19.10 vers 30. vers 37. v. g. Thou shalt not glean thy Vineyard neither shalt thou gather every Grape of thy Vineyard but thou shalt leave them for the Poor I am the Lord thou shalt Reverence my Sanctuary I am the Lord. You shall observe all my Statutes and all my Judgments and do them I am the Lord. Now God is still the Lord of Christians but hence it will not follow that they are obliged to observe these Ceremonial Precepts enjoined for Reasons still remaining and equally concerning Christians it therefore cannot rationally be concluded that Christians are obliged to observe the Rest enjoined in the Fourth Commandment because it is commanded for a Reason that doth still remain 4. Hence we may easily discern the Reason why the Christians still observed one day in Seven and also why they chose to observe the first day of the Week and not the last For when Christianity began it had two sorts of Adversaries to encounter viz. The unbelieving Jews and the Idolatrous Gentiles and therefore as a Testimony against the Heathens who worshipped false Gods that is the Gods who made not Heaven and Earth they chose one day in seven to signifie they worshipped the true God and the Creator of all things But then they chose the first of these seven days to testifie against the Jews that they worshipped this God not now as one in Covenant with the Jews or as their Redeemer out of Egypt but as the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ and through him our most loving Father and to own themselves the Servants of that God who on the morning of that day vanquished Satan the Spiritual Pharaoh and redeemed us from our Spiritual thraldom by raising Jesus Christ our Lord from the dead begetting us instead of an Earthly Canaan to an Inheritance incorruptible in the Heavens Dr. Spencer de Legibus Hebr. Mr. Mede Disc 15. this account of this change of the day I have borrowed from two very Learned and Ingenious men and for the further illustration and confirmation of it lot it be observed 1. That the Jews never worshipped God or put up their addresses to him under the name of Father as we Christians by our Lord are taught and commanded to do in these words When you pray say Our Father this being as the Apostle hath observed the peculiar privilege of Christians above the Jews Rom. 8.15 that we have not received as they the spirit of bondage unto fear but the spirit of adoption whereby we cry Abba Father They were it is confessed Children also Gal. 4.1 4. but nothing differing from servants as being Children in their Minority and so in bondage to the Rudiments of the world whereas we having received through faith in Christ Jesus the Adoption of Sons God hath sent forth the Spirit of his Son into our hearts crying Abba Father It is the saying of the Jews that a servant cannot say unto his Lord Abba this being a word proper to a Son and only used by natural or adopted Sons we being therefore all the Children of God and his adopted Sons through faith in Christ Jesus Joh. 1.12 Gal. 3.26 we have through him received this privilege to address our selves unto him by the name of Abba or our Father and yet more certainly is it peculiar to the Christian to own him as the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ which is his usual name in the New Testament and to address unto him in and by that Name 2ly Observe that the Resurrection of our Lord Christ is generally ascribed in the New Testament to God the Father and when our Lord declares that he had power to lay down his life Joh. 10.18 and take it up again he adds immediately This Commandment have I received of my Father Hence doth the Holy Ghost assure us that God the Father said unto him Thou art my Son Act. 13.33 this day have I begotten thee for this as well as other reasons that he had raised him from the dead and that He was declared to be the Son of God with power Rom. 1.4 by his raising him from the dead 3ly Observe that our Lord's Resurrection is represented as the Great foundation of all the mercies derived to us from our Saviour as being that by which they were compleated or confirmed to us 1 Pet. 3 21. Our Baptism doth save us saith St. Peter through the Refurrection of Christ Jesus Our freedom from condemnation is ascribed rather unto his Resurrection than his death as in that question Rom. 8.34 Who is he that condemns us it is Christ that died yea rather that is risen again Our Justification is ascribed to it Rom. 4.25 For Christ was delivered for our offences and rose again for our justification From it derives our hope of Glory 1 Pet. 1.3 for we are begotten to a lively hope through the Resurrection of our Lord Jesus from the dead of an inheritance incorruptible and undefiled reserved in the Heavens for us In a word 't is the foundation of our whole faith 1 Cor. 15.14 for if Christ be not risen then our faith is vain Since then these blessings so far exceeding those of the Creation or of the Jews deliverance from Egypt were procured to us by the Resurrection of our Lord Ephes 1.19 which was effected 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 by the operation of the strength of the power of God the Father since he became the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ and through him our Father by raising him from the Dead there seems great reason why this day should be appointed as the day in which the Christian should acknowledge himself a Worshipper of God his Father through our Lord Jesus Christ Moreover this day being peculiarly stiled the Lords-day it is highly probable it was observed by Christians primarily in honour of our Lord Jesus Christ and through him to the Glory of God the Father to whom our prayers our praises and spiritual sacrifices are offer'd on that day through Christ And for Illustration of this matter let it be observed 1. That the times of the Messiah were still represented by the Jews under the Notion of Holam Habba or the world to come and the work of the Messiah as a new Creation or a Creation of new Heavens and a new Earth The Lord God shall slay ye and call his servants by another name Isa 65.15 17. Isa 66.22 For behold I create new Heavens and a new Earth and the former shall not be remembred nor come into my mind Accordingly Heb. 2.5 the Author to the Hebrews stiles this new Dispensation 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the world to come and they who then enjoy'd the Gift of Miracles or other extraordinary operations are said to have tasted 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the powers of the world to come Heb. 6.5 And the Renovation of Christians by this Dispensation is represented as a new Creation wrought
therefore though we have used other words in our controversial Discourses against Hereticks 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Ibid. e. yet now that a Confession of the sound Faith and simple manifestation of it lies before us we will temper our stile accordingly 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Pag. 387. c. explaining it more simply and properly and doing only that which may instruct you according to that saying of the Apostle To give a reason of your Faith. Now Pag 389. b. c. saith he in doing this we neither have ability nor leasure to collect all that is said in Scripture of the Father Son and Holy Ghost but we hope saith he to satisfie your Consciences as to the manifestation of our knowledge in the holy Scriptures 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and your full assurance of Faith by those few things we shall select out of the Holy Scriptures And after this long Protestant Preface comes a Creed owned by all Protestants in these words P. 389. d. e. We believe therefore and confess one only true and Good God and Father Almighty of whom are all things the God and Father of our Lord and God Jesus Christ And we believe one only begotten Son of God our Lord and God Jesus Christ the only true God by whom all things both visible and invisible were made and by whom all things consist who in the beginning was with God and was God and after was according to the Scriptures seen on Earth and conversed with Men who being in the Form of God coveted not to be in the World like to God but emptied himself and taking upon him the Form of a Servant by his Nativity of a Virgin and being found in fashion as a Man he fulfilled all things which were written of and concerning him according to the command of the Father being Obedient even to Death the Death of the Cross and being raised again the Third Day from the Dead according to the Scriptures P. 390. a. he was seen by his holy Disciples and the rest as it is written and he ascended into the Heavens and sitteth at the Right-hand of the Father from whence he comes at the end of the World to raise up all and to give to every one according to his Work when the Righteous shall be taken up into Life Eternal and the Kingdom of Heaven but the wicked shall be condemned to everlasting Punishment where their Worm dieth not and the Fire is not quenched and we believe one Holy Ghost and Comforter by whom we are sealed unto the Day of Redemption the Spirit of Truth and of Adoption in whom we cry Abba Father who distributeth and worketh in us the Gifts given of God to every one to profit withal as he willeth who teacheth and brings to our Remembrance all things which he hath heard from the Son. The Good Spirit who Guides us into all Truth and confirmeth all Believers in true and exact Knowledge in pious Worship and spiritual Adoration and in the true Confession of God the Father his only Son our Lord and God Jesus Christ and of himself 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 This we think this is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the Rule of Holy Men. P. 392. And I beseech you laying aside all curious Questions P. 391. and indecent strifes about words 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 to rest contented with the things spoken by Holy Men and by the Lord himself and to withdraw your selves from them that are alien from the Evangelical and Apostolical Faith the Apostle having said That if an Angel from Heaven preach to you any other Doctrine besides that which we have preached unto you let him be accursed and having warned you to withdraw from every one who walks disorderly and not according to the Tradition which you have received from us So that according to St. Basil this Creed is the Tradition received from the Apostles the Evangelical and Apostolical Faith the Rule of Faith to which nothing is to be superadded besides which nothing to be preached as any portion of the Rule of Faith and this whole Faith expresly is contained in Scripture and is delivered in the words of Scripture Laurentius sends an Epistle to St. Austin to know of him Quid sequendum maximè Enchir. c. 4. quid propter diversas principaliter Haereses sit fugiendum What was chiefly to be followed and what by reason of the diversity of Heresies was principally to be avoided quod certum propriumque fidei Catholicae fundamentum what was the sure and proper Foundation of the Christian Faith In Answer to this Enquiry he receives a Treatise from St. Cap. 3. Austin containing 122. Chapters in which he undertakes to teach him what he was to believe to love and hope for and in the general he tells him Cap. 6. that it is easie to instruct him in these three particulars nam ecce tibi Symbolum dominica oratio in his duobus tria illa intuere Cap. 7. for behold the Symbol and the Lord's Prayer in these two see these three things Faith believes Hope and Charity prays and then he goes on to a particular Discourse on all these Heads not speaking throughout all those numerous Chapters of one Article of the Romish Faith excepting only when Chapter the 69. he speaks of Purgatory Fire as of a doubtful and uncertain thing and Chapter 109. he utterly confounds it by laying down for certain That during the time betwixt the Death of Christians and the last Resurrection of their Bodies their Souls are kept in hidden Receptacles as they by reason of the Actions done in their Life time became worthy of Rest or Misery One thing there is still more considerable that when the Arian Heresie sprung up and even in the time and at the Session of the Nicene Council this was still produced as the Faith of the Apostolick Church the Rule of Faith the Faith which they had learned from the Scriptures and had received at Baptism and on account of which they challenged to be owned as Orthodox by all their Christian Brethren Alexander Bishop of Alexandria in his Epistle to his Namesake of Constantinople recites his Creed with this Preface Apud Theodor Hist Eccl. l. 1. c. 3. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 so we believe as it seemed good to the Apostolick Church viz. We believe in one only unbegotten Father and in one Lord Jesus Christ his only begotten Son. Besides this pious Faith of the Father and the Son We confess as the Holy Scriptures teach us one Holy Ghost the Sanctifier of Holy Men under the Old Testament and of the divine Teachers of the New and one only Catholick and Apostolick Church inexpugnable by the World and triumphing over all the wicked Insurrections of the Heterodox after this we confess the Resurrection of the Dead of which our Lord Jesus Christ was the first fruits who indeed and not in appearance only took his Body from the God-bearing Virgin
under Heaven Act. 2.5 and all received the same Traditions and Doctrines which were condemned by our Lord and his Disciples and that it was incredible that Churches so dispersed through many Countries and Nations should agree together to affirm a Falshood for a Truth Now to this way of Arguing I desire to know what Answer can be given but by shewing by what ways such Opinions actually might have spread among them though not originally received and proving from their own Scriptures and Writers That these Opinions were not always held among them and if this way be good when used by Christians against them it must be as good when used by Protestants against Papists if this Plea be sophistical when put into the Mouth of an unbelieving Jew it must be as sophistical when it proceedeth from the Mouth of Papists I have not been so fortunate as to meet with any direct Answer to this Argument only to the Argument urged from the actual Condemnation of our Lord as an Impostor by the Sanhedrim That no Submission no blind Obedience could be due to the Church Guides then ruling in the Jewish Church The Guide of Controversies Disc of the necessity of Ch. Guides c. 3. §. 25. p. 17. Confer avec M. Claude p. 183 184 185. and the Bishop of Meaux thus answer That the Messias coming with Miracles and manifested by the other Two Persons of the Trinity by the Father with a Voice from Heaven commanding to hear him and by the Holy Ghost seen descending on him as also by the Baptist was now from henceforth to be received as the supreme Legislator and nothing to be admitted from others or from the Sanhedrim it self contradictory to what he taught which high Court therefore now for the Accomplishment of his necessary Sufferings was permitted by God to be the greatest Enemy of Truth and guided therein not by Gods but a Satanical Spirit of whose Doctrines therefore our Lord often warned the People to beware The Bishop of Meaux adds nothing considerable to this Answer and is plainly baffled by his learned Adversary Mr. Claude to whose Works I remit the Reader Now First Is it not wonderful to see how these Men say and unsay pronounce a thing impossible in one Case and in another like unto it confess it actually done We shew them That in the Jewish Church such false Traditions had generally prevail'd as tended to evacuate the Law of God render his Worship vain and to engage them to reject the true Messiah and yet they were received as Doctrines of their great Prophet Moses handed down to them by oral Tradition that infallible Preserver of Truth True say they the Church Guides were then permitted by God to be the greatest Enemies of Truth and guided therein not by Gods but a Satanical Spirit add now to this That the Doctrines and Traditions of these Men found general Reception in the Jewish Church And will it not hence follow That Doctrines taught Traditions introduced by the greatest Enemies of Truth and by Men acted not by the Spirit of God but that of Satan may generally prevail to be received as true Doctrines and Traditions derived from prophetical Authority and fit to be assented to received and practised by all Secondly Did these Traditions and false Doctrines against which our Saviour cautioned them begin then only to spring up among them when our Saviour appeared with his Miracles when at his Baptism the Holy Ghost descended visibly upon him and God gave Testimony to him by a Voice from Heaven If so you see that even the whole Jewish Church though scattered throughout the World might all at once embrace Traditions of such evil and pernicious Consequences though they before had never heard one tittle of them and so not only in the Compass of one Age but of Three Years at farthest new and pernicious Doctrines might generally obtain in the whole Jewish Church and why not also in the Western Churches within the compass of Eight hundred Years But that these Doctrines of the Scribes and Pharisees these Traditions which they had received touching Christ's temporal Kingdom and touching the personal Appearance of the Tisbite to be his Fore-runner and touching the Expositions of the Law condemned by Christ were not of so late Date as our Lord's Baptism and Entrance upon his prophetick Office is evident beyond Dispute from what I have discoursed already from Josephus Ch. 11. §. 7. asserting that they were received from the most ancient Jews from Epiphanius that they derived them from Moses from the mention of them in our Saviour 's time as 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Act. xxviij 17. Gal. i. 14. Customs and Traditions received from their Fathers and from the great Incredibility that these things should so generally obtain to be received as Traditions in so short a time Besides we know the Expectation of their temporal King had alarm'd all the East before and their Tradition that Elias the Tisbite should come in Person to anoint him and be his Fore-runner must be as old as the Translation of the Septuagint These Doctrines and Traditions must be therefore taught whilst these Church Guides and Rulers were infallible in the Interpretation of the Scriptures and were true Judges of what they had received by Tradition if ever they were so or rather it must be apparent that they were not so because they generally had prevailed upon the People to receive Doctrines and Traditions of such fatal and pernicious Consequences and therefore all the specious Harangues the Papists make concerning the Impossibility that false Traditions and corrupt Doctrines should prevail amongst them must be as plausible when uttered by the Jew against the Christian as by the Papist against Protestants For v. g. where may they say will you produce the Men of former Ages who taxed the Jewish Church with such corrupt Traditions as your Jesus taxed them with or bid Men beware of the Doctrine of them who sate in Moses Chair or of those Scribes and Pharisees who had obtained so great Credit on the Account of Piety and Learning Do not you Christians own that we were once a right Vine the true and only Church of God till the Appearance and Baptism of your Jesus Who therefore can believe that God would suffer such dangerous Doctrines to prevail in his own Church and raise up no Church Guides except the Sadducees to contradict them until your Jesus and his Disciples undertook to be Reformers of it Where then had God a true Church in the World if not among the People of the Jews What other Church could Christ and his Disciples mention besides that whose Governors he taxed with voiding the Commandments of God and rendring his Worship vain because of some Traditions which they had received from their Fore-Fathers If then God suffered his Church to be all over-run with such a fatal Leprosy where was the watchful Eye of Providence Yea where the Care or Conscience of
will flee Deceit Wisd 1.5 and from Thoughts that are without Understanding and will not abide when Unrighteousness cometh in Now saith he P. 72. if according to the Testimony of the Lord the Holy Spirit rests only upon the Humble and the Meek the Man who trembles at God's Word Et secundum mores hodiernos pauci admodum tales verisimiliter in conciliis sunt and according to the Manners of our Times 't is very likely that few such are in our Councils but of carnal worldly ambitious and contentious Men and of Men having that Knowledge which puffeth up turba solet adesse copiosa the Number usually is very great what necessity is there to believe that the Holy Spirit doth prevail in those Councils and move the Minds of them who always do resist and do oppose his Motions to those things which are most sound and salutary P. 73. If it be not from humane Infirmity but from the Guidance of the Holy Spirit that Councils cannot be deceived who can be sure this Holy Spirit will be present with the major part of an Assembly of such Men they being though in Profession Christians ye in reallity Men of the World who Joh. 14.17 saith St. John cannot receive the Spirit of Truth 2ly Because such corrupt Manners do provoke God in his righteous Judgment to give Men up to strong Delusions and to permit the great Deceiver to prevail upon them according to that Expression of St. Paul That evil Men and Seducers will grow worse and worse 2 Tim. 3.13 deceiving and being deceived Thus of the Times of Antichrist he hath foretold 2 Thess 2.9 10. That because Men received not the Truth in the Love of it therefore God should send among them strong Delusions that they should believe a Lye. And this Account St. Basil also gives of the forementioned Miscarriages of the Church Governors of his Time Ibid. p. 394. viz. That they befel them because being corrupt and abominable in their doings they had deserved the Punishment which the Apostle speaks of saying because they liked not to retain God in their Knowledge therefore he gave them up to a reprobate Sence and which our Lord inflicted on the wicked Jews to whom he therefore spake in Parables 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 that they might not perceive the Divine Mysteries of the Gospel because they first had shut their Eyes made their Ears heavy and their foolish Heart was waxed gross that is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 That by way of Punishment they might be subject unto Blindness in greater Matters Clemangis in this also follows the Sentiments of St. Basil For after he had abundantly declared the great Corruptions of their Manners who usually then met in Councils he puts this Question Ibid. p. 73. Quis certo possit scire an major pars concilij sit digna decipi who therefore can know surely whether the major Part of a Council be not worthy to be deceived 3ly Mens evil Lives had they no other Tempter do naturally incline them to cast off those Principles and Practices which contradict and do condemn their Actions and hinder their Pursuit and free Enjoyment of their sensual Appetites this they must be enclined to do partly to free themselves from the continual Gripings of an evil and condemning Conscience For as Theodoret observes They who have put away the upright Conscience do afterwards cast off the Faith 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 because they cannot bear the Accusations of a guilty Conscience And partly that they may exert more freely that natural Opposition that is in them to that Law of Holiness and Light by which their Actions are reproved according to that saying of our Lord Every one that doth Evil hateth the Light John 3.20 neither cometh he unto the Light least his Deeds should be reproved 'T is this Corruption of Manners which seemeth to have turned all the Severities of ancient Penance and all the wholesom Methods of Church Discipline into Formalities and Superstition into fruitless Pilgrimages the going barefoot the carrying wax Tapers the mumbling over a few Pater Noster's Ave Maria's or penitential Psalms which either the penitent doth not or at the least is not obliged to attend to and which have very little Tendency to the Conversion and Reformation of a Sinner but rather do encourage him to sin at such an easy rate 'T is this hath introduced so many easy Ways of Pardon and Justification Attritio ex turpitudinis peccati Consideratione vel ex Gehennae poenarum metu communiter concipitur Concil Trid. Sess 14. c. 4. Et eum ad gratiam dei in Sacramento poenitentiae impetrandam dispoint Ibid. vid. Catechism Rom. Part. 2. c. 5. §. 37 38. without the bringing forth Fruits meet for Repentance and taught even Councils to determine that Attrition or Sorrow out of apprehension of the Foulness of Sin or the fear of Punishment will dispose Men to obtain the Favour of God in the Sacrament of Penance So that if the vilest Wretch when going out of that World in which he hath lived most lewdly all his Life be afraid of Punishment for his Enormities or apprehensive of the Foulness of them as the more wicked he hath been the likelier he is and the greater Reason he still hath to be provided he be absolved by a Priest he must go out of the World in the Favour of God and in a justified Estate And if so what necessity is there of adding to our Faith Vertue and of patient Continuance in well doing that we may seek for Honour and Immortality or of following after Holiness and Purity of Life that we may see God Moreover Men by their wicked Conversations will be disposed to introduce and cherish such Doctrines as best comply with their impure Inclinations that they may have the greater Freedom in the Pursuit of their Ambition Covetousness and all their other sensual Appetities and may the better gratify those Inclinations And here we have a wide Door open at which the Innovations of the Church of Rome might enter seeing most of them have an apparent Tendance to the gratification of Pride and love of Empire of Covetousness and Ambition of Ease and Freedom from restraint in the Ecclesiasticks and Church Governors and give them Opportunity to Lord it over Mens Consciences to engross the Wealth and the Conveniences of the World to live at ease and to be uncontroulable by any but themselves For do not the Doctrines of Purgatory Pardons and Indulgences directly tend to make them Masters of Mens eternal and by that of their temporal Estates Is not the Treasury of the Saints and of our Saviour 's Merits a way of driving Trade for the enriching their own Treasuries Do not their Masses and Oblations of true propitiatory Sacrifices for the Dead tend to engage all dying Persons to sacrifice their Estates unto them and leave them lumping Summs of Money for that end Are
historical Traditions shewed 1. In the Instance of our Lord's Birth Clauso utero § 4. Of his Age § 5. Of the penetration of his Body through the Doors and the Stone of the Sepulchre § 6. Of the Story of the Phoenix § 7. And of the Cells of the Seventy Interpreters § 8. Observe 3dly That we contend not with the Church of Rome touching Ecclesiastical Traditions concerning Ceremonials and unnecessary Observations but only touching necessary Rules of Faith and Manners § 9. FOR the right stating of this Question let it be considered 1. § 1 That we acknowledge That a Doctrine is neither more or less the Word of God for being written or unwritten for that Word which our Saviour spake unto the Jews was for a time unwritten and yet was nevertheless the Word of God because not written We also say there is no reason to dispute Whether the written or unwritten Word of God when equally known to be so is most to be relied on For the Word of God being therefore believed because known to us to be the Word of God must equally be believed in that Case whether it be written or unwritten Concil Trid. Sess 4. We do not therefore quarrel with the Church of Rome for saying That the Traditions which proceeded from the Mouth of Christ or his Apostles speaking by the Holy Spirit and preserved by a continual Succession in the Catholick Church are with the same Reverence and pious Affection to be received as what they writ But only desire them to prove the things which they affirm and we deny to have been thus delivered and then we promise to receive them as the Truths of Christ. And because Mr. M. hath the Confidence to say P. 397 398. That our Ministers usually so confound the Business that they make their Auditors even to startle when they tell them that we hold Tradition equal to Scripture whereas if they meant to deal really they should say what the Truth is that we do indeed equalize Tradition to Scripture and that we have all reason to do so To let him see how little reason he had to accuse us of corrupt Dealing in this Matter I will faithfully transcribe the Assertions of our most able Writers touching this Point Sect. 16. n. 20. Archbishop Laud declares That the Voice and Tradition of that Church which included in it Apostles Disciples and such as had immediate Revelation from Heaven was Divine and the Word of God from them is of like validity written or delivered Bishop Taylor owns Duct Dubit §. 2. c. 3. p. 484. That Tradition would be of the same use as Scripture is if the Tradition were from Christ and his Apostles and were as Certain as Vniversal as Credible as that is by which we are told that Scripture is the Word of God. We willingly grant saith Mr. Chillingworth Chap. 3. §. 45. vid. Chap. 2. §. 53 88. the Church to be as Infallible in her Traditions as the Scripture is if they be as Vniversal as the Tradition of the undoubted Books of Scripture is And again The Tradition of the Church you say must teach us what is Scripture and we are willing to believe it Answer to the Jes p. 35. Rat. p. 168 210 216. and now if you make it good unto us that the same Tradition down from the Apostles hath delivered from Age to Age and from Hand to Hand any Interpretation of any Scripture we are ready to embrace that also So also Bishop Vsher and Doctor Stillingfleet in his Rational Account frequently And therefore R. H. Guid. Disc 3. c. 11. p. 157. who was better acquainted with our Writings than Mr. M. declares That Protestants acknowledge a sufficient certainty of the Tradition concerning Scripture and consequently concerning all the Articles of Christian Faith that are built on Scripture upon which ground also they freely grant N. B. That if any other point wherein they dissent from Catholicks can be proved by as Universal a Tradition as that of the Scriptures they will subscribe to it We therefore manifestly do agree with Chrysostom Oecumenius and Theophylact when they say That the things delivered by the Mouth of the Apostles Oecum in 2. Thess ij 15. Chrysost ibid. Theophylact and by their Writings are 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 both worthy of Observation That 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 both equally deserve to be credited when we have equal certainty of both and therefore these passages are vainly cited against us by Mr. M. Let him once prove that the same Tradition tells us That the Apostles delivered the Points in Controversy betwixt us and the Church of Rome as Divine Verities by word of Mouth only and we are all his Humble Servants But alas he knows how vain and how impossible an attempt this would be § 2 and therefore thinks it better boldly to assert what he can never prove by saying P. 399. That our best and only assurance that the Scripture is the Word of God is that all the Christian world saith so but the same Tradition which tells us this tells us also that the Apostles delivered these and these Points to us as Divine Verities by word of Mouth viz. All the Traditions received as Apostolical in the Roman Church Now to reflect a little on this false Assertion and to expose this way of Arguing 1. Put it into the Mouth of a Jew and it thus pleads for those Traditions which our Lord condemned and by which they condemned him The best and only Assurance which you Jewish Christians can have that the Scripture of the Old Testament is the Word of God is that all the Jews say so but the same Tradition which tells us this tells us also That Moses and the Prophets delivered these and these Points to us as Divine Verities by word of Mouth which your Jesus rejected as vain Worship and as the Doctrines of Men 1 Pet. 1.18 and your St. Peter mentions as Traditions received from our Fathers though he stiles them vain you therefore must have equal Reason to receive those Traditions which condemn your Jesus and shew he could not be the true Messiah as to own those Scriptures of the Old Testament which say you Prophesied of him 2. Though we grant the Attestation of the whole Christian World to be a very good assurance of any necessary Article of Christian Faith yet have we more assurance that the Scriptures are the Word of God than so As 1. The necessity that the Christian Revelation should be preserved in some Records and the assurance that we have that it hath been preserved to us in no other The necessity I say that the Christian Revelation should be preserved in some Records for if St. Paul thought it necessary to write to the Church of Rome Rom. xv 15. 2 Cor. i. 13. to put them in remembrance of the Grace given to him as also to send in writing
by Christ Ephes 2.10 for we are his workmanship created in Christ Jesus to good words He hath abolished the Law of Commandments 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Ver. 15. that he might create those two the Jew and Gentile into one new man in himself so that now if any man be in Christ Jesus he is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 a new Creation 2 Cor. 5.17 old things are pass'd away that all things might become new in him for in Christ Jesus nothing availeth 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Gal. 6.15 but this new Creation 2ly Observe that this new World and new Creation Hieron Theodoret in Isa 9.6 Euseb dem Evan. l. 7 p. 336 as it was made by Christ so is it immediately subjected to him He by the Septuagint was stiled 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the Prince of Peace the Father of the Age to come to him and not unto the Angels Heb. 2.5 Ver. 8 9. hath God subjected this world to come He hath crown'd him with Glory and Honour and set him over the works of his own hands and hath put all things in subjection under his feet Joh. 5.23 Phil. 2.10 11. declaring that he will have all men honour the Son even as they honour the Father and determining that at the Name of Jesus every knee should bow and every tongue should confess that Jesus was the Lord to the Glory of God the Father Moreover this power he received at the Resurrection having then Mat. 28.18 as he saith all power both in Heaven and Earth committed to him being then saith the Apostle Peter made both Lord and Christ Act. 2.36 and exalted to be a Prince and a Saviour whence he is said to be the first born from the dead Col. 1.10 that he might be in all things 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the preeminent 3ly Observe that Christians are represented in the New Testament as those who do succeed the Jews in all their Covenant-Relations Rom. 11.19 They being broken off from the true Olive and we grafted in and being therefore a chosen Generation a peculiar people a Royal Priesthood an Holy Nation to shew forth the vertues of him who called us from darkness to light 1 Pet. 2 9. and from the power of Satan unto God. This Covenant-Relation they enjoy by virtue of that Jesus who is the Mediator of a better Covenant and who gave himself for us that he might redeem us Tit. 2.14 and purifie us to himself a peculiar people In fine the vertues for which we are to celebrate his Praises are our Redemption by him from the wrath to come from the curse of the Law from the power of Satan from the dominion of sin our Adoption our receiving of the spirit by which we are enabled to cry Abba Father and as a consequent of that our being heirs of Glory and all these mercies as I have observed already were confirmed by and were compleated to us at his Resurrection If then in this Oeconomy there be a new world and a new Creation a new Lord to whom this world is subject and who is to be honoured and worshipped as the former was tho' to the honour of the former if there be a new Covenant established in his blood and by which he hath purified to himself a peculiar people if to this Lord all power both in Heaven and Earth is given by the Creator of the World unto this very end that all men might thus honour him if this Lord hath procured for us a Redemption from the power of Sin and Satan much more valuable than the Redemption of the Jewish Nation from Egyptian thraldom if by his Resurrection we are all begotten to the lively hope of a much better Canaan is there not cause sufficient for the Translation of the Day appointed for the celebration of the mercies of the old Creation and of deliverance from the Jewish thraldom and the agnizing of the Author of it as the Lord that sanctified them to a day appointed for Celebration of the new Creation and the deliverance accomplished by it and the acknowledging the Author of it as the Christians Lord Is there not cause sufficient why Christians should observe the day on which their Lord did triumph over their spiritual Pharaoh redeem'd them from spiritual thraldom begot them to a lively hope of a Spiritual Canaan â—nd by the observation of it should profess that they are Christians and 〈◊〉 that Jesus who is Lord of all things Can we refuse to give this honour to the Son who is by God's appointment to be honoured as the Father and whom we do thus worship to the Glory of God the Father Mr. M. in behalf of the Sabbatarians Objects § 15. Obj. 2. §. 9. p. 207 208. Mat. 19.17 18. Mark 10.19 Luk. 18.20 That ouâ— Lord said to one enquiring of him What good thing shall I do to have eternal life if thou wilt enter into life keep the Commandments and when he still enquired of him which Commandments did clearly explicate himself to mean all the Commandments of the Decalogue given by Moses whence he insers That the Author of our new Law with his own mouth required no less the keeping of this Commandment of the Saturday Sabbath as necessary for our entrance into life everlasting than the keeping any other Commandment Answ 1. This Assertion is expresly false and manifestly contradicts the Text for in none of these Evangelists doth our Lord mention the Commandments of the first Table of which that of the Sabbath is one but only doth enumerate those which belonged to the second 2ly His Inference is also-false for Christ there speaks not of what was necessary to Salvation to be observed by the Christian after his Resurrection but of what was necessary then to be observed by the Jew speaking there to a Jewish Governour who was acquainted already with the Law of which he spake and had observ'd it from his Youth Mr. M. Objects That St. Paul preached every Saturday §. 16. Obj. 3. Act. 18. p 209. for he disputed in the Synagogue every Sabbath Answ 1. To this I answer first That this Apostle hath declared that the seventh-day Sabbath was part of that hand-writing of Ordinances which Christ took away and was a shadow of good things exhibited by Christ and so he plainly did discharge the Christian from observation of the Rest required by the fourth Commandment on the Sabbath day 2ly That He or any of his Brethren preached the Gospel in the Jewish Synagogues upon that day can be no evidence that they esteemed the Rest required on that day obliging to the Christian but only that they prudentially complied with Jews and Proselytes in coming to their Assemblies on that day that so they might have more familiar access unto them and better opportunity to instruct them in the Christian faith and therefore in pursuance of the same good end St. Paul who was most free
Lib. 1. c. 2. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 from the Apostles and their Disciples The true and life-giving Faith quam ab Apostolis Ecclesia percepit distribuit filiis suis Lib. 3. c. 1. Apol. c. 47. which the Church received from the Apostles and distributes to her Sons It saith Tertullian is the Rule of Truth quae venit à Christo transmissa per comites ejus which came from Christ and was by his Companions handed down to us De praescrip Cap. 9. Cap. 14. Cap. 21. Epist ad Jov. Tom. p. 246 247. Pag. 501. Epist 81. The Institution of Christ which all Nation ought to believe Regula à Christo instituta The Rule prescribed by Christ and which the Churches received from the Apostles the Apostles from Christ This saith Athanasius is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the Divine and Apostolical Faith which was preached from the beginning It is saith Cyril of Jerusalem the Tradition 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 of the Holy and Apostolick Faith. Is is saith Ambrose the Symbol of the Faith of the Apostles which Symbol the Church of Rome keeps undefiled Ruffinus in his Exposition of this Symbol saith Apud Hieron Tom. 4. f. 46. That their Ancestors left to them this Tradition that the Apostles being to depart one from the other did first agree upon this as the Rule of what they afterwards should preach and determined hanc credentibus dandam esse regulam this should be given as a Rule to Believers and as an Index of their Faith by which he should be known qui Christum vere secundùm Apostolicas regulas praedicaret who preached Christ truly according to the Rules of the Apostles It is saith Austin De Temp. Serm. 181. To. 10. p. 984. certa Regula Fidei the sure Rule of Faith which the Apostles delivered And then he proceeds almost in the very words of Ruffinus De Off. Eccles l. 2. c. 22. to declare That this was the Tradition of the Ancients Isidore Hispalensis saith Tali ratione institutum majores nostri dixerunt Our Ancestors have said that the Apostles Creed was instituted after this manner and then he goes on in the very words of Ruffinus to the end of that Chapter De instit Cler. l. 1. c. 27. l. 2. c. 56. Rabanus Maurus also hath transcribed the same words and in them brought down the Tradition to the Ninth Century And to return to the Age following Ruffinus Pope Leo tells us Ep. 96. This is the short and perfect Confession of the Symbol which is signed with the twelve Sentences of the Apostles Praefat. ad Expos Symb. Apost Apud Ivon decret part 1. c. 35 36. Venantius Fortunatus in the Sixth Century informs us That this is the Symbol which they among themselves wholesomely made by the assistance of the Holy Spirit It is saith venerable Bede the Symbol of Faith delivered by the Apostles 3. It is also evident from Tradition § 6 that Christians were received into the Church by Baptism on the profession of this Faith or that this only was the Faith which they required them to believe and to profess at Baptism Justin Martyr saith only in the general That as many as believed Apol. 2. p. 93. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 that the things which were said and taught by Christians were true were admitted by Baptism among the number of Christians But Irenaeus his Cotemporary L. 1. c. 1. p. 40. gives us the Creed delivered by the Apostles and says it was the undeclinable Rule of Truth 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 which the Christian received by Baptism and the preaching of that Truth by which 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the Church illuminates all that are willing to come to the knowledge of the Truth L. 7. c. 40 41. The Apostolical Constitutions tell the Priest what the Catechist who is to be Baptized must renounce 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and the things which cencern his being Listed among Christians Now they are these I rank my self among the Souldiers of Christ and I believe I am Baptized into the one unbegotten only true God c. And after he hath made profession of this Creed he is to be Anointed and Baptized Can. 46. The Council of Laodicea saith That they who are to be Baptized must first 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 learn the Faith and recite it to the Bishop or his Presbyter The Seventy eighth Canon of the Sixth General Council saith the same thing Now what it is to learn the Faith we know from all the Fathers of those times who do with one consent inform us that the Catechists were prepared for Baptism by being taught the Creed the Symbol or the Rule of Faith delivered and taught by the Apostles and afterwards explained by that of Nice or of Constantinople and that they were Baptized into the profession of this Creed Hist Eccl. l. 1. c. 18. Sozomen and Gelasius inform us that a plain Lay-man and Confessor undertook to confute a Philosopher in the Council of Nice Gelas Cyz l. 2. c. 13. And that he did this by repeating of his Creed saying to the Philosopher There is one God who having made all things sustained them by his Word and holy Spirit This word O Philosopher we adore knowing him to be the Son of God and believing that for our Redemption he was incarnate of a Virgin and was born and was made Man and that by his Death and Passion on the Cross he delivered us from eternal condemnation and by his Resurrection he purchased for us Life eternal whom being ascended into Heaven we hope that he will come again to be judge of all our Actions And that the Philosopher answering 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Syn. Const sub Menna Act 5. Bin. Tom. 4. P. 78 82. He believed this the Confessor bid him then follow him to the Church to be Baptized at which 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the Nicene Synod rejoiced From both which Instances we learn what was the Symbol into which Christians were Baptized when that Council met and which they owned as sufficient for that end Eusebius Caesariensis speaks thus of his own Creed approved by the Nicene Council As we have received from the Bishops that were before us Socr. Hist Eccl. l. 1. c. 8. p 24. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 both when we were Catechized and when we received Baptism and as we have learned from the Scriptures and as we have both believed and taught when we were made Priests and Bishops so believing at present we declare this our Faith unto you The Council of Constantinpole confirms the Nicene Confession of Faith as 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Theodor. Hist Eccl. l. 5. c. 9. being most ancient and annexed to Baptism Con. Constant sub Menna Act. 5. Bin. Tom. 4. p. 78 87 85. 91 96. The Synod of Jerusalem says it was 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 The Holy Symbol into which we were Baptized and
It is saith Hilary Ad. Const Aug. p. 342. 343. the safest course to retain that first and only Evangelical Faith confessed in Baptism and to innovate nothing in it And this he affirms in opposition to the New Creeds so frequent in his Days 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Orat. 52. init Ep. ad Epictet Tom. 1. p. 582. a. Epist ad Afric Episc p. 932. The Creed of Nice saith Nazianzen is a short Boundary and Rule of Christian Wisdom It is saith Athanasius sufficient for the destruction of all Impiety 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and for the confirmation of the true Faith in Christ for the destruction of every wicked Heresie 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and for confirmation of the ecclesiastical Doctrine The Synod held at Sardis defined That nothing farther should be written of the Faith but that all Men should rest contented with the Faith confessed at Nice Athanas Ep. ad Antioch p. 576. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 because it was in nothing defective and because if any other Faith should be composed that might be looked upon 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 as imperfect St. De tempore Serm. 115 119 131 Austin saith That the Catholick Faith is made known to the Faithful in the Creed that this Creed is Comprehensio fidei nostrae atque perfectio The comprehension and perfection of our Faith that it is Plenitudo credentium totum continens compendio brevitatis confirmans onnes perfectione credendi The fulness of Believers comprising the whole of their Faith in a compendious brevity Ep. 84. Tom. 3. p. 961. and confirming all in perfect Faith. Theodoret writes to the Bishops of Cilicia that they would require their People tokeep the Nicene Faith entire and undefiled 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 as compendiously teaching the Evangelical and Apostolical Doctrine Damasus closeth his Symbol which for substance is the same with that of Nice Apud Hieron Tom. 4. f. 44. in these expressions Haec crede haec retine believe and retain these things Subject thy Soul to this Faith and thou shalt obtain Life and a reward from Christ which shews he thought this Faith sufficient for that end Ibid. f. 46. Ruffinus informs us that according to the request of Pope Laurence he was to compose something de fide secundum Symboli traditionem of the Faith delivered in the Symbol And of this he declares That it was norma praedicationis the Rule of the Apostles preaching the Rule which they composed credentibus dandam to be delivered to Believers fidei suae indicium the index of their Faith. Petrus Chrysologus saith Serm. 57 58 59 60 61. That it is salutis symbolum vitae symbolum forma fidei credulitatis norma fides quam credimus docemus the symbol of Life and Salvation Ep. 27. ad Pulcher c. 4. p. 492. the Rule of Faith the Faith which we believe and teach Pope Leo That it is a short perfecta confessio and perfect Confession of the Catholick Faith. The Great Council of Chalcedon saith of the Faith of Nice Act. 5. in fine That it sufficeth 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 to the perfect knowledge and confirmation of Piety Theodor. Hist Eccl. l. 2. c. 15. The Synod of Ariminum That it was 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 an exact Rule of Faith that of Sardis That nothing was to be added to it Apud Athanas Ep. ad Antioch P. 576. Id. de Synod Arim. Selsach p. 876 878. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 because nothing was wanting to it that of Sirmium adds That there was no need of running to Synods that of Nice Having done all things for the Catholick Church a Synod to which 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 all Men assented and all Men judged it sufficient The Ordo Romanus or old Roman Liturgy saith Apud Hittorp p. 38 39. This is that Faith qua credentes justificati sumus by which believing we are justified salutaris sides the saving Faith which the Holy Spirit dictated to the Masters of the Church The summ of our Faith which as they had received so they delivered it unto them Isidore Hispalensis saith of the Apostles Creed De Eccl. Officiis l. 2. c. 22. That they appointed it to be given to Believers as a Rule that it contained few words but in them were contained omnia Sacramenta all the Articles of Faith that they who could not read the Scriptures retaining in their Heart these things might have sufficient and saving knowledge that it contains the Confession of the Trinity and the Vnity of the Church Orig. l. 6. c 19. omne Christiani dogmatis Sacramentum and the whole Christian Doctrine that this Symbol of Faith and the Lord's Prayer Sentent l. 1. c. 21. parvulis Ecclesiae sufficit ad coelorum regna capessenda sufficed to bring the little ones of the Church to the Kingdom of Heaven De Eccles Off. l. 1. c. 16. And of the Nicene Creed he adds That it speaks de omni parte fidei of every part of Faith. Rabanus Maurus in his Book of the Institution of the Clergy Lib. 2. c. 56. transcribes the forecited words of Isidore Regino in the same Century saith That all who come to Penance De Eccl. Discipl l. 1 c. 272. or to receive the Sacrament must be able to recite the Creed and the Lord's Prayer for in the one is contained the Christian Faith in the other we are taught what we are to pray for and that no Man in these matters must pretend the slowness of his Vnderstanding or defect of Memory for these things are so short as that the dullest Man may learn them and yet they are tam magna ut qui eorum scientiam pleniter capere potuer it sufficere ea sibi credatur in salutem so great that whosoever fully understands them will find them sufficient for his Salvation Moreover Ruffinus Isidore and Rabanus Maurus do inform us that the Apostles made this the sign by which he should be known who preached Christ truly secundum Apostolicas literas according to the directions of the Apostles from those deceitful Workers who did not preach him integris traditionum lineis according to the integrity of Tradition Accordingly 5. Observe § 8 That these Fathers do constantly assert this Symbol to be a Test of Orthodoxy and that by which they did prescribe against all Hereticks proving their Doctrines to be new and such as ought to be rejected as being not contained in this Symbol or this Rule of Faith. Irenaeus in his Book against Heresies declares Lib. 3. cap. 3. that it is sola vera vivifica fides the only true and life-giving Faith which the Church received from the Apostles and distributes to her Children That even without arguing we might exactly discern the firmness of the Truth preached by the Church Lib. 1. c. 1. and the falseness of the Heretical perswasions there being nothing of them
are plainly opposite to the Doctrines Practices and Traditions formerly received and approved in the Church of Christ and this they do believe so firmly that they rather chuse to suffer loss of Life and all the Comforts of it than own these Doctrines of the Church of Rome as Apostolical Traditions Moreover whereas it is no Man's Interest to make the World believe there was such a City as London if there was no such place in being it is the Interest of the whole Church of Rome to set up this pretence to Infallibility in the General that finding it disclaimed by other Churches she with some Colour may pretend unto it and 't is the Interest of the Roman Clergy as much to stickle for the Truth of her pretended Traditions as it was the Interest of Demetrius and his Fellow Artists to avouch to the Ephesians They might be truly Gods which were made by Hands and that the Image of Diana truly fell down from Jupiter since otherwise their Craft would be set at nought And as it was the Interest of the Master of the Pythonisse to be angry with St. Paul for casting out the Evil Spirit from her because thereby his Hopes of Gain was gone For if Men will not receive their Traditions as the Truths of God they cannot Lord it over their Consciences nor drain their Purses nor give Laws at pleasure to the Christian World but must be put to the hard task of proving what they would have us take upon their Words And Fourthly Whereas he that doubteth whether there be such a City as London may repair unto it to be convinced by ocular demonstration whither shall he repair who doubteth of the Truth of the Traditions of the Church of Rome for Satisfaction in that Matter Will you send him to Scripture You have already told him he cannot know what is Scripture what Copies and what Texts are uncorrupted what Translation of it is Authentick but by the Church and also that when he knows all this he cannot understand the meaning of the Scriptures in places disputable and variously sensed as you know those are by which you prove both the Churches Infallibility and the Pretences of the Roman Church to be Infallible Will you send him with Mr. P. 360. M. To the unanimous Consent and Tradition of our Church that is the Church of Rome what is this but to bid him believe that Self-evident which he thinks evidently false to believe the Church of Rome to be Infallible in her Traditions and then he will not doubt of her Infallibility or to turn Roman Catholick and then he will no longer be a Protestant Will you add with him That what is proposed by the Tradition of such a Church is evidently credible Ibid. and sufficient to beget an infallible assent Is it not then matter of Amazement that so many Millions of Persons throughout the World endowed with intellectuals as piercing and accomplished with all Abilities which their Adversaries can boast of yea who many of them have strong temporal motives to incline them to embrace the Romish Traditions and all the miseries which Papal Tyranny can inflict to awaken them into a serious consideration of all the Evidence that can be offered for them and who are Men seriously industrious to attain Salvation and Men who know they must perish everlastingly if they resist the Truth clearly propounded to them I say is it not matter of Amazement that so many persons so qualified should from Generation to Generation so unanimously reject what is evidently credible and able to beget within them an infallible assent yea that they should dispute and write many Books against it though they could never do so but they must contradict what is self-Evident What is this but in effect to say All Protestants always were are and must be whilst they continue Protestants resolved to be damned and as obstinate as the very Devil in doing what they know must tend to their eternal Condemnation Will you send him to the Vniversal Church either by it you mean only the R. Church and her Adherents or you do not if you do you again send him to the Church of Rome if you do not you must renounce that Article of Faith which all your Clergy stand by Oath obliged to defend viz. the Roman Catholick Church and with it your Pretences to Infallibility on the account of any of these Promises which do confessedly belong only unto the Vniversal Church of Christ CHAP. XII Mr. M ' s. Fifth Assertion That all Catholicks ever held that for true which was owned by the Vniversal Church of their times and rejected the contrary as an Error answered by way of Concession § 1. First That this is absolutely true in reference to Doctrines and Practices truly necessary to the Being of a Church But Secondly That this is with Lirinensis to be restrained to the Fundamentals of Faith is proved 1st from Scripture 2dly from Reason § 2. Thirdly From Instances as First That of the Administration of the Sacrament to Infants which they generally practised both in the Eastern and the Western Churches § 3. They declared this Practice to be necessary § 4. That they speak not this of such a participation of the Body and Blood of Christ as may be had in Baptism but plainly of the Puriticipation of the Eucharist § 5. Inferences hence 1. To prove the Definition of the Trent Council touching this Matter actually False 2ly That the Practice or Doctrine of the Church in any Age is no true Evidence of Tradition or the right Interpretation of Holy Scripture 3ly That Mr. M ' s. Argument for Prayer for the Dead from Tradition is not convincing § 6. 2. From the Opinion of the Fathers That it was not lawful for a Christian to swear at all § 7. 3ly From their Opinion That good Angels were transported with the Love of Women and got Gyants of them § 8. 4ly From their Opinion That it was unlawful for any Clergyman to engage himself in Secular Affairs § 9. Or to go from one Church or Diocess to another § 10. 3ly When whole Churches and Nations differ and Heresies prevail the Fathers say we are for finding out the Truth to have Recourse only to Scripture and to primitive Tradition § 11. A full Answer to Mr. M ' s. Argument for Tradition from the Ancient Custom of praying for the Dead shewing on what Accounts the Ancients did it what Reason we have not to do it That the Prayers for them used by the Church of Rome are Novelties and that those used by the Ancients were perfectly destructive of the Roman Purgatory § 12. MR. § 1 M. saith That whatsoever was held by the Vniversal Church P. 367 368. was without farther Question held for true and the contrary to it was ever rejected as an Error Neither will you ever find a Catholick who ever had the Boldness to say that the Church of
them after Death 〈◊〉 purgatory Torments 3. Theâ— by the Prayers Alms and Masses performed by the Living they are relieved from those Punishments and are advanced from Purgatory to Heaven from Torment to the Vision of God before the Resurrection of the Body and the Day of Judgment And when Mr. M. will undertake to prove these things Ex antiqua Patrum traditione from the Tradition of the Fathers of the first Five Centuries or from the Tradition of the Apostles he will justify the Decrees of these Councils and confute the Protestants But this if he be well acquainted with the Writings and Customs of the Ancient Church he must know to be a vain Attempt it being evident that they knew nothing of these Doctrines yea that they often spake things as expresly contrary to every one of these Particulars as Light is opposita to Darkness For 4. Even from the Proyers 〈…〉 and from the Sentiments of those that 〈…〉 most certain Demonstrations 〈…〉 received in the Ancient Church of 〈…〉 It is the Observation of St. 〈…〉 That even their Funeral Hymns taught them to believe that the Feithful immediately after Death were Happy Hom. 14. in 1. ep ad Tim. p. 309. That they returned then unto their Rest and were delivered from all their Labours We send out saith he the Departed 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 with Hymns then is there Joy and Gladness every one praying thus to dy Hom. 14. in 1. Ep. ad Tim. p. 309. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 to cease from their Labours and Conflicts 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 to be delivered from all dreadful things 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and to see Christ Hom. 4. in Epist ad Hebr. p. 453 454. And inveighing against the 〈◊〉 Custom of Lamenting the Faithful at their Death he 〈…〉 do the burning Lamps import is it not that 〈…〉 Champions What mean the Hymns do we 〈…〉 and give Thanks 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈…〉 he hath crowned the Departed that he 〈…〉 Labours that freeing him from 〈…〉 Are not these the Import of 〈…〉 are the Actions of Men rejoycing 〈…〉 Return unto thy Rest O my Soul for the 〈…〉 ously with thee I will fear no Evil for 〈…〉 art my Refuge from the Trouble that compasse◠〈…〉 what these Psalms import But thou wilst not do 〈…〉 with Grief Dost thou say Return unto thy Rest O my Soul and weepest Are not these things seen and Hypocrisy for if thou really believest what thou sayest thou weepest superfluously if thou dost not Why dost thou sing why dost thou suffer what is done and dost not drive away the Singers And again Tom. 5. Hom. 61. p. 420 421. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 ibid. Let the manner of his Interment shame thee Psalms and Thanksgivings and the Catalogue of his Progenitors are things done not that thoâ— mayst weep but mayst give Thanks for them 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 as being â—alled to greater Honour and consider to whom they 〈…〉 that place where is Peter and Paul and the 〈…〉 saith he if an Heathen 〈…〉 wouldst not 〈…〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈…〉 Rest And lastly 〈…〉 who are gone before 〈…〉 Hymns signifying our 〈…〉 Lamps and Incense we attend thâ—◠〈…〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈…〉 being delivered from this Life of Darkness they are the to the true Light. Tom. 6. Hom. 116. p. 944. The Prayers used for the Dead in the Apostolical Constitutions 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 l. 8. c. 41. Wisd 3.1 i. e. the most ancient of that kind which are extant suppose the Souls for which they prayed 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 resting in Christ and in the Hands of God so that no Torment can touch them and yet their Prayer for them is That God would forgive them all their voluntary and involuntary Sins That he would place over them kind Angelâ— which should conduct them into the Regions of 〈…〉 Bosom of Abraham Isaac and 〈…〉 beginning have pleased God 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and 〈…〉 there is neither Sorrow Grief nor Sigh but 〈…〉 the Region of pious Souls free from 〈…〉 Pseudo 〈…〉 Discourse touching those things which are performed about the Dead De Hier. Eccl. c. 7. p. 405 406 407. Pachym p. 427. declareth That the 〈…〉 to the Term of their Life 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈…〉 their sacred Conflicts and that being arrived 〈…〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 they sleep in Joy that being come to the end 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 of this present life 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 they are filled with divine Pleasure as well knowing they for ever shall enjoy 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the good things they possess P. 407 408. Pachymeres p. 428. That the Relations of the Faithful do pronounce him blessed as being come desirably 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 to his triumphant End that they bring him to the Priest 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 as to the conferring of his Crown and therefore pour out Psalms of thanksgiving to the Author of his Victory That others tho' unfit to be partakers of the Holy Communion are admitted to these Funeral Solemnities P. 410.411 that seeing him who died piously in the Liturgick Offices 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 declared to be one who indeed enjoys Communion with the Saints who have been from the beginning 〈…〉 the same End. P. 416. Pachym p. 434. That 〈…〉 the Combatant is 〈…〉 they bury his Body 〈…〉 Soul Pachym Ibid. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈…〉 joys its good things 〈…〉 bly deposited And then he tells us That 〈…〉 the Priest made for him P. 411. was That the Divine 〈…〉 would forgive him all his Sins committed through humane infirmity and would place him in Light and in the Region of the Living in the Bosom of Abraham Isaac and Jacob 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 in the Place from which is banished all Grief Sorrow and Sighing For Explication of which Prayer He and his Paraphrast there Note First That these things thus prayed for are Ibid. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 The plain and the most blessed Rewards of Holy Men. Secondly That 〈…〉 Ibid. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈…〉 of Rest which receive Pious 〈…〉 Thirdly 〈…〉 for us by a Kingdom 〈…〉 of Darkness 〈…〉 Sighing signifie 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈…〉 things â—y others to he suffered in the future Life That accordingly 〈…〉 Patriarchs and all the Saints are 〈…〉 and that the Metaphor seems to be taken from 〈…〉 Bosoms of the Sea to which those who 〈…〉 that they may be at Rest for as it is with them so they who are in this Life tossed with Tempests Pachymeres p. 430. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 then rest in those Bosoms of the Patriarchs as in an Haven Moreover to this Question or Objection Why should the Priest pray God to pardon the Sins of the Dead and to give him a portion in Light with Divine Spirits since every one receives from divine Justice a retribution according to