HISTORICAL RELATIONS OR A DISCOVERY Of the true causes why IRELAND Was never intirely Subdu'd nor brought under obedience OF THE CROWN OF ENGLAND UNTIL The beginning of the Reign of King James of happy memory By Sir John Davis Knight His Majesties Attorney General of Ireland The third Edition corrected and amended Dublin Printed for Samuel Dancer Bookseller in Castlestreet 1666. THE PRINTER TO THE READER THE former Edition of this Book being rarely now to be got and much sought after by many for the worth thereof I procured from the Honourable Sir James Ware one of the former printed Books according to which I now publish this second Edition The Author of the Work was Sir John Davis a Learned man and an excellent Orator who for his great Abilities was by King James first made His Solicitor and afterwards his Attorney-General in this Kingdom of Ireland Which Place he discharged for divers years and having access to the Records from them for the most part as from the purest Fountains he gathered these his Observations A DISCOVERY OF THE True causes why Ireland was never entirely subdued and brought under obedience of the Crown of England until the beginning of His Majesties happy Reign DUring the time of my Service in IRELAND which began in the first year of His Majesties Reign I have visited also the Provinces of that Kingdom in sundry journeys and circuits Wherein I have observed the good Temperature of the Ayre the Fruitfulness of the Soyl the pleasant and commodious seats for habitation the safe and large Ports and Havens lying open for Traffick into all the West parts of the World the long Inlets of many Navigable Rivers and so many great Lakes and fresh Ponds within the Land as the like are not to be seen in any part of Europe the rich Fishings and Wilde Fowl of all kinds and lastly the Bodies and Mindes of the people endued with extraordinary abilities of Nature THe observation whereof hath bred in me some curiosity to consider what were the true causes why this Kingdom whereof our Kings of England have borne the Title of Soveraign Lords for the space of four hundred and odde years a period of time wherein divers great Monarchies have risen from Barbarism to Civility and fallen again to ruine was not in al that space of time thoroughly subdued and reduced to Obedience of the Crown of England although there hath been almost a continual War between the English and the Irish and why the manners of the meer Irish are so little altered since the days of King Henry the second as appeareth by the description made by Giraldus Cambrensis who lived and wrote in that time albeit there have been since that time so many English Colonies planted in Ireland as that if the people were numbered at this day by the poll such as are descended of English race would be found more in number than the ancient Natives AND truly upon consideration of the conduct and passage of affairs in former times I find that the State of England ought to be cleared of an imputation which a vulgar errour hath cast upon it in one point namely That Ireland long since might have been subdued and reduced to Civility if some Statesmen in policy had not thought it more fit to continue that Realm in Barbarism Doubtless this vulgar opinion or report hath no true ground but did first arise either out of Ignorance or out of Malice For it will appear by that which shall hereafter be laid down in this Discourse that ever since Our Nation had any footing in this Land the State of England did earnestly desire and I did accordingly endeavour from time to time to perfect the Conquest of this Kingdom but that in every age there were found such impediments and defects in both Realms as caused almost an impossibility that things should have been otherwise than they were THe Defects which hindred the Perfection of the Conquest of Ireland were of two kindes and consisted first In the faint prosecution of the war and next In the looseness of the Civil Government For the Husbandman must first break the Land before it be made capable of good seed and when it is thoroughly broken and manured if we do not forthwith cast good seed into it it will grow wilde again and bear nothing but weeds So a barbarous Country must be first broken by a war before it will be capable of good Government and when it is fully subdued and conquered if it be not well planted and governed after the Conquest it will eft soons return to the former Barbarism TOuching the carriage of the Martial affairs from the seventeenth year of King Henry the second when the first overture was made for the Conquest of Ireland I mean the first after the Norman Conquest of England until the nine and thirtieth year of Queen ELIZABETH when that Royal Army was sent over to suppress Tirones Rebellion which made in the end an universal and absolute conquest of all the Irishrie It is most certain that the English forces sent hither or raised here from time to time were ever too weak to subdue and master so many warlike Nations or Septs of the Irish as did possess this Island and besides their weakness they were Ill paid and worse Governed And if at any time there came over an Army of competent strength and power it did rather terrifie than break and subdue this people being ever broken and dissolved by some one accident or other before the perfection of the Conquest FOR that I call a Perfect Conquest of a Countrey which doth reduce all the people thereof to the Condition of Subjects and those I call Subjects which are governed by the ordinary Laws and Magistrates of the Soveraign For though the Prince doth bear the Title of Soveraign Lord of an entire Countrey as our Kings did of all Ireland yet if there be two third parts of that Countrey wherein he cannot punish Treasons Murthers or Thefts unless he send an Army to do it if the Jurisdiction of his ordinary Courts of Justice doth not extend into those parts to protect the people from wrong and Oppression if he have no certain Revenue no Escheates or Forfeitures out of the same I cannot justly say that such a Countrey is wholly conquered FIrst then That we may judge and discern whether the English Forces in Ireland were at any time of sufficient strength to make a full and final Conquest of that Land let us see what extraordinary Armies have been transmitted out of England thither and what ordinary Forces have been maintained there and what service they have performed from time to time since the seventeenth year of King Henry the second IN that year Mac Murugh Lord of Leinster being oppressed by the Lords of Meath and Connaught and expelled out of his Territory moved King Henry the second to invade Ireland and made an overture unto him for the obtaining of the Soveraign Lordship thereof The King refused to undertake the War himself
to avoid the charge as King Henry the seventh refused to undertake the discovery of the Indies for the same cause but he gave license by His Letters Patents that such of his Subjects might pass over into Ireland as would at their own charge become adventurers in that enterprize SO as the first attempt to conquer this Kingdom was but an adventure of a few private Gentlemen Fitz-Stephen and Fitz-Gerald first brake the ice with a party of three hundred ninety men The Earl Strongbow followed them with twelve hundred more whose good success upon the Sea-coasts of Leinster and Mounster drew over the King in person the next year after cum quingentis Militibus as Giraldus Cambrensis reporteth who was present in Ireland at that time Which if they were but five hundred Souldiers seemeth too small a train for so great a Prince But admit they were five hundred Knights yet because in those days every Knight was not a Commander of a Regiment or Company but most of them served as private men sometimes a hundred Knights under a Spear as appeareth by the Lists of the ancient Armies we cannot conjecture his army to have been so great as might suffice to conquer all Ireland being divided into so many Principalities and having so many Hydraes heads as it had at that time For albeit Tacitus in the life of Agricola doth report that Agricola having subdued the greatest part of Great Brittain did signifie to the Senate of Rome that he thought Ireland might also be conquered with one Legion and a few aids I make no doubt but that if he had attempted the conquest thereof with a far greater army he would have found himself deceived in this conjecture For a Barbarous Country is not so easily conquered as a Civil whereof Caesar had experience in his Wars against the Gauâ—es Germanes and Britaines who were subdued to the Roman Empire with far greater difficulty than the rich Kingdoms of Asia And again a Country possessed with many petty Lords and States is not so soon brought under entirely as an entire Kingdom Governed by one Prince or Monarch And therefore the late King of Spain could sooner win the Kingdom of Portugal than reduce the States of the Low-Countries BUt let us see the success of King Henry the Second doubtless his expedition was such as he might have said with Caesar veni vidi vici For upon his first arrival his very Presence without drawing his Sword prevailed so much as all the Petty-Kings or great Lords within Leinster Conaght and Mounster submitted themselves unto him promised to pay him tribute and acknowledged him their chief and Soveraign Lord. Besides the better to assure this inconstant Sea-Nymph who was so easily wonne the Pope would needs give her unto him with a Ring Conjugio jungam stabili propriamque dicabo But as the Conquest was but slight and superficial so the Popes Donation and the Irish Submissions were but weak and fickle assurances For as the Pope had no more Interest in this Kingdom than He which offered to Christ all the Kingdoms of the earth so the Irish pretend That by their Law a Tanist might do no act that might bind his successor But this was the best assurance he could get from so many strong Nations of people with so weak a power and yet he was so well pleased with this title of the Lordship of Ireland as he placed it in his Royal Stile before the Dutchies of Normandy and Aquitain And so being advertised of some stirs raised by his unnatural Sons in England within five months after his first arrival he departed out of Ireland without striking one blow or building one Castle or planting one Garrison among the Irish neither left he behind him one true subject more than those he found there at his coming over which were only the English Adventurers spoken of before who had gained the Port Towns in Leinster and Mounster and possessed some scopes of Land thereunto adjoyning partly by Strongbow's alliance with the Lord of Leinster and partly by plain invasion and Conquest And this is that Conquest of King Henry the second so much spoken of by so many Writers which though it were in no other manner than is before expressed yet is the entire Conquest of all Ireland attributed unto him But the troth is the conquest of Ireland was made by peice and peice by slow steps and degrees and by several attempts in several ages There were sundry revolutions as well of the English fortunes as of the Irish some-whiles one prevailing some-whiles the other and it was never brought to a full period till his Majesty that now is came to the Crown As for King Henry the second he was far from obtaining that Monarchy Royal and true Soveraignty which His Majesty who now reigneth hath over the Irish For the Irish Lords did only promise to become Tributaries to King Henry the Second And such as pay onâ—y Tribute though they be placed by Bodin in the first degree of Subjection are not properly Subjects but Soveraigns For though they be less and inferiour unto the Prince to whom they pay Tribute yet they hold all other points of Soveraignty and having paid their Tribute which they promised to have their peace they are quit of all other duties as the same Bodin writeth And therefore though King Henry the second had the title of Soveraign Lord over the Irish yet did he not put those things in execution which are the true marks and differences of Soveraignty FOr to give Laws unto a people to institute Magistrates and Officers over them to punish and pardon Malefactors to have the sole authority of making war and peace and the like are the true marks of Soveraignty which K. Henry the second had not in the Irish countries but the Irish Lords did still retain all these prerogatives to themselves For they governed their people by the Brehon Law they made their own Magistrates and Officers they pardoned and punished all Malefactors within their several Countries they made war and peace one with another without controulment and this they did not only during the Reign of King Henry the Second but afterwards in all times even until the Reign of Queen Elizabeth and it appeareth what manner of Subjects these Irish Lords were by the Concord made between King Henry the Second and Roderick ô Connor the Irish King of Conaght in the year 1175. which is recorded by Hoveden in this form Hic est finis Concordia inter Dominum regem Angliae Henricum filium Imperatricis Rodoricum Regem Conactae scilicet quod Rex Angliae concessit praedict ' Roderico Ligeo homini suo ut sit Rex sub eo paratus ad servitium suum ut homo suus c. And the Commission whereby King Henry the Second made William
King and his successors all their Lands and possessions which they held in Leinster and taking with them only their moveable goods should serve him in his wars against his other Rebels In consideration whereof the King should give them pay and pensions during their lives and bestow the inheritance of all such Lands upon them as they shouâ—d recover from the Rebels in any other part of the Realm And thereupon a pension of eighty Marks per annum was granted to Art ' Mac Murrogh chief of the Kavanaghes the enroulment whereof I found in the White book of the Exchequer here And this was the effect of the service performed by the Earl Marshal by vertue of his Commission The King in like manner received the submissions of the Lords of Vlster namely O Neal O Hanlon Mac Donel Mac Mahon and others who with the like Humility and Ceremony did homage and fealty to the Kings own person the words of O Neales homage as they are recorded are not unfit to be remembred Ego Nelanus Oneal Senior tam pro meipso quam pro filiis meis tota Natione mea Parentelis meis pro omnibus subditis meis devenio Ligeus homo vester c. And in the Indenture between him and the King he is not only bound to remain faithful to the Crown of England but to restore the Bonaght of Vlster to the Earl of Vlster as of right belonging to that Earldom and usurped among other things by the Oneals These Indentures and submissions with many other of the same kind for there was not a Chieftain or head of an Irish sept but submitted himself in one form or other the King himself caused to be inrolled and testified by a Notary publick and delivered the enrolments with his own hands to the Bishop of Salisbury then Lord Treasurer of England so as they have been preserved and are now to be found in the Office of the Kings Remembranceâ— there With these humilities they satisfied the young King and by their bowing and bending avoided the present storm and so brake that Army which was prepared to break them For the King having accepted their submissions received them in Osculo pacis feasted them and given the honor of Knighthood to divers of them did break up and dissolve his army and returned into England with much honor and small profit saith Froissard For though he had spent a huge mass of Treasure in transporting his army by the countenance whereof he drew on their submissions yet did he not encrease his revenue thereby one sterling pound nor enlarged the English borders the bredth of one Acre of Land neither did he extend the Jurisdiction of his Courts of Justice one foot further than the English Colonies wherein it was used and exercised before Besides he was no sooner returned into England but those Irish Lords laid aside their masks of humility and scorning the weak forces which the King had left behind him began to infest the borders in defence whereof the Lord Roger Mortimer being then the Kings Lieutenant and Heir apparent to the Crown of England was slain as I said before Whereupon the King being moved with a just appetite of revenge came over again in person in the 22. year of his Reign with as potent an army as he had done before with a full purpose to make a full Conquest of Ireland he landed at Waterford and passing from thence to Dublin through the wast Countries of the Murroghes Kinshelaghes Cauanaghes Birnes and Tooles his great army was much distressed for want of victuals and carriages so as he performed no memorable thing in that journey only in the Cavanaghes Country he cut and cleared the paces and bestowed the honour of Knighthood upon the Lord Henry the Duke of Lancasters son who was afterwards King Henry the fifth and so came to Dublin where entring into Counsel how to proceed in the war he received news out of England of the arrival of the banished Duke of Lancaster at Ravenspurgh usurping the Regal authority and arresting and putting to death his principal Officers This advertisement suddainly brake off the Kings purpose touching the prosecution of the war in Ireland and transported him into England where shortly after he ended both his Reign and his life Since whose time until the 39. year of Queen Elizabeth there was never any Army sent â—ver of a Competent strength or power to subdue the Irish but the war was made by the English Colonies only to defend their borders or if any forces were transmitted over they were sent only to suppress the rebellions of such as were descended of English race and not to enlarge our Dominion over the Irish DUring the Raign of King Henry the Fourth the Lord Thomas of Lancaster the Kings second Son was Lieutenant of Ireland who for the first eight years of that Kings Reign made the Lord Scroope and others his Deputies who only defended the Marches with forces levyed within the Land In the eighth year that Prince came over in person with a smal retinue So as wanting a sufficient power to attempt or perform any great service he returned within seven moneths after into England Yet during his personal abode there he was hurt in his own person within one mile of Dublin upon an incounter with the Irish enemy He took the submissions of O Birne of the Mountains Mac Mahon and O Rely by several Indentures wherein O Birne doth Covenant that the King shall quietly enjoy the Mannor of New-Castle Mac Mahon accepteth a State in the Ferny for life rendering ten pound a year and O Rely doth promise to perform such duties to the Earl of March and Vlster as were contained in an Indenture dated the 18. of Richard the second IN the time of K. Henry the fifth there came no forces out of England Howbeit the Lord Furnival being the Kings Lieutenant made a martial circuit or journey round about the Marches and Borders of the pale and brought all the Irish to the Kings peace beginning with the Birnes Tooles and Cauanaghes on the South and so passing to the Moores O Connors and O Forals in the West and ending with the O Relies Mac Mahons O Neales and O Hanlons in the North. He had power to make them seek the Kings peace but not power to reduce them to the Obedience of Subjects yet this was then held so great and worthy a service as that the Lords and chief Gentlemen of the Pale made certificate thereof in French unto the King being then in France which I have seen Recorded in the White Booke of the Exchequer at Dublin Howbeit his Army was so ill paid and governed as the English suffered more damage by the Sess of his Souldiers for now that Monster Coigne and Livery which the Statute of Kilkenny had for a time abolished was risen again from hell than they gained profit or security by abating the pride of their
enemies for a time DUring the minority of King Henry the sixth and for the space of seven or eight years after the Lieutenants and Deputies made only a bordering war upon the Irish with small and scattered forces howbeit because there came no Treasure out of England to pay the Souâ—dier the poor English Subject did bear the burthen of the men of war in every place and were thereby so weakned and impoverished as the State of things in Ireland stood very desperately Whereupon the Cardinal of Winchester who after the death of Humfrey Duke of Glocester did wholly sway the State of England being desirous to place the Duke of Somerset in the Regency of France took occasion to remove Richard Duke of York from that Government and to send him into Ireland pretending that he was a most able and willing person to perform service there because he had a great inheritance of his own in Ireland namely the Earldom of Vlster and the Lordships of Conaght and Meth by discent from Lionel Duke of Clarence We do not finde that this great Lord came over with any numbers of waged Souldiers but it appeareth upon what good terms he took that Government by the Covenants between the King and him which are recorded and confirmed by Act of Parliament in Ireland and were to this effect 1. That he should be the Kings Lieutenant of Ireland for ten years 2. That to support the charge of that Country he should receive all the Kings Revenues there both certain and casual without accompt 3. That he should be supplyed also with treasure out of England in this manner he should have four thousand Marks for the first year whereof he should be imprested 2000. li. before hand and for the other nine years he should receive 2000. li. per annum 4. That he might Let to Ferm the Kings Lands and place and dis-place all Officers at his pleasure 5. That he might levy and wage what numbers of men he thought fit 6. That he might make a Deputy and return at his pleasure We cannot presume that this Prince kept any great army on foot as well because his means out of England were so mean and those ill paid as appeareth by his passionate letter written to the Earl of Salisbury his Brother in Law the Copy whereof is Registred in the Story of this time as also because the whole Land except the English Pale and some part of the Earldome of Vlster upon the Sea-Coasts were possest by the Irish So as the Revenue of the Kingdom which he was to receive dâ—d amount to little He kept the borders and Marches of the Pale with much adoe he held many Parliaments wherein sundry Laws were made for erecting of Castles in Louth Meath and Kildare to stop the incursions of the Irishry And because the Souldiers for want of pay were sessed and laid upon the Subjects against their wills upon the prayer and importunity of the Commons this extortion was declared to be High-Treason But to the end that some means might be raised to nourish some forces for defence of the Pale by another Act of Parliament every twenty pound Land was charged with the furnishing and maintenance of one Archer on horseback Besides the native subjects of Ireland seeing the Kingdom utterly ruined did pass in such numbers into England as one Law was made in England to transmit them back again and another Law made here to stop their passage in every Port and Creek Yet afterwards the greatest parts of the Nobility and Gentry of Meth past over into England and were slain with him at Wakefield in Yorkshire Lastly the State of England was so farr from sending an army to subdue the Irish at this time as among the Articles of grievances exhibited by the Duke of Yorke against King Henry the sixth this was one That divers Lords about the King had caused his Highness to write Letters unto some of his Irish enemies whereby they were encouraged to attempt the conquest of the said Land Which Letters the same Irish enemies had sent unto the Duke marvailing greatly that such Letters should be sent unto them and speaking therein great shame of the Realm of England After this when this great Lord was returned into England and making claim to the Crown began the War betwixt the two Houses It cannot he conceived but that the Kingdom fell into a worse and weaker estate WHen Edward the fourth was setled in the Kingdome of England he made his Brother George Duke of Clarence Lieutenant of Ireland This Prince was born in the Castle of Dublin during the Government of his father the Duke of York yet did he never pass over into this Kingdom to govern it in person though he held the Lieutenancy many years But it is manifest that King Edward the fourth did not pay any Army in Ireland during his Reign but the Men of War did pay themselves by taking Coigne and Livery upon the Country which extortion grew so excesssive and intolerable as the Lord Tiptoft being Deputy to the Duke of Clarence was enforced to execute the Law upon the greatest Earl in the Kingdom namely Desmond who lost his head at Droghedagh for this offence Howbeit that the State might not seem utterly to neglect the defence of the Pale there was a fraternity of men at armes called the Brother-hood of St. George erected by Parliament the 14. of Edward the fourth consisting of thirteen the most Noble and worthy persons within the four shires Of the first foundation were Thomas Earl of Kildare Sir Rowland Eustace Lord of Port-lester and Sir Robert Eustace for the County of Kildare Robert Lord of Howth the Mayor of Dublin and Sir Robert Dowdal for the County of Dublin the Viscount of Gormanston Edward Plunket Senesha I of Meth Alexander Plunket and Barnabe Barnewale for the County of Meth the Mayor of Droghedagh Sir Lawrence Taaffe and Richard Bellewe for the County of Lowth These and their Successors were to meet yearly upon St. Georges day and to choose one of themselves to be Captain of that Brother-hood for the next year to come Which Captain should have at his command 120. Archers on horseback forty horsemen and forty Pages to suppress Out-laws and rebels The wages of every Archer should be six pence Per diem and every Horseman five pence Per diem and four marks Per annum And to pay these entertainments and to maintain this new fraternity there was granted unto them by the same Act of Parliament a subsidy of Poundage out of all Marchandizes exported or imported thoroughout the Realm hydes and the goods of Free-men of Dublin and Droghedah only excepted These 200. men were all the standing forces that were then maintained in Ireland And as they were Natives of the Kingdom so the Kingdom it self did pay their wages without expecting any treasure out of England BUt now the wars of Lancaster
Irish did not exceed the number of twelve hundred men as appeareth by the Treasurers Accompt of Ireland now remaining in the Exchequer of England With these Forces did Sir Henry Sidney then Lord Deputy march into the farthest parts of Tirone and joyning with Captain Randal did much distress but not fully defeat O Neal who was afterwards slain upon a meer accident by the Scots and not by the Queens Army TO prosecute the Wars in Munster against Desmond and his Adherents there were transmitted out of England at several times three or four thousand men which together with the standing Garrisons and some other supplies raised here made at one time an Army of six thousand and upwards which with the Vertue and Valour of Arthur Lord Gray and others the Commanders did prove a sufficient power to extinguish that Rebellion But that being done it was never intended that these Forces should stand till the rest of the Kingdom were settled and reduced onely that Army which was brought over by the Earl of Essex Lord Lieutenant and Governor General of this Kingdom in the nine and thirtieth year of Queen Elizabeth to suppress the Rebellion of Tirone which was spread universally over the whole Realm That Army I say the command whereof with the Government of the Realm was shortly after transferred to the command of the Lord Montjoy afterwards Earl of Devonshire who with singular wisdom valour and industry did prosecute and finish the War did consist of such good men of War and of such numbers being well-nigh twenty thousand by the Poll and was so royally supplied and paid and continued in full strength so long a time as that it brake and absolutely subdued all the Lords and Chieftains of the Irishry and degenerate or rebellious English Whereupon the multitude who ever loved to be followers of such as could master and defend them admiring the power of the Crown of England being bray'd as it were in a Morter with the Sword Famine and Pestilence altogether submitted themselves to the English Government received the Laws and Magistrates and most gladly embraced the Kings Pardon and Peace in all parts of the Realm with demonstration of joy and comfort which made indeed an entire perfect and final Conquest of Ireland And though upon the finishing of the War this great Army was reduced to less numbers yet hath His Majestie in his Wisdom thought it fit still to maintain such competent Forces here as the Law may make her progress and Circuit about the Realm under the protection of the Sword as Virgo the figure of Justice is by Leo in the Zodiack until the people have perfectly learned the Lesson of Obedience and the Conquest be established in the hearts of all men THus far have I endeavoured to make it manifest that from the first adventure and attempt of the English to subdue and conquer Ireland until the last War with Tyrone which as it was Royally undertaken so it was really prosecuted to the end there hath been four main defects in the carriage of the Martial Affairs here First the Armies for the most part were too weak for a Conquest Secondly when they were of a competent strength as in both the journeys of Richard the second they were too soon broken up and dissolved Thirdly they were ill paid And fourthly they were ill governed which is always a consequent of ill payment BUt why was not this great work performed before the latter end of Queen Elizabeths Reign considering that many of the Kings her Progenitors were as great Captains as any in the World and had elsewhere larger Dominions and Territories First who can tell whether the Divine Wisdom to abate the glory of those Kings did not reserve this Work to be done by a Queen that it might rather appear to be his own immediate work And yet for her greater Honor made it the last of her great actions as it were to Crown all the rest And to the end that a secure peace might settle the Conquest and make it firm and perpetual to Posterity caused it to be made in that fulness of time when England and Scotland became to be united under one Imperial Crown and when the Monarchy of Great Britany was in League and Amity with all the World Besides the Conquest at this time doth perhaps fulfil that prophesie wherein the four great Prophets of Ireland do concur as it is recorded by Giraldus Cambrensis to this effect That after the first Invasion of the English they should spend many ages in crebris conflictibus longoque certamine multis caedibus And that Omnes fere Anglici ab Hibernia turbabuntur nihilominus orientalia maritima semper obtinebunt Sed vix paulo antè diem Judicii plenam Anglorum populo victoriam compromittunt Insula Hibernica de mari usque ad mare de toto subacta incastellata If S. Patrick and the rest did not utter this Prophesie certainly Giraldus is a Prophet who hath reported it To this we may adde the Prophesie of Merlin spoken of also by Giraldus Sextus moenia Hiberniae subvertet regiones in Regnum redigentur Which is performed in the time of King James the sixth in that all the paces are cleared and places of fastness laid open which are the proper Walls and Castles of the Irish as they were of the British in the time of Agricola and withall the Irish Countreys being reduced into Counties make but one entire and undivided Kingdom But to leave these high and obscure causes the plain and manifest truth is that the Kings of England in all ages had been powerful enough to make an absolute Conquest of Ireland if their whole power had been employed in that enterprize but still there arose sundry occasions which divided and diverted their power some other way Let us therefore take a brief view of the several impediments which arose in every Kings time since the first Overture of the Conquest whereby they were so employed and busied as they could not intend the final Conquest of Ireland KIng Henry the second was no sooner returned out of Ireland but all his four Sons conspired with his Enemies rose in Arms and moved War against him both in France and in England This unnatural Treason of his Sons did the King express in an Emblem painted in his Chamber at Winchester wherein was an Eagle with three Eglets tiring â—n her breast and the fourth pecking at one of her eyes And the troth is these ungracious practises of his Sons did impeach his journey to the Holy-Land which he had once vowed vexed him all the days of his life and brought his gray hairs with sorrow to the grave Besides this King having given the Lordship of Ireland to John his youngest Son â— his ingratitude afterwards made the King careless to settle him in the quiet and absolute possession of that Kingdom RIchard the first which succeeded
Henry the second in the Kingdom of England had less reason to bend his power towards the Conquest of this Land which was given in perpetuity to the Lord John his Brother And therefore went he in person to the Holy War by which journey and his Captivity in Austria and the heavy ransome that he paid for his liberty he was hindred and utterly disabled to pursue any so great an action as the Conquest of Ireland And after his delivery and return hardly was he able to maintain a Frontier War in Normandy where by hard fortune he lost his life KIng John his Brother had greatest reason to prosecute the War of Ireland because the Lordship thereof was the portion of his inheritance given unto him when he was called John Sans-Terre Therefore he made two journeys thither one when he was Earl of Morton and very young about twelve years of age the other when he was King in the twelfth year of his Reign In the the first his own youth and his youthful company Roboams Counsellors made him hazard the loss of all that his Father had won But in the latter he shewed a resolution to recover the entire Kingdom in taking the submissions of all the Irishry and settling the estates of the English and giving order for the building of many Castles and Forts whereof some remain until this day But he came to the Crown of England by a defeasible Title so as he was never well settled in the hearts of the people which drew him the sooner back out of Ireland into England where shortly after he fell into such trouble and distress The Clergy cursing him on the one side and the Barons Rebelling against him on the other as he became so far unable to return to the Conquest of Ireland as besides the forfeiture of the Territories in France he did in a manner lose both the Kingdoms For he surrendred both to the Pope and took them back again to hold in Fee-farm which brought him into such hatred at home and such contempt abroad as all his life time after he was possest rather with fear of loosing his head than with hope of reducing the Kingdom of Ireland DUring the infancy of Henry the third the Barons were troubled in expelling the French whom they had drawn in against King John But this Prince was no sooner come to his majority but the Barons raised a long and cruel war against him Into these troubled waters the Bishops of Rome did cast their Nets and drew away all the wealth of the realm by their provisions and infinite exactions whereby the Kingdom was so impoverished as the King was scarce able to feed his own houshold and train much less to nourish Armies for the conquest of Forraign Kingdoms And albeit he had given this Land to the Lord Edward his eldest son yet could not that worthy Prince ever find means or opportunity to visit this Kingdom in person For from the time he was able to bear armes he served continually against the Barons by whom he was taken prisoner at the battel of Lewes And when that rebellion was appeased he made a journey to the Holy Land an employment which in those dayes diverted all Christian Princes from performing any great actions in Europe from whence he was returned when the Crown of England descended upon him THis King Edward the first who was a Prince adorned with all vertues did in the managing of his affairs shew himself a right good husband who being Owner of a Lordship ill husbanded doth first enclose and mannure his demeasnes near his principal house before he doth improve his wasts afar off Therefore he began first to establish the Common-wealth of England by making many excellent Laws and instituting the form of publick Justice which remaineth to this day Next he fully subdued and reduced the Dominion of Wales then by his power and authority he setled the Kingdom of Scotland and lastly he sent a Royal army into Cascoigne to recover the Dutchy of Aquitain These four great actions did take up all the raign of this Prince And therefore we find not in any Record that this King transmitted any Forces into Ireland but on the other side we find it recorded both in the Annals and in the Pipe-Rolls of this Kingdom that three several Armies were raised of the Kings subjects in Ireland and transported one into Scotland another into Wales and the third into Cascoigne and that several aids were levyed here for the setting forth of those armies THe Son and Successor of this excellent Prince was Edward the second who much against his will sent one small army into Ireland not with a purpose to finish the Conquest but to guard the person of his Minion Piers Gaveston who being banished out of England was made Lieutenant of Ireland that so his exile might seem more honourable He was no sooner arrived here but he made a journey into the Mountains of Dublin brake and subdued the Rebels there built New-Castle in the Birnes Country and repaired Castlekeuin and after passed up into Mounster and Thomond performing every where great service with much Vertue and Valour But the King who could not live without him revokt him within less than a year After which time the invasion of the Scots and Rebellion of the Barons did not only disable this King to be a Conqueror but deprived him both of his Kingdom and life And when the Scottish nation had over-run all this land under the conduct of Edw. le Bruce who stiled himself King of Ireland England was not then able to send either men or mony to save this Kingdom Only Roger de Mortimer then Justice of Ireland arrived at Youghall cum 38. milit saith Friar Clinn in his Annals But Bremingham Verdon Stapleton and some other private Gentlemen rose out with the Commons of Meth and Vriel and at Fagher near Dondalke a fatal place to the enemies of the Crown of England overthrew a potent army of them Et sic saith the red Book of the Exchequer wherein the victory was briefly recorded per manus communis populi dextram dei deliberatur populus dei a servitute machinata praecogitata IN the time of King Edward the third the impediments of the Conquest of Ireland are so notorious as I shall not need to express them to wit the war which the King had with the Realms of Scotland and of France but especially the Wars of France which were almost continual for the space of forty years And indeed France was a fairer mark to shoot at than Ireland and could better reward the Conqueror Besides it was an inheritance newly descended upon the King and therefore he had great reason to bend all his power and spend all his time and treasure in the recovery thereof And this is the true cause why Edward the third sent no army into Ireland till the 36. year of his
Reign when the Lord Lionel brought over a Regiment of 1500. men as is before expressed which that wise and warlick Prince did not transmit as a competent power to make a full conquest but as an honorable retinue for his son and withall to enable him to recover some part of his Earldom of Vlster which was then over-run with the Irish But on the other part though the English Colonies were much degenerate in this Kings time and had lost a great part of their possessions yet lying at the siege of Callis he sent for a supply of men out of Ireland which were transported under the conduct of the Earl of Kildare and Fulco de lâ— Freyn in the year 1347. AND now are we come again to the time of King Richard the second who for the first ten years of his Reign was a Minor and much disquieted with popular Commotions and after that was more troubled with the factions that arose between his Minions and the Princes of the blood But at last he took a resolution to finish the Conquest of this Realm And to that end he made two Royal voyages hither Upon the first he was deluded by the faigned submissions of the Irish but upon the latter when he was fully bent to prosecute the war with effect he was diverted and drawn from hence by the return of the Duke of Lancaster into England and the general defection of the whole Realm AS for Henry the Fourth he being an Intruder upon the Crown of England was hindered from all Forraign actions by sundry Conspiracies and Rebellions at home moved by the house of Northumberland in the North by the Dukes of Surrey and Exceter in the South and by Owen Glendour in Wales so as he spent his short Raign in establishing and setling himself in the quiet possession of England and had neither leisure nor opportunity to undertake the final conquest of Ireland Much less could King Henry the fifth perform that work for in the second year of his Reign he transported an Army into France for the recovery of that Kingdom and drew over to the siege of Harflew the Prior of Kilmaineham with 1500. Irish In which great action this victorious Prince spent the rest of his life AND after his death the two Noble Princes his Brothers the Duke of Bedford and Glocester who during the minority of King Henry the sixth had the Government of the Kingdoms of England and France did employ all their Counsels and endeavours to perfect the Conquest of France the greater part whereof being gained by Henry the fifth and retained by the Duke of Bedford was again lost by King Henry the sixth a manifest argument of his disability to finish the Conquest of this Land But when the civil War between the two Houses was kindled the Kings of England were so far from reducing all the Irish under their Obedience as they drew out of Ireland to strengthen their parties all the Nobility and Gentry descended of English race which gave opportunity to the Irishry to invade the Lands of the English Colonies and did hazard the Loss of the whole Kingdom For though the Duke of York did while he lived in Ireland carry himself respectively towards all the Nobility to win the general love of all bearing equal favour to the Giraldines and the Butlers as appeared at the Christning of George Duke of Clarence who was born in the Castle of Dublin where he made both the Earl of Kildare and the Earl of Ormonde his Gossips And having occasion divers times to pass into England he left the sword with Kildare at one time and with Ormonde at another and when he lost his life at Wakefield there were slain with him divers of both those families Yet afterwards thâ—se two Noble houses of Ireland did severally follow the two Royal houses of England the Giraldines adhering to the house of York and the Butlers to the house of Lancaster Whereby it came to pass that not only the principal Gentlemen of both those Sur-names but all their friends and dependants did pass into England leaving their Lands and possessions to be over-run by the Irish These impediments or rather impossibilities of finishing the Conquest of Ireland did continue till the Wars of Lancaster and York were ended which was about the twelfth year of King Edward the fourth Thus hitherto the Kings of England were hindred from finishing this Conquest by great and apparent impediments Henry the second by the rebellion of his Sons King John Henry the third and Edward the second by the Barons Wars Edward the first by his Wars in Wales and Scotland Edward the third and Henry the fifth by the Wars of France Richard the second Henry the fourth Henry the sixth and Edward the fourth by Domestick contention for the Crown of England it self BUT the fire of the civil war being utterly quenched and King Edward the fourth setled in the peaceable possession of the Crown of England what did then hinder that warâ—ick Prince from reducing of Ireland also First the whole Realm of England was miserably wasted depopulated and impoverished by the late civil dissentions yet as soon as it had recovered it self with a little peace and rest this King raised an Army and revived the Title of France again howbeit this Army was no sooner transmitted and brought into the field but the two Kings also were brought to an interview Whereupon partly by the fair and white promises of Lewis the 11. and partly by the corruption of some of King Edwards Minions the English forces were broken and dismissed and King Edward returned into England where shortly after findâ—ng himself deluded and abused by the French he dyed with melancholy and vexation of spirit I Omit to speak of Richard the Usurper who never got the quiet possession of England but was cast out by Henry the seventh within two years and a half after his Usurpation AND for King Henry the seventh himself though he made that happy Union of the two houses yet for more than half the space of his Reign there were walking spirits of the house of Yorke as well in Ireland as in England which he could not conjure down without expence of some bloud and Treasure But in his later times he did wholly study to improve the Revenues of the Crown in both Kingdomes with an intent to provide means for some great action which he intended which doubtless if he had lived would rather have proved a journey into France than into Ireland because in the eyes of all men it was a fairer enterprize THerefore King Henry the eighth in the beginning of his raign made a Voyage Royal into France wherein he spent the greatest part of that treasure which his Father had frugally reserved perhaps for the like purpose In the latter end of his Reign he made the like journey being enricht with the Revenues of the Abby Lands But in the
Sir Richard Capel Prisoner with divers Lords of Munster being then in his Company In the year 1288. Richard Bourke Earl of Vlster commonly called the Red Earl pretending title to the Lordship of Meath made war upon Sir Theobald de Verdun and besieged him in the Castle of Athlone Again in the year 1292. John Fitz-Thomas the Geraldine having by contention with the Lord Vesci gotten a goodly inheritance in Kildare grew to that heighth of imagination saith the story as he fell into difference with divers great Noblemen and among many others with Richard the Red Earl whom he took Prisoner and detained him in Castle-Ley and by that dissention the English on the one side and the Irish on the other did waste and destroy all the Countrey After in the year 1311. the same Red Earl coming to besiege Bonratty in Thomond which was then held by Sir Richard de Clare as his inheritance was again taken prisoner And all his Army consisting for the most part of English overthrown and cut in pieces by Sir Richard de Clare And after this again in the year 1327. most of the great Houses were banded one against another viz. The Giraldines Butlers and Breminghams on the one side and the Bourks and Poers on the other The ground of the quarrel being none other but that the Lord Arnold Poer had called the Earl of Kildare Rimer But this quarrel was prosecuted with such malice and violence as the Counties of Waterford and Kilkenny were destroyed with fire and sword till a Parliament was called of purpose to quiet this dissention Shortly after the Lord John Bremingham who was not long before made Earl of Louth for that noble service which he performed upon the Scots between â—undalk and the Faher was so extremely envied by the Gernons Verdons and others of the ancient Colony planted in the County of Louth as that in the year 1329. they did most wickedly betray and murther that Earl with divers principal Gentlemen of his name and family using the same speech that the Rebellious Jews are said to use in the Gospel Nolumus hunc regnare super nos After this the Geraldines and the Butlers being become the most potent families in the Kingdom for the great Lordship of Leinster was divided among Coparceners whose Heirs for the most part lived in England and the Earldom of Vlster with the Lordship of Meath by the match of Lionel Duke of Clarence at last discended upon the Crowne had almost a continuall warre one with another In the time of King Henry the sixt saith Baron Finglas in his Discourse of the Decay of Ireland in a sight betweene the Earles of Ormond and Desmond almost all the Townes-men of Kilkenny were slaine And as they followed contrary parties during the Warres of Yorke and Lancaster so after that civil dissention ended in England these Houses in Ireland continued their opposition and feud still even till the time of K. Henry the eight when by the Marriage of Margaret Fitz-Girald to the Earl of Ossory the houses of Kildare and Ormond were reconciled and have continued in amity ever since Thus these great Estates and Royalties granted to the English Lords in Ireland begate Pride and Pride begat Contention among themselves which brought forth divers mischiefs that did not onely disable the English to finish the conquest of all Ireland but did endanger the loss of what was already gained And of Conquerors made them Slaves to that Nation which they did intend to Conquer For whensoever one English Lord had vanquished another the Irish waited and took the opportunity and fell upon that Countrey which had received the blow and so daily recovered some part of the Lands which were possessed by the English Colonies Besides the English Lords to strengthen their parties did ally themselves with the Irish and drew them in to dwell among them gave their Children to be fostered by them and having no other means to pay or reward them suffered them to take Coigne and Livery upon the English Free-holders which Oppression was so intollerable as that the better sort were enforced to quit their Free-holds and flye into England and never returned though many Laws were made in both Realms to remand them back again and the rest which remained became degenerate and meer Irish as is before declared And the English Lords finding the Irish exactions to be more profitable than the English Rents and services and loving the Irish Tyranny which was tyed to no Rules of Law or Honour better than a just and lawful Seigniory did reject and cast off the English Law and Government received the Irish Laws and Customs took Irish Surnames as Mac William Mac Pheris Mac Yoris refused to come to the Parliaments which were summoned by the King of Englands Authority and scorned to obey those English Knights which were sent to command and govern this Kingdom Namely Sir Richard Capel Sir John Morris Sir John Darcy and Sir Raphe Vfford And when Sir Anthony Lucy a man of great Authority in the time of King Edward the third was sent over to reform the notorious abuses of this Kingdom the King doubting that he should not be obeyed directed a special Writ or Mandate to the Earl of Vlster and the rest of the Nobility to assist him And afterwards the same King upon good advise and Counsel resumed those excessive Grants of Lands and Liberties in Ireland by a special ordinance made in England which remaineth of Record in the Tower in this form Quia plures excessivoe donationes terrarum libertatum in Hibernia ad subdolam machinationem petentium factae sunt c. Rex delusorias hujusmodi machinationes volens elidere de consilio peritorum sibi assistentium omnes donationes Terrarum libertatum praedict duxit revocandas quousque de meritis donatoriorum causis ac qualitatibus donationum melius fuerit informat ideo mandatum est Justiciario Hiberniae quod seisiri faciat c. Howbeit there followed upon this resumption such a division and faction between the English of Birth and the English of blood and race as they summoned and held several Parliaments apart one from the other Whereupon there had risen a general war betwixt them to the utter extinguishing of the English Name and Nation in Ireland if the Earl of Desmond who was head of the faction against the English of Birth had not been sent into England and detained there for a time yet afterwards these liberties being restored by direction out of England the 26. of Edward the third complaint was made to the King of the easie restitution whereunto the King made answer as is before expressed so as we may conclude this point with that which we find in the Aâ—nals published by Master Camden Hâ—bernici debellati consumpti fuissent nisi seditio Anglicorum impedivisseâ— Whereunto I may add this note that though some are of opinion that
work in the third year of his raign made the Lord Thomas of Lancaster his second son Lieutenant of Ireland Who came over in person and accepted again the submissions of divers Irish Lords and Captains as is before remembred and held also a Parliament wherein he gave new life to the Statutes of Kilkenny and made other good Laws tending to the Reformation of the Kingdom But the troubles raised against the King his Father in England drew him home again so soon as that seed of reformation took no root at all neither had his service in that kind any good effect or success After this the State of England had no leisure to think of a general reformation in this Realm till the civil dissentions of England were appeased and the peace of that Kingdom setled by King Henry the seventh For albeit in the time of King Henry 6. Richard Duke of York a Prince of the blood of great wisdom and valour and heir to a third part of Kingdom at least being Earl of Vlster and Lord of Conaght and Meath was sent the Kings Lieutenanr into Ireland to recover and reform that Realm where he was resident in person for the greatest part of ten years yet the troth is he aimed at another mark which was the Crown of England And therefore he thought it no pollicy to distast either the English or Irish by a course of Reformation but sought by all means to please them and by popular courses to steal away their hearts to the end he might strengthen his party when he should set on foot his Title as is before declared Which pollicy of his took such effect as that he drew over with him into England the Flower of all the English Colonies especially of Vlster and Meath whereof many Noblemen and Gentlemen were slain with him at Wakefield as is likewise before remembred And after his death when the wars between the Houses were in their heat almost all the good English blood which was left in Ireland was spent in those civil dissentions so as the Irish became victorious over all without blood or sweat Only that little Canton of Land called the English Pale containing four small Shires did maintain a bordering was with the Irish and retain the forme of English Government But out of that little Precinct there were no Lords Knights or Burgesses summoned to the Parliament neither did the Kings Writ run in any other part of the Kingdom and yet upon the Marches and Borders which at that time were grown so large as they took up half Dublin half Meath and a third part of Kildare and Lowth there was no law in use but the March-Law which in the Statutes of Kilkenny is said to be no law but a leud Custom So as upon the end of these civil wars in England the English Law and Government was well nigh banisht out of Ireland so as no foot-step or print was left of any former Reformation THen did King Henry 7. send over Sir Edward Poynings to be his Deputy a right worthy servitor both in war and peace The principal end of his employment was to expel Perkin Warbecke out of this Kingdom but that service being performed that worthy Deputy finding nothing but a common misery took the best course he possibly could to establish a Common-wealth in Ireland and to that end he held a Parliament no less famous than that of Kilkenny and more available for the reformation of the whole Kingdom For whereas all wise men did ever concur in opinion that the readiest way to reform Ireland is to settle a form of Civil Government there conformable to that of England To bring this to pass Sir Edward Poynings did pass an Act whereby all the Statutes made in England before that time were enacted established and made of force in Ireland Neither did he only respect the time past but provided also for the time to come For he caused another Law to be made that no Act should be propounded in any Parliament of Ireland but such as should be first transmitted into England and approved by the King and Council there as good and expedient for that Land and so returned back again under the Great Seal of England This Act though it seem Prima facie to restrain the liberty of the Subjects of Ireland yet was it made at the Prayer of the Commons upon just and important cause For the Governors of that Realm specially such as were of that Country Birth had laid many oppressions upon the Commons and amongst the rest they had imposed Laws upon them nor tending to the general good but to serve private turns and to strengthen their particular factions This moved them to refer all Laws that were to be passed in Ireland to be considered corrected and allowed first by the State of England which had alwayes been tender and carefull of the good of this people and had long since made them a Civil Rich and Happy Nation if their own Lords and Governors there had not sent bad intelligence into England Besides this he took special order that the summons of Parliament should go into all the shires of Ireland and not to the four shires onely and for that cause specially he caused all the Acts of a Parliament lately before holden by the Viscount of Gormanston to be repealed and made void Moreover that the Parliaments of Ireland might want no decent or honorable form that was used in England he caused a particular Act to pass that the Lords of Ireland should appear in the like Parliament Robes as the English Lords are wont to wear in the Parliaments of England Having thus established all the Statutes of England in Ireland and set in order the great Council of that Realm he did not omit to pass other Laws as well for the encrease of the Kings Revenue as the preservation of the publick peace To advance the profits of the Crown First he obtained a Subsidy of 26 shillings eight pence out of every six score acres manured payable yearly for five years Next he resumed all the Crownland which had been aliened for the most part by Richard Duke of York and lastly he procured a Subsidy of Pondage out of all Merchandizes imported and exported to be granted to the Crown in perpetuity To preserve the publick peace he revived the Statutes of Kilkenny He made wilful Murther High-treason he caused the Marchers to book their men for whom they should answer and restrained the making War or Peace without special Commission from the State These Laws and others as important as these for the making of a Common-wealth in Ireland were made in the Government of Sir Edward Poynings But these Laws did not spread their Vertue beyond the English Pale though they were made generally for the whole Kingdom For the Provinces without the Pale which during the War of York and Lancaster had wholly cast off the the English Government were not apt to receive this
Egypt in Pharaohs Dream devouring the fat of England and yet remaining as lean as it was before it will hereafter be as fruitfull as the land of Canaan the description whereof in the 8. of Deutronomy doth in every part agree with Ireland being Terra Rivorum aquarumque fontium in cujus Campis Montibus erumpunt fluviorum abyssi Terra frumenti hordei Terra lactis mellis ubi absque ulla penuria comedes panem tuum rerum abundantia perfrueris And thus I have discovered and expressed the defects and Errors as well in the managing of the Martial Affairs as of the civil which in former Ages gave impediment to the reducing of all Ireland to the Obedience and Subjection of the Crown of England I have likewise observed what courses have been taken to reform the Defects and Errors in Government and to reduce the People of this Land to obedience since the beginning of the raign of King Edward 3. till the latter end of the raign of Queen Elizabeth And lastly I have declared and set forth How all the said errors have been corrected and the defects supplyed under the prosperous Government of His Majesty So as I may positively conclude in the same words which I have used in the Title of this Discourse That untill the beginning of His Majesties Raign Ireland was never entirely subdued and brought under the Obedience of the Crown of England But since the Crown of of this Kingdom with the undoubted right and Title thereof descended upon His Majesty The whole Island from Sea to Sea hath been brought into his Highness peaceable possession and all the Inhabitants in every corner thereof have been absolutely reduced under his immediate subjection In which condition of Subjects they will gladly continue without defection or adhaering to any other Lord or King as long as they may be Protected and justly Governed without Oppression on the one side or impunity on the other For there is no Nation of people under the Sun that doth love equal and indifferent Justice better than the Irish or will rest better satisfied with the execution thereof although it be against themselves so as they may have the protection and benefit of the Law when upon just cause they do desire it FINIS Two main impediments of the conquest The faint prosecution of the war What is a perfect Conquest How the war hath been prosecuted since the 17 year of Henry the second In the time of Henry the second Giraldus Cambrensis The first attempt but an adventure of private Gentlemen With what forces the King himself come over Archiu Remem Regis apud West What manner of Conquest K. Henry the second made of Ireland Bodin de Repub. The true marks of Soveraignty Hoveden in Henrico secundo fol. 312. 6 Johannis Claus membrana 18.17 Johannis Chart. m. 3. 6. Hen. 3. chart m. 2. Archiu in Castro Dublin â—2 Hen. 3. Coâ—poâ—â—â— Will de la Zouch 36. Hâ—n 3. â—omâ—â—tus Huberti de Rouly How the warâ— was prosecuted in the time of King John Giraldus Cambrensis Giraldus Cambrensis Geraldus Cambrensis Matth. Pacis in Richardo primo â—â— 15 19. Matth. Paris This Charter yet remaineth perfect with an entire Seal in the treasury at Westminster Archiu in Castro Dublin Archiu Turr. 52â— Hen. 3 patent m. 9. How the martial affairs were carried from the 12 year of King John to the 36. year of King Edward the Third Archiu in Castro Dublin Stat. 10. H. 7. c. 4. rot Parliam in Castro Dublin Annales Hiberniae in Camden Baron Finglas Manus Stat. 10. H 7. cap. 4. Rot. Parli in Castro Dublin Stat. 11. H. 4. c. 6. Baron Finglas M. S. The Army transmitted with Lionel Duke of Clarence the 36 of Edw. 3. Archiu Remem Regis apud Westm The manner of levying Souldiers informer ages What service Lionel Duke of Clarence performed Archiu Tur. 36. Edw. 3 Claus m. 21. in dorso m. 30. â—â—r Will. Winsor Lieutenant 47 Ed. 3. his forces service 47 Ed 3. Claus m. 1. Stow in Rich 2. The state of the revenue of Ireland in the time of Edw. 3. Walsingham in Rich. 2. Archiu Turr. 11 H. 3. patent m. 3. 21 Ed. 3. m. 41. 47 Ed. 3. claus pers 2. m. 24. 26. Archiu in Castro Dublin Hollingshead in R. 2. Archiu in Castro Dublin 5 Edw 3. How the war proceeded in the time of King Richard the second 3 Rich. 2. Archiu Tur Rot. Parl. 42. Pat. 2. pars 9. Rich. 2. m. 24. Walsingham in Rich. 2. Annales Tho. Otterbourne Manuscript Stow in Rich. 2â— Archiu in officio Rememorat regis apud Westmon Hollingshead in Richard the 2. Henry 4. The Lord Thomas of Lancaster his service Archiu Rememorat regis apud Westm Henry 5. The Lord Furnival his service Alb. libr. Scacc. Dublin Henry 6. Richard Duke of York his service Archiu in Castro Dublin Hollingshead in Henry the sixth Rot. Parl. in Castro Dublin Archiu Tur. 17. Hen. 6. Clausam 20. Manuscript of Baron Finglas Hollingshead in Hen. 6. Edw. 4. How the War was maintained in the time of King Edw. 4. Hollingshead in Edw. 4. Book of Howth Mâ—rus The fraternity of Saint George in Ireland 14. of Edw. 4. Rot. Parl. Dublin Henry 7. How the war was prosecuted in time of K Hen. 7. Arâ—â—â—â— Remem Regis apud West The book of Howth Manus Holinshead in Hen. 7. Sir Ed Poynings service Rot. Parl. in Castro Dublin The book of Howth The battle of Knocktow Henry 8. How the war was carried during the reign of King Henry the eight The Earl of Surries service The Lord Leonard Grayes service The fight at Belahoo Book of Howth Manus Sir Anthony St. Leger Sir Edw. Bâ—llingham in the time of King Edw. 6. Archiu Remem Regis apud West ' Tho Earl of Sussex in the time of Queen Mary Queen Elizabeth How the war was prosecuted in the time of Qu Elizabeth Shane O Neales Rebellion Archiu Remem Regis apud Westm Desmonds Rebellion Tyrones Rebellion Four main defects in the prosecution of the War Why none of the Kings of England before Qu. Elizabeth did finish the conquest of Ireland Giraldus Cambrensis How the several Kings of England were diverted from the Conquest of Ireland King Henry 2. The book of Howth Manus Rich. 1. K. John Henry 3. Edw. 1. Archiu in Castro Dublin Annales Hiberniae in Camden Edw. 2. Annales Hiberniae in Camden Archiu in Castro Dublin Manuscript of Friar Clinn Rubr. libr. Scac. Dublin Edw. 3. Annales Hiberniae in Cam den Rich. 2. Henry 4. Henry 5. Annales Hiberniae in Camden Henry 6. Hollingshead in Hen. 6. Manuscript of Baron Finglas Edw. 4. Rich. 3. Henry 7. Henry 8. King Edward 6. and Qu. Mary Qu. Elizabeth 2. The defects in the Civil Policy government 1. The Laws of England were not given to the meer Irish Matth. Paris Hist major fol. 121. Matth. Paris Histor major 220 b.
time was securely setled in peace and Obedience and hath attained to that Civility of Manners and plenty of all things as now we find it not inferiour to the best parts of England I will therefore knit up this point with these conclusions First that the Kings of England which in former Ages attempted the Conquest of Ireland being ill advised and counselled by the great men here did not upon the submissions of the Irish communicate their Laws unto them nor admit them to the state and condition of Free-subjects Secondly that for the space of 200. years at â—east after the first arrival of Henry the second in Ireland the Irish would gladly have embraced the Laws of England and did earnestly desire the benefit and protection thereof which being denyed them did of necessity cause a continual bordering war between the English and the Irish And lastly if according to the examples before recited they had reduced as well the Irish Countries as the English Colonies under one form of civil government as now they are the Meers and Bounds of the Marches and Borders had been long since worne out and forgotten for it is not fit as Cambrensis writeth that a King of an Island should have any Marches or Borders but the four Seas both Nations had been incorporated and united Ireland had been entirely Conquered Planted and Improved and returned a rich Revenue to the Crâ—wn of England THE next error in the Civil pollicy which hindered the perfection of the Conquest of Ireland did consist in the Distribution of the Lands and Possessions which were won and conquered from the Irish For the Scopes of Land which were granted to the first Adventures were too large and the Liberties and Royalties which they obtained therein were too great for Subjects though it stood with reason that they should be rewarded liberally out of the fruits of their own Labours since they did Militare propriis stipendiis and received no pay from the Crown of England Notwithstanding there ensued divers inconveniences that gave great impediment to the Conquest FIrst the Earl Strongbow was entituled to the whole Kingdom of Leinster partly by Invasion and partly by Marriage albeit he surrendred the same entirely to King Henry the second his Soveraign for that with his license he came over and with the Ayd of his Subjects he had gained that great inheritance yet did the King regrant back again to him and his Heirs all that Province reserving onely the City of Dublin and the Cantreds next adjoyning with the Maritime Towns and principal Forts and Castles Next the same King granted to Robert Fitz-Stephen and Miles Cogan the whole Kingdom of Cork from Lismore to the Sea To Phillip Bruce he gave the whole Kingdom of Limerick with the Donation of Bishopwricks and Abbies except the City and one Cantred of land adjoyning To Sir Hugh de Lacy all Meath To Sir John de Courcy all Vlster To William Burke Fitz-Adelm the greatest part of Conaght In like manner Sir Thomas de Clare obtained a grant of all Thomond and Otho de Grandison of all Tipperary and Robert le Poer of the Territory of Waterford the City it self and the Cantred of the Oastmen only excepted And thus was all Ireland Cantonized among ten persons of the English Nation and though they had not gained the possession of one third part of the whole Kingdom yet in Title they were Owners and Lords of all so as nothing was left to be granted to the Natives And therefore we do not find in any Record or story for the space of three hundred years after these Adventurers first arived in Ireland that any Irish Lord obtained a grant of his Country from the Crown but onely the King of Thomond who had a grant but during King Henry the third his Minority and Rotherick O Connor King of Conaght to whom King Henry the second before this distribution made did grant as is before declared Vt sit Rex sub eo and moreover Vt teneat terram suam Conactiae it a bene in pace sicut tenuit antequam Dominus Rex intravit Hiberniam And whose Successor in the 24 of Henry the third when the Bourkes had made a strong Plantation there and had well-nigh expelled him out of his Territory he came over into England as Matth. Paris writeth and made complaint to King Henry the third of this Invasion made by the Bourkes upon his Land insisting upon the grants of King Henry the second and King John and affirming that he had duely paid an yearly tribute of five thousand marks for his Kingdom Whereupon the King called unto him the Lord Maurice fitz-Girald who was then Lord Justice of Ireland and President in the Court and commanded him that he should root out that unjust plantation which Hubert Earl of Kent had in the time of his greatness planted in those parts and wrote withal to the great men of Ireland to remove the Bourks and to establish the King of Conaght in the quiet possession of his Kingdom Howbeit I do not read that the King of Englands commandment or direction in this behalf was ever put in execution For the troth is Richard de Burgo had obtained a grant of all Conaght after the death of the King of Conaght then living For which he gave a thousand pound as the Record in the Tower reciteth the third of Henry the third claus 2. And besides our great English Lords could not endure that any Kings should Reign in Ireland but themselves nay they could hardly endure that the Crown of England it self should have any Jurisdiction or Power over them For many of these Lords to whom our Kings had granted these petty Kingdoms did by vertue and colour of these Grants claim and exercise Jura Regalia within their Territories insomuch as there were no less than eight Counties Palatines in Ireland at one time For William Marshal Earl of Pembroke who married the Daughter and Heir of Strongbow being Lord of all Leinster had Royal Jurisdiction thoroughout all that Province This great Lord had five sons and five daughters every of his sons enjoyed that Seigniory successively and yet all dyed without issue Then this great Lordship was broken and divided and partition made between the five daughters who were married into the Noblest Houses of England The County of Catherlough was allotted to the eldest Wexford to the secâ—nd Kilkenny to the third Kildare to the fourth the greatest part of Leix now called the Queens County to the fifth In every of these portions the Ceparceners severally exercised the same Jurisdiction Royal which the Earl Marshal and his Sons had used in the whole Province Whereby it came to pass that there were five County Palatines erected in Leinster Then had the Lord of Meath the same Royal liberty in all that Territory the Earl of Vlster in all that Province and the
both Kingdoms than it did at any time since the Norman Conquest Then did the State of England send over John de Hotham to be Treasurer here with commission to call the great Lords of Ireland together and to take of them an Oath of Association that they should loyally joyn together in life and death to preserve the right of the King of England and to expel the common enemy But this Treasurer brought neither men nor mony to perform this service At that time though Richard Bourk Earl of Vlster commonly called the Red Earl were of greater power than any other Subject in Ireland yet was he so far stricken in years as that he was unable to manage the martial affairs as he had done during all the raign of King Edward the first having been General of the Irish forces not only in this Kingdom but in the Wars of Scotland Wales and Gascoign And therefore Maurice Fitz-Thomas of Desmond being then the most active Noble man in this Realm took upon him the chief command in this War for the support whereof the Revenue of this Land was farr too short and yet no supply of Treasure was sent out of England Then was there no means to maintain the Army but by Sessing the Soldiers upon the Subject as the Irish were wont to impose their Bonaught Whereupon grew that wicked Extortion of Coigne and Livery spoken of before which in short time banished the greatest part of the Free-holders out of the County of Kerry Limerirk Corke and Waterford Into whose possessions Desmond and his Kinsemen Allies and Followers which were then more Irish than English did enter and appropriate these Lands unto themselves Desmond himself taking what scopes he best liked for his demeasnes in every Countrey and reserving an Irish Seigniory out of the rest And here that I may verifie and maintain by matter of Record that which is before delivered touching the Nature of this wicked Extortion called Coigne and Livery and the manifold mischiefs it did produce I think it fit and pertinent to insert the preamble of the Statute of 10. of Henry seventh c. 4. not printed but recorded in Parliament Rols of Dublin in these words At the request and supplication of the Commons of this Land of Ireland that where of long time there hath been used and exacted by the Lords and Gentlemen of this Land many and divers damnable customs and usages which been called Coigne and Livery and Pay that is Horse meat and Mans meat for the finding of their Horsemen and Foot-men and over that 4. d. or 6. d. daily to every of them to be had and paid of the poor Earth Tillers and Tenants inhabitants of the said Land without any thing doing or paying therefore Besides many Murders Robberies Rapes and other manifold extortions and oppressions by the said Horsemen and Footmen daily and nightly committed and done which been the principal causes of the desolation and destruction of the said Land and hath brought the same into ruine and Decay so as the most part of the English Free-holders and Tenants of this Land been departed out thereof some into the Realm of England and other some to other strange Lands whereupon the foresaid Lords and Gentlemen of this Land have intruded into the said Free-holders and Tenants inheritances and the same keepeth and occupieth as their own inheritances and setten under them in the same Land the Kings Irish Enemies to the diminishing of Holy Churches Rites the disherison of the King and his obedient Subjects and the utter ruine and desolation of the Land For reformation whereof be it enacted That the King shall receive a Subsidy of 26. s. 8. d. out of every 120. acres of arable land manured c. But to return to Thomas Fitz-Maurice of Desmond By this extortion of Coigne and Livery he suddainly grew from a mean to a mighty estate insomuch as the Baron Finglas in his discourse of the decay of Ireland affirmeth that his ancient inheritance being not one thousand marks yearly he became able to dispend every way ten thousand pounds per annum These possessions being thus unlawfully gotten could not be maintained by the just and honourable Law of England which would have restored the true Owners to their Land again And therefore this Great man found no means to continue and uphold his ill-purchased greatness but by rejecting the English Law and Government and assuming in lieu thereof the barbarous customs of the Irish And hereupon followed the defection of those four shires containing the greatest part of Munster from the obedience of the Law In like manner saith Baron Finglas the Lord of Tipperary perceiving how well the house of Desmond had thrived by Coigne and Livery and other Irish exactions began to hold the like course in the Counties of Tipperary and Kilkenny whereby he got great scopes of Land especially in Ormond and raised many Irish exactions upon the English Free-holders there which made him so potent and absolute among them as at that time they knew no other Law than the will of their Lord. Besides finding that the Earl of Desmond excluded the ordinary Ministers of Justice under colour of a Royal liberty which he claimed in the Counties of Kerry Corke and Waterford by a grant of King Edward the first as appeareth in a Quo warranto brought against him Anno 12. Edw. 1. the Record whereof remaineth in Breminghams Tower among the common Plea-Rolls there This Lord also in the third of Edward the third obtained a Grant of the like liberty in the County of Tipperary whereby he got the Law into his own hands and shut out the Common Law and Justice of the Realm And thus we see that all Munster fell away from the English law and Government in the end of King Edward the second his raign and in the beginning of the raign of King Edward the third Again about the same time viz. in the 20. year of King Edward the second when the State of England was well-ny ruined by the Rebellion of the Barons and the Government of Ireland utterly neglected there arose in Leinster one of the Cavanaghes named Donald Mac Art who named himself Mac Murrogh King of Leinster and possessed himself of the County of Catherlogh and of the greatest part of the County of Wexford And shortly after Lisagh O Moore called himself O Moore took eight Castles in one Evening destroyed Duamase the principal house of the L. Mortimer in Leix recovered that whole Country De servo Dominus de subjecto princeps effectus saith Friar Clynn in his Annalls Besides the Earl of Kildare imitating his Cosin of Desmond did not omit to make the like use of Coigne and Livery in Kildare and the West part of Meath which brought the like Barbarisme into those parts And thus a great part of Leinster was lost and fell away from the Obedience of the Crown near about the time before expressed Again in the
11 Hen. 3. pat m. 3. 30 H. 3. pat m. 20 The meer Irish not admitted to have the benefit of the Laws of England The meer Irish reputed Aliens Archiu in Castro Dublin Archiu in Castro Dublin Archiu in Castro Dublin Archiu in Castro Dublin Archiu in Castro Dublin Archiu in Castro Dublin That the meer Irish were reputed enemies to the Crown Archiu in Castro Dublin Archiu in Castro Dublin Archiu in Castro Dublin Archiu in Castro Dublin Stat. de Kilkenny c 2. 3.10 Hen. 6. c. 1.28 Hen. 8 c. 13. The Irish did desire to be admitted to the benefit and protection of the English Laws but could not obtain it 2. Ed. 3. claus 17. The Council Book of Ireland 34 Hen 8 What mischief did grow by not Communicating the English Laws to the Irish What good would have ensued if the meer Irish had been governed by the English Laws Three general submissiof the Irish The English Laws were executed only in the English Colonies Archiu in Castro Dublin Statut. de Kilkenny c. 4. The Romans did communicate their laws to the nations which they conquerred Tacitus in vita Agricolae William the Conqueror governed both the Normans and the English under one Law Camden in Norfolke K. Edw. 1. did communicate the English laws to the Welshmen Giraldus Cambrensis l. 2. de Hibernia expugnata 2. The Lands conquered from the Irâ—sh were not well distributed The proportions of Land granted to the first Adventurers were too largeâ— Giraldus Cambrensis l. 2. de lâ—â—bernia expugnata In Arch. Tur. 5 Ed. 3. escheat numero 104. 2 Johan Chart. m. 15. m. 38. 6 Johan Chart. m. 1. 7 Johan Chart. m. 12. n. 109. 6 Edw. 1. Chart. m. 19.18 Ed. 1. m. 29. Girald Cambr. l. 2. de Hibernia expug All Ireland distributed to ten persons of the English Nation 6 H. 3. Chart. m. 2. Hovend in H. 2. fol. 302. Archiu tur 17 Johan Chart. m. 3. 6 Johan Claus m. 18. Matth. Paris in Henry the third 3 Hen. 3. The liberties granted to the first Adventurers were too great Eight Counties Palatines in Ireland at one time Annales Hiberniae in Camden In Archâ—uâ— 1â— Eâ—w 3. 〈…〉 Five Counties Palatines in Leinster Archiu in Castro Dublin Archiu Tur. pat 3. E. 3. m. 28. Archiu in Castro Dublin The inconveniences which grew by the large grants of lands liberties The English Lords in Ireland made war peace at their pleasure The war and dissention of the English Lords one with another Annales Hiberniae in Camd. Annal Hiber in Caâ— Annales Johan Clyn. Manusc Baron Finglas Manusc Stat. 10 H. 7. c. 4. Rot. Parl. in castro Dublin Baron Finglas Manuscript Archiu Tur. 5. Ed. 3. claus m. 4. Archiu tur 15. Ed. 3. claus m. 4. Annales Hiberniae in Camden The first Adventurers obtained these liberal Grants because the Kings of England dâ—d not prosecute the war at their own charge How the State of Rome rewarded their men of war William the Conqueror Camden in Chester Wales distributed to the L. Marchers The English Lords did not reduce the woods and wasts in Forrests and Parks Chart. de forest c. 2. 3. The English Colonies rejected the English laws and customs and embraced the Irish The Nature of Irish Customs The Irish laws and customs differing from the laws and customs of all civil Nations The Irish law in criminal causes The Irish custom of tanistry The Irish Custome of Gavel-kind The mischiefs that arise by these two customs The wicked customs of Coigne and Livery The mischiefs that did arise by Coigne and Livery The cause of idleness in the Irish Why the Irish are Beggars in forreign Countrys Why the Irish are reputed a crafty people Why the Irish are inquisitive after news Cosherings Sessings Cuttings Gossipred How the English Colonies becaâ—â—e degenerate Alb. libr. Scacc. Dubl 5 Ed. 3. m. 25. When how the English Colonies became degenerate The Scots overrun Ireland Annales Hiberniae in Camden Desmond chief commander in the war against the Scots When and how the extortion of Coign and Livery began among the English The rising Mac Murrogh and O Mâ—re in Leinster Annales hiberniae in Camden Annales Johan Clynne Manus The defect and loss of a great part of Leinster The Earl of Vlster murdered Annales Johan Clynne Manus The Earldom of Vlster recovered by the Irish Abridgement of Salus populi mascript Baron Finglas Manus Annales Hiberniae in Camden The defection of Conaght Baron Finglas Manus Annales Hiberniae in Camden What courses have been taken to reform this Kingdom since the English Colonies became degenerate Edw. 2. K. Edw. the third did first endeavour a reformation Archiu Tur. 2. E. 3â— clau pers 1. m. 16. Sir Anthony Lucy Annales Hiberniâ— in Camden Resumption of liberties Annales Hiberniae in Camden Sir Raphe Vfford Annales Joâ—an Manus Clynn Annale Hibernâ— in Caâ—deâ— Maurice Fitz-Thomas the first Earl of Desmond the author of the great oppressions and dissentions which destroyed the English Colonies The fortune of the house of Desmond The Council-book of Ireland 32 H. 8. The course Reformation pursued by Lioâ— Duke Clareâ— Archiu in Castro Dublin Statutes of Kilkenny C. 2. C. 3. C. 4. C. 10. C 12. C. 13. C. 15. C. 17. C. 22. C. 24. The Statutes of Kilkenny did much reform thâ— degenerate English Stat. 10 H. c. 8. The presence of the Kings son did much advance the reformation Absence of our Kings great English Lords a chief cause why the Kingdom was not reduced Abseâ—â— of oâ—â— King The absence of the great English Lords Baron Finglas Manusc Baron Finglas Manusc Arch Tur â— parliâ— n. 42. Arch in Oâ— Remâ— Dublâ— Act of Absentees 28 H. 8. The reformation intended by K. Ricâ— 2. Archiâ— Tur. 3 Rich. claus 3. Riâ— 2. Rotâ— Parlâ— 11.42 9 Riâ— 2. cl Walsiham â— Rich 349. Plac. coram Regâ— in Hibernia Hillar 18. Richâ— 2. The reformatâ—on intâ—â—ded by Hen. â— The course of reformation held by Sir Edward Poynings in the time of K. Hen 7. Poynings Act. The Coâ—â— Booâ— Irelâ— 16 â— The Reformation intended by the L. Leonard Gray 28 H. 8. Annalâ—â— Hiberâ—â— Manuâ— The Counâ—â— Book◠〈◊〉 Irelaâ—â— 2â— â—â— The câ—ursâ— Reforâ—â—tion â—sued Sir Aâ—thony S. Lâ— Four neraâ— submâ—ons the Iâ— The Couâ— Booâ— Irelâ— 32 3â— 34 â— The and genâ— Eaâ— renâ— the The Council Book of Ireland 33 H. 8. The course of reformation prosecuted by Tho. Earl of Sussex in the time of Queen Mary Liâ—x and Offaly made two Countiâ—s 3. 4. Phil. Mariae The course of reformation followed by Sir Henry Sidney in the time of Queen Elizabeth 〈◊〉 reâ—â—â—matiâ—â— adâ—â—â—ced 〈◊〉 Sir â—ohn â—errot The service of William Fitz-Williams tending to reformation How the Defects and errors in the government of Irel. have been supplied and amended since the beginning of his Majesties Reign Errors â—n the carriage of the martial affairs amended How the defects in the Civil Government have bin supplied â— By establishing the publick peace 2 By establishing the publick Justice in every part of the Kingdom The good effects which followed the execution of the Law throughout the Kingdom 3. The setling of the states and possessions of the Irishry as well as of the English How the commissions for Surrenders and defective Titles have been pâ— in execution No granâ— of Irish Captain-ships oâ— Sâ—neschaâ—ships since â—iâ— Majestie Reign The plantation on of Vlster