indifferent so farre foorth as they shall further us in godlinesse For we ought to doe all things not only to the edification of others but also of our own selues And therefore it is a flat abuse of christian liberty for men so to pamper their bodies with meate and drinke that thereby they disable themselues to heare Gods word to pray to giue good counsell to doe the ordinary works of their callings The fourth things indifferent must be used within the compasse of our callings that is according to our ability degree state and condition of life And it is a common abuse of this liberty in our dayes that the meane man will be in meate drinke apparell building as the gentlemans the gentleman as the knight the knight as the lord or Earle Now then things indifferent are sanctified to vs by the worde when our consciences are resolued out of the word that we may use them so it be in the manner before named and according to the rules here set downe They are sanctified by prayer when wee craue at Gods handes the right use of them and hauing obtained the same giue him thanks therefore Coloss. 3. v. 17. Whatsoever yee doe in worde or deede doe all in the name of our Lorde Iesus giving thankes to God the father by him Thus much of Christian liberty by which wee are admonished of sundry duties I. to labour to become good members of Christ of what estate or condition soeuer we be The liberties of the citie of Rome made not onely Romanes borne but euen the men of other countreyes seeke to be citizens thereof Act. 22. 28. The priuiledges of the Iewes in Persia made many become Iewes Hest. 8. 17. O then much more should the spirituall liberty of conscience purchased by the blood of Christ mooue us to seeke for the kingdome of heauen and that we might become good members thereof II. Againe by this we are taught to study learne and loue the scriptures in which our liberties are recorded Wee make account of our charters wherby we holde our earthly liberties yea wee gladly reade them and acquaint our selues with them what a shame then will it be for vs to make no more account of the word of God that is the law of spirituall liberty Iam. 2. v. 16. III. Lastly we are aduertised most heartily to obey and serue God according to his worde for that is the ende of our liberty the seruant doeth all his businesse more chearefully in the hope and expectation he hath of liberty Againe our liberty most of all appeares in our seruice and obedience because the seruice of God is perfect freedome as on the contrary in the disobedience of Gods commandements standes our spirituall bondage The second property of conscience is an vnfallible certenty of the pardon of sinne life euerlasting That this point may be cleared I will handle the question betweene vs and Papistes touching the certenty of saluation And that I may proceede in order we must distinguish the kindes of certenty First of all Certenty is either Vnfallible or Conjecturall Vnfallible wherein a man is neuer disappointed Conjecturall which is not so euident because it is grounded onely upon likelihoodes The first all Papiste◠〈◊〉 but the second they 〈◊〉 in the matter of saluation Againe certenty is either of faith oâ— experimentall which Papistes call â—â—rall Certenty of faith is whereby any thing is certenly beleeued and it is either generall or speciall Generall certenty is to beleeue assuredly that the word of God is trueth it selfe and this both wee and papistes allow Speciall certenty is by faith to apply the promise of saluation to our selues and to beleeue without doubt that remission of sinnes by Christ and life euerlasting belongs unto us This kind of certenty we holde and maintaine and Papists with one consent deny it acknowledging no assurance but by hope Morall certenty is that which proceedes from sanctification and good workes as signes and tokens of true faith This wee both allowe yet with some difference For they esteeme all certenty that comes by workes to be uncerten and often to deceiue but wee doe otherwise if the workes be done in uprightnesse of heart The question then is whether a man in this life may ordinarily without reuelation be vnfallibly certeâ— of his owne 〈◊〉 first of all â—â—d principally by faith and then secondly by such workes as are unseperable â—…panions of faith We hold this for a cleare â—tudent principle of the â—â—â—ord of God and â—â—â—trariwise the Pepists deny it wholly I will 〈◊〉 prâ—… the trueth by some â—ewe argâ—… and then answer the common obiections Argâ—â—â—â—t 1. That which the spirit of God doth first of all testifie in the heart and conscience of any â—â—n and then afterward fully confirme is to be beleeued of the same man as vnfallibly certâ—… but the spirite of God first of all doeth testifie to some men namely true beleeuers that they are the sonnes of God and afterward confirmes the same unto them therfore men are unfillibly to beleeue their owne adotion Now that the spirit of God doth giue this testimony to the conscience of man the scripture is more then plaine Rom. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 â—e have received the spirit of adoption whereby vvee cry Aâ—â—a Fâ—ther The same spirit beareth witnes vvith our spirit that we are the sonnes of God Answere is made that this testimony of the spirite is giuen onely by an experiment or feeling of an inward delight or peace which breeds in vs not an infallible but a coniâ—cturall certenty And I answere againe that this exposition is flat against the text For the spirit of adoption is said here not to make vs to thinke or speake but to cry Abba Father and crying to God as to a father argues courage confidence boldnesse Againe the same spirit of adoption is opposed to the spirit of bâ—â—dage causing feare therefore it must needs be a spirit giuing assurance of liberty by that means driuing away distrustfull feares And the end no doubt why the holy ghost comes into the heart as a witnes of adoption is that the truth in this case hidden therfore doubtful might be cleared and made manifest If Gòd himself haue appointed that a doubtfull truth among men shal be confirmed and put out of doubt by the mouth of two or three witnesses it is absurd to thinke that the testimony of God himselfe knowing all things and taking vpon him to be a witnes should be coniecturall S. Bernard had learned better diuinity when he saide who is iust but he that being loved of God returnes love to him againe which is not done but by the spirit of God reuealing by faith vnto man the eternall purpose of God concerning his salvation in tiâ—â— to come which revelation vndoubtedly is nothing else but an 〈◊〉 of spirituall grace by which whilest the deeâ—es of the flesh are mortified the man is prepared to the
the Hebrue text and Popish translaâ—…s themselues follow it not Obiect 2. Eccles. c. 9. Man knowes not whether he be worthy of loue or hatred For al things are kept vncerâ—eâ— till the time to coâ—e Answer First I say the translation is not 〈◊〉 the words are thus in the Hebrue and in the Sevenâ—â—e No man knoweth loue or hatred all things are before them As for these words all things are 〈◊〉 vncerten till the time to come are thrust into the text by head and shoulders and Hierome hath them not Secondly I answer that the H. Ghost doth not denie sâ—mply the knowledge of Gods loue or hâ—tred as though there could be 〈◊〉 certen assurance of it in this life If we vnderstand the words thus then the argument of the holy Ghost must be framed on this manner If loue or hatred were to be knowne then it must be knowne by the outward blessings of God but it cannot be knowne by the outward blessings of God for all things come alike to all therefore loue and hatred cannot be knowne The propositioÌ„ is false For loue may be known other waies then by outward benefits and therefore the reason is not meete to be ascribed to the spirit of truth Wherefore the true and proper sense of the words is that loue or hatred cannot be iudged or discerned by outward blessings of God S. Bernard speaks of this text on this manner that no man knowes loue or hatred namely by himselfe yet that God giues most certen testimonies thereof to men vpon earth And seâ—m 5. de Dediâ— his words are these who knowes if he be worthie loue or hatred who knowes the minde of the Lord. Here both faith truth must needs helpe vs that that which is hidden in the heart of the father may be reuealed vnto vs by the spirit and his spirit giuing testimonie persvvades our spirit that we are the sonnes of God and this perswasion is caused by his calling and iustifying vs freely by faith And S. Hierome though comonly abused to the contrarie saith no more but that men cannot know loue or hatred by the present afflictions which they suffer because they know not whether they suffer them for triall or for punishment Obiect 3. 1. Cor. 4. I iudge not my selfe I know nothing by my selfe Here Paul as not being privic to his own estate refuseth to giue any iudgement of his owne righteousnes Answ. It is manifest by the words of this epistle that certaine in Corinth boldly more then wisely censured the Apostles ministerie and withall disgraced it in respect of the ministery of other teachers Therfore Paul in this chapter goes about to make an Apologie for himselfe speaking nothing of his owne person and the estate thereof before God but onely of his ministerie and the excellencie thereof And this is the iudgement of Theodoret Aquinas and Lira vpon this text And when he saith I iudge not my selfe his meaning is I take not vpon me to iudge of what value and price my ministerie is before God in respect of the ministerie of this or that man but I leaue all to God Here then Paul refuseth onely to giue iudgement of the excellencie of his owne ministerie and in other cases he refused not to iudge him selfe as when he said I haue fought a good fight I haue kept the faith henceforth is laid vp for me the crowne of righteousnes which the Lord the righteous iudge shall giue me 〈◊〉 Tim. 4. 8. And Chrysostome on this place saith that Paul refused to iudge himselfe not simply but onely for this ende that he might restraine others and teach them modestie And where Paul saith I know nothing by my selfe the speach is not generall but must be vnderstoode of negligences and offences in the compasse of his ministery For he was priuie to himselfe that in simplicitie and godly purenes he had his conuersation in the world 2. Cor. 1. 12. and he knew this by himselfe that nothing should seuer him from the loue of God in Christ. Rom. 8. 38. Obiect 4. That we may be iustified there is somewhat required of vs namely faith and repentance and where these are wanting a man cannot be iustified Now no man can be certen by the certentie of faith that he repents of his sinnes with all his heart and that he hath such a faith as God requires at our hands considering there is no testimonie in the word of our faith and repentance in particular Therefore no man can be certen by certentie of faith that his sinnes are pardoned Answer It is not necessarie that any man should be certen by faith of his faith and repentance because faith is onely of such things as are absent where faith and repentance are truly present in all that truly beleeue and repâ—… it shall be sufficient if a man may any way â—…bly certen that he hath them And though â—ome men falsly perswade themselues that they beleeue yet he that hath true faith indeede knowes that he hath true faith euen as 〈◊〉 as he that vnderstands knowes that he vnderstands Paul saith to the Corinthians 〈◊〉 your sâ—…es vvhether ye be in the faith or 〈◊〉 2. Cor. 13. 5. hereby giuing them to vnderstand that all which beleeue haue the spirit of discerning to know certenly that they doe beleeue Againe he saith of himselfe 2. Tim. 1. 12. I knowe â—home I haue beâ—eeued And Saint Iohn saith 1. â—p 3. 24. By this we know that he dwells in vs by the spirit which he hath giuen vs making no question of it but that he which hath the spirit knowes that he hath the same And testimonies of men are not wanting in this case Augustine Euery one seeth faith to be in his owne heart if he beleeue if not he seeth it to be vvanting Againe A beleeuer seeth his oâ—ne faith by which he answereth that he beleeueth without doubt And He which leueth his brother more knoweth the leue whereby he â—â—â—eth then his brother whome he loueth Againe whereas it is said that hauing faith yet we know not whether it be â—â—â—ficient or no I answear that faith beeing without hypocrifie is sufficient to saluation though it be imperfect God more respects the trueth of our faith then the perfection thereof And as the hand of the child or of the palsie man though it be feeble is able to reach out it selfe and receiue an almes of a prince so the faith that is but weake is able to apprehend and receiue Christ with all his benefits Obiect 5. Prov. 28. Blessed is the man that feareth alvvaies Pâ—â—l 2. Worke your salvation with feare and trembling Answer There is a threefold feare one of nature the secoÌ„d of grace the third of distrust Feare of nature is that whereby the nature of man is troubled with any thing that is hurtfull vnto it and therefore auoideth it Feare of grace is that excellent gift which is called the beginning of wisdome and
are forgiven thee For so the Apostle thinketh that a man is iustified freely by faith Papists being much choked with this place make answer that S. Bernard doeth not say that wee â—ust beleeue the pardon of our sinnes absolutely without respect of workes but that hee requires the condition of our conversion and repentance as signes whereby this perswasion is wrought I answer againe that hee auoucheth plainly the generall faith whereby the points of religion are beleeued to be but a beginning or â—udiment of faith and therefore not sufficient vnlesse we goe further and apply the grace of God to our selues by faith simply without respect of any condition perfourmed on mans parte Indeede I graunt that the trueth of conversion and other workes are by him mentioned afterwarde but that was for this ende to shewe how any man may haue a sensible and euident experience by workes as fruits of the pardon of his owne sinnes life euerlasting which he beleeueth Argument 3. S. Iohn penned his first epistle that he might shewe unto the Church of God a way how they might ordinarily and fully be assured of the loue of God and of eternall life and therefore he affordeth vs many pregnant testimonies for this purpose 1. Ioh. 2. v. 3. And by this we know that we haue knowen him if wee keepe his commandements And v. 5. Hee which keepes his word in him is the word of God truely accomplished by this vvee know that wee are in him cap. 3. 10. By this are manifest the children of God and the children of the devill And v. 19. By this vve know that we are of the trueth and before him vvee shall make our hearts confident cap. 4. 13. By this we know that we dâ—â—ll in him and hee in vs because he hath given vs of his spirit cap. 5. 2. By this vvee knowe that we love the sonnes of God when we love god and keepe his commandements vers 13. I have written these things vnto you vvhich beleeve in the name of the sonne of God that yee may knovve that you haue life eternall To these testimonies first of all answere is made that none of them doe necessarily imply a certentie of diuine faith because wee are saide to knowe the thinges which wee leaâ—…e by coniectures Beholde a â—…y and poore shifte Saint Iohn saieth cap. 1. vers 4. These things vvee vvrite vnto yâ—â— that your â—oy may be full Now it is but an uncerten â—oy that riseth by coniecturall knowledge Againe this knowledge brings foorth conscience and bolâ—…sse even before God c. 3. v. 19 21. and therefore it can not but include an infallible cerâ—enâ—y and to put it out of question that the knowledge here mentioned is the knowledge of divine faith or as unâ—â—â—â—ible as it is or can be it is added cap. 4 16. And vvee have knovvon and beleeved the love vvhich God hath tovvardes vs. Secondly it is answered that all these speeches are generall and not concerning particular men but it is false for when Saint Iohn saieth vve know hee speakes of himselfe and includes the rest of the Church in the same condition with himselfe Now hee himselfe was fully assured of his owne saluation For Christ a little before his departure out of the worlde did comfort all his disciples partly by renewing the promise of life euerlasting and of the presence of his spirite unto them and partly by praying unto the father for their finall preseruation so as they could not but be fully resolued of their happy estate both in this life and in the life to come 〈◊〉 4. Abrahams faith 〈◊〉 a 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 whereby hee applyed the promise vnto himselfe Rom. 4. v. â—1 And this faith of his is an example propounded unto vs according to which we are to beleeue and therfore hee is called the father of the faithfull â—â—r 16. and Pâ—…l hauing 〈◊〉 downe the 〈◊〉 â—…d effectes of his faith saith It vvas 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 onely for him but also for vs vvhich 〈◊〉 v. 22. It is obiected that Abrahams faith was not of salvation but it concerned his 〈◊〉 in his olde age as Paul saieth Rom. 4. v. 〈◊〉 Abreham about hope beleeved that 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the father of many nations according to that vvhich vvas spoken so shall thy seeâ—… be Aâ—svver Wee must distinguish the obiect of faith which is either principall or lesse principall Principall is alwaies Christ with his benefites lesse principall are other lesse and particular benefites obtained by Christ. As of Abrahams faith the obiect lesse principall was a carnall seede or issue and the principall obiect most of all respected as the foundation of all other blessings was the blâ—… seede Christ Iesus Gâ—lat 3. v. 16. To Abraham and his seede vvere the promises made Hee saith not And to the seeds as of many but 〈◊〉 thy â—eed as of 〈◊〉 which is Christ. And v. 29. If yee be Christs then Abrahams seed Thuâ— it is plaine that issue was â—â—ither promised nor desired but with respect to Christ who coulde not haue descended of Abraham if he had bene wholly without seed Hauing thus alledged some arguments for the trueth I come now to consider the obiections of the Papistes Obiect I. Iob beeing a righteous man wanted certenty of grace in himselfe Iob. 9. v. 20. If I vvoulde iustifie my selfe mine evvne mouth shall condemâ—… 〈◊〉 if I vvoulde be perfect he shall iudge me â—icâ—ed though I vvere perfect yet my soule shall 〈◊〉 knovve it Againe vers 28. I am afraid of all my workes knovving that thou vvilt not iudge me innocent Answer Bildad in the former chapter had extolled the iustice of God Iob in this chapter giues assent thereto saying vers 2. I knovve verely it is so and hee likewise spendes the whole chapter in magnifying the iustice of God and hauing propounded this ende of his speech hee doth not speake of him selfe and his owne estate simply as it is considered 〈◊〉 it selfe bus as he esteemed himselfe being compared with God specially then when hee entereth into a straight examination of his creature And so must the speach â—e vnderstoode if 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 my soule should not knovv it that is I will not acknowledge or stand vpon any righteoâ—… of mine owne when God shal enter into iudgement with me And thus much the very Efect angels beeing in possession of heauen and therefore hauing more then assurance thereof can not but say when they are compared with God Againe the words according to the originall are commonly of all and so may well â—e translated thus Am I perfect I know not my soule I â—â—horre my life that is if I thinke my selfe perfect I haue no respect of mine owne soule oâ— thus I am perfect in respect of you and I know not my soule and I abhorre my life namely in respect of mine owne vprightnes And the other place is thus to be translated I feare all â—â—y sorrowes and not all my works for this is flat against
it is a certaine awe or râ—â—erence vnto God in whose presence we doe whatsoeuer we doe Feare of distrust is when men tremble at the iudgemeÌ„ts of God for their sinnes because they haue no hope of mercie Of these three the first was good by creation and therfore it was in our Sauiour Christ but since the fall it is defective The third is a vice called slâ—â—ish feare And the second is that which is commaunded in these and the like places of Scripture the intent whereof is to make vs circumspect and fearefull least we should offend God by any 〈◊〉 our owne weaknesse considered and the â—â—vineible iudgements of God And this kinde of feare as also the first may stande with câ—râ—â—ntie of faith Rom. 11. Thou standest by faith be not high minded but feare Psal. 2. Serâ—e the Lord in feare and reioyce in trembling Obiect 6. Where there is no word there is no faith For faith and the word of God be relatiues But there is no word of God that saith to particular men Cornelius or Peter or Iohn thy sinnes are pardoned excepting 〈◊〉 few persons as Mâ—… Magdâ—… and the pâ—… 〈◊〉 c. Therefore there is no particular faith Ansvv. Though there be no word set downe in Scripture touching the saluation of this or that particular man yet there is set downe that which is equivaleâ—â— to a particular word and as much in effect For the promise of remission of sinnes and life euerlasting is giuen with a commâ—undement that euery man applie the promise to himselfe as I haue before prooued and this is altogether as much as if euery mans particular name had beene put in the promise I adde further that the promises of the Gospel must be considered two waies first as they are generally set downe in Scripture without application to any person secondly as they are â—â—â—ght and published in the â—â—inisterie of the word the end whereof is to applie them to the persons of men partly by prâ—â—ching and pâ—â—tly 〈◊〉 administâ—ing the sacraments of baptisme and the Lords supper which are seales of righteoâ—â—â—â—s of faith Now the promise applied and as I may say particularized to the members of the Church is by the vertue of Gods ordinance as much as if God himselfe had giuen the promise particularly and â—…dment names vnto it It is further â—nswered that the promise of remission of sinne is preached not simply but vpoâ— condition of 〈◊〉 faith 〈◊〉 which 〈◊〉 be 〈◊〉 knowne I answer againe 〈◊〉 I haue alreadie prooued that he which truly beleeueth and repâ—…th knoweth that he doth certenly beleeue and repeâ—t Obiect 7. To beleeue the pardon of a mans owne sinnes is â—one of the articles of faith propounded in any Creede either of the Apostles or the Niceâ—e fathers or Athanasâ—â—s or any other Creede Answer This faith is contained vnder these words I beleeue remission of sâ—…es and I prooue it thus These words are an article of Christian faith and therefore they must in sense containe more then the deuill doth or can beleeue nowe the deuill beleeueth thus much that God giues remissioÌ„ of sinnes to his Church Christian men therefore must goe one steppe further and beleeue particularly the remission of their owne sinnes Otherwise if the Papists will haue the Catholicke faith to beleeue no more in this point then the damned spirits beleeue let them take it to themselues But they replie further that if there were any such article of faith then some persons must beleeue that they are iust though they willingly commit mortall sinne which is an euident falshood Ansvver He that beleeues the pardon of his owne sinnes by true faith hath the spirit of God in him and a constant purpose not to sinne against God and therefore if he sinne it is against his purpose and without any full consent of wil and it is not he that doeth it but the sinne that dwelleth in him But if it so fall our that the child of God be ouertaken with any actual sinne then his case standeth thus He hath by his fall wounded his conscience weakned his faith bereaued himselfe of Gods fauour as much as in him lieth made himselfe guiltie of a sinne and worthie of damnation and God for his part accordingly turnes the woonted signes of his sauour into signes of anger and displeasure and the sinne though it be pardoned in the purpose of God yet is it not actually pardoned till the partie repent Things standing thus we teach not that men must beleeue the pardon of their sinnes while they liue and lie in them for that were â—â—â—tly to teach falshoode for truth but our doctrine is that such persons must first of all humble themselues and say with the prodigall childe that they haue sinned against God and are not worthie to be called his children any more and againe renew their decaied faith and repentance that they may beleeue as before their perfect reconciliation with God Obiect 8. In respect of God who is truth it selfe we are to beleeue the promise in particular yet if we respect our owne vnworthines and indisposition we are to feare and in some part to doubt For the promise of remission of sinnes is not absolute but depends vpon the condition of our workes Therefore our certentie is onely coniecturall Answer I answer first that in respect of our owne vnworthines we are not to doubt of our saluation but to be out of all doubt yea to dispaire before the iudgement seate of God For they which are of the workes of the lawe are vnder â—he curse Gal. 3. 10. and Paul saith of his owne workes of grace in this am I not iustified 1 Cor. 4. 4. And Dauid being out of all doubt of his owne deserued damnation in regard of his owne vnworthines saith freely Enter not into indgement with thy servant O Lord for no flesh shallbe iâ—stified in thy sight Againe the consideration of any vnworthines in our selues doth not hinder a resolution concerning Gods mercy in Christ. For true faith makes an entrance vnto God vvith boldnes I say with boldnes euen for those persons that are vnworthy in themselues Eph. 4. 12. And Abraham whose faith is to be followed of vs did not vpon the consideration of his olde decaied bodie rest himselfe with bare hope vpon alikelihood of the accomplishment of Gods promise but he beleeued vnder hope euen against hope Rom. 4. 18. Lastly I answear that the ground of the former obiection is erronious namely that the promise of saluation depends on the condition of our workes because the Scripture saith it is made and accomplished on mans part freely I graunt indeede that to the promise there is annexed a condition of faith yet faith here must not be considered as a worke but as an instrument apprehending Christ with his benefits and withall â—epentance with the fruits thereof are on our part required yet no otherwise but as they are necessaric consequents of faith and the signes
of the reward of their perseverance yet they are founde to be vncerten of the perseverance it selfe for vvhat man can knovve that hee shall persevere in the practise and increase of righteousnesse vnto the end except he be assured of it by some revelation IV. Some places must be understoode of experimentall certenty when the euent is accomplished Hieronym booke 2. against Pelagians Callâ—o man blessed before his eâ—de for as long as vvee live here vve are in the fight and as long as vvee are in the fight vve haâ—â— no 〈◊〉 victory V. Some places speakes of the uncertenty of other mens salâ—â—â—tion which we grant The authour of the booke de vâ—◠〈◊〉 Gâ—… 〈◊〉 clast saith we caâ— prâ—…ce of 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 before his end that hee shall be in the glory of the 〈◊〉 August lib. 〈◊〉 Per sever c. 13. Men are not vvâ—… any 〈◊〉 asseveration to 〈◊〉 that 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 this calling VI. Some speake of that 〈◊〉 which comes by reuelation without the worde Greg. lib. 6. 〈◊〉 2â— 10 Gregoria Whereas you adde in your epistles that you will be earnest with me till I write that it hath bene made knowen unto me that your sâ—â—nes are forgiven you haue required a hard and unprofitable thing Harde because I am unvvorthy to vvhome a revelation should be made Vnprofitable because you must not be made secure touching your sinnes vnlesse it be in the last day of your life for then you should not be able to bewaile the same sinnes VII Some places denie unto man that certentie which is proper to God which is to discerne in himselfe all things to come plainly as they shal come to passe without helpe of testimonies and outward signes Bernard serm 1. de Septuages Who can say I am of the elect I am of the predestinate to life certenly we haue none as yet but the affiance of our hope comforteth vs. Conferre these wordes with those that follow For this cause certaine signes and manifest tokens of salvation are given that it may be a thing out of doubt that he is in the number of the elect in vvhome these signes are Thus I haue in some part made manifest that an unfallible certenty of pardon of sinne and life euerlasting is the property of euery renued conscience Now therefore I will proceede further to consider how this certenty is caused and imprinted in the conscience The principall agent and beginner thereof is the Holy ghost in lightning the minde and conscience with spirituall and diuine light and the instrument in this action is the ministery of the gospell wherby the worde of life is applyed in the name of God to the person of euery hearer And this certentie is by little and little conceiued in a forme of reasoning or practicall syllogisme framed in the mind by the holy ghost on this manner Euery one that beleeues is the child of God But I â—â—e beleeve Therefore I am the child of God The proposition is made by the minister of the worde in the publike congregation and it is nothing else but the promise of eternall life applyed to the particular hearer The second part or the assumption is the voice of conscience regenerate or the voice of Gods spirite in the same Now Papistes write and auouch that the assumption is false but the reasons which they use to prooue the same are of small moment First they alledge that many are deceiued in their perswasions thinking they haue that which they haue not I answere againe that many doe falsely presume of Gods mercy and imagine they haue that faith which they haue not and in all such the assumption is false yet in all them that are chosen to saluation and truely called it is vnfallibly true For such as haue receiued the gift of true faith haue also another gift of discerning whereby they see and know their owne faith It is further obiected that Ieremy saieth 17. 9. The heart is deceitfull and vvicked above all things vvho can knovve it But the intent of this place is onely to shew that no man can search his heart to the very bottome to see all and euery want infirmitie and wicked inclination that is therein For originall sinne wherewith the heart of man is tainted is a pronenesse or disposition to all the sinnes that are or may be And though men can not discerue all their sinnes yet many of them are certenly knowen why may not then many of the graces of God be certenly known specially those which be of the principall as faith sanctification repentance Againe it is alledged that Peter beleeued that he was able to lay downe his life for Christs sake and yet indeede was not as the euent declared for when the time came he denyed Christ. Ansvv. Peter at this time was but weake in faith and hee was much carried away with a confidence of his owne strength which made him speake these wordes of presumption and though he failed in this one particular action yet failed hee not in the principall that is in the perswasion of the pardon of his owne sinnes and of life euerlasting In a word it is certen that many perswade them-selues of Gods mercy and yet are deceiued neuerthelesse all such as doe truly beleeue are not deceiued The holy ghost making them to see that in themselues which by nature they can not discerne as Paul signified when he said I speake the truth I lie not my conscience bearing me witnesse by the Holy Ghost Rom. 9. v. 1. Againe the same testimony is giuen otherwise thus Euery childe of God hath the pardon of his sinnes saith Gods word But I am Gods child and therefore have the pardon of my sinnes saith the renewed conscience by the direction of Gods spirit Rom. 8. 16. Gal. 4. 6. After that this testimony is once begun it is confirmed by the same meanes as also by prayer and the sacraments Now it may be demanded how a bodily element as bread wine water should be able to confirme a perswasion of our adoption that is in the conscience Ansvv. The element in the sacrament is an outwarde seale or instrument to confirme faith not as a medicine restores and confirmes health whether we thinke on it or not whether we sleepe or wake and that by his owne inherent vertue but by reasoning in syllogisme made by the good conscience the 〈◊〉 thereof beeing the outwarde signe in the sacrament By means of which syllogisme the Holy Ghost mooues and stirres the mind yea cherisheth and increaseth faith on this manner Hee which vseth the elements aright shall receive the promises But I do or I haue used the elements aright Therefore I shall receive the promises Whereas presumption and the illusion of Satan will as well tell a man that he is the childe of God as the true testimony of regenerate conscience the way to put difference betwene them is this I. Presumption is naturall and from the very wombe but this testimony of conscience
higher powers Rom. 13. 1. or Honour father and mother Exod. 20. which commaundements binde vs in conscience to performe obedience to the good laws of men As S. Peter saith Submit your selues to euery humane ordinance for the Lord 1. Pet. 2. 13. that is for conscience of God as he saith afterward v. 19. wherby he signifieth two thing first that God hath ordained the authority of gouernours secondly that he hath appointed in his word and thereby bound men in conscience to obay their gouernours lawfull commandements If the case fall out otherwise as commonly it doth that humane laws be not inacted of things indifferent but of things that be good in themselues that is commanded by God then are they not 〈◊〉 properly but divine lawes Mens laws intreating of things that are morally good and the parts of Gods vvorshippe are the same with Gods laws and therfore binde conscience not because they were inacted by men but because they were first made by God men beeing no more but instruments and ministers in his name to revive renew and to put in exequution such precepts and laws as prescribe the worship of God standing in the practise of true religion vertue Of this kind are all positiue lawes touching articles of faith the duties of the morall law And the man that breakes such lawes sinnes two waies first because he breaks that which is in conscience a law of God secondly because in disobaying his lawfull magistrate he disobâ—… the generall commandement of God touching magistracie But if it shall fall out that mens lawes be made of things that are cuill and forbidden by God then is there no bonde of conscience at all but contrariwise men are bound in conscience not to obay Act. 4. 19. And hereupon the three children are commended for not obaying Nabuchadnezzar when he gaue a particular commandement vnto them to fall downe and worship the golden image Dan. 3. Moreouer in that mans law binds onely by power of Gods law hence it follows that Gods law alone hath this priuiledge that the breach of it should be a sinne S. Iohn saith 1. epist. 3. Sinne it the anomie or transgressioÌ„ of the law vnderstanding Gods lawe When Dauid by adulterie and murder had offended many men that many waies he saith Psal. 51. against thee against thee haue I sinned And Augustine defined sinne to be some thing said done or desired against the law of God Some man may say if this be so belike then we may breake mens laws without sinne I answer that men in breaking humane lawes both may and doe sinne but yet not simply because they breake them but because in breaking them they doe also breake the law of God The breach of a law must be considered two waies First as it is a trespasse hinderance iniurie damage and in this respect it is committed against mens lawes secondly the breach of a law must be considered as it is sinne and so it is onely against Gods law The second point namely How farreforth mens lawes binde conscience I explane on this manner It is all that the lawes of God doe or can doe to binde conscience simply and absolutely Therefore humane laws bind not simply but so farre forth as they are agreeable to Gods word serue for the coÌ„mongood staÌ„d withgood order and hinder not the libertie of conscience The necessitie of the law ariseth of the necessitie of the good end thereof And as the end is good and profitable more or lesse so is the law it selfe necessarie more or lesse Hence it followeth that a man may doe any thing beside humane lawes and constitutions without breach of conscience For if he shall omit the doing of any law I. without hindrance of the ende and particular considerations for which the law was made II. without offence giuing as much as in him lieth III. without contempt of him that made the law he is not to be accused of sinne Example In time of warre the magistrate of a citie commands that no man shall open the gates the end is that the citie and euery member thereof may be in safetie Now it falls out that certaine citizens beeing vpon occasion without the citie are pursued by the enemie and in daunger of their lifes Herupon some man within openeth the gate to resâ—…e them The question is whether he haue sinned or no. And the truth is he hath not because he did not hinder the ende of the law but rather further it and that without scandal to men or contempt to the magistrate And this stands euen by the equitie of Gods word God made a law that the priests onely should eate of the shewbread now Dauid being no priest did vpon vrgent occasion eate of it without sinne If this be true in Gods law then it may also be true in the lawes of men that they may in some cases be omitted without sinne against God Neither must this seeme strange For as thâ—re is a keeping of a law and a breaking of the same so there is a middle or meane action betwâ—â—ne them both which is to doe thing beside the law and that without sâ—â—â—e To proceede further mens laws be either civill or ecclesiasticall Civill laws are for their substance determinations of necessarie and profitable circumstances tendâ—â—â— to â—â—hold and maintaine the commandemâ—… of the 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 More specially they prescribe what is to be doâ— and what is to be left vndone touching actions both civill criminal touching offices and bâ—rgines of all soâ—â—â— c. yea they conclude inioyne commaÌ„d not onely such affaires as be of smaller importaÌ„ce but also things actions of great waight tending to maintaine common peace civill societie and the very state of the common wealth Now such laws binde so farre forth that though they be omitted without any apparanâ— sâ—â—ndal or contempâ— yet the breach of them is a sinne against God Take this example A subiect in this lande vpon pouertie or vpon a couctous minde against the good law of the land coines money which after ward by a sleight of his wit is cunningly conuaied abroad into the hands of men and is not espied Here is no euident offence giuen to any man nor open contempt shewed to the lawgiuer and yet in this action he hath sinned in that closely otherwise then he ought to haue done he hath hindered the good of the common wealth and robbed the soueraigne prince of her right Ecclesâ—sticall lawes are certaine necessarie and profitable determinations of circumstances of the commaundements of the first table I say bâ—â—e 〈◊〉 because all doctrines pertaining to the foundation and good estate of the Church as also the whole worshippe of God 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 downe and commaâ—nded in the written word of God and cannot be prescribed and concluded otherwise by all the Churches in the world Aâ—â—or the Creedes and Confessionâ— of particular Churches they are in substance Gods word and they binde not in conscience by any power
because conscience 〈◊〉 not say of them that they please God Esa. 29. 13. Mark 7. v. 7. Lastly wee learne here that igâ—orâ—nce of Gods will and word is a daungerous thing and makes the life of man to abound yea to flowe with a sea of offences against God Men commonly thinke that if they keepe themselues froÌ„ petiurie blasphemie murder theft whordome all is well with them but the truth is that so long as they liue in ignorance they want right and true direction of conscience out of Gods word and therfore there best actions are sinnes euen their eating and drinking their sleeping and waking their buying and selling their speach and silence yea their praying and seruing of God For they doe these actions either of custome or example or necessitie as beasts doe and not of faith because they know not Gods will touching things to be done or left vndone The consideration of this point should make euery man most carefull to seeke for knowledge of Gods word and daily to increase in it that he may in all his affaires haue Gods lawes to be the men of his counsell Psal. 119. 24. that 〈◊〉 may giue heede to them as to a light shining in a â—â—rke place 〈◊〉 Pet. 1. 19. that he may say with Pâ—â—er when Christ commanded him to lanch forth into the deepe and to cast forth his net Lord â—ve hâ—â—e ben allâ—ight ana haue catched nothing yet in thy word vvill I let dâ—vvne my â—â—t Luk 5. 5. CAP. III. Of the kindes of conscience and of conscience regenerate COnscience is either good or badde Good conscience is that which rightly according to Gods worde excuseth and comforteth For the excellence goodnes and dignitie of conscience standes not in accusing but in excusing And by doing any sinne whatsoeuer to giue an occasion to the conscience to â—…use or condemne is to wound it and to offend in Thus Paul saith that the Corinthians â—…ded the consciences of their 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 whâ—… they vsed their libertie as an â—ccasian of offence to them 1. Cor. 8. 9. 〈◊〉 Agaiâ—… he calleth a good conscience a conscience without offence that iâ— which hath no stoppe o◠〈◊〉 to hinder it from excusing Act. 24. 16. Good conscience is either good by 〈◊〉 or by regeneration Good by creation was the conscience of Adam which in the estate of innocencie did onely excuse could not accuâ—â— him for any thing though it may be an 〈◊〉 to accuse was not wanting 〈◊〉 afterward an occasion should be offered And hence we haue further direction to consider what a good conscience is namely such an one as by the order set downe in the creation exâ—…th onely without accuâ—… 〈◊〉 cuse is a defect in the 〈◊〉 following â—…ter the first creation Fee naâ—â—rally there is an agreement and harmony betweene the parts and the whole but if the conscience should naturally accuse there should be adâ—ssent and disagrâ—â—ment and diuision betweene the conscience and the man himselfe Regenerate conscience is that which bâ—eing corrupt by nature is renewed and purged by faith in the blood of Christ. For to the regenerating of the conscience there is required a conversion or chaunge because by 〈◊〉 all mens consciences since the fall are euill and none are good but by grace The instrument â—…ing to make this chaunge is faith Act. 15. 9. Faith purifieth the heart The mâ—…orious cause is the blood of Christ Hebr. 9. 14. How much more shal the blood of Christ c. purge your conscience froÌ„ dead works to sâ—rue the liuing God The propertie of regenerate conscience is twofold Christian 〈◊〉 Câ—ttentiâ— of saluation Because both these haue their place not in the outward man but in the 〈◊〉 and conscience Châ—istian libeâ—… 〈◊〉 spirituall and holy freedome purchased by Christ. I say it is spiâ—… first to put a difference bâ—…ne it and civill libertie which standes in outward and bodily freedomes and priuiledges secondly to confute the Iewes that looke for earthly libertie by Christ and the Anabaptists who imagine a freedome from all authoritie of magistrates in the kingdome of Christ. Againe I say it is an holy freedome to confute the 〈◊〉 who thinke that by the death of Christ they haue libertie to liue as they list Lastly I say that it is purchased by Christ to shew the author thereof Gal. 5. 1. Standfast iâ— the libertie vvhere with Christ hath made you free And to confute the Papists whose doctrine in effect is thus much that this libertie is prâ—…red indeede by Christ but is continued partly by Christ and partly by the man himselfe Christian libertie hath three parts The first is a freedome from the iustification of the morall lawe For he that is a member of Christ is not bound in conscience to bring the perfect righteousnes of the law in his owne person for his iustification before God Gal. 5. 1. with v. 3. Hence it followeth that he that is a Christian is likewise freed from the curse and condemnation of the law Rom. 8. 1. There is no condemnation to them that are in Christ. Gal. 3. 13. Christ hath redeemed vs from the curse of the law when he was made a curse for vs. By this first part of Christian libertie it appeares that there cannot be any iustification of a sinner by workes of grace before God For he that will be iustified but by one worke is debter to the vvhole lavv Gal. 3. 3. but no man that is a member of Christ is debter to the whole law for his libertie is to be free in that point therefore no man is iustified so much as by one worke The second part is freedome from the rigour of the law which exacteth perfect obedience and condemneth all imperfection Rom. 6. 14. Sinne hath no more dominion ouer yoâ— for ye are not vnder the law but vnder grace 1. Ioh. 5. 3. This is the loue of God that ye keepe his commandements and his commandements are not grieuous Hence it followeth that God will accept of our imperfect obedience if it be sincere yea he accepts the will desire and indeauour to obay for obedience it selfe Malach. 3. 17. And I vvill spare them as a man spareth his owne sonne that serueth him The third part is that the conscience is freed from the bond of the ceremoniall law Gal. 3. 25. But after that faith is come we are no more vnder a schoolemaster Eph. 2. 15. And hath broken the stoppe of the partition wall in abrogating through his flesh the lavv of commaundements vvhich standeth in ordinances Coloss. 2. 14. And hath put out the hand vvriting of ordinances vvhich vvas against vs. v. 16. Let no man therefore condemne you in meate and drinke or in respect of an holy day or of the new moone c. Hence it followeth that all Christians may freely without scruple of coÌ„science vse all things indifferent so be it the manner of vsing them be good And first when I say that all may