yet it cannot be denied but that in this discouraging Affect there is also some mixture of Grief or secret regret proceeding from apprehension of Dispraise because being ever accompanied with inward displeasure at the defect or fault uncircumspectly discovered it cools or damp's the Spirits teaching more wariness for the future The Contrary to this is Impudence which is contempt of Shame yea and oftentimes of Glory too But because there is in us no special motion of the Spirits and heart that may excite Imprudence it seems to be no Passion but a certain Vice opposite to Shame and to Glory also so far forth as they are both good and laudable as Ingratitude is opposed to Gratitude and Cruelty to Commiseration And the chief cause of this vicious insensibility of Honor is founded in grievous contumelies to which a man hath been accustomed in former times and which he by degrees comes to despise as of no force to hinder his enjoyment of commodities belonging to his body whereby he measures all good and evil thereby freeing himself from many necessities and streights to which honor would have obliged him This therefore being no Passion we are not concerned here further to consider it But as for Pride and Dejection that they are not onely Vices but Passions too is evident enough from the commotion of the Spirits and blood that discovers itself outwardly in men surprised by them upon any new and suddain occasion The same may be said of Generosity also and Humility For notwithstanding their Motions be less quick and conspicuous and that there seem to be much less of Convenience or fellowship betwixt Virtue and Passion than between Passion and Vice yet no reason appears why the same Motion that serves to confirm a conception that is ill grounded may not serve likewise to confirm the same conception though itbe well grounded And because Pride and Generosity consist equaly in Self-esteem differing only in the injustice and justice thereof they seem to be but one and the same Passion originaly excited by a certain motion not simple but composed of the motions of Admiration Ioy and Love aswell that love which is conceived for ones-self as that for the thing which makes one to value himself as on the Contrary the Motion that causeth Humility whether it be Vertuous or Vicious seems to be composed of the motions of Admiration Grief and self-love mixt with Hatred of the Defects that give occasion to one to conceive a mean opinion of himself Now what are the Motions of the Spirits or Sensitive Soul that produce Admiration and Pride we have formerly declared and as to those that are proper to each of the other passions already considered they remain to be particularly described in their due places ¶ As Admiration the first of all the Passions ariseth in the Soul before she hath considered whether the thing represented to her be good and convenient to her or not so after she hath judged it to be good instantly there is raised in her the most agreable and complacent of all Passions Love and when she hath conceived the same to be Evil she is as quickly moved to Hatred For Love seems to be nothing but a Propension of the Soul to that thing which promiseth pleasure or good to her and Hatred is nothing but the Souls Aversation from that which threatens Pain or Grief By the word Propension here used is to be understood not Cupidity or desire which is in truth a distinct passion proceeding from love and always respecting the future but Will or consent by which we consider ourselves as already joyned to the thing loved by a certain conception of ourselves to be as it were a part thereof As on the contrary in Aversation or Hate we consider ourselves as intirely separate from the thing hated According to these two opposite notions I should define Love to be a Commotion of the Soul produced by a motion of the Spirits which inciteth her to joyn herself by her will to objects that appear convenient and gratefull to her and Hatred to be a Commotion produced by the spirits that inciteth the Soul to be willing to be separated from objects that are represented to her as ungratefull and hurtfull Of Love there are made by the Schools two Sorts whereof the first is commonly called Amor Benevolentiae love of Benevolence or Good-will whereby we are incited to wish well to the thing we love the other Amor Concupiscentiae which causeth us to desire to enjoy or possess the object loved But this Distinction if considered without prejudice will be found to concern onely the Effects of love not the essence of it For so soon as a man hath in Will joyned himself to an object of what nature soever it be he is at the same instant carryed toward it by Benevolence or to speak more plainly he in will also adjoyns thereunto what things he believeth conducible to the good thereof which is one of the principle Effects of love but doth not infer a different Species of it And the same object if it be judged good to be possessed or to be joyned to the Soul in another manner than by the will alone is instantly desired which also ought to be accounted among the more frequent effects of love Whence I conclude that Desire connexed to Love is Benevolence as connexed with Hate it is Malevolence or ill will I add that as Amity or Friendship seems to be nothing but constancy of Love so Enmity nothing but constancy of Hatred If then you seek for a more genuine Distinction of Love I know not how better to gratify your Curiosity than by entertaining it with that delivered by the most excellent Monsieur Des Cartes in his book concerning the Passions which I will therefore faithfully recite Love saith He may in my judgement be with good reason distinguished by the several degrees of Esteem we have of the thing loved For when a man hath less esteem for an object than for himself and yet loves it his love is no more but simple Propension or Benevolence when as much as for himself 't is Amity or Friendship when greater than for himself it may be called Devotion By the First a flower a Bird a Horse c. may be loved By the second no man of understanding can love any thing but Men who are so properly the object◠of this passion that one can hardly be found so imperfect but he may be conjoyned to another in the most perfect bond of friendship if that other conceive himself to be truely and sincerely beloved by him and think him to have a Soul truely noble and generous And as for the last Devotion indeed the principal object thereof is God Almighty toward whom there is no man living who considers as he ought the incomprehensible perfections of the Divine nature but must be devote for as Seneca Deum colit qui novit Yet there
is a Devotion also to ones Prince or Country or City or to any private person whom we esteem above ourselves And the difference betwixt these three sorts of Love is chiefly manifest from their divers Effects For when in each of them the person loving considers himself as joyned and united to the thing loved he is always ready to quit or leave the least part of the whole that he makes with the same to preserve the rest Whence it comes that in simple Benevolence the Lover always prefer's himself to the thing loved but on the contrary in Devotion he always prefers the thing loved so far above himself that he fears not to dye for the conversation thereof of which noble Love there have been glorious Examples in men who have voluntarily exposed themselves to certain death for defence of their Prince or of their City yea sometimes also for private persons to whom they had particularly devoted themselves This Distinction being admitted as in my opinion it well deserves to be there will remain no necessity of constituting so many distinct sorts of Love as they are various objects to excite it seeing there are many Passions very different among themselves and in respect of their several objects which yet agree in this that they all participate of Love For Example the Passion by which the Ambitious is carried on to Glory the Avaricious to riches the Drunkard to wine the Libidinous to women the Honest to his friend the Vxorious to his wife the good Father to his Children c. differ very much among themselves and yet so far resemble each other that they all participate of Love But the love of the first four aimeth at nothing but the possession of their peculiar objects nor have they indeed any thing of love for those objects but only Desire mixt with some other special passions Whereas the love of a Parent to his Children is so pure that he desires to obtain nothing at all from them nor to possess them in any other manner than he doth already or to bring them to a neerer conjunction with himself but considering them as parts of himself seeks their good as his own yea with greater care than his own as not fearing to purchase their felicity at the rate of his own undoing And the Love of an honest man to his Friends is also of the same perfection But the Love of a man to his Mistress commonly distinguished by the name of the Erotic passion is alwaies mixed with desire of Fruition And as for Hatred though that be directly opposed to Love yet cannot it be distinguished into as many different kinds because the difference betwixt Evils from which we are by our will separated cannot be so well observed as that which is betwixt the Goods to which we are by by our will joyned From what hath here been said concerning Love as distinguishable chiefly by the several degrees of Estimation conceived for the thing loved it may easily be collected that from Love ariseth Cupidity or Desire whereby the Soul is disposed to covet for the time to come those things which she represent's to herself as convenient and likely to afford her pleasure Thus we desire not onely the presence of an absent good but also the conservation of the good that is present yea we desire likewise the absence of Evil aswell that which is already incumbent as that which we believe possible to come upon us in the future For in Cupidity or Desire of any thing whatsoever which the Soul judges to be wanting to herself she alwaies looketh foreward to the time to come It may be collected also that though Desire cannot be without Love yet Love may be without Desire of possessing or enjoying the object otherwise than by the pure embraces of the will alone And this may be confirmed by observations of the different Motions of the Soul and Spirits raised in these two Passions and the divers symptoms consequent thereunto For In Love when it is not accompanyed either with Cupidity or with vehement Ioy or with Sadness but continues pure and simple the Soul being incited to conjoyn herself in will to objects that appear good and convenient to her and instantly dilated the Animal Spirits are like lightning dispatched from the brain by the nerves instantly into the Heart and by their influx render the pulse thereof more strong and vigorous than is usual and consequently the circulation of the blood more nimble and expedite Whereupon the blood being more copiously diffused by the arteries and more particularly those ascending to the brain carries with it a recruit of vital spirits newly enkindled which being there further sublimed or refined and corroborating the idea or image that the first cogitation hath formed of the thing loved oblige and in some sort compell the the Soul to continue fixed upon that cogitation and continually to indulge the same And herein if I am not much mistaken doth the passion of Love principally consist For they who are affected therewith have their pulse equal the Spirits that cause it being immitted into the Cardiac nerves with an equal and placid motion but stronger and more frequent then ordinary they feel a certain agreable heat diffused in their breast they find their brain invigorated by abundance of Spirits and thereby grow more ingenuous and in fine they digest their meat quickly and perform all actions of life readily and with alacrity All which may be ascribed to the free and expedite but equal Circulution of the blood caused by a copious influx of Animal Spirits into the Heart Whence we may safely conclude that this grateful passion is highly beneficial to all parts of the body and conduceth much to the conservation of health provided it continue within the bounds of moderation But if it exceed them and break forth into a wild and furious desire then on the contrary by degrees enervating the members it at length induceth very great weakness and decay upon the whole body For Love accompanied with vehement desire doth so intirely imploy the Soul in the consideration of the object desired that she retains in the brain the greatest part of the Spirits there to represent to her the image thereof so that the whole stock of nerves and all the Muscles are defrauded of the influx of Spirits from the brain with which they ought to be continualy inspired or invigorated Whence in process of time the whole Oeconomy of nature is perverted and an universal languor ensueth And in Cupidity whereby the Soul is so effused towards good or pleasure represented to her as certainly to come as that she is suddainly checked and contracted again by reflection upon the delay of the same there occurs this Singular that it agitateth the heart more violently and crouds the brain with more legions of spirits than any other of all the passions For out of Desire to obtain what we ardently pursue the Spirits are
such as the Rational Soul by her excellent faculties and proper acts appear's to be can act physicaly in and upon a gross and ponderous body such as ours are immediately or without the mediation of a third thing which though corporeal too may yet be of a substance so refined and subtil as to approach somwhat neerer to the nature of a pure Spirit than the body itself doth and therefore for the more probable explication of the Phenomena of the Passions which are not raised in the Rational Soul I found myself obliged to admit her to have a Sensitive one conjoyned with her to receive her immediate suggestions and to actuate the body according to her soveraign will and pleasure there being less of disparity betwixt the most thin and subtil bodies of Light and Flame whereof many eminent Philosophers have conceived a Sensitive Soul to consist and a substance purely Spiritual than between a pure spirit and a gross heavy body as ours is Secondly it seem'd to me no less unconceivable whence that dismal 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 or intestin war which every Man too frequently feels within himself and whereof even St. Paul himself so sadly complained when in Epist. ad Roman cap. 3. he cries out video aliam legem in membris meis repugnantem legi mentis meae should arise if not from a Duumvirate as it were of Rulers contending for superiority within us and inclining us two contrary ways at once For to conceive that one and the. same Simple thing such as the Reasonable Soul is rightly presumed to be can be repugnant to itself or at one and the same time be possessed with opposite affections is manifestly absurd There are indeed who to evade this absurdity imagine it possible that of one and the same Rational simple Soul there may be two distinct Faculties or powers opposite each to other from whose clashings and contrary inclinations this civil war may proceed But to oblige us to swallow this palpable contradiction these Men ought to have reconciled those two repugnant notions of Simple and Compound and to have told us why in the same simple substance of fire there cannot likewise be two mutualy repugnant faculties heat and cold In a Mixed body there may be I confess opposite faculties and therefore the like may be imagined also in the Rational Soul if she be conceived to be of a mixed or compound nature but this is against their own supposition and destructive to the natural immortality of the Soul What then can remain to cause this dire war daily observed within us betwixt the allurements of our Sense on one side and the grave dictates of our Mind on the other but two distinct Agents the Rational Soul and the Sensitive coexistent within us and hotly contending about the conduct of our Will But You Sir will perhaps tell me there may another and that a more probable cause be given of this hostility and that the searching wit of Monsieur des Cartes hath been so happy to discover what it is in libr. de Passion part 1. art 47. where he thus reasoneth In no other thing saith he but in the repugnancy that is between the motions which the Body by its spirits and those which the Soul by her will do at the same time endeavour to excite in the Glandula Pinealis in the brain consist all the Conflicts which Men commonly imagin betwixt the inferior part of the Soul which is named the Sensitive and the Superior which is called the Rational or betwixt the appetites natural and the will For in us there is only one Soul which hath in her no variety of parts the same that is Sensitive is also Rational and all the appetites thereof are volitions The Error by which divers persons as it were that are for the most part mutualy contrary come to be imposed upon her hath proceeded only from hence that hitherto her functions have not been sufficiently distinguished from the functions of the Body to which alone is to be ascribed all that can be observed in us to be repugnant to our reason So that here is no other Contrast but that when the Glandule seated in the middle of the brain is impell'd on one part by the Soul and on the other by the Spirits Animal which are nothing but bodies as I have before declared it often happens that those two impulses or impressions are contrary each to other and that the strongger hindereth the effect of the weaker Now there may be distinguished two kinds of motions excited in the Glandule by the spirits some represent to the Soul objects that move the Senses or impressions found in the brain and use no force upon the will others use force namely those that make the Passions or the motions of the body that accompany them And as for the first though they often hinder the actions of the Soul or be hindered by them yet because they are not directly contrary there is no strife or contention observed in them but only betwixt the last and the Wills that are repugnant to them for Example betwixt the endeavour by which the spirits impell the Glandule to induce upon the Soul a desire of some one thing and that by which the Soul repells the same Glandule by her will to avoid it And this chiefly demonstrateth this strife that since the will hath not power as hath been already shown to excite Passions directly the Soul is therefore compell'd to use art and to apply herself to the consideration of various things successively Whence if it happen that any one of those various things hath the force of changing for a moment the cours of the spirits it may so fall out that the next thing that occurs to be considered may want the like force and the spirits may resume their former cours because the precedent disposition in the nerves in the heart and in the blood hath not been changed whereby it comes to pass that the Soul almost in the same moment feels herself impell'd to desire and decline the same thing And this hath given Men occasion of imagining in the Soul two powers mutualy repugnant But yet there may be conceived a certain Conflict in this that oftentimes the same cause that exciteth some Passion in the Soul exciteth also in the Body some certain motions whereunto the Soul contributeth nothing at all and which she stops or endevours to stop so soon as she observes them as is manifest from experience when that which exciteth Fear causeth also the spirits to flow into the Muscles that serve to move the leggs to flight and occasioneth the will of exercising Courage to stop them To this Objection therefore I answer 1. that had this excellent Man Monsieur des Cartes been but half as conversant in Anatomy as he seems to have been in Geometry doubtles he would never have lodged so noble a guest as the Rational Soul in so incommodious a closet of the brain as the
and confused with delusory whimzies as it too frequently happens to Men in Hypochondriacal Melancholy and madness and likewise in drunken fits And as for the various Gestures of the Soul by which respectively to the various impressions of sensible objects she expresseth one while Gladness and Pleasure another Aversion and Offence it is worthy our observation that sometimes she is allured outwardly into the organ of some one of the senses and that she occasionaly crowds herself into the Eye Ear Palate or other instrument of sense there more neerly to approach and entertain the pleasing object somtimes on the contrary to avoid an Evil she apprehends and decline an encontre with an ingratefull object she retreats inwardly and leaving her watches shrinks up herself as if she labourd to hide her head from the danger threatned So that we can scarcely perceive or imagine any thing without disquiet and commotion and at the apprehension of almost any object whatsoever the whole Soul is moved and put into a trembling and the substance of it variously agitated as a field of corn is waved to and fro by contrary gusts of winds Nor do these agitations especially if they be any whit violent stop at the Sensitive part of the Soul or spirits Animal which I imagine to make a kind of lucid Fluidum subject to Undulations or waving motions throughout upon either external or internal impulses but as waves rowl on till they arrive at the shore are carried on by an Undulating motion even to the Vital part glowing in the blood and impelling the flame thereof hither and thither make it to burn unequaly For so soon as an object is either by the sense or by the Memory represented to the Imagination under th' apparence of Good or Evil in the very same instant it affects and commoves the Animal Spirits destined to maintain the Pulse of the heart and by their influx causing the heart to be variously contracted or dilated consequently renders the motion and accension of the blood variously irregular and unequal And thus you see in what manner the two parts of the Sensitive Soul the Vital flame and the Animal spirits reciprocally affect each other with their accidental alterations But this you may understand more clearly and fully from the following Theory of the Passions where we shall enquire into the reasons and motions of them more particularly Mean while I find my self in this place arrested by a certain mighty Difficulty which though perhaps I shall not be able to overcome ought nevertheless to be attempted not only for its own grand importance but because without some plausible Explication of it at least all our precedent speculations concerning the nature and proprieties of a Sensitive Soul will fall to the ground as an arch that wants a key or middle-stone to support all the rest It is concerning the Knowledge of Brutes by which they are directed in actions voluntary For supposing all we have hitherto been discoursing of the Origin Substance Subsistence Parts Faculties Inclinations Passions and Alterations of a Corporeal Soul to be true and evident which is more than I dare assume yet doth it not from thence appear what such a Soul can by her own proper virtue do more than a Machine artificialy fram'd and put into motion To speak more plainly tho it be granted that first th' impression made by an external object upon the instrument of sense doth by impelling the Animal Spirits inwards and by disposing them into a certain peculiar figure or mode as the Cartesians speak cause the act of Sensation or simple Perception and that then the same spirits rebounding as it were by a reflex undulation outward from the brain into the nerves and muscles produce local motions granting this I say yet still we are to seek How this Soul or any one part of it comes to be conscious of Sensation or how it can by a reflex act as the Schools phrase it perceive that it doth perceive and according to that perception is impell'd to diverse acts directed to an appetite of this or that good and somtimes in prosecution of the good desired to perform actions that seem to be the results of counsel and deliberation such as are daily observed to be done by several sorts of Beasts as well wild as domestic In Man indeed it seems not difficult to conceive that the Rational Soul as president of all thâ—inferiour faculties and constantly speculating the impressions or images represented to her by the Sensitive as by a mirrour doth first form to herself conceptions and notions correspondent to their nature and then proceed to acts of reason judgement and will But as for Brutes that are irrational in what manner the perception distinction appetite memory of objects and other acts resulting from an inferior kind of reason are in them performd this I confess is more than I can yet understand Some there are I know who rather then acknowledge their insufficiency to solve this Problem have attributed to Brutes also Souls immaterial and subsistent after separation from their bodies But these considered not that the Soul of a Brute however docil and apprehensive and using organs in their structure very little if at all different from those in the head of Man can yet have no capacity of Arts and Sciences nor raise it self up to any objects or acts but what are Material and that by consequence the same is different from and inferiour to the Rational Soul of Man and material So that instead of solving the Doubt by teaching us how from a certain Modification of subtil matter there may result such Power which residing in the brain of a Brute may there receive without confusion all impressions or images brought in by the Senses distinctly speculate judge and know them and then raise appetites and imploy the other faculties in acts respective to that knowledge and to those appetites instead of this I say they have entangled themselves in an absurd Error ascribing to a thing meerly material a capacity of knowing objects immaterial and performing actions proper only to immaterial Beings We are therefore to search for this Power of a Sensitive Soul by which she is conscious of her own perception only in Matter in a peculiar manner so or so disposed or modified But in what matter this of the Soul or that of the Body Truely if you shall distinctly examine either the Soul or the Body of a Brute as not conjoyned and united into one Compositum you will have a hard task of it to find in either of them or indeed in any other material subject whatever any thing to which you may reasonably attribute such an Energetic and self-moving Power But if you consider the whole Brute as a Body animated and by divine art of an infinite wisdom designed framed and qualified for certain ends and uses then you may safely conclude that a Brute is by the law of the Creation or institute of Almighty
being interrupted is forced to undergo irregular floods and ebbs and other violent fluctuations but the Animal spirits also impelled to and fro in a tumultuous manner cause great disorders in the functions of sense and motion yea more by their exorbitant manner of influx into the nerves of the Heart and Lungs they move them irregularly and so contribute to render the course of the blood yet more unequal Nor doth the tempest stop here it extends sometimes also to other Humors of the body to the solid parts and members of it and even to the discomposure of the Reasonable Soul her self The Tranquillity of the Sensitive Soul is easily observable in sleep when the spirits are bound up or at least at rest and very often also when we are awake namely whensoever the objects affecting the sense or created in the imagination appear to import neither good nor evil to us and we are no further concerned than barely to apprehend and know them For then they smoothly and calmly slide into the common sensory and imagination and soon pass away without any the least disquiet or commotion of the appetite The Perturbation of it is as easily manifest in all the passions which are the consequents of desire or of aversation For when any object is represented under the apparence of good or evil to us in particular instantly the Sensitive Soul is moved to imbrace or avoid it and imployes not only the Animal Spirits her Emissaries but the blood also and other humors universally diffused through the body and even the solid parts too as instruments to effect her design More plainly when the Imagination conceives any thing to be embraced as good or avoided as evil presently by the spirits residing in the brain and ranged as it were into order the Appetite is formed and then the impression being transmitted to the Heart according as that is contracted or dilated the blood is impelled and forced to various fluctuations and irregular motions and thence the Appetite being by instinct transmitted to the nerves ordained for that use they cause motions of the solid parts respective thereunto And this we may conjecture to be the order of motions excited successively in the phantasy spirits blood and solid parts in every Passion of the mind of what sort soever Nor can it indeed sink into my dull head by what other means of mutual intercourse besides such a quick transmission of spirits first from the brain into the Praecordia and thence back again to the brain by nerves to that end extended betwixt those sources of life and sense the great and speedy commerce in all passions observed to be maintained between them can be effected But however this admirable Commerce may be otherwise explained it is lawful for us us to conceive that the Sensitive Soul when put into this state of perturbation doth strangely vary her Postures according to the diversity of motions caused in her and though that diversity be very great yet that in all perturbations whatever she is more or less amplified so as to swell beyond her ordinary bounds or more or less contracted within her self so as to be less extense or diffused than usually she is at other times in her state of tranquillity as will be exemplified in all the passions we design particularly to describe Mean while it is observable that sometimes she being affected with joy or pride and as it were exulting above measure doth advance and expand her self as if she strove to be greater and to stretch her grandure beyond the narrow limits of the body Whereupon the Animal Spirits being respectively commoved in the brain enlarge the sphere of their irradiation and by a more abundant influx vigorously agitate the Praecordia or vital parts so forcing the blood to flow more copiously into all parts and to diffuse it self more freely and speedily through the whole body On the contrary sometimes being surprised with grief or fear she contracts her self into a narrower compass so that shrunk up to a scantling less than her usual circuit of emanation she becomes of too small a size vigorously to actuate the body as she ought Whence the Animal faculties drooping as it were perform their actions either slowly and weakly or perversly and the Praecordia wanting their due influx of spirits almost flagg suffering the blood to remain in their conduits longer than it ought even to danger of stagnation and consequently of sudden death These two contrary Motions therefore of Contraction and Expansion I suppose to be the two General ones to which all the various Postures of the Sensitive Soul when she is perturbed may be commodiously referr'd it seeming to me considering her to be exactly like a Flame and obnoxious to the like accidental mutations that she is not naturally capable of other besides these and that how great soever the variety of such her Mutations may be in the vast diversity of Passions yet they are all but several degrees and divers modes of either her Extension or Contraction This being then supposed I proceed to the first and General Causes of all Passions Where I observe first what was only hinted a little afore that it is not the simple representation of good or evil in any object how great soever it be that is sufficient to raise Commotion in the sensitive Soul for we usualy without perturbation behold the prosperous or adverse events befalling other Men no waies related to us and therefore it is further required to the moving our affections that the good or evil apprehended be by us conceived to concern ourselves in particular or our Friends at least and near relations who in this case are part of our selves Secondly that even that good or evil wherein a Man conceives himself to be concern'd is not always apprehended by him under one and the same ration or aspect but variously aswell in respect of the object itself as of the Subject to which it doth more peculiarly and immediately appertain Of the divers rations under which one and the same object good or evil may be apprehended by one and the same Man respectively to the various circumstances thereof we shall more opportunely speak anon And as for those that respect the Subject or Man apprehending it is worthy our serious remark That all Good or Evil represented to Man doth concern the Sensitive Soul either as she is distinct from the body and abstract from all relation or as she is intimately conjoyn'd to the body and interressed therein or finally as she is subordinate to the Rational Soul For though every Affect or Passion be founded in the Corporeal Soul yet it always respects the good or evil of one or other of these three subjects and is first raised on the behalf of this that or the other Wherefore according to this triple relation of the Sensitive Soul all Passions incident thereto may be said to be either Physical or Metaphysical or
the propriety of those expressions in scripture which seem to ascribe all our sacred passions principaly to the heart 3. And as for Passions Moral I refer to their classis all those that are excited in the Sensitive Soul upon her perception of such good or evil objects as concern her confederate the Body with which she is most intimately conjoynd and upon whose welfare her safety doth necessarily depend Concerning these in general it is remarkable that though the Sensitive Soul hath secret loves and aversations of her own commonly called as we have already said Sympathies and Antipathies and though she owes obedience to the commands and dictates of her superior the Rational Soul yet being by so strict a ligue and as it were a conjugal union affianced to the body she is strongly inclined to prefer the conservation of that her favorite to all other relations and accordingly to gratify and indulge it even in those things that are prohibited by religion and reason So that no wonder if she be affected with pleasure or pain and with all other passions referible to them for the prosperous or adverse state of the body To make this our entrance into the spring-head of all Passions somwhat more lightsome we are here to recount two fundamental verities both of so conspicuous evidence I do not remember I ever heard them contradicted One is that all Affects which external objects can possibly excite in us in respect of the various modes or manners by which they fall under our notice may be commodiously referred to two general heads namely Pleasure and Pain For whatever is perceived by the Senses appears to the Soul to be Good or Evil gratefull or offensive and whatever is offered to her under the apparence of Good or Gratefull instantly causeth some certain Pleasure in her as on the contrary whatever is represented to her as Evil or offensive as quickly raiseth in her some kind of Pain or trouble provided as was before advertised she apprehend herself to be any way concerned in such good or evil So that we cannot but applaud the judgment of Epicurus and Aristotle in constituting but two kinds of Passions namely Pleasure and Pain the one calling them 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 voluptatem dolorem the other naming them 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 voluptatem molestiam The other is that all the various motions of the spirits and blood or of the Sensitive Soul excited in the various Passions may likewise be conveniently reduced to two general heads namely Contractions and Effusions which our Master Galen I remember terms 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 as they are referred to Pain and Pleasure Because in Pleasure the Soul dilateth herself as much as she can that is she diffuseth the spirits as her Emissaries to meet and receive the good represented to her and in Pain she on the contrary compresseth or withdraws herself inward that is she recalls the spirits toward herself in avoidance of the Evil apprehended Manifest it is therefore that all Corporeal Passions have their roots grounded in Sense whereof pleasure and pain â—re two opposite affects one 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 agreeable and familiar to nature â—he other 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 alien and offensive And that I may as far as I am able â—xplain wherein pleasure and displeasure of â—â—nce doth consist I take liberty to supâ—ose that at first when an object affects â—he Sensory with soft and smooth touâ—hes or motions such as are consentaâ—eous to the delicate contexture of the â—erves of which the sensory is chiefly composed or to the internal motions of the spirits therein residing it instantly causeth that gratefull sense called delight as on the contrary if the object invade the sensory with asperity or violence such as hurts the tender nerves thereof or hinders the natural motions of the spirits therein then it produceth that ingrateful sense call'd displeasure or pain The impression being thus made by the object upon the Organ of sense and thence by a certain motion of the spirits resembling the waving of water carried on to the brain if it be pleasant it immediately puts the spirits therein reserved into brisker but regular motions conformable to their nature and uses if displeasing it puts them into confusion If the impression be light the motion thereby caused in the brain soon decayeth and vanisheth of itself if strong the motion is continued from the brain down to the breast and the heart and blood participate thereof respectively and so passion instantly succeeds But whether this be the true manner of objects producing pleasure or displeasure of sense or not most evident it is that we have as no conceptions of things without us in the brain so no passions for them in the heart but what have their firsâ— original from Sense Now having in this manner shewn as plainly as I could 1 what Mutations are incident to the Sensitive Soul 2 what are the most considerable Causes of those Mutations 3 what the most remarkable Effects and consequents of them upon the body and mind of Man 4 the Differences of Passions respective to the various relations of the Sensitive Soul to the Rational and to the body 5 that all passions are referible to pleasure or pain 6 that all Motions of the Spirits and blood caused in passions belong to Contraction or Effusion and 7 wherein consist pleasure and displeasure of Sense our next work must be to speak SECT V. Of the Passions in particular NOt of all that are incident to the mind of Man which were extremely difficult if not altogether impossible for me to do For seeing the objects that raise pleasure and displeasure are innumerable and the various waies or manners by which they affect the sense and excite motions in the brain spirits and heart are equaly innumerable even those Philosophers themselves who have with all possible attention of mind laboured to search out the several sorts of Passions have not been able to take notice but of very few nor to give names to all those neither Besides considering of how subtil particles how fluid and easily moveable a substance and how delicate a contexture the Sensitive Soul seems to be composed we may soon conceive her to be subject to greater variety of impressions commotions fluctuations inclinations alterations and perturbations than can possibly be observed and distinguished even by the most curious It may well suffice then to enumerate and describe the most remarkable of her Passions such as like so many lesser streams flow from the two general fountains before mentioned Pleasure and Displeasure of sense or motions begun in the sensory traduced to the brain and continued to the heart and that are of a more simple nature Which that we may perform with more of order and less of obscurity we are to consider that the Passions receiving their most notable diversity from certain circumstances of Time may therefore be most
intelligibly distinguished by having respect to the same Circumstances For since there are of Conceptions three sorts whereof one is of that which is present which is sense another of that which is past which is Remembrance and the third of that which is to come which is called Expectation it is manifestly necessary that the condition of the pleasure or displeasure consequent to conceptions be diversified according as the Good or Evil thereby proposed to the Soul is present or absent For we are pleased or displeased even at things past because the Memory reviving and reviewing their images sets them before the Soul as present and she is affected with them no less than if the things themselves were present So also of things future forasmuch as the Soul by a certain providence preoccupying the images of things that she conceives to come looks upon them as realy present and is accordingly pleased or displeased by Anticipation every conception being pleasure or displeasure present This being presupposed we proceed to the Genealogy of the passions When the image of any new and strange object is presented to the Soul and gives her hope of knowing somwhat that she knew not before instantly she admireth it as different from all things she hath already known and in the same instant entertains an appetite to know it better which is called Curiosity or desire of Knowledge And because this Admiration may and most commonly is excited in the Soul before she understands or considers whether the object be in itself convenient to her or not therefore it seems to be the first of all passions next after Pleasure and Pain and to have no Contrary because when an object perceived by the sense hath nothing in it of new and strange we are not at all moved thereby but consider it indifferently and without any commotion of the Soul Common it is doubtless to Man with Beasts but with this difference that in Man it is always conjoyned with Curiosity in Beasts not For when a Beast seeth any thing new and strange he considereth it so far only as to discern whether it be likely to serve his turn or to hurt him and acordingly approacheth neerer to it or fleeth from it whereas Man who in most events remembreth in what manner they were caused and begun looks for the cause and beginning of every thing that ariseth new to him Whence it is manifest that all natural Philosophy and Astronomy owe themselves to this passion and that ignorance is not more justly reputed the mother of Admiration than Admiration may be accounted the mother of knowledge the degrees whereof among Men proceed from the degrees of Curiosity Now this Passion is reducible to delight because Curiosity is delight and so by consequence is Novelty too but especialy that novelty from which a Man conceiveth an opinion of bettering his own estate whether that opinion be true or false for in such case he stands affected with the hope that all Gamesters have while the Cards are shuffling as Mr Hobbs hath judiciously observed Nevertheless it seems rather a calm than a tempest of the mind For in Admiration whereby the Soul is fixt upon the contemplation of an object that appears to her new and strange and therefore well worthy her highest consideration the Animal spirits are indeed suddainly determined and with great force partly to that part of the brain where the image is newly formed and partly to the Muscles that serve to hold the organs of the external senses in the same posture in which they then are that so the object may be more clearly and distinctly perceived yet in the heart and blood there happens little or no commotion or alteration at all Whereof the reason seems to be this that since the Soul at that time hath for her object not good or evil but only the Knowledge of the thing which she admires she converts all her power upon the brain alone wherein all sense is performed by the help whereof that knowledge is to be acquired And Hence it comes that Excess of Admiration sometimes induceth a Stupor or Astonishment and where it lasteth long that wonderful disease of the brain which Physicians name Catalepsis whereby a Man is held stiff motionless and senseless as if he were turned into a statue For it causeth that all the Animal Spirits in the brain are so vehemently imployed in contemplating and conserving the image of the object that their usual influx into other parts of the body is wholy intercepted nor can they by any means be diverted whereby all members of the body are held in a rigid posture inflexible as those of a dead carcas or of Man killed by lightning Of this admirable effect of excessive Admiration Nich. Tulpius an eminent Physician of Amsterdam hath recorded observ medic lib. 1. cap. 22. a memorable Example in a young Man of our Nation who violently resenting a suddain and unexpected repulse in his love and astonished thereat became as it were congeal'd in the same posture and continued rigid in his whole body till next day Immoderate Admiration therefore cannot but be by fixation of the Spirits hurtfull to health After admiration followeth Esteem or Contempt according as the thing appears great and worthy estimation or of small value and contemptible For which reason we may esteem or contemn ourselves also from whence arise first the Passions and consequently the Habits of Magnanimity or Pride and of Humility or Abjection But if the Good that we have a great esteem of in another man be extraordinary then our esteem is increased to Veneration which is the conception we have concerning another that he hath the power to do unto us both good and hurt but not the will to do us hurt accompanied with an inclination of the Soul to subject ourselves to him and by fear and reverence to purchase his favour All which is evident in our worship or veneration of God That these two contrary Passions Existimation and Contempt are both consequents of Admiration is inferrible from hence that when we do not admire the the greatness or smalness of an object we make neither more nor less of it than reason tells us we ought to doe so that in such case we value or despise it without being concerned therein that is without passion And although it often happens that Estimation is excited by Love and Contempt proceeds from Hatred yet that is not universal nor doth it arise from any other cause but this that we are more or less prone to consider the greatness or meanness of an object because we more or less love it But though Estimation and Contempt may be referred to any objects whatsoever yet are they then chiefly observed when they are referred to ourselves that is when we put great or small value upon our own merit And then the motions of the Spirits upon which they depend are so discernible that they change
most swiftly transmitted from the brain into all parts of the body that may any way serve to do the actions requisite to that end but above all into the Heart which being thereby dilated and contracted both more strongly and more frequently than in the state of tranquility quickly forceth up a more abundant supply of Vital Spirits with the blood into the brain aswell that they may there conserve and corroborate the Idea of this Desire as that whole brigades of them may be from thence dispatched into the Organs of the Senses and into all Muscles whose motions may more especially conduce to obtain what is so vehemently desired And from the Souls reflexion upon the delay of her fruition which she at the same time makes there ariseth in her a sollicitude or trouble whereby she is checked and contracted again and the spirits are by intervals retracted toward the brain So that the more subtil and spiritual blood being with the spirits recalled from the outward parts the heart comes to be constringed and streightned the Circulation of the blood retarded and consequently the whole body left without spirits and vigor Let none therefore admire if many of those Men whom Lust or Concupiscence Ambition Avarice or any other more fervent desire hath long exercised and inslaved be by continual sollicitude of mind brought at length into an ill Habit of body to leanness a defect of Nutrition Melancholy the Scurvy Consumption and other incurable diseases Nor are you after this so clear manifestation of the great disparity betwixt the Motions and necessary Consequents of Love when pure and simple and those of Love commixt with Cupidity or ardent Desire of enjoyment longer to doubt but that Love and Desire are Passions essentially different notwithstanding it be true that the Later is alwaies dependent upon the Former And as for the Motions of the Spirits and blood in that anxious Affect of the mind Hatred which is directly opposed to Love evident it is that when the Soul is moved to withdraw herself from any object that appears to threaten Evil or pain instantly the Spirits are retracted inwards to the brain and principaly to that part of it which is the instrument or mint of Imagination there to corroborate the idea of Hatred which the first thought hath formed of the ungrateful object and to dispose the Soul to sentiments full of bitterness and detestation So that the while very few of them and those too inordinately and by unequal impulses are transmitted into the Heart by the Pathetic nerves And from this offensive Contraction of the whole Sensitive Soul and as it were compression of the Animal spirits and subsequent destitution of the Heart it comes that in this sowr passion alwaies the Pulse is made weak and unequal and oftentimes frequent and creeping that cold mixt with a certain pricking heat not easy to be described but sensibly injurious to the vital parts and repugnant to their regular motions is felt within the breast and that even the stomach itself diverted from its office of Concoction nauseateth the meats it had received and strives to reject them by vomit Which often happens upon sight of an odious and abominable object Now all these evil effects of Hate give indisputable evidence that it can never be either gratefull to the mind or beneficial to the motions of life upon which health so nearly depends and this because Hate always hath Sadness for its concomitant and because by diversion of the Animal spirits partly to assist the Imagination partly to move the members for avoidance of the hated object it defrauds the blood of its due supplies of spirits and fewel retards the motion and equal distribution of it and by that means destroies concoction incrassates the humors heaps up melancholy and by degrees brings the whole body to poverty and leanness Moreover sometimes this disagreeable Passion is exalted to Anger whereby the Soul offended with the Evil or wrong she hath suffered at first Contracts herself and by and by with vehemency springs back again to her natural posture of Coextension with the whole body as if the strove to break out into revenge and then it is that the spirits are in a tumultuous manner and impetuously hurried hither and thither now from the brain to the heart then back again from the heart to the brain and so there follow from these contrary motions alternately reciprocated aswell a violent agitation palpitation burning and anxiety of the heart as a diffusion of the blood distension of the veins redness of the face and sparkling of the eyes together with a distorsion of the mouth such as may be observed in great indignation and seems composed of laughter and weeping mixt together grinding of the teeth and other symptoms of Anger and fury It is not then without reason Physicians advise Men to decline this passion as a powerful enemy to health in all but such as are of a cold dull and phlegmatic temperament because it inflames first the spirits then the blood and when violent it puts us into fevers and other acute distempers by accension of choler and confusion of humors And I could furnish you with examples of some whom this short fury hath fired into perpetual madness of others whom it hath fell'd with Apoplexies others whom it hath thrown into Epilepsies rack'd with Convulsions unnerved with Palseys disjoynted with the Gout shook with tremblings and the like but that the books of Physicians are full of them Here before we proceed to other consequent Passions it is fit to make a short reflexion upon Hatred that I may verify what was only hinted in the precedent enumeration of the evil Effects thereof viz. that it is ever accompanied with Sadness Concerning this therefore I reason thus Forasmuch as Evil the proper object of Hate is nothing but a Privation and that we can have no conception thereof without some real Subject wherein we apprehend it to be and that there is in nature nothing real which hath not some goodness in it it follows of necessity that Hatred which withdraws us from some Evil doth at the same time remove us also from some Good to which the same is conjoyn'd And since the Privation of this Good is represented to the Soul as a Defect or want belonging to her it instantly affecteth her with sorrow For Example the Hate that alienateth us from the evil manners of a man with whom formerly we have been acquainted separateth us likewise from his Conversation wherein we might find somthing of Good and to be deprived of that Good is matter of regret and Sorrow So in all other Hatred we may soon observe some cause of Sorrow ¶ To the excitement of Desire in the Soul it is sufficient that she conceive the acquisition of the Good or avoidance of the Evil represented to her as to come to be possible but if she further consider whether it be Easy or Difficult for her to
are observable from their respective Characters or Effects In Hope therefore which we defined to be a gentle and sweet Effusion or Expansion of the Soul towards some good expected to come if we be possessed with an opinion that the thing desired will shortly come to pass I conceive that presently the Animal Spirits which before were imployed as Emissaries to contemplate the image of the object returning toward the Soul give notice of the approach of the guest expected and that thereupon the whole Soul composing herself by expansion to receive and welcome the same sets open all the doors of the Senses to admit more freely all the good belonging thereunto retains the imagination fixt and intent upon the gratefull idea thereof and by copious supplies of spirits dispatched into the nerves of the Heart so invigorates and quickens the pulse thereof that thereby the blood is more briskly sent forth into the outward parts of t he body as it were to meet the expected thing Whence it is that when we are full of Hope we feel a certain inflation both within and without in our whole body together with a glowing but pleasant heat from the blood and spirits universaly diffused But if during this comfortable emotion of the Soul there occurr any suddain cause of Doubt or fear she is instantly checked and coold into an anxious Retraction of herself and a sinking of the spirits so that the motion of the heart becomes weaker and slower and the external parts grow languid and pale For In Fear the Sensitive Soul which was before expansed being surprised with apprehension of approaching Evil and willing to decline it immediately withdraws herself into her retiring room and shrinks up herself into herself at the same time recalling her forces the spirits to her aid and compressing them If the Fear be exalted to the degree of Terror and the Evil seem impendent then at the same time the spirits are suddainly recall'd from the outguards the pores of the skin also are shut up by strong constriction as if the Soul would obstruct and barricado all avenues against her invading enemy whereby the hairs are raised an end and the whole body is put into a Horror or shaking After this if the passion continue the whole army of spirits being put into confusion so that they can not execute their offices the usual succors of Reason fail and the powers of voluntary motion become weak yea sometimes by reason of a resolution of the nerves and sphincters of the gutts and bladder the Excrements themselves are let forth involuntarily From this damp obscuring the Lucid part of the Sensitive Soul there quickly succeeds an Eclipse also of the Vital For the influx of the Animal spirits from the brain into the Cardiac nerves being intermitted the motions of the heart must of necessity be renderd weak and insufficient to maintain with due vigour and celerity the circulation of the blood which therefore stopping and stagnating in the ventricles of the heart causeth fainting and swooning by oppression and sometimes where the passion is hightned into Consternation also suddain death And from this arrest of the blood in the heart by strong constriction of the nerves thereunto belonging we may with reason derive that same anxious oppression and chilling weight which men commonly feel in their breast when they are invaded by violent Fear and upon which the most acute Monsieur Des Cartes seems to have reflected his thoughts when he defined Consternation to be not only a cold but also a perturbation and stupor of the Soul which takes from her the power of resisting evils that she apprehends to be neer This Fear when it excludes all hope of evasion degenerateth into the most cruel of all passions Desperation Which though by exhibiting the thing desired as impossible it wholy extinguish desire which is never carried but to things apprehended as possible yet it so afflicts the Soul that she persevering in her Constriction either through absolute despondency yeelds up herself as overcome and remains half-extinct and entombd in the body or driven into confusion and neglect of all things contracts a deep Melancholy or flyes out into a furious Madness in both cases seeking to put an end to her misery by destroying herself On the contrary when Fear gives place to Hope and that Hope is strong enough to produce Courage thereby to incense the Soul to encounter the difficulties that oppose her in the way to her end in this case she first dilates herself with great vigor and celerity breaking forth as it were into flashes of efforts then instantly diffuseth whole legions of spirits into the nerves and muscles to extend them in order to resistence or striking with all their forces and uniting all her powers into a brave devoir to overcome undauntedly pursues the the conflict Hence it comes that the breast being strongly dilated and contracted alternately the voice is sent forth more sounding and piercing than at other times as if to sound a defiance and charge at once the armes are raised up the hands constringed into fists the head advanced into a posture of daring and contempt of danger the brows contracted and the whole face distorted into an aspect full of terror and threatnings the neck swoln and most other parts distended beyond their usual dimensions All which symptoms evidently arise from a copious and impetuous effusion of Animal spirits from the brain and of blood from the heart into the outward parts ¶ From this concise explication of the motions of the Sensitive Soul the spirits and blood that constitute the passions of Hope and Fear with their dependents Animosity and Desperation the clue of our method leads us to the fifth classis of passions The consideration of good present and belonging to us in particular begets in the Soul that delight which we call Ioy wherein consisteth our possession of that good which the impressions of the brain represent to the Soul as her own First I say that in this delightful commotion doth consist the possession of good because in truth the Soul reaps no other fruit from all the goods she possesseth and when she takes no delight or joy in them it may justly be said she doth no more injoy them than if she did not at all possess them Then I add that the good is such as the impressions made upon the brain represent to the Soul as hers that I may not confound this Joy whereof I now speak and which is a Passion with Joy purely intellectual which enters into the Rational Soul by an action proper to her alone and which we may call a pleasant commotion raised by herself in herself wherein consisteth the possession of good that her intellect represents to her as her own Tho realy so long as the Rational Soul continues conjoyned with the Sensitive it can hardly be but that this intellectual joy will have the other that is a passion for its
companion For so soon as our Intellect observes that we possess any good though that good be so far different from all that pertains to the body that it is wholy unimaginable yet presently the Imagination makes some impression in the brain from whence followeth a motion of the Sensitive Soul and of the Spirits that exciteth the passion of Joy Of this so gratefull affection there are divers sorts or to speak more strictly degrees For as various circumstances may intervene and cause the Soul to be more or less affected with her fruition of the good she possesseth so may we distinguish various differences of the passion itself To be more particular as the good she possesseth is great or small unexpected or long desired durable or transitory and as reason moderateth the appetite or suffers it to be unbridled so it comes to pass that the Effusion of the Soul and consequently the pleasure is greater or less permanent or momentary immoderate or temperate c. And hence the kinds of more remiss Joy are call'd Complacency Iucundity Gladness Exhilaration and those of more intens Rejoycing Exsultation Triumph Boasting Transport or Ecstasy Laughter c. By the same reason as the Evil that causeth the opposite passion of Grief is in the present great or little suddain or foreseen long or short and the like so are there excited various kinds or degrees of Trouble or Grief and accordingly the passion is distinguished into Discontent Sollicitude Vexation Sadness Sorrow Affliction Misery Lamentation Weeping and Howling All which belong to Grief which is an ingrateful Languor of the Sensitive Soul wherein alone consisteth the incommodity that hapneth to her from Evil or defect which the impressions made upon the brain represent to her as her own For besides this there is also an Intellectual Sorrow proper to the Rational Soul which is not to be placed in the number of the passions tho for the most part it hath for its adjunct the passion of Sorrow by reason of the most strict conjunction betwixt the two Souls in this life As the Good or Evil present being represented as belonging particularly to ourselves produceth Joy or Grief in us so when Good or Evil is proposed to us as belonging to others we so far concern ourselves therein as to judge them worthy or unworthy of the same If we judge them unworthy of the good that is hapned to them that raiseth Envy in us if we think them not to deserve the Evil that is befallen them then we are affected with Pity or Commiseration which is a species of Sorrow and the contrary to it is Hardness of Heart proceeding either from slowness of imagination for men of dull capacities are generally less apt to pity the calamities of others or from strong opinion of our own exemption from the like sufferings or from that inhuman temper of mind which the Grecians call Misanthropia Hatred of all or most men or finally from despair after long adversity whereby the mind being grown as it were callous or brawny as Seneca expresseth it is apt to conceive that no evil can come to it greater than what it hath been accustomed to undergo On the contrary they are more than others propens to Commiseration who think themselves very weak and obnoxious to adverse fortune because representing to themselves anothers misfortune as possible to happen to themselves also for the evil that happeneth to an innocent man may happen to every man they are easily moved to pity but more out of love of themselves than of others And yet it hath been ever observed that men of the most generous and Heroick spirits such who having by brave resolutions and habitual magnanimity elevated their souls above the power of fortune and so could fear no evil that she could bring upon them have nevertheless been prone to Commiseration when they beheld the infirmity of others and heard their complaints because it is a part of true Generosity to wish well to every one But the Grief of this Heroick Commiseration is not as the other bitter but like that which Tragical cases represented in a Theatre produce it is placed more in the Sense than in the Soul itself which at the same time injoyeth the satisfaction of thinking that she doth her duty in sympathizing with the afflicted And the difference betwixt the Commiseration of the vulgar and that of Generous minds doth chiefly consist in this that the vulgar pittieth the misery of those who complain as thinking the evil they suffer to be very grievous and intollerable but the principal object of generous pity is the imbecillity and impatience of those who complain n because men of great Souls think that no accident can fall upon a man which is not really a less evil than the Pusillanimity of those who cannot endure it with constancy which Seneca intimateth de tranquillitate animâ— cap. 15. where he saith neminem â—â—ebo sientem nam suis lacrymis efficit ne ullis dignus sit and though they hate the vices of men they do hate not their persons but only pity them Manifest it is therefore that in some Commiseration is nothing but imagination of future Calamity to our selves proceeding from the sense of another mans calamity as it is defined by Mr Hobbs in others a species of Grief mixt with Love or Benevolence toward those whom we observe to suffer under some evil which we think they have not deserved as it is defined by Monsieur des Cartes Manifest it is likewise that the contrary passion Envy is a sort of Grief mixt with Hate proceeding from our sense of prosperity in another whom we judge unworthy thereof A passion never excusable but where the Hatred it contain's is against the unjust distribution of the good that is envied not the person that possesseth it or that distributed it But in this corrupt age there are very few so just and generous as to be free from all Hate towards their competitors who have prevented them in the acquisition of a good which is not communicable to many at once and which they had desired to appropriate to themselves though they who have acquired it be equally or more worthy thereof When we reflect our thoughts upon good done by our selves there results to us that internal Satisfaction or Acquiescence of mind which is a species of Ioy calme indeed and serious but incomparably sweet and pleasant because the Cause of it dependeth upon nothing but our selves But then that cause ought to be just that is the good upon which we reflect our cogitations ought to be of great moment otherwise the Satisfaction we fansy to our selves is false and ridiculous serving only to beget pride and absurd arrogancy Which may be specially observed in those who esteem themselves truely religious and pretend to great perfection of Sanctity when in reality they are Superstitious and Hypocrites that is who because they frequent the temple recite
many praiers wear short hair observe fasting-daies give alms and perform other the like external duties of Religion therefore think themselves to be arrived at the highest degree of purity and to be so far in the favor of Almighty God that they can do nothing that may displease him and that whatever their passion suggesteth to them is of holy zeal though it not seldome suggesteth the most detestable crimes that can enter into the heart of Man as the betraying of Cities assassination of Princes extermination of Nations only because they follow not their fanatique opinions And this Delusion seems to be the Daughter of internal Acquiescence grounded upon an unjust cause Again to excite this most comfortable passion it is requisite that the good act upon which we reflect be newly done by us because that constant satisfaction or self-acquiescence which alwaies is a concomitant and certain reward of Virtue is not a passion but a pacific Habit in the Rational Soul and is therefore call'd Tranquility and Quiet of Conscience On the contrary from our remembrance of an Evil act by us committed ariseth Repentance which is a branch of Grief alwaies most bitter because the cause of it is only from ourselves but then this Grief is allayed by expectation of amendment or returning into the right way to good which is referrible to Ioy. Nor doth the bitterness of this passion hinder it from being of excellent use in our life when the action whereof we repent is realy Evil and we certainly know it to be so because in such cases it strongly inciteth us to doe better in the future But it is not universaly profitable For it is no rarity for men of weak and timorous minds to be touchd with Repentance of actions they have done tho they do not certainly know those actions to be realy evil but only believe them to be so because they fear lest they be so and if they had done the contrary they would have been equally disquieted with repentance Which is an imperfection in them well worthy Commiseration and they ought to repent of such their Repentance When we observe or recall to mind good performed by an other tho not to ourselves we are thereby moved to Favour the doer because we are by nature inclined to like and love those who doe actions that we think good althouh from thence nothing of good redounds to us in particular Favour therefore is a species of Love accompanied with desire of seeing good to happen to the person whom we favour and somtimes with Commiseration because the adversity that falls upon those whom we think to be good makes us the more to reflect upon their merits But if the good done by another upon which we reflect our cogitations hath been done to Vs then to favor is adjoined Gratitude which likewise is a kind of Love excited in us by some action of another whereby we believe that eitheâ—â—he hath realy benefited noâ— at least intended to benefit us in particularâ— and accompanied with Desire to shew ourselves thankful to 〈…〉 therefore this passion of Gratitude 〈…〉 excells simple Favour in this that it is grounded upon an action which concerns Vs so hath it far greater force upon the mind especialy in men of noble and generous natures The Contrary hereunto is Ingratitude which notwithstanding is no Passion for Nature as if she abhorr'd it hath ordained in us no motion of the Spirits whereby it might be excited but a meer Vice proper to men who are either foolishly proud and therefore think all benefits due to them or fottishly stupid so as to make no reflexion upon good turns done them or of weak and abject minds who having been obliged by the bounty and charity of their Benefactors instead of being gratefull prosecute them with hatred and this because either wanting the will to requite or despairing of ability to make equal returns and falsely imagining that all are like themselves venal and mercenary and that none doth good offices but in hope of remuneration they think that their Benefactors have deceived them and so deprave the benefit itself into an injury Hatred then being an adjunct to Ingratitude it follows that Love must attend on Gratitude which is therefore alwaies honest and one of the principal bonds of human Society On the contrary when we consider Evil committed by an other tho not against us we are moved to Indignation which is a species of Hatred or Aversion raised in us against those who do any thing that we judge to be evil or unjust whatsoever it be somtimes commixed with Envy somtimes with Commiseration somtimes with Derision as having its object very much diversified For we conceive Indignation against those who doe good or evil to such who are unworthy thereof but we Envy those who receive that good and pity those who suffer that evil And yet in truth to obtain good whereof one is unworthy is in some degree to doe evil and to do Evil is in some sort to suffer evil Whence it comes that somtimes we conjoyn Pity somtimes Derision to our Indignation according as we stand well or ill affected toward them whom we observe to commit Errors And therefore the Laughter of Democritus who derided the folly and the Tears of Heraclitus who bewail'd the misery of mankind might both proceed from the same cause Indignation But when Evil is done to ourselves the passion thereby kindled in us is Anger which likewise is a species of Hatred or Aversation but different from Indignation in this that it is founded upon an action done by another with intention to hurt us in particular and in this that when it hath proceeded to a determination of hurting him who did it it passeth into Revenge whereas at first accension the Passion is no more but Excandescence or suddain Heat of blood The Desire of Revenge that for the most part accompanieth Anger whether it aim at the death or only at the subjection of our Enemy is indeed directly opposed to Gratitude for this is desire of returning good for good and that desire of requiting evil with evil as Indignation is to Favour but incomparably more vehement than either of those three affections because the desire of repelling harm and revenging our selves is a part of natural instinct necessary to self-preservation and so of all desires the strongest and most urgent And being consociated with Love of ourselves it affords to Anger all that impetuous agitation of the Spirits and blood that Animosity and Boldness or Courage can excite and its assistant Hatred promoting the accension of the Choleric or more Sulphureous parts of the blood as it passeth through the heart raiseth in the whole mass thereof a more pricking and fervent heat than that which is observed in the most ardent Love or most profuse Ioy. Now as men inflamed with this violent passion or as Seneca calls itâ— short fury of Anger differ in
point of temperament and as this or that of the usual concomitants of it is more powerful than the rest so must the Effects thereof upon the body be likewise various And from this variety men have taken notice chiefly of two sorts of Anger One that is quickly kindled violent at first and discovers it self visibly by outward signs but performs little and may be easily composed And to this they are most obnoxious who are good-natur'd i.e. who are inclined to goodness and love For it ariseth not from profound Hatred but from a sudden Aversion surprising them because being propens to conceive that all things ought to proceed in that manner which they judge to be the best whenever they see others to act otherwise first they admire and then are offended and so what would be to others matter only of Indignation to them proves cause of Anger But this commotion is soon calmed because the force of the sudain Aversion that raised it continues not long and so soon as they perceive that the thing for which they were offended ought not to have commoved them to passion they suppress their displeasure and repent of it The Other that wherein Hatred and Grief are predominant and which though at first it hardly betray it self by external signs unless by the suddain paleness of the countenance and trembling is notwithstanding more impetuous within secretly gnaws the very heart and produceth dangerous effects And to this pernicious sort of Anger they are most subject who have prouâ— cowardly and weak Souls For so much the greater doe injuries appear by how much the better opinion pride makes Men to have of themselves yea and by how much greater value is put upon the things which the injuries take away and these things are alwaies so much the more valued by how much the more weak and abject the Soul is because they depend upon others but the Generous put little value upon any thing that is not dependent upon themselves When we consider what opinion other Men have of Us the Good which we believe to be in us disposeth us to Glory which seems to be composed of Self-estimation and Ioy for to see ourselves well esteemed by others gives us cause to have a good esteem for ourselves and on the contrary the Evil we are conscious of forceth us to Shame which is a sort of Modesty or Humility and Self-diffidence for as we have formerly observed who thinks himself above Contempt will hardly be humbled to shame These two Passions Glory and Shame tho directly opposite each to other doe yet agree in their End which is to incite us to Virtue the first by hope the other by fear and that we may make a right use of them both we are to have our judgment well instructed what actions are truely worthy praise or dispraise lest otherwise we be ashamed of virtuous actions or affect glory from vices as it happeneth to too great a part of mankind Thus have we at length recounted all the Passions of this our fifth division and deduced them successively from their several causes or occasions in that order wherein their most remarkable diversity seemd to us most easily distinguishable But now because some of these passions are simple others Composed and that to our more clear understanding of the nature of both sorts it is necessary to enquire more profoundly into the Motions of the Sensitive Soul and spirits that constitute their Essential Differences it remains that we yeeld obedience to that necessity so far forth at least as to explain the Motions proper to that couplet of more simple affections Ioy and Grief the two points in which all human actions end and to that most violent one Anger In Ioy therefore which is a delightful commotion of the Sensitive Soul as it were triumphing in her fruition of good or pleasure I conceive that the Animal spirits being in great abundance but with a placid and equal motion sent by the nerves to the heart cause the orifices thereof to be opened and dilated more than at other times and so the blood to be imported and exported more copiously and freely and that by this means from the blood are brought into the brain a plentious supply of new spirits which extracted out of the purest and most refined parts of the blood are most fit to confirm the idea formed of the present good in the imagination and so to continue the Soul in her pleasant Emotion Hence probably it is that in this most agreeable passion both the pulse is alwaies made equal and more frequent tho not so intense and strong as in Love and a certain gratefull heat is felt not only through the Lungs and all the breast but through all outward parts of the body from the diffusion of the blood in full streams into them which is discernible even by the florid purple colour wherewith they are suddainly tinged and by the inflation or plumpness of all the muscles of the face which is thereby rendered more serene sweet and cheerful Easy therefore it is to infer that as this passion is most congruous to the nature of the Corporeal Soul so are the corporeal motions that accompany and characterize it most profitable to health provided they be moderare For this Commotion and Effusion may be so vehement and suddain that the Soul may become weak and unable to rule the body or to actuate the organs of speech yea swooning and death itself somtimes follow profuse and insolent Joy So Lacon Chilo an eminent Philosopher suddainly expired in excessive joy beholding his Sonne a Victor in the Olympic games So Sophocles the Tragedian also and Dionysius the Tyrant died of a surfet of suddain Joy The reason whereof seems to consist not in a vehement effusion and dissipation of the vital spirits and a destitution of the Heart consequent thereunto as Fernelius would have it because the faster the blood is effused through the arteries from the heart the swifter must it return to the heart through the veines so that the heart cannot be totaly exhausted and left destitute of blood but rather in a surcharge and suffocation of the heart by too redundant an afflux of blood For upon extraordinary dilatation of the floud-gates of the heart by immoderate joy the current of blood both out of the Vena cava and from the arteria venosa may pour itself with so much violence and in so great a quantity into the ventricles thereof that the heart unable to discharge itself soon enough of that oppressing deluge by retruding its valves may be suffocated its motions stopped and the Vital Flame in a moment extinguished For certain it is that in the state of health the blood is not admitted into the heart beyond a certain proportion nor can that proportion be much exceeded whatever the cause be that maketh an apertio portarum there without manifest danger of life Among the Signs of this delightful passion
only to make all the Evils they produce easily tollerable but even to reap internal satisfaction and joy from all And secondly it is evident from the very nature of our Passions that they cannot carry us on to any actions whatsoever but only by the Desire they excite in us and therefore if we can but direct that desire to right objects that is to things realy Good we may by that alone prevent our being deceived that is our being carried to evil actions by violence of our Passions but that Right Reason is of itself able so to direct our desire arising from passions is manifest from the known Utility of Moral Philosophy which prescribeth certain rules to that end I will conclude then that I commit Errors in passion not because I am naturaly prone to Passions nor because I want an omniscious Understanding but only because I make not a right use of that finite indeed yet sufficient Vnderstanding God hath given me in the conduct of that Cupidity my passions excite in me That I may therefore be henceforth better able to make use of my Understanding as I ought in such occasions it highly concerneth me to enquire in the next place into the origin of that Error to which the Cupidity accompanying our Passions doth most frequently expose us for that being once known will be the more easily avoidable This Error then doth arise if I mistake not from hence that we do not sufficiently distinguish those things that depend intirely upon ourselves from those that depend upon others as to their events it being a general rule that Desire is alwaies good when grounded upon certain Knowledge and on the contrary alwaies evil when founded upon some error Now as to things that depend upon ourselves alone that is upon our Free-will to know them to be good is sufficient to assure us we cannot desire them too fervently because to doe good things that depend upon ourselves is to pursue Virtue which cannot be too fervently desired nor can the event of our desire of such things possibly be unhappy because from the conscience that by desiring them we have rightly used the freedom of our will we receive all the satisfaction we expected But alass the Error that is too commonly committed in such cases lieth not in the over fervent but in the overcold desire And the best remedy against this defect is to free the mind as much as is possible from all other desires less profitable and then to endeavour clearly to understand and with due attention to examine the goodness of the thing that is represented as worthy to be desired As for the things that are altogether independent upon Vs however good they may be yet we are never to desire them vehemently not only because t is possible they may never arrive and so vex and torment the mind so much the more bitterly by how much the more eagerly they have been desired but chiefly because by preoccupating our thoughts they withdraw our study from other things whereof the acquisition depends upon ourselves And against these vain desires there are two general Remedies whereof the first is true Generosity the other a firm belief of and tranquill dependence upon Providence Divine For that noble and heroic habit of the mind which is called Generosity and which seems to comprehend all other Virtues though it animateth Men to great and honorable enterprises doth yet at the same time restrain them from attempting things which they conceive themselves incapable to effect inspiring courage not temerity Then by teaching that nothing is either more worthy of or more delightful to a spirit elevated by the love of Virtue above the vulgar that to doe good to others and in order thereunto to prefer beneficence to self-interest it makes us perfectly charitable benign affable and ready to oblige every one by good offices when it is in our power so to do Again being inseparable from virtuous Humility it makes us both to measure our own Merits by the impartial rule of right reason and to know that we can have no just right to praise or reward but from the genuin and lauâ—â—ble use of the freedom of our Will. And from these and other the like excellent effects of this divine Virtue it is that the Generous attain to an absolute dominion over their exorbitant passions and desires They conquer Iealousie and Envy by considering that nothing whereof the acquisition depends not wholy upon themselves is realy valuable enough to justify their earnest desire of it They exempt themselves from Hatred towards any by esteeming all as worthy of love as themselves They admit no Fear by being duely conscious of their own innocency and secure in the confidence of their own Virtue They banish Grief by remembring that while they conserve their will to doe good they can be deprived of nothing that is properly theirs And Anger they exclude because little esteeming whatsoever depends upon others they never yeeld so much to their Adversaries as to acknowledge themselves within the reach of their injuries It is not then without reason that I fix upon Generosity as one of the universal remedies against our inordinate Cupidities And As for the other namely frequent reflection upon Providence Divine this doubtless must likewise be of soveraign efficacy to preserve us from all distempers of mind For it establish us in a certain perswasion that it is absolutely impossible that any thing should come to pass otherwise than this Providence hath from all eternity determined and consequently that Fortune is but a Chimera hatch'd in the brain out of an Error of human understanding and nourished by popular superstition For we cannot desire any thing unless we first think the same to be some way or other possible nor can we think those things to be possible that depend not upon us unless so far as we imagine them to depend upon Fortune and that the like have hapned in times past But this opinion proceeds only from hence that we know not all the Causes that concurr to single Effects For when a thing that we have apprehended to depend upon Fortune and so to be possible succeeds not that is a certain sign that some one of the Causes necessary to make it succeed or come to pass hath been wanting and consequently that the same was absolutely impossible as also that the like event that is such a one to the production whereof the like necessary Cause was wanting hath never come to pass So that had we not been ignorant of that deficient Cause we never had thought that event to be possible nor by consequence ever desired it We are therefore utterly to renounce that vulgar absurdity that there is in the World a certain Power called Fortune that makes things to happen or not to hapen as she pleaseth and in the â—oom thereof to establish this great verity that all things are directed by Divine Providence whose decree
obtain her end and there occur to her more reasons for the facility then there succeeds that gentle Effusion or Tendency of the Soul toward the good desired which is called Hope or Expectation of good to come Whereas on the contrary if the greater weight be found in the other Scale and she apprehend the thing desired to be Difficult she is immediately Contracted and coold with that ungrateful passion Fear which is expectation of Evil to come And as Hope exalted to the highest degree is changed into Trust Confidence or Security So on the contrary Fear in extremity becomes Desperation Again if this Contraction of the Soul by Fear be suddain and profound and the Evil expected very great then is the passion called Terror Dread and Consternation which sometimes is so violent as to cause Exanimation or suddain Death If the Soul upon apprehension that the Good desired is not indeed absolutely impossible but highly difficult for her to obtain or the Evil feared is not altogether impossible yet extremely hard to be avoided persist in her Contraction she is daunted or cowd into that ignoble weakness called Pusillanimity or Cowardise But if after her Contraction at first she exserting her strength spring forth as it were and with vehemency dilate herself to surmount her fear and overcome the difficulties apprehended then is she reanimated as it were or fortified with the noblest of all Passions Courage or Boldness or Bravery of Mind which makes her contemn all obstacles to her attainment of her end whether it be the acquisition of good or declination of Evil and which when it is not a habit or natural inclination seems to be an ardor or flashing of the Sensitive Soul disposing her to act vigorously and without fear toward the vanquishing of difficulties that stand betwixt her and the scope she aims at And of this Animosity Emulation is a species whereby the Soul is disposed to attempt or enetrprise difficult things which she hopes will succeed happily to her because she observes them to do so to others But then it is to be distinguished from simple Animosity by two proprieties Whereof One is that it hath not only an internal Cause viz. such a disposition of the spirits and body that Desire and Hope may have greater power in impelling the blood in abundance to the heart than Fear or Despair can have in hindering that motion but also an external Cause namely the Example of others who have been prosperous in the like attempts which creates a belief in us that we also shall be able to conquer the difficulties occurring afwell as those others have done The Other this that Emulation is ever accompanied with secret Grief which ariseth from seeing ourselves exceeded or excelled by our concurrents But simple Animosity wants both Example for incitement and Grief for alloy But both these passions equaly depend upon Hope of good success For Though the object of Audacity be difficulty yet to animate us to contend bravely with that difficulty we must be possessed with a strong hope or certain belief that we shall at length attain our end Yet this end is not the same thing with that object for there cannot be both Certitude and Despair of the same thing at the same time So when the Roman Decii rushed into the thickest troops of their enemies and ran to certain death the object of their daring was the difficulty of conserving their lives in that action for which difficulty they had nothing but Desperation being resolved certainly to dye but their End was either by their example to inspire courage into the Roman army and by them to obtain the victory they hoped or to acquire posthume Glory whereof they were certain If therefore even in this action that was in itself desperate Courage were grounded upon Hope we may well conclude that it is alwaies so From the reasons we have alleged of Hope and Fear it is evident that we may have those contrary passions excited in us though the Event of the thing expected no way depend upon our selves But when we proceed to consider the Event as altogether or for the most part depending upon our own counsel and perceive a difficulty to arise either in our election or execution of the means whereby to obtain our end then there immediately follows a Doubting or Fluctuation of the mind whereby we are disposed to deliberate and consult and which is indeed a species of Fear And this wavering while it retains the Soul as it were in a doubtful balance betwixt two actions which are offered to her election is the cause that she performs neither but takes time to consider before she determineth which to do for fear of erring in her choice Which Fear if moderate and under the command of Prudence is always of good use in that it serves to prevent Temerity or Rashness but in some over-cautious persons it is so vehement that though but one thing occurr to be done or omitted by them it holds them too long upon the rack of suspence and hinders them from proceeding to action And in this case the passion is Excess of Doubting arising from too ardent desire of good success and weakness of Vnderstanding which hath indeed many confused notions but none perspicuous and distinct concerning the means to effect its design If during this irresolution we have determined the liberty of our choice and fixed upon some one action in order to our end and the event be not answerable to our expectation presently we are affected with that disquiet of mind which is named by the Greeks Synteresis by the Latins Morsus Conscientiae and by the French Regret which yet doth not as the precedent passions respect the future but present or past time This Remorse of Conscience is no other but a kind of Sorrow arising from a scruple interposed whether what we are doing or have done be good or not And it necessarily presupposeth dubitation For if we were clearly convinced that the action we are doing is realy evil we should certainly abstain from doing it because the will is not carried to any thing but what hath some shew of goodness in it And if it were manifest that what we have done is realy evil we should presently be touched not with simple regret but with Repentance For as the Good we have done gives us that internal Acquiescence or satisfaction which is of all other Passions the sweetest so on the contrary the ill we have done punisheth us with Repentance which is of all passions the bitterest Having in this manner discovered the originals and distinct proprieties of these two opposite Passions Hope and Fear with their genuin dependents it may not a little conduce to the illustration of what hath here been briefly delivered concerning them if we more expresly describe the divers Motions of the Sensitive Soul and Spirits that constitute their formal reasons so far at least as those motions