people must we not see with our own eyes but only with those of the Church Shall we pin our faith upon any mens sleeves What need we the authority of men when we have Gods own authority for our direction and men are but men i. e. frail and liable to error so that all they affirm is not to be taken for Gospel In answer whereunto consider Answ 1. That there is a great deal of difference betwixt an implicite faith and blinde obedience to the dictates of the Church and a submission to the publique judgement thereof The first deprives the people of their reason and judgement the second renders them more meek humble submissive and obedient and thereby more capable to receive the impression of the knowledge of celestial mysteries 2. That we assert not the ancient and learned Fathers of the Church ut dominos sed ut duces sidei Nihil carum rerum scire quae antè nascereris facta sunt hoc est semper esse puerum Cic. Not as Lords over our faith but as guides in the true belief And he that knows nothing of the Religion of the Fathers for his guidance and direction is most likely still to continue a childe in his religion Nor 3. are we to receive for Oracle all that the ancient reverend Fathers of the Church did affirm being very few amongst them Quicquid omnes vel plures uno eodemque sensu manifeste frequenter perseveranter velut quodam sibi consentiente concilio accipiendo tenendo tradendo firmaverint id pro indubitato certo ratcque habeatur Quicquid vero quamvis ille doctus sanâ—tus quamvis Episcopus praeter omnes aut etiam contra omnes senserit id inter proprias privatas opiniunculas à communis publicae generalis sententiae authoritate secretum sit Vinc. Lyr. but had their particular errors and mistakes and in many particulars also 't is confessed they did contradict each other 'T is not therefore the affirmations and private opinions of particular persons we must look upon as the Doctrine of true Religion and true meaning of the Scriptures but the general and universal consent of all for that all should erre and fall from the truth is contrary to what our Lord hath promised who will undoubtedly be as good as his word Mat. 16.18 Vpon this rock I will build my Church and the gates of Hell shall never prevail against it and Mat. 28.20 I am with you alway even to the end of the world In a word in the interpretation of Scriptures and for the confirmation of holy truths thence deduced the authority of the ancient Fathers and Doctors of the Church is to be consulted and known for these reasons 1. Because they are certain and undeniable witnesses of what the Church and the people of Christ did in their respective times believe and hold for orthodox Doctrine If the same doctrine St. Augustine taught in Africk was also taught by St. Chrysostome in Greece by St. Ambrose in Italy by St. Hierome in Palestine and so in other places by holy and reverend Bishops and Pastors of the Church then this undoubtedly was the doctrine of the Church and thus were the holy Scriptures understood in those ages of the Church Ita intellexit Ambrosius ita Cyprianus c. Thus Ambrose thus Cyprian understood such or such a place of Scripture this had some weight in St. August time and St. Aug. opinion and there is no reason but that it should be of the same force still amongst us 'T is no way probable but that persons so eminent in learning and in piety so frequent in holy prayers and meditations in fastings and wailings so indefatigable in their studies and labours in the Word and Doctrine and who laid down their lives and fortunes for the doctrine they preached should more truly understand the Scriptures and the truth of Christian Religion then we who if there be any thing of Modesty and Humility in our hearts must confesse our selves far inferiour to them in the said gifts and graces of the holy Spirit Aug. Vsque adeo promiscuit imis summa longus dies c. Hath time so confounded all things is light so changed into darkness and darkness become light ut videant Pelagius c. that Haeretiques now are the only seers Et caeci sunt Hilarius Cyprianus Ambrosius And the learned pious Fathers of the Church become blinde The words are too much appliable to the Heretiques of the times 3. The judgement of the Fathers being so far remote from these times wherein we live must needs be impartial as to the controversies amongst us touching the interpretation of any texts of Scripture or doctrines therein delivered as being altogether disinterested and knowing nothing of our disputes and contestations thereabouts Aug. contra Julian Pelag Nullas nobiscum vel vobiscum amicitias attenderunt c. They were neither in friendship nor in community with us or with them who in this age are of a contrary opinion to us they were neither angry with us nor them neither did they pity either of us but what they found professed in the Church they faith fully preserved what they learned they taught and what they received from their fathers they delivered unto us their children and undoubtedly Survey of the pretended discipline as a learned man of our Church observes they that contemn the learned Fathers that went before them do but open a gap to their own discredit making way thereby to be contemned themselves by all those that shall come after 4. We cannot but reasonably imagine that those holy and learned persons who lived nearer the Apostles times should proportionably know better the Apostles meaning in their writings and the doctrine they preached then any of us who live so many hundred years since Iren. l. 3. ch 4. Therefore saith Irenaeus who was the Disciple of Polycarpus the Disciple of St. John Where any question ariseth and the holy Scripture as 't is too common is so perverted Vinc. Ler. as to be made speak for both sides whither shall we have recourse for satisfaction but to the ancient Churches of Christ in which the Apostles converst from thence to hear what the truth is viz. Quid Apostoli quid primi fideles quid eorum successores c. what the Apostles what their Disciples and successors what the primitive Saints and Martyrs Councels and Fathers have received taught and delivered unto others For what came the word of God our from you or came it unto you only 1 Cor. 14.36 Since the Word of God comes not first to us but by and from the Church it is delivered it followes that the sense and meaning of Gods word must not spring from our own heads but to be by and from the Church delivered together with the word The learned Doctor Whittaker in his disputes against the authority of the Church Whit. de sac Q. 3. con 1. c.
〈◊〉 contention is one thing and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 to be contentious is another To contend for the Truth is the duty of all good Christians but to contentious about harmless ceremonies and things indifferent is not the custome of Gods Church and people If any man list to be contentious we have no such custome nor the Church of God 1 Cor. 11.16 From the cohaerence of which Text the danger of contentiousness is also observable For 1. all the contention was about ceremonies about wearing long or short hair praying covered or bare vers 13 14 15. vers 4 5 6. And being contentious about these things presently there followed Schisms or divisions amongst them vers 18. and shortly after down-right Heresies vers 19. Thus Pruritus disputandi becomes Scabies Ecclesiae the itch of contention breeds the scab of Schism and Heresie in the Church Hear from a person interested in such contentions the truth hereof confessed Publique wars and private quarrels which do usually pretend to the reformation of the Church Bauter Saints Rest 3. part ch 13. the vindicating of the truth and the welfare of souls do usually prove in the issue the greatest means to overthrow all it is as natural for wars and contentious to produce Errors Schisms contempt of Magistracy Ministry and Ordinances as it is for a dead carrion to breed worms and vermine beleeve it from one who hath too many years experience of it both in armies and Garrisons It is as hard a thing to maintain in a people a sound understanding tender conscience a lively gracious heavenly frame of spirit and upright life in a way of war and contention as to keep a candle lighted in a storm or under the waters 4. When a Schism is once made and the communion of the Church deserted the separatists like travellers out of the beaten road finde no path to walk in and so become circular and endless in their waies or like such folks which continually toss and turn themselves upon their bed seeking that rest and repose which cannot be found till the humours of the body recover their due temper and be confin'd to their proper limits Hence it comes to pass that new doctrines and new opinions in religion are commonly broacht and set a foot by Schismaticks and this in opposition still to those ancient Truths which are the doctrines of the Church from which they have separated themselves Alienati vero à veritate digni in omni volutantur errore fluctuati ab eo aliter atque aliter per tempora de iisdem sentientes nunquam scientiani stabilem habentes Iren. l. 3. c. 4. adv Haer. Nullum Schisma non sibi aliquam fingit Haeresim ut recte ab ecclesia recessisse videatur Hier. ad Tit. c. 3. It being the essential property of a Schismatick like Proteus to change his minde into every opinion represented to his fancy as plausible Hereunto agrees that ancient authentick father of the Church Irenaeus When men are once alienated from the truth they deservedly wallow themselves in the mire of all kinde of errors being tossed to and fro thereby Sometime of one opinion and sometime of another even in the same things having no certain sixt and setled knowledge at all And the reason hereof why Schismatiques must need become Heretiques is rendred by S. Hierome No Schism saith he but will beget an Heresie that thereby the Schismatique may the better maintain his unlawful separation from the Church CHAP. V. Of the causes of Heresie and Schism and the manners of Heretiques HE that will convert an Heretique Euâ—n qui Haereticum vult convertere oportet scire regulas sive argumenta eorum Nec n. est possibile alicui curare quosdam malè habentes qui ignorat passionem eorum qui malè valent Iren. part in lib. 4. advers Haer. saith Ireneus he must know as the arguments which they use so the Rules whereby they proceed It being not possible for any to work a cure upon another that is diseased if he know not the causes of his disease and the waies of its progresse in the infection of the humors spirits or more solid parts of the body so that to heal the distempers of Heresie and Schism 't is necessary to search out the causes and take notice of those evil waies and corrupt customes of seduced spirits 1. The first original cause of all Heresies and Schisms is pride and ambition which was the original sin both in men and Devils saith Syracides Ecclus. 10.13 Therefore he admonisheth Extoll not thy self in the counsel of thine own heart that thy soul be not torn in pieces as a wilde bull straying alone chap. 6.2 Thus Simon Magus the first Heretique in the Church of Christ bewitched the people of Samaria giving out that himself was some great one Act. 8.9 Thus Montanus as Eusebius records being inflamed with the greedy desire of primacy and superiority Eccles Hiâ—t lib. 5. cap. 16. yeelded to the Actings of contrary or evil spirits in himself by whom being sodainly extasied and entransed he began to utter strange and new doctrines contrary to such as were generally received in the Church pretending to the gift of prophesie by immediate Revelation Theodor. l. 1. hist eccl c. 24. Thus Arrius and Novatus being defeated of their ambitious desires of being Bishops the one of Alexandria the other of Rome became the heads and pestilent Authors of most pernicious Heresies Siâ—n radix elaâ—ionis abscindiâ—ur rami pravae assertionis arcfiunt Greg. that they might lift up themselves to be the heads and leaders of Heretiques since they could not be so of orthodox Christians S. Augustine affirms of Primianus and Maximinianus who through pride and vain glory lifted up themselves to be the heads of two factions among the Donatists And 't was well for them saith the Father such factions fell out for otherwise Primianus had been Postreminianus and Maximinianus had been Minimianus persons of whom no notice had been taken but now in a Schism either of them is a jolly fellow and notorious in the way of opposing the Church So Jack Straw and Wat Tiler had been buried in oblivion had they not raised a mutiny and made an insurrection And are there not too many amongst us whose mean stamp calling and parts pride and vain-glory hath stir'd up to faction and Schism partly to raise themselves up out of the dust of contempt and oblivion and partly out of covetousness knowing it to be the best fishing in troubled waters What else can it be but pride of heart that either moves some to decry government as scorning to be under any command or that moves others so stifly to contend for a parity in government as scorning any superiors Lib. 6. 'T was noted by every man saith the History of the Church of Scotland That of all men none could lesse endure parity and loved more to command then they
most holy faith whatsoever opinion therefore either opposeth the practise or disanuls the vertuous influence of these holy Christian performances makes void the commandements of Christ infringeth the seales of the new Covenant obstructs the blessed means of grace and must therefore necessarily be false erroneous and destructive to the Truth 2. A second general rule for the avoiding of errors Id tencamus qued semper quodubique quâ—l ab â—mn bus Viâ—c â—ir c. 3. is That in these and in all things that relate to Religion we suspect every opinion that is new and strange to be false and erroneous for 't is a certain and infallible rule That what is most ancient and generally received is most true For God who is the fountain of Truth is immutable Jam. 1.17 with him is no variableness nor shadow of turning And holy Truth being a celestial ray displayed from his sacred Majesty must needs be like unto him ever constant to it self and not liable to alteration That we may be guided in the waies of Truth hear what counsel the holy Ghost in this respect gives unto us Deut. 4.32 Aske now of the daies that are past which were before thee from the day that God created man upon earth c. and Joh 8.8 9 10. For inquire I pray thee of the former age and prepare thyself to the search of their Fathers For we are of yesterday and know nothing Shall not they teach thee and tell thee And Jer. 6.6 Thus saith the Lord stand ye in the waies and see and for the old paths where is the good way and walk therein and ye shall finde rest for your fouls But they said 't is the saying of all Heretiques and Schismatiques we will not walk therein we are for new waies new lights and new revelations we have itching ears and these must be scratcht with new doctrines till the scab of Heresie arise upon the soul your old Doctrines are out of dare they are nauseous and offensive their age and antiquity makes them tedious to our souls 2 Tim. 4.3 4. thus sound doctrine will not be endured because men have itching ears and therefore they shall be tutned away from the truth and shall be turned unto fables and lies But Catholicorum hoc fere proprium c. Vinc. liâ— in It is the prophesie of all holy Catholick good Christians to hold fast the Doctrines deposited and committed by the Apostles first to the ancient fathers of the Church and by them transmitted to all posterity Hier. in loc 1 Tim. 6.20 Cum Galatae falsis Prophetis auditis nausea quodam veritatis adfecti catholicae doctrinae manna revomentes haereticae novitatis sordibus oblectarentur ita se Apostolica exercuit authorit as ut summa cum veritate decerneieâ— â—iceâ—nos aut angelus de coelo c. Vino c. 12. O Timothy keep that which is committed to thy trust avoiding profane and vain bablings profane and vain because new and strange Quae à me non audisti saith S. Hierâ—me Doctrines which the Apostles delivered not Nay if they should deliver any doctrine strange and new or if an Angel from heaven should do it the Apostle hath said it and said it again Though we or an Angell from heaven should preach any other Gospel then that you have received let him be accursed Gal. 1.9 Let that therfore abide in you which ye have heard from the beginning if that which ye have heard from the beginning remain in you then shall ye also continue in the Son and in the Father 1 Joh. 2.24 And this same rule is again prescribed 2 Joh. 6. and the reason is given vers 7. Because many deceivers are entred into the world q. d. the way not to be deceived is to hold fast what you heard from the beginning and to walk in it Thus the Nicene Fathers 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Hold fast the old doctrines and usages of the Church And this was ever the cry of the Church Mos antiquus obtineat let antiquity be the judge what is true and what false He therefore that will not headlong himself into Heresie must not be new fangled in his Religion not affecting novelty but stick close to antiquity Nil novandum nisi quod traditum est Nos religionem non quâ vellemus ducere sed quâ illa duceret sequi oportet Vinc. adv Haer. c. 9. Discamus hoc esse proprium diaboli artisicium si non potest nocere persequendo destruendo hoc facit corrigendo aedisicando Luc. de refut Haer. receiving nothing for truth but what was first received by our ancestors and delivered from one generation to another by continued succession from the times of the Apostles For we must not follow Religion saith the Father which way we would lead it but what way Religion leads us 3. To avoid errors in Religion we must beware of extremity in opposing errors 'T is an ordinary piece of cunning in the devil as Luther hath observed that whom he cannot hurt by persecution and affliction he hath ruin'd in the way of correction aedification and reformation Thus by sad experience we have seen almost an extirpation of Religion under the notion of Reformation a blinde zeal of reforming errors hath deformed the truth it self and in stead of paring the nails hath cut off both the hands and feet of Christs spouse the Church Thus in opposition to Prelacy we have run into Anarchy and in crying out Popery popery we have cryed down many necessary Truths and banisht all decency and order in divine worship together with all Ecclesiastical Discipline and government from amongst us Thus also a pretended purity to separate from sinners hath caused many to separate from people more righteous then themselves and whilest they have presumptuously thought to leave the wicked of the world they have left their religion behinde them according to the old proverbe making a great deal more hast then good speed That therefore our much forwardness in opposing one error may not headlong us into another and our zeal to truth over-run and trample it under foot we must remember that this zeal is to be tempered ever with meekness of wisdome Quia quos im plet omnes columnae simplicitate mansuetos igne zeli ardentes exhibet Gal 6.1 therefore the holy Ghost descended on our Saviour in shape of a Dove as well as on his Apostles in likeness of fire to denote unto us that we are as well to be endued with the meekness and innocence of a dove as with the heat and fire of zeal that as by the one we are quickned and enlivened unto piety so by the other we may be tempered and qualified to keep within the limits of truth and sobernesse 4. That we beware of opposing one part of religious truth against another and of disjoyning those things which God hath joyned together e. g. God hath joyned faith and good works as the
1. His written Word 2. Those several means and helps forementioned both divine and humane outward and inward for the right understanding of his Word by the blessing of God and the secret influence of his holy Spirit upon our studies and meditations therein laies himself open to manifold temptations and dangerous seductions of the spirit of error and delusion and as much as in him lies subverts the very foundation of the holy Christian Faith for hereupon these destructive inconveniencies must needs ensue 1. The canon of holy Scripture is transgrest and dissolv'd by the superaddition of new Revelations and the authority of Gods Word is made null and void that must passe for a dead letter when the fictitious dreams and delusions of every idle enthusiastical brain under the mask of Revelations shall be mistaken and miscalled too The quickning Spirit And he that sets up any thing of Religion to the dishonour of holy Scriptures Optaâ— l. 3. 1. saith the Father he doth adificium de ruina construere erect a building upon the ruines of Gods truth and such a building can be no better but an heap of errors and deceits For what will not he dare to affirm and hold who holds any thing besides or above or but equal to the Word of God for the Rule of Faith Hereupon the Resurrection hath been denied and the last judgement and the necessity of all holy just and good works the necessary consequences of these points of our faith for he that believes not the Resurrection and last judgement Quid boni aut veri what holy Truth will he care to believe or what good action will he make conscience to practise 2. He opposes himself to the doctrine of the universal Church of Christ for 1600 years together who with one unanimous and common consent have received the holy Scriptures as the very canon of Faith without addition or diminution without ever hoping or waiting for any new Revelations to be superadded thereunto and very good reason sure if that dismal curse wherewith the canon of holy Scripture is concluded have any influence upon the mindes of men Rev. 22.18.19 If any man adde unto these things God shall adde unto him the plagues that are written in this book c. 3. And more particularly he makes void all those commandements of God to search the Scriptures to hear read meditate and study and delight our selves in the Lawes of God For all immediate Revelation of Gods will presupposes the knowledge of the truth without any search study c. The contempt or neglect of which duty hath sad and heavie judgements threatned thereunto as Jer. 9.13 c. And the Lord saith Because they have forsaken my Law which I set before them And have walked after the imagination of their own heart I will seed them with wormwood and give them water of gall to drink I will scatter them among the heathen c. with manifold texts to the same purpose both in the old and new Testament as Prov. 13.13 28.9 Psal 81.11 12. Zach. 7.12.13 Joh. 5.45 46. 12.48 4. He makes void and unnecessary the sacred function of the Priesthood or Ministery which God hath in all ages ordained and setled in his Church as to mediate with God for the people so to instruct the people from God And this sacred office God hath both confirmed by miracles and by testimony of his blessings ordinary and extraordinary and guarded the same by many direful threatnings denounced and many heavie judgements inflicted upon such as have or shal sacrilegiously violate infringe or usurp this office or neglect refuse or contemn to hear the word of God in the mouthes of his Prophets and faithful Ministers See amongst many other places Jer. 5.12 c. Because the people belied the Lord and said It is not he when he spake by his Prophet And because they said moreover The Prophets shall become â—inde and the word is not in them Therefore thus saith the Lord Because ye speak this word I will make my words in thy mouth fire and this people wood and it shall devour them And to the same purpose Jer. 6.10 11 12. Mat. 10.14 15. Luk. 10.11 12. 5. All pretence to immediate Revelation lords it over the faith of our Christian brethren For an immediate Revelation commands an immediate belief and blinde obedience without any further fearch or trial at all contrary to those expresse commands 1 Joh. 4.1 Beleeve not every spirit but try the spirits 1 Thess 5.21 Prove all things hold fast that which is good or agreeable to the word of God but reject that which is not so and hold for accursed the publishers and promoters thereof Gal. 1.8 Though we or an Angel from heaven should preach unto you another Gospel besides what ye have received let him be accursed 6. The faith of the Enthusiast if it may be called a faith and not rather an illusion of his fancy is not built upon the same grounds with the faith of Christs Church which is the pillar and ground of truth the Church is built upon the foundation of the Prophets and Apostles Jesus Christ himself being the head corner stone Eph. 2.20 i. e. what the Prophets of the Old Testament and the Apostles of the New have revealed to be the doctrine of salvation in Christ is the foundation which the faith of all true Christians is built upon But the Enthusiasts faith is not built upon old but upon new Revelations not upon what is revealed already through the mediation of the Prophets and Apostles and communicated by their successors but upon what shall be immediately revealed from heaven and this groundless ground of faith is opposed to that which is the true ground of faith indeed and made of equal authority therewith so that upon this ground every private mans sayings and affirmations are of as great authority and as much to be regarded as the divinely inspired sayings of the Prophets and Apostles and this must needs be so were there any truth in mens pâ—etended Revelations for undoubtedly we owe as much faith reverence and obedience to every Revelation from heaven how mean soever the person be that receives it as we do to any part of Gods Word already revealed though by the greatest Patriarch or Prophet that ever lived upon earth 7. All dependence upon new Revelations laies a secret stain of dishonour upon God and this in two respects 1. That God notwithstanding his several methods of divine Revelation by the Patriarchs and Prophets of old by his own Son Jesus Christ and his Apostles in these last daies should yet be defective in making known to his people the waies of his service and of their own salvation 2. All pretence to new lights and Revelations makes God the Father of Lights with whom is no variablenesse or shadow of change to vary and change his minde as oft as the fickle and deceitful mindes of men do alter Nay thus God
laid in the right understanding and firm adherence to the principles of holy Religion Now the general ground and foundation of all holy and saving Truth is the word of God or the divinely inspired writings of Moses and the Prophets in the old and of Christ and his Apostles in the new Testament Ye are built upon the foundation of the Prophets and Apostles Jesus Christ himself being the head corner stone Eph. 2.20 But although all things contained in the holy Scriptures be infallibly true and in some respect or other usefull and edifying yet all are not therefore fundamentall Truths Those principles of holy truth contained in the Scriptures which are fundamental are according to the doctrine of the Church reduced to five Heads 1. Repentance 2. Faith Ch. catec 3. Obedience 4. Prayer 5. Sacraments If any winde of doctrine move us from off any of the grounds our souls must needs suffer the shipwrack of holy Truth and be split upon the rocks of false erroneous opinions As to these principles therefore these particular rules must be observed for the avoiding of errors 1. And first for Repentance which is termed the foundation of Christian Doctrine Heb. 6.1 He that will not build but upon what is the foundation of truth must not admit of any opinion whatsoever that shall take him off from the constant confession of his sins with all humility and godly sorrow remembring that there is not a just man upon earth that doth good and sinneth not Eccl. 7.20 And the only means left us to recover our selves out of the snares of sin is by Repentance to wash our hearts with the tears of godly sorrow for sin to empty our souls of them by confession and make them clean by more stedfast purposes and strong resistance against all temptations unto sin And this is the first part of that Baptismal vow or of that covenant we made with God when any of us by holy and lawful Baptism were admitted into the bosome of his Church even to forsake the devil and all his works the pomps and vanities of this wicked world and all the sinful lusts of the flesh or manfully to sight under the banner of Christ against the devil the world and the flesh which is no other but to adhere to the doctrine and to continue in the practise of true Repentance 2. As to Faith which is joyned with Repentance as another essential part of the same foundation of Truth Heb. 6.1 't is necessary for the avoiding of Errors to admit of no opinion relating to Religion that is not agreeable to those Articles of the Christian faith summarily exprest in the Apostles Creed which is that 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 or form of sound words in faith Symbolum Apâ—slorum est râ—gula fidei vestrae brevis grandis braevis numâ—ro verborum graâ—dis pondere sentâ—ntâ—arum Aug. de Temp. we are commanded to hold fast 2 Tim. 1.13 That modell of faith once given to Saints we are commanded earnestly to contend for Jud. 3. The Apostles Creed saith S. Aug. is the rule of your faith which is though short yet weighty short in the number of words but weighty in sentences or the several articles thereof The Gospel of Christ is indeed the grand Rule of faith whereof this lesser Rule the Apostles Creed is the sum and Epitome And he that gees besides and not according to the Rule of faith goes not forward in the way but backward from the way of Truth 3. As to Obedience To entertain no opinion that agrees not with that all-perfect rule of Righteousness the Decalogue or ten Commandements of the moral Law for whatsoever shall oppose thwart make void or any way take off our obedience to any of Gods Commandements is to be rejected as false and erroneous Whosoever saith our Lord shall break one of these least Commandements and teach men so to do he shall be called least in the Kingdome of heaven that is saith the Glosse the most despised in the Church of Christ Minimus in râ—gno h. c. dâ—spectissimuâ— in ecclesia quia decidit à side Lir. in loc and the reason is given because he is saln from the faith he is lapst into error which is expresly asserted by S. John Hereby we are sure we know God if we keep his commandements he that saith he knowes God and keepeth not his commandements is a lyar and the truth is not in him 1 Joh. 2.3 4. And in order to this Rule 't is necessary also to admit of no opinion that tends to the breach of either of those general Rules of Charity which is the fulfilling of the Law viz. To love God above all and thy neighbour as thy self for on these two hang all the Law and the Prophets Mat. 22.37 c. Whatsoever therefore doth not tend either 1. to the inflaming of our souls with the sacred fire of divine love to the advancement of Gods glory and the promoting of his service both inward and outward As also whatsoever 2. tends not to the maintenance of love and unity justice and charity innocence and beneficence towards our neighbors is not to be entertained as a beam shining from the light of holy Truth but as a slash of illusion suggested by the spirit of Error Hereby shall all men know that you are my disciples if ye love one another Joh. 13.35 He omits saith the Father the gift of Miracles Tongues Prophesies Aug. Knowledge to understand all mysteries Faith to remove mountains by none of those but by your charity you shall be known to be my disciples 6 As to the doctrine of Prayer That we admit of no opinion that shall take us off either from the frequent and fervent use of holy Prayers in general or more particularly from the use of the Lords Prayer the which is not only commanded by our Lord to be used when we pray Luk. 11.2 but by the which also we do communicate in our prayers with all holy orthodox Christians there being no time when ever we do use this prayer but many thousands of pious persons are at the same time powring forth their souls unto God in the words of the same prayer To neglect therefore much more to despise the use of this prayer if it be not a piece of disobedience to the plain and positive command of Christ and so a branch of Hecesie yet 't is a depriving our selves of the greatest benefit of the Communions of Saints and so a branch of Schism 7. As to the Sacraments that we reject what ever doth either obstruct the use or deny the efficacy either of Baptism or the Supper of the Lord Mat 26 26 27. c 28 1â— Joh. 6.51.53 Act. 2.38 The use thereof being positively commanded and the efficacy thereof as positively asserted by Christ himself These being also the seales of the covenant of grace Baptism the seale of our admission and the Eucharist of our confirmation in the
qualifications To instance in some particulars First It is a truth by the Spirit of God both foretold promised and performed That the actings and impressions of Gods Spirit upon the mindes of men are both more strong and frequent as also more general and common under the Gospel then they were under the Law That the gift of the Ministry it self is dilated being not limited to the single Tribe of Levi but all men of what quality soever have a title thereunto meaning Genera singulorum not singula generum that is men of all sorts and kindes not all of all kindes but hereupon to make void pull down and level with the undistinguisht multitude the high and solemn order and offices of the Priest-hood instituted by God himself both under the Law and under the Gospel for a people to snatch the Divine Oracles from the lips of the Priest and presume to teach their Teachers to invade the chair of Moses and offer incense with unhallowed censors for private persons to assume the publique administration of Ministerial Offices without a lawful Call and due Ordination thereunto though they may be otherwise qualified with knowledge and piety These are false glosses imposed upon the former truths by the Spirit of lies Tares fowed by the Enemy of mankinde amidst the purer wheat And that 1. To the high dishonour of God and profanation of all that is religious and sacred 2. To involve the Church of Christ and bury it in the rubbish of confusion and disorder 3. To take away those bounds and limits distinguishing Priest from people which all Nations Jewes and Gentiles all Ages of the Church both Ancient and Modern have kept firm and inviolable 4. To pull down heavy judgements upon the heads of all such sacrilegious Usurpers and Invaders of Divine Rites 2 Sam. 6 6 7. 2 Chron. 26. 16 c. 2. It is an impression of Gods Spirit upon the soul of man to wait and depend upon God for spiritual wisdome knowledge Prov. 3.5 c. and not to lean to our own understanding or trust too much to our own wit judgement reading learning Prov. 2.6 or the like as knowing full well That the Lord gives wisdome and from him cometh knowledge and understanding But hereupon either to despise or neglect those waies and means and helps which God in his merciful providence hath afforded us for to attain wisdome c. as the study of Tongues and Languages Arts and Sciences the reading and distinctly weighing the Discourses of the learned and to depend upon immediate Revelation and Infusion of such gifts from Heaven as if they should drop upon our barren hearts as did the Manna in the Wildernesse upon the Tents of Israel out of the clouds and by miracle this is a false gloss which the spirit of delusion puts upon the former truth thereby to inveigle us 1. To tempt the good Spirit of God 2. To be exposed and laid open to seducing spirits 3. To enshrine Lady Ignorance again as the Mother of Devotion which all men know but who are blinded with ignorance to be the Dam of superstitions errors and confusions 3. Rightly to beleeve in the Son of God as the mean of our justification here and ground of our hope of salvation hereafter this is an impression of Gods Spirit on the soul of man and in respect hereof we are said to have the Spirit of Faith 2 Cor. 4.13 2 Cor. 4.13 We having the same spirit of faith according as it is written I beleeved therefore have I spoken faith as it is doctrinal being a spiritual gift and reckoned amongst them 1 Cor. 12.9 And as it is practical 1 Cor. 12.9 being a grace or fruit of the Spirit and reckoned amongst them also Gal. 5.22 Gal. 5. 22. But now to mingle and divide and as it were to cut asunder this true Evangelical Faith as it stands full and intire in all its integral parts both of doctrine and practice so as to be vainly pust up with a conceit of being ingraffed into Christ and thereby to be justified here and sure of heaven hereafter whether we live according to the rule of Faith and in obedience unto the Gospel of Christ or no to define and measure our Faith not by the sacred acts thereof commanded which is called the righteousnesse of Faith but by our own too too credulous fancies and apprehensions Rom 10.6 as if it were no more to be in Christ but presumptuously to pretend unto it and impudently without just ground to believe it This surely cannot be that true Evangelical Faith whereunto so many promises are annext but a false glosse which the spirit of Error hath put thereupon thereby 1. To puffe up the hearts of too too credulous men with spiritual pride and presumption and make them swell with the empty conceit and airy fancy of their own happy and eminent state and condition when there is no such matter And 2. To inveigle men to neglect the use and practice of Christian graces those fruits of the Spirit which are as it is already said the very life and soul of Christianity and consequently the way to heaven if ever we mean to arrive there 4. It is an impression of Gods Spirit on the soul of man To be zealous for the Lord of Hosts that is to be exceedingly fervent and forward 1 King 19 1â— earnest and desirous by all possible waies and means to advance the religious worship and service of God but to be so factions and forward so fiery and furious as by any illegal extravagant and disorderly means to advance the truth it self much lesse to set up any private opinions in relation to Gods Service which have not been semper ubique ab omnibus Vincenâ—â— the three rules of Catholick Doctrine and Worship to be generally and for the most part of the Primitive times at least of all persons at all times and in all places received and not now and then here and there by hereticks and schismaticks only introduc'd I say to be zealous for such pieces of Religion Doctrine and Worship and that per fas nefásque through just or unjust means by right or by wrong to endevour the advancement thereof this is not true zeal but a false gloss which the Devil puts thereupon even through the violence of this distempered heat 1. To divide separate and break men into sects factions and parties that they might so elash together to the ruine of each other And 2. To inveigle men into conspiracies seditions and rebellions against their Governors The like may be observed of zeal for the conversion of a sinner and bringing souls into the obedience of Christ the more zealous and active diligent and industrious any man is herein with the more fire of Gods Spirit no question he is endued But withall observe that to be active and zealous to seduce and deceive to inveigle and draw men aside into false and
Religion as it was viz. Lest the Temple of the great goddesse Diana should be nothing esteemed and her magnificence whom Asia and all the world worshipt should be destroyed but this Religion was blown by the winde of his own worldly ends his profit his gain which he got by making silver shrines for Diana was in danger to be lost and therefore it was now time for to stir not so much for the maintenance of her honour Act. 19.27 as his own profit Act. 19.27 And 't is this spirit of the world that possesses the greatest part of the world generally and for the most part men measure and square out their Religion by the rule of their profit or pleasure or preferment or credit and esteem amongst men or indeed at the best by the rule of self-preservation so far perhaps they will sail by the winde of Gods Spirit as the Sea of this world is calm peaceable pleasant and the navigation gainful or at least not chargeable but if any tempest arise any gusts of trouble or opposition against the truth blow in the face of its professors if any dammages or dangers pursue them in their course they presently tack about and will sail no longer by the heavenly winde of God but by the earthly winde of their own worldly ends and interests not by the winde which blows from heaven but by that which ariseth out of the caves and hollows of an earthly minde Jam. 1.6 suffering themselves by this wind to be tossed to and fro and driven to be of this or that 2 Sam. 24.24 or any Religion that shall cost them nothing nothing of charge trouble or danger ebbing and flowing in this worlds vast sea as the tide either of prosperity or adversity danger or security makes for or against them But this surely is such a spirit as blows quite crosse and contrary to the spirit which guided and directed the Apostles for they finished their course over the troublous sea of this world to the celestial Canaan by sayling in all weathers encountring all oppositions and passing through all storms that met and opposed them In afflictions in necessities in distresses in stripes in prisons in tumults in labours by watchings by fastings c. 1 Cor. 6.4 5 6. And yet in all these difficulties still saith the father The yoke of Christ is easie and his burthen light 1 Cor. 6 4 5 6. Aug. nay there is ease peace and comfort to the soul in the midst of all the troubles dangers wants or necessities that can in this life encounter us whilest the holy Ghost secretly by his comforts both cheers our spirits and fils the sails of our desires with the hopes of arriving safe in the end at the harbour of eternal peace and felicity CHAP. IX Of the Tryal of Spirits SInce then that grand malignant Spirit the enemy of our salvation 3. Gen. working by these two Familiars mans own deceivable spirit and the spirit of the world doth thus many waies counterfeit poyson pervert and consequently obstruct impede and overthrow the workings of the Spirit of grace as an Antidote against this poyson of the serpent and that his countermines prevail not to the subversion of our souls we must make use of that friendly admonition of the Apostle never so necessary to be observed and practised as now 1 Joh. 4.1 Dearly beloved beleeve not every Spirit but try the spirits whether they be of God or no for many false Prophets are gone out into the world The admonition is twofold First negative Beleeve not every spirit Secondly positive Try the spirits and there is one general reason given for both because many false prophets are gone out into the world He then that shall be so credulous as to give heed to every one that pretends to the Spirit of truth and under that pretence treats of holy and spiritual things and shall not first by the rule of truth examine and try such things and persons shall be sure to have lies and errors obtruded upon him under the dresse and attire of Truth because there ever was and ever shall be by Gods permission and the Devils suggestion false Prophets or false Teachers in the world and yet as fair and great pretenders to the truth as the very true patrons and promoters thereof such there were ever in the Church of God both under the Law of old 2 Pet. 2.1 and under the Gospel anew 2 Pet. 2.1 But there were false Prophets also among the people even as there shall be false Teachers among you which privily shall bring in damnable heresies even denying the Lord that bought them and shall bring upon themselves swift destruction And 't were well if the poyson spread no further so that others were not infected therewith also but so nauseous is Truth to the mindes of men for its age and antiquity and so acceptable are Lies and Errors for their novelty that these false Teachers never fail of many disciples and followers 2 Pet. 2.2 so it followes vers 2. And many shall follow their destructions by whom the way of truth shall be evil spoken of First then beleeve them not follow them not be not cousen'd by their fair pretences so as to be infected with their false doctrines 'T is our Saviours own command Mat. â—4 23 Mat. 24.23 If any man shall say unto you Lee here is Christ or Loe there beleeve it not for there shall arise false Christs and false Prophets and shall shew great signs and wonders so that if it were possible they should deceive the very elect But that being forewarn'd ye may be arm'd against their delusions Behold I have told you before Wherefore if they shall say unto you Behold he is in the desert go not forth Behold he is in the secret places beleeve it not The same care and caution was commanded by God to his people under the Law Deut. 13 1. If there arise among you a Prophet or a Dreamer of dreams and give thee a sign or a wonder and the sign and the wonder which he hath told thee come to passe saying Vers 2 Let us go after other Gods which thou hast not known and let us serve them Thou shalt not hearken unto the words of the Prophet or unto that Dreamer of dreams Vers 3 For the Lord your God proveth you to know whether you love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul From whence it is also further observable The reason why God suffers false Prophets to arise viz. for the probation and trial of our proficiency and integrity in the love and service of God for so saith the Father upon those words Aug. for the Lord your God proveth you to know whether ye love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul Tentat nos Dominus non ut sciat ipse quem nihil latet sed ut scire nos faciat
quantum in ejus dilectione profecerimus God suffers us to be tempted tryed and proved by the lying wonders of false Peophets arising amongst us not that he himself may know what is in us to whom the hearts of all men are naked and bare but that we may thereby know our selves and our own proficiency and constancy to the principles of truth and integrity The very same reason is given by the Apostle for the necessity of heresies 1 Cor 11.19 1 Cor. 11.19 For there must be heresies among you Aug. de civ Dei lib. 18. that they which are approved among you may be known Quolibet errore caecentur c. With what error soever our enemies are blinded or with what wickedness soever they are deprav'd 't is for the proof trial and exercise of the graces of Gods Spirit within us Have they received power to afflict persecute imprison c. 'T is for the trial of our patience in suffering and charity in loving our enemies and praying for our persecutors as becomes the Disciples of Christ Mat. 5.44 Mat. 5.44 Do they only by fair words and cunning speeches distil their false and poysonous Doctrines 'T is for the trial of our wisdome in resisting Gal. 6.1 and beneficence in perswading and endevouring to restore them with the spirit of meeknesse proving whether God will give them repentance to the acknowledgement of the truth that they may escape the snare of the Devil of whom they are taken captive at his will 2 Tim. 2.25 26. 2 Tim. 2.25 26. Secondly Try the spirits whether they be of God or no Try them how but by the revelations of the Spirit which is of God who being the Spirit of truth must necessarily therefore in all his qualifications and impressions be consentaneous and agreeable to himself Aug. Veritas veritati congrua one truth ever holds proportion with another nay all truths are as it were the images and resemblances one of another they are all links of the same golden chain which affixt to the throne of heaven displayes ' its radiant lustre unto the mindes of men upon earth They are all but streams flowing from one and the same fountain the God of truth There is nothing then that we are to receive for truth but what is consonant and agrees with the Spirit of truth which ever blessed Spirit speaking in the Word hath thereby prescribed and given us a sure and infallible rule of truth What the Apostle cals a being filled with the Spirit Eph. 5.18 19. he also cals the dwelling of the word of Christ in us richly which any one that will compare the places may perceive whence it is easie to observe that the Apostle means no other by being filled with the Spirit then to be full of the Word of Christ or to be mighty in the Scriptures and the reason is because the holy Spirit is not only the great Dictator of the Scriptures unto us but also our guide in several respects as to the right understanding of them The first rule of trial then is the holy Word of God in general that 's the grand general rule that 's the great square or level according to which we are to try and examine the rectitude truth and integrity both of the doctrines and opinions of others without and also the impressions and workings of the Spirit within Gal. 1.8 Though we Gal. 1. â— or an Angel from Heaven should preach unto you another Gospel besides that you have received let him be accursed Though we preferring authority of the Gospel they had preached before their own authority the Preachers thereof nay before the authority of celestial spirits Though an Angel from Heaven c. He saw saith the Father Aug. that it might so come to passe that Satan transforming himself into an angel of light and working by his mediators and instruments those deceitful workers who transform themselves into the Apostles of Christ 2 Cor. 11 13 14. might so cousen and deceive them if they did not keep close to the Gospel received which is the true rule of faith therefore he saith another Gospel besides c. praeter any thing that is besides that holds not square and is not level to that rule Qui praetergreditur fidâ—i regulam non procedit in via sed recedit à via he that goes besides and not according to the rule of faith goes not forward in the way but backward from the way of truth so 1 Joh. 4.8 We are of God speaking of himself and the rest of his fellow Apostles He that knoweth God heareth us acquiescendo doctrinae nostrae cleaves to our doctrine and he that is not of God heareth us not Lyra. neither is obedient to our word And hereby know we the Spirit of truth and the spirit of error q. d. He that cleaves to our doctrine is guided by the Spirit of truth and he that doth not so by the spirit of error But the spirit of error will come with his scriptum est likewise as he did against our Lord himself Mat. 4. And all hereticks and schismaticks do generally alledge Scriptures and wrest the very sayings of the Spirit of truth against himself to insinuate thereby their lies and errors For as Tertullian observes of the writings of Ovid Virgil Homer both the matter of them hath been transferr'd unto other uses and the verses applyed to other matter Even so do hereticks deal with the holy writings of inspired men De Praeser adv Haer. cap. 39. Nec periclitor dicere c. I fear not to say that the Scriptures were so disposed by the wisdome of God that they might accidentaliter and by the by even administer matter to Heresies since I read that heresies must come and without the Scriptures they cannot come For 't is in the production of heresies as of natural things Corruptio unius est generatio alterius the corruption of truth is the generation of heresie all heretical opinions being generally grounded upon and flowing from the fountain of truth the Scripture not as they are in themselves rightly interpreted and understood but as they are wrested and perverted either in the words or in the sense either by additions or diminutions or by not considering them together but divided into parts and taken up by shreds and pieces for the avoiding whereof these following rules must be observed in the trial of spirits by the Scriptures First try and oxamine by the coherence whether that be the very intent and aim of the holy Ghost in the text for the which it is urg'd and alleged For the same words of the Spirit may be misapplyed both to other things and other persons then the Spirit ever meant or intended therein Secondly distinguish betwixt times ages persons when wherein and to whom this or that word was spoken For there are many things both said and recorded to be done in the Word which are only agreeable
Saviour of the world Gen. 22.18 In thy seed shall all the nations of the earth be blessed 16. These and what other revelations soever Abraham received immediately from God were upon this condition delivered to him that he should instruct his family who not immediately by revelation or inspiration from God but by the mediation and ministerial instruction of Abraham were to be taught the knowledge of God and of his holy Lawes upon this very ground God himself affirms himself to have revealed his will unto him Gen. 18.17 c. And God said Shall I hide from Abraham the things that I do c. For I know him that he will command his children and his houshold after him and they shall keep the way of the Lord. 17. From Abraham Isaac and Jacob the knowledge of God was by tradition transmitted from Patriarch to Patriarch and the Church or people of God now confin'd to the seed of Israel was by the several heads of their respective families instructed in the service of God till turning away after the Idols of Egypt God gave them up to a cruel bondage and slavery under the tyranny of Pharaoh In which great affliction when they besought the Lord he sent redemption to his people by the hands of Moses his servant and Aaron whom he had chosen Psal 105.25 26. 18. Moses the seventh from Abraham was selected and immediately call'd by God as to be the leader and deliverer of his people so his Law-giver also who receiving the minde of God by immediate revelation made it known unto the people The sum whereof was engraven in tables of stone and commanded to be kept as the standing rule of Gods worship and mans obedience to all posterity and the people were herein so far from depending upon immediate revelation that they petition'd to receive the minde of God by the mediation and ministry of Moses Exod. 20.19 Speak thou with us and we will hear but let not God speak with us lest we die 19. The Law of God thus published and standing upon record there was now lesse need of immediate revelation then before the people of God had now a more sure word of prophesie then what formerly 1. By revelation from heaven 2. By tradition from Patriarch to Patriarch was delivered To these sacred writings therefore they were commanded to have recourse by them to be guided and directed and not to swerve from what was contained therein either to the right hand or to the left Josh 1.7 To the Law to the testimony if they speak not according to this word 't is because there is not light in them Isa 8.20 Where all pretence to new lights is cut off and that pronounc't to be no true light which is not grounded on the Lawes of God 20. For the preservation of this law pure and inviolate a ministery or priesthood was ordained and by Gods special command transferr'd from the first born of every Tribe upon the Tribe of Levi. To them belonged the interpretation of the Law and the performance of all the sacred rites therein contained neither were the people either presumptuously to depend upon immediate revelation in respect of the one or sacrilegiously entermeddle with any part of the sacordotal function in the other respect But as to the first 't was ordain'd that the Priests lips should keep knowledge and they i. e. the people should seek the Law at his mouth Mal. 2.7 And as to the second that no stranger that is not of the house of Aaron come neer to offer incense before the Lord that he be not as Corah and his company Numb 16.40 21. But because there is nothing amongst men so well established but through the Devils suggestion and mans corruption 't is liable to depravation and abuse God was pleased the better to restrain both his Priests and people from the violation of his written Law to stir up in every age some choice and select persons whom he enabled more immediately and extraordinarily some to understand and clear the Truth and true meaning of his divine Law when 't was corrupted or obscur'd by mis-interpretations and false glosses others to foretell and pronounce both judgements to come upon the transgressors and mercies upon such as observ'd and kept his commandements whose inspired writings both by way of History and Prophesie Doctrine and Example Praying and Preaching are as so many commentaries of the Divine Law and compleat the Canon of the Old Testament which is reduc't by our Lord himself to these two general heads the Law and the Prophets Mat. 22.40 22. Thus from Adam unto Christ there is no pretence or colour for a people to depend upon immediate revelation the will of God being made known to his people generally and ordinarily by the mediation and ministery of man and but seldome and by a few choice persons and upon extraordinary occasions by immediate revelation The truth whereof will further appear and the weak grounds whereupon immediate revelation depends will be discovered in the succeeding chapters CHAP. II. Of the several manners of extraordinary and more immediate Revelation 1. GOD at sundry times and in diverse manners spake in time past to our fathers Heb. 1. The divers manners of Gods extraordinary revelation of himself to his people of old are reducible to six heads 1. By the ministery of Angels who frequently appeared in humane shape and revealed the minde of God to some of his choice extraordinary servants as Gen. 32.1 2. Zach. 1.9 Mat. 28.2.5 Act. 23.9 and many of those Texts wherein 't is said the Lord appeared unto such and such are to be understood of the appearance of Angels Ob honorem sc mittentis ut plena sit ejus authoritas hoc dr isti qui missus est quod est illi qui misit ut saepius factum est de Angelis Clem. Rec. lib. 2. see for this Exod. 3.2 compar'd with Act. 7.30 where in one place 't is said the Lord appeared unto Moses in the other an Angel of the Lord and Exod. 29.20 ch compar'd with Act. 7.53 and Exod. 23.20 21. Not that any Angel presumed to be called by the name of the Lord or to be worshipped as God but to adde the greater weight and authority to the message he brought from the Lord the messenger was called by the name of the Lord that sent him 2. By Dreams as Numb 12.6 Is there a Prophet among you I the Lord will make my self known unto him in a vision and will speak unto him in a dream and Job 33.24 c. For God speaketh in a dream in the vision of the night then he openeth the ears of men and sealeth their instruction Quia anima clousis sensibus exterioribus ad recipiendam revelationem magis est apta quia tunc non est per occupationem sensuum exteriorum impedita Lyr. in Mat. 1. And the reason hereof is because when the outward senses are shut the inward soul is more
order and right application to the clearing of any truth they would seem to affirm that as they themselves know not well what they say nor whereof they affirm so is it very unlikely that any man else should rightly understand their meanings 3. The Prophets of the Lord had never any motions from the good Spirit but what tended unto good and not to the least harm either of themselves or others But such as were entranced by the evill spirit had motions to do harm and mischief both to themselves and to others also As Saul would have killed David in his Prophet-like trances 1 Sam. 18.11 And Prisca and Maximilla two heretical Prophetesses and great pretenders to immediate revelation hanged themselves in one of their counterfeit Rovelation Extasies which will further appear in the 16. chapter of this Discourse 4. All that was delivered unto or uttered by the true Prophets of God in any of their Extasies were for the good and edification of the Church and people of God But all the revelations of false Prophets are at the best unprofitable useless and vain if not destructive to the Truth The lies errors and deceits the blasphemies and devilish doctrines which these counterfet extasies and revelations have brought forth are both manifold and notoriously manifest also But that ever any saving truth either not known before or nor understood hath in these last daies been by immediate revelation discovered cannot I believe by the greatest Enthusiast of the Age be made to appear Chrys in Mat. c. 7. Hom. 19. S. Chrysost gives us two rules whereby to know true Miracles and consequently true Revelations also from such as are false and counterfeit 1. If necessary as to the time and occasion of them 2. If usefull and profitable as to the issue and fruits thereof but if neither of these concur in a Miracle or Revelation they are false and illusive and to be ascribed rather to the cunning of Satan then to the power of God 5. The Visions and Prophesyings of the Lords Prophets were at all times and altogether true having not the least mixture of error or falshood therein But those of the false Prophets are sometimes true and sometimes false and sometimes neither true nor false but of such a dubious nature as to be seemingly true not only in several but even in contrary senses Et est evidentis judicii c. 'T is evident enough that those things are not from the true God wherein there is the least mixture of falshood or of a lye in any particular Et in his qui mentiuntur Iren. proem advers Haer. saith Irenaeus Even in lying vanities and doctrines of Devils there is ever some truths enter mixed that under the covert thereof the falshood and deceit may unperceivably pass and be entertain'd Thus though the Diabolical spirit appear in the likeness of holy Samuel and the Extasies and entrancings of false Prophets be like unto those of the Lords Prophets yet 1. By their wilde exotique gestures and vexatious agitations 2. By their loss of the use of their reason and understanding for the time 3. By their harmful motions and mischievous incitements 4. By the uselesnesse and unprofitableness of their revelations And 5. though they may speak much truth yet by the least intermixture of falshood and of a lie therewith they may easily be distinguisht the one from the other But to leave these extraordinary means of divine Revelation so long ceased in the Church of God and not of late pretended unto but by Impostors and seduced persons which will appear yet further by considering in the next place the ordinary means of divine Revelation before Christ and their Schools of the Prophets CHAP. IV. Of the ordinary waies of Divine Revelation before Christ 1. THE ordinary means whereby God revealed and made known his will unto his people were in the firster ages the Tradition or delivery of divine Truths from Patriarch to Patriarch together with the Catechetical instructions of the first born and heads of families in whom the several offices of King Priest and Prophet were pro tempore enstated These divine truths were not at the first committed to writing because the years of the first Patriarchs were so many that their memories might well serve them in stead of books Hook eccl pol. l. 1. ser 13. the imperfections and defects whereof God mercifully relieved by often putting them in minde of what was most necessary to be remembred by them In which respect it is easie to observe how many times one thing hath been iterated even to sundry of the best and wisest amongst them And thus it continued in the Church of God which was governed and instructed by a traditionary and unwritten Law from Adam to Moses 2. When the lives of men upon earth were shortned The written Law of God as a surer and more durable means of divine Revelation was commanded to be the Rule of their actions But yet not so as that 't was permitted to each man to give his own sense and make his own interpretation of this divine Law at will and pleasure but 't was to be expounded to them by the consecrated Priests and lawfully called Prophets of God in all ages Neh. 8.4 5 c. Mal. 1.7 Luk. 4.17 Act. 8.30.37 3. And this way of revealing the will of God in the exposition of his holy Lawes did differ much in the time of the first and of the second Temple For under the second Temple Prophesie by extraordinary Revelation generally ceased and hereupon came in a multitude of other Expositors Scribes and Pharisees Wisemen and Disputers 1 Cor. 1.20 to all whom the people were commanded to give ear and to seek the Law at their mouth Mat. 23.2 3. The Scribes and Pharisees saith our Lord sit in Moses chair whatsoever they say unto you observe and do it 4. God ordinarily revealed himself as by his Word and the interpretations thereof so by his Works in several instances of his providence and acts of his service commanded E.G. The delivery of his people out of Aegypt was a revelation of Christs flight and return thence and of our deliverance by him from the bondage of spiritual Pharaoh the Prince of darknesse and from that worse then Egyptian darkness of sin Mat. 1.15 and ignorance here and blackness of darkness for ever hereafter Gods command to Abraham to offer up his only Son Isaac Gen. 22. was a Revelation of his gracious purpose to offer his only son a sacrifice for the sins of the world in whom all the nations of the earth are blessed The erection of the brazen Serpent in the wilderness Joh 3.19 was a Revelation of the son of mans elevation on the Crosse The Passeover or eating of the Paschal Lamb a Revelation of Christ our Passeover 1 Cor. 9.7 that Lamb of God who taketh away the sins of the word The very place where Adam was created being the same where
is made to speak things quite opposite and contrary to himself whilest the several conceits secret suggestions and whispers of mens hearts which are as numerous as the sand and contrarious as light and darkness are yet all under pretence of immediate Revelation fixed upon God who changeth not 8. It doth extremely much derogate and detract from the honour of holy Christian Religion to have no better ground and foundation then either the divinity of the Heathens of old or that of the Mahometans which of later times hath so far overspread and swallowed up so many Christian Kingdomes and flourishing Common-wealths in the world and both the one and the other of these not only derive their original but also their progresse successe and present continuance doth depend upon immediate Revelations which no good Christian surely doth doubt to be any other then Diabolical Delusions The Divinity of the Heathens was such as the Priests of their respective Temples and Oracles delivered to the people in their prophetick trances for celestial Responses and divine inspirations And the more subtil and sublime of the heathen Philosophers recommend unto us an Ecstatical contemplation even to the abolition of the understanding and Reason as the highest and most perfect way of divine knowledge Mahomet began with Raptures and extasies and supposed Revelations of Angels He therefore that shall seriously consider the monstrous Idolatries of the one and the horrid Blasphemies of the other will be careful surely how he trusts unto or depends upon immediate Revelations 9. This doctrine of immediate Revelation should it be granted is not safe for sober and peaceable-minded Christians to embrace or depend upon it but is fittest rather for such persons whose destructive plots and designs under the mask of Religion are to dethrone and murder Christian Princes ruine well establisht government and governors both Ecclesiastick and Civil massacre their Christian brethren rob ruine and destroy whatever opposes their designs and private perswasions in point of faith and manners how sacred and useful soever it be such mischiefs and barbarous cruelties when open force is wanting to effect may be and too often have been effected by pretended Revelations and men of ecstatical and seduced fancies who have though they have greatly merited thereby and done God good service by destroying the enemies of his Truth and abolishing Haeresie Superstition c. when as indeed they have made havock of a people more righteous then themselves destroy'd the truth and true worship of God open'd the way to disorder and confusion and this through perjury sacriledge murder rebellion and the breach of all the lawes of piety justice and charity 10. The neglect of the means of saving knowledge viz. learning divine and humane and to depend upon Revelation without the use of such means is the way to advance Lady Ignorance again as the mother of devotion to drown the world in Barbarism Espencaeus to reduce the Church of Christ to that sad condition wherin it was in the ninth age which was called The unlearned and the unhappy age of the Church wherein he that studied Philosophy and the Mathematicks was counted a Magician he that knew the Greek tongue was shrewdly suspected but if he understood Hebrew also he was no better then an Haeretique 'T is observed by the learned both Historians and Divines that all the ten bloudy persecutions of the Church by the Heathen Emperors did not so damage holy Christian Religion as did the subtil underminings of Julian the Apostate Euseb eccl hist l. 10. c. 32. Soz. l. 5. c. 5. Theod. l. 3. c. 7. who fought not against Christian Religion as did the rest of the persecuting Emperors with fire and faggot but by taking from them all offices of dignity and places of preferment all Ecclesiastical promotions and Church priviledges and more especially by putting down and forbidding all Schools of learning for the training up their youth in the knowledge of tongues and sciences that so the light of holy Religion might be lost in the dark of ignorance and decay of arts For Arts and Tongues are the handmaids to holy Religion these as 't were hold the candle whilest the sacred light of Truth is display'd for our direction in the waies of light and life everlasting 11. He tempts the good Spirit of God who expects to receive the knowledge of Truth by immediate Revelation and miracle which by ordinary common and known means is attainable Dominum tentare est novo miraculo velle pâ—rficere quod aliis rationibus sieri potest so the Devil tempted our Lord to seed himself with the bread of a miracle when Gods ordinary and common providence yeelded bread enough Mat. 4.3 and to cast him self down from the pinnacle of the Temple when the way to come down by steps was plain and easie without any such praecipitation That dependence upon immediate Revelation is unnecessary and consequently uselesse and unprofitable is manifest from what hath been already said from the sufficiency of Gods revealed Truth and is yet further manifest from the vain and bootlesse issue of all such dependence For what sacred Mysteries of holy Religion have been either made known or more plainly unfolded by immediate Revelation in these last daies since the time of Christ and his Apostles many Impostures and lies many Haeresies and errors many Schismes and divisions have fancied Revelations brought forth but that any sound soul-saving truth hath been of later times immediately revealed I could yet never hear or read of by any authentick witnesses and it is most just with God to give men up to the vanity of their minde and to the delusions of their own hearts who thus tempt his holy Spirit by leaving the known and beaten paths of Truth revealed to depend upon what is unnecessary useless and vain and not only so but also 12. Dependence upon immediate Revelations laies us open to the delusions of Satan 2 Cor. 11.14 who transforming himself into an angel of light insinuates his suggestions and diabolical doctrines under the shew and vizard of divine Revelations Many pious men have been deluded by this wile of the Devill and have faln into grosse errors Tert. de anima c. 9. Tertullian though he observed this and saw how grosly many of Montanus sect were cheated into foul mistakes and errors upon fancied Revelations yet notwithstanding so strongly doth the Devil work upon the fancy by the force of this inchantment that he himself was deceived also and became a Montanist being cousened hereunto especially by the pretended Revelations of a holy sister whom he much extols in his tract de Animâ whose pretended vision of the substance of a soul corporally exhibited to her view made him believe the soul to be corporeal and although for this opinion he was not condemned for haeresie neither yet was guilty of those more gross and blasphemous opinions of the Montanists which their fancied Revelations brought forth
soul of sanctification infused in the obediential and practical use of this knowledge And both of these are the work of Gods Spirit the one the issue of his gifts and the other of his graces but neither without the use of those respective means which God hath thereunto most graciously appointed 2. Whosoever pretend to immediate Revelation and to have a secret teaching from God because they are of the number of his Saints and such as fear God must remember that 't is an act of great presumption misbecoming the humility of Saints and directly opposing the fear of God to neglect the means and depend upon miracle for the knowledge of his will so that by the very act of depending upon immediate Revelation they cut themselves off from all title and interest in those promises that are made to the meek lowly humble and such as fear the Lord for how can they be of the number of those babes to whom the mysteries of heaven are revealed who rank themselves amongst the most wise and perfect All professions and boastings of wisdome and holiness being symptomes of pride and presumption are thereby evident tokens that there is no true sober wisdome or solid soul-saving piety in the hearts of such professors but that they intrude into those things Col. 2.18 which they have not seen being vainly puft up by their fleshly minde And the minde never swels with that fleshly humour of self-conceited knowledge and purity without the secret infusions of that Diabolical spirit who as he was the first original of all pride and presumption so of all sinfulness and error thence derived and infecting the hearts and lives of men For pride is the beginning of sin and error also and he that hath it shall powr out abominations Ecclus. 10.13 What and how great are the benefits of piety and holiness of life as to the right understanding of Gods revealed will hath been already expressed That it is as the very soul and spirit so the top and perfection of true wisdome and knowledge that it is the end of all our studies and endevours and of all learning and knowledge both divine and humane and that without this holiness of life all our learning and knowledge shall be so far from being any way useful as to our own particulars that it shall tend to our greater condemnation at the last day Luk. 12.47 That whilest we study for learning and knowledge with desires and intentions only to be more wisely and knowingly pious and religions and withall do make a sanctified use of our knowledge received not suffering it to continue notionary and speculative in the brain but to be practical in the heart and have its influence upon the actions of our life That thus I say God is invited and according to his promises will undoubtedly multiply and increase our talent and by his holy Spirit open our eyes to see more clearly the waies of his service and our own salvation then such persons who have perhaps a greater portion of learning but less piety and hence undoubtedly many persons of meaner gifts and less learned have outstript others more learned and knowing in the knowledge of holy mysteries God of his great mercy enriching their understanding with more for the holy and pious use they have made of the less portion of knowledge imparted to them But yet notwithstanding the soul must not be advanc'd to the destruction of the body of sacred knowledge nor that which is the end and perfection of true wisdome must not make null and void the means God hath destin'd thereunto nor may we presume upon our good desires pious intentions and fancied relations unto God as this Elect and people further then in all humility to wait upon him for his blesting not without but in the use of those means of grace and truth which he hath ordained for our direction and guidance therein To conclude this discourse in the words of judicious Hooker If license were given to every man Eccl. polit l. 5. sect 10. to follow what himself imagineth that Gods Spirit doth reveal unto him or what he supposeth that God is likely to have revealed to some special person whose vertues deserve to be highly esteemed what other effect would ensue hereupon but utter confusion of his Church under pretence of being taught led and guided by his Spirit The gifts and graces whereof do so naturally all tend unto common peace that where such singularity is they whose hearts it possesseth ought to suspect it the more in as much as if it did come from God and should for that cause prevail with others the same God which revealeth it to them would also give them power of confirming it to others either with miraculous operation or with strong invincible remonstrance of sound reason such as whereby it might appear that God would indeed have all mens judgements give place unto it Whereas now the error and insufficiency of their arguments doth make it on the contrary against them a strong presumption that God hath not moved their hearts to think such things as he hath not enabled them to prove The Prayer O blessed Father of lights and fountain of all holy true divine and celestial Revelations as thou hast been pleased to reveal thy Son unto us to be the way the truth and the life so give us hearts to cleave fast to these divine Revelations both to acquiesce and persevere in the sacred doctrine and saving practise thereof take from us all vanity of mind and deceitfulness of imagination and let not the Author of lies prevail upon our depraved fancies to take us off from an holy humble and constant dependence upon thee in the use of the means of grace and truth ordained by thee Let thy Word be ever a light unto our feet and a lanthorn unto our paths and let thy holy Spirit ever clear this light to our minds and inflame our hearts with the sacred fire of divine love and zealous obedience to thy holy will revealed in thy word that by the guidance of this twofold light thy Word without and thy Spirit within both our outward and inward man may be directed in the waies of thy service and of our own salvation through Jesus Christ our Lord Amen The Ground and general Heads of the ensuing Discourse 1. THere were never any times wherein that admonition of S. Peter was more necessary to be observed by all careful and conscientious Christians Be sober and vigilant for your adversary the Devil as a roaring Lion walketh about seeking whom he may devour 1 Pet. 5.8 2 There are two waies whereby the Devil working upon mens frailties and upon their extravagant lusts and passions doth devour or destroy their souls 1. By blinding their understandings whereby they become apt to be seduced to the entertainment of errors and belief of lies 2. By poysoning their affections with the false paint of worldly vanities whereby they are ininveigled
into sinfulnesse and vice 3. And so nearly and entermixedly are the acts of the understanding enterwoven with those of the will and affections that the corruption of the one doth ever corrupt and vitiate the other So that as sinfulness on the one hand clouds the judgement and is ever productive of errors in the understanding so an erroneous Judgement on the other hand is ever fruitful in the production of sinful acts and habits 4. Hence it comes to passe by necessary consequence the just judgement of God concurring that the great and crying sins of our Nation have produced so many great and dangerous overspreading errors amongst us For the broaching and belief of lies as 't is in it self a sin and the fruitfull dam of many sins so 't is also by the just judgement of God a punishment for sin which is affirmed 2 Thess 2.10 11. Because they received not the love of the Truth that they might be saved For this cause God shall send them strong delusions that they should believe a lie 5. The love of the Truth is not received so as to be effectual unto salvation three waies 1. When we do not acquiesce and rest in it but fondly doat upon new Lights and new Revelations as if the truth of Christ revealed were imperfect and defective 2. When we do not practise and live according to the truth having a form of godlinesse in the doctrinal knowledge and discourse of the truth only but no power in the conscientious practise thereof 3. When we do not persevere either in the profession of the true Faith or practicall obedience thereof 6. When any of these waies the love of the truth is rejected the guilt of so great a crime most justly provokes the Almighty to permit holy Truth to be poysoned with lies and doctrines of Devils And in this respect God himself affirms him self to be the author not actively but permissively of all delusions as Ezek. 14.9 If the Prophet be deceived when he hath spoken a thing If the Lord have deceived that Prophet which God doth most justly for the sinful disobedience of the people for this is no other saith Hierome Hier. in lâ—c but what is agreeable to that threat Luk. 26.27 28. If you will not hearken unto me but walk contrary unto me then will I walk contrary unto you in fury c. There being nothing that God inflicts more contrary to the happinesse of a people then the infatuation of their Priests and Prophets Haeretici veris catholicis membris Christi malo suo prosunt dum Deus utitur malis bene diligentibus eum omnia coopâ—rantur in benum Rom. 8. But as all things work together for good to them that love God so do Heresies and errors also The which as they are for evil by the infatuation of the wicked so they are for good also in the further illumination and sanctification of the Righteous Nor would the supreme goodnesse ever suffer the evill of Heresie or any other evill to be but that he full well knows how to bring good out of evill 8. That we may then attain those good ends for the which God permits Heresies amongst us and avoid the evil of infection and infatuation thereby or according to the same Father Aug. Ut quisque sic carpet botrum ut caveat spinas ex luto aurum colligat That every one may so pluck the fruits as to avoid the thornes and gather the gold of sound doctrine out of the mire of filthy Dreams and delusions 't will be necessary seriously to weigh and consider 1. The nature of Error Heresie and Schism with the general heads hereof 2. The danger of being infected thereby 3. The ends for which God permits them 4. To observe such rules and receive such directions as may by divine assistance keep him free from infection by them Of ERROR HERESIE and SCHISM CHAP. I. Of Error in general 1. EVery man by nature is as prone to Error as to sin the understanding being as well clouded as the will and affections corrupted by the fall of Adam Our first parents out of a sawcy presumption affecting to know what they ought not involv'd themselves and all their posterity in blindness and ignorance of what they ought to know The body of man being subjected to natural corruption and mortality subjects the soul whilest 't is imprisoned therein to a spiritual corruption also through ignorance and error For the corruptible body saith the wise man presseth down the soul and the earthly tabernacle weigheth down the minde that museth upon many things and hardly do we guesse aright at things that are upon earth In is â—llo errore non hunanitatis sed Deitatis selum est Aug. serm ad fâ—ati in erem and with labour do we sinde the things that are before us and the things that are in heaven who hath searched out Wisd 9.15 16. So that not to be ignorant and not erre in the points and particulars of heavenly truth is not humane saith the Father but the sole prerogative of the divine nature 2. There is a threefold ignorance wherewith all the minds of men are naturally clouded 1. To be ignorant of what is necessary to be known 2. Not to know what is necessary and expedient for us agreeable to our persons callings breeding and the times wherein we live 3. When through a corrupt and depraved disposition of minde we mistake falshood for truth and darkness for light and this whether in bare opinion or else of set purpose and setled determination The last of these is the most sinful ignorance and that which properly and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 is called Error whereunto that woe belongeth Isa 5.20 Wo unto them that call evill good c. 3. In many things we offend all Jam. 3.2 And this not only by iniquity in life and action but also by error in judgement opinion But as God of his great mercy through the merits of Christ imputes not unto us those sins which through natural frailty and meer infirmity daily and hourly invade the innocence of the soul i. e. if with an humble lowly penitent and obedient heart we confesse them and unfeignedly beleeve in Christ for the pardon of them so neither doth he impute those errors of our judgements which are of smaller consequence whilest they infect not the will and affections so as obstinately and perversely to persevere therein A bare and naked error in the understanding only is rather an infelicity then a crime 't is the obstinacy of the will the animosity and perverseness of the affections in cleaving to the mistaken conception of the understanding that renders the mistake a sinful and diabolical error for saith the Father Aug. de verbis Apost serm 22. Whilest we do but erre we are but like our selves frail mortal men whose thoughts are miserable and whose devices are but uncertain but when through animosity and perversness we
truth which their understandings being not able to digest they are intoxicated therewith and stagger like drunken men being tossed and fro with every winde of doctrine against which presumption the wise Syracides admonisheth Ecclus. 3.21 Seek not out the things that are too hard for thee neither search the things that are above thy strength But what iâ— commanded thee think thereupon with reverence For many are deceived through their own vain opinion and an evil suspiâ—ion hath overthrown their judgement Hence 4. Even from ignorance under the pretext of knowledge 't is the custome of Heretiques to snarle and detract and speak evil of those Truths the profound and deep excellency whereof their darkned understandings cannot fathom so they are described 2 Pet. 2.12 and Jude vers 10. To speak evil of the things they understand not As the Jewes because they understood not Christs Doctrine of the bread of life therefore they strove amongst themselves saying How can this man give us his flesh to eat Joh. 6.52 And Nicodemus because he understood not the nature of Regeneration was offended at the doctrine saying How can a man be born when he is old c. Joh. 3.4 Whereas all good Christians who have any grain of true faith do believe with reverence even those mysteries of godliness which they understand not expecting with all humility and obedience till they shall be opened and made known unto them Hist eccl l. 7. c. 13. So Eusebius records of Dionysius Alexand who speaking of the Revelation of S. John saith I do not impugn those things therein which I understand not but rather admire them the more for that they are above my understanding And S. Aug. gives us this rule to be observed as touching the mysteries of holy Religion Quod secundum fidem qua imbuti sumus inteligere valucrimus tanquam de cibo guadeaâ—us quod secundum saâ—aâ—n sidei regulam intelligere non poterimus bonum tanen verum esse minime dubitemus Aug. in Joh. tract 18. What according to the measure of faith wherewith we are endowed we do understand aright let us therein rejoyce as 't is the food of our souls but what we cannot according to the sound rule of faith conceive we must not therefore doubt but to be holy just and good Hence 5. ariseth so much levity and inconstancy of minde in all heretical and schismatical persons like children tossed to and fro with every winde of doctrine Ephes 4.14 Even as children for want of judgement distinguish not betwixt wholsome and unwholsome diet betwixt food and poyson so all persons become erroneous and wavering for want of knowledge and judgement rightly to distinguish betwixt light and darkness tares and wheat corn and chaffe betwixt what is the food and what they poyson of their souls therefore they are compared to clouds without water carried about with windes Jude vers 12. denoting the emptiness of sound knowledge which renders them not only inconstant in the tenents of religious Truths but also obnoxious both to the broaching and belief of lies having ever an itching desire to things new and strange but with the Israelites loathing the old Manna though it be the food of Angels for no other reason but because they are accustomed to it And this spiritual itch a more baneful disease then the corporal is grown epidemical and so overspreading the body of our Church as that prophesie of the Apostle hath at no time been more manifestly fulfilled then in these our daies 2 Tim. 4.3.4 For the time will come when they will not endure sound doctrine but after their own lusts shall heap to themselves teachers having itching ears And they shall turn away their ears from the Truth and shall be turned unto Fables This itch saith the Father Pruritus in auribus spiritualiter fornicantibus sicut pruritu libidinis in carne corrumpitur integritas castitatis Aug. in Joh. Hom. 43. is as pernicious to the purity of Truth as is the itch of lust to the vertue of chastity for hence many solid and soul-saving Truths are often contemned for their antiquity because they were heard of before and so they tickle not their itching ears And lies and errors are readily embrac'd in their stead meerly for their novelty And those teachers which feed this humor and claw this itch by bringing things new and strange to their ears are the only persons they lust after delight in and follow by heaps and multitudes But undoubtedly amongst many other this is one infallible mark whereby to distinguish Truth from Error and consequently Heretiques and Schismatiques from orthodox Christians Truth like the Sun in the firmament is ever one and the same and constant to it self but Error changes like the Moon is multifarious and endless knowes no stint or limits therefore Tertullian cals the faith of Heretiques Fides annua menstrua sides temporum non evangeliorum Not like the faith of the Gospel which is fixt and setled permanent and constant but the faith of a year or of a moneths continuance and the faith of the times as the times change and alter so doth the Religion commonly of all seduced and erroneous persons From which inconstancy new sect and parties daily and hourly do arise amongst Heretiques as from the shop of Simon Magus Heresie sprung all those innumerable sorts of Heretiques in the Church till the time of the Manichaean heresie And these Manichees were also subdivided into Catharists Macarians and Manichees strictly so called From Arrius sprung the Macedonians Aerians Aetians Aug. cont Don. l. 1. c. 6. and innumerable others Donatus party saith S. Aug. was soon broken into many lesse and smaller parcels Denique penitus inspectae omnâ—s haereses in multis cum autoribus suis dissentientes deprehenduntuâ— Teit. de prae cont Haer. c. 42. The Anabaptists amongst us are subdivided into Antinomians Brownists Seekers Ranters Quakers Familists c. And finally saith the Father look into all Heresies and you may easily finde them in many things dissenting even from their own authors and Founders And seldome shall you see Heretiques agree in any one point except it be to oppose and cry down the Truth as Herod and Pilat against Christ 6. From the same dark Abysse of Ignorance Neque n. natae sunt haereses quaedam dogmata illaqueantia animos in profundum praecipitantia nisi dum scripturae bonae intelligerentur male quod in its non bene imelligitur etiam temere audacter asseritur Aug. in Joh. Tract 18. under the semblance of self-conceited wisdome hath sprung that which is of all others the greatest cause of Heresies viz. The misinterpretation and mis-application of the holy Scriptures For saith the Father Heresie had never sprung up nor false doctrines bewitching and destroying the souls of men had never been broacht had not the good word of God been ill understood and that also which is but ill and weakly understood been rashly
and presumptuously affirmed 'T is ever the custome of Heretiques to alledge holy Scriptures in a wrested and perverted sense making those sacred writings like a nose of wax turning and writhing them to this and to that and to every sense that best agrees with their own vain imaginations Aliter Photius aliter Novatianus c. One Heretique understands it this way and another diversly from him and a third distinct from both and all put another sense upon the words of God then ever his holy Spirit intended therein Pro voluntatis sue sensu Hilar. Vinc. Lir. adversus Har. c. 1. Hil de trinitate l. 2. The sense of their own minde and spirit not of Gods Spirit they put upon the Scriptures which occasion'd that complaint plaint of S. Hierome 'T is only the Art of understanding Scriptures which all persons challenge to themselves Soâ—a scripturarum aâ—s est quam sibi passim omnâ—s vendicant Hanc gariula avus hanc delirus senex hanc so phista verbesus hanc universi presumunt lacerant docent ante quam discant Hier. ad Pâ—l l. 1. c. 6. This the pratling old wise and the doting old man and the wrangler full of words this all men presume unto and upon presumption of their interest therein they tear and wrest and abuse it at their pleasure presuming to teach the doctrine thereof before they have half learned it As in the natural creation of children too many are the issue of lust and wantonness nor is it considered when they are begotten how they shall be kept even so 't is in the spiritual brood of Heresies pride covetousness and ignorance begets them before the authors know how to maintain them but as children when they are once gotten must be kept though they pinch upon their neighbours so this heretical crew rather then the opinions which are the issue of their pride and vanity should die they will steal the sincere milk of the word to nourish them or in language of another strain rather then they will submit their vain imaginations to the truth and true meaning of Gods word the truth of that must submit to their imaginations And this Videtis id vos agâ—re ut omnis scripturarum de medio auferatur authoritas suus cuique animus author sit quid in quaque scriptura probet quid improbet id est non ut authoritati subjiciatur sâ—ripturarum ad fidem sed ut sibi scripturas ipse subjiciat non ut illi ideo placeat aliquid quia hoc in sublimi authoritate scriptum legitur sed ideo recte scriptum videatur quia hoc illi placâ—â—t Aug. cont Faust saith the Father is the way to rob the Scripture of its authority whilest every mans own imagination must tell him what it allowes and what it disallowes this is not to be subject to the authority of the Scriptures but to make the Scriptures subject to our imaginations so that therefore this or that is not acceptable unto them because 't is written in the word of God but therefore 't is well said or written there because 't is acceptable unto them The great danger they incur who put another sense upon the holy Scriptures then Gods holy Spirit ever intended therein is represented to us by the strange fire which that rebellious crew under the conduct of Corah Dathan and Abiram offered up unto the Lord there came out a fire from the Lord and devoured the presumptuous sacrificers Numb 16.18 35. So those unlearned and unstable souls which wrest the Scriptures do it to their own destruction 2 Pet. 3.16 As a remedy to prevent so great mischief the ancient Fathers thought it meet to provide saith the reverend Andrewes that they who took upon them to interpret the Scriptures Lat. conâ— secundum sâ—ss 11. should put in sureties that the sense they gave of them should be no other then what the Church in former times acknowledged So Vinc. Lirin also By reason of the manifold windings and turnings of the Scriptures Propter tantos tam varii erroris anfractus necesse est ut prophetiâ—ae Apostolicae interpretationis lâ—nea secundum ecclesiastici catholici sensus normam dirig atuâ— Vine Lir. advers Haer. c. 2. for the maintenance of several errors 't is necessary to direct the line of prophetical and Apostolical interpretation according to the rule of an Ecclesiastical sense and meanings for Quis unquam Haereses c. saith the same Author Who ever brought in an Haeresie but first he disagreed from the consent of antiquity and of the ancient Catholique Church Et in laqueum sit verbum Dei saith Estius the holy Word of God becomes a snare and a stumbling block to all those who contemning the authority of the Church presume to impose their own private sense upon it And he that obtrudes his private sense of Scripture upon his hearers not only lords it over their faith but over the faith of the universal Church of Christ Estius in Rom. 11.9 nay he makes null and void the authority of holy Scriptures for Scripture is no more Scripture if not rightly interpreted 7. Another general cause of erroneous opinions in Religion is Hypocrisie when men are cold and lukewarm and too negligent in the practise which is the life of Christianity when they receive not the love of the Truth so as readily to obey and practise it then it is just with God to give them up to strong delusions Nay hereby men lay themselves open to the delusions of Heretiques because the excellency of holy Christian truths are not cannot be known but by the practise and experience thereof therefore said our Saviour If ye do his will ye shall know of my doctrine whether it be of God or no Joh. 7.17 So that undoubtedly what ever piety or purity Heretiques may pretend unto yet generally 't is but a meer formal outside a show and shadow of truth but no substantial solid piety or charity having a form of godliness but denying the power 2 Tim. 3.5 For to such who by obedience practise and experience do know and believe the excellency of Truth it is not possible to be seduced and drawn aside therefrom Qu imdiu bona epâ—ra saâ— imus ipsum lumen ju stitiae ante oculos nosties adaperit veritatem Chrys in Mat. 7. Hom. 19. therefore our Lord cals all false Prophets Woolves in sheeps cloathing Mat. 7.15 that is Nominis Christiani extrinseous superficies meer nominal outside Christians no men so seemingly austere and strict and yet all is but empty appearance of holiness no men assume to themselves more holy titles the Saints the Elect the People of God If they be simple and illiterate persons then they apply to themselves God hath chosen the simple 1 Cor. 1.27 and those that confute them in discourse do it by carnal Reason and the wisdome of the flesh if they be subtil and acute in argumentation and put
and sacriledge These censers saith the Father are a figure of the holy Scriptures wherein Heretiques offer strange fire by imposing a strange sense and distinct from the minde of Gods Spirit therein which is so abominable unto God that 't is commonly the ruine of the Authors and abettors thereof But yet if we bring these brazen censers to the golden Altar of God and compare the strange fire therein with the true fire from heaven the lustre of the one will appear more clear and eminent through the false and counterfeit glosse of the other for as that maxime is true in general Contraria inter se opposita magis elucescunt All contraries by their mutual opposition do more clearly shew themselves so this in particular also is as true veritas falsorum comparatione magis fulgebit Truth when compared and opposed to falshood appears like gold from the dross when tryed in the fire more illustrious and shining 'T is one reason therefore why holy catholick doctrine is so much besieged and impugned by heretical gainsayers and tares of erroneous opinions are intermixt with the pure grain of sincerity and truth vizâ— That tho holy faith might not loose its gloss and lustre but appearing like it self clear and perspicuous might more effectually conduce to the illumination of our souls 3. The holy faith by the opposition of Heresie is elevated and raised to a higher pitch of perfection and the mysteries thereof become thereby to be more acutely handled more narrowly sifted and throughly considered whereas otherwise like children we should ever be content with milk and neglect the more solid and substantial food Haereticos permisit Deus ne semper lacte nutriamur in bruta infantia remaneamus Aug. Trâ—ct 36. in Joh. resting in generals and not descending to the discussion and right understanding of particular truths So saith the Father God therefore suffers Heretiques amongst us that we might not alway be nourished with milk and continue for ever in the more brutish estate of infancy 4. The holy faith by the opposition of Heresie is the more confirmed and strengthned even as trees shaken with the winde take the faster hold and are thereby more firmly enrooted in the earth so the more the foundation of our faith is assaulted and shaken by the gusts of heretical opinions the faster hold is taken and more firmly the principles of holy truth are enrooted in our hearts Nor is this the weakest argument to perswade us of and confirm us in the truth of all the Articles of the Christian faith that notwithstanding the several oppositions of Heresies in all ages many whereof have for the time so prospered and prevailed as to infect the greater and more eminent sort of Christian professors yet the true faith hath ever in the end triumphed over them they have dasht themselves in pieces like waves against a rock have broken into a foam and vanisht into smoke for magna est veritas praevalebit As for truth it endureth and is alwaies strong it liveth and conquereth for evermore Esd 4.38 The second general end why God permits Heresies is in respect of the professors of the holy faith And these being of two sorts good and bad either such as are sound grain or else such as are empty chaffe therefore he suffers the fan of temptation to passe over all by the assaults of erroneous opinions that the one might be distinguisht from the other that the corn might be winnowed from the chaffe the wheat separate from the tares and sound orthodox Christians might be known from the un sound hollow-hearted Chrys Hom. 19. in Mat. 7. hypocritical professors of the faith That the evil may not be crowned with the good therefore God sends temptations saith the Father and that the good may not perish with the evil therefore he commands us to beware of false Prophets 2. The reason why the unsound and sinful professors are tempted and by temptation overcome by the assaults of erroneous opinions in Religion is by the just judgement of God permitted for a punishment upon them for as it is in the way of sinfulness one sin is commonly the punishment of another God most justly withdrawing the assistance of his divine grace from such as wilfully transgress his most holy Lawes Peccatum quod non per poenitentiaÌ„ diluituâ— mox suo pondere ad aliud trahitur Greg. So that when sin saith the Father is not washed away with the tears of repentance the weight thereof sinks the soul into the puddle of following sins His own iniquities shall take the wicked himself and he shall be holden with the cords of his sins Prov. 5.22 So it is in the way of Error they who receive not the truth in the love and life thereof which is sound and sincere obedience thereunto For this cause God shall send them strong delusions that they should believe a lie that they all might be damned who believed not the truth but had pleasure in unrighteousness 2 Thess 2.10 11 12. So Saul for his disobedience 1 Sam. 15.22 23. The Spirit of the Lord departed from him and an evil spirit from the Lord troubled him 1 Sam. 16.14 So Ahab for his many abominations refused to ear â—â—hthe voice of the true Prophet Micaiah and listned to false Prophets to his own ruine and destruction 2 Chron. 18. And so Judas whose faith in Christ was never sound but his Religion lay in his purse not in his heart was therefore suffered to be tempted and eternally ruined by that temptation to betray his Master 3. In respect of the sound and sincere professors of Christianity God permits Heresies for many useful and profitable reasons 1. That those smaller errors and mistakes wherewithall through ignorance or misperswasion the understandings of many good men are infected might by the opposition of Heresies be cleared and done away and the chaffe by the fan of temptation be winnowed Datam scimus Sa anae potestatem ut servos Christi cribâ—aret ut quod de trinco inveniri pâ—ssit hâ—rreis â—ungeretur quod de his ad ign um alimenta transiret Anacleti epist and sifted from the purer grain so saith an ancient Father of the Church We know that power is given to the Devil to winnow and sift the servants of God that what is found to be sound and good wheat might be gathered into the barn and carefully treasured up in the stedfast belief thereof and what proves but chaffe and fit for the fire might be shaken off The inundation of heresies being one of those fiery trials whereby every mans work shall appear whether it be gold silver and precious stones to be continued or whether no better then wood hay and stubble which too often is built upon the same foundation with the other and to be consumed 1 Cor. 3.11 12 13. 2. Heresies are permitted to scoure off the rust of idleness sloth negligence and carelesness in matters of faith they
all truth and peace be pleased together with his Truth to restore unity and order in his worship whereof for our manifold sins he hath so long deprived us 5. Heresies and Schisms as they are the cursed parents of sin so of judgements also both temporal and eternal as to temporal judgements S. Stephen tels us out of Amos 5.25 That if we make to our selves tabernacles or figures to worship them our punishment shall be to be carried away beyond Babylon Act. 7.43 Babylon Aug de civit dei l. 18. saith the Father est civitas illa confusionis quae indifferenter habet philosophos inter se diversa adversa sentientes That city of câ—nfusion which consists of persons of diverse and contrary opinions each to other and that 's the portion of those people that either vent or addict themselves to new opinions the fond imaginations of their own hearts they shall dwel in the midst of perpetual strifes and contentions and the Babylonish confusion of diverse and contrary opinions each to other whereas Gods city the Church is a city that is at unity in it self the bâ—essed inhabitants of which city the members of the true Church are all of one heart and of one minde neither is there or ought there to be in this city as in Babel liberty for every sect-master to set up what imaginations he please without controll for when liberty of conscience produces licentiousness of opinion confusion and disorder must needs ensue and if Babylons confusion goes before the captivity of Babylon will not be far behinde for what else can be the end of confusion through diversity of opinion but ruine and desolation The blessed fruits of unity and concord are peace and prosperity Concordia res parvae cresennt and the cursed effects of contentions and variety of opinions are war and destruction Discordia maximae dilabuntur The world is full of examples of both kindes therefore is there no one Christian duty whereunto we have more pathetical and zealous admonitions in the Scriptures then this of unity and agreement both in judgement and affection for this our blessed Lord so fervently prayed Joh. 17.11 22 23. To this he so frequently exh reeth his Apostles Mark 9.50 Joh. 14.27 And his Apostles all Christians Rom. 12.4 c. chap. 15.6 1 Cor. 1.10 Qui perversa mente de praeceptis pacis discordiam faciunt justo dâ—i examine ipsi de verbis vitae moriuntur Greg. de cur past Adm. 25. Now I beseech you brethren by the name of our Lord Jesus Christ that ye all speak the same thing and that there be no divisions among you but that ye be perfectly joyned together in the same minde and in the same judgement so also 2 Cor. 13 11. Ephes 4.1 c. Phil. 1.27 2.2 He therefore faith the Father that through perversness of minde shall out of the precepts of peace and concord create dissension and strife creates death to himself out of the words of life Charity is of the very essence of Christianity the Qâ—een of graces the sum perfection and fulfilling of the divine Law but all the bonds of Christian Charity and therein all the sacred duties we owe both to God and man Quam verò dilectionem custodit cogitat qui discordiaefarore â—r sanus eccl siam semdit pacem â—urbat chaâ—itatem dissipat Cyp. de unit eccl are infringed and transgrest by contention strife and Schismatical rending and tearing the Church of Christ into factions and parties and what ever piety such persons may outwardly make shew of yet can they not have any true charity saith Cyprian or love either to God in the first place or to their neighbours in the next who endevour not to keep the unity of the Spirit in the bend of peace Ephes 4.3 without which no man shall ever see the Lord Heb. 12.14 And this will yet further appear if we consider 6 That Schism alone without any heretical opinions though these two can hardly be parted cuts a man off from the unity of the Church for 't is an insurrection a being in armes against the Church Arma contra ecclesiam poâ—tat Cyp. de unit eccl saith Cyprian And he that is separated from the Church the spouse of Christ is joyned to an adulteress saith the same Father and euts himself off from all the promises made unto the Church and people of God nor must he think to own God for his Father who acknowledgeth not the Church for his Mother Cyp ib. d. For as the body is one and hath many members and all the members of that one body being many are one body so also is Christ 1 Cor. 12.12 And for this cause faith S. Aug. No man can be righteous whilest he stands separated from the unity of Christs body Aug de corree Domst c. 25. but as any part or member of mans natural body being câ—t off the body is thereby devoid of the spirit of liâ—e so the man that is cut off from the body of Jesus Christ the righteous is thereby devoid of the spiritual life of righteousness though he do retain the shape form and likeness of a true living member and the ancient Father Irenaeus gives the reason further out of 1 Cor. 12.28 In the Church God hath set Apostles Prophets teachers universam operationem Spiritus reliquam all the gifts and graces of Gods holy Spirit are therein dispensed Irenae advers Haerd 3. c. 40. Cujus non sunt participes c. whereof they are not partakers who come not unto the Church to be joyned thereunto but defraud themselves of life by evil opinions and worse actions Vbi enim ecclesia ibi spiritus for where the Church is there is the Spirit of life and sanctification 7. Heretiques Extra ecclesiam consistenâ— contra pacem dilectionem Christi sacions inter adversarios computetur Cyp. ep 76. and Schismaticks have been ever accounted the great adversaries of Christs Church and people whose intestine broyles and homebred divisions have done more mischief to the truth and doctrine of Christ then all the external persecutions of bloudy tyrants and Heathens hence the sharp command of the Apostle against such Tit. 3.10 11. A man that is an heretique after the first or second admonition reject knowing that he that is such subverteth and sinneth because condemn'd of himself such a one is self-condemned having 1. passed sentence upon himself by professing against the doctrine and dividing from the communion of the Church And 2. he hath done execution upon himself also for he hath excommunicated himself in going out from the Church Quomodo te à tot gregibus scidisti Firmil ad Cyp. Ep. 75. exscidisti teipsum He that is such a one reject have no company with him 2 Thess 3.14 S. John going to wash himself in a Bath and there espying Cerinthus an Heretique leapt hastily out of the Bath again saying that he
conform to his example He had his feigned Visions Paulus Odor bornius in vita qâ—at l. 2. and Revelations also and yet a greater Tyrant and a more bloudy villain Christendome hath not seen The Scribes and Pharisees of the Jewish Church and the Novatians and Donatists of the Christian were far greater pretenders to piety and strictness of life then the truly orthodox of either Church and yet very great and notorious Schismatiques Not to be cousened therefore with fair and goodly pretences of any party or sect of men how seemingly holy and zealous soever and pretending that they have Christ that they have the Spirit that they only are in the right when they are deeply involv'd in an abysse of errors our Lord hath fore-arm'd us with sound and saving counsell Mat. 24.23 c. Then if any shall say unto you Lo here is Christ or lo there believe it not for there shall arise false Christs and false Prophets Wherefore if they shall say Behold he is in the desert goe not forth behold he is in the secret chambers believe it not for as the lightning cometh out of the East and shineth unto the West so shall the comming of the Son of man be Two rules for the avoiding infection by false Prophets under specious pretences are hence observable Habet unaquaecunque Haeresis vel certas mundi partes unde dâ— ecce hic ecce illâ—c 1. Every Heresie saith the Glosse is limited to some particular parts of the world and the infection is not universally diffused therefore 't is said Lo here or lo there If any man then shall limit Christ to his particular Church much lesse to his particular sect or fraternity believe it not for such are false Christs and false Prophets For the Truth displaid from Christ the Sun of righteousnesse Ne crâ—datur schismaticis nomine autem oâ—ientis occidentis totum orhem designat Gloss ordin like the light of the heaven is diffused from East to West or spread over the face of the whole earth which renders the Church i. e. all sound and sincere professors of the Truth as well Catholique as Holy Vel in occultis aut obscuris conventiculis curiositatem hominum decipit haeresiâ— Id. 2. Heresie and Schism seek out obscure and retired places and begin in conventicles and private meetings therefore 't is said Behold he is in the deserâ— behold he is in the secret chambers So the Apostle of deceivers also they creep into houses and lead captive silly women c. 2 Tim. 3.6 But Veritas non quaerit angulos Truth seeketh no lurking holes is not ashamed to appear in publique being like the light that shineth from East to West open free and manifest to all except forc't to retirement by persecution and violence 9. For the avoiding of errors 't will be necessary to observe further that a Truth is not to be disbelieved or rejected because 't is profest by lewd and licentious persons or maintained by a Church and people that are in other respects erroneous and misguided For Truth is Truth by what mouth soever it bee spoken and 't is the more confirmed to be Truth because 't is even by the enemies of Truth attested to be so The unwary neglect of this rule hath not been the least in let to manifold errors for 't is too usual with many to object both against orthodox truths and ecclesiastical orders on the one hand that this or that the Papists hold and against a strict careful conscientious life on the other that thus and thus the Puritans profess Hence many truths have been rejected for errors and many decent useful orders customes ceremonies and necessary acts of discipline have been cryed down as superstitious idolatrous and antichristian and the sacred body of religion it self is almost wholly turned out of the Church under the style of Popery Nor hath that piety and integrity of life which is required of particular persons escap'd better but under the notion of Puritanism hath been too much banisht from the lives and manners of men for fear of being branded with the guilt of Schism faction and separation 10 He that will not unawares headlong himself into the gulph of error must not presume upon any extraordinary infusion of Gifts and Graces from above but in all humility wait upon God in the use of means and the careful improvement of what gifts and graces he hath already received It is the manner of Heretiques and Hypocrites saith a learned man ever to pretend to high lights of the Spirit and to finde new Joh. Cast and unheard of waies of walking with God slighting all that is common though never so commendable and catching at all that is curious though never so dangerous and thus they lose themselves in their chymerical conceptions and pretending to refine ancient piety and truth are puft up with secret pride and presumption and grasp nothing but froth and vanity That there are such things as Extasies and more then ordinary ravishments of spirit and infusions of divine gifts and qualifications is not doubted but such supereminences only superexcellent souls are capable of neither yet are they afforded to all pious devout and heavenly minded persons that so none may presume to depend upon them but that every man should keep his station and walk humbly with his God not relying upon extraordinary inspirations in the neglect of ordinary means which is in many respects destructive and dangerous as in the former Treatise And although it be most true that the conversion of every man to the truth being a work of the Spirit is therefore sudden and at one instant or moment of time begotten and wrought in the soul yet notwithstanding our progress towards perfection and bliss in the waies of Truth and Holiness goes on step by step leisurely and by degrees The pathes of the just are as the shining light which shineth more and more to the perfect day Prov. 4.18 Both the knowledge of the Truth and the practise of holiness begins with dawnings like the light of the day all darkness of ignorance and sin being not presently and in the same instant dispel'd and scattered but by little and little the light of Grace and Truth increaseth and still more and more clearly shineth towards perfection and we ascend from gift to gift and from grace to grace as the Sun mounts up by degrees to the vertical point not unlike the motions of the Angels upon Jacobs ladder Gen. 18.12 who although they had wings did not suddenly fly up and down but ascended and descended step by step so saith the Apostle Adde to your faith vertue to vertue knowledge and to knowledge temperance c. 2 Pet. 1.5 There be many now adaies wherein dissimulation and presumption so generally reigns who like to those heretical Messalians of old pretend to that perfection as to be above ordinances and means And although it be true that some few