forth serpents of a sudden Contra. The excellency of the agent doth adde to the manner of the worke as to doe it sooner or better it addeth noâ— to the matter Angels working by naturall meanes doe it more admirably than nature can worke it of it selfe but beyond the strength of nature or against the course of nature they can doe nothing 3. Pererius misliking both these answers of Cajetane yet consenting to his opinion for the truth of this miracle addeth a third that Satan fetched those serpents and suddenly transported them into this place and suborned them in stead of the rods Cont. But the text saith the rods were turned into serpents the serpents then were not brought from any other place but there changed or seemed so to be Againe as here they turne their rods into serpents so afterward did they change water into bloud but that was not by transportation for from whence could Satan convey such abundance of true lively bloud which is not ingendred but in the body neither have they power to alter substances it was therefore done by collusion and so was this 3. Wherefore the founder opinion is that those serpents which the Egyptian Sorcerers brought forth were only such in shew not indeed or in truth so Iosephus writeth that the Magicians serpents In speciem ac similitudinem verorum serpentium reptasse did creepe in shew and likenesse of true serpents lib. 2. antiquit cap. 15. And Iustinus Martyr Those things which the Magicians did by the helpe of the Devill spectantium oculis praestigias offundebant did dazle and deceive and as it were cast â— mist before the eyes of the beholders quaest Orthodox 16. Tertullian Mosis veritas mendacium Magorum devoravit Moses trueth devoured their lie lib. de anima Gregor Nyssenus saith they were visus deceptione serpentes serpentes onely in the mistaking of the fight Ambrose calleth it commentitiam emulationem a fained emulation in cap. 3.2 Epist. ad Timoth. Hierome saith imitabantur signa quae faciebat Moses sed non erant in veritate They did imitate the signes which Moses did but they were not in truth lib. 2. advers Iovin The reasons of this opinion before alleaged are these 1. because solius divinae potestatis est It belongeth onely to the power of God to convert a dead substance into a living creature Rupert 2. Moses true serpents devoureth the other which Iosephus and Ferus urge as an argument that they were imaginary 3. Other signes which they did were only imaginary as the turning of water into bloud as is before shewed and so this also QUEST XXII By what meanes Satan deluded Pharaoh with a shew of serpents THis being then thus resolved upon that those were but serpents in shew and to the outward sense this counterfeit signe might be wrought two wayes by the operation of Satan 1. Either by the confounding the inward sense and phantasie of the beholders that they imagined to see that which was not as sicke men of phrensie doe conceive they see strange sights and there is no question but that the Devill can effect whatsoever by diseases or other naturall meanes may be wrought 2. Or else which is more like Satan did forme such a shape and shew of spirits as before is shewed that the Devill hath such power by illusions apparations and phantasies to deceive as the Apostles seeing Christ walking upon the seas supposed it had beene a spirit Phantasma that is a phantasticall apparition Mark 6.49 Ex Perer which sheweth that such illusions were usuall QUEST XXIII Why the Lord suffered the Sorcerers of Egypt to shew such contrary signes NOw the Lord suffered the Magitians thus by their lying signes to contend with Moses for divers weighty causes 1. That by this meanes Moses the faithfull servant of God and true Prophet might be the better knowne as darkenesse maketh the light more glorious and sicknesse health Chrysostome So Saint Paul saith There must bee Heresies that they which are approved among you might bee knowne 1. Cor. 11.29 2. That Moses might be freed from the imputation of being a Sorcerer which thing some have not beene affraid to object and a difference might appeare betweene his working by the power and in the name of God and of the Sorcerers working by the power of Satan Rupert 3. That thereby it might be made manifest how the truth hath alwayes gainesayers and is never without contradictions and oppositions as Lucifer opposed himselfe to God in heaven Cain to Abel in earth Ismael was against Isaack the true Prophets were molested by the false Thus Saint Paul collecteth that as Iannes and Iambres withstood Moses so these also resist the truth 2. Tim. 3.8 Perer. 4. Hereby also it is manifest how according to the common saying the Devill is Gods ape that he taketh upon him to imitate and counterfeit Gods workes that therefore wee should examine such workes and signes whether they be of God that wee be not deceived and as the Apostle saith cry every spirit 1. Ioh. 4.1 5. Another reason is that seeing the Devill by his ministers can doe such strange things that the servants of God bee not offended when thy see wonders and signes to be done in the false Church by Heretikes or Idolaters the instruments of Satan 6. This was permitted for the triall of the faith and constancie of Moses and Aaron and the rest of the Hebrewes whether because of the contrary signes they would doubt of the truth of Gods promises Perer. 7. And for the further hardning of Pharaohs heart as hee had deserved by his former sinnes that God might take occasion thereby to worke all his wonders in Egypt Simler Ferus Borrh. QUEST XXIV Whether Pharaoh being deceived by the Magicians false signes be thereby excusable BUt seeing these Magicians by their Satanicall craft doe so strongly deceive whether is Pharaoh to be excused that he doth not acknowledge Moses to be the Minister and Prophet of God To this the answer is that this notwithstanding Pharaoh is not to be held excusable because there are evident signes to have discerned betweene the working of the one and of the other so that Pharaoh could not plead ignorance To omit the differences before noted Quest. 20. how that true miracles differ from false in the power of working in the quality of persons that worke the worke it selfe the manner and the end which differences are not so easie to be discerned of all there were besides most notorious workes that discovered the hypocrisie and weaknesse of those Sorcerers 1. Moses serpent devoured theirs which required a greater power 2. They could counterfeit the like plagues but they could not remove the true plagues as Moses did 3. They faile in their working they could not bring forth lice nor counterfeit any of the plagues following 4. The plagues doe fall upon the Sorcerers themselves chap. 9.11 5. Lastly they themselves doe give way and confesse it was the finger of God By all these
tamen sequitur ex hoc quòd fuit idololatra and yet it followeth not hereupon that he was an idolater for howsoever Aaron thought in his heart the verie making of an idoll to be worshipped erecting of an altar and offering sacrifice unto it all which Aaron did doe proclaime him guiltie of externall idolatrie QUEST LXII Why idolatrie is called a great sinne THis great sinne 1. Idolatrie is counted a great sinne even in the highest degree because it is a sinne committed directly against God not as other sinnes of the second table which are done against our neighbour which are also against God because they are against his Law but not directly against Gods honor as the sins against the first table are 2. And among all the sins of the first table there is none which so directly impugneth the honour of God as idolatrie for he which taketh Gods name in vaine or prophaneth the Sabbath is an enemie to Gods honour but yet such an one denieth not the Lord to bee God as idolaters doe Tostat. qu. 33. 3. Like as then in a Common-wealth all offences are against the King because they are against his Lawes but those which are against his person are most directly against him and among them treason specially which is intended against his life of the same nature is idolatrie which is high treason against God 4. Thomas saith Tantum est aliquod peccatum gravius quanto longius per ipsum homo à Deo separatur A sinne is so much the more grievous the further wee are thereby removed from God but by infidelitie and idolatrie one is furthest separated from God 5. Idolatrie also is a great and grievous sinne in regard of the judgement and punishment which it bringeth with it for here Aaron as much as in him lay aâ—â—er fit ultimam cladem had brought upon them utter destruction Calvin if Moses had not turned the Lords wrath they had all beene at once destroyed QUEST LXIII Why Moses onely rebuketh Aaron and forbeareth further punishment NOw that Moses spared Aaron from further punishment and onely rebuked him 1. Some make this to be the cause for that the Lord had revealed unto Moses Aarons sinne in the mount before he came downe at what time Moses prayed also for him seeing the Lord bent to kill him Tostat. qu. â—5 But that intreatie for Aaron was afterward at Moses second going up to God when hee fasted fortie dayes and fortie nights as before at that time he saith he prayed for Aaron Deut. 9.20 And seeing at this time the Lord purposed to destroy all the nation and so Aaron could not escape Moses now onely prayed in generall for all Israel that God would not destroy the whole nation 2. Others thinke that Moses did after a milde manner reprove Aaron quiae sic arguendi praelati because Prelates and Ecclesiasticall Governours are so to be reproved Ferus he thinketh he was now the high Priest So also Oleaster calleth him Pontificem summum the chiefe Priest But as yet Aaron was not consecrated as Lippoman inferreth upon these reasons Quia non illi improperatur conspâ—râ—atum sacerdotium He is not upbraided with defiling of his Priesthood by this meanes neither doe we read of his reconciliation afterward which should not have beene omitted in such a case of irregularitie 3. Procopius thinketh that Aaron was both spared at this time and afterward likewise when he repined against Moses cum propter alias causas tum propter sanctos ex ejus lumbis prodituros Both for other causes as also for those holy mens sakes which should come out of his loynes But if this had beene the reason all the tribes should have beene spared likewise because out of all of them came holy and worthy men Judges Prophets or Kings 4. But the causes rather were these 1. Aaron confessed his sinne and therefore Moses inclined to favour him 2. Moses afterward intreated the Lord for him and the Lord at his instance forgiving his sinne the punishment also was remitted Simler 3. Adde hereunto that Aaron was now appointed to be high Priest order was taken for his priestly apparell and his office what it should be and how he and his sonnes should bee consecrated all which had beene in vaine if Aaron now had perished 4. Beside Moses had direction from God to put divers of the people to the sword for this offence but for Aaron hee had no such commandement 5. But Augustine yeeldeth the best reason Novit ille cui parcat c. God onely knoweth whom to spare for amendment and whom not to spare at all or for a time for his wayes and judgements are past finding out qu. 148. 5. Now whereas Tostatus further reasoneth that Moses by all likelihood had prayed for Aaron in the mount because then the Lord did specially reveale unto him his sinne for otherwise Moses had knowne nothing of Aarons doings as he did as it appeareth by this reprehension it may be answered that it is not necessarie for this cause to presuppose any such notice to have beene given unto Moses in the mount for either Moses might by examination and inquirie after hee came downe learne out the truth or which is rather like Moses Aaronem vicarium constituerat had left Aaron his deputie governour when he went up into the mount Simler and therefore he was sure that such a thing could not bee attempted in the host without Aarons permission at the least and sufferance QUEST LXIV What things are to be commended in Aarons confession what not Vers. 22. THen Aaron answered c. 1. Some things are to be commended here in Aarons confession 1. His modestie that being Moses elder brother yet hee calleth him Lord and submitteth himselfe unto him whereof these two reasons may be yeelded both because Moses was greater in office than Aaron both as a Prophet and Governour of Israel Tostat. qu. 32. and his owne conscience accused him agnoscebat sejure argui he knew he was worthily reproved 2. Aaron confesseth and acknowledgeth his fault in saying Let not the wrath of my Lord waâ— fâ—erce Agnoscit crimen hee therein yeeldeth himselfe to be in fault Borrh. 3. He maketh a full and large declaration of the manner rem gestam liberè confiâ—etur he freely openeth all the matter how it was done Pelarg. both what the people required and upon what reason and ground what he did and what came thereof rem ut gesta est simpliciter narraâ— he simply declareth the matter as it was done 2. But Aaron in some things sheweth his infirmitie 1. Peccatum culpam in alios trajicere studet Hee seeketh to turne over the sinne and offence upon others laying the fault upon the people Ferus 2. Aaron bewrayeth some hypocrisie that seeketh to extenuate his fault as much as he can being afraid nâ— aliquid de existimatione sua decodat lest he should lose any thing of his credit Simler 3. He sheweth his ignorance thinking
Mercer Wherefore in this manner to aske a signe not of distrust in Gods power or doubtfulnesse of his promises but with confidence in God nor prescribing unto him but onely desiring to be assured what is his good pleasure and this to doe not with any superstitious minde but with devout prayer and by the secret motion of Gods spirit it is no tempting of God at all But as Augustinus saith of Gedeon asking a signe Consultatio illa magis quà m tentatio fuit It was a consultation rather than a tentation Now seeing an entrance is made into this question concerning the lawfulnesse of such ghesses and conjectures as are made by mens speeches or behaviour of things to come as Abrahams servant desireth here to be informed by the answer and behaviour of the maid whether she were appointed to be Isaacks wife it shall not bee amisse some what more fully to discusse this matter QUEST XV. Of the divers kindes of conjecturall and ominous predictions THere are then foure sorts of such conjectures and ominous predictions of things to come The first are naturall which doe for the most part certainly foreshew that which followeth as the cause producing the effect as a cloud rising in the west causeth and foresheweth raine the Southwind heat Luke 14.55 or the effect doth sometime premonstrate the cause following as the lightning the thunder which though it be first seene and perceived by reason of the quicknesse of sight yet is it last done These signes and conjectures it is not superstitious or vaine to observe Secondly there are some humane conjectures which are taken by the words behaviour and actions of men as when the king of Israel had let fall a word calling Benhadad brother the messengers tooke it for a good signe the Latine translation saith acceperunt pro omine they tooke it for good lucke 1 King 20.22 they thereby gave conjecture of the kings favour So when the king Ahashuerosh had said of Haman will he force the queene also before me c. they tooke this as a signe of the kings displeasure and covered Hamans face Esther 6.8 The like in forraine stories is recorded of Tarquinius Superbus king of Rome who being sent unto by his sonne Sextus Tarquinius how hee should use the Gabii that had received him into their citie he gave no other answer to the messenger but topped the heads of the poppies in his garden with his staffe whereby his sonne perceived his meaning that he should make the chiefe of the citie lower by their heads By these humane conjectures we may ghesse of such things which are in mens owne power and purpose to doe but otherwise to catch at words and syllables and to make them as divine oracles it is a superstitious and ridiculous use as Cicero giveth an instance how when M. Crassus did ship his Armie at Brundusium one in the haven that brought figs from Cannus a citie in Caria chanced to crie out caricas canneas Cannean figges if Crassâ—s had taken this hint as a signe of evill lucke and gone no further he had not perished Tullie himselfe condemneth such observations as ridiculous for then saith he by the same reason pedis offensio abruptio corrigiae sternut amenta sunt observanda the stumbling of the foot breaking of the shooe point sneesing and other such things must be observed as ominous Perer. The third sort of predictions is divine which are either uttered by men inspired of God being well advised and knowing what they say as Ionathan encourageth himselfe with this signe thereunto directed by the spirit of God that if the Philistims should say come up unto us he would take it as a signe that God had delivered them into his hand and so it came to passe 1 Sam. 14.10 Sometime God directeth mens tongues to speake the truth unawares as Caiphas prophesied that it was better for one man to die for the people than the whole nation to perish Iohn 11.50 yet Caiphas understood not what he said of this kinde was that direction given unto Augustine much perplexed within himselfe what profession of life he should betake himselfe unto by a voice saying unto him Tolle lege Take up thy booke and read and then opening the booke hee light upon that place Rom 13.13 See that wee walke honestly c. not in gluttonie and drunkennesse chambering and wantonnesse c. by reading which sentence hee was resolved to reforme his life and to leave his youthfull pleasures The fourth kind of ominous predictions is superstitious and diabolicall whereof Augustine giveth his judgement thus Cum ad decipiendos homines fit spirituum seductorum operatio est VVhen it is done to deceive men it is the working of seducing spirits such was that conjecture of the priests and soothsayers among the Philistims that if the arke which they had put into a new cart went up the way by Bethshemesh then it is he that is the God of Israel that hath done this great evill 1 Sam. 6.9 This indeed came so to passe and the event answered the prediction whereby the devill cunningly wrought that those idolatrous priests and soothsayers should still retaine their credit and estimation Pausanias maketh mention of the like superstitious observation in the towne of Phare in Achaia where after the people had consulted with the oracle their manner was going away to stop their eares and the first voyce which they heard afterward they tooke as a divine oracle Pausan. in Achaic Cicero reporteth of Paulus Aemilius that preparing to goe against Perses king of Macedonia and seeing his daughter sad and she answering being asked the reason because her little dogge called Persa was dead saith he Accipio omen I take this as a signe of good lucke my daughter Such superstitious curious and vaine observations are not beseeming a Christian profession which Sathan useth as meanes to keepe men in a superstitious awe and feare and to seduce them from trusting in the providence of God QUEST XIV Why it is said that Rebecca was a virgin with this addition and unknown of man Vers. 16. A Virgin and unknowne of man c. Lest this might be thought a superfluous speech because she could not have bene a virgin unlesse she were unknowne of man divers interpretations are given 1. Some thinke that she is called a virgin in respect of her outward habit and unknowne of man for her chastitie Cajetan 2. Others that because there was a lewd use among the Gentiles to abuse other parts of the body to their filthy lust beside the place of virginitie they thinke shee is called not onely a virgin but altogether untouched or unknowne in any part of her body Rasi Rabbi Salomon 3. Some that she was not a virgin onely in body but unknowne of man that is not tempted in her minde of the devill Origen hom 10. in Genes 4. Some thinke this clause is added to shew a difference