praying in the Holy Ghost does confine that Text to be understood of teaching or edifying one another in a disorderly way speaking all together or that from those words your selves praying in the Holy Ghost spoken in general unto the Saints they are commanded to pray all vocally together Moreover if any say that the following words ver 20. Giving Thanks always for all things unto God and the Father in the Name of our Lord Jesus Christ are explanatory of the former Verse and being in such general terms cannot exclude a vocal Singing and Thanksgiving to God of the Church all together from being understood therein I do make reply That though speaking to your selves in Psalms and Hymns and Spiritual Songs ver 19. and Giving Thanks always for all things ver 20. are from the Fillings of the holy Spirit yet I make a difference between them for the one is limited to your selves and making Melody in your Heart to private Edifications Praises and Thanksgivings but the other is in such general Words as may comprehend all Thanksgiving both vocal and mental in the Heart So that the Apostle Paul is here pressing the Saints of Ephesus to endeavour after a plentiful measure of the holy Spirit of Christ and to put forth his Gifts and Graces both in mental and vocal in private and more publick Praising and Thanksgiving to God according to the different occasions and circumstances that might attend them 2dly Coloss 3.16 I confess that vocal Singing is here to be understood otherwise it could not be teaching and admonishing to others in Word and Deed ver 17. but yet herein is nothing to prove a vocal Singing together by all the Church For teaching and admonishing one another in Psalms c. is meant of the ministring Brethren whose Work and Office it was to teach and admonish the other Members according to the Gift of the Holy Spirit they had received And none can prove any more by these words one another than what must be understood from Heb. 3.13 But exhort one another daily while it is called To day c. And therefore as the Word of Exhortation is not used in the Service of God in the Church but in an orderly ministerial Way by one at once so teaching and admonishing one another c. must be used also according to Gospel-Rule 1 Cor. 14.30 31. 3. Nor can 1 Cor. 14.26 How is it then Brethren when you come together every one of you hath a Psalm hath a Doctrine c. be understood of a vocal singing all together for I think none will say that those words Every one of you hath c. were spoken of their all having of all those spiritual Gifts which cannot be thought of every Minister in that Church ver 28. and much less of all the Members therefore it follows that as all the ministring Brethren were not supposed to have all those Gifts but every one of them had one or more of the Gifts of the Holy Spirit so there is no Conclusion can be made that all the Ministry had the Gift of Singing or that there was any distinction of its Universality in Delivery more than of other Gifts in the same Text besides the Context from ver 27 to 32. speaks of single Persons that must exercise in the Church and therefore those words Every one of you can't be meant of all together That Spiritual and Vocal Singing was used in the Primitive and Apostolical Church of Christ is undeniable and that such spiritual Singing is you allowed is freely granted but the Question is Whether David's Psalms or any humane prescribed or precomposed Matter may or ought not to be vocally sung by all the Church together as part of the publick constant and ordinary Worship of God instituted in his Gospel-Church To demonstrate which I shall treat of these six Particulars I. Of the Essence or Being of Singing II. Of David's Psalms III. Of prescribed or precomposed Songs and Hymns IV. Of Womens Singing V. Of the Order of Singing VI. Of Scriptural and other Objections I. Of the Essence of Singing Though intelligible Singing for teaching and admonishing others cannot be without the use of the Organical Instruments of the Voice yet the Essence or Being of Singing consists in an inward spiritual Exercise of the Soul or Mind of Man And this must be granted for we all do own that true Prayer may be made in our Hearts to God without the use of our Voice otherwise we deny all worshipping of God in the Church save only what is done by the Minister and exclude the Members of it from adding to joining with or having any share in Divine Worship and consequently that nothing can be properly called Sin that is only in the inward exercise of the Spirit but that which is so manifested by Words or Deeds And as I think that none will deny either the Principal or its contrary Consequences so the Scriptures do clearly witness that the Essence of Prayer and Praises and of Sin do all consist in an inward Exercise of the Soul or Spirit First The Essence of Sin is in the Spirit for Paul saith Rom. 7.7 That he had not known the Sin of Lust except the Law had said Thou shalt not covet Psal 94.11 And the Lord knoweth the Thoughts of Man that they are Vanity And that every Imagination of the Thoughts of his Heart are only evil continually Gen. 6.5 And Christ saith That whosoever looketh on a Woman to lust after her Mat. 5.28 hath committed Adultery with her already in his Heart So that the Essence of Sin consists in the corrupt and evil Thoughts and Imaginations of the Hearts and Minds of the Sons of Men tho not expressed by Words or Actions Secondly The Essence of Prayer is in the Heart or Spirit Neh. 2.4 for Nehemiah while he was in the King's Presence made his Prayer to God which most rationally must be taken for secret Ejaculations and Heart-Prayer And Hannah in the bitterness of her Soul prayed and spake in her Heart 1 Sam. 1.13 c. only her Lips moved but her Voice was not heard And for the sighing of the Needy now will I arise Psal 12.5 Psal 79.11 Ps 102.20 saith the Lord. Let the Sighings of the Prisoners come before thee And the Lord heareth their Groanings And this kind of Prayer our Lord himself used for looking up to Heaven Mar. 7.34 he sighed when he was opening the deaf Ears Rom. 8.26 And these are the Prayers that the Apostle calls unutterable for many times there is more in our inward Sighings Groanings Longings Pantings Breathings and Supplications of Heart and Spirit than can be expressed by our Tongues and God looketh on the Heart more than on the outward Appearance 1 Sam. 16.7 for he being a Spirit seeketh spiritual Worshippers And they that worship him John 4.23 24. must worship him in Spirit and in Truth And herein lies the
PRELIMITED FORMS of Praising GOD Vocally sung by all the Church together Proved to be no Gospel-Ordinance In a Sober Discourse concerning SINGING With a Large APPENDIX Thereunto added Containing several Things not treated of before and wherein the Case of SINGING is more fully opened and discussed in divers principal Branches of it Greatly tending to the clearing and confirmation of the Truth discoursed of in the Former Part. By ISAAC MARLOW 1 Sam. 15.22 Behold to obey is better than Sacrifice and to hearken than the Fat of Rams London Printed for the Author 1691. THE EPISTLE DEDICATORY TO THE Baptized Churches Of Christ in England and Wales Grace Mercy and Peace be multiplied unto you from God our Father and Jesus Christ our Saviour Honoured and Beloved Brethren AS the subject Matter of the following Discourse is in defence of the true Apostolical Scripture manner of Divine Service and of the Spiritual Worship of God which you have owned and suffered for and in which thrô the Grace of Christ you still continue and as it tends to the mutual Peace and Unity of the Churches so I hope that my Work and Service herein will find the greater acceptance with you And seeing it hath graciously pleased God to preserve you so stedfastly in the Truth under the greatest Trials and Sufferings of our Age it is to be hoped that the Errors of some Persons shall never corrupt your Minds from the Simplicity that is in Christ in any part of Divine Worship or to offer your Praises to God in such humane Forms and after such a manner as we have no example for nor can be any ways warranted from the Word of God And that those Churches which have had a watchful eye against the finest-spun Errors of their Day will not be now lull'd asleep by any among themselves to suffer the bringing in of such a humane Tradition as is utterly inconsistent with their professed Principles and to their Practice in other parts of Divine Worship but that they will labour to have Oil in their Vessels with their Lamps that so when the Bridegroom cometh they may be ready to enter into the Joy of their Lord. For though this Error is dearly fondled by some Christians and as it is observed mostly by such among us who have not well digested those things which they have received yet of about an hundred Churches in England according to the best and strictest Information I have received I hear of but seven or eight and those are in and about Norfolk Suffolk and Essex one of them lately in London and but four or five of all those Churches in South-Wales which own the Doctrine of Personal Election and final Perseverance and but two of all those Churches that are for the general Point that practise such formal Singing in the publick and constant Worship of God with the Ministry of the Word Some few also there are that use it at the Administration of the Lord's Supper To whom and to all others in particular of my Christian Brethren that herein differ from the Body of the Churches and are declining from the Truth and Spirituality of Gospel-Worship I humbly present that which the Lord hath convinced me of through the Light of the Holy Scriptures to remove the Mistake you are under concerning Singing And truly the Sense I have of the sad Effects of this apostatizing Principle in some Christians if it should grow and increase among us and the unwearied Endeavours of some Persons to lead us back to such Traditions of Men from which we were clean escaped with the Love I have for the Truth and Simplicity of the Gospel are the only Motives of my appearing in this Work or Service And it is matter of Grief and Lamentation to many Christians that while the Lord is saving his Church and People and is drawing of us with the gracious Cords of his Love that any should be departing from the Truth and Purity of his Worship which after so clear a light and recovery of it from the mists and darkness of Men is now called in question amongst our selves And it is somewhat marvellous to consider that some Persons who are studious and understanding in the Holy Scriptures should not see their Practice to be opposite to the positive Command of Jesus Christ through whose knowledg others that are weak are made to sin And that any should be so cold in their Love and Affections to Christ and so indifferent in their Obedience unto his revealed Will as that they should rather trust to others for what is truth than to take the pains to search the Scriptures for satisfaction from a good Understanding within themselves whereby they follow the Dictates of Men more than the Precepts of Jesus Christ But forasmuch as humane Forms of Worship do naturally proceed from a carnal and worldly Spirit we may then fear that some Christians excepting others that err through a mistaken Zeal having left their first Love begin to cast off their first Faith and to turn unto Mens Traditions of whom and to whom we may say as the Apostle did to those who were turning again to the weak and beggarly Elements of the Law O foolish Gal. 3.1 3 4. Galatians who hath bewitched you that you should not obey the truth Are ye so foolish having begun in the Spirit are ye now made perfect by the Flesh Have ye suffered so many things in vain if it be yet in vain And is it a small and indifferent thing with you how and in what manner you worship God and offer your Praise unto him Have ye not as much reason to observe the Rule of Christ in praising and giving Thanks as well as in Prayer Baptism and other Ordinances in the Church If any should tell you that because Prayer and Baptism are commanded by Jesus Christ therefore you must use Forms of Prayer and Infants-sprinkling will you not say to them again That the Conclusion is not rational For though these are commanded yet the manner how these Ordinances are to be performed whether in and through the Gifts and Graces of the Holy Spirit and by dipping or by humane precomposed Forms and sprinkling is not left to our own Wills but are also shewed to us in the holy Scriptures which are the Rule for the manner of performance of all the essential Parts of Gospel-Worship And if any should further say that Infants sprinkling is not expresly forbidden in the Scriptures and therefore it may be used by us will you not make reply that though it is not forbidden in such express words yet there being but one manner of Water-Baptism commanded by Christ and his holy Apostles whose Precepts and Examples therein we are bound to follow it is a sufficient Warrant for our practice of it and to exclude the form of Sprinkling as a sinful Practice in that it changeth the Ordinance and maketh void the Command of Christ through Mens Traditions And therefore if you
Whether you will assert that meerly natural Worship without Gospel-Institutions and Qualifications for that which is Legal and Ceremonial is done away will please God and ought to be exercised in his Gospel-Church Or 3. Do you say that the acceptable manner of praising God in his Gospel-Church for that is the chiefest Point in question is discovered and warranted to us both from the Light of Nature and Divine Revelations and Gospel-Institutions and so because you have no Warrant from either of them for your Practice of formal Singing together do you shuffle between them both If you say that your Practice of singing Praises to God in his Church is a constant Ordinance by Divine Revelation and Institution only then you cannot pretend to the Practice of it from the Law or Instinct of Nature and if you found it on the Law of Nature only then you bring it into the Gospel-Church without regard being had to the Tenor of the Gospel which is that as God is a Spirit so they that worship him must worship in Spirit and in Truth as Christ saith The Hour cometh and now is Joh. 4.23 24. when the true Worshippers shall worship the Father in Spirit and in Truth for the Father seeketh such to worship him Which is not to be understood of worshipping in our natural Spirits only For the Apostle saith Rom. 8.8 26 27. that they that are in the Flesh cannot please God But ye are not in the Flesh but in the Spirit if so be that the Spirit of God dwell in you Now if any Man have not the Spirit of Christ he is none of his And that the Spirit also helpeth our Infirmities for we know not what we should pray for as we ought but the Spirit it self maketh intercession for us with Groanings which cannot be uttered And we are commanded to pray always with all Prayer and Supplication in the Spirit Ephes 6.18 And to pray in the Holy Ghost and to be filled with the Spirit Chap. 5.18 19. speaking to your selves in Psalms and Hymns and Spiritual Songs And I will pray with the Spirit 1 Cor. 14.15 and I will sing with the Spirit And the Apostle saith in his Epistles to the Romans and Galatians Rom. 8.15 Because ye are Sons God hath sent forth the Spirit of his Son into your Hearts crying Abba Father And ye have received the Spirit of Adoption Gal. 4.6 whereby we cry Abba Father So that Gospel-Prayer and Singing is in with and by the help of the Holy Spirit And therefore if no regard be had to Gospel-Institutions and Qualifications for Prayer Singing but that they are to be practised from the Law Light or Instinct of Nature only then such Prayer and Singing so perform'd can't be part of Gospel-Worship nor should they be knowingly suffered in any Gospel-Church For the design of God in erecting the Gospel-Church was that he might have a Spiritual House 1 Pet. 2.5 9. an Holy Priesthood to offer up spiritual not natural Sacrifices acceptable to God by Jesus Christ Moreover if Singing and Prayer are put together and performed by you as spiritual Duties why do you not follow the spiritual Rule and plain Gospel-Order for Singing as well as Prayer And if you put them together as natural Duties from the Law or Instinct of Nature only without regard being had to Divine Institutions and Qualifications it is the ready way to bring the World by Shoals into the Gospel-Church and so to turn it by major Votes which is no argument of Truth into a natural Church-state And it also opens a wide door for Forms of Prayer as well as for Forms of Singing for if the Practice of both are alike from the Law of Nature and Singing be performed in stinted precomposed Forms what reason can you render why such Forms of Prayer should not be used as well as such Forms of Singing But if Singing and Prayer are not put together by you as founded alike on the Law of Nature how can you demonstrate their Essences to be from the different Principles of Nature and Grace when true Gospel spiritual Singing is from the Fountain of the Holy Spirit as well as Prayer and preserve the Gospel-Church from the Confusion of apparently-known natural and spiritual Persons in having full Communion together if natural Worship meerly as such should be allowed therein Farthermore what Scripture-Grounds and Reasons can you render when you perform Prayer according to Gospel-Order in the Church with a single Voice by one at once in subjection to the Rule of Christ 1 Cor. 14.26 to 34. though Prayer is not expresly mentioned therein wherefore you do reject the Psalm expresly named and annexed with other Gifts unto the Rule from coming under the Order of it And what can you say to the Practice of Womens vocal Singing in the Church when it is so directly against the plain and positive Command of Christ To conclude this Epistle to you it highly concerns you to consider whether your practice of Singing or what I have herein asserted in this Treatise 1 Cor. 3.12 13 14 15. Rom. 2.16 can stand our Trial at the Day of Jesus Christ when both you and I shall appear before him and receive our Loss or Gain according to the Gospel And therefore that the Lord would graciously awaken you and convince you of your Error which I am perswaded that one day or other you will be made ashamed of and pardon your Sin and Injury to the Church of Christ therein and prevent your building of Hay and Stubble on the true Foundation and make you an Instrument of his Glory and his Peoples Comfort as it hath been my earnest Prayers to God for you so I desire in Love and Faithfulness to continue I. M. The CONTENTS of the Brief DISCOURSE or the First Part. 1. A Brief Exposition of Ephes 5.18 19. Col. 3.16 1 Cor. 14.26 Page 5 2. Of the Essence or Being of Singing Page 5 3. Of David's Psalms Page 9 4. Of Precomposed Songs and Hymns Page 15 5. Of Womens Singing Page 21 6. Of the Order of Singing Page 22 7. Objections answered 1. Of Moses Deborah and Barak's Singing Page 24 2. Of Musick used by the Prophets in Saul's Time Page 25 3. That Musick and Singing was an Institution to continue till Temple-Worship was made void is no Argument to prove that Gospel-Singing should continue in constant use from the Primitive Church till the second Coming of Christ Page 26 4. To Isa 52.8 9. Page 28 5. To Matth. 26.30 Page 29 6. To Acts 16.25 Page 32 7. To Ephes 5.19 Page 33 8. Of Wicked Mens praying and singing Praises Page 36 9. That true Believers having cause to praise God is no proof that they must constantly sing his Praise in his Worship Page 38 10. That Formal Prayer and Singing under the Law is no Argument for such under the Gospel Page 43 11. That Prayer and consequently Singing are of the same Nature under the Gospel as
Excellency of a true Christian who being sanctified by the Holy Spirit in the Faculties and Powers of his Soul he out-doth the most refined Hypocrite in the World who may glorify God with his Tongue while his Soul is destitute of the Graces of the Holy Spirit but the true Christian being bought with a Price 1 Cor. 6.20 glorifies God not only in his Body but in his Spirit which are the Lord 's Thirdly If the Essence of Prayer be inwardly in the Spirit why not of Singing also 1 Cor. 14.15 I will pray with the Spirit and I will pray with the Vnderstanding also I will sing with the Spirit and I will sing with the Vnderstanding also The Apostle expresses them alike because their Essences are alike inwardly in the Soul or Spirit But some will say This is meant of vocal Singing in the Church and therefore comes short of proving the Essence of Singing in the Spirit True this is meant of Vocal Prayer and Singing in the Church Ver. 11 13 14 15 16 17. which the Apostle calls Speaking viz. in Prayer Singing and giving Thanks But in ver 28. it is said That if there is no Interpreter let him keep silence in the Church and let him speak to himself and to God And that this speaking to himself and to God relates to the Gift of Singing as well as to other Gifts is manifested ver 26 27. in that with other Gifts a Psalm is there mentioned and to be delivered or interpreted in a known Tongue but in case there is no Interpreter then the Psalm c. must be spoken to God and to himself for improving his own Soul Now what can be more plain than that Singing and other Gifts of the Holy Spirit have their Essences in our Spirits Phil. 3.3 wherein we are capable of worshipping God without the verbal and vocal Instruments of the Body Moreover as the Holy Spirit is the Spirit of Prayer so the same Spirit is also the Spirit of Joy Rom. 8.26 and as there is unutterable Prayer so there is unspeakable Joy 1 Pet. 1.8 and Rejoicing full of Glory viz. inward Glory and Melody in the Heart see the Text. The Essence of Singing is in the Heart such as cannot be vocally expressed by Words of the Tongue And though vocal Joy and Singing may be teaching to others yet the speaking to Gr. in your selves viz. in your own Hearts in Psalms and Hymns and spiritual Songs singing and making Melody in your Hearts to the Lord is Musick of an higher strain surpassing all verbal and vocal Melody in the Ears of God as unspeakable Joy and rejoicing full of Glory excels that which is speakable Indeed we find in Scripture another kind of unspeakable Singing which is more inferiour than this we have treated of viz. the virtual Singing of the Creatures 1 Chron. 16.32 33. Let the Fields rejoice and all that is therein Then shall the Trees of the Wood sing out Psalm 65.13 The Pastures are clothed with Flocks the Vallies also are covered over with Corn they shout for Joy they also sing Now if the flourishing State of the Creatures and of the Fruits of the Earth are called a Singing how much more properly may the harmonious Melody of the Spirit of God with our Spirits be called Singing which is the Essence and Being of it II. Of David's Psalms First There was no Institution of Singing before David's time for though we find the Song of Moses Deut. 32. Ex. 19.19 ch 20.22 Gen. 31.11 Gen. 37.7 8 9 10. ch 15.12 13. containing a prophetical Description of the State and Accidents of the Jewish Church for time to come yet this was no present Institution for the Church in the constant Service of God but a way of Conveyance of his Word which in those times was in divers manners delivered to us Num. 24.4 viz. by Dreams Heb. 1.1 Visions Words Songs and Musick but now by Jesus Christ And though we find the Songs of Moses Num. 12.6 7. and of Deborah occasioned from those great Deliverances of the Children of Israel 2 Kings 3.15 yet none was instituted for the Levitical Worship and constant Service of God till David's time 1 Sam. 10.5 who had prepared prescribed and set in Order Matter Persons and Things for the most splendid and perfect Worship of God and Temple-State of the Church which should be in Solomon's Days Now as the Law was a Shadow of good things to come let us see what the Jewish Church in her Wilderness afflicted unsetled Tabernacle-State may be said to prefigure out to us in the case of Singing As for her Minority in the Wilderness through Sin and Unbelief they had many Judgments which did befal them and cut them short of the promised Rest so that of six hundred Thousand Footmen that came out of Egypt there was but two that entred into the Land of Canaan wherein there were many Wars and Troubles that did attend them till the latter end of David's Reign therefore while the Jewish Church met with so many Sorrows Troubles and Afflictions the Worship of God was suited to her State but when they had Rest from all their Enemies in David's time 1 Chron. 23.25 and Solomon a King of Peace and Type of Christ to reign over them God was pleased to beautify inlarge and perfect his Service and Worship according to the Temple-State top-Glory and Happiness of his Church and People Now if these things were a Figure of Gospel-times what may we then say but that as Moses and Deborah for the signal Deliverance of that Day sung to God through the Gift of the Holy Spirit so the Church of Christ under the New Testament have their occasional Songs as the 144000 being the first Fruits unto God and to the Lamb who sang not David's Psalms Rev. 14.3 4. ch 5.9 for no Man could learn their Song but the 144000 which were redeemed from the Earth And the new Song for the opening of the Book of the Revelations and the Song of Moses and of the Lamb ch 15.2 3 4 6 7. by those that had gotten Victory over the Beast and over his Image and over his Mark and over the Number of his Name about the going forth of the seven Vial-Angels with the seven last Plagues of the Wrath of God but none of these were David's Psalms or do warrant the singing of them or any other precomposed Songs in Gospel-times in the constant and ordinary Worship of God by all the Church any more than those particular Songs of Moses and Deborah were an Institution for the Jewish Church for the constant Service of God in their Day For there was no such Institution of Songs in the Wilderness nor while that Church was under Troubles until David's and Solomon's time Eccl. 3.11 Prov. 25.20 for the Temple-Worship For every thing is beutiful in his time As he that taketh away a Garment