's certaine also that beleevers amongst themselves have charge of each other by vertue of the communion of Saints whereby they all dispersed through the whole world are associated into one body Eph. 4. 1 2 3 4 5 6. and 1 Thes 5. 14 15. and by the duty of Charity which requires this mutuall care from all Lev. 19. Heb. 3. and 10. 3. We reject also the opinion of those who affirme that the Sacraments of the Old and New Testament are signes and seales to confirme this Church-covenant and so instituted by God for the ratifying of it that they are to be administred to those only who are by such a Church-covenant united amongst themselves but to be denied to others though knowne to be Godly who be not in such a Church-communion and strict fellowship Whereas it doth most cleerly appeare out of the holy Scriptures that the Sacraments were instituted by God in his Church chiefly and in the first place to be signes and seales of the Covenant of Grace and of the benefits promised in the Covenant of Grace and of Salvation procured by Christ for us as is manifest by the Sacrament of Circumcision Gen. 17. 7 10. Rom. 4. 11. of the Passeover 1 Cor. 5. of Baptisme Mark 1. 4. Act. 2. 38 39. and 22. 16. Rom. 6. 3 4. Tit. 3. 5. and of the Lords Supper Matth. 26. 26 27 28. 1 Cor. 11. 24 25 26. But in a secondary respect we acknowledge the Sacraments to be seales of our outward ingrafting into the Church visible and our conjunction into one body of the Church Act. 2. 41. 1 Cor. 12. 12 13. and that as we conceive of the Catholicke Church so that he that is baptized is not baptized into the communion only of this or that particular or parochiall Church but is joyned into that one body of the Church Catholike and universall as the whole Ministery of the Church is given by Christ to men to bring them to the unity and conjunction of the Church Catholike and universall and to ingraft them as members into it Eph. 4. 11 12. 1 Cor. 12. 28. Rom. 12. 5 6 7. And as by Excommunication duly performed the person excommunicate is not cast out of this or that particular Church only but is bound all the world over and shut out from the brotherly communion of the Church universall Matth. 18. 17 18. so the Sacraments of Baptisme and the Lords Supper are seales to a man of Ecclesiasticall communion not only in a particular Church but in the Church universall And therefore we hold that these Sacraments are to be administred not to those only who by a Church Covenant have joyned themselves to some particular Church but to all the members of the Church Catholike who have duly prepared themselves for the partaking of them Thus our Belgick Churches deny not the seale of Baptisme to the children of those parents who have not by a confession of faith and submission to Ecclesiasticall Discipline joyned themselves to any particular Church according to the practise of the Jewish Church Josh 5. 4 6. as neither doe we deny the participation of the Lords Supper to those who by reason of the necessity of their calling cannot joyne themselves to any particular Church but are forced to travell through divers Parochiall Churches CHAP. III. Of an institute visible Church Question VVHether no other externall visible Church be described in Scripture and acknowledged by the word of God but a parochiall or particular Church which is confined to such limits as that of necessity it must be such as may be contained and ought to meet ordinarily in one place for the celebrating of Gods publike worship and all the Ordinances of God with mutuall edification so that the constitution of such a Church which by reason of their multitude or some other cause cannot in all their members meet ordinarily in one place for the celebration of the worship of God and exercise of all Gods ordinances is unlawfull and repugnant to the word of God and the Apostles institutions concerning the constitution of a Church described in the holy Scripture Answer VVE judge an externall visible particular Church to be a Church duly and lawfully constituted according to the patterne of the Churches erected by the Apostles which when it may be doth in one Place under the inspection of one Pastor and Elders adjoyned frequent the service of God for their mutuall edification But when by reason of the multitude which God daily addeth to the Church or some other cause it cannot meet in one place but doth in severall places exercise the divine worship of God and the work of the Ministery under more Pastors and Elders joyned into one Consistory Presbytery or Classis the constitution of such a Church we say doth very well agree with the word of God and the Apostolicall institution And therefore wee also conceive that the visible Church described in the holy Scripture is not only a parochiall or particular Church but that there is also a Nationall and Universall Church dispersed through a whole kingdome yea through the whole world which doth in Ecclesiasticall communion make up one body Catholike Yea we affirme that the name Church in Scripture is applyed to a company of Elders with Ecclesiasticall jurisdiction assembled together for transacting Church affaires Therefore concerning a visible Church instituted by the word of God we defend these following positions 1. That the constitution of such a Church which by reason of its multitude or some other cause cannot meet ordinarily in one place for celebrating Divine worship and exercising the ordinances of God is lawfull and consonant to the word of God and the Apostolicall institution though they exercise the worship of God and the work of the Ministry in diverse places under severall Pastors and Elders joyned into one Presbitery This position is proved 1. From the constitution of the Church of Jerusalem instituted and erected by the Apostles which could not meet in one place but must by reason of their multitude meet distributively from house to house in divers places under the inspection of divers Pastors and yet was a visible instituted Church and is called in Scripture a Church in the singular number For the number of that Church was so great that three thousand were added to it in one day Act. 2. 41. and the number of those that beleeved and were added to the Church grew up to the number of five thousand men Act. 4. 4. and the number of those that believed increased daily more and more both of men and women Act. 5. 14. Act. 2. 47. which yet daily met and that in the time of persecution from house to house for performing the exercises of Divine worship Act. 2. 46. and 5. 42. 2. The Church of Ephesus duly constituted according to the word of God was one Church Revel 2. 2. which yet was governed by divers Pastors joyned in a common Presbitery for Ecclesiasticall jurisdiction Acts
Ecclesiastically and when one of them hath made defection from the Gospell of Christ others indeavour by Ecclesiasticall Ministry and the Discipline of Christ to reduce it into the right way and if they refuse to hearken to their Ecclesiasticall admonition they judge them as a company of heathens and publicans avoid and exclude them from their holy communion Since then the Churches of one people or nation performe amongst themselves these specificall exercises of Ecclesiasticall communion and union there is therefore a coalition of them into a Church Nationall Hence also our Churches of the Netherlands in their Synodall Canons have ordained not only Ecclesiasticall Assemblies Consistoriall Presbyteriall and Classicall but have also often decreed that Synods Provinciall and Nationall are to be called for the Ecclesiasticall judging of the affaires of the Church As appeares by the Synod at Emda Anno 1571. art 6 7 8 9. at Dort Anno 1578. art 16 17. at Middleburgh Anno 1581. art 20 21. at the Hagh Anno 1586. art 26 27. at Middleburgh Anno 1591. art 25 26. at Dort Anno 1619. art 29 30. where it is decreed that there shall be foure sorts of Church Assemblies held to wit Consistories Classes Synods Provinciall and Nationall wherein nothing but Ecclesiasticall affaires may be handled and that in an Ecclesiasticall manner III. We affirme that there is described in Scripture an universall externall Church dispersed through the whole world which in a visible polity maketh one Ecclesiasticall organicall body under which are contained all Particular Classicall Provinciall and Nationall Churches as parts of that whole This assertion we thus prove from Scripture 1. From 1 Cor. 12. 28. God hath set some in the Church c. where by the word Church is signified that one body of which there are many members spoken of ver 12. wherein is not described the Invisible and mysticall Church of Christ as such but the Church of Christ as Visible and externall as being that which is distinguished by the visible Sacrament or signe of Baptisme ver 13. which consisteth of various and heterogeneous externall members and organs ver 15 16 17 18. to which are given from God those various and externall administrations for edification spoken of ver 28. which is subject to Schisme and separation ver 25. Nor is it any Particular Church that is there described but the Universall and Catholike Church wherein all as well Jewes as Gentiles are joyned into one body ver 13. which comprehends all that are baptized in one Spirit ver 13. to which are given from God Apostles Prophets Teachers Pastours the gifts of tongues and miracles c. ver 28. which are not given to this or that particular but to the Catholike Church visible There is therefore here described an Universall Church 2. There is by the Word of God some fellowship and communion Ecclesiasticall betweene all the visible Churches of the whole world and therefore we must acknowledge by the Institution of Christ a universall body of the Church For there is between them an internall fellowship and an obligation to mutuall duties of Christianity Eph. 4. 3 4 5 6. which requireth also an externall Ecclesiasticall fellowship and communion in exhorting reproving comforting and edifying of all and bindeth us to offer prayers and thanksgivings to God in the Ministry of the Church in behalfe of all the Churches of the whole world to reduce Churches gone astray c. and that fellowship which the members of a particular Church hold amongst themselves the same in a due proportion ought the Provinciall and Nationall Churches to hold amongst themselves for the mutuall edification and increase of the body of Christ by which Ecclesiasticall communion all Nationall Churches doe make up one Universall Ecclesiasticall body 3. So also we see in Scripture Ecclesiasticall meetings held which represented the Church Catholike and Universall of the whole world wherein businesses were transacted which concerne the Universall Catholike Church of the whole world as Act. 1. where an Ecclesiasticall meeting is held by Preaching the Word and exercises of Discipline or Church-Government ver 15 16 26. and that in the name of the Church Catholike for there are the Pastours of the Church Catholike the Apostles sent into the whole world Matth. 28. 19. with the brethren out of Galilee and Jerusalem ver 15. and they transact a businesse which concerneth the Church Universall to wit the Election of an Apostle to be a Pastor of the Church Universall And they who transact those things which concern the rule government and oversight of the Church Universall ought to represent the Church of the whole world And All. 15. 22. that meeting of Apostles Elders and Brethren is called a Church who by an ordinary power prescribed Ecclesiasticall decrees and canons to all the Churches of the Gentiles and imposed them in a way of Jurisdiction which no Provinciall or Nationall much lesse Parochiall Church might lawfully do but is an act of the Catholike Church The Reformed Divines also acknowledge a Catholike visible Church see amongst others Walaeus in his common places loco de Ecclesia militante pag. 458. of his works in folio where explaining the nature of the Church visible after the definition of it he affirmes that this Church visible is considered two wayes either Vniversally for the Church which through the whole world is by the preaching of the Gospell called out of the world which in some respect may be called also Catholike or for a Particular company confined to one certain place See also the Positions of the Professours of Leyden disp 40. thes 27. where they tell us that the Church Visible is by some consounded with a Church Particular and the Invisible with the Vniversall But we say they saving alwayes better judgements thinkâ— these members ought not to be confounded And thes 33. thus they say This Church visible is considered two wayes either as a certaine company of one particular village towne or province those to wit who are knit together not only in a community of Faith and Sacraments but also in the forme of externall Government and Ecclesiasticall rites or as a certaine company Occumenicall and universall dispersed in divers places through the whole world though in the very externall forme of Government and circumstantiall rites they doe often much differ amongst themselves yet agreeing in the essentiall communitie of the Faith and Sacraments whence also that is frequent in Cyprian The Bishoprick is one whereof each severally hold a part IIII. We affirme that a company of Presbyters met together with Ecclesiasticall jurisdiction for transacting Church affaires are a Church to wit a ministeriall or a governing and representative Church as they call it and therefore called in Scripture by the name Church We confesse that such a company of Presbyters are not a Church Representative properly so called as if the Elders were the delegates of the beleevers who in their name and their stead governe the
And our assertion is proved 1. From Mat. 16. 17 18. where the Keys of the Kingdome of Heaven are promised to Peter as a Pastor and ordinary Ruler of the Church of God for to those is promised the power of binding and loosing of retaining and remitting sinnes ver 19. which authority is peculiar to Christs Embassadours whom he sendeth into the world with his authority Joh. 20. 20 21 22. 2 Cor. 5. 19 20. To those therefore is the exercise of the Keyes in Excommunication intrusted and not to the whole people to whom they are not promised 2. From Matth. 18. 17 18. We have shewed before that this place is to be understood of a Church representative or Company of Presbyters to whom Christ hath given power whereby they actually cast out the scandalous and obstinate as heathens and publicans from Church-communion which power is not given to the multitude of beleevers 3. Our assertion is evident from 1 Cor. 5. 4 5. You saith the Apostle and my spirit being gathered together in the Name of the Lord Jesus Christ with the power of the Lord Jesus Christ let such a man be delivered to Satan and this rebuke or Church censure was done 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 by many as he writes 2 Cor. 2 6. Surely that by these many the Apostle understandeth not the whole multitude is easily manifest if all were present at the deliberating every one even of the meanest capacity may see there was no reason why Paul should not have written 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 of all for this had been very sutable to commend that cause which the Apostle was urging for from the multitude of those who had by Ecclesiasticall Discipline corrected the incestuous person he endeavours to prevaile with the Corinthians that they would now afford pardon to him upon his repentance And further let it be remembred that these 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 these many are described in the former place to be 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 gathered together with the power of our Lord Jesus Christ For since we know that this power is by Christ committed to the Ministery of the Church and lies in the administration of the spirituall Keyes we may easily guesse that by the terme many is to be understood the company of Pastours and Elders to whom the care of Ecclesiasticall Discipline is committed Hence Bullinger on that place 1 Cor. 5. doth thus comment Therefore the ancient Church had a holy Senate of Presbyters which did diligently admonish offenders in the Church sharply correct them yea and exclude them from Church fellowship to wit if it appeared that no amendment might be expected And Hyperius noteth upon this place That by Congregation must not simply be understood the whole multitude amongst whom are mingled many Jewes Ananias's false brethren men vitious who would never suffer that such a sentence should be unanimously passed but rather certaine selected Elders eminent for learning and piety in whose power he would that the Judgement of the Church should be in like causes so that these by a Synecdoche are taken for the whole Church Which hence appeares that Matth. 18. after it was said Tell the Church it is added Where two or three are gathered together in my Name I will be in the midst of them And 2 Cor. 2. 6. he saith Sufficient is the punishment that was inflicted by many And Tertullian in his Apologetick chap. 39. saith that all the approved Elders used to preside If any saith he do so offend as that he be to be debarred from communicating in Prayer and Assemblies and all holy commerce all the approved Elders did preside who attained that honour not for mony but desert CHAP. V. Of the Ecclesiasticall Ministery and the Exercise thereof Question 1. WHether the end and effect of the work of the Ecclesiasticall Ministery be only the Confirmation and Edification of those Church-members who are already converted and truly godly so as that Pastours are not more obliged by vertue of their Ecclesiasticall function to convert the straying soules of such as live in the world and in sins out of church-Church-communion then all beleevers indued with the gifts of the holy Ghost are by the common duty of Charity bound to doe Answer WE judge that the Word of God duly and truly preached and publikely received is both a meanes of constituting a Visible Church and a note of a true Visible Church and a meanes also of confirming and saving of beleevers who doe already in a visible Church professe the Faith We grant in this Question 1. That private Christians from the common duty of Charity making use of those spirituall gifts which they have received from God for mens edification doe sometimes convert to the faith those souls which went astray and bring those who live in the world out of the Church unto the body of the Church of Christ See John 4. 29. c. 1 Cor. 7. 16. 2. We doe not think that the office of him who preacheth the Word as sent of God and the Church doth conferre any efficacie to the Word preached by him or hath any influence upon the soule of him that is converted For the power of God only and the Spirit which accompanieth the Word preached doth give to the Word preached a vertue and saving efficacy for the Conversion and Salvation of soules 1 Cor. 12. 11. 15. 10. But we affirme that the Word preached by him who is ordained to an Ecclesiasticall Office and doth by his Ecclesiasticall Office authoritatively preach the Word is the ordinary meanes to which God doth by the Efficacy of his Spirit give assistance for the Conversion of those who live in sinne out of Church-communion So that Pastours as Pastours by vertue of their Pastorall Office are the ordinary meanes of the Conversion of those men who live in the world This Assertion is proved 1. Because Faith is given and first attained by the Word preached by those who by an Ecclesiasticall call are sent of God to the Pastorall Office and by vertue of mission and function preach the Word whereby faith is wrought in man See Rom. 10. 14 15. 1 Cor. 3. 19. Gal. 3. 2. 2. Because Pastours of Churches by reason of the Office they beare are Fathers who doe first beget their children to Christ in the Church and by the spirituall seed of God do give spirit and life to those that are dead in sins See 1 Cor. 4. 15. Gal. 4. 19. 2 Cor. 2. 16. 3. Pastours are injoyned as an Office peculiarly belonging to them to preach the Word of God with all meeknesse mildnesse and patience if perhaps God will give repentance to those who are held captives in the shares of the devill 2 Tim. 2. 24 25 26. to open the eyes of those who sit in darknesse and to bring them to the light of the Gospel and of Grace Act. 26. 18. to seek lost sheep for the Lord Ezek. 34. 4 5. and to bring into captivitie to the
and Synods that they may so farre as conveniently can be make use of common consent and mutuall assistance especially in those things that are of greater moment But yet how much greater and further space and remotenesse of distance there is between particular Churches so much the lesse also is the visible communion of those Churches because the danger of scandall and infection and the opportunity of mutual edification is lesse or more according as the distinct distance of places is greater or lesse Wherfore there is a more strict visible Ecclesiasticall communion between the Churches of one Province or Nation then between the particular congregations of the Church Universall and consequently the jurisdiction and Ecclesiasticall government is also lesse visible between these then between the Churches of one Nation This communion of Churches in government and Church discipline is not only for the informing of Churches what is commanded by the word of God but also for the governing of them by laws and spirituall jurisdiction for there is an authority and power of rule belonging by the word of God to Churches joyned in Classes and Synods which to particular Churches singly and severally belongeth not to wit a power of making Canons and laws Ecclesiasticall which may bind all the particular Churches of one Province or Kingdome to obey them We grant in this controversy 1. That the power of Classes and Synods doth not take away or hurt the power or liberty Ecclesiasticall of a particular Church for it serveth to direct preserve and promote the power of Synods is not privative but cumulative and granted for this end that the power given to particular Churches may be more efficacious orderly regular able and apt for edifying 2. That there is a power belonging to a particular Church immediatly granted from God not derived from Classes or Synods as likewise there is belonging to Classes and Synods a power of their own immediatly granted by God and not derived from the particular Churches For though in regard of the Originall or the rise and constitution of a Synod particular Churches intire in themselves collaterall one to another and equall in Church power do in common contribute associate and exercise their Church power and so make up a collective and combined body of a Synod yet the Synodicall authority of it selfe is not granted to any other first subject from whence it should be derived to the Synod then to the Synod it selfe to which alone by the word of God and Apostolicall institution that power belongeth for no particular Churches singly and severally considered may exercise a Synodicall power over other Churches But we affirme 1. That this union and communion of particular Churches in a government and discipline Ecclesiasticall in common which is exercised in Synods and Classes is grounded upon the word of God and in the examples of the Apostolicall Church is proposed to us to imitate 2. That these Synods and Classes have a power and authority Synodall and Classicall whereby they do by spirituall jurisdiction authoritatively decerne matters Ecclesiasticall and impose those decrees under paine of Ecclesiasticall censure on particular Churches Our opinion is proved by these following arguments 1. In Act. 15. we have in the Apostles practise an expresse example of a Synod held at Jerusalem about a question concerning the observation of the Law of Moses In which Synod that businesse which had wrought a disturbance in the particular Churches ver 2 4 5 23. is by the deputies of severall Churches ver 2 6 23. Act. 21. 17 18 25. determined with power authoritative to bind particular Churches to obedience ver 22 28. chap. 16. 4. 21 25. And the false doctrine of those who subverted the soules of their hearers is by an Ecclesiasticall judgement condemned with spirituall power ver 28 29. which thing is an act of Ecclesiasticall jurisdiction as appeareth Revel 2. 2 14 20. and the determination of this Ecclesiasticall law was not by an extraordinary Apostolike authority but by an ordinary authority Ecclesiasticall for it was done not by the Apostles alone extraordinarily acted by the Spirit of God but by the Elders and brethren of the Church joyned with the Apostles acting not by their Apostololicall but by their ordinary Pastorall authority with great discussion and disputation and the assent of the Churches which argue that the decrees of this Synod were not made by an extraordinary Apostolicall authority but by an ordinary Ecclesiasticall power 2. Our assertion is proved from Christs institution Mat. 18. 17 18. where he doth institute such Ecclesiasticall Assemblies as may by Ecclesiasticall authority make provision and prepare efficacious remedies against all scandals and offences If the members of a particular Church do give scandall to one another he bids that it be shewed to a superior Ecclesiasticall Judge to wit the Church representative which by Ecclesiasticall authority doth condemne and punish and remove from Ecclesiasticall and brotherly communion the person offending and therefore doth likewise command that if particular Churches give offence to one another it should be carried to a superior Ecclesiasticall Judge which may by spirituall authority condemne punish and put from Ecclesiasticall communion the particular Church offending for where the law makes no distinction or restriction there must not we distinguish or restrain And certainly the remedy instituted in this place is ordained by Christ for the removing out of the visible Church all scandals not only caused by particular members but also by whole Churches and therfore there must be acknowledged a superior Ecclesiasticall Assembly which may by authoritative Ecclesiasticall power judge of the scandall of particular Churches as well as a superiour Ecclesiasticall judge in a particular Church is to be acknowledged from this institution for judging the scandalls of particular members For since that according to the holy Scriptures we must grant that there is an Ecclesiasticall communion between the visible Churches of one Province Nation yea and of the whole World as is proved before which communion is not only fraternall but Ecclesiasticall whereby Churches as Churches or bodies Ecclesiasticall are joyned and united in doctrine government worship discipline and Ecclesiasticall polity and seeing that in this holy communion scandals are committed which are unbeseeming those Churches and to be cast forth from that Ecclesiasticall communion therfore both by the law of nature and this divine law here instituted by Christ we must acknowledge a superiour Ecclesiasticall Senat furnished with spirituall and Ecclesiasticall authority which may remove those scandals Hence Parker himselfe de politia Ecclesiast lib. 3. cap. 24. groundeth the authority of Synods on this place And the Professors of Leyden disput 49. thes 10. discourse thus The institution of Ecclesiasticall Assemblies and so also of a Synod is not of humane but of divine right being founded on the words of Christ Tell the Church if he heare not the Church c. Whomsoever ye bind on earth c. Where
two or three are gathered together in my name there am I in the midst of them Matth. 18. and I am with you to the end of the World Matth. 28. Which primarily are to be understood of the inferior Consistories but there being an union and communion amongst themselves of all Churches the superior consistories are comprehended likewise 3. We deduce our argument from the practise of the Iewish Church For the Christian Church borroweth her frame of her Ecclesiasticall polity from the cōstitution not pedagogicall but essentiall and perpetuall of the ancient Church and therfore the Churches Consistories are now lawfully constituted according to the same forme according to which the Ecclesiasticall assemblies were constituted under the Old Testament And the reason is because it is manifestly evident that this order besides that it was of old instituted by God and by the fathers most religiously observed belonged onely to the 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 or good order of a Church not to the pedagogy of the Law nor the distinct nature of that government But now under the Old Testament there were Synagogicall consistories in each City wherin the Scribes and Levits being presiding some Elders of the people and men more eminent in dignity were joyned to them whose office consisted as well in teaching as in moderating the actions of the Church and who tooke notice of beleevers manners and dispensed pious reprehensions and Ecclesiasticall censures towards the vices of offenders And there was also at Jerusalem a generall consistory or Synedrium held to which the most weighty matters were brought which in the lesser Synagogicall judicatories either by reason of their difficulty or the dissentions of parties could not be decided or ended Se Deut. 17. 8 9. 2 Chron. 19. 5 6 7. Jer. 26. 9 c. This argument our eminent and reverend Gersom Bucer in his dissertation de gubernatione Ecclesiae pag. 65. doth thus propose and not to be tedious it was requisite to set downe distinctly in what respect the order appointed amongst the Jews doth expresse the polity to be observed by the Christian Church in holding their meetings For first as of old the use of sacred Consistories as well Synagogicall in the severall Cities as the supreme at Jerusalem was appointed by Gods institution for the passing of judgements and determining controversies So in the New Testament even from the beginning of the Churches birth the Lord would have as well particularly in each City as in many Cities in common some form of ordinary judicatory to the end that both the Ordination of Ministers may be duly performed and the censure of manners administred else what could be more absurd either then the Precept of Christ commanding that he who refused to heare his brethren should be brought to the Church or the Apostles reproofe reprehending the Corinthians that they had neglected to proceed in the publike judicatory of the Church against the incestuous person Neither only had each particular Church their proper distinct Consistories but that also divers Churches when more weighty controversies did arise which could not in lesser Assemblies be determined did in the new Testament come together to one generall Councell the history of the Apostles testifieth Acts 15. c. And doubtlesse not only this ordinary superiour Court or Sanedrim was kept at Jerusalem but extraordinary Conventions called for the Churches Reformation the establishing Religion and the sincere Worship of God by a Nationall Covenant and for other holy occasions See Examples thereof Deut. 29. 20. 2 Chro. 15. 9. 29. 4 34. 29 Nehem. 10. 32. to 34. And such conventions being celebrated for morall duties the celebration of them lyeth as a duty on the Churches of Christ at all times 4. A fourth Argument is taken from 1 Cor. 14. 32. where the spirits of the Prophets are to be subject to the Prophets by Apostolicall Precept whatsoever therefore an Ecclesiasticall Prophet doth in his sacred function performe either in sacred Doctrine or divine Worship or Ecclesiasticall Discipline it ought to be submitted to the judgements of other Prophets Therefore one single Prophet of this particular Church is to be subject to the judgement of Prophets of other Churches And consequently Assemblies of many Prophets meeting out of divers Churches are here established to whom by the Word of God the Spirits and wayes of Prophets of particular Churches are subject Other arguments are also at hand in this cause if we purposed to contend by number of Arguments Hence also doe the Churches of the Netherlands hold their Synods endowed with authority and power Ecclesiasticall which do so impose their decrees on particular Churches that they permit not a private or particular Church to alter the order established by the Synods but injoyne all to observe their Canons established till it shall be otherwise appointed by the Synods See the Synod at Embden Ann. 1571. art 53. at Dort Anno 1574. art 91. at Middleburgh Anno 1581. art 69. at the Hagh Anno 1586 art 79. at Middleburgh Anno 1591. art 80. at Dort Anno 1619. art 86. We reject therefore the opposite Assertions 1. Of those who allow to Synods and Classes no other power then of Counsell and Perswasion as one brother towards another and one particular Church towards another Particular Sister Church may be counsell and perswasion direct and exhort to their duty so neither have the whole number of Churches that hold Ecclesiasticall Communion in Synods and Classes any other authority granted them by the Word of God but to perswade exhort and admonish Against whom we use no other arguments then what Master John Cotton himselfe hath in a late Treatise in English concerning The Power of the Keyes Chap. 6. We dare not say saith he that their power reacheth no further then giving counsell for such as their ends be for which according to God they do assemble such is the power given them of God as may attaine those ends As they meet to minister light and peace to such Churches as through want of light and peace lye in errour or doubt at least and variance so they have power by the grace of Christ not only to give light and counsell in matter of Truth and Practise but also to command and injoyne the things to be beleeved and done The expresse words of the Synodall letter imply no lesse It seemed good to the Holy Ghost and unto us to lay upon you no other burden Acts 15. 27. This burden therefore to observe those necessary things they speake of they had power to impose It is an act of the binding power of the Keyes to bind burdens And this binding power ariseth not only materially from the weight of the matters imposed which are necessary necessitate praecepti from the Word but also formally from the authority of the Synod which being an Ordinance of Christ bindeth the more for the Synods sake Thus Master Cotton 2. We reject also their contrary opinion who allow to
bind by Oath our owne soules and the soules of others who live under our power to such a profession of saving Faith we may bind them also by Lawes and Canons to the same profession for of like things there is like judgement Question 2. VVHether it be lawfull to use in the Church prescript Formes of Prayer administration of the Sacraments c or whether those Churches who use them be guilty of superstition and will-worship and whether it be lawfull to hold Ecclesiasticall Communion with those Churches where such Formes in the publike worship are in use Answer IN this controversie we easily assent to what is written by Ames upon this question in his Cases of Conscience lib. 4. cap. 17. quaest 4. and to what the professors of Leyden have in their Synopsis Theologiae disput 36. Thes 33 34. And that we may handle the question distinctly 1. We reject such Formes of prayer of Administration of Sacraments c. which for the matter of them are vitious for we may not in prayers and other parts of the publike worship of God propound any thing unlawfull impertinent and unfitting which savoureth of superstition Idolatry or heresy or carnall profanenesse and pomp of the World and which introduceth a communion with the unfruitfull workes of darknesse And for this cause we reject the ceremonies and forms of publike worship introduced in the Church of England in these last corrupt times by the Hierarchicall Bishops as which being superstitious and idolatrous did deface the Church and worship of God and obscure the brightnesse and beauty of a glorious Reformation and a Church which takes up superstitious and idolatrous ceremonies partakes in superstition and idolatry 2. We reject also those Forms of prayers and publike worship which by a tyrannicall and violent command are imposed on the consciences of men as absolutely necessary and as essentiall parts of Gods worship though for the matter of them they be legitimatly disposed yet for the Form of them and the manner of their introducing they become illegitimate instruments of cruelty and pretences for perverse wickednesse and occasions of violent tyranny against the worthiest and best sonnes of the Church For there are not by Christ or the Apostles whose institutions are not defective in the absolutely necessary parts of Gods worship any Forms prescribed as simply and absolutely necessary wherein they have drawne up an exact and immutable rule for all Christians in Churches in matter and form and method to which all faithfull worshippers of God to the worlds end are to be precisely bound 3. The question is not here of the absolute necessity of Forms whereby they are obtruded as parts of Religion and essentiall meanes of divine worship but of such a prescribing them whereby they are by Ecclesiasticall authority commended for the order and decency of the worship of God as usefull and profitable for those who want either sufficient ability or freedome of exercising it for the seemly expression of those parts of divine worship that they may be as it were guided by them as helps in their meditations petitions words and actions and that the attention of the auditors especially in great Congregations may by those forms be helped and directed and that there may be an Uniformity observed in the exercises of publike worship in all Churches for the preventing of scandalls and for the greater edefication of the Churches But we judge those Forms as well publikely as privatly used to be lawfull and profitable so that they be read out of the booke with due attention reverence faith and spirituall affection and zeale towards God and that not only in case of necessity when he that is to perform those parts of divine worship is destitute of sufficient ability and fit words to expresse the prayers and other parts of divine worship but also for the helping and directing the attention of the auditors thereby and for keeping an uniformity in the exercises of Divine Worship for the edification of the Churches of God This Assertion is proved 1. Because we may in a prescript form sing Psalmes and offer thanksgivings to God with due reverence faith spirituall affection and zeale Asaph and his brethren had Forms for the due praising of God prescribed them by David according to the prescript whereof they were in set words to celebrate publike thanksgivings See 1 Chron. 16. 7 8. So in the dedication of the Temple the Priests and Levites did celebrate the publike worship of God according to the set-Forms prescribed by David 2 Chron. 7. 6. The like examples we have Numb 6. 22 23. 2 Chron 20. 21. Esra 3. 10 11. Psal 92. 1. But now if thanksgivings and singing of Psalmes which ought to be performed with spirituall affection reverence and understanding and joy 1 Cor. 14 15. Ephes 5. 19. Col. 3. 16. both lawfully may be and were performed according to the Word of God in set Forms then also Prayers and other parts of Divine Worship may in set Forms be duly and lawfully conceived and offered to God for thanksgivings and blessing of God are kinds of prayer and of the same nature which require the same affections of mind with other parts of Divine Worship 2. That is a just and lawfull forme of prayers in which are observed the essentialls and necessary requisites to all prayers But all things which in the holy Scripture are required to the due constitution of prayers may be observed and by the godly are observed in a holy manner in prayers conceived in set Forms and pronounced out of a booke Therfore this form of prayers is just and lawfull For what is there in Scripture required to the worship of supplications and godly prayers but that the matters of them be lawfull and stily disposed according to the present necessities that they be offered to God in a holy manner with reverence zeale humility and faith and that they duly expresse our urging necessities But we know by certaine experience that a prayer holy and lawfull for the matter of it may in a set Form be pronounced and offered to God with an humble sence of our necessities desire and zeal holinesse of affections faith and religious motions of our will towards God and that according as our affairs require The faithful reade the text of holy Scripture with understanding humility reverence zeale religious motions of the will and faith in God and application of them to particular necessities and why may not prayers in like manner be pronounced in prescript formes when as prayers differ in this only from hearing and reading the Word of God that in the one our will is moved towards God that we may be moved by him but in the other our will is moved towards God that he may be affected with our desires as Ames elsewhere observeth 3. Our Lord and Saviour Christ hath prescribed us a form of prayer For he hath given us the Lords-Prayer not only as a pattern or platform according to
Pastors from that function CHAP. V. Of the Ecclesiasticall Ministery and the Exercise thereof p. 66 Q. 1. WHether the end and effect of the work of the Ecclesiasticall Ministery be only the Confirmation and Edification of those Church-members who are already converted and truly godly so as that Pastours are not more obliged by vertue of their Ecclesiasticall function to convert the straying soules of such as live in the world and in sinnes out of church-Church-communion then all beleevers indued with the gifts of the holy Ghost are by the common duty of Charity bound to doe Question 2. p. 70. Whether the Minister of a particular Church may not only by vertue of his gifts and from the common duty of Charity but also by vertue of his Ecclesiasticall Function lawfully performe ministeriall acts of his office in the Ecclesiasticall Communion of another particular Church to whose ordinary ministery he is not called Question 3. p. 75 Whether the exercise of Prophesie be a perpetuall institution in the Church of God whereby private men who beare no Church-Office may for the exercise of the gifts of the Spirit publikely before the whole body of the Church preach the Word of God with all authority in the Name of God and explaine and apply it for instruction confutation reprehension and consolation of the hearers Question 4. p. 84 Whether those Infants whose next parents doe not by a solemne Church-Covenant joyne themselves to some particular Church are not to be baptized in the Church but are to be accounted as incapable of Baptisme and to have no right to Church-priviledges CHAP. VI. Of Classes and Synods and their authority p. 89 Q. 1. VVHether Classes and Synods have an authoritative power whereby they may authoritatively judge causes Ecclesiasticall with Ecclesiasticall jurisdiction so as that particular Churches ought to submit themselves to their decrees under the penalty of Ecclesiasticall censure Question 2. p. 103 VVhether Classes and Synods have power of sending or ordaining Pastors in a particular Church Question 3. p. 118 Whether Synods and Classes have power of Excommunication CHAP. VII Of set Formes p. 130 Q. 1. VVHether it be lawfull for Churches to prescribe to themselves constituted lawes and formes and certaine Canons by Ecclesiasticall authoritie wherein Articles of Faith and things necessarily required by God for the Government and Discipline of the Churches are out of the holy Scriptures expounded and determined and things not necessarily required are by Ecclesiasticall power prescribed according to the generall rules of Scripture from the precepts of the law of Nature and holy Prudence for the edification of the Church and the order and decency of Gods Worship and imposed on particular Churches and Church-Governours as bonds of Peace and Vnity Question 2. p. 143 Whether it be lawfull to use in the Church prescript Formes of Prayer Administration of the Sacraments c. or whether those Churches who use them be guilty of superstition and will-worship and whether it be lawfull to hold Ecclesiasticall Communion with those Churches where such Formes in the publike worship are in use FINIS VVE whose names are subscribed Delegates of the Walacrian Classis doe testifie that our Reverend Colleague Mr William Apollonius was injoyned by the said Classis that in these sad troubles of England he should by writing set downe what is the Government practised in the Churches of the United Provinces which we also judge agreeable to the Word of God and what are the Controversies at this time agitated in England concerning the Government of the Church of God and state that controversie by way of Theses and Antitheses shewing the Grounds of them And that we have diligently perused and approved that writing of his We desire from our soule that there were a way of Government as much as may be Uniforme observed in all Reformed Churches for the greater edification of the Church of Christ and the destruction of the kingdome of Satan We pray that the learned and worthy our Brethren and Fellow-labourers in the Kingdome of England would be pleased fairly to interpret this our affection Iacobus D'Herde President of the Wallacrian Classis pro tempore Iodocus Larenus Assessor pro tempore Isaacus Hoornbekius Preacher at Middleburgh Cornelius Beuckelarius Preacher at Vere Melchior Burs Minister of the word at West-Souburch Maximilianus Teellinck Preacher at Middleburgh This writing is set forth by prescript of the 46. Article of Ecclesiasticall Policy established by the most Renowned and Noble the States of Zealand Melchior Burs Minister of the Word at West-Souburch
sincere Word unite your hearts in the bands of brotherly love incline your minds to the Kingdomes and Churches Peace Middleburgh in Zeland Octob. 16. 1644. stilo novo Subscribed in the name of the Walachrian Churches by us Jacobus D'Herde President of the Walachrian Classis pro tempore Iodocus Larenus Assessor pro tempore Isaacus Hoornbekius Preacher at Middleburgh Cornelius Beuckelarius Preacher at Vere Melchior Burs Minister of West Souburch Errata PAg. 98. lin 16. And doubtlesse c. to the end of this Section change of letter p. 104. lin ult Luke relates unto p. 105 l. 9. Calvin these words must all be in the same letter as the former and the following p. 113. l. 19. And it appeares c. untill p. 114. l. 13. where he shewes exclusivè all these words must be in other letter p. 114. l. 5. and one dele p. 136. l. 11. Though therefore c. fifteen lines change of Letter p. 137. l. 2. For a Synod c. this whole page and the following unto lin 20. We hold exclusive change of letter p. 97. l. 1. dele being l. 18. read and not to be tedicus p. 98. l. 21. read see examples p. 114. l. 10. read 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 p. 128. l. 27. dele so p. 137. l. 22. r. this is p. 135. l. 3. and 1◠5 Indices lin 16. 1. Index A Consideration of certain Controversies at this time agitated in the Kingdome of England concerning the Government of the Church of God sent from the Churches of Walachria to the Synod at London to declare the sense and consent of their Churches CHAP. I. Of the Qualification of Church-members Question WHether there be none to be admitted into the Communion of the externall visible Church but who is indued with the reall internall holinesse of Regeneration and with justifying faith in Christ or who upon strict examination doth manifest such evident signes of true faith and reall internall holinesse as may convince the consciences of the Church to which he joyneth himselfe of his sincere faith repentance and communion in Christ and that if any Congregation admit others in whom there is not evident proofe of these signes they admit impure and false Church-members Answer THe Reformed Churches distinguish between the Mysticall invisible Church of Christ which is the Company of Beleevers called who have communion with Christ to which are made all the Promises of heavenly good things in Christ to which no hypocrites can belong which hath the power of Christs Spirit inwardly working and the externall visible Church of Christ which is the company of those who professe the true faith for the exercise of Church-Communion and Fellowship amongst themselves to which hypocrites may belong For any one to be a true member of the invisible Church we require according to the Word of God true justifying faith repentance and spirituall Communion with Christ The admission of members into this Church is Gods work who by effectuall saving Vocation doth ingraft men into the mysticall body of Christ But the admission of members of the Church visible is committed to the care of the Overseers and Pastors of the Church who by the Word of God may admit none other to the compleat externall communion of the Church visible and ought to admit all such who by externall federall holinesse are separated from the world are instructed in the knowledge of God and of the true Religion professe the name of Christ and walking without offence in their outward conversation are accounted in the judgement of Charity as true Beleevers and upon examination of the Eldership concerning these things are received into brotherly and Ecclesiasticall Communion We grant therefore in this question 1. That any one be in foro Dei at Gods tribunall a true member of the Church invisible there is required in him that he be indued with reall internall holinesse of regeneration and justifying faith in Christ 2. That it is mans duty who will duly for Salvation joyne himselfe to the Church that he truly beleeve in Christ and being indued with reall holinesse worship God aright in all his wayes But we affirme that to the externall and visible Church the Pastors are to admit those who professe the true Religion and faith of Christ lead their lives without scandall or being fallen into scandals doe by repentance wash them away in foro Ecclesiae at the Churches Tribunall submit themselves to Discipline publikely frequent all exercises of divine worship and desire Church Communion with us although they doe not manifest such evident signes of Regeneration which may convince the Consciences of the Church of their true faith in Christ Our opinion is proved by these arguments 1. From the admission of members into the Primitive Church in the Apostles time when all who made profession of Faith according to the Word of God and desired Ecclesiasticall Communion living without manifest scandals or having given scandals did by repentance in foro Ecclesiae amend them were by them admitted into the Communion of the Church visible see for instance Act. 2. 41 42 45. Act. 8. 13. Act. 4. 34 37. in so much as even hypocrites had entrance into the Church notwithstanding that the Apostles were indued with an extraordinary spirit of discerning as appeareth in the Examples of Ananias Judas Simon Magus Hymeneus Philetus 2. From the admission of members into the Church of the old Testament where those were admitted into the externall Church and the visible communion thereof who being adorned with federall holinesse did professe the true God of Israel as appeares by the admission of the whole people into that Church Deut. 29. 4 c. Josh 24. 23 c. 3. From the description of the Church visible the nature whereof is described in the Word of God that it is as a Barne wherein the chaffe is gathered together with the Wheat the House of God in which are vessels both of gold and of wood a Net wherein are caught fishes good and bad Matth. 3. 12. and 13. 47. 2 Tim. 2. 20 21. so that to the admission of any to be a member of the Church visible the Pastors can require no more in foro ecclesiastico as a necessary requisite then what may also be found in hypocrites 4. Frō the state and condition of the Churches of God in the time of the Apostles who acknowledged for true Churches of Christ those visible societies amongst whom there were hypocrites carnall men schismaticks and others not indued with reall holinesse of Regeneration and justifying faith to whom notwithstanding the Apostles wrote their Epistles as members of the Church visible See to this purpose the condition of the seven Churches in Asia Rev. 2. 3. Chap. The condition of the Churches of Corinth and Galatia 1 Cor. 1. 11 12. and 3. 3. and 6. 1 2 3. and 11. 17 18. Gal. 1. 6. and 3. 1 2 3 4. and 5. 7 8 9 c. Thus have our Divines determined this controversie
Calvin Instit lib. 4. cap. 1. sect 7. But oft-times saith he by the name of the Church the Scriptures intend the whole multitude of men throughout the world who professe to worship one God and Christ are initiated by Baptisme into his faith testifie by their partaking the Lords Supper a unity in the true Religion and Charity consent to the Word of God and for the preaching thereof maintain a Ministery instituted by Christ But in this multitude are many mingled who are hypocrites and have nothing of Christ but the name and shew c. which in respect of men is called a Church and we commanded to maintaine the communion of it And sect 8. he shewes that it is the Prerogative of God alone to know who are unfeined Saints and true members of the Church Yet saith he because he fore saw that it was somewhat requisite that we should know who are to be accounted for his childrâ—n herein he applyeth himselfe to our capacity And because a certainty of faith is not herein requisite he hath in stead thereof appointed the judgement of Charity in which judgement we acknowledge for members of the Church those who in the confession of faith and example of their life and participation of the Sacraments professe the same God and Christ with us Hence Ames affirmes it to be false that the Reformed Churches require inward graces to the admitting of any into the Church as to the visible state thereof Antibellarm tom 2. iib. 2. cap. 1. not 5. And not 3. of the same chapter he affirmeth out of Augustine that there is in the Church the inward soule to wit the gifts of grace and the body or outward profession whence it comes to passe that some are both of the soule and the body of the Church others of the body only and not the soule Which saith he is expressed by Alexander Alensis in other words when he saith That evill men are of the unity of the Church but not of the unity of the body of the Church not of the body of the Church according to the true nature of a body or in reference to the union of the body mysticall Which distinction he proveth out of 1 Joh. 2. 19. Rom. 2. 28. a Jew openly and a Jew in secret So Trelcatius the elder in his common places loco 15. puts the differences between the members of the visible and of the invisible Church in a lively faith purity of life certainty of Election and Salvation and Perseverance in faith which are found in the members of the Church invisible in sincerity and truth but in the members of the Church visible only in the judgement of Charity oft-times not in truth because of a vocation and profession externall but oft hypocriticall So almost all the eminent Reformed Divines affirme the matter of the Church visible to be men outwardly called professing the faith of Christ for they define it to be a company of men who by an outward calling or the preaching of the Word and participation of the Sacraments are called to the exercise of the Worship of God and Ecclesiasticall Fellowship amongst themselves See both the Trelcatii in their common places loco de Ecclesia The Professours of Leyden disp 40. thes 33. Hence also have our Belgick Churches in our Nationall and Provinciall Synods ordeined that he be admitted to the Lords Supper who hath first made profession of his faith submitted himselfe to the Discipline of the Church and brought testimony of unblameable life See the Synods at Dort Anno 1574. art 70. and Anno 1578. art 64. at Middleburgh Anno 1581. art 43. at the Hage Anno 1586. art 54. at Middleburgh Anno 1591. art 51. at Dort Anno 1619. art 61. We reject therefore these ensuing opinions I. Of those who affirme the externall and particular visible Church to be the proper subject to which belongeth the Covenant of Grace all the Promises of God the Properties and Priviledges which Christ the Mediatour hath purchased for his Church The reasons of our deniall are 1. Because that Church for which these priviledges are purchased is perpetuall which never falleth away for this infallible Promise is made to it from God Jer. 31. 36. Matt. 16. 18. But now no particular visible Church is secured from falling away as our Orthodox Divines demonstrate against the Papists it is not for it therefore that these Priviledges are purchased by Christ the Mediatour 2. Those Churches for which all these promised Priviledges are procured are called out of the world by the word and Spirit of God to faith and holinesse and have sincere and inward Communion and fellowship with Christ and all true beleevers whence frequently in Scriptures they are called the Spouse and Beloved of Christ Cant. 4. 7. Eph. 5. 27. The Holy Sion and heavenly Jerusalem and the Israel of God Isai 52. 1. Gal. 4. 26. and 6. 16. so likewise The Church which Christ hath purified for himselfe to present her to himselfe glorious not having spot or wrinckle Eph. 5. 27. The Body of Christ fitly joyned together and compacted by that which every joynt supplyeth Eph. 4. 16. It 's called Christs people whom he saveth from their sins Joh. 10. 16. Matt. 1. 21. Gods house and a holy Priesthood 1 Pet. 2. 5. The Temple of God in which the Spirit of God doth dwell 1 Cor. 3. 16. The Lambs wife Apoc. 21. 4. All which and such like doe not agree to an externall visible particular Church as such Rom. 9. 6. but onely to the Church invisible which Christ had redeemed with his bloud Acts 20. 28. 3. The Priviledges promised and procured for the Church of God amongst many others are these That God puts his Law and his Feare into the minds of the members of it Jer. 31. 33. That they are all taught of God and know him Joh. 6. 42. That they are redeemed by the bloud of Christ Act. 20. 28. Eph. 5. 27. But these agree not to an externall and visible particular Church Therefore that externall visible particular Church is not the proper subject of the Covenant of grace or of these Priviledges which by Christ our Mediatour are procured for the Church Whereunto the Reformed Divines assent See amongst others the Professours of Leyden in their Synopsis Theologiae disput 40. Thes 29 30 31. And Ames himselfe against Bellarm. tom 2. lib. 2. cap. 1. not 10. where he affirmes that those glorious things which are spoken in Scripture of the Church of Christ that it is redeemed by Christ the Body of Christ the Spouse of Christ quickned acted and guided by the Holy Spirit partaketh of all spirituall blessings so that the gates of hell shall never prevaile against it doth properly and fully agree not to the whole multitude of those that professe the Christian faith but to those only that are true beleevers or they agree to the Church militant according to iâ—s essentiall nature peculiar to true beleevers not according to