trickes of Monckes and Friers to cousen the people by making images wagge or seeme to speake may serue as an embleme of that imposture or Gull which Satan by Gods iust iudgement hath put vpon their subtilest wits in this argument These Couseners made the people ofttimes thinke some Saint had moued or spoken when a knaue did stirre the image or vent his own vnhallowed breath through it or about it and Satan makes them beleeue they are moued by the spirit of God in such actions as are not enspired by faith but thrust vpon them by his wicked Angels Workes of charity they esteeme all such as outwardly resemble the actions of Christ or his Saints though conceiued not by faith but vpon other motiues as motion infused by art may to the eye of man exactly counterfeit motion naturall This is a maine branch of that great mistery of iniquity For by this error as their faith is neuer reuiued so their workes though faire and pompous in outward shew and such as would be most pleasant vnto their God did they spring from minds and affections renewed by liuely faith being superadded onely to this dead faith neither can perfect it nor receiue perfection from it but become like sweet flowers vsually put vpon dead corps the sent of whose corruptions hinder they may for a time but surer at length to participate thereof then communicate their fragrancieto it 10 It is a contemplation very profitable to marke what troopes of errors may issue from one place of scripture mistaken and how priuate opinions conceiued through ignorance and conceiued by negligence are oftimes established by wilfulnesse of publike authority for who but a schooleman that considers morall propositions in scriptures as if they were mathematicall definitions or indemonstrable principles no whit dependent of what went before or comes after could not at first perusall haue obserued that Saint Iames had a purpose in that Chapter to taxe his pupils as well for want of true faith as of good workes yea the workes they did to be nothing worth becouse not wrought by faith had without all respect of persons or partiality in the Law of God But the Romanist not obseruing what is a point most cleare that vniforme fidelity or faithfulnesse in all commaundements of God is the very formall effect of that faith which was in Abraham and Saint Paul so much commends First takes that dead and vaine faith Saint Iames disproues to be the same with that Saint Paul so much commends and consequently to this error denies iustification by faith but as it is informed with charity which is as much as to say we are iustified by charity and not by faith and vnto these two errors annexeth a third most pernitious concerning the nature of workes which either not conceiued by such vniformity of faith as Paul requires or not managed by a paralel vniformity become altogether Iewish and their best righteousnesse that practise them like the righteousnesse of the Scribes and Pharises Lastly to reare vp a roofe euery way answerable to the foundation they leade vs from the Gospell vnto the Law and make the eternall couenant made vnto mankinde in Christ subseruiant to the couenant made with our first parents as shall be demonstrated against them in the Article of the last iudgement And what other consequence could one expect of this error whereto noe other could be paralell which makes Charity the forme or workes the spirit of faith yet that not onely their best priuate writers but their Church representatiue is tainted with this stupide heresie this decree of the Trent Counsell will serue as a testimony vpon record If any man shall auouch that as oft as grace is lost through sinne faith is alwaies lost together with it or that faith which remaines after losse of grace to be no true faith although no liuing faith or the man that hath faith without charity to be no Christian Let him be accursed 11. If these curses could hurt any Saint Paul should haue the fulles measure of them for questionlesse he neuer thought such faith as hee commended could remaine without grace or integrity of conscience Saint Iames I thinke should hardly escape vnlesse he would subscribe to this conclusion that the Diuell was a Christian And were Scotus Ockain or Swisset now aliue they would find all the Iesuites in the world play for these hundred yeares to hold the contrary and defend the Trent Councell in this decree For such faith as the Councell requires to make a Christian may be yea is in the worst kinde of Diuels albeit Valentian hath laboured to find this difference That faith without workes or grace is in men the gift of God so is not the faith of Diuels No more was this answere of his suggested by Gods spirit or the spirit of truth For not to question whether such dead faith as Saint Iames speakes of be the gift of God or no but rather supposing it were this argues a difference onely in the cause none in the essence nature or quality That God created wants in the beginning doth not argue they were of a more excellent nature then ordinary Lions not created but propagated by nature are now of And if the quality of faith be the same in the Trent Councels Christians and in Diuels Valentian doth rather wrong the Almighty in making him the Author of it in the one then prooue either it or his owne cause to be the better by saying it is the gift of God For though it be his gift and yet may be without grace or charity and without these of necessitie as vnfruitfull as the faith of Diuels both which Valentian grants it is no more auaileable to make a Christian then the faith of Diuels is Nay in that it may be without workes theirs is more fruitfull then it for as Saint Iames tels vs theirs workes feare and trembling in them were that faith which the Trent Councell makes the forme of a Christian so operatiue in it nature it could not be as is obserued before without workes or charity For if it wrought a trembling feare of his power it would worke a reioicing loue of his mercie and impell them as to auoid the stroke of the one so to embrace the gentle strokings of the other Their owne writers obserue that to feare God in the language of Canaan is to worship him and is it lesse to beleeue in him then to feare him To conclude what ancient father is there which should not be accursed if God did not blesse where these Trent Fathers curse For though their charity would not suffer them to depriue any professing true religion of that title wherein he ioied the name of a Christian because they knew not what faith they had in their hearts yet few of them but indefinitely auouch thus much That he falsly vsurps the glorious name of a Christian or faithfull man which is not faithfull in Gods commandement
in sciences or workes of nature or of addition and substraction in Arithmetique or of laying or reducting sums in accompts As young Dauid first encountred Beares and Lions or other enemies of his flocke and afterwards ouercomes the great Goliah that had defied the whole host of Israell so true and liuely faith first begins with petty desires or such temptations as are incident to our present state or calling alwaies so much lesse grieuous in themselues as our places are meaner and hauing gotten mastery ouer them still encreaseth as difficulties or oppositions multiply vntill at length it become victorious ouer the diuell world and flesh by a sincere discharge of particulars contained in the view of Baptisme Hypocrisie acknowledgeth the same summe of Christian duties or practices and subscribes vnto it not onely in grosse but vnto most particulars therein contained yet still reducts or exonerates as much as well displeasing humours disallow vntill it finally dissolue what true faith doth build euen vnto the first foundation if the opposition betweene it and carnall feares hopes loue or hate come once to be direct eager What protestation could any true professor either conceiue in tearmes more decent or submissiue or tender in more serious and ample forme then that supplication which the remnant of Iudah and Ierusalem presented vnto the Prophet Ieremy after the captiuity of their brethren Then all the Captaines of the host and Iehonan the sonne of Kareah and Iezaniah the sonne of Hoshaiah and all the people from the least vnto the most came and sayd vnto Ieremiah the Prophet Heare our prayer we beseech thee and pray for vs vnto the Lord thy God euen for all this remnant for we are left but a few of many as thine eyes doe behold that the Lord thy God may shewe vs the way wherein we may walke and the thing that we may doe After he had vndertaken this sacred businesse and past his word for his integrity in translating it they more pathetically oblige themselues to whatsoeuer obedience God by his mouth shall enioine them Then they sayd to Ieremiah The Lord bee a witnesse of truth and faith betweene vs if we do not euen according to all things for the which the Lord thy God shall send thee vnto vs whether it bee good or be euili wee will obey the voice of the Lord God to whom wee send thee that it may be well with vs when wee obey the voice of the Lord our God A man would think the proposall of Gods commaundement by a Prophet so well knowne vnto this people one whom they had chosen for this purpose should haue enforced them to performance of their promise Yet Ieremiah foreseeing the hypocrisie of their hearts though hidden from their owne eyes returnes his message in such a forme as if hee had vsed artificiall inuention to perswade obedience Hauing called some of the parties that had late made this serious protestation he tells them Thus sayth the Lord God of Israell vntowhom ye sent me to present your prayers before him if yee will dwellin this land then I will build you and not destroy you and I will plant you and not root you out for I repent me of the euill that I haue done vnto you Feare not for the king of Babed of whom ye are afraide be not afraid of him saith the Lord For I am with you to saue you and to deliuer you from his hand And I will grant you mercy that he may haue compassion vpon you and hee shall cause you to dwellin your land But if ye say wee will not dwell in this land neither heare the voice of the Lord your God saying Nay but wee will goe into the land of Egypt where we shall see no warre nor heare the sound of the trumpet nor haue hunger of bread and there we will dwell and now therefore heare the word of the Lord yee remnant of Iudah thus sayth the Lord of hosts the God of Israell If ye set your forces to enter into Egypt and go to dvveâ—l there then the sword that yee feared shall take you there in the Land of Egypt and the famine for which you care shall there hang vpon you in Egypt and there shall ye die And all the men that set their forces to enter into Egypt to dwell there shall die by the sword by the famine and by the pestilence and none of them shall remaine or escape from the plague that I will bring vpon them For thus sayth the Lord of hostes the God of Israell As mine anger and my vvrath hath been poured out vpon the inhabitants of Ierusalem so shall my vvrath be poured out vpon you vvhen you enter into Egypt and ye shall be a detestation and an astonishment and a curse and a reproach and ye shall see this place no more O yee remnant of Iudah the Lord hath sayd concerning you Goe ye not into Egypt know certainly that I haue admonished you this day And as Iosuah at his last farewell vnto his people suspecting their pronenesse to idolatrie did by a seeming prouocation of them to the practice and profession of it wisely wrest from them more serious protestation to the contrary and a stricter obligement to the seruice of the onely true God then otherwise they would haue conceiued so Ieremiah instructed by his God that the hypocrisie of this peoples heart now secretly began to work giues them notice of it most desirous to be disapproued by them in the euent Surely yee dissembled in your hearts when you sent me vnto the Lord your God saying pray for vs vnto the Lord our God and according vnto all that the Lord our God shall say so declare vnto vs and we vvill doe it And now I haue this day declared it to you but ye haue not obeyed the voice of the Lord your God nor anie thing for vvhich he hath sent me vnto you Now therefore know certainly that yee shall die by the sword by famine and by the pestilence in the place whither ye desire to goe and soiourne Ierusalems ruines and the Temples ashes did witnesse the seuerity and iustice of their God against the obstinate and disobedient The Babylonians themselues knew Ieremiah for a Prophet euen this people to whom hee brings this message were well perswaded of his familiarity with their God and hee himselfe had past his word for acquainting them fully with his will Then Ieremiah the Prophet sayd vnto them I haue heard you behold I will pray vnto the Lord your God according vnto your words and it shall come to passe that whatsoeuer thing the Lord shall answere you I will declare vnto you I will keepe nothing backe from you And was it possible the same men should bee so dislike themselues as to forget their late protestations and refuse to do Gods will so fully made knowne vnto them by his Prophet To doe the will of God if so they knew it to
and liuely when wee feele a present benefit redounding to our selues from the good we do to others as if we actually perceiued the cooperatiue cōcurrence of diuine goodnesse in these workes of charity As well this loue of God as of our neighbours are though in different manner effects or properties of liuely faith or of that grace whereof faith it selfe is the principall stemme as it illuminates the minde or supreme faculty of the soule Our loue of God may well seeme to be an effect immanēt or residing in the same faculty with faith Loue to our neighbour an effect transient as hauing a distinct roote or originall whence it springs and takes it proper substance though quickned and moued to euery good worke by faith as the moone hath a distinct bodie of it owne more capable of light then others are but illuminated by the sunne The substance or body of loue to our neighbours is naturall humanity or kindnesse whose illumination perfection and guidance is from faith apprehending the goodnesse of God whom we immediately loue aboue all for himselfe as the onely Creator and preseruer of all the onely procurer of all good to all others in him and for him as our fellow creatures and ioint obiects with vs of his vnrecompensable loue 3. The same dependance on faith haue trust and confidence or that affection which in latine we call Fiducia Confidence in their language of whom we borrow the name implies a boldnesse or hopefull assurance of good successe in the businesse we goe about and naturally springs from a perswasion either of our owne or others sufficiencie of whose helpe or furtherance we may presume Thus the strong are vsually confident in matters of strength wise men or well experienced in matters to be tried by wit or worldly pollicie the wealthy in causes that may be swaied with bribery men well allied in businesses that may be carried best by multitude of friends But all these branches of confidence haue the cursed fig-trees hap Cursed be the man that trusteth in man and maketh flesh his arme and with-draweth his heart from the Lord. For he shall be like the heath in the wildernesse and shall not see when any good commeth but shall inhabite the parched places in the wildernesse in a salt land and not inhabited The stocke notwithstanding whence they grow being purified and seasoned by grace these lopt off and the true knowledge of God ingrafted in their steed beareth fruit vnto saluation For blessed is the man that trusteth in the Lord and whose hope the Lord is For hee shall be as a tree that is planted by the water which spreadeth out her rootes by the water and shall not feele when the heate commeth but her lease shall be greene and shall not care for the yeare of drought neither shall cease from yeelding fruit The points towards which this naturall affection whereof all participate more or lesse must be set ere it grow vp into such confidence as spreads it selfe throughout all the waies that God hath appointed vs to walke in are the articles of Gods power and wisdome ouer all the workes of his hands and his fauour towards vs. The manner how faith doth raise it the Reader may more easily perceiue if it please him call to minde or hereafter obserue that as well in the dialect of sacred writers whether Canonicall or Apochriphall as other morall Authors or common speech there is a twofold faith One passiue or obiectiue which in English we vsually call fidelitie or faithfulnesse whereunto we may safely trust another actiue or apprehensiue by which we assent vnto the former and rely vppon it as farre as our needfull occasions shall require Of this reliance or reposall confidence is but a further degree presupposing a firmer apprehension or experience of more then ordinarie sufficiency and fauour towards vs in the party to whose trust we commit our selues or our affaires Fidelity or faith passiue he well notified in part that told vs Quando fit quod dicitur tunc est fides Faithfull hee is in his sayings that hath good ground for what he speakes or called to an account is able to make such proofe of his assertions as the nature of the businesse shall require Faithfull in his doing he is that approues the truth of his promises by performance whom wee cannot better describe then the Psalmist hath done One that walketh vprightly worketh righteousnesse and speaketh the truth in his heart or as we say one whose heart goes with his mouth and changeth not his oath or promise albeit the performance of it be to his greater hinderance then he conceiued when he made it Alwaies the better opinion we retaine of this passiue fidelity or faithfulnes the greater is our actiue faith trust or reposall in it but trust or confidence in fallible or absolute wee cannot haue in any mortall man For besides that his heart or intention is vnknowne to vs such abilities as now he hath are obnoxions to change so is his purpose and resolution Not the honestest man on earth but is mutably honest at least in respect of vs and where all other conditions be equall we trust him better whose meanes are whole and sound then one of a broken or crased estate For few there be but sore pinched with pouerty will shrinke from what they promised vpon presupposed hopes of better ability And most men perhaps out of a consciousnesse of their owne mutabilitie vpon like change of fortunes or new discouery of dangers before vnknowne seeme to grant a generall pardon or dispensation to others in like cases at the least if abilities vpon such casualties be wanting ingenuous creditors doe not expect performance of promises made howsoeuer their debtors minds were affected when they made them whence as I said confidence in such men if other conditions be equall are lesse safe yet the more we trust them vpon lesse probable meanes of abilitie or vpon externall appearances of danger or suspitions cast by others of their likelihood to breake the greater eredite and honour we doe them For as loue vnlesse it proceed from a party odious and vnlouely is vsually repaid with like affection according to the olde saying V is vt ameris ama so ipsa fides habita obligat fidem Men oft times become more trusty then otherwise they would be by the trust or credence we giue vnto them God in whom only this fidelity or faith obiectiue according to the most absolute idea or perfection of it is immutable is alwaies more fauourable to such as faithfully commend themselues and their affaires vnto this care and trust And vnto faithfull reliance and reposall on his promises wee are tied by a triple bond of faith which cannot possibly breake or vntwine once surely fastened If we fully assent to his veracitie we cannot question whether he purpose whatsoeuer he promised if to his omnipotencie we cannot doubt of his allsufficiencie to performe For
as true and good whilest considered onely in themselues without oppositions of such matters as they much value So our Sauiour telleth vs that some when they haue heard receiue the word with ioy and for a while belieue but in time of tentation depart and Saint Iohn that euen amongst the Rulers many belieued on him By true and liuely faith rooted in the heart So Bellarmine would perswade vs or otherwise wee might make the Scriptures as a nose of waxe or alter the nature of sacred phrase as wee do counters in accompts Yet if they had in heart belieued vnto righteousnesse they had confessed with their mouth vnto saluation but sayth the Euangelist because of the Pharisees they did not confesse him least they should be put out of the synagogue And was not this to be ashamed of him and of his Gospell before men And whosoeuer is so affected belieueth not in that sense the Prophet speakes whosoeuer belieueth on him shall not be ashamed for vnlesse he acknowledge them in that day they shall not only bee ashamed but confounded with vnbelieuers yea the very reason the Euangelist giues why they did not confesse him condemns the Cardinals glosse either of great folly or impietie For sayth he they loued the prayse of men more then the prayse of God vnto which latter they had assented as much better had they so belieued as our Sauiour meanes when hee demaunds of the Iewes How can ye belieue which receiue honour one of another and seeke not the honour vvhich commeth from God onely Ere our faith become such as layes sure hold on life for of such in that place he speakes wee must Assent vnto the honour that comes from God alone as so much better then that we receiue of men that the later must seem as nothing in coÌ„parison of the former The same word beliefe oft-times is taken not only as it includes these last degrees or proper differences of Assent vnto diuine truthes but as it is accompanied with it essentiall properties or with such works as impulsiuely are from it though proper acts or exercises of other vertues faculties or affections whence they spring as from their naturall roote wherein they reside as in their natiue subiect The places are obuious to euerie one conuersant in Scriptures The like latitude of perfection whether from difference of essence or diuersitie onely in degrees knowledge or vnderstanding in the vse of sacred writers admits Nor did Saint Iohn in that speech He that sayth hee knoweth God and keepeth not his Commandements is a lyar contradict our Sauiour where he supposeth that many know their masters will and do it not For the disciple speakes of true and perfect knowledge the Lord of knowledge externall or imperfect The same analogie the Fathers retaine in the vse of beliefe or faith That the Pontificians can alledge their testimonies to proue faith may bee separated from works or charity is as little pertinent to the point in question betwixt vs and them as it would bee in the schooles to vrge the authority of late Philosophers that stones and mettals did not growe or that trees and plants had no locall motion against him that out of Aristotle did maintaine all bodies endued with life were capable of growth and diminution or all with sense of locall motion He that holds the former conclusions would account stones and mettals amongst bodies inanimate and trees and plants amongst vnsensitiue Now our question is not of euery sort or degree of faith but of that by which the Iust doe liue That no Father did affirme it should be without fruites or workes of holinesse is more then my small reading in them can secure me to affirme albeit reason I haue none to thinke otherwise but iust cause so to presume by the places our aduersaries alleadge so idle they are and impertinent Howsoeuer I dare vndertake for our assertion to bring three Fathers for one or testimonies thrice as many out of the best approued as any Iesuite shall do for his And because some of them scramble at some scattered sentences in Cyprians vvorkes or others fathered vpon him I will instance at this time in him especially the rather because he sealed the truth of his profession with his blood and had least reason to bee partiall for Faith against Charitie of whose abundance in his heart euery letter in his writings almost is a character yea so he esteemed of it that hee thought it impossible for him to prooue a true witnesse of Christ though dying in his cause if hee had liued without brotherly loue How doth hee say he belieues in Christ that doth not vvhat Christ hath giuen him in charge to doe Or how shall hee ataine to the reward of faith vvhich vvill not faithfullie keepe his Commaundements And againe Seeing to see Christ is our ioy nor can our ioy haue being vntill we see him what blindnesse of heart what mad nesse is this to loue the grieuances the paines and miseries of this world not rather to make hast vnto that ioy which neuer can be taken from vs Yet all this beloued brethren comes to passe because wee haue no faith because none belieues the truth of what God hath promised who is true whose word is eternally sure to belieuers If a graue man and of good note should promise thee any thing thou wouldst rely vpon his promise thou wouldst not belieue thou shouldst be deceiued or disappointed by him whom thou knowest to be constant in his words and deeds Behold God speaks to thee and â—ost thou perfidiously wauer through incredulity of minde God hath promised thee at thy departure out of this world immortality and eternity and dost thou doubt This is to be altogether without the knowledge of God this is to offend Christ the master of the faithfull vvith the sin of incredulity this is to haue a place in the Church and to be without faith in the house of faith The like hath Bernard who speaking of the victory that is by faith thus resolues flesh and blood moouing doubts to the contrary Perchance it may tempt some in that they see so many acknowledging Christ to bee the Sonne of God still entangled with the lusts of this world How sayth the Apostle then who is he that ouer commeth the world but he which belieues that IESVS is the Sonne of God vvhen as the world it selfe belieues this truth yea do not the very diuels belieue as much and tremble but I reioine Dost thou imagine that he reputes CHRIST for the sonne of God whosoeuer hee be that is not terrified with his threats that is not allured with his promises which obeies not his commandements and rests not satisfied with his aduise doth not such a one albeit he professe he knowes God deny him by his deeds Valentian notwithstanding would perswade vs that the Fathers when they say faith without works is dead would onely giue vs to
but would seeke to merit their fauour by gratefull offices It was extraordinary in this woman firmly to belieue as shee told the messengers but resting so perswaded a worke of no perfection to make her peace with the Israelites â—ad shee doubted whether their title vnto the land of Canaan had been iust or suspected Gods donation of it vnto Abraham to haue been forged by his successors as Constantines is by the baser Roman cleargy shee might without any iust imputation for want of loue or other good works haue aduentured her life amongst her neighbours in defence of her country Or had she vpon the Israelites misdemeanours distrusted their successe she might at last in worldly policy haue rather hazarded their future displeasure then incurred present danger of death or torture of her Citizens for harbouring spies But whiles she firmly belieues both that the Israelites donation was from God that they would certainly preuaile against her people though her entertainment and concealement of them were acts of kindnesse prudence and humanity yet their omission had been properly not of faith because impulsiuely they were from faith nor could they haue been omitted but through vnbeliefe or distrust vnto Gods promises Worldlings would haue condemned her not for vvant of charitie but for excesse folly rather had shee not done as shee was perswaded By faith then those workes become righteous which without it had been traiterous And if we respect not the cause of our knowledge but the thing knowne faith did perfect the workes the workes only made the perfection of faith knowne to men In this sense it is most true of faith what some misapply to iustification of mens persons workes iustifie and perfect faith not in the nature of the thing but in the sight of man to whom they witnesse the liuelihood and perfection of faith noâ— as causes but effects and signes of our iustifiattion they are not onely signes but conditions concomitant or precedent In the same sense are these other words of the Apostle to be vnderstood As the body without the spirit is dead so faith vvithout vvorkes is dead also For if a humane bodie want spirit breath or motion we rightly gather it wants life yet are breath and motion rather effects then causes of life But the schoole-men dreaming the holy Ghost had been scholler to Aquinas or some chiefe masters of their profession take the sprit in this place for actus primus as the soule by which wee liue and breath and hence they conceiued that grosse error which the Romanist now makes an article of his beliefe to wit that works animate or at least casually perfect faith as the soule of man doth his bodie And wheras Caluin most acutely and orthodoxally infers that if faith without works or charity bedead it is not properly but equiuocally called faith They reply workes or charitie do not informe faith intrinsecally as the reasonable soule doth man for so it would follow that as he is not a man but a dead trunk which hath no soule so it should not bee true faith but an image or dead picture of faith which wants vvorkes or charitie How then do they perfect faith Extrinsecally as the soule doth the body or other halfe of man which remaines a true body though no true man after the soules departure For application of this distinction they adioine when Saint Iames affirmes faith to be dead without workes he tearmes it dead in such a sense as we say a body is dead by the soules absence and yet remains a true bodie Whence sayth Valentian the sectaries haue furnished vs with an argument against themselues Rather this answere is contrary to Valentians and his fellowes assertions for were his illustration true and pertinent workes or faith should constitute one grace and qualitie as the body and soule make one man which no Papist dare affirme of the habite of faith and charitie being graces in their iudgements specifically distinct And Valentian who stands most vpon the former illustration expresly denies that charity much lesse workes can be any proper forme of faith either intrinsecall as the reasonable soule is of man or extrinsecall as whitenesse is of the body Some perfection notwithstanding Charitie giues to Faith in which respect it may by analogie to true and proper formes bee metaphorically said to informe saith The perfection it giues hee so expresseth that the Latine Reader by his words cited at full in the margine for I will not trouble the text with them may plainly perceiue hee was desirous to say somewhat but he knew not what Arias Montanus who better vnderstood Saint Iames his phrase by the analogie of faith and forme of wholsome doctrine then Valentian did himselfe or this fictitious analogie betwixt Charitie naturall formes interprets the former place in part to our purpose To liue as Philosophers say is to operate and vitall operation proceedeth not from the bodie but from the spirit nor doth â—â—e Apostle say workes are the spirit of faith where he speakes only of the appellation or name of life His meaning is that faith without workes is as truely reputed dead as the body without the spirit is rightly sayd as it truely is dead But if wee will not wrest the letter against the Apostles meaning but rather gently apply his words to his intent the word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 implies onely breath or motion enspired from the soule for workes in their nature are operations and are more fitly compared to breathings or motions then to the substantiall spirit or soule or the faculty whence these flow which last in proportion best answeres to faith Now as the readiest waie to â—et breath in one fallen in a swound or raise one vp out of a dead â—it is to reuiue the spirits by which vitall motions are inspired and managed so the onely way to bring forth liuing workes or fruites of righteousnes is to quicken or strengthen faith which liuely in it selfe and able to performe it proper acts as firmly to apprehend Gods power iustice and mercie will vndoubtedly giue life to all other powers and affections and impell them to their proper functions The Romanist as ignorant as the Iew of this righteousnesse which is by faith preposterously seekes to make vs new men in Christ not by reuiuing faith which is as the animall spirit by whose influence works become vitall but as if one from this principle in nature man is dead vvithout breath and motion should seeke to bring men out of swounds or dead fits by blowing breath into them with a quill or making them moue by deuises so he grosely mistaking that saying of S. Iames as the body without the spirit so faith without workes is dead also hence seekes to raise vp such as die in Adam after the same manner we haue seene them raised which fall downe dead in an anticke first by wagging one arme then another vntill the whole body moue The anticke
brother abideth in death vnlesse out of this loue as iointly respecting our brethren we lay downe our liues in loue or testimony of the truth we doe not rightly confesse CHRIST nor die in faith for whosoeuer hateth his brother is a murtherer And as he addeth hereby perceiue we the loue of God because he laid downe his life for vs. but whereby shall we perceiue our loue to him if we doe as we ought and we ought as it followeth to lay downe our liues for the brethren Not onely to redeeme many of them if that were possible from a bodily death by dying for them but rather to encourage euery one by our examples to embrace the truth and confesse CHRIST before men whether by life or death whether by profession of truth or practise of workes commanded as occasion shall be offered He that requires vs to lay downe our liues for their soules will looke we should distribute our goods to relieue their bodies otherwise to die for them is no true testimony of our loue to CHRIST for who so hath this worlds goods and seeth his brother hath neede and shutteth vp his bowels of compassion from him how dwelleth the loue of God in him Againe though we feede the poore with all our goods and yet haue not this loue to lay downe our liues for the brethren it profiteth nothing and though we giue our bodies to be burned for them and haue not this other part of loue to feede them or those attributes of it in the same place expressed by the Apostle as long sufferance kindnesse without enuie without boasting without pride without disdaine without exaction of our owne with placide affections neither prouoking nor easie to be prouoked but reioscing in truth and detesting iniquity with viformity of faith hope and conscience it profiteth nothing For as hath beene obserued before consideration of what CHRIST hath done for vs must bring foorth in vs the same minde that was in him a minde to doe his fathers will in euery point alike sincerely but with greater intentions or alacritie as the occasions or exigence of seasons shall require Sometimes we may more faithfully confesse his name by standing for some branch of truth no generall point of saluation in opposition to men of contrary mindes with whom we liue whose proiects tending to the dishonour of Gods name and preiudice of his dearest children we may hinder then by professing all the articles of true religion vpon the enemies racke or witnessing some principall truth before the fagot 7. Besides the obhomination of the causes they maintaine great presumptions or rather strong euidences there be many of their corrupt mindes whom the Romish Church in latter yeares sets footh for Martyres to the world First the Diuifications ascribed vnto them as their enrolements in the catalogue of former Saints inuocations adorations of their reliques and the like would haue mooued most heathen Romanes or Egyptians to haue aduentured on greater dangers or indignities then they are put to for one of their foolish Gods an ape a serpent or a crocodile Yet these men not inconsequently I must confesse vnto their magicall conceipt of faith and holinesse imagined by them in dead workes thinke their blood shed in the Catholique cause shall wipe away their actuall sinnes as clearely as the water of baptisme by their doctrine doth originall And as that sweete relator of his fruitefull obseruations in matters of religion hath ascertained vs that Italians are vsually imboldned to sinne because they must haue matter to confesse so men of great place and authority in this land would not suffer vs retired students to be ignorant that some seminary priests haue purpoposely giuen the raines to fleshly lusts vpon confidence the executioners knife should worke a perfect circumcision or the fire purifie their polluted members at the day of execution Or in case they neuer felt the seuere stroake of iustice yet their constant resolution to suffer and daily expectation of being called vnto this fiery triall should serue as a cloake to couer those impuriâ—es which the purity of CHRISTS blood shed vpon the Crosse such is the abhomination of their hypocrisie without perfect inherent righteousnesse cannot hide So farre too many of them are from sobriety meeknes and humility those other qualifications required by Saint Cyprian in true Martyres that the gift of impudence scurrility and disdaine serues no home-bred malefactors halfe so well in the time of their durance or whilest they are brought before the face of authority or arraigned at the barre of iustice as it doth them as if they would giue vs to vnderstand that the marke of the beast spoken of by S. Iohn had some such especiall vertue as these characters traiterous Gowry brought out of Italy which stopped his blood from running out after his body was runne through as this doth theirs from appearing in their foreheads for onely to blush they are ashamed euen whilest they pierce through their owne soules and pollute their country aire with hideous forraine blasphemies but in re mala animo sâ—vtare bono iâ—uat a good face put vpon a bad matter ofttimes auaileth much yet with men not with God vnto whose mercy I leaue such as affect to bee Pseudo-martyres beseeching him of his infinite goodnesse to alighten their hearts that they may see at length the abhominable filth of that Idole to which so many parents in this land are desirous to sacrifice their dearest children and these men their very soules But oh Lord stop the infection that it spread not from the dead vnto the liuing 8. But leauing this huge lake two no small sinckes of hypocrisie I haue espied from whose noysomenesse many otherwise well affected scarce are free but into which Lord let not my soule descend for their euâ—cation is into the bottomelesse pit The one an opinion there can bee no fit matter of martyrdome in a state authorising the free profession of that religion which amongst many we like best and left to our selues would make choise of The other which in part feeds this is a perswasion that meere errors in doctrine or opinion are more pernitious then affected indulgence to lewd practises or continuance in sinfull courses or open breaches of Gods commandements These are teliques of Romish sorcery which puts an abstract sanctity in the mathematicall forme or superficial draught of orthodoxal doctrine as it is in the braine though deuoide of true holinesse in life and conuersation or good affection in the heart and hence accompteth heresie that is euery opinion different from the tenents or contrary to the practises of their Church a sinne more deadly then any other and which in their iudgement doth vtterly depriue vs of such faith as they maintaine though that no better if not worse then diuels But if we recall what hath been hitherto discussed First That Christian faith is an Assent vnto diuine reuelations not only as true in themselues
CHRIST as we doe but terminated his beliefe vnto the generall mercie and prouidence of God whereof the great mystery of the incarnation was the principall branch and CHRIST IESVS in the fulnesse of time exhibited in our flesh the visible fruit of life which that other IESVS did but hope for as yet in the roote not distinctly knowing it nor the vertue of it but ready actually to embrace it and feed vpon it whensoeuer it should be brought forth For as much as I haue obserued out of this speech is implied in the exegeticall repetition of it He that belieueth the Lord taketh hâ—ed to the Commaundements and hee that trusteth in him shall not be hurt there shall no euill happen vnto him that feareth the Lord but in temptation euen againe he will deliuer him 3. That wee may practice what is commaunded and yet not keepe the commandement Saint Iames hath put out of all question If yee fulfill the râ—iall Law according to the Scripture thou shalt loue thy neighbour as thy selfe ye doe well But if ye haue respect to persons ye commit sinne and are conuinced of the Law as transgressors For whosoeuer shall keepe the whole Law and yet offend in one point is guilty of all This fulfilling of the Law or keeping of the commaundements which as Solomon saith is the whole man or the whole duty whereunto man was ordained the complete and perfect Christian vertue consists of two parts a bodie and a soule The bodie is the doing of what the written Law commaunds whether by acts positiue or inhibitiue the soule is the reason or internall law of the minde which impels seuerall faculties to such acts or workes For to speake properly and scholastickely all performance of good workes commaunded or forbearance of things forbidden spring not immediately out of faith as the truncke out of the roote the branches out of the truncke or the fruit out of the branches But as the fruits of righteousnesse are of seuerall kindes and qualities so haue they seuerall faculties or affections for their proper stockes out of which they grow The auoidance of adultery fornication or whatsoeuer pollutions of the flesh with the fruites of holines contrary to these vices spring immediately from the vertues of temperance and chastity Abstinence from murder with the acts of mercy opposite to the seuerall branches thereof flourish out of the affection or vertue of humanity courtesie gentlenesse or the like So haue the acts of the affirmatiue precept contained in that negatiue thou shalt not steale as of euery other Commaundement whether positiue or inhibitiue a peculiar habite or inclination out of which they bud yet as all motion is inspired from the head albeit we goe vpon our feete or moue our hands or other member to defend our selues or serue the necessities of nature So although we are truely said to walke in Gods waies to fight his battailes or doe him seruice when we vse any facultie or affection to his glory yet is our firme assent vnto his good will and pleasure reuealed vnto vs by the doctrine â—f faith as the animall faculty which impels vs to these exercises Hence as we gather the body is dead if it want spirit or motion so as Saint Iames implies the image of God and his goodnesse or to vse another Apostles words the forme or fashion of CHRIST IESVS in vs is without life vnlesse our faith and assent vnto them haue this soueraigne commaund to impell and moue euery faculty to execute that part of Gods will whereto by the doctrine of faith it is designed And yet as the exercise of outward members increaseth internall vigor and strength and refresheth the spirits by which we moue so doe the acts of euery faculty vertue or affection righly imploied perfect faith not by communication or imputation of their perfection to it as the Romanist out of his doting loue to his faithlesse charitie dreames but by stirring vp exercising or intending its owne naturall vigor or perfection Vnlesse euery practique facultie receiue this influence from liuely faith or from the image of God or Christ which it frameth in our mindes and proposeth as a visible patterne for ouâ— imitation in all our workes thoughts and resolutions dâ—cimur vt neruis alâ—enis mobile lignum we may be operatiue as puppets are nimble in outward shew but our seeming workes of charity or best other we can pretend will be as a pish and counterfeit as their motions neither in their kinde truely vitall But as puppets are mooued wholly at his direction and bent that extends or slackes the strings whereon they dance so are our soules carried hither and thither as the diuell the world and flesh or our owne foolish affections â—osse them vsually excessiue where they should be sparing and there most sparing where they should exceed This difformity was most apparent in their workes whose reformation Saint Iames seekes for destitute of all good workes most of them were not but onely of vniformity in working They had learned to giue honour not verball but reall where honour was due duty and good respect to whom such offices belonged The rich and men of better place and fashion they did friendly and louingly entertaine which was a worke in it nature good and commendable but their abundant kindnesse towards equals or superiours became as a wen to intercept that nutriment which should haue descended to other inferiour members of CHRISTS body and by these outward exercises of magnificence their internall bowels of compassion become colde towards their poore brethren whom principally they should haue warmed and refreshed Yet such defects or difformities in their actions these halfe Christians halfe gentiles true hypocrites hoped to couer with the mantle of faith whose nature vse and properties they quite mistooke That they were not without workes the world might witnesse and no question but these enterteinments were intended as feasts of charity and with purpose to winne the fauour of the great ones with whom they liued to their profession in which respect their kindnesses might well seeme vnto themselues exercises of religion as the like doe to many of the best sort amongst vs when there is any ground of hope for gaining furtherance and countenance to good purposes as indeed with such references they are if done in fath but that this difformity in these mens workes did proceed from a precedent defect in faith is manifestly implied in that the Apostle seekes their reformation by reducing them to such an vniformity in working as can proceed onely from such true and liuely faith as hath beene described For the rectifying of faith it selfe he expresseth vnto them the exemplary forme or patterne first of the imitable perfection of the godhead then of that which is in CHRIST of both which as hath beene obserued true faith in the minde is the liue operatiue image and must imprint the like character vpon inferior faculties or affections ere their
present danger or disagrace as not odious in the worlds sight And many scattered delights meeting in one like a multitude of broad shallow streames falling into one deepe narrow channell carry the soule with least interruption of speedy passage into the bottomlesse gulfe Vnited force is alwaies strongest and for this reason it is oft harder to renounce one sinne wherein wee delight much then a great manie we equally affect Freedome from manie vsually breeds secret presumption or indulgence to our delight in some one or few and indulgence bringeth forth hardnesse of heart Of if the worldly wise-man can curbe all his desires from bursting out into knowne euils this aboundantly contents him but so doth it not his God vnto whom this permanent luke-warme ciuill temper symbolizing onely with true religion in abstinence from actuall euill not in feruency of deuotion is more abhominable then the distemperature of publicanes and open sinners accompanied vsually with most vices yet not so firmely wedded vnto any but discouerie of their filthinesse may induce them to be diuorced from all It is much worse to be at the verie entrie into the kings banquet and retire or not goe in than to stay at home and pretend excuses A chaste infidell sayth S. Augustine is not onely lesse prayse-worthy than an incontinent belieuer in that hee is continent without beliefe but rather lyable to greater reproofe in that being continent hee doth not belieue 7. Of such vniformity in practising dueties expresly taught by the rule of faith as hitherto hath beene prosecuted is that most true which the moderne Romanist in no point destitute of one ape tricke or other to mocke God and man with a counterfait shape of true religion misapplies to curious points of speculation bearing men in hand that if they belieue not euerie point of faith alike they belieue none aright Whence many things they teach as necessarie to saluation being intricate and impossible to be conceiued with such euidence or probabilitie as may ground certaintie of faith seely soules are brought to distrust the perspicuitie of scriptures and to repose that confidence in their instructers which they should doe in Gods word and so for feare least they should haue no faith but by belieuing as the Church doth they belieue the Church only not God nor any article of faith as was deliuered in the former booke Nor can their workes if conceiued or begotten by the booke or Iesuiticall rules of life be euer acceptable in Gods sight because not inspired by true and liuely faith vniformely spreading it selfe throughout all their faculties cherishing and strengthening them as the Sunne doth plants to bring forth fruite To speculatiue points or our Assent vnto diuine reuelations as true the former rule is onely then appliable when wilfull contempt or indulgence to our owne affections doth blinde our vnderstanding He that vpon such motiues doubts of any principall article or disâ—ents from it rightly belieueth none but if for want either of naturall capacity or particular illumination of Gods spirit hee cannot so firmely Assent vnto some principall truth as others doe to whome they are more fully reuealed so hee demeane himselfe during the time of his dissent or doubt according to that measure of knowledge God hath giuen him his faith may be sincere and sound though not so farre spread as it is in other men 8. But some better minded perhaps will here demaund how farre this vniformity in practise is to be extended as whether a man may not be more prone to one sinne then another or more apt to conforme his will and desires vnto Gods wil in some points of his seruice then in others without preiudice to the sincerity or liueli-hood of his faith If this pronenesse to euill and negligence in good proceed from strength of naturall inclination or long custome his relapse into the one or holding off from the other doth not disproue his obedience in those points wherin faith hath gotten full conquest ouer his desires if his inclinations to his beloued or bewitching sins proportionably decrease or wane as his zeale or deuotion in the points of duty are augmented But euery member of the old man must be mortified ere our faith be euery way such as that whereby the Iust doe liue The manner of whose life by Faith is now necessarily to be discussed more fully then in these present meditations was intended least from some passages in the former discourses the vnobseruant Reader happily suspect the difference betwixt vs and the Romish Church in this controuersie to be but small or to consist rather in words than in substance especially if works be so necessarily included as wee suppose in that faith which iustifies Nor seems it easie to reiect our aduersaries form of doctrine without some preiudice to Saint Iames in whose tearmes their assertions for the most part are conceiued This last preiudice notvvithstanding first remooued wee are to manifest their dissent from vs and from the forme of wholsome doctrine which Gods Word prescribes to bee as great in this question as in anie For admitting their Faith vvere sound and their workes which is before refuted liuely they vtterly inuert the right vse of both and by artificiall sleights or tricks of wit not discouerable by euery eye drawe poore soules from CHRIST the onely end of the Lawe as well morall as ceremonial the sole load starre of Faith and all other sanctifying graces CHAP. VI. Of difficulties arising from the former discourses in the Protestants doctrine of Iustification by faith without workes That faith is as immediately apt to do good vvorkes of euery kinde as to iustifie Of the diuers acceptions of iustification That the iustification by workes mentioned by Saint Iames is presupposed as subordinate to Saint Paules iustification by faith without workes The true reconcilement of these two Apostles contrarie speeches in appearance from the contrarietie of their seuer all ends or intentions 1. SAint Paul as is declared at large before includes workes in faith which Saint Iames takes as hee found it in vnfruitfull hearers destitute of good workes This difference notwithstanding alone considered doth no way salue but rather remooue the seeming contradiction between the one auouching and the other disclaiming iustification by faith without workes and cause it wholy to settle in Saint Pauls assertion or in the doctrine of Protestants thence deriued For whether iustified we be by workes and faith as Saint Iames expresly speakes or by a working saith as Saint Paul implies this faith workes such righteousnes as Saint Iames requires not in others but in our selues Seeing then both faith and the righteousnesse it workes are inherent in vs how are we not iustified by inherent righteousnes if iustified by such a working faith as Saint Pauls commaunds and we haue hitherto described This which we conceiue by way of doubt our Sauiours doctrine seemes to put out of all controuersie Except your righteousnesse exceed the righteousnesse of
helping and nourishing the poore For when Zacheus said Loe the one halfe of my goods I giue to the poore and if I haue defrauded any man I restore it fourefold Iesus answered and said This day is saluation come to this house was much as this man also is the sonne of Abraham For if Abrahams belieuing God were reputed vnto him for righteousnesse he likewise that giues almes according to Gods commandement belieues God and he that hath the truth of faith retaines the feare of God and he that retaines the feare of God hath God in his thoughts whiles he shewes compassion to the poore Therefore he workes because he belieues because he knowes all the word of God fore tels is true that the sacred scripture cannot lie that vnfruitfull trees i men barren of good workes must be cut downe and cast into the fire but the mercifull shall be called vnto the heauenly kingdome And in another place he cals such as are fruitfull in works faithfull denying this title to the vnfruitfull and barren If ye haue not beene faithfull in the vnrighteous Mammon who will commit the true riches to your trust And if ye haue not beene faithfull in that which is another mans who will giue you that which is your owne Saluianus * words here inserted in the margine imports no lesse 3. If the workes required by Saint Iames be not truely good without presupposall of saith nor iustification possible without presupposall of such workes the more opperatiue wee make Saint Pauls faith the more we rather draw then loose this former knot whose solution in this respect must be sought by vnfolding the diuerse acceptions of iustification Sometimes then it imports the decree or purpose of God to iustifie sinfull men as whom he predestinated them also he called and whom he called them also he iustified and whom he iustified them also he glorified About iustification in this sence there either is or neede to be no controuersie at least none pertinent to our present purpose But as God decreed before all times to create man yet did not create him vntill time had numbred sixe daies so although his purpose was from eternity to iustifie or absolue vs from our sinnes yet actually he doth not iustifie or absolue vs before we haue actuall being nor doth he iustifie all that haue such being but those onely which haue the seales or pledges of his calling of which whosoeuer are partakers are in a secondarie sence accompted iustified How shall we â—aith the Apostle that are dead to sin liue yet therein Know ye not that all we which haue beene baptized into Iesus Christ haue beene baptised into his death wee are buried then with him by baptisme into his death All persons baptized may be accounted iustified in the same sence they are dead to sinne and dead all such are to sinne not really or actually but by profession in as much as by receiuing this outward seale of Gods couenant or other like pledges of his fauour they binde themselues to abrogate the soueraigntie of sinne in their mortall bodies and to giue their members weapons of righteousnesse vnto God Thus when the Apostle speakes indefinitely of all their saluation or iustification to whom he writes his meaning can be no other then this that all of them haue receiued vndoubted pledges of Gods mercy and neede doubt of iustification actuall or finall absolution so they walke worthy of their calling Their error whose rectification Saint Iames sought did consist in holding these outward seales or conspicuous tokens of Gods fauour whereby their Assent vnto his promises as true was confirmed sufficient to finall approbation or admission into the inheritance of Saints albeit they did not consent vnto euery part of the Law as good in the practise Concerning iustification thus taken there is at this day little or no controuersie vnlesle betweene the spirit and the flesh or betweene our owne conscience and Sathan who still labours to perswade vs this kinde of iustification might suffice Thirdly in as much as God decreed to iustifie man by faith which euen in such as are saued by it is not ordinarily perfected in a moment we are said sometimes to be iustified when the first seeds of that faith which by taking firme roote by fructification or perfection added by the immediate hand of God becomes saluificall are first sowne in our hearts Hee that hath but a resolution for the present syncere though variable to walke in all the waies of his God is in scripture often instiled iust or righteous and may by this resolution or purpose be truely said iustified in the sight of God not absolutely but in respect of opposite prophanenesse or expresse dissimulation If the righteous saith the Lord vnto his Prophet turne away from his righteousnesse and commit iniquities in his transgression that he committed and in his finne that hee hath sinned in them he shall die And againe The righteousnesse of the righteous shall not deliuer him in the day of transgression c. when I shall say vnto the righteous that he shall surely liue if hee trust to his owne righteousnesse and commit iniquitie all his righteousnesse shall be no more remembred but for his iniquitie that he hath committed he shall die for the same And vnto such as are here specified though not vnto such alone that speech of Saint Iohn is litterally appliable Qui iustus est iustificetur adhuc he that is righteous let him be righteous stil or more iustified Nor can that other of S. Paul be restrained to those that haue attained sauing faith or final absolution The hearers of the law are not righteous before God but the doers of the Law shall be instified That is God doth approue their deeds so farre as they are consonant to his law and accounts the syncere practise of morall dueries whereunto light of nature did leade the Gentiles much better then the outward obseruance of legall ceremonies or sabhatarian delight in hearing Thou art not farre from the kingdome of God saith our Sauiour to him that that had discreetely acknowledged this truth to loue the Lord withall the heart and with all the vnderstanding and withall the soule and withall the strength and to loue his neighbour as himselfe is more then all burnt offerings and sacrifices Now if by such workes as the heathen or auditors of the Law not yet sanctified often practised much more by those workes which accompany true and liuely faith we may in a higher degree of the same sence be accounted iustified that is approueable in the sight of God or passiuely capable of a finall absolution or effectuall iustification And this was all Saint Iames meant in that assertion Yee see then how that a man of workes is iustified and not of faith onely which words are but equiualent to the like precedent what auaileth it my brethren though a man say he hath faith when he hath no workes
cause of iustification by which our sinnes are formally remitted is as if we should aske one of their young pupils what were Latine for manus Iustification taken as we doe it for remission of sinnes not by inherent righteousnesse or ought within vs immediatly incompetible with them but by the externall merits of Christ is a forme or entity as simple as any formall cause can be and simple or vncompounded entities can neither haue formall causes or ought in proportion answearing to them Wherefore as I said it is either the follie or knauery of our aduersaries to demaund a formall cause of their iustification that deny themselues to beformallie iust in the sight of God For so to be iust and to bee iust onely by acceptance or non-imputation of vniustice are tearmes as opposite as can bee imagined Hee alone is formallie iust which hath that forme inherent in himselfe by which he is denominated iust and so accepted with God as Philosophers deny the same to be formally hot because it hath no forme of heate inherent in it but onely produceth heat in other bodies To be formally iust we for these reasons attribute onely vnto Christ who alone hath such righteousnesse inherent in himselfe as by the interposition of it betweene Gods iustice and sinfull flesh doth stop the proceeding of his iudgements as Phinehas zeale did stay the plague otherwise ready to deuoure the host of Israell Our aduersaries in that they acknowledge inherent righteousnesse to be the sole formall cause of iustification doe by the same assertion necessarily graunt it to be the sole true immediate cause of remission of sinnes of absolution from death and admisâ—ion to life This is the onely point from which they cannot start at which neuerthelesse whiles they stand they may acknowledge Christ come in the flesh crucified dead and buried or perhaps ascended into heauen but denie they doe the power of his sitting at the right hand of God the vertue of his mediation or intercession and more then halfe euacuate the eternity of his Priesthood as shall be shewed after this briefe explication of our assertion 2. When we teach iustification by faith and not by workes our meaning is by the doctrine of faith wee are bound to acknowledge and confesse that CHRIST IESVS by his eternall Priesthood whose offices in their seuerall places shall bee expressed is not onelie the sole meritorious cause of all graces or righteousnesse inherent requisite to finall absolution but these supposed in the party to bee absolued hee is likewise the sole immediate cause of finall absolution or iustification The latter part of this assertion may admit this ilustration Suppose a man not destitute of other senses yet ready euery moment to droupe or fall into some deadly fit vnlesse his spirits were refreshed by pleasant musicke we might truely say one in this case did liue by the sense of hearing for deafe hee should quickly die yet were musicke the sole immediate cause of his preseruation without actuall application of whose sound euen this sense it selfe by whose meanes his spirits refreshed better enable his other senses to their proper functions would foorthwith faile him In this sort doe sinfull men drawe life from CHRIST by faith alone by which likewise and not by workes wee are sayd to abide in him as being vnited in spirit to him albeit by abiding so vnited our other faculties are strengthened and viuificated to bring forth the fruits of righteousnesse The former instance notwithstanding doth not exemplifie the first part of our Assertion for musicke only continues life naturall which is supposed to haue another originall But if we speake of life spirituall maintained by saith and of which faith it selfe is a part it was originally and wholly deriued from CHRIST on whom faith and all other graces whatsoeuer tam in fieri quam infacto as well in the first production as during the time of their continuance and preseruation depend as essentially and perpetually as the light of the moone or other participated or reflected splendor doth on the brightnesse of the Sunne Nor may wee imagine that this borrowed and variable righteousnesse in vs though thus depending on the Sonne of righteousnesse is or can be euen whiles it remaines without eclipse or in such fulnesse as in this life the best men at any time are capable of sufficient for the time being to acquit or absolue vs if God should enter into iudgement with vs. This strict dependence of such righteousnesse as we haue on CHRISTS righteousnesse presupposed faith is said to iustifie vs not by any effects in vs deriued from him but by its transeunt acts reciprocally lifting vp our hearts to the fountaine whence grace and spirituall life doth flow and reflecting the beames or raies of our mindes thus illuminated vnto our mysticall head still deâ—iuing vertue from his crucified body to stint the deadly issues of sinne not vtterly to expell all reliques of vnrighteousnesse For when we take the eyes of faith of him albeit the habite of faith and other graces remaine as intire in vs as euer they were the very memory of transgressions past or the sight of sinnes inherent whilest we look on them deiect vs. According to this disferent aspect euen the best men liuing whilest this brittle glasse of mortality and mutability is in running may bee subiect to the like subalternation of hopes and feare the exiled Poâ—t hath expressed Spes mihi magna subest dum te mitissime Caesar Spes mihi respicio dum mea facta cadit Strength to my hopes doth still accrewe whil'st Caesars mildnesse I do vie we But mine owne facts whilest I beholde my heart doth faile my hopes growe colde But though sinne may often sting vs by fits and bring vs almost to deaths dore by vicissitude of despaire or dismaâ— yet we recouer as presently by faithfull looking on the glorious author as the Israelites did by beholding the visible signe of saluation 3. The controuersie hitherto proposed and declared in as scholasticke forme as our English tongue well can beare may be reduced in fewest tearmes and fittest for popular instruction vnto the right vse and immediate end of faith and other sanctifying graces We of reformed Churches with vnanimous consent of heart and minde belieue and teach and thou O CHRIST our Lord our life and strength giue iudgement out of thy throne of Maiestie whether not more agreeable to thy minde then shee which sits as Queene of heauen and brags as if she were thy best beloued Spouse or her children do That our Faith our Hope and Charitie or whatsoeuer pledges of thy fathers loue and fauour towards vs we through thy merits haue obtained were giuen vs not to alter but to better that plea we made before we had them Being by nature the sonnes of wrath and groning vnder the heauie burden of our sinnes with teares and sighes by thy precious blood by thy death and passion wee daily besought Him for
them and shall his goodnesse in giuing them flake the feruency of our wonted desires or supplications when as we seeke grace onely to the end we may finde and truly taste his mercie Thou hast taught vs Not euery one that sayth Lord Lord shall enter into the kingdome of heauen but such as doe the will of thy Father which is in heauen and his wil as the Apostle witnesseth they only do which obey it in all things omitting no commaundement when occasion is giuen taking no occasion to breake or violate any Shall we then enter into the kingdome of heauen because we thus farre do thy fathers will and in some measure obserue his Commaundements Rather without such obseruance we shall not we cannot enter therein yet when we haue done all this wee are still vnprofitable seruants To what vse then doth our inherent righteousnesse or obseruance of Gods Commaundements serue vs If sincere that haue been and vnfaigned though imperfect yet the faith which brought it forth will make a sincere and faithfull plea for mercy in the day of triall in which he that hath been an hearer only and no doer of the lawe or hath done in part what God would haue done but not sincerely nor faithfully because it was his will and pleasure but out of humour naturall affection or hipocrisie shall cry Lord Lord and shewe many tokens of Gods loue and fauour towards him in hope to better this present sute for mercie yet shall not be heard Why Either because he neuer had any true pledge of Gods fauour or did not vse such as hee had aright because as his workes haue been such now are his prayers presumptuous vnfaithfull or hypocriticall such as cannot obtaine any other answere of God then that depart from mee I neuer knew thee It shall not boote him to make proofe that hee hath giuen his goods to the poore or his body to the fire that he hath healed the sicke cast out diuels and wrought other wonders in CHRISTS name vnsesse his faith haue quelled all trust all pride or glory in these gracings wholly set on Gods mercies in CHRIST from whose apprehension vnlesse these other acts or exercises though of mercie sprung they are not truely done in faith but springing thence we cannot be so ready to doe them as hauing done them to renounce all trust or confidence in them For whiles we compare these slender yet sincere effects of our loue and thankfulnesse to him with his infinite loue and mercie towards vs wheron true faith alwaies lookes whiles it conceiues them the sight of them causeth greater humilitie for the present more hearty sorrow for sinnes past then we could haue conceiued if wee had not done them as the sight of Zorobabels temple finished did make the auntients of Israell weepe because the perfection and glorie of the former was more liuely represented to their senses by this visible and semblable model then by the ruines meere absence or imperfect reparations of it To be able to sound the depth of many conclusions better then others can giues stayed and setled iudgements a more distinct and compleat measure of the knowledge they wanted then fantasticke or shallow wits can haue For this cause solid learning alwaies contracts verball knowledge and superficiall skill in any facultie dilates mens estimates of theÌ„selues puffes them vp with preiudiciall conceits of their owne worth And seeing all our knowledge in this life though of matters naturall and neere at and is euery way imperfect the increase of it is alwaies vnnaturall and monstrous vnlesse the more we know the better we know our imperfectious and be humbled with a more sensible feeling of our wants Now in as much as the fruits of life do neuer take so kindely as the fruites of knowledge in any sonne of Adam since he made that impious and crroneous choice and euery mans owne experience can teach him that his practique faculties or performances come still short of his speculatiue notions or apprehensions of what is good and fit to be done we are by this twofold reason enforced to take the vnfained acknowledgement of our imperfection in working and serious distrust both to our works and our selues as no way iustifiable or approueable in the sight of God but for the perfect and compleate righteousnesse of CHRIST IESVS for an essentiall branch of that vniformity before required in true and sauing faith The growth of these particulars is like the growth of twins the more firme and liuely faith we haue the better and more sincerely we worke the bettter and more sincerely we worke the more vnfaignedly and faithfully wee renounce all confidence in our workes and our selues the more faithfully we renounce all confidence in these the more caâ—tiestly we seeke after saluation only by CHRIST of whose allsufficient sacrifice and righteousuesse fully satisfactory of Gods law and meritorious of mercy our righteousnes inherent though imperfect giues vs a truer tast then vnbelieuers can haue Thus the weaker we are in our selues the stronger we are in Him 4. The former question about the vse of grace depends vpon another betwixt the Romanist and vs about the measure of inherent righteousnesse They make the encrease and growth of grace not to perfect but vtterly to abolish the nature of it by conuerting it into righteousnes inherent as well for quantity as quality acceptable of it selfe to God without his fauour or indulgence We as the name imports make it alwaies subordinate vnto gratious acceptance and seeing we take it onely as a pledge of diuine fauour whereof wee stand perpetually in need as it is first giuen so we desire it may be increased onely to the end we may more constantly and faithfully sue for mercie and seeke diuine approbation aright Of our edification in CHRIST faith is not the foundation onely but the roofe vnto which all other graces haue the same reference that Hur and Aaron had vnto Moses The best seruice euen charitie it selfe can performe is to vnderprop the hands of faith lifted vp vnto the throne of grace from which the sentence of absolution must proceed Directly contradictory to this declaration saith the Romanist faith iustifies onely as it disposeth vs to the attainment of charity which is the formall cause of iustification the complete forme of such perfect righteousnesse inherent as is the onely immediate cause of saluation Charitie though giuen for CHRIST is to him the Crowne of faith reaching heauen by it owne perfection to vs not charity onely but faith it selfe as it is part of our imperfect righteousnesse inherent is footstoole to it selfe in the act of iustification or whiles it pleads for mercy Nor vas any sonne of Adam for the least moment of time euer so righteous but the actuall mediation of Christ or interposition of his sacrifice secluded from his triall at the tribunail of Gods iustice he might besides all his other sinnes iustly haue beene condemned for not stirring vp
illâ—c dâ—â—câ—atur inambulat illic amat sibi offerri victimaâ—â— puram in omni loco Et qui in hoc templum Deo sacrum eiecto Sancto Spiritu â—nducit abominationes quas in mystica visione conspexâ—â— Ezâ—â—biâ—l qui illic sedem facit Mammonae Veneri Coâ—o Baâ—cho alijsque portentis qui ibi demonibus immâ—lat spurcissimas hâ—â—â—ias veretur ingredi fanum gentiuâ— ne contaminetar Proiâ—d nemo sibi frustra â—laâ—diatur Deus non inrideâ—ur constet sibi nostrareligio nec alios detestemur ipsi graâ—ioriâ—â—â—â—â—â—â—oxâ—j criminibus vec alibi fimas religiosi timidi alibi impudenter impij Sed Christum semel professi â—â—ta vita reddamus illi testimonium vndique glorificemus illum obedientes illius praeceptis vt in hoc cognoscant homines quod vere fidimus illi quod ex animodiligimâ—â— illuÌ„ quod non simulatè ad sacrum laâ—achrum addâ—ximus nosillius militiae Author de duplici Martyrio VVhether this Treauâ—e were written as Espeâ—â—â—us â—eliâ—â—s most in his time thought by Erasmus desirous to try whether be could equalize Cyprian or by some other the opinion of antiquity concerning the nature of true Christian faith is so wel and pithilâ— expressed by him as no treatise of like quantity ancient or moderne will giue better satisfaction to the iuditious vnpartiall Reader c Continens infidelis homo non soluÌ„ minus laudandus est quia se continet dum non credat verum etiam multâ— magis vituperandus quia non credit cum se contineat August de ciuit dei lib 16. ca. 36. Hinc apparet quam parum momenti sit in rivulis externorum operum nisi ex puero interiore fonte manent L. Vines in illum locum a Math. 5. 20 b Math. 5. 17 c Verse 19. d VVhat manner of casualtie this speech includes see § 7. e 1. Iob. 3. 7 f Tertium Iestimonium Qui facit iustitiam iustus est non docet quid facit hominem formaliter iustum sed vnde possit cognosci an aliquis fit iustus Ille enim iustus est qui iustitiam facit sicut ille viâ—ens esâ— qui mouetur illa est arbor bona quia facit fructus bonos nec tamen ideo est arbor bona quia facit fructus bonos nec â—deâ— viuit aliquis quia monetur sed contra ideo mouetur quia viuit ideo facit fructus bonos quia est arbor bona Sic igitur qui facit iustitiam iustus est sed non ideo iustus quia facit iustitiam sed ideo iustitiam facit quia iustus est Belsar lib. de iustis cap. 16. a James 1. 27. * Sess 6. c. 10. * In what sence workes are said to iustifie vs in respect of men not in respect of God â—ee parag 6. a So likewise is it taken in the 12. Article of our Church Albeit that good works which are the fruits of saith follow after justification cannot put away our sins and endure the seuerity of Gods iudgement yet are they pleasing and acceptable to God in Christ and doe spring out necesâ—arily of a true liuely faith insomuch that by them a liuely faith may bee as euidently known as a tree disâ—erned by the fruit b Sect. 1. c. 10. VVorkes done in faith are acceptable to God for the merits of Christ vnâ—aignnedly a prehended as the onely author of saluation and sole end of faith vvith whom our soules seeke perfect vnion not from our perswasion of our owne saluation on such vnion already accomplished a See sect 3 cha 3 4. a Galat. 3. v. 7. Ioh. 8. 39 40. * Eos denique filiâ—s Abrahe dicit quos in iuâ—andis alendisque pauperibus operarios cernit Nam cum Zacchaeus dixisset Ecce dimidium ex substantiâ meâ do egenis si cui quid fraudaui quadâ—uplum reddoâ— respondit IESVS dixit quia salus hodie huic domuâ— fecta est quoniam hic filius est Abrahae Nam si Abraham credidit Deâ— reputatum est ei ad iustitiam Vtique qui secundum praeceptum Dei elemosynas facit Deo credit qui habet fidei veritatem seruat Dei timorem qui autem Dei timorem seruat in miserationibus pauperum Deum cogitat Operatur enim ideo quia credit quia scit vera esse quae praedicta suâ—â— verbu Dei neâ— scripturam sanctam posse mentiri arbores infructussâ—â— id est steriles homines excidi â—â— ignem mitti miserecordes autem ad regnum vocari Quia in aliâ— loco operarius fructuoses fideles appellat infructuosis verò sterilibus â—tdem deregat diceâ—s Si in iniusto mamona fideles non fuistis quod est verum quis credet vobis si in alieno fideles non fuistis quod est vestrum quis dabit vobis Sivereris metuis ne â—â— operariplurimum câ—peris patrimonie tuâ— largâ— operatione â—â—â—â—to ad penuriam forte redigaris eâ—â—â— in bac parte intrepidus esto securus Finiri non potest vnde in vsus Christi impenditur vndè opus caleste celebratur Cyprianus de opere eleemosynâ * Quid est igitur credulitas aut fides opinor hominem fideliter Christo credere est fidelem deo esse hoc est fideliter Dei mandata seruare ficut enim serui hominum diuitum â—ut procuratores quibus vel supellectiâ—â—â— copiosa vel cellaria opulenta creduntur fideles absque dubiâ— dici non queunt si res traditâ—â— deuorarent sic profecte etiam Christiani homines fideles non sunt si bona sibi a Deo assignata corrumperent Saluianus lib. 30. Rom. 8 b Rom 6. 2. 3. 4. Non obsetuance of this distinction betweene iustification presumed and accomplished or on Gods part proclaimed and sealed to vs hath made many expositors other wise men of admirable iudgement and sagacitie run counter in some passages of C. Pauls Epistles Ezech. 18. 24. d Reuel 22. 2. e Rom. 2. 13. f Mark 12. 33. 34 g James 2. 24. h ver 14. a Gen. 12. v. 1. 2. c. b Gen. 15. v. 3. 4. â— 6. c Gen. 22. v. 1â— Iames 2. v. 23. Pro. 20 9. Psal 19. v. 9. o In this sence is it taken by Saint Paul Rom. 8. ver 33. 34. Who shall lay any thing to the charge of Gods chosen It is God that iustifieth VVho shall condemne It is Christ which is dead yea or rather which is risen againe who is also at the right hand of God and maketh request also for vs. d Rom. 1. v. 17. Galat. 3. 11. e Cum hoc loco propheta nomine sidei persuasionem siue assensum firmuÌ„mentis 〈…〉 fiduciam siue spem compreheaderit certum est Apostolum quoque dum ait Iustitia Dei in eo reuelatur ex fide in fidem fic accepisse fidem vt vtromque complectatur Nec detor fil apostolus sed propris vsus est vaticinio prophetae ad suae sententiae
Salomons raigne that he deemed vs sufficiently charged with thankefulnesse to our Creator in that we were enioined to remember him and vpon this consideration he exhorts vs to take the inuentory of what we receiued from him in our creation in those dayes wherein we most delight in which the characters of his blessings bestowed vpon vs and their true worth are most fresh and sensible in all our faculties well knowing that if wee deferred this suruey til old age come vpon vs in which life it self becomes a burthen our returne of thanks for fruition of it and the vnpleasant appertinencies would be but wearyish Remember now thy Creator in the dayes of thy youth while the euil daies come not nor the yeeres drawe nigh when thou shalt say I haue no pleasure in them While the sun or the light or the moone or the starres be not darkned nor the cloudes returne after the raine c. 4 In like sort as well in sacred as common though lesse in the schoole language the greater the schoole-mens folly to know or belieue include not only a logicall conceit of the things we know or of their truth considered in themselues but withal a right esteeme of their worth or consequence in respect of vs. The originall of these scholastique solecismes in morall or sacred arguments iâ— I mistake nor ariseth hence that intentionall or abstract truths whereunto in younger daies wee are most accustomed being most comprehensible and best known we vse our apprehension or conceit of them because definite and vnuariable as the fittest scale to measure matters of morality not considering that these require more dimensions then obiects meerely speculatiue that their degrees are of another size and oft-times asymmetrall with the former that our soules for the exact discernment of their quality require a more peculiar touch then that light tincture or impression they haue taken from matters logicall mathematicall or meerly secular albeit all true knowledge euen of these must be commensurable to the subiect we professe to know rightly propâ—â—â—tionate or rather actually reaching to that end where at it leâ—els Euen in matters secular or most abstract if we wel obserue that conceit or knowledge which in respect of one obiect or some subordinate end thereof is exact and perfect applied either to an obiect altogether different or to an other end of the same will appeere to be meer ignorance or knowledge either imperfect or impertinent 5 Know we may the length or circumference of some plot of ground to an haire-breadth and this abundantly sufficeth euen curiosity it selfe in him that hath no other intent then to course or exercise in it In iourâ—ying or shooting wee examine not how wide but how long the countrie is through which we roue or trauâ—il but the exact knowledge of this dimension would little auaile a surueier vnlesse he haue skil withall to gather the iust quantity of the whole surface from the breadth as accurately knowne as the length or he that could from these two dimensions curiously calculate thus much should be accounted meerely ignorant in measuring timber or other solids vnlesse he knew th 〈…〉 icknesse of them and from the distinct knowledge of all three dimensions to notifie the iust quantity of the whole masse or substance the most accurate knowledge whereof vvere little pertinent to him that stands more vpon their weight then magnitude both which onely to know vnto a scruple would argue ignorance in him vnto whose purpose or profession the notification of their qualities vse or operation were only or principally necessary 6. Such a difference as I haue specified betweene knowledge of lines and plaine figures betweene them and solids or betweene the quantity of such bodies as their weight or quality we must imagine betweene the knowledge of truths speculatiue and morall or betweene meerely morall and diuine concerning our owne saluation The conceit or knowledge of these last how exact soeuer it be if it be only in the braine and imprint not the true character of it selfe vpon the affection is no better to a Christian then it would be for a Carpenter to know the length oâ— bredth of a peece of timber without the thicknesse or all three dimensions without any iudgement whether it were sound or faulty whether rightly seasoned or vnto what vse it would best serue in building It would be all one as if a Physitian or Apothecary should know the picture shape or colour of any hearbe in Mathiolus or other Herbalist ignorant of its vertue or operation or how it should be prepared for medicine Or as if a Merchant or Auditor should be able to display all the perfections nature hath bestowed on goâ—d 〈…〉 other mettals not acquainted with the worth of it 〈…〉 ents or in what countries it is most currant Briefly seeing all knowledge must be measured by the vse or end and this in the subiect we treat of is the saluation of our soules whereunto we growe by newnesse of life our knowledge cannot be perfect vnlesse terminated to a right structure of affections in the heart answerable to the Idea or modell of truth in our braines vnlesse it bring forth readinesse or promptitude in euery faculty to put such precepts as require their seruice in execution Of these two parts of Christian knowledge the one in the head the other in the heart much better the former were defectiue then the latter He that knowes rightly to husband the ground he enioyes what part is good for medow what for pasture what for corne what for this kinde of graine what for that how euery parcell may bee imploied to the best commodity of the owner may be ignorant in suruaying or drawing a right plat-forme of it with lesse losse then he that could suruey it most exactly but hath no experimentall skill at all in tillage or husbandry Now seeing our Sauiour tels vs his father is an husbandman and is best glorified by such fruites as we shall bring forth vnto saluation the true end of Christian knowledge he may be truly sayd to know more at least better then others doe that can improue whatsoeuer he heares or reades to the benefit of his owne soule and imploy those faculties God hath giuen him to his seruice It shall be little or no preiudice to such a man albeit hee cannot draw a map or perfect systeme of diuinity or deduce one diuine attribute from another Albeit he that can do this and leaue not the other vndone shall receiue his reward according to the measure of his talent rightly imployed But if his chiefe knowledge consist in distinct conceiuing of the deity or methodicall discoursing of diuinity this glorifies God but as the Painter doth the party whose picture hee hath exactly taken whereas our Creators glory must shine not in liuelesse painted words but in our workes patternized to his image renewed in our minds as towardly children expresse their noble ancestors worth by liuely resemblance of
Confident perswasions they had of Gods extraordinary fauour which notwithstanding because it proceeded not from faith fructifying in deeds conformable to his goodnesse made them presumptuous and open rebels against his Sonne the onely image of his glory for dooing the workes here prophecied by this Psalmist They despised him as a sinner once for raising vp a poore creature not bowed downe only but together so as she could not raise her selfe another time for giuing sight vnto the blinde vpon a Sabbaoth day Often for the like workes here ascribed to that God whose name they were to sanctifie by hallowing the Sabbaoth day all liuely documents that he which visibly wrought them was the Lord to whom this Psalme of praise and thanksgiuing was dedicated Such confidence as they whiles thus affected boasted in was the very way of the wicked which the Lord turneth vpside downe His sentence is already pronounced vpon it Euerie one that exalteth himselfe shall bee brought lowe which words he spake of the proud Pharisee and such as trusted in themselues that they vvere iust despising others Notwithstanding euen this Pharisee himselfe whom he makes the patterne of hypocrisie gaue God thankes for his conceited righteousnesse acknowledging that whatsoeuer he had he had receiued but in that hee gloried in it as if he had not receiued it the holy Ghost taxeth him for trusting in it not in the Lord whom he intended to glorifie for this gift amongst others And were we so wise that a word though from the spirits owne mouth might suffice for our admonishment this one place alone would instruct vs that he trusts not in the Lord but in his wealth or dignity that contemnes his brother for his meane giftes whether of Art or Nature or disparageth his worth onely for the lownesse of his fortunes 6. Thus much of confidence fiducia or trust so nearely allied to faith that some include it in the essence or formall signification of the word in the learned tongues which opinion may seeme to haue some countenance from the booke of Homilies But what there is said of faith to this purpose is a popular description not an accurate or artificiall definition like as also we may not think the Author of those Homilies meant formally and essentially to define faith when he saith that faith is a firme hope for so in the same place doth he describe it And to speake the truth he that puts fiducia in the essentiall definition of faith and leaues hope out had need of as much cunning as hee that should vndertake to make paiment of ten pounds and substract seauen For confidence or this trust in their form of doctrine whose authority for the right vse of such words is most authentique is the period or complement of Hope contemnenda est omnis iniuria malorum praesentium fiducia futurorum bonorum sayth Saint Cyprian And againe Laus est fides fiducia futurorum mundi aduersa tolerare It is the commendation of Faith to support our selues vnder such grieuances as the vvorld layes vpon vs with sure hope of future good In this godly fathers orthodoxall conceit of this chaine of christian vertues we may behold patience springing from faith but presupposing trust or confidence at least if perfect paralell herein to the Apostle Cast not away your confidence which hath great recompence of revvard for ye haue neede of patience whose hold-fast he supposeth confidence that after ye haue done the will of God ye might receiue the promise The ground or supporter as well of patience as confidence and fidelity in doing Gods will is faith as is before deduced Whether such confidence as we haue that there is a reward laid vp for the faithfull reach in the same strength and tenor vnto personall saluation or bring forth like assurance of our possessary right in state of grace or if so whether it be proper to all as it is doubtlesse onely to such as are endued with sauing faith or whether equall in all or at all times or rather decreasing according to the degrees of their delinquencie in such duties as this confident hope of Gods mercy and fidelity in rewarding all without respect of persons that doe his will doth impell and encourage them to cannot so fitly be disputed vntill the tenor of Gods couenant with mankind and other difficulties concerning free-will and contingencie with the articles of Christs death and resurrection from firme Assent vnto which this speciall confidence or assurance must flow be vnfolded Here I onely would commend that place of our Apostle to the religious Readers priuate meditation for rectifying and strengthening his faith in this point Hauing therfore Brethren bouldnesse to enter into the Holiest by the blood of IESVS by a new liuing way vvhich he hath consecrated for vs through the vaile that is to say his flesh And hauing an high Priest ouer the house of God Let vs draw neere with a true heart in full assurance of faith hauing our hearts sprinkled from an euill conscience and our bodies washed vvith pure water Let vs hold fast the profession of our faith without vvauering for he is faithfull that promised And let vs consider one another to prouoke vnto loue and to good workes Many other properties of faith there be and diuerse peculiar branches of these generall ones here touched to be discussed after the explication of the Articles out of which they properly spring CHAP. XI Of the diuerse acceptions of faith in Scriptures or Fathers of the Romanists pernicious error concerning the nature of it and charitie whereby his imaginarie workes of merit necessarily become either dead apish or polluted 1. FRom the seuerall degrees or differences of Assent vnto diuine truthes before assigned it will bee easie for the Reader to deriue the diuerse acceptions of beliefe whether in writings Canonicall Apochriphall or of Fathers from one head Albeit I hold it not worth the inquirie whether the name of Faith in the Hebrew Greeke and Latine were propagated from the obiect to our apprehension or Assent or from these vnto the obiect for in all three tongues faith is taken as well for that which deserues credit as for the credence we giue vnto it More pertinent to our present occasions it is that beliefe euen in scriptures is sometimes applied to the very first and lowest degree of Assent vnto truths diuine and they are sayd to belieue that acknowledge any article of faith or part of Christs doctrine as true albeit the ground of their Assent were not sincere or sound but rather humorous So it is sayd in the second of Iohn that many when they saw his Miracles belieued in him but IESVS committed not himselfe vnto their hands because hee knewe them all so did hee their humours to bee like theirs that vpon like beliefe of his power would haue made him king Others againe are sayd to belieue when they Assent perhaps to all Articles of faith
vnderstand that it is not liuely and perfect such as indeed it should be He meanes they denie it not to be numerically the same without workes and with them as the body in his conceipt is one and the same without the soule and with it And it is a manner of speech in his obseruation vsuall to account that which is imperfect in any kinde not to bee true in the same kinde As for example wee vse to say ioy or griefe imperfect or little is no true ioy or griefe although it be some ioy or griefe Who vseth to say so but dunces or who but haeretickes would denie the least degree of spirituall ioy to be true ioy the least sting of conscience to be true griefe Things little in any kinde actually compared with others incomparably greater we vse to reckon as none so we might say the ioy of the godly in this life is as none in respect of that which shall be reuealed But yet the least measure of our internall ioy truely denominates vs ioyfull if we speake absolutely as the Fathers doe when they denie faith without workes to bee true faith For they denie withall that it then denominates as truely faithfull or belieuers as is euident from that obseruation of Gregory vpon those wordes of our Sauiour He that shall belieue and be baptized shall be saued It is likely euery one of you will say within himselfe I haue beleeued therefore I shall be saued He speakes the truth if he haue faith with workes For that is true faith which in manners or deedes contradicts not what it thus professeth in wordes Hence it is that Paul saith of certaine false beleeuers They confesse they know God but denie him by their workes Hence saith Iohn He that saies he beleeues God and keepes not his commandements is a liar This should teach vs to acknowledge the truth of faith in examination of our life For then we are truely faithfull or belieuers when we fulfull in deed what we promised in word For in the day of baptisme wee promised vtterly to forsake all workes and pomps of the old enemy Therefore let euery one of you turne the eies of his minde vnto the former examination and if after baptisme he haue kept his promise made before then let him reioice being thus assured that he is faithfull He ads with all that he which knowes to bewaile his offences past shal haue them couered in the day of iudgement 2. This last testimony will direct the reader to gather the like in other Fathers from their expositions of those passages wherein mention is made of that faith whereunto our Sauiour ascribes eternall life or his Apostles righteousnesse The euidence of which places is in it selfe to such as weigh the circumstances co 〈…〉 nt and praecedent or compare one place with another so forsible that it oft times extorts confessions from pontifician expositors against the most receiued Tenents of their Church first hatched by the schoolemen which neuer saw the light of heauen but through the darke painted glasses of the Cels wherein they were imprisoned and hence imagine our Sauiours forme of doctrine to be of the same hew with midnight Dunsery or grossest ignorance of sacred dialects One vpon these wordes of the Prophet The worke of righteousnesse shall bee peace and the effects of righteousnes quietnes and assurance for euer saith that faith whereto S. Paul ascribeth righteousnes includes all these branches to commit our selues and all our waies vnto God as to a most louing father to whom we haue plight our faith whom we accept for our God sincerely promising to obey him and obserue his lawes He thinks withall that the Apostle did borrow this speech Being iustified by faith wee haue peace with God through our Lord Iesus Christ from the former place of the Prophet Yet this Commentator stiffely denies iustification by such faith alone how inconsequently to this obseruation shall hereafter be examined It well fits our present purpose that the righteousnesse herespoken of by the Prophet is included in Saint Pauls faith 3. Another vpon those wordes of the same Apostle The Gospell of Christ is the power of God vnto saluation counsels vs to learne the right signification of this tearme to belieue as it is vsed in Saint Paules disputes from other places of Scripture especially from that speech of our Sauiour Hee that belieueth on me as the Scripture hath said out of his belly shall slow riuers of liuing water The scripture saith this iudicious pontifician expositor whereto our Sauiour had respect is in the sixteenth Chapter of the second of Chronicles Thâ—â—â—ies of the Lord behold the whole earth and giue strength to such as belieue on him with a perfect heart Now they belieue with a perfect heart which doe not onely giue credence to what the Scripture saith or is otherwise reuealed from aboue but further addresse all the faculties of their soules to doe what faith requires or praescribes And in this sence doth Saint Paul vse this word belieue as if it were to be moued at the hearing of the vvord and to embrace vvhat is said vvith an entire adhaerence of the soule Very fitly to this purpose doth our English translation in the booke of common praier render that place of the Psalmist whose spirit cleaueth not stedfastly vnto God Which the vulgar latine seeking to expresse the hebrew word by word hath rudely expressed non est creditus cum Deo spiritus eius 4. Two places of Scripture onely there be with whose difficultie or obscurity the Iesuite or other of the Trent Councels vassailes hope to extinguish the light and euidence of all the rest so pregnant for vs. The first is that of Saint Paul though I speake vvith the tongues of men and Angels and haue not charity I am become as sounding brasse or as a tinckling cymball He that supposeth all faith may be without charity saith Valentian excepteth none But our writers reply That the faith by which miracles of what kind soeuer are wrought is here onely mentioned and such faith though neuer so entire and perfect may be as in these Corinthians it was without true loue The truth of which answeare most probable from the circumstances of the place as it needs perhaps no further confirmation so for the fuller illustration of it impertinent it will not be for the reader to obserue that of all the Churches which Saint Paul had planted of all he wrote vnto or vouchsafed any mention this of Corinth did most abound in all those extraordinary gifts of the spirit which might set forth the glory of Christ and his gospell before heathen and vnregenerate men especially such as these Corinthians by nature and education weere earnestly addicted to humane arts and sciences wherewith that City at this time flourished most for which reason the Lord in his wisdome would haue the messengers of his truth vnto that place rich in all kind
should make loue to our meate the soule or forme of a perfect taste For meate wholsome and pleasant we cannot perfectly relish but we must loue it howbeit we liue not by louing it but by tasting eating and digesting it No more can we rightly belieue Christs death and passion but we must loue him and his members yet liue wee not by louing them but by tasting Gods loue and fauour to vs or as I need not be afraid to speake by eating Christs flesh and drinking his blood For though by faith one and the same wee Assent vnto euery article in our creed yet this faith doth not iustifie but as it respects Christs bodie giuen for our sinnes or as it cleaues vnto Gods mercies manifested in that eternall sacrifice alwaies breathing out life to men renot neing all trust and confidence euen in such graces as wee haue receiued from him All this notwithstanding if we compare loue and faith together as parts of that righteousnesse which is in vs not considering the necessary dependance Loue hath of Faith in nature to loue is more then to belieue because it necessarily includes beliefe so is it more to loue our meate then to taste it because loue supposeth taste howbeit in respect of life to taste our meate is of more vse then to loue it So is it more to moue then to liue for all vicall motion includes in it acts of life yet is not motion simply better then life or the sensitiue sacultie whence it proceeds because it wholly depends on them not they on it 9. The second principall place of Scripture they vsually alleage doth vtterly discredit themselues but breeds no difficulty to vs in this present argument for that the faith whereof Saint Iames speakes doth differ as much from that whereto S. Paul ascribeth righteousnesse as a liue man doth from a dead or a body endued with life and motion from a statue or painted image no heathen artist that could but vnderstand the very tearmes of their seeming contradictory propositions would deny albeit some Romish writers of no meane ranke haue been giuen ouer vnto such Iewish blindnesse as to abuse Saint Iames authority not onely to hold iustification by workes as well as faith wherto his words incline as the thing it self in his sence though not in that construction they make of it is most true but to perswade the ignorant that such faith as S. Paul commends may be without works or christian loue But their folly herein will worke shame in such of their successors as shall comment vpon these two Apostles writings as in some of their predecessors it hath done if they consider that those very workes without which faith in Saint Iames construction sufficeth not vnto saluation are expresly comprehended in that faith wherby S. Paul tels vs the Iust do liue Was not Abraham our father iustified through vvorks when he offered his son Isaac vpon the altar he meant no more nor was more pertinentto his intended conclusion then if he had thus spoken If Abraham had sayd as they did whose empty faith he disapproues I haue faith but had not proued his sayings true by his deedes or readinesse to offer vp his onely Sonne vvhen God commaunded him for actually hee did not offer him he had not been iustified before God Why because he had not belieued in such sort as Saint Paul meant when he sayth by faith Abraham offered vp Isaac when he was tried But it may bee this faith was informed perfected or instigated to this act by loue of whom not of Isaac for that was the maine obstacle to worke distrust the chiefe antagonist of his faith Not of Sarah or any other friends or neighbours all which doubtlesse had disswaded him had he acquainted them with his purpose Was it then the loue of God Him indeed he loued aboue all because he firmely belieued his mercy and louing kindnesse towards him but this loue supposed it vvas his Assent vnto Gods omnipotent power which as the Apostle expresly tels vs moued him to this act For hee considered that God was able to raise him from the dead from whence also hee receiued him in a figure This consideration or inducement was a worke yet a proper act of faith no way of loue But loue perhappes did make it meritorious The loue indeede wherewith God loued him made his working faith acceptable in his sight but that it was strength of faith not the quality of loue which God imputed vnto him for righteousnesse the same Apostle for doubtlesse the same hand it was which penned the eleuenth to the Hebrâ—es and the fowrth vnto the Romans puts it out of doubt beeing not weake in faith he considered not his body now dead vvhen he was now a hundred yeere old neither yet the deadnesse of Sarahs wombe He staggered not at the promise of God through vnbeliefe but vvas strong in faith giuing glory to God And being fully perswaded that what he had promised he vvas also able to performe And therefore it was imputed vnto him for righteousnesse One and the same faith it was and standing at the same bent vnlesse by continuance of like triall increased in strength which wrought in him a readinesâ—â— of minde to sactifice his onely sonne in hope of a ioyfull resurrection and to expect his birth from the dead wombe of Sarah The obiect likewise whereto his Assent did adhere was one and the same his fidelitie which had promised on which faithfully still relying it was impossible his other faculties or affections should not subscribe to whatsoeuer his Assent of faith should enioine them and that remaining in wonted strength it could not but bring forth perfect loue and good works which may be sayd in such a sense to perfect it as we are sayd to blesse God that is to declare his blessednesse For as Gods loue to vs was most apparent in offering his onely Sonne So Abrahams loue to God was best manifested by sacrificing his sonne Isaac vvhom he loued yet he sacrificed him by faith wherefore his loue did result from firme Assent to Gods couenant and mercie made to mankinde in him in the faithfull acceptance whereof and full acquiescence therein his righteousnesse as in due place shall be shewed did consist 10. This comment vpon the Apostles words concerning Abrahams workes giues vs the true meaning of the like concerning Rahab Likewise also was not Rahab the harlot iustified by vvorkes vvhen she receiâ—ed the messengers and had sent them out another way If she had said vnto these messengers only thus I belieue the God of heauen earth hath giuen you this whole land for a possession yet I dare not shew you any kindnesse in this city her belief had bin as dead as a body without breath or motion But what man or woman liuing is there of common sense which once firmly perswaded that God in iustice had giuen his natiue country vnto forreine people whom he loued
them I leaue to the better experienced and more eloquent Pastors only of this I would admonish them that seeing the diseases are grieuous and the Patients strong it is not a milde and gentle medicine can worke their cure Much better they endured the smart of our reproofes though vnpleasant for the present then that they themselues when it shall come into their mindes to compare their resolutions and practices with their professions either made in Baptisme or renued vpon receiuing the Sacrament of Christs body and blood should out of the anguish of their soule and griefe of conscience take vp more bitter complaints then Iob or Ieremy euer vttered euen to detst the memory of that day wherein it was said a soule is added to the Church to curse the hands that brought them to this sacred lauer or lippes which there did promise or vow on their behalfe to wish hot scalding oile had beene powred vpon their heads insteed of the water wherewith they were besprinckled or that their foreheads had beene branded with some stigmaticall marke when signed they were with the Crosse in token they should neuer be ashamed to fight vnder Christs banner from whose tents notwithstanding their consciences witnesse they haue beene continuall fugitiues Doubtlesse the water which putteth away the filth of the flesh and is powred on vs as a pledge of Gods speciall fauour vnlesse by it the conscience which makes request to God be purified from these and the like dead workes of heathenisme will be a sore witnesse against vs Christians and solicit our deliuerance ouer to the euerlasting flame wherein the hypocrite and the periured shall aboue others be alwaies melted neuer purified 11. But if any man shall in this life purge himself from these he shal be a vessell vnto honor fit for euery good worke And God forbid we should take either any of these last mentioned or fowler practices for sure markes or signes of reprobation into which estate men are not drawne so much by multitude of sinnes past as by resolution to continue in them still which oft-times might be broken off and sauing Faith ingraffed in it place did not the Physicions of mens soules or others in charity bound to attend their brethren in their sicknesse giue them for dead or past recouery before their time In many appointed ouer seers of others well reformed in life and conuersation themselues there is a branch of Ethnicke incredulity or distrust of Gods prouidence vnder whole shelter the former weeds growe and prosper in inferiours For whether from a positiue error in opinion that whatsoeuer comes not to passe it was Gods will it should not come to passe we gather it is not his pleasure things long amisse shold be amended or that the christian world should grow better then it hath bin but rather worse worse or whether from a want of consideration or apprehension of his peculiar assistance promised to such as are gathered together in his sonnes name or perhaps by both meanes so it vsually comes to passe that good motions for reformation of whatsoeuer is amisse are no sooner proposed but the wiser or better experienced in the world men are or would be thought the readier they are to except that the same or like hath beene before attempted by men of farre greater place wisdome and experience and for vs to seeke the establishment of what they vpon better opportunity haue giuen for lost and desperate were to disparage their sufficiencie and arrogate too much to our owne Duties very acceptable vnto God and most necessary for time and place I haue knowne altogether neglected vpon like suggestions when as the voices of such as out of this politike humour did dash the motion without any trouble losse aad danger in the world vnto themselues without any contradiction or disturbance of other suffragants might with the generall applause of all indifferently affected and the best contentment of the greater part to be reformed haue fully ratified what was proposed Thus partly from a willingnesse to conforme our selues vnto the world partly from a perswasion that it is sufficient to reforme our selues not necessary to seeke the reformation of others we canuase secretly for the Prince of darkenesse and strengthen the faction of the world and flesh seeking as it were a maior part to disanull the Apostles Canon as out of date in our daies Greater is hee that is in vs then he that is in the world But had our predecessors beene daunted with such politike surmises or suspitions Christianitie had neuer preuailed against Heathenisme whose obiections against it were the selfe same our worldly wise men now bring against all attempts of reformation and because they are of the world the world â—eareth them and being Professors in shew deceiue manie honestly minded 12. Finally let the Christian Magistrates and Ministers pretend what other cause they list from their ignorance of Gods mercie and goodnes and want of faith it is for the most part that the people are so bad Neither haue that confidence in their God they ought but from an opinion in it selfe most true that God in these daies vsually workes by ordinary meanes or second causes we come to relie more on the appearances we see in them then on his fidelity and truth that is inuisible Were wee but as well acquainted with the fundamentall points of our profession as other professors are with theirs we mighted escrie it was the politician that foolishly dreames hee can mould states in his braine and Paracelcus-like giue life immortall to humane bodies polliticke which still spoiles the fashion of the Christian world by taking vpon him to be a grand Physician where he should be but Gods Apothecary or to be architect or chiefe plotter of those edifices wherein he should be but a labourer or handworker continually expecting the direction and instruction of that Maister builder which laid the foundation in Sion We our selues often know the matter or staffe whereon as also the tooles wherewith we see Artificers worke yet cannot learne their skill or cunning but should be ill fauouredly serued if wee tooke vpon vs to make those vtensiles our selues which they doe for vs. Thus albeit the instruments or inferiour agents God vseth to effect his will bee conspicuous and apparent his wisdome notwithstanding in their disposall or contriuance is incomprehensible to flesh and blood and it is a madnesse to thinke the like secondary meanes should alwaies produce the same effects But did the present dressers of Christs vineyard first sincerely renouncing their owne as firmely assent to the wisdome of God as the first planters did vnto his power in producing miracles they might see though not so quickely yet as certainely fruits of their faith not properly miraculous but to the wisdome of the world vntill the euent did work the truth altogether as strange and incredulous as the others did This part of the world wherein we liue with others adioining should in
same faith though not hypostatically yet truely vnited by such a mysticall but reall vnion as may without solecisme ground as well this denomination as our title or interest in Gods fauour More consequently by much to his owne positions might Bellarmine likewise haue granted that as we are truly the sonnes of wrath by nature albeit euery lineament of Gods image in vs be not quite razed but rather all or most much defared by Adams sinne made ours partly by reall propagation but more principally in his doctrine by imputation so we become the sonnes of God by the spirit of adoption though not so powerfull in vs as vtterly to extirpate all relickes of sin yet able so to dead the force or operation of it as it did the remainder of Gods image in vs before we were renewed by Christ Thus walking not after the flesh though in the flesh nor working sin though sin worke in vs we may through grace or this earnest of the spirit but onely for the righteousnesse of Christ whereto wee are by it vnited haue a more reall title to be enstiled his brethren sons of our heauenly father then Hee can haue as Bellarmine obiects by our doctrine he hath to be called the son of him that is the father of lies and Iesuiticall equiuocation Albeit there was no guile in him yet hee bare the punishment due to our rebellions and was not this commutation of punishment â—herby the seruants of sin are acquitted and the Lord of righteousnesse condemned sufficient to make such as are in part willing to doe for others as hee hath done for them immediately capable of absolution by his innocency of reward by his righteousnesse The a Apostle doubtlesse meant no lesse when hee saide He hath made him to be sin for vs which knew no sin that we should be made the righteousnesse of God in Him 7. The second point against which our aduersaries dash doth so euidently bewray their greatest pilots vnskilfulnesse in this hauen of saluation as euery childe that can repeate his Pater noster may easily perceiue the Trent Fathers themselues did not vnderstand it Nor can the subscribers to this decree vse that celestial prayer without plain mocking of God and Christ This imputation needs no other proofe then the cleare proposall of such positions as they now all holde de fide Take wee then one of their Catechumenies whether destitute of faith or no it skils not that hath not as yet attayned to the first iustification as they distinguish that is one destitute of habituall grace or inherent righteousnesse such a man by their Churches discipline is â—â—â—mitted or rather commanded to vse this petition amongst the rest forgiue vs our trespasses as wee forgiue them that trespasse against vs. What sinnes or trespasses doth hee request should be forgiuen him Mortall especially for their remission onely is necessary to the first iustification But how must God remit them Immediately by pardoning or forgiuing them No they are immediately remitted by actuall introduction of the contrary former grace inherent which formally expels them out of the soule as light to vse Bellarmines owne illustration of their positions in this point doth darknesse out of the aire Nor is there any possibility of remitting sinnes by other meanes left to omnipotence it selfe since the publication of Iesuiticall Comments vpon the Trent Councells decree What then is the full meaning or finall resolution of this petition whilest vttered by men as yet not iustified Lord forgiue vs our trespasses or mortall sinnes This verily and no other Lord by infusion of thy grace make vs such as shall not need of thy pardon or forgiuenesse For to holde that ouer and aboue the infusion of that grace by which the staine of sinne being clearely wiped out we are made iust Gods fauour or condonation to vse their Latine word with addition of one English letter is any way requisite for our acceptance or approbation with him is in formall tearmes the very opinion which Vasquez so peremptorily condemnes in Canus Nedina Victoria Gabriel Richardus Ariminensis Scotus and others as contradictorie to the Trent Councells oft mentioned decree and so indeede it is for by that decree being made formally iust by grace alone we become the immediate or formall obiects of Gods iustice or fidelity now strictly bound to render vs quid pro quo eternall life for grace inherent vtterly exempted from all dependance on his mercy and fauour And whereas some of their late Writers desirous to giue the Church all possible satisfaction yet partly fearing openly to wrong God or flatly to contradict his word had granted that grace infused did quite extirpate all sinne and make vs absolutely iust in our selues but yet could not by it nature or sole entitie obliterate all relation of trespasse or offence commited against God before wee had it as being vnable to make full recompence or satisfaction for them euen this opinion is now reiected as hereticall and contrary to the Councells meaning It remaines therefore that the true and full meaning of that petition in the Lords prayer forgiue vs our trespasses according to our aduersaries construction is Lord grant that we stand not in neede of thy forgiuenesse if wee suppose this petition to be conceiued either by men destitute of perfect inherent righteousnesse or such as distrust or doubt whether they haue it or no. But imagine a man could be as I thinke few Papists are more then morally certaine hee were in the state of perfect grace his vse of the same request would bee superfluous or requisite onely in respect of veniall sinnes albeit euen these if they imprint any vncomely marke or aspersion neuer so light on their soules must be taken away by introduction of the contrary forme as by acts of penitency or the like whereunto Gods concourse or aide of grace is necessarie so that his desiring God to forgiue him them is but to request his help that he may not need his fauour And though in their esteeme but a light one yet a prety mockery of God it is that after infusion of grace they should not stand in neede of his mercy or imputation of their Redeemers righteousnesse either for remitting or taking away of the staine of mortall sinnes or the punishment due vnto them and yet after God hath done all and Christs mediation as farre as concernes them fully accomplished most of them must be highly beholden to the Pope not onely in this life but after death for releasing the punishment due to veniall and petty sinnes 8 Some part of the first difficultie Bellarmine from what place of Caluin Melancthon and Chemnitius I remember not he expresseth not hath thus proposed CHRIST is our mediatour not onely in our first reconciliation but during the whole time of our life in which regard we alwayes stand in neede of his intercession and consequently alwayes sinne and transgresse the Law otherwise CHRIST after our first reconciliation