hath abounded that they may live in all filth and folly because God hath promised never to forsake them not turne away his Love from them they doe not looke upon it as an hellish abuse of the Love of God which they labour to crucifie no lesse then any other worke of the flesh whatsoever Presuppose indeed the Saints of God to be Dogges and swine wholly sensuall and unregenerate that is no Saints and our Doctrine to be such that God will Love them and save them continuing in that state wherein they are and you make a bed for Iniquity to stretch it selfe upon But suppose that we teach that the wrath of God will certainly come upon the Children of disobedience that he that Believeth not shall be damned and that God will keepe his owne by his power through Faith unto Salvation and that in and by the use of meanes they shall certainly be preserved to the end and the mouth of iniquity will be stopped 2. They say it takes away that strong curbe and bridle §. 14. which ought to be kept in the mouth of the flesh to keepe it from running headlong into sin and folly namely the feare of Hell and punishment which alone hath an influence upon it to bring it to subjection and under Obedience But now if there be nothing in the world that is of use for the mortification and crucifying of the flesh and the lusts thereof but it receives improvement by this Doctrine this crimination must of necessity vanish into nothing 1. Then it tells that the flesh and all the deeds thereof are to be crucifyed and slaine God having ordained good workes for us to walke in That for the workes of the flesh the wrath of God comes upon the Children of disobedience if any say let us continue in sinne because we are not under the Law or the condemning power of it for sinne but under Grace it cries out God for bid Rom. 6. 15 16. And saith this is Argument enough and Proofe snfficient that sinne shall not have dominion over us because we are not under the Law but under Grace It tells you also that there is a twofold feare of Hell and punishment of sinne First of Anxietie and doubtfullnesse in respect of the end Secondly Of Care and diligence that respecteth the meanes And for the first it saith that this is the portion of very many of the Saints of God of some all their dayes though they are so yet they know not that they are so and therefore are under anxious and doubtfull feares of Hell and Punishment notwithstanding that they are in the armes of their Father from whence indeed they shall not be cast downe as a man bound with chaines on the toppe of a tower he cannot but feare and yet he cannot fall He cannot fall because he is fast bound with strong chaines He cannot but feare because he cannot actually and clearely consider often times the meanes of his preservation And for the latter a feare of the wayes and meanes leading to punishment as such that continues upon all the Saints of God in this life neither is there any thing in this Doctrine that is suited to a removall thereof And this it saies is more much more of use for the mortification of the flesh then the former 2. It sayes that the great and Principall meanes of mortification of the flesh is not feare of Hell and Punishment but the Spirit of Christ as the Apostle tells us Rom. 8. 13. If ye through the Spirit do mortifie the deeds of the flesh yee shall live It is the Spirit of Christ alone that is able to do this great Worke We know what bondage and Religious drudgery some have put themselves 〈◊〉 upon this account and yet could never in their lives attaine to the mortification of any one sinne It is the Spirit of Christ alone that hath soveraigne power in our soules of killing and making alive As no man quickneth his owne soule so no man upon any Consideration whatsoever or by the power of any threatnings of the Law can kill his own sinne There was never any one sinne truly mortified by the Law or the threatning of it All that the Law can do of it selfe is but to intangle sinne and thereby to irritate provoke it like a Bull in a net or a beast lead to the slaughter It is the Spirit of Christin the Gospell that cuts its throate destroyes it Now this Doctrine was never in the least charged with denying the Spirit of God to Believers which whilst it doth grant maintaine in a way of opposition to that late Opinion which advanceth it selfe against it it maintaines the mortification of the flesh and the lusts thereof upon the only true and unshaken foundations 3. It tells you that the great meanes whereby the Spirit of Christ worketh the mortification of the flesh and the Lusts thereof is the Application of the Crosse of Christ and his Death and Love therein unto the soule and saies that those vaine endeavours which some promote and encourage for the mortification of sinne consisting for the most part in slavish bodily exercises are to be bewayled with teares of bloud as abominations that seduce poore soules from the Crosse of Christ For it saies this work is truly and in an acceptable manner only performed when we are planted into the likenesse of the death of Christ having our old man crucified with him and the body of sinne destroyed Rom. 6. 5 6. and thereupon by Faith reckoning our selves dead unto sinne but alive unto God v. 11. It is done only by knowing the fellowship of the sufferings of Christ and being made conformable to his death Phil. 3. 10. by the Crosse of Christ is the world crucified unto us and we unto the world The Spirit brings home the power of the Crosse of Christ to the soule for the accomplishing of this work and without it it will not be done Moreover it saies that by the way of motive to this duty there is nothing comes with that efficacy upon the soule as the love of Christ in his death as the Apostle assures us 2 Cor. 5. 14. for the Love of Christ constraineth us because we thus judge that if one died for all then were all dead and that he died for all that they which live should not henceforth live unto themselves but unto him which died for them and rose againe now it was never laid to the charge of this Doctrine that it took off from the vertue of the Death and Crosse of Christ but rather on the contrary though falsely that it ascribed too much thereunto so that these importune exceptions notwithstanding the Doctrine in hand doth not only maintaine its own innocency as to any tendency unto loosenesse but also manifestly declareth its own usefulnesse to all ends and purposes of Gospell Obedience whatsoever For 3. It stirres up §. 15. provokes and drawes out into action every
of perfection and when he doth evill there is still a non-submitting an unconsenting principle this the Apostle complains of and declares Rom. 7. 19. 20. The good that I would I doe not but the evill which I would not that doe I now if I doe that I would not it is no more I that doe it but sinne that dwelles in mee I find then a Law that when I would doe good evill is present with mee For I delight in the Law of God after the inward man There is an I and an I at opposition a will and not willing a doing and not doing a delighting and not delighting all in the same person so that there is this difference at the entrance between what sinne soever of Regenerate persons and others though the principle of sinning be the same for the kind and nature of it in them and others all sinne every mans sinnes be who he will be believer or unbeliever being tempted by his own Lust yet that Lust possesseth the whole soule and takes in the vertuall consent of the whole man notwithstanding the controwle and checks of conscience the light of the judgement in him that is unregenerate but in every Regenerate person there is an unconsenting principle which is as truly the man himselfe that doth not concurre in sinne that doth expressely dissent from it as the other is from whence it flowes Secondly §. 12. That sinne neither can doth nor ever shall reigne in Regenerate Persons The reason of this I acquainted you with before and the Apostle thinks this a sufficient proofe of this assertion because they are under grace Rom. 7. 14. Whilest the principle of Grace abides in them which reignes where ever it be or the free acceptance of God in the Gospell is towards them it is impossible upon the account of any actuall sinne whatever whereinto they may fall that sinne should reigne in them nothing gives Sinne a Reigne and dominion but a totall defect of all true grace whatever not only as to the exerting it selfe but as to any habituall relicts of it It may be overwhelmed sometimes with Temptations and corruptions but it is Grace still as the least sparke of fire is fire though it should be covered with never so great an heape of ashes and it reignes then Thirdly That Regenerate persons sinne not with their whole and full consent §. 13. Consent may be taken two wayes First Morally for approbation of the thing done so the Apostle saies that in the inward man he did consent to the Law that it was good Rom. 7. 16. that is he did approve it as such like it delight in it as good and thus a Regenerate man never consents to sinne no nor unregenerate persons neither unlesse they are such as being past feeling are given up to work lasciviousnesse with greedinesse a Regenerate person is so farre from thus consenting to sinne that before it in it after it he utterly condemnes disallowes hates it as in himselfe and by himselfe committed Secondly Consent may be taken in a Physicall sence for the concurrence of the commanding and acting principles of the soule unto its operations and in this sence an unregenerate man sinnes with his full consent and his whole will a Regenerate man doth not cannot doe so For though there is not in that consent to sinne which his will inclined by the remaining disposition of sinne in it doth give an actuall sensible Reaction of the other principle yet there is an expresse not consenting and by the power that it hath in the soule for habits have power in and over the Subjects wherein the are it preserves it from being wholly ingaged into sinne and this is the great intendment of the Apostle Rom. 7. 19 20. 21. 22. From what hath been spoken will easily appeare what Answer may be given to the former Argument to wit That notwithstanding any sinnes that either the Scripture or the experience of men do evince that the Saints may fall into yet that they never sinne or perpetrate sinne with their full and whole consent whereby they should be lookt upon in and under their sinnes in the same state and condition with unregenerate persons in whom sinne reigneth committing the same sinne and how insufficient any thing produced by Mr Goodwin in defence of the argument layd downe at the entrance of this Chapter is to remove the Answer given unto it from Believers not sining with their whole consent may easily be demonstrated This he thus proposeth Some to mainetaine this position That all the sinnes of true Believers are sinnes of infirmity lay hold on this shield such men they say never sinne with their whole wills or with full consent therefore they never sinne but through infirmity that they never sinne with full consent they conceive they prove sufficiently from that of the Apostle for the good that I would I do not but the evil that I would not that I do Now if I do that I would not it is no more I that do it but sinne that dwelleth in me I Answer first that the Saints cannot sinne but with their whole wills or full consents is undeniably proved by this consideration viz. Because otherwise there should be not only a plurality or diversity but also a contrariety of wills in the same persō at one the same instant of time viz. when the supposed act of evill is produced now it is an impossibility of the first evidence that there should be a plurality of acts these contrary one to the other in the same subject or agent at one or the same iustant of time it is true between the first movings of the flesh in a man towards the committing of the sinne and the compleating of the sinne by an Actuall and Externall patration of it there may be successively in him not only a plurality but even a contrariety of Volitions or Motions of the will according to what the Scripture speaketh concerning the flesh lusting against the Spirit and the Spirit against the flesh But when the flesh having prevailed in the combate bringeth forth her desire into act the Spirit ceaseth from his act of Lusting otherwise it would follow that the flesh is greater aud stronger in her lusting than the Spirit of God in his and that when the flesh lusteth after the perpetration of such or such a sinne the Spirit as to the hindering of it lusteth but in vaine which is contrary to that of the Apostle greater is he that is in you speaking as t is cleare of the Spirit of God unto true Believers than he that is in the world meaning Sathan and all his Auxiliaries Sinne Flesh Corruption Ans. What we intend by the Saints not sinning with their whole wills hath been declared §. 16. that there is not a consistency in the explanation we have given Mr Goodwin asserts because it would inferre a plurality yea a contrariety of wills in the same person at the same time
from any Love of God whether it be from the common Love of God to man as men and if so why are not all men endowed with those qualifications If from his peculiar Love how come they to be the effects and causes of the same thing Or whether indeed this assertion be not destructive to the whole Covenant of Grace and the effectuall dispensations of it in the bloud of Christ And to his second Testimony I shall adde no more The third place insisted on is that of the Apostle 1 Cor. 9. 27. Hence he thus argueth §. 21. If Paul after his conversion unto Christ was in a possibility of being or becoming a Reprobate or cast away then may true Believers fall away both totally and finally for finally ever includes totally But the Antecedent is true Paul after his conversion was in the possibility mentioned ergo the Major Proposition I presume will passe without controle Ans. That Mr Goodwin is not able to make good eitheir of the Propositions in this syllogisme will evidently appeare in the conclusion of our examination of what he drawes forth new and old to that purpose of the Major he gives you only this account It will passe I presume with out controulc but by his favour unlesse cleared from ambiguity of expressions and fallacy it is not like to obtaine so faire a passage as is presumed and fancyed Though the terme of possibility in the supposition and may be in the inference seeme to be equipollent yet to render them of the same significancy as to the Argument in hand they must both be used in the same respect but if a possibility of being a reprobate that is one rejected of God by a metonymy of the effect be ascribed to Paul in respect of himselfe and the infirmity of his owne will as to abiding with God in which case alone there is any appearance of truth in the Assumption of this supposition and the terme of may be in respect of Believers falling totally finally away respects the event purpose decrees or Promise of God concerning it in which sence alone it is any step to the purpose in hand I deny the inference and thereby at the very entrance give checke and controule to Mr Goodwin's procedure That which is possible to come to passe that terme possible affecting the end or comming to passe must be every way and in all respects possible this is the intendment of the inference That which is possible in respect of some certaine causes or principles the termes of possibility affecting the thing it selfe whereof it is spoken in its next causes may be impossible on another account in this sence only is there any colour of truth contained in the supposition so that the Major Proposition of this Syllogisme is laid up and secured for doing any farther service in this case The Minor is §. 22. But Paul after his conversion was in a possibility of becoming a Reprobate or cast-away Ans. He was not in respect of the event upon the account of the purpose and promises of God of him and to him made in Christ though any such possibility may be affirmed of him in respect of himselfe and his own will not confirmed in Grace unto an impossibility of swerving Now this Proposition he thus farther attempts syllogistically to confirme That which Paul was very sollicitous industrious to prevent he was in a possibility of suffering or being made But Paul was very sollicitous and industrious to prevent his being made a cast-way as the Scripture in hand plainely avoucheth he kept under his body and brought it in subjection in order to prevent his becoming a cast-away Ergo He was in danger or possibility of being made a cast-away The reason of the consequence in the Major Proposition is because no man of understanding will be sollicitous to prevent or hinder the coming to passe of such a thing the comming to passe whereof he knowes to be impossible Ans. Once more The major is questioned Paul might and ought to labour in the use of meanes for the preventing of that which in respect of himselfe he might possibly run into God having appointed those meanes to be used for the prevention of the end feared and avoided although in respect of some other preventing cause it was impossible he should so do He who complained that in him that is in his flesh dwelleth no good that he had a law in his members leading him captive to the Law of sinne and sinne working in him all manner of concupisence for whose prevention from running out into a course of sinning God hath appointed meanes to be used might use those meanes for that end notwithstanding that God had immutably Purposed and Faithfully Promised that in the use of those meanes he should attaine the end aymed at And the Reason Mr Goodwin gives for the confirmation of the consequence is no other but that which we have so often exploded viz. That a man need not ought not to use meanes for attaining of any end though appointed and instituted of God for that end and purpose if so be the end for which they are ordained shall certainely and infallibly be compassed and accomplished by them Our Saviour Christ thought meet to use the ordinary wayes for the preservation of his life notwithstanding the Promise of keeping him by the Angels and Hezechiah neglected not the meanes of Life notwithstanding the infallible promise of Living so long which he had received Paul was carefull in the use of meanes to prevent that which inhimselfe it was possible for him to runne into though he had or might have assurance that through the faithfulnesse and power of God in the use of those meanes as an antecedent of the consequent though not the conditions of the event he should be preserved certainely and infallibly from what he was so in himselfe apt unto So that whatever be the peculiar intendment of the Apostle in this place taking the terme 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 in the largest sence possible and in a significancy of the greatest compasse yet nothing will regularly be inferred thence to the least prejudice of the Doctrine I have undertaken to maintaine And this may suffice as to the utmost of what Mr Goodwins Argument from this place doth reach unto §. 23. There is another and that a more proper sence of the place and accommodated to the context and scope of the Apostle wherewith the Doctrine indeavoured to be confirmed from hence hath not the least pretence of communication And this ariseth as was before manifested from the scope of the place with the proper native signification of the word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 here translated a cast-away The businesse that the Apostle hath in hand from v. 15. of the chapter and which he presses to the end is a relation of his own principles wayes and deportment in the great worke of the preaching of the Gospell to him committed in the
these persons and their Judgment in the point under debate more afterwards For the thing it selfe last proposed on what foot of account it is placed and on what foundation asserted The Treatise it selfe will discover That the thing aymed at is not to be straightned or restrained to any one peculiar Act of grace will easily appear The main foundation of that which we plead for is The Eternal purpose of God which his owne nature requireth to be absolutely immutable and irreversible The Eternal Act of the will of God designing some to salvation by Christ infallibly to be obtained for the Prayse of the glory of hu grace is The Bottome of the whole Even that foundation which standeth for ever having this seale The Lord knoweth who are his For the Accomplishment of this eternal purpose and for the procurement of all the good things that lye within the compass of it 's in tendment are The Oblation and Intercession the whole mediatory undertaking of Chist taking away sinne bringing in Life and immortality interposed giving further causal influence into the truth contended for In him and for his sake as God graciously powerfully and freely gives his Holy Spirt faith with all the things that accompany salvation unto all them whom he accepts and pardons by his being made sinne â—or them and Righteousness unto them so he takes them therby into an everlasting Covenant that shall not be broken and hath therein given them innumerable promises that he will continue to be their God for ever and preserve them to be and in bâ—ing his people to this end because the principle of Grace and living to him as in them inherent is a thing in i'ts own nature changable and lyable to failing he doth according to his promise and for the Acccomplishment of his purpose dayly make out to them by his Holy Spirit from the great treasury and store-house thereof the Lord Jesus Christ helps and supplies encreasing of faith Love and Holiness recovering them from falls healing their back-slidings strengthening them with all might according to his glorious power unto all patience and long suffering with joyfulness so preserving them by his power through faith unto salvation And in this way of delivering the doctrine contended about it is clearly made out that the disputes mentioned are as needless as groundless so that we shall not need to take them into the state of the controversy in hand though I shall have occasion once more to reflect upon them when I come to the consideration of the doctrine of the School-men in reference to the opinion proposed to debate The mayne of our enquiry is after the Purpose Covenant and promises of God the undertaking of Christ the supplies of Grace promised and bestowed in him on which accounts we doe assert and maintaine That all true Believers who are in being so interested in all those causes of preservation shall infallibly be preserved unto the end in the favour of God and such a course of Gospel obedience as he will accept in Jesus Christ. That as was formerly sayd which at present I ayme at in Reference to this Truth is to declare it's Rise and Progress it 's course and opposition which it hath found in several Ages of the Church with it's state and condition at this day in respect of Acceptance with the people of God It 's rise with all other divine truths it owes only to Revelation from God manifested in the Scriptures of the Old and new Testament some of the most eminent places wherein it is delivered in the old Testament are Gen 3. 17. chap 17. 1. Deut 33. 3. Josh 1. 5. 1 Saw 12. 22. Psal 1. 3. Psal 23. 4 6. Psal 37. 39 40. Psal 52. 8 9. Psal 89. 31 32 33 34 35. Psal 33. 9 10 11. Psal 92. 13. c. Is 27. 3 4. Is 46. 4. Is 59. 21. Is 54 9. 10. Is 4. 4 5. Is 40. 27 28 26 30. Is 43. 1 2. 3 4 5 6 7 8. Jer 3 3 31 32 33 34. Jer 32. 38 39. 40. Ezek 36. 25 26 27. Hosea 2. 19 20. Zach 10. 12. Mal 3. 6 with innumerable other places In the new Testament God hath not left this truth and work of his Grace without witness as in sundry other places so it is testified unto Math 6. 13. Mat 7. 24 25 Mat. 12. 20. Mat 16. 18. Mat 24. 24. Luk 1. 70 71 72 73 74 75. Luk 8. 5 8. Luk 22. 32. Joh 3. 36. Joh. 4. 13 14 16. Joh. 5. 24. Joh 6. 35 36 37 38 39 57. Joh 7. 38. Joh 8. 35 Joh 10. 27 28 29 30. Joh 13. 1. Joh 14 15 16 17. Joh 16. 27 Joh 17. throughout Act 2. 47. Act 13 48. Ro 6. 14. Rom 8. 1 16 17 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 c. 1 Cor 1. 8 9. 1 Cor 10. 13 14. 1 Cor 15. 49 58. 2 Cor 1. 21. Eph 1. 13 14. Eph. 3. 17. Eph 4 30. Eph. 5. 23. Gal 2. 20 Phil 1. 6. Phil 2. 13. 1 Thes 5 24. 2 Tim 4. 17 18. Tit 1.1 Heb 6. 19. Heb 10. 38 39. Heb 12. Heb 9. 14. Heb 13. 5 21. 1 Pet. 1. 2 3 4 5. 1 Joh. 2. 19 24. 1 Joh 3. 9,19 1 Joh. 5. 14 18. Jude 1 Rev 20. 6. So plentifully hath the Lord secured this sacred Truth wherein he hath enwrapped so much if not as in the meanes of conveyance the whole of that peace consolation and Joy which he is willing the heires of promise should receive Whether the faith hereof thus plentifully delivered to the Saints found Acceptance with the primitive Christians to the most of whom it was given not only to believe but also to suffer for Christ to me is unquestionable And I know no better proof of what those first Churches did believe than by shewing what they ought to believe which I shall unquestionably be perswaded they did believe unless most pregnant Testimony be given of their Apostacy That Paul believed it for himselfe and concerning others is evident Ro. 8. 38 39. 1 Cor. 1. 8 9. Phil 1. 6. Heb. 6. 9 10 are sufficient proof of his faith herein That he built up others in the same perswasion to the enjoyment of the same peace and Assurance with himselfe is undenyable And if there be any demonstration to be made of the beliefe of the first Christians of any evidence comparable unto this I shall not deny but that it ought to be attended unto But that we may not seem willing to decline the Consideration of what those who went before us in the several Ages and Generations past apprehended and have by any means communicated unto us of their thoughts about the businesse of our contest having no reason so to be I shall after a little preparation made to that work present the Reader with something of my Observations to that end and purpose Of the Authority of the Ancients in matters of Religion and worship of God of the Right use and
Consideration wherewith to reflect upon and review and ponder so oft as they please what they See Vnderstand and Know in this kind Now what soever a man is capable First of Seeing and Knowing Secondly of Pondering and Considering he is capable of raising or working an inclination in himselfe towards it answerable in Strength Vigour and Power to any degree of Goodnesse or Desireableness which he is able to apprehend therein for what is an inclination towards any thing but a propension and laying out of the heart and soule towards it So that if there be worth and goodness sufficient in any object whatsoever to beare it and Secondly if a man be in a capacity of discovering and apprehending this good clearly and Thirdly be in a like capacity of considering this vision certainly he is in a capacity and at liberty to worke himselfe to what strength or degree of desire and inclination towards it he pleaseth now 't is certaine to every man that there is more good in abstaining from things either Eminently dangerous or Apparantly destructive to his Soule then in forbearing things Apparantly destructive to his natuturall being Secondly as evident it is that every man is capable of attaining or comeing to the certaine knowledge of and cleare apprehending this excesse of good to him in the former Good then in the latter Thirdly neither is it a thing lesse evident then either of the former that every man is as capable of ruminating or reapprehending the said excess of Good as much as oft as he pleaseth as he is simply of apprehending it at all which supposed as undeniably true it followes with an high hand above all contradiction that the Saints may and have meanes and opportunityes faire and full for that purpose plant inclinations or dispositions in themselves to refraine all manner of sinnes apparently dangerous destructive to the safety of their Soules fuller of energie vigor life strength power then the naturall inclination in them which teacheth them to refraine all occasions which they know must needs be accompanied with the destructioÌ„ of their naturall beings Therefore if they be more or so much afraid of destroying their lives volluntarily knowingly as by the casting theÌ„selves into the fier or the water or the like then they are of falling away through sin the fault or reason thereof is not at all in the Doctrine which affirmes or informes them that there is a possibility that they fall away but in themselves and their owne voluntary negligence they have meanes and opportunityes as we have prooved in abundance to render themselves every whit as secure yea and more secure touching the latter as they are or reasonably can be concerning the former When I first cast an eye on this Discourse of Mr Goodwin § 38. Ans. I confesse I was surprized to as high a degree of Admiration some other Affections also as by any thing I had observed in his whole Booke as having not met if without offence I may be allowed to speake my Apprehensions with any discourse whatsoever of so transcendent a derogation from and direct tendency to the overthrow of the Grace of Christ but only in what is remembred by Austin Hilary Pulgentius with some others of the disputes of Pelagius Coelestius Julianus with their followers and the Socinians of late with whom Mr Goodwin would not be thought to have Joyned in their Opposition to the Merit and Grace of Christ As I said then before if this should proove in the issue to be the summe of the meanes afforded to preserve the Saints from Apostacy and falling away into ruine I shall be so farre from opposing a possibility of their defection that I shall certainely conclude their Perseverance to be impossible Being fully perswaded that withall the contribution of strength which the considerations mentioned are able of themselves to afford unto them they are no more able to meet their Adversaries who come against them with tweuty thousand subtilties and Temptations then a man with a straw and a feather is to combate with and overcome a royall Army The Scripture tells us and we thought it had been so that we are kept by the power of God unto Salvation and that to this end he putts forth the exceeding greatnesse of his power in them that Believe 1 Pet. 1. 5. Ephes. 1. 17 18. 19. 20. Col. 1. 11. according to the mighty Workings which wrought in Christ when he raised him from the Dead whereby he strengthens them with all might according to his Glorious Power making them meet partakers of the inheritance of the Saints Light It seemes though there be a Glorious sound of words in these innumerable the like Expressions of the ingagement of the Power and faithfullnesse of God for the safegarding of his Saints yet all this is but an empty noyse and beating of the ayre That which is indeed materiall to this Purpose consisting in certaine Considerations which rationall men may have concerning their present State future Condition But let us a little consider the Discourse it selfe 1. First it is all along Magnificently supposed that there is the same Power and Ability in a Rationall Inlightened man to Deliberate and Conclude of things in reference unto the Practicall Condition of his Spirituall Estate as there is of his Naturall and that this Ability is constantly resident with him to make use of upon all occasions what ever our Saviour say to the contrary viz. That without him we can doe nothing Joh. 15. 5. 2. Secondly to make way for that that such a one is able to know Ps. 119. 144. 1 Cor. 2. 14. and to desire the things of his Peace in a Sprirituall and usefull manner notwithstanding the vanity of those many seemingly fervent Prayers of the Saints in the Scripture that God would give them understanding in these things and his manifold Promises of that Grace 3. Thirdly that upon such deliberations men are put into a capacity and liberty or are inabled to worke themselves to what strength or degree of desire and inclination towards that Good considered they please and according as the good is that men apprehend as abiding with God is the greatest Good such will be the strengh and the vigour and power of their inclinations thereto Rom. 7. â—8 9 10 11 c. That they have a Law in their members rebelling against the Law of their minds leading them captive under the Law of sinne needs not to be taken notice of 2 Cor. 3. 5. This sufficiency it seemes is of themselves He was a weake unskilfull man who supposed that of our selves we could not think a good thought seeing we are such perfect Lords and Masters of all good thoughts and actings whatever 4. Fourthly the whole summe of this Discourse of the means afforded Believers to inable them to Persevere amounts to this that being rationall men they may First consider that some kinds of sinnes
an interest in the good of them all that being only represented variously for the advantage of them that believe My designe is Gal. 16. 17. to describe the generall intention of God in all Gospell Promises whereby they being equally Spirited Eph. 2. 12. Heb. 6. 17. become as one and concerning these I say 1. That they are free and Gracious as to the rise §. 5. and fountain of them They are given unto us Tit. 1. 2. meerely through the good will and pleasure of God That which is of Promise 2 Pet. 1. 3 4. is every where opposed to that which is of doubt or that which is any way deserved or procured by us Gal. 3. 18. If the inheritance be of the Law which includes all that in us is desireable acceptable and deserving it is no more of Promise that is free and of meere Grace He that can find out any Reason or cause without God himselfe why he should promise any good things whatever to Sinners as all are are shut up under sinne till the Promise came Mat. 20. 15. Gal. 3. 22. may be allowed to Glory in the invention which he hath found out A well conditioned Nature necessitating him to a velleity of doing good and yeelding reliefe to them that are in misery though justly receiving the due reward of their deeds which even among the Sonnes of men is a vertue dwelling upon the confines of vice for their recovery is by some imposed on him But that this is not the fountaine and rise of his Promises needs no other evidence but the light of this Consideration That which is naturall is necessary and universall Promises are distinguishing as to them in misery at least they are given to men and not to fallen Angells But may not God doe what he will with his own Farther Jesus Christ is himselfe in the Promise he is the great originall matter and subject of the Promises and the giving of him was doubtlesse of free Grace and Mercy so Iohn 3. 16. God so Loved the World that he gave his only begotten Sonne and Rom 5. 8. God commendeth his Love towards us in that whilest we were Sinners Christ died for us and in the first of Ioh 4. 10. Herein is Love Mat. 11. 26. not that we Loved God but that he Loved us and sent his Sonne to be a Propitiation for us All is laid upon the account of Love and free Grace I confesse there are following Promises given out for the orderly carrying on of the persons to whom the maine originall fundamentall Promises are made unto the end designed for them that seeme to have Qualifications and Conditions in them but yet even those are all to be resolved into the Primitive grant of Mercy That which promiseth Life upon believing being of use to stirre men up unto and carry them on in Faith and Obedience must yet as to the pure nature of the Promise be resolved into that which freely is promised viz. Christ himselfe and with him both Faith and Life Believing and Salvation As in your Automata there is one originall spring or wheele that giveeth motion to sundry lesser and subordinate movers that are carried on with great variety sometimes with a seeming contrariety one to another but all regularly answering and being subservient to the impression of the first mover The first great Promise of Christ Gen. 3. 15. 16 and all good things in him is that which Spirits and principles all other Promises whatsoever Gen. 49. 10. Isa. 9. 6. and howsoever they may seem to move upon conditionall termes 2 Cor. 1. 20. yet they are all to be resolved into that absolute and free Originall Spring Hence that great Grant of Gospell Mercy is called the Gift by him Rom 5. 16 17. yea all the Promises of the Law as to their Originall Emanation from God and the constitution of the reward in them ingaged to be bestowed for the services required are free and Gracious There is not any naturall indispensable connexion between Obedience and Reward Diatr de Iust. Div. as there is between Sinne and Punishment as I have elsewhere at large Disputed and Proved 2. I call them Discoveries and Manifestations of Gods Good-will and Love §. 6. which is the prime and sole cause of all the good things which are wrapped up and contained in them Of this Good-will of God the Promises which he hath given are the sole discoveries We doe not in this Discourse take Promises meerely for what God hath said he Will doe in termes expresly but for every Assertion of his Good will and Kindnesse to us in Christ all which was first held out under a word of Promise Gen 3. 15. And this the Apostle inferres in Tit. 1. 2 3. In hope of eternall life which God that cannot lye promised before the◠World beganne but hath in due time manifested his Word through Preaching or discovered or made known that good will of his by the Promises in Preaching of the Gospell And to this extent of significancy is that Promise in the Scripture both name and thing in very many places stretched out Every thing whatever that is manifestative of Grace and good will to Sinners is of the Promise though it be not cast into a Promissory forme of expression Yea whereas strictly a Promise respecteth that which is either only future and not of present existence or the continuance of that which is yet even expressions of things formerly done and of a present performance some Individuals to the end of the World being to be made a new partakers of the Grace good will and Mercy in them doe belong to the Promise also in that Acceptation of it which the Holy Ghost in many places leads unto and which we now insist upon Mica 7. 17 18 19. 3. I say they are made unto sinners and that as sinners under no other Qualification whatever it being by the Mercy of the Promise alone that any men are relieved out of that condition of being sinners and morally nothing else Were not the Promises originally made to sinners Ephes. 2. 12. there would never any one be found in any other state or Condition Rom. 3. 19. I know there are Promises made to Believers Gal. 3. 22. even such as are unchangeable and shall beare them into the bosome of God but I say these are all consequentiall and upon supposition of the first and great Promise whereby Christ himselfe and Faith for his sake is bestowed on them This runs through them all as the very tenor of them Ioh. 3. 16. Rom. 8. 32. and method of God in them do manifest as we shall see afterwards So the Apostle Gal. 3. 22 The Scripture hath concluded all under sinne 1 Cor 1. 30. that the Promise by Faith of Jesus Christ might be given to them that Believe Phil. 1. 29. All are shut up under sinne Ephes. 1. 3. untill
the Promise of Salvation by Jesus Christ and Faith in him cometh in for their deliverance The Promise is given to them as shut up under sinne which they receive by mixing it with Faith And Rom 3. 23. 24. All have sinned and come short of the Glory of God being justified freely by his Grace through the Redemption that is in Christ. Their condition is a condition of sinne and falling short of the glory of God when the Promise for Justification is given unto them and finds them Thence the Lord tells us Isai 54. 8 9. that this Promise of mercy is like that which he made about the waters of Noah Gen 5. 21 22 where is mentioned no condition at all of it but only the sinnes of men And in that state unquestionably was Adam when the first Promise was given unto him To say then that Gospell Promises are made to men in such conditions and are to be made good only upon the account of mens abiding in the condition wherein they are when the Promise is made to them is to say Ephes. 2. 4 5 8. that for men to leave the state of sinne is the way to frustrate all the Promises of God All deliverance from a state of sinne is by Grace all Grace is of Promise under that condition then of sinne doth the Promise find men and from thence relieve them 4. I say §. 7. these Discoveries of Gods good Will are made through Christ as the only medium of their Accomplishment 2 Cor. 1. 20. and only procuring cause of the good things that flowing from the good will of God are enwrapped and tendred in them And they are said to be in Christ as 1. The great Messenger of the Covenant as in him who comes from the Father because God hath confirmed and ratified them all in him not in themselves but unto us He hath in him and by him given Faith and Assurance of them all unto us declaring and confirming his good Will and Love to us by him He reveals the Father as a Father from his own Bosome Ioh 1. 18. declaring his name or Grace unto his Ioh 17 3. 2 Cor. 1. 20. In whom all the Promises of God are yea and in him amen to the Glory of God by us Ioh 17. 3. In him and by his Mediation they have all their Confirmation Establishment and unchangeablenesse unto us And 2. Because he hath undertaken to be Surety of that Covenant whereof they are the Promises Heb 7. 24. He is the Surety of the Covenant that is one who hath undertaken both on the part of God and ours what ever is needfull for confirmation thereof 3. Because that himselfe is the great Subject of all these Promises and in him it being of his own Purchase and procuring he having obtained Eternall Redemption for us Heb 9. John 1. 16. there is treasured up all the fulnesse of those Mercies Col. 1. 18 19. which in them God hath graciously engaged himselfe to bestow cap. 2 10. c. they being all annexed to him as the portion he brings with him to the Soule Rom. 8. 32. Then I say 5. That they are discoveries of Gods good will in a Covenant of Grace they are indeed the Branches Streames and manifesting conveyances of the Grace of that Covenant and of the Good Will of God putting it selfe forth therein Hence the Apostle mentions the Covenant of Promise Ephes 2. 12. either for the Promises of the Covenant or its manifestation as I said before Indeed as to the Subject-Matter and eminently the Promise is but one as the Covenant is no more but both come under a plurall Expression because they have been variously delivered and renewed upon severall occasions So the Covenant of Grace is said to be established upon these Promises Heb 8. 6. that is the Grace and Mercy of the Covenant and the usefulnesse of it to the Ends of a Covenant to keep God and man together in Peace and Agreement is laid upon these Promises to be by them confirmed and established unto us God having by them revealed his Good Will unto us with an attendency of stipulation of duty Their use for the begetting and continuing Communion betweene God and us with the concomitancy of precepts places them in the capacity of a Covenant And then 6. I mentioned the foundation of the Certainty and Vnchangeablenesse of these Promises with our Assurance of their Accomplishment The Engagements and Undertakings of God upon his Truth and Faithfulnesse is the stock and unmoveable foundation of this respect of them Therefore speaking of them the Holy Ghost often backs them with that Property of God He cannot lye so Heb 6. 17. 18. God willing more abundantly to shew unto the heirs of Promise the immutability of his Councell confirmed it by an Oath that by two immutable things wherein it was not possible for God to lye c. So Tit 1. 2. God which cannot lye hath promised us eternall life There is no one makes a solemne Promise but as it ought to proceed from him in sincerity and Truth so he engageth his Truth and Faithfulnesse in all the credit of them for the Accomplishment thereof what lyeth in him And on this account doth David so often appeale unto Psal. 31. 1. 5. 14. and call upon the Righteousnesse of God as to the fulfilling of his Promises Isa 45. 19. 2 Pet 1. 1. and the word which he caused him to put his trust in It is because of his engagement of his Truth and Faithfulnesse whence it becometh a righteous thing with him to performe what he hath spoken How farre this Respect of the Promises extends and wherein it is capable of a dispensation is the summe of our present Controversy but of this afterwards Then 7. A briefe description of the Matter of these Promises and what God freely engageth himselfe unto in them was insisted on Of this of the Promises in this regard there is one maine Fountaine or Spring whereof there are two everlasting Streames whence Thousands of refreshing Rivolets doe flow The originall Fountaine and spring of all good unto us both in respect of its being and manifestation is that He will be our God Gen 17. 1 2. I am Almighty God walke before me and be thou perfect and I will make my Covenant So every where as the bottome of his dealing with us in Covenant Ierem 31. 33. I will be their God Hos 2. 23. and they shall be my People Isai 54. 5. And in very many other places Now that he may thus be our God two things are required 1. That all Breaches and Differences between him and us be removed perfect Peace and Agreement made and we rendred acceptable and well pleasing in his sight These are the termes whereon they stand to whom he is a God in Covenant For the Accomplishment of this is the first maine streame that floweth from the former Fountaine namely the
it and to preserve it from being destroyed But may it not at one time or other be surprized into desolation No saith he I will keep it night and day but what if this vineyard prove barren what will he then doe Nay but he will so deale with it that it shall never be so barren as to cause him to cast it up He is not with it for nought his presence is attended with Grace and Kindnesse I water it saith he and that not now and then but every moment He powres out fresh supplies of his Spirit upon it to make it fruitfull Thence it becomes a vineyard of red wine v. 2. the best wine the most delicious the most pretious to cheare the heart of God himselfe as Zep 3. 17. The Lord thy God in the midst of thee is mighty he will Save thee he will rejoyce over thee with joy he will rest in his Love he will joy over thee with singing He causes them thereby that come of Iacob to take root he makes Israel blossome and bud to fill the face of the World with fruit This is that which God promiseth his people he will not forsake them he will alwaies give them his presence in the kindnesse and supplies of a God in Covenant to protect them from others to make them fruitfull to himselfe This is his not forsaking them He will preserve them from others who shall take them out of his hand he will make them fruitfull to himselfe he will worke and who shall let him 2. The Reason why the Lord will not forsake his People why he will continue doing them good is expressed in these words for his owne name sake and in this Assertion two things are considerable 1. A tacite exclusion of any thing in themselves for which or upon Consideration whereof God will constantly abide with them It is not for their sakes for any thing in them or what they have done may or can do it is not upon the account of any Condition or qualification whatever that may or may not be found on them but meerely for his name sake which in the like case he expresseth fully Ezek. 36. 32. Not for your sakes doe I this saith the Lord be it knowne unto you be ashamed and confounded for your owne wayes oh House of Israel The truth is they may prove such as on all accounts whatever shall deserve to be rejected that nothing in appearance or in their owne sence as well as others though the root of the matter be in them may be found upon them when God takes delight in them Like those you have described at large Isai. 43. 22 23 24 25. But thou hast not called upon me Oh Jacob but thou hast been weary of me Oh Israel thou hast not brought me the small Cattell of thy burnt offerings neither hast thou honoured me with thy Sacrifices I have not caused thee to serve with an Offering nor wearied thee with Incense thou hast brought me no sweet cane with money neither hast thou filled me with the fat of thy Sacrifices but thou hast made me to serve with thy sinnes thou hast wearied me with thine iniquities I even I am he that blotteth out thy transgressions for mine owne sake and will not remember thy sinnes any more Weary of God they are neglecting his worship making his Patience and Forbearance to serve with their iniquities It seemes to be impossible almost for any Creature to apprehend that God will not give them up to everlasting confusion Yea perhaps they may be forward in their follies and contend with God when he goes to heale them Isai. 57. 17. For the iniquity of his covetousnesse was I wroth and smote him I hid me and was wroth and he went on forwardly in the way of his heart Iniquity is upon them a vile iniquity the iniquity of Covetousnesse God is wroth with them and smites and hides him and they goe on frowardly and yet for all this he forsakes not for ever he abides to be their God and that because his so doing is not bottomed on any consideration of what they are have been or will be but he doth it for his Names sake and with regard unto that which thereupon he will doe for them And upon this account this Promise of Gods abiding and continuing with his let Grace be never so weake corruption never so strong temptations never so violent may be pleaded and the Lord rejoyces to be put in remembrance of it by the weakest frailest sinfullest Saint or Believer in the World 2. The Cause or reason is positively expressed § 6. why God will not forsake them it is for his Great Name sake His Great name is all that he consults withall about his continuance with his people this he calls himselfe Isa. 43. 25. I blot out thy sinnes for my own sake that is for no other cause in world that may by found in thee or upon thee The Name of God is all that whereby to us he is knowne all his Attributes his whole will all his Glory When God is said to doe any thing for his name it is either the Cause and End of what he doth or the Principle from whence with the motive wherefore he doth it that is by him intended In the first sence to doe a thing for his Name sake is to doe it for the manifestation of his Glory that he may be known to be a God in the Excellency of those Perfections whereby he reveals himselfe to his with most frequently a speciall regard to his Faithfulnesse and Grace it is in those properties to make himselfe knowne and to be exalted in the hearts of his So all his dispensations in Jesus Christ are for the praise of his glorious Grace Eph. 1. 6. That he may be exalted lifted up made knowne believed and received as a God pardoning iniquity in the Sonne of his Love And in this sence may the Lord be said to abide with his people for his Name sake for the exalting of his Glory that he may be known to be a God faithfull in Covenant and unchangeable in his Love who will not cast off for ever those whom he hath once received into favour It will not enter into the hearts of Believers sometimes why the Lord should so deale with them as he doth and not cast them off their soules may goe to rest as to this thing he himselfe is glorious herein he is exalted and doth it on that account 2 ly If by his name you understand the principle from whence he worketh and his motive thereunto as it comprehends the whole long-suffering gratious tender unchangeable nature of God according as he hath revealed himselfe in Iesus Christ in whom his name is Ex. 23. 21. and which he hath committed to him to be manifested Ioh 17. 6. so evidently two things in God are engaged when he promiseth to work for his Names sake or according to his great Name 1. His Power or sufficiency
to the body of the Jewes returning out of Captivity was before demonstrated The Righteousnesse here mentioned is that which God will and doth exercise in this very Act of Betrothing and not any other act of it which he will make use of to that purpose God engageth to betroth them to himselfe in Righteousnesse using and exercising his Righteousnesse in that very Act of his Love and Grace to them and this is now given in an alluring them to love him by appearing Righteous in bringing them out of Captivity The like interpretation is given of the other expressions following §. 33. Judgement It is saith he by punishing and judging their enemies and destroying them that led them into captivity and held them in bondage and subjection and Loving-kindnesse is his giving them corne wine oyle peace and plenty and Mercy in pardoning of daily sins and insirmities and Faithfulnesse is he knoweth not what This is made the summe of all God by doing them good with outward mercies and pardoing some sins and infirmities will morally try to get their affections to himselfe Virgula Pictoris 1. It is not an Expression of Gods attempting to get their Love but of the establishing and confirming of his own 2. That God should morally try and essay to doe and effect or bring about any thing which yet he doth not will not or cannot compasse and effect is not to be ascribed to him without casting the greatest reproach of Impotency Ignorance Changeablenesse upon him imaginable 3. God promising to Betroth us to himselfe fixing his love on us that we shall know him so fixing our hearts on him to say that this holdeth out only the use of some outward meanes unto us enervateth the whole Covenant of his Grace wrapt up in these Expressions so that all things considered it is not a little strange to me that any sober learned man should ever be tempted so to wrest and corrupt by wrested and forced Gsosses the plaine words of Scripture wherein whatever is pretended he cannot have the least countenance of any Expositor of note that went before him Although we are not to be pressed with the name of Tarnovius a Lutheran a professed Adversary in this cause yet let his Exposition of that place under consideration be consulted with and it will plainely appeare that it abideth not in any compliance with that which is here by our Author imposed on us The Promises we have under consideration §. 34. looking immediately and directly only to one part of that Doctrine whose defence we have undertaken to wit the Constancy and Unchangeablenesse of the Grace of Justification or God's abiding with his Saints as to his free acceptance of them and love unto them unto the end I shall not insist on many more particulars The 10. §. 35. Iohn 27 28 29. closeth this Discourse My sheepe heare my voice and I know them and I give unto them Eternall Life and they shall never perish neither shall any man pluck them out of my hand my Father which gave me them is greater then all and no man is able to pluck them out of my Fathers hand In the verse foregoing our Saviour renders a reason why the Pharisees notwithstanding all his Preaching to them and the Miracles he wrought among them yet believed not when sundry others to whom the same dispensation of outward meanes was afforded did heare his voice and did yeild obedience thereunto and this he telleth us was because they were not of his sheepe such as were given him of his Father and for whom as the good Shepheard he lay'd downe his life v. 14 15. upon the close of this discourse he describeth the present Condition of his Sheepe their Preservation in that Condition from the power of himselfe and his Father engagedthere unto He layeth their abiding him as his Sheepe upon the Omnipotence of God which upon account of the constancie of his Love towards them he will exercise and exert as need shall be in their behalfe There are many emphaticall expressions both of their continuance in the Obedience of Faith and of his undertaking for their Preservation therein The latter I at present only intend Saith he 1. I know them 2. I give them Eternall Life 3. They shall never perish 4. No man shall plucke them out of my hand 5. My Father is Omnipotent and hath a Soveraignty over all and he taketh care of them and none shall take them out of his hand It is not easy to cast these words into any other form of arguing then that wherein they lye without loosing much of that convincing Evidence that is in them this you may take for the summe of their influence into the Truth in hand Those whom Christ so owneth as to take upon him to give them Eternall Life and by his Power and the Power of his Father to preserve them thereunto which power shall not nor possibly can be prevailed against so that the end aimed at to be accomplished therein should not be brought about those shall certainely be kept for ever in the Favour and Love of God they shall never be turned from him Such is the case of all Believers for they are all the Sheep of Christ they all heare his voice and follow him Some few things to wrest this Gracious assurance given Believers of the everlasting good will of God Christ unto them §. 36. by Mr Goodwin Cap. 10. Sect. 37. Page 203. are attempted 1. He granteth that there is an engagement of the mighty power of God for the safegarding of the Saints as such or remaining such against all adverse power what ever But no where for the compelling or necessitating of them to persevere and continue such is there any thing in the Scripture Ans. The sum is if they will continue Saints God will take care that notwithstanding all opposition they shall be Saints still Very well if they will be so they shall be so But that they shall continue to be so that is not promised The termes of Compelling or Necessitating are cast in meerly to throe dirt upon the Truth least the beauty shining forth too brightly there might have bin danger that the very Exceptor himselfe could not have born it We say not that God by his Power compelleth men to persevere that is maketh them doe it whether they will or no. Perseverance being an habitual Grace in their wills it is a grosse contradiction once to imagine that men should be compelled thereunto But this we say that by the Almighty Power of his Spirit and Grace he confirmeth his Saints in a voluntary abiding with him all their dayes Having made them a willing People in the day of the Power of Christ towards them he preserveth them unto the end Neither are they wrapt up by the power of God into such a necessity of Perseverance as should obstruct the liberty of their Obedience The necessity that regardeth them in that Condition respecting
Ephes. 1. 7. in whom we have redemption through his bloud even the forgivenesse of sinnes or the Intercision of that Obligation unto punishment which attends sinne in reference to the sinner and his subjection to the Law of God and the righteousnesse thereof As the oblation of Christ respecteth God and his justice to whom it is given as a price and Ransome and whereof it is an Attonement so it is and is called or we are said to receive thereby Redemption As it respects them who receive the benefit of that Redemption Rom. 1. 5. it is the forgivenesse of sinnes Forgivenesse of sinnes as t is compleated and terminated in the Consciences of Believers requireth the interposition of Faith 1 Cor. 1. 30. for the receiving of Christ in the Promise who of God is made unto us Righteousnesse but in respect of the procurement of it and the removing all causes Rom. 4. 4. upon the account whereof sinne should be imputed unto us that is perfected in the oblation of Christ hence he is said to beare our sins in his own body on the Crosse 1 Pet 2. 24. and being once on him either he was discharged of them or he must for ever lye under the burthen of them They were on him on the Tree what is then become of them If he were freed of them and Justifyed from them as he was Isa. 50. 8 9. how should they ever be laid to our charge And yet this freedome from condemnation for sin for all the Elect which God himselfe so clearly asserts Rom. 8. 32. 33. c. doth not in the least set them free from the necessity of Obedience nor acquit them from contracting the guilt of sin upon the least irregularity or disobedience Secondly we are said to doe together with Christ those things which he doth for us in his own person Rom. 6. 5 8. and that upon the account of that benefit which by those his personall performances 2 Cor. 5. 15 16. doth redound unto us and which being done Col. 3. 1. the Quarrell about sinne as to make an utter separation between God and our souls Rom. 6. 7. is certainly removed Thus we are said to dy with him to be raised again with him and with him we enter into the holy place this whole businesse about sin being passed through for he that is dead is justifyed from sin Now all this being done by us and for us in by our head can we hencesorth dy any more shall death any more have dominion over us This the Apostle argues 2 Cor. 5. 15. we judge saith he that if one dyed for all then were all they that is all those for whom he dyed dead or dyed likewise they were dead in and with him their sponsor as to the curse due for sin that henceforth they might live to him that dyed for them Thirdly the Compact or agreement that was between the Father and the Sonne as Mediator about the businesse of our Redemption in his blood manifests this Truth Psal. 40. 8. The Father required at his hands that he should doe his will Isa. 53. 10 11. fulfill his pleasure and counsell make his soule an offering for sinne and do that which the Sacrifices of Bulls Goates shadowed out Heb. 10. 5 9 7. but could never effect upon the performance whereof he was to see his Seed and to bring many Sonnes to Glory Heb. 2 10. A covenanting and agreement into an uncertaine Issue and event as that must be of God and the Mediator if the Salvation of the persons concerning which and whom it was be not infallibly certaine ought not at any cheap rate or pretence to be assigned to infinite Wisdome In the Accomplishment of this undertaking whereunto Christ was designed the Father dealt with him in strict aud rigid Justfce Rom. 8. 32. There was neither composition about the debt 2 pet 2. 4. nor commutation about the punishment that he had taken upon himselfe 2 Cor. 5. 21. Now doth not exact Justice require that the Ransome being given in Gal. 3. 13. the Prisoners be delivered That the debt being paid Heb. 2. 9. the bond be cancelled as to any power of imprisoning the Originall debtor That punishment being undergone and the Law fulfilled the offendor goe free Especially all this being covenanted for in the first undertaking doubtlesse wrath shall not arise a second time The right knowledge use and improvement of this Grace being given bounded directed by the Gospell it is safegarded from abuse by that which God calls his owne Wisdome Fourthly §. 13. it appeares from what God bestowes upon his Elect upon the Account of the undertaking of Christ for them in the pursuit of the Eternall purpose of his Will antecedently to any thing whatsoever in them that should ingage him to do them the least good when God comes as a friend to hold out unto bestow good things upon men I meane good in that kind of Mercy which is peculiarly suited to the bringing of them to the enjoyment of himselfe it is evident that he hath put an end to all enmity and quarrell between him them Isa. 59. 20. 21 Now antecedently unto any thing in men God for Christs sake bestowes Rom. 8. 11. with the greatest act of friendship imaginable Gal. 5. 22. no lesse than the holy Spirit on them 1 Cor. 7. 4. By him they are quickned 2 Cor 3. 5. their Faith is but a fruit of that Spirit bestowed on them John 15. 3 5. If they have not any sufficiency in themselves as much as to think a good thought Ephes. 2. 1 2. nor can doe any thing that is acceptable to God being by nature dead in trespasses and sinnes which at present the Scripture affirming it I take for granted then assuredly God doth give his Holy Spirit to the Saints whereby he workes in them both to will and to do of his owne good pleasure Phil. 1. 13. antecedently to any good thing in them Col. 1. 12. that is well pleasing unto him Every thing that men do must either be brought forth by the strength and Ability of their owne naturall facultyes assisted and provoked by motives and perswasions from without or it must be of the operation of the Spirit of God there is not another principle to be fixt on The first at present I take for granted is not the fountaine of any Spirituall acting whatsoever John Gal Neither can any Gracious act be educed radically from the corrupt naturall faculty Gen. 8. 21. however assisted or advantaged It must be the Spirit then Job 14. 4. that is the sole principall cause and Author of all the movings of our soules towards God Mat. 12. 33. that are acceptable to him in Christ Now the cause is certainely before the effect and the Spirit in order of Nature is bestowed upon us
antecedently to all the Grace which he worketh in us whether the Spirit be bestowed on men on the account of Christ's undertaking for them none can question but they must withall deny him to be the Mediator of the new Covenant The Spirit of Grace is the principall Promise thereof Isa. 59. 20 21. We are blessed with all Spirituall Blessings in Christ Ephes. 1. 3. Surely the holy Spirit himselfe so often Promised to us of God is a Spirituall Blessing God's bestowing Faith on us is antecedent to our Believing this also is given upon the account of Christ. Phil. 1. 29. It is given to us on the behalfe of Christ to Believe on him If then God for Christs sake antecedently to any thing that is good that is not enmity to him that is not iniquity in men do bestow on them all that ever is good in them as to the root principle of it surely his quarrell against their sins is put to an Issue Thence Christ being said to make Reconciliation for the sins of the people Heb. 2. 17. God as one pacifyed and attoned thereupon is said to be in him reconciling the world unto himselfe 2 Cor. Eph. 2. 13 24 5. 19. And in the dispensation of the Gospell he is still set forth as one carrying on that peace whose foundation is laid in the blood of his Sonne by the Attonement of his Justice and we are said to accept or receive the Attonement Rom. 5. 10. We receive it by Faith it being accepted by him Thus his death and Oblation is said to be a Sacrifice of a sweet smelling savour Eph. 5. 2. that wherein God is abundantly delighted wherewith his soule is fully satisfyed so that as when he smelt a sweet savour from the Sacrifice of Noah Gen. 8. 21. he sware he would curse the Earth no more smelling this sweet savour of the Oblation of Christ on the account of them for whom it was Offered John 17. 19. he will not execute the Curse on them whereof they were guilty Rom. 5. 10. I might also insist on those Testimonies for the further proofe of the former Assertion Rom. 6. 6. where an immediate efficacy for the taking away of sinne 2 Cor. 5. 21. is ascribed to the death of Christ Eph. 5. 25. 26 But what hath been spoken may at present suffice Titus 2. 14. The Premises considered § 14. some Light may be brought forth to discover the various mistakes of men Heb. 9. 14. about the effects of the Death of Christ Heb. 10. 14. as to the taking away of sinne 1 Pet. 2. 24. if that were now the matter before us Some having truly fixed their thoughts on the efficacy of the death of Christ 1 Joh. 1. 7. for Abolition of sin Revel 1. 5 6 doe give their Lusts and darknesse leave to make wretched inferences thereupō as that therefore because we are so compleatly justified accepted before without our believing or the consideration of any thing what ever in us that therefore sinne is nothing nor at all to be accounted of And though they say we must not sinne that Grace may abound yet too many by wofull experience have discovered what such corrupt Conclusions have tended unto Others againe fixing themselves on the necessity of Obedience and the concurrence of actuall Faith to the compleating of justification in the soule of the sinner with a no lesse dangerous reflection upon the Truth do suspend the efficacy of the death of Christ upon our believing which gives life vigour virtue unto it as they say is the sole originally discriminating cause of all the benefits we receive thereby without the antecedent accomplishment of that condition in us or our Actuall believing it is not say they nor will be usefull yea that the intention of God is to bestow upon us the fruits and effects of the death of Christ upon condition we do Believe which that we shall is no part of his purchase and which we can of our selves performe say some of them others not Doubtlesse these things are not being rightly stated in the least inconsistent Christ may have his due and we bound to the performance of our duty which might be cleared by an enlargement of the ensuing Considerations 1. First That all good things that are spirituall whatsoever that are wrought either for men or in them are fruits of the death of Christ. They have nothing of themselves but nakednesse bloud and sinne guilt and impenitency so that it is of indispensable necessity that God should shew them favour antecedently to any Act of their Believing on him Faith is given for Christs sake as was observed 2. Secondly That all the Effects and Fruits of the death of Christ antecedent to our Believing are deposited in the hand of the Righteousnesse and Faithfulnesse of God 1 Tim. 2. 5 6. to whom as a ransome Heb. 2. 17. it was paid as an Attonement it was offered before whom as a price and purchase it was laid downe It is all left in the hands of Gods Faithfulnesse 2 Cor. 5. 18 19. Righteousnesse Mercy and Grace to be made out effectually to them 1 Cor. 6. 19 20. for whom he died in the appointed time or season So that 3. Thirdly The state or condition of those for whom Christ died is not actually and really changed by his death Eph. 2. 1 2 3 4 5. in its selfe but they lye under the curse whilest they are in the state of nature unregenerate and all effects of sinne whatever John 3. 36. That which is procured for them is left in the hand of the Father They are not in the least intrusted with it untill the Appointed time do come 4 Fourthly That Faith and Beliefe are necessary not to adde any thing to compleat the procurement of forgivenesse of sins any or all but only to the Actuall receiving of it when upon the account of the death of Christ it pleaseth God in the Promise of the Gospell to hold it out and impart it unto the soule thereby compleating Covenant-justification And thus the whole businesse of Salvation may be resolved into the mediation of Christ and yet men carried on under an orderly dispensation of Law and Gospell into the enjoyment of it Acts 13. 38 39. Of the whole these degrees are considerable 1 Gods eternall purpose of saving some Rom. 5. 10. in and by the mediation of Christ Joh. 3. 16 that mediation of Christ being interposed between the purpose of God Rom. 5. 7 8. and the accomplishment of the thing purposed 1 Joh. 4. 10. as the fruit and effect of the one Heb. 2. 17. 9. 14. the meritorious procuring cause of the other This Act of the Will of God Eph. 1. 4 5. 6 7 8 9. c. the Scripture knowes by no other name then that of Election or Predestination or the Purpose
height under their pressures that we have great cause of rejoycing in them all Yea but whence is this Do these Graces readily come forth and exert themselves with an efficacy suitable to this triumphing frame The ground spring of all is discovered v. 5. it is because the Love of God is shed abroad in our hearts by the Holy Ghost that is given to us From this fountaine do all these fresh streames flow the Spirit that is given us that sheds abroad the Love of God in our Hearts and thereby sets all our Graces on worke He oyles the wheeles of the soules obedience when we neither know what to do nor how to performe what we know 5. This indwelling Spirit § 27. gives Restraint Restraining Grace doth mainly consist in morall perswasions from the Causes Circumstances and Ends of things When a man is disswaded from sinne upon Considerations taken from any such head or place as is apt to prevaile with him that perswasion so applyed and intended of God for that end is unto him restraining Grace By this meanes doth the Lord keepe within bounds the most of the Sonnes of men notwithstanding all their violent and impetuous lusts Hell shame bitternessee disappointment on the one hand Credit Repute quietnes of Conscience the like on the other binde thē to their good Behaviour God through these things drops an awe upon their Spirits binding them up from running out unto that compasse of excesse and ryot in sinning which otherwise their lusts would carry them out unto This is not his way of dealing with the Saints Jer. 31. 34. he writes his Law in their hearts and puts his feare in their inward parts that they may not depart from him making them a willing people through his owne Power Psal. 110. 3. By his effectually remaining Grace he carryes them out kindly chearefully willingly to do his whole will working in them to will and to do of his owne good pleasure yet notwithstanding all this often times through the strength of Temptation the subtilty of Sathan and his readinesse to improve all Advantages to the utmost the treachery and deceitfulnesse of indwelling sinne and corruption they are carryed beyond the bounds and lines of that principle or Law of Life and Love whereby they are lead What now doth the Lord do They are ready to runne quite out of the pasture of Christ doth he let them goe and give them up to themselves Nay but he sets an hedge about them that they shall not find their way He leades them as the wild Asse in her month that they may be found he puts a Restraint upon their Spirits by setting home some sad considerations of the evil of their hearts and wayes whether they are going what they are doing and what shall be Issue of their walking so loosly Even in this life what shame what scandall what dishonour to themselves their profession the Gospell their Brethren it would prove and so hampers them quiets their Spirits and gently brings them againe under obedience unto that principle of Love that is in them and the Spirit of Grace whose yoake they were casting off whereby they are lead Many times then even the Saints of God are kept from sinnes especially outward actuall sinnes upon such outward motives reasonings and considerations as other men are Peter was broken loose and running downe hill apace denying and forswearing his Master Christ puts a restraint upon his Spirit by a looke toward him this mindes him of his folly unkindnesse his former rash confidence and ingagement to dye with his Master and sets him on such Considerations as stirred up the principle of Grace in him to take its place and rule againe and in obedience thereunto he not only desists from any farther denyall but Faith Repentance Love all exerting themselves he goes out and wept bitterly It is so frequently with the Saints of God though in lesser evills by neglect and omission of duty or inclination to evill and closing with temptations they breake out of the pure and perfect Rule and Guidance of the Spirit whereby they ought to be lead instantly some Considerations or other are pressed on upon their Spirits taken perhaps from outward things which recovers them to that obedientiall frame from whence through violence of Corruption and Temptation they had broken Like an Hawke sitting on a mans hand eating her meat in quietnesse is suddenly by the originall wildnesse of her nature carryed out to an attempt of flying away with speed but is checkt by the string at her heeles upon which shee returnes to her meat againe We have an innate wildnesse in us provoking and stirring us up to runne from God Were we not recovered by some clog fastned on us for our Restraint we should often runne into the most desperate paths And this Restraint I say is from the indwelling Spirit He stirrs up one thing or other to smite the Hearts Conscience when it is under the Power of any Temptation to sinne and folly So it was with David in the Attempt he made upon Saul when he cut of the lappe of his Garment Temptation opportunity had almost turned him loose frō under the power of Faith waiting and dependance on God wherein lay the generall frame of his Spirit he is recovered to it by a blow upon the heart from some dismall Consideration of the Issue and scandall of that which he was about 6. We have hereby also the Renewall §. 28. daily Renewall of sanctifying Grace Inherent Grace is a thing in its owne nature apt to decay and dye it is compared to things ready to dye Rev. 3. 2. strengthen the things that remaine saith Christ to the Church of Sardis that are ready to dye It is a thing that may wither and decline from its vigor and the soule may thereby be betrayed into manifold weaknesses and backslidings It is not meerely from the nature of the Trees in the Garden of God that their fruit failes not nor their leaves wither Psal. 1. 4. but from their Planting by the Rivers of water Hence are the sicknesses weaknesses and decayes of the Spirit mentioned in the Scripture Should he who had the richest stock of any living be left to spend of it without new supplies he would quickly be a Bankrupt This also is prevented by the Indwelling Spirit He is the fatnesse of the Olive that is communicated to the branches continually to keep them fruitfull and flourishing He is that golden Oyle which passes through the Branches and empties it selfe in the fruitfulnesse of the Church He continually fills our Lamps with new Oyle and puts new vigor into our spirits Psal. 92. 10. thou liftest up my horne as the horne of an Vnicorne I am anoynted with fresh oyle or renewed supplies of the Spirit And this Psal. 103. 5. is called a renewing of Youth like the Eagles a Recovery of former strength and vigor new power and ability for new duties and
with a farther opening of his mind as to what he had last spoken of The world the world being vile wretched deceitfull and set upon Opposition against them a man would have thought that the Lord Jesus should have desired that his Saints might be taken out from the midst of this world and set in a quiet place by themselves where they might no more be troubled with the baits and oppositions of it But this is not that which he requests he hath another worke for them to do in the world they are to beare witnesse to him and his Truth by their Faith and Obedience to convince the wicked unbelieving world They are to Glorifie his name by doing and suffering for him so that this is no part of his request I pray not saith he that thou shouldest take them out of the world but that they may not be prevailed on nor conquered by the evill that is in the world That they may be kept and preserved from the power of evill which would separate them from me and my Love This he presseth for and this he is heard in and that not only for his Apostles and present followers but as he tells you v. 20. for all that should believe on him to the end of the world The things prayed for the Reason of his Intercession the opposition against the accomplishment of the things interceded for the distinction put between them for whom he Intercedes and the perishing world all delivered in plaine and expresse termes evidently evince the intendment of Christ in his Intercession evidently to regard the safeguarding of Believers in the Love and Favour of God by their continuance in Believing and preservation from the Power of temptations and oppositions arising against their Perseverance in communion with God The result of what hath been spoken §. 5. as to its influence into the confirmation of the Truth under Demonstration amounts unto thus much That which the Lord Jesus Christ as Mediator requesteth and prayeth for continually of the Father according to his mind in order to the Accomplishment of the Promises made to him and Covenant with him all his desires being bottomed upon his exact perfect performance of the whole will of God both in doing and suffering that shall certainly be accomplisht and brought to passe But thus in this manner upon these accounts doth the Lord Jesus intercede for the Perseverance of Believers and their Preservation in the Love of the Father unto the end therefore they shall undoubtedly be so preserved It is confessed that the Persons Interceded for are Believers all Believers that then were or should be to the end of the World the efficacy of this Intercession having commenced from the foundations thereof the thing prayed for is their Preservation in the state of Union with Christ and one another the motives used for the obtaining this request in their behalfe are taken from the work they have to doe and the opposition they were to meet withall and all the Saints being thus put into the hand of God who shall take them from thence On what account is it that they shall not be preserved To say they shall be thus preserved in case themselves depart not wilfully from God is to say they shall be preserved in case they preserve themselves as will afterwards be farther manifested This Argument is proposed by the Apostle §. 6. in the most triumphant assurance of the Truth and Certainty of the inference contained in it that he any where useth in any case whatsoever Rom 8. 33 34. Who shall lay any thing to the charge of Gods Elect It is God that justifieth Who is he that condemneth It is Christ that died yea rather that is risen againe who is even at the right hand of God who also maketh Intercession for us he laies the immunity of the Elect justified Persons from just crimination or Condemnation on the foundation of the Oblation and Intercession of Christ The first part of this Argument from the Oblation of Christ who shall condemne It is Christ that died asserting the immunity of Believers from Condemnation upon the account of the punishing of all their sinnes in Christ and the perfect satisfaction made by his death for them whence the justice of God in the issue will not have any thing to lay to their charge we have formerly insisted on The other which the Apostle induces emphatically and comparatively though not in respect of procurement and purchase made yet of assurance to be given with 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 in respect of his Oblation is that now before us To make the Assurance of Believers plentifull that they may know both the Truth of his first generall Assertion that all things shall work together for good to them and this particular conclusion now laid downe by way of interrogation rejecting all evill opposed to their former enjoyments who shall lay any thing to their charge who shall condemne He gives them a threefold consideration of the state and actings of the Lord Christ after the Expiation of their sinnes by this bloud in reference to them 1. He is Risen 2. He is at the Right hand of God 3. Makeeth Intercession for them the First denoting his Acquitment and theirs in him for he died in their stead from all the sinnes that were charged on him For he was declared to be the Sonne of God accepted with him and justified from all that debt which he undertook in his Resurrection and if he be risen who shall lay any thing to the charge of them whom he died for and for all whose sinnes in their stead he was acquitted The Second is his Exaltation and Power for having purged our sinnes he is sate downe at the right hand of the Majesty on High Heb. 1. 3. receiving thereby a most plenary demonstration of his Fathers good will to him and his in respect of the work that he had undertaken and gone through for them For if he had not made an end of sinne when he was obedient unto death the death of the Crosse he could not expect that God should give him a name above every name with fulnesse of power to give Eternall Life to all that the Father gave him This to assure us that he will doe having power in his own hand the Apostle addes who also Intercedes for us hereby thirdly testifying abundantly his good will and care for our Salvation Upon these considerations the Apostle leads the Faith of the Saints of God to make a conclusion which is to be believed as a Divine Truth that tenders to us the Doctrine we have under Demonstration triumphant against all Objections and oppositions that can be made against it And hence we thus argue Those against whom no Charge can be laid who cannot by any means be separated from the love of God in Christ cannot totally and finally fall away from Faith and fall out of Gods Favour but that this is the condition of all true
fighting against their soules their continuance in Believing the falling from whence is indeed all the danger they are exposed to for whilst they continue so doing all other things are lighter then vanity that Christ takes no care about though he pray that God would sanctify them and keepe them but they must shift for themselves as well as they can he will not doth not Intercede for them that from these they may be preserved Doubtlesse he that shall think to be maintained long at any high rate of Consolation and laves in no other nor no better provision to live on then this mentioned will quickly be reduced to a dry morsell But yet some Reasons of the foregoing interpretation of this place of the Apostle Rom. 8 § 9. are offered unto us This to be the tenour and effect of Christ's Intercession for his Saints saith he is evident from the first of the three passages cited And for that demand who shall separate us from the love of Christ It is not meant from the Love wherewith we love Christ but from the Love wherewith Christ loveth us as we are Saints and abide in his love and keepe his commands neither is it so to be conceived as if sinne wickednesse loosenesse profanenesse could not unsaint men and hereby separate them from them from that love wherewith Christ sometimes loved them for that Iniquity will separate between men and their God is evident from Isa. 59. 2. But the cleare meaning is that nothing no Creature whatsoever person or thing can make Christ an enemy to those who shall in Faith and Love cleave fast unto him Ans. 1. All this respecteth only one expression in this one place of Scripture and ariseth not with the least power against our Argument taken from many places in Conjunction explicatory one of an other It runns also upon the same mistake with the former taking the exaltation of Believers upon the Intercession of Christ in their behalfe which holds out the Issue of it to be expressive of the matter of his Intercession being only a demonstration of the event of of it But grant this to be the tenor and effect of Christs Intercession that Believers may not be separated from his Love is he heard therein or is he not Whatsoever be the issue of the question our procedure will be facile But it is said that it is not the Love wherewith we love Christ but that wherewith he loveth us that we shall not be separated from take this also for granted that it is that that only will this advantage your Cause If we be never separated from that Love that Christ bears us is it possible we should wholly be separated from that Love that we beare him Wherein consists our separation from that Love that Christ bears us How is it caused or may it be procured Is it not by the losse of our Faith and Love to him Or at least is it not an inseparable consequence thereof Or can it possibly come to passe any otherwise then on that account If then he Intercedes that we may not be separated from that Love he bears us and that Love inferrs the continuance of ours doth he not withall Intercede that we may never loose that Love wherewith we love him by which we continue in his Love If the old shift be not at hand for a reliefe this young part of the Answer will instantly suffer losse It is added therefore he loveth us as we are Saints and abide in his Love that is for so we must understand it whilst we are so for that he beares any effectuall Love to us to keepe us up to Saintship that is denyed 't is true Christ loveth us as Saints and as abiding in his Commandements but it is also his Love to keepe us and he intercedeth that we may abide in that Condition wherein alone it is possible for us so to do Neither is the Question whether sinne loosenesse profanenesse do not separate between God and men more or lesse but whether Believers shall not be preserved from such loosenesse profanenesse as would make a totall separation between God and them and if God intercedes as is added in the close that nothing may make him an enemy to us certainely he must Intercede that no sinne may do it For indeed sinne is something in this businesse and this must be as to the keeping us from it I suppose no man thinks any thing in all this Discourse of Mr Goodwin's to looke like the least attempt of proofe that Christ doth not Intercede for the Perseverance of Saints Neither hath he confidence enough positively to deny it therefore spends his whole Discourse hereabout in evasions and diversions Let it be directly denyed that Christ doth not intend that the Faith of Believers may not faile that his Saints may be preserved and Saved and we know what we have to apply our selves unto And if the contrary cannot be proved the Saints know what they have to trust unto that they may no longer leane on that which will yeild them no supportment If this will not be let it on the other hand be granted that he doth so intercede for de unoquoque affirmare aut negare verum est As to this then he proceeds Secondly Were it granted that part of Christs Intercession for his Saints is that their Faith may never faile yet the intent thereof would not necessarily nor indeed with any competent probability §. 10 be this that no sinne nor wickednesse whatsoever that shall or can be perpetrated by them might cause them to make shipwracke of their Faith but rather that God would graciously vouchsafe such meanes and such a presence of his Spirit unto them as whereby they may be richly inabled to keepe themselves in Faith Good conscience to the end Ans. Whether prejudiced men will grant it or no it is clearly proved if the words of Christ themselves may be taken for proofe that he Intercedes for his Saints that their Faith may not faile and that notwithstanding the interposition of any such sinnes as they can or may suppositis supponendis amongst which is his Intercession fall into So he tells Peter upon the prediction of his dreadfull fall that neverthelesse he had prayed for him that his Faith should not faile That they may fall into such sinnes and continue in such as are inconsistent with their Acceptation with God according to the termes and tenor of the new Covenant is that which we have been disproving all this while and which our Author ought not as he doth in all his Reasonings to suppose In the not failing or dying of their Faith in their preservation therein is included their deliverance from the perpetration of the sinnes intimated or at least from such a manner of committing any sinne as should utterly separate them from God It is the continuance of a living Faith that Christ prayes for and where that is there will be workes of
new Obedience and there will be the work of that Faith in purifying the Heart and mortifying of the sinnes supposed Farther the way here prescribed and limited to the Lord Jesus how he shall intercede for his and for what viz. not for actuall Perseverance and continuance in the Faith to be wrought in them by the exceeding greatnesse of the power of God but for meanes to inable them to preserve themselves we are perswaded he walkes not in And that much upon this account that the way whereby God begins and carries on Believers in the way of Faith and Obedience is not by such a supply of meanes as leaves them to themselves to work and effect the things for which they are so supplied but he himselfe workes in them to will and to doe of his own good pleasure fulfilling in them all the good pleasure of his Goodnesse and the worke of Faith with power giving them all their sufficiency and preserving them by his power through Faith unto salvation To make Faith and Perseverance therein to follow such a supply of meanes as leaves the production of them to the power of the wills of men so that after God hath done all that on his part is to be done or performed that is quickned them being dead giving them new Hearts Spirtis shone into their mindes to give them the knowledge of his Glory in the Face of his Sonne c. it is yet uncertaine whether â—ver Faith shall be wrought in their Soules or no or rather whether men so supplied with means will Believe and Persevere or no is an Assertion that will never be proved to Eternity nor whilest Truth is Truth it is capable of proofe The granting of such meanes and such a presence of his Spirit that men may be inabled to worke for themselves is an expression exceedingly unsuited to all the Promises of the new Covenant what ever either of the Spirit of Grace or the meanes of it is given out to Believers Christ intercedes that his Father would keepe them not that they should keepe themselves he was too well acquainted with our frame and our temptations to desire we might be our own keepers God forbid we should be left to our owne preservation to the hand of our owne counsell and power though compassed with all the supposed sufficient meanes that may be not eventually effectually God creates a defence upon our Glory and doth not leave it to our owne safegarding Our salvation is not in our own custody That the Father doth not keepe us or preserve us that the Sonne doth not Intercede that we may be so preserved that the Spirit doth not make us meete for and keepe us unto the Inheritance of the Saints in Light but that in the use of meanes we are as Adam was our own keepers are some of the Principles of that new way of administring consolation to Believers which Mr Goodwin hath found out This then is the utmost which Mr Goodwin will allow to be for disputation sake not that he really believes it granted that Christ intercedes for his Saints as to their continuance and preservation in that condition viz. That God would give them such meanes as they may use or not use at their liberty which may be effectuall or not effectuall as their own wils shall choose to make use of them which he also takes for granted to be common to all the World and not to be peculiar unto Believers But it is farther argued If Christ should simply and absolutely Intercede that no sinne or wickednesse whatsoever may destroy the Faith of any true Believer and consequently deprive him of Salvation should he not hereby become that which the Apostle rejects with indignation as altogether unworthy of him I meane a Minister of sinne Is therefore Christ the Minister of sinne God forbid or whereby or wherein can it lightly be imagined that Christ should become a minister of sinne rather then by interceding with his Father that such and such men how vile and abominable soever they shall become may yet be precious in his sight and receive a Crowne of Righteousnesse from his hand Or doth not such an Intercession as some men put upon him as they who make him to Intercede simply and absolutely for the Perseverance of Believers in their Faith amount to an Intercession of every whit as vile and unworthy Import as this Ans That this is the tenor of Christs Intercession with his Father for men let them become as vile as they will how vile and abominable soever yet that they may be still precious in his sight and that he would give them a Crowne of Righteousnesse M. Goodwin knoweth full well not to be the Doctrine of them he opposeth If he shall otherwise affirme it will be incumbent on him to produce some one Author that hath wrote about this Doctrine in what language soever and so stated it If he be ignorant that this is not their Doctrine he ought not to have ingaged into an opposition thereof if he argue that it is otherwise this procedure is unworthy of him That Christ Intercedes for his Saints that they may be kept from all such sinnes as would separate them from the Love and Favour of his Father for which there is no Remedy provided in the Covenant of Grace and that their Faith may not faile or perish under such sinnes as they may through Temptation fall into is the Doctrine which he opposeth or at least ought to oppose to make good his undertaking Now if this be so then saith he is Christ the minister of sinne why so He sees and foretells that Peter should deny him thrice yet he prayes that Peters Faith may not faile under that sinne and wickednesse is he therefore a minister of sinne because he Intercedes that his Saints may not be given up to the power of sinne nor every time they are assaulted lye conquered by sinne is he therefore a minister of sinne or rather a deliverer from sinne That very thing which M. Goodwin affirmes would make him a minister of sinne he affirmes himselfe to do in the case of Peter how he will free himselfe from this charge and imputation ipse viderit 2. What it is to Intercede simply and absolutely for Believers that they may continue believing we are not so cleare in Christ Intercedes that they may be preserved by the power of his Father in and through the use of those meanes which he graciously affords them and the Powerfull presence of the Spirit of God with them therein and that not on any such absurd and foolish conditions that they may be so preserved by his Father provided they preserve themselves and continue Believers on condition they continue to believe and if this be of a vile and unworthy import the Gospell is so too and one of the most eminent Graces that is inwrapped in the New Covenant is so too What there is farther in M. Goodwin Sect. 34. Pag. 249
Rom. 5. 1. and Justified by Faith to have Peace with him which as to his present condition the Adversaries of the Doctrine of Perseverance acknowledge that he may attaine though how upon their principles I understand not consider a little how he can safegard his Peace for a moment and deliver himselfe from perplexing thoughts and feares renouncing any interest in the ingagement of the Love and Faithfulnesse of God for his preservation He may say within himselfe I am for the present in some good state and condition but were not the Angels so that are now Devills in Hell were not they in a farre better and more excellent state then I am and yet they are now shut up under chaines of everlasting darknesse to the judgment of the great day Adam in Paradise had no lust within him to tempt and seduce him no World under the curse to intangle and provoke him and yet being in that honour he had no understanding he abode not but became like the beast that perisheth was it not in their power to persevere in that condition if they would Did they want any meanes that were usefull thereunto And what hope is there left to me Rom. 7. in whom there dwelleth no good thing who am sold under the power of sinne and encompassed with a world of temptations that I shall endure unto the end I see thousands before mine eyes partakers of the same heavenly calling with my selfe of the same Grace in Jesus Christ every day falling into irrecoverable perdition There is not any Purpose of God that I should be preserved nor Promise that I shall never depart from him no prayer of Christ that my Faith may not faile but I am rolled upon mine own hand and what will be the end of this whole undertaking of mine in the wayes of God I know not Let I say a man be exercised with such thoughts as these and then try if any thing under heaven can bring his soule to any possible composure untill it be cast into the mould of that Doctrine which hath been delivered But of this more directly afterwards when we come to treat of the Consolation which from the breast of it doth flow 2. §. 11. It is exceedingly suited to the deliverance of the Soules of the Saints from all such hard thoughts of God as are apt to impaire and weaken their Love towards him and delight in him so setting the two principles of all their Obedience Faith and Love at liberty and free from their intanglements to act in the duties they are called unto He that had hard thoughts of his absent Lord as an austere man though he was not excused in his disobedience by it yet he was evidently discouraged as to his Obedience When men shall be taught that God takes no more care of his Children in his family but that the Divell may enter in among them and and take them away making them Children of Hell when he might with the greatest Advantage of Glory and Honour to himselfe imaginable prevent it That the Lord Jesus Christ the great Shepheard of the Sheep takes no more care of his flock and fold but that the Lion Beares and Wolves may enter in and make havocke and spoile at their pleasure May they not think that God is little concerned in the Salvation of his and that all that which is so Gloriously expressed of his peculiar and speciall Love carries nothing but an empty noise the burthen of their preservation being thrown soly upon their owne shoulders And are not such thoughts fitte only to cast water upon their flames of Love to God and insensibly to weaken that delight which they ought alwayes to take in the riches of his Grace and Love Is there any thing possible more indearing to the heart of a Creature then to heare such a testimony as that Zeph. 3. 17. concerning the stability of the Love of God and its excellency The Lord thy God in the midst of thee is mighty he will save he will rejoyce over thee with joy he will rest in his Love he will joy over thee with singing Gods resting in his Love towards his Saints fixes their soules in their Love to him 3. §. 12. It puts high and unspeakable Obligations on the Saints to live to God and to perfect Holinesse in the feare of the Lord Saints we suppose to have their Birth from above to be begotten of the Will of God through the immort all seed of the Word and to be quickened with a Noble Child-like Ingenuity befitting the family of God Neither is any thing more injurious to the worke of God's Grace then to suppose that those whom God calls Children Friends Heirs of Heaven and Glory his Crowne his Diadem Brethren of his only Sonne are to be dealt withall or that God deales with them as if they were wholly acted by a servile slavish Principle and were wholly under the power of such an unworthy disposition There are two things usually spoken to the prejudice and disadvantage of § 13. the Truth we have under Consideration much insisted on by Mr Goodwin Cap 9. As 1. That a perswision of the certaine continuance of the Love of God to any one is a ready way to make them carelesse negligent and to give up themselves to all manner of abominations But what Vipers Snakes and Adders do such men suppose the Saints of God to be that their new nature their Heavenly Principles for what the flesh in them is prone unto we now consider not should conclude that it is good to sinne that Grace may abound that because God Loves them with an Everlasting Love therefore they will hate him with a perpetuall hatred that because he will assuredly give them Grace to serve him with reverence Goâ—ly fear therefore they will despise him and trample on all his Goodnesse because he will never forsake them that they will no more abide with him What is in the inner man what is in the new Creature what is in the nature of any Grace wherewith they are indowed that is apt or inclinable to make such hellish Conclusions If we heare of any such thing among the Sonnes of men if we see a Child or a servant resolving to be profligate wicked stubborne prodigall because his Father or Master is kind loving and will not disinherit him or put him away we looke upon him as a monster in nature and think that it would be good service to the interest of mankind to take him off from the face of earth And yet such monsters are all the Saints of God supposed to be who if their Father once give them the least Assurance of the Continuance of his Love they presently resolve to doe him all the dishonour despite and mischeife they can I appeale to all the experience of all the Saints in the world whethâ—â— if any such thought at any time arise in them that they may continue in sinne because Grace
of the weakenes of Grace rather then of the flesh which yet it is not able to do for if there be no Promise to the contrary why may not the principle which carrieth men forth to lesser carry them also forth to greater more provoking sinnes what boundaries will you prescribe unto these sinnes of infirmitie The pretension from the strength of the flesh yea from the weakenesse of it holdeth good against the Saints establishment in Peace and Assurance upon the account of their being destitute of any Promise of preservation by God 2. If the Saints be willing saith he to strengthen the Spirit in them §. 22. and make him willing proportionably to the meanes prescribed and vouchsafed unto them by God for such a purpose this will fully ballance the weakenesse of the flesh prevent the miscarriages breaking out hereof This I say then saith the Apostle walke in the Spirit and ye shall not fulfill the lusts of the flesh and againe If you be lead by the Spirit you are not under the Law and consequently are in no danger of loosing the Favour of God or of perishing for such sinnes which under the conduct of the Spirit you are subject unto Ans. But that all now must be taken in good part and nothing called strange or uncouth since we have passed the pikes in the last Section I should somewat admire at the Doctrine of this Paragraph For 1. Here is a willing in reference to a great Spirituall duty supposed in men antecedent to any Assistance of him who worketh to will and to do of his owne good pleasure What he worketh he worketh by the Spirit But this is a willing in us distinct from and antecedent to the appearing of the Spirit for the strengthning thereof 2. That whereas we have hitherto imagined that the Spirit strengthneth the Saints and that their supportment had been from him as we partly also before declared at least we did our minde to be so perswaded it seemeth they strengthen the Spirit in them and not he them How or by what meanes or by what principles in them it is that so they do is not declared Besides what is here intended by the Spirit is not manifested If it be the Holy and Blessed Spirit of God be hath no need of our strengthning he is able of himselfe to make us meet for the Inheritance of the Saints in Light If it be the gracious principles that are bestowed upon the Saints that are intended the new Creature the inwardman called the Spirit in the Scripture in opposition to the flesh if our strengthning this Spirit be any thing but the acting of the Graces intended thereby in us I know not what you meane Especially in what is or consists their acting to make the Spirit willing proportionably to the meanes we do receive am I to seeke to say that we receave outward meanes of God for so they must be being distinguished from the Spirit and thereupon of our selves do make the Spirit willing and strengthen him to the performance of God surely holdes out a very sufficient power in Spirituall things inbred in us and abiding with us whereof there is not the least Line or appearance in the whole Booke of God nor in any Author urged by Mr Goodwin to give countenance to his perswasion neither 2. Is the summe of all this Answer any other but this If we are willing will prevent all miscarriages from the weakenesse of the flesh we may But how we become willing so to do and what Assurance we have that we shall be so willing seeing all in us by nature John 3. 6. as to any Spirituall duty is flesh is not intimated in the least This is strenuously supposed all along that to be willing unto spirituall good in a spirituall manner is wholly in our owne power and an easie thing it is no doubt The plea in hand is that such is the strength of indwelling sinne in the best of the Saints and so easily doth it beset them that if they have not some Promise of God to assure them that they shall have constant supply of Grace from him and by his power be preserved it is impossible but that they must be filled with perplexing feares that they shall not hold out in giving him willing Obedience to the end Their Will being in an especiall manner entangled with the power of sinne It is answered If men be but willing c. they need not feare this or any such issue i. e. If they do the thing which they feare and have reasons inviucible to feare that they shall not they need not feare but that they shall do it which is nothing but a most absurd begging of the thing in Question Nether is there any thiug in the Scripture that will give a passe to this Begger or shelter him from due correction The Apostle indeed saith that If we walke in the Spirit we shall not fulfil the lusts of the flesh And good Reason there is for it for as he told us these are contrary to one an â—ther and opposite to one another bring forth such divers contrary fruits in them in whom they are that if we walk in the one we shall not fullfill the lusts of the other But what assurance have we that we shall walke in the Spirit if it be not hence that God hath promised that his Spirit shall never depart from us And if we are lead by the Spirit we are not under the Law Which by the way letteth us see that the Spirit leadeth us that is maketh us willing and strengtheneth us not we him But on what account shall or dare any man promise to himselfe that the Spirit will continue so to do if God hath not promised that he shall so do Or if his leading of us be only on condition that we be willing to be lead how shall we be in the least assertained supposing us in any measure acquainted with the power of indwelling sinne that we shall be alway so willing let then this passe with what was said before as nothing to the thing in hand 3. It is answered then 3 ly and lastly there is no such aptnesse or pronenesse unto sinne §. 23. sinnes I meane of a disinheriting import in Saints or true Believers as is pretended But on the contrary a strong propension or inclination unto Righteousnesse raigneth in them we heard formerly from the Apostle 1 John 3. 9. That he that is borne of God cannot sinne and also from the 1 John 5. 3. From these suppositions with many other of like import it is evident that there is a pregnant strong over powring propension in all true Believers to walke Holily and to live Righteously so that to refraine sinning in the kind intended is no such great mastery no such matter of difficulty unto such men and that when they are overcome and fall into sinne it is through a meere voluntary neglect and thus
we see all things unpartially weighed and debated to and fro that the Doctrine which supposeth a possibility of the Saints declining is the Doctrine which is according to Godlinesse and the corrivall of it an enemy thereto Ans. We have here an Assertion an Inference and a Conclusion The Assertion is that there is no such aptnesse and pronenesse to sinne in Believers as is intimated and that because there is such a strong propensity in them to Righteousnesse which that they have is proved from sundry places of Scripture That is because the Spirit is in Believers the flesh is not in them Because they have a new man in them they have not an old because they have a principle of Life they have not a body of death That is where the Spirit lusteth against the flesh the flesh lusteth not against the Spirit We thought the Doctrine of Paul Rom. 7. Gal. 5. and in innumerable other places with the experience off all the Saints in the World had laine against this piece of Sophistry It is true their propension unto Righteousnesse raigneth in them but it is as true their propension unto sinne rebelleth in them Though the Land be conquered for Christ yet the Canaanites will dwell in it if the Saints leave of but one day the worke of killing crucifying and mortifying they will quickly finde an actuall rebellion in them not easie to be suppressed They have indeed a propension to Holinesse ruling in them but also a propension unto sinne dwelling in them so that when they would do good â—vell is present with them and the good they would do they cannot But when Mr Goodwin can prove this consequence that Saints have strong inclinations to Righteousnesse therefore they have not so to sinne for my part I will forbeare for ever disputing with him If he can beat us not only from Scripture but all our Spirituall sence and experience doubtlesse it is to no purpose to contend any longer with him Hence then 2. He inferreth §. 24. that to abstaine from sinning that is sinning customarily against conscience so as to endanger the losse of the Favour of God is no such great mastery no such matter of difficulty to such men This abstaining from such sinnes on the one hand is the whole course of our Gospell Obedience which it seemeth however it be compared to running in a race striving for masteries called resisting unto blood wrestling with principallities and powers requiring for its carrying on the exceeding greatnesse of the power of God with suitable help in time of need from Jesus Christ who is sensible of the weight of it as no small matter knowing what it is to serve God in Temptations yet is it indeed but a trifling thing a matter of no great difficulty or mastery Doe men Watch Pray Contend Fight Wrestle with God and Satan doth the Lord put forth his Power and the Lord Jesus Christ continually intercede for the preservation of the Saints Ad quid perditio haec to what end is all this toile and labour about a thing of little or no weight Egregiam vero laudem We know indeed the Yoke of Christ is easy and his Commandement not grievous that we can doe all things through him that inableth us but to make Gospell obedience so slight a thing that it is no great mastery or matter of no great commendation to hold out in it to the end this we were to learn till now and are as yet slow of heart to receive it The Conclusion is Io §. 25. Pâ—an vicimus all things unpartially weighed the case is ours and Godlinesse exceedingly promoted by the Doctrine of the possibility of the Saints defection 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and the corrivall of it an enemy to it to prove which not one word in the Argument hath been spoken nor to free the other from a charge of a direct contrary importance one word to the purpose and of Mr Goodwins sixth Argument for his Doctrine of the Apostasy of Saints this is the end But this is not all he hath to say in this case §. 26. in hand Indeed the maine designe of his whole 13. Chap. consisting of 41. Sections and about so many pages in his Book and containing all which in an Argumentative way he insisteth on in the case in hand looketh this way and therefore having already pluckt away one of the maine propps of that discourse I shall apply my selfe to take away those which doe remaine that the whole may justly fall to the ground and therefore shall as briefely as I can consider the whole of that discourse containing nine Arguments against the Perseverance of Saints for the possibility of their totall and finall defection CAP. XII 1. M. G. entrance and preface to his Arguments from the Apostasy of the Saints considered 2. The weaknesse of his first Argument The import of it 3. Answer to that first Argument Doctrine may pretend to give God the glory of being no accepter of Persons and yet be false Justification by workes of that rank and order 4. Acceptation of Persons what and wherein it consisteth No place for it with God contrary to distributive Justice 5. The Doctrine of the Saints Perseverance charged with rendring God an accepter of Persons 6. Unjustly what it saies looking this way 7. The summe of the charge against it considered and removed 8. M. G. second Argument and the weight by him hanged thereon the originall of this Argument by whom somewhat insisted on 9. The Argument it selfe in his words proposed of the use and end of the Ministry whether weakned by the Doctrine of Perseverance 10. Entrance unto an Answer to that Argument The foundation laid of it false and when it falsely imposeth on the Doctrine of Perseverance sundry things by it disclaimed the first considered 11. The iniquiry of those impositions farther discovered 12. The true state of the difference as to this Argument declared 13. The Argument satisfied 14. The reinforcement of the Minor attempted and considered 15. The manner of Gods operations with and in naturall and voluntary Agents compared Efficacy of Grace and liberty in man consistent 16. An Objection to himselfe framed by M. G. that Objection rectified Perseverance how absolutely and simply necessary how not 17. The removall of the pretended Objection farther insisted on by M. G. 18. That discourse discussed and manifested to be weake and sophisticall The consistency of Exhortations and Promises farther cleared 19. The manner of the operation of Grace in and upon the wills of men considered 20. The inconsistency of exhortations with the efficacy of Grace disputed by M. G. 21. That discourse removed and the use of Exhortations farther cleared Obedience to them twofold Habituall Actuall of the Physicall operation of Grace and meanes of the word their compliance and use How the one and the other affect the will 22. Inclination to Persevere when wrought in Believers 23. Of the manner of Gods operation
lesse Anti-evangelicall This foundation then being removed what ever is built upon it mole ruit su◠Neither is it in any measure restored or laid a new by the reason of it given by Mr G. viz. That the Scripture affirmeth in sundry places that God is no accepter of persons for he that shall hence conclude that what ever Doctrine affirmeth directly or by consequence that God is no Aceepter of persons what ever other abomination it is evidently deeming with all is yet true and according to the minde of God shall have leave notwithstanding the antiquated Statute of our Vniversity against it to goe and reade Logicke at Stamford On this account do but provide that a Doctrine be not gnilty of any one crime and you may conclude that it is guilty of none For instance That Doctrine which impeacheth not the Omnipresence of the Diety is true according to the Scripture for the Scripture aboundeth with cleare Testimonyes of the Presence of God in all places Now the Doctrine of the Vbiquity of the humane nature of Christ doth no way impeach the omnipresence of the Diety therefore it is true and according to Scripture I might supersede all further considerations of this Argument having rendered it altogether uselesse and unserviceable in this warfare by breaking its right legge or rather cruteh whereon it leaned but something also may be added to the Minor because of its reflection in the close of its proofe upon the Doctrine we maintaine intimating an inconsistency of it with that Excellency of God spoken of namely that he is no Accepter of Persons Prosopolepsia §. 4. or Accepting of Persons is an evill in Judgment when he who is to determine in causes of righteousnesse hath respect to personall things that concerue not the merit of the Cause in hand and judgeth accordingly This properly can have no place in God as to any bestowing of free Grace Mercy or Pardon There is Roome made for it only when the things that are bestowed or wrought by it are such as in Justice are due it being an Iniquity solely and directly opposed to distributive Justice Exod. 23. 2 3 6 7 8 9. that rendreth to every one according to what is Righteous and due Iob. 31. 34. That with God there be no Accepting of Persons there is no more required but this that he appoint and determine equall Punishments to equall faults and give equall Rewards to equall deservings If he will dispose of his pardoning Mercy and free Grace to some in Christ not to others who shall say unto him what dost thou May he not do what he will with his owne So he giveth a peny to him that laboureth all day he maygive a peny also to him that worketh but one houre Now suppose that Mr G's Doctrine render God free from this or rather chargeth him not with it yet if withall it calleth his Truth Righteousnesse Faithfulnesse Oath and Immutabillity into question shall it passe for a Truth or be embraced ever the sooner But the sting of this Argument lieth in the Taile §. 5. or close of it in the Reflection insisted on upon the common Doctrine of Perseverance as it is called viz. that it teacheth God to be an accepter of Persons This is Mr Goodwin's way of Arguing all along When at any time he hath proposed a proofe of the Doctrine he goeth about to establish finding that as somthing heavy worke to lye upon his hand and not much to be said in the case he instantly turneth about and falleth upon his Adversaries in declaiming against whom he hath a rich and overflowing Veine There is scarce any one of his Arguments in the pursuit and improvement whereof one fourth part of it is spoken to that head where in he is engaged But wherein is the Common Doctrine of Perseverance guilty of this great crime §. 6. It teacheth that He that believeth shall be saved and he that believeth not shall be damned It teacheth that God hath allotted equall punishments to equall Transgressions and appointed equall Rewards to equall wayes of Obedience That the Wages of every sinne is death and that every sinner must dye unlesse it be those concerning whom God himselfe saith Deliver them I have found a Ransome Job 33. 24. that he is a like displeased with sinne in whomsoever it is and that in a peculiar and eminent manner when it is found in his owne Indeed if this be to impute Acceptation of Persons to God to say that he hath Mercy on whom he will have Mercy and whom he will he hardeneth that he is tender to his owne as a Father to his only Child that serveth him and will recover them being faithfull in his Promises from their sinnes and heale their backeslidings though he suffer others to lye wallowing in their rebellions and pollutions all their dayes that he will not give pardon to any finner but upon Faith and Repentance but will give Faith and Repentance to those whom he hath chosen and given unto Jesus Christ to be saved If this I say be acceptance of Persons our Doctrine owneth the imputation of ascribing it to God and glorieth in it we being ascertained that God taketh all this to himselfe clearely and plentifully in the Word of Truth The summe of what our Author gives in §. 7. to make good his charge upon the common Doctrine of Perseverance is That it affirmeth that though Saints and Believers fall into the same sinnes of Adultery and Idolatry and the like with other men yet they are not dealt withall as other men but continued in the Love and Favour of God To wave the consideration of the false impositions by the way on the Doctrine opposed as that is that it teacheth the Saints to fall into and to continue in them to the significancy of that expression never so long under Abominations and to joyne Issue upon the whole of the matter I say 1. That in and with this Doctrine and in perfect Harmony and Consistency therewith Rom. 1. 32. we maintaine that the judgement of God is the same in respect of every sinne in whomsoever it is and that he that doth it on that account is worthy of death and 2. That the sentence of the Law is the same towards all cursing every one that continueth not in all things written in the Book thereof Deut. 27. 26. to doe them 3. That in and under the Gospell wherein a remedy is provided in reference to the rigour and severity of both the former Apprehensions yet the Judge of all dealeth with all men equally according to the tenor of it He that Believeth shall be Saved and he that Believeth not shall be damned Men in the same condition shall have the same recompence of reward But you will say Doe not the same sinnes put men into the same condition and deserve the same punishment in one as in another Ans. 1. They doe deserve the same punishment God
good pleasure what validity there is in these inferences will be easily discerned God worketh Grace in men as men and as men impotent and corrupted by sinne As men he workes upon them by meanes suited to their Rationall being by Precepts and exhortations but as men impotent and corrupt by sinne they stand in need of his effectuall power to worke that in them which he requireth of them Of the termes wherewith his arguing in this case is clowded and darkened enough hath been remarked already His second Argument to this purpose §. 22. viz. That the Inclination of the will to good and to persevere in a Saint must be after his being made a Saint is as weake and no lesse Sophysticall than the former That inclination is radically wrought in every Believer at his Conversion the Spirit being bestowed on him which shall abide with him for ever and the Seed of God laid in his heart that shall remaine and never utterly faile with an habituall inclination to the exercise of all those Graces wherein their persevering doth consist Actually this is wrought in them according to the particular dutyes and actings of Grace that are reqnired of them which they are carryed forth unto by the daily influence of Life Power and Grace which they receive from Christ their head without whom they can do nothing Neither is the third Exception of any more validity being only a Repetition of what was spoken before rendred something more impedite darke and intricate by the termes of Physically Irresistibly and Necessitated which how farre and wherein we doe allow hath been frequently declared The summe of what is spoken amounts to this Gods reall worke in and upon the Soule by his Spirit and Grace is inconsistent with the exhortations to Obedience which we have before disproved and do reject it as an Assertion destructive to all the efficacy of the Grace of God and the whole worke of it upon the Soules of Men. What his Fourth Argument also is but a Repetition of the same things before crudely Asserted in other termes let them apprehend that can If God worke Faith and Love in the hearts of his Saints and support them in them to the end what place is left for Exhortations I say their own proper place the place of meanes of meanes appoynted by God to stirre up his to Perseverance and which himselfe makes by his Spirit and the immediate efficacy thereof effectuall to that end and purpose And I know no use of that Query Are exhortations effectuall to perswade men to Persevere after the end being built only on his false Hypothesis and begging of the thing in Question viz. That if God worke Faith and Love and continuance of them in our hearts effectually by his Grace there is no need no use of exhortations though God so work them by and with those exhortations And this is his first Attempt upon the first member of the Division made by him selfe wherein what successe he hath obtained is left to the judgement of the Reader And but that I shall not having now the part of one that Answers incumbent on mee turne aside unto the proofe of things denied I should easily confirme what hath been given in for the removall of his Objections from the Testimony of God by innumerable places of Scripture He proceeds then Sect. 6. and saies §. 23. Secondly Neither can the latter of the said consequences stand God doth not make use of the said Exhortations to influence or effect the Wills of the Saints upon any such termes as hereby to make them Infallibly Infrustrably Necessitatingly willing to Persevere or to do the things upon which Perseverance dependeth For first If so then one and the same act of the Will should be both Physicall and Morall and so be specifically distinguished in and from it selfe for so farre as t is produced by the irresistible force or power of the Spirit of God it must needs be Physicall the said irresistible working of the Spirit being a Physicall action and so not proper to produce a Moralleffect Againe as farre as the said Exhortations are meanes to produce or raise this Act of the Will or contribute any thing towards it it must needs be morall because Exhortations are Morall causes and so not capable of producing Physicall Naturall or Necessary effects Now then if it be impossible that one and the same Act of the Will should be both Physicall and Morall that is Necessary not Necessary impossible also it is that it should be produced by the irresistible working of God and by exhortations of this joynt efficiency It may be Objected they who hold or grant such an influence or operation of the Spirit of God upon the Will which is frustrable or resistible do or must suppose it to be a Physicall action as well as that which is irresistible If so then the act of the Will so farre as t is raised by the meanes of this action or operation of God must according to the tenor of the former Arguments be Physicall also and so the pretended Impossibility is no more avoided by this opinion then by the other I Answer Though such an operation of God upon the Will as is here mentioned be in respect of God of the manner of its proceeding from him Physicall yet in respect of the Nature and Substance of it t is properly Morall because it impresseth and affecteth the Will upon which t is acted after the manner of Morall causes properly so called that is Perswadingly not Ravishingly or Necessitatingly When a Minister of the Gospell in his preaching presseth or perswadeth men to such such dutyes or actions this act as it proceedeth from him I meane as 't is raised by his naturall abilityes of under standing or speaking is Physicall or Naturall but in respect of the substanceo◠native tendency of it 't is clearely Morall viz. because it tendeth to incline or move the wills of men to such or such Elections without necessitating them thereunto and so comports with those Arguments or Exhortations in their manner of efficiency by which he presseth or moveth them to such things By the way to prevent stumbling and quarrelling it no way followes from the Premises that a Minister in his preaching or perswading unto duty 's should doe as much as God himselfe doth in or towards the perswading of men hereunto it only followes that the Minister doth cooperate with God which the Apostte himselfe affirmes in order to one the same effect i.e. that he operateth in one the same kind of efficiency with God Morally or perswadingly not necessitating for where one necessitates another only perswades they cannot be said to cooperate or worke the one with the other no more than two when the one runnes the other walkes a soft pace can be said to goe or walke together But when two perswade in one and the same action one may perswade more effectually by many
meanes that this Originall of all sinne useth for the production of it is also discovered and that is Temptation every mans owne lust tempts him The progresse also it makes in carrying on of sin whereunto it tempts is farther described in the severall parts degrees of it 1. It drawes away and intices the persons towards whom it exerts this efficacy are drawne away or inticed 2. It conceives Lust conceives the subject being prepared answering its drawing away and inticing without more adoe it conceives sinne and then it brings it forth into Action that is either into open perpetration or deliberate determination of its accomplishment and then it finisheth sinne or comes up to the whole worke that sinne tends to Whereuuto is subjoyned the dismall end and issue of this progresse of sinne which is Death Eternall Death is in the wombe of finished sinne and will be brought forth by it This being the progresse of sin from the first Rise which is Lust to the last end which is Death the way and path that the best and most refined Unregenerate men in the world do never throughly forsake though they may sometimes step out of it or be stopt in it a way wherein who ever walkes to the end may be sure to find the end I shall consider the severall particulars laid downe and shew in them all at least the most materiall the difference that is betweene Believers Vnbelievers whilest they do walke or may walke in this path and then manifest where and when all Saints breake out of it forever so that they come not to the close thereof and therein shall give a full Answer unto the whole strength and designe of the Argument in hand which consisteth as was said in a comparison instituted between the sins and demerits of Believers and Unbelievers 1. The Fountaine §. 4. principle cause of all sin whatever in all persons whatever is Lust every ones owne Lust is the cause of his owne sin This is the mother wombe fomes of sin which Paul sayes he had not been acquainted withall but by the Law Rom. 7. 7. Nay I had not knowne sin but by the Law for I had not knowne Lust except the Law had said thou shalt not Covet That which in the entrance he calls sin indefinitely in the close he particularly termes Lust as being the hidden secret cause of all sinne and which once discovered swallowes up the thoughts of all other sin it being altogether in vaine to deale with them or to set a mans selfe in opposition to them whilst this sinfull wombe of them is alive and prevalent this is that which we call Originall sinne as to that part of it which consists in the universall alienation of our hearts from God and unconquerable habituall naturall inclination of them to every thing that is evill for this sinne workes in us all manner of concupiscence Rom. 7. 8. This I say is the wombe cause and principle of sinne both in Believers and Vnbelievers The Roote on which the bitter fruit of it doth grow where ever it is no man ever sinnes but 't is from his owne lust And in this there is an agreement between the sinnes of Believers and others they are all from the same Fountaine yet not such an agreement but that there is a difference herein also for the clearing whereof observe First that by nature this Lust §. 5. which is the principle of sinne is seated in all the facultyes of the Soule receiving divers Appellations according to the variety of the subjects wherein it is and is sometimes exprest in tearmes of Privation Want and Deficiency sometimes by Positive inclination to evill In the Understanding t is Blindnesse Darkenesse Giddinesse Folly Madnesse In the Will Obstinacy and Rebellion In the Heart and Affections Pride Stubbornenesse Hardnesse Sensuality In all Negatively and Privatively Death Positively Lust Corruption Flesh Concupiscence Sinne the Old man and the like There is nothing in the soule of a man that hath the least influence into any Action as Morall but it is wholly possessed with this depraved vicious habit and exerts it selfe alwayes and only in a suitablenesse thereunto Secondly thar this Lust hath so taken possession of men by Nature that in reference to any Spirituall Act or duty they are nothing else but Lust and Flesh §. 6. that which is borne of the flesh is flesh John 3. 6. It is all so it is all Spirituall Flesh That is it is wholly and habitually corrupt as to the doing any thing that is good If any thing in a man might seeme to be exempted it should be his minde the seat of all those things which are commonly called the Relickes of the Image of God but that also is flesh as the Apostle at large Asserts it Rom. 8. and enmity to God Neither is it of any weight which is Objected That there is in Unregerate men the knowledge of the Truth which they retaine in ungodlinesse Rom. 1. 18. Conscience accusing and excusing Rom 2. 14. The knowledge of sinne which is by the Law with sundry other endowments which they say doubtlesse are not flesh I Answer they are all flesh in the sence that the Scripture useth that word The Holy Ghost speakes of nothing in man in reference unto any duty of Obedience unto God but it is either Flesh or Spirit these two comprehend every man in the world every man is either in the flesh or in the Spirit Rom. 8. The utmost improvement of all naturall facultyes whatever the most compleat subjection whereunto they are brought by convictions yet leaves the same impotency in them to Spirituall good as they were borne withall the same habituall inclination to sinne however entangled and hampered from going out to the Actuall perpetrating of it neither are they themselves any thing the better nor hath God any thing of that Glory by them which ariseth from the willing Obedience of his Creatures Thirdly §. 7. it being the state of every mans proper Lust which is the Fountain of all sinne two things will follow First That in whomsoever it is in its compasse and power as above described as ' t is in every unregenerate Man how ever convinc'd of sinne he sinnes with his full and whole consent all that is within him consents to every sinne he commits Unregenerate men sinne with their whole hearts and soules In every act their carnall minds are not will not be subject to the Law of God their wills and all their Affections delight in sinne and this because there is no principle in them that should make any opposition to sinne I meane such a spirituall opposition as would really take off from their full consent It is true Conscience repines witnesses against sinne reprooves rebukes excuses or causes but Conscience is no reall principle of operation but either a Judge of what is done or to be done or a morall inducer to doing or not doing and whatever
That there is a plurality yea a contrariety of wills in the Scripture sence of the expression of the will of a man was before from the Scripture declared not a plurality of wills in a Physicall sence as the will is a naturall faculty of the soule but in a Morall and Analogicall sence as 't is taken for a habit or principle of good or evill The will is a naturall faculty one nature hath one will in every Regenerate man there are two natures the new or divine and the old or corrupted In the same sence there are in him two wills as was declared But saith he It is an impossibility of the first evidence that there should be a plurality of Acts in the same subject at the same time and these contrary one to another But 1. If you intend acts in a Morall Consideration unlesse you adde about the same Object which you do not this Assertion is so farre from any evidence of truth that it is ridiculously false May not the same person love God and hate the Divell at the same time But 2. How passe you so suddenly from a plurality of wills to a plurality of acts by the will we intend in the sence wherein we speak of it an habit not any act i.e. The will as habitually invested with a new principle not as actually willing from thence by vertue thereof Arminius from whom our Author borrowes this Discourse fell not into this Sophystry he tels you There cannot be contrary wills or volitions about the same Act But is it with M.G. or Arminius an impossibility that there should be a mixt action partly voluntary partly involuntary actions whose principles are from without by perswasion may be so a mans throwing his goods in the Sea to save his owne life Now the principles whereof we speak Flesh Grace are internall contrary shall not the actions that proceed from a faculty wherein such contrary principles have their residence be partly voluntary partly involuntary 3. But he tells you That though there might be lusting of the Spirit against the flesh before the act of sinne yet when it comes to the acting of it then it ceaseth so the act is wrought with the whole will First though this were so yet this doth not prove but that the Action is mixt and not absolutely and wholly voluntary Mixt Actions are so esteemed from the antecedent deliberation and dissent though the will be at length prevailed upon thereunto and I have shewed before that in the very action there is a vertuall dissent because of the opposite principle that is in the will But Secondly How doth it appeare that the Spirit doth not lust against the flesh though not to a prevalency even in the exertion of the acts of sinne In every good act that a man doth because evil is present with him though the prevalency be of the part of the Spirit and the principle of Grace yet the flesh also with its lustings doth alwayes in part corrupt it Thence are all the spots staines and imperfections of the holy things and dutyes of the Saints and if the flesh in its lusting will immix it selfe with our good Actions to their defilement and impairing why may not the Spirit in the ill not immix its selfe and its lustings threwith but beare off from the full influence of the will into them which otherwise it would have But saith he If the spirit doth not cease lusting before the flesh bring forth the act of sinne then is the Spirit conquered by the flesh contrary to that of the Apostle 1 John 4. 4. % Stronger is he that is in you than he that is in the world But First If from hence the flesh must be though conceived to be stronger than the Spirit because it prevailes in any act unto sin notwithstanding the contending of the Spirit how much more must it be judged to prevaile over it and to conquer it if it cause it utterly to cease and not to strive at all He that restraines an other that he shall not oppose him at all hath a greater power than he who conquers him in his resistance But why doth Mr Goodwin feare least the flesh should be asserted to be stronger in us than the Spirit Is not his whole designe to prove that it is or may be so so much stronger and more prevalent than it that whereas it is confessed on all hands that the Spirit doth never wholly conquer the flesh that it shall not remaine in the Saints in this life yet that the flesh doth wholly prevaile over the Spirit and conquer it to an utter expulsion of it out of the hearts of them in whom it is Secondly In the prevalency of the flesh it is not the Spirit himselfe that is conquered but only some motions actings of him in the heart Now though some particular actings and motions of his may not come out eventually unto successe yet if he generally beares Rule in the heart he is not to be said even as in us and acting in us not to be stronger than the flesh He is as in us on this account said to be stronger than he that is in the world because notwithstanding all the opposition that is against us he preserveth us in our state and condition of Acceptation with God and walking with him with an upright heart in good workes and dutyes for the most part though sometimes the flesh prevailes unto sinne from which yet he recovers us by Repentance Thirdly To speake a little to Mr Goodwin's sence By the Spirits insufficiency it is manifest from the Text urged and from what followes in the same place that he intends not a Spirituall vitall principle in the will having its residence there with its contrary principle the flesh perhaps he will grant no such thing but the Spirit of God himselfe How now doth this Spirit lust Not formally doubtlesse but by causing us so to do and how doth it do that in Mr Goodwin's judgement Meerely by perswading of us so to do so that to have the flesh prevaile against the Spirit is nothing in his sence but to have sinne prevaile and the motives of the flesh above the motives used by the Spirit which may be done and yet the Spirit continue unquestionably stronger than the flesh Fourthly The summe is If the Spirit and the flesh Lust and Grace may be lookt on as habituall qualityes and principles in the wills of the same persons so that though a man hath but one will yet by reason of these contrary qualityes He is to be esteemed as two diverse principles of operation it is evident that having contrary inclinations continually the will hath in its actings a Relation to both these principles so that no sinne is commited by such an one with his whole will and full consent That contrary qualityes in a Remisse degree may be in the same subject is knowne Lippis Tonsoribus These adverse
man the principle of grace that is in the wills of Believers with the Convictions of the judgements and consciences of unregenerate persons and their striving against sinne on that account The judgements and consciences of wicked men tell them what they ought to do and what they ought not to doe without respect to the principle in their wills that is predominant But the Apostle mentions the actings of the will it selfe from its owne regenerate principle We wholly deny that any unregenerate man hath any vitall principle in his will not consenting to sinne what ever the dictates of his judgement and conscience may be or how effectuall soever to prevaile unto an abstinence from sinne To discover the differences that are between the contest that is between the wills in unregenerate men wholly set upon sinne on the one hand and their judgements and Consciences enlightned to an apprehension and approving of better things on the other and the contest that is between the Flesh and Spirit lusting to contrary things in the same will as it is in regenerate men is a common place that I shall not goe forth unto We grant then that in unregenerate men there may be there is and was in some degree perhaps in Herod in Pilate a conviction of conscience and judgement that the things they doe are evill but say withall that all this being forraigne to their wills it hinders not but that they sinne with the full uncontrouled consent of their wills which are at perfect Liberty or rather in perfect bondage unto sinne That the Spirit should lust against the flesh and the flesh against the spirit both in the same will as it appears they doe Gal. 5. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. for the fruits that they both bring forth are acts of the will in any unregenerate man we deny and this is that and not the former which abates and takes off from the wills consent to sinne He concludes the whole § 25. And to the passage of the Apostle mentioned Rom. 7. I answer farther that when he saith the evill which I would not that doe I he doth not speake of what he alwaies and in all cases did much lesse of what was possible for him to doe but of what he did ordinarily and frequently or of what was very incident unto him through the infirmity of the flesh viz. through inconsideratenesse and anticipation by temptations to doe such things which when he was in a watchfull and considerate posture and from under the malignant influence of a temptation he was altogether averse unto now what a man doth ordinarily is one thing and what he doth sometimes and in some particular cases especially what it is possible for him to doe is another that true believers whilest such ordinarily sinne not upon worse termes then those mentioned by the Apostle concerning his sinning I easily grant but it no waies followeth from hence that therefore they never sinne upon other termes much lesse that it is impossible that they should sinne upon others and thus we see all things throughly and impartially argued and debated to and fro that even true Believers themselves as well as others may do those works of the flesh which exclude from the Kingdome of God and that inrespect thereof they are subject to this exclusion as well as other men The summe of this part of the Reply is that what Paul speaks is true of the ordinary course of Believers but not of extraordinary surprisals this seems I say to be the tendency of it though the direct sence of the whole is not so obvious to mee by that expression the evill that I would not that I doe you intend either the expression of he would not or that he did if the latter then you say he did not sinne ordinarily and frequently but only upon surprisalls which is freely granted but is not at all to your purpose but rather much against it If you attend that part of it which holds out his Renitency against the evill he did in the expression of I would not then you say it was not ordinary with the Apostle to nill the evill that he did but in case of surprisall to sinne which I believe is not intended for is it credible that any one should think that in the ordinary course of a mans walking there should be no opposition made to sinne the falling whereinto men are liable but upon surprizalls and anticipations by temptation as it is phrased there should Nor is it on the other side that he intends the things that he did ordinarily but was surprized by temptation then it might be otherwise But first is a Saint to be supposed to sinne ordinarily to sinne not prevailed on by temptation is not all sinne from temptation doe they sinne actually but upon the surprisall of temptation to impose this upon the Apostle that he should say truly for the most part or in my ordinary walking I doe not sinne but withall I will it not but when I am surprized with temptations then it is otherwise with mee there is no Renitency in my will to sinne is doubtlesse to wrong him He doth not limit his not willing of the evill he did to any consideration whatever but speakes it generally as the constant state and condition of things with him Secondly in the beginning of this Section the nilling of sinne was antecedent to the sinne here it is something that may be allowed in ordinary cases but not at all in extraordinary so that these two expositions put together amount to thus muh Ordinarily the Apostle antecedent to any sinning before the lusting of the spirit ceased did not will the thing that he did which was evill but in case of temptation it was not so that is antecedently to his acting of that which was evill he had no opposition in the inward man unto it nor lusting of the spirit against it which how it can be made good against him whose heart is upright and who hates every evill way I know not Thirdly it is confessed that ordinarily Believers sinne at no worse a rate than that expressed by the Apostle But what doth that containe If would not be referred to their doing of sinnes then you grant that which all this while you have endeavoured to oppose and are reconciled to your owne contradiction in the first evidence sinne cannot ordinarily or extraordinarily be committed but by an act of the will and yet ordinarily there is a dissent of the will also thereunto If you adhere to your other former interpretation that the willing against sin committed is antecedent to the commitment of it layd a sleepe before the perpetration of any sinne then this also is imposed on you that there are sinnes whereunto they may be surprised by temptations that antecedently to the commitment of them they do not not-will that as to them the Spirit lusteth not against the flesh which is notoriosly false for the flesh lusteth against the Spirit
and all the wayes of it and all the fruits thereof and the Spirit lusteth against the flesh with all its wayes and fruits Fourthly it appeares then that this being the description of a Regenerate man which the Apostle gives as to indwelling sinne and all the fruits thereof that it is most ridiculous to exempt his frame in respect of such sinnes as they may fall into by surprisalls of temptations from this description of him and so to frame this distinction to the Apostles generall Rule that it holds in cases ordinary but not in extraordinary when nothing in the whole Context gives the least allowance or continuance to such a limitation It appears then notwithstanding any thing offered here to the contrary upon due consideration of it that Believers sinne not with their whole wills and full consents at any time §. 26. nor under the power of what temptation soever they may fall for a season and that because of the Residence of this principle of a contrary tendency unto sinne in their wills which is allwayes acting either directly in inclining unto good or in taking off or making remisse the consent of the will to sinne not withstanding the prevalency of the principle opposite thereunto by its committing of sinne And hence have we sufficient Light for the weakning of the Argument proposed in the beginning of this Chap. §. 27. For though it is weak in its Foundation as shall be shewed concluding to what the Saints may do from what is forbiddē them to do that prohibition being the Ordinance of God certainly to preserve thē from it yet taking it for granted that they may fall into the sin intimated yet seeing they do it not customarily not maliciously not with the full and whole consent of their wills that there is a principle in them still opposing sin though at any time weakened by sinne and the conclusion of that Argument concernes them not I say then First to the Major proposition they who are in a capacity and possibility that is an universall possibility not only in respect of an internall principle but of all outward prohibiting causes as the purpose and Promise of God of perpetrating the workes of the flesh not of bringing forth any fruits of the lusting of the flesh which are in the best willingly and ordinarily with the full and whole consent of their wills in which sence alone such workes of the flesh are absolutely exclusive from the Kingdome of Heaven they may posibly fall out of the favour of God and into destruction This proposition being thus limited and the termes of it cleared for to cause it to passe I absolutely deny the minor that true Believers do or can so sinne that is so bring forth the workes of the flesh as to leave no roome for the continuance of Mercy to them according to the tenour of the Covenant of Grace But now frame the Proposition so as the Assumption may comprise Believers we shall quickly know what to judge of it Those who are in a capacity or possibility of falling into such sinnes as deserve rejection from God or of perpetrating workes of the flesh though they do so overborne by the power of temptation nilling the things they do not abiding in their sinnes may fall totally and finally from God but Believers may so do As the matter is thus stated the Assumption may be allowed to passe upon Believers but we absolutely deny the Major Proposition in the sence wherein it is urged I shall only adde that when we deny that Believers can possibly fall away it is not any absolute impossibility we intend nor an impossibility with respect to any principle in them only that in and from it selfe is not perishable nor an impossibility in respect of the manner of their acting but such an one as principally respecting the outward removing cause of such an actuall defection will infallibly prevent the event of it And thus is the cloud raised by this fifth Argument dispelled and scattered by the light of the very first consideration of the difference in sinning that is between Regenerate and unregenerate men so that it will be an easy thing to remove take a way what afterwards is insisted on for the reinforcement and confirmation of the severall Propositions of it The Major Proposition he confirmes from Gal. §. 28. 5. 21. Eph. 5. 5 6. 1 Cor. 6. 9 10. All affirming that neither whoremongers nor adulterers nor idolaters nor the like have any inheritance in the Kingdome of God or can be Saved That the intendment of the Apostle is concerning them who live in a course of such sinnes who sinne with their whole wills and from an evill roote with whose sappe they are wholly leavened tainted throughout not them who through the strength of temptation and the surprisalls of it not without the renitency in their wills unto all sin any sin the sinne wherewith they are overtaken may possibly fall into any such sinne as did David and Peter was before declared and in that sence we grant the Proposition For the proofe of the Minor Proposition which should be that Believers may perpetrate the Workes of the flesh in the sence intended in the places of Scripture before mentioned he insists on two things First the direction of those Scriptures unto Believers Secondly the Experience of the wayes of such persons that is of Believers The Apostle tells Believers that they who commit such and such things with such and such circumstances in their commitment cannot be saved therefore Believers may commit those sinnes in the manner intended What hath been said before of the use of threatnings and denunciations of judgements on impenitent sinners in respect of Believers will give a sufficient account if there be need of any for our deniall of this consequence and for the Second that the experience of such mens waies and walking evinceth it it is a plaine begging of the thing under debate and an assuming of that which was proposed to be proved a thing unjustly charged by him on his Adversaries as though they should confesse that Believers might sinne to the extent of the lines drawn out in the places of Scripture mentioned and yet not loose their faith when because they cannot loose their Faith they deny that they can sinne to that compasse of excesse and riot intimated I cannot see then §. 29. to what end and purpose the whole ensuing discourse from the beginning of this Argument to the end of the 21. Sect. is It is acknowledged that all those places doe concerne Believers The intendment of the Holy Ghost in them being to discover to them the nature of the sinne specified and the end of the committing of them in the way intended and that God purposes to proceed according to the importance of what is threatned to those sinnes so committed with all that doe them that so they may walk watchfully and carefully avoiding not only those things
having proceeded thus with M. Goodwin that a foundation may be the better laid for the removall of what he farther adds proceed to consider the progresse of sinne and to remarke from thence the difference that is betweene Regenerate and Vnregenerate men in their sinning The second thing proposed in the Apostles discourse of the Rise and progresse of sinne is the generall way that Lust proceedeth in for the bringing of it forth and that is Temptation every one is tempted of his own Lust This is the generall way that Lust proceeds in for the production of actuall sinne It tempts and he in whom it is is tempted There is a Temptation unto sin only and a Temptation unto sin by sin The first is no sinne in him that is so tempted our Saviour was so tempted he was tempted of the Divell Math. 4. 1. % He was in all points tempted like as we are without sin That his temptations were unto sin is apparent from the story of them but the Prince of this world coming had nothing in him John 14. 30. Found nothing in him to Answer and close with his Temptations and therefore though he was tempted yet was he without sin Now though this sort of temptations from Sathan are not Originally our sinnes but his yet there being tinder in our soules that kindles more or lesse in and upon every injection of his fiery darts there being something in us to meet many if not all of his Temptations they prove in some measure in the issue to be ours Indeed Sathan sometimes ventures upon us in things wherein he hath doubtlesse small hope of any concurrence and so seemes rather to aime at our disquiet than our sinnes as in those whom he perplexes with hard and blasphemous thoughts of God a thing so contradictory to the very principles not of Grace only but of that whereby we are men that it is utterly impossible there should be any assent of the soule thereunto to think of God as God is to think of him every thing that is Good Pure Great Excellent incomprehensible in all perfection Now at the same time to have any Apprehensions of a direct contradictory importance the mind of man is not capable Were it not for the unbeliefe causelesse feares and discontentments that in many do insue upon Temptations of this nature which are consequents and not effects of it Sathan might keepe this dart in his owne forge for any mischeife he is like to doe with it The Apostle speakes here of Temptations by sinne as well as unto sinne and these are mens sinnes as well as their Temptations they are Temptations as tending to farther evill they are sinnes as being irregular and devious from the rule Now this tempting of Lust compriseth two things First §. 33. The generall active inclination of the Heart unto sinne though not fixed as unto any particular act or way of sinne the motus primò primi of this you have that Testimony of God concerning man in the state of nature Gen. 6. 5. % Every figment of the thought of his heart is only evill every day the figment or imagination of the thoughts is the very roote of them their generall moulding or active preparing of the mind for the exerting of them so 1 Chrou 28. 9. % God understandeth all the imaginations of the thoughts The figment of them The next disposition of the soule unto them and 2 Cron. 29. 19. Keepe this for ever in the imagination of the thoughts of their hearts or keep their hearts in a continuall framing posture and condition of such good thoughts This I say is she first way of Lusts Temptation it makes a mint of the heart to frame readily all manner of evill desires and thoughts that they may as our Saviour speakes proceed out of the heart Mat. 15. 19. Their actuall fixing on any object is their proceeding antecedent whereunto they are framed and formed in the heart Lust actually disposeth inclines bends the heart to things suitable to it selfe or the corrupt habituall principle which hath its residence in us Secondly The actuall tumultuating of Lust and working with all its power and policy in stirring up provoking to and drawing out thoughts and contrivances of sin with delight and complacency in inconeiveable variety the severall degrees of its progresse herein being afterwards described In the first of these there is no small difference between Regenerate Vnregenerate persons §. 34. and that in these two things First In its universality In Unregenerate men every figment of their heart is only evill and that every day there is an universality of actings exprest positively exclusively to any actings of another kind every figment of their heart is only evill and of time every day whatever good they seeme to do or do whatever dutyes they performe that in them all which is the proper figment of their heart is only evill On this account take any duty they do any worke they performe and weigh it in the ballance and t' will be found in respect of principles and circumstances or aimes to be wholly evill That indeed there is nothing in it that is acceptable to God their hearts are casting minting and coyning sinne all the day long With Believers 't is not so there is also a good treasure in their hearts from whence they bring out good things there is a good Root in them that beares good fruit though they are or may be overtaken with many sins yea with great sins yet lust doth not tempt thē as it doth unregenerate men with a perpetuall continuall active inclination unto evill even some way or other in all the good they do The Spirit is in them will and doth in what state so ever they are dispose their hearts to Faith Love Meekenesse and actuates those Graces at least in the elicite acts of the will for a good tree will bring forth good fruit never any Believer is or was so deserted of God or did so forsake God as that every figment of his heart should be evill only and that continually That no one act of sinne can possibly expell his habit of Grace hath been formerly shewed neither is he ever cast into such a condition but from the good principle that is in him There is a panting after God longing for his Salvation with more or lesse efficacy the sparke is warme and glowing though under ashes Secondly In respect of power Lust tempts in unregenerate men out an absolute uncontrouleable dominion and that with a morally irresistible efficacy All its dominion as hath been shewed and very much of its strength is lost in Believers this is the intendment of the Apostles discourse Rom. 6. concerning the crucifying of sinne by the death of Christ. The power strength vigour and efficacy of it is so far abated weakned mortified that it cannot so effectually impell unto sin as it doth when 't is in perfect life and strength But you 'l say then
's added to put some colour and glosse upon this Assertion viz. That such persons as are affirmed to be so separated from the Body of Christ do voluntarily disfaith as 't is called themselves is not to the purpose in hand For 1. The question is about the thing it selfe whereunto this Answer de modo is not satisfactory 'T is urged by the Argument that it cannot be allowed any way the answer is t is done this way 2. Were Mr Goodwin desired to explaine unto us the manner how Believers voluntarily do or may disfaith themselves I suppose he would meet with no small difficultyes in the undertaking However this sounds handsomely 3. That they should so disfaith themselves through sinne and wickednesse without being overcome by the temptations of Sathan and the power of the enemyes with whom they have to do and wrestle doubtlesse will not be affirmed whilst they continue in their right witts and if they loose them t will be difficult to manifest how they can voluntarily disfaith themselves The state wherein they are described to be by Mr Goodwin and the considerations which for their preservation he allowes them should not me thinkes suffer him to suppose that of their owne accord without provocations or temptations they will wilfully ruine their owne soules Now that Believers should by the power of any Temptation or opposition whatever or what affliction soever arrising against them be prevailed upon to the losse of their Faith and so to their dismembring from Christ is that which is objected as an unseemely uncouth thing which in this Answer Mr Goodwin earnestly begges may not be so esteemed and more he adds not as yet The following Discourse § 42. wherein he pursues the businesse in hand is so pretty as that I cannot but once more present it to the Reader Saith he As to a politicke or civill corporation 't is better that the Governers should permit the members respectively to go or be at liberty that so they may follow their businesse and occupations in the world upon the better termes though by occasion of this liberty they may behave themselves in sundry kinds very unworthily than it would be to keepe them close prisoners though hereby the said inconveniences certainly be prevented in like manner 't is much better for the Body of Christ and for the respective members of it that he should leave them at liberty to obey and serve God and follow the important affairs of their soules freely and without any Physicall necessitation though some do turne this liberty into wantonnesse and so into destruction than I would be to deprive them of this liberty and to cause and constraine them to any course whatsoever out of necessity though 't is true the committing of much sinne and iniquity would be prevented hereby in many the dismembring of the body of Christs Apostles by the Apostacy of Judas was no disparagement either to Christ himselfe or it Ans. The summe of the whole discourse is that the Lord Jesus Christ hath no way to keepe and secure his members to himselfe that none of them perish but by taking away their liberty which rather than do 't is more to his honour to let them abuse it to their everlasting destruction to this end sundry sine supposalls are scattered through the whole Discourse As 1. That the liberty of Believers is a liberty to sinne which they may abuse to their owne destruction The Apostle is of an other mind Rom. 6. 17 18 19. God bethanked that ye were the servants of sinne but ye have obeyed from the heart that forme of Doctrine which was delivered to you being then made free from sinne ye became the servants of Righteousnesse c. 2. That there is no reall efficacy of Grace that will certainely fulfill in Believers the good pleasure of Gods Goodnesse and bring forth the fruits of an abiding Holinesse but what must needs deprive them in whom it is of their liberty and suitably hereunto 3. That God having through Christ made his Saints Spiritually free frō sin unto Righteousness so that with the utmost liberty that they are capable of as Creatures they shall surely do good cannot by his Spirit continue them in that condition infallibly without the destruction of their liberty 4. That the Spirituall operation of God in with the wills of men induceth a necessitation as to their manner of operation that they must act on that account as necessary not as free Agents with such other the like supposals which are so many grosse figments whereof M. G. shall be able to prove no one to Eternity For the removeall then of all the fine words here tendered out of our way it may suffice to tell their Author that he who is made Redemption to his Saints that sets them free from their bondage to sinne by his Spirit which is allwayes accompanied with Liberty and makes them willing ready and free to Righteousnesse and Holinesse in the day of his power towards them whose effectuall Grace enlargeth and improves all their facultyes in their operations with the choicest attendences as to the manner their of working can and doth by in and with the perfect exercise of their liberty keepe them to himselfe in their union and communion with him for ever That this pretended liberty unto sinne is a bondage from which Christ frees his Saints neither is any thing that can be imagined more derogatory to the glory of his Grace than to affirme that he cannot keepe those committed to him infallibly to the end without depriving them of the liberty which they have alone through him Of Physicall necessitation enough hath been spoken before Judas was never a member of the Body of Christ or of Christ in the acceptation whereof we speake By the body of the Apostles is intended only their number of which Judas though he was never of that body whereof they were members was one Farther the wickednesse of this Apprehension §. 43. that Christ should loose any of those who are true and living members of his Mysticall body is aggravated upon the accovnt of that state and condition whereinto he parts with them They being thereby made members of Sathan and his Kingdome God and the Divell so interchanging Children to the great dishonour and reproach of his name to his M. Goodwin replyes in the 28. Section For the interchange of members between Christ and Sathan the Scripture presenteth it as a thing possible yea as frequent and ordinary know ye not saith the Apostle that your Bodyes are the members of Christ Shall I then take the members of Christ and make them the members of an harlot in the originall it is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 c. i. e. taking away the members of Christ shall I make them c. meaning that true Believers who only are the members of Christ disrelate themselves to him cease to be members of his body whilst they live in a course of
be regenerate is to have a new and another generation not any one repeated In the place mentioned of John by M. Goodwin there is mention neither of a repetition of a former generation nor directly of a new one Though it be so it is not there called so our Saviour at first saies 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 unlesse a man be borne from above as the word is elsewhere rendred and properly signifies as Iohn 3. 31. % Iohn 19. 11. % Mark 15. 38. % Iames 3. 17. and sometimes of old or former daies as Acts 26. 5. once only it signifies againe Gal 4. 9. but there joyned with 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 which restraines it And in the exposition afterwards of what he intended by that Expression he calls it simply a being borne of the water the spirit v. 5. without the least intimation of the repetition of any birth but only the asserting of a new spirituall one called a birth indeed with allusion to the birth Naturall which is the road opinion well beaten ever since Christ first trod that path Besides the very same thing which is exprest under the name of Regeneration being a spirituall birth which a man had not before is also delivered unto us in such words and termes as manifest no reiteration of any state condition or thing to be included therein as Conversion to God a Quickning from death Sanctification by the spirit c. all which manifest the induction of a new Life and forme and not the Repetition of another hence the ancients called Baptisme Regeneration being the initiall ordinance of Christianity and expressive of the new life which in and through Christ we receive and that from Tit. 3. 5. Regeneration then neither in the import of the word nor in the nature of the thing doth require a reiteration of any generation but only the addition of a new one to that which a man hath before and whereunto this doth allude The receiving of a new spirituall Birth and Life is our Regeneration Renovation Resurrection Quickning implanting into Christ and the like so that the foundation of all the ensuing discourse is a meere quagmire where no firme footing can be obtained and of the same Nature is that which ensues It is saith he the common sence of Divines that the two generations mentioned the Naturall and spirituall are membra dividentia and contra-distinguished the one unto the other and so the Apostle Peter too seemes to state and represent them as also our Saviour himselfe Ioh 3. 6. % Now there can hardly any instance be given where the introducing of one contrary forme or quality into the Subject is termed a reiteration or repetition of the other Calefaction for example is never termed a repetition of Frigefaction nor Calefaction called a reiteration of Frigefaction nor when a Regenerate or mortifyed man dyeth his naturall death is he said to reiterate or repeat his Spirituall death Ans That in the terme Regeneration two births are implyed may be granted that the same is intimated to be repeated is denyed and not proved at all And therefore Mr Goodwin sayes well that the introducing of a contrary forme is not called the reiteration of an other no more is it here our new birth is called our Regeneration or new generation in allusion to our naturall birth not as a repetition of it neither is the Allusion in respect of the contrary qualityes wherewith the one and the other are attended but in respect of the things themselves in which regard as they are not the same so they are not contrary but diverse They are both births the one Naturall the other Spirituall Naturall and Spirituall in that sence are not contrary qualityes but diverse adjuncts and so are the two births compared 1 Pet. 1. 23. Iohn 1. 13. In which last place our Regeneration is exprest under the simple terme of being borne with distinction to the naturall birth and not the least intimation of the iteration of any birth or Generation subjoyned so also is it Iames 1. 18. so that hitherto little progresse is made by Mr Goodwin towards his intendment whatever it be thus then he expresseth it I rather saith he conceive that Regeneration which the Scripture makes appropriable only unto persons living to yeares of discretion §. 48. who generally in the dayes of their youth degenerate from the innocency of their childhood younger yeares and corrupt themselves with the principles wayes of the world relates not to the Naturall generation as such I meane as naturall but unto the Spirituall estate and condition of men in respect of their Naturall generation and birth in and upon which they are if not simply absolutely yet comparatively innocent harmeles free from pride and malice and inrespect of these qualifications in Grace and favour with God upon the account of the death and sufferings of Christ for them as we shall afterwards prove Here you have the summe of the designe and the Doctrine of Regeneration cleared from all those vaine and erroneous opinions wherewith it hath so long been clouded It is the returning of men into the good state and condition wherein they are borne after they have degenerated into waies of wickednesse we thought it had been the quickening of them who are by nature dead in trespasses and sinnes their being begotten againe by the will of God the bestowing of a new principle of Spirit and Life upon them a Translation from Death to Life the opening of blind eyes making them who were darknesse to be light in the Lord. It seemes we have all this while been in the darke and that Regeneration indeed is only a returning to that condition from whence we thought it had been a delivery but let us a little see the Demonstration of this new notion of Regeneration First he saith the Scripture makes it appropriable only to them who come to yeares of discretion Sir your proofe we cannot take your bare word in a thing of this importance In the place your selfe chose to mention as the foundation you laid of the inferences you are now making our Saviour saies t is a being borne of the spirit doth the Scripture make this appropriable only unto men of discretion Men only of discretion then can enter into the Kingdome of God for none not so borne of the Spirit shall enter therein Ioh. 3. 5. If none but men of discretion can be borne of the Spirit then infants have no other birth but only that of the flesh and that which is borne of the flesh is flesh v. 6. Not capable of entring into the Kingdome of heaven surely you better deserve the title of durus pater infantum than He to whom of old 't was given perhaps a grosser figment was never framed by a man of Discretion Secondly It is true Infants are comparatively innocent in respect of Actuall Transgressions but equally nocent and guilty with Sinners of discretion in respect of naturall state and
condition They are no lesse obnoxious to that death from whence our Regeneration is a delivery by the bestowing of a new Spirituall life than a sinner of an hundred yeares old A returning to this condition it seemes is Regeneration Quantum est in rebus inane Thirdly The qualifications of Infants not Regenerated are meerely negative and that in respect of the acts of sinne not the habituall seed and root of them for in them dwells no good that in respect of these qualifications of Innocency that are in them by nature Antecedent to any Regeneration all which are resolved into a Naturall impotency of perpetrating sinne they are accepted in Grace and favour with God had been another new notion had not Pelagius and Socinus before you fallen upon it without Faith it is impossible to please God Heb. 11. 6. And his wrath abides on them that Believe not Iohn 3. 36. That Infants have or may have Faith and not be regenerated will scarcely be granted by them who believe the Spirit of Christ to cause Regeneration where he is bestowed Tit. 3. 5. And all Faith to be the Fruit of that Spirit Gal 5. 26 27. Farther for the qualifications of Infants by Nature how are they brought cleane from that which is uncleane Are they not conceived in sinne and brought forth in iniquity Or was that Davids hard case alone If they are borne of the flesh and are flesh if they are uncleane how come they to be in that estate upon the account of their Qualifications accepted in the Love and favour of him who is of purer eyes than to behold iniquity If this be the Doctrine of Regeneration that M. G. preaches I desire the Lord to blesse them that belong unto him in a deliverance from attending thereunto Of the Effects of the death of Christ in respect of all children I shall not now treat That they should be saved by Christ not washed in his Bloud not sanctifyed by his Spirit which to be is to be Regenerate is another new notion of the new Gospell The Countenance which Mr Goodwin would begge to his Doctrine from that of our Saviour to his Disciples Except ye be turned and become as little Children ye cannot enter into the Kingdome of God reproving their ambition and worldly thoughts from which they were to be weaned that they might befit for that Gospell state imployment whereunto he called them wherein they were to serve him does no more advantage him nor the cause he hath undertaken than that other caution of our Saviour to the same persons to be wise asserpents innocent as Doves would do him that should undertake to prove that Christians ought to become pigeons or snakes Thus much then we have learned of the mind of M. G. by this digression 1. That no children are Regenerate 2. That they are all accepted with God through Christ upon the account of the good Qualifications that are in them 3. That Regeneration is a mans returing to the state wherein he is borne And having taken out this Lesson which we shall never learne by heart whilst we live we may now proceed I shall only adde to the maine of the businesse in hand §. 49. that so long as a man is a child of God he cannot he need not to repeat his Regeneration But that one who hath been the child of God should cease to be the child of God is somewhat strange How can that be done amongst men that he should cease to be such a mans sonne who was his sonne Those things that stand in Relation upon any thing that is past and therefore irrevocable cannot have their beings continued and their Relation dissolved it is impossible but that cause and effect must be related one to another such is the relation between Father and Sonne The foundation of it is an act past and irrevocable and therefore the Relation it selfe is indissoluble Is it not so with God and his Children when they once stand in that Relation it cannot be dissolved But of these things hitherto To proceed with that place of Scripture which I laid as the foundation of this discourse §. 50. The generall way of Lusts dealing with the soule the bringing forth of sinne whereof there are two acts expressed v. 14. the one of drawing away the other inticing is to be insisted on Upon the first the person tempted is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 drawn off or drawne away and upon the second he is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 inticed or intangled The First stirring of sinne is to draw away the soule from what it ought to be fixed upon by its rising up irregularly to some delightfull object For a man to be drawne away by his lust is to have his Lust drawne out to some object suited to it wherein it delighteth Now this drawing away denoteth two things 1. The turning of the soule from the actuall rectitude of its frame towards God Though the soule cannot alwayes be in actuall Exercise of Grace towards God yet it ought alwayes to be in an immediate readinesse to any Spirituall duty upon the account whereof when occasion is administred it doth as naturally goe forth to God as a vessell full of water floweth forth when vent is given unto it Hence we are commanded to pray alwayes Our Saviour giveth a Parable to instruct his Disciples that they ought to pray 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Luke 18. 1. And we are commanded to pray 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 without ceasing or intermission 1 â—hess 5. 17. Which the same Apostle in an other place calleth praying 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 in every place namely as occasion is administred It is not the perpetuall exercise of this duty as the Iewes some of them have ridiculously interpreted the first Psalme of reading the Law day and night which would shut out and cut off all other dutyes not only of mens Callings and Employments as to this Life but all other dutyes of the wayes worship of God whatever But it is only the readinesse and promptitude of the heart in its constant frame to that necessary duty that is required Now he who is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 by lust is drawne off from this frame that is he is interrupted in it by his lust diverting unto some sinfull object And as to this particular there is a great difference betwixt the sinning of Believers and those who arise not beyond that height which the power of Conviction beareth them oftentimes up unto For 1. The maine of a true Believers watching in his whole life § 51. and in the course of his walking with God is directed against this off-drawing from that habituall frame of his heart by lust and sinne His great businesse is as the Apostle telleth us to take the whole armour of God to him that sinne if it be possible may make no approach to his soule Eph. 6. 13. It is to keepe up their spirits to a hate of
ordinary course and walking of a regenerate man that Paul describeth in that place and not his extraordinary falls and failings under great and extraordinary temptations This is evident from the whole manner of his discourse and scope of the place Now ordinarily through the grace of God the Saints doe not doe outwardly and Practically the things they would not that is commit sinne actually as to the outward act but they are ordinarily only swayed to this intanglement by the baits of sinne Secondly It is the sole worke of Indwelling sinne that the Apostle there describeth as it is in its selfe and not as it is advantaged by other Temptations in which it carrieth not Believers out to actuall sinnes as to such accomplishment of them which is their state in respect of great temptations only It is then I say the great burthen of their soules that they have been in their affections at any time dealing with the baits of sinne which causeth them to cry out for helpe and filleth them with a perpetuall selfe-abhorrency and condemnation 3. In such surprisalls of sinne although the Affections may be insnared and the judgement and Conscience by their tumultuating dethroned for a season yet the Will still maketh head against sinne in Believers and crieth out that whether it will or no it is captived and violently overborne calling for reliefe like a man surprized by an enemy There is an active renitency in the Will against the sinne whose bait is exposed to the Soule and wherewith it is inticed allured or intangled when of all the faculties of the Soule if any thing be to be done in any act of sinne in Unregenerate men the will is the ringleader Conscience may grumble and Judgement may plead but the Will runneth headlong to it And thus farre have I by way of digression proceeded in the difference there is betwixt Regenerate and Unregenerate men as to the root and foundation of sinne as also to their ordinary walking what is farther added by the Apostle in the two following degrees in the place mentioned because thence also may some light be obtained to the businesse in hand shall be briefely insisted on The next thing in the Progresse of sinne §. 55. is Lusts conceiving When it hath turned off the heart from its Communion with God or consideration of its duty and intangled or hampered the Affections in delight with the sinfull object proposed prevailing with the soule to dwell with some complacency upon the thoughts of sinne it then falleth to conceiving that is it warmes foments cherisheth thoughts and delights of the sinne entertained untill it so farre prevaile upon the will in them in whose wills there is an opposition unto it that being wearied out with the sollicitations of the flesh it giveth over its power as to its actuall predominant exercise and sensibly dissenteth not from the sinne whereunto it is tempted That this may sometimes befall a Regenerate Person I have granted before and what is the difference herein betwixt them and Unregenerate persons may be collected from what hath been already delivered Of the next step of sinne §. 56. which is its bringing forth or the actuall accomplishment of the sinne so conceived as above expressed there is the same Reason 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 it bringeth out of its wombe the Child of sinne which it had conceived it is the actuall perpetration of sinne formerly consented unto that is expressed under this Metaphor I have little to adde upon this head to what was formerly spoken For 1. As they are not the sinnes of daily infirmities that are here intended in the place of the Apostle under consideration but such as lye in an immediate tendency unto Death as to their eminent guilt as also being the fruit of the hearts conception of sinne by fomenting and warming thoughts of sinne with delight untill consent unto it be prevalent in the soule so falls of this nature in the Saints are extraordinary and alway attended with their losse of peace the weakeneng of their Faith wounding of their soules and obnoxiousnesse without Repentance unto death God indeed hath provided better things for them but for themselves they have done their endeavour to destroy their own soules 2. That God never suffereth his Saints to fall thus but it is for the accomplishment of some very glorious end of his in their afflictions trialls patience humiliation which he will bring about These ends of God are many and various I shall not enter into a particular discourse concerning them 3. That an impenitent continuance in and under the guilt of such a sinne is a sore signe of an heart that neither hath nor ever had any true faith In others there is a truth of that of Austin who affirmed that he dared say that it might be good for some to have fallen into some eminent particular sinne for their humiliation and caution all their daies 4. That this frequent conception of sinne and bringing of it forth in persons who have been heightned by conviction to a great regularity of walking and conversation is the means whereby they doe goe forth unto that which is mentioned in the last place which is finishing of sinne that is so to be brought under the power of it as to compleate the whole worke of sinne Now men bring it forth by the temptations and upon the surprisalls forementioned but they that come to finish it or doe the worke of it in them it will bring forth death This I take to be the intendment of that expression 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 sinne perfected The word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 is no where used in the New Testament 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 are there is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 which is not to doe any one act which the Law requireth but to walke studiously and constantly according to the rule thereof and so 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 as the Apostle useth it Philip 1. 6. where we translate it as here 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 To perfect the good worke is to walke in the way of Grace and the Gospell unto the end So to perfect sinne is to fulfill the worke of sinne and to walke in the way of sinne to be under the dominion and reigne of sinne so far as to be carried out in a course of sinning and this is that alone which we exempt Believers from which that they are exempted from unto all that hath formerly been spoken I shall adde the consideration of one place of Scripture being turned aside from my thoughts of handling this at large as the second part of the Doctrine of the Saints Perseverance the former being grown under my hands beyond expectation Now this place is the I Iohn 3. 9. Whatsoever is borne of God doth not commit sinne §. 57. for his seed remaineth in him and he cannot sinne because he is borne of God A place of Scripture that alway hath amazed the adversaries of
So that notwithstanding these Exceptions the Exposition of the words is cleare as before given in And yet this is all M. G. produceth as his ground and foundation whereon to stand in denying ths proposition he that is borne of God sinneth not that is falleth not under the power of raigning sinne sinneth not to death as the Children of the wicked one which I shall leave under that consideration wherewith it is educed from the scope of the Text and the paralell place of Chap. 5. 16 17. The truth is there is not much need to contend about this expression M. G. granting that the intendment of it is that such as are borne of God do not walke ordinarily customarily in any wayes of known sin Sect 28. Which as he saith is the import of that Phrase 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the contrary whereof might yet be easily evinced he maketh no trade or occupation of sinning that is he doth not sinne in an inconsistency of communion with God in the Covenant of his Grace Now in this sence he granteth this Proposition he that is borne of God sinneth not i. e. ordinarily or customarily that is so as not to be accepted of God that is no Believer sinneth at such a rate as not to be accepted with God Adde now hereunto the ground reason of this Assertion viz. His being borne of God the abiding of the seed in him we have obtained all that we desire to evince from this place Because such an one is borne of God which is a Reason which holdeth good to Eternity being an act irrevocably past and because the seed abideth in him he cannot sinne ordinarlly or customarily which kind of sinning alone as is supposed can eject the abiding seed that is he sinneth not beyond the rate of sinnes of infirmity nor in any such way as should render him uncapable of communion or acceptance with God The Apostle nextly advanceth farther with his designe and saith He that is borne of God cannot sinne that is That sinne which he sinneth not he cannot sinne §. 64. He cannot fall under the power of raigning sinne unto death I confesse the words can cannot are variously used in the Scriptures some kind of impossibility in one respect or other for things may be in some regard impossible that are not so absolutely it alway denoteth The whole of the variety in this kind may be referred to two heads 1. That which is morally impossible Of that it is said that it cannot be done 2 Cor. 13. 8. Saith Paul we can do nothing against the Truth And Acts 4. 20. Say the Apostles we cannot but speake the things we have seen and heard It was morally impossible that ever any thing should have been done by Paul against the truth or that the Apostles having received the Spirit should not speak what they had seen and heard of Christ. And of many things that are thus morally impossible there are most certaine and determinate causes as to make the thing so impossible as in respect of the event to be absolutely impossible It is morally impossible that the Divell should do that which is Spiritually good and yet absolutely impossible There is more in many a thing that is morally impossible than a meere opposition to Justice as we say Illud possumus quod jure possumus The causes of morall impossibility may be such as to tye up the thing which it relateth unto in an everlasting nonfuâ—urition There is also 2. An impossibility that is Physicall from the nature of the things themselves So Jerem. 13. 23. % Can the Aethyopian change his skin that is He cannot Mat. 7. 18. % A good tree cannot bring forth evill fruit neither can an evill tree bring forth good fruit That is nothing can act contrary to its owne naturall principles And as we shall see afterwards there is of this impossibility in the cannot here mentioned They cannot do it upon the account of the new Spirituall nature wherewith they are indued Now there may be a third kind of impossibility in Spirituall things arising from both these which One hath not ineptly called Ethico-physicall or morally-naturall partaking of the nature of both the other It is morall because it relateth to duty what is to be done or not to be done And it is Physicall because it relateth to a cause or principle that can or cannot produce the effect So our Saviour telleth the Pharisees How can ye being evill speake good things Or ye cannot Mat. 12. 34. % You cannot heare my words John 8. 43. It was morally impossible they should either speake or heare that is either believe or do that which is Spiritually good having no principles that should enable them thereunto having no root that should beare up unto fruit being evill trees in themselves and having a principle a root continually universally uninterruptedly inclining and disposing them an other way to acts of a quite contrary nature Of this kind is that impossibility here intimated The effect denyed is morally impossible upon the account of the internall Physicall cause hindring of it However then the word in the Scripture may be variously taken yet here it is from adjacent circumstances evidently restrained to such a signification as in respect of the event absolutely rejecteth the thing denyed The gradation of the Apostle also leadeth us to it He sinneth not nay he cannot sin He cannot sin riseth in the Assertion of that before expressed He sinneth not which absolutely rejecteth the glosse that some seeke to put upon the words namely that cannot sinne is no more but cannot sinne easily and cannot sinne but as it were with difficulty such is the Antipathy habituall opposition which they have to sinne which Mr Goodwin adhereth unto For besides That this is in it selfe false there being no such Antipathie in any to sinne but that they may easily fall into it yea and with great difficulty and labour do restraine from it as the Apostle argueth at large Rom. 7 So is it also flatly contradictory to the words themselves the Apostle saith He that is borne of God sinneth not cannot sinne He can sinne saith this Glosse though difficultly now he that can sinne difficultly can sinne can sinne and cannot sinne are flatly contradictory He cannot then sinne at all the sinne that is intended in the place of whom it is said he cannot sinne Thus we have cleared the first Proposition in the words both as to the Subject every one that is borne of God and the Predicate sinneth not cannot sinne Which last expression taken in its only proper and most usuall signification denoteth an Impossibility of the event plainely confirmeth in direct termes the position we insist on from the words Mr Goodwin knoweth not well §. 65. If I am able to gather any thing of his thoughts from his expressions to the Argument in hand what to say to this Assertion of the Apostles The Argument he intendeth
as a reason of the former for though the future continuance of the thing in being can be no reason of the effect present yet it will be a ground or reason of the continuance of a present effect Ans I have thus at large transcribed this discourse because it is the sum of what Mr Goodwin hath to offer for the weakning of our Argument from this place of what weight this is will quickly appeare For 1. This Reason the seed abideth in him though brought in illatively in respect of what was said before he doth not commit sinne yet hath its causall influence chiefly into that which followeth he cannot sinne To make good what was first spoken of his not committing sinne that is borne of God the Apostle discovereth the cause of it which so farre secureth the truth of that expression as that it causeth it to ascend and call them up higher to a certaine impossibility of doing of that which was only at first simply denyed Neither is this Assertion the seed of God abideth in him any otherwise a Reason of the first Assertion He committeth not sinne than as it is the cause of the latter He cannot sinne Now Mr Goodwin granteth in the close of his Discourse that the future continuance of a thing in being is or may be the cause of the continuance of an effect which at present it produceth and what Mr Goodwin may more curiously discover of the intent of the Apostle his words plainly assert the continuance and abode of the seed of God in them in whom it is and using it as he doth for a reason of the latter claâ—se of that Proposition He cannot sinne he speaketh properly enough so great a Master of one language at least as Mr Goodwin being judge 2. The Reason insisted on by the Apostle is neither from the word seed nor from the word abideth nor from the nature of the seed simply consideâ—ed nor from its permanency and continuance the seed abideth So that it is no exception to the intendment of the Apostle to assert the abiding of the seed not to be a sufficient cause of the Proposition because its abiding or permanencie is not a cause of present not sinning for it is not asserted that it is His present not sinning in whom it is is from God his being borne of God by the seeds his continuance and estate of not sinning both which are intended is from the abiding of the seed The whole condition of The Person that He sinneth not neither can sinne which teâ—mes regard his continued estate is from the whole Proposition The seed of God abideth in him Separate the permanency of the seed which is asserted in the consideration of it and it respects only and solely the continuance of the effect which is produced by it as seed or of the estate wherein any one is placed by being borne of God All that Mr Goodwin hath to offer in this case is that the abiding of the seed is so asserted to be the Reason of that part of the Proposition He commits not sinne as not to be the cause 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 he cannot sinne When the abiding of the seed singly considered is not used as any reason at all of the first nor in the proposition as it lyeth the seed abideth any otherwise but as it is the cause of the latter he cannot sinne 3. Even the expression he committeth not sinne denoteth not only the present actuall frame and walking of him of whom it is spoken but his estate and condition being once borne of God he committeth not sinne no one that is so borne of God doth none in the state condition of a Regenerate Person doth so that is in his course and walking to the end and this is argued not so much distinctly to the permanencie of the seed as from the seed with such an Adjunct 4. Mr Goodwin's Allusions to the soule and the Obedience of Angels are of little use or none at all to the illustration of the businesse in hand For though the Reason why the soule moveth the body to day is not because it will move it to morrow yet the reason why the body moveth and cannot but do so is because it hath the Soule abiding in it and he that shall say he that liveth moveth for he hath a soule abiding in him and cannot but move shall speake properly enough And the reason why the Angells do the will of God in Heaven that is actually continue in so doing is because they have such a confirmed uncontroulable principle of Obedience So that all these Exceptions amount not to the least weakning of the Apostles Arguments Sect. 32. §. 71. Our Authour giveth two instances to prove that the word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 in the Scripture signifieth sometime only to be not to abide and they are the one John 14. And the other 1 John 3. 14. And one Argument to manifest that in the place under Consideration it must needs signify a present abode and being and not a continuance c. Ans. 1. If any such places befound yet it is confessed that it is an unusuall sence of the word and a thousand places of that kind will not inforce it to be so taken in another place unlesse the circumstances of it and matter whereabout it treateth enforce that sence and will not beare that which is proper 2. M. G. doth not make it good by the instances he produceth that the word is tyed up in any place to denote precisely only the being of a thing without relation to its abiding and continuance Of the one John 14. 17. % But ye know him because he remaineth with you shall be in you saith he the latter clause shall be in you will be found a meere Tautologie if the other phrase abideth with you importetha perpetuall residence or inbeing But that this phrase abideth with you importeth the same with the phrase in the foregoing verse where it is clearely expounded by the addition of the terme forever that he may abide with you forever I suppose cannot be questioned Nor 2. Is there any the least appearance of a Tautology in the words His remaining with Believers being the thing promised and his inbeing the manner of his abode with them Also the 1 John 14. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 doth not simply denote an Estate or Condition but an estate or condition in its nature without the interposition of Almighty Grace abiding and permanent so that neither have we yet any instance of restraining the significancy of the word as pretended produced nor if any place could be so would it in the least inforce that Acceptation of the word in this place contended about Wherefore M. Goodwin as I said addeth an Argument to evince that the word must necessarily be taken in the sence by him insisted on in this place which is indeed a course to the purpose if his Argument prove so in any measure It
profession and done some good yet upon the whole matter first or last they had all declined and therefore ought to owne the punishment of their sinnes God dealing severely and unto death and destruction with none but those who either wholly or upon the summe of the matter turned away from his Judgements and Statutes So that 6. This being the tenour and importance of the words insisted on this their tendency aime and accommodation to the objection levyed against the Righteousnesse of God in dealing with that people this their rise and end their spring and fall it is evident beyond all Contradiction from any thing but prejudice it selfe that all the enquiries and disputes about them as whether the declaration of the minde of God in them be Hypotheticall or Absolute what is meant by the Righteous Person what by his turning away and what by the death threatned all which expressions of the Text are in themselves ambiguous and must be limited from the circumstances of place are altogether uselesse and needlesse the words utterly refusing any accommodation to the businesse of our present debate So that 7. This dependance of the words scope of the Context designe of the place and intendment of God in it the accommodation of the whole discourse to the removeall of the Objection and disproving of the proverbiall selfe Justification of a sinfull People the only directoryes in the investigation of the true proper native genuine sence and meaning of them eyed weighed nor considered by Mr Goodwin who knew how much it was to his advantage to rend away these two verses from the body of the Prophets discourse I might well supersede any farther proceeding in the Examination of what he has prepared for a Reply to the Answers commonly given to the Argument taken from this place yet that all security imaginable may be given to the Reader of the inoffensivenesse of this place as to the Truth we mainetaine I shall briefely manifest that Mr Goodwin hath not indeed effectually taken up and off any one Answer or any one parcell of any such that hath usually been given by our Divines unto the Objection against the Doctrine of Perseverance hence levied That which naturally first offers it selfe to our Consideration §. 11. is the forme and tenour of the Expression here used which is not of an absolute nature but Hypotheticall The import of the words is If a righteous man turne from his Righteousnesse and continue therein he shall dy True say they who make use of this Consideration God here proposes the desert of sinne and the connexion that is by his appointment between Apostacy and the punishment thereunto allotted but this not at all inferres that any one who is truly righteous shall or may everlastingly so Apostatize Such comminations as these God maketh use of to caution Believers of the evill of Apostasy and thereby to preserve them from it as their tendency to that end by the appointment of God and their efficacy thereunto hath been declared So that to say because God sayes If a righteous man turne from his Righteousnesse he shall dye the whole Emphasis lying in the connexion that is between such turning away dying to conclude considering what is the proper use intendment of such threatnings that a man truly Righteous may so fall away is to build up that which the Texts contributes not any thing to in the least Against this plea Mr Goodwin riseth up with much contempt and indignation §. 12. Chap. 12. Sect. 9. in these words But this Sanctuary hath also been profaned by some of the chiefe Guardians themselves of that cause for the protection and safety whereof it was built There needs no more be done though much more might be done yea and hath been done by others than that Learned Doctor so lately named hath done himselfe for the demolishing of it Having propounded the Argument from the place in Ezekiel according to the import of the interpretation asserted by us Some saith he answer that a condition proues nothing in being which how true soever it may be in respect of such Hypotheticalls which are made use of only for the amplyfication of matters serve for the aggravating either of the difficulty or indignity of a thing as if I should climbe up into Heaven thou art there Psal. 139. It were ridiculous to inferre therefore a man may climbe up into Heaven yet such conditionoll sayings upon which Admonitions Promises or Threatnings are built do at least suppose something in possibility however by vertue of their tenour forme they suppose nothing in being For no man seriously intending to encourage a student in his way would speak thus to him If thou wilt get all the Books in the Vniversity Library by heart thou shalt be Doctor this Commencement Beside in the case in hand he that had a minde to deride the Prophet might readily come upon him thus But a righteous man according to the Judgement of those that are Orthodox cannot turne away from his righteousnesse therefore your Threatning is in vaine Thus we see to how little purpose it is to seeke for starting holes in such Logicke quirkes as these Thus farre the great Assertor of the Synod of Dort and the cause which they maintained to shew the vanity of such a sence or construction put upon the words now in debate which shall render them meerely conditionall and will not allow them to import so much as a possibility of any thing contained or expressed in them Ans. Doctor Prideaux his choosing not to lay the weight of this Answer to the Argument of the Arminians from this place on the Hypotheticall manner of the expression used therein is called a defiling this Sanctuary by the Guardians of the cause whose protection it undertakes Criminarasis librat in Antithesis doct as posuisse figuras laudatur what are my thoughts of it I need not expresse being unconcerned in the businesse as knowing it not at all needfull to be insisted on for the purpose for which it is produced the Text looking not at all towards the Doctrines under consideration yet I must needs say I am not satisfied with the Doctors attempt for the removall of it nor with what is farther added by the Remonstrants in the place which we are sent unto by M. Goodwins marginall directions though it should be granted that such conditionall expressions do suppose or may for that they alwaies do is not affirmed and in some cases it is evident they doe not that there is something in posse as the Doctor speakes whereunto they doe relate yet they doe not inferre that the possibility may by no meanes be hindred from ever being reduced into Act. We grant a possibility of desertion in Believers in respect of their own principles of operation which is ground sufficient for to give occasion to such Hypotheticall expressions as containe comminations and threatnings in them but yet notwithstanding that possibility on that account