there any Virtue in Christ's Presence that is not in God's Presence Is not the Father Son and Holy Spirit one Being though different as to Relation and Degrees of Manifestation But how plainly contradictory is it one while to confess Christ's being in men his essential Presence as God to be in all men and yet that his Light in the Heathen or greatest Part of men is natural and created O monstrous Inconsistency He affirms that the Form of Doctrine delivered to the Christians to wit the Scriptures was to be the Rule of Faith and Christian Practice to rule and govern themselves by p. 22 23. And yet confesseth That those who are sincere make it their dayly Care and Endeavour to walk according to the Light and Guidance of that Rule that hath its Seat in their Conscience p. 40. Observ. Here he has found another Rule then the Scripture to wit the Light in the Conscience Though it is true the Apostles Doctrine contains Rules but the Light within that gave it forth was The Rule the Chief or Highest Rule for Guidance and Power and that wherein was the Power of Rule and Government to all true Christians He gives this Judgment against us viz. That in Truth there is no Light in us how much soever we vainly boast of it he sayes p. 40. And yet hath confessed That the essential Presence of Christ as God is in all men and that Christ doth enlighten every man with a Faculty of Reason or natural Light by which he hath acknowledged some Light to be in every man though it is true they that speak not according to the Word it is because there is no Morning in them yet it follows not that there is no Light at all in them for there may be some Light in them before the Morning Upon Joh. 1. 9. he saith that there is no such thing as that Christ so enlightens all men as with what he ought to believe and do in order to his Salvation without outward Teaching can be proved p. 41. And yet confesseth That Christ indeed as God doth enlighten every man by which he may know that there is a God that he is to be worshipped that he is placable and that this may be a Light sufficient to direct the Heathen to do as much as God expects from them if they live up to it But in Contradiction again He calls this a natural Light not sufficient c. p. 42. Observ. What! A Light sufficient to give the Knowledge of God and his Worship that he is placable and to direct the Heathen to as much as he expects from them and yet not sufficient to enlighten men with a Knowledge of what they ought to believe and do in order to Salvation Is not this palpable Contradiction That Men may by the Light within be directed to acknowledge and worship God and to as much as he expects from them and yet not be saved These can never hold together any more then that the Light in the Heathen may be sufficient to direct them to as much as God expects and yet not to believe in his Son for Salvation according to pag. 42. As if God did not require all men to believe in his Son when their not believing in him is the very thing for which his Spirit reproveth the World of Sin and he that believeth not in the Son of God is condemned already because he hath not believed in the Name of the only begotten Son of God And this is the Condemnation that Light is come into the World and men love Darkness rather then Light because their Deeds are Evil Joh. 3. 18 19. So that it is evident That Light is come into the World that men may believe in the Name of the Son of God and escape Condemnation Again he errs in saying Paul knew of no such Way to propagate the Faith as immediate Revelation and inward Teaching of the Light within after it was once set on foot in an extraordinary Way p. 46. And this he hath contradicted in his confessing That the Work of Grace in men is most properly attributed to God to Christ and that the Scripture attributes it to God to Christ to the holy Spirit p. 18. And also he had almost granted that the holy Spirit may be communicated to men by immediate Revelation p. 28. Observ. So then God may and doth work by his immediate Power and Spirit for the begetting men into the true Faith and it is only this Spirit immediately attending true Ministers that maketh their Preaching effectual for the turning men to the Word of Faith in their Hearts Whereas the Tenour and Stress of this man's Work is against Enthusiasm in the best sense even against being savingly illuminated in an immediate way and saith that the plentiful Effusion of the Spirit is far from giving any Countenance to our Opinion of the Spirit 's being given to teach men immediately by internal Illumination pag. 60. And on John 16. 13. he accounteth that this is not a Promise to guide all Christians by its immediate Motion but a Promise to his Apostles pag. 61. And yet in Contradiction to himself in this and in Concession to the Truth he in words assents to the Operation of God's Grace and good Spirit pag. 15. And that men are said in Scripture to be born of the Spirit to be born of the immortal Seed of the Word pag. 18 19. But then he is nconsistent again in accounting these different Causes he hath also confessed the essential Presence of Christ as God to be in men p. 20. And that in Revel 2. Chap. 3. it is seven times said He that hath an Ear let him hear what the Spirit saith to the Churches p. 27. And that Christ's Ministers are Ministers of the New Testament not of the Letter but of the Spirit p. 33. That he accompanies their Ministration with the Presence of his Grace and Power p. 38. And also he asserts to the inward Assistance of his Spirit p. 41. And saith It is the Spirit that beareth witness because the Spirit is Truth p. 55. And on 1 Joh. 2. Ye need not that any man teach you but as the same Anointing teacheth you he grants that the Apostle's Meaning must be That they needed not from him or any other man any teaching that could give them greater Assurance of any thing then that Anointing gave them of Jesus his being the Christ and of the Truth of that Doctrine that Anointing being God's Witness from Heaven pag. 68. And that the Spirit doubtless is not wanting to assist the sincere Endeavours of men in searching after the Sense of the Scriptures p. 69. Howbeit for men to be guided by the internal Teachings of the Spirit without outward Teaching this he calls our Wild Notion And yet citeth Rom. 8. 14. As many as are led by the Spirit of God they are the Sons of God p. 71. And Gal. 5. 18. If ye are led by the Spirit
doth savingly enlighten or afford super-natural Revelation in an immediate Way hath at once excluded and denyed both the Knowledge of God and Christ and this is the very Way to bring in Atheism for what shall assure us either of the Knowledge of God Christ Scripture or true Preaching if immediate Illumination be denyed us And yet this man to his own Confutation pretends not to exclude the concurrent Operation of God's Spirit upon the Heart p. 18. But how should we believe that he really owns the Christian Doctrine contained in Scriptures to be any Rule at all either of his Faith or Practice while he opposeth the very thing which it directs us to viz. The New Covenant the Spirit 's Teaching immediate Illumination c. Sect. II. Of the Divine Unction Light New Covenant and Use of the Ministry ANd this Opposer will have his Sense and Meaning upon some plain Scriptures contrary to their very Import as upon 1 Joh. 2. 20. But ye have an Unction from the Holy One and ye know all things And again ver 27. But the Anointing which ye have received of him abideth in you and ye need not that any man teach you but as the same Anointing teacheth you of all things and is Truth and is no Lye and even as it hath taught you ye shall abide in him About this he appears very much puzled and cannot tell how to wind off the plain Words on the Behalf of the Anointing and its full and plentiful Teaching And after he hath spoken doubtfully about the Sense of this Scripture he concludes our Notion of the holy Spirit 's Teaching Men that live under the Gospel cannot be the Sense of it when the Words are plain Ye need not that anyman teach you but as the same Anointing teacheth you of all Things Nor would this render the Design of John in this Epistle and other Writings needless p. 64. while his Epistle and Writing proclaims the Sufficiency of the Anointing wherein he writes both to little Children young Men and Fathers and what he writes was as he had received from the Anointing and not meerly as Man's Teaching and argued no Defect in the Anointing at all but rather exalts it and tends to encourage others to continue in it to abide in the Truth it being confest That both the Apostles other Believers were established in Christ by the Anointing of God upon them from 2 Cor. 1. 21 22. As also That they were induced at the first to believe the Doctrine to be from God because they perceived the Anointing of God to be upon them that preached it p 66 67. So that here it is confest that Believers Establishment in Christ both Preachers and Hearers was by the Anointing of God upon them as he which stablisheth us with you in Christ and hath anointed us is God and that they were induced to believe the Doctrine to be from him because that they perceived that Anointing to be upon or in the Preachers Surely then there was a spiritual Eye opened in them so to perceive And this is our Method both for believing obeying and saving Men which one while this Man hath opposed as contrary to God's Way another while he confesseth to it but then he darkens the Matter again upon the Words Ye have an Unction from the Holy One and ye know all Things he gives this Meaning viz. Not that by this Uâ—ction the commmon Christians were immediately inspired with the Knowledge of all Truths but that by it they were assured of the Truth of all things which the Apostles had taught and further adds It is not said that this Anointing did teach them all Things but that it did teach of all Things that is of or concerning the Truth of all Things to which it was a Witness or Evidence p. 66 67. He seems to lay a great stress here upon the Particle Of as if the Anointing did only teach them Of or concerning those Doctrines which the Apostles preached but not the Doctrines themselves and then who taught the Apostles to preach Was it not the Anointing And did not several Gifts flow from one Spirit But the man overlooks the Words of the Apostle cited by him viz. Ye need not that any man teach you but as the same Anointing teacheth you and did not this Anointing teach the Believers in the Apostles Absence and when they had not their Epistles read among them Or was it only a Witness or Evidence to what they spoke or preacht Or did it abide in them not to speak to them in the Absence of the Apostles and their Epistles but only in their Presence What a strange Limitation would this be that indeed endeavours to stop the Mouth of the Anointing And his denying that by this Unction the common Christians were immediately inspired with the Knowledge of all Truths leaves the Matter still doubtful on his Part and seems at least to be a Sense twarting the Apostles Words Ye have an Unction from the Holy One and ye know all Things He should have told whether he believes that the common Christians as he calls them were inspired with any Truths necessary to Salvation If he denies this then he bids adieu to all divine and saving Knowledge as to those Christians Whereas the same God that anointed the Apostles to preach and established them in Christ did both anoint and establish those Believers to whom they preached so their Ministry was effectual only through that Anointing which enabled them to preach And we never denyed the Apostles Preaching in order to direct men to that Anointing All which still prefers the Anointing as the principal Means and Rule and owns true Preaching as in Subordination to it But does not therefore oppose or deny the Anointing's immediate Teaching or Sufficiency to save them that believe in and obey it And because all are not converted or come to this divine Unction within or Dispensation of the New Covenant God hath been and is pleased to make Use of such effectual Means and to accommodate his divine Truth to mens low Capacities by Preaching and Demonstration of the Spirit as may be for their Help and Advantage in order thereto So that the Controversie is brought to this narow Compass viz. our present Opposer pretends to own super-natural Revelation and divine Illumination but not now in an immediate Way but only in a mediate Way of Preaching and Scripture We own and assert divine Illumination and super-natural Revelation in an immediate Way as also that God is pleased to make Use of such mediate Wayes and Means as are attended with his Presence and divine Illumination without which no outward Means can be effectual or to any real Advantage to the Soul This Opposer reckons that God operates now only in a mediate Way we own that God works both immediately and mediately as also we assert the sole Sufficiency of the Spirt's immediate Illumination and Teaching both as the Ground of the Effectual Ministry and of
ye are not under the Law p. 73. And Paul exhorted Eph. 2. Be filled with the Spirit in order to their speaking to themselves in Psalms and Hymns and spiritual Songs Ephes. 5. 18 19. p. 74. And he cites Acts 26. 17 18. viz. Unto whom I now send thee to open their Eyes and to turn them from Darkness to Light p. 85. Now I ask If this Darkness was not within that they were to be turned from And if this Light they were to be turned to was not also within in some Degree and that in an immediate VVay And also Did not the Apostle turn the Gentiles to the Light that they might receive Forgiveness of Sins and an Inheritance among them that are sanctified by Faith that is in Christ Further he confesseth to the Truth in these words If all good Christians then had been guided by an infallible Light within they would not have needed to have bin taught and re-taught what were the first Principles of the Oracles of God as some of them were Hebr. 5. p. 105. Is it not plain here that he hath placed the Fault or Deficiency upon those that needed so to be taught as being awanting to themselves not following the Infallible Light within and not upon the Light it self but justified it as a sufficient Rule and Teacher and that they that are guided by it need not mens Teaching And he also confesseth That the Humble God will teach and the Meek he will guide in Judgment Psal. 25. And also that the Spirituality of Christians is such that they are Partakers of the spiritual and divine Nature or Likeness to Jesus Christ in Purity in Lowliness Humility Meckness and in Love to God and Charity to men in Peace and Gentleness in Contempt of the World c. on the Account of which spiritual Qualifications Christians are said to be one Spirit with Christ and by this Spirit and Temper we know that we dwell in him and he in us and if any man have not the Spirit of Christ in some measure he is none of his pag. 119. Is not this a plain Confession to the Immediateness of Christ's In-dwelling in us And does not he then teach us by himself immediately It is also confessed We are also exhorted in a due Sence of our own Weakness and Insufficiency and of the great Need we have of the constant Assistance of God's holy Spirit in all to make instant and important Supplication to God for it p. 122. Here he plainly grants to the Necessity of Divine Inspiration and immediate Assistance of God's holy Spirit which plainly overthrows and confuteth the Body of his Work to the contrary And further observe that in his Postscript he confesseth That he hath not so plainly represented the Nature of Faith which is the condition of the New Covenant and that he that Believes and considers Christs Doctrine must needs be under the Influence of the most powerful Motives to Repentance of a bad and lead a good Life And that Faith works that Change in men by which they become new Creatures are born of God and sanctified and that it doth evidence to the Soul of things not seen and that a Believer is described by his coming to Christ John 6. 35. For mens coming to learn of him is the Effect of their believing him to be the Son of God and Believers are described by the Receiving of Christ John 1. 12. As many as received him to them he gave Power to become the Sons of God even to them that believe on his Name and that Believers are described by their trusting in Christ or relying on him Eph. 1. 12. p. 135. Now mark serious Reader how he has confessed to the Truth of Believers coming to Christ to learn of him receiving Christ trusting in and relying on Christ And what is this but a Confession to a Believer's immediate Enjoyment of Christ himself and his immediate Teaching and Assistance For if men come to Christ to learn of him or be taught by Christ himself is not this immediate and the End of Outward Teaching to those that come to this Blessed Attainment See how the man hath justified that Enthusiasm as he calls it which he he hath bestowed so much Pains against Now Reader by this time thou mayst see where the Stress of the Controversie consists and that it is not about the word Enthusiasm but about the Doctrine of God's Immediate Way of Enlightening Working which this man in a Way of Opposition is pleased to term Enthusiasm and the Quakers Enthusiasts for owning that Doctrine Some other more particular Fling sand Groundless Objections he has against us of less moment which I pass by as Trifles not deserving my Time and treating about G. W. A Postscript by another Hand ENthusiasm all along used by Plutarch in Discourse about Apollo's Nuâ—n or Prophetess ceasing to give Oracles in Verse and about the ceasing of Oracles which was in his time about Anno 100. after the Apostle John's Decease this word Enthusiasm he uses to that Divination and Inspiration which the Heathen Oracles gave through their Priests Clemens Alexandrinus writes that in his time which was almost 200 years of Christ Divine Inspiration was in their Assemblies For in his 3d Book of his Paedagoguâ— cap. 11. thus he complains of some who did not abide in that which they had tasted in the Assembly nor walk in it and worthy of it or else dissembled it saith he These putting away the inspired Thing 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 of the Congregation after their Departure thence are like them with whom they converse or else they are found to be such as they were not thought to be Eusebius lib. 9. Eccl. Hist. saith Prophecying continued till Constantine's time which was above the 300 year of Christ his words are these If any man inspired by the Grace of God should speak unto the People they all with great Silence fixing their Eyes upon him gave such Attention as if he had brought them some Errand from Heaven See Jacob Acontius Satan's Stratagems p. 128. The same Clem. Alex. saith Stromat lib. 5. Exod. 33. Moses saith Shew me thy self evidently noting that God cannot be taught to men nor expressed by words to men but that he can only be known by that Power which is of himself The same lib. 2. cap 4. Paedagog saith Before sleep it is a holy thing to give Thanks to God as enjoying his Bounty and Favour so as we go to sleep divinely inspired The word is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 divinely inwardly for he is a Greek Writer Of 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 contracted is made 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 whence comes the word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Enthusiasm not Enthysiasm as it is in the Latin Dictionary of 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 which is another word signifying sacrificing I have found where the Mistake is by sâ—arching the Greek so it must be written Enthusiasm There was a Sect called Enthusiasts which Theodoret speaks of in his 4 Book of his Ecclesiastical History The word in the Scripture is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 theopneustos the Scripture is called so 2 Tim. 3. 16. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 graphe theopneustos Scripture breathed of God scriptura a deo spirata Spencer of Prophecy p. 110. A Synod in Germany called on purpose against vulgar Prophecies declined it saying Yet no Church or Consistory or University had altogether rejected or condemn'd such kind of new Prophecys and why would we be first Cyprian Epist. 71. saith Many things are better revealed to several Clemens Hom. a very ancient Book in the primitive Times sayes That Operation is more certain then Vision see p 726 728. See Book of Martyrs 2 volumn of the Prophecy of Huss and certain others in the History of Luther 3 vol. of Dr. Sands John Rogers c. John Fox himself touching the Lady Hennage's Recovery see his Life Bishop Jewel fore-told the Reformation Bp. Ridley's Burning his own Sickness then the precise day of his death see his Life THE END Joh. 6. 45. p. 24. p. 5. p. 123. pa. 24. p. 15 41 24 33. pa. 79. p. 80. p. 42. p. 76. p. 98. p. 110. * So there is a Spiritual Baptism and an Eating and Drinking with Christ in his Kingdom ‖ See Isaiah 53. 10 11. Psalm 22. 30. Jo. 6. 39. Gal. 3. 16. 4. 19. Act. Mon. v. 1. f. 593. * These are also said to be the Words of Pope Urban pleaded by Jo. Huss P. 47 61. John 1. 4. 9. 2 Cor. 4. 6. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 affler numine an Inspiration Entheatus numine afflatus 〈…〉 in quo Deus est ab 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 et 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Deus Divine inspir'd See the Copious Dictionaries * Where hath he a Scripture for God's Teaching in Person Unsavoury Expressions not according to sound Words * He had almost said Truth p. 88 89 90 91. Mal. 3. 8 9 19. Deut. 14. 28 29 p. 90 91. p. 91. p. 41 86 87. p. 56. p. 88 89 90 123. p. 47. 84. p. 41 42. Note That mens not believing in the Sou and their rejecting his light within are equivalent bothtend to the same End