being indeed the Articles of the Creed viz That there is but one God who made all things of nothing That this God sent his Sonne our Lord Jesus Christ begotten of the Father before every Creature by whom all Creatures were made He was incarnate and made man assuming a Body like in all things to us but that it was borne of the Virgin being conceived by the Holy Ghost He truly Dyed not in apearance the comon death of all men for he truly rose againe Having converst with his Disciples after his Resurrection he was taken up into Heaven That the Holy Ghost is associate with the Father and Sonne in the same Honor and Dignity there shall be a time for the Resurrection of the Dead when this body which is sowne in corruption shall rise in incorruption and that which is sowne in dishonor shall rise in glory This world was made and had a certaine time of begining and by reason of ' its corruptability shall be at length dissolved That there are certain Angels of God and good spirits which minister unto him in procuring the salvation of man kind He adds at last an other Traditionall Foundation viz. That the Scriptures were written by the Holy Ghost After all he concluds oportet igitur velut elementis ac fundamentis hujusmodi uti That we ought to make use of these as the first Elemens and Grounds of Christian Religion which he accordingly explaines at large in those foure bookes of his entituled therefore 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 of the Principles of Christianity a worke fit for his office of Catachist which he bore for many years in the Church of Alexandria 4. Marcellus Bishope of Ancyra in Gallatia fellowsuferer with the great Athanasius being accused by the Arians of Sabellianisme as Athanasius also was and by their means expeld his Bishoprick flies unto Iulius Bishope of Rome for succour and having long there in vaine expected his adversaries comming by confronting of whom he desired to have accquitted himselfe at length weary of longer stay he takes his leave of Iulius and leaves behind him an Epistle wherein he makes this Profession of Faith exceeding conformable to that of the Apostles as we read it at this Day 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 That is I Believe in God Almighty and in Jesus Christ his only-begotten Sonne our Lord conceived by the Holy Ghost and borne of the Virgin Mary crucifyed under Pontius Pilate and buried the third Day he rose againe from the Dead he ascended into the Heavens and sitteth at the right hand of the Father whence he shall come to judge the quick and the dead And I believe in the Holy Ghost the Holy Church the forgivenesse of sinnes the resurrection of the Body the Life Everlasting But this is not all to shew that this Creed was not of his own framing a little after he subjoynes these words 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 that is Having received this Faith from the holy Scriptures and being taught it of my spirituall Progenitors or Divine Ancestors I both Preach it in the Church of God and have now wrote it unto thee O Iulius This Epistle with the foresaid Creed inclosed we find recorded by Epiphanius in his 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Haeres 72. Now whom doth Marcellus meane by his Progenitors or Ancestors 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 according to or in God Sure he understands either his Godfathers at the Font or the Bishops of the Church by whom he was instructed in the Ancient Faith Or lastly which seemes to me most probable the Apostles themselves who were the true and proper Fathers or Founders of the Christian Church whence that of S. Paul 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 that is Though you have ten thousand Instructers or Pedagogues in Christ yet have ye not many Fathers It followes there 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 For in Iesus Christ I have begotten you through the Gospell 1 Cor. 4. 15. 5. S. Basil the Great in his Tract 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 concerning the Creed or Christian Faith sets downe this Symbole or Confession thereof 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 that is We Believe and professe one only true and good God the Father Almighty of whom are all Things the God and Father of our Lord and God Jesus Christ and one only begotten Sonne of his our Lord and God Jesus Christ the only True one by whom all things were made both visible and invisible and by whom all things consist who was in the Begining with God and was God and afterward according to the Scripture he appeared upon Earth and conversed with men being in the forme of God he thought it not robbery to be equall with God yet he made himselfe of no reputation and taking upon him the forme of a Servant by being borne of a Virgin and being found in fashion as a man he fulfilled all things which concerned him and were written of him according to the commandment of his Father he became obedient to the Death even the Death of the Crosse and the third Day arising from the Dead according to the Scriptures he appeared to his holy Disciples and to the Rest according as it is written he ascended into the Heavens and sitteth on the right hand of the Father from whence he shall come at the end of this world to raise up all and to render to every one according to his workes when the righteous shall be taken into Life Eternall and the Kingdome of Heaven and the sinners shall be condemned to everlasting punishment where their worme dieth not and the fire is not quenched And in one only Holy Ghost the Comforter by whom we are sealed to the day of Redemption the Spirit of Truth Here we have all the Articles of the Creed but two viz. The Beleefe of the Holy Catholick Church and the forgivenes of sinnes which he sets downe in the ensuing words wherein he largely descants on the gifts of the Holy Ghost towards the Church 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 c. By which Spirit we are sealed unto the day of Redemption the Spirit of Truth the Spirit of Adoption by whom we cry Abba Father which distributeth and effecteth in every one the Graces of God unto edification according to his pleasure the good Spirit which leadeth into all Truth and establisheth all that believe in the true and exact knowledge in the Godly and Spirituall service and worship and true confession of God the Father and his only-begotten Sonne c. Concluding thus 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 thus we think and thus we baptize 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 into a coessentiall Trinity according to the command of our Lord Jesus Christ who said goe and teach all nations baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Sone and of the Holy Ghost A little after he intimates from whom he received the foresaid confession of faith namely from Christ and his Apostles 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 c. I beseech you saith
whom the objectour cites I shall returne a more particular Answer First Cyril indeed in that place tels us that the mysteries of the Faith ought not to be delivered unto the Catechumeni simply nakedly but as clothed with scripture and that they should not simply believe him unlesse he brought proofes from thence for what he delivered because the safety of our Faith saith he depends not on the pleasingnes of Rhetorick but on the demonstration of Gods Word written The reason whereof he assignes in the begining of the same Homily 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 c. The Disciples of the Hereticks by their elegancy of speech and fair soothing tongues under the name of Christians deceive the hearts of the simple they hide the poysoōusdartes of their ungodly Doctrines with sugred expressions of all whom joyntly our Lord saith beware least any man deceive you then he goes on 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 for this cause the doctrine of Faith is delivered with expositions thereon So that he would not have the Creed or himselfe believed without Scripture not that the Creed but the Times required such proofe for the Heretickes of those Dayes partly framed new Creeds of their own partly added to altered and perverted the old withall indeavouring to make their doctrine good by seeming probabillities of Reason and flourishes of Rhetorick It was necessary therefore in this case to discover these false Creeds and Interpretations by bringing all unto the Text of Scripture Secondly The other Father Paschasius in the begining of his Booke De Spiritu Sancto written against Macedonius taxeth a false reading of the Creed crept into it through the ignorance of some Transcribers who wrote I believe in the holy Church for I believe the holy Church by this error enervated an Argument usually alleadged by the Fathers for the Deity of the holy Ghost against Macedonius and his Followers Paschasius therefore proves by certeine Places of Scripture that they are commanded to believe in God alone but never in man wherefore seeing the Church consists of a company of men that reading of the Creed must consequently be false which enjoynes us to believe in the Church But what of all this He appealed not in this from the Creed unto Scripture but by Scripture corrects a false reading of the Creed as the Fathers in their polemicall writings against Hereticks frequently correct their corrupt quotations of some places of Scripture by other undoubted places Ob. 8th The Reason assigned why the Apostles composed this Creed discovers the vanity of the Tradition what was that That it might be forsooth to the Apostles a Canon or Rule according to which they should square and conforme their Preaching what to the Apostles to whom Christ promised his Blessed Spirit that should lead them into all Truth Certeinly they needed it not for their owne sakes amongst whom there was no ground of difference nor doubt of the Principles of Christianity And whereas others more probably say it was framed for the Churches sake that shee might have a short plaine yet full confession of Faith as a Formula of Beliefe to be publickly recited at the Time of Baptisme neither will this hold for in the Apostles Age the Confession of Faith was plaine and simple when they came to be Baptized namely in Jesus Christ or in the Father Son and holy Ghost as appeares by the History of the Acts so that the Church had then no need of such a Formula It began not to be required till diverse Heresies brake into the Church Answ First It is readily confest that the Apostles needed no Rule of Faith whereby to square their Preaching as if otherwise they should have erred yet they might well agree one a Canon or Rule of Fundamentals wherewith they thought fit to acquaint all Christians as with Points necessary to Salvation whereas otherwise they might have Preached more at large and intermixt matters of lesser Consequence As for the Authors who bring the Reason alleaged in the objection they lay it downe not in these Termes least the Apostles being seperated each from other ipsi inter se in varias scinderentur partes much lesse thus ne subinde alii abaliis in doctrinâ abirent as is odiously alleaged but Ruffinus renders the reasō thus Ne diversum aliquid his qui ad fidem Christi invitabantur exponerent S. Austin in like words Ne diversum vel dissonum praedicarent his qui ad fidē Christi invitabantur Now diversum and abversum dissonum and absonum are two things there was no feare that the Apostles by being severed each from other should Preach ought contrary to the Truth or to one Another if they had not before agreed uppon a Forme yet they might have Preached somewhat diverse from the Fundamentalls of Christianity namely other Points of inferiour concernment or at least the same in other wordes if they had not agreed on this Rule at their setting forth whence their Auditours might have taken occasion to suspect and argue them of falsehood not believing they were all guided by the same Spirit or to part themselves into factions as it fell out in the Church of Corinth about Paul and Apollos although they taught the same Gospell And what stirres arose in the Church about a Ceremony viz. the time of observing Easter derived frō a different tradition of S. Iohn to the Churches of Asia frō the rest of the Christian world though they all agreed in the main the keeping of the Feast Eusebius others will sufficienly informe us But to come closer to our Subject A notable instance in the very same kind namely in matter of of Doctrin such as the Creed is we find in the Greek and Latine Church about the middle of the fourth Century touching the Grand mystery of the Trinity which yet upon due examination proved only a difference of the tongue language The Controversie is thus set down by Greg. Naz Orat. 21. written in praise of the Great Athanasius Num. 46. 47. The Orientals saith he held one 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 or Essence and three Hypostases or or subsistences The Latines by Reason of the barrennesse of their Tongue and the narrownesse of expression could not distinguish Hypostasis from 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Subsistence from Essence therefore insteed of Hypostasis brought in the new-coind word Persona Gr. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 to signify the 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the proper distinctive Relations of the Three as 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 signified the 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 or Nature what was the effect of this saith he 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 The effect deserved laughter or rather Lamentation this small difference of wordes seemed a diversity of Beliefe for the Orientals suspected the Westrne Church of Sabilianisme because they would not acknowledge three Hypostases but caled them by the name of three Persons And the Western Church suspected the Orientals of Arianisme for holding three Hypostases
and Dignity of each Person so named so that they are Three in the manner of Subsistence but one in the Consent Socr. Hist lib. 2. cap. 7. The Fourth was Framed on this occasion Certaine Bishops being sent by Constantius to his Brother Emperour of the West for to give an account of the Casting out of Paulus Athanasius concealed the precedent Formula of Beliefe made at Antioch and exhibited this other of their owne composure viz. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 c. We believe in one God the Father Almighty Creator and maker of all Things of whom the whole Family in Heaven and Earth is named and in his only-begotten Sonne our Lord Jesus Christ begotten of the Father before all Worldes God of God Light of Light by whom all things were made both in the Heavens in the Earth whether Visible or Invisible who is the Word and the Wisdome and the Power and the Life and the true Light who in these last Dayes was for our sakes made Man and Borne of the holy Virgin was Crucified Dead and Buried and rose againe the third Day from the Dead he ascended into the Heavens sitteth on the right hand of the Father and shall come at the end of the World to Judge the Quicke and the Dead to render unto every one according to his workes Whose Kingdome never ceasing endureth unto all eternity for he sitteth at the right Hand of God not only in this world but also in that which is to come We believe also in the holy Ghost that is in the Comforter whom according to his Promise he sent to his Apostles after his ascent into Heaven to teach them bring all things to their remembrance by whom also the Soules of those who syncerely believe in him are Sanctifyed But those who say the Sonne was made of nothing or of any other Substance and was not of God and that there was a Time when he was not the Catholick Church doth not acknowledge them for her owne Socr. hist lib. 2. cap. 14. The Fift Creed is that which was rehearsed by Vrsacius and Valens two Arian Bishops in the Synod of Ariminum had bin not long before Composed by the Bishops of that Faction in the Synod of Sirmium The Forme is this which followes We believe in one only and true God the Father Almighty Creator Framer of all things in one only-begotten Sonne of God begottten before all Worlds before all Begining before all imaginable Time which we can possibly conceive or comprehend begotten of God without sense or passion by whom the Worlds or Ages were set in order and all things were made the only Son of his Father God of God like unto the Father who begat him according to the Scriptures whose Generation no one knoweth but the Father who begat him This only-begotten Sonne of his we know came from Heaven for the puttting away of sinne by the will of his Father was borne of the Virgin Mary conversed with his Disciples fulfilled every Part of his office according to the will and Councell of his Father was crucifyed suffered and Dyed descended into the lower Partes of the Earth and ordered all things there the Porters of Hell Trembling at his sight he rose againe the Third Day Conversed with his Disciples and after forty Dayes was taken up into Heaven and sitteth at the right hand of the Father and shall come at the last Day in the Glory of his Father to render unto every one according to his workes And in the holy Ghost whom the same only-begotten Sonne of God Jesus Christ promised to send unto mankind the Comforter according as it is writtē I depart unto my Father I will beseech the Father and he shall send you another Comforter the Spirit of truth he shall receive of mine and shall teach you and bring all things to your remembrance As for the word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 essence because it being set downe by the Fathers without explication and not understood by the People gives cause of offence and because the Scriptures have no such word we have thought good to take it away and to make no mention at all hereafter of it when we speake of God because the holy Scriptures mention not at all the essence of the holy Ghost or the Sonne but we say that the Sonne is like unto the Father in all Things as the holy Scriptures say and Teach Soc. lib. 2. cap. 29. The sixt Confession of Faith is that new Formula which Acacius Bishop of Caesarea in Palestine one of the Arian Party proposed in the Synod of Seleucia by Leo a great officer in the Emperours Court The Forme was this 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 c. We professe and believe in one God the Father Almighty maker of Heaven and Earth of things Visible and Invisible we believe also in our Lord Jesus Christ his Sonne begotten of him without Sense or Passion before all worlds God the Word the only-begotten of God the light the life the Truth the Wisdome by whom all Things were made both which are in Heaven and which are on Earth whether visible or invisible we believe that in the latter Age of the World he tooke flesh of the holy Virgin Mary for the putting away of sinne was made man suffered for our sinnes rose againe was taken up into Heaven sitteh at the right hand of the Father and shall come againe in Glory to judge the Quicke and the Dead we believe also in the holy Ghost whom our Lord and Saviour called the Comforter when he promised to send him to his Disciples after his departure and accordingly sent him by whom also he sanctifyeth those in the Church who believe and are Baptized in the name of the Father and of the Sonne and of the holy Ghost Those who Preach any other Faith than this wee Judge them aliens from the Catholick Church See for this Socr. Hist lib. 2. cap. 32. The Seventh Confession of Faith is that of the Macedonians exhibited by them to Liberius Bishop of Rome when they fled to him and the Emperour Valentinian for succour from the Persecution of his Brother Valens and the Arian Bishop Eudoxius The Forme was this We believe in one God the Father Almighty maker of all things visible and invisible and in one only-begotten God the Lord Jesus Christ the Sonne of God begotten of the Father that is of the Substance of the Father God of God light of light very God of very God begotten not made consubstantiall to the Father by whom all Things were made both which are in Heaven and which are on Earth who for us men and for our Salvation came downe was incarnate and made man suffered and rose againe the third Day he ascended into the Heavens and shall come to Judge the Quick and the Dead And in the holy Ghost But those who say of the Sonne of God that there was a Time when he was not a Time
of Theology most necessary to be established and in that most especially the Creed as the Foundation of the rest and this for three Reasons A double abuse of the Creed which occasioned this Treatise together with the abuse of Catechismes The five Heads of the ensuing Treatise The Creed containes all and only Fundamentals The Trinity and Incarnation of the Sonne of God cleared out of it AMongst the severall parts of Divinity which brancheth it selfe forth so largly and variously the Positive or Dogmaticall is Best and most necessary As for Controversies it had been happy for the Church if shee had never been exercised with any they arose as accidentally as unfortunately for Ignorance or Malice hath been the Mother of them All Ignorance when men could not Malice when they would not see and acknowledge the Truth Truth it selfe is still but one which requires establishing rather then questioning for whilst we call all things into Dispute even the maine Grounds of our Religion some begin to doubt others deny Now amongst the Dogmaticks in Divinity which are reducible to these foure Heads the Principles of the Christian Catechisme viz. The Creed the Commandements the Lords Prayer and the Sacraments I have thought good to pitch upon the first named the Creed as the most necessary and Fundamentall Part of Christianity and so most requisite to be premised unto the other three for without a right Faith whereof the Creed is the Rule and Ground we can neither Pray nor Obey nor use the the Sacraments as we ought this it is which directs our Prayers which quickens our Practice and disposeth us aright for all Sacred Mysteries But this necessity is more pressing in these distracted Times and that for these following Reasons 1. Some we have and those who would be thought the most Orthodoxe Reformers who dare cavill at the Authority of the Creed and question the letter of it yea not only question but dash out and abolish the Article of Christ's Descent into Hell either in words or in the ancient and received Sense though generally attested by the Verdict of Antiquity and guarded by the third Article of our Church on purpose inserted as we may in all likelyhood suppose for setling the minds of her Children in this particular because it began to be controverted or at least perverted in the exposition thereof by some Divines in those Dayes 2. Others we have of a farre higher straine who overthrow the very Foundations of Religion especially in the Articles of the Sacred Trinity and the Incarnation of our Blessed Saviour the eternall Sonne or word of God made flesh by which he became 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 both which are asserted in the Creed as will appeare by the following Discourse And that they might the more boldly vent their desperate Tenents have slighted the authority of the Creed as an humane Invention or Compilemēt as falsly bearing the Apostles name in the Front so the followers of Servetus Valentinus Gentilis Socinus and others The Framers of which Sects were not ashamed to divulge their project to the world as well by the Pencill as the Pen. They drew a Picture wherein the Church of Rome was described under the forme of a great Edifice on the Roofe whereof sate Luther and his Assistants throwing away the Tiles the Roofe being thus bared Zwinglius Calvin and others beate downe the Walls when this was done to perfect the worke come these Tritheits Photinians Arians with the rest of their Consorts armed with Spades and Pick-axes to digge up the Foundation Here be Rooters with a witnesse whose designe it is not to Prune the Tree by cutting of some superflous Branches but utterly extirpate it that they may plant a new Gospell of their owne such who instead of repairing fall to ruining and instead of of restoring the Decayes of Gods Church by a deliberate and well-ordered Reformation indeavour to erect a new Building in the Desolations of the old 3. The Age miserably labours with as many Religions almost as men every one strongly confidently pretending to the True and Excommunicating as Reprobates all those who are either contrarily or but diversly minded in a word who agree not with them in every Point though of the smallest Concernment Amongst which various Sects and Divisions it concernes us first to search out then to adhere unto some constant Rule whereby to regulate and establish our Faith Now this Rule is at Hand for the Creed was anciently stiled and I hope is still accounted by all good Christians Regula Fidei A short plaine certaine and Compleat Rule Short without Tediousnesse Plaine without Perplexednesse or Obscurity Certaine without Crookednesse or Errour and Compleat without Defect It comprehends the whole Body of our Beleefe omnes Articulos all the Joynts or Members of that Body no one wanting If all Christians would but hold to this as the Primitive Church did then all Heresies and Sects would soone vanish and the severall Members of the Church which now lie distracted and torne asunder like the Bones in Ezekiels vision the severed Parcels of a Skeleton rather then a Body would quickly come together Bone to his Bone the sinewes flesh and skinne would soone cover them and then the Breath of the Lord the Spirit of Christ who is the Head of this Body would Reenter into them and give them life There have been two Grand Causes as I conceive of these miserable Divisions both sprung from an abuse of the Creed what by adding to it what by altering of it 1. The Church of Rome contrary to S. Peters Rule from whom shee boasts to derive her Prerogative Lording it over Gods Heritage 1 Pet. 5. 3. And contrary to that of S. Paul her Joynt Founder taking upon her to have Dominion over our Faith 2 Cor. 14. hath added new Articles to these of the Apostles especially in her last Councill of Trent and these she hath enjoyned to be beleeved under an Anathema and made the so beleeving necessary to Salvation Which domineering carriage of hers hath bred many heart-burnings and stirs in the world that otherwise would never have arisen if she had kept her self entirely unto the old Rule which only was required to be profest by the Genuine Orthodoxe Sons of the Chuerh in the Primitive and Best Times for the Nicene Chalcedon other succeeding Creeds were only expositions of not Additions to the Apostles Creed as will be made appeare 2. Bold Sectaries under the specious Title of Reformers taking occasion and advantage from hence what from the Tyranny and what from the example have fil'd the world with Institutions and Catechismes and I know not what severall Tracts of their false hereticall Tenents arrogating the name of Truth and of the true Church unto themselves Some Tenents they have urged all to beleeve which are besides and not a few quite contrary to this Creed of the Apostles promised Salvation to their own Disciples but denounced damnation not
which it plainly appeares that they esteemed it essentiall to these but pleonasticall unto those The like may be said of some old Latine Copies of the Creed which yet are very few wherein In redounds by the like Hebrew Pleonasme Ob. 2. The Socinians say they doe all acknowledg the Apostles Creed for the matter though they doubt whether it were composed in this Forme by the Apostles wherein they are not the first nor alone Erasmus seems to have first made question of it after him Calvin and most of his followers wholy yet deny not the Authority but acknowledge the matter to be true Nay the Socinians complaine that whereas the Creed containes all Fundamentall Truthes yet other Articles are obtruded as necessary such as be not contained in the Creed how then can the denyall of the Composure of this Creed by the Apostles any way advantage the Socinians Answ The Socinians deny some Articles of the Creed in the Sense which the Ancient Fathers understood them from whom they received the Creed it selfe for words and ought to have done for meaning and the denyall of the Authors makes them in all likelihood the bolder in their mis-interpretations Then although they hold that the Creed containes all Fundamentall Truthes yet they hold not all the Articles thereof Fundamentall On the other side they unjustly complaine of other Articles obtruded on their Beleefe whereas the Church hath only explained some few Articles of the Creed and vindicated them from Hereticall Glosses and Corruptions warranting those her Expositions by old Catholick Tradition upon a due legall search in an Oecumenicall Synod Lastly the denyall of the Composure of this Creed by the Apostles as a Summary of Truthes ordinarily necessary to Salvation which was the maine end of Composing it much advantageth the Socinians who beleeve not all to be necessary and some not true as they are construed in the old received Sense If Erasmus began first to doubt of the received Authors of the Creed he cannot well be excused for questioning so ancient and establish'd a Tradition whereby no Benefit could redound to the Christian Church but the Faith of many might be startled and Heresies awaked as we have seen by the Event and I am sorry that the Socinians should look on him as they doe though I hope amisse as their first Founder or chiefe Patron in this latter Age by reason of this and some other extravagancies of his Pen so that what Posseuine from others saies of him in relation to Luther may be verified in respect of Socinus in some of his Errours Erasmus innuit Socinus irruit And this Nescio of Erasmus which others have since improved to a Nego was presently censured by the Parisian Divines As for Mr Calvin though he saith indeed that he will not contend with any one about the Authors of the Creed as a Thing in his judgment not overmuch materiall yet he produceeth two Arguments in the same place which evince the Apostles and none others to have been the Composers thereof namely the concordant suffrages of Antiquity and the publike receiving or use thereof presently upon the Rise or originall of the Christian Church Instit lib. 12. cap. 16. 6. 18. But of his Testimony more fully hereafter Ob. 3. It seemes that the Creed containes not the whole Body of the Credenda or Christian Beleefe not all Credenda in generall for there are many thousand more which lie scattered in the Scriptures no nor all Fundamentall Points or necessary Doctrinall Truthes E. G. faith in the Trinity the Canon of Scripture that we are to worship God and goe to the Father by the Sonne the doctrine of Repentance good Works Baptisme Imposition of hands which are expresly called a Foundation Heb. 6. 1 2. none of which are in the Creed Adde hereunto the Deity of the Sonne of God which seems not to be proved by those words in the second Article His only begotten Sonne for he is called the Sonne of God in Scripture in respect of his Conception and Resurrection both which relate to his Humane Nature See Luk. 1. 35. Act. 13. 32 33. Rom. 1. 4. Answ The Creed containes all Fundamentall Points purely Doctrinall or Speculative that is necessary Credenda as opposed to the Agenda or Practicalls of Christianity The Canon of Scripture containes these Fundamentalls dispersedly and is delivered downe to us as the Creed is by Tradition but not comprehended in the Creed for when we name Fundamentals we speake of Matters or Points to be beleeved not of the Bookes which containe those Points The Points cited out of Heb. 6. are all Practicall so also is the worship of God and comming to the Father by the Sonne Baptisme is a Sacrament one of the Agenda's in the Church yet referr'd in the Nicene Creed to the 10th Article as the outward ordinary meanes for remission of Sinnes The Mystery of the Trinity is included in the Creed as hath been already shewed And so is the Divinity of our Saviour in those fore-cited words Vnigenitum Patris Filium The only begotten Sonne of the Father For though he be called the Sonne of God in relation to his Humanity in Luk. 1. 35. because in his Conception or Incarnation the Holy Ghost did supplere vicem Patris by a miraculous overshadowing or rather not simply as man but as 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 God and man in one Person in respect of that strange Vnion of the Humane Nature in one Hypostasis with the Divine by the supernaturall operation of the Holy Ghost as also in relation to his Raising againe whereby he was chiefly demonstrated to be the true Messiah or Sonne of God the first begotten of the Dead Act. 13. 32 33. Rom. 1. 4. Col. 1. 18. and Revel 1. 5. comp Col. 1. 15. Rom. 8. 29. Yet in the second Article of the Creed he is called the Only begotten Sonne of God with relation to God the Father and in respect of his Divinity which he received of the Father by an ineffable Generation from all Eternity for this Article is placed before his Conception by the Holy Ghost and his Nativity of the Virgin Mary much more before his Resurrection which manifested not made him the Sonne of God and therefore cannot relate to his Manhood but to his Godhead not to his Conception or Resurrection in time but to his Generation from Everlasting CAP. II. The History of the Apostles Composing the Creed out of Ruffinus Five Reasons why the Apostles delivered it to the Church not in Writing but by an Orall Tradition An objection against the preserving of it by Tradition Answered TOuching the Composing of the Creed by the Apostles which is my first Head Ruffinus Presbiter of Aquileia St Jeromes Contemporary and great Emulatour gives us this Relation in the beginning of his Exposition on the Creed Tradunt majores nostri quod post Ascensionem Domini cum per adventum Sancti Spiritus super singulos quosque Apostolos igneae
dextram Patris venturum judicare vivos mortuos per carnis etiam Resurrectionem Hac lege fidei manente caetera jam Discipilinae Conversationis admittunt novitatem correctionis operante sc proficiente usque in finem gratia Dei That is The Rule of Faith is one only solely immoveable and unchangeable to wit Of Believing in one only God Almighty the Maker of the world and in Jesus Christ his Sonne borne of the Virgin Mary crucified under Pontius Pilate the third Day raysed againe from the Dead received into the Heavens and now sitting at the right hand of the Father who shall come to judge the Quick and the Dead by the Resurrection of the body This Law of Faith abiding firme the other parts of Christian Discipline and Conversation are capable of amendment and reformation the Grace of God still working and proceeding onward unto the end of the world Secondly In his booke against Praxeus cap. 2. He sets downe the Creed in this short Forme Unicum Deum credimus sub hac tamen Dispensatione quam 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 dicimus ut vnici Dei sit Filius Sermo ipsius qui ex ipso processerit per quem omnia facta sunt sine quo factum est nihil hunc missum a Patre in Virginem ex eâ natum Hominem Deum filium hominis filium Dei cognominatum Jesum Christum hunc passum hunc mortuum sepultum secundùm Scripturas resuscitatum a Patre in Coelos resumptum sedere ad dexteram Patris venturum judicare vivos mortuos qui exinde miserit secundùm Promissionem suam a Patre Spiritum sanctum Paracletum Santificatorem fidei eorum qui credunt in Patrem Filium Spiritum sanctum That is We believe one only God yet vnder this Order or Oeconomy that this one God hath a Sonne his Word who came forth from him by whom all Things were made and without whom nothing was made he was sent by God the Father into the Virgine and borne of her God and man the Son of man and the Son of God called Jesus Christ he Suffered Died and was Buried according to the Scriptures was raised up againe by the Father and being taken up againe into Heaven sitteth at the right hand of the Father he shall come to judge the Quick and the Dead who afterward according to his promise sent from the Father the Holy Ghost the Comforter the Sanctifier of their Faith who believe in the Father and the Son and the holy Ghost Then shewing the Originall of the Creed he tels us Hanc Regulam ab initio Evangelii decurrisse etiam ante Priores quosque haereticos nedùm ante Praxean hesternum probabit tam ipsa Posteritas omnium haereticorum quam ipsa novellitas Praxeae hesterni quo peraequè adversùs vniversas haereses jam hinc praejudicatum sit Id esse verum quodcunque primum Id esse adulterum quodcunque posterius i That this Rule hath descended to us from the begining of the Gospell before any Heretick arose much more before Praxeas a fellow of yesterday will easily appeare both by the succession of all Hereticks and the yersterday Rise of the Novellist Praxeas which newnes doth equally convince all Heresies and condemne them according to this Rule or Precedent That which is most Ancient is the Truth that which Followes is the Forgery 4. St Ambrose Serm. 38. Thus affirmes Duodecim Apostolorum Symbolo Fides sancta concepta est qui velut periti Artifices in unum convenientes Clavem suo consilio conflaverunt That is The Holy Faith is comprehended or conceived in the Creed of the twelve Apostles who meeting together like so many skilfull workmen by joynt advice framed this Key of the Christian Beleefe or mysteries of Religion And in his 81. Epistle written by him Bassianus and others to Syricius Bishop of Rome Credatur Symbolo Apostolorum quod Ecclesia Romana intemeratum semper custodit servat Let the Apostles Creed be believed which the Church of Rome constantly keepes and preserves inviolate So Canisius and Augerius in their Catechismes read the Place but two Editions of Ambrose at Paris viz. That of Erasmus by Chevalonius Anno Domini 1529. And that of Felix Card de Monte Alto 1586. Dedicated to Greg. 13. for Intemeratâ—m read Iteratum alluding as I conceive to the solemne Rehearsall of the Creed at Baptisme or in the publique service of the Church but both these Readings come in effect to one for there 's no better way to keepe the Creed inviolate and preserve it from corruption then the constant publique repeating of it so the Intemeratum is an effect of the Iteratum 5. S. Jerome in his Epistle to Pammachius which he wrote against the errors of John Patriarch of Jerusalem saith thus In Symbolo fidei spei nostrae quod ab Apostolis traditum non scribitur in Chartâ Atramento sed in Tabulis cordis carnalibus post confessionem Trinitatis unitatem Ecclesiae omne Christiani dogmatis Sacramentum carnis Resurrectione concluditur In the Creed or Profession of our Faith and Hope which being delivered by the Apostles is not written with inke and paper but in the fleshy Tables of the Heart after the confession of the Trinity and the unity of the Church the whole mystery of the Christian beleef is shut up with the Resurrection of the Body Now he ends the Creed with the Article of the Resurrection because as some others of the Ancients he reads the last Article of the Creed thus The Resurrection of the Body unto Life Eternall thus joyning two in one 6. S. Austin in his 181. Sermon de Tempore concures with Ruffinus in the forecited Relation of the Apostles composing the Creed thus Sancti Apostoli certam Regulam Fidei tradiderunt quam secundum numerum Apostolorum duodecim sententiis comprehensam Symbolum vocaverunt per quam Credentes Catholicam tenerent unitatem per quam haereticam convincerent Pravitatem Tradunt enim quod post ascensionem Domini Salvatoris nostri ad Patrem cum per Aduentum Spiritus Sancti Discipuli ejus inflaÌ„mati linguis omnium loquerentur ad singulas quasque Nationes ut Dei Verbum praedicarent ituri ac discessuri ab invicem normam prius sibi futurae Praedicationis in commune statuerunt ne localiter ab invicem Discedentes diversum vel dissonum praedicarent his qui ad fidem Christi invitabantur omnes igitur in uno positi Spiritu sancto repleti Breve suae praedicationis Indicium conserendo in unum quod sentiebat unnsquisque computabant atque hanc ita Credentibus dandam esse Regulam instituerunt That is The holy Apostles delivered a certaine Rule of Faith which having according to their owne number comprehended in twelve Sentences they called a Symbole or collation by meanes of which the Believers might hold the Catholick unity
VI. Testimonies of the Authors and Authority of the Creed taken out of the Protestant Divines who have unanimously received and acknowledged this Creed of the Apostles together with the Nicene Creed and that of Athanasius ALthough the Testimonies of the Fathers might well suffice in this Busines the Ancient Doctours of the Church being the most apt and able Witnesses of so ancient a Tradition yet because the Church at this day especially this Western Part of it is so unhappily broken into severall divisions whereto diverse too pertinaciously addicting themselves think nothing right or true but what their owne side allowes and their heades maintaine thus measuring all Religion by the private judgment of some late masters of the Reformation whom though choise Instruments in that worke we ought not sure to looke on as infallible dictatours least in a crosse ridiculous vanity we be found to imitate what we so much blame in our Adversaries by giving that unto them which we have taken from the Pope and so setting up many for one I thought it not amisse by declaring their Judgment also in this Point to comply a little with these prejudices and so give satisfaction even to the most partiall who look upon the Fame of the Author rather than the Force of the argument and value the proofe according to the esteeme they have of the Person as if the Truth were commended by the Teacher not the Teacher by the Truth contrary to that short and sharpe expostulation of Tertullian num ex Personis aestimamus Fidem an ex Fide Personas In compliance I say with these I have thought good to subjoyne unto the consent of Antiquity the suffrages of our latter Protestant Divines many of them the prime Instruments of the Reformation who fully agree with the Fathers in this Point whereby also I shall shew the convincing evidence of this Truth which hath obteined a free confession from the Mouthes Pens of those who have rejected so many other doctrines received in the Church of Rome Especially matters of Tradition such as the Creed is which hath been so universally received by them who have repudiated or Reformed all that they could find any fault with after a most severe examination who in other Points not a few have shewed themselves not only of a contrary judgment unto the Church of Rome but even of a Different among themselves These Testimonies then may justly much prevaile with those who professe themselves of the Reformed Churches not only because of the Dignity of their Name and the uncorruptnesse of their writings as being composed of late not at all suspected of coruption by any Romish fraud but also that when they speake of the Apostles Creed they questionlesse meane that 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the same in expresse Termes which is now extant and so are not liable to that Exception which some though without just Ground have made against those Creeds set downe in the writings of the Fathers that they vary from the Forme we now have at least in some words and in the manner of expression Hereby also two sorts of men may likewise see their errour First the Romane-Catholik who with alike loudnes and lying proclaimes to the world that the Protestant or Reformed Churches have brought in a new Religion whereas their endeavour hath been to restore the old unto its Primitive Simplicity by paring off from it as well eroneous superstructures in matter of Doctrine as Superstitious or Burdenous Appendixes in matter of Ceremonies Discipline Government and Manners Secondly the Novellist who though he seemes outwardly much to honour the Prime Reformers yet adheres not to their Principles but runs wildly after his owne Inventions foolishly measuring the Truth of Religion by its opposition to the Church of Rome as if shee had wholy apostatized from the Faith Now betweene these two extreames the old Catholick Truth keeps a mean though for this cause much suffering on both sides Mat. 11. 19. But Wisdome is justifyed of her Children Among these Protestant Divines I have already produced the Testimonies of Calvin Beza Grynaeus and Paraeus in their Comments on the fore-alleaged Places of Scripture viz. Beza and Grynaeus on Rom. 12. 6. Calvin and Paraeus on Heb. 1. 6. To these I shall now adde the Testinnies of others and withall cite Calvin and Grinaeus in their other writings 1. Martin Luther in his Tract of the three Creeds which we find extant in the seventh Tome of his workes hath these words Because some after Confession of my Faith Questioned my Religion I have thought good to Publish these three Symboles as they are cald or confessions of the Christian Faith packt up as it were in one bundle which Creeds the universall Church hitherto hath with generall Approbation taught read sung quas quidem hactenus universa ecclesia magno consensu docuit legit cantavit Quare iterum testatum volo sentire me unice cum vera Christianâ ecclesiâ quae ista Symbola magno consensu hactenùs tum docuit tum retinuit e contra toto Pectore abhorrere ac dissentire a falsâ illâ hypocriticâ ecclestâ quae est saevissimus hostis verae ecclesiae Christi quaeque neglectis obscuratis istis pulcherrimis Symbolis multiplicem interea Idololatriam in ecclesiam invexit Whereby saith he I againe desire to testify that I wholy cōforme my judgment to that true Christian Church which hath hitherto concordantly retained and delivered those Creeds and on the contrary doe cordially dissent from and abhorre that false and hypocriticall Church which is the most cruell enemy of the true Church of Christ which neglecting and debasing those most excellent Creeds hath in the meane time introduced manifest Idolatry into the Church Thus he in his preface to the Reader He proceedes thus Est autem primum illud Apostolorum Symbolum ex reliquis pulcherrimum maximeque concinnum utpote quod brevissime quodam ceu compendio omnes fidei christianae Articulos complectitur quo nomine facilius à Pueris Simplicioribus percipi ac disci potest Alterum Athanasii sc Symbolum est paulo prolixius estque hoc velut propugnaculum primi illius Apostolici Symboli ab eo contra Arianos haereticos conditum est That is The first of these is the Apostles Creed the most excellent best composed of the rest as which most briefely compendiously comprehends all the Articles of the Cristian Beliefe in which regard it may be more easily learned and understood of Children and the more simple sort The Second is the Creed of Athanasius which is somewhat larger and is in the nature of a Bulwarke to that first Creed of the Apostles It was framed by him against the Arrians The Third which he there sets downe is Te Deum being as well a Creed as an Hymne Then after In Symbolo Apostolorum jactum est fundamentum Christianae Fidei Subjiciemus sub finem ad
contentions dayly growing hotter betweene them had like to have seperated the East and West about a syllabicall difference But Athanasius saith he with much patience and prudence calling unto him and hearing both Parties having examined their meaning and the sense of the words when he found them agreeing in the thing signifyed and at no difference about the doctrine it selfe 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 granting them the diversity of their Termes he unites them together in the same Truth Secondly Though we hold it most certaine that the Apostles considered single and apart delivered nothing to the Church either by word or writing but what they were specially assisted in by the holy Ghost and therefore most undoubtedly true yet for ought I know as the holy Ghost revealed not all truths to the Apostles at once no not when he descended on them at the Feast of Pentecost but delayed the manifesting of some till afterwards as for example the Conversion of the Gentiles to Peter in the vision of the sheet Act. 10. So he might not reveale some truthes unto them when they were single and apart but only when they met and consulted together For though every one of them by himselfe was infallible in all necessary Points that is so as to deliver nothing contrary to the Faith or Truth of Christian Religion yet without any Derogation to his priviledge they might need the more especiall assistance of the holy Ghost upon their Assembly to instruct them which Points of Faith were necessary to Salvation which not We have a famous Instance of this recorded Act. 15. For when there arose a great question in the Church of Antioch whether the Gentiles newly converted in Syria and Cilicia should be circumcised and obey the Law of Moses That Paul and Barnabas were sent unto Jerusalem about it v. 2. that the Apostles and Elders came together to consider of this matter v. 6. What needed this considering in a solemne meeting if they had been ascertained what to resolve before they met It followes v. 7. That there was much disputing or debate in the Councell Why not even among the Apostles themselves who were the chiefe members thereof At least this disputing might have been spared or cut short by the Apostles as a thing unnecessary if it had not beene thought a good and needfull Preamble unto a finall Decision If the Church had conceived S. Peter or any other of the Apostles an infallible Judge in this Point with out due examination thereof and the speciall assistance of the holy Ghost in a Synod they might have spared both their meeting and dispute But when there had been much disputing and not before they joyntly determined what Lawes to free them from and what to impose upon them as things necessary to be observed v. 28. Namly the abstaining from Bloud and consequently things strangled v. 29. According to that primitive law given to the Sons of Noah Ge. 9. 4. a Law still observed by the Greek Church by the Moscontieth their neighbour churches of Polād which have admitted the Reformation and long observed generally by the whole Western Church even til the Times of Ludovicus Pius as appeares by his and his Father Charles capitular together with the abstaining from Fornication and things offered to Idols which the Apostle makes a species of Idolatry 1 Cor. 10. 19 20 21. And are more clearly against the Morall Law though not so esteemed by the generality of the Gentiles Then and not before they use that stile It seemed good to the Holy Ghost and to us that is To us in the Plurall to us assembled together Consonantly to this S. Paul tells us more plainly Gal. 2. 2. that long after his conversion and calling unto his Apostleship he went up to Jerusalem by Revelation and communicated the Gospell which he Preached among the Gentiles unto the Apostles who there resided namely to Iames Cephas and Iohn giving this for a Reason least saith he by any meanes I should run or had run in vaine Gal. 2. 2. Now the composing of the Creed wherein were to be comprised the maine Grounds of Christian Religion was a matter of the highest consequence and so might very well require the joynt and serious deliberation of the Twelve together with the speciall assistance of Gods spirit Thirdly To the Reply against the second Reason I Answer That 't is a groundlesse supposall to think that the Persons to be Baptized in the Apostles times were required to believe only in Iesus Christ or in the Trinity alone for First we find other Principles of Christian Doctrine distinctly set downe in Heb. 6. 1 2. And Preached by the Apostles before they Baptized their Auditors for instance the Article of Remission of Sinnes by Peter Act. 10. 43. And by Paul Act. 13. 38 39. The Article of the Creation of the World by the same Paul Act. 17. 24. Secondly As for beliefe in Iesus Christ the Apostles indeed required it as the maine poynt as we read in the History of the Eunuch Act. 18. 37. and of the Jaylor Act. 16. 31. Yet not as the sole poynt for beliefe in the holy Ghost was also required as appeares by the history of the Disciples at Ephesus Act. 19. 2 3 6. 'T is mentioned therefore as the principall and that which virtually includes all the rest for to believe in Jesus Christ as wee ought is to believe the Doctrine which he taught revealed unto the world from the Father as the guide or light to true Blessednesse now what was this but the Gospell of Salvation whereof the Creed for mater of Doctrinalls is the Epitome consult to this purpose Io. 17. 3. And chap. 3. 13. 36. Thirdly As for beliefe in the most Holy Trinity it gives us more scope as that which comprehends all the Articles of our Faith for as to believe in Jesus Christ implicitely conteines all the mysteries of our Redemption viz. His Godhead Incarnation and Birth Passion Buriall Descent into Hell Resurrection Assension Sitting on the right hand of the Father and second comming to Judgment so to believe in God the Father conteines his workes of Creation and Providence which are the Visible effects of his eternall Power and Godhead Ro. 1. 20. And to believe in the holy Ghost involves the whole worke of Sanctification the applying of Christs Benefits to his Church and compleating the Salvation of mankind which are distinctly set downe in the foure last Articles And this S. Chrysostome teacheth us in his first homily on the Creed already cited where his Text ends thus I believe in the holy Ghost but in his explication he thus unravels the Article and layes it open to view in its full extent who brings us to the holy Church she remiteth our sinnes promiseth the Resurrection of the Body and life everlasting This beliefe therefore in Christ or in the Trinity is not to be nakedly simply understood as if no other Particulars were required but with