ought to receive and obey the Truth and to believe no more than what Christ hath commanded to be believed and to worship God according to the Will of Christ Shall we say the Protestants in France do not hold the Faith nor worship God according to the Gospel then what are they who say so If they profess and believe the Truth they ought to be permitted that 's plain for the Truth 's sake and for the Lord's sake Doth Christian Love and Compassion prompt us to wish our persecuted Brethren in France enjoyed the Liberty of the true Religion there and if they should enjoy a Freedom there shall we deny a Liberty to Protestant Brethren here I can see no way to avoid a Justification of the barbarous Usage of Protestants there by them that prosecute Protestants here for far lesser Differences from our Establishments than theirs from the Papists Suppose an Embassador was sent to treat with the French King at this time of Prosecution of our Native Protestants for a Cessation of that cruel Persecution how readily might an Answer be made Why may not I suppress Hereticks when in England you suppress Protestants 4. A Diversity of Order and Manner of Discipline and Worship may be as well permitted without breach of Church-Unity in the same Nation as in divers Nations without breach of Christian and Catholick Unity If different Forms of Belief are allowed the matter being divine and the one more large and explicit than others why may not different Modes and Order of Discipline and Worship be allowed and permitted Our Worship is according to our Faith as we believe so we worship Notwithstanding our use of three Forms of Profession of our Faith we agree in one Faith so in different Forms of Worship we agree in one Evangelical Worship And our Reformers might with as great Reason have pitched upon one of the three Creeds and for Uniformity sake required Assent to that and the use of that and no other as our Modern Fathers pitch upon one Form of Worship and require our Assent and Use of that and no other For Uniformity in Faith is more necessary than Uniformity in Orders and Rites We use the Creed called the Apostles Athanasian and Nicen Creed Bishop Jewel hath written a larger Form in his Apology for the Church of England agreeing in Words with neither and in his Reply to Harding reckons up eight Forms composed by several Authors and Fathers Apol. 2d part 1. c. Divis 1. Diversity of Creeds fol. 38. Harding cavilling against his Declaration of our Faith as many in our days exclaim a-against Dissenters said In our Fathers days Christian People lived in perfect Vnity c. before Luther 's New Gospel But let us learn from our Reverend Father Jewel that Unity of Faith may agree with Diversity of Forms of Faith and by Consequence with Diversity of Forms of Worship Object But the Administration of God's Worship ought to be uniform in one Nation and variety of Rites in one National Church would Cause Division of Judgment and by Consequence Division of Affection and to tolerate divers ways of Administrations would be to tolerate matter of perpetual Discord and Schism Answ Besides what the learned and acute Sir Thomas Overbury answers to a part of the matter of this Objection pag. 106. and the Commissioners in the Savoy Account of Proceedings p. 8 9. I 'll return my Answer in two things 1. Without Controversy our Lord Jesus took care for the Preservation of Unity such a Unity as is necessary among his Disciples and yet took no such Course as these Men build all Unity upon 2. The Church of Corinth was doubtless a particular Church and according to the Sense of the Reverend Bishop Bilson quoted before there was no Form of Liturgy prescribed p. 619 620. To be short Multitudes of learned and able Men living in one Kingdom have diversity of Apprehensions and Notions of things as well as in divers Nations and except Uniformity of Words might produce an inward Uniformity of Conceptions it hath not that Influence upon Unity as some Men think by their too violent urging of it 3. I am for Uniformity according to General Rules not excluding Prudence which must judg what 's necessary what 's expedient what 's edifying or what not for to exclude Prudence is to limit Divine Providence to particular Rules Divine Providence proceeds from Soveraignty Prudence observes it and Conscience must obey it Saving the Dominion of Providence and the Exercise of Ministerial Prudence let 's be as uniform as we can This prudential Latitude is allowed to every Curate in the choice of Homilies in dividing them leaving a part for the After-noon and changing of Lessons reading one for another as shall be most for Edification in the Admonition to all Ecclesiastical Ministers before the second part of the Homily To conclude this Question I desire the violent and active and the violent and oppressive Disputants of these times to answer Whether they think that our Protestant-Dissenting-Brethren that preach the Faith and labour to convert and build up precious Souls are unworthy to enjoy Liberty to preach the Gospel or to enjoy their Estates or to live in any part of the World If not what ground have they for their ill Opinion What Christian Charity have they How do they conspire with Bloody Inquisitors and French Persecutors yea Irish Rebels and Inhuman Rooters out of Heresy But if not worthy to live among us retaining their Liberty of Conscience and Religion Whither shall they go Where are they like to sind more natural Affection than among their Native Country-men and Acquaintance Where shall they be more wel-come among the Papists among Infidels where Satan bears so much Rule or among Protestants abroad Alas where who can entertain them Would you banish them to Scotland Ireland there are too many already Whither would you have them go for they are bid begon if they 'll not conform by some where they may do good there 's work enough for them where ever they are Why may they not do good here among us To be short they who turn them out of their Hearts and Charity upon the same reason banish them out of the Land if not out of the World And what if they should say as their Ejectors do We had better live or be in any Land or Nation even among the Papists or Insidels than live among such as these Would it not sound worse than all that yet they have said And what a Division or Schism at the very root would that be if it grew to it Which it hath not done and I wish never may But we may see that Violence is a Wedg to make the most ghastly Schism that ever was seen in a Christian Church But rather than be guilty of so unpeaceable and uncharitable a Thought or Carriage capable of such a Construction which all Christians should as ill endure to lodg within them as the
K. CHARLES I. ΕΙΚ. ΒΑΣΙΛ 27. To the Prince of Wales BEware of exasperating any Factions by the Crossness and Asperity of some Mens Passions Humours and private Opinions imployed by you grounded only upon Differences in lesser Matters which are but the Skirts and Suburbs of Religion Wherein a charitable Connivance and Christian Toleration often dissipates their Strength whom rougher Opposition fortifies THE Conformist's Third Plea FOR THE Nonconformists Argued from the King's Declaration concerning Ecclesiastical Affairs Grounded upon the approved Doctrine AND Confirmed by the Authorities of many Eminent Fathers and Writers of the Church of England By the Author of the two former PLEAS Lord Bishop of Cork's Protestant Peace-maker Pag. 128. To these who ask What need of more Vnion I return What need of more Holiness What need of Godliness Charity Justice Are these Christian Duties and is not Vnion and Peace as much so I am and must be in the mind that the Strength of the Protestant Cause both here at home and throughout Christendom lies in the Vnion of Protestants and the Glory Purity and Fower of Christianity in this World stands or falls with Protestantism LONDON Printed by J. D. for Jonathan Robinson at the Golden Lion in St. Paul's Church-Yard MDCLXXXII A PREFACE to the Christian and Peaceable Reader that seeks the things that be of Christ A Zeal for Peace and Vnion hath overcome all Discouragements arising from many Causes and inspired me to a Boldness prevailing against much Fear even to publish the secret Workings of my Heart As long as the Church dare shew her Face my Notions are not afraid of the Light they can receive no Luster from my Name let them go forth in that Light and Power which the Father of Lights and the God of Peace hath given and shall give unto them and if they may but give any Light to discover the way of Peace let me not only ly in Obscurity which I love because fittest for me but be disgraced by them who speak all manner of Evil of me If I have not forsaken and betrayed the Truth I have not forsaken nor betrayed the Church and when you come to see the Weapons which I handle and the Leaders and Authorities which I follow in the following Treatise as well as the Cause for which I plead I hope you will be convinced that as far as I have pleaded for the Nonconformist Brethren I have not run from my Colours There is common Truth a large and spacious ground to take them in and to build up one and the same Fabrick upon it comfortable to all true Christians receptive of all the Family of God and impregnable against all their and our Enemies It is some Relief and Comfort to see many lift up their Feet i. e. come and view the Desolations of the Church of Christ among us to be affected with them and some in whom is an excellent Spirit are contriving to bring the separate Apartments under one Roof and within one Line and Wall And these do stand upon the Rock of Evangelical Principles when not supported by the Arm of Flesh But no sooner do Arbitrators move for a Reconciliation but others do all they can to thrust them from them without respect to their Persons or due Reverence to Truth and Reason He that interposeth in this Difference doth at the Peril of Opposition The R. Rev. Author of the first Naked Truth hath found this true though his Quality and Person were more than guest at yet the Episcopal Staff could not bear off the Lashes of several Junior Writers from the Back of Naked Truth But Truth be it never so naked can bear Blows and Lashes as it hath always born the Violence of Storms and Times Truth cannot long be confined within Doors but will appear in open view whatever its Entertainment be whether Scorns Contradictions Laughter and Mockery Abuses and Scourgings or Approbation and Honour The Appearance of such a Book as that Naked Truth at such a time was like a Comet it drew the Eyes of all that could to look upon it it was a Divine Manifestation of a Primitive Christian-Spirit of Love And certainly as that pious Endeavour hath encreased his Comforts so he hath not lost all his Labour for since that we have had more Overtures of Peace than we heard of in the many Years of Discord and Troubles from the Learned in the Church of England The Nonconformists have born all the Blame and Scorn and Sufferings of our Divisions and have offered as much towards Peace and Accommodation as was possible for them to offer But partly their Writings and the doleful State of Religion have drawn out some Wishes and Concessions from some Men of Eminency in the Church towards Peace and Accommodation And tho these as yet seem too little yet there is much to be gathered from them first as to their Propensity to Peace 2. The Influence which their Concessions may have upon austerer Tempers 3. Because they being satisfied in the Point of Conformity as to their own Practice do yet for a greater Good and Peace incline to a Comprimise The Learned Dean of St. Paul's hath with submission to Authority made some Proposals and I hope would yield to more if the Composure were put into his hand Even Dr. Sherlock who is currantly thought to have writen the Defence of Dr. Stillingfleet Pag. 103. doth wish with all his Heart that some Expressions were altered to prevent any Scandal to the scrupulous or to the profane this he writes only for the Office of Burial of the Dead which he calls an excellent Office supposing the due Exercise of Church-Discipline to cast all notorious Sinners and Schismaticks out of the Communion of the Church which the Church supposeth to be done I am of his Mind Pag. 102. concerning the Excellency of that Office It is most comfortable to the Minister and most Comfort to all true Christians when we can use it upon good Evidences concerning the Dead But as the visiting of the Sick hath been too often to me the most uncomfortable Office of my Ministry so it hath been a great Addition of Sorrow to commit those Bodies to the Earth concerning whom I had no hope of their resting in Christ O what dejecting Stories could I write of too many but I forbear If he be so sensible of the ill use which may be made of that excellent Office and do so heartily wish that some Expressions were altered to prevent Scandal to the scrupulous and prophane methinks for the same Reasons he might wish more Alterations might be made in other things and Offices Most frank and generous are those Expressions of the Right Reverend and Pious Bishop of Cork Protestan-Peacemaker p. 29. We are ready to sacrifice all we can otherwise i.e. without Schism to the publick Peace and Safety what most of the Dissenters would be at no Liturgy no Episcopacy no Vniformity may not be cannot be without
Devil himself or expose our Brethren to Temptations and Sufferings let us all most earnestly pray for Peace and Union and lay aside all Thoughts and Passions which are the beginnings of Schism And so I come to the last Query Query 3. Whether we ought not to unite as abovesaid and so to unite and become one by the removal or abating the things which divide and break us so that we may hold mutual and actual Communion in the same Exercise of Religion without fear of offending our Superiours or any other That we ought to unite is the Cry and Voice of all in whom Christianity doth but faintly breath and the Spirit of God hath any effect or Interest but the Quomodo is most difficult in this as in many other Operations I have betrayed my self and discovered my poor Opinion in the very Question by removing and abating the things which divide and break us But it appears clear to my Apprehension that no other way or means will ever do If the Dissenters should be miraculously convinced or charmed into a Consent then that which was a Cause of dissent is become as no Cause and while their Understandings stand at this distance and they be but sincere and obedient and honest to their own Thoughts and Judgments they can never come over to us and to use force without Reason is the way to drive them from God when we pretend to drive them to Church Would we have them act against the settled Dictates of their Conscience and is Force the way to convince the Conscience And really what hath been offered to inform their Understandings hath been ineffectual to that End Is it likely such Writtings that convey neither Love nor distinctive Reasonings will ever perswade Men better studied in their own Case than they that unite against them Is it likely that a display of Words and sounding the Trumpets not to call the Congregation together to unite in Love and Peace but to alarm People to arm themselves and to watch as against Seditious Persons will ever incourage them to come in and unite with us We must argue from better Topicks than Sarcasms Flouts Mockery Emulation Wrath and Reviling these Deeds of the Flesh will never allure Men to walk with us in one Spirit There are large Encomiums of Unity and Peace and every part of the Encomium or praise of it contains an Argument in perswado us to it And two mighty Arguments should at this time prevail with us * Since this was written I find the Right Reverend Bishop of Cork â—â—se these two Arguments in terminis p. 29. of the first excellent Sermon Necessity and Self-preservation we see our apparent Dangers by being scattered abroad like an Army in a Rout or Disorder or Tumult while our Potent Enemies are united against us We cry out upon Dissenters as factious but were it not for a Factious Spirit among our selves they had never been thus broken and separated from us Our Life our Delights our Happiness doth consist in or spring from Union after this our Desires do run or fly they move at no slower rate Our Death Sorrows Griefs and Unhappiness doth follow our Separation from the things wherein Life Delight and Happiness consist A divided State is an unhappy State Charity is the Bond of Perfectness when Charity dies then the Church is like a Princely Family broke up dispersed and divided They who do not love cannot unite but make a Breach and Separation The uncharitable Man is the factious Man To impute Factiousness to one Party who would unite but cannot and to excuse another who may unite but will not is to judg with too apparent a Partiality for an equal Judg. Had the upper side but the very same Reasons and Arguments which now the oppressed use and urge for themselves they would be of Authority and very considerable if not unanswerable whereas now they are look'd upon as weak and scorned as ridiculous Favour and Authority gives Force and Weight to the Reasons of them that enjoy the benefit of the Favour and when Persons are exposed to Contempt their strongest argnings are despised as weak and their loudest Complaints are not heard but rebuked as causeless and themselves branded as a Faction tho they are Catholick and Loyal in their Faith and Principles And this is plain the Nonconformists have found it so their Arguings Representations Complaints which have been but few Motions Supplications Apologies have been despised because they are despised and low in the World and a worldly Interest keeps them down I have sometimes thought that if Authority had been against the use of the Cross and commanded Mr. Parker to write his Book against it then he had been dignified with the Epithets that Mr. Hooker hath been adorned with of the Judicious Parker and the Profound Parker and the Excellent Parker whereas being on the decried side he hath been often laughed at The greatest number of Men consider more the Condition of the Person than the thing spoken or written by him and give him the greatest Honour by whom they may receive a Favour From this Partiality a Faction grows up and thrives exceedingly when it is fatned by the Richness of the Soil and influenced from some that sit above and hence it comes even from Partiality and Faction that the imputation of Faction is constantly thrown upon Dissenters because they do not what they cannot do with a good Conscience according to their Light But if all of us would set up God's Glory the Edification of his Church Truth Peace and Union in the middle as a Center and all of us that are scattered and divided in the Circumference run up to it by the Lines of Scripture-Rules then God would be more glorified than he is Vid. Cypr. de simplicitate Clericorum Unitas servatur in Origine the Church more edified and we more happy in Peace and Union than we are or if we were all affected to glorisy God to edify the Church and to keep the Unity of the Spirit in the Rond of Peace as long as we agreed and met in God as in a Center and the Lines of Holy Scripture tho we did not all run in on Line in one Way but different Ways Our Diversity would be without Schism and all our Divisions would be like the dispersing of a numerous Family without Alienation of Affection like the Distribution of the Patriarchs into their several Tribes inhabiting the Land of Canaan all of the same Blood the same Religion in the same Covenant with God Towards this Union we must confider I. Wherein it consists II. Remove the Causes of Division as much as possibly we can The Causes of Division are 1. Inward 2. Outward and apply our selves to the Means of Union III. Wherein the nature of Schism doth properly consist I. The Persons united are Christ and his Church under the Denomination of his Members his Body and his Spouse compared to several kinds