A SHORT VINDICATION OF THE CONSTITUTION OF THE Church of England Endeavouring to Prevent all Future QUARRELS AND DISCONTENTS PHIL. II. 14. Do all things without Murmurings and Disputings LONDON Printed for R. C. and are to be Sold by Randal Taylor 1689. TO THE Most Illustrious PRINCESS Her Royal Highness ANN Princess of DENMARK MADAM I Humbly Confess It is a great Presumption in Me to Offer any thing to a Person of so Great Majesty and Judgment but the Assurance I have of Your excellent Disposition to favour the Meanest Thing from a good Intention besides the Greatness of Your Charity towards many of my Relations gives me this Encouragement I am confident of Your Highnesses readiness to promote the Peace of All People which makes me conclude That whatever is tending thereunto will be graciously Accepted One of Your Deceased Servants hath often told me of Your Highnesses Zeal to God and to Your Country which nothing here below can sufficiently Requite therefore I doubt not but the Almighty will give You the Fruits of Peace which can only answer so much Piety and Goodness It is impossible but there must be Diversity of Opinions so long as the World endures Mens Dispositions being generally as various as their Tempers and Complexions but methinks this should not cause Difference in Affection which is the only thing that gives Occasion to our needless Quarrels and Superstitious Scruples To prevent which it must be the Work of Heaven only And so far as it may be lawful for me to Judge I think there can be Nothing more proper than to consider how agreeable the Constitution of Our Church is to the Commands of GOD which all must of Necessity comply with if they would but lay aside all Passion and Prejudice which hath all along given Birth and Growth to our Divisions And it is sad to think That our Gall-less Religion should by this means he Entituled to so much War and Bloodshed It is a Blessed Thing to be an Instrument of Peace and the least Hopes of promoting it is very pleasing to the Minds of all Good Men and I am sure Your Highness will to the uttermost Encourage it having always the Fruits of it in Your own Breast That Your HIGHNESS may always continue Stedfast and Unmoveable as You have hitherto done and in the End obtain Everlasting Life is the Hearty Prayer of MADAM Your Highnesses Most Humble and Most Obedient Servant THOMAS GRICE A SHORT VINDICATION OF THE Church of England ENDEAVOURING To Prevent all Future Quarrels and Discontents GOD Almighty thô Man by his Disobedience had pull'd off the Seal of the Indenture which he had made with him was pleased to renew his Covenant for the Salvation of lost Mankind He was pleased also to give forth a Commission to certain Elected Persons to proclaim unto him the grand Instance of his Divine Love and his Gracious Goodness namely What it is he hath done for them in and by his Son Jesus Christ and withal to assure Mankind that unhappy Seed of Adam that the Merits of Christ's Blood are sufficient thrô Grace to effect their Reconciliation with their offended God And that they believing the Power of his Resurrection and committing themselves to him by submitting to the Motions of his Holy Spirit and by Faith placing their Affiance upon his gracious Promises may obtain an Eternal Inheritance among the Blessed thrô the merciful Mediation and Merits of his Son Jesus Christ But since these Holy Men whom God had thus Commissioned are fallen asleep the vigilant and watchful Enemy of Mankind Satan hath prevailed by his sly and deceitful Subtilties not only to bring in a Counter-Doctrine and to commit High-Treason against the Royalty Love Goodness and Sovereignty of the Son of God by altering changing and contradicting his Gospel-Proclamation to the great obscuring and dishonoring of his Name and grand Prejudice of the Sons of Men but also hath employed many to pretend unto their Brethren that they have a more Seraphical Understanding and a greater insight into the Word of God than the Apostolical Doctrine holds forth making the World believe that Religion is nothing else but a Politick Engine and the Precepts of the Gospel of Jesus Christ to be nothing else but Human Arts and Constitutions and the Apostles and Evangelists not Men inspir'd by the Holy Ghost but States-Men employ'd to make these Constitutions to take effect in the World. But not only this did the Satanical Subtilties of the Devil effect but also he induc'd many to neglect the Fundamental Principles of Religion to spend their whole time about Discipline Ceremonies and Circumstantial Points And in this their fierce and eager pursuit the Spirit of Error not suffering them to be content with those Rules and that clear Light which so brightly shines and is so eminently refulgent in the Word of God They are led by their own foolish Fancies daily creating in them diversity of new Opinions and so falling into Sects and Schisms and by their Divisions and Mental Reservations they preserve not the Unity of the Holy Spirit but like so many discontented Members separating themselves from their Body they become monstrous in the Profession of their Religion breaking the bond of Peaceable Love and falling off from the Communion of Saints as if it were no Article of their Creed and being in love with their Inventions and New Opinions they contend for them as Fundamental Tenets And not only so But malign and uncharitably Asperse those that dissent from them therein tho never so Conscientious and Religious as if they Professed not the same Faith yea served not the same GOD nor believed in the â—ame Jesus Christ Thus by their dissatisfy'd Curiosities by their groundless and pragmatical Disputations about Religion they pretend without Legal Authority or Approved Reasons to induce a Reformation into our Church And thus these Pretending Brethren breed great Factions and Seditions in the Commonwealth of Israel and raise such Storms and Tempests as endanger even the Shipwreck of the Church To prevent which Disturbances S. Paul gave this Advice Do all things without Murmurings and Disputings And that for these several Reasons First Because whilst we are Disputing about Controversies of Religion by the Suspicion of the Truth we omit the Honour of God and neglect the observing of his indispensable Commandments Secondly Because in Doubting there is no Progress nor Satisfaction Thirdly Because no Moral Evils are Secret or Vnknown Fourthly Because the Tradition of the Scriptures is Infallible therefore the Truth of them is so too Fifthly Avoid Disputing out of a respect to the Example of Christ our Saviour who was so far from a different Apprehension of things that he condescended unto and willingly complied with any reasonable Terms Of these in their Order First Forbear Disputing because whilst we are so we omit the Honour of God. Men refusing to stand to the Determinations of the Church and submit to the Constitutions and
Adoration If then I say to use them be a thing not contrary to right Reason and thereby we do no Dis-service to the Cause of Religion or Divine Service then consequently to use and observe them is a thing morally good Which being granted it necessarily follows That not to submit to the Determinations of the Church not to communicate with the Members thereof by a Submission to him who is the only lawful and Supreme Magistrate not to conform to Episcopal Constitutions or if necessity requireth to Actions of General Synods or Counsels which make or tend to Uniformity Order and Edification consequently is a thing Morally Evil and does as naturally appear to be Evil as the contrary appears to be good For if Obedience and Conformity be Moral Vertues it necessarily follows from the Suggestions of Natural Reason that the contrary viz. That Rebellion and Nonconformity are Moral Vices Therefore avoid Cavillings for there needs no Disputing since that no Moral Evils relating to Ecclesiastical Constitutions are secret or unknown But I shall now pass from the Ceremonies of the Church to the Censures thereof That Censures as they are Judgments of the Church for ratification of the Threats of the Gospel against the Abuses thereof are indispensably necessary and therefore good and convenient as doth most evidently appear First Their use is this That as Magistrates by the Laws of the Commonwealth do exercise their Justice by inflicting and dispensing Punishments to the Offenders according to the nature of the Crime So the Spiritual Censures are are necessary to the Church both to help the Godly and restrain and extirminate out of it the Profane and Irreligious Party as the Penal Laws of the Magistrate in the Commonwealth But then their necessity does farther appear since in the Church of God there are of all sorts both Holy and Unholy Obedient and Disobedient it is impossible without Correction to preserve good Order therein especially to restrain the Sons of Disobedience from Offending or Slanderng their Profession From whence we may learn That they who upon this Pretence viz. That God forceth no man to come unto him to serve or Worship him therefore if they will retain Communion with the Members of the Church If they will submit to the Constitutions and Determinations of it If they will Assemble and Meet together to invoke and call upon God's Name to condole and publickly confess their Sins and Infirmities with them to ask and beg Forgiveness at the hands of God or in a word to serve and worship God or do any Religious Act they may if they please or will but so to do they are not oblig'd forc'd or compell'd I say That they who upon this Pretence contemn and think the Censures of the Church useless and unprofitable or things not warrantable from God's Word but only Acts and Constitutions of Men forward and ambitious of exercising Authority and therefore by them they are no whit debarr'd thô nevertheless whom the Church separateth from the Outward Seals they are also depriv'd of the Inward Graces I say That these Men are sensless and unreasonable like them in the 20th of S. Matthew that refuse to bear the Yoke of Government and to have a Sword in the Commonwealth But furthermore There are many among us who affecting or aspiring to the Celestial Supremacy always endeavour either to induce a Reformation into Our Church or else to institute a new Religion and this they would fain do by pretending that they and none else are the true Tribe of Levi sufficiently wise to be their own Priests to Teach and Administer themselves fitter to Instruct than to Learn to Teach than be Taught to Govern than to be Governed and thus they go merrily on in their foolish Conceits and being possess'd with the Spirit of Disquiet they seek to gratifie their Envy by procuring and causing the Jurisdiction of the Clergy to be Voted and Cried-down and the power of the truly lawful Ministers of God to be Reviled that they themselves might be exempted from Canonical Obedience and so become Independent And this they do by Courting the People and pleading the Cause of a Godly Party and telling them that their Priests take too much upon them in studying for foolish and useless Ceremonies strange and unnecessary Censures for them whereas they are all Holy yea very Holy every one of them And who do you think these Men are Why these are they who are only Zealous and Devout the seeming Godly Party And yet a People so silly that when they come to Encounter they are sure to be sufficiently Baffled and to have themselves and Religion sufficiently expos'd to Contempt and upon all manner of Attacks either wounded with a secret Dislike of their own Religion or else oblige themselves to a stupid and bruitish Wilfulness and Obstinacy 'T is from hence we hear of so many so often and so easily seduc'd and that is the time viz. when Men fall off from the Rational Way and sink into Blind and Ignorant Devotion from whence we may date most of our great Ills of Rebellion and privy Conspiracy In a word From whence even all those Devout Fooleries which so much incumber'd the World had their first Rise Therefore since that Ecclesiastical Censures as appears from what hath been said are warrantable and also of indispensable Necessity for the Good and Government of the Church they are therefore to be dispens'd and born without Murmurings and Disputings Fourthly Do things without Disputing Because the Tradition of the Scriptures is Infallible and therefore the Truth of them is so too wherefore there needs no Reasoning or Contention about their Doctrine or the Truth of their Information There are many Men in the World who by their Prophane Discourse which they themselves call Wit would fain Hector all Religion out of the World by deriding all Attempts which tend to its Rational Justification And this they do by making the World believe That Religion is nothing but the Fear of some invisible Power feigned in the Minds of some fearful Foolishly devout Men and that the Bible is of no force as a Law Divine but only there where it is made to be so by Laws Civil and Political But that the Authority of the Scripture is altogether Divine and Infallible and the Matter therein the immediate Inspiration of the Holy Ghost I shall to take away all Cavilling and Disputing sufficiently convince and demonstrate by these following Reasons Now the Authority of the Scriptures must either depend upon the Authority of the Church or else God must be the Author of them but the Authority of the Scripture can no way depend upon the Authority of the Church because to believe the Scripture is a work of Faith but the Church cann't infuse Faith. Again Any Authority which the Church hath must be proved by the Scripture therefore the Scriptures depend not upon the Church Now that God is the Author of them and that the Truth
Actions of those who are the Ruling part thereof and the only lawful Magistrates do Cavil oftentimes about the least necessary Points of Religion and Divine Worship and forget to Honour God for the glorious Nativity and Incarnation of his Son for the Merits of his Death and the Power and Efficacy of his Resurrection whereby they are brought by a lively Hope to be justified by the Righteousness and perfect Obedience of Christ in the Court of Heaven and are at last Capacitated thrô the Merits of his gracious Mediation to be reconcil'd to God and consequently to obtain Everlasting Salvation They forget to praise God for the several Offices of his Son Jesus Christ First For sending him to be our High-Priest and Mediator that by the Sacrifice of his Blood and by the only Merit and Intercession of the same our High-Priest Divine Justice might be satisfy'd and Man notwithstanding his Transgressions and Contra-Walkings to his Divine Ordinances might be presented at Peace before God he accepting the Righteousness of his Son and thereupon disabling his own Justice from making any further Demands Secondly For sending his Son to be our Prophet to Instruct his Church by revealing unto it the Way and Means of Salvation in communicating unto the Members thereof that Grace and Redemption which he hath purchased for them from his Father Rom. 5. 17. in declaring the whole Will of his Heavenly Father unto them Whence we may learn That it is a gross and intollerable Error in Men to think that our Saviour Christ hath not delivered all things pertaining to the necessary Instruction and Government of the Church but left them to the Traditions and Intentions of Men And that we may rest abundantly satisfy'd with that Doctrine which he hath communicated unto us let us leave off all Murmurings and Disputings But then again As in the time of Cavilling and Disputing we omit the Honour of God so also we neglect our indispensable Duties We make no progress nor proficiency in our Duty God's Services are left undone his Will unfulfill'd his Ordinances neglected the Conditions and Promises of his Covenant not thought upon but his Mercies are slighted his Grace is rejected his Goodness undervalu'd and his Name so often in our Disputes talkt of that his Nature is almost quite forgotten Thus whilst we are Disputing whilst we are in our Angelical Raptures as we think them whilst only in our own vain and foolish Conceits we are carry'd like Elijah in a Fiery Chariot in our hot Disputings even unto Heaven we rather keep our selves distant from the Union and Communion of Jesus Christ and deprive our selves of that Mercy and Salvation which by an humble Submission thrô Faith unto God we might have obtain'd Thus by our Disputings and Cavillings about Religion about the Way to our Heavenly Jerusalem we at least make no progress and I am afraid too often miss of our intended Journey Which brings me to my Third Reason which is That we should do things without Disputing because no Moral Evils relating to Ecclesiastical Constitutions are secret or unknown among all things that concern the Interest or are serviceable to the Cause of Religion and the Service and Worship of God. There 's nothing that makes a greater Blustering and Hurly-burly or gives a greater Affront to the unpeaceable unquiet and unreasonable Temper of those who are devoid of the Spirit of Conformity and Allegiance than Ceremonies and Censures of the Church which how allowable and conformable to right Reason is easily prov'd and reconcil'd from the several Uses and Ends for which they were instituted and ordain'd And First Concerning the Ceremonies of the Church Now that the Ceremonies of the Church are things in themselves meerly Indifferent and so no direct part of Worship is a Truth acknowledg'd and declar'd since that they are only Ecclesiastical and Human Constitutions And the Doctrine of Common-Prayer and of the Homilies speaking of Ecclesiastical Ceremonies expresly declareth That they are for a godly Discipline and Order which may be chang'd and alter'd and therefore are not to be accounted equal with God's Law which is altogether unalterable And again our Articles assert That our Church hath Authority to change and abolish Ceremonies ordain'd by Human Authority that all things thereby may tend to Edification All which shews that there is no Holiness plac'd in them and that they are in themselves no direct part of Divine Worship Yet the observation of Ecclesiastical Ceremonies thô things in themselves meerly indifferent and left only to the Determination and Appointment of the Church so far as they make for Order and Decency may render our Services more acceptable to God. Thus in our Religious Adorations all comly and reverend Gestures as Kneeling Standing Lifting up our Hands and Eyes Silence in the Service of God and such like Decent Rites which are not determined particularly as necessary Duties yet as they include a Reverence of God and his Ordinances as they are an obedient Respect to that Command That all things be done in Decency and Order Lastly As they include a subjection to the only Lawful Magistrate and a desire of the Churches Peace are things which may be highly serviceable to the Cause of GOD's Glory and the Honour of his Religion Whence we may observe That all irreverent and unbeseeming Gestures all Ecclesiastical Ceremonies and Rites of Religion repugnant to the Word of God or not warrantable by the general grounds thereof such as are not for Order Decency or Edification in general that all Will-worship whereby we make any thing a part of God's Service which is not commanded by himself or has Episcopal Authority in it thô it has never so great a shew of Godliness in it yet in that it leaneth to Man's Wisdom is altogether forbidden and unlawful Col. 2. 23. Secondly Thô these External Rites and Ceremonies be never so good and innocent in their own Nature as being neither owned as our necessary Duties or used as the Papists use them namely as operative Means to convey Grace to our Souls in and by themselves alone yet the admitting or introducing too many would be very prejudicial to the Cause of Christian Religion as by causing us rather to attend those External Rites than to mind our Spiritual Duties and by carrying our Affections from that inward and Spiritual Worship and Adoration by which alone God is glorified and our Souls Eternally saved Thirdly That no Power is to be admitted in the Church to prescribe any other Forms of Worship repugnant to God's Word or contrary to good Order and Decency Since therefore these Ecclesiastical Ceremonies thô things in themselves altogether Indifferent yet as for matter of use are allowable in that they make for Decency Order and Edification and in that thereby the Mind is better holden in the thing affected and better holpen and furnish'd in Inward Worship when the Mind and Body are both joyn'd together in the same Religious Exercise and
of them is unquestionable and infallible we may easily be convinc'd from these Reasons First From the Doctrine of them The Mystery of the Incarnation of the Son of GOD his Resurrection and Ascension after his Death and Passion the Union of his Divine and Human Nature into one Emmanuel Three Persons and Subsistences in One GOD and GOD to become Man are things that the finite Capacity of Man cann't reach being far beyond the narrow Sphere of his Understanding Secondly From the Matter about which they Treat They promise Eternal Life to the Faithful and Obedient and Eternal Woe to the Disobedient They prescribe Laws for the Thoughts which none but God can pierce They require Sacrifice but prefer Obedience They enjoyn Fasting but 't is from Sin They forbid Lusting and Coveting which Exactions and Prohibitions are not to be found in Human Laws but only in his who searches the Heart GOD Almighty Thirdly From the continuation of the Wonderful Prophecies foretelling things to come so long Marked out before with their Circumstances not doubtful like the Oracles of the Heathen but such as had in all their Times certain Performances and therefore unto what may we attribute them but the Inspiration of the Holy Ghost Thus was the Messias promised to Adam Four Thousand years before he was born Thus was the Rejection of the Jews the Calling of the Gentils the Kingdom of Antichrist foretold all things coming to pass aright without any failing or mistake the fulfilling of which Promises cann't be ascribed to any but the Infinite GOD who grasps all Seasons and Times and with the same infinite Eye beholds all things present past and to come Fourthly From the quality and condition of the Pen-men and Writers of them some of whom were never train'd up in the Schools of Men and yet in their Writings shew that depth of Wisdom which the most Learned Philosophers could never attain unto And then the Matter of the Holy Scripture being altogether of the Heavenly Doctrine and savouring nothing of Worldly and Earthly Affections but every where condemning the same declaring the GOD of Heaven to be the Inspirer thereof Whence also farther to avoid all occasions of Questioning and Doubting or rather of Cavilling and Disputing we may learn by the way That since the Scriptures do receive indispensably their Authority not from the Church but from the only perfect and True GOD that thereupon being themselves holy perfect and true as he is are also sufficient for the knowledge of Christian Religion that they do most plentifully contain all Doctrines necessary to Salvation Whence it followeth we need no unwritten Verities no Traditions no Inventions of Men no Canons of Councils no Sentences of Fathers much less the Decrees of Popes to supply any supposed defects therein or to give us more perfect Directions in the Worship of GOD or in the Way of Life than are express'd in Canonical Scripture We may also learn from hence That the Authority of the Scripture being Infallible the Rule thereof is indispensably true and sufficient to make us wise unto Salvation and consequently that there is to be learned out of it a Rule both of Faith and Works for our Instruction by the ordinary Means of Reading and Praying to which GOD promises the assistance of his Grace Jam. 1. 5. If any of you lack Wisdom let him ask it of God who giveth to all men liberally and upbraideth not and it shall be given him for the Sword of the Spirit which is the Word of GOD is given unto us by the Holy Ghost both to defend our Faith and overcome all our Spiritual Adversaries viz. together with all false Prophets Hereticks Schismaticks and such like Eph. 6. 17. Therefore the Scriptures the immediate Inspiration of the Spirit of Truth the Holy Ghost are not to be canvas'd up and down or any way as we please alter'd their nature being as unchangeable as their Author therefore leave off reasoning and do all things without Disputing But Fifthly and Lastly Avoid all Strife out of the Example of our Saviour Christ Our Saviour had the Spirit of Godly Constancy in him His Carriage was always Civil and Urban Humble and Candid Quiet and Peaceable toward his Church he was so far from the Spirit of Non-conformity and Contention of Morosity and Disobedience that he rather condescended unto and comply'd with any National Terms than sought to work Disturbance and Faction Separation and Division among his Apostles Therefore let us stand to the Determination of the Church and of Wiser Men than our Selves Let us stand to the Constitutions and Actions of our Bishops the only Lawful Magistrates Let us still retain Communion with the Church and Members thereof that by Peaceable Living Uniformity of Conversation the Honour of GOD's Name the Cause of his Religion the Interest of his Service and Worship may be promoted and advanced In a word Let us joyn with the Apostle and do all things without Murmurings and Disputings that we may be blameless and pure the Sons of God without rebuke in the midst of a naughty and crooked Generation that at last we may enjoy the Fruits of Peace and Obedience viz. Eternal Life and Glory thrô the Merits and Mediation of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ Amen FINIS