succession of ordination and sanctification descend from Christ our Lord who is the second Adam And there is no minister in the Church but can deduce the power wherwith the coÌ„secrateth sacrificeth absolueth from synnes administreth other Sacraments and sanctifieth Christian people from Christ himselfe as the first head and Author therof So as also all those workes which by this power he effecteth are attributed to Christ as to the first and chiefe Author who instituted this said power and doth inuisibly protect and assist the same man being only but the instrument wherby all these thinges are done as S. Augustine other Fathers do excellently declare Tract in Ioan. Chrysost bom 60 Ambros l. 4. desacram cap. 4. 5. In like maner all the power of Iuridiction of Ministers in the Catholike Church by which they gouerne Christian people preach the word of God and exercise all other Pastorall offices doth descend from Christ and may be perspicuously reduced to him For that Pastors haue their Iurisdiction from Bishops Bishops from the Pope and the Pope himselfe for that he is the successour of S. Peter in the same Chayre and gouernement of the Catholike Church doth necessarily also suceed in the same Iurisdiction which was giuen immediatly by God to S. Peter and in him to all his lawfull successours And those also in the Church who haue not power ordinary but only delegated to witt no proper Iurisdiction of their owne do receiue the same from their Pastours Bishops or the Pope So as there is no minister in the Catholike Church no preacher or teacher of the word of God that cannot eleerly demonstrate his mission and shew the same to be deriued from Christ And truely except they could so do they were by no meanes to be heard or regarded but had in suspition for wolues when as they entred not into the sheepfold through the dore but crept in secretly some other way This argument alwaies did the ancient Fathers greatly esteeme and alleage Irenaeus l. 3 c 3. Tertul de praescrip August epist 165. Optatus l. 2. contr Parmen cap. 4. for the conuincing of all heresies For therby is shewed the continuall succession of our Religion throughout all Ages vp to the Apostles times I am held in this Church saith S. (a) cap. 4. contra Eâ—ist Fundam Augustine by the Succession of Priests Bishops that haue come downe eueÌ„ froÌ„ the Sea of Peter the Apostle to whoÌ„ the care of feeding our Lords flocke was coÌ„mitted to the present Bishop of Rome Anastasius that holdeth the sea at this day And the very same hath S. Hierome in his dialogue against the Luciferian Heretikes which by and by we shall haue occasion to recite Now none of the ministers of the reformed religion can shew this And as for the power of order wherby to administer Sacraments and sanctify the people truly they cannot reduce it to the Apostles and Christ as we haue done for that they haue vtterly taken all such power away Neither is there any Bishop or Priest among them except perhaps some Apostata from the Catholik ReligioÌ„ whose degree ordignity amongst theÌ„ is now no more of value wheras not withstanding the Church of Christ hath alwaies had these degrees and byn gouerned therby Neither haue they any power of Iurisdiction wherby to preach the word of God administer Baptisme gouerne the people with diuine reuerence in spirituall affayres of their soules For I would demaund of whome Luther and Caluin receiued this power of Iurisdiction By whome was cyther of them sent to preach the new Ghospell and reforme the people That they were not sent by the ordinary Pastors of the Church it is euident therfore they came of themselues being sent by none But what can be a more certaine signe that they are not to be heard but rather to be fled from For how shall they preach saith the Apostle vnlesse they be sent Rom. 10. Ioan. 10. He that entreth not saith S. Iohn by the dore into the sheepfold but clymbeth vp another way he is a theese and robber but he that entreth by the dore is the Pastour of the â—heepe Now whosoeuer without ordinary and lawfull authority do exercise the office of a Pastour they enter not in by the dore But perhaps they will say that they were sent immediatly by Christ of him receaued authority to reforme the Church Whether sectaries be sent of Christ or no. But that is not inough so to say for that all Archeretikes do say the same of themselues Wherfore it behooueth them to bring forth shew their euidence wherby to witnesse it and so to conuince vs that they were sent of Christ as the Apostles did confirme their mission with many and great miracles otherwise we ought not to accept of their reformation Nay we are rather bound to reiect them as false impostors Againe how is it possible for them to be sent of Christ when as they teach so diuers and disagreeing opinions among themselues For if Luther were sent of Christ then can not Caluin be also sent of him who in many points impugneth Luthers doctrine and damneth it to the pit of hell as impious and hereticall And contrariwise if Caluin were sent of Christ then could not Luther be sent of him also for that God is not contray to himselfe neither do the spirits of his true Prophets impugne or contradict one another Other things I omit which might be alleaged to the same purpose VIII CONSIDERATION From the consent of the ancient Fathers and Doctors of the Church and from the decision of controuersies without which there is no sodality or followship THAT Religion is thought to be of Christ and to be preferred before al other in which the whole and full consent of Doctors of euery age Nation about the principall heads of our faith hath concurred and wherin there hath byn an easy determination of all Controuersyes from which if once thou chance to decline or fall thou hast no certainty left which way to betake thy selfe But such is only Catholike Religion and therfore the true religion of Christ And first of all concerning the consent of Doctors about the chiefe heads of our religion it is manifest out of their wrythings For what ancient Doctors soeuer eyther in Greece Asia Aegipt Asricke Spaine Italy France Germany or England that haue written of the mysteries of our religion they do all agree about the liberty of Freewill about merit of good workes sacrifice of the Masse for the quicke and the dead Monasticall vowes fastes inuocation of Saints and the like which are by these newfangled Religions reiected and reproued Caluin l. 2. c. 2.3.14 16. l. 3. c. 4. 5. l. 4. c. 22. Centurtatores cent 2.3.4.5 c. 4. and cannot be denied by the Lutherans Caluinistes themselues only they say that these things were blemishes of the ancient Doctors inclining as it were to superstition
remission of Synns they explicate of not imputation only not acknowledging any inward renouation by inherent iustice and the infused gifts of God after which manner the Catholikes do hold that sinnes are forgiuen By these it is manifest how great a difference there is in the vnderstanding of the Creed Seing therfore that there is but only one truth and this in our Consultation we haue shewed to be among Catholikes it necessarily followeth â—â— one God Creator of all thinges because his Alcoran doth teach him so which he thinketh to be written by the spirits of God his faith albeit he belieue that which is true relyeth vpon a false and deceytfull reason by the force whereof he is moued to belieue many false and blasphemous thinges as that there are not three Persons in the B. Trinity and that Christ is not God and that Christ is inferiour to Mahomet and that Circumcision the like are still to be kept That faith therfore by reason of the foundation is both deceitfull and hurtfull the same hapneth vnto alheretikes the which being supposed I vrge the argument in this manner That faith which relieth vpon a false foundation albeit it belieueth somethings which are true cannot be sufficient to saluation but the faith of all the sects of this tyme relieth vpon a false foundation it cannot be therefore sufficient for saluation The first proposition is manifest in it selfe for how can that which is deceitfull vncertayne be the â—oundation of our eternall 〈…〉 How can the true Religion whereâ—â— we please God be grounded in a false deceitfull faith Truly it is no lesse repugnant to reason then if thou shouldest say that truth is grounded vpon lyes wisdome vpon error and vertue vpon folly The second proposition The faith of all sectaries dependeth vpon a false ground to wit that all Sects are grounded vpon a false and deceitful foundation I proue in this manner for eyther they belieue their opinions for the authority of their Apostles Luther Caluin Melancthon Zwinglius c. whom they iudge to be endewed with the spirit of God or because euery one of them in their owne priuate iudgement do beleeue those things to be coÌ„teyned in holy Scripture or lastly because their owne priuate spirit doth inwardly testify vnto them that those things are true or that this is the meaning of holy Scripture for whatsoeuer the sects of these tymes do belieue they are moued thereunto by one of these three reasons and they appoint one of them to be the foundation or reason of their beliefe but these foundations and reasons be altogeather false and deceitfull As for the first reason to wit the authority of Luther Caluin and the rest who first inuented these new Religions that it is deceitfull is many fest because we see by experience that both they might and haue byn often deceyued for they haue reuoked many things corrected many things and in many things haue they contradicted themselues as hath byn declared in our Consultation of Religion in the 9. Consideration and the sixt Reason Hence it commeth to passe that few now adayes will rely vpon their authority because they say they were men and therefore subiect to error wherfore their followers also do leaue them at their owne pleasure when they thinke they haue found any thing fitter for their purpose their authority therfore is deceitfull vncertayne euen by the iudgement of their owne schollers and followers Neyther is the other to wit the priuate iudgment whereby they expound the holy Scripture lesse deceitful for many false thinges by that priuate iudgement seeme to be true and many things which before seemed true are afterward iudged false From hence ariseth so great variety and inconstancy in many of them concerning matters of faith because indeed mans iudgement is weake especially in the mysteries of our fayth and the vnderstanding of holy Scripture the which far exceedeth the reach of mans wisdome and reason Many do answere that they do not rely vpon their iudgment in matters of faith but vpon the holy Scriptures which cannot erre Whether all sectaries do rely vpon the Scripture wherin how miserably they are deceiued by this appeareth because almost all the sects do say that they rely vpoÌ„ holy Scripture wheras notwithstanding they differ among themselues in most of the matters one teaching contrary vnto another the which could by no meanes come to passe if they did not rest vpon their owne iudgments but vpon the lawfull and common vnderstanding of the holy Scripture for the holy Scripture is no where contrary vnto it selfe neyther doth it any where disagree from it selfe that therefore they so greatly iarre disagree among themselues is caused by that they make a sense to the holy Scripture according to their owne priuate iudgment the which is diuersly framed by them according to the diuersity of iudgments and vnderstanding among them they rely therfore vpon the holy Scripture not as it is interpreted by the Catholike Church the holy Fathers but as they in their priuate iudgment do interprete it for the vertue and force of the holy Scripture doth not only consist in the bare words but in the sense and meaning therof but the priuate iudgment inuenteth this sense and ioyneth it to the words of the Scripture as lyfe vnto the body the whole reason of their fayth therefore is their priuate iudgmeÌ„t the which how deceitfull oftentymes it is may easily be declared by the disagreement of so many sects For it is all one whether thou saist that thou reliest vpon Scripture as it is interpreted by thy proper iudgment or that thou reliest vpon thy owne iudgment precisely in it selfe Finally the third reason whereupon many now adayes do rely is most deceitfull and skornfull of all a manifest signe wherof is that among the Anabaptists who aboue all others are guyded by the instinct of the spirit there is the greatest variety of sects and disagrement of faith the which could not be but that the spirit whereupon they rely and by whome they are gouerned is deceitfull and variable The same also is to be seene among Caluinists and Lutherans and amongst their sects and diuers factions for their owne opinion is certayne and euident vnto euery one of them by the testimony of their owne priuate iudgment the which inwardly teacheth euery one of them and affoardeth the testimony of truth vnto euery one of them whereby it is manifest that this spirit is not the holy Ghost the spirit of truth who cannot teach contraryes or be opposite vnto it selfe but it is a wicked spirit the spirit of error who is a lyar from the begining and the father of lyes who worketh in the children of incredulity of whome the Apostle saith Because they haue not receiued the charity of truth 2. Thess 6. he will therefore send them the operation of error that they may belieue in lyes And in another place 2. Tim. 4. In
vnited themselues to the Church of Christ and now to force them as it were into other abhominable errors and new Idolatry and that by such who were accompted and accepted of all men for lawfull Ministers of the Church and were famous for sanctity of life wisdom miracles God for bid that euer we should so thinke of his Diuine goodnes and prouidence which he vseth for mans saluation Furthermore to Lutheranisme Caluinisme or Anabaptâ—sme there was neuer heard of any conuersion of Nations or Pagan Kingdomes but only a defection of some few who professing the name of Christ and weary of their ancient Religion and discipline did follow the liberty of their lust nouelty which is a manifest argument of heresy For that heresy is nothing els but a corruption of Catholike doctrine and a defection or falling away from ancient Christian Religion only retayning the name of a Christian â—â—esides the study of hereticall teachers is not to conuert Ethnicks but peruert Christians which Tertullian excellently describeth in his booke of Prescriptions Of administration of the word saith he what shall I say Seing that their busines is not to conuert Ethnicks but to peruert ours Christians They do take more glory to bring to ruine those that stand fast then to help those vp that are fallen because that this their endeauour comes not from their owne building but from the destruction of truth They digge vp ours to build vp theirs So as it commeth to passe that they worke the downfall of standing edifices more easily then the building of decayed ruines VI. CONSIDERATION From the Name Catholike from the thinge it selfe signed or marked with this Name FVRTHERMORE that Religion is to be esteemed for the true Religion which hath alwayes byn accompted called Catholike according to that of the Apostolicall creed Credo Sanctam Ecclesiam Catholicam I beleeue the holy Catholik Church But the Roman Church of all other Churches is only called the Catholick and her followers Catholikes Ergo only the Roman Religion is the true ReligioÌ„ of Christ That the Roman Church is and alwayes hath byn only called Catholick is manifest First by the very vse custome of so calling her receyued throughout the world so as oftentymes the heretikes themselues in their wrytings do call her Catholike and her followers Catholiks neyther did any Sect whatsoeuer deserue that name For neuer were the Marcionites Montanistes Donatists Pelagians Vigilantians Waldenses Lutherans Caluinists or Anabaptistes called Catholikes or their doctrine Catholike Only the Roman Church with the people adhering vnto her is called the Catholike and the Religion faith doctrine of this Church is called the Catholike Religion the Catholikefaith the Catholike doctrine and her followers Catholikes Secondly Catholike is extended to all Nations because Catholike is the same that Vniuersall most largely extending it selfe to all And such is the Roman Religion for that it being dilated and spread ouerall the world doth extend it selfe to all nations and Kingdomes For that there is no Kingdome nor Nation vnknowne to vs which eyther doth not or somtymes did or doth not now begin to imbrace this religioÌ„ Nay now adayes the professioÌ„ of this our religion is almost publike amongst all Nations to wit amongst those of Iaponia China India Persia Tartariae Turky Africa Brasile Peru Mexico c. For that in all these places are found Catholikes Churches Altars Images of Christ and of Saintes Masse is there celebrated our Sacraments are there administred holydayes and fasting dayes are there kept and finally the Roman religion is there publikely obserued Who can then doubt but that this is the true way of saluation to all which our Sauiour would haue taught preached and proposed to all nations which he would haue to increase and fructify in all Kingdomes in due tyme and season and which he doth stil conserue by some meanes or other in euery place ordayning that Catholikes be so dispersed throughout the whole world that by them Infidels may come to the knowledge of true Religion Moreouer this Catholike Religion doth extend it selfe to al tymes It extendeth it selfe to all tymes euen froÌ„ the Apostles For that there can be no age from that tyme assigned wherin this Religion did not florish In all ages hath Masse byn celebrated both for the liue and dead feastes solemnized fastes obserued Monasticall vowes made Saints worshipped their reliques honoured and such other like proper ensignes of our religion haue byn in vse and practice as is manifest out of the writers of all tymes On the contrary side No sect euer called Catholick let vs looke vpon all other sectes and we shall neuer find that any one of them was euer called Catholike nor their followers Catholikes as we haue said but that euery one tooke their names of their first Authors as the Simonians Valentinians Pelagians Lutherans No sect euer spread ouer the world Caluinists c. No sect was euer spread ouer the world When Catholike Religion began once to appeare in short tyme it was spread ouer the whole world and began to increase and fructify almost in all Kingdomes Rom. 1â— ColoÌ„ss 1. as S. Paul affirmeth But Lutheranisme Caluinisme and Anabaptisme now after 70. or 80. yeares are yet confined to certayne strayt corners do rather daily decay by eyther going into other sects or els returning to Catholike Religion then any way increase For that none of them hath continued from the Apostles tymes but all sprung vp and inuented within these 70. or 80. yeares last past and therfore neyther in regard of tyme place nor otherwise can they be called Catholike Againe I say that Catholike Religion is one and the selfe same euery where But these religions are exceeding different amongst themselues and disagreeing in their chiefe heads and members one damning another to the pit of hell of heresy how therfore can they be called Catholike VII CONSIDERATION From Succession FVRTHER MORE that Religion is to be accompted the true whose ministers do all descend from the Apostles and are eyther the Apostles successors or haue receiued their order and authority from their sucessours For by this reason it will appeare manifest that that Religion and Church which doth honour imbrace a religion so descended to be Apostolicall Ergo c. Now that all Ministers of the Catholike Religion whether we consider the power of their order or Iuris diction haue descended from the Apostles it is cleere For that all inferiour ministers especialy Priests Deacons Subdeacons receiue their order from Bishops Bishops also haue their order from other Bishops and these likewise againe from others and so futhermore vpwards to the Apostles who receiued this power immediatly from Christ As all men therfore according to their vitall and naturall power do by a long course of genealogy descend from our first Parent Adam so do all ministers of the Catholike Church according to their supernaturall power by a longe
Apostles or their sucessours to gouerne the people And therfore it is cleere that the Church of Christ is not with them The III. Reason From the defect of their Mission THE third reason is because these Religions were brought in by them that were sent by no lawfull authority but came of themselues and for this cause are they and their Authors worthily to be suspected of errour least perhaps they proue to be wolues and seducers For that no man may preach in the Church vnlesse he be sent by lawfull authority according to that of the Apostle How shall they preach Rom. 10. vnlesse they be sent otherwise there should soone arise a great confusion in the Church for that euery one might take vpon him the office of preaching and gouerning the Church and sow abroad what errors he listed And if in a temporall Common wealth humane Policy no man may intrude himselfe and take vpoÌ„ him the office of a magistrate to gouerne the people in temporall things only pertaining to this life but that he must first be appointed therunto by the Prince How much lesse then in the Church and spirituall kingdone of Christ may any man assume vnto himselfe the office of Pastour to gouerne the people in those things which belong to eternall saluation but he that is ordained and appointed therunto by the supreme rector of the Church and Prince of Holyes For that confusion in gouerment of the Church is much more to be auoided theÌ„ in Policy when as the one threatens destruction to the soule the other only losse of goods and fortune Againe Ioan 10. he that entreth not by the dore into the theepfold but climbeth vp some other way is a theefe and robber saith our Lord. But he that taketh to himselfe the office of a Pastour in the Church without lawfull Mission and Auchority he entreth not in at the dore but climbeth vp some other way as the holy Fathers do commonly expound the place and is manifest of it selfe For what is it to enter in at the dore but to enter by the lawfull way and by lawfull authority The dore is the ordinary way and made of purpose wherby to enter into the sheepfold and wherby is designed that authority by which the Ministers of the Church are to be admitted into the sheepfold of Christ to gouerne and feed his sheepe Furthermore our Lord saith in S. Iohns Ghospell Ioan. 7. he that speaketh of himselfe seeketh his owne glory but he that seketh the glory of him that sent him he is faithfull and in him there is no iniustice By which words we are warned not to belieue them who are not lawfully sent but come of themselues because they seeke their owne glory and therfore they do not speake for truth but for their owne praise and comodity and thither do they direct all their doctrine And finally the Apostle in the Epistle to the Hebrews doth account this mission so necessary that he doth require the same in our Sauiour Christ saying Neyther doth any man take the honour to himselfe but he that is called of God as Aaron Hebr. 5. So Christ also did not glorify himselfe that he might be made a High Priest but he that spake to him My Sonne art thou this day haue I begotten thee Wherby our Sauiour did so often inculcate to the Iewes his mission to wit that he came not of himselfe but was sent of his Father and confirmeth the same many wayes From whence it is cleerly deduced that Luther Caluin and the rest of these new Doctours are not to be heard but their doctrine altogeather to be shunned because it is manifest that they were not sent by any lawfull authority but came of themselues It is also manifest that they vsurped vnto themselues the offices of magistrates and Pastors the Authority of reforming the Church It is manifest I say that they came not in at the dore and by the lawfull way but clâ—mbed ouer some other way into the sheepfold and therfore according to our Sauiours iudgment and sentence they are to be accompted for theeues and robbers Perhaps they will say that they were sent of Christ immediatly as in old tyme the Prophets were sent by God in an extraordinary manner to reforme the people and as the Apostles were sent by Christ our Sauiour to coÌ„uert the world and as S. Paul after the Ascension of our Lord who was not sent of men nor yet receiued the Ghospell from men but immediatly froÌ„ God himselfe To this I answere first it is not inough to say and stoutly to affirme but it must be proued and conuinced to be true least it may seeme to the people ordinary pastors to reiect them as deceauers for a lawfull cause as the Prophets and Apostles did not only say that they were sent of God but shewed the same also abundantly by heauenly signes Secondly all Archeretikes and false Prophets throughout euery age haue affirmed the same to wit that they were sent of God from him receaued their Authority And therfore eyther we must receaue them all or none For why should I for example sake rather belieue that Caluin was sent of God then Luther or Menno or Munzer Arius or any other Archeretike when as he can produce no greater signes or testimonies for his mission then they Thirdly if Caluin were sent of God then Luther was not sent of God and so likewise to the contray Because if two men do prophesy coÌ„trary things and that the one doth condemne the others prophesy and doctrine of errour and heresy the one doth so destroy the others religion and therfore if they were both sent of God it seemes that the spirit of God doth oppugne deny and ouerthrow it selfe destroying by one what he had built by another But amongst the Prophets truly sent by God there hath alwaies bin a principal vnity and consent in doctrine Fourthly if Luther or Caluin were set of God to reforme the Church I demaund then what tyme and in what place God gaue them this Office what words did he vse vnto them cyther internall or externall In what manner did he declare vnto them the chiefe heads and points of this Reformation what order and manner did he prescribe them How or in what forme did he appeare vnto them Externally in a visible shape as he did to S. Paul or internally by imaginary vision in some extasis as he did to the Prophets to S. Iohn Euangelist in the Apocalyps For that he is wont to obserue al these things with those whome he sendeth And the Prophets themselues presently in the beginning of their preaching did explicate and declare all these things to the people that they might vnderstand of whome they were sent or what commanÌ„dement was giuen vnto them to performe as out of the Prophesyes of Isay Ieremy Ezechiel Daniel and others is manifest that they were all wont to premit these things first of all And