a â— Ier. 23.30.31 steale my word euery one from his neighbour that vse their tongues and say He saith They borrowed of the true Prophets the words of God which they abused to giue luster and sway vnto their impostures b Ier. 2.3 17. They say still vnto them that despise me The Lord hath said ye shall haue peace and they say vnto euery one that walketh after the imagination of his owne hart no euill shall come vpon you To them that hearkned vnto them they cried c Ezech. 13.10 Peace peace and there was no peace but prophesied disasters curses and death against those that would not giue eare vnto their lies d Ezech 13.18.19 Will ye hunt the soules of my people saith the Lord vnto them and will ye saue the soules aliue that comes vnto you and will ye pollute me among my people for handfuls of Barley and for pieces of Bread to slay the soules that should not die and to saue the soules aliue that should not liue by your lying to my people that heare your lyes Who would haue beleeued them now the greatest part of the people beleeued them they saw the Visions of God they were Gods Messengers they prophesied the words of God the beginning and conclusion of all their lyes was The Lord hath said who beleeues God and but few beleeued him e Jer. 23.21 He hath not sent these prophets yet they came he spake not to them yet they prophesied f Ezech. 13.2 They were prophets that prophesied out of their owne hearts foolish prophets that follow their owne spirit and haue seene nothing They haue seene vanitie and lying diuination saying The Lord saith and the Lord hath not sent them and they haue made others to hope that they would confirme the Word They haue spoken vanities and seene lies and haue seduced Gods people hunting their soules and all for filthie lukers sake for handfuls of Barley and for pieces of Bread all of them being like foxes in the desarts which being hunger-starued hunt on all sides after their prey and doe cast themselues on it hastily and rauenously II. Saint Peter prophesied g 2. Pet. 2.1.3 that as there were false prophets among the people so there shall bee false teachers amongst vs who priuily shall bring in damnable heresies and through couetousnesse shall with fained words make merchandise of vs. And notwithstanding the world shall become so brutish h Vers 2. that many shall follow their pernitious waies by reason of whom the way of Truth shall be euill spoken of Saint Iude saith of them i Jude 16. that their mouth speaketh great swelling words hauing mens persons in admiration because of aduantage he saw in his daies the fulfilling of Saint Peters prophecie We see the like also in our daies abounding as much in this kind of people as any other that hath been since the beginning of the world wee neede no other witnesses then the Patrons and fautors of the Monasticall life in these our daies who with great swelling words doe display lay open and expose vnto the view of the whole world this Monkish life k Bellar. praefat in lib. de monach §. 1. That it is a kinde of life more strict more sublime and eminent then the diuine or humane Law prescribes which the infirmitie also and weakenesse of many men cannot beare l Ibid. §. vnto the which God hath promised a hundred for one in this world an honourable seate in the day of iudgement a place and name in the kingdom of heauen greater and more noble then is that of sonnes and daughters yea a marke whereby they shall be knowne amongst all the rest of the blessed a marke which our good Doctors terme aureola which is say they m In lexico Theologico quaedam decentia pulchritudo singulariâ— repraesentatiua aureolae praedicatorim ore virginibus in illâ— parte martyribus in cicatricibus vel alijs partibuâ— corporis secundum geniâ— martyrij vt statim ex aspectâ— corporis sciatur qualis quisque fuit virgo martyr aut Doctor words that I am ashamed to expound and expresse what more The rule and order of Cordeliers or Gray-Friers of Saint Francis order n Librâ— confor is the book of life the hope of saluation the marrow of the Gospell the key of Paradise the state of perfection the contract of the euerlasting Couenant All they which being of this Rule and Order dye are saued In a word o Bernardin in Rosario Thomas in lib. 4. sentent distinct 4. the same grace descends on him that takes an Habit or Garment of Religion which descends on him that is baâ—tised the taking and wearing of a Monkes Cowle conferrs a full remission of sinnes both in regard of the fault as also of the punishment That is good for him but that is a small matter he is borne for others he merits for others he doth more then the Law of God or man doth prescribe And by his ouerplus by his Masses Orisons Preachings Fastings Contemplations by his Watching and Waking Abstinency Cloisterlie and Monasticall Discipline Deuotion Songs lessons Labour and other good-deeds he redeemes the liues of those that desire to be made partakers of the merits of his order and societie That is that which they terme Workes of Supererogation properly seeing it is more then the diuine or humane Law prescribes and God approues and allowes of saying p Deut. 4.2 Ye shall not adde vnto the word which I command you neither shall ye diminish ought from it and notwithstanding prudently according to the world for these good Fathers that are not of this world barter and exchange their superstitions for the goods of this world and make good traffick and trade of them according to Saint Peters prophecie giuing their spirituall goods for corporall eternall for temporall the fruit of their contemplations and monasticall occupations for the fruit and profit that the poore abused and gulled worldling hath got with the sweate of his brow and labour of his hands the fruite of their merits which these goodly meÌ„ know in their coÌ„sciences are nothing but chymeracs and idle conceits for gold siluer houses rents possessions and other reall substantiall and perdurable things And that wee may know how wise and prouident they are in their generation they neuer giue any thing but of what they superabound and exceede in purueying and prouiding first for themselues their brethren and companions of their Order and Society of so great and good store of merits as they haue need of for to carrie l' Aureola in illa parte when they shall be in the Kingdome of heauen if this be the meanes to attaine vnto it and then making largesse of that which shuld be to them euery way superfluous and vnprofitable both here and there wise in comparison of Lucullus who offered all his tapistrie to him that had neede of it q Horat. epis 6.
IACOBS VOVV OPPOSED TO THE VOWES OF MONKES AND FRIERS The first Volume in two Bookes Of the Holy Sripture And Euangelicall Counsels WRITTEN IN FRENCH BY Mr. GILBERT PRIMEROSE MINISTER of the Word of God in the Reformed Church of Burdeaux And TRANSLATED INTO ENGLISH by IOHN BVLTEEL Minister of the Gospell of Iesus Christ August de Trinit lib. 4. c. 6. Contra Rationem Scripturas Ecclesiam Nemo Sobrius Christianus Pacificus Senserit 2. COR. 13.8 We can doe nothing against the truth but for the truth LONDON Printed by Felix Kyngston for Nathaniel Newbery and are to be sold at his shop vnder Saint Peters Church in Corne-hill and in Popes-head Alley 1617. TO HIS DEARE AND LOVING BRETHREN Mr. IAMES BVLTEEL AND Mr. PETER BVLTEEL Merchants I. B. wisheth increase of externall prosperitie and internall peace and comfort in this life and eternall felicitie in the life to come through our Lord Iesus Christ ALL Scripture is giuen by inspiration of God deare and louing Brethren and is profitable for doctrine a 2. Tim. 3.16.17 for reproofe for correction for instruction in righteousnesse that the man of God may be perfect throughly furnished vnto all good workes And therefore the same Scripture is called b Heb 6.5 the good Word of God c Psal 119.103 the sweete Word d Heb. 4.12 the quicke and powerfull Word e Colos 1.5 the Word of truth f Heb. 5.13 the Word of righteousnes g Act. 14.3 the Word of grace h Act. 13.26 the Word of saluatioÌ„ i Psal 19.7 making wise the simple yea k 2. Tim. 3.15 wise vnto saluation through faith which is in Christ Iesus l Psal 19 â— conuerting the soule reioycing the heart enlightning the eyes m Rom. 15.4 instructing vs and n Deut. 31.13 making vs to feare God â—â—endring in vs o Iob. 20.31 faith p Rom. 15.4 consolation hope patience q Joh. 5.39 hauing 〈◊〉 eternall life r Joh. 20.31 Gregor 1. Origen Isider Fulgent Athanas Greenam Tilen Molin for by it wee beleeue in Christ Iesus and beleeuing we haue life through his name Hence it commeth to passe that the holy Scripture is for diuers considerations diuersly termed of the Fathers both ancient and moderne A long Epistle which the Creator sends to the creature The Testament of God the Sonne The Librarie of God the holy Ghost The booke of true loue wherein God vnfoldeth his loue vnto man The mirror of Diuine grace and mans misery The rich Treasury of the King of glory wherein is the spiritual Manna the Bread of life common to the perfect ones and to the young ones where is Iacobs Well out of the which the learned and the simple may drinke where are meates for all ages the sincere and wholesome milke of the Word the two Testaments being the two brests of the Church of God for the new borne babes and strong meates for them that are of full age where are remedies for all euils preseruatiues to keepe vs from diseases plasters to heale our wounds weapons against tentations heresies a sword to kill hereticks a touchstone of truth to display error an exact rule of all things the Mistris of faith and of vertue a lanterne to direct our steppes an anker in time of tempest Yea the Scripture is called Paradise God sometimes Å¿ Ambros ep 41 Deambulabat Deus in Paradiso nunc deambulat in Paradise Deus quando scripturas lego Paradisus Genesis in quo virtutâ—s pullulant Patriarcharum Paradisus Deuteronomium in quâ— germinant legis praecepta Paradisus Euangelium in quâ— arbor vitae bâ—nos fructus facit walked in Paradise saith Saint Ambrose and now God walketh in Paradice when I reade the Scripture Genesis is a Paradise wherein the vertues of the Patriarkes doe branch forth Deuteronomie is a Paradise wherein the Law doth spront forth The Gospell is a Paradise wherein the tree of life doth bring forth good fruits And truly well may it be called a Paradise for the godly person can in no place finde a sweeter and pleasanter refreshing then in the Paradise of the holy Scriptures where the tree of knowledge is not of that that was forbidden but of that which is appointed of God for the elect where standeth in the middes the tree of life which is Chris t. The dore whereunto is not kept close by Cherubins and the fierie sword but it is opened by the instinct of the holy Spirit and the light of the Gospell to all that be hungrie where the riuers be of liuely waters whereof the Church of the faithfull is ouerflowne and cherished and where the mindes of the godly are enriched with most fine gold and precious stones that is with the riches of heauenly graces t Muscul loc Com. cap. 20. de S Script where bee trees of all sortes faire to the eye and sweete to the taste trees planted by God handsome and fruitfull that is the Patriarkes Prophets and Apostles where the aire passeth very smooth and calme I meane the breathing of the holy Spirit most sweetly cherishing the hearts of the dwellers in this Garden where the voice of God is walking and seeking the saluation of the seduced man not crying this onely Adam where art thou but calling all men also vnto him instructing and teaching the ignorant correcting and prouoking to amendment them that do sinne shewing vnto them that bee deceiued the tree of true knowledge leading them that bee subiect vnto death and destruction vnto the tree of life raising vp them that are fallen comforting the carefull and refreshing them that bee wearie The Garden of Eden out of the which Adam was thrust for his disobedience had scarsely the shadow of the true pleasure which the Elect doe enioy in this garden of holy Scripture wherein they heare the voice of God they see the appearings of Angels they bee conuersant with the holy Patriarkes and Prophets with Christ himselfe and the Apostles and do feede on the tree of life not onely taking no hurt but exceeding profit being made partakers of it for euer But as the old Serpent indeuoured to banish our first parents out of the corporall and terrestriall Paradise so hath he laboured to banish his posteritie out of the spiritual and heauenly Paradise of the holy Scripture depriuing them of the vse profit and consolation thereof Witnesse the u August contra Petil. lib. 1. c. 27. Circumcellians who seduced by this old SerpeÌ„t and brought into a distast dislike therof contemptuously refused and contumeliously reiected yea defaced and burnt the Scripture If x Ioseph Antiq. lib. 20. cap. 4. a wicked Souldier and an Heathen was beheaded by the Commandement of Cumanus an Heathen gouernor of Iudaea for tearing a copie of the booke of the Law of Moses at the sack of a Towne What were these wicked hereticks not heathen but Christians though vnder that name worse then
pretended Paracler which might be such an holy Ghost as Å¿ Epâ—ph here 's 2â— that of Simon Magâ—â— was or such a one as was carried in poste in a cloke-bagge from Rome to Trent The Heretickes t Terâ—â—â— de â—â—retâ— 50. Nâ—â—â—â— heresâ—â—â—â— Alphabâ—â—â— Grâ—â—â—rum compâ—sâ—â—runt c. Marcus and Câ—lâ—barsuâ— did 〈…〉 new heresie out of the Greeke Alphabet maintaining that the truth could not bee found out without these characters and that the fulnesse perfection of 〈◊〉 wâ—â— contained in these letters for which cause Christ said I am 〈◊〉 and 〈◊〉 The Hereticks 〈…〉 Apelles Mareâ—â—â— â—â—thsuch like did boast that they had receiued many doctrines and 〈◊〉 without scripture u Euseb bist lib. 5. c. 28. Eusebius â—els vs that the Hereticke Aâ—â—â—mâ—â— did beast that his doctrine was 〈◊〉 from the Apostolike 〈◊〉 x Clem. Alex. 〈◊〉 lib. 7. 〈…〉 did glory in that he had a certain Glaucus for his teacher who had serued as an interpretor to S. Peter that Valentine did vaunt to haue been Saint Pauls auditor that the Marcionites did brag that they were the disciples of them that had seene and heard the Apostle Matthias of whom they held obserued and teached their doctrine In a word as the Scribes and Pharisies esteemed the traditions of the Elders the Râ—bbines their Cabala the Moutanists the new Comforter these Hereticks their reuelations and traditions to be necessary to saluation without the which the truth could not bee learned out of the Scripture So the Papists doe maintaine that the sacred and Canonicall Scripture is not sufficient to prooue matters of faith and charity and therefore haue recourse vnto traditions and the vnwritten word which are necessary to saluatioÌ„ But as the holy Fathers did accuse that iustly Samosateâ—us y Euseb hist lib. 7. cap. 30. because that departing from the Canonicall bookes hee had been author of an hereticall doctrine and had not followed the Apostolicke doctrine Euen so may wee accuse the Papists who haue corrupted the word of God by their traditions and fables and straying from the Scripture haue strayed from the truth And surely it is no maruell if they erre so long as they forsake the sea-manâ— compasse without the which all things are to vs vncertaine yea rather it were a wonder yea more then a wonder if without that compasse they could hold their course and not suffer ship wracke against the rockes the sands and the vnknowne shores of humane traditions For as z Plutar. in vita Thesei in princip Plutarke saith The Histriographers which doe set â—ooâ—th the description of the earth in figure are wont to place in the lowermost part of their mappes the farre distant regionâ— vnknowne vnto them and to marke in the margent such like notes and reasons as these beyond these countries are nothing but deep dry sands without water full of soule ill fauoured venomous beasts or much mud vnnauigable or Scythia forsaken for cold Euen so say wee The Scripture is a map containing a description of the place of our soiourning here in this vale of misery of our iourney to our heauenly Ierusalem containing all thinge necessary for vs in this our pilgrimage both for our instruction and saluation Beyond the Scripture and without the mappe there of as in the lowermost parts and borders of mappes there is nothing but â—â—rra incognita vnknowne land and dry deâ—â—res full of barres sands of humane traditions nothing but stinking pooles full of venomous and cruell beasts that is to say of false opinions and detestable heresies nothing but vnknowne and doubtfull waies the mother of all kind of errors Beyond this Scripture there is nothing but scriptura incognita the vnknowne and vnwritten word and traditions dangerous gulphes and whirle-pooles where the anker of our faith can haue no hold where all our sounding plummets are found too short and where wee must of necessity make shipwrack of our faith and therefore wee keepe our selues within the mâ—ppe and compâ—sse of the Scripture the sea-mans compasse the rule of our sobriety the bridle of our discourse the limit of our faith for our safety lest wee should bee tossed and cast vpoÌ„ some vnknowne coasts so perish a August Hypognost articul 6. Sede in portu fidei catholicae vbi te nuâ—â—a possit fluctuosae curiâ—sitatis tempestas turbare vel mergere we rest our selues in the hauen of the Catholicke faith where no tempest of troublesome â—â—â—â—sity 〈◊〉 either trouble or drowne vs. If then they aske vs why we retaine not their doctrine their determinations decrees Councels and traditions we answere that we receiue them not because they are not described nor contained in the mappe of the holy Scripture if they accuse vs b Matth. 15.2.3 Marke 7.5.7 as the Pharisies and Scribes did the Disciples of Christ because wee walke not according to the traditions of the Elders but transgresse them wee will answere them with Christ Why doe you also transgresse the commandement of God by your tradition In vaine doe ye worship God teaching for doctrine the commandements of men If they reproue vs because we c Fox pag. 1441 Boner will haue no more then Scripture teacheth but euen as Christ hath left it bare we will answere d Thomas Hawkes He that teacheth vs otherwise wee will not beleeue him If they call vs Hertickes wee will confesse with Saint Paul that e Act. 24.14 after the way which they call hereâ—ie so worship we the God of our fathers beleeuing all things which are written in the Law and the Prophets Nay they themselâ—es are Heretickes because they doe not beleeue all the things that are written in the Law and the Prophets f Fulke against the Rhemists Tit. 3.10 but doe obstinately defend grieuous errours against the manifest authority of the holy Scriptures and detract from them and adde vnto them teaching another doctrine another Gospell and therefore are accursed for it g Gal. 1.8 any man preach another Gospell vnto you then â—hat which you have receiued let him be accursed And h Reuel 22.18.19 if any man adde vnto these things God shall adde vnto him the plagues that are written in this booke If any man shall take away from the words of this booke God shall take away his part out of the booke of life and out of the holy City and from the things which are written in this booke But the Romanists doe not only detract from Scripture and adde vnto it but they peruert it also by their false glosse and irregular expositions which they i 2. Pet. 3.16 wrest vnto their owne destruction as S. Peter saith witnesse the point of Euangelical Counsels which they display to set forth their workes of supererogation the supererogation of their workes placing them aboue the perfection of the Law the Law of perfection though some of them denie any perfection in them and maintaine that they doe auaile but instrumentally
in this Citie of Bourdeaux Two Virgins daughters of an honourable Citizen of the Romish religion withdrew themselues from the obedience of their father and mother to follow a Religion of a new stampe and edition called Of the Vrselines This fact being found strange of many learned men and others of the said Religion Cardinall Sourdis took vpon him to defend it by writing and I was requested to vndertake the refutation thereof which I not being able to refuse to those that requested of mee this piece of seruice I tooke in hand this worke some fourteene monethes agoe But I perceiued by the prosecution and sequell of this worke that I should labour in vaine if I refuted not in order all the principall arguments which the Church of Rome doth alleage in fauour and defence of the Monkish life which I haue done according to the method I haue here summarily and briefly set downe beginning first with the holy Scriptures because the author of the Pastorall letter begins with that point My discourse shall bee truth the fountaine thereof shall be charity the end thereof shall be the glory of God the edificatioÌ„ of his Church the conuersion of those that walke in darknesse and in the shadow of death to the true light and the discharge of my conscience before God and my Church to the which I would giue an account of my studies if she receiue any edification thereby I shall remaine fully satisfied THE SVMME OF THIS FIRST VOLUME THE FIRST BOOKE Of thâ— holy Scripture Chap. 1. Of the necessity and sufficiencie of the Scriptures Chap. 2. All men ought to reade the Scriptures Chap. 3. The Scriptures are perspicuous and plaine to bee read of all men Chap. 4. They are to be read with the same spirit wherewith they were written Chap. 5. 6. 7. What is the authority of the Fathers in the interpreting of the Scriptures Chap. 8. Of the Iudge of the sense and meaning of the Scriptures THE SECOND BOOKE Of Euangelicall Counsels Chap. 1. The holy Scripture makes no mention of Counsels which they terme Euangelicall Chap. 2. They are neither of the Law nor of the Gospell The difference betweene the Law and the Gospell Chap. 3. They are falsly termed Counsels of Perfection There is no other perfection then charity which is commanded to all men Chap. 4. The Monkes and Friers doe speake in vaine of keeping Counsels seeing there is no man liuing can keepe the Commandements Not the vnregenerate man that wants all the conditions required to the doing of a good worke Chap. 5. Nor the regenerate man who is imperfect and defectiue in his most holy actions Chap. 6. Which is proued by the examples of the holy men of the old Testament Chap. 7. And by them of the new Testament Chap. 8. Whence all their sinnes are mortall in their nature though veniall by grace Chap. 9. An answere to the two first obiections concerning that God doth promise to circumcise our hearts that wee should loue him with all our heart and the testimony giuen to many that they haue kept the Law and loued God with all their heart Chap. 10. An answere to the third obiection touching those that are called perfect Chap. 11. An answere to the fourth obiection accusing God of crueltie if he haue giuen an impossible Law How and to whom the Law is possible and impossible Chap. 12. Answere to the fifth obiection that Gods commandements are not grieuous Answere to the sixth obiection whosoeuer is borne of God sinneth not Chap. 13. An answere to the 7. obiectioÌ„ that all Gods workes are perfect An answere to the 8. obiection that we must not do good works if they be sins we must doe good workes and for what cause Chap. 14. Foure reasons why God doth not perfect our regeneration in this life Chap. 15. An answere to the 56. chapter of Isaias and to the 3. chapter of the booke of Wisdome where mention is made of Eunuches Chap. 16. An answere to an obiection drawne from the parable of the sower and the seede bringing forth an hundreth threescore thirtie fold and to that which the Lord saith of those which haue made themselues Eunuches for the kingdome of heauens sake Chap. 17. An exposition of Christs words Goe and sell all that thou hast Chap. 18. An answere to the obiection taken out of 1. Cor. 7. Chap. 19. An answere to that which the Apostle saith He hath preached freely 1. Cor. 9. Also to that which is in the Reuelation chap. 14. concerning the 144000 Virgins Chap. 20. Answere to the example of those that haue liued in the state of Virginitie The end of the Contents AD MONACHOS Admonitio HIc discipatis nubibus Sol enitet Non iste lucem corpori qui sufficit Sed qui tenebras mentis illico fugat Hic scena fraudum tota hic mysteria Reclusa fictae sanctimoniae patent Deuota turba belluae teterrimae Quae vaticani montis incubat iugo Exosa coelo orbigranis grata inferis Procul hinc facesse Nam tibi certissima Mors hic paratur Ista si perlegeris Dâ—lâ—re victa non potes non emori IACOBS VOW OPPOSED TO THE VOWES OF MONKES AND FRIERS THE FIRST BOOKE CHAP. I. Of the holy Scriptures I. We cannot learne what seruice is acceptable vnto God but of God himselfe II. God teacheth it vs within by his holy Spirit and without by his holy Word III. The whole Word of God necessarie and sufficient vnto saluation is comprehended in the holy Scriptures WHat a Iob 36.22 teacher is like God said Elihu in his conference with Iob the same say we here where the question is betweene vs of Gods seruice of that seruice which he approues and to the which hee hath annexed a gratious promise of ample remuneration who then can better tell vs what he is then he himselfe Both we and they seeke for eternall life and desire to finde the way that leades vs vnto it it is God that hath giuen it vs who then shal shew vs the way of life but God Our b Col. 3.3.4 life is hid with Christ in God yea Christ is our life and c John 14.6 10 7. as hee is our life so is he the way of life the doore by the which the sheepe doe enter and there is none other then he d Heb. 10.20 that hath consecrated for vs a new and liuing way through the vaile that is to say his flesh As he hath consecrated it so hath he shewed it vnto vs by his truth e Iohn 17.17 His word is his truth and he himselfe is that truth f Iohn 14.6 I am saith he the way the truth and the life no man commeth vnto the Father but by me * August in Joan tract 22. Ambulare vis ego sum via falli non vis ego sum veritas mori non vis ego sum vita hoc dicit saluator tuus non est quò cas nisi
complaines of those that reade and speake of them Let them defend them and forbid them with threatnings I will not feare what man can doe to me but knowing that the word of God is of such vertue n Psal 119.130 that the entrance of his words giueth light and giueth vnderstanding vnto the simple I will loue it I will put it close to my heart I will take in it all my delight and pastime his words shall be folkes of my counsell I will alwaies adhere and sticke fast vnto them that I may say in good conscience vnto my God with Dauid o Psal 119.97 O how loue I thy Law it is my meditation all the day CHAP. IIII. I. The Scripture is to be read with the same Spirit wherewith it was written II. The proofes which the Pastorall Letter alleageth are nothing to the purpose III. The Philosophers iustly blamed by Saint Hierome for that they did frame and apply the places of Scripture vnto their sense and opinions IIII. This blame pertaines and belongs vnto the Author of the Pastorall Letter V. Two true reasons why the Scriptures cannot be vnderstood but by the same Spirit they haue been indicted with VI. The Spirit of God is in the Church in generall and in euery member of the same according to the measure of the gift and grace of Christ. SAint Peter speaking of the writings of the Prophets saith that the a 2. Pet. 1.21 prophesie came not in old time by the will of man but holy 〈◊〉 of God spake as they were moued by the holy Ghost Out of these words of Saint Peter the Author of the Pastorall Letter inferres that we must reade the Scriptures with the same spirit that they were written by which is the Spirit of charitie a pure Spirit a cleane Spirit we adde to this that b Iohn 15.16 he is the Spirit of truth and so we say Amen to this doctrine II. But not to the proofes thereof that are allegoricall or false or corrupted and peruerted That which is said of the commandement giuen vnto him that preacheth the Gospell that he should gâ—â— vp to the mountaine of vertue is allegoricall and repugning to the sense of the Scriptures In like manner that which is added that no beast way approch vnto this mountaine that is to say no carnall sense or meaning and that haue we seene in the Chapter going before The second proofe taken from c Genes 6.3 that of Genesis is false God saith there My Spirit shall not alwaies striue with man for that he is also flesh and the meaning is that God will no longer beare with the malice of men because they are nothing but flesh that is to say finne and corruption but hee will destroy them from the face of the earth if they repent not in the space of an hundred and twentie yeeres Here is therefore no question of the abode of Gods Spirit in men but of the strife that God hath with men obstinatly hardned and not harkning vnto his admonitions but taking occasion by his blessings to liue according to the flesh The third proofe is mained and defectiue Saint Paul saith that d Rom. 15.4 Whatsoeuer things were written aforetime were written for our learning that we through patience and comfort of the Scriptures might haue hope In the Pastorall Letter these words are thus changed Pag. 6. cut off and falsified The whole Scripture is giuen of God for our instruction that so by the example that we imbrace in seeing the recompence of the verâ—â—ous and the punishment of the wicked we comfort our selues in hope to attaine vnto the inestimable goods that are promised there So that whole comfort of the Scriptures is falsely referred and applied to the example that we take of the recompence of the good and the punishment of the wicked whereas it doth altogether consist in the death and passion of Christ Iesus in whose blood al those good men e Reuel 7.14 haue washed their long robes hauing all of them been iustified and graciously saued by the blood of him on the crosse and not by the merit of any vertue that was in them Whence the Lord is called f Luke 25. the Consolation of Israel namely of all the Saints the peace comfort and ioy of whom is wholy limited and stinted in him and to the witnesse that Gods Spirit beareth to their spirit and consciences by the holy Scriptures that God hath reconciled them to himselfe in him not imputing to them their sins where with ioy they crie out with the Prophet Dauid a man according to Gods heart g Psalm 32.1.2 Blessed is hee whose transgression is forgiuen whose sinne is couered Blessed is the man vnto whom the Lord imputeth not iniquitie But not being of a subiect and matter to examine this place any more I doe approue the conclusion that is drawne from hence for seeing the Scripture hath been giuen vs for our instruction and consolation we ought not alter it or diuert it to our destruction III. Neither ought we to imitate those of whom Saint Ierome complaines h Hieron that comming to the holy Scriptures after the studie of the Sciences of this world doe imagine that all that they say is the Word and Law of God and take not the paines to search and examine diligently what the Prophets and Apostles haue said but doe frame vnto their sense the places of Scriptures which haue no resemblance agreement or relation vnto it being like the Israelites in this who made a golden Calfe of the treasures they brought out of Egypt whereas they that vse holily humane Sciences making them serue and attend on Diuinitie are like those that did imploy the iewels and riches of the Egyptians towards the building of the Tabernacle and entertainement of Gods seruice IIII. But when they say Pag. 7. that parents which binde their children to the obedience of the commandement they giue them to stay with them to serue them and not to enter into such or such a cloister are like those first that they doe subuert all order imagine they ought to preferre their commandement before Gods commandement their wills before the Euangelicall Counsels against the expresse Texts of the Gospell the example of Saints the interpretations of all the Fathers and the decisions of the holy Canons They charge them with a false blasphemie wherewith the Author of the Pastorall Letter shall finde himselfe touched and tainted who takes violently by the haires as we say the places of Scripture and the interpretations of the Fathers and frames them after his owne imagination wherewith they haue no resemblance or relation as we shall see in the Chapters following V. Notwithstanding this remaines as true that the same Spirit which hath indicted the Scriptures and giuen it to bee written ought and doth vnfold and giue vs the sense and meaning thereof The reason is in them or in vs In them their
6.44.45 man can come to me except the Father which hath sent me draw him It is written in the Prophets And they shall be all taught of God euery one therefore that hath heard and hath learned of the Father commeth vnto me They that thus heare and learne thus of the Father doe not stand to their owne sense nor are not wedded to their owne humours but are directed by the holy Spirit to the sense and meaning of the Scripture as much as is necessarie for them that they suffer themselues not to be distracted and with-drawne from the saluation which is in our Lord Iesus by the deceit of men II. The Pastoral Letter vnderstands not so the words of Micah and acknowledgeth none to be the mountaine of Sion Pag. 7. but the ancient Fathers and those of these times Pastors and Doctors there is difference saith he betweene one heretick and another which interprets the Scripture according to his sense the one with more the other with lesse obstinacie and wilfulnesse but both of them are alike in error To be like an hereticke is to make himselfe like the diuell and to beare his image This is his argument they are hereticks which do interpret the Scripture according to their owne sense wee ought not to resemble hereticks wee ought not therefore and must not interpret the Scripture according to our senses The Canon Law defineth an heretick thus g 24. q. 3. Can. 27. Haeresis quicunque aliter scripturam intelligit quà m sensus spirituâ— sancti flâ—gitat quo scripta est licet de ecclesia non recesserit tamen haereticus appellari potest Whosoeuer vnderstandeth the Scripture otherwise then the sense of the holy Spirit by the which it hath been written requireth although he hath not with-drawne himselfe from the Church he may be cald an hereticke is to be vnderstood if he be obstinate and being conuicted of error by the truth will not leaue his error to embrace the truth h 24 q. 3. can dixit For they which maintain and defend their false and peruerse opinion without any stubbornes and obstinacy being ready willing to be corrected are not to be reckoned amongst hereticks but i 24. q. 3. can 31. Qui in ecclesia they which being in the Church of Christ haue any contagious and peruerse opinion if being reproued of it that they may knâ—w and acknowledge that which is sound and right they resist with stubbornnesse and contumacie and will not reforme and correct their pâ—stilent and mortall opinions and doctrines but persist to defend and maintaine them they become heretickes And if we will know who are they which haue a bad and peruerse opinion and doctrine Leo the first will tell vs that k 〈◊〉 epist 10. ad FlauianuÌ„ est 24. q. 3. can 30. quid autem those fall into this furie and madnesse who being hindred by some obscurenes and darkenes to know the truth haue not their recourse to the voice of the Prophets to the Epistles of the Apostles and to the authorities of the Gospell but to themselues and therefore are masters of errors not hauing been disciples of truth All these conditions being put and laid together hee is an hereticke who despising all admonitions doth maintaine obstinatly an error contrary to the doctrine of the Prophets and Apostles contained in the holy Scriptures Of such a one the Apostle faith l Tit. 3.10.11 A man that it an herericke after the first and second admonition reiect knowing that he that is such is subuerted and sinneth being condemned of himselfe I desire the Reader to marke and remember this definition to the ende he may iudge by the same of the truth and false-hood of the matters debated in our writings and finde and hold for an hereticke the one of vs who being an Idolater of his owne sense and opinion defends with obstinacie a sense contrary to the holy Scripture For as Tertullian saith m Tert. de praes aduers haeret cap. 38. Inde scripturarum expositionum adâ—lteratio deputanda est vbi diuersitas inuenitur doctrinae There is the corruption of the Scriptures and of Expositions where the diuersitie of doctrine is found and else where The n Ibidem ca. â—2 Hereticorum doctrina cum Apostolica comparant ex diuersitate contrarietate sua pronunciabit neque Apostoli alicuius authoris esse neque Apostolici doctrine of heretickes compared with that of the Apostles will pronounce by her difference and contrarietie that she hath not for her author any Apostle or any Apostolick person The Pastorall Letter will not haue nor permit vs to make this comparison of the writings of men with those of the Apostles but binds vs to depend altogether on that which the holy Fathers and our spirituall Fathers which haue lawfull succession will tell vs and reach vs. III. Pag. 7. The Christian saith the Letter ought per omnia assimilari Christo in all things be made like vnto Christ who for our example said in Saint Iohn o Iohn 7.16 Mea doctrina non est mea sed eius qui misit me My doctrine is not mine but his that sent me In another place p Iohn 15.15 Omnia quaecunque audiui à patre nota feci vobis Al things that I haue heard of my Father I haue made knowne vnto you euen so you ought not to speake of the Scriptures but sicut audiui à patre as the holy Fathers doe expound This reason may be reduced to this forme The Christians ought to be like vnto Christ in all things but Christ hath said nothing but that which he hath heard of his Father therfore we ought not to say any thing of the Scripture but that we haue heard of our fathers or as they expound it Who seeth not that here are foure termes as Schoolemen speake and that the conclusion sayes more then the premise doe afforde let vs make a new this Syllogisme All Christians ought to be like vnto Christ in all things but Christ hath said nothing hath done nothing but that which his Father hath told him and commaunded him the maiden daughters therefore of whom the question is ought to say nothing to doe nothing but that which their father hath told them and commanded and consequently they ought not nor may not enter into the new religion and religious House or Cloister of Saint Vrsula the Virgin because their father hath told them and commaunded them not to doe it Let vs make it of another fashion All Christians must be like vnto Christ in all things but Christ hath spoken of all those things which he hath heard of his Father who is God the true One and holy One Therefore we must hold all that we haue heard of our Fathers of whom he most holy is but man and not God is a sinner q 1. King 8.46 for there is no man that sinneth not and a lyer
20.3 Till the thousand yeeres should be fulfilled Who would now suffer himselfe to be swaied and caried away with this error should with good reason bee held and condemned for an heretick Doth not Stapleton tell vs y Staplet lib. â— de authorit Scripturae c. 2. §. 5. that Clement the Roman Tertullian Origen Irenaeus Chrysostome Theodoret Oecumenius Theophylact Ambrose Bernard were of opinion that the soules doe not enioy the vision of God before the day of iudgement Another adds to these z Senens lib. 6. annot 345. Iustine Martyr Lactance Victorinus Prudentius Arethas Iohn Pope of Rome Is not this an horrible errour VI. a Canus locorum Theolog. lib. 7. c. 1. num 1. §. Sancti namque Canus expounding S. Pauls words b Rom. 5.12 In whom all haue sinned saith that from these words All the Saints doe affirme with one consent that the Virgin Marie was conceiued in sinne Chrysostome Eusebius Remigius Ambrose Austin Bernard Bede Anselme Erardus Martyr Saint Antonie Doctor Bonaâ—enture Thomas of Aquin Vincentius Hugo de Sancto Victor why then doth not he himselfe follow this consent and opinion Let he himselfe say why Although no author hath contradicted it Infirmumest tamen ex omnium patrum consersu argumentum The argument notwithstanding taken from the consent of all the Fathers is weake and the contrarie opinion is more probably and holily held and maintained Of late then and newly haue they left and forsaken the vniuersall beleefe of all the Saints the space of 1400 yeeres and c Salmeron Iesuit in Rom. c. 5. disp si §. Deinde Salmeron the Iesuite tells vs that we must answere to this whole multitude that which one alleages and obiects that which is written of Gods word d Exod. 23.2 Exod. 23. Thou shalt not follow a multitude to doe euill neither shalt thou speake in a cause to decline after many to wrest iudgement Let this suffice for an answere to those that say we may not speake of the Scripture but onely as the holy Fathers expound it for if it were so we ought and should be Millinaries with many of the holy Fathers we should beleeue against all Scripture that the soules of the faithfull departed see not God vntill the vniuersall resurrection with the Fathers wee should race out of the catalogue of festiuall dayes that of the conception of the Virgin Marie the mother of Christ and hold with the Scripture that she was conceiued in sinne for so all the holy Fathers haue held VII The Romish Church should giue vnto the people the Eucharist vnder both kindes for so haue they beene instituted and giuen by the Master receiued and recommended by the Apostles celebrated by all the Fathers and of the whole Christian Church the space of 1400 yeeres wee ought to detest the new Fathers of Constance who haue presumed against Christs institution the doctrine of the Apostles the practice of the whole Church for so many ages to take away the cup to bereaue and depriue the Christians of the Sacrament of the bloud which the Sonne of God hath shed for them in the remission of their sinnes VIII To crie out alwaies the Fathers the Fathers to make great shew of the Fathers to relie on them to shelter themselues vnder the exposition of the Fathers and yet not follow the Fathers is to doe like e Matth. 26.49 Iudas which betraied Christ in speaking to him with great reuerence and kissing him or like the souldiers f Mat. 27.18.30 who hauing clothed our King and Sauiour Christ with a scarlet Robe and giuen him in his hand a Reede in stead of a Scepter they bowed their knees before him made a shew to adore him but forthwith did spit vpon him tooke the Reede and smote him on the head with it CHAP. VII I. What opinion wee are to haue and what iudgement to make of the Fathers in what and how farre they are to be beleeued II. The Author of the Pastorall Letter tyes and bindes the exposition of the Scriptures vnto the Pastors and Doctors hauing lawfull succession III. What is their authoritie charge and dutie IIII. They are not to bee heard vnlesse they speake according to the Scriptures V. Many vnder the Law and vnder the Gospell High-Priests Bishops and Popes hauing succession haue been Idolaters Hereticks Sorcerers VI. The obiection taken from the words of Malachie is contrary to the opponent I Doe not pretend to abate or diminish in any wise the authoritie of the Fathers I say that they haue been great men of God that they haue serued God and his Church in their time with great profit that their writings are of great vse and that by the reading of them a man may become wiser and holier And I hold for certaine that they are bound in the bundle of life and doe raigne in heauen with Christ Iesus their King for whose sake God hath been mercifull vnto them But when men make a buckler of their errors and when men say that we may not speake of the Scripture but as they are interpreted by them we are inforced to say the truth that first they all were men and not God secondly they were all disciples of the truth and not Author of the same all Interpreters of the law not Law-giuers all our fellow-Brethren and fellow-Seruants and not our Masters Thirdly that we ought to beleeue them in matters of fact or of things done in their time and that which they assuredly know when they speake of things not by heare-say but which themselues haue seene and knowne these certain things Fourthly that in matters of faith they are not to bee beleeued if they proue not their doctrine by the bookes of faith because as a Canus cent 3. sequent c. 4. Canus saith All the Saints those onely excepted who haue digested and committed vnto writing the Canonicall bookes haue spoken by human spirit and haue sometimes erred in things which appertaine to faith The reason is b 1. Cor. 13.9 They knew onely in part and prophesied in part c Gal. 5.17 The flesh lusteth against the Spirit and the Spirit against the flesh in in them as well as in vs. The Apostles onely were priuiledged with an extraordinarie measure of the holy Ghost to leade them without any imperfection d Iohn 16.13 in all truth Fifthly that the Spirit of Christ Iesus is not dead with them but is as yet in his Church enlightning it in the truth and sanctifying her by the truth in so much as although there were no writings of the Fathers the people of God for all that should not leaue to know vnderstand the Scriptures to know the voyce of Christ and follow it Sixthly that the writings of the Fathers are as much or more obscure then the holy Scriptures if it might bee said without blasphemy that there were obscurenesse in those bookes which were dictated by him e Iohn 1.9 Who is the light
any not vnderstanding the language of Canaan striues against the sound doctrine imagining in himself that Iob for being better then other men was without sinne before God he will be conuinced of error by Iobs owne booke there shall he finde Eliphas preaching q Iob 4.17 Hier. aduers Pelag. lib. 2. Shall mort all man be more iust then God shall a man be more pure then his Maker Behold be put no trust in his seruants and his Angels he charged with fally How much lesse on them that dwell in houses of clay whose foundation is in the dust which are crushed before the moth A Sermon whence Saint Ierome inferres r Hier. aduers Jouian lib. 2. Angelos quoque omnum creaturam peccare posse that the Angels themselues and all creatures may sinne There also shall he finde the same Eliphas preaching againe Å¿ Iob 15.14.15.16 What is man that he should be should be cleane and he which is borne of a woman that he should be righteous Behold be putteth no trust in his Saints yea the Heauens are not cleane in his sight How much more abominable and filthie is man which drinketh iniquitie like water A sentence from the which Saint Hierome implies that euery man is a sinner t Hieron ad Rusticum epist 44. circa sinne There is none saith he pure from sinne though his life were but a day Now the yeeres of his life are many The starres themselues are not cleane and pure in his presence and he hath found some peruersitie in his Angels Si in caelo peccatum quanto magis in terra If there be sinne in heauen how much more on earth if there be trespasse or omission of dutie in those which are without corporall tentation how much more in vs that are compassed about with this weake flesh and may say with the Apostle u Rom. 7.24 O wretched man that I am who shall deliuer me from the body of this death There shall he finde Iob agreeing and consenting vnto this holy doctrine and sighing forth these true words from the bottom of his heart x Hieron aduers Pelag. lib. 1. Job 9.2 I know it is so of a truth but how should man be iust with God If he will contend with him he cannot answere him one of a thousand How much lesse shall I answere him and chuse out my words to reason with him whom though I were righteous yet would not I answere but I would make supplication to my Iudge If I iustifie my selfe mine owne mouth shall condemne me If I say I am perfect it shall also proue me peruerse If I wash my selfe with snow water and make my hands neuer so cleane yet shalt thou plunge me in the ditch and mine owne clothes shall abhorre me There shall he finde God himselfe rebuking Iob and reprouing him of his sinne for that a Iob 38.2 he darkened counsell by words without knowledge and Iob confessing his sinne and saying to him b Iob 40.4.5 Behold I am vile what shall I answere thee I will lay my band vpon my mouth once haue I spoken but I will not answere yea twice but I will proceede no further c Iob 4â— 6 wherefore I abhorre my selfe and repent in dust and ashes V. Such was the condition of all those that haue liued from Abel vntill the Law which being come hath not diminished sinne but hath augmented it hath not quickned nor giuen life to them that followed it but hath killed them and put them to death hath not made any one iust but hath condemned the most iust and righteous among them in discouering their vnrighteousnes When the Morall Law was giuen after a manner fitting the Maiestie of the Law-giuer and sutable vnto the iustice and rigour of the same d Heb. 12.19.21 They that heard it entreated that the Word should not be spoken to them any more And so terrible was the sight that Moses said Moses I exceedingly feare and quake euen that Moses notwithstanding who c Numb 12.3 was very meeke aboue all the men which were vpon the face of the earth with whom the Lord spake f Numb 12.8 mouth to mouth and not in darke speeches and by whose hand the Lord gaue the Law when God published his Law he must needes haue trembled because hee saw in the same the Iustice of God and his owne vnrighteousnesse Surely if any could haue beene conformable to the iustice and vprightnesse of the same it was he that was the mediatour and it is of him that wee haue the confession of his sin and of the people g Psal 90.8 Thou hast set our iniquities before thee our secret sinnes in the light of thy countenance It is he himselfe which hath written the historie of his vnbeliefe and of that of Aaron his brother Aaron when they glorified not God at the waters of strife for which cause the Lord spake vnto them saying h Numb 20.12 Chrysost de pâ—niten homil 6. to 5. Because ye beleeue me not to sanctifie me in the eyes of the children of Israel therefore ye shall not bring this Congregation into the Land which I haue giuen them Moses who gaue the Law Aaron who kept the Law the one a Prophet and Leader of the people the other the High-Priest and Teacher of the people who should haue been pure from sinne so holy without spot without vice as these especially that carried written on his forehead i Exo. 28.36.38 HOLINES TO THE LORD that in his Priesthood did represent Iesus Christ the High-Priest of his Church who is the holy of holy ones k Exod. 30.10 Leuit. 16.2 Heb. 9.7 who alone went into the holy place who only bare vpon his brest the Vrim and Thummim alone saw the Arke of the Testimonie who onely asked at the mouth of the Lord who answered him from betweene the Cherubins couering the Arke It is hee notwithstanding that made l Exod. 32 4. a molten calfe and said to the people These bee thy Gods O Israel which brought thee vp out of the land of Egypt He with his sister Miriam a Prophetesse m Numb 12.1 All the Priests spake against Moses It is he who with all the Priests that should succeede him was expressely commanded to offer sacrifice once euery yeere and to n Leuit. 16.17 Heb. 9.7 mâ—ke an attonement for himselfe and for his house-hold and for all the Congregation of Israel VI. They which are come after them haue not been better for sinne doth propagate it selfe alwaies from the fathers to the children and passeth from the one to the other without sparing of any one the whole world is his nurse-child Excellent things are said of Dauid by him Dauid which saith alwaies true o 1. King 14.8 He hath kâ—pt saith he my Commandements and hath followed me with all hâ—s heart to doe that onely which was right in mine eyes Vnderstand that onely
Luke 18.13 God be mercifull to me a sinner and I am assured that I shall returne to my house iustified because x Psal 145.18 the Lord is nigh vnto all them that call vpon him to all that call vpon him in truth CHAP. IX I. The Righteousnesse of the Saints in this life consists rather in the remission of sinnes then in the perfection of vertues II. The first obiection God hath promised to circumcise our hearts to the ende we loue him with all our heart III. An Answere to this obiection IIII. Second obiection Many haue this testimony that they haue kept the Law and haue loued God with all their heart V. An Answere to this obiection VI. According to Dauids words in the 119 Psalme VII And the consent of the Ancient Fathers THe a Psal 19.7.8.9 Law of the Lord is perfect The Testimonie of the Lord is sure the Statutes of the Lord are right the Commandement of the Lord is pure the Iudgements of the Lord are true and righteous altogether In this word therefore there is nothing imperfect nothing doubtfull nothing crooked nothing impure nothing false nothing that bends to one side there is no opposition no contradiction By it haue we proued that there is no thought word or action of the holiest men which being ruled and leuelled by the Law of God is not found crooked and oblique For S. Austin said b August in Psal 42. How streight and vpright soeuer I seeme to my selfe thou drawest a rule from thy treasurie thou measurest and squarest me by the same and I am found crooked and awry Whence I concluded and doe conclude againe c August de Ciuit Dei lib. 19. cap. 27. that our righteousnesse it selfe although it be true hauing respect vnto the end of true good wherevnto it is referred and applied is notwithstanding such of that nature in this life that it consists rather in the remission of sins then in the perfection of vertues Witnesse saith S. Austin the prayer and supplication of the Citie of God which is a Pilgriâ—esse on earth which cries to God in all her members Forgiue vs our debts By this word notwithstaÌ„ding they that are ashamed to be too much bound vnto God and presume to haue obtained plenteously grace of Christ to haue no more neede of Christ indeuour to improue and impugne this truth and opposing the Scripture to it selfe doe seeke in it men that haue perfectly kept the Law and arguments concluding that the Law may be kept by him that is here liuing on earth assisted with the grace of God II. God say they hath promised so to worke in men 1 Obiection that in the time of the new Testament he may be loued with all the heart with all the soule and Moses said vnto the people d Deut. 30.6 Bellar. de monach c. 13. §. 24. The Lord thy God will circumcise thine hart and the hart of thy seed to loue the Lord thy God with al thine hart and with al thy soulâ— that thou mayest liue And there are many such like promises in the Prophets wherefore either God hath lied which cannot bee or this Commandement is simply fulfilled in this life III. e Rom. 3.4 Let God be true but euery man a lyar as it is written that thou mightest f Psal 51.4 be iustified in thy sayings and mightest ouercome when thou art iudged That which he promiseth hee performeth but he hath not promised that we shall loue him in this life with a perfect loue wherein nothing is omitted nothing can bee desired but onely that hee will circumcise our hearts that we may loue him with al our hearts which he doth by order and successiuely giuing vs here the beginnings and proceedings and so prosecuting that which concernes vs vntill he folly consummate it and finish it in the Kingdome of heauen vnto which is reserued the prerogatiue to bee inhabited by the Saints which haue neither wrinkle nor spot nor any such like thing IIII. 2 Obiection Bell. ibid. §. 2â— But there haue been some found that haue kept the Law God saith of Dauid * 1. King 14 8. He hath kept my Commandements and hath followed me with all his heart to doe that onely which was right in mine eies And of Iosiah g 2. King 23.25 like vnto him was there no King before him that turned to the Lord with all his heart and with all his soule and with all his might according to all the Law of Moses neither after him arose there any like him Dauid witnesseth also of himselfe before God and saith h Psal 119.10 With my whole heart haue I sought thee * Bellar. de iustificat lib. 4. c. 11. §. 11 12. 13. Saint Luke writeth of Zacharie and Elizabeth his wife i Luk. 1.6 They were both righteous before God walking in all the Commandements and ordinances of the Lord blamelesse And Iesus Christ saith of his Apostles k Iohn 17.6 They haue kept thy Word these therefore haue kept the Law V. Surely if they speake of a soueraigne and singular perfection and such a one as the Law requireth vnder paine of eternall damnation condemning concupiscence and all the first bad motions of the Spirit wee haue heretofore proued and conuinced that no man liuing hath so kept the Law Iesus Christ onely excepted l Thom. 2.2 q. 184. art 3. Est autem infimus diuinae dilectionis gradus vt nihil supra eum aut contra eum aut aequaliter ei diligatur A quo gradu persectionis qui deficit nullo modo implet praeceptum The lowest degree of the dilection or loue of God is that nothing be beloued aboue him or against him or alike to him whosoeuer failes of this degree of perfection accomplisheth in no wise the precept saith Thomas None therefore hath euer kept the precept for since the fall there neuer was found any which hath attained vnto this lowest degree of diuine charitie yea that hath not been exceeding farre from it For seeing that m Eccles 7.20 there is not a iust man vpoÌ„ earth that doth good and sinneth not as Salomon saith and that Dauid Iosiah Zacharie the Apostles haue sinned as we haue seene it cannot be but that they haue loued in regard of the flesh sinne aboue God and against God seeing that sinne is against the will of God and displeaseth infinitely the Maiesty goodnesse holinesse and iustice of God The Saints therefore are said to loue God with all their heart because they loue him sincerely and truly without fraud and hypocrisie For sometimes the Scripture opposeth all the heart vnto a double heart witnesse that which is said of those of Zebulun to establish Dauid King ouer Israel n 1. Chro. 12.33 they kept their ranke without a heart and a heart that is expounded by these words these men of warre that could keepe their ranke came with o Vers 38. a
ser 50. Nec latuit praeceptorem praecepti pondus hominum excedere vires sed iudicauit vtile ex hoc ipso suo illes insufficieâ—tiae admoneri vt scirent sanè ad quem iustitiae finem niti pro viribus oporteret Ergo mandando impossibilia non praeuaricatores homines fecit sed humiles c. The Master was not ignorant saith Saint Bernard that the burden of the Commandement did surpasse the strength of man but hee thought it good and necessarie that by the very same they should be warned of their insufficiencie that they might know to what ende and marke of righteousnesse they ought to make towards with all their strength and power commanding therefore things impossible he hath not made men preuaricators but humble that euery mouth may be stopped and all the world may become subiect to the iudgement of God because that by the workes of the Law there shall be no flesh iustified in his sight for receiuing the CoÌ„mandements and feeling our defect and want wee will crie vp to heauen and God will haue mercy vpon vs and wee shall know in that day that hee hath saued vs not by the workes of righteousnesse that wee haue done but according to his mercie Secondly because he vnderstands not the language of the Scripture hee restraines the choice to voluntarie and free things to the obseruation of the which man is not bound and compelled by any Law Hee might haue read the words of the Prophet Moses saying to the people of Israel touching the Law x Deut. 30.19 I call heauen and earth to record this day against you that I haue set before you life and death blessing and cursing therefore chuse life that both then and thy seede may liue As also Ioshuahs words to the same people y Ioshua 24.15 If it seeme euill vnto you to serue the Lord chuse you this day whom ye will serue Conformably to this Dauid saith z Psal 119.30 I haue chosen the way of truth thy iudgements haue I laid before me And Saint Cyrill expounds the Prophets words of them which chuse and retaine Christs Testament as Lyrinensis of those that liue righteously and vprightly with their neighbour VII He expounds as falsely these words I will giue vnto them a name better then of sons and of daughters a Bellar. de monach c. 9. parag 3. 9. maintaining that by sons and daughters God meanes those good and godly persons that are married which are Gods sons and daughters and that God promiseth to those which are virgins a greater good and a greater glory then to these What could he say more impertinently then this For to be a sonne and a daughter of God is the common name of all the faithfull and their highest and most excellent title and degree of honour from whence depends all their prerogatiue glory ioy and consolation both in life and death and it is not a name of an inferiour qualitie appertaining onely to some lesse priuiledge Witnesse our Sauiour Christ when he saith To as many as receiued him to them b Iohn 1.12 gaue he power to become the sonnes of God euen to them that beleeue in his name Witnesse God himselfe saying by his Prophets and by his Apostle c Isa 52.11 Ierem. 31.1.9 2. Cor. 6.17.18 Come out from among them and be ye separate saith the Lord and touch not the vncleane thing and I will receiue you and will be a Father vnto you and ye shall be my sonnes and daughters saith the Lord Almightie d Rom. 8.17 And if children then heires heires of God and ioynt-heires with Christ saith the Apostle What may we What can we hope desire wish more It is that which is giuen to honest and good men married persons by Bellarmines confession what remaines then to the Monkes what haue the Friers else a name saith he more excellent then of sonnes of God why then they are not sonnes of God And to maiden Virgins a name better then of daughters of God why then they are not Gods daughters what other name shall we giue them for he which is not the childe and sonne of God is the sonne of rebellion the childe of wrath whose father is the Deuill a name saith he better then of sonnes What greater or better name I pray you can wee haue on earth then to bee sonnes and heires of a King except we were Kings And what better or greater name in heauen then to bee Gods sonne and heire without being God The Angels are called e Iob 1.6 2.1 the sonnes of God The Saints are called the sonnes of God he which is the Sonne of God by nature was manifest in the flesh that we might be made the sonnes of God by grace The holy Ghost is sent into our hearts to assure vs that wee are the sonnes of God f Rom. 8.15.16 Ye haue receiued the Spirit of adoption whereby wee cry Abba Father The Spirit it selfe bearâ—th witnesse with our spirit that we are the children of God And there is no name in the Scripture so expresse so significatiue and of so large extent for it comprehends in it all the good that God bestowes on his elect and chosen people vnto whom he giues all his blessings in the name title and state of children and out of this state and condition he giue them no spirituall wholesome and sauing blessing VIII Now we shall finde the true sense and meaning of this place if wee adde thereunto that which goes before and that which followes after which hath been industriously and wittingly omitted by Bellarmine lest it should haue hindred hiâ— bad cause The words going before are Let not the sonne of the stranger that hath ioyned himselfe to the Lord speake saying The Lord hath vtterly separated me from his people neither let the Eunuch say Behold I am a drie tree Here then the stranger and the Eunuch fearing God are ioyned together both of them bewailing their miserie The one because he was separated from Gods people The other because he was a drie tree The Eunuch is first comforted by the wordes of this place whereupon Bellarmine grounds his Counsels The stranger is comforted in the verses following in these words Also the sonnes of the stranger that ioyne themselues to the Lord to serue him and to loue the name of the Lord c. euen them will I bring to my holy mountaine and make them ioyfull in my house of prayer c. The Gentils called by the Prophet the sonnes of the stranger g Ephes 2.12 were at that time without Christ being aliens from the Common-weale of Israel and strangers from the couenants of promise hauing no hope and without God in the world As for the Iewes God made a promise to Abraham their father saying h Gens 22.17 In blessing I will blesse thee and in multiplying I will multiply thy seede as the starres of the heauen and as the sand
consequently neither perfect sound man nor Eunuch but they are all one in Christ Iesus b Act. 10.35 And that in euery Nation hee that feareth him and worketh righteousnesse is accepted with him as Saint Peter saith IX As this is the onely true and sole exposition conformable to the Text so is it of the ancient Doctors c Clemens Alexand stromat lib. 3. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Clement Alexandrinus saith that the Eunuch is not he that is gelded nor he that is not married but he which ingenders not the truth Such a one was heretofore drie wood but if he obey the word and keepe the Sabbaths by abstinence from sinne and doth the Commandements he shall be more honourable then those which without an vpright conuersation are instructed by the Word alone c. and therefore the Eunuch shall not enter in Gods Church namely he which is barren and beares no fruit neither in conuersation nor in word But they that geld themselues from all sinne for the kingdome of heauen they are those happy ones which fast and doe abstaine from the world that is to say from worldly desires This exposition is allegoricall and comes neere the true one d Cyrill in Isai lib. 5. tom 3. Bellarmine belies Saint Cyrill who hauing shewed that the Iewes did glorifie in their children and boasted of them thus expounds the Prophets words Id est carens liberis sobole Id est ne molest è ferat orbitatem Although a man bee an Eunuch that is to say destituted of children and of-spring let him not say in himselfe I am a drie tree that is to say let him not beare impatiently the want of children for that is nothing towards God and God will not cast him off for that for what vertue is it what great exploit the luster â—nd glistering whereof is to haue a linnage and succession of children For these things are the worke of the flesh and deserue neither reproofe nor commendation For although that hath been giuen to some in lieu of blessing God calling them vnto it it shal be no discommodity to them that haue none at all At nibil erit non habentibus incommodi He adds that these words of God may be appropriated to them which haue made theÌ„selues Eunuches for the kingdom of heauens sake And in that he giues vs to vnderstand that the naturall sense and meaning of the Text agrees consents with the true Eunuches only and cannot be referred to those which make themselues Eunuches for the kingdom of God but by application Now to make himselfe an Eunuch for the Kingdome of heauen is not to enter into a cloister as it shal be shewed in his place He goes on and expounds the words of comfort giuen vnto the stranger These words saith he are to bee annexed vnto the words going before that the meaning of that which hath been said be The Lord saith these things vnto the Eunuches and vnto strangers which is worthie to be obserued for in that the Eunuch is placed in the same ranke the Gentile is and is comforted alike it followes that as it was a vice and defect to be a Gentile in like manner it was a defect to be an Eunuch a defect of the one and of the other which had neede of comfort whereas to be a voluntarie Eunuch and to abstaine from marriage for the Kingdome of heauens sake is not a vice but a vertue not a defect that wants consolation but the highest degree of perfection yea a worke of supererogation worthy of recompence stipend and reward say our Monkes and Friers Saint Ierom expounding the same place e Hieronim in Esai c. 56. Qai â—uâ—mliâ—er hunc 〈◊〉 intelligunt ad proselytoâ— ex gentibus verè Eunuchos referunt quae dicuntuâ— c. They which expound this Text humbly doe referre the things which are said vnto the Proselites among the Gentiles and vnto right Eunuches that the strangers if they keepe the Law and are circumcised and the Eunuches such as was the Aethiopian Eunuch of Candace are not strangers from the saluation of God Therefore he shewes that in his time some vnderstood this place as wee expound it although he preferre before it his allegoricall exposition contrary to the Text wherein God vnder the name of the persons and seruice of that time did declare what grace and fauour he would doe vnto all persons without exception vnder the Gospell Now in that time there was no Counsell of chastitie but it was the glory of the Iewes to haue wiues and children Saint f Chrysost in Mat. homil 56. in fine Prophetae quidem omnes vxores domos habebant â—icut Esaâ—as Ezecâ—iel eximius ille Moses nihil hinc virtuti illorum fuit impedimento Chrysostome tell vs that all the Prophets had wiues and children as Isaiah Ezechiel and that great man Moses and that it hath not been any hinderance to their vertues If all the Prophets which were the holiest and perfectest were maried surely the rest of the people haue not sought perfection in abstaining from marriage g Lyrienesin Esai c. 6. Jd est impotens ad generandum non faciens prolis fructum Lyriensis expounds word for word as we doe The Eunuch that is to say he which is impotent to ingender let him not say I am a drie tree and haue not linnage For thus saith the Lord c. Here the contrary truth is affirmed namely that the Eunuch and the Gentile hauing faith shall obtaine as much good grace in this life and glory in the world to come the other things being alike as the Iew by nation and he which is inriched and endowed with many children shall receiue and it appeares that this hath been fulfilled in the new Law Act. 10.44 Where it is said that the holy Ghost fell on Cornelius and the other Gentiles which heard the Word with him as it fell on the Apostles and other Saints which were Iewes wherefore the Apostle Paul saith Rom. 10.12 There is no difference betweene the Iew and the Greeke for the same Lord ouer all is rich vnto all that call vpon him c. The second obiection Bellar. de Monach c 9. § 11. X. The second Argument of Bellarmine is taken out of the booke of Wisedome which booke was neuer in Hebrew and therefore hath neuer been in the Canon of the Hebrewes a booke which h Athanas in Synops Cypr. in symbol Hieron in prologo galeato in praefatione in libros Salâ—monis Epiphan lib. de mensur ponderib Hugo de S. victore sacram lib. 1. c 7. Lyran. in Esai c. 1. in praefat in Tobiam Caietan in lib. Hest c. 10. Athanasius Cyprian or Ruffinus in the exposition of the Creede Ierome Epiphanius Hugo de S. Victore Lyrinensis Caietan c. doe acknowledge is not Canonicall and hath neuer been put in Aaron neither in the Arke of the
that wee haue to our neighbour and keepe nothing for our selues but wee keepe this Commandement if we giue partly and retaine in part But Bellarmine dissembleth to say that in the Commandement Thou shalt loue thy neighbour as thy selfe the word As doth not signifie the quantitie measure and rule of our charitie but onely the qualitie thereof for we loue our selues without measure and limit and God will not haue vs to loue our neighbour in this manner Furthermore if the loue we beare to our selues were the rule of our charitie towards our neighbour the common prouerb would be true that charitie begins at her selfe But reason and experience sheweth that to be false for we are bound to loue Father Mother our King our Country the Church of God more then our selues The Scripture saith that Å¿ 1. Cor. 13.5 Charitie seeketh not her owne and according to that giues vs this expresse Commandement t Phil. 2.4 looke not euery man on his owne things but euery man on the things of others wherefore this As is not a marke of equalitie but of similitude and signifies the truth and sinceritie that ought to be in our charitie for as wee loue our selues in truth and without dissimulation or reseruation so ought we to loue our neighbour u 1. Iohn 3.18 not in word neither in tongue but in deede and in truth saith Saint Iohn The rule and measure of our loue towards our neighbour is the loue of Christ towards vs x John 13.34 A new Commandement I giue vnto you that ye loue one another as I haue loued you that yee also loue one another Now his loue consists in this that he died for vs therefore ours also towards our neighbours ought to consist in this if God call vs therevnto y 1. Iohn 3.16 Hereby perceiue we the loue of God because he laid downe his life for vs and we ought to lay downe our liues for the brethren If our liues how much more all our goods that are not so much as our life is Secondly Iesus Christ commanding this rich man to sell all that hee had did not bid him giue all to the poore to become a beggar a vagabond and a wallet bearer for in the Text there is but and giue to the poore Now he could haue giue of his all without giuing all But because Christ would haue made him a Disciple and one of his attendants and followers during the dayes of his flesh and afterwards a Preacher of his Gospell in those places where it would haue pleased him to haue sent him he commands him to ridde himselfe speedily of his possessions that they might not with-hold nor hinder him to follow Gods calling and to giue liberally to the poore but hee commaunds him not to giue them to the poore without reseruing any thing for his need and there is nothing in the Text from whence they can gather any such either Commandement or Counsell Thirdly it is true in generall that charitie requires not of vs that wee giue all we haue to the poore without any reseruation for our selues neither also that wee sell all that we haue for ordinarily this sentence of the Apostle takes place a 2. Cor. 8.13 I meane not that other men be eased and you burthened but by an equalitie But such a time may happen that a man shall be called of God to lay downe not all his goods onely but his life also for his brethren then such a one receiueth of God a true Commandement to doe so if he doth not so he transgresseth the Commandement of God and becomes guiltie before God It is not a generall Commandement to euery man to goe out of his Countrie to serue God and to offer vp to God his children to obey God Notwithstanding this was a particular Commandement giuen to b Genes 12.1.4 Genes 22.2.3 Abraham which Abraham could not haue refused to doe without shewing himselfe an hypocrite without offending God Thus although it be not a generall Commandement of charitie to sell all that wee haue and to giue it all to the poore yet was it a Commandement of charitie particularly giuen and in expresse termes from Christs owne mouth to this young Ruler who for not obeying thereunto is by the Lord declared to be excluded out of the Kingdome of heauen This I say presupposing with the most part that it was inioyned him as well to giue all as to sell all XIIII The other Commandement is And come and follow me expresly added to the first c August epist 89. quaesâ— 4 Deinde addidit veni sequere me ne cuiquam quando haec feâ—â—rit aliquid prodesse existimetur si non sequitur Christum to the end saith S. Austin we think not that it can profit any body when he shall haue done these things when he shall haue sold all that he hath and shall haue giuen it to the poore if he follow not Christ This commandement is tearmed by Bellarmine d Bellar. de Monach c. 9. §. 41.6 Obiection A Counsell of obedience A Counsell saith he and no Commandement because it is giuen but to him to whom it hath been said Goe and sell all that thou hast And this is his sixth obiection whereby hee pretends to proue the obedience which the Monks yeeld and giue to their Abbot Prior Generall or other Superiour Nothing can bee more ridiculous as if an Abbot were Iesus Christ and to follow an Abbot were to follow Christ Iesus said And follow me and did not command this yong man to become a Monke and to ranke himselfe vnder the obedience of an Abbot in a Monasterie Friers Abbots Cloisters and Monasteries were things vnknowne in those times and a long time after To follow Christ is taken diuersly in Scripture Sometimes it is referred to the time onely wherein our Sauiour Christ was in the flesh and to the attendance of his person in which sense he said vnto one of his Disciples that asked him leaue e Mat. 8.22 to goe and buriâ— his father Follow me and let the dead bury their dead and vnto Matthew sitting at the receit of custome f Mat. 9.9 Follow me and he arose and followed him As much said g Iohn 1.43 he vnto Philip. To follow him was to accompany Christ froÌ„ place to place to become his disciple for to be after imployed by him in the ministerie of the holy Gospell Thus all the Apostles except Paul haue followed Christ not by counsell but by expresse commandement Thus would Christ haue had this yong man to haue followed him corporally and accompanie him wheresoeuer hee went And in this manner hee commanded him to follow him not by a commandement common to all men but by a personall commandement directed and giuen but to a few persons For our Sauiour Christ refused to take to his corporall attendance some men that would haue ranked themselues thereunto h Mat. 8.19 A
esse in fide In mulieribus errorem significauit Saint Ambrose expounding the words of the Apostle to the Corinthians that were married I am iealous ouer you with godly iealousie for I haue espoused you to one husband that I may present you as a chaste virgin to Christ He writes that the Apostle requires that they be virgines in the faith He alleageth to this purpose these words of Saint Iohn and saith He signified the error in women because that error began by a woman as also he names the woman Iezabel because of Achabs wife who by a zeale shee bare towards Baal killed the Prophets of God vnderstanding the idolatrie whereby the manners and the truth of faith are corrupted and tainted Excludis ab hac gloria sanctos quia omnes Apostoli exceptis Ioâ—â—ne Paulâ— â—xoâ—es habuerunt For if you vnderstand by the women light women indeede and thinkest that they are called virgines because they haue kept their bodies vntoucht thou excludest the Saints from this glory because all the Apostles except Iohn and Paul haue had wiues and see if it be fâ—â—â—t to accuse the Apostle Saint Peter who is the first among the Apostles how much more among the rest Let vs heare Saint Austin or whosoeuer is Author of the Homilies vpon the Reuelation g Jn Apocal. homil 11. Virgines hoc lâ—co non solum corpore castos intelligimus sed maximè omnem ecclesiam quae fidem puram tenet nulla adulterina haereticorum mixtione pollutam c. We vnderstand saith he by virgins not onely those that are chaste of body but principally the whole Church that holds a pure faith As the Apostle saith I haue espoused you to one husband that I may present you as a chaste virgine to Christ not polluted and defiled by the adulterous companie of heretickes nor tied by a wretched perseuerance to her liues ende vnto the dangerous alluring and deadly pleasures of this world without the remedie of repentance They are then virgins not corporall but spirituall not that haue kept their bodie from the lawfull touching of women but that haue preserued their soules from the vnlawfull touching of heresies compared to whores in the Scripture which being stored with cunning pranckes assurements and flatterings and which a thousand inticements doe make the ill aduised to swarue from their right way So the Antichristian heresie is called h Reuel 17.1.2 the great whore with whom the Kings of the earth haue committed fornication According to that which Moses and the Prophets say so often of the Idolaters that goe a whoring after the false gods l Origen in Leuit hom 12. Simplicitas fideâ— virginitas appellata est c. And contrariwise Origen saith that the simplicitie of faith is called virginitie c. and that the soule by the singlenesse of faith and puritie of hir actions is held to be a virgin We oppose therefore these Fathers to the others and doe affirme that these hundred and fortie and foure thousand are either the elect among the Iewes or all the elect of the Iewes and of the Gentiles few in number in comparison of the reprobates which haue not defiled themselues by whoredome with dumbe idols but haue followed in all their actions the conduct and leading of the Lambe of God adhering vnto him by faith as now they walke with him by sight enioying continually his glorious presence according as he had redeemed them by his blood and sanctified and separated them from the rest of the world for this ende as the first fruites were separated from the whole heape that remained common The spouse speakes of these virgins when she saith vnto her Spouse k Cant. 1.3 Because of the sauour of thy good ointments thy name is as ointment powred forth therefore doe the virgins loue thee Virgins surely not by vow of virginite and chastitie whereof there was no mention in Salomons time the parents thinking in that time that they did iniurie and wrong to their Virgins to their Families to their Tribe if they gaue not their daughters in marriage but virgins by spirituall chastitie and puritie as it hath been said CHAP. XX. I. The tenth obiection taken from examples II. The first example of the vestall virgins III. Impertinent and nothing to the purpose IIII. Saint Ambrose iudgement touching marriage V. And touching the vestall virgines VI. The second example of Iesus Christ who was neuer married VII Why Christ abstained from carnall matrimonie VIII Virginitie makes not virgines like vnto Christ IX The third example of the foure virgins daughters to Philip the Euangelist X. This example is false and impertinent XI The fourth example of virgines in Iustines and Cyprians time XII As much impertinent as the rest THere is no good worke in all the Scripture The tenth obiection but hath a commandement to doe it a promise to them that doe it and examples of Saints which haue done it Vowes are good workes say our aduersaries and Bellarmine and the Author of the Pastorall Letter haue laboured much to authorize them both by the Counsels of Christ as also by large promises made vnto the obseruers thereof But they haue turmoiled themselues in vaine and haue alleaged nothing that serues to their purpose They haue seene vanity and haue written lies Let vs see if they speake better to the purpose in the allegation of the examples of Saints that haue kept their Counsels II. The first example is that of the Vestall virgins or Nunnes of the Heathenish Romans Pag. 34. For so reade we in the Pastorall Letter The onely light of nature had taught the Heathens the price and value of this vertue and although few followed it yet all bad it in admiration witnesse Augustus the Emperour who gaue great rewards and prizes to virginitie Tit. Liui. 1. decad lib. 5. And Albinus seeing the Vestall virgins goe afoote commanded his wife and children to come downe from their chariot and made the virgins get vp in their place To this purpose the Author alleageth a long sentence of Saint Ambrose taking an argument from the honour that men gaue in time past vnto the Vestall virgins to the honour due to Christian virgins III. And in all that how many faults To say that the Heathen haue acknowledged by the light of Nature that virginitie was a vertue of great price and therewith to cal it an Euangelicall Counsell For if it be of the Gospell it is vnknowne by Nature the Gospell a Ephes 3.4.5 Rom. 16.25.26 being a mysterie which in other places was not made knowne vnto the sonnes of men as it is now reuealed vnto his holy Apostles and Prophets by the Spirit Flesh and bloud reuealeth nothing of the things of the Gospell how then could the Heathens that were nought but flesh bloud haue knowne the value of this virginitie the price and merit thereof the Aureolas that are reserued to it in heauen in illa parte