though I have the Gift of Prophesie and understand all mysteries and all knowledge addeth neverthelesse vers 10. To another is given the working of miracles to another Prophesie distinguishing the Grace of foretelling things to come from the wisdome and knowledge inspired by the Holy Ghost which are all sometimes comprehended under one Grace of Prophesying But that which the Apostle calleth REVELATION is without doubt the disclosing of secrets That I take to be questionlesse by what we find afterwards vers 24 25. But if all Prophesie and there come in one that believeth not or one unlearned he is convinced of all he is judged of all and thus are the secrets of his heart made manifest and so falling down on his face he will worship God and report that God is among you of atruth S. Chrysostome here 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 It is not the same for a man to come in and see one speaking of Greek another Persian as it is to heare the secrets of his own mind and whether he came in to try with an evil mind or with a sound one and that he hath done this or that for this is much more terrible and usefull then that To this purpose he alledgeth Nebuchadnezzars act falling down before Daniel upon the discovery of his dream ii 47. And that under the Old Testament Revealing of secrets was a thing required at their Prophets hands By the way we may perceive by that which Saul and his Fathers servants did 1. Sam. ix 6. repairing to Samuel to inquire of his Fathers Asses that were strayed From whence we must conclude that this Grace of PROPHESYING under the New Testament was of immediate inspiration of the Holy Ghost to all purposes as under the Old For you shall find vers 30. If Revelation be made to another that sitteth by let the first hold his peace To shew us that some were inspired upon the very point of time with the truth of matters in debate at their Assemblies as was Jehaziell sonne of Zachariah at the meeting which Josaphat had assembled 2. Chron. xx 14. As were those by whom Paul and Barnabas were sent Acts xiii 2. And those by whom Timothy was ordained 1. Tim. iv 14. And as that Maid at least pretended to be of whom Tertullian De Anima c. ix Besides we see how often these Prophets of the New Testament are inspired to foretell things to come And in reason the Gift of Languages being inspired both for the subject and the tongue in which it is expressed it is certain that the Gift of Prophesying is not contained within humane conceptions And indeed the Offices specified out of the Apostle of Edifying Exhorting Comforting of Speaking words of wisdome and knowledge of mysteries may well be referred to that rank of inspirations whereby a man is moved to speak that which the use of his humane reason inableth him not to conceive with assurance that the motion is from the Holy Ghost which kind of inspirations are counted Prophesies even among the Ebrew Doctours as hath been said And in this kind the Exposition of Scripture is not without cause understood under the Gift of Prophesying in this place The Commentaries intituled to S. Ambrose Prophetas dicit Interpretes Scripturarum Sicut enim Propheta futur a praedicit quae nesciuntur ità hic dum Scripturarum sensum qui multis occultus est manifestat dicitur PROPHETARE By Prophets he meaneth Expositours of the Scriptures For as a Prophet foretelleth things to come which are not known so such an one manifesting the meaning of the Scripture which many perceive not is said to PROPHESIE The same is to be found again in him and others divers times not so much because the Apostle hath specified here any such part of Prophets office as because the rules which he prescribeth in Prophesying afterwards from vers 29. do plainly belong to those that had the Scripture in hand to expound as shall appear afterwards Therefore it is plain that these Propheticall inspirations were seen in the Exposition of Scripture because it is that upon which the Apostles rule proceedeth vers 30. If revelation be made to another sitting by let the first hold his peace meaning that he that was expounding the Scripture should give way to him to whom the truth of it was revealed upon the instant of time But there is something else besides this belonging to the Gift of Prophesying as well as of Languages For the Apostle from vers 14. here thus writeth If I pray in an unknown tongue my spirit prayeth but my understanding is unfruitfull What is it then I will pray with my spirit but I will pray with understanding also I will sing with my spirit and I will sing with understanding also Else when thou shalt blesse with the spirit how shall he that occupieth the place of the unlearned say Amen at thy giving of thanks seeing he understandeth not what thou sayest For thou verily givest thanks well but the other is not edified It is not so clear how the Apostle here saith My spirit prayeth but my understanding is unfruitfull having said afore He that speaketh in a tongue edifieth himself For if he that hath the Gift profiteth in the understanding of the mysteries which the spirit suggesteth to him in a strange Language how is his understanding unfruitfull Therefore S. Chrysostome acknowledging this difficulty yieldeth that some of them which had this Grace understood what they said others not for thus he writeth upon these words He that speaketh in a strange Language edifieth himself 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 And how if he know not what he saith But thus farre he speaketh of those that understand what they say but know not how to expresse it to others But the words of Theodoret are thus in the Greek of Oecumenius 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 That is He meaneth by SPIRIT the spirituall Grace but by UNDERSTANDING the declaration and interpretation of things that are spoken By thus expounding the word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 to signifie a meaning understood he seemeth to reconcile the text with that afore without acknowledging that they understood not what they spake in strange Languages According to which sense 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 beareth this interpretation my meaning is fruitlesse to wit to the hearers not yielding them the fruit required of it and again 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 is I will pray in a meaning understood Whether the words will bear this meaning or not let men of learning judge The thing is probable enough seeing the fault which the Apostle findeth vers 17. is not that a mans self is not edified but saith he another is not edified And if we follow the intent of the Apostle close it will easily appear that the purpose of his speech requireth more then that a man himself should understand what he speaketh in an unknown tongue to wit that his Audience also should understand it And therefore let who will
dispute the proper signification of his words a thing not so seasonable in this place so long as the drift and purpose of the argument guideth and over-ruleth the sense when he saith I will pray and sing with my SPIRIT I will pray also and sing with UNDERSTANDING to be this I will pray and sing by inspiration but it shall be in a meaning understood or understandable according to the words of Theodoret alledged afore 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 And it followeth thus 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Now he saith It is fit that he that speaketh in another tongue whether singing Psalmes or Praying or Teaching should either interpret himself and understand what he saith for the benefit of his hearers or that another should do it that is sufficient to be taken for an Assistant to his Doctrine The words inclosed are added by Oecumenius desiring to jumble S. Chrysostomes Interpretation and Theodorets into one which proceed from contrary opinions for all the rest besides those words is extant in the Latine of Theodoret who hath delivered the right of the Apostles meaning That it is requisite for him that speaketh tongues to interpret supposing that he understandeth what he saith The same sense is expounded by S. Basil Reg. Brev. 278. otherwise the nature of this Branch of the Gift of Languages is truly set down by S. Chrysostome in these words 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 For of old there were many that had the Grace of Prayer with that of Language and they prayed and the tongue praying spake the Persian or Romane Language but the mind knew not what was said In that he thinketh that he which had the Gift understood not what he said I have shewed for what cause I leave him afore but in that he saith They had a Grace of Praying with that of Languages as a branch of it it shall further appear how right he is afterwards The more I marvell that the learned Heinsius of late should so disguise the meaning of this whole passage in expounding that appertenance of this Gift of Languages whereof the Apostle speaketh here vers 13. Wherefore let him that speaketh in an unknown tongue pray that he may INTERPRET The meaning whereof he maketh this When a man hath spoken in an unknown tongue let him repeat the summe of it in his prayer afterwards and so interpret his meaning in a known Language These are some of his words Siquis ergò inquit linguâ peregrinâ usus est adjungat preces quibus antedictainterpretetur Peregrinâ enim linguâ preces si concipiantur frustrà fit hoc certè quia non intelliguntur If a man have used a strange language saith the Apostle let his prayers follow wherein he may interpret what he said afore For if prayer be conceived in an unknown tongue sure it is to no purpose being not understood Thus do men sometimes imploy their wit and learning to make things obscure that are plain enough when they are let alone But though as he saith it is now in use in divers Churches to recapitulate the Sermon in a prayer after it yet it concerned him to have shewed us some trace or step of like practice in the writings of the Apostles or Primitive Christians if he would have us to believe this to be the meaning of the Apostle Now the Apostle as he speaketh of praying so he speaketh of singing of blessing of giving thanks with the Spirit and with understanding these are no dependances of that which was preached afore therefore neither that Praying whereof he speaketh here For you heard what Theodoret said afore 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Whether in praying or in singing Psalms or in Teaching And you shall see what the Apostle saith afterwards vers 26 27. When ye come together every one of you hath a Psalme hath a Doctrine hath a Tongue hath an Interpretation Let all things be done to edifying If any man speak in an unknown tongue let it be by two or at the most by three and let one interpret Where as Theodoret hath well expressed his meaning that all things as well singing of Psalmes as teaching matter of Doctrine and Theodoret had cause to adde Praying finding it afore vers 15. might be done to the best purpose of edifying his will is that whatsoever is spoken in any of those kinds in a strange Language be interpreted by one whether the same that spoke already or another that had the Gift to do it In fine to make appear that the Apostle when he saith vers 13. Let him that speaketh in an unknown tongue pray that he may Interpret intendeth that he should pray for the Gift of Interpreting that which he was inspired to speak in a strange Language It shall here be declared that the Apostle directeth them to labour after these Graces by their Prayers as well as by their Studies or what means else they could addresse to God for the attaining of them That which we saw practised by the Disciples of Prophets under the Old Testament that we shall see prescribed by the Apostle under the New when he saith 1. Cor. xii 31. But be zealous of the best Gifts and 1. Cor. xiiii 1. Be Zealous of spirituall Gifts and again Let him that speaketh in an unknown tongue pray that he may Interpret Where S. Chrysostome 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Here he sheweth that it is in them to receive the Grace For LET HIM PRAY saith he that is Let him contribute that which is required at his hands for if thou ask studiously thou shalt receive it When he expoundeth Let him pray to be Let him contribute what is required from him he meaneth that Zeal and Study which is spoken of in the other places of which you have again vers 39. Be zealous or studious of Prophesying and forbid not to speak with Tongues and 1. Thess v. 20. Despise not Prophesying The like you shall find in S. Chrysostome upon Cor. xii 31. and the Commentaries under S. Ambrose his name upon 1. Cor. xiiii 32. The Spirits of the Prophets are subject to the Prophets Idcirco dixit SUBJECTUS EST PROPHETIS ut ingenia accenderet hâc spe quòd Spiritus conatus adjuvet Therefore he saith IS SUBjECT TO THE PROPHETS to incourage wits with hope that the Spirit helpeth their endeavours And by and by he draweth to this purpose the words of the Apostle For they drank of the spirituall Rock that followed them and addeth Hoc est enim subjectum esse quod est sequi Ità Spiritus Subjectus dicitur ut conatus bonos adjuvet cùm perficit Subjectus enim videtur qui coepta alterius perficit For to be subject is the same as to follow So the Spirit is said to be Subject because of his help to good endeavours when he bringeth them to passe For he that bringeth anothers undertakings to effect seemeth to be subject This is not to allow this meaning of the Apostles words which I shall shew afterwards
to be otherwise but to take notice what impression of this truth they received from the places alledged And you shall find the same Authours to let passe others expounding the Apostles words Rom. xii 3 6. no otherwise According as God hath dealt to every man the measure of Faith and whether Prophesying according to the proportion of Faith S. Ambrose Haec ergò datur pro modo accipientis hoc est quantum causa exigit propter quam datur This therefore that is Prophesie is given according to the measure of him that receiveth that is as much as the cause requireth in respect whereof it is bestowed And S. Chrysostome 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 For though it be a Grace it is not indifferently poured forth But taking the measure from them which receive it floweth upon them in measure as it findeth the vessel of faith offered understanding that faith which moveth men to sue to God for such Graces as he saith pray that he may Interpret And this is it which the Apostle writeth to Timothy 1. Tim. iv 13 14. Till I come give attendance to reading to exhortation to doctrine neglect not the Gift that is in thee which was given thee by Prophesie with the laying on of the hands of the Presbytery And 2. Tim. 1. 6. Wherefore I put thee in remembrance that thou stirre up the Gift of God that is in thee by the putting on of my hands For in calling it a Gift he signifieth an extraordinary Grace of that time but in willing him to stirre it up and not to neglect it he sheweth that it was in him to procure it at Gods hands by reading and teaching and praying and the like means which he nameth or nameth not The true meaning then of the Apostle when he saith vers 14 15 16 17. For if I pray in an unknown tongue my spirit prayeth but my understanding is unfruitfull What is it then I will pray with the spirit but I will pray with the understanding also I will sing with the spirit but I will sing with the understanding also Else when thou shalt blesse with the spirit how shall he that possesseth the room of the unlearned say Amen at thy giving of thanks seeing he understandeth not what thou sayest For thou verily givest thanks well but the other is not edified I say the meaning of this whole passage supposeth that which we began to prove of the Prophets under the Old Testament that it was part of their Office to compose the praises of God and the prayers of their Congregations For if we take not our marks amisse we shall see that the strength of our advantage upon these words against the Church of Rome lieth in this because the Apostle argueth expressely against them that to shew their Gift of Languages took vpon them not onely to utter the mysteries of God in strange Tongues but also in them to conceive Prayers and Psalmes of Gods praises in the name and behalf of the Church This they are desirous to decline if the Apostle would give leave For that which he saith vers 17. ANOTHER is not edified is as much as we find vers v. and vers xii that the CHURCH may be edified and vers xix In the Church I had rather speak five words to teach OTHERS and the Apostle afterwards vers 16. What is it then my brethren when you come TOGETHER every one of you hath a Psalme And to this purpose it will be very effectuall to observe That as in the Old Testament Saul and his servant are said to meet a whole Quire of Prophets Prophesying and the sonnes of Asaph Heman and Jeduthun are said to Prophesie in singing the praises of God which the spirits of Prophets had indited so in the New Testament for the same cause it seemeth that singing the praises of God is called Prophesying by the Apostle For let me ask what the Apostle meaneth when he saith 1. Cor. xi 5. Every woman praying or PROPHESYING with her head uncovered his speech concerning Christian Assemblies wherein he forbiddeth a woman to speak 1. Cor. xiiii 34 Is it that which the Italian Glosse of Diodati after Beza hath expounded It seemeth saith he this word is to be taken here not onely for handling or expounding the Mysteries of the word of God as Rom. xii 6. but also for hearing them marking them meditating upon them while they are proposed of those that have the Charge This cannot be allowed Praying is the parties own act why not PROPHESYING that standeth in rank with it The Commentaries under S. Ambrose his name Prophetari autem est adventum fore Domini voce Symboli post Orationem effari To Prophesie is to pronounce in the words of the Creed that the Lord shall come The Creed was pronounced by the whole Congregation this he thinketh was called Prophesying because it speaketh of the coming of Christ which shall be I bring not this because I allow it for it is somewhat strange to make all people Prophets that say their Creed because one Article of it speaketh of things to come besides I do not find that the Creed was from the beginning any part of the Church-Service But because he saw the true point of the difficulty that hearing Prophesies was no Prophesying but it must be something that the Congregation uttereth as well as in Praying which the Apostle calleth Prophesying And what doth the whole Congregation send forth but Prayers and Psalmes In both these as near as can be the people bear their part the whole pack of Prophets Prophesied together when Saul and his servant and his messengers came because they all joyned in the Praises of God Samuel guiding the Quire when the Spirit of God came on them they uttered the Praises of God which the Spirit of God suggested the rest bearing part in their sense Isidore Pelusiota lib. ii Epist 90. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 The Apostles of our Lord and Teachers of our Orders desirous to suppresse idle talking in Churches understandingly permitted women to sing in them I know there are other Texts of the Apostle where he speaketh in generall to all persons to sing Psalmes Ephes v. 18 19. Be filled with the spirit speaking to your selves in Psalmes Hymnes spirituall songs singing making melody in your hearts unto God And Coloss iii. 6. Teaching and admonishing one another in Psalmes Hymnes and spirituall songs singing with grace in pure hearts unto God yet with good right are these words referred to no place but this because expresse mention of women singing in Assemblies we find none but here If any man thinketh that Isidore in those words reflecteth not upon any thing delivered in writing by the Apostles but of the custome which the Church received at their hands It must needs neverthelesse seem the most probable sense of S. Pauls words which maketh them agree with that custome which he saith the Church received from the Apostles Tertullian de Virg.
the understanding of the Scripture and of matters debated upon it vers 25. and 30. the Praises of God and the Prayers of the Congregation which were inspired in strange Languages as it is said vers 14. My spirit prayeth but my understanding is unfruitfull and therefore were no lesse inspired to them of whom the Apostle vers 15. I will pray and sing with the Spirit and with understanding In fine there is no cause to make doubt that all the particulars through this whole Chapter ranged under the generall Grace of Prophesying are by him understood to proceed from men indued with immediate inspirations And therefore the question wil be What is his meaning in that which followeth vers 32. The Spirits of the Prophets are subject to the Prophets for on the one side when he saith The Spirits of the Prophets the word SPIRITS in this subject hath alwayes signified inspirations true or pretended on the other side the inspirations of the Holy Ghost are not to be subject are not to be judged as vers 29. though it be by Prophets The meaning of these words give me leave thus to debate S. Ambrose thinketh that when it is said The Spirits of the Prophets are subject to the Prophets a reason is given for the Rule which commandeth to speak by turns and to give way to him that is inspired upon the instant vers 29 and 30. to shew that this they might well do because they were not so inspired by the Holy Ghost as to be transported to speak whether they would or not but that it was in them to moderate as it was in them to procure the influence of it according to his words produced afore In this sense the Spirits of Prophets are subject to the Prophets themselves But though we grant that mens particular indeavours were means to attain the Grace of immediate inspirations as was proved yet we are not therefore bound to grant that it was in them to be inspired at their pleasure In the Old Testament it is said That the Spirit of the Lord CAME upon Saul and his servants and Jer. xlii 7. After ten dayes the word of the Lord CAME to Jeremiah having undertaken to pray for the revealing of the will of God to them before from whence the Ebrew Doctours collect that he could not obtain the Grace in the mean time Maimoni Fundam Legis viii 5. and the late Annotations there Besides this sense is impertinent to the Apostles purpose who when he saith vers 29. Let the Prophets speak two or three and let the others judge speaketh of things brought from home and conceived afore the time of meeting as you may see vers 26. When you come together every one of you hath a Psalme and so forth But when he saith vers 30. If revelation be made to another as he sitteth let the first hold his peace he speaketh of that which is inspired at the instant of time And therefore it seemeth more reasonable to conceive that the Apostle when he saith vers 31. ye may all Prophesie one by one rendereth a reason for what he had said in commanding them to speak by turns that all might contribute to the edification of the Church as it followeth there That all may learn and all may be comforted But when he addeth And the Spirits of the Prophets are subject to the Prophets he rendereth a reason for what he said in commanding the other to judge because if some should not yield to the judgement of others the confusion and unquietnesse ensuing hereupon might be imputed to the Ordinance of God Theodoret after S. Chrysostome Ità Jesus subjiciebatur Mosi ità Elizaeus Eliae ità ipsi Elizaeo multitudo Prophetarum ità ipsi Apostolo Timotheus Titus reliqui So was Josue subject to Moses so Elizeus to Elias so a number of Prophets to Elizeus so Timotheus Titus and the rest to the Apostle And this sense Calvine embraceth According to which the judgement whereof the Apostle speaketh if we conceive it to concern immediate inspirations must not be understood to call them to account as for the truth of that which the Holy Ghost inditeth but to consist in judging the meaning and consequence of things inspired which even the persons from whom they came though not ignorant throughout as not bereft of their senses and understanding in Prophesying yet were not able themselves to sound to the bottome Do we not see the Prophet Daniel ix 2. studying about the seventy years which the Prophet Jeremiah had foretold for the desolations of Jerusalem whereupon he prayeth and obtaineth the Revelation of the seventy weeks And the Apostle 1. Pet. i. 10 11. expressely affirmeth that the ancient Prophets who Prophesied of Salvation by Christ searched and enquired diligently about it and the time of it whereof the Spirit within them Prophesied And to shew that it was no otherwise with them that were endued with like spirituall Graces under the New Testament it is to be observed with what earnest obtestations the Apostle dealeth with the Thessalonians 2. Ep. ii 1 2. not to be troubled as if the day of Christ were at hand either by SPIRIT or by word or by letter as from us For if the Spirit spake it how are they otherwise to be perswaded Is it because the Apostle speaketh of pretended inspirations So it is said indeed but them he had instructed them to discern 1. Thess v. 21. How then shall we think that the Apostle beseecheth them not to be moved with that which the Spirit spake but as it might be a meaning collected out of words spoken by some man that had such Graces And therefore in 1. Tim. iiii 1. the Apostle thus writeth 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 The Spirit speaketh EXPRESSELY saith the Apostle making that a different thing from the meaning apprehended or collected from things which the Spirit spake And to my apprehension we have an eminent instance hereof in the Apostle himself who having had a Revelation Acts xix by which he purposed in the Spirit when he had passed through Macedonia and Achaia to go to Jerusalem saying After I have been there I must also see Rome under this resolution writeth to the Romanes in that Epistle dated not long afterwards xv 23. That he had now no place in those parts and to the Elders of Ephesus not long after that thus speaketh Acts xx 25. I know that ye all among whom I have gone preaching the kingdome of God shall see my face no more All which neverthelesse being afterwards at Rome he writeth to the Philippians from thence ii 24. That he hopeth to come to them shortly And to Philemon in the parts of Asia about the same time vers 22. To prepare him a lodging as hoping to be granted to them through their prayers Things which can no wayes stand with that which he had written afore that he had no longer place in those parts and that the Ephesians should see
they prayed by heart For the words sine Monitore quia de pectore of Tertullian affected alwayes to imitate and expresse the Greek are to my best apprehension the translation of that which is called in Greek 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 in English to say by heart and so they could not have shewed a passage more pregnant with the sense they intended to destroy That they prayed by prescript forms The fairest proof we can make that the Church after the Apostles time and the use of extraordinary Graces betook thēselves to prescript forms of Prayer as well as other parts of Gods Service will be from the parts of it The Psalmes of David in the first place do mix Prayers with the praises of God and are no extemporary conceptions yet were alwayes one of the first parts of publick Service as shall appear in due time As for other Hymnes of private composure Conc. Laod. Canon 15. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 That besides inrolled Singers that go up into the Desk and sing out of the Parchmine others ought not to sing in the Church Canon 59. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 That Psalmes of private persons must not be said in the Church These Canons seem to make opposition between those that came from private persons and those that were entered in the Church-books These onely to be sung out of those books by Clergie Chanters inrolled in the list of the Church that other persons might take no occasion to bring any into use besides those that were prescribed and received I find that to meet with the poison of Arrius sicut in principio was added to Gloria Patri in the Church-Service And I have heard that to meet with the poison of Pelagius they took up the custome to put Dei Gratia in Titles and Inscriptions of Letters But that the custome of using such set forms was taken up first because the Arian and Pelagian heresies conveyed and spread themselves by that means is strange news to heare It might have been said with more reason of the hymns of Valentinus so long afore which Tertullian taxeth De carne Christi C. xvii And let unpartiall reason answer the question Whether it be more like if any such thing were that they should make that advantage because set forms were then in practice or Whether the Church should fall to use that course because it was first taken up by these heresies In reading and expounding the Scriptures the question is not made But that is the particular wherein I must yield something of private conception to have been used in the Primitive Church-Service It is believed that in the flourishing times of the Church Preachers were wont in the beginning of their Sermons to commend themselves and their labours to Gods blessing the form is extant which S. Ambrose used neither do we find that it was not at their own choice But after the Sermon the Catechumeni or Hearers those that were under Penance those that were vexed with unclean spirits were dismissed with the severall Prayers of the Congregation Benedictions of the Bishop or Presbyter on their severall behalves When that was done the Prayers which were used at the Eucharist by the Congregation that was admitted to it were of two sorts as shall be shewed afterwards when I come to compare the Service which this Church useth with that of the Primitive The first was of those which the Apostle calleth Supplications and Intercessions not onely for the generall and particular necessities both of the Congregation and the members of it but of all members of Church and Common-wealth together or in particular which are the same for substance which have since been called Litanies The second was that Thanksgiving from which that Sacrament is still called the Eucharist because it was alwayes consecrated with it wherein remembrance was made of all the blessings of Gods Providence in particular that of our Lord Christ which it pretendeth to commemorate with prayer that his Ordinance may be effectuall to the present I know there followed Thanksgiving after the Communion besides other pieces of that Service as shall be said which I regard not so much now because they seem not to have been of such consideration in the frame of their Service My intent is to show in due time that these were the prayers practised upon the Apostles order 1. Tim. ii 1. I exhort therefore before all that Prayers Supplications Intercessions and giving of Thanks be made for all men For kings and all that are in Eminence That they are the same which the Apostle intimateth and specifieth to have been practised at that time when he saith 1. Cor. xiv 15. I will pray with the Spirit but I will pray also with the understanding I will sing with the Spirit but I will sing also with the understanding else when thou BLESSEST with the Spirit how shall he that filleth the place of the ignorant say Amen at thy GIVING OF THANKS seeing he knoweth not what thou sayest In fine that these Intercessions whereof the Apostle speaketh Rom. viii 26. when he saith The Spirit it self INTERCEDETH for us with groans not to be uttered are the same which in the Primitive Church were solemn perpetual before Celabrating the Eucharist according to S. Chrysostomes Exposition averred afore This must be done after we have showed what reason there is to think that the Eucharist was celebrated at these Assemblies whereof the Apostle writeth to the Corinthians chap. xiv In the mean time as concerning the Prayers for Hearers Penitents and possessed Persons as well as the said Supplications Intercessions that they were all done by prescript form let me argue as I did afore of the Prayers of the Synagogue because they were ministred by the Deacon as S. Chrysostome said and as it shall appear afterwards by the remembrance we shall find of the Custome of the Church For I suppose no reason will yield that the Church referred themselves to be directed in their Publick Service by that rank of Ministers As for the THANKSGIVING which the Sacrament was consecrated with I will here use no more then the words of S. Cyprian de Lapsis Serm. xiv Vbi verò SOLENNIBUS adimpletis dare calicem Diaconus praesentibus coepit c. and in another place where he calleth it Calicem SOLENNI benedictione sacratum And ask whether the Eucharist were consecrated with an Ex tempore Prayer in Justine or Tertullians time the form whereof by S. Cyprians time was become SOLEMN Of the Preface Sursum Corda remembred by the same S. Cyprian de orat Domini and yet extant in all ancient Liturgies as well as ours as well as of other particulars there will be occasion to speak afterwards From that which hath been said of a prescript form of Prayer at celebrating the Eucharist I will take upon me to presume no lesse of other Services at other Assemblies Conc. Laod. Can. xviii taketh Order 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 That the
which the Rationalists call the Litanies to be that which remains of them the model of the Latine Service being so abbridged as was observed afore And by S. Ambrose or whosoever writ those books de Sacramentis it appeareth that prayer was made to that effect before the consecration of the Eucharist his words are iv 4. Oratio praemittitur pro populo pro Regibus pro caeteris Prayer is premised saith he to the Consecration of the Eucharist for the people for the Emperours for the rest But in those words he speaketh of prayers that were made at the Lords bord by him that celebrated the Eucharist of which afterwards not of those that were ministred by the Deacon speaking to the people in the manner aforesaid which neverthelesse S. Augustine of the Latine Church remembreth when he saith Epist 118. Cùm communis oratio voce Diaconi indicitur when Common prayer is indicted by the Deacons voyce for this is that which Justine Martyr called Common Prayer afore Rhenanus in Tertull. de Corona Et arbitrantur quidem illi Missam incepisse dicente Saceraote Dominus vobiscum mox Sursum corda Gratias agamus Domino Deo nostro And they truly that is those that studied the Ancient Form of Service out of the eldest and best Church-writers think that the Masse begins when the Priest sayes THE LORD BE VVITH YOU and by and by LIFT UP YOUR HEARTS afterwards LET us GIVE THANKS TO OUR LORD GOD. If his meaning be that the Celebration of the Eucharist began alwayes with the Preface Sursum corda well and good But if he mean this that the second Service or the Prayers at which Believers alone were present began then it is an oversight The testimonies produced are beyond exception to show that according to the most ancient Custome of the Church prayer was made for all states of men and of the Church first in the manner aforesaid In fine the great agreement of all the Liturgies specified coming from those most Ancient Eastern Churches with the eldest of Church-writers together with other pregnant circumstances that concurre make me bold to conclude that the practice of these prayers is derived from the Apostles and the Custome of their time and are the same whereof S. Paul writes Rom. viii 26 27. Likewise the spirit also helpeth our infirmities for we know not what we should pray for as we ought but the spirit it self maketh intercession for us with groanings which cannot be uttered And he that searcheth the hearts knoweth what is the mind of the spirit that it maketh intercession for the Saints according to God For according to the exposition of S. Chrysostome proved good afore these prayers which in the Primitive times were made by men indued with Prophetick Graces called here the Spirit were afterwards ministred by the Deacon going afore the people which holds good of these not onely according to all the Liturgies and Authorities alledged but according to Justine in chief and in the eldest place who when he relates that he which ministred the Eucharist began not but with the Thanksgiving after these which he calls the Common Prayers were ended gives presumption enough that the said Common Prayers were ministred by the Deacon with him as with S. Chrysostome Then the terms in which the Apostle expresses the nature of these prayers calling them Intercessions for the Saints seem to specifie the subject whereof we speak for all states of the Church And last when the Apostle saith maketh intercession for us with gronings not to be uttered and afore vers 23. Our selves also which have the first-fruits of the spirit even we our selves grone within our selves S. Chrysostome testifieth that the Correspondent hereof was done by the Deacon in his time with whom agree the words of Justine 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 wherein he witnesseth the earnest vehemence which these prayers were made with And in the prayers quoted in the Constitutions of the Apostles for the Hearers and Penitents which as hath been shewed were made after the same sort 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Let us beseech the Lord for them still more vehemently and in that for the faithfull at the end of it 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Let us stand up having vehemently prayed And to the Penitents in the beginning 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Pray ye that are under Penance vehemently And the Cyrie cleeson or Lord have mercy the foot and burden of this Prayer as you have seen in the Liturgies of S. Basil and S. Chrysostome is called 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and in that of S. Peter 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 understanding 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the Prayer of vehement and earnest supplication to God All Arguments of that vehemence and earnest devotion which the fashion and manner of the Litanies if it were relished aright still breatheth derived from those grones and tears with which men indued with Primitive Graces made then intercession to God for the Church and states of it And perhaps the Apostle when he said 1. Cor. xiiii 15. I will pray with the spirit but I will pray with the understanding also I will sing with the spirit but I will sing with the understanding also meant no other prayers but those whereof he writes to the Romanes those first sort of Prayers whereof here we speak at the Service of believers For in that which follows vers 16. Else when thou shalt blesse with the spirit how shall he that occupieth the room of the unlearned say Amen at thy giving of thanks seeing he understandeth not what thou sayest for thou verily givest thanks well but the other is not edified many things induce me to think that the Apostle speaks of nothing else but of that Thanksgiving which from the beginning the Eucharist was consecrated with and from which it hath the name and is the next point in the order of this Service For so the Apostles directions will appear complete reaching to all parts of the Service which proceed from mens particulars For the reading of the Scriptures we must here except presupposed as the subject and imployment of present Graces For the Psalmes of Gods praises which the spirit then indicted he provideth when he saith I will sing with the spirit but I will sing with the understanding also For the Exposition of the Scriptures more at large in the rules that follow from vers 26. For the Prayers which by the suggestion of the holy Ghost were made for the Church and all States of it when he saith I will pray with the spirit but I will pray with the understanding also For the Prayers which the Eucharist was celebrated with in the words now in hand vers 16 17. The Commentaries under S. Ambrose his name Hi ex Hebraeis erant qui aliquando Syrâ linguâ plerumque Hebraeâ in Tractatibus Oblationibus utebantur ad commendationem Gloriabantur enim se dici Hebraeos propter meritum Abrahae
Velandis cap. xvii Quantam autem castigationem merebuntur etiam illae quae inter Psalmos vel in quacunque Dei mentione retectae perseverant Meritóne etiam in oratione ipsa facilimè fimbriam aut villum aut quodlibet filum cerebro superponunt tectas se opinantur But what reproof shall even they deserve that continue unveiled in singing Psalmes or in any mention of God Have they reason in their very Prayers at their best ease to lay a fringe or thrumme or any thred upon the brain and think themselves veiled here you have the two particulars of Psalmes and Prayers expressed which the Apostle calleth Praying and Prophesying with the reason of reverence at the mention of God to inforce his purpose that they ought not to content themselves with no veil at Psalmes or with a slight one at Prayers And afterwards Oportet ergò omni tempore omni loco memores Legis incedere paratas instructas ad omnem Dei mentionem qui si fuerit in pectore cognoscetur in capite foeminarum It behooves therefore to walk mindfull of this Law at all times and in all places ready and provided against all mention of God who if he be in womens hearts wil be known on their heads expressing the Apostles reason Reverence at the mention of God And as for the Prayers of the Church we have a singular passage in the Apostle Rom. viii 26. to the best of my judgement to be understood to this purpose And the Spirit also helpeth our infirmities for we know not what to pray for as we ought but the Spirit maketh intercession for us with groanings which cannot be uttered For what is it that the Apostle calls the first fruits of the Spirit vers 23. there afore but the flowr cream of those spirituall Graces whereof the Apostle writeth all this while to the Corinthians And when he saith we know not what we should pray for as we ought true it is we are sufficiently informed what we are to pray for in the Scripture but seeing the purpose of the Scripture in generall is not so perfectly understood by all persons much lesse the Exigence of it duly pointed in particular it is no marvel if we believe that the inspiration of the holy Ghost is able far better to inform us what we are to pray for even at our Assemblies when we see the Apostle himself pray for the goad in the flesh to be removed which God thought not fit to be granted But when he saith the Spirit maketh intercession for us we know first that by the SPIRIT the Apostle in this subject continually understandeth the Inspirations of it as hath been observed afore we know again what endlesse debate difficulties the sense of these words breedeth and what better course have we to end them then by understanding in these words the intercessions which the holy Ghost inspireth And those unutterable groans of the Spirit whose mind he that searcheth the heart trieth vers 27. and findeth that it maketh intercession for the Saints according to God what are they else but those desires which the Spirit inspireth to them which have the first fruits of it causing them to groan within themselves waiting for the adoption to wit the redemption of the body as it went afore vers 13 For as men inspired were not able to expresse the vehemence of the desires they were inspired with no more were they able to comprehend the meaning of them the depth of things inspired being sounded by him alone that inditeth the same This exposition is S. Chrysostomes who hath delivered us the ground of it for Historicall truth upon the place telling us that there was no lesse peculiar an inspiration to pray at that time then there was to foretell things to come to cure diseases to do miracles to speak strange languages 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 With all these saith he there was also a Grace of Prayer which was also called A SPIRIT as the spirit of knowledge the spirit of wisdome and the like that is the spirituall Gift of it and he that had this prayed for all the multitude For because not knowing many of those things that are good for us we desire those that are not as here it is said We know not what to ask for as we ought the grace of Prayer came upon some man then and he stood up to desire in the name of all that which was good for the Church in Common and taught others to do it And again 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 For he that was vouchsafed this Grace standing with much compunction with many groans such as prostrate a man in mind before God asketh such things as are good for all Correspondent whereto now is the Deacon when he offereth to God the prayers for the people The opinion and relation of this most excellent man at expounding the Scripture going so clear with the words of the Apostle maketh this beyond question with me to be the meaning of the Apostle which shall afterwards get still more credit by the profer which shall be made of designing the kind and nature of these Prayers and Thanksgivings whereof the Apostle speaketh here to have been the same that the Church hath practised in all Ages since And these things supposed the meaning of the Apostle in the passage which we are in hand with sufficiently sheweth that as these which were indowed with the grace of Languages did not stick to do those things to utter the praises of God the prayers and thanksgiving of the people at their Assemblies in unknown tongues to make show of their Gift which he forbiddeth so those that had the Grace of Prophesying did and are directed to do the like for the benefit of the Congregation in all particulars whereof he speaketh These things thus cleared give us full assurance of the kindred between these two kinds of Graces of Languages and Prophesying by the limbes and branches of the offices expected from both and that by consequence all these Propheticall Graces were of immediate inspiration as much as that of Languages which the Apostle coming up to his first purpose in this whole discourse which was to regulate the use of both kinds of these Graces at their Assemblies further declareth in recapitulating those Offices of both vers 27. which he thinketh fit to remember there His words are these vers 26. How is it then brethren when ye come together every one of you hath a Psalme hath a doctrine hath a tongue hath a revelation hath an interpretation Let all things be done to edifying Tongues and Interpretations of them it is plain belong to none but those that have that Grace Revelations are specified afore to be a kind of Prophesying but there is no reason to convince that they might not be suggested in strange languages Psalmes it is plain by that which went afore were uttered in strange languages but the Apostle
OF RELIGIOUS ASSEMBLIES AND THE PUBLICK SERVICE OF GOD A Discourse According to Apostolicall Rule and Practice By HERBERT THORNDIKE HINC LVCEM ET POCVLA SACRA CAMBRIDGE Printed by Roger Daniel Printer to the Vniversitie and are to be sold at the Angel in Lombardstreet in London 1641. To the Readers THere is no such light to the true meaning of the Scripture as the practice of matters contained in it under the Synagogue first and in the Church afterwards This is the reason of the course held here in inquiring what was done or arguing what is to be done for the Publick Service of God It is not to be expected that the particulars here observed or discoursed under the judgement of this Church and the Learned in it should indifferently take place It is enough if the main foundation which I have given my thoughts a little freedome to dig for prove not fleeting Then may it serve for the edifying of it unto peace However you see wherefore writing in English neverthelesse I produce the passages of Writers in their own formall words You shall find them translated for the satisfaction of all sorts The learned Readers may please to excuse me if walking for the most part an untrodden path they find nothing but work cut out to be made up at leisure All may please to do so much right to themselves or me as to referre themselves to such things as the delay of the Presse hath given occasion to adde at the end before they begin to reade The Heads of matters here intreated are premised for the ease of such as make choice of what they think best to reade The Contents of the Chapters Chap. I. THe Publick Service of God the most eminent work of Christians How the form of it may be derived from the Scriptures The Subject and the Proceeding of this Discourse Chap. II. Dayes of Assemblies appointed by the Law The Morall Service of God not specified in it but collected from it How the Jews are taxed for spending the Sabbath in pastime Places of such Assemblies not provided in it The Priests charged to teach the Law by deciding controversies of it The Chair of Moses the Chair of Prophets High places to what purpose Beginning of Synagogues Disciples of Prophets studied to be Prophets They ministred the Morall Service of God in High places and Synagogues Chap. III. The profession of Scribes that succeeded the Prophets Wisemen of the Jews were the learned sort of Scribes Scribes of all the three Sects They taught in Synagogues Who were Lawyers Who sate in their Courts and of their Disciples The manner of their sitting in Schools and Synagogues How they sate in Feasting Of the Elders of Synagogues Who among them received Imposition of hands Chap. IV. Presbyteries of Churches with their Bishops answerable to the Jews Consistories made with Imposition of hands They sate in the Church as the other in the Synagogue That argueth their Office of Governing the Church And the difference of them from the people The Elders of the people in the Africane Churches were not of this rank What is the double Honour of Presbyters in S. Paul The Apostles Rule in discerning Spirituall Graces The Proceeding and Extent of his Discourse His Catalogue of Graces and Ministeries How divers of them may meet in the same man Doctours are those of the Presbyters that preached Helps were Deacons Chap. V. Prophets in most of the Churches remembred by the Apostles The gift of Languages the purpose and nature of it The Limbes and Branches of both these Graces in S. Paul Of praying and praising God by the Spirit Those that spake strange Tongues understood what they said Interpretation concerneth all that was spoken in strange Languages They prayed and studied for spirituall Graces Prophesying in S. Paul signifieth singing psalmes Prayers of the Church conceived by immediate inspiration The nearnesse of the Graces of Prophesying and Languages The ground and meaning of the Apostles Rule It proceedeth of none but Prophets What is to be judged in that which Prophets spake The custome in the Primitive Church of many preaching at the same Assembly came from hence Chap. VI. The parts of that work of Gods Service for which Christians assemble Psalmes of Gods praises part of the substance of it The ground and efficacie of Common prayers Reading the Scriptures a substantiall part of publick Service The necessitie and excellence of preaching for expounding the Scriptures The Eucharist the chief part of publick Service The Apostles Rule of Order and Comelinesse The force of Custome in preserving Order and of Reason in judging of Comelinesse All practice of the Primitive Church prescribeth not to us Correspondence with it necessary The practice of it in the point in hand of what advantage Order of Publick Service a Law of Christian Kingdomes Direction of Ministers of the Church requisite The Obligation of it The Agreement of the chief Reformers Chap. VII The prohibition of Quenching the Spirit concerneth immediate inspirations Prescript Form of Prayers as well as of other parts of the Service is for the Edification of the Church Order not to be maintained without it Three parts of the Service of the Temple The praises of God the Confession of sinnes the Priests Blessings The Service of the Synagogue prescribed Of the eighteen Benedictions Of the Service of their Fast of Seven dayes The Deacon ministred their Service Justine Martyr and Tertullian misunderstood Summe of the Church-service All Prescript Of Canons that prescribe the Service to be ordered by Councels Alterations in Liturgies Agreement of Reformed Churches Chap. VIII Of times of Assemblies Daily morning and evening Service is for the edification of the Church Humane Institution of Festivals lawfull Publick Service upon them and upon weekly and yearly times of Fasting is for increase of godlinesse Of frequent celebration of the Eucharist Houres of Prayer among the Apostles and Primitive Christians from the Synagogue Festivalls of the Law for gladnesse and those of humane institution in the Synagogue Of Fasting-dayes in the Synagogue and Primitive Church How the Eucharist was frequented in the Primitive Church The Order of this Church agreeable with the judgement of chief Reformers Chap. IX The reasons why it is for the edification of the Church to use Ceremonies in Publick Service It is avowed by the chief Reformers Of the respect of times and places Of the difference of Vestures and Gestures Caution in matter of Ceremonies The obligation of Rules whereby they are determined Chap. X. What is to be considered touching our Service The Service of Hearers and Believers Confession of sins whether of old the beginning of Service The ancient order of Psalmes and Lessons The Masse containeth an abridgement of it Severall manners of singing Psalmes Purpose of Lessons The Place of the Sermon Dismission of Hearers Originall of Litanies Prayer indicted by the Deacon The Thanksgiving from whence the Sacrament is called the Eucharist Prayer which it was celebrated
concerned the edification of the Church in doctrine whereof there he speaketh and of nothing else And thereupon conclude that Pastours and Doctours are both one there with the Apostle For what reason else can be rendered why there is no remembrance of Pastours in either of those other places wherein the Apostle maketh a more particular reckoning of the Ministeries of the Church both to the Romanes and to the Corinthians What reason but this Because they are set down in both places under the name of DOCTOURS Well may it seem that the Office of them whom the Synagogue called PASTOURS being referred in the Church to the inferiour Order of Deacons the name stuck upon those that ministred the food of the soul in the Church which is for the purpose of it Clemens Epist ad Cor. p. 63. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Be a man faithfull be a man able to utter knowledge be he wise in discerning discourses be he pure in works He seemeth to point at some of the Presbyters there in whom these abilities were Tertull. de praescript c. 3. Quid ergò si Episcopus si Diaconus si Vidua si Virgo si Doctor si etiam Martyr lapsus à regula fuerit What then if a Bishop if a Deacon a Widow a Virgin if even a Martyr shall fall from the rule In this list of principall ranks in the Church Presbyters have no room unlesse we understand them in the name of DOCTOURS the best part of their Office Theodoret Epit. Haer. l. v. c. penult 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 What can they say of the Incestuous person at Corinth who was not onely vouchsafed the divine mysteries but also had attained a Doctours Grace He followeth S. Chrysostomes conjecture which conceiveth that the Corinthians were puffed up as the Apostle blameth them 1. Cor. v. 3. with the opinion of that man because he was one of their Doctours that is one of the Presbyters of that Church that exercised the Office of Preaching and by that means bore sway among the people In fine the Apostle intendeth by Doctours the same that are so called in all Ecclesiasticall Writers that is the Bishops or such of the Presbyters as were seen in Preaching It is worth the observing that Beza hath expounded those whom the Apostle calleth 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 no otherwise then Deacons and Presbyters meaning indeed those Elders of the people which he imagined But having shewed that there never was any such in the Church well may we take his judgement along with so much of the truth as he acknowledgeth which deserveth still more credit from the President of Synagogues which had Elders some learned some not some that preached and some that did not as hath been said Salmasius of late in his work De Foenore Trapezit hath shown some evidence of two sorts of Presbyters in the first times of the Church But according to his admirable knowledge he saw withall that they were all of one rank in the Church all of the Ecclesiasticall Order all made by Imposition of hands and by consequence none of those Elders of the people which have been set up to manage the keys of the Church that is the Office of the Ecclesiasticall Order according to the Scriptures Besides it is to be observed that the Office of Bishops which name he thinketh most proper to those Presbyters which preached not but were exercised in ordering Church-matters and Presbyters is described almost in all places where there is mention of it in the Scriptures by both qualities of Teaching and Governing the Church Which is my argument to conclude That howsoever some mens abilities might be seen in the one rather then in the other howsoever some men according to their abilities might be applied to this rather then to that yet both Offices concerned the whole Order that of Preaching in chief To which though some attained not yet all are incouraged to labour towards it as the most excellent work of their place as by S. Paul allowing them that double maintenance ESPECIALLY in that respect So by these Constitutions allowing them that double portion at their Feasts of Love for that purpose that they may take pains in the Word of Doctrine as the words go there Be it then resolved that the Presbyters of the Church at least part of them were those Doctours whereof the Apostle writeth and from thence be it considered what distempers slight mistakes in the sound of the Scripture bring to passe when we see the Order of Doctours distinct from that of Presbyters pressed as a point of that Discipline that maketh one of the essentiall marks of a visible Church But whether the Prophets of the Primitive Church which taught the people at their Assemblies were Presbyters or not is not so easie to determine Some of them we have reason enough to think were be it but for those Prophets of Antiochia Acts xiii 2. that ministred unto the Lord and fasted when the Holy Ghost said unto them Separate me Barnabas and Saul for the work to which I have appointed them and those other among whom Timothy received Imposition of hands with prophesying 1. Tim. iv 14. But that all Presbyters were Prophets or all Prophets Presbyters is more then I can resolve Of these Prophets henceforth we are to intreat CHAP. V. Prophets in most of the Churches remembred by the Apostles The Gift of Languages the purpose and nature of it The Limbes and Branches of both these Graces in S. Paul Of Praying and Praising God by the Spirit Those that spake strange Tongues understood what they said Interpretation concerneth all that was spoken in strange Languages They prayed and studied for Spirituall Graces Prophesying in S. Paul signifieth singing Psalmes Prayers of the Church conceived by immediate inspiration The nearnesse of the Graces of Prophesying and Languages The ground and meaning of the Apostles Rule It proceedeth of none but Prophets What is to be judged in that which Prophets spoke The custome in the Primitive Church of many Preaching at the same Assembly came from hence IN the beginning of the Christian Faith it pleased God for the propagation and maintenance of it to revive the Grace of Prophesying decayed and lost among his Ancient people in a large measure in most of the Churches planted by the Apostles though there be not found so much concerning their Office any where as in this Church of Corinth In the Church of Jerusalem the mother of all Churches Acts xi 27. And in those dayes came Prophets from Jerusalem to Antiochia xv 32. And Judas and Silas being Prophets also themselves In the Church of Antiochia Acts xiii 1. Now there were in the Church that was at Antiochia certain Prophets and Doctours At Thessalonica 1. Thess v. 20. Despise not Prophesying At Corinth as we see at large At Ephesus Ephes iv 11. And he gave some Apostles some Evangelists some Prophets some Pastours and Doctours At Rome Rom. xii 6. Whether Prophesie according to
found with the world must end in confusion before we practise that virtue It is never lawfull to do any thing that is evil but it is not evil but necessary in the sphere of things indifferent to follow the Law that standeth though a better might stand in stead of it Herewith agreeth the judgement of the principall reformed Divines themselves chief Reformers which my desire is to repeat here though it hath been produced more at large not as pretending to stand or fall by pluralitie of voices but desiring to make it appear that nothing is said here to crosse the Principles of the Reformation and chief Reformers Philip. loco de Caerem in Ecclesia p. 651. In Ecclesiis emendatis reliqui sunt ritus aliqui adiaphori quia hujus vitae actiones ordine aliquo distribuendae sunt Hominum natura intelligit amat ordinem qui quidem maximè decet Ecclesiam congressus publicos In reformed Churches there remain some indifferent rites rites concerning indifferent things because the actions of this life are to be disposed in some order Man by nature apprehendeth and loveth order which especially becometh the Church and Publick Assemblies Calv. 4. Instit x. 27. Neque enim haberi potest quod Paulus exigit ut decenter omnia ordine fiant nisi additis observationibus tanquam vinculis quibusdam ordo ipse decorum consistat That whith Paul requireth that all things be done decently and in order is not to be obtained unlesse that Order and Comelinesse stand upon some observances added as bonds to wit to inforce it To the same purpose a little afore Si in rebus agendis vigere semper aliquem ritum oportet quem non respui publicae honest at is intersit at que adeò humanitatis ipsius id in Ecclesiis praesertim observandum quae cum bene composita omnium constitutione optimè sustinentur tum verò sine concordia nullae sunt prorsus And a little after he toucheth the reason here discoursed to the quick At cùm in hominum moribus tanta sit diversitas tanta in animis varietas tanta in judici is ingentisque pugna neque politia ulla satis firma est nist certis legibus constituta nec sine stata quadam forma servari ritus quispiam potest But there being so much difference in mens manners so much diversitie of minds so much contrariety of judgements and dispositions neither is any Common-wealth firm as it should be till it be settled with certain Laws neither can any rite be observed without some settled form Rites prescribed by God cannot be observed but according to Forms prescribed by man Philip ubi suprá Rursus autem munitur publics tranquillitas hâc doctrinâ quòd dicimus propter 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 eos ritus qui boni ordinis causâ instituti sunt servandos esse peccare homines petulantes qui in Ecclesiis emendatis violant tales ritus cum scandalo Again the publick quiet is fortified by this doctrine wherein we say that for good Orders sake those Rites which are ordained for good Orders sake are to be observed and that such saucy persons as violate such Rites with offense in reformed Churches do sinne Again Aliqui homines c. Some men of savage nature hate all Laws as a prison but others of gentle nature and sociable and understanding themselves to be born to Communicate nay that their chief work is to contribute their indeavours to help and cherish the Church of their own accord observe honest usefull Rites and avoid Offenses and knowing that publick Assemblies of the Church are ordained by the singular providence and blessing of God and that God would have this frequency credited that the voice of the Gospel may sound upon earth study to maintain the order the quiet the gravitie of these Assemblies CHAP. VII The prohibition of Quenching the Spirit concerneth immediate inspirations Prescript Form of Prayers as wel of as other parts of the Service is for the Edification of the Church Order not to be maintained without it Three parts of the Service of the Temple The Praises of God the Confession of sinnes the Priests Blessings The Service of the Synagogue prescribed Of the eighteen Benedictions Of the Service of their Fast of Seven dayes The Deacon ministred their Service Justine Martyr and Tertullian misunderstood Summe of the Church-service All Prescript Of Canons that Prescribe the Service to be Ordered by Councels Alterations in Liturgies Agreement of Reformed Churches THis is the substance of those things that are to be done for the publick Service of God at the Assemblies of Christians And these are the grounds of those Rules by which the form in which they are done is to be directed Before we come to touch that particular form of Service which we use with these Rules let us make triall of them in some particulars which in the generall point of publick Service are or may be questionable And that by the method already set on foot of Reasons drawn from the grounds and rules of the Apostle seconded by the practice of the Primitive the judgement and agreement of Reformed Churches Among which there is none of more account then this Whether there ought to be a set Form of Prayer prescribed for our Assemblies For it is not denied that their ought to be an order prescribed for Publick Service in the whole but Publick Prayers and the form of them it is pretended are to be referred to the discretion of the person by whom they are ministred by virtue of that charge of the Apostle wherein he forbiddeth to Quench the Spirit 1. Thes v. 19. which is conceived to be done when the conceptions of mens minds or the expressions of their tongues are stinted to prescribed forms and men by that means so confined that they cannot make demonstration of those graces which the Spirit of God hath indued them with This is to my understanding the best of that Argument that casteth so much and so dangerous scruple in a clear businesse And at a distance carrieth an appearance of the Word of God and the meaning of Scripture but survayed near hand may be a warning to all men how they trouble the Church with misapprehension received upon the superficiall sound of the words of it For when the Apostle forbiddeth to Quench the Spirit he speaketh of immediate inspirations of the holy Ghost such as they were by which men were inabled to discern the secrets of other mens hearts As in 1. Cor. xiv 24. by which the Prophets of Antiochia were informed of the will of God for the sending of Paul and Barnabas And those others for the ordination of Timothy Act. xiii 2. 1. Tim. iv 14. by which the truth was revealed unto them as concerning matters in hand at their Assemblies 1. Cor. xiv 30. And the Rule of the Apostle If Revelation be made to another as he sitteth let the first be silent is to
compasse of common sense to imagine that a man should stumble in following the example against which he professeth In fine the opposition made to publick Order and that which it injoyneth is evidence enough that they are not the weak but the strong not the doubtfull but the erroneous weak in reason but strong in will or as it was once well said headstrong in refusing without reason what Order prescribeth not those whom the Apostle chargeth to forbear but those whom he forbeareth not a moment Gal. ii 5. whom he chargeth the Colossians and Titus not to forbear that we have to deal with The matters were light wherein their offense stuck but the consequence which opposition drew involved the substance of the Gospel So are the things slight which we stick at but publick Order which dependeth upon the right of prescribing and the edification of the Church intended in the particulars deserve not to be abandoned for an unjust offense True it is that a private person that will be charitable must forbear the use of his freedome which no Rule confineth when he seeth it will be offense to the weak if he forbear it not he giveth just offense according to the Apostle And it is to be thought that under the countenance and wing of the erroneous and strong there walk divers of those doubtfull and weak to whom respect is to be had according to the Apostle But if the question thereupon be made Whether it be expedient for the Church to Order such things as shall seem to advantage the Form the Order the Rites of Divine Service Whether it be expedient for those whom it concerneth to observe and exact the same in case there may be doubtfull Consciences that may take offense The answer will be Yes even according to the Apostle because otherwise the publick Order which he recommendeth can by no means be preserved in the Church since it is not possible so to order things of this nature as to leave no possible doubt in any Conscience Might not those of the Gentiles whom the Apostles enjoyned to forbear things dying in their bloud and offered to Idoles have taken offense because they were confined in the just use of their freedome Or the Corinthians that S. Paul suffered not their women to sit with bare faces at publick Service as the Virgins of Tertullians time professed themselves scandalized at those of their rank that practised it Suppose the Church cannot say as the Apostles It seemed good to the Holy Ghost and to us S. Paul in the other case proceedeth upon no other reasons then such as the Church must now use in like cases And I suppose the President inspired by the Holy Ghost authorizeth the Church to proceed in like matters though not pretending immediate inspirations Last of all Who can doubt but among the erroneous of them that did Judaize under the Apostles there were also of the doubtfull and weak led away with their pretenses And yet we see the Apostle forbeareth them not a moment in respect to the weak All this containing no more inconvenience then this That whereas all men are bound to indeavour themselves to satisfie and overcome such doubts of their Conscience the Apostles opposition redoubleth a new obligation to do it lest they offend this Ministery if they do it not So doth the Constitution of the Church adde a new obligation of resolving doubtfull Consciences for fear of offending the publick Order which it settleth And in all this I suppose there is no just offense For as there is alwayes means in the Church with satisfaction to overcome doubts of Consciences so is there no means to procure that there shall be no doubts of Conscience in the Church so long as there are unperfect Christians in it But he whom it concerneth to observe or exact publick Order must not give just offense to publick Order and all that go by it by neglecting it for fear of giving unjust offense to private persons by observing or exacting it CHAP. X. What is to be considered touching our Service The Service of Hearers and Believers Confession of sinnes whether of old the beginning of Service The ancient Order of Psalmes and Lessons The Masse containeth an abridgement of it Severall manners of singing Psalmes Purpose of Lessons The Place of the Sermon Dismission of Hearers Originall of Litanies Prayer indicted by the Deacon The Thanksgiving from whence the Sacrament is called the Eucharist Prayer which it was alwayes celebrated with Prayer for all the Church at celebrating the Eucharist The residue of that Service The charge of the Masse on our Service Extent of the power of the Keyes and wherein in consisteth Of Confession of sinnes and Absolution at the beginning Our Order of Psalmes and Lessons Of the Creed and Collects The Sermon part of our Service Of the Communion-Service and appertenances of it BEing now to compare the Form of Service which we use with that of the Primitive Church and to derive both from the practice pointed out to us in those particulars which are remembred in the Scriptures I am to professe at the beginning that my purpose is not to be extended to the particulars of words or conceptions wherein it is couched It will be enough to reduce the main substance and order of it to that which we find practised under the Apostles My businesse therefore is to describe the most ancient and generall Form of that Solemn Service which was used when the Eucharist was celebrated not out of the Liturgies extant alone but out of the Testimonies of the Eldest Ecclesiasticall writers concurring For it shall appear that from hence is derived and herein is contained first the Order of daily Morning and Evening Service then the Litanies appointed besides for Lords-dayes Wednesdayes and Fridayes and last the Celebration of the Eucharist which is all or almost all that which this Discourse intendeth to comprise In the first place it is to be known that from the first times of the Church there were alwayes two parts of Publick Service At the one all persons might be present though not Christians till the Sermon was done the Church-doores were open and free But when they went to celebrate the Eucharist then all Hearers or Catechumeni that is those that were willing to be instructed in the Faith but were not as yet admitted to Baptisme all that were under Penance all possessed with unclean spirits were dismissed and shut out none suffered to be present but those that were admitted to Communicate Of these two parts we have sufficient remembrance in Justine Martyr the most ancient of Church-writers that remain unquestionable His words are these Apol. ii 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 As many as are perswaded and believe those things to be true which are taught and said of us and undertake to be able so to live are taught to pray and desire of God with Fasting forgivenesse of foregoing sinnes we also praying and fasting with them For
what prayers were these whereof he speaketh but those which we shall shew afterwards were wont to be made as a part of their Service on behalf of the Hearers as also of Penitents and persons beset with evil spirits by themselves and the Congregation both immediately afore their departure Afterwards 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 But we having thus washed him that is perswaded and agreed bring him to those that are called Brethren where they are assembled to make Common-Prayers both for themselves and for him that is baptised and all men else every where earnestly It shall appear in due time that the Prayers of the Church for all states of persons in the Church followed after the Hearers were dismissed before celebrating the Eucharist Therefore at them onely the Brethren are present whereas the Hearers were at those which were made for the forgivenesse of their sinnes That unbelievers were admitted to be present at Preaching or Expounding the Scriptures in the time of the Apostles it appeareth by S. Paul 1. Cor. xiv 24. But if all Prophesie and there come in one that believeth not That they were excluded at that time as afterwards when the Eucharist came to be celebrated I have not the like evidence but in reason I must needs presume it Hereupon riseth the difference between these which once were called the First and Second Service The ground whereof being taken away in this state of the Church in which all are baptized Infants and publick Penance for the greatest part is unknown neverthelesse that Service must needs remain the chief part of Gods publick Service which the Eucharist is celebrated with howsoever it come to passe that the Eucharist is not celebrated at the greatest part of solemn Assemblies This is remembred here upon occasion of that Confession of sinnes which our Service beginneth with as also the Service of almost all reformed Churches in which it may be counted a generall order to begin with Confession of sinnes Which order Du Plessis laboureth to derive from the ancient practice of the Synagogue first and consequently of the Church Primitive alledging to that purpose those forms of Confession over the sacrifices which P. Fagius hath produced from the Hebrew Doctours upon Lev. xvi 21. where the Law saith And Aaron shall lay both his hands upon the head of the live Goat and confesse over him all the iniquities of the children of Israel and all their transgressions in their sinnes together with the words of Liranus upon that place Sicut facimus in Confessione facta in principio Missae As we do saith he in the Confession which is made at the beginning of the Masse As also the Authour de de Cardinal Christi Operibus among S. Cyprians works Hierarcha pius quem Spiritus s compungit excitat inhabitat sanctificat confidenter orat pro sua populi ignorantia recolens pudibundi contriti animi confessione quòd aliquando praevalente adversùm se peccato fuerit derelictus The pious Bishop whom the H. Ghost pricketh stirreth inhabiteth and sanctifieth prayeth confidently for his own and the peoples ignorance recalling in the Confession of a mind ashamed and contrite that sometime he hath been forsaken sinne prevailing against him It is manifest indeed that this Confession of sinnes is used in the Breviarie in Feriali officio ad Primam as well as at the beginning of the Masse in these words Confiteor Deo omnipotenti The people answering Misereatur tui omnipotens Deus dimissis peccatis tuis perducat te ad vitam aeternam Which done the people also make the like Confession for their parts the Minister answering the same And this is the Confession of sinnes which is meant in the words of Liranus and the Authour de Cardinalibus Christi operibus though it is not probable that it passed in those scandalous terms that follow in his time And this in the Rubricks of the Maronites Missall as it is printed at Rome is called Absolving the Priest by the people But since sacrifices are no part of the morall Service of God and it hath been declared how Confession of sinnes was used in the Temple at that morall Service it seemeth impertinent here to consider that which was done at offering Sacrifices As for the Service of the Primitive Church at which unbelievers and such as onely pretended to Baptisme with those that were under Penance and the like were present This will be a constraining reason to prove that no Confession of sinnes no prayer for Forgivenesse was made in common for them and all believers at the beginning of Service because of the great distance of their estates and conditions in the Church and because this was the subject of those Prayers which Hearers Penitents were dismissed with at the end of the first Service the Congregation joyning with them and the Bishop or Priest blessing them to that purpose as must be said afterwards Therefore in Justin Martyr and Tertullian where they describe what was done at those solemn Assemblies in the Constitutions of the Apostles L. viii which seems to be the most ancient Form extant and in most of the Greekish Liturgies there is no Confession of sinnes at the beginning And therefore it may justly seem to have been put there after that the difference of first and second Service came to be observed rather for fashions sake and remembrance of the ancient custome then for the originall reason when the world was become Christian and the difference between hearers and the rest abolished In the beginning of the copie which they give us of the Ancient Spanish Course called the mosarabe or mustarabe there is this Rubrick Factâ priùs Confessione uti fit in Miss is Latinis juxta usum Toletanum antiquum dicitur Introitus to qui sequitur modo Confession first being made as in Latine Masses according to the ancient use of Toledo the Introit is said in manner following As if this Confession were proper to the Latine Service in opposition to the Greekish Which notwithstanding in that which is intitled to S. James he that celebrateth maketh Confession of his sinnes praying for pardon to the purpose that his Service in celebrating the Eucharist may be accepted which originally when no mention was made of the Eucharist at the beginning being kept private from the unbelievers could not have been That which is now at the beginning of the Masse by the stuff is discovered to be of later date being as scandalous a passage as any in all the Masse besides when he sayes Confiteor Deo Omnipotenti B. Mariae semper Virgini B. Michacli Archangelo B. Joanni Baptistae SS Apostolis Petro Paulo B. N. Omnibus SS vobis Fratres quia peccavi nimis cogitatione verbo opere This is not to say that Confession of sinnes is not fit for the beginning of Service I mean nothing lesse as shall be said afterwards But that it is not derived from the generall and originall Form of