the happines to deale with men evidently guilty of many miscarriages and for the most part absurd ad foolish so many of them having fallen upon such a notion of the Catholick Church and Schisme as hath given occasion to many woefull mistakes and much darknesse in the following Ages I cannot so easily give up the nature of this evill to their determination and judgement About the aggravations of its sinfullnesse I shall not contend The evidence which remaines of an indulgence in the best of them 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 in this businesse especially deters from that procedure From what other principle were those words of Augustine Obscurius dixerunt Prophetae de Christo quaÌ„ de Ecclesia puto propterea quia videbant in spiritu contra Ecclesiam homines facturos esse particulas Et de Christo non tantam litem habitutos de Ecclesia magnas contentiones excitaturos Conc. 2. ad Psal 30. Neither the Affirmation it selfe nor the reason assigned can have any better root Is any thing more cleerly and fully prophesy'd on then Christ Or was it possible that good men should forget with what contests the whole Church of God all the World over had been exercised from its infancy about the Person of Christ Shall the tumultuating of a few in a corner of Africk blot out the remembrance of the late diffusâ—on of Arrianisme over the world But Hierom hath given a Rule for the interpretation of what they delivered in their polemicall engagements telling us plainely in his Apology for himselfe to Pammachius That he had not so much regarded what was exactly to be spoken in the Controversy he had in hand as what was fit to lay load upon Jovinian And if we may believe him this was the manner of all men in those dayes If they were engaged they did not what the truth only but what the defence of their cause also required Though I believe him not as to all he mentions yet doubtlesse we may say to many of them as the Apostle in another case 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Though Aristides obteined the name of just for his uprightnesse in the management of his own private affaires yet being ingag'd in the Administration of those of the Common-Wealth he did many things professedly unjust giving this Reason he did them 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Besides the Age wherein we live having by virtue of that precept of our Saviour Call no man Master in a good measure freed it selfe from the bondage of subjection to the dictates of men and the innumerable evills with endlesse intanglements thence insuing because they lived so many hundreds of years before us that course of procedure though reteining its facility hath lost its usefullnesse and is confessedly impertinent What the Scripture expressly saith of this sinne and what from that it sayth may regularly rationally be deduced whereunto we stand and fall shall be afterwards declared And what is spoken suitably thereunto by any of Old or of Late shall be cheerfully also received But it may not be expected that I should build upon their Authority whose principles I shall be necessitated to examine And I am therefore contented to lye low as to any expectation of successe in my present undertaking because I have the prejudice of many Ages the interest of most Christians and the mutuall consent of Parties at variance which commonly is taken for an unquestionable evidence of truth to contend withall But my endeavours being to goe non quà itur sed quà eundum est I am not sollicitous about the event In dealing about this businesse among Christians the Advantage hath been extreamly hitherto on their part who found it their interest to beginne the charge For whereas perhaps themselves were and are of all men most guilty of the Crime yet by their clamarous Accusation putting others upon the defence of themselves they have in a manner cleerly escaped from the triall of their own guilt and cast the issue of the Question purely on them whom they have accused The Actors or Complainants part was so priviledged by some Lawes and Customes that he who had desperately wounded another chose rather to enter against him the frivolous plea that he received not his whole Sword into his body then to stand to his best defence on the complaint of the wounded man An accusation mannaged with the craft of men guilty and a confidence becoming men wronged and innocent is not every ones worke to sleight wave And he is in ordinary judgements immediately acquitted who averrs that his charge is but recrimination What advantage the Romanists have had on this account how they have expatiated in the aggravation of the sinne of Schisme whilst they have kept others on the defence and would faine make the only thing in Question to be whether they are guilty of it or no is known to all And therefore ever since they have been convinced of their disability to debate the things in difference between them and us unto any advantage from the Scripture they have almost wholly insisted on this one businesse wherein they would have it wisely thought that our concernment only comes to the triall knowing that in these things their defence is weake who have
with the issue and successe of them in severall places namely that of enforcing uniformity by a secular power on the one side as was the case in this Nation not many yeares agoe and is yet liked by the most being a suitable judgemement for the most and that of Toleration on the other which is our present condition Concerning them both I dare say that though men of a good zeale and small Experience or otherwise on any account full of their own Apprehensions may promise to themselves much of peace Union and Love from the one or the other as they may be severally favoured by men of different interests in this world in respect of their conducinges to their ends yet that a little Observation of Events if they are not able to consider the causes of things with the light and posture of the minds of men in this Generation will unburden them of the trouble of their expectations It is something else that must give peace unto Christians then what is a product of the prudentiall considerations of men This I shall only adde as to the former of these of enforcing Vniformity as it hath lost its reputation of giving temporall tranquillity to States Kingdomes and Common-wealths which with some is onely valuable whatever became of the soules of men forced to the profession of that which they did not believe the readiest means in the world to roote out all Religion from the hearts of men the letters of which plea are in most Nations in Europe washed out with rivers of bloud and the residue wait their season for the same issue so it continues in the possession of this advantage against the other that it sees and openly complaines of the evill and dangerous consequences of it when against its own where it prevailes it suffers no complaints to lye As it is ludicrously said of Physitians the Effects of their skill lye in the Sunne but their mistakes are covered in the Church-yard So is it with this perswasion what it doth well whilst it prevailes is evident the anxiety of Conscience in some hypocrisie formality no better then Atheisme in others wherewith it is attended are buried out of sight But as I have some while since ceased to be moved by the clamours of men concerning bloudy persecution on the one hand and cursed intolerable toleration on the other by finding all the world over that Events and Executions follow not the Conscientious imbracing of the one or other of these decryed Principles perswasions but are suited to the Providence of God stating the civill interests of the Nations so I am perswaded that a generall Alteration of the State of the Churches of Christ in this world must determine that controversie which when the light of it appeares we shall easily see the vanity of those Reasonings wherewith men are intangled that are perfectly suited to their present condition of Religion But hereof I have spoken elsewhere Farther let any man consider the proposals and attempts that have been made for Ecclesiasticall peace in the world both of old and in these latter dayes let him consult the rescripts of Princes the Edicts of Nations Advices of Politicians that would have the world in quietnesse on any termes Consultations Conferences Debates Assemblies Councells of the Clergy who are commonly Zelots in their severall ways and are by many thought to be willing rather to hurle the whole world into confusion then to abate any thing of the rigor of their opinions and he will quickly assume the liberty of affirming concerning them all that as wise men might easily see flawes in all of them and an unsuitablenesse to the end proposed and as good men might see so much of carnall interest selfe and Hypocrisie in them as might discourage them from any great Expectations so upon many other accounts a better issue was not to be looked for from them then hath been actually obtained which hath for the most part been this that those that could dissemble most deeply have been thought to have the greatest Advantage In Disputations indeed the truth for the most part hath been a gainer but in attempts for Reconciliation those that have come with the least Candor most Fraud Hypocrisy secular baits for the subverting of others have in appearance for a season seem'd to obteine successe And in this Spirit of craft and contention are things yet carryed on in the world Yet I suppose the Parties at variance are so well acquainted at length with each others Principles Arguments Interests Prejudices and reall distance of their causes that none of them expect any Reconciliation but meerly by one Parties keeping its station and the other coming over wholy thereunto And therefore a Romanist in his Preface to a late Pamphlet about Schisme to the two Vniversitys tells us plainly that If we will have any peace we must without limitation submit to and receive those 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 those Commanding Oracles which God by his holy Spouse propoundeth to our Obedience The sence of which expressions we are full well acquainted with And in pursuite of that principle he tells us againe p. 238. That suppose the Church should in necessary points teach errour yet even in that case every child of the Church must exteriorly carry himselfe quiet and not make commotions that is declare against her for that were to seek a cure worse then the disease Now if it seem reasonable to these Gentlemen that we should renounce our sence and Reason with all that understanding which we have or at least are fully convinced that we have of the mind of God in the Scripture and submit blindly to the commands and guidance of their Church that we may have peace and union with them because of their huge interest and advantage which lyes in our so doing we professe our selves to be invincibly concluded under the power of a contrary perswasion and consequently an impossiblity of Reconciliation As to attempts then for Reconciliation between parties at variance about the things of God and the removeall of Schisme by that meanes they are come to this issue among them by whom they have been usually mannaged namely Politicians and Divines that the former perceiving the tenaciousnesse in all things of the latter their promptnesse readinesse to dispute and to continue in so doing with confidence of successe a frame of Spirit that indeed will never praise God nor be usefull to bring forth truth in the world doe judge them at length not to have that prudence which is requisite to advise in matters diffused into such variety of concernments as these are or not able to breake through their unspeakable prejudices and interests to the due improvement of that wisedome they seem to have and the latter observing the facile condescention of the former in all things that may have a consistency with that peace and secular Advantage they aime at doe conclude that notwithstanding all their
pretences they have indeed in such consultations little or no regard to the Truth whereupon having a mutuall diffidence in each other they grow wearie of all endeavours to be carryed on joyntly in this kind the one betaking themselves wholy to keep things in as good state in the world as they can let what will become of Religion the other to labour for successe against their Adversaries let what will become of the world or the peace thereof And this is like to be the state of things untill another Spirit be powred out on the professors of Christianity then that wherewith at present they seeme mostly to be acted The only course then remaining to be fixed on whilst our divisions continue is to enquire wherein the guilt of them doth consist and who is justly charged therewith in especiall what is and who is guilty of the sinne of Schisme And this shall we doe if God permit It may I confesse seem superfluous to adde any thing more on this subject which hath been so fully already handled by others But as I said the present concernement of some fearing God lying beyond what they have undertaken and their endeavours for the most part having tended rather to convince their Adversaries of the insufficiency of their charge and Accusation then rightly and cleerly to state the thing or matter contended about something may be farther added as to the satisfaction of the Consciences of men injustly accused of this Crime which is my aime and which I shall now fall upon CAP. II. The nature of Schisme to be determined from Scripture only This principle by some opposed Necessity of abiding in it Parity of Reason allowed Of the name of Schisme It s constant use in Scripture In things Civill and Religious The whole Doctrine of Schisme in the Epistles to the Corinthians The case of that Church proposed to consideration Schisme entirely in one Church Not in the separation of any from a Church Nor in substraction of obedience from Governours Of the second Schisme in the Church of Corinth Of Clemens Epistle The state of the Church of Corinth in those dayes 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 who 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 what 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 paracia To whom the Epistle of Clemens was precisely written Corinth not a Metropoliticall Church Allowance of what by parity of Reason may be deduced from what is of Schisme affirmed Things required to make a man guilty of Schisme Arbitrary definitions of Schisme rejected That of Austin considered as that also of Basil The common use and acceptation of it in these days Separation from any Church in its own nature not Schisme Aggravations of the evill of Schisme ungrounded The evill of it from its proper nature and consequences evinced Inferences from the whole of this discourse The Church of Rome if a Church the most Schismaticall Church in the world The Church of Rome no Church of Christ A compleat image of the Empire Finall acquitment of Protestants from Schisme on the Principle evinced Peculiarly of them of the late Reformation in England False notions of Schisme the ground of sinne and disorder THe thing whereof we treate being a disorder in the instituted worship of God and that which is of pure Revelation I suppose it a modest request to desire that we may abide solely to that discovery and description which is made of it in Scripture that that alone shall be esteemed Schisme which is there so called or which hath the entire nature of that which is there so called other things may be other crimes Schisme they are not if in the Scripture they have neither the name nor nature of it attributed to them He that shall consider the irreconcilable differences that are among Christians all the world over about this matter as also what hath passed concerning it in former Ages and shall weigh what prejudices the severall parties at variance are intangled with in reference hereunto will be ready to think that this naked appeale to the only common principle amongst us all is so just necessary reasonable that it will be readily on all hands condescended unto But as this is openly opposed by the Papists as a most destructive way of procedure so I feare that when the tendency of it is discovered it will meet with reluctancy from others But let the Reader know that as I have determined 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 so to take the measure of it from the Scripture only Consueâ—udo sine veritate est vetustas erroris Cyp. Ep. ad Pomp. and the sole measure of Evangelicall Truth is this word of whom it was said 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Id verius quod prius id prius quod ab initio id ab initio quod ab Apostolis sayes Tertul It is to me a sufficient answer to that fond question where was your Religion before Luther Where was your Religion in the dayes of Christ and his Apostles My thoughts to this particular are the same with Chrysostomes on the generall account of Truth 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Homil. 3. in Acta But yet least this should seem too streight as being at first view exclusive of the learned debates disputes which we have had about this matter I shall after the consideration of the precise Scripture notion of the name and thing wherein the Conscience of a Believer is alone concerned propose and argue also what by a parity of Reason may thence be deduced as to the Ecclesiasticall common use of them and our concernment in the one and the other The word which is Metaphoricall as to the businesse we have in hand is used in the Scripture both in its primitive native sence in reference to things Naturall as also in the tralatitious use of it about things Politick and Spirituall or Morall In its first sence we have the Noune Mat. 9. 16. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈…〉 in the cloth it 〈…〉 Verbe Mat. 27. 51. 〈…〉 veile of the Temple 〈…〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and the 〈…〉 noting an interruption of 〈…〉 externall power in things me 〈…〉 this is the first sence of 〈…〉 or division of parts befoâ—â—â—ontinued by force or violent dissolâ—◠〈◊〉 The use of the world in a Politicall sence is also frequent Joh. 7. 43 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 there was a division among the multitude some being of one mind some of another Joh. 9. 16. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 there was a division amongst them and cap. 10. 19. likewise So Act. 14. 4. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the multitude of the City was divided and cap. 23. 7. There arose a dissention between the Pharisees and the Sadduces 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the multitude was divided some following one some another of their leaders in that dissention the same thing is expressed by a word answering unto it in Latine Scinditur incertum studia in contraria vulgus And in this sence relating to civill things it is often used
forbearance in the latitude of it as prescribed to us by Christ and it will evidently beare no proportion thereunto So that such differences though arising on reall miscarriages and faults of some because they might otherwise be handled and healed and ought to be so cannot be persisted in without the contempt of the immediate Authority of Jesus Christ If it were considered that he standeth in the Congregation of God Ps 82. 1. That he dwells in the Church in glory as in Sinai in the Holy place Ps 68. 17 18. walking in the mid'st of the Candlesticks Rev. 1. 13. with his eyes upon us as a flame of fire v. 14 his presence and Authority would perhaps be more prevalent with some then they seem to be Againe His wisdome whereby he hath ordered all things in his Church on set purpose that Schisme and divisions may be prevented is no lesse despised Christ who is the Wisdome of the Father 1 Cor. 1. 24. The stone on which are seaven eyes Zech 3. 9. upon whose shoulders the government is laid Is 9. 6 7. hath in his infinite wisdome so ordered all the Officers Orders Gifts Administrations of and in his Church as that this evill might take no place To manifest this is the designe of the Holy Ghost Rom. 12 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1. Cor. 12. Eph. 4. 8 9 10 11 12 13 14. The consideration in particular of this Wisdome of Christ suiting the Officers of his Church in respect of the places they hold of the Authority wherewith from him they are invested the way whereby they are entered into their Function distributing the Gifts of his Spirit in marveilous variety unto severall kinds of usefulnesse and such distance and dissimilitude in the particular members as in a due correspondencie and proportion give comelinesse and beauty to the whole disposing of the order of his worship and sundry ordinances in especiall to be expressive of the highest Love and Vnion pointing all of them against such causelesse divisions might be of use were that my present intendment The Grace and Goodnesse of Christ whence he hath promised to give us one heart and one way to leave us peace such as the World cannot give with innumerable others of the like importance are disregarded thereby So also is his prayer for us with what Affection and Zeale did he powre out his soule to his Father for our union in love That seems to be the thing his heart was chiefely fixed on when he was leaving this World Joh. 17. what weight he layes thereon how thereby we may be known to be his Disciples and the World be convinced that he was sent of God is there also manifested How farre the exercise of Love and Charity is obstructed by it hath been declared The consideration of the Nature Excellency Property Effects Usefulnesse of this Grace in all the Saints in all their ways its especiall designation by our Lord and Master to be the bond of union and perfection in the way and Order instituted for the comely celebration of the Ordinances of the Gospell will adde weight to this aggravation It s constant growing to farther evill in some to Apostacy it selfe its usuall and certaine ending in strife variance debate evill surmisings wrath confusion disturbances publick and private are also to be laid all at its doore What farther of this nature and kind may be added as much may be added to evince the heinousnesseâ— of this sinne of Schisme I shall willingly subscribe unto so that I shall not trouble the Reader in abounding in what on all hands is confessed It is incumbent upon him who would have me to goe farther in the description of this evill then as formerly stated to evince from Scripture another notion of the name or thing then that given which when he hath done he shall not find me refractory In the meane time I shall both consider what may be objected against that which hath been delivered and also discusse the present state of our divisions on the usuall principles and common acception of Schisme if first I may have leave to make some few inferences or deductions from what hath already been spoken and as I hope evinced On supposition that the Church of Rome is a Church of Christ it will appeare to be the most Schismaticall Church in the World I say or supposition that it is a Church and that there is such a thing as a Schismaticall Church as perhaps a Church may from its intestine differences be so not unfitly denominated that is the state and condition thereof The Pope is the head of their Church severall nations of Europe are members of it Have we not seen that head taking his flesh in his teeth tearing his body and his limbs to pieces Have some of them thought on any thing else but arise Peter kill and eate all their dayes Have we not seen this goodly head in disputes about Peters Patrimony and his own Jurisdiction wage warre fight and shed blood the blood of his own members Must we believe Armies raised and battailes fought Townes fired all in pure love and perfect Church order not to mention their old altare contra altare Anti-Popes Anti-Councells look all over their Church on their Potentates Bishops Friars there is no end of their variances What do the Chiefest choisest pillars eldest sonnes and I know not what of their Church at this day doe they not kill destroy and ruine each other as they are able let them not say these are the divisions of the Nations that are in their Church not of the Church for all these Nations on their hypothesis are members of that one Church And that Church which hath no meanes to prevent its members from designed resolved on and continued murthering one of another nor can remove them from its society shall never have me in its communion as being bloudily Schismaticall Noâ— is there any necessity that men should forgoe the respective civill interests by being members of one Church Prejudicate apprehensions of the nature of a Church and its Authority lye at the bottome of that difficulty Christ hath ordained no Church that enwraps such interests as on the account whereof the members of it may murther one another Whatever then they pretend of Vnity and however they make it a note of the true Church as it is a property of it that which is like it amongst them is made up of these two ingredients subjection to the Pope either for feare of their lives or advantage to their livelyhood and a conspiracy for the destruction and suppression of them that oppose their interests wherein they agree like those who maintained Hierusalem in its last Siege by Titus they all consented to oppose the Romans and yet fought out all other things among themselves That they are not so openly clamorous about the differences at present as in former Ages is meerely from the pressure of Protestants round about them
However let them at this day silence the Jesuits and Dominicans especially the Baijans and the Jansenians on the one part and the Molinists on the other Take off the Gallican Church from its Schismaticall refusall of the Councell of Trent Cause the King of Spaine to quit his claime to Sicilie that they need not Excommunicate him every yeare compell the Commonwealth of Venice to receive the Jesuits stop the mouths of the Sorbonists about the Authority of a generall Councell above the Pope and of all those whom opposing the Papall omnipotency they call Politicians quiet the contest of the Franciscans and Dominicans about the Blessed Virgin burne Bellarmines books who almost on every Controversy of Ch. Religion gives an account of their intestine divisions branding some of their opinions as haereticall as that of Medina about Bishops and Presbyters some as Idolatricall as that of Thomas about the worship of the Crosse with latria c. and they may give a better colour to their pretences then any as yet it wears But what need I insist upon this supposition when I am not more certaine that there is any instituted Church in the World owned by Christ as such then I am that the Church of Rome is none properly so called Nor shall I be thought singular in this perswasion if it be duely conâ—idered what this amounts unto Some Learned men of latter daies in this Nation pleading in the justification of the Church of England as to her departure from Rome did grant that the Church of Rome doth not erre in Fundamentalls or maintained no errors remedilesly pernitious and destructive of Salvation How farre they entangled themselves by this concession I argue not The foundation of it lyes in this cleer truth that no Church what ever universall or particular can possibly erre in Fundamentalls for by so doing it would cease to be a Church My denying then the Synogogue of Rome to be a Church according to their principles amounts to no more then this The Papistâ— maintaine in their publique Confessions fundamentall errors in which Assertion it s known I am not alone But this is not the principle at least not the sole nor maine principle whereon I ground my judgement in this case but this that there was never any such thing in any tolerable likenesse or similitude as that which is called the Church of Rome allowing the most skillfull of its Rabbies to give in the Characters and delineations of it instituted in reference to the worship of God by Jesus Christ The truth is the whole of it is but an imitation exemplar of the old Imperiall Goverment one is set up in chiefe and made 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 in Spiritualls as the Emperors were in civill things from him all power flowes to others and as there was a communication of power by the Emperors to the Civill state Praefects Proconsulls Vicars Presidents Governours of the lesser and greater Nations with those under them in various civill subordinations according to the dignity of the places where they did beare rule and preside and ni the military to Generalls Legates Tribun's and the inferior Officers so is there by the Pope to Patriarchs Arch-bishops Bishops in their severall subordinations which are as his civil state and to Generalls of Religious orders Provincialls and their dependants which are as his military And it is by some not in all things agreeing with them confessed that the Goverment pleaded for by them in the Church was brought in and established in correspondency and accommodation to the civill Goverment of the Empire which is undeniably evident and certaine now this being not throughly done till the Empire had received an incurable wound it seemes to me to be the making of an image to the beast giving life to it and causing iâ—to speake So that the present Roman Church is nothing else but an image or similitude of the Roman Empire set up in its declining among and over the same persons in succession by the craft of Sathan through principles of deceit subtilty and Spirituall wickednesse as the other was by force and violence for the same ends of power dominion fleshlinesse and persecution with the former The exactnesse of this correspondency in all things both in respect of those who claime to be the stated body of his Ecclesiasticall Commonwealth and those who are meerly dependent on his will bound unto him professedly by a military Sacrament exempted from the ordinary Rules and Goverment of his fixed Rulers in their severall subordinationâ— under Officers of their own immediately commissionated by him with his mannagement of both those parties to ballance and keep them mutually in quiet and in order for his service especially confiding in his men of warre like the Emperors of old may elsewhere be farther manifested I suppose it will not be needfull to adde any thing to evince the vanity of the pretensions of the Romanists or others against all or any of us on the account of Schisme upon a grant of the principles layd down it lyes so cleare in them without need of farther deduction and I speake with some confidence that I am not in expectation of any hasty confutation of them I meane that which is so indeed The earnestnesse of their clamours importuning us to take notice of them by the way before I enter upon a direct debate of the cause as it stands stated in reference to them I shall only tell them that seeking to repose our consciences in the minde of God revealed in the Scriptures we are not at all concerned in the noise they make in the world For what have we done wherein doth our guilt consist wherein lyes the peculiar concernment of these 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 let them goe to the Churches with whom we walke of whom we are and aske of them concerning our wayes our Love and the duties of it Doe we live in strife and variance Do we not beare with each other doe we not worship God without disputes and divisions have we differences and contentions in our Assemblies doe we break any bond of Union wherein we are bound by the expresse institutions of Jesus Christ if we have let the righteous reprove us we will own our guilt confesse we have been carnall and endeavour Reformation If not what have the Romanists Italians to doe to judge us knew we not your designe your interest your lives your Doctrines your Worship we might possibly think that you might intermeddle out of Love and mistaken zeale but ad populum Phaleras you would be making shrines and thence is this stirre and uproare But we are Schismaticks in that we have departed from the Catholick Church and for our own Conventicles they are no Churches but styes of beasts But this is most false We abide in the Catholick Church under all the bonds wherein by the will of Christ we stand related unto it Which if we prove not with as much evidence as
the nature of such things will beare though you are not at all concerned in it yet we will give you leave to â—riumph over us And if our own Congregations be not Churches whatsoever we are we are not Schismaticks for Schisme is an evill amongst the members of a Church if S. Paul may be believed But we have forsaken the Church of Rome But Gentlemen shew first how we were ever of it No man hath lost that which he never had nor hath left the place or station wherein he never was Tell me when or how we were members of your Church We know not your language you are Barbarians to us It is impossible we should assemble with you But your Forefathers left that Church and you persist in their evill Prove that your Forefathers were ever of your Church in any communion instituted by Christ and you say somewhat To desert a mans station and relation which he had on any other account good or bad is not Schisme as shall farther be manifested Upon the same principle a plea for freedome from the charge of any Church reall or pretended as Nationall may be founded and confirmed either we are of the Nationall Church of England to give that instance or we are not if we are not and are exempted by our Protestation as before whatever we are we are not Schismaticks if we are fatally bound unto it and must be members of it whether we will or no being made so we know not how and continuing so we know not why shew us then what duty or office of Love is incumbent on us that we doe not performe Doe we not joyne in externall acts of worship in Peace with the whole Church Call the whole Church together and try what we will doe Doe we not joyne in every Congregation in the Nation This is not charged on us nor will any say that we have right so to doe without a Relation to some particular Church in the Nation I know where the sore lyes A Nationall Officer or Officers with others acting under them in severall subordinations with various distributions of power are the Church intended A non-submission to their rules and constitutions is the Schisme we are guilty of Quem das finem Rex magne laborum But this pretence shall afterwards be sifted to the utmost In the meane time let any one informe me what duty I ought to performe towards a Nationall Church on supposition there is any such thing by vertue of an Institution of Jesus Christ that is possible for me to performe and I shall 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 addresse my selfe unto it To close these considerations with things of more immediate concernment Of the divisions that have fallen out amongst us in things of Religion since the last Revolutions of this Nation there is no one thing hath been so effectuall a promotion such is the power of Tradition and prejudice which even beare all before them in humane affaires as the mutuall charging one another with the guilt of Schisme That the notion of Schisme whereon this charge is built by the most if not all was invented by some of the Ancients to promote their plea and advantage them with them with whom they had to doe without due regard to the simplicity of the Gospell at least in a suitablenesse to the present state of the Church in those daies is too evident For on very small foundations have mighty fabricks and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 in Religion been raised As an Ability to judge of the present posture and Condition of affaires with counsell to give direction for their order and mannagement towards any end proposed not an Ability to contriâ—e for events and to knit on one thing upon another according to a probability of successe for continuance which is almost constantly disturbed by unexpected providentiall interveniences leaving the Contrivers at a perplexing losse will be found to be the summe of humane wisdome so it will be our wisdome in the things of God not to judge according to what by any meanes is made present to us and its principles on that account rendred ready to exert themselves but ever to recoile to the originall and first institution When a man first falls into some current he finds it strong and almost impassable trace it to its fountaine and it is but a dribling gutter Paul tells the members of the Church of Corinth that there were divisions amongst them breaches of that Love Order that ought to be observed in Religious Assemblies Hence there is a sinne of Schisme raised which when considered as now stated doth no more relate to that treated on by the Apostle then Simon Sonne of Jonas lovest thou me doth to the Popes Supremacy or Christs saying to Peter of John If I will that he tarry till I come what is that to thee did to the report that went afterwards abroad that that Disciple should not die When God shall have reduced his Churches to their Primitive Purity and institution when they are risen and have shaken themselves out of the dust and things of Religion returne to their native simplicity it is scarce possible to imagine what Vizards will fall off and what a contrary appearance many things will have to what they now walke up and downe in I wish that those who are indeed really concerned in this businesse namely the members of particular Churches who have voluntarily given up themselves to walke in them according to the appointment of Christ would seriously consider what evill lyes at the door if they give place to causelesse differences and divisions amongst themselves Had this sinne of Schisme been rightly stated as it ought and the guilt of it charged in its proper place perhaps some would have been more carefull in their deportment in their Relations At present the dispute in the World relating hereunto is about Subjection to the Pope and the Church of Rome as it is called And this mannaged on the Principles of Edicts of Councells with the practices of Princes and Nations in the dayes long agoe past with the like considerations wherein the concernment of Christians is doubtlesse very small Or of Obedience and conformity to Metropolitan and Diocesan Bishops in their constitutions and wayes of worship joyntly or severally prescribed by them In more Ancient times that which was agitated under the same name was about persons or Churches renouncing the Communion and Society of Saints with all other Churches in the World consenting with them in the same Confession of Faith for the substance of it And these differences respectively are handled in reference to what the state of things was and is grown unto in the dayes wherein they are mannaged When Paul wrote his Epistle there was no occasion given to any such Controversies nor foundation laid making them possible That the Disciples of Christ ought every where to abound in love and forbearance towards one another especially to carry all things
and visible of any Church or Churches on the pretension and plea be it true or otherwise that the worship Doctrine discipline instituted by Christ is corrupted among them with which corruption he dares not defile himselfe it is no where in the Scripture called Schisme noâ— is that case particularly exemplified or expressely supposed whereby a judgement may be made of the fact at large but we are left upon the whole matter to the guidance of such generall principles and Rules as are given us for that end and purpose What may regularly on the other hand be deduced from the commands given to turne away from them who have only a forme of Godlinesse 2 Tim. 3. 5. to withdraw from them that walk disorderly 2 Thes 3. 6. not to beare nor endure in communion men of corrupt principles and wicked lives Rev. 2. 14. but positively to separate from an Apostate Church Rev. 18. 4 that in all things we may worship Christ according to his mind and appointment what is the force of these commands 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and the like is without the compasse of what I am now treating about Of one particular Church departing from that communion with another or others be it what it will which it ought to hold unlesse in the departing of some of them in some things from the common Faith which is supposed not to relate to Schisme in the Scripture we have no example Diotrephes assuming an Authority over that Church wherein he was placed 3 Joh. 9 10. and for a season hindering the brethren from the performance of the duty incumbent upon them toward the great Apostle and others makes the nearest approach to such a division but yet in such a distance that it is not at all to our purpose in hand When I come to consider that communion that Churches have or ought to have among themselves this will be more fully discussed Neither is this my sence alone that there is no instance of any such separation as that which is the matter of our debate to be found in the Scripture It is confessed by others differing from me in and about Church affaires To leave all ordinary communion in any Church with dislike where opposition or offence offers it selfe is to separate from such a Church in the Scripture sence such separation was not in being in the Apostles time say they Papâ—â—accom p. 55. But how they came to know exactly the sence of the Scripture in about things not mentioned in them I know not As I said before were I unwilling I doe not as yet understand how I may be compelled to carry on the notion of Schisme any farther Nor is there need of adding any thing to demonstrate how little the conscience of a godly man walking peaceably in any particular Church society is concerned in all the clamarous disputes of this Age about it being built on false Hypotheses presumptions and notions no other way considerable but as received by tradition from our Fathers But I shall for the sake of some carry on this Discourse to a fuller issue There is another common notion of Schisme which pleads to an originall from that spoken expressly of it by a parity of reason which tolerable in it selfe hath been and is injuriously applyed and used according as it hath fallen into the hands of men who needed it as an engine to fixe or improve them in the station wherein they are or were wherewith they are pleased Indeed being invented for severall purposes there is nothing more frequent then for men who are scarce able to keep off the force of it from their own heads whilest mannaged against them by them above at the same time vigorously to apply it for the oppression of all under them What is on all hands consented unto as its generall nature I shall freely grant that I might have liberty and advantage thence to debate the restriction and application of it to the severall purposes of men prevailing themselves thereon Let then the generall demand be granted that Schisme is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the breach of Vnion which I shall attend with one reasonable postulatum namely that this union be an union of the appointment of Jesus Christ The consideration then of what or what sort of union in reference to the worship of God according to the Gospell is instituted appointed by Jesus Christ is the proper foundation of what I have farther to offer in this businesse Let the breach of this if you please be accounted Schisme for being an evill I shall not contend by what name or title it be distinguished It is not pleaded that any kind of relinquishment or desertion of any Church or Churches is presently Schisme but only such a separation as breakes the bond of Vnion instituted by Christ Now this union being instituted in the Church according to the various acceptions of that word so is it distinguished Therefore for a discovery of the nature of that which is particularly to be spoken to and also its contrary I must shew 1. The severall considerations of the Church wherein and with which union is to be preserved 2. What that union is and wherein it doth consist which according to the minde of Christ we are to keep and observe with the Church under the severall notions of it respectively 3 And how that union is broken and what is that sinne whereby it is done In handling this triple proposall I desire that it may not be expected that I should much insist on any thing that falls in my way though never so usefull to my end and purpose which hath been already proved and confirmed by others beyond all possibility of controule and such will many if not most of the principles that I proceed upon appeare to be CAP. IV. Severall Acceptations in the Scripture of the name Church Of the Church Catholick properly so called Of the Church visible Perpetuity of particular Churches A mistake rectifyed The nature of the Church Catholick evinced Bellarmine his description of the Church Catholick Vnion of the Church Catholick wherein it consists Vnion by way of consequence Vnity of Faith Of Love The Communion of the Catholick Church in and with itsselfe The breach of the Vnion of the Church Catholick wherein it consisteth Not morally possible Protestants not guilty of it The Papall world out of interest in the Church Catholick As partly profane Miracles no evidence of Holinesse Partly ignorant Selfe Justitiaries Idolatrous Worshippers of the Beast TO begin with the first thing proposed The Church of Christ living in this world as to our present concernment is taken in Scripture three wayes 1. For the Mysticall body of Christ his Elect Redeemed Justifyed and Sanctifyed ones throughout the world commonly called the Church-Catholick-Militant 2. For the Vniversality of men throughout the world called by the preaching of the word visibly professing and yeilding obedience to the Gospell called by some
are enquiring after But because there is very little security to be enjoyed in an expectation of the sobriety of men in things wherein they are or suppose they may be concerned that they may know before hand what is farther incumbent on them if in reference to us they would prevaile themselves of any such notion I here informe them that our perswasion is that this union was never utterly broken by any man taken into it or ever shall be to the end of the World and I suppose they esteeme it vaine to dispute about the Adâ—uncts of that which is denyed to be But yet this perswasion being not common to us with them with whom we have to doe in this matter I shall not farther make use of it as to our present defence That any other union of the Catholick Church as such can possibly be fancyed or imagined by any as to the substance of what hath been pleaded leaving him a plea for the ordinary soâ—ndnes of his Intellectualls is denyed Let us see now then what is our concernment in this discourse unlesse men can prove that we have not the spirit of God that we do not savingly believe in Jesus Christ that we doe not sincerely love all the Saints his whole body and every member of it they cannot disprove our interest in the Catholick Church It is true indeed men that have so great a confidence of their own Abilities and such a contempt of the World as to undertake to dispute them out of conclusions from their naturall sences about their proper Objects in what they see feele and handle and will not be satisfied that they have not proved there is no motion whilst a man walks for a conviction under their eye may probably venture to disprove us in our spirituall sense and experience also and to give us Arguments to perswade us that we have not that communion with Christ which we know we have every day Although I have a very meane perswasion of my own Abilities yet I must needs say I cannot think that any man in the world can convince me that I doe not love Jesus Christ in sincerity because I doe not love the Pope as he is so Spirituall Experience is a security against a more cunning Sophister then any Jesuâ—â—te in the world with whom the Saintâ— of God have to deale all their lives Eph. 6. 12. And doubtlesse through the rich grace of our God helpe will arise to us that we shall never make a Covenant with these men for peace upon conditions for worse then those that Nahash would have exacted on the men of Jabesh Gileadâ— which were but the losse of one eye with an abiding reproach they requiring of us the deprivation of whatsoever we have to see by whether as men or Christians and that with a reproach never to be blotted out But as we daily put our Consciences upon triall as to this thing 1 Cor. 13. 5. and are put unto it by Sathan so are we readie at all times to give an account to our Adversaries of the hope that us in us Let them sift us to the utmost it will be to our advantage Only let them not bring frivolous objections and such as they know are of no weight with us speaking as is their constant manner about the Pope and their Church things utterly forraigne to what we are presently about miserably begging the thing in Question Let them weigh if they are able the true nature of Vnion with Christ of faith in him of Love to the Saints consider them in their proper Causes Adjuncts and Effects with a sprituall eye laying aside their prejudices and intolerable impositions if we are found wanting as to the truth and sincerity of these things if we cannot give some account of our translation from death to life of our implantation into Christ and our participation of the Spirit we must beare our own burthen if otherwise we stand fast on the most noble and best account of Church Vnion what ever and whilest this shield is safe we are lesse â—mxious about the issue of the ensuing contest Whatever may be the apprehensions of other men I am not in this thing sollicitous I speake not of my selfe but assuming for the present the person of one concerning whom these things may be spoken whilest the efficacy of the Gospell accomplisheth in my heart all those divine and mighty effects which are ascribed unto it as peculiarly it workes towards them that believe whilest I know this one thing that whereas I was blind now I see whereas I was a servant of sinne I am now free to righteousnesse at liberty from bondage unto death instead of the fruits of the flesh I find all the fruits of the Spirit brought forth in me to the praise of Gods glorious grace whilest I have an experience of that powerfull work of conversion and being borne againe which I am able to mannage against all the accusations of Satan having peace with God upon justification by faith with the love of God shed abroad in my heart by the Holy Ghost investing me in the priviledges of Adoption I shall not certainly be moved with the disputes of men that would perswade me I doe not belong to the Catholick Church because I doe not follow this or that or any part of men in the world But you will say this you will allow to them also with whom you have to doe that they may be members of the Catholick Church I leave other men to stand or fall to their own Master only as to the Papall multitude on the account of severall inconsistencies between them and the members of this Church I shall place some swords in the way which will reduce their number to an invisible scantling I might content my selfe by affirming at once that upon what hath been spoken I must exclude from the Catholick Church all and every one whom Bellarmine intends to include in it as such namely those who belong to the Church as hairs and ill humours to the body of a man But I adde in particular 1. All wicked and prophane persons of whom the Scripture speakes expressly that they shall not enter into the Kingdome of God are indisputably cut off Whatever they pretend in shew at any time in the outward duties of Devotion they have neither faith in Christ nor love to the Saints and so have part and fellowship neither in the union nor communion of the Catholick Church How great a proportion of that Synogogue whereof we are speaking will be taken off by this sword of their Popes Princes Prelates Clergie Votaries and people and that not by a rule of private surmises but upon the visible issue of their being servants to sin â—aters of God and good men is obvious to all Persons of really so much as reformed lives amongst them are like the berries after the shaking of an Olive tree 1 Cor 6. 7 8
otherwise formerly paroecia being the care of a private Bishop Provincia of a Metropolitan Diocesis of a Patriarch in the order mentioned and hath pointed out which of his Churches shall be of those severall kinds throughout the world which that it will not be done to the disturbance of my principles whilst I live I have some present good security And Because I take the men of this perswasion to be charitable men that will not think much of taking a little paines for the reducing any person whatever from the errour of his way I would intreat them that they would informe me what Patriarchate according to the institution of Christ I who by the providence of God live here at Oxon doe de jure belong unto that so I may know how to preserve the union of that Church and to behave my selfe therein And this I shall promise them that if I were singly or in conjunction with any others so considerable that those great Officers should contend about whose subjects we should be as was done heretofore about the Bulgarians that it should not at all startle me about the truth and excellency of Christian Religion as it did those poore Creatures who being newly converted to the faith knew nothing of it but what they received from men of such Principles But that this constitution is humane and the distributions of Christians in subjection unto Church Officers into such and such divisions of Nations and Countries prudentiall and aobitrary I suppose will not be denyed The 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 of the Nicene Synod intends no more nor is any thing of institution nor so much as of Apostolicall tradition pleaded therein The following ages were of the same perswasion Hence in the Councell of Chalcedon the Archiepiscopacy of Constantinople was advanced into a Patriarchat and many provinces cast in subjection thereunto wherein the Primates of Ephesus and Thrace were cut short of what they might plead 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 for And sundry other alterations were likewise made in the same kind Socrat lib. 5. cap. 8. The ground and reason of which procedure the Fathers assembled sufficiently manifest in the reason assigned for the advancement of the Bishops of Constantinople which was for the Cityes sake 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Can. 3. Con. Constan And what was the judgement of the Councell of Chalcedon upon this matter may be seen in the composition determination of the strife between Maximus Bishop of Antioch and Invenalis of Hierusalem Ac. 7. Con. Cal. with translation of Provinces from the Jurisdiction of one to another And he that shall suppose that such Assemblys as these were instituted by the will and appointment of Christ in the Gospell with Church Authority for such dispositions and determinations so as to make them of concernment to the unity of the Church will if I mistake not be hardly bestead in giving the ground of that his supposall 4. I would know of them who desire to be under this Law whether the power with which Jesus Christ hath furnished the Officers of his Church come forth from the supreame mentioned Patriarchs and Arch-Bishops and is by them communicated to the inferiors or vice-versa or whether all have their power in an equall immediation from Christ if the latter be granted there will be a greater independency established then most men are aware of though the Papalins understood it in the Councell of Trent and a wound given to successive Episcopall Ordination not easily to be healed That power is communicated from the inferiors to the Superiors will not be pleaded And seeing the first must be insisted on I beseech them not to be too hasty with men not so sharp sighted as themselves if finding the names they speak of Barbarous and forraigne as to the Scriptures and the things themselves not at all delineated therein 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 5. The truth is the whole subordination of this kind which de facto hath been in the world was so cleerly an humane invention or a prudentiall constitution as hath been shewed which being done by men professing authority in the Church gave it as it was called vi◠Ecclesiasticam that nothing else in the issue is pleaded for it And now though I shall if called thereunto manifest both the unreasonablenesse unsuitablenes to the designe of Christ for his worship under the Gospell comparative noveltie and mischievous issue of that constitution yet at the present being no farther concerned but only to evince that the union of the Generall visible Church doth not therein consist I shall not need to adde any thing to what hath been spoken The Nicene Councell which first made towards the confirmation of something like somewhat of what was afterwards introduced in some places pleaded only as I said before the 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 old usage for it which it would not have done could it have given a better Originall thereunto And whatever the Antiquities then pretended might be we know that 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 And I doe not feare to say what others have done before me concerning the Canons of that first and best generall Councell as it is called they are all hay and stubble Nor yet doth the laying this custome on 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 in my apprehension evince their judgement of any long prescription Peter speaking of a thing that was done a few years before saies that is was done 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Act. 15. 7. somewhat a greater Antiquity then that by him intended I can freely grant to the custome by the Fathers pretended But a Generall Councell is pleaded with the best colour and pretence for a bond of union to this Generall visible Church In Consideration hereof I shall not divert to the handling of the rise right use Authority necessity of such Councells about all which somewhat in due time towards satisfaction may be offered to those who are not in bondage to Names and Traditions Nor shall I remark what hath been the mannagement of the things of God in all Ages in those Assemblies many of which have been the staines and ulcers of Christian Religion Nor yet shall I say with what little disadvantage to the Religion of Jesus Christ I suppose a losse of all the Canons of all Councells that ever were in the world since the Apostles daies with their acts and contests considering what use is made of them might be undergone Nor yet shall I digresse to the usefulnesse of the Assemblies of severall Churches in their representatives to consider and determine about things of common concernment to them with their tendencie to the preservation of that communion which ought to be amongst them but as to the present instance only offer 1. That such Generall Councells being things purely extraordinary and occasionall as is confessed cannot be an ordinary standing bond of union to the Catholick Church and if any one shall reply that though in themselves and
in their own continuance they cannot be so yet in their Authority Lawes and Canons they may I must say that besides the very many Reasons I have to call into question the Power of Lawmaking for the whole Society of Christians in the World in all the Generall Councells that have been or possibly can be on the Earth the dispute about the Title of those Assemblies which pretend to this honour which are to be admitted which excluded are so endlesse the Rules of judging them so darke lubricous and uncertaine framed to the interest of contenders on all hands the Lawes of them which de facto have gone under that Title and Name so innumerable burthensome uncertain and frivolus in a great part so grossely contradictory to one another that I cannot suppose that any man upon second thoughts can abide in such an assertion If any shall I must be bold to declare my affection to the doctrine of the Gospell maintained in some of those Assemblies for some hundreds of years and then to desire him to prove that any Generall Councell since the Apostles fell asleep hath been so convened and mannaged as to be enabled to claime that Authority to it selfe which is or would be due to such an Assembly instituted according to the mind of Christ That it hath been of Advantage to the Truth of the Gospell that Godly Learned men Bishops of Churches have convened and witnessed a good Confession in reference to the Doctrine thereof and declared their abhorrencie of the Errors that are contrary thereunto is confessed That any man or men is are or ever were entrusted by Christ with Authority so to convene them as that thereupon and by vertue thereof they should be invested with a new Authority Power and Jurisdiction at such a convention and thence should take upon them to make Laws and Canons that should be Ecclesiastically binding to any Persons or Churches as theirs is not as yet to meattended with any convincing evidence of Truth And seeing at length it must be spoken I shall doe it with submission to the thoughts of good men that are any way acquainted with these things and in sincerity therein commend my Conscience to God that I doe not know any thing that is extant bearing clearer witnesse to the sad degeneracy of Christian Religion in the profession thereof nor more evidently discovering the efficacy of another Spirit than what was powred out by Christ at his Ascension nor containing more hay and stubble that is to be burned and consumed then the stories of the Acts and Laws of the Councells and Synods that have been in the World 2. But to take them as they are as to that alone wherein the first Councells had any evidence of the presence of the Holy Ghost with them namely in the declaring the doctrine of the Gospell it falls in with that which I shall give in for the bond of union unto the Church in the sense pleaded about 3. Such an Assembly arising cumulative out of particular Churches as it is evident that it doth it cannot first and properly belong to the Church Generall as such but it is only a means of communion between those particular Churches as such of whose representatives I mean vertually for formally the persons convening for many years ceased to be so it doth consist 4. There is nothing more ridiculous then to imagine a Generall Councell that should represent the whole Catholick Church or so much as all the particular Churches that are in the World and let him that iâ— otherwise minded that there hath been such an one or that it is possible there should be such a one prove by instance that such there have been since the Apostles times or by Reason that such may be in the present Age or be justly expected in those that are for to succeed and we will as we are able crowne him for his discovery 5. Indeed I know not how any Councell that hath been in the World these 1300 years and somewhat upwards could be said to represent the Church in any sence or any Churches whatever Their convention as is known hath been alwaies by Imperiall or Papall Authority the persons convened such and only they who as was pretended and pleaded had right of suffrage with all necessary Authority in such conventions from the Order Degree and Office which personally they hold in their severall Churches Indeed a Pope or Bishop sent his Legate or Proxie to Represent or rather personate him his Authority But that any of them were sent or delegated by the Church wherein they did preside is not so evident I desire then that some man more skilled in Laws and Common usages then my selfe would informe me on what account such a convention could come to be a Church Representative or the persons of it to be representatives of any Churches Generall grounds of Reason and Equity I am perswaded cannot be pleaded for it The Lords in Parliament in this Nation who being summoned by Regall Authority sate there in their own personall right were never esteemed to represent the body of the people supposing indeed all Church power â—â—n any particular Church of whatever extract or composition to be solely vested in one single person a collection of those persons if instituted would bring together the Authority of the whole But yet this would not make that Assembly to be a Church Representative if you will allow the name of the Church to any but that single person But for men who have but a partiall power Authority in the Church and perhaps separated from it none at all without any delegation from the Churches to convene and in their own Authority to take upon them to represent those Churches is absolute presumption These severall pretensions being excluded let us see wherein the Vnity of this Church namely of the great society of men professing the Gospell and obedience to Christ according to it throughout the World doth consist this is summoned up by the Apostle Eph. 4. 5. one Lord one Faith one Baptisme It is the Vnity of the doctrine of Faith which men professe in subjection to one Lord Jesus Christ being initiated into that profession by Baptisme I say the saving doctrine of the Gospell of Salvation by Jesus Christ and obedience through him to God as professed by them is the bond of that union whereby they are made one body are distinguished from all other societies have one head Christ Jesus which as to profession they hold and whilest they doe so are of this body in one professed hope of their calling Now that this Vnion be preserved it is required that all those grand and necessary Truths of the Gospell without the knowledge whereof no man can be saved by Jesus Christ be so farre believed as to be outwardly and visibly professed in that variety of waies wherein they are or may be called out thereunto There is a proportion
state of things unsuited to those of old Apostacy from the Vnity of the Church Catholick charged on the Romanists Their claime to be that Church sanguinary false Their plea to this purpose considered The blasphemous mannagement of their plea by some of late The whole dissolved Their inferences on their plea practically prodigious Their Apostacy proved by instances Their grand Argument in this cause proposed Answered Consequences of denying the Roman Church to be a Church of Christ weighed LEt us see now what as to conscience can be charged on us Protestants I meane who are all concerned herein as to the breach of this union The Papists are the persons that undertake to mannage this Charge against us To lay aside the old Plea subesse Romano Pontifici and all those â—eats wherewith they jugled when the whole world saâ—e in darknesse which they doe not now use at the entrance of their charge The summe of what they insist upon firstly is The Catholick Church is intrusted with the interpretation of the Scriptures and declaration of the Truths therein contained which being by it so declared the not receiving of them implicitely or explicitely that is the disbelieving of them as so proposed and declared cuts off any man from being a member of the Church Christ himselfe having said that he that heares not the Church is to be as an Heathen man or Publican which Church they are that is certaine It is all one then what we believe or doe not believe seeing that we believe not all that the Catholick Church proposeth to be believed and what we doe believe we believe not on haâ— account Ans Their insisting on this plea so much as they doe is sufficient to evince their despair of making good by instance our faylure in respect of the way and principles by which the unity of the visible Church may be lost or broken Faile they in this they are gone and if they carrie this plea we are all at their disposall The summe of it is the Catholick Church is intrusted with sole power of delivering what is truth and what is necessary to be believed This Catholick Church is the Church of Rome that is the Pope or what else may in any juncture of time serve their interest But as it is known 1. We deny their Church as it is stiled to be the Catholick Church or as such any part of it as particular Churches are called or esteemed So that of all men in the World they are least concerned in this Assertion Nay I shall goe farther Suppose all the members of the Roman Church to be found in the Faith as to all necessary Truths and no way to prejudice the Advantages and priviledges which accâ—â—e to them by the profession thereof whereby the severall individualls of it would be true members of the Catholick Church yet I should not only deny it to be the Catholick Church but also abideing in its present Order and Constitution being that which by themselves it is supposed to be to be any particular Church of Christ at all as wanting many things necessary to constitute them so and having many things destructive utterly to the very Essence and being of that Order that Christ hath appointed in his Churches The best plea that I know for their Church state is that Antichrist sits in the Temple of God Now although we might justly omit the Examination of this pretence untill those who are concerned in it will professedly owne it as their plea yet as it lyes in our way in the thoughts of some I say to it that I am not so certaine that 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 signifies to sit in the Temple of God seeing a Learned man long agoe thought it rather to be a setting up against the Temple of God Aug. de Civitate Dei lib. 10. cap. 59. But grant the sence of the expression to be as it 's usually received it imports no more but that the man of sinne shall set up his power against God in the midst of them who by their outward visible profession have right to be called his Temple which intitles him and his Copartners in Apostacy to the name of the Church as much as changing of mony and selling of Cattle were Ordinances of God under the old Temple when by some mens practising of them in it it was made a den of Theeves 2. Though as to the plea of them and their interest with whom we have to do we have nothing requiring our Judgements in the case yet ex abundanti we adde that we deny that by the will and appointment of Jesus Christ the Catholick Church visible is in any sence intrusted with such an interpretation of Scripture as that her declaration of Truth should be the measure of what should be believed or that as such it is intrusted with any power of that nature at all or is inabled to propose a Rule of Faith to be received as so proposed to the most contemptible individuall in the world or that it is possible that any voice of it should be heard or understood but only this I believe the necessary saving Truths contained in the Scripture or that it can be consulted with all or is as such intrusted with any Power Authority or Jurisdiction nor shall we ever consent that the Office and Authority of the Scriptures be actually taken from it on any pretence As to that of our Saviour of telling the Church it is so evidently spoken of a particular Church that may immediately be consulted in case of difference between Brethren and does so no way relate to the businesse in hand that I shall not trouble the Reader with a debate of it But doe we not receive the Scripture it selfe upon the Authority of the Church I say if we did so yet this concernes not Rome which we account no Church at all That we have received the Scripture from the Church of Rome at first that is so much as the Book its selfe is an intollerable figment But it is worse to say that we receive and own their Authority from the Authority of any Church or all the Churches in the World It is the expression of our Learned Whitaker Qui Scripturâ—â—â— non credit esse divinam nisi propter Ecclesiae vocem Christianus non est To deny that the Scripture hath immediate force and efficacy to evince its own Authority is plainly to deny them on that account being brought unto us by the providence of God wherein I comprize all subservient helps of humane Testimony we receive them and on no other But is not the Scripture to be interpreted according to the Tradition of the Catholick Church and are not those interpretations so made to be received I say among all the figments that these latter Ages have invented I shall adde amongst the true stories of Lucian there is not one more remote from Truth then this Assertion That all that any one Text of
at large insisted on In briefe put the whole Church of God into that condition of libertie and soundnesse of Doctrine which it was in when the great uproare was made by the Donatists and we shall be concerned to give in our judgements concerning them To presse an example of former dayes as binding unto duty or convincing of evill in respect of any now without stating the whole substratum of the businesse and compleat cause as it was in the dayes and seasons wherein the example was given we judge it not equall Yet although none can with ingenuity presse me with the crime they were guilty of unlesse they can prove themselves to be instated in the very same condition as they were against whom that crime was committed which I am fully assured none in the world can the communion of the Catholick Church then pleaded for being in the judgement of all an effect of mens free liberty and choice now pressed as an issue of the Tyranny of some few yet I shall freely deliver my thoughts concerning the Donatists which will be comprehensive also of those other that suffer with them in former and after ages under the same imputation 1. Then I am perswaded that in the matter of fact the Donatists were some of them deceived and others of them did deceive in charging Caecilianus to be ordained by Traditores which they made the maine ground of their separation however they took in other things as is usuall into their defence afterward Whether any of themselves were ordained by such persons as they are recharged I know not 2. On supposition that he was so and they that ordained him were known to him to have been so yet he being not guilty of the crime renouncing Communion with them therein and themselves repenting of their sinne as did Peter whose sinne exceeded theirs this was no just cause of casting him out of Communion he walking acting in all other things suitable to principles by themselves acknowledged 3. That on supposition they had just cause hereupon to renounce the Communion of Caecilianus which according to the principles of those days retained by themselves was most false yet they had no ground of separating from the Church of Carthage where were many Elders not obnoxious to that charge Indeed to raise a jealousy of a fault in any man which is denyed by him which we are not able to prove which if it were proved were of little or no importance and on pretence thereof to separate from all who will not believe what we surmise is a wild and unchristian course of proceeding 4. Yet grant farther that men of tender consciences regulated by the principle then generally received might be startled at the cōmunion of that Church wherein Caecilianus did preside yet nothing but the height of madnesse pride and corrupt fleshly interest could make men declare hostility against all the Churches of Christ in the world who would communicate with or did not condemne that Church which was to regulate all the Churches in the world by their own fancy and imagination 5. Though men out of such pride and folly might judge all the residue of Christians to be faulty and guilty in this particular of not condemning and separating from the Church of Carthage yet to proceed to cast them out from the very name of Christians and so disanull their priviledges and ordinances that they had been made partakers of as manifestly they did by rebaptizing all that entered into their communion was such unparalleld Pharisaisme and Tyranny as was wholy to be condemned and untollerable 6. The Divisions Outrages and Enthusiasticall furies and Riots that befell them or they fell into in their way werein my judgement tokens of the hand of God against them so that upon the whole matter their undertaking and enterprise was utterly undue and unlawfull I shall farther adde as to the mannagement of the cause by their Adversaries that there is in these writings especially those of Austin for the most part as sweet and gratious spirit breathing full of zeale for the glory of God Peace Love Union among Christians and as to the issue of the cause under debate it is evident that they did sufficiently foyle their Adversaries on principles then generally confessed and acknowledged on all hands though some of them seem to have been considering Learned and dexterous men How little we are at this day in any contests that are mannaged amongst us about the things of God concerned in those differences of theirs these few Considerations will evince yet notwithstanding all this I must take liberty to professe that although the Fathers justly charged the Donatists with disclaiming of all the Churches of Christ as a thing wicked and unjust yet many of the principles whereon they did it were such as I cannot assent unto Yea I shall say that though Austin was sufficiently cleare in the nature of the invisible Church Catholick yet his frequent confounding it with a mistaken notion of the visible generall Church hath given no small occasion of stumbling and sundry unhappy intanglements to diverse in after Ages His own book De unitats Ecclesiae which contains the summe and Substance of what he had written elsewhere or disputed against the Donatists would afford me instances enough to make good my assertion were it now under consideration or proofe Being then thus come off from this part of our Charge and accusation of Schisme for the relinquishment of the Catholick visible Church which as we have not done so to doe is not Schisme but a sin of another nature and importance according to the method proposed a recharge on the Romanists in reference to their present Condition and its unsuitablenesse to the Vnity of the Church evinced must briefly ensue Their claime is known to be no lesse then that they are this Catholick Church out of whose Communion there is no salvation as the Donatists was of old that also the union of this Church consists in its subjection to its head the Pope and worshipping of God according to his appointment in and with his severall qualifications and attendencies Now this claime of theirs to our apprehension and Consciences is 1. Cruell and sanguinary condemning Millions to hell that invocate and call on the name of the Lord Jesus Christ believing all things that are written in the Old and New Testaments for no other cause in the World but because they are not convinced that it is their duty to give up Reason Faith Soule and all to him and his disposall whom they have not only unconquerable presumptions against as an evill and wicked Person but are also resolved and fully perswaded in their Consciences that he is an enemy to their deare Lord Jesus Christ out of Love to whom they cannot beare him Especially will this appeare to be so if we consider their farther improvement of this principle to the killing hanging torturing to death
them the least direction to make their addresse to him that should succeed Peter in his Power and Office for reliefe and redresse Strange that it should be of necessity to Salvation to be subject to him in whom this power of Peter was to be continued that he was to be one in whom the Saints were to be consummated that in Relation to him the Unity of the Catholick Church to be preserved under paine of damnation should consist and yet not a word spoken of him in the whole Word of God But they say Peter had not only an Apostolicall power with the rest of the Apostles but also an ordinary power that was to be continued in the Church But the Scripture being confessedly silent of any such thing let us heare what proof is tendered for the establishment of this uncouth Assertion Herein then thus they proceed It will be confessed that Jesus Christ ordained his Church wisely according to his infinite wisedome which he exercised about his body Now to this wisdome of his for the prevention of innumerable evils it is agreeable that he should appoint some one person with that power of declaring truth and of Jurisdiction to enforce the receiving of it which we plead for For this was in Peter as is proved from the texts of Scripture before mentioned therefore it is continued in them that succeed him And here lyes the great stresse of their cause That to prevent evills and inconveniences it became the wisedome of Jesus Christ to appoint a person with all that Authority power infallibility to continue in his Church to the end of the world And this plea they mannage variously with much Sophistry Rhetorick and Testimonies of Antiquity But suppose all this should be granted yet I am full well assured that they can never bring it home to their concernment by any Argument but only the actuall claime of the Pope wherein he stands singly now in the world which that it is satisfactory to make it good de fide that he is so will not easily be granted The truth is of all the attempts they make against the Lord Jesus Christ this is one of the greatest wherein they will assert that it became his wisedome to doe which by no meanes they can prove that he hath done which is plainly to tell us what in their judgement he ought to have done though he hath not that therefore it is incumbent on them to supply what he hath been defective in Had he taken the care he should of them and their Master that he and they might have ruled and reviled over and in the house of God he would have appointed things as now they are which they affirme to have become his wisedome He was a King that once cryed Si Deo in creatione adfuissem mundum melius ordinassem But every Fryar or Monck can say of Jesus Christ had they been present at his framing the world to come whereof we speake they would have told him what had become his wisedome to do Our Blessed Lord hath left sufficient provision against all future emergencies inconveniences in his word Spirit given promised to his Saints And the one Remedie which these men have found out with the contempt and blaspemy of him and them hath proved worse then all the other evills and diseases for whose prevention he made provision which he hath done also for that remedy of theirs but that some are hardned through the righteous judgement of God and deceitfulnesse of sin The mannagement of this plea by some of late is very considerable say they Quia non de verbis solum Scripturae sed etiaÌ„ de sensu plurima coÌ„troversia est si ecclesiae interpretatio non est certâ—… intelligendi norma ecquis erit istiusmodi Controversiae judex sensuÌ„ enim suuÌ„ pro sua virili quisque defendet quod si in Exploranda verbi Dei intelligentia nullus est certus judex audemus dicere nullam rempublicam fuisse stultius constitutam Sin autem Apostoli tradiderunt Eccclesiis verbum Dei sine intelligentia verbi Dei quomodo praedicarunt Evangelium omni Creaturae quomodo decuerunt omnes Gentes servare quaecunque illis fuerunt a Christo commendata Non est puerorum aut Psittaeorum praedicatio qui sine mente dant accipiuntque sonum Walemburg Con. 4. Num. 26. It is well that at length these men speak out plainly If the Pope be not a visible supreame Judge in over the Church Christ hath in the constitution of his Church dealt more foolishly then ever any did in the constitution of a Commonwealth If he have not an infallible power of determining the sense of the Scriptures the Scripture is but an empty insignificant word like the speech of Parats or Popyniaies Though Christ hath by his Apostles given the Scriptures to make the man of God wise unto Salvation and promised his spirit unto them that believe by whose assistance the Scripture gives out it s own sence to them yet all is folly if the Pope be not Supreame and Infallible The Lord rebuke them who thus boldly blaspheame his word and wisdome But let us proceed This Peter thus invested in power that was to be traduced to others went to Rome and Preached the Gospell there It is most certain nor will themselves deny it that if this be not so and believed their whole fabrick will fall to the ground But can this be necessary for all sorts of Christians and every individuall of men among them to believe when there is not the least insinuation of any such thing in the Scripture certainly though it be only a matter of fact yet being of such huge importance and consequence and such a doctrine of absolute indispensable necessity to be believed as is pretended depending upon it if it were true and true in reference to such an end and purpose as is pleaded it would not have been passed over in silence there where so many things of inconceivable lesse concernment to the Church of God though all in their respective degrees tending to edification are recorded As to what is recorded in story the order and series of things with the discovery afforded us of Peters course place of abode in Scripture doe prevaile with me to think stedfastly that he was never there against the selfe contradicting testimonies of some few who took up vulgar reports then when the mystery of iniquity had so farre â—pâ—rated at least that it was judged meet that the chiefe of the Apostles should have lived in the chiefe City of the World But that we may proceed grant this also that Peter was at Rome which they shall never be able to prove and that he did Preach the Gospell there yet so he did by their own Confession at other places making his residence at Antioch for some years what will this availe towards the setling of the matter under consideration There Christ
appointed him to fixe his Chaire and make that Church the place of his residence 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Of his meeting Simon Magus at Rome who in all probability was never there for Seme Sangus was not Simon Magus nor Sanctus nor Deus Magnus of the conquest made of him and his Divells of his being instructed of Christ not to goe from Rome but tarry there and suffer some thing may be said from old Legends But of his chaire and fixing of it at Rome of his confinement as it were to that place in direct opposition to the tenour of his Apostolicall commission who first told the story I know not but this I know they will one day be ashamed of their Chaire Thrones and Sees and Jurisdictions wherein they now so please themselves But what is next to this The Bishop of Rome succeeds Peter in all that Power Jurisdiction Infallibility with whatsoever else was fancied before in him as the ordinary Lord of the Church and therefore the Roman Church is the Catholick quod erat demonstrandum Now though this inference will no way follow upon these Principles though they should all be supposed to be true whereof not one is so much as probable and though this last Assertion be vaine and ridiculous nothing at all being pleaded to ground this Succession no Institution of Christ no Act of any Councell of the Church no Will nor Testament of Peter but only it is so fallen out as the world was composed of a casuall concurrence of Atomes yet seeing they will have it so I desire a little farther information in one thing that yet remains and that is this The Charter Patents and Grant of all this power right of succession unto Peter in all the Advantages priviledges and Jurisdiction before mentioned being wholly in their own keeping whereof I never saw letter or title nor ever conversed with any one no not of themselves that did I would be gladly informed whether this grant be made to him absolutely without any manner of condition whatever so that who ever comes to be Pope of Rome and possessed of Peters Chaire theâ—e by what meanes soever he is possessed of it whether he believe the Gospell or no or any of the saving Truths therein contained and so their Church must be the Catholick Church though it follow him in all Abominations or whether it be made on any condition to him especially that of cleaving to the doctrine of Christ revealed in the Gospell If they say the first that it is an absolute grant that is made to him without any condition expressed or necessarily to be understood I am at an issue and have nothing to adde But my desire that the Grant may be produced for whilest we are at this variance it is against all Law and Equity that the parties litigant should be admitted to plead bare Allegations without proofe If the latter though we should grant all the former monstrous suppositions yet we are perfectly secure against all their pretensions knowing nothing more clearly and evidently then that He and they have broken all conditions that can possibly be imagined by corrupting and perverting almost the whole doctrine of the Gospell And whereas it may be supposed that the great condition of such a grant would consist in his diligent attendance to the Scriptures the Word of God herein doth the filth of their Abominations appeare above all other things The guilt that is in that society or combination of men in locking up the Scriptures in an unknown tongue forbidding the people to read it burning some men to death for the studying of it and no more disputing against its power to make good its own Authority charging it with obscurity imperfection insufficiency frighting men from the perusall of it with the danger of being seduced and made Hereticks by so doing setting up their own Traditions in an equality with it if not exalting them above it studying by all meanes to decry it as uselesse and contemptible at least comparatively with themselves will not be purged from them for ever But you will say this is a simple question For the Pope of Rome hath a promise that he shall still be such an one as is fit to be trusted with the power mentioned and not one that shall defend Mahumet to be the Prophet of God sent into the world or the like Abominations at least that be he what he will placed in the chaire he shall not â—â—re nor mistake in what he delivereth for Truth Now seeing themselves as was said are the sole keepers of this promise and grant also which they have not as yet shewed to the world I am necessitated to aske once more whether it be made to him meerly upon condition of mounting into his Chaire or also on this condition that he use the means appointed by God to come to the knowledge of the Truth If they say the former I must needs say that it is so remote from my apprehension that God who will be worshipped in spirit and in truth only should now under the Gospell promise to any persons that be they never so wicked and abominable never so openly and evidently sworne enemies of him and his Anoynted whether they use any means or not by him appointed that they shall alwayes in all things speake the truth which they hate in love which they have not with that Authority which all his Saints must bow unto especially not having intimated any one word of any such promise in the Scripture that I know not whatever I heard of in my life that I cannot as soone believe If they say the latter we close then as we did our former enquiry Upon the credit and strength of these sandy foundations and principles which neither severally nor joyntly will beare the weight of a feather in a long continued course of Apostacy have men conquered all Policy Religion and honesty and built up that stupendious fabrick coupled together with subtle and scarce discernable joynts and ligaments which they call the Catholick Church 1. In despight of policy they have not only enslaved Kings Kingdomes Common-wealths Nations People to be their vassalls and at their disposall but also contrary to all Rules of goverment beyond the thoughts and conjectures of all or any that ever wrote of or instituted a Goverment in the world they have in most Nations of Europe set up a Government Authority and Jurisdiction within anothers Government and Authority setled on other accounts the one independent on the other and have brought these things to some kind of consistency which that it might be accomplished never entered into the heart of any wise man once to imagine nor had ever been by them effected without such advantages as none in the world ever had in such a continuance but themselves Unlesse the Druids of old in some Nations obtained some such thing 2. In despight of Religion it self they have made
a new Creed invented new wayes of worship given a whole summe and system of their own altogether alien froÌ„ the Word of God without an open disclaiming of that word which in innumerable places beares testimony of its own perfection and fulnesse 3. Contrary to common Honesty the first principles of Reason with violence to the evident dictates of the Law of nature they will in confidence of these principles have the word sentence of a Pope though a beast a witch a Conjurer as by their own confession many of them have been to be impliciteâ—y submitted to in about things which he neither knoweth nor loveth nor careth for being yet such in themselves as immediately and directly concerne the everlasting condition of the soules of men And this is our second returne to their pretence of being the Catholick Church to which I adde 3. That their plea is so far from truth that they are and they only the Catholick Church that indeed they belong not to it because they keep not the Vnity of the faith which is required to constitute any person whatever a member of that Church but faile in all the conditions of it For 1. To proceed by way of instance they doe not professe nor believe a Justification distinct from Sanctification and acceptance thereof the Doctrine whereof is of absoluâ—e indispensable necessity to the preservation of the Vnity of the Faith and so faile in the first condition of professing all necessary Truths I know what they say of Justification what they have determined concerning it in the Councell of Trent what they dispute about it in their books of Controversies But I deny that which they contend for to be a Justification so that they doe not deny only Justification by Faith but positively over and above the infusion of Grace and the acceptance of the obedience thence arising that there is any Justification at all consisting in the free and full absolution of a sinner on the account of Christ 2. They discover principles corrupt and depraved utterly inconsistent with those truths and the receiving of them which in generall by owning the Scriptures they doe professe Herein to passe by the principles of Atheisme wickednesse and profannesse that effectually worke and manifest themselves in the generality of their Priests People that of self â—ighteousnes that is in the best of their Devotionists is utterly inconsistent with the whole Doctrine of the Gospell and all saving Truths concerning the mediation of Jesus Christ therein conteined 3. That in their Doctrine of the Popes supremacy of merits satisfaction the masse the worshipping of Images they adde such things to their profession as enervate the efficacy of all the saving truths they doe professe and so faile in the third condition This hath so abundantly been manifested by others that I shall not need to adde any thing to give the charge of it upon them any farther evidence or demonstration Thus it is unhappily fallen out with these men that what of all men they most pretend unto that of all men they have the least intâ—erest in Aâ—haeneus tells us of one Throsâ—â—aus an Aâ—henian who being phrenetically distempered whatever ships came into the Pyraeum he looked on them and thought them his own and rejoyced as the Master of so great wealth when he was not the owner of so much as a boate such a distemper of pride and folly hath in the like manner ceased on these persons with whom we have to doe that where ever in Scripture they meet with the name Church presently as though they were intended by it they rejoyce in the priviledges of it when their concernment lyes not at all therein To close this whole discourse I shall bring the grand Argument of the Romanists with whom I shall now in this Treatise have little more to doe wherewith they make such a noise in the world to an â—ssue Of the many formes and shapes whereinto by them it is cast this seems to be the most perspicuously expressive of their intention Voluntarily to forsake the communion of the Church of Christ is Schisme and they that doe so are guilty of it You have voluntarily forsaken the communion of the Church of Christ Therefore You are guilty of the sinne of Schisme I have purposely omitted the interposing of the terme Catholick that the reason of the Argument might runne to its length for upon the taking in of that terme we have nothing to doe but only to deny the Minor Proposition seeing the Roman Church be it what it will is not the Church Catholick but as it is without that limitation called the Church of Christ indefinitely it leaves place for a farther and fuller Answer To this by way of inference they adde that Schisme as it is declared by S. Austin and S Thomas of Aquin being so great and damnable a sinne and whereas it is plainâ— that out of the Church which as Peter says is as Noahs Arke 1 Pet. 3. 20 21. there is no salvation it is cleare you will be damned This is the summe of their plea. Now as for the forementioned Argument some of our Divines answer to the Minor Prop. and that both as to the tearmes of voluntary forsaking and that also of the Communion of the Church For the first they say they did not voluntarily forsake the communion of the Church that then was but being necessitated by the command of God to reforme themselves in sundry things they were driven out by bell book and Candle cursed out killed out driven out by all manner of violence Ecclesiasticall and Civill which is a strange way of mens becoming Schismatick 2. That they forsook not the communion of the Church but the Corruptions of it or the communion of it in its corruption not in other things wherein it was Lawfull to continue communion with it To give strength to this Answer they farther adde that though they grant the Church of Rome to have been at the time of the first separation a true Church of Christ yet they deny it to be Catholick Church or only visible Church then in the World the Churches in the East claiming that title by as good a right as shee So they Others principally answer to the Major Prop. and tell you that separation is either causeles or upon just ground and cause that t is a causeles separation only from the Church of Christ that is Schisme that there can be no cause of Schisme for if there be a cause of Schisme materially it ceaseth to be Schisme formally and so to strengthen their answer in Hypothesi they fall upon the Idolatrys Heresies Tyranny and Apostacy of the Church of Rome as just causes of Separation from her nor will their plea be shaken to eternity so that being true and popular understood by the meanest though it contain not the whole Truth I shall not in the least impaire it For them who
have found out new ways of justifying our separation from Rome on principles of limiting the Jurisdiction of the Bishop of Rome to a peculiar Patriarchat and granting a power to Kings or Nations to erect a Patriarchate or Metropolitan within their own Territories and the like the Protestant cause is not concerned in their Plea the whole of it on both hands being forraigne to the Scripture relating mostly to humane constitutions wherein they may have liberty to exercise their Witts and Abilities Not receding from what hath by others solidly been pleaded on the Answers above mentioned in answer to the principles I have hitherto evinced I shall proceed to give my account of the Argument proposed That we mistake not I only premise that I take Schisme in this Argument in the notion and sense of the Scripture precisely wherein alone it will reach the Consciences and bear the weight of inferring damnation from it 1. Then I wholly deny the Major Prop. as utterly false in what sense soever that expression True Church of Christ is taken Take it for the Catholick Church of Christ I deny that any one who is once a true member of it can utterly forsake its communion no living member of that body of Christ can perish and on supposition it could doe so it would be madnesse to call that crime Schisme nor is this a meer deniall of the Assertion but such as is attended with an invincible Truth for its maintenance Take it for the generall visible Church of Christ the voluntary forsaking of its communion which consists in the profession of the same faith is not Schisme but Apostacy and the thing it selfe is to be removed from the question in hand And as for Apostates from the faith of the Gospell we question not their damnation it sleepeth not who ever call'd a Christian that turned Jew or Mahumetan a Schismatick Take it for a particular Church of Christ I deny 1. That Separation from a particular Church as such as meerly separation is Schisme or ought to be so esteemed though perhaps such separation may proceed from Schisme and be also attended with other evills 2. That however separation upon jusâ— cause and ground from any Church is no Schisme This is granted by all Persons living Schisme is causelesse say all men however concerned And herein is a truth uncontroulable Separation upon just cause is a duty and therefore cannot be Schisme which is alwayes a sinne Now there are 500 things in the Church of Rome whereof every one grafted as they are there into the stock principle of imposition on the practice and confession of men is a sufficient cause of separation from any particular Church in the world yea from all of them one after another should they all consent unto the same thing impose it in the same manner if therebe any Truth in that Maxime It is better to obey God then man 2 I wholy deny the Minor Proposition also if spoken in reference to the Church of Rome Though I willingly acknowledge our separation to be voluntary from them no more being done then I would doe over againe this day God assisting me were I called unto it But separation in the sense contended about must be from some sâ—ate and condition of Christs Institution from communion with a Church which we held by his appointment otherwise it will not be pleaded that it is a Schisme at least not in a Gospell sense Now though our Forefathers in the faith we professe lived in sub ection to the Pope of Rome or his subordinate engines yet they were not so subject to them in any way or state instituted by Christ so that the relinquishment of that State can possibly be no such separation as to be termed Schisme For I wholy deny that the Papacy exercising its power in its supreame and subordinate Officers which with them is their Church is a Church at all of Christs appointment or any such thing And when they prove it is so I will be of it So that when our Forefathers withdrew their neck from his Tyrannicall yoke and forsook the practice of his abominations in the worship of God they forsook no Church of Christs institution they relinquished no communion of Christs appointment A man may possibly forsake Babylon and yet not forsake Sion For the Aggravations of the sinne of Schisme from some Ancient Writerâ— Austin and Optatus men interested in the contests about it Leo and Innocent gaining by the notion of it then growing in the World Thomas Aquinas and such vassalls of the Papacy we are not concerned in them what the Lord speaks of it that we judge concerning it It is true of the Catholicâ— Church alwaies that out of it no salvation it being the Society of them that shall be saved and of the visible Church in generall in some sense and cases Seeing with the heart man believeth to Righteousnesse and with the mouth confession is made unto Salvation But of a particular Church in no sense unlesse that of contempt of a known duty and to imagine Peter to speak of any such thing is a fancy The consequence of this devesting the Roman Synogogue of the priviledges of a true Church in any sense arising in the thoughts of some to a denyall of that ministry which we have at this day in England must by the way a little be considered For my part be it spoken without offence If any man hath nothing to plead for his ministry but meerly that successive Ordination which he hath received through the Church of Rome I cannot see a stable bottome of owning him so to be I do not say if he will plead nothing â—lse but if he hath nothing else to plead He may have that which indeed constitutes him a Minister though he will not ownâ— that so it doth Nor doth it come here into enquiry whether there were not a true Ministry in some all along under the Papacy distinct from it as were the thousands in Israell in the days of Elijah when in the ten Tribes as to the publick worship there was no true Ministry at all Nor is it said that any have their Ministry from Rome aâ— though the Office which is an Ordinance of Christ was instituted by Antichrist But the question is whether this be a sufficient and good basis and foundation of any mans interest in the office of the Ministry that he hath received Ordination in a succession through the administration of not the woman flying into the Wildernesse under the persecution of Antichrist not of the two witnesses prophesying all along under the Roman Apostacy not from them to whom we succeed in doctrine as the Waldenses but the Beast it selfe the persecuting Church of Rome the Pope and his adherents who were certainly Administrators of the Ordination pleaded for So that in doctrine we should succeed the persecuted Woman and in Office the perseâ—uting Beast I shall not plead this at
large professedly disclaiming all thoughts of rejecting those Ministers as Papall and Antichristian who yet adhere to this Ordination being many of them eminently gifted of God to dispense the word and submitted unto by his people in the Administration of the Ordinances and are right worthy Ministers of the Gospell of Christ But I shall only remarke some thing on the plea that is insisted on by them who would if I mistake not keep up in this particular what God would have pull'd downe They aske us why not Ordination from the Church of Rome as well as the Scripture In which enquiry I am sorry that some doe still continue We are so farre from having the Scripture from the Church of Rome by any Authority of it as such that it is one cause of daily praising God that by his providence he kept them from being either corrupted or destroyed by them It iâ— true the Bible was kept among the people that lived in those parts of the World where the Pope prevailed so was the Old Testament by the Jews the whole by the Easterne Christians By none so corrupted as by those of the Papall Territorie God forbid we should say we â—ad the Scriptures from the Church of Rome as such if we had why doe we not keep them as she delivered them to us in the vulgar Translation with the Apochryphall additions The Ordination pleaded for is from the Authority of the Church of Rome as such The Scriptures were by the providence of God preserved under the Papacy for the use of his People and had they been found by chance as it were like the Law of old they had been the same to us that now they are So that of these things there is not the same Reason It is also pleaded that the granting true Ordination to the Church of Rome doth not prove that to be a true Church This I professe I understâ—and not they who ordained had no power so to doe but as they were Officers of that Church as such they did it and if others had ordained who were not Officers of that Church all would confesse that Action to be null But they who will not be contented that Christ hath appointed the Office of the Ministry to be continued in his Churches that he continues to dispense his gifts of the Spirit for the Execution of that Office when men are called thereunto that he prepares the hearts of his people to desire and submit unto them in the Lord that as to the manner of entrance upon the worke they may have it according to the minde of Christ to the utmost in all circumstances so soon as his Churches are shaken out of the dust of Babylon with his Glory shining on them and the Tabernacle of God is thereby once more placed with men shall have leave for me to derive their interest in the ministry through that darke passage wherein I cannot see one step before me if they are otherwise qualified and accepted as above I shall ever pay them that honour which is done to Elders labouring in the word and doctrine CHAP. VII Of a particular Church its nature Frequently mentioned in Scripture Particular Congregations acknowledged the only Churches of the first Institution What ensued on the multiplication of Churches Some things premised to clear the unity of the Church in this sence Every Believer ordinarily obliged to joyne himselfe to some particular Church Many things in instituted worship answering a naturall principle Perpetuity of the Church in this sence True Churches at first planted in England How they ceased so to be How Churches may be again reerected Of the Vnion of a particular Church in its selfe Foundation of that Vnion twofold The Vnion its selfe Of the communion of particular Churchers one with another Our concernment in this Vnion I now descend to the last consideration of a Church in the most usuall Acceptation of that name in the New Testament that is of a particular instituted Church A Church in this sence I take to be a Society of men called by the word to the obedience of the Faith in Christ and joynt performance of the worship of God in the same individuall Ordinances according to the order by Christ prescribed This generall description of it exhibits its nature so farre as is necessary to cleare the subject of our present disquisition A more accurate definition would only administer farther occasion of contesting about things not necessary to be determined as to the enquiry in hand Such as this was the Church at Hierusalem that was persecuted Act. 8. 1. The Church whereof Saul made havock v. 3. The Church that was vexed by Herod Act. 12. 1. Such was the Church at Antioch which Assembled together in one place Act. 13. 14. wherein were sundry Prophets Act. 13 1. As that at Hierusalem consisted of Elders and Bretherren Act. 15. 22. The Apostles or some of them being there then present which added no other consideration to that Church then that we are now speaking of Such were those mens Churches wherein Elders were ordained by Pauls appointment Act. 14. 23. As also the Church of Coesarea Act. 18. 22. at Ephesus Act. 20. 14. 28. As was that at Corinth 1 Cor. 1. 2. c. 6. 4. 11. 12. 14. 4 5. 12. 19. 2 Cor. 1 1. And those mentioned Rev. 1. 2 3. All which Paul calls the Churches of the Gentiles Rom. 16. 4. in contradistinction to those of the Jews and calls them indefinitely the Churches of God v. 16. or the Churches of Christ 1 Cor. 7. 17. 2 Cor. 8 18. 19. 23. 2 Thess 1. 4. and in sundry other places Hence we have mention of many Churches in one Country as in Judaea Act. 9. 1. in Asia 1 Cor. 16. 19. in Macedonia 2 Cor. 8. 1. in Galatia Gal. 1. 2. the seven Churches of Asia Rev. 1. 11. and unto 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Act 16. 4. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 answers v. 5. in the same Country I suppose that in this description of a particular Church I have not only the consent of them of all sorts with whom I have now to doe as to what remaines of this discourse but aso their acknowledgment that these were the only kinds of Churches of the first Institution The Reverend Authors of the Jus Divinum Ministerii Anglicani p. 2 c. 6. tell us that in the Beginning of Christianity the number of Believers even in the greatest Citys were so few as that they might all meet 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 in one and the same place And these are called the Church of the City and the Angell of such a City was Congregationall not Diocesan which discourse exhibits that state of a particular Church which is now pleaded for and which shall afterwards be evinced allowing no other no not in the greatest Cityes In a rejoynder to that Treatise so far at the case of Episcopacy is herein concerned by a person well known
and of your own accord forsaken and renounced the communion of this Church cast off your subjection to the Bishops and Rulers rejected the forme of worship appointed in that Church that great bond of its communion and set up separated Churches of your own according to your pleasures and so are properly Schismaticks This I say if I mistake not is the summe of the charge against us on the account of of our late attempt for Reformation and reducing of the Church of Christ to its primitive institution which we professe our aime in singlenesse of heart to have been and leave the judgement of it unto God To acquit our selves of this imputation I shall declare 1. How farre we owne our selves to have been or to be members or Children as they speake of the Church of England as it is called or esteemed 2. What was the subjection whein we or any of us stood or might be supposed to have stood to the Prelates or Bishops of that Church And then I shall 3. Put the whole to the issue and enquiry whether we have broken any bond or order which by the institution and appointment of Jesus Christ we ought to have preserved entire unviolated not doubting but that on the whole matter in difference we shall finde the charge mannaged against us to be resolved wholy into the Pruâ—ence and interest of some men wherein our Consciences are not concerned As to the first proposall the severall considerations that the Church of England may fall under will make way for the determination of our Relation thereunto 1. There being in this Country of England much people of God many of his Elect called and Sanctified by and through the Spirit and blood of Christ with the washing of water and the Word so made true living members of the mysticall body or Catholick Church of Christ holding him as a spirituall Head receiving influences of life and grace from him continually they may be called though improperly the Church of England that is that part of Christs Catholick Church militant which lives in England In this sense it is the desire of our soules to be found and to abide members of the Church of England to keep with it whilst we live in this world the Vnity of the Spirit in the bond of Peace Hierusalem which is above is the Mother of us all and one is our Father which is in Heaven one is our Head Soveraigne Lord and Ruler the dearly beloved of our Soules the Lord Jesus Christ If we have grieved offended troubled the least member of this Church so that he may justly take offence at any of our waies we professe our readinesse to lye at his or their feet for Reconciliation according to the mind of Christ If we bear not love to all the Members of the Church of England in this sense without dissimulation yea even to them amongst them who through mistakes and darknesse have on severall accounts designed our harme and ruine if we rejoyce not with them and suffer not with them however they may be differenced in and by their opinions or walkings if we desire not their good as the good of our own Soules and are not ready to hold any communion with them wherein their and our Light will give and afford unto us peace mutually if we judge condemne despise any of them as to their Persons Spirituall state and Condition because they walk not with us let us be esteemed the vilest Schismaticks that ever lived on the face of the Earth But as to our membership in the Church of England on this account we stand or fall to our own master 2. The Rulers Governors Teachers and Body of the People of this Nation of England having by Laws Professions and publick Protestations cast off the Tyranny Authority Doctrine of the Church of Rome with its Head the Pope joyntly assented unto and publickly professed the doctrine of the Gospell as expressed in their publick Confession variously attested and confirmed declaring their profession by that publick confession Preaching Laws and Writings suitable thereunto may also be called on good account the Church of England In this sense we professe ourselves members of the Church of England as professing and adhering to that Doctrine of Faith in the Unity of it which was here established and declared as was before spoken As to the attempt of some who accuse us for everting of fundamentalls by our doctrine of Election by the free grace of God of effectuall Redemption of the Elect only conversion by the irresistible efficacy of Grace and the associate doctrines which are commonly known we suppose the more sober part of our Adversaries will give them little thanks for their pains therein If for no other Reason yet at least because they know the cause they have to mannage against us is weakned thereby Indeed it seems strange to us that we should be charged with Schisme from the Church of England for endeavouring to reforme our selves as to something relating to the worship of God by men everting and denying so considerable a portion of the Doctrine of that Church which we sacredly retaine entire as the most urgent of our present Adversaries doe In this sense I say we still confesse our selves members of the Church of England nor have we made any separation from it but do daily labour to improve and carry on the light of the Gospell which shines therein and on the account whereof it is renowned in the world 3. Though I know not how proper that expression of Children of the Church may be under the New Testament nor can by any meanes consent unto it to the urging of any obedience to any Church or Churches whatsoever on that account no such use being made of that consideration by the Holy Ghost nor any parallell unto it insisted on by him yet in a generall sence so farre as our receiving our Regeneration and new birth through the grace of God by the preaching of the Word and the saving truths thereof here professed with the seale of it in our baptisme may be signified by that expression we owne our selves to have been and to be Children of the Church of England because we have received all this by the administration of the Gospell here in England as dispensed in the severall Assemblyes therein And are contented that this concession be improved to the utmost Here indeed are we left by them who renounce the Baptisme they have received in their infancy repeat it again amongst themselves Yet I suppose that He who upon that single account will undertake to prove them Schismaticall may find himselfe intangled Nor is the case with them exactly as it was with the Donatists They doe the same thing with them but not on the same Principles The Donatists rebaptized those who came to their societies because they professed themselves to believe that all Administration of Ordinances not in their Assemblyes was null
administring the holy ordinances of the Gospell in and to their â—wn flock and whatever else of duty and ratione officii belongs to a rightly constituted Bishop and â—et all that have disturbed this course so duly â—â—tled in this Church and in all Churches of Christ â—â—nce the Apostles planting them discerne their â—â—â—rour and returne to that peace and Vnity of the Church from whence they have causelesly and inexcusably departed Though I was not then speaking of the Bishops of England yet I am contented with the application to them there being amongst them men of piety and learning whom I exceedingly honour reverence Amongst all the Bishops He of Oxford is I suppose peculiarly instanced in because it may be thought that living in this place I may belong to his Jurisdiction But in the condition wherein I now am by the providence of God I can plead an exemption on the same foot of account as he can his Jurisdiction So that I am not much concerned in his exercise of it as to my own person If he have a particular flock at Oxon which he will attend according to what before I required he shall have no let or hindrance from me but being he is as I heare he is a Reverend and Learned person I shall be glad of his Neighbourhood acquaintance But to suppose that the Diocesse of Oxon as legally constituted and bounded is his particular flock or Church that such a Church is instituted by Christ or hath been in Being ever since the Apostles times that in his presidency in this Church he is to set up Courts and exercise a Jurisdiction in them and therewith a power over all the inhabitants of this Diocesse or Shire excepting the exempt peculiar jurisdiction although gathered into particular Congregations and united by a participation of the same Ordinances and all this by the will and appointment of Jesus Christ is to suppose what will not be granted I confesse as before there was once such an Order in this place that it is now removed by Lawes on which foundation alone it stood before And this is that where in I am not concerned Whether we have causelesly inexcusably departed froÌ„ the Vnity of the Church is the matter now in enquiry I am sure unles the Vnity can be fixed our departure will not be proved A law Vnity I confesse an Evangelicall I am yet in the disquisition of But I confesse it will be to the prejudice of the cause in hand if it shall be thought that the determination of it depends on the controversy about Episcopacy for if so it might be righteously expected that the Arguments produced in the behalfe and defence thereof should be particularly discussed But the truth is I shall easily acknowledge all my labour to no purpose if have to deale only with men who suppose that if it be granted that Bishops as commonly esteemed in this Nation are of the appointment of Christ it will thence follow that we have a Nationall Church of Christs appointment between which indeed there is no Relation or connexion Should I grant as I said diocesan Bishops with Churches answerable to their supportment particled into severall Congregations with their inferiour Officers yet this would be remote enough from giving subsistence and Vnion to a Nationall Church What then it is which is called the Church of England in respect whereto we are charged with Schisme is nextly to be considered Now there are two wayes whereby we may come to the discoverie of what is intended by the Church of England or there are two ways whereby such a thing doth arise 1. Descendendo which is the way of the Prelates 2. Ascendendo which is the way of the Presbyterians For the first to constitute a Nationall Church by descent it must be supposed that all Church power is vested in Nationall Officers viz. Arch-Bishops and from them derived to severall Diocesians by a distribution of power limited in its exercise to a certaine portion of the Nation and by them communicated by severall engines to Parochiall Priests in their severall places A man with halfe an eye may see that here are many things to be proved Thus their first Church is Nationall which is distributed into severall greater portions termed Provinces those againe into others now called Diocesses and those againe subdivided into Parochiall or particular Congregations Now the Vnion of this Church consisteth in the due observance of the same worship specifically by all the members of it and subjection according to Rules of their own appointment which were called commonly Canons by way of distinction unto the Rulers before mentioned in their severall capacities And this is that which is the peculiar forme of this Church That of the Church Catholick absolutely so called is its Vnity with Christ and in its selfe by the one Spirit whereby it is animated That of the Church Catholick visibly professing the Unity of the Faith which they doe professe as being by them professed That of a particular Church as such its observance and performance of the same Ordinances of worship numerically in the confession of the same faith and subjection to the same Rules of Love for edification of the whole Of this Nationall as it is called in the subjection of one sort of Officers unto another within a precinct limited Originally wholy on an account forraigne to any Church state whatever So that it is not called the Church of England from its participation of the nature of the Catholick Church on the account of its most noble members nor yet from its participation of the nature of the invisible Church in the world on the account of its profession of the Truth in both which respects we professe our Unity with it nor yet from its participation of the nature of a particular Church which it did not in its selfe nor as such but in some of its particular Congregations but from a peculiar forme of its owne as above described which is to be proved to be of the Institution of Jesus Christ In this description given of their Church state with whom we have now to doe I have purposely avoided the mention of things odious exposed to common obloquy which yet were the very â—ies ligaments of their order because the thing as it is in its selfe being nakedly represented we may not be prejudiced in judging of the strength and utmost of the charge that lyes against any of us on the account of a departure from it The communion of this Church they say we have forsaken and broken its Vnity and therefore are Schismaticks I answer in a word laying aside so much of the Iurisdiction of it mentioned before and the severall ways of its administration for which there is no colour or pretence that it should relate to any Gospell institution passe by also the consideration of all those things which the men enjoying Authority in or exercising