commanded but was highly displeased with as of Masses Pilgrimages pardons paines of Purgatory and such like further that no one sequell vrged by the Apostle against the Galathians for ioining circumcision with Christ but might be aswell enforced against the Lutherans that is that for their vbiquitie it may be aswell said to them if yee hold the body of Christ to be in all places you are fallen frō grace you are vnder the curse of the law saying cursed be he that fulfilleth not all things written in this booke with such like he added yet further that to a Bishop of the Church of Rome to a Cardinall yea to the Pope himselfe acknowledging Christ to bee the saviour of the world denying other errours being discomforted for want of workes whereby he might be iustified he would not doubt but vse this speech Thou holdest the foundation of Christian faith though it bee but by a slender thread thou holdest Christ though but as by the hem of his garment why shouldst thou not hope that vertue may passe from Christ to saue thee That which thou holdest of iustification by thy workes overthroweth indeed by consequent the foundation of Christian faith but be of good cheere thou hast not to doe with a captious Sophister but with a mercifull God who will iustifie thee for that thou holdest and not take the advantage of doubtfull construction to cōdemne thee And if this hee said bee an errour I hold it willingly for it is the greatest comfort I haue in this world without which I would not wish either to speak or to liue Thus far being not to bee answered in it any more he was bold to proceed the absurditie of which speech I need not to stand vpon I thinke the like to this and other such in this sermon and the rest of this matter hath not beene heard in publique places within this land since Queene Maries daies What consequēce this doctrine may be of if he bee not by authoritie ordered to revoke it I beseech your HH as the truth of God his gospell is deere and pretious vnto you according to your godly wisdomes to consider I haue beene bold to offer to your HH a long and tedious discourse of these matters But speech being like to tapestrie which if it be folded vp sheweth but part of that which is wrought and being vnlapt laid open sheweth plainely to the eye all the worke that is in it I thought it necessarie to vnfold this tapestrie to hang vp the whole chamber of it in your most Honorable senate that so you may the more easily discerne of all the peeces and the sundry workes and matters contained in it Wherin my hope is your HH may see J haue not deserved so great a punishment as is laid vpon the Church for my sake and also vpon my selfe in taking from me the exercise of my ministery which punishment how heavie it may seeme to the Church or fall out indeed to be J referre it to them to iudge spare to write what I feare but to my selfe it is exceeding grievous for that it taketh from mee the exercise of my calling Which I doe not say is deare vnto mee as the meanes of that little benefit whereby I liue although this be a lawfull consideration and to bee regarded of me in due place and of the authority vnder whose protection I most willingly liue even by Gods commandement both vnto them and vnto me but which ought to bee more pretious to me then my life for the loue which J should beare to the glory and honour of Almightie God and to the edification and salvation of his Church for that my life cannot any other way be of like service to God nor of such vse and profit to men by any meanes for which cause as J discerne how deare any ministery ought to be vnto me so it is my harty desire and most humble request vnto God to your HH and to all the authoritie I liue vnder to whom any dealing herein belongeth that I may spend my life according to his example who in a word of like sound of fuller sense * comparing by it the bestowing of his life to the offering powred out vpon the sacrifice of the faith of Gods people and especially of this Church wherevpon I haue already powred out a great part thereof in the same calling from which I stand nowe restrained And if your HH shall finde it so that J haue not deserved so great a punishment but rather performed the duty which a good and faithful servant ought in such a case to do to his Lord the people he putteth him in trust withall carefully to keepe I am a most humble suiter by these presents to your HH that by your godly wisdome some good course may be taken for the restoring of me to my ministery and place againe Which so great a favour shall bind me yet in a greater obligation of dutie which is already so great as it seemed nothing could be added vnto it to make it greater to honour God daily for the continuance and increase of your good estate and to be ready with all the poore meanes God hath given me to doe your HH that faithfull service I may possibly performe but if notwithstanding my cause be never so good your HH can by no meanes pacifie such as are offended nor restore me againe then am I to rest in the good pleasure of God and to commend to your HH protection vnder her Maiesties my privat life while it shall be led in dutie and the Church to him who hath redeemed to himselfe a people with his pretious blood is making ready to cōe to iudge both the quick the dead to giue to every one according as hee hath done in this life bee it good or evill to the wicked and vnbeleever iustice vnto death but to the faithfull and such as loue his truth mercy and grace to life everlasting Your Honours most bounden and most humble suppliant Walter Travers Minister of the word of God
point According to which course of late when as hee had taught that the Church of Rome is a true Church of Christ and a sanctified Church by profession of that truth which God hath revealed vnto vs by his sonne though not a pure and perfect Church further that he doubted not but that thousaÌ„ds of the fathers which lived and died in the superstitions of that church were saved because of their ignorance which excuseth them misalleaging to that end a * 1. Tim. 1.13 text of scripture to proue it the matter being of set purpose openly and at large handled by him and of that moment that might preiudice the faith of Christ encourage the ill affected to continue still in their damnable waies and other weake in faith to suffer themselues easilie to bee seduced to the destruction of their soules I thought it my most bounden duetie to God and to his church whilest I might haue oportunitie to speak with him to teach the truth in a generall speech in such points of doctrine At which time I taught that such as die or haue died at anie time in the Church of Rome holding in their ignorance that faith which is taught in it and namelie iustification in part by workes could not be said by the scriptures to be saued In which matter foreseeing that if swaded not warilie in it I should be in danger to bee reported as hath fallen out since notwithstanding to condemne all the fathers I said directlie and plainly to all mens vnderstanding that it was not indeede to bee doubted but manie of the fathers were saued but the meanes I said was not their ignorance which excuseth no man with God but their knowledge and faith of the truth which it appeareth God vouchsafed them by manie notable monuments and recordes extant of it in all ages Which being the last point in all my sermon rising so naturally from the text I then expounded as would haue occasioned me to haue delivered such matter notwithstanding the former doctrine had bin souÌ„d and being dealt in by a generall speech without touch of his particular I looked not that a matter of controversie would haue beene made of it no more then had beene of my like dealing in former time But far otherwise then I looked for Mr Hooker shewing no griefe of offence taken at my speech all the weeke long the next Saboth leaving to proceed vpon his ordinarie text professed to preach againe that he had done the day before for some question that his doctrine was drawne into which he desired might be examined with all severity So proceeding he bestowed his whole time in that discourse concerning his former doctrine and answering the places of Scripture which I had * Apoc â—3 4. Gal 5â— 3 4. alleaged to proue that a man dying in the Church of Rome is not to be iudged by the Scriptures to be saved In which long speech and vtterly impertinent to his text vnder colour of answering for himselfe he impugned directly and openly to all mens vnderstanding the true doctrine which I had delivered and added to his former points some other like as willingly one errour followeth another that is that the Galathians ioining with faith in Christ circumcision as necessarie to salvation might not be saved And that they of the Church of Rome may be saved by such a faith of Christ as they had with a generall repentance of all their errours notwithstanding their opinion of iustificatioÌ„ in part by their works merits I was necessarily though not willingly drawn to say something to the points he obiected against souÌ„d doctrine which J did in a short speech in the end of my sermon with protestation of so doing not of any finister affection to any man but to beare witnesse to the truth according to my calling And wished if the matter should needs further be dealt in some other more convenient way might bee taken for it wherein I hope my dealing was manifest to the consciences of all indifferent hearers of me that daie to haue beene according to peace and without any vncharitablenesse being duly considered For that I conferred with him the first day I haue shewed that the cause requiring of me in duety at the least not to be altogither silent in it beeing a matter of such consequence that the time also being short wherin I was to preach after him the hope of the fruit of our communication being small vpon experience of former conferences my expectation beeing that the church should be no further troubled with it vpon the motion I made of raking some other course of dealing I suppose my differring to speake with him till some fit opportunitie cannot in charitie be iudged vncharitable The second day his vnlooked for opposition with the former reasons made it to be a matter that required of necessitie some publique answere which beeing so temperate as I haue shewed if notwithstanding it be censured as vncharitable and punished so grievously as it is what should haue beene my punishment if with out all such cautions respects as qualified my speech I had before all and in the vnderstanding of all so reproved him offending openly that other might haue feared to do the like Which yet if I had done might haue beene warranted by the rule charge of the Apostles them that offend openly rebuke openlie that the rest may also feare and by his example who when Peter in this verie case which is now betweene vs had not in preaching but in a matter of conversation not gone with a right foot as was fit for the truth of the gospell conferred not privately with him but as his owne rule required reproved him openlie before all that other might hear and feare and not dare to doe the like all which reasons togither weighed I hope will shew the manner of my dealing to haue beene charitable and warrantable in everie sort The next saboth day after this Mr Hooker kept the way he had entred into before and bestowed his whole houre and more only vpon the questions hee had moved and mainetained wherein he so set forth the agreement of the Church of Rome with vs their disagreement from vs as if we had consented in the greatest weightiest points and differed only in certaine smaller matters which agreement noted by him in two chiefe points is not such as hee woulde haue made men beleeue The one in that he said they acknowledged al men sinners even the blessed Virgin though some of them freed her from sin for the Councel of Trent holdeth that shee was free from sinne Another in that he said they teach Christs righteousnesse to be the only meritorious cause of taking awaie sinne and differ from vs onlie in the applying of it For Thomas Aquinas their chiefe schooleman and Archbishop Catherinus teach that Christ tooke awaie onlie originall sin and that the rest are to be taken away by our selues yea the councel of Trent
teacheth that righteousnes wherby we are righteous in Gods sight is an inherent righteousnesse which must needes be of our owne works and cannot be vnderstoode of the righteousnesse inherent only in Christs person and accounted vnto vs. Moreover hee taught the same time that neither the Galathians nor the Church of Rome did directly overthrow the foundation of iustification by Christ alone but only by consequent and therefore might well bee saved or else neither the Churches of Lutherans nor any which hold anie manner of errour could bee saved because saith he everie errour by consequent overthroweth the foundation In which discourses and such like hee bestowed his whole time more which if he had affected either the truth of God or the peace of the Church he would truely not haue done Whose example could not draw me to leaue the Scripture I tooke in hand but standing about an houre to deliver the doctrine of it in the end vpon iust occasion of the text leaving sundrie other his vnsound speeches and keeping me still to the principall I confirmed the beleeving the doctrine of iustification by Christ only to be necessarie to the iustification of all that shoulde bee saved and that the Church of Rome directlie denieth that a man is saved by Christ or by faith alone without the workes of the law Which my answere as it was most necessarie for the service of God and the church so was it without anie immodest or reprochfull speech in Mr Hooker whose vnfound and willfull dealings in a cause of so great importance to the faith of Christ and salvation of the Church notwithstanding I knew well what speech it deserved and what some zealous earnest man of the spirit of Iohn and Iames surnamed * Mark 3 17. Boanerges sonnes of thunder woulde haue saide in such a case yet I chose rather to content my selfe in exhorting him to revisite his doctrine as * 2. Sam. 7.2.3.4.5 Nathan the Prophet did the devise which without consulting with God hee had of himselfe given to David concerning the building of the Temple and with * Gal. 2.11.14 Peter the Apostle to indure to be withstoode in such a case not vnlike vnto this This in effect was that which passed betweene vs concerning this matter the invectiues I made against him wherewith I am charged which rehearsall I hope may cleare me with all that shall indifferently consider it of the blames laid vpon me for want of duty to Mr Hooker in not conferring with him whereof I haue spoken sufficiently alreadie and to the high commission in not revealing the matter to them which yet now I am further to answere My answere is that I protest no contempt nor willfull neglect of any lawfull authoritie staide me from complaining vnto them but these reasons following First I was in some hope that Mr Hooker notwithstanding he had beene overcarried with a shew of charitie to preiudice the truth yet when it should bee sufficientlie proved would haue acknowledged it or at the least induced with peace that it might be offered without either offence to him or to such as would receiue it either of which would haue taken away anie cause of iust complaint When neither of these fel out according to my expectation and desire but that he replyed to the truth and obiected against it I thought hee might haue some doubtes and scruples in himselfe which yet if they were cleared hee would either embrace some doctrine or at least suffer it to haue his course which hope of him I nourished so long as the matter was not bitterlie and immodestlie handled betweene vs. Another reason was the cause it selfe which according to the parable of the tares which are said to bee sowne amongst the wheat sprung vp first in his grasse Therefore as the servants in that place are not said to haue come to complain to the Lord till the tares came to shew their fruits in their kind so I thinking it yet but a time of discovering of it what it was desired not their sickle to cut it downe For further answer it is to be considered that the cōscience of my duty to God and to his Church did bind me at the first to deliver sound doctrine in such points as had beene otherwise vttered in the place where I had now some yeares taught the truth Otherwise the rebuke of the * 〈…〉 Prophet had fallen vpon mee for not going vp to the breach and standing in it and the * 〈…〉 perill for answering the blood of the Cittie in whose watch-tower I sate if it had bin surprised by my default Moreover my publike protestation in being vnwilling that if any were not yet satisfied some other more conveniēt way might be taken for it And lastly that J had resolued which I vttered before to some dealing with me about the matter to haue protested the next Saboth day that I would no more answere in that place any obiections to the doctrine taught by any meanes but some other way satisfie such as should require it These I trust may make it appeare that I failed not in duty to authoritie notwithstanding I did not complaine nor giue over so soone dealing in the case If I did how is he cleere which can alleage none of all these for himselfe who leaving the expounding of the Scriptures and his ordinary calling voluntarily discoursed vpō schoole points and questions neither of edification nor of truth who after all this as promising to himselfe and to vntruth a victory by my silence added yet in the next Saboth day to the maintenance of his former opinions these which follow That no additament taketh away the foundation except it be a privatiue of which sort neither the workes added to Christ by the Church of Rome nor circumcision by the Galathians were as one denieth him not to be a man that saith he is a righteous man but hee that saith he is a dead man whereby it might seeme that a man might without hurt adde workes to Christ and pray also that God and S. Peter would saue him That the Galathians case is harder then the case of the Church of Rome because the Galathians ioined circumcision with Christ which God hath forbidden and abolished but that which the Church of Rome ioined with Christ were good workes which God hath commanded wherein he cōmitted a double fault one in expounding all the question of the Galathians and consequently of the Romans and other Epistles of circumcision only and the ceremonies of the law as they doe who answer for the Church of Rome in their writings contrary to the cleere meaning of the Apostle as may appeare by many strong and sufficient reasons the other in that hee said the addition of the Church of Rome was of workes commanded of God whereas the least part of the workes whereby they looked to merit was of such workes and most were of supererogation and of workes which God never