8. and the Law requiring That those for whom the Sacrifice was offered should be present and put their hands upon the head of it and there being an impossibility That every Man should appear in his own Person it was appointed That the several stations should appear in their turns as the representatives of the whole Community These Maimonides stiles 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the Men of the station Those which were near to Jerusalem belonging to such a station constantly appeared in their course according to what was appointed Those who lived at a greater distance Vid. Temp. Service 62. used to assemble themselves in Synagogues and to pray and read the Law that they might maintain Communion with their Brethren at Jerusalem Besides the Temple the Jews had their Proseucha's and Synagogues By the express words of the Law the Males were obliged to appear thrice a year at Jerusalem The same Law obliging them to the celebration of a Sabbath every week their reason did lead them to make choice of such places where they might conveniently assemble for that purpose These are stiled Proseucha's and Synagogues Such was the Sanctuary in Sichem Jos 24.26 And the place of Prayer in Mizpeh 1 Sam. 7.6 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 1 Macc. 3. â— 40. And the houses of God Ps 74.8 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Aquila translates 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Jerusalem it self was not without them as is evident from S. Paul's words He making an Apology for his behaviour there says They neither found him in the Temple disputing with any man nor raising up the people neither in the Synagogues nor in the City Act. 24.12 Tho' there is some distinction usually made betwixt a Proseucha and a Synagogue as that a Proseucha was in the Field a Synagogue in the City The Proseucha open at top The Synagogue covered The Proseucha built in some place near a River The Synagogue in the highest place of the City The Proseucha might entertain the least number The Synagogue no fewer than Ten yet we find the words promiscuously used by Philo Judaeus He calls the Synagogues 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 De vita Mâ—sis l. 3. It is probable where the Magistrate would not permit the Jews the exercise of their Religion in Cities that they built places in the Fields equivalent to them where they might convene for the Worship of God So that tho' a Proseucha and a Synagogue might differ in some external modes yet they did agree in the main end After the Law when the Messias was come these places were frequented for some time Notwithstanding there was corruption in the publick administrations yet our Blessed Lord did not forsake them The Scribes and Pharisees Ministers in the Jewish Church were chargeable with many personal defects by their procurement unnecessary Rites were blended with the Worship of God The persons which they ministred unto were so enormous in their conversion That the Temple upon the account of their presence is stiled a Den of Thieves Yet for all this our Saviour did not withdraw himself from their Assemblies Into this Church he was admitted by Circumcision Luk. 4.16 did frequently celebrate the Passeover with them honour their Synagogues with his presence every Sabbath and commands his Disciples to hear the Scribes and Pharisees Jo. 11.49 Tho' there was an innovation about the Priesthood the Office of the High Priest which was perpetual by the Law of God was made annual by the Law of Man yet when he had cured the Leper he sends him to the Priest Mat. 8.4 He continued in a Proseucha praying all night Luke 6.12 After his Death his Disciples did tread in his steps So soon as he was ascended the principal of them which were a Hundred and Twenty did presently gather together in an upper room belonging to the Temple and continued in Prayer and Supplication When such multitudes of Converts were added to the Church as one room would not contain them they made use of diverse They continued in the Temple and brake Bread 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 from room to room S. Peter and S. John went up to the Temple at the hour of prayer Act. 3.1 The Disciples were all with one accord in Solomon 's Porch Act. 5.12 The Apostles are bid to speak in the Temple to the people Act. 5.20 S. Paul preached Christ in the Synagogues Act. 9.20 At Antioch in Pisidia he and Barnabas did repair thither on the Sabbath day Act. 13.14 This was his practice at Iconium Thessalonica Corinth Ephesus and so much a general custome That the assembling of Christians together is stiled 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Heb. 10. This Communion of the Christians with the Jews continued as long as their circumstances were reconcileable with it Afterwards they held their Assemblies apart and had peculiar places for their Sacred Conventions known by the name of 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 When ye come together in the Church 1 Cor. 11.18 Here is first a coming together which makes the Congregation and then the place is expressed where the Congregation is met 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 The word imports something antecedent to and distinct from the Assembly Upon this account the Church is opposed to private houses Have ye not houses to eat and drink in or dispise ye the Church of God Let the women keep silence in the Churches and if they will learn any thing let them ask their husbands at home 1 Cor. 14.34 As Houses and home signifie private dwellings so the rule of opposition will justifie us in asserting That the Church or Churches which are opposed to them must signifie publick set apart for Religious Conventions Such were the Houses of Nymphas Philemon Priscilla and Aquila Col. 4.15 Rom. 16. Priscilla and Aquila We read of the Church in them that is The Congregation which use to meet there for the Worship of God these persons having set apart some part of their dwelling for that sacred purpose If by the Church in their Houses we must understand only the members of their families which were converted to the Faith no good reason can be given why the same form of salutation should not be addressed to others as well as to them Rom. 16. â— 10 11. There were many others as Narcissus and Aristobulus who had in their housholds those who did embrace the Doctrine of Christ We are not destitute of very early Testimonies to the same effect in Ecclesiastical Writers L. 8. c. 1 â—u l. 2. c. 17. Lamprid. Eusebius stiles the Churches 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 ancient edifices Several of them were in Alexandria in S. Mark 's time Alexander Severus upon a controversie did adjudge such a publick place to the Christians Irenaeus and Clemens Alexandrinus use the word Ecclesia in the sence which we contend for Such a place is stiled Domus Dei in Tertullian and Dominicum in S. Cyprian These words import a resignation of the right
never charge this crime upon the Primitive Professors of it Amongst the errours objected against them in the conference with Tryphon in the discourse of Tertullian and many other disputations we never read of the Adoration of Images The Mishna which is believed to be Written about Two Hundred years after Christ is wholly silent in this matter altho' the Composer had a convenient opportunity to speak of it in his Treatise concerning strange Worship Their implacable enmity to the Laws of Christ gives us the highest degree of assurance that nothing could be the cause of their silence but the innocence of the Christians In the Gemara which was finished about the time that Images were brought into Churches a Christian Temple is stiled a House of Idolatry The Heathens when they were accused by the Christians for worshipping Idols never mention in their vindication of themselves the adoration of Images among Christians which certainly they would have done in case there had been any such practice Dall de Imag. When the Idols of the Americans were demolished by the command of Alphonsus Suasus they sent four men to complain of the injury who acquainted him that they did not expect such usage from Christians who gave Divine Honour to Images and pointed to the Picture of Sebastian which hung in his chamber and told him That the same honour which he gave that Picture they gave to their Idols When he replied That Christians did not worship such Pictures upon their own account but as they were representations of glorified Persons in Heaven They answered Neither did they their Idols for their own sakes but as they represented the Sun Moon and Stars When Bernier told the East-Indians That he was scandalized upon the account of their worshipping Idols he received a like answer from some of the chief of them Hist of the Gent. of Indostan Vol. 3. p. 172. We have indeed in our Deuras or Temples store of divers Statues as those of Brahma Mehaden Genick and Gavani who are some of the chief and most perfect Deutas and we have also many other of less perfection to whom we pay great honour prostrating our selves before them and presenting them Flowers Rice Scented Oiles Saffron and such other things with much Ceremony But we do not believe these Statues to be Brahma and Bechen c. but only their Images and representations and we do not give them that honour but upon the account of what they represent They are in our Temples because it is necessary for praying well to have some thing before our eyes to six our mind and when we pray it is not the Statue we pray to but he who is represented by it For the rest we acknowledge that it is God that is absolute and only Omnipotent Lord and Master If these barbarous People were so quick as to make so apposite a retort when they were set upon by Christians the first expresly accusing them of the like practice the second drawing a representation of their own religion exactly parallel to what they knew to be in use in the Roman Community No doubt Tryphon and Celsus c. would have done the like in case in their time there had been the same reason The Primitive Christians in many places were so remote from the worshipping Images That they did not allow the making of them as is plain by the words of Clemens and Tertullian Strom. 5. de Specta c. 23. In case they were made they would not permit them to be brought into Churches When Adrian gave command That Temples should be built without Pictures it was taken for granted that he intended them for the Worship of Christ When Epiphanius found in a Church a Veil with the Picture of a Man painted upon it he presently rent it in pieces and defended his action by alledging that it was contrary to the Scripture That the Picture of a Man should be hanged up in the Church of Christ When Images were brought into Churches the worship of them was utterly disallowed Serenus was for the banishing them out to prevent danger Greg. Mor. lib. 9. Gregory for the keeping them in to instruct the illiterate Both agree in this That they are not to be adored When Philippicus being transported with an intemperate love to the Monothelites took down the Pictures of the first Six General Councils and by this action provoked Rome to a greater measure of zeal for Images than the adoration of them was thought upon The hint that was expressed gave an alarm to the Synod called by Constantius Copronymus and occasioned the making a decree That to give religious veneration to Images is nothing else but to revive the Superstition of the Pagans When the Council under Irene did rescind this decree it is observable that it did prohibit the making the Picture of God This impiety then had no Umbrage from Authority If we consult the Monuments of Antiquity it will be apparent That in the Sixth Seventh and Eighth Ages there were hot disputes about the worship of Images but no countenance given to the making or worshipping the Image of God In the Three Ages immediately before They are sometimes mentioned as Ornaments of Churches and instruments to teach the ignorant but not as the Objects of Worship In the Three first Centuries there is no mention of them at all in the concerns of Religion The Resemblance upon the Chalice which Tertullian speaks of was an Emblem of the Parable of the lost Sheep and not a Picture of Christ or any particular Saint It was not drawn with a design to be Worshipped but to signifie That those who are gone astray may upon their repentance be received into the Communion of the Church The story in Eusebius Eccl. Hist l. 7. c. 18. concerning the Statues of Christ and the Woman cured by him of her issue of blood is too dubious to lay a foundation for a clear testimony Eusebius indeed asserts That he saw two Statues of brass at Caesarea Philippi but he doth not say That they were the Statues of Christ and Woman but that the people said so Nothing is more familiar than for them to be mistaken in their account of such publick Monuments It is incredible that such famous testimonies of the Truth of Christian Religion should remain in the open street untouched for the space of Three Hundred Years amidst the slames of the hottest persecutions when the greatest privacy could not secure any thing appertaining to the Christians from the rage and fury of the Heathens Suppose all this was so yet the Romanists will gain no advantage by it For no Religious Addresses were made to these Statues They were not in the Church but the street Not erected to be Objects of Worship but Memorials of a Miracle That which was reputed to be the Statue of Christ Philostorgius assures us had no adoration given to it and adds his reason 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 For it was not
is usually more violent than that which ariseth from a diversity in Civil The pretence of a Sacred Institution communicates an edge to the Spirits of those who are concerned for them They are easily induced to believe That they are engaged in the quarrel of the Deity and that their zeal for them will render the Divine Power propitious to them This consideration pushes them forward and makes them as fierce as the Poet represents the Combites to be against the Tentyrites An old grudge to immortal hatred turn'd Juv. Sat. 15. Betwixt the Tentyrites and Combites burn'd A wound in those adjacent towns past cure Because that neither people could endure Their neighbours Deities or would have more Held to be Gods than they themselves adore Such heats are frequently attended with very direful consequences Rev. 8.5 They produce strong Convulsion-fits in the Community Thundrings Lightnings and an Earthquake are represented as proceeding from the Fire of the Altar The Fire which consumed the Senate-House in Constantinople began in the Church Socr. p. 727. Nothing can be safe when Men are inflamed with a zeal for their own private Sentiments They think every one is under an obligation to submit to them The want of power is the only thing which gives a temper to their deportment So soon as they are numerous and prevalent enough nothing will satisfie but a complete Conquest all must stoop to their perswasions They account it an evidence of weakness if they cannot and of irreligion if they will not settle that which they conceive to be best And they believe they are not secure in the enjoyment of their power except they suppress others and bend them into a compliance with them 6. If Contests arise in the same Church about external modes a ready way to compose them is to appeal to Primitive Order and give the preference to those who come nearest to it If we view it as it lies in the Holy Scriptures and those undoubted Records which are next in Antiquity we shall find it to be not pompous and theatrical but grave and comely not calculated for the gratification of the Sensitive but Intellectual part not apt to divert the Intention from the import of Worship and yet sufficient to secure it against the assaults of Rudeness and Contempt The Ministerial part was appropriated to Three Orders of Men Apostles Elders and Deacons persons sound in Doctrin Sober and unspotted in their Conversation Presbyters were ordained in every Church and City The solemn time for Sacred Conventions was the first of the week In the Assemblies The Men were uncovered the Women veiled The Minister began with Prayer This he directed to God with the most important expressions of Devotion without the help of such a Prompter as the Ethnick Priests use to have lest they might forget the names of any of their Gods which were very numerous After this were read the Writings of the Apostles and Prophets And because some things are hard to be understood and those which are easie ought not only to be entertained in the Head but the Heart in the next place followed Preaching with the most pathetical Exhortations to Practice When the Sermon was finished all did rise from their seat and joyn in Prayer After this succeeded the celebration of the Holy Communion in which the President poured forth Thanksgiving and Supplication with all his might the People expressing their concurrence by saying Amen All was concluded with a contribution for the relief of the Poor Besides these circumstances There were some Symbolical Rites in use namely The Love-Feasts the Holy Kiss As the laying of these aside in some time doth plainly express That the Church did not believe they were grounded upon a perpetual institution but taken up upon Prudential Considerations in a Conformity to the general rules of Scripture So the Practice of them in the purest Age when Christian Simplicity was in its greatest vigour doth manifestly teach us That we have no just grounds to condemn our own Church because she retains some Rites not burdensome in their number and as innocent in their meaning as They were 7. If by reason of paucity of records or any obscurity in those which are extant it cannot be agreed what was the Primitive Order The ready way to Peace before Authority has made any determination is for the several Members of the Church to make prudent Condescensions one to another so as none may be nourished in their errour nor any have any just reason of offence administred to them This was the condition of the Romans when S. Paul did address his Epistle to them Their contests were violent Authority had not yet interposed The Counsel of the Apostle has an entire aspect upon this purpose Let not him that eateth despise him that eateth not and let not him who eateth not judge him who eateth One man esteemeth one day above another another man esteemeth every day alike Let every man be fully perswaded in his own mind Matters were not then ripe enough in that Church for a decision The converted Jews had not a full insight into the liberty which Christ purchased for them Therefore S. Paul doth not determine the case on either side but adviseth every member to a prudent demeanour and To follow the things which make for peace and things with which one may edisie another The Apostle suspending the exercise of his authority in these circumstances cannot be brought into an argument against all determinations about things which are adiaphorous for he in other Churches did decide this matter as appears by his Epistles to the Galatians and Colossians How turn ye again to the weak and beggarly elements whereunto ye desire again to be in bondage ye observe days months times and years Gal. 4.9 10. Let no man therefore judge ye in meat or in drink or in respect of an holy day or of the New Moon or Sabbath days which are a shadow of things to come but the body is of Christ Col. 2.16 17. Certainly if the Apostle had believed That all Churches are to enjoy a freedom equal to that in which he left the Romans he would not have been so positive as he is with these eminent Churches 8. If Condescensions cannot be procured and circumstances become such That Rulers believe it prudential to make a determination both weak and strong are bound to acquiesce in the decision Such a determination is within the Sphere of humane authority God has commanded all that is Good and interdicted all Evil. The only things which are left to be the immediate object of Sublunary Power are those which are neither They may become useful or not useful as circumstances happen but in their own nature they are neither good or evil If any apply themselves to the doing of them for the sake of some intrinsick bonity which they fansie to be in them and others stand at a distance from them upon the account of some
intimation of any particular delinquency which the Rest of the Sabbath of the Fourth Command typifies our cessation from Not from all For betwixt the Type and the thing signified there ought to be some resemblance which is not discernable betwixt the Souls Rest from some enormities and the Rest of the Body The Soul then rests from sins of omission when it is conversant about the discharge of those duties which are devolved upon it This kind of Spiritual Rest consists in operation and the Rest of the Body bears no resemblance to the operations of the Soul Now I have finished the Seventh Proposition the solemn Time for Worship which ought to be no less than One Day every Week determined in the Fourth Command to One in Seven as a proportion perpetually to be devoted to Divine Worship VIII This proportion One in Seven was determined to the Jewish day by another Precept which was to oblige only till the Jewish Oeconomy had a period put to it Here are Two things to be evinced 1. That the Jewish Sabbath was set out by a Law distinct from the Fourth Command 2. That this Law was to continue no longer than the Jewish Oeconomy 1. The Jewish Sabbath was set out by a Law distinct from the Fourth Command This Law we find Exod. 16.23 To morrow is the rest of the Sabbath and likewise Exod. 31.15 In the seventh is the Sabbath of rest Here in both places the word is double 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the rest of the Sabbath and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the Sabbath of rest but in the Fourth Command it is single 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 which can import no less than some difference and distinction betwixt the Two Laws The reason of the duplication may be this The Jews being under a twofold Command the Law concerning the particular Day and the Law touching the Proportion They had a double Sabbath namely the last of the Week and the Sabbath of the Fourth Command which is One Day in a Week The Fourth Command enjoyning only vagum quid One in Seven and this vagum taking up its rest for a time in the particular Jewish day That day is stiled Sabbatum Sabbati the rest of the Sabbath of the Fourth Command The calling afterwards the Tenth Day of the Seventh Month and the Seventh Year of release by the same name doth not weaken this observation The name is first given to the Jewish weekly Sabbath upon the grounds expressed and then afterwards applyed unto those times to signifie That the Jews ought to make the Rest of the Sabbath the pattern of their Rest on those Solemnities and therefore when the day of expiation is so stiled Lev. 23.32 in the LXX these words occur 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 You shall sabbatize or imitate in the observation of this yearly solemnity the Rest of the weekly Sabbath When the year of release is so named Lev. 25. The Vulgar Latin plainly points at this imitation Sabbatizes Sabbatum This Law is likewise mentioned Nehem. 9.13 14. In the Thirteenth verse We have an account of the whole Decalogue under these names Right judgments true laws good statutes and commandments That by these we are to understand the Ten Commandments and nothing else is clear in that it is said That God himself gave them from Mount Sinai God gave there immediately by himself the whole Decalogue and no other Laws After the Ten Commandments are thus expressed of which number the Fourth is one it is said in the next Verse And thou madest known unto them thy holy Sabbath and commandedst them precepts and statutes and laws by the hand of Moses thy servant Here the particular Jewish day is expressed as a thing distinct from the Sabbath of the Fourth Command and reckoned amongst the Precepts Statutes and Laws which were given by the hand of Moses Therefore there must be some distinction betwixt the Sabbath as it lies amongst the Ten Commandments and the particular Jewish day The Tradition of the Jews is not disagreeable to what has been represented The Fourth Command reacheth to the stranger within the gate 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 as Solomon Jarchius glosseth The particular Jewish Sabbath according to the common opinion extends no further than to those of their own nation More Nevo P. 2. c. 30. pag. 283. P. 3. c. 43. pag. 471 Maimonides intimates That there was a Sabbath given to them in particular and a Sabbath likewise given to all the scope of which was That the Seventh part of the life of a Man might be free of toil and dedicated to the remembrance of the Creation In the Six Hundred and Thirteen Precepts commonly reputed by the Rabbins to have been given to Moses upon Mount Sinai the Sabbath according to the collection of Abraham Ben Kattani as it lies in Exod. 20.8 makes the Twenty Seventh as it lies in Exod. 23.12 makes the Seventy Ninth Now the Sabbath in the 23. of Exod. is undoubtedly the last of the week therefore the Sabbath in the Twentieth must be something else Nothing can be so properly thought upon as the proportion of time the immutable rule of the Church's rest in all ages 2. This Law concerning the particular day on which the Jews rested was to continue no longer than the Jewish Oeconomy The day of the resurrection of our Blessed Lord put a period to it Upon the Sabbath immediately preceding it is said That the Women which came with Christ from Galilee rested according to command Luk. 23.55 56. Tho' the Disciples had observed many of the Jewish Sabbaths before yet this expression according to command is never used till now which intimates That there must be some special reason for it and what can this be but only to shew how far the Disciples might go in the celebration of the old day according to Precept namely to the Resurrection of Christ If they went any further it was without command That being designed to continue no longer Indeed the Apostles did afterwards frequent the Synagogues upon the Jewish Sabbath but it is never said that they entred into them 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 but 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 according to custom Act. 17.2 It was a custom for them for a while to comply with the Jews in some things which were in reality abrogated and to seek the gaining of them by prudential condescensions and accommodations to their weakness After this time was in some measure over and ignorance of the liberty procured by Christ from the rites of the ceremonial became less excusable we find the Jewish Sabbath by degrees fully declared against as an antiquated rite It is represented 1. As a day equal with others 2. As a beggarly element 3. As a shadow that was vanished away 1. As a Day equal with others One man esteemeth one day above another another esteemeth every day alike Let every man be fully perswaded in his own mind he that regardeth a day regardeth it to the Lord and