so may be reduc'd to two general heads viz. 1. In respect of the faith it self 2. In respect of the professors thereof 1. In respect of the faith of Christ 1. The excellency thereof doth appear from the manifold assaults and machinations of the devil thereagainst for were not the stedfast profession of the Christian faith and the conscientious practise thereof the way both of Gods acceptable service and of mans salvation the devil would never be so busie to corrupt and adulterate the same whose inveterate enmity both to God and man incites provokes him perpetually to deprave and falsifie the pure worship of the one and hinder the salvation of the other 2. The holy faith of Christ appears more pure sincere and illustrious by the test and opposition of heretical positions we read Numb 16.36 that the Lord commanded Moses to take the censers of those proud rebels which rose up against Moses and Aaron wherein they offered strange fire before the Lord and to make broad plates for a covering of the Altar for they offered them before the Lord therefore are they hallowed sc sanctificata in mortibus peccatorum Through the death of the offenders they were sanctified to be a memorial to the children of Israel to beware of the like schism insurrection and sacriledge These censers saith the Father are a figure of the holy Scriptures wherein Heretiques offer strange fire by imposing a strange sense and distinct from the minde of Gods Spirit therein which is so abominable unto God that 't is commonly the ruine of the Authors and abettors thereof But yet if we bring these brazen censers to the golden Altar of God and compare the strange fire therein with the true fire from heaven the lustre of the one will appear more clear and eminent through the false and counterfeit glosse of the other for as that maxime is true in general Contraria inter se opposita magis elucescunt All contraries by their mutual opposition do more clearly shew themselves so this in particular also is as true veritas falsorum comparatione magis fulgebit Truth when compared and opposed to falshood appears like gold from the dross when tryed in the fire more illustrious and shining 'T is one reason therefore why holy catholick doctrine is so much besieged and impugned by heretical gainsayers and tares of erroneous opinions are intermixt with the pure grain of sincerity and truth viz. That the holy faith might not loose its gloss and lustre but appearing like it self clear and perspicuous might more effectually conduce to the illumination of our souls 3. The holy faith by the opposition of Heresie is elevated and raised to a higher pitch of perfection and the mysteries thereof become thereby to be more acutely handled more narrowly sifted and throughly considered whereas otherwise like children we should ever be content with milk and neglect the more solid and substantial food Haereticos permisit Deus ne semper lacte nutriamur in bruta infantia remaneamus Aug. Tract 36. in Joh. resting in generals and not descending to the discussion and right understanding of particular truths So saith the Father God therefore suffers Heretiques amongst us that we might not alway be nourished with milk and continue for ever in the more brutish estate of infancy 4. The holy faith by the opposition of Heresie is the more confirmed and strengthned even as trees shaken with the winde take the faster hold and are thereby more firmly enrooted in the earth so the more the foundation of our faith is assaulted and shaken by the gusts of heretical opinions the faster hold is taken and more firmly the principles of holy truth are enrooted in our hearts Nor is this the weakest argument to perswade us of and confirm us in the truth of all the Articles of the Christian faith that notwithstanding the several oppositions of Heresies in all ages many whereof have for the time so prospered and prevailed as to infect the greater and more eminent sort of Christian professors yet the true faith hath ever in the end triumphed over them they have dasht themselves in pieces like waves against a rock have broken into a foam and vanisht in to smoke for magna est veritas praevalebit As for truth it endureth and is alwaies strong it liveth and conquereth for evermore Esd 4.38 The second general end why God permits Heresies is in respect of the professors of the holy faith And these being of two sorts good and bad either such as are sound grain or else such as are empty chaffe therefore he suffers the fan of temptation to passe over all by the assaults of erroneous opinions that the one might be distinguisht from the other that the corn might be winnowed from the chaffe the wheat separate from the tares and soundorthodox Christians might be known from the unsound hollow-hearted Chrys Hom. 19. in Mat. 7. hypocritical professors of the faith That the evil may not be crowned with the good therefore God sends temptations saith the Father and that the good may not perish with the evil therefore he commands us to beware of false Prophets 2. The reason why the unsound and sinful professors are tempted and by temptation overcome by the assaults of erroneous opinions in Religion is by the just judgement of God permitted for a punishment upon them for as it is in the way of sinfulness one sin is commonly the punishment of another God most justly withdrawing the assistance of his divine grace from such as wilfully transgress his most holy Lawes Peccatum quod non per poenitentiā diluitur mox suo pondere ad aliud trahitur Greg. So that when sin saith the Father is not washed away with the tears of repentance the weight thereof sinks the soul into the puddle of following sins His own iniquities shall take the wicked himself and he shall be holden with the cords of his sins Prov. 5.22 So it is in the way of Error they who receive not the truth in the love and life thereof which is sound and sincere obedience thereunto For this cause God shall send them strong delusions that they should believe a lie that they all might be damned who believed not the truth but had pleasure in unrighteousness 2 Thess 2.10,11,12 So Saul for his disobedience 1 Sam. 15.22,23 The Spirit of the Lord departed from him and an evil spirit from the Lord troubled him 1 Sam. 16.14 So Ahab for his many abominations refused to ear hthe voice of the true Prophet Micaiah and listned to false Prophets to his own ruine and destruction 2 Chron. 18. And so Judas whose faith in Christ was never sound but his Religion lay in his purse not in his heart was therefore suffered to be tempted and eternally ruined by that temptation to betray his Master 3. In respect of the sound and sincere professors of Christianity God permits Heresies for many useful and profitable reasons 1. That
that by the guidance of this twofold light thy Word without and thy Spirit within both our outward and inward man may be directed in the waies of thy service and of our own salvation through Jesus Christ our Lord Amen A DISCOURSE OF ERROR HERESIE SCHISM The Nature Kindes Causes c. With Directions for avoiding thereof For there must be Heresies among you that they which are approved may be made manifest among you 1 Cor. 11.19 Ecce habes ecclesiam per totum mundum noli sequi falsos justificatores sed veros praecipitatores Aug. in Joh. Tract London Printed 1656. The Ground and general Heads of the ensuing Discourse 1. THere were never any times wherein that admonition of S. Peter was more necessary to be observed by all careful and conscientious Christians Be sober and vigilant for your adversary the Devil as a roaring Lion walketh about seeking whom he may devour 1 Pet. 5.8 2. There are two waies whereby the Devil working upon mens frailties and upon their extravagant lusts and passions doth devour or destroy their souls 1. By blinding their understandings whereby they become apt to be seduced to the entertainment of errors and belief of lies 2. By poysoning their affections with the false paint of worldly vanities whereby they are ininveigled into sinfulnesse and vice 3. And so nearly and entermixedly are the acts of the understanding enterwoven with those of the will and affections that the corruption of the one doth ever corrupt and vitiate the other So that as sinfulness on the one hand clouds the judgement and is ever productive of errors in the understanding so an erroneous Judgement on the other hand is ever fruitful is the production of sinful acts and habits 4. Hence it comes to passe by necessary consequence the just judgement of God concurring that the great and crying sins of our Nation have produced so many great and dangerous overspreading errors amongst us For the broaching and belief of lies as 't is in it self a sin and the fruitfull dam of many sins so 't is also by the just judgement of God a punishment for sin which is affirmed 2 Thess 2.10,11 Because they received not the love of the Truth that they might be saved For this cause God shall send them strong delusions that they should believe a lie 5. The love of the Truth is not received so as to be effectual unto salvation three waies 1. When we do not acquiesce and rest in it but fondly doat upon new Lights and new Revelations as if the truth of Christ revealed were imperfect and defective 2. When we do not practise and live according to the truth having a form of godlinesse in the doctrinal knowledge and discourse of the truth only but no power in the conscientious practise thereof 3. When we do not persevere either in the profession of the true Faith or practicall obedience thereof 6. When any of these waies the love of the truth is rejected the guilt of so great a crime most justly provokes the Almighty to permit holy Truth to be poysoned with lies and doctrines of Devils And in this respect God himself affirms him self to be the author not actively but permissively of all delusions as Ezek. 14.9 If the Prophet be deceived when he hath spoken a thing If the Lord have deceived that Prophet which God doth most justly for the sinful disobedience of the people for this is no other saith Hierome Hier. in loc but what is agreeable to that threat Luk. 26.27,28 If you will not hearken unto me but walk contrary unto me then will I walk contrary unto you in fury c. There being nothing that God inflicts more contrary to the happinesse of a people then the infatuation of their Priests and Prophets But Haeretici veris catholicis membris Christi malo suo prosunt dum Deus utitur malis bene diligentibus ewn omnia cooperantur in bonum Rom. 8. as all things work together for good to them that love God so do Heresies and errors also The which as they are for evil by the infatuation of the wicked so they are for good also in the further illumination and sanctification of the Righteous Nor would the supreme goodnesse ever suffer the evill of Heresie or any other evill to be but that he full well knows how to bring good out of evill 8. That we may then attain those good ends for the which God permits Heresies amongst us and avoid the evil of infection and infatuation thereby or according to the same Father Aug. Ut quisque sic carpet botrum ut caveat spinas ex luto aurum colligat That every one may so pluck the fruits as to avoid the thornes and gather the gold of sound doctrine out of the mire of filthy Dreams and delusions 't will be necessary seriously to weigh and consider 1. The nature of Error Heresie and Schism with the general heads hereof 2. The danger of being infected thereby 3. The ends for which God permits them 4. To observe such rules and receive such directions as may by divine assistance keep him free from infection by them OF ERROR HERESIE and SCHISM CHAP. I. Of Error in general 1. EVery man by nature is as prone to Error as to sin the understanding being as well clouded as the will and affections corrupted by the fall of Adam Our first parents out of a sawcy presumption affecting to know what they ought not involv'd themselves and all their posterity in blindness and ignorance of what they ought to know The body of man being subjected to natural corruption and mortality subjects the soul whilest 't is imprisoned therein to a spiritual corruption also through ignorance and error For the corruptible body saith the wise man presseth down the foul and the earthly tabernacle weigheth down the minde that museth upon many things and hardly do we guesse aright at things that are upon earth In nallo errore non humanitatis sed Deitatis solum est Aug. serm ad frat in erem and with labour do we finde the things that are before us and the things that are in heaven who hath searched out Wisd 9.15,16 So that not to be ignorant and not erre in the points and particulars of heavenly truth is not humane saith the Father but the sole prerogative of the divine nature 2. There is a threefold ignorance wherewith all the minds of men are naturally clouded 1. To be ignorant of what is necessary to be known 2. Not to know what is necessary and expedient for us agreeable to our persons callings breeding and the times wherein we live 3. When through a corrupt and depraved disposition of minde we mistake falshood for truth and darkness for light and this whether in bare opinion or else of set purpose and setled determination The last of these is the most sinful ignorance and that which properly and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 is called Error
High-priests and Pharisees to take counsell against our Saviour to put him to death for say they If we let him alone all men will believe on him 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 The Romans will come and take away our place and Nation Joh. 11.48 It was this spirit also that stirred up Demetrius the Silver-smith with the rest of the Crafts-men of the like occupation against St. Paul and his companions and the holy Christian Religion preached by them his Pretence was Religion such a kinde Religion as it was viz. Lest the Temple of the great goddesse Dianu should be nothing esteemed and her magnificence whom Asia and all the world worshipt should be destroyed but this Religion was blown by the winde of his own worldly ends his profit his gain which he got by making silver shrines for Diana was in danger to be lost and therefore it was now time for to stir not so much for the maintenance of her honour as his own profit Act. 19.27 Act. 19.27 And 't is this spirit of the world that possesses the greatest part of the world generally and for the most part men measure and square out their Religion by the rule of their profit or pleasure or preferment or credit and esteem amongst men or indeed at the best by the rule of self-preservation so far perhaps they will sail by the winde of Gods Spirit as the Sea of this world is calm peaceable pleasant and the navigation gainful or at least not chargeable but if any tempest arise any gusts of trouble or opposition against the truth blow in the face of its professors if any dammages or dangers pursue them in their course they presently tack about and will sail no longer by the heavenly winde of God but by the earthly winde of their own worldly ends and interests not by the winde which blows from heaven but by that which ariseth out of the caves and hollows of an earthly minde Jam. 1.6 2 Sam. 24.24 suffering themselves by this wind to be tossed to and fro and driven to be of this or that or any Religion that shall cost them nothing nothing of charge trouble or danger ebbing and flowing in this worlds vast sea as the tide either of prosperity or adversity danger or security makes for or against them But this surely is such a spirit as blows quite crosse and contrary to the spirit which guided and directed the Apostles for they finished their course over the troublous sea of this world to the celestial Canaan by sayling in all weathers encountring all oppositions and passing through all storms that met and opposed them In afflictions in necessities in distresses in stripes in prisons in tumults in labours by watchings by fastings c. 1 Cor. 6.4,5,6 1 Cor. 6,4,5,6 And yet in all these difficulties still faith the father Aug. The yoke of Christ is easie and his burthen light nay there is ease peace and comfort to the soul in the midst of all the troubles dangers wants or necessities that can in this life encounter us whilest the holy Ghost secretly by his comforts both cheers our spirits and fils the sails of our desires with the hopes of arriving safe in the end at the harbour of eternal peace and felicity CHAP. IX Of the Tryal of Spirits general 3 SInce then that grand malignant Spirit the enemy of our salvation working by these two Familiars mans own deceivable spirit and the spirit of the world doth thus many waies counterfeit poyson pervert and consequently obstruct impede and overthrow the workings of the Spirit of grace as an Antidote against this poyson of the serpent and that his countermines prevail not to the subversion of our souls we must make use of that friendly admonition of the Apostle never so necessary to be observed and practised as now 1 Joh. 4.1 Dearly beloved beleeve not every Spirit but try the spirits whether they be of God or no for many false Prophets are gone out into the world The admonition is twofold First negative Beleeve not every spirit Secondly positive Try the spirits and there is one general reason given for both because many false prophets are gone out into the world He then that shall be so credulous as to give heed to every one that pretends to the Spirit of truth and under that pretence treats of holy and spiritual things and shall not first by the rule of truth examine and try such things and persons shall be sure to have lies and errors obtruded upon him under the dresse and attire of Truth because there ever was and ever shall be by Gods permission and the Devils suggestion false Prophets or false Teachers in the world and yet as fair and great pretenders to the truth as the very true patrons and promoters thereof such there were ever in the Church of God both under the Law of old 2 Pet. 2.1 and under the Gospel anew 2 Pet. 2.1 But there were false Prophets also among the people even as there shall be false Teachers among you which privily shall bring in damnable heresies even denying the Lord that bought them and shall bring upon themselves swift destruction And 't were well if the poyson spread no further so that others were not infected therewith also but so nauseous is Truth to the mindes of men for its age and antiquity and so acceptable are Lies and Errors for their novelty that these false Teachers never fail of many disciples and followers so it followes vers 2. 2 Pet. 2 1. And many shall follow their destructions by whom the way of truth shall be evil spoken of First then beleeve them not follow them not be not cousen'd by their fair pretences so as to be infected with their false doctrines 'T is our Saviours own command Mat. 24.23 Mat. 24.23 If any man shall say unto you Loe here is Christ or Loe there beleeve it not for there shall arise false Christs and false Prophets and shall shew great signs and wonders so that if it were possible they should deceive the very elect But that being forewarn'd ye may be arm'd against their delusions Behold I have told you before Wherefore if they shall say unto you Behold he is in the desert go not forth Behold he is in the secret places beleeve it not The same care and caution was commanded by God to his people under the Law Deut. 13 1. If there arise among you a Prophet or a Dreamer of dreams and give thee a sign or a wonder Vers 2. and the sign and the wonder which he hath told thee come to passe saying Let us go after other Gods which thou hast not known and let us serve them 3. Thou shalt not hearken unto the words of the Prophet or unto that Dreamer of dreams For the Lord your God proveth you to know whether you love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul From whence
not so sublime and piercing as by its own innate force and vertue to be raised up and enrapt with celestial knowledge Wisd 9 15. For the corruptible body presseth down the soul and the earthly tabernacle weigheth down the minde that museth upon many things and hardly do we ghesse aright at things that are upon earth and with labour do we finde the things that are before us but the things that are in heaven who hath searched out and thy counsel who hath known except thou give wisdome and send thy holy Spirit from above For so the waies of them that lived upon earth were reformed and men were taught the things that are pleasing unto thee and were saved through wisdome 3. The first and fundamental act of faith then which is to believe this or that Article of holy Religion to be a divine truth and the subject matter of our obedience depends upon Divine Revelation and command from God He hath shewed thee O man what is good Micah 6.8 What thing so ever I command thee observe to do it Holy Religion is not of an earthly but of a heavenly descent It is a beam displayed from that light of truth which is eternal and immutable her dwelling is in the holy heavens Wisd 9 10. where she waits upon the throne of glory And to earth she descends not by any natural investigation but by supernatural revelation Mirand de fid oâ—d cred Omnis religio supernis revelationibus nititur aut niti praesumitur All religion depends upon revelation from above Flesh and bloud hath not revealed it but my Father which is in heaven Mat. 16.17 4. That there is a general knowledge of God and some notions of that religious worship we owe unto him imprinted in the hearts of all men by nature and is legible in the book of the creatures the Apostle affirms Rom. 1.20 For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen being understood by the things that are made even his eternal power and Godhead But this sight of God being not clear enough to bring us to the beatifical vision and fruition of God which is that perfection and felicity whereunto by being enstampt after the image of God he hath created c. therefore it hath pleased him more clearly to reveal himself and the waies of his religious worship to his Church and people in all ages And this either 1. extrardinarily and immediately or 2. ordinarily and in the use of means 5. The first revelation of divine truth was immediate i. e. without the mediation or ministry of man intervening But yet so as that 1. All those holy persons to whom God immediately revealed himself by certain infallible signs did themselves know and make known to others that the revelations they recelyed were no delusions but from God himself the fountain of truth proceeding God never speaks so extraordinarily but by the same act he both makes known the things spoken and himself to be the speaker 2. That all immediate revelation was generally confirmed by miracle therefore the Jews required signs of Christ as the means to confirm every new and immediate revelation Joh. 2.18 6.30 1 Cor. 1.22 3. That not all nay nor all holy persons but only some few choice select vessels had the honour of this immediate revelation the main body of the people still received the knowledge of God by mediation i. e. from their hands in whom the office of Priesthood was in all ages enstated For the Priests lips should keep knowledge and they i. e. the people should seek the Law at his mouth for he is the messenger of the Lord of hosts Mal. 2.7 6. The truth whereof as also what we are to beleeve concerning divine revelation will appear if we do impartially consider and weigh 1. To what persons and after what manner God revealed himself from Adam unto Christ 2. That by Christ and his Apostles the whole minde of God is so fully revealed that we must not now look for the revelation of any new truths 3. That the right understanding of what is already revealed depends not upon Gods immediate inspiration or revelation from heaven but is to be acquired by Gods blessing in the use of means And that in order hereunto the knowledge of tongues and sciences is both useful and necessary 4. That to depend upon immediate revelation is not only dangerous but destructive to the truth already revealed 5. That all those texts of holy Scripture commonly alledg'd for the proof of immediate revelation are misunderstood and wrested OF DIVINE REVELATION Mediate and Immediate CHAP. I. Of divine Revelation from Adam unto Christ 1. MAn being created after the Image of God was undoubtedly at the first endued with such a perfect knowledge of divine truth as was necessary to the attainment of that felicity whereunto God created him viz. the beatifical vision and fruition of his Creator for ever For as Philosophers do affirm If it were possible that the invisible and all spiritual God could be represented under any visible or compounded shape and being His body then must needs be composed of Light and his soul of Truth So essential to the very being of God is knowledge and truth and so consequently to the being of man after the image of God 2. But this light of divine knowledge was by mans disobedience too soon eclipst and his soul involv'd in the darknesse of sinfulness ignorance and error our first parents out of a sawcy ambitious affectation to know what they ought not engulft themselves and all their posterity into a natural blindness and ignorance of what they ought to know so that ever since hoc tantum scimus quòd nihil scimus the most knowing man knowes best his own ignorance and want of knowledge For if any man think he knows any thing he knoweth nothing yet as he ought to know 1 Cor. 8.2 3. But since without the knowledge of God and of his most holy will that perfection of our being whereunto God hath created us cannot be attained Joh. 17.3 therefore it pleased God to restore our first faln parents in some measure to the knowledge of himself and of his will in the waies of his worship and this he did either immediately by himself or by the mediation of intervening Angels by the voice from heaven convey'd upon the wings of the winde for so we read Gen. 3.8 And they heard the voice of the Lord God walking in the garden in the cool or in the winde of the day Junins in loc winde conveying his voice into their ears and thereby his into their hearts 4. By vertue of this divine Revelation or some others not recorded in holy Writ Adam received from God both the knowledge of that religious service and obedience which God then required from man and therewithall the honour of the Priesthood also being as the first man so the first Priest in the world 5.
ministerial gifts may be obtained in the use of outward means without the internal sanctification of soul which consists in charity or love which is the fulfilling of the Law 2. But then secondly The gift of prophesie with all the wisdome and knowledge of holy things though they may be and often are useful for the edification of others yet are they altogether fruitless and ineffectual to the person that hath them if not animated by the grace of charity or obedience to the Lawes of God for so they are not much unlike a candle in a dark lanthorn which casteth its light abroad upon others leaving the person that holds it in darknesse CHAP. XV. The dangerous and destructive consequences of and depending upon immediate Revelation HEe that pretends unto or depends upon any further Revelations from heaven then God in his great mercy hath already afforded unto his Church and people viz. 1. His written Word 2. Those several means and helps forementioned both divine and humane outward and inward for the right understanding of his Word by the blessing of God and the secret influence of his holy Spirit upon our studies and meditations therein laies himself open to manifold temptations and dangerous seductions of the spirit of error and delusion and as much as in him lies subverts the very foundation of the holy Christian Faith for hereupon these destructive inconveniencies must needs ensue 1. The canon of holy Scripture is transgrest and dissolv'd by the superaddition of new Revelations and the authority of Gods Word is made null and void that must passe for a dead letter when the fictitions dreams and delusions of every idle enthusiastical brain under the mask of Revelations shall be mistaken and miscalled too The quickning Spirit And he that sets up any thing of Religion to the dishonour of holy Scriptures Optal 1.3 1. saith the Father he doth aedificium de ruina construere erect a building upon the ruines of Gods truth and such a building can be no better but an heap of errors and deceits For what will not he dare to affirm and hold who holds any thing besides or above or but equal to the Word of God for the Rule of Faith Hereupon the Resurrection hath been denied and the last judgement and the necessity of all holy just and good works the necessary consequences of these points of our faith for he that believes not the Resurrection and last judgement Quid boni aut veri what holy Truth will he care to believe or what good action will he make conscience to practise 2. He opposes himself to the doctrine of the universal Church of Christ for 1600 years together who with one unanimous and common consent have received the holy Scriptures as the very canon of Faith without addition or diminution without ever hoping or waiting for any new Revelations to be superadded thereunto and very good reason sure if that dismal curse wherewith the canon of holy Scripture is concluded have any influence upon the mindes of men Rev. 22.18.19 If any man adde unto these things God shall adde unto him the plagues that are written in this book c. 3. And more particularly he makes void all those commandements of God to search the Scriptures to hear read meditate and study and delight our selves in the Lawes of God For all immediate Revelation of Gods will presupposes the knowledge of the truth without any search study c. The contempt or neglect of which duty hath sad and heavie judgements threatned thereunto as Jer. 9.13 c. And the Lord saith Because they have forsaken my Law which I set before them And have walked after the imagination of their own heart I will feed them with wormwood and give them water of gall to drink I will scatter them among the heathen c. with manifold texts to the same purpose both in the old and new Testament as Prov. 13.13 28.9 Psal 81.11,12 Zach. 7.12.13 Joh. 5.45,46 12.48 4. He makes void and unnecessary the sacred function of the Priesthood or Ministery which God hath in all ages ordained and setled in his Church as to mediate with God for the people so to instruct the people from God And this sacred office God hath both confirmed by miracles and by testimony of his blessings ordinary and extraordinary and guarded the same by many direful threatnings denounced and many heavie judgements inflicted upon such as have or shal sacrilegiously violate infringe or usurp this office or neglect refuse or contemn to hear the word of God in the mouthes of his Prophets and faithful Ministers See amongst many other places Jer. 5.12 c. Because the people belied the Lord and said It is not he when he spake by his Prophet And because they said moreover The Prophets shall become winde and the word is not in them Therefore thus saith the Lord Because ye speak this word I will make my words in thy mouth fire and this people wood and it shall devour them And to the same purpose Jer. 6.10,11,12 Mat. 10.14,15 Luk. 10.11,12 5. All pretence to immediate Revelation lords it over the faith of our Christian brethren For an immediate Revelation commands an immediate belief and blinde obedience without any further search or trial at all contrary to those expresse commands 1 Joh 4.1 Beleeve not every spirit but try the spirits 1 Thess 5.21 Prove all things hold fast that which is good or agreeable to the word of God but reject that which is not so and hold for accursed the publishers and promoters thereof Gal. 1.8 Though we or an Angel from heaven should preach unto you another Gospel besides what ye have received let him be accursed 6. The faith of the Enthusiast if it may be called a faith and not rather an illusion of his fancy is not built upon the same grounds with the faith of Christs Church which is the pillar and ground of truth the Church is built upon the foundation of the Prophets and Apostles Jesus Christ himself being the head corner stone Eph. 2.20 i. e. what the Prophets of the Old Testament and the Apostles of the New have revealed to be the doctrine of salvation in Christ is the foundation which the faith of all true Christians is built upon But the Enthusiasts faith is not built upon old but upon new Revelations not upon what is revealed already through the mediation of the Prophets and Apostles and communicated by their successors but upon what shall be immediately revealed from heaven and this groundless ground of faith is opposed to that which is the true ground of faith indeed and made of equal authority therewith so that upon this ground every private mans sayings and affirmations are of as great authority and as much to be regarded as the divinely inspired sayings of the Prophets and Apostles and this must needs be so were there any truth in mens pretended Revelations for undoubtedly we owe as much
whereunto that woe belongeth Isa 5.20 Wo unto them that call evill good c. 3. In many things we offend all Jam. 3.2 And this not only by iniquity in life and action but also by error in judgement opinion But as God of his great mercy through the merits of Christ imputes not unto us those sins which through natural frailty and meer infirmity daily and hourly invade the innocence of the soul i. e. if with an humble lowly penitent and obedient heart we confesse them and unfeignedly beleeve in Christ for the pardon of them so neither doth he impute those errors of our judgements which are of smaller consequence whilest they infect not the will and affections so as obstinately and perversely to persevere therein A bare and naked error in the understanding only is rather an infelicity then a crime 't is the obstinacy of the will the animosity and perverseness of the affections in cleaving to the mistaken conception of the understanding that renders the mistake a sinful and diabolical error for saith the Father Aug. de verbis Apost serm 22. Whilest we do but erre we are but like our selves frail mortal men whose thoughts are miserable and whose devices are but uncertain but when through animosity and perversness we persist in our errors we are then of our father the Devil who as he was a lyar from the beginning and abode not in the truth so doth he obstinately abide for ever in the destructive and damnable errors of his waies Joh. 8.44 Both this infelicity and also this sinfulness of error will more fully appear by considering and rightly understanding the nature of Heresie and Schism the two general heads whereunto all sinful error is reducible CHAP. II. Heresie the nature and ingredients thereof HEresie hath its denomination from the Greek word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 to chuse or follow by way of division and separation the which being continued and increased by perversness and obstinacy therein gives unto Heresie its perfection and compleatment The former is an error of the understanding the latter an exorbitancy of the will And thus both the Sententiarist and the Schoolman define an Heretique He is an Heretique who both erres in the Articles of holy faith through defect in his understanding and withal pertinaciously cleaves to such errors through the perverseness of his will From this general description of an Heretique and the nature of Heresle the particular ingredients whereof the cup of Heretical poyson is compounded will appear to be these 1. To be an Heretique is to erre in matters of faith not of Fact and in points of Doctrine not of Discipline the former distinguishes Heresie from sinfulness of life The latter opposes Heresie to Schism These points of faith are either 1. Fundamental such as are the grounds pillars and constituent parts of holy Christian Religion Or 2. Superstructive such clear and evident truthes as are built upon and by necessary consequence do flow from those grounds An error in the former is primarily and principally and in the latter secondarily and consequentially Heresie 2. He that in either of these respects erres in the most holy faith through ignorance misunderstanding or misinformation is not presently to be adjudged an Heretique untill this error in his understanding hath so infected his will and affection that he cleaves to this his private erroneous opinion even against the judgement of holy Catholick Church and the doctrine of Christ sufficiently made known unto him so the Father Aug. de civit dâ—… l. 18. c. 51. Qui in ecclesia Christi morbidum aliquid pravúmque sapiunt si correpti ut sanum rectumque sapiant resistunt contumaciter c. They who in the Church of Christ do believe any pernicious doctrines and being instructed and admonisht to receive the sound and saving truth do yet pertinaciously persist in their errors and continue to defend them still without conversion and amendment are hereby become Heretiques of whom S. John They went out from us but they were not of us for if they had been of us they would no doubt have continued with us 1 Joh. 2.19 viz. In the society of holy or thodox Christians And being gone out through the obstinate maintaining the delusions of their own heads they become saith the Father of the number of those enemies whom God-permits for the trial of our faith and exercise of our charity And this particular ingredient of Heresie the same Father in one of his Epistles more fully cleareth thus Qui sententiam suam quamvis falsam nulla pertinaet animositate defendit praeserâ—…m quam non dudacia suae praesumptionis peperit sed à seductis in errorem lapsis parentibus accepit Quaerit autem cautâ solioit udine veritatem corrigi paratus cum invenerit nequaquam est inter hareticos deputandus Aug. Epist 162. He that defends his opinion though it be false with no perversness and animosity especially if it arise not from his own bold and sawcy presumption of minde but from his erroneous and seduced guides and pastors or parents he hath received it if with all carefulness and diligence he seek to know the Truth being of a ready and prepared heart to imbrace it when he shall finde it such a person though he does erre in the most holy faith is not to be accounted an Heretique 3. The third ingredient then of Heretical poyson is the obstinate cleaving to an erroneous opinion or tenent in Religion contrary to the judgement of the universal Church So Isidore defines Heretiques to be such persons Isid de verbo Haeres who of their own heads depart from the judgement of the Church hammering out of their own brains false and perverse doctrines whereas saith he it is not lawful for us orthodox Christians to bring in any thing of our own heads nor yet to receive and believe what any others of their own heads have brought into the Church We have the Apostles of Christ for our Authors for even they brought in nothing of their own minde but the doctrine they received from Christ they faithfully published and preached to the world And though we saith the Apostle or an Angel from heaven should preach any other Gospel besides c. Gal. 1.18 From the Apostles the sound and saving Truth is received by the Church so that saith Irenaeus Non oportet adhuc quarere apud alios veritatem quam facile est ab ecclesia sumere cum Apostoli quasi in depositorium dives plenissimè in ea contulerint omnia quae sunt veritatis ut omnis quicunque velit sumat ex ea potum vitae Irenae l. 3. c. 4. We ought not else where to seek the truth which in the Church may be easily found since the the Apostles have most fully treasur'd up therein as in a rich store-house all things that are of Truth so that whosoever list may thence take out the waters of life
Therefore the Apostle styles the Church The pillar and ground of Truth 1 Tim. 2.15 The pillar In Gloss ordin In se bene sustinent veritatem ne corruat licet tribuletur Upholding the Truth that it fall not though daily distressed by the gates or powers of hell whose instruments are Wolves without or Foxes within the one by open persecutions assailing the other by secret infectious opinions undermining the Truth but the Church like a pillar supports it and like the ground which God hath made to stand continually both upholds and holds forth the true faith and like a rock against the raging billowes of the sea stands it out against all the gusts of persecutions heresies and schismes which are as 't were that spiritual ammunition wherewith all the gates of hell are furnisht to fight against the Church of Christ and the most holy faith thereof But whilest we stand with the Church we shall not need to fear either the crafts or assaults of these ghostly enemies For upon a Rock Christ hath grounded his Church and the gates of hell shall never prevail against it Mat. 16.18 When any particular person then opposes his private spirit and judgement against the publique judgement and spirit of that Church whereof he is a member or when any particular Church opposes the judgement of the Catholick or universal Church in point of holy faith this necessarily makes one ingredient in the sin of Heresie for so he or they do not stand upon the rock whereupon holy faith is grounded nor rest on that pillar which upholds the Truth Haec est vitae introitus omnes a. reliliqui fures sunt latrenes St quis tam obstinatè in suo errore persistat ut umversam Christi ecclesiam audire nolit talis juxta Christi mandatum pro ethnico publicano nobis babendus est Irenaeus This saith Irenaeus is the way of life meaning the way of the Church and all the rest are theeves and robbers Whosoever he be that will obstinately persist in his own erroneous opinion and refuse to hear the Church let him be unto thee according to the command of Christ as a Heathen or Publican As in the natural body he is accounted a monster rather then a perfect man who hath any exuberant member that is disproportionate and not agreeable with the rest of the members of the body so in the mystical body of Christ he is an Heretique Sicut mensura est unius cujusque partis ita totius corporis quod omnibus suis partibus constat Aug. no orthodox Christian whose particular faith is exuberant and agrees not with the whole body of the Church according to that undeniable axiome Turpis est pars omnis toti non congrua That part is disorderly and sinful which agrees not with the whole whereof it is a part As there is but one faith Ephes 4.5 which is therefore called The unity of the faith vers 13. and though there be several articles or parts of holy Truth which constitute this one body of faith yet saith the Father August Veritas est veritati congrua one truth bears such a proportion with another as is agreeable to the whole so that the whole body of the true faith is like it self in all the parts or particular points thereof Vna fides non numero sed genere qua similis in omnibus even so there is but one body Eph. 4.4 i. e. one Church professing this one faith and though there be many members of this one body yet each true member is so proportionate to the whole as that all makes up but one orderly mystical body of Christ which ought to be as without spot or stain of sn so without the exuberant disorder of error 'T is the end and office of the Ministery to bring all Christians to this pitch of perfection even to be all incorporate as members of one mystical body of Christ by the unanimous acknowledgement of one faith Ephes 4.11 c. He gave some Apostles for the perfecting of the Saints for the work of the Ministry for the edifying of the body of Christ till we all come into the unity of the faith and of the knowledge of the Son of God unto a perfect man unto the measure of the stature of the fulness of Christ that we henceforth be no more children tossed to and fro and carried about with every winde of doctrine by the sleight of men and cunning craftiness whereby they lie in wait to deceive but speaking the truth in love may grow up into him in all things from whom the whole body fitly joyned together and compacted by that which every joynt supplyeth according to the effectual working in the measure of every part maketh increase of the body to the edifying of it self in love 4. The 4. ingredient of Heresie is to hold and maintain an error in faith with frowardness and opposition to lawful determinations For though all Christians cannot perhaps in their judgements submit to all lawful determinations of controversies in Religion yet however these are thereby obliged to a passive obedience to possesse their souls in patience not to oppose the authority and disturb the peace of the Church Remembring 1. That the unity peace and authority of the Church in general is more to be valued then any particular mans satisfaction And 2. That the publique resolution of the Church is to be preferred before any private mans perswasion to the contrary That opinion of S. Cyprians concerning Rebaptization was in him but an error because the Church had not determined any thing for or against it but after the Church had defin'd it and adjudged Rebaptization unlawful Euseb eccl hist lib. 7. c. 2. 't was in all persons that maintained it not an error only but an Heresie To sum up all in few words A man becomes guilty of Heresie 1. By disheleeving any fundamental Article of Faith or neressary part of saving Truth in that sense as it was evermore received by the universal Church of Christ 2. By beleeving any superstitious Errors or Additions which do vertually and by necessary and evident consequence subvert any article of holy faith or overthrow a fundamental Truth 3. By beleeving and maintaining these or lesser errors then these with perversenesse and obstinacy after sufficient conviction 4. By beleeving and obstinately opposing private opinions in points of faith against the publique lawful Determinations of the Church to the contrary CHAP. IV. Of Schisme the nature and kindes thereof 1. SChism is so called from the Greek word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 to divide or rent the word is used 1 Cor. 1.10 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 That there be no Schisms or divisions amongst you And because Schism and contention are inseparable twins what therefore in this verse are called Schisms in the next vers 11. are cal'd 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 contentions 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 That there are contentions
amongst you And the better to conceive what is meant by these schisms and contentions 't is exemplified vers 12. One saith I am of Paul another I am of Apollo another I am of Cephas and another will not depend upon any acknowledging neither Paul nor any mortal man to be his Tutor and instructer and he saith I am of Christ Thus the immaculate body of Christ is divided into parties and sects the partakers and followers of which several sects are therefore called Sectarists and Separatists viz. Such as cleave not to the whole body but follow some one part that is broken off and divided from the whole 2. Heresie and Schism in the mystical body of Christ do differ as an inward sicknesse and outward wound in the natural body of man but yet so that there are several internal aswel as external parts and branches of Schism for by how many waies and means communion is maintain'd amongst Christians by so many waies it may be broken and dissolv'd And every breach of communion is a Schism 3. Now the Communion to be maintained amongst Christians is either Internal External The internal communion hath several branches viz. 1. To beleeve and assent to all those saving truths revealed to us by Christ and his Apostles and in all ages of the Church maintained 1 Cor. 13.7 2. To be with all obedience prepared in heart to assent to the Dictates of the Church whether universal or particular that are agreeable to such revealed Truths Mat. 18.17 3. To judge charitably each of other accounting all such for our Christian brethren who profess this same Christian faith and are of this Christian minde and spirit Col. 2.16 4. To sympathize in each others affections which includes several particulars as 1. To sorrow for the sins and errors of others 2. To condole in the sufferings of others or to weep with them that weep Rom. 12.15 As also to congratulate the prosperities of others or to rejoyce with them that rejoyce which enjoynes also 3. To rejoyce as do the Angels of heaven at the conversion of a sinner or any misguided soul from the errors of his waies Luk. 15.7 5. To pray for the growth and perseverance of all holy and orthodox persons in faith and obedience and for the conversion of all profane schismatical and heretical persons and for the reunion of all such to the Church as are divided from it 1 Sam. 12.23 Psal 122.6 1 Tim. 2.1 6. To hold communion in our desires and affections with all such as are divided from us in perswasion and judgement and by all means to endevour an external communion with them according to our several powers and in our several places and offices Gal. 6.1 The external communion consists also of several branches As 1. In the oral confession of the same Creeds or Symbols of Christian Faith Rom. 10.9,10 2 Tim. 1.13 2. In the participation of the same Sacraments 1 Cor. 10.16 3. In the admission of and submission unto the same Apostolical discipline and government Heb. 13.17 4. In the use of the same Liturgies or publique forms of external divine worship 1 Cor. 1.10 Rom. 15.6 4. Hence by the rule of contraries 't wil appear plainly who is a Schismatique or in what respects the guilt of Schism is contracted 1. He is guilty of Schism who withdrawes his assent from the doctrine of Christ and his Apostles either as 't is by the Church universal professed or else as 't is exprest by the doctrine and establisht by the Lawes of that particular Church whereof he is a member whilest this particular Church opposes not the doctrine of the Church Catholique for when any particular person shall in any point of faith oppose his private opinion against the publique judgement of the Church this is not only Schism in him but such a branch of Schism also as coincident with Heresie whereof before 2. He who shall limit the Church of Christ to his own particular sect or fraternity Recepimus pro missiones de universalitate ecclesiae tote mundo diffusae si ergo angelus de coelo tibi has premissiones tenenti diceret Dimitte Christianitatem totius orbis tene partem Donati anathema esse deberet quia tea tote pracicidere in partem contrudere conaretur alienare à promissis Dei Aug. Epist 165. saying we are the Church we are the elect and people of God and all who joyn not in communion with us are cast-awaies and out of the State of salvation he is guilty of Schism in that he cuts off the main body of Christian people or rather cuts off himself and his own fraternity from the main body of Christs holy Catholick Church So the Donatists of old limited the Church of Christ to their own sect and the confines thereof to that part of Africk where they inhabited contrary to the promises of God who hath given unto Christ the heathen for his inheritance and the uttermost parts of the earth for his possession Psal 2.8 Gen. 22. In thee shall all the nations of the earth be blessed whereupon the Father infers since we have the promises of God concerning the universality of the Church to be diffused and spread over the face of the earth if therefore an Angel from heaven should say unto thee Forgo thy relation to the Catholick Church and be of this or that particular Church or sect which saith we and we only are the Church and people of God he ought to be accursed because he hath endevoured to cut thee off from the whole and to limit thee to a part and thereby to alienate thee from the promises of God in Christ Jesus A third branch of Schiâ—m necessarily depends upon and flowes from the second And this is rashly to judge and uncharitably to condemn the Churches or societies of our Christian brethren so the Montanists perswaded their followers to speak evil of the universal Church where ever spread over the face of the earth Euseb eccl hist l. 5. c. 16. and not only to deny thereunto all reverence and esteem but also in no wise to joyn with them of this kinde of Schism are all such guilty who refuse to joyn with their Christian brethren in the publique service of God under pretence of separating from the wicked of the world who with the proud Pharisee in the Gospel presumptuously justifie themselves and their own Church and faction and unjustly condemn all others Verè existimemus posse aliquid esse occultum in alio quo vobis superior sit etiam si bonum nostrum quo illo videmur superiores esse non sit occulium Aug. de verbis Apo. ser 21. Luk. 18.9 who are so pure in their own eyes as to say to others Stand by thy self come not neer to me I am holier then thou Isa 65.5 little esteeming the exhortation of the Apostle Phil. 2.3 Let nothing be done through strife or vain glory but in lowliness of minde
therefore said our Saviour If ye do his will ye shall know of my doctrine whether it be of God or no Joh. 7.17 So that undoubtedly what ever piety or purity Heretiques may pretend unto yet generally 't is but a meer formal outside a show and shadow of truth but no substantial solid piety or charity having a form of godliness but denying the power 2 Tim. 3.5 For to such who by obedience practise and experience do know and believe the excellency of Truth it is not possible to be seduced and drawn aside therefrom Quamdiu bona opera saâ—imus ipsum lumen jusitiae ante oculos nostâ—… adaperit veritatem Câ—rvâ— in Mat. 7. Hom. 19. therefore our Lord cals all false Prophets Woolves in sheeps cloathing Mat. 7.15 that is Nominis Christiani extrinsecus superficies meer nominal outside Christians no men so seemingly austere and strict and yet all is but empty appearance of holiness no men assume to themselves more holy titles the Saints the Elect the People of God If they be simple and illiterate persons then they apply to themselves God hath chosen the simple 1 Cor. 1.27 and those that confute them in discourse do it by carnal Reason and the wisdome of the flesh if they be subtil and acute in argumentation and put to silence some weak adversary then 't is the wisdome of the spirit in them which the wisdome of the flesh cannot resist Tell them of their folly and madness they say Christs own Apostle was accounted mad if they suffer according to law for their enormities then they say they suffer for righteousness sake nay their sins and delinquencies they would make appear to be pieties so subtil are all Hypocrites in the outward and nominal part of Religion that if it were possible they would deceive the very Elect and many thousands are deceived by their appearances of holiness and strictness of life but 't is such only who are somewhat infected with Hypocrisie as well as themselves therefore they are styl'd Wels without water clouds that are carried with a tempest 2 Pet. 2.17 For as empty clouds are most tossed by the winde so men that are religious only in religious names and religious talk and outward shew of Religion being not ballast with sincere devotion towards God and charity towards man such are they that are most apt to be tossed with every winde of doctrine 8. All errors and seditions in the most holy faith are generally thrown upon the grand impostor and father of lies the Devil who no question hath a great iufluence therein therefore cal'd The doctrines of devils and he and his Angels seducing spirits 1 Tim. 4.1 and all that are seduced the children of the wicked one Mat. 13.38 but yet withall we must know that if the voluntary sins of pride covetousnesse presumption c. did not first infect the minde his tares of Heresie and Schism could never take rooting there 't is of the corruptions of the mindes and manners of men that all Heresies are engendred and like the creatures of putresaction to which heat and moisture gives a natural being so the filthy moisture or corruption of mens hearts quickned by the incessant operation of the evil spirit gives unto all Heresies their spiritual being and growth in the minde For wickedness saith the wise man doth alter the understanding and the bewitching of naughtiness doth obscure things that are honest Wisd 4.11 Sin saith Chrys doth so blinde the senses of sinners that seeing not the waies of falshood and error they headlong themselves therein nor could ever any errors prevail over man if sin had not made the way for first a man is blinded by his sins and then drawn away by the devil and seduced For error saith he begetteth not sins but sins beget and bring forth error Chrys in Mat. 7. Hom. 19. CHAP. VI. The ends why God permits Heresies and Schismes ALmighty God as by his powerful word of nothing he hath made all things so doth he still not only uphold all things by the word of his power but most wisely govern order and dispose of all being the Master-wheel of all motions and the original cause of all actions and events whether they be good or evil of the good by his active and of the evil by his permissive providence as Amos 3.6 Shal there be any evil in the city and the Lord hath not done it And as it is in the greater world Terra salutiferas herbas eademque nocentes Nutrit urticae proxima saepe rosa est all good and useful things have their contrary evils there are fruitful showres and the fatning dew of heaven and there are also harmful storms of hail and corrupt and infectious vapours There are trees of wholsome fruit and herbs for the use and nourishment both of man and beast and there are also both trees and herbs that are unwholsome and poysonous there are living creatures also both tame and wilde both such as are serviceable unto man and such also as are destructive fierce cruel and mischievous so in the lesser world also there is in the field of Gods Church both wheat and tares corn and chaffe both true and false Prophets the one the pillars of sound celestial soul-saving Truth the other the deceitful workers and Patrons of errors heresies and schisms Truth stands ever firm upon its own proper base and being supported by no other but it s own native excellency and vertue ever appears like it self in its own plain simple naked colours But Error being in it self crooked and deformed puts on the shape and ever appears in the likeness of holy truth following her steps to trip up her heels and take possession of her throne The very Philosophy of the Heathens was followed and undermin'd by false Philosophers and amongst the Jewes their circumcision and some other rites and ceremonies were imitated by the Arabians and other nations and yet the one were the worshippers of the true God herein and the others worshipped Idols And in the worship of the true God to that which is sound and sincere is opposed false counterfeit and hypocritical worship to the true and lawful Baptism is opposed unlawful and extraregular dipping to the commandements of God the traditions of men to the Apostles and faithful Ministers of Christ false Apostles and deceitful workers and in a word there is nothing of the most holy fath but by the cunning of the Devil working upon the corruptions of mens hearts something is forged in opposition thereunto 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Athen. lib. de resur No article of the Christian faith escaping the invasion of Heretiques and the corruption thereof by heretical and false positions the which will easily appear to every man that list to consult Philastrius Epiphanius Augustine Joh. Damscene who out of Ecclesiastical records have given the several catalogues of Heresies and Heretiques The Reasons why God is pleased to permit it should be
is there is the Spirit of life and sanctification 7. Heretiques Extra ecclesiam consistens contra pacem dilectionem Christi saciens inter adversaros computetur Cyp. ep 76. and Schismaticks have been ever accounted the great adversaries of Christs Church and people whose intestine broyles and homebred divisions have done more mischief to the truth and doctrine of Christ then all the external persecutions of bloudy tyrants and Heathens hence the sharp command of the Apostle against such Tit. 3.10,11 A man that is an heretique after the first or second admonition reject knowing that he that is such subverteth and sinneth because condemn'd of himself such a one is self-condemned having 1. passed sentence upon himself by professing against the doctrine and dividing from the communion of the Church And 2. he hath done execution upon himself also for he hath excommunicated himself in going out from the Church Quomodo te à tot gregibus scidisti exscidisti teipsum Firmil ad Cyp. Ep. 75. He that is such a one reject have no company with him 2 Thess 3.14 S. John going to wash himself in a Bath and there espying Cerinthus an Heretique leapt hastily out of the Bath again saying that he feared the fabrick of the Bath would fall upon them all that were there since Cerinthus the enemy of truth is in it Iren. advers Haer. l. 3. c. 3. And Polycarpus who was S. Johns disciple and heard these words from the Apostle meeting with Marcion another Heretique who saying unto him Cognosce nos acknowledge us for the true Disciples of Christ answered I know thee to be the first born of Satan So great fear saith Irenaeus had the Apostles and their Disciples of having any communication with persons that had depraved and corrupted the Truth Id. l 4. c. 62. according to Tit. 3.10 For nulla ab iis tanta potest esse corruptio quanta est schismatis pernicies saith the same Father Athanasius and Epiphanius deny Heretiques nisi homonymωs to be called Christians and Optatus tels us Apparet Antichristos omnes esse quos constat à charitate atque ab unitate ecclesiae r ecessisse Opt. l. â— that Schismatiques are the Antichrists spoken of by S. John 1 Joh. 2.18 for so they are described vers 19. They went out from us but they were not of us c. Which is the way of Schism and the description of Schismatiques and he instances in Novatian qui extra ecclesiam consistens inter Antichristos computetur The Samaritans who were Schismatiques Cyprian Addendo autem civitatem Samaritano um deâ—ere omitti ubi crant schismatici ostendit schismaticos Gemilibus adaequari Cyp. Ep. 76. from the Jewish Church the Jewes therefore had no conversation with them Joh. 4.9 And they are reckoned by our Saviour with the Gentiles Mat. 10.5 8. The sad condition of all Heretiques and Schismatiques lying under the guilt of grievous sin and being obnoxious thereby to the judgements of God is frequently also remembred by the Fathers How are they without all hope saith Cyprian Id. ibid. and incur Gods heavy indignation to their own ruine who make a Schism the holy Scripture doth declare in the book of the Kings where the ten tribes making a breach and Schism in the Church and departing from Judah and Benjamin the Lord is said to be wroth with the whole seed of Israel And by the example of Corah D. than and Abiram is manifested and proved saith the same Father in the same place Aug. ep 164. that they are not only guilty of great sin but liable to grievous punishment who rashly joyn themselves with Schismatiques Illud scelus ad exemplum devitandi God for the present so grievously punished the sin of Corah and his complices giving us thereby an example saith S. Aug. to avoid the same and shewing that when he spares to punish such persons in this life the greater punishment he reserves for them in the life to come which is affirmed 2 Pet. 2.9 For God will judge such persons saith Irenaeus who make Schisms and divisions minding more their own utility then the Churches unity Qui propter modicas quaslibet causas magnum gloriosum corpus Christi censeindunt 〈…〉 who for every light cause and unnecessary scruples rend the great and glorious body of Christ and as much as in them lies destroy the same speaking of peace and charity but making war and division straining at a gnat and swallowing the camel Gods service is the way of mans salvation and that nation or kingdome which will not serve the Lord shall perish Isa 6.12 The ground and foundation of Gods service is faith for without faith it is impossible to please God Heb. 11.6 Now-the true holy and orthodox faith is but one Eph 4.5 therefore termed the unity of faith vers 13. Now he that pleaseth not God by the mean of a true faith doth displease and fight against him by the opposition of a false faith according to our Saviours own rule Mat. 12.30 He that is not with me is against me and he that gathereth not with me scattereth abroad And undoubtedly he that is against Christ he that is his adversary makes himself immediately liable to eternal condemnation which is effected by every one that holds not the unity of the true faith for he that beleeveth not in me is condemned already Joh. 3.18 In a word as the true faith believed and obeyed is the way of life so a false faith embrac't and followed is the high way of death and ruine as the word of truth is the key of the kingdome of heaven so the word of untruth and error is the key that opens the gates of hell as the first is that true and sacred light which discovers and clears the way that leads to light and life everlasting so the latter is the ignis fatuus the false fire that misguides the wandring souls of men to the confines of that kingdome where dwelleth blackness of darkness for evermore Of all seducers and maintainers of Heresies the Apostle S. Peter affirms that they bring upon themselves swift destruction that their judgement of a long time lingreth not and their damnation slumbreth not 2 Pet. 2.1,2,3 CHAP. VIII Rules and directions for the avoiding of Errors in Religion THat we might be the better armed against the assaults of Heretiques and heretical opinions in Religion our Lord and Master hath not only foretold us that false teachers should in all ages of the Church arise and errors spring up with the truth Mat. 24.23 7.15 Mar. 13.21 Luk. 17.23 as tares amidst the wheat but also hath strictly charged us to beware of them not to follow after them nor believe them whose pretences shall be so plausible their outward appearances of holiness so specious and taking and their words and works by the secret and invisible assistance of Satan so extraordinary as that if it were possible
to strictness and austerity of life then others have and there is a natural quickness and volubility of language and a natural ardour and fervency of minde wherewith some men are endowed more then others which are not therefore infallible tokens that all opinions such persons maintain are orthodox and true Scultetus tels of an arch-heretique in Germany cal'd Swenchfield Abrab Scult annual eccles a great Sect-master who amongst other extravagancies held many blasphemous opinions touching the Scriptures and yet this man did ardentes ad Deum preces creberrimè fundere was both very fervent and very frequent in his prayers unto God Hacket who was executed for blasphemy in the daies of Queen Elizabeth is reported to have excelled so much in the gift of extempore prayer that his disciples did believe him to be altogether inflamed with the Spirit of God and that his expressions were immediately from the Spirit and that there was nothing he might not obtain from God by his prayers Basilides the great Duke of Muscovy was very much exercised both in Prayer and Fasting and very severe towards others under his command that did not conform to his example He had his feigned Visions Paulus Odor bornius in vita quat l. 2. and Revelations also and yet a greater Tyrant and a more bloudy villain Christendome hath not seen The Scribes and Pharisees of the Jewish Church and the Novatians and Donatists of the Christian were far greater pretenders to piety and strictness of life then the truly orthodox of either Church and yet very great and notorious Schismatiques Not to be cousened therefore with fair and goodly pretences of any party or sect of men how seemingly holy and zealous soever and pretending that they have Christ that they have the Spirit that they only are in the right when they are deeply involv'd in an abysse of errors our Lord hath fore-arm'd us with sound and saving counsell Mat. 24.23 c. Then if any shall say unto you Lo here is Christ or lo there believe it not for there shall arise false Christs and false Prophets Wherefore if they shall say Behold he is in the desert goe not forth behold he is in the secret chambers believe it not for as the lightning cometh out of the East and shineth unto the West so shall the comming of the Son of man be Two rules for the avoiding infection by false Prophets under specious pretences are hence observable 1. Habet unaquacunque Haeresis vel certas mundi partes unde 〈◊〉 ecce hic ecce illic Every Heresie saith the Glosse is limited to some particular parts of the world and the infection is not universally diffused therefore 't is said Lo here or lo there If any man then shall limit Christ to his particular Church much lesse to his particular sect or fraternity believe it not for such are false Christs and false Prophets Ne credatur schismaticis nomine autem orientis occidentis torum orbem designat Gloss ordin For the Truth displaid from Christ the Sun of righteousnesse like the light of the heaven is diffused from East to West or spread over the face of the whole earth which renders the Church i. e. all sound and sincere professors of the Truth as well Catholique as Holy 2. Vel in occultis aut obscuris conventiculis curiositatem hominum decipit haeresis Id. Heresie and Schism seek out obscure and retired places and begin in conventicles and private meetings therefore 't is said Behold he is in the desert behold he is in the secret chambers So the Apostle of deceivers also they creep into houses and lead captive silly women c. 2 Tim. 3.6 But Veritas non quaerit angulos Truth seeketh no lurking holes is not ashamed to appear in publique being like the light that shineth from East to West open free and manifest to all except forc't to retirement by persecution and violence 9. For the avoiding of errors 't will be necessary to observe further that a Truth is not to be disbelieved or rejected because 't is profest by lewd and licentious persons or maintained by a Church and people that are in other respects erroneous and misguided For Truth is Truth by what mouth soever it bee spoken and 't is the more confirmed to be Truth because 't is even by the enemies of Truth attested to be so The unwary neglect of this rule hath not been the least inlet to manifold errors for 't is too usual with many to object both against orthodox truths and ecclesiastical orders on the one hand that this or that the Papists hold and against a strict careful conscientious life on the other that thus and thus the Puritans profess Hence many truths have been rejected for errors and many decent useful orders customes ceremonies and necessary acts of discipline have been cryed down as superstitious idolatrous and antichristian and the sacred body of religion it self is almost wholly turned out of the Church under the style of Popery Nor hath that piety and integrity of life which is required of particular persons escap'd better but under the notion of Puritanism hath been too much banisht from the lives and manners of men for fear of being branded with the guilt of Schism faction and separation 10 He that will not unawares headlong himself into the gulph of error must not presume upon any extraordinary infusion of Gifts and Graces from above but in all humility wait upon God in the use of means and the careful improvement of what gifts and graces he hath already received It is the manner of Heretiques and Hypocrites saith a learned man Joh. Câ—st ever to pretend to high lights of the Spirit and to finde new and unheard of waies of walking with God slighting all that is common though never so commendable and catching at all that is curious though never so dangerous and thus they lose themselves in their chymerical conceptions and pretending to refine ancient piety and truth are puft up with secret pride and presumption and grasp nothing but froth and vanity That there are such things as Extasies and more then ordinary ravishments of spirit and infusions of divine gifts and qualifications is not doubted but such supereminences only superexcellent souls are capable of neither yet are they afforded to all pious devout and heavenly minded persons that so none may presume to depend upon them but that every man should keep his station and walk humbly with his God not relying upon extraordinary inspirations in the neglect of ordinary means which is in many respects destructive and dangerous as in the former Treatise And although it be most true that the conversion of every man to the truth being a work of the Spirit is therefore sudden and at one instant or moment of time begotten and wrought in the soul yet notwithstanding our progress towards perfection and bliss in the waies of Truth and Holiness goes on step by step