and how manifold shall hereafter be shewed Here God speaketh emphatically as of a thing most strictly charged and injoyned Remember that thou keep holy that is with great care and religion keep holy the Sabbath day and else-where hee commanded him to be put to death which breaketh the Sabbath The causes why God doth so severely command the keeping of the Sabbath Three causes why the observing of the Sabbath was so severely commanded are 1. Because the breach and violating of the Sabbath is the breach and violating of the whole worship of God For the neglect of the Ministery doth easily corrupt the doctrine and worship of God 2. Because by so severe exacting of the ceremoniall or typicall Sabbath God would signifie the greatnesse and necessity of the thing signified by this type namely the spirituall Sabbath 3. Because God will have the externall Sabbath to serve for the beginning and perfecting of the spirituall Sabbath Keep holy To sanctifie and keep holy the Sabbath is not to spend the day in slothfull idlenesse What it is to keep holy the Sabbath but to eschew and avoid sin and to doe good works on the Sabbath Now God is otherwise said to sanctifie the Sabbath than are men God is said to sanctifie the Sabbath because he appointeth it for divine worship How God and how man are said to sanctifie the Sabbath Men are said to sanctifie the Sabbath when they referre it to that use unto which God hath appointed it Six dayes shalt thou labour Six dayes God allotted unto men to labour in the seventh hee selected to his worship not that hee would that on other dayes the worship of God and the meditation of divine things should be omitted but hee requireth these two things 1. That on the Sabbath day there be not onely a serving of God Two things required by God of us on the Sabbath as on other dayes but also a publike serving of him in the Church 2. That on that day all other labours should give place to the private and publike service of God which on other dayes every one doth exercise according to his vocation What workes are forbidden on the Sabbath Thou shalt doe no worke God forbiddeth that on the Sabbath day wee should worke not any worke whatsoever but onely servile workes or such as hinder the worship of God and exercise of the Ministery which declaration is expresly elsewhere set down Yee shall doe no servile worke Levit. 23.25 Therefore Christ defendeth his Disciples pulling the eares of corne on the Sabbath day to drive away hunger and himselfe healeth a man having a dry hand and saith that an Oxe or any Beast Mat. 12.3 Luke 14.4 5. falling into a pit on the Sabbath may be drawn out thence without any sin Macchabaeus fighteth on the Sabbath day that there might be some preserved which should keep the Sabbath And of the like actions there are two reasons given 2 Maccab. 15. 1 Mac. 2.40 41. If we doe all as our brethren have done and fight not against the heathen for our lives and for our lawes then shall they incontinently destroy us out of the earth Therefore they concluded at the same time saying Whosoever shall come to make battell with us on the Sabbath day wee will fight against him For the maintenance of their life and religion they say it is lawfull to fight even on the Sabbath day By the same reasons doth Christ defend his Disciples and himselfe citing a place of Hosea cap. 6. If yee knew what this is Mat. 12.7 Marke 2.27 I will have mercy and not sacrifice yee would not have condemned the innocent And The Sabbath was made for man and not man for the Sabbath that is ceremoniall works must give place to the morall works so that rather the ceremonies must be omitted than such works of charity as our necessity or the necessity of our neighbour requireth And Have yee not read in the law how that on the Sabbath dayes Mat. 5.6 the Priests in the Temple break the Sabbath and are blamelesse but I say unto you Here is one greater than the Temple Also Yee on the Sabbath day circumcise a man If a man on the Sabbath day receive circumcision that the law of Moses should not be broken be ye not angry with me John 7.22 23. because I have made a man every whit whole on the Sabbath day By which words hee sheweth that such works as hinder not the use of the Sabbath but rather further and establish it such as are the works which appertain to the service of God or sacred ceremony or to charity and love towards our neighbour or to the saving of our owne or anothers life as that present necessity will not suffer them to be deferred untill another time doe not break or violate the Sabbath but are most of all required to the right and lawfull observation or keeping of the Sabbath Thou and thy Son and thy Daughter He will also have our children and family to cease from their labours for two causes Two causes why our children and family must cease from labour on the Sabbath 1. Principally that these also may be brought up by their Parents and Masters in the service of God and may be admitted unto the Ministery of the Church For God will have these also to be members of his Church 2. Because he will have especially on the Sabbath day love and bountifulnesse towards our neighbour to be shewed and seen in the Church Why Converts strangers must cease from labour on the Sabbath Why Infidels strangers must cease from labour on the Sabbath The stranger c. He willeth also strangers to intermit their labours and that if they were converted to true religion because they were of the houshold of the Church if they were Infidels he commandeth it them not in respect of themselves but in respect of the Israelites 1. Lest by their example they should give offence to the Church 2. Lest their liberty might be an occasion to the Jewes to accomplish by them those labours which it was not lawfull for them to work by themselves and so the law of God should be deluded Hereby is answer made unto three questions 1. Whether other Nations were also bond unto Mosaicall ceremonies if any of them lived among the Jewes 2. Whether they which are aliens from the Church may or ought to be forced to religion 3. Whether the Sacraments among which was also the Sabbath ought to be common unto Infidels with the Church Unto these questions we thus answer To the first and second as concerning binding and constraint the strangers which conversed among the Jewes Three questions concerning the Sabbath answered were not forced either to all ceremonies or to religion but to externall discipline which was necessary for the avoiding of breeding offences in the Church wherein they lived For a Magistrate ought to be a maintainer
3. That the doctrine be applied to the use of the Church which it hath in confirming true opinions or refuting errours in knowing of God and our selves in exhorting in comforting and in directing of our life 2 Tim. 2.15 Titus 1.9 as Paul commandeth Study to divide the word of truth aright And A Bishop must hold fast the faithfull word according to doctrine that he also may be able to exhort with wholesome doctrine and improve them that say against it And wisely did Epiphanius advise Lib. 2. cont haeres Not all words of Scripture have need to be allegorized or construed according to a strange sense but they must be understood as they are and further they require meditation and sense for the understanding of the drift and purpose of every argument That is All places of Scripture are not to be transformed into allegories but we must seek out the proper sense of the words by meditation and sense that is using the rules of Art and having a regard of the propriety of tongues and our own experience by which we know the nature of those things which are signified by words commonly used in the Church 6 Instance Concerning the deciding of a controversie about the text and meaning thereof But here is cast in another difficulty for that in controversies concerning the text and the meaning thereof such a Judge is required whose authority and testimony may suffice for determining the meaning of the text For when both parties say they who strive about the meaning pleadeth each of them that his interpretation is true except judgement be given of such a Judge from whom it may not be lawfull to make any appeale the contention will never be decided and wee shall still remaine doubtfull of the sense of the Scripture Furthermore this judgment must needs belong to the Church for in the Church alone wee are to seek for an examining and determining of controversies concerning Religion What the Church therefore doth pronounce in these matters wee must of necessity rest upon that as the assured meaning of the Scripture And hereof they say it is manifest that the decrees of the Church are of no lesse authority then the expresse sentence of Scripture But we as we willingly grant that the eontroversies of the Church must be at length determined Answ Not the Church but holy Ghost is Judge of the Word and that according to the sentence of that Judge of whom wee may be certainly assured that wee cannot be deceived so we acknowledge this Judge to be not the Church but the holy Ghost himselfe speaking unto us in the Scripture and declaring his owne words For he is the supream Judge whose judgment the Church onely demandeth declareth and signifieth he cannot be deceived whereas all men are subject to the danger of errour in a word hee being the author of the Scripture is the best and surest interpreter of his own words And therefore the Scripture it self in all doubts recalleth us and bindeth us unto it self 2 Pet. 1.19 John 5.39 Isa 8.20 We have a most sure word of the Prophets to which ye do well that ye take heed as unto a light that shineth in a dark place Search the Scriptures To the Law and to the Testimony If they speak not according to this word it is because there is no light in them The Church doth not alwaies speak the words of the holy Ghost For although the holy Ghost speaketh also by the Church yet because shee doth not alwaies speake the words of the holy Ghost she cannot be the supreame and chiefe Judge of controversies in Religion For this Judge must be such a one whose sentence may by no meanes be called in question But we have none such besides the word of God registred in the Scriptures Neither do we at all take away the deciding of controversies Deciding of controversies is not taken away when wee make Scripture Judge of meaning of the Scripture For although contentious persons alwaies seek sophismes by which they may delude and shift off the testimonies of Scripture yet do they this against their conscience and the lovers of the truth require no other interpreter of the Scripture but the Scripture and do acknowledge and confesse themselves to be plentifully satisfied by it 6 Waies how to decide doubtfull places For whereas unto men also it is granted to be themselves the best interpreters of their owne words how much more ought this honour to be yeelded unto the holy Scripture wherefore if controversies be moved concerning the meaning of some place in the Scripture we ought much more to do that here which we would doe in other writings The analogy of faith To consider and respect the analogy of faith that is to receive no exposition which is against the ground of doctrine that is against any article of Faith or commandement of the Decalogue or against any plaine testimony of Scripture Even as Paul admonisheth forbidding to build wood hay 1 Cor. 3.12 stubble upon the foundation Examining of Antecedents and Consequents To weigh the things that go before and follow after that place which is in question that so not onely nothing contrary to these may be feigned on it but also that they may be set for the meaning of it which these require For these either not being observed or being dissembled the meaning of the Scripture is not seldome depraved So those words of the Psalme Psal 91.11 Hee shall give his Angels charge over thee that they shall beare thee in their hands that thou hurt not thy foot against a stone the Divell tempting Christ interpreteth them as if they served to maintaine over-rash and curious attempts when yet that which is added In all thy waies doth shew that they are to be understood of men doing those things that are proper unto their calling Resorting to places which teach the same more clearly To search every where in the Scripture whether there be extant any place where it stands for confessed or is manifest or may be shewed that the same doctrine in other words is delivered touching the same matter which is contained in that place which is in controversie For if the meaning of the clearer and undoubted place be manifested unto us we shall also be assured of the place which is doubted of because in both places the same is taught As when it is said Rom. 3.28 We conclude that a man is justified by faith without the works of the Law that in this place to be justified by faith is not to please God for the worthinesse of faith but for the merit of Christ apprehended by faith and that the workes of the Law signifie not the ceremonies onely but the whole obedience of the Law chiefly the morall other places do teach us which in moe and clearer words delivered the same doctrine concerning the justification of man before God as in the
Christ already exhibited dead and raised again from the dead and sitting at the right hand of his Father as now it is but it was a preaching of Christ which should hereafter be exhibited and perform all these things Notwithstanding there was a Gospel that is some glad tidings of the benefits of the Messias to come sufficient to the Fathers to salvation according as it is said Abraham saw my day and rejoyced To him bear all the Prophets witnesse c. John 8.56 Acts 10.43 Rom. 10.4 and 16.25 Ephes 3.5 Christ is the end of the Law Object 2. The same Apostle Paul saith that The Gospel is the mystery which was kept secret since the world began and that In other ages it was not opened unto the sons of men Answ This reason hath in it a fallacie of division as Logicians call it dis-membring and dis-joyning those things which are to be joyned for the Apostle in the same place presently addeth as it is now which clause is not to be omitted because it sheweth that in former times it was also known though not so plainly and to fewer speciall men then now it is It is also a fallacy in affirming that simply to be said so which was so said but in some respect for it followeth not that it was simply and meerly unknown then or utterly covered and hidden because now it is more cleerly and that by more particular persons discerned for it was known unto the Fathers though not so distinctly known as it is now unto us The one signifieth the promise of Christ to come the other the preaching of Christ already come John 1.18 And hither properly belongeth the distinction and difference of the words 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 above expounded Ob. 3. The Law was given by Moses grace and truth by Jesus Christ Therefore the Gospel was not from the beginning Ans Grace and truth did appear by Christ exhibited and manifested to wit in respect of the fulfilling of the types and ful performance and plentiful application of those things which of ancient were promised in the old Testament But hereof it followeth not that they in the old Testament were destitute of this grace for unto them also was the same grace effectually applyed by Christ and for Christ but being as yet to be manifested hereafter in the flesh and therefore more sparingly and faintly then unto us Whatsoever grace and true knowledge of God was ever in any men they had it by Christ Joh. 1.18 14.6 15.5 as the Scripture saith No man hath seen God at any time the only begotten Son which is in the bosome of the Father he hath declared him unto us No man cometh to the Father but by me Without me ye can do nothing Repl. But hee saith The law was given by Moses Therefore not the Gospel Ans The law is said to be given by Moses because this was chiefly belonging to his office that hee should publish the law though withall he taught the Gospel albeit more obscurely and sparingly as hath been already proved But it was Christs chief function to publish the Gospel albeit he also taught the law but not principally as did Moses for he purged the morall law from corruptions by rightly interpreting it and did write it by the working of his holy Spirit in the hearts of men he fulfilled the ceremoniall law and together with the judiciall law abrogated the same 3. How the Gospel differeth from the Law Four differences between the Law and the Gospel THe Law and the Gospel agree in this that each doctrine proceeded from God and that in both of them is entreated of the nature of God and of his will and works howbeit there is a very great difference between them both 1 The Law knowne by the light of nature Rom. 2.15 In their revealings or in the manner of their revealing The knowledge of the Law was graffed and engendred in the minds of men in the very creation and therefore is known unto all although there were no more revealing of it The Gentiles have the effect of the law written in their hearts The Gospel is not known by nature but is peculiarly revealed from heaven to the Church alone by Christ our Mediatour The Gospel known by the light of grace only For no creature could have seen or hoped for that mitigation of the law touching satisfaction for our sins by another of which we have before entreated except the Son had revealed it Matt. 11.27 16.17 John 1.18 No man knoweth the Father but the Son and he to whom the Son will reveal him Flesh and bloud hath not revealed it unto thee The only begotten Son which is in the bosome of the Father he hath declared him The law teacheth what we ought to be but not how we may be as wee ought The Gospel teacheth how wee may be In the very kind of doctrine or in the subject or matters which they deliver for the law teacheth us what we ought to be and what we stand bound to perform to God but it administreth us no ability of performing this duty neither pointeth it out the means by which we may become such as it requireth us to be but the Gospel sheweth the means whereby wee may be made such as the law requireth for it offereth unto us the promise of grace touching Christs righteousnesse imputed unto us by faith no otherwise then if it were properly our own teaching us that we by this imputation of Christs righteousnesse are reputed just before God Matt. 18.28 Luke 10.28 Mark 5.36 The Law saith Restore that thou owest Do this and live The Gospel saith Only beleeve The law requireth our righteousness the Gospel admitteth of anothers Levit. 18.5 Matth. 19.17 The Law and the Gospel are not contrary In the promises the Law promiseth life to them that are just and righteous in themselves or with a condition of our own righteousnesse and perfect obedience performed by us He that doth them shall live in them If thou wilt enter into life keep the commandements The Gospel promiseth the same life to them that are justified by faith in Christ or with condition of anothers righteousnesse to wit Christs applied unto us by faith Neither for these respects are the Law and the Gospel at ods one with the other for albeit the Law will that thou keep the commandements if thou wilt enter into life yet doth it not shut thee from everlasting life if another fulfill the Law for thee for it verily setteth downe one way of satisfying for sins namely by thy selfe but it doth not exclude the other that is satisfying by another as hath been heretofore shewed Rom. 3.20 4.15 2 Cor. 3.6 The Law is the ministery of death In effects The Law without the Gospel is the letter which killeth and the ministery of death By the Law cometh the knowledge of sin The
testifie that he doth in a lawfull and right use of them bestow the thing promised and so may confirme our faith or that he may instruct us of his will by his Sacraments and by them exhort us to receive and imbrace the blessings purchased by Christ and further seale by those Sacraments these benefits and blessings of Christ unto us Now the Sacraments seale these benefits and blessings unto us 1. Because Sacraments are signes 2. Because they are pledges having a promise Therefore by these signes and pledges of Gods favour towards us the holy Ghost effectually moveth our hearts no lesse then by the Word The second end is the distinguishing of the Church from Painims 2. To distinguish the Church from others and all other Sects whatsoever For God will have his Church to be beheld in the world and to be knowne by these sacred signes as souldiers are knowne by their military tokens and sheep by those marks which their shepheard seareth seareth in them He willeth the Jewes to be circumcised and Christians to be baptized he interdicteth aliens and strangers and excludeth them from eating of the Paschall Lamb. God will have his Kingdome discerned from the Synagogue of Sathan for these two causes 1. For his owne glories sake 2. For our comfort and salvation For as he will not have himselfe shuffled and mingled with Idols so neither will he have his people shuffled and mighled with the Kingdome of the Devill The third end is the profession and testification of our thank fulnesse and duty towards God 3. To prosesse and testifie our thankfulnesse which is the bond whereby we are obliged unto Christ to be his people as he is our God to shew true repentance to beleeve in him and to receive of him his benefits offered unto us The fourth is the propagation and maintenance of the doctrine 4. To propagate and maintain the doctrine because God will not have the use of his Sacraments to be without the Word and application thereof The fifth is an occasion thereby given to the yonger sort to inquire what these things meane 5. To give an occasion to the younger to inquire and learne the things by them signified Exod. 13.14 and so an occasion also of explicating and preaching the benefits of Christ unto them As also the Lord saith unto his people When thy son shall aske thee to morrow saying What is this Thou shalt then say unto him With a mighty hand the Lord brought us out of Egypt out of the house of bondage The sixth and last end is that they may be bonds of mutuall dilection and love because they 6. To unite us in mutuall love and affection who are entred into an association or confederacy with Christ the head of the Church ought not to be at difference among themselves By one spirit are we all baptized into one body In like manner the Sacraments are the bonds of publike meetings and congregations in the Church When ye come together to eate tarry one for another For we that are many are one bread 1 Cor. 12.13 11.33 10.17 Ephes 4.5 and one body because we are all partakers of one bread One God one Faith c. But we cannot settle among us this communion neither maintaine and continue it being once settled neither profitably annunciate and shew sorth the death of the Lord as long as we dissent and jarre among our selves contentiously about the institution of the Sacraments For the Sacraments are pledges of that communion which Christians have first with Christ and then between themselves In what Sacraments differ from Sacrifices WE must hold and observe a difference betweene Sacrifices and Sacraments that we may know what to doe when we come unto the Sacraments and not make Sacrifices of Sacraments that is present our owne workes imagining that they please God for the very work done and deserve remission of sinnes as Papists doe Now the difference betweene these consisteth especially in two things In their kind and nature In their kinde and nature For Sacraments are onely ceremonies witnessing unto us Gods will Sacrifices may be ceremoniall and morall works also as our Sacrifices of thanksgiving of praise and thankfulnesse the calves of our lips our almes c. are morall works whereby we yeeld unto God due obedience and honour without any ceremony In their principall end In their principall and chiefe end In the Sacraments God offereth unto us his benefits but Sacrifices are testimonies of our obedience towards God This appeareth out the definition of both A Sacrament it a work wherein God giveth us something to wit the signes and the things signified A Sacrament A Sacrifice and wherein he testifieth of his offering and bestowing his benefits upon us A Sacrifice is a work wherein we yeeld unto God obedience or the worship which he hath commanded us Or it is our work done in faith and to this end principally That God may have his due honour and obedience They differ then as these two To give and To take differ For God giveth Sacraments unto us and he receiveth Sacrifices of us Howbeit the same rite or ceremony may be in diverse respects both a Sacrament and a Sacrifice A Sacrament as it is given of God A Sacrifice as it is used by the godly performing to God their obedience and yeelding him tanks Therefore a Sacrament and Sacrifice are often one and the selfe-same thing The same thing or work may be a Sacrifice and a Sacrament in a diverse respect but still they differ in respect All Sacraments then in respect of us are Sacrifices also but those onely Eucharisticall and of thanksgiving not propitiatory For there is but one onely Sacrifice propitiatory to wit the ransome of Christ offered for us on the Crosse Hence we easily may answer unto that objection Object The Passeover and other ceremonies of the Old Testament were both Sacrifices and Sacraments Therefore the Sacraments doe nothing differ from Sacrifices Ans More is in the conclusion then in the premisses because this only followeth That the same thing may be a Sacrament and a Sacrifice So Baptisme and the Lords supper are Sacraments and Sacrifices in a diverse manner and respect They are Sacraments and that principally because they are the work of God who giveth us something in them and doth therein testifie his gift unto us For in them he reacheth unto us certaine symbols and tokens by his Ministers as also by his Ministers he speaketh as by his mouth unto us according as it is said Luke 10.16 He that heareth you heareth me So therefore every Minister reacheth with his hand the Sacraments unto us and we receive them at their hands as at the hands of God if so we take them with reverence but much more God giveth and as it were reacheth with his hand unto us in the lawfull and right use of the Sacraments the things themselves which are
that will he have to be avoided by the discipline of the Church and that God hath willed the Church to forbid and exclude professed ungodly persons is manifestly proved by the fore-alledged places Obj. 2. Men are not able to discern the worthy from the unworthy they cannot know who truly repent and who persist in pietie neither can they cast a man into hell Therefore that judgment is not committed unto the Church whereby the godly may be distinguished from the ungodly Ans The Church doth not judge of such as are hidden or secret but of those that are manifest namely of those who shew themselves in outward life and profession and this she doth when concerning such she subscribeth to the judgement of God that is when she judgeth of them according to the prescript of Gods word as when out of the word of God she pronounceth the obstinate to be condemned as long as they continue such and when out of the word of God she absolveth them which shew repentance But to discern from others such as are close and hidden as the Church is not able so neither doth she take it upon her Object 3. Christ saith in the parable of tares Let both grow together untill the harvest Matth. 13.30 Therefore none ought to be excluded Ans 1. Christ speaketh there of hypocrites who cannot be discerned alwayes from the true servers of God Therefore his meaning is that hypocrites ought not to be cut off or separated from the Church as whom wee know not to be such but that the Angels shall do this at the last day 2. Christ distinguisheth there the office of the Magistrate and of Ministers Let them grow that is put not to death any which are estranged from the Church For the Ministers may not use corporall force against any man as may the Magistrate Now if this difference be put the difference which is between the Church and the kingdome of the divell shall not be taken away Object 4. Men are to be forced and compelled unto good works The use of the Sacraments is a good work Therefore they are to be forced and compelled to the use of the Sacraments Ans 1. The Minor is not true except it be understood of that use which is celebrated by the faithfull otherwise when unbeleevers use the Sacraments their use is no good work The use of the Sacraments is a good work when good morall works go before this use and then is it truly called the use of the Sacraments otherwise it is rather an abuse and profaning of the Sacraments For when the wicked take the Sacraments they abuse them whence it is that Christ expresly dehorteth the wicked from this good work when as he saith Leave there thine offering before the Altar and goe thy way 2. The Major proposition is to be distinguished Men are to be compelled unto good works but in their order so that there goe before an enforcing to morall works and then follow after an enforcing to ceremoniall works Luke 14.23 and so is that to be understood which Christ saith Compell them to come in It they thus urge the argument Good works are not to be forbidden The use of the Sacrament is a good work Therefore not to be forbidden If I say they thus argue we grant them their Conclusion fo we forbid not the use but the abuse Rep. 1. God would that all should celebrate the passeover numb 15.30 Ans All Not not orious wicked ones but such as were members of his people and ought to be tolerated in a civill society but concerning obstinate persons there was a commandement that they should be taken from amidst the congregation Rep. 2. Yet neverthelesse many evils accompany this use and are therein committed Ans These evils are done by them that hinder and will not follow this good use not by them that exhort thereunto yet Blessed are they that hunger and thirst after righteousnesse Mat. 5.6 that is which desire the performance of that which is good which if it be not practised it is not their fault And we may not doe evill or omit those good things which God commandeth that good may come thereof only let us do our duty and leave the event unto God If that which is good be not put in practice by others yet our conscience is cleer and we have discharged our selves Object 5. We have not examples of this exeluding The Prophets Apostles and John excluded none nay John baptised a generation of vipers Therefore our Ministers may not exclude any from the sacraments Ans The Prophets albeit they could not exclude the wicked from the sacrifices and sacraments yet they condemned that wickednesse of theirs in approaching thither and made oftentimes long sermons bot against the wicked who did approach and against the Church which admitted them unto the sacrifices But that the Apostles did exclude Paul alone doth sufficiently shew by his example as we saw before in that he commanded the incestuous person to be delivered unto Sathan Mark 1.3 Luke â— 3 and to be cast out of the Church and John baptised them only who promised faith and repentance he baptised a generation of vipers when they did repent Wherefore although they were a viperous brood whom John baptised yet were they not any longer vipers when they were baptised for John baptised none but such as confessed their sins as also he preached the baptisme of repentance for the remission of sins and required of them whom he baptised that they should bring forth fruits worthy amendment of life Object 6. If they are to be admitted unto the sacraments which professe faith and repentance and the unbeleevers and wicked are to be excluded the same shall be done after the same manner as it was done by John But John by himself alone admitted them who professed faith and repentance unto baptism and he alone also rejected the impenitent Therefore it shall be lawfull for one Minister alone either to admit them who professe the doctrine and repentance or to reject the obstinate Ans The reason is not alike For John was endued with a propheticall and apostolick authority which our Ministers have not Again at that time the gathering of the new Church was respected and not the excluding of them who were in the Church and had revolted from it Certain Arguments assoyled whereby some in a publick disputation held in Heidelberge An. 1568. June to D. Peter Boquine being Moderator and M. George Withers English-man the Respondent endeavoured to abolish Ecclesiasticall Discipline which Arguments with their Solutions were taken word by word from the mouth of D. Ursine at the repetition of this disputation the next day privately made in Colleg. Sapient The THESES proposed concerning Church Discipline were these two 1. To the sincere preaching of the word and lawfull administration of the Sacraments is required an office or power of Government in the Church 2. This office I thus interpret That
to do any thing with a true faith is 1. That the person who is the Agent beleeve that he is acceptable to God for Christs satisfaction What it is to doe any thing with true faith 2. That the obedience it self pleaseth God both because it is commanded by him and also because the imperfection thereof is accepted of God through Christs satisfaction for which the person is accepted Without faith it is impossible for any man to please God Neither is such a faith here sufficient which assureth thee that God willeth this or that this work is commanded of God For then the wicked also should do that which God willeth with a true faith A true and justifying faith therefore stretcheth further as both comprehending historicall faith and also which is the chiefest thing applying the promise of the Gospel unto us Rom. 14.23 Heb. 11.6 Of this true faith are these things spoken Whatsoever is not of faith is sin Without faith it is impossible to please God And the reasons of both these sayings are not obscure because without faith there is no love of God and so consequently no love of our neighbour And whatsoever worke ariseth not from the love of God is hypocrisie yea a reproach and contempt of God For he which dareth to doe any thing whether it be acceptable to God or no despiseth God and dishonoureth him Neither can there be a good conscience without faith and that which is not done with a good conscience cannot please God A referring of them principally to Gods glory It is required that this worke be referred principally to the glory of God onely and to his honour Now honour comprehendeth love reverence obedience and thankfulnesse Therefore to doe any thing to Gods glory is so to doe it that we may testifie thereby our love reverence and obedience towards God and that by way of thankfulnesse for benefits received Hereunto must our works principally be referred if we will that they be good and acceptable to God namely to Gods glory not to our glory and profit Otherwise they shall proceed from the love of our selves not from the love of God When as thou doest any thing thou must not heed or eare what men speak whether they praise thee or no so that thou know that it pleaseth God according to the saying of the Apostle 1 Cor. 10.31 Doe all things to Gods glory But yet true glory wee may lawfully desire and seek for according to that Let your light so shine before men that they may see your good works Briefly Mat. 15.16 in good works faith is required because except wee be certainly perswaded that they are acceptable unto God they are done with a contempt of God The commandement is required because faith hath an eye unto the Word Wherefore seeing there is no faith besides the Word there can be no good works also besides the Word Lastly Three sorts of works failing in the former conditions it is required that they be done to the glory of God because if they be attempted with a desire of our own glory or profit they cannot please God By these former conditions all these works are excluded 1. Which are sins in themselves and repugnant unto Gods law and his will revealed in the Word 2. Which indeed are not repugnant unto the law neither in themselves good or evill but which may yet by an accident be made good or evill Workes not repugnant unto the law are made evill or sins by accident when as they being not commanded of God but imposed by men are done with an opinion of worshiping God therein or with the offence of our neighbour These kinde of works faile in these two former conditions of good workes 3. Which are good in themselves and commanded by God but yet are made sins by accident in that they are unlawfully done as not arising from those lawfull causes by which the doers of them should be moved to them and which in doing they should respect that is they are not done by faith neither to this end chiefly that God might therein be honoured These kind of works faile in the two latter conditions of good works 2. The works of the regenerate and unregenerate differ in that the good works of the regenerate are done after all the conditions before specified but the good works of the unregenerate though they be commanded by God yet 1. They proceed not of faith 2. Are not joyned with an inward obedience and therefore are done dissemblingly and are meere hypocrisie 3. As they proceed not of the right cause that is of faith so are they not referred to the chief end which is Gods glory Therefore they deserve not the name of good works 3. This difference which appeareth in the works of the godly and the wicked confirmeth also that the morall works of the wicked are sins though yet not such sins as those are which in their own nature are repugnant unto Gods law For these are sins by themselves and in their own kind but those other are sins only by an accident namely by reason of defect because they neither come of faith neither are done for Gods glory Wherefore this consequence is not of force All the works of the wicked and Paynims are sins Therefore they are all to be eschewed For the defects only are to be eschewed not the works A Table of the kinds of good works Of good works some are 1. Truly good which according unto the definition of good works are done 1. By Gods commandement 2. Of faith and these are 3. To Gods glory and these are and these are 1. Perfect as are the workes of Angels and mans workes were before the fall shall be in the life to come 2. Unperfect as are the workes of the regenerate in this life 2. Apparently good such as are indeed commanded by 1. God and are in their kind good but evill by accident because they are not performed on that manner and to that end which they should 2. Men for religions sake as traditions advertisements and precepts of Pharisees and Papists Mat. 15. In vaine they worship mee c. 2. How good works may be done Against the Pelagians and Papists THis question must be unfolded and plainly expressed because of the Pelagians who attributed good works even to the unregenerate and because of the semi-Pelagian Papists who have coyned preparative workes of free will Good workes may be done through the grace or assistance of the holy Ghost only and that by the regenerate onely whose heart is truly regenerated of the holy Ghost by the faith of the Gospel and that not onely in their first conversion and regeneration but also by the perpetuall and continuall government of the holy Ghost who both worketh in them an acknowledgement of sin faith a desire of new obedience and also doth daily more and more increase and confirm the same gifts in them Unto this doctrine S. Jerome
are not able to merit or deserve any thing But there cometh good rather unto our selves by good works For the good works which we doe are a conformity with God and therefore are Gods gift by which gift and benefit we are bound unto God but not God unto us Wherefore it is no lesse absurd to say that we merit salvation at Gods hands by good works than if one should say Thou hast given mee an hundred florens therefore thou oughtest also to give mee a thousand florens Howbeit God enjoyneth us good works and promiseth free recompence to them that doe them as a father promiseth rewards unto his sons ON THE 34. SABBATH Quest 92. Which is the law of God Ans God spake all these words a Exod. 20.1 Deut. 5.6 1. I am the Lord thy God which hath brought thee out of Egypt out of the house of bondage thou shalt have no other gods in my sight 2. Thou shalt make to thee no graven Image nor the likenesse of any thing that is in heaven above or in the earth beneath or in the water under the earth Thou shalt not bow downe to them nor worship them for I the Lord thy God am a jealous God and visit the sins of the Fathers upon the Children unto the third and fourth generation of them that hate mee and shew mercy unto thousands of them that love mee and keep my commandements 3. Thou shalt not take the name of thy Lord thy God in vain for the Lord will not hold him guiltlesse that taketh his name in vain 4. Remember thou keep holy the Sabbath day six daies shalt thou labour and doe all that thou hast to doe but the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God in it thou shalt doe no maner of works thou and thy son and thy daughter thy man-servant and thy maid-servant thy cattell and thy stranger that is within thy gate For in six daies the Lord made heaven and earth the sea and all that in them is and rested the seventh day wherefore the Lord blessed the seventh day and hallowed it 5. Honour thy father and thy mother that thy daies may be long in the land which the Lord thy God giveth thee 6. Thou shalt doe no murther 7. Thou shalt not commit adultery 8. Thou shalt not steale 9. Thou shalt not beare false witnesse against thy neighbour 10. Thou shalt not covet thy neighbours house nor his wife nor his servant nor his maid nor his oxe nor his asse nor any thing that is his The Explication Now followeth the doctrine of the Law which is the Canon and Rule of good works The chief questions concerning the Law are 1. What the law is in generall 2. What are the parts of Gods law 3. How far the law is and is not abrogated by Christ. 4. In what the morall law differeth from the Gospell 5. How the Decalogue is divided 6. What is the true meaning of the Decalogue and of every commandement thereof 7. How far forth the law may be kept of the regenerate 8. What is the use of the law THe first foure of these questions pertaine to this 92. Question of Catechisme the fifth to the 93. Question the sixth to the 94. and to the rest which follow untill the 114. Question the seventh to the 114. Question the eighth to the 115. Question of the Catechisme 1. What the law is in generall THe Latine word Lex which signifieth the law is derived from Lego which signifieth to reade and publish or from Lego which signifieth to choose With the former derivation agreeth the Hebrew word with the latter the Greek word For in the Greek the Law is called 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 which cometh from a word that signifieth to divide and distribute and therefore the Law is so called because it distributeth unto every one proper charges and functions In Hebrew the Law is called Thorah that is doctrine because Lawes are published unto all that every one may learn them And hereof is it that the ignorance or not knowing the Law doth not excuse nay rather they who are ignorant of those Laws which belong unto them doe even in that very respect sin because they are ignorant The Law in generall is a sentence or decree commanding things that are honest binding creatures endued with reason unto obedience with a promise of reward and commination or threatning of punishment It is a sentence commanding things that are honest otherwise it is no Law It bindeth creatures endued with reason for the Law was not made for them who are not bound to obedience With a promise of reward The Law freely promiseth blessings unto those who performe obedience because no obedience can be meritorious before God Object But the Gospell also promiseth freely good things and blessings Therefore the Law differeth not from the Gospel Ans The Law promiseth freely after one manner and the Gospel after another The Law promiseth freely with a condition of our obedience But the Gospel promiseth freely without the workes of the Law with a condition of faith not with a condition of our obedience Wherefore the Gospel doth not promise blessings freely without all condition but without such a condition as wherewith the Law promiseth blessings unto us And with a commination or threatning of punishment otherwise the Law were a vaine and empty sound and should effect nothing Plato saith A Law is a right forme of government directed to the best end by fit meanes proposing punishments to transgressors and rewards to the obedient Oftentimes by the word Law the course and order of Nature appointed by God is improperly signified So we say The Law that is the order of Nature requireth that fruit spring of a tree But more improperly doth S. Paul call originall sin the law of sin because as a law it constraineth us to sin 2. What are the parts of the Law LAwes are some divine and some humane Humane lawes are they which being established by men doe bind certain men unto certain externall actions whereof there is no divine commandement or prohibition expresly with a promise of reward and commination or threatning of punishments corporall and temporall These humane lawes are either Civill or Ecclesiasticall Civill lawes are such as are made by Magistrates or some whole body and corporation concerning a certain order of actions to be observed in civill government in bargaines and contracts in judgements and punishments c. Ecclesiasticall or Ceremoniall lawes are those which are made by the consent of the Church concerning some certain order of actions to be observed in the Ministery of the Church which are the limitations of circumstances serving for the Law of God Divine lawes that is the lawes of God partly belong unto Angels and partly unto men and partly unto certain speciall men And these doe not only bind unto externall actions but require further internall or inward qualities actions and motions neither propose they corporall and
of discipline and order according to both Tables of the Decalogue amongst his subjects and to forbid manifest idolatry and blasphemies and to take care as far forth as he may that strangers and sojourners minister or give no open scandall to his subjects Moreover as concerning the binding there was a peculiar consideration and respect of the Sabbath which was not then first by Moses prescribed to the Israelites but commanded by God from the beginning of the world unto all men and so did binde all men untill the coming of the Messias Although indeed this commandement and ordinance was so growne out of use among other Nations that they accounted it among the number of the chief reproaches wherewith they derided and scoffed at the Jewes terming them Sabbataries because they so religiously observed the Sabbath To the third question fore-alledged we answer that the Sabbath was no Sacrament unto Infidels though they also ceased from their labours as well as the faithfull because neither did the promises belong unto them that God would be their sanctifier neither were they therefore constrained to cease from their daily labours as for a testification or confession of this promise but only for avoiding of offence and for preventing of such occasion of breaking the Sabbath as might be given by them unto Gods people Thy cattell By this it is the better understood that the Sabbath was not a Sacrament instituted for Infidels in that their cattell also are commanded to rest whose rest had no respect or consideration either of Gods worship Two causes why the rest of our cattell on the Sabbath is commanded or of a Sacrament but was commanded onely in respect of men 1. That all occasion of labouring might be cut off by forbidding the labour or use of their beasts 2. That they also sparing brute beasts might learn how God will have regard to be had of mercy and favourablenesse towards men For in six dayes The reason which is annexed unto the commandements is drawn from Gods rest and appertaineth to the ceremoniall commandement concerning the seventh day as before hath been shewed Two causes why the seventh day is appointed the Sabbath And rested on the seventh day That is he ceased to create any new parts of the world as being now perfect and such as God would have it to be This seventh day he consecrated to divine service 1. That this rest of the seventh day might be a monument of the Creation then finished and absolved by God and of the continuing of his perpetuall preservation and governing of his worke ever since that day unto his owne glory and the safety of his chosen and that so it might be a pricke to stirre us up to the consideration and magnifying of these Gods workes and benefits towards mankinde for whose sake all things are made and preserved by God 2. That by the example of his owne rest as a most forcible and effectuall argument hee might exhort men to the imitation thereof in omitting on the seventh day their accustomed workes of the six dayes A two-sold imitation of Gods rest Two sorts of our workes And so the imitation of Gods rest is double Ceremoniall or signifying and Morall or spirituall or signified So also our workes from which wee are commanded to cease are of two sorts Labours in our vocation Some of them are indeed commanded by God but they are not to be done with the hinderance of Gods worship of which sort are the functions and labours of each mans vocation Sins Labour and sinne forbidden by the Sabbath in divers respects Some are forbidden of God as sins Both these are forbidden on the Sabbath but in a three-fold difference For 1. Labours are forbidden but in a respect only to wit as they hinder the Ministery of the Church or as they give offence to their neighbour but sins are simply forbidden 2. Labours are forbidden onely to be used on the Sabbath day sinnes are forbidden at all times 3. The ceasing from labour is a type of ceasing from sinnes which is the thing signified by that type OF THE SABBATH HAving expounded the words of the Commandement that the doctrine concerning the Sabbath and the sanctifying thereof may be better understood wee are further to consider of the Sabbath What and how manifold the Sabbath is 2. How the Sabbath belongeth unto us 3. The causes for which the Sabbath was instituted 4. How the Sabbath is sanctified or kept holy and how it is broken or profaned 1. What and how manifold the Sabbath is THe Sabbath is called in Hebrew Schabbat Schebbet and Schabbaton Three causes why the day appointed to Gods publike service is called the Sabbath day each of which signifieth a quietnesse or rest or ceasing from labours And God so called the day appointed in his publike service and worship 1. Because God rested on that day namely from making any new or moe kinds of creatures though not from the preserving of the same which he had made or from continuing the generations of the singulars of every kind 2. Because the Sabbath is an image of the spirituall rest from sinne which should be in the life to come 3. Because we also and our families and our cattell are to rest and cease from our workes on that day not from all workes but from houshold and civill workes and from others of the like kind that God may then shew and exercise in us his workes The Sabbath therefore is a time appointed for the ceasing from externall workes which are either morally or ceremonially forbidden that is from sinnes and labours in our vocation pertaining to the use of this life and a time consecrated to the execution and performance of such things as belong to Gods worship or service And this concerning the name of the Sabbath Furthermore the Sabbath is of two sorts Internall and Externall The internall What the Sabbath is What the internall or morall Sabbath is or morall or spirituall is the study of the knowledge of God and his works of avoiding sins and of worshipping God by confession and obedience To be short The spirituall Sabbath or spirituall rest is a ceasing from sins and an exercising of the works of God This Sabbath though it ought to be continuall and perpetuall with the godly yet it is begun only in them in this life and is called the Sabbath both because this is that true rest from labours and miseries and the consecration of us to Gods worship and also because it was in time past signified by the ceremoniall Sabbath And this spirituall Sabbath shall be perfectly and perpetually continued in the life to come wherein is a perpetuall worshipping and magnifying of God Two causes why ceasing from sin and study of the word is called a Sabbath Isa 6.13 What the externall or Ceremoniall Sabbath is all those labours being left and surceased wherein we are now busied and occupied And from month to month
why the ceremoniall law belongeth not unto us are especially these 1. One part of this law of sanctifying the Sabbath is ceremoniall Col. 2.16 2. Paul saith Let no man condemne you in respect of an holy day 3. The Apostles themselves did change the Sabbath of the seventh day 4. From the end or purpose of the law It was a type of things that were to be fulfilled by Christ namely of sanctification and every type must give place to the thing thereby signified Likewise it was a severing or distinguishing the Jewes from other Nations but this severing and distinction was taken away by Christ Object 3. The Lord saith of the Sabbath day Exod. 31.27 It is a signe between me and the children of Israel for ever and an everlasting covenant Therefore the Sabbath of the seventh day is never to be abolished Ans 1. The ceremoniall Sabbath was perpetuall untill Christs coming who is the end of ceremonies 2. The Sabbath is eternall as concerning the thing signified which is a ceasing from sins and a rest in God for in this sense are all the types of the old Testament eternall even the kingdome of David also which yet was overthrown before the coming of the Messias Object 4. Wee grant the Mosaicall ceremonies to be changeable yet it followeth not thereof Look the question concerning the abrogating of the Law Ob. 1. Pag. 2. that the lawes which were made before Moses time are changeable in the number whereof also is the keeping of the Sabbath day Answ The ceremonies which were ordained of God before Moses are also changeable because they were types of the benefits of the Messias to come and therefore are by his coming abolished as circumcision which was given unto Abraham as also the sacrifices which were prescribed unto our first Parents Object 5. The lawes which were given of God before the fall are not types of the benefits of the Messias and binde all mankinde for ever for then was not given as yet the promise of the Messias and there was one and the same condition of all mankind But the Sabbath of the seventh day was ordained by God as soon as the creation of the world was finished before the fall of mankinde Therefore it is universall and perpetuall Ans The Major proposition is true concerning the morall law the notions whereof were imprinted in mans mind at the first creation but it is not true as touching the ceremony or observing of the seventh day as which after the fall was made a type of the benefits of the Messias in the Mosaicall law and therefore in like manner as other ceremonies which were either then or before instituted it became subject to mutation and change by the coming of the Messias For God would not have the shadowes of things to continue or remain the things themselves being once come and exhibited Wherefore albeit wee grant that the exercises of divine worship were to have been kept on the seventh day according to the commandement and prescript of the Decalogue as well if men had never sinned as now after they sinned yet notwithstanding seeing God hath enrolled this ceremony amongst the shadowes of the Messias to come he hath by this new law enacted by Moses made it changeable together with other ceremonies Object 6. The cause of the law being perpetuall doth make the law it selfe also perpetuall The memory and celebration of the creation and the meditation on the workes of God is a perpetuall cause of the Sabbath Therefore the Sabbath is perpetuall yea even after Christs coming Ans A law is made perpetuall or unchangeable by reason of an unchangeable cause that is if that cause it and doe necessarily or perpetually require this law as an effect or meane but not if at other times that end may be better come unto by other meanes or if the Law-giver may as well obtaine the same end by another law In like manner seeing also this law of sanctifying the Sabbath of the seventh day being repealed and abolished we may neverthelesse godlily and holily by other meanes meditate on Gods workes it followeth not that this law of the ceremoniall Sabbath is perpetuall although the memory and celebration of Gods creation and works ought to be perpetuall and therefore hath the Church by common consent according to Christian liberty well changed this ceremony of observing the seventh day being taken away by Christ and hath substituted in the place of the seventh day the first day of the week yet so that there is observed no difference of daies which is utterly forbidden in the Church seeing one day is not holier than another The Anabaptists also against the observation of the first day of the week Objecti against the observing of Sunday or the Lords day Col. 2.16 Galat. 4.10 Rom. 14.6 or the Lords day oppose those sayings of Scripture which forbid the putting of difference between daies and daies in the new Testament Let no man condemne you in respect of an holy day Yee observe daies and months and times and yeares Hee that observeth the day observeth it to the Lord and he that observeth not the day observeth it not to the Lord. Therefore say they the observation of the first day of the week or the Lords day is no lesse in these places reproved than the solemnizing of the Sabbath Ans We answer to the Antecedent that a putting difference between dayes and dayes is indeed forbidden amongst Christians but not simply or wholly but on this wise namely if it be done with an opinion of ceremonious worship or necessity Now the first day of the week or the Lords day is not so observed by the Church For there is a double difference between the Christian observing of the Lords day and the Jewish observing of the Sabbath or seventh day A double difference between the Christian observing of the Lords day and the Jewish observing of the Sabbath For 1. It was not lawfull for the Jewes to change the Sabbath or to omit it as being a part of ceremoniall worship and this they might not doe by reason of the expresse commandement of God to the contrary But the Christian Church retaining still her liberty allotteth the first day unto the Ministery without adjoyning any opinion of necessity or worship 2. The old ceremoniall Sabbath was in the old Testament a type of things to be fulfilled by Christ but in the new Testament that signification ceaseth and there is had regard only of order and comelinesse without which there could be either no Ministery or at least wise no well ordered Ministery in the Church 3. The causes for which the Sabbath day was instituted THe finall causes or ends for which the Sabbath day was instituted are these For publike service and worship of God in the Church The publike service and worship of God in the Church exercise of prayers confession and obedience in which consisteth the study of the knowledge of
administer the Sacraments 2. For what end and purpose the Ministery was instituted THe causes why God ordained the Church Ministery are Gods glory Psal 68.26 Gods glory because God will be magnified and invocated in this life by mankinde not only privately by particular men but also by the publique voice of the Church Give thanks to God in the Congregation Mens conversion Ephes 4.11 12. That it may be an instrument whereby to convert men unto God He gave some Apostles some Prophets c. for the gathering together of the Saints Mens instruction by men That God may apply himselfe to our infirmity in teaching men by men Mens edification by good example Psal 22.22 That men may provoke one another by their example unto godlinesse and to the magnifying and praising of God I will declare thy name unto my brethren in the midst of the Congregation will I praise thee Mans advancement in so high a calling That God may shew his love towards man in that he will have men to be Ministers of that great worke the ministery of reconciliation which also the very Son of God did administer The cleere apparency of the Church That the Church may be seene and heard among men and may be discerned from the other blasphemous and idolatrous multitude of men that so the Elect may be gathered unto it and that the Reprobate may be made more inexcusable while they contemne and endeavour to represse the voice and calling of God which they have heard But have they not heard No doubt their sound went out through all the earth and their words into the end of the world Now thanks be unto God which alwaies maketh us to triumph in Christ Rom. 10.18 2 Cor. 2.14 15 16. and maketh manifest the savour of his knowledge by us in every place for we are unto God the sweet savour of Christ in them that are saved and in them that perish to the one we are the savour of death unto death and to the other the savour of life unto life 3. What are the degrees of Ministers OF Ministers some are immediately called of God some mediately by the Church Immediately are called the Prophets and Apostles 1. Immediately called 1. Prophets The Prophets were Ministers immediately called of God to teach and open the doctrine of Moses and of the promise of the Messias to come as also to correct their manners in the Church and Common-wealth of Moses and to utter Prophecies of events in and without the Church having a testimony and warrant that they could not erre in doctrine 2. Apostles The Apostles were Ministers immediatly called by Christ to teach the doctrine concerning the Messias now exhibited and to spread it throughout the whole world having likewise a testimony and warrant that they could not erre in doctrine 2. Mediately called Mediately were called Evangelists The Evangelists who were helpers of the Apostles in their labours and were sent of the Apostles to teach divers Churches Bishops or Pastors Bishops or Pastors which are Ministers called by the Church to teach the word of God and to administer the Sacraments in some one certaine Church Doctors Doctors who are Ministers called by the Church to teach in some certaine Church Governours Governours who are Minsters chosen by the judgement of the Church to administer discipline and to ordaine things necessary for the Church Deacons Deacons who are Ministers chosen by the Church to take care for the poore and to distribute almes 4. What are the duties and functions of Ministers THe duties and functions of Ministers of the Church are in generall 1. Faithfully and skilfully to propound and deliver the true and sound doctrine of Gods Law and Gospel that the Church may know and understand it 2. Rightly to administer the Sacraments according to Gods institution 3. To goe before and shine unto the Church by their good example of Christian life and conversation Titus 2.7 Above all things shew thy selfe an example of good works 4. To give diligent attendance unto their flocke Acts 20.28 Take heed therefore unto your selves and to all the flocke whereof the holy Ghost hath made you over seers to feed the Church of God 5. To yeeld their service in such judgements as are exercised by the Church 6. To take care that regard and respect be had of the poore 5. Vnto whom the Ministery is to be committed UNto whom and what manner of persons the Ministery is to be committed Saint Paul plainly delivereth in his Epistles to Timothy and to Titus And briefly to comprise them the Ministery of the Church is to be committed 1. Unto men 2 Tim. 2.12 not to women I permit not a woman to teach 2. To such as have a good testimony in and without the Church 1 Tim. 3. ◠7. A Bishop must be unreproveable well reported of even of them which are without lest he fall into rebuke and the snare of the Devill 3. To such as are able to teach that is to such as rightly understand the doctrine and have gifts in some measure rightly to expound the same 2 Tim. 2.10 A Bishop must be apt to teach A work-man that needeth not to be ashamed Titus 1.9 dividing the word of truth aright Holding fast the faithfull word according to doctrine that he also may be able to exhort with wholesome doctrine and reprove them that say against it OF CEREMONIES WHereas one part of the fourth Commandement is Ceremoniall it shall not be unfit or impertinent to say and set downe some thing in this place concerning Ceremonies The speciall questions are 1. What Ceremonies are 2. How Ceremonies differ from Morall workes 3. How many sorts of Ceremonies there are 4. Whether the Church may ordaine Ceremonies 1. What Ceremonies are ALl divine worship was called of the Romans by the name of Ceremony d ee 1. lib. y. Ceremonia à carenio Macrob. Saturnal lib. 3. cap. 3. from the towne Caere wherein the Images of the gods were kept from the Gaules as Livie writeth In the Church Ceremonies are called Externall and solemne actions ordained in the ministery of the Church either for orders sake or signification 2. How Ceremonies differ from Morall works CEremonies differ from Morall works in that 1. Ceremonies are temporary Morall works are perpetuall 2. The Ceremonies are done alwaies alike The Morall are not done alwaies alike 3. The Ceremonies signifie The Morall are signified 4. The Morall are as the generall The Ceremoniall are restrained in speciall 5. The Ceremoniall serve for the Morall The Morall are the end or scope of the Ceremoniall 3. How many sorts of Ceremonies there are CEremonies are of two sorts some commanded by God some ordained by men Those that are commanded by God are the worship of God and cannot be changed but by God only Commanded by God 1. Sacrifices 2. Sacraments and those are either
same chapter By the works of the law shall no flesh be justified in his sight Vers 20 21 22 23. for by the law cometh the knowledge of sinne But now is the righteousnesse of God made manifest without the law having witnesse of the law and of the Prophets The righteousnesse of God by the faith of Jesus Christ unto all and upon all that beleeve for there is no difference For all have sinned and are deprived of the glory of God and are justified freely by his grace through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus Conferring like places together To conferre places of Scripture where though the same words be not spoken of the same thing yet the words and formes of speaking are used of the like things For if the interpretation of the like place be certaine and there be the same causes for the like interpretation to be given in the place in controversie which are in the other then of the like places we must give one and the same judgement Mat. 5.29 30. The Lord willeth to put out our eye to cut off our hand if they be a cause of offence unto us Now whereas the Law forbiddeth us to maime our body Thou shalt not kill that therefore by this figure of speech the Lord would have us that wee should rather forsake things most deare unto us than by the rust and motion of them wee should suffer our selves to be withdrawne from God the like forme of speech other-where used Jeremy 22.24 Deut. 32.10 to signifie things most deare and precious doth shew as If Jechoniah were the signet of my right hand yet would I plucke thee thence and Hee kept him as the apple of his eye Consent of the catholike Church with 3 rules of direction therein John 8.37 When once according to that rule the controversies concerning the text and meaning thereof are judged we may lawfully also descend to the consent of the Church yet putting great space betwixt and not without great advisement For lest by the name of the Church we be beguiled 1. No sentence or meaning is to be received which these rules of examining and judging which have been now declared do not suffer 2. Wee must consider what times and what writings are purest what points of doctrine have beene and in what ages either rightly expounded or depraved with errours 3. Whose interpretation either is of the authour or may be of 〈◊〉 confirmed by the testimonies of the Scripture And to this deciding of all controversies about the meaning of the Scripture drawne out of the Scripture it selfe doe all the godly and lovers of truth agree even as it is said Hee that is of God heareth the words of God Now the testimony of the ancient and catholike Church so farre as they see it to accord with the Scripture they doe with glad and thankful mindes embrace and are so much more assured of the knowne truth But if any quarrelling men doe not yeeld unto the testimonies of the Scriptures we must not seeke because of them a Judge higher then the word of God but must leave them unto the judgement of God as the Apostle counselleth us Reject him that is an hereticke after once or twice admonition Titus 3.20 knowing that he that is such is perverted and sinneth being damned of his owne selfe 1 Cor. 14.38 Rev. 22.11 And If any man be ignorant let him be ignorant Hee that is filthy let him be more filthy Neither verily doth he whom the word of God doth not satisfie rest on the authority of men as the truth it selfe doth shew but as these things are sufficient to shut the mouthes of them who gainesay the truth or at leastwise to manifest their impudency so is there further required for the fencing of the consciences of all the godly in debate of Religion besides a care of learning the doctrine of the word of God Prayers An ardent and daily invocating of God by which wee may desire that wee may be taught and guided by his holy Spirit This if wee shall doe hee will not suffer us to make stay in errour which may pull us from him but will open unto us the true and certaine meaning of his word concerning all things necessary to our salvation that our faith may depend not on humane but divine authority even as it is promised Mat. 7.7 Aske and it shall be given you seeke and ye shall finde knock and it shall be opened unto you Luke 11.13 James 1.5 For whosoever asketh receiveth and hee that seeketh findeth and to him that knocketh it shall be opened How much more shall your heavenly Father give the holy Ghost to them that desire him If any of you do lack wisedome let him ask it of God which giveth to all men liberally and reproacheth no man and it shall be given him but let him ask in faith and waver not Object 11. It is unmeet that the holy Ghost should be subject unto another Answ We make him not subject to any other but compare him with himselfe To their former arguments our adversaries adde That it is a shame that the holy Ghost speaking in the Church should be subject to the examination and judgment of another and therefore we must not examine him by the rule of the Scripture But seeing that the same Spirit speaketh in the Church and in the Scripture when wee doe examine the voice of the Church by Scripture we do not subject the holy Ghost to another but we compare him with himself And by this means 1. We give unto him the praise of truth and constancy while we do acknowledge and restifie that he is alwaies like himself and doth never square from himself 2. We confesse that the supreme authority of pronouncing the will of God belongeth unto him while we doe not seek whether those things be true and certaine which he hath spoken but whether those be his words which men ascribe unto him and this doe we even after the selfe same manner which he hath prescribed us and after we find out by the rule of the written word that any thing hath proceeded from him to that without making any controversie we submit our minds and wils Contrariwise it is easie to see 2 Contumelies against the holy Ghost issuing out of the Papists opinion of the Judge of the Scripture that our adversaries themselves are guilty of that contumely against the holy Ghost of which they accuse us For while they will have the authority of giving judgement concerning the meaning of the Scripture and deciding of controversies not to belong unto the Scripture but unto themselves by this very thing 1. They imagine that the holy Ghost may dissent from himselfe 2. They make themselves Judges higher then the holy Ghost and Word of God Lastly whereas Paul saith That he is the Minister of the New Testament Object 12. The Letter killeth the Spirit quickneth 2
it which hatred of truth was not in Adam or Peter Augustine therefore saith Faith failed not Peter in his heart when confession failed him in his mouth God sparing Cains life doth not thereby shew his pardoning of his sin but a further revenging of it Object 2. The sinne of Cain was not unpardonable because God would not have him killed therefore he pardoned him his sinne but Cains sinne was committed against the holy Ghost Therefore some sinne against the holy Ghost is not unpardonable Answ In the proofe of the Major is a fallacy putting that which is no cause as if it were a cause For the cause why God would not have him killed was not for that hee had pardoned Cain his sinne not repenting him of it but that the murderer might be the longer tormented with the furies of his conscience that in so long time not repenting he might be made inexcusable and further also that murders might not wax rife among men Every sin of the unregenerate unpardonable because not repented of which to others through repentance are pardoned Object 3. They who are altogether ignorant of Christ sin not against the holy Ghost but all that know not Christ have unpardonable sinne because it is never pardoned them Therefore some unpardonable sinne is not against the holy Ghost Answ We grant the whole reason if in the Minor and Conclusion thereof be understood by unpardonable sinne those sinnes of the unregenerate which are not indeed remitted unto them for that they persist in those sinnes to the end without repentance yet to others they are remitted who persist not in them but repent of them in this life For not all who commit them persist in them But if that kind of sinne be understood it is never remitted to any man because all they who commit it persist in it to the end of their life without repentance then is the Minor false And so is there no consequence in this reason What pardonable sin is Pardonable sinne or sinne not against the holy Ghost is any sinne whereof some repent and obtaine pardon The fifth division of sinne THere is some sinne which is of it selfe sinne and some which cometh to be sinne by an accident Sinnes of themselves and in their owne nature are all those things which are forbidden in the Law of God What is sin of it selfe as are inclinations motions and actions disagreeing from the Law of God yet they are not sinnes as they are motions nor in respect of God moving all things For motions as they are meere motions are good in themselves and proceed from God in whom we live move and have our being but they are sins in regard of us as they are committed by us against the Law of God For in this sense of themselves and in their owne nature they are sins Sins by an accident are the actions of the unregenerate and hypocrites which are indeed prescribed and commanded by God What is sin by an accident but yet are displeasing unto him because they are done without Faith and Repentance Of this kind are all actions also of indifferency which are effected with scandall Whatsoever is not of faith is sinne To them that are deâ—iled and unbeleeving is nothing pure Rom. 14.23 Tit. 1.15 Heb. 11.6 The vertues of the unregenerate are sins by accident Without faith it is impossible to please God Wherefore all the vertues of the unregenerate as the chastity of Scipio the valour of Julius Cesar the fidelity of Regulus the justice of Aristides c. howsoever in themselves they are good actions and enjoyned by God yet by occasion and accident they are sin and displease God both because the person from whom those actions proceed pleaseth not God neither is reconciled unto God and also because the actions themselves are not done after the same manner neither to the same end which God would have them to be done that is they are not grounded on faith nor wrought to the glory of God which conditions and circumstances are so necessarily required to a good work that without them our best actions are defects and sins as it is sin when a wicked man or an hypocrite prayeth giveth almes offereth sacrifice c. because hee doth it not of faith nor referreth it unto Gods glory Hypocrites give Mat. 6.2 Isa 60.3 c. He that killeth a bullocke c. There is then a main difference betweene the vertues of the regenerate and the unregenerate For 1. The good workes of the regenerate are wrought The differences between the vertues of the regenerate and the unregenerate having Faith for their harbenger and are accepted of God But it fareth not so with the unregenerate 2. The regenerate do all things to the glory of God the unregenerate and hypocrites to their owne praise and glory 3. The workes of the regenerate are linked with inward obedience and a true desire of pleasing God the unregenerate and hypocrites onely performe an outward discipline and homage without the inward obedience therefore their vertues are meer maskes of hypocrisie and no true vertues 4. The imperfection of the workes of the regenerate is covered by the satisfaction and intercession of Christ and the spots of sinne wherewith they are stained are not imputed unto them neither is it objected unto them that they defile the gifts of God with their sinnes The vertues of the unregenerate being in themselves good notwithstanding become and continue sinnes by accident and are polluted with many other sinnes 5. The good workes of the unregenerate are adorned by God with temporall rewards onely and that not as if they pleased God but that by this meanes hee might invite both them and others to honesty and outward discipline of civility necessary for mankind But the good works of the godly God accepteth for Christs sake and crowneth them with temporall and eternall rewards as it is said 1 Tit. 4.8 Godlinesse hath the promise of the life present and that that is to come 6. The unregenerate by practising good workes enacted by God obtaine indeed mitigation of their punishment lest they should with other wicked Impes suffer more exquisite tortures in this life but the good workes of the godly serve not onely for this that they may suffer lighter and easier punishments but also that they may be quite freed from all evill Object We may not do that which is sinne The morall actions of the unregenerate are not therefore to be omitted of us because in themselves they are sin but we must avoid the sin and performe the action Why civill discipline is necessary amongst the unregenerate The workes of the unregenetate though civilly good are sinnes therefore we may not do them Answ Here is a fallacy of accident The Major is true of sinnes which are in themselves sinnes The Minor of sins which are sins by accident Now those things which are in themselves sinne ought simply to be
him by contemning these to our own perill and danger 2. That we may obtain those blessings decreed for us according to his promise and that to our salvation 3. That we may retain a good conscience in using the means although the expected events do not alwaies follow either in our selves or others The sixth Sophisme of the merit of good and evill WHatsoever is necessary doth not merit rewards or punishments But all morall good and evill is done necessarily Therefore neither the good meriteth reward nor the evill punishment Answ This argument is handled by Aristotle in his Ethicks Lib. 3. cap 5. No good work of the creature meriteth reward But the answer thereto is easie First The Major is either particular and so there is no consequence or sequel or being generally taken is false and that even in morall or civill consideration to wit in respect of those things which are necessary by supposition and yet are done freely as the actions of men Secondly Wee grant the reason in respect of the judgement of God concerning good works For the creature cannot merit any thing no not by his best works of God Rom. 4.1 because both they are due and are the effects of God in us And therefore the more good things God worketh in us so much the more hee bindeth and indebteth us to him Wherefore in the godly God crowneth and rewardeth of his free bountifulnesse not their merits but his owne gifts But as touching evill works we deny the reason For they merit punishment and that most justly Evill works merit punishment justly for although men forsaken of God cannot but sin yet the necessity of finning both was purchased by their own fault as who freely and willingly departed from God and remaineth in them joyned and accompanied with great desire and delight Wherefore to this that they should merit punishment their own will sufficeth whereas especially the punishment was before denounced This solution or answer Aristotle himself giveth us Ibid. when as he sheweth That men are deservedly reprehended and punished for vices either of mind or body though they cannot avoid them or leave them because themselves are the cause of their own vices and have purchased them unto themselves of their own accord and voluntarily Last of all Certain places of Scripture wrested against Gods providence John 8.44 James 1.13 Syrac 15.20 they wrest also certain places of Scripture by false interpretations against Gods universall providence As When the divell speaketh a lie then he speaketh of his own God tempteth no man He hath commanded no man to do ungodly as also other the like places which deny God to be the author of sin But those places attribute unto the wicked and remove from God the sinnes as lies and temptations to sâ—n but the actions themselves of the wicked as they are not sins but operations and motions serving for the exercising and manifesting of Gods goodnesse or justice the whole Scripture sheweth to be done by the will of God and also as they are sins by his just permission as Of Sathan deceiving the Prophets of Achab Of the false Prophets by whom God tryeth and openeth the hypocrisie or constancie of men in true religion Acts 5.3 2 Cor. 4.4 Sathan filled the heart of Ananias The god of this world hath blinded the hearts of unbeleevers In these and the like sayings also is discerned the work of the Divell unjustly blinding men to destroy them and of God justly blinding them by the Divell Acts 5.38 Isa 31. to punish them If this counsell be of men it will come to nought Woe be to the rebellious children that take counsell but not of mee The counsels of men are said to be not of God but of themselves in respect of the ends which men letting passe the will of God revealed unto them respect not and attain not unto but not in respect of the ends which God doth respect and attaineth unto as well by the wicked not knowing or contemning his will as by the godly or which is in effect the same the counsels of men are said to be of them not of God as they are sins that is as they swerve from the known will of God but not as they are the execution of Gods either secret or known will 2 Cor. 9.9 God doth not take care for oxen Not principally or not in such sort as for men For he giveth also to beasts their meat Those words then Thou shalt not muzzle the mouth of the oxe that treadeth out the corn were therefore spoken especially that God might thereby shew what hee would have by men unto men to be performed So the wicked are often said to be cast out of the sight of God not that the providence of God is not extended to them but that he doth not tender them with his mercy and bounty as he doth the godly For the godly also complain That they are neglected of God when they are afflicted not that God is not present with them in affliction but that humane sense and judgment suggesteth this unto us Levit. 20 5. And God is said to set his face against the wicked to cut them off Quest 28. What doth this knowledge of the Creation and Providence of God profit us Answ That in adversity we may be patient a Rom. 5.3 James 1.3 Job 1.21 22. Psal 39.10 and thankfull in prosperity b Dâ—â—â— 8 1â— 1 Thess 5.18 and have hereafter our chiefest hope reposed in God our most faithfull Father c Psal 55 2â— Rom. 5.4 being sure that there is nothing which may withdraw us from his love d Rom. 8.38 â—9 forasmuch as all creatures are so in his power that without his will they are not able not only to do any thing but not so much as once to move e Job 1.12 2.6 Prov. 21.1 Acts 17.25 The Explication The causes why this doctrine is to be known THis doctrine of Gods providence is necessary to be known The glory of God For the glory of God for he will have us to ascribe to him most great liberty goodnesse wisdome power and justice and this he will have us to acknowledge and professe against the dreams and dotings of Epicures Manichees and Stoicks But if the providence of God in moving and guiding all things even the least both good and bad be denied these also his properties are denied and if these be denied God is not worshipped and magnified of us but denied Our own comfort salvation 1. Patience in adversity For our own comfort and salvation that by this means there may be stirred up in us first Patience in adversity because all things come to passe by the most wise just and available counsell and will of our heavenly Father and whatsoever either good or bad God sendeth us in them we consider the fatherly will of God towards us Whatsoever cometh unto us by the counsell
this warfare there is no end but in death You may to this purpose reade the Sections immediatly following as farte as to the fifteenth in which the whole disputation touching the remnâ—nts of sin in the Saints is learnedly maintained against the Cathari and Anabaptists 7. In what the conversion of the godly differeth from the repentance of the wicked THe name of Repentance is attributed as well to the wicked as to the godly because they both agree in some things to wit in the knowledge of sinne and the griefe for sinne but in the rest there is great difference Their griefe is divers In the impulsive cause of repentance which is Grief The wicked are grieved onely for the punishment and torment ensuing not for that they offend and displease God So was Cain grieved onely in respect of his punishment Gen. 4.13 My iniquity that is the punishment of mine iniquity is greater than I can beare Behold thou hast cast mee out this day from the earth Now the godly hate indeed the punishment but they are grieved especially for that God is offended and for their sin So David Psal 51.4 Against thee against thee onely have I sinnned my sin is ever before mee The good hate to sin for the love they beare to vertue the wicked for the feare they stand in of punishment So in Peter was a sorrow and griefe for that he had offended God in Judas for his torment ensuing not for the Sin it self This difference hath the Heathen Poet Horace described in this his Poem Horat. lib. 1. Epist 16. The good avoide offence for vertues sake The wicked to abstaine base feare doth make The cause of their griefe is divers In the cause which breedeth repentance in both The wicked repent by reason of a despaire distrust and diffidency so that they run more and more into desperation murmuring and hatred against God But the Godly repent by reason of faith and a confidence which they have of the grace of God and reconciliation through Christ The manner of their repentance is diverse In the forme and manner of their repentance For the repentance of the godly is a returning unto God from the Divell from their sins and from their old nature because they doe not only grieve but also comfort and erect themselves againe by confidence in the Mediatour they trust in God and rejoyce in him and relye on him with David Purge mee with Hysope and I shall be cleane The repentance of the wicked is a back-sliding from God unto the Divell a hatred of God a flight from him and a murmuring or repining against him and a beginning of desperation The effect of their griefe is diverse In the effect which their repentance worketh in them In the wicked new obedience doth not follow repentance but they goe forward in their sins and returne to their vomit though they counterfeit repentance for a time as Achab did They are mortified in feed themselves and quite destroyed but the old corruption of their nature that is sin is not crucified in them and how much the more they give them selves to repentance so much the more is in them a hatred of God murmuring flying and turning away from God and an approaching unto the Divell But in the godly new obedience followeth and accompanieth repentance and how much the more they repent so much the more dieth the old man in them and the study and desire of righteousnesse and living well is in them so much the more increased Quest 91. What are good workes Answ Those onely which are done by a true faith a Rom. 14 23. according to Gods law b Levit. 18.4 1 Sam. 5.22 Ephes 2.10 and are referred only to his glory c 1 Cor. 10.31 and not those which are imagined by us as seeming to us to be right and good or which are delivered and commanded by men d Ezek. 20.18 19. Esay 29.13 Mâ—tthew 15.7 8 The Explication UNder this Question is contained the Doctrine of good works the chief questions whereof are 1. What good workes are 2. How they may be done 3. Whether the workes of Saints be pure and perfectly good 4. How our workes though not perfectly good please God 5. Why wee are to doe good workes 6. Whether good works merit any thing in the sight of God 1. What good works are GOod workes are such as are done according to the prescript rule of Gods law with a true faith to the glory of God only Three things are here to be considered 1. The conditions and circumstances required for the making a good work 2. The difference between the works of the regenerate and the unregenerate 3. In what sort the morall works of the wicked are sins 1. That a work which we doe Three things required to a good work may be good and acceptable to God these conditions are required necessarily unto it Gods commandement Mat. 15.9 How morall and naturall good differ That it be commanded of God In vaine they worship me teaching for doctrine mens precepts No creature hath the right or wisdome and understanding to institute and ordaine the worship of God But good workes we speak of morall good and the worship of God are all one Now morall good is far different from naturall good inasmuch as all actions as they are actions even those of the wicked are good naturally that is they are some-thing framed by God in nature but all actions are not good morally that is agreeing with the justice of God And thus is excluded by this condition all will-worship and that coyned device of good intentions when as namely men doe evill things that good things may come thereof Likewise when they devise and imagine workes which they thrust upon God instead of worship Neither doth it suffice if a work be not evill or not forbidden 1 Sam. 15.22 Fizek 20.19 Mat. 15.9 Esay 29.12 but it must also be commanded if it shall serve for Gods worship according to the Scripture Obedience is better than sacrifice Ye shall walk in my statutes Object But you will say Things of indifferency that is things in themselves neither good nor evill and such as may be done or left undone by men at their pleasure are not commanded of God and yet many of them please God Answ They please him not of their owne nature but by accident inasmuch as they are contained under the generall of love that is they are done in respect and regard of charity and to avoid offence and to further the salvation of the weaker brethren For in this regard they are in generall though not in speciall commanded by God True faith That the worke have his originall from a true faith which faith must be grounded and depending on the merit and intercession of the Mediatour and by which thou mayest know both thy person and thy work to be accepted of God for the Mediatours sake For
graven Images differ or are distinguished in matter or meaning for the first teacheth who is to be worshipped namely the alone true God the second sheweth how God is to be worshipped namely not by the inventions of men the first forbiddeth any other god besides the true God alone to be worshipped the second prohibiteth any other worship of that only true God then himselfe hath commanded Therefore they are diverse and distinct Commandements So of the contrary the Commandements touching concupiscence which some divide into the ninth and tenth that it is in sense and meaning but one Commandement both themselves are witnesses as often as in their Expositions and Paraphrases hereon they joyne this their ninth and tenth together and Paul also teacheth the same doctrine when he speaketh of all concupiscence as of one Commandement Rom. 7.7 I had not knowne lust to be sin except the Law had said Thou shalt not lust Wherefore the two first Commandements before specified are two divers Commandements and this last imagined by some to be two is but one Commandement But if therefore yet the tenth Commandement must be cut in two diverse Commandements because it distinctly maketh mention of divers things not to be coveted or lusted after namely our neighbours house and our neighbours wife it shall thereof follow that so many Commandements must be numbred as there are recited kinds of things in every Commandement 2. Doubtlesse those Commandements are divers and not the same which are distinguished of Moses by diverse periods or sentences and verses and those no whit different in themselves but one Commandement which are comprised of Moses in one period or verse But Moses hath distinguished the first Commandement which proceedeth Of not having strange gods from the second which is Of not making Idols in divers verses and periods Therefore they are distinct Commandements Contrariwise Moses hath not distinguished the Commandement touching the coveting of our neighbours house and wife by severall periods but hath comprehended it in one period or sentence therefore there is but one Commandement concerning concupiscence 3. Questionlesse Moses retained one and the same order of the Commandements both in Exodus and Deuteronomy But he transposeth in those places the words of the tenth Commandement touching the coveting of our neighbours wife for in Exodus is placed first Thou shalt not covet thy neighbours house and then followeth Thou shalt not covet thy neighbours wife but in Deuteronomy these words are foremost Thou shalt not covet thy neighbours wife and these follow Thou shalt not covet thy neighbours house Therefore these two members are parts of one Commandement else there can no ninth Commandement be assigned and the Adversary must needs say that Moses in one of these places confoundeth the ninth Commandement with the tenth and substituteth a part of the tenth in place of the ninth which absurdity Moses may by no meanes be accused of By this transposing therefore and displacing of the words the holy Ghoft doth sufficiently declare that he would have all to be but one Commandement whatsoever is read in the tenth Commandement joyntly comprehended and contained in one period or sentence 4. There is very great and weighty authority whereby this distinction of the Commandements is confirmed For thus doe the ancient Writers of the Jews Josephus and Philo a Ioseph l. 3. Antiq Iud. Philo in exâ—osit Decalog distinguish the first and second Commandement and knit up in one the tenth Commandement which our Adversaries divide into two In like sort doe the Greek Ecclesiasticall Writers divide the Decalogue as Athanasius Origen Gregory Nazianzene Chrysostome Zonaras and Nicephorus b Athanas in Syâ—ops script l. 2. Orig. l. 3. sup â—xod â—om 8. Greg. Naz. iâ— Carm. Chrys sive Aut. opti pers in Mat. 49. Zoâ— Tom 1. histor Ni ceph hist Eccles And unto this opinion and sentence subscribe also the Latin Ecclesiasticall Writers as Jerome Ambrose Sulpitius Severus and Austin c Hier. in cap. 6. ad c phe Aâ—â—bros in â—und loc ad Eph Sulp Sâ—ver lib. 1. hist sacrat Aug. l. quaest vet â—oâ— Toâ—t quaeâ—â— 7. l. 2. quaest sup Exod câ—p 7.1 Therefore this distinction of the Decalogue was of ancient reputed best and so received in the Greeke and Latine Churche We have therefore restored not changed or altered the Decalogue Now whereas Josephus Philo and some Greek Writers attribute to each Table five Commandements this maketh nothing against us For howsoever they so do yet herein they all agree that the words and clauses touching the worshipping of one God and not having any graven Image are two distinct Commandements and the clause touching Concupiscence maketh not two but one Commandement Likewise we finde another division in Augustine d August Epist 119. ad â—aâ— car cap. 11. quaest sup Exod cap. 7. which reckoneth onely three Commandements in the first Table and seven in the second But the Allegory of the Trinity whereon Augustine groundeth this reason is too weak a proofe for confirmation thereof Howbeit this we must observe that if the doctrine and purpose of the Decalogue touching the true God and his true worship be no way impeached but reserved whole and entire we ought not to maintaine any bitter contention about the reckoning or account of the Commandements in their Tables The third division of the Decalogue In'o the immediate and mediate worship of God 3. The Decalogue is divided according to the things themselves which are commanded or forbidden in the Decalogue into the immediate and mediate worship of God Generally in the Decalogue is commanded the worship of God that which is contrary to Gods worship is forbidden The worship of God is either immediate when Morall workes are immediatly performed unto God or mediate when Morall workes are performed unto our neighbour in respect of God The immediate worship is contained in the first Table and is either internall or externall The internall consisteth in this partly that we worship the true God and that that be performed unto the true God which is commanded in the first Commandement partly that the manner or forme of worship be right and lawfull whether it be internall worship or externall This forme which is to be observed in Gods worship is taught in the second commandement The externall worship is either private or publique The private containeth the private Morall works of every one which are alwaies to be of every man in particular performed as touching the confession of God in our words and works and this private worship is delivered in the third Commandement The publique worship consisteth in sanctifying of the Sabbath and is delivered in the fourth Commandement The mediate worship of God which containeth our duties towards men or our neighbours is delivered in the second Table and this likewise either externall or internall The mediate externall worship consisteth partly in the duties of superiours towards their inferiours and so of the contrary
the worship to be thus done unto him Wil-worship is false worship And To worship God truly is so to worship him as himselfe hath manifested in his word that he will be worshipped Contrariwise in this second Commandement is forbidden all will-worship that is all false worship namely not onely that creatures or Images be not reputed or worshipped for God but also that we resemble not him the very true God by any Image or shape neither worship him by Images and at Images or with any other kinde of worship which himselfe hath not commanded For when he condemneth the chiefe or grossest and most evident kind of false worships namely the worshipping of God at or by Images it is manifest that he forbiddeth also the other kinds of false worships seeing this is the head and fountaine of all the rest For he forbiddeth the most grosse kind of Idolatry not thereby to exclude others and acquit them from this inhibition but because this is the fountaine of all the rest Wherefore all worships whatsoever are instituted by men not by God and in which the same cause of prohibiting or forbidding appeareth are forbidden by the forbidding of this the grossest kind of the rest Therefore whatsoever things hinder Gods true worship they are all contrary to this Commandement Twofold Idolatry 1. Idolatry which is a false or superstitious worship of God Idolatry as we have heretofore shewed is of two sorts 1. When a false god is worshipped that is when in place of the true God or besides him honour or worship is given to some either imaginary or existent thing which is agreeing unto the true God onely This kinde of Idolatry is especially forbidden in the first Commandement and further also in some part in the third Commandement 2. When men erre in the kinde of worship that is when worship or honour is imagined to be done to the true God by some such worke which himselfe hath not commanded This kind is properly condemned in this second Commandement and is called will-worship Who are superstitious Esay 29.13 Mat. 15.9 Col. 2.8.16.22 23. or superstition adding mens inventions to Gods Commandements They are said to be superstitious whosoever adde humane inventions to the Commandements of God This superstition or wil-worship is condemned every where in Scripture In vaine they worship me teaching for doctrine mens precepts Beware lest there be any man that spoile you through Philosophy and vaine deceit through the traditions of men according to the rudiments of the world and not after Christ Let no man condemne you in meat and drink c. Which all perish with the using and are after the commandements and doctrines of men Which things have indeed a shew of wisdome in voluntary religion and humblenesse of minde and in not sparing the body neither have they it in any estimation to satisfie the flesh Hence we answer this objection Object Idolatry is forbidden in the first Commandement and in this second also therefore they both make but one Answ One kind of Idolatry is forbidden in the first Commandement to wit when another god is worshipped another in the second namely when the true God is worshipped otherwise then he ought Repl. Yea but still in both there is Idolatry committed and a strange god worshipped Ans There is indeed an Idol in both alwaies but not alwaies in the intent and profession of men Therefore whosoever offend against the second Commandement offend against the first because they who worship God otherwise then he will be worshipped imagine God to be another or otherwise affected and qualified then he is Therefore they worship not God but the invention of their owne braine which they perswade themselves to be so affected Hypocrisie Hypocrisie which is a pretending or feigning true godlinesse and worship of God doing the externall works commanded by God whether Morall or Ceremoniall without true faith and conversion This vice is depainted and described in these words by the Prophet Esaias This people come neere unto me with their mouth Esay 29.13 14. and honour me with their lips but have removed their hearts farre from me and their feare towards me was taught by the precepts of men Therefore behold I will againe doe a marvellous worke in this people Profanenesse Profanenesse which is a voluntary letting goe or contempt of all religion and of the whole worship of God both internall and externall or else of some part of divine worship This profanenesse is repugnant not onely to this Commandement but also to the whole worship of God in the first and second Table For defence of superstition some alledge Object 1. That such places and sayings as are brought against will-worship speake onely of Mosaicall and Jewish ceremonies and of the wicked and ungodly commandements of men but not of such precepts of men as are authorised by the Church Bishops and such as command nothing contrary to Gods word Answ That this is false which is replyed some demonstrances which are added unto certaine places declare which also reject those humane Laws and ordinances that command any thing in regard of divine worship which is not commanded by God although the same be a thing in his owne kinde not wicked nor forbidden of God So Christ rejecteth the Jews tradition of washing of hands Mat. 15.11 because they had an opinion of worshipping God thereby whereof he saith That which goeth into the mouth defileth not the man but that which cometh out of the mouth that defileth the man Hither also may that be referred which Christ speaketh Mat. 23.25 Woe be to you Scribes and Pharisees Hypocrites for ye make cleane the outer side of the Cup and of the Platter but within they are full of bribery and excesse Now that these and the like things are lawfull setting aside an opinion of superstition in them the Apostle in sundry places doth shew He that observeth the day observeth it to the Lord Rom. 14.16 and he that observeth not the day observeth it not to the Lord. He that eateth eateth to the Lord for he giveth God thanks and he that eateth not eateth not to the Lord and giveth God thanks Againe Whatsoever is sold in the shambles eate ye and aske no question for conscience sake 1 Cor. 10.25 For the earth is the Lords and all that therein is Wherefore they are not simply so condemned but only so farre as they are prescribed for divine worship that is if they be so prescribed as that by the performance of them God is honoured and dishonoured by the omission of them In the same respect is single life also condemned especially seeing the same is not a thing indifferent but to those onely who have the gift of continency according as it is said of Christ He that is able to receive this Mat. 19.12 let him receive it For all men as in the same place Christ saith cannot receive this thing save
falling into the hands of a thiefe should be required of the thiefe to give a peece of mony for the redeeming of his life verily hee not only may but also ought if hee be able to performe that which the thiefe requireth And if this be lawfully performed unto a thiefe it is lawfully also performed unto him by an oath Likewise it is lawfull also to promise by an oath silence unto the thiefe and such an oath made for the keeping of silence promised unto the thiefe both may and ought to be kept Object That which is hurtfull to the Common-wealth is not to be promised or if it have been promised not to be kept Such silence promised unto the thiefe is hurtfull to the Common-wealth Therefore it is not to be promised or if it have been promised it is not to be kept Ans 1. That which is hurtfull to the Common-wealth is not to be promised that is if wee may doe it without hazzard and danger of our life And further if at that instant when a man is in such danger of his life he be not rather to provide for his own safety than to reveale such a thing 2. It is rather profitable than hurtfull to the Common-wealth to promise silence unto the thief and to keep promise For he which hath promised silence by an oath to the thiefe is by this meanes saved Moreover if he should not promise by oath silence unto the thiefe threatning him death he should thereby neither profit the Common-wealth nor himselfe Wherefore to promise silence by an oath unto the thiefe and to keep it seeing it is a lesser evill then that a Citizen should be slain is of the two rather to be chosen ON THE 38. SABBATH Quest 103. What doth God command in the fourth Commandement Answ First that the Ministery of the Gospel and the Schools of learning should be maintained a Titus 1 5. 1 Tim. 4.13 14.15 16. 2 Tim 2.2 3.15 1 Cor. 9.12 13 14 and that I both at other times and especially on Holy-dayes should frequent studiously divine assemblies b Psal 40.10 11. 68.26 Acts 2.42 46. heare the Word of God diligently c 1 Tim 4 13. 1 Cor. 14.29 use the Sacraments d 1 Corinth 11.33 joyn my praiers with the common praiers of the assembly e 1 Tim. 2.1 2 3 8. 1 Corinth 14.16 and bestow something according to my ability on the poore f 1 Cor. 16.2 And further that all my life time I be free from misdeeds and evill actions yielding unto the Lord that he may be his holy Spirit work in mee his work and so I may begin in this life that everlasting Sabbath g Esay 66.3 The Explication The parts of the fourth Commandement THe parts of this fourth Commandement are in number two A Commandement A Commandement A reason thereof A reason of the Commandement The Commandment is Remember that thou keep holy the Sabbath day and In it thou shalt doe no manner of worke The parts of the Commandement are also two The first is morall and perpetuall namely That the Sabbath be sanctified that is that some certaine time be allotted to the Ministery of the Church The Commandement twofold or to the publike service of God The other part is ceremoniall and temporary namely 1. Morall and perpetuall That that time be the seventh day That the former part is morall and perpetuall 2. Ceremoniall and temporary is cleerly proved by the end and perpetuall causes of the Commandement The end of the Commandement is The publike service of God in the Church Or The first part of the Commandement is morall and perpetuall the perpetuall preservation and use of the Ecclesiasticall Ministery For God willeth that at all times there be some publike Ministery of the Church and assembly of the faithfull 1. The end of it in which the true doctrine concerning himself may daily resound 2. The causer of it and that for these causes 1. That himselfe may be publikely served in the world 2. That the religion and faith of the Elect may be stirred up and cherished by publike exercises 3. That men may mutually edifie one another in the faith which they professe and provoke one another to piety and godlinesse 4. That consent in the doctrine of the Church and worship of God may be continued 5. That the Church may be apparent in the world and may be discerned from other companies of men Now whereas these causes pertaine not to any definite or certaine time but to all ages and estates of the Church and the world it followeth hereon that God will have the Ministery of the Church perpetually maintained and the use thereof often frequented and therefore that the morall part of this Commandement bindeth all men from the begining of the world unto the end to keep some Sabbath that is to allot some time to Sermons Prayers and the Administration of the Sacraments That the latter part is ceremoniall That the latter part is ceremonial and temporary and not perpetuall it is evident because the Sabbath of the seventh day was in the promulgation and publishing of the law ordained by God for the observation of the Leviticall Ceremonies and given unto the Jewes for a Sacrament that is for a type of the sanctifying of the Church by the Messias to come Fzek. 10 12. according as it is said Keep yee my Sabbath for it is a signe between mee and you in your generations that yee may know that I the Lord doe sanctifie you Moreover I gave them also my Sabbaths to be a signe between mee and them that they might know that I am the Lord that sanctifie them Wherefore the Sabbath also of the seventh day was together with the rest of the ceremonies and types fulfilled and abrogated by the coming of the Messias And thus much briefly of the Commandement The reason of the Commandement is For in six dayes the Lord made heaven and earth The reason of the commandement c. It is drawne from the example of God who rested on the seventh day from his worke of Creation after six dayes labour ended Wherefore properly it pertaineth to the circumstance of the seventh day or to the ceremoniall part of the Commandement concerning the seventh day Howbeit the imitating of that rest whereunto God inviteth us is not only ceremoniall and belonging to the Jewes but morall also and spirituall signified by the ceremoniall and extending it selfe to all men But that the Commandement with the reason thereunto adjoyned may more fully be understood wee will in briefe expound the words of both and afterwards summarily handle and unfold the Common-places hitherto belonging namely the Common-places concerning the Sabbath the Ministery of the Church and touching Ceremonies Remember that thou keep holy the Sabbath day A briefe explication of the words of the commandement Numb 15.35 What the Sabbath is
and from Sabbath to Sabbath shall all flesh come to worship before mee saith the Lord. The externall or ceremoniall Sabbath is a certain time ordained and in stituted by God in the Church dedicated to a ceasing from works and labours and given to the Ministery of Gods Word and to the administration of the Sacraments or to the externall publike worship of God This ceremoniall Sabbath was necessary in the Old Testament to be the seventh day and that on that day as also on other holy dayes the Leviticall ceremonies should be observed This ceremoniall Sabbath is a thing indifferent in the N. Testament This externall Sabbath is also of two sorts Immediate and Mediate Immediate is that which was immediatly instituted by God himselfe and prescribed to the Church of the Old Testament and this was diversly taken in the Old Testament Divers Sabbaths in the Old Testament The Sabbath of daies The Sabbath of dayes was every seventh day of the weeke which was in a more particular sense called the Sabbath both in respect of Gods rest from the Creation of the world and in respect of that rest which was commanded the people of God to be kept on that day Hence the whole seven dayes or the whole weeke was with the Hebrewes called by the name of the chiefe day the Sabbath or Sabbaths Now in the end of the Sabbath Mat. 28.1 when the first day of the Sabbath that is of the week began to dawne Likewise Levit. 23.15 the Sabbaths of daies were other festivall dayes as the feast of the Passeover Whitsontide Tabernacles Trumpets c. because in these feasts the people were to rest as on the seventh day The Sabbath of months The Sabbath of months was the new Moones The Sabbath of yeeres The Sabbath of yeares was every seventh yeere Lâ—v. 25.4 26 35. Levit. 25.8 wherein the Jewes were commanded to intermit the tillage of their fields And hereof also the whole seven yeeres were by a Synecdoche called Sabbaths Thou shalt number seven Sabbaths of yeeres unto thee even seven times seven yeeres The mediate externall Sabbath is that which God doth mediately constitute by his Church in the New Testament such as is the first day of the week to wit Sunday or rather the Lords day which the Christian Church ever since the Apostles time observeth instead of the seventh or Sabbath day in respect of Christs resurrection witnesse that of John I was ravished in spirit on the Lords day Revel 1.10 More briefly thus The ceremoniall Sabbath is twofold one of the old Testament another of the new The old Sabbath was tied to the seventh day and the keeping of it was necessary and was the precise worship of God The new Sabbath dependeth on the arbitrement or appointment of the Church which for certaine causes maketh choice of the first day and that first day is to be observed for orders sake but without any opinion of necessity as if that and no other were to be observed by the Church of which difference more shall be spoken in the Question next ensuing A Table of the distinction of the Sabbath The Sabbath that is to say the ceasing or rest from working is 1. Internall morall and spirituall as the rest from sinne 2. Externall and Ceremoniall instituted by God 1. Immediately in the old Testament as the Sabbath of 1. Dayes which were the 1. Seventh day 2. Feast-dayes of the Passeover Whitsunday c. 2. Months as the new Moones 3. Yeâ—res as every seventh yeare 2. Mediately by the Church in the new Testament as the Lords day 2. How the Sabbath belongeth unto us Christians THe Sabbath of the seventh day was even from the beginning of the world designed by God to signifie that men should after the example of God himself rest from their labours and especially from sinnes and afterwards in Moses law this Commandement was againe repeated and then with all was the ceremony of ceasing from labour on the seventh day ordained to be a Sacrament that is a signe and token of that sanctifying whereby God signifieth himselfe to be the Sanctifier of his Church that is to pardon her all her sinnes and offences to receive her to favour to endue and rule her with his holy Spirit for the beginning of new and everlasting life in her in this life which afterwards should be accomplished and perfected for and by the Messias promised to the Fathers And this is the reason why the Ceremoniall Sabbath of the seventh day is now abolished namely because it was typicall admonishing the people of their own duty towards God of Gods benefits towards them which was to be performed by Christ for which selfe same cause also all the other Sacraments and Sacrifices and ceremonies made before and after the Law were abolished by the coming of Christ by whom that was fulfilled that they signified But although the Ceremoniall Sabbath is abrogated and disannulled in the new Testament yet the Morall Sabbath continueth still and belongeth unto us and doth still remain which is that some time is to be allotted for the Ministery of the Church For as heretofore in the Jewish Church so now in the Christian Church we must ever have some day wherein the Word of God may be taught in the Church and the Sacraments administred But neverthelesse we are not restrained or tied to have either Saturday or Wednesday or any other certaine day For the Apostolike Church to distinguish it selfe from the Jewish Synagogue according to the liberty where-with shee is enfranchised by Christ instead of the seventh day hath on good reason made choice of the first day namely because on that day was Christs resurrection whereby the spirituall and internall Sabbath is begun in us Briefly the Sabbath doth not belong to us Ceremonially in speciall and particular albeit it doth belong to us and so to all men and ever continueth both morally and ceremonially in generall that is wee must have some day wherein the Church may be instructed and the Sacraments administred but wee are not tied to any certaine day Object against the abrogating of the Ceremoniall Sabbath The Jews against the abrogation of the Ceremoniall Sabbath thus urge Ob. 1. The Decalogue is a perpetuall law The commandement of the Sabbath is a part of the Decalogue therefore it is a perpetuall law and not to be abolished Ans The Decalogue is a perpetuall law as it is a Morall law But the Additions or circumstances and limitations of the Morall precepts annexed by way of signification were to be kept untill the coming of the Messias Object 2. The commandements of the Decalogue belong unto all This is a commandement of the Decalogue therefore it belongeth unto all Answ The commandements of the Decalogue which are morall belong unto all But this commandement is in part ceremoniall and so as it is ceremoniall it belongeth not to us albeit the generall belong unto us The reasons
to sanctifie the Sabbath in shewing our obedience which we yeeld unto the doctrine Hither appertaineth the Sermon of Christ concerning the Sabbath wherein he declareth against the Jews Whether it be lawfull to do no good on the Sabbath day And whereas God will have his Sabbath to be kept all our life time yet will he have examples and testimonies thereof to be shewed especially on the externall or ceremoniall Sabbath day that is at those times which are allotted to the teaching and learning of Gods word For if at that time any man shew not his desire of obeying God when Gods doctrine soundeth in his eares and when God willeth us surceasing and omitting all other cares to meditate on godlinesse and amendment of life he giveth a token that he will far lesse doe it at another time Therefore hath it beene alwaies the custome of the Church to bestow almes on the Sabbath day and to performe the works of charity towards those that are in want nehem 8.10 Send part unto them for whom none is prepared for this day is holy unto our Lord. The contrary vices To the bestowing of almes is repugnant 1. A neglect or contempt of the poore and of the workes of charity towards them as when we doe not according to our power succour the poore that stand in need of our help 2. Ostentation and vaine-glory in giving our almes Mat. 6.2 which Christ condemneth 7. The honour of the Ministery of the Church VII Vertue or our obedience towards the whole Ministery in life and manners and this is the Morall Sabbath Five parts of the honour of the Ministery Now that obedience towards the Ministery comprehendeth many things Reverence Reverence that is an acknowledging of Gods order and will in the ordaining and maintaining of the Ministery and in the gathering of his Church by it that is a declaration both in words and deeds of this our acknowledgement and judgement of the Ministery 1 Cor. 4.1 Let a man so thinke of us as of the Ministers of Christ and the disposers of the secrets of God 2 Cor. 5.20 We are Embassadours for Christ as if God did beseech you through us Love Love whereby we gladly frequent divine assemblies and heare and learne the doctrine of the Church and wish well unto the faithfull Ministers of the Church not onely in respect of that duty of charity which we owe but also of the Ministery which they discharge How amiable are thy Tabernacles My soule longeth Psal 84.1 2. yea and fainteth for the courts of the Lord. Psal 122.1 I was glad when they said unto me We will goe into the house of the Lord. Obedience Heb. 13.17 Obedience in those things which are belonging unto the Ministery Obey them that have the over-sight of you Hither belong the works of love towards God and our neighbour even the whole life of a Christian which is that spirituall or morall Sabbath For to hold and celebrate that spirituall Sabbath is in the direction and ordering of our life to obey the voice of God speaking by the Ministery of the Church For God will therefore have the true doctrine to be learned of us that we may obey it James 1.22 Be ye doers of the word and not hearers onely deceiving your owne selves Thankfulnesse Thankefulnesse that is such duties as tend to the preservation and maintenance of the Ministery Ministers and Schooles For if God will have Ministers to be in his Church he will also that every one according to his ability help forward and further the maintenance of the Ministery and Schooles of learning and doe his endeavour that the Ministers Teachers and Schoole-masters be honestly provided for For without the study and learning of Arts and Sciences neither can men be made fit to teach nor the purity and sincerity of doctrine be upheld and maintained against Hereticks Hither appertaine Moses Laws of the first-borne of first-fruits of tithes and such like offerings which were allotted to the Priests and Levites by way of stipend whereby they might sustaine their owne life and their houshold that so they might wholly be imployed in the Ministery And albeit the circumstances of these Laws are abolished yet the generall remaineth for ever because God will have his Ministery to be maintained to the end of the world Deut. 12.19 1 Cor 9.7 Gal. 6.6 1 Tim 5.17 Mat. 10.14 Beware that thou forsake not the Levite as long as thou livest upon the earth Who goeth a warfare any time at his owne cost Who planteth a vineyard and eateth not of the fruit thereof Or who feedeth a flocke and eateth not of the milke of the flocke Lenity Lenity and moderation in bearing with such infirmities of the Ministers as do not enormously or manifestly corrupt or hinder the Ministery 1 Tim. 5.19 and hurt the Church by offence Against an Elder receive none accusation but under two or three witnesses To the honour of the Ministery of the Church is opposed the contempt of the Ministery as when either the Ministery of the Church is abolished or committed to men unworthy or unable or is denied to be the meanes and instrument which God will use for the gathering of his Church likewise when the Ministers are reproached when their doctrine is heard and not obeyed in the ordering of our life when the works of charity are neglected when necessary maintenance is not allowed the Ministers when the defence and protection of them and other duties of thankfulnesse are not performed towards them when the maintenance of Schooles and Studies and learning is neglected when the tolerable defects of the Ministers are not borne with and when for such the Ministery suffereth reproach and contumely In like manner also it is against the use of the whole Ministery not onely when some one privately neglecteth or omitteth the use of the Ministery but also when one by his commandement and perswasion or example or by some other hinderance calleth away his children family or any other from the use of the Ministery OF THE ECCLESIASTICALL MINISTERIE WHereas the publique externall worship of God and consequently the Ministery it selfe of the Church and the use and honour thereof is in this Commandement authorised as appeareth by that which hath beene already handled the doctrine concerning the Ministery of the Church is here to be examined The chiefe questions thereof are 1. What the Ministery of the Church is 2. For what end and purpose it was instituted 3. What are the degrees of Ministers 4. What are the duties and functions of Ministers 5. Vnto whom the Ministery is to be committed 1. What the Ministery of the Church is THe Ministery of the Church is a function by God ordained of teaching Gods word and administring his Sacraments according to his divine ordinance The parts then of the Ministery of the Church are two 1. To preach Gods word 2. Rightly to