euill it maketh the work also euill 79 NW But yet neuerthelesse it cannot bee that any Worke being euill in it owne nature may by our conscience bee made good For whatsoeuer conscience thou hast yet when thou doest forsweare thy selfe or when thou committest adulterie thou doest grieuously sinne Wherefore the force of conscience hath power onely in Things indifferent and also in those actions which of their owne nature are good 80 Some thing may seeme to be against the Conscience two waies And amongst these things somewhat may seeme to be against a mans conscience or vnlawfull two waies First Vncertainly and doubtfully without full assent perswasion or resolution namely when a man doubteth or is vncertaine whether some thing bee lawfull or not Secondly Determinately and absolutely with a resolued perswasion to wit when a man is certainly perswaded that some thing is simply lawfull albeit by error of conscience or vpon false and erroneous grounds 81 If any thing appeares to bee vnlawfull vnto a man Vncertainely and doubtfully he is to abstaine from doing of it of himselfe so long as hee is at his owne free choice and libertie till his doubts be remoued 82 But if a certaine commandement of a lawfull Magistrate comes and commands it then the Subiect is bound to obey for his doubting vpon vncertaintie ought not to withhold his due obedience according to that Heb. 13.17 Obey and submit your selues obey with perswasion and yeeld though you be not perswaded 83 Euery commandement of the Magistrate NW either it is certaine that it is Iust and good and then the Subiect ought to obey Or it is certaine that it is Vntust and euill and then the Subiect ought not to obey A Rule in case of doubt Or peraduenture it is Doubtfull and in case of doubt this Rule is to be followed Tene certum relinque incertum Keepe that which is certaine leaue that which is vncertain Now it is CERTAINE that we must obey the Superiour Power if it doth not command those things which are manifestly vniust And verily the Subiects are worthily to be excused when in a doubtfull case they obey their Prince How a man may be perplexed in conscience and how he may be rid from such perplexitie 84 If any mans conscience albeit erroneous being lead by false and supposed grounds doth dictate vnto him Determinately and absolutely that some thing is vnlawfull that man should sinne if he should doe any thing against such a conscience Because it is a common axiome Conscientia errans obligat An erroneous conscience bindeth a man though not to doe according vnto the same yet not to doe any thing against it for he that doth any thing against his conscience is conuinced to haue a will to sinne 85 If any mans Conscience doth absolutely command him necessarily to doe that which of it selfe is euill and forbidden by the law of God or if it forbiddeth him to doe that which of it owne nature is good and necessarie and which God or the Magistrate doth command him It is a Sinne both to doe what his Conscience commandeth him and also not to do it For the Conscience hath a man so tied and bound that he can decline into neither part without sinne except he depose the error of his Conscience 86 NW For it is a Rule confirmed by the consent of all Diuines that The dictate of an erroneous Conscience in a vicious matter determined by precept or prohibition doth so binde a man that his conscience standing so he cannot doe any thing neither according to his conscience nor against it 87 Yet is he not in such a case to suspend his consent no not for neuer so little time but is presently bound to depose his erroneous conscience and to know that such a thing is not prohibited but commanded THE CONCLVSION VNTO THE BELOVED BRETHREN in Christ the Ministers who conforme not themselues vnto the Discipline and Ceremonies of the Church of England HItherto beloued Brethren haue we handled those things which seemed to appertaine vnto the true and lawfull vse of Things indifferent that so we might more throughly vnderstand the Nature thereof Wherein I presume I haue fully satisfied ALL SVCH as are Christianly affected who truly walke according vnto the Spirit and yeeld vnto the Truth embracing the same simplie sincerely and constantly In so much that in this Controuersie I dare vndergoe the censure and iudgement of all the Learned and good men throughout the whole world who I hope will allow of this my counsell and easilie perceiue that I haue not disputed concerning these so important matters with other mens affections nor with any desire of attaining the fauour of any man nor with the endeuor of dissenting from others nor for the loue of Noueltie nor of pertinacious obstinacie nor yet of any other euill and inordinate affection or desire but that I haue to my poore abilitie serued the necessitie of the Church For when I had vnderstood that in the first Visitation of the Right reuerend father in God the L. BISHOP OF LONDON there were many dissonant clamours of vnlearned men contending about many things specially about Ecclesiasticall Rites and Ceremonies I haue gathered the Summe of the Doctrine concerning THINGS INDIFFERENT deliuered by Caluin Melancthon Bucer Zanchius Vrsinus Beza and other learned and approued Diuines in their seuerall Volumes of Comentaries Sermons and other Tractats as it were into one Body whereby any man might plainly see at the first blush as in a Table what is to be held and what to be auoyded in this whole busines And I will that Writing to be vnderstood rightly and ingenuously without cauilling without calumniations It is certaine that in this so great infirmitie of men The Militant Church neuer perfect the Church can neuer be so pure but that there will bee some abuses therein And it is certaine also that wee must dissemble and beare with some abuses for maintaining of publique peace and concord NW Which must bee vnderstood of those abuses which by reason of infirmitie arise among vs the Doctrine of truth being safely preserued and not of such as ouerthrow the necessarie Articles of faith or are Idolatrous or compell men to manifest sinnes and impietie Hereupon some men most grieuously sinne both against themselues and against the rest of their Brethren who are contentious and turbulent for euery little moale or blemish so trouble both their owne and other mens consciences as if all Christianitie were in danger to be lost and wholly ouerthrowne Neither doe I speake this as if I thought that any corruption ought to be winkt at and tolerated Nay rather let the Earth swallow me vp or the Sea stop my breath before that I defend any corruption of the celestiall Doctrine or contend with the Church of God wherein I desire as in an eternall Schoole after this life to see and behold the Sonne of God the Patriarkes Prophets
diuine Maiestie The Generall kind of Things indifferent is Morall 19 The Generall kind of these is morall seeing they are determinations of circumstances necessarie or profitable for the obseruation of the morall precepts of the first Table that is to preserue order and decencie in the assemblie and meetings of the Church and in the vse of the Ecclesiasticall Ministrie or for publike or priuate exercises of pietie or to shun and auoid the scandall of the weake and to bring them to the Church and the acknowledgement of the truth 20 Hence it is Note well that they are and may be called Worship of GOD namely in their General not in their Special kind I will speake more plainly 21 Things indifferent Traditions or Ecclesiastical precepts of men are the WORSHIP of GOD as they be Morall but not as they be Ceremoniall 22 For examples sake The assemblie or meeting together of the Church to exercise the duties and offices of pietie is the Worship of God Publique and priuate Prayers Diuine Sermons c. are the worship of God but to meete to gether this or that day or houre to conceiue or recite our prayers to sing Psalmes or other holy hymnes in this or that forme of words or pronunciation either standing or sitting or kneeling is not the Worship of God It is a Worshiop of God not to scandalize our neighbour but to eate or not to eate flesh is not a Worship of God Hitherto haue we declared the Definition and Nature of Things indifferent It followeth that we speake of the Causes thereof CHAP. II. Of the CAVSES of Things Indifferent And first of the EFFICIENT Cause THe EFFICIENT Cause of Things Indifferent The Efficient Cause of Things indifferent 1. Principall is two-fold Principall or Adiuuant 2 The Principall Efficient Cause is GOD by whom Things Indifferent are GENERALLY instituted and commanded who in his Word declareth vnto the Bishops and Gouernours of the Church the fountaine from whence they ought to be deduced and drawne gouerning also their wittes and directing their tongues in that busines For GOD will haue all things to be done in good order so as they may serue both for the setting forth of his owne glory and also for the edification of the Church 1. Cor. 14.40 seeing he is the GOD of order and not of confusion 2. Adiuuant and this is either 3 The Adiuuant Cause is either the Whole Church together or Certaine wise and intelligent Men to whom the Church hath committed the institution of Things indifferent 4 The whole Church The Whole Church because she hath power to appoint and prescribe rites and ceremonies in particular for all things are the Churches 1. Cor. 3.22 which performeth this her Office with a Free and Godly will Free being no manner of way compelled Godly that is fitted and accommodated to the will of God which may only regard the glorie of God and the edification of good and godly men and no way seeke after humane or worldly commodities by the institution or vse of any Indifferent things 5 Now the institution and ordering of these rites and ceremonies Or Certaine Men. the Church ought to commit to the care of certaine godly wise and circumspect Men whom she perceiueth to be endued with diuine gifts and well able to iudge of such matters So the Apostles command the Church to chuse and ordaine such Deacons Act. 6.3 And that chosen vessell of God writeth vnto the Church of Corinth that she ought to ordaine Iudges who might vnderstand and decide the controuersies and causes of the Christians 1. Cor. 6.7 6 Concerning which Ceremonies notwithstanding the iudgement and censure thereof is to be permitted vnto the Church as also of the whole Doctrine taught by the Ministers and Pastors according vnto that which the Apostle saith Let two or three Prophets speake and let the other iudge And if any thing be reuealed to another that sitteth by let the first hold his peace The Spirit of the Prophets is subiect to the Prophets 1. Cor. 14.29.30.32 And the Doctors and Teachers of the Church are not LORDS ouer the same but Ministers and Seruants vnto it 7 Out of these things which haue been spoken of the Efficient Cause it is plainly gathered Ecclesiasticall Traditions are not meerly Humane but also Diuine that such Indifferent things as by the Church haue been lawfully and orderly instituted and approoued are so farre Humane as that they are also Diuine and therefore haue more than Humane authoritie yea plainly DIVINE 8 The reason hereof is Because the Church is directed and gouerned by the Spirit of Christ who is Truth therefore the Precepts of the Church in THINGS INDIFFERENT are both true and holy 9 Moreouer sithence the Church of Christ doth alwaies depend on the Word of God insomuch that if it should erre which notwithstanding is impossible and fall from the same it should not bee the Church of Christ Therefore the Traditions and Constitutions which are ordained by the Church following the Word of God are grounded vpon the authoritie of GOD himselfe and drawne out of the holy Scriptures and therefore consequently DIVINE 10 An example hereof we haue in the Surplice which Ministers vse to put on Question in the solemnizing of Diuine Seruice or the administration of the Sacraments It is demanded Answere Whether this be an HVMANE Tradition or not I answere It is so an HVMANE Tradition as that it is also DIVINE It is DIVINE so farre foorth as it is a part of that Decencie the care and obseruation whereof is commended vnto vs by the Apostle 1. Cor. 14.37.40 But it is HVMANE as it doth particularly designe what hath been generally pointed at rather than plainly declared Note For it si our part to determine in particular and precise forme and manner that Decencie and Order which in generall termes is deliuered in the holie Scriptures By this one example may appeare what we are to thinke and iudge of all other of this kinde 11 These things repugne and are contrarie to the Efficient Cause What things are contrarie vnto the Efficient Cause namely I. To institute and ordaine such rites and ceremonies as are contrarie vnto the will and Word of GOD. 12 Of which sort are in the Church of Antichrist the Popes Supremacie the Sacraments of Penance Confirmation Order Matrimonie Extreame Vnction the oblation of the sacrifice of the Masse the Communion vnder one kind Crucifixes Inuocation of Saints Prayers for the dead Purgatorie Indulgences Single life of Priests Auricular confession Papisticall satisfactions c. 13 II. To peruert contrarie vnto the Word of GOD such Ceremonies as are lawfully and aduisedly instituted by the Church 14 III. To appoint and ordaine indifferent Ceremonies and rites to be obserued without the consent and approbation of the Church 15 IV. Wilfully or carelesly to neglect and omit those indifferent ceremonies which the Church hath lawfully commanded and
idolatrous Recusant may it please your Wisedomes to consider that the benefit thereof through the blessing of God must needes be inestimable both to the present state of the Church in composing our home-Controuersies and recouering those our poore Brethren who now alas are enstranged and alienated from vs that there may bee but one flocke and one folde as there is but one Shepheard Christ IESVS and also to all posteritie who hauing the holy Doctrine and Sacraments of Christ vniformely taught and deliuered according to the truth of the Gospell as an inestimable treasure left and committed vnto their trust to be deliuered ouer from age to age to the end of the world should haue infinite cause to glorifie and praise God for so vnspeakeable a benefit and reuerently to keepe with all honour the famous names of their so Christian and noble progenitors and predecessors in euerlasting memorie Which so honourable an ACT for the seruice of GOD and infinite commoditie of the Church though I bee not worthie vpon my knees to make any such motion vnto your Wisedomes yet apprehending the benefit thereof to be such as I haue declared with your gracious fauours as kneeling before the barre of your most noble Court in all humilitie and reuerence I most humbly beseech your Honours for the zeale you beare to God and to his onely Sonne Christ Iesus for the loue you haue to the faith and doctrine of the Gospell for the pitie you must needs haue to behold the contentions and ruptures of our Church and finally for the happie example and direction not only of your own noble children and childrens children but of all the posteritie of Christendome to whom the knowledge hereof may happely come that it would please your Wisedomes to be the Honourable meanes vnder his excellent Maiestie who I know cannot but Royally assent to what you shall decree herein to vndertake so Christian and famous an enterprise and to see so worthy an ACT performed to the great Glorie of almightie GOD and the perpetuall settlement and quietnes of our most flourishing Church and kingdome Which worke of immortall fame to all posteritie if your Honours shall effect the Church of God shall pray for you and blesse you and the Lord IESVS shall abundantly reward you for it Thus leauing this most humble Suite not of one though offered by my vnworthie hand nor of a few but of the whole CHVRCH of Christ vnto your Honors godly Wisedomes and the same vnto the happie direction of Gods holy Spirit I come now to ioyne with my Antagonist A REIOYNDER VNTO THE MILD DEFENCE Justifying the Consideration of the silenced Ministers Suplication to the Parliament THe maine Proposition of this Defence The Defenders Proposition tendeth to the vindicating and clearing of the Arguments of the silenced Ministers in their Supplication vnto the high Court of Parliament against the iust exceptions taken against them in the Consideration thereof But how wel the Defender quitteth himself and iustifieth his Cause against all exceptions shall God willing be manifest in the sequele The Title of the Supplication Certaine Arguments to prouoke the present high Court of Parliament to zeale for the Ministers now silenced Supplication ANSVVERE The exception here generally taken in the Cōsideration was that all these XIIX Reasons vrged by the Suppliants were Common Arguments excepting one or two Answere and might be vrged for Poperie That the Suppliants Arguments are Common Arguments or for any other Heresie whatsoeuer which the learned know to be an intolerable fault in a Scholler and were a sufficient answere vnto them all c. The Defender replieth that they are not Common Arguments Replie Are Popish or other hereticall Priests saith he Ministers of Christ in grace and fauour with him Do the Angels so long after and reioyce in their Ministerie as in ours Do they as truly interprete the mysteries of God to eternall life as Ioseph interpreted dreames for this life The like may be said of the other Arguments But the question is not Reioynder what either these or they of the Defenders faction are indeed but what euery one of them esteemeth and taketh himselfe to be There is not one of these named by the Defender but will affirme that he is the Minister of Christ in grace and fauour with him that the Angels long after and reioyce in their Ministerie that they truly interprete the mysteries of God to eternall life and so of the rest as bodlly and as confidently as any of the Refractarie Ministers will Wherefore if all these will infill in and produce the very same Arguments for confirmation of their heresie and to procure grace and fauor vnto their partie as well as the Suppliants do how is it that they may not be termed Common Arguments The Defenders fallacie in his impertinent instances is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 for he changeth the state of the Question Wherefore the Defenders Epiphoneme which heere he hath vauntingly and triumphantly inserted may be returned into his owne bosome This beginning sheweth what we are to looke for in the rest of the Defence I. ARGVMENT The Ministers supplicated for Supplicat are the Ministers of Christ sent by God and in grace and fauour with God Not to speake for them is to spare speech for God himselfe for Christ Iesus and for the euerlasting saluation of many thousand Soules Ergo The honorable and high Court of Parliament ought to intercede with his Maiestie for them ANSVVERE I. To the Antecedent I WE willingly grant that the Refractary Ministers are indeed the Ministers of Christ in the ministration of his Gospell Answere that they are brought in question and we hope also that they are sent by GOD and in grace and fauour with GOD. Yet must they remember that their Sanctification being in part they haue but their measure of gifts and graces for our knowledge is but in part as the Apostle testifieth and therefore that they may be ignorant and ouerseene in some things wherein they ought not to flatter themselues but by all meanes labour to come to vnderstanding that they may attaine vnto the knowledge of the truth The Defender replieth Heere is a mnaifest contrarietie Replie He that is refractarie cannot be such a Minister of Christ. He that is in grace and fauour with God Reioynder In what sense the refractarie Ministers may be good Men. ought not to be disgraced and molested by men But I wonder the Defender is so Eagle-sighted that he can spie a contrarietie where there is none at all He that is Refractarie cannot be such a Minister of Christ. Well Neither do I say that he is such as he is Refractarie but in the ministration of the Gospell which words the Defender hath purposely if not maliciously omitted in my answere lest his cunning might haue bin espied at the first blush Aaron was the Priest of almighty God in grace and fauour with him
this day we see whole families and assemblies compelled to flie out of their owne countrie and to liue in exile for Religion sake II. When the sinceritie of faith is so corrupt that holesome doctrine as the Apostle speaketh can bee neither taught nor learned the godly may depart For agreement and vnitie is commendable onely in the truth if truth be away wee ought to make no question of agreement and vnitie III. When the Sacraments are so corruptly administred that there is not scarse any step to be seene of Christs institution There is no doubt but a man may lawfully separate himselfe from that societie which retaineth not true Doctrine and the lawfull vse of the Sacraments But here both the Separatists and the Refractaries step in Obiections of the Brownists and Refractaries and labour to defend their Schisme alleaging 1. That we liue not according to our dostrine neither Ministers nor people 2. That whereas we abound with wickednesse yet we admit euery one promiscuously vnto the Lords Supper without further censure or discipline 3. That we vse Popish ceremonies in the worship of God I answere Answ generally These are no iust and sufficient causes to make a Schisme as appeareth in that the truth of doctrine and puritie of faith consist not in these things which whilest they grant vnto vs they condemne themselues in that they haue inconsideratly made a schisme from vs without iust cause Neither is it any hard matter to answere all their arguments in particular excepting the first Touching the Munisters therefore It is most certaine Of Scandalous Ministers that a faithfull Minitier of Christ ought not onely to know the will of God but also to do thereafter What Paul spake of the Law that not the hearers but the doers thereof should be iustified Rom. 2.13 that Christ speaketh of his Disciples Ioh. 13.17 If you know these things happie are you if you doe them But it cannot bee denied but that some Ministers offend this way which how they will answere before God let themselues looke vnto For my owne part I can say no more of such Ministers than what Christ saith of the Scribes and Pharisies Mat. 23.2.3 They sit in Moses chaire All therefore whatsoeuer they bid you obserue that obserue and doe but after their works do not for they say and do not It ought to content vs that they teach true doctrine and that they liue not thereafter it hurteth not me for they shall carrie their owne burdens The doctrine is ours the life is theirs let vs take the doctrine and leaue the manners I had rather haue a sincere Preacher of Gods Word that will declare Christ vnto me purely rebuke my sinful liuing comfort me with the sweete promises of the Gospell shew me how I ought to frame my life according to the will of God c. albeit his manners be somewhat corrupt and dissent from his preaching then to haue a wicked Heretique a pestilent Pharisie or a superstitious Hypocrite who outwardly shall pretend a certaine grauitie and a pure manner of liuing and yet corrupt the holy Scriptures leade the people into superstitious errors slatter the hearers preach for lucre mangle the doctrine of Christ and obscure the way of truth Of such Christ warneth vs to take heed saying Matth. 7.15 Beware of false Prophets which come to you in sheepes cloathing but inwardly are rauening wolues These things our Schismatiques know very well but not contented herewith they vrge Such a man was vnworthie to be admitted and now being in the Ministerie be ought to be put out which I leaue to the Magistrates and such as be in auctoritie to consider of As for the People Of Scandalous People the Separatists and Refractaries do limite and hedge in the Church too narrowly and straightly It is very lamentable indeed that the doctrine of truth is not heard with more fruit yet do they offend who looke for pure assemblies in earth without spot or blemish Christ compareth the Gospell vnto a net that containeth fish and filth and the Lords field hath in it both good corne and tares which yet must not be weeded out vntill haruest be come Vainely therefore doe they labour to seeke pure assemblies albeit if they would looke into their owne societies it may be they might finde therein as many Sinners as are in ours But these men ought to content themselues as the godly haue euer done that the wicked being knowne cannot hurt the saithfull who either haue no auctoritie to curbe them or cannot otherwise prouide for publique peace then by tolerating such And yet there want not in the meane time publique Lawes and penalties to restraine and bridle such as be notorious offenders That which they speake concerning the Communion Of promiscuous admission to the Communion is very inconsiderate also and foolish seeing neither Christ nor the Apostle Paul did euer speake any thing at all concerning the censuring and examining of others But command only that euery man should examine himselfe Christ celebrated his Supper with his weake Disciples and admitted Iudas to be partaker thereof as many excellent Diuines do hold Paul expressely commandeth that euery man examine himselfe It is my dutie to looke vnto my selfe and thine vnto thy selfe of euery other vnto himselfe So that a faithfull Minister seemeth to haue sufficiently discharged his dutie if he shall diligently admonish the Communicants hereof and not curiously prie into the secrets of other men Concerning manifest crimes the Church hath prescribed Lawes of admonition of Counsell c. If any list to communicate contemning these I see not how any man may exclued those from the Communion whom God the Father and Christ Iesus admit their ghuests neither doest thou know what God may worke in a Sinner euen in that very houre It is not a signe of an ingenuous and charitable mind to depart because of Sinners whom Christ inuiteth to come vnto him The Apostle saith 2. Tim. 2.20 In a great house there are not only vessels of gold and siluer but also of wood and of earth c. we must endeuour that we may be vessels of gold and siluer God only is to breake the vessels of earth in pieces As touching that we vse Popish Ceremonies in the Worship of GOD that appeares otherwise in my booke De Adiaphoris whereunto I referre the Reader Many men moue this Question Whether Schismatiques may be compelled Whether Schismatiques ought to be compelled to vnitie I answere Compulsion seemeth to be hard specially in such things as ought to be voluntarie Augustine confesseth that he was once of mind that neither Schismatiques nor Heretiques ought to bee compelled Lib. Retract cap. 5. But afterwards hauing by vse and experience learned what good a little discipline would effect he altreth his opinion and plainly defendeth that Schismatiques ought by all meanes to be compelled to concord and vnitie Yet herein great moderationought to be vsed we must
that therefore I censure the Parliament house c. or charge them with rashnes and foole-hardines For the Parliament house is not of their faction and straine as wee haue noted before What they deserue for this their continuall insolencie and malepertnes in slandring the high Court of Parliament I referre vnto the religious censure of that noble and wise Assemblie II. To the Consequence I Answere This Consequence hath no coherence with the Antecedent For there are great ods betweene these examples proposed and the refractarie Ministers case The Defender replieth Reply There should be such ods For the Auctor reasoneth not à similibus or paribus from likes or equals but from the lesse to the greater But the oddes are such Reioynder that they make the Argument to be plainly inconsequent for the Auctor of the Supplication makes that lesse which is euery way greater as shall appeare in examining the particulars II. In the time of Nehemiah Answere the Church of the lewes hauing been long captiuated was in great affliction and reproach and the walles of Hierusalem were broken downe Nehem. 1.3 which was not so in the daies of their Fathers But our Church hauing by the mercies of God now long continued in prosperous and flourishing estate is God be thanked glorious still yea more now then euer it was in the daies of our Fathers Furthermore Nehemiah after he had wept mourned fasted and prayed Nehem. 1.4 spake vnto King Artashaste an Heathen and prophane man and finding grace in his eyes obtained leaue to build vp Hierusalem Nehem. 2.6 But Sanballat Tobiah Geshem and others deriding and despising the Iewes laboured to hinder the worke but preuailed not Nehem. 2.19 and 4.7.15 Then Nehemiah prayed My God remember thou Tobiah and Sanballat according vnto these their workes Nehem. 6.14 So euen in the very beginning of our religious Soueraignes raigne many worthy Nehemiahs finding grace in his eyes haue moued his Maiestie for the continuance of the prosperous estate of our Church as it was in the daies of our late blessed Queene albeit his Highnesse was more readie to graunt their request then they to aske it And now so many Sanballats Tobiahs and Geshems as there be refractarie Ministers and Papists deriding and despising vs labour to hinder our Ministerie blaspheming the same either to be none at all or adulterate and very corrupt but God willing shall not preuaile And we still thinking that most of them do sinne of ignorance cease not to pray vnto God O Lord open the eyes of these men and lay not this sinne to their charge The Defender replies Reply All things being granted that you say concerning the glorie of our Church doth not hinder but further the cause The more the Church flourisheth the more easie it is to grant that which the Arguments pleade for Ministers also of the Word are as necessarie for preseruing and increasing of the glorie of Churches as for the procuring thereof at the first Not hinder Reioynder If our Church be glorious and flourishing both in the entire and sound profession and practise of Gods truth in the exercises meanes and signes of faith which is the true and principall glorie of the Church and also in the outward state Discipline and Gouernment thereof which Glorie is secondarie and depending of the former how can it bee but that giddie innouation the vtter ouerthrow of Ecclesiasticall policie and the bringing in of the Presbyterian prelacie euen almost equalizing Papall tyrannie should be a maine blemish and vncurable maime vnto the GLORIE of our Church It is true indeed that the Ministers of the Word are necessarie for preseruing and encreasing of the glorie of Churches but are there no Ministers but such as be refractarie Haue we not store God be praysed of sufficient religious Ministers alreadie And are not the Vniuersities able continually to afford farther supplie But alas Reply saith the Defender I would God our Church did so flourish as you pretend Indeed it hath many rich mercies God be blessed for them but he that seeth not what the Church wanteth doth not rightly acknowledge that which it hath We want some of those Officers that Christ hath commended by his Apostles to the Church What Christian heart is so stonie that it doth not mourne what eye so blind that it doth not gush out with teares to consider and behold the miserie of our supposed glorious Church by the spirituall nakednes blindnes and pouertie thereof I meane the great ignorance the super ficiall worship of God the fearefull blasphemies and swearings in houses and streetes the direfull cursings the open contempt of the Word and Sacraments the wicked prophanations of the Lords dates the dishonor of superiours the pride the crueltie the fornications adulteries and other vncleannesses the drunkenes the couetousnes the vsuries and other the like abominations almost as grieuous as either heretofore in the time or now in the places of Poperie when and where there was no preaching at all of the Gospell O behold and pittie the woefull and lamentable state of our Church in these things What maruell is it Reioynder that the Owle cannot SEE in a cleare Sun-shining day whose only delite is to flutter and to roue about in the profound darkenesse of the night And can any man thinke it strange that the Defenders eyes dazle at the Glorie and goodly order of our Church when nothing pleaseth him but the Aërian or Presbyterian confusion Oh but there want some Officers in our Church which Christ commended vnto vs by his Apostles What Officers be those ô they are the Lay Presbyterian Aldermen Hinc illae lachrimae heere lyeth the soare a bleeding We want the supposed Apostolicall Senate of Aldermen and for this cause we are spiritually naked and blind and poore and miserable and what not But when wil the Defender proue that either Christ or his Apostles commended any such Aldermen vnto vs Shall we beleeue him on his bare word What other proofe brings he or any other of the faction And yet vpon this most beggerly Supposition neuer granted by vs because neuer proued nor able to be proued by them he openeth his foule mouth The Defenders slanders against the Church most wickedly traducing and slandering the Church of GOD as guiltie of great ignorance of superficiall worship of GOD of blasphemies swearings direfull cursings and many other horrible and monstrous enormities which my pen doth euen blush to relate after him We reade 1. King 22.21.22 of a wicked Spirit that liberally promised his seruice in seducing King Ahab by being a lying Spirit in the mouth of all his Prophets Except this foule fiend hath entred into the Defender and wholly possessed him I cannot possibly imagine how his pen could so leasingly raue against our whole Church I beseech the Lord that hee would vouchsafe to rebuke the euill Spirit and to giue the Defender grace to repent him in time
is not of faith is sinne Rom. 14. vlt. that is it is polluted and accursed before God 27 Now then it remaineth that we expresse a certaine Canon or RVLE whereby we may assuredly know what Things are INDIFFERENT vnto vs and what are not and the RVLE is this 28 If these Traditions on the one side A Certaine RVLE to know what Things are Indifferent be grounded vpon the Written Word of GOD or at the least be not repugnant vnto it and on the other side tend to the aduauncement of godlines and pietie that is if they be profitable as well for the exciting conseruing promouing of the Inward Worship which consisteth in faith hope charitie and a good conscience as also for the more reuerent exercising of the Outward Worship which consisteth in the hearing of the Word receiuing of the Sacraments publike Prayers and such like then we constantly affirme that such Traditions and Ceremonies are profitable Indifferent things and therefore being commanded by the Church they are necessarily to be obserued and entertained as godly and wholesome 29 The Reason of this Rule or Canon is because all the Traditions of the Apostles had these two things First They had Grounds from the Scriptures Secondly Profit to the furtherance and helpe of publique piety and edification 30 And this is manifested by two arguments First out of the general Rule which the Apostle prescribeth for these matters 1. Cor. 14. Let all thingi be done to edification and againe Let all things be done decently and in good order Secondly by a particular Induction of those places wherein we reade the Constitutions of the Apostles whereof I haue thought good to expresse some Examples 31 1. Cor. 11. The Apostle ordaineth that Women should pray in the Church couered and Men bare-headed First of all this is not repugnant to holy Scriptures Secondly the end of this Constitution is honestie the preseruation of Decency and the edification of the Church that is to say that the outward Worship may be performed with greater honesty and comlinesse Againe Another End of that Ceremonie is that thereby euery one might be admonished and put in mind of his owne place and dutie namely that the Man is the head of the Woman and the Woman was put in mind of her subiection to the Man which things are profitable to the Internall Worship 32 In the same place the Apostle setteth downe an order for the due celebration of the Lords Supper that all of them should meete and assemble together and tarry one for another First he sheweth that this ought to be done out of the Word of God that is out of the Institution of Christ himselfe Secondly The End hereof is their Saluation least they should be guiltie of the body and blood of Christ Thirdly that the same holy Supper might be celebrated with greater reuerence Lastly that this outward Ceremony of meeting and assembling together might serue to the inward Worship namely to faith charity and the spirituall vnion of the minds or soules 33 1. Cor. 14. He ordaineth how Tongues may be vsed in the Church to wit that no man speake in a strange language without interpretation and explication First How many reasons doth the Apostle vse drawen out of the holy Scriptures to proue this ordinance to be according vnto will of God to be good and honest After many Reasons vsed to that purpose at last he bringeth the authoritie of sacred Writ saying It is written in the Law I will speake vnto this vnbeleeuing people in diuers tongues and with strange lippes that so they may not heare me as if the Apostle had said in other words Suffer not these men to speake straunge tongues in your congregation without explication for this were a signe that God loueth you not for he is wont to send such Prophets to the vnbeleeuing Nations whom he would not haue to know his will or to attaine to the knowledge of the truth Secondly he plainly affirmeth that the End of this constitution is the edification of the Church that they might haue consolation exhortation instruction c. that is that it might serue the inward Worship faith loue and consolation of Spirit 34 The selfe same thing may be said of all other Canons Constitutions and Ordinances of the Apostles all which it were very tedious to repeate in this place First They haue their foundation in the Word of God or else they doe not repugne the same Secondly They serue to aduance pietie to stirre vp repentance and faith and finally they serue to the end that the godly in the Church may with greater desire and more fruite heare the Word of God receiue the Sacraments beleeue his promises and obserue his commandements all their whole life 35 Out of these things which hitherto wee haue declared these Conclusions following doe manifestly follow 36 I. What Traditions and Ceremonies are not to be accounted Indifferent Those Traditions which of their owne nature are contrarie vnto the Word and Commandement of God or which cannot bee performed without sinne are not to bee numbred among Indifferent things because in themselues they are Things impious and damnable 37 II. Euen then also when Traditions doe speake of things in their owne nature Indifferent yet they are made impious and doctrines of Diuels by adding vnto them the false opinion to wit 38 1. Of Merit as though the obseruation of them did merit Remission of sinnes 39 2. Of Worship as though God would be worshipped thereby contrarie to that expresse saying Matth. 15. In vaine doe they worship me with the precepts of men Also that of Ezech. 20. Walke in my commandements and not in the precepts of your fathers 40 3. Of Perfection as if their obseruation did make vs perfect before God 41 4. Of absolute Necessitie as if it were simply necessarie to obserue them for Conscience sake 42 III. Ridiculous Scenicall or theatricall gestures idle and vnprofitable Ceremonies which neither serue for Discipline nor for Order but rather make ostentation and apparance of heathenish vanitie and expose Religion to contempt and scorne which obscure true Doctrine and are the sinewes of Popish superstitions which make men prophane and without all true reuerence of God such as are a pish ridiculous gestures processions about Church-yards carrying about of Images and reliques the laying of Christ into the Sepulchre the Play of Christs resurrection and ascention and such like fooleries None of these are to be ranged among the number of Indifferent things 43 IV. Those Ceremonies which are either the Seminaries of superstition or cannot be vsed without superstition or certainly without some shew or appearance of superstition which they draw with them inseparably by the very vse thereof doe not belong to this place of Indifferent things 44 V. Neither are those Ceremonies rightly termed Indifferent things by whose vse the Enemies of truth are confirmed or the weake Christians offended For all Ceremonies ought to be helpes
prouocations inducements and sinewes of godlinesse edification the workes of charitie Discipline good Order and Comelinesse CHAP. VII Of the lawfull VSE of Things Indifferent THE true Church of God hath libertie at all tiems and in all places The Church vleth Things Indifferent freely to vse those things which are truly Indifferent to her owne purpose and commoditie or else to abstaine from them also to change and alter them according to her owne will and pleasure 2 For so saith the Apostle Coloss 2.16 Let no man iudge you in meate and drinke or in a holy day or new Moone or Sabbaths which are but shadowes of good things to come but the bodie is Christ 3 And 1. Tim. 4. speaking of the Indifferent vse of meates Euery creature of GOD is good and not to be reiected but to be receiued with thanksgiuing for it is sanctified by the word of God and prayer Also God hath created meates to bee receiued of the faithfull with thanksgiuing and of all them that know the truth 4 And seeing there is a two-fold Condition of mans life one Worldly which wee call Animall A two-fold Condition of Mans life because it respecteth our being in this present world the other Spirituall which is referred to the world to come Meates and euery externall Indifferent thing are referred to the first condition of life in this world and they ought not to be conioyned or mingled with the Spirituall estate or condition 5 Therefore the Apostle 1. Cor. 6.13 writeth Meate is for the belly and the belly for meate and againe Meate doth not commend vs to GOD for if wee eate wee haue nothing the more neither if we eate not haue we any thing the lesse 2. Corinth 8.7 6 Whereupon the words of S. Paul 1. Cor. 10.25 concerning Christian libertie and power are rightly opposed against Iewish Traditions Whatsoeuer is sold in the shambles that eate asking no question for conscience sake for the earth is the Lords and the fulnesse thereof 7 And this Doctrine is also taught by our Sauiour Christ when he reprooueth the Pharisies for taxing his Disciples eating meate with vnwashed hands That which goeth into a man doth not defile him but that which commeth out that defileth the man for that which goeth into the mouth descendeth into the belly and is cast foorth into the draught Matth. 15.11.17 8 But the place of S. A place of Rom. 14.1 c. concerning Things Indifferent expoūded Paul to the Rom. cap. 14. is most cleere of all others about the vse of Indifferent things wherein he prescribeth three remarqueable Rules whereby we may know both what and how this is to be performed 1. That the Weake in faith ought not to be reiected or scandalized 2. That no mans Conscience bee charged or burthened thereby 3. That by outward and indifferent things we ought not to iudge of other mens faith and religion 9 And for the better vnderstanding of that place of the Apostle wee will paraphrastically expound the nine first verses of this XIV Chap. whereby this matter shall bee made more cleere 10 Seeing there are many younglings A Paraphrase of the 1. verse weake or sicke in faith and such as haue not attained to any great measure of spiritual strēgth because they haue not learned throughly the Doctrine of the Gospel and the true vse of Christian Libertie but are still in opinion that they are bound to obserue the Ceremoniall law of Moses about forbidden meates and other such externall rites yet they heare the Gospell preached and are no enemies thereunto it is therfore necessarie and not the least part of Christian charitie that such persons bee not offended but rather cherished patiently tolerated taught and instructed with all meekenes and lenitie that they may be deliuered from their present scruple doubtfulnes and anxietie of minde and Conscience And this ought to bee done not onely by permitting them to liue after such manner as they please but also by curteous and familiar conference and conniuencie and by applying or conforming our manners and behauiour to theirs by a peaceable and delectable societie or conuersation so long vntill they bee brought without all contention scandall or dispute to lay aside their vaine perswasions and to vnderstand the doctrine of Christian Libertie how by IESVS CHRIST we are deliuered from sin wrath and damnation and therefore much more from Ceremoniall types rites sacrifices obseruance of daies choice of meates and humane Traditions And before they can bee brought to beare these things their Consciences ought not to bee troubled neither ought any man to reason with them contentiously racking and snatching their words sayings or actions vnto the worser part but their weaknes is to bee tendred and cured by little and little seeing they doe not sinne of malice nor haue any purpose to defend their errors stubbornely but are docible albeit they are not as yet confirmed and setled in iudgement 11 Hereupon when those which are Stronger in faith Verse 2. and well instructed in the Doctrine of Christian libertie do know that notwithstanding the law of Moses yet they haue a freedome to eate any kinde of meate without any offence of God And the Weaker on the other side straine at all the law of Moses both for meates daies and other things liuing vpon herbes and abstaining from meates thinking that their religion cannot bee sound and sincere nor their conscience quiet except after their old fashion they liue according to the law of Moses From hence one side falleth to despise another and mutually accuse each others manners whereby simultation ielousies and contentions arise Yet neither of both sides doe well 12 Wherefore Verse 3. they ought to handle the matter in this sort The Stronger that can eate any kind of meat must not cōtemne deride or set light by the other which are Weak as though they were blockish superstitious stubborne froward ignorant in the doctrine of Christian Libertie Contrariwise the Infirmer and weaker sort which are not yet perswaded of Christian Libertie but hang vpon Moses Law must not rashly condemne their Brethren that abstaine not from forbidden meates or proclaime them wicked prophane rash and polluted persons For there is one LORD of both whom they serue because they are both the members of Christ conuerted vnto the true faith and religion and haue one common right of Redemption and know that they are equally cherished and norished by the fatherly loue of God 13 Vnto this their LORD Verse 4. and GOD shall euery one render an account for himselfe not this man for thee nor thou for him And therefore it is nothing vnto thee what thy neighbour doth in this point for he is not thy seruant but the seruant of God It is GODS right and not thine to giue iudgement or sentence vpon his seruant who if he do not well shall be chastened by the Lord but if he do well he shall be approued and