the words are that he may fall into sinne not that he doth cast himselfe into sinne in a voluntary presumptuous and wilfull manner so that this word fall into sinne implies that these sinnes here mentioned are sinnes of infirmity and incogitancie not of malice and presumption now I hope you will grant that sinnes of infirmitie and incogitancie without any precogitated and resolued malice doe not cast a man totally from the state of â—…ce for then euery Saint of God should fall from the state of grace continually but only sinnes of malice and presumption committed with an high hand and with an absolute full and deliberate consent Wherefore the sinne mentioned in the Article being but a sinne of infirmitie only and not of praecogitated and resolued malice it cannot be imagined that this falling into sinne in the Article should bee a totall or a finall fall from grace Thirdly obserue the order of the words they doe first depart from grace giuen and then fall into sinne they doe not fall into sinne first and then depart from grace giuen if then they depart from grace before they fall into sinne then this departure from grace cannot be intended of a falling from the state of grace because our Antagonists will confesse that the sinne committed is that which casts men downe from the state of grace and that men fall not from grace before but after sinne committed this departure therefore from grace giuen being before the sinne committed cannot be a totall departure from the habit and state but from the act of grace Fourthly the very coherence and connexion of the words will cleere the sense and meaning of them For and being a conjunction copulatiâ—…e â—…itting both sentences together it makes the sense of the Article After wee haue receiued the holy Ghost 〈◊〉 may depart from grace giuen and full into sinne to bee no more but this after wee haue receiued the holy Ghost wee may â—…all into sinne so that 〈◊〉 departure from grace giuen is nothing else but to fall into sinne which a man may doe and yet not fall from grace so that torture and rackâ—… these words which way you will they will not warrant this doctrine of a totall or a finall fall from grace Yâ—…a but you will object that these subsequent words By the grace of God wee 〈◊〉 rise againe and amend our liues doe necessarily imply thus much that the Saints of God may fall totally and finally from grace True Mr. Mountague if you if Bortius or the Rhemists bee the interpreters else there might be some doubt of it For you must know that the only reason wherefore these words were added to the former was but to meete with the Montanists Nâ—…uations Anabaptists and Brownists who denied forgiuenesse and reconciliation to such as sinned after Baptisme and if you had not beene purblinde when as you reade the Article you could not but haue seene it But God in his justice hath giuen you eyes according to your minde which alwaies looke besides and ouerthwart the truth but not vpon it But if you will haue the sense of these words it is only this that the Saints of God may rise againe from that sinne into which they were fallen and amend their liues not that they rise againe from the state of condemnation That from which the Saints of God must rise is only from that into which they were fallen for falling and rising they are Relatiues but the thing into which the Saints were fallen was but into some act of sinne as appeares by the words of the Article wee may depart from grace and fall into sinne it was not a fall from the state of grace into the state of damnation and therefore this is but a rising from some actuall sinne to amendment of life Secondly I say that these words make much against you For if those that fall doe rise againe this doth necessarily imply that they were not fallen quite away from the state of grace into the death of sinne that all their spirituall life was not extinguished and abolished by their fall for if they were dead in trespasses and sinnes they could not rise againe Hee that is quite dead in sinne and without the life of grace is not said to rise againe and amend his life for that implies a continuance of the former life but hee is said to reuiue againe and to haue a new life put into him and therefore if the Article had intended this departure from grace giuen and falling into sinne of a totall or finall fall from grace into the state of death and damnation the words should haue beene these Hee may reuiue againe or God may raise him vp to a new estate of grace againe and hee may haue a new life of grace infused into him which would crosse this rule in Logicke à priuatione ad habitum non datur regressus and not that he may rise againe and amend his life Take then either the title or the scope and substance or the very letter and words of the 16. Article yet neither of them will warrant this doctrine of a totall or a finall fall from grace All the argument which any man can raise from this Article in proofe of this conclusion is but from the bare words and letter abâ—…racted from the sense to wit Those who haue receiued the holy Ghost may depart from grace giuen and fall into sinne and by the grace of God may rise againt and amend their liues Therefore the true regenerate Saints of God may both finally and totally fall from grace therefore faith once â—…ad may be both totally and finally lost which how wâ—…ll it followes let all men judge But to giue M. Mountague and others full satisfaction in the sense and meaning of this Article I will compare it with some other Articles which are expresse in point that the true regenerate Saiâ—…ts of God â—…an neither finally nor totally fall from grace The 5. Article of Lambeth concluded and agreed vpon Nouemb. 20. 1595. by diuers reuerend and learned Bishops and Diuines of this our Church for the determining of some controuersies in the Vniuersitie of Cambridge is expressely contrarie to Mr. Mountagues collection from our 16 Article for the words of that Article are these True liuing iustifying faith and the sanctifying Spirit of God is not extinguished it fayles not it vanisheth not away in the Elect either finally or totally If the 16. Article had beene expresse to the contrary I suppose the reuerend and learned Composers of this Article would not haue varied from it But Mr. Mountague pleads to this that the Articles of Lambeth are forbidden by Authority but when and where and by what authority that he sets not downe Surely for my owne part I neuer yet could learne that these Articles were disallowed by any publike authoritie but only by Mr. Mountagues who like a Magisteriall Dictator and Cathedrall moderator ouer all divinitie and Diuines approues
cast them all into the depth of the sea ler. 31. 34 and Mich. 7 18. 19. and therefore these their sinnes cannot bee mortall and deadly vnto them If a man should commit treason for which hee deserues to dye if the King will either pardon it or take no notice of it it is not deadly vnto him that doth it though it bee deadly in it selfe God will pardoâ—… or else passe by the sinnes of all his Saints hee will not take aduantage of them and therefore though they are mortall and deadly in themselues they are not so to them Lastly wee haue the expresse testimonie of Saint Iohn 1 Iohn 3. 6. 9. and cap. 5. 16 17 18. that the Saints of God and such as are borne of God can neuer sinne vnto death and therefore their sinnes can neuer put them into the state of death and damnation no not for a time Neither will that of Ezech. 18. 20. the soule that sinneth it shall dye nor that of 1 Cor. 6. 9. 10. make any thing to the contrary all that these two places proue is but this that sinne is mortall in its owne nature that euery one shall beare his owne sins and that the vnrighteous and such as liue and dye in the sinnes there specified such as make a common trade of those sinnes being neuer washed sanctified and iustified from them shall not inherit the kingdome of God neither of them proue that the sinnes of the Saints are mortall vnto them or that they put them into the state of death and damnation Consider therefore the sinnes of the Saints as the sinnes of the Saints as they are inherent in and conioyned with the Saints and not as they are abstracted and deuided from them consider how God hath promised to forgiue them in his mercie and to remember them no more and then you shall discouer and discerne your Error and finde your selues to bee ouer-reached with a Fallacy and quirke of Logicke in seuering those things which should not be deuided To the second clause of the objection that the sins of the Saints are not forgiuen before their actuall and particular repentance for them and therefore after that they commit any grosse and knowne sinne till their actuall and particular repentance for it they are in the state of death and damnation and not in the state of grace I answer first that the argument it selfe is false and followes not which that you may the better and more perspicuously vnderstand You must know that when a regenerate man falls into any sinne his repentance in this case is not required as a meanes to put a new life and a new estate and seed os grace into him as it was vpon his first regeneration and conuersion vnto God but it is onely required as physicke is in a sicke man to heale him and to cure him and to preserue that life that estate and seed of grace was in him before which by reason of this his sinne are like the graces of the Church of Sardis Reu. 3. 2. ready to dye but yet not wholly dead and therefore euen before his actuall tepentance for his sin he is not wholly dead in trespasses and sinnes he is not in the state of death damnation but in the state of grace I will euidence and make this cleare by some few familiar and common similitudes Suppose a regenerate man should fail into any mortall and deadly sicknesse which might proue his death vnlesse hee tooke some antidote and physicke to expell it you will not presently say that this man is but a dead man or that hee is in the state of death because hee is fallen into this disease or because hee lieth sicke of it for a moneth or two without recouery for hee hath life within him still hee is still a liuing man and for ought you know hee may recouer and therefore you doe still account him call him and repute him a liuing man So if a regenerate man commit a felonie for which his life may be drawne into question you will not forthwith determine that heee is in the state of death and damnation because hee hath committed such a felonie for it may bee that no man will prosecute him for this felonie or if hee be prosecuted hee may bee either acquitted or pardoned and so escape that death which hee did deserue So if a wife commit adultery for which shee deserues to be deuorced from her husband and so cease to be his wife you will not presently say that this woman iâ—… deuorced or that she is no wife for her husband may forgiue her and she is still a wife till the deuorce be sued out So if a sonne doth highly offend his gratious and louing father for which hee doth justly deserue to be disinherited he doth not therefore cease to be a sonne neither is he forthwith disinherited but hee continues a sonne and an heire still hee only incurs his fathers anger for the present and perhaps he may receiue some stripes and correction at his hands but neuer ceaseth to be his sonne and heire till he incnrre his fathers hatâ—…ed his whole and finall displeasure till he be actually disinherited and utterly cast off Iust so is it in our present case Sinne in the regenerate Saints of God it is a deadly disease and sicknesse to the soule it is such a felonie as may justly draw their liues into question before the barre of Gods Tribunall it is such an adultery as might justly cause the Lord their husband to sue out a bill of diuorce against them and it is such an offence as might moue their gratious and louing Father to disinherit and to cast them off But yet they are not presently dead neither are they in the state of death because they are sicke of sinne for they may recouer and purge out this disease yea it is certaine that they alwaies doe and shall recouer for the Lord himselfe is their physition hee will recouer them and raise them vp and restore them to their health againe he will not suffer them to dye or perish in this sicknesse of their sinnes they haue his owne expresse word and promise for it Psal. 41. 2 3. Iohn 6. 51 58. cap. 10. 28. cap. 11. 25 26 Hosea 14. 4. Mal. 4. 2. and 1 Iohn 5. 11 12 13. and he will surely performe make good his word to the vttermost They are not presently in the state of death and condemnation when as they commit any treason or felonie against the Lord before their actuall repentance for it for God may passe by their sinnes and treasons and take no notice of them hee may in his mercy pardon them and not arraigne them for them Yea he will be sure for to doe it For hee is a God that passeth by the transgression of his heritage hee will forgiue their iniquities and remember their sinnes no more because hee delights in mercy and because it is his couenant so to doe Mich.
7. 18 19. and Ier. 31. 33 34. If hee doth take notice of those sinnes of theirs as to scourge them for them yet he neuer drawes them into question for their soules hee neuer brings them into the judgement of eternall condemnation as we may reade expresly Isay 45. 17 Iohn 3. 19. cap. 5. 24. and Rom. 8. 1 2. wherefore though the Saints commit treason against the Lord for which they deserue to be perpetually condemned yet this their treason neuer puts them into the state of death and damnation So when the Saints of God commit adultery against him and such sinnes as might cause him to deuorce them from him yet they are not presently deuorced because they doe not presently repent for God is a louing and kinde husband to them hee is not easily prouoked to put them away and to giue them a bill of deuorce vpon euery act of adultery which they doe commit as is euident by Ier. 3. 1. If a man put away his wife and shee goe from him and become another mans shall he returne vnto her againe but thou hast played the harlot with many louers yet returne againe to me saith the Lord. The adulteries of the Saints doe neuer breake that bond of matrimonie which is betweene God and them because God will not take aduantage of them hee hath married them vnto himselfe for euer in faithfulnesse in louing kindnesse in mercies therefore will he loue them and not cast them off therefore will hee not seuer or deuorce them from him Hee hath commanded vs not to seperate those whom hee hath ioyned together therefore hee himselfe will neuer seuer nor deuorce those from himselfe whom hee hath married and betrothed to himselfe for euer but hee will seperate their sinnes from them that so they may not seuere or diuorce them from himselfe and therefore when as they sinne against the Lord they are not presently in the state of death and damnation because they are still married to and not deuorced from the Lord. So when the sonnes of God offend their gratious and louing father by their sinnes they doe not therefore cease to bee his sonnes neither are they forthwith disinherited but they continue sonnes and heires still and he continues to bee a gratious father to them It may be they may incurre his anger and displeasure for a time it may bee hee doth chasten and correct them with the rods of men and with the stripes of the children of men out of his fatherly care and loue vnto them and out of a desire of their good that so they may not be condemned with the world But yet they neuer incur his hatred or his whole displeasure hee neuer disinherits them or casts them out of doores hee alwaies dealeth with them as a gratious mercifull and louing father who delights in mercy hee will not alwaies chide them neither keepeth hee his anger foreuer hee will not deale with them after their sinnes nor yet reward them according to their iniquities but will euen pitty spare and pardon them as a father pittieth spareth and pardoneth his onely son that serueth him And therefore though they sinne against their gratious Father and lie perhaps in this their sinne for a time without repentance yet they are not thereby disinherited nor put from the state of grace I will now contract all this into this Syllogisme Hee that is still aliue in Christ and is but only sicke and not dead of sinne hee that is onely in a meere possibilitie to be questioned arraigned diuorced disinherited for his sinne and is not actually questioned arraigned diuorced disinherited and condemned for it He that is more likely to liue to recouer more likely to escape vnsentenced and vncondemned more likely to continue a wife and an heire vnto God then to dye of sinne and to be perpetually condemned diuorced and disinherited of God for sinne Nay hee that is sure to recouer and neuer to die of sinne sure to scape scot-free and neuer to bee condemned diuorced or disinherited for sinne it is vndoubtedly true that such a one is not in the state of death and damnation but in the state of life and grace For no man can be in the state of death and damnation but such a one as is either dead in trespasses and sins such a one as is actually condemned diuorced and disinherited for his sins or such a one as is more likely to dy to be condemned diuorced and disinherited in and for his sins then to liue and to escape vncondemned vndiuorced and vndisinherited for his sins But all those who are once truly regenerated ingrafted into Christ by a true and liuely faith they are aliue in Christ and euen then when as they lie in any knowne sin without repentance they are but only sicke not dead of sin they are only in a mâ—…ere remote possibility to be questioned arraigned diuorced disinherited and condemned for their sinne they are not actually questioned arraigned diuorced disinherited and condemfor it They are more likely to liue and to recouer more likely to escape vnsentenced and vncondemned more likelyto continue wiues and heires vnto God then to dye of sin and to be perpetually condemned diuorced and disinherited of God for sin Nay they are sure to recouer and neuer for to dye of sin they are sure to escape scot-free and neuer to be condemned diuorced or disinherited for sinne as is euident by the former premises Therefore it is vndoubtedly true that such as are once truly regenerated and ingrafted into Christ by a true and liuely faith euen then when as they lye in any knowne sinne without repentance are not in the state of death and damnation but in the state of life and grace and so the argument which is produced followes not Secondly I answer that the Antecedent is false For these sinnes of the Saints they are and may be pardoned and actually forgiuen without any particular repentance for them First because when men are once truly justified the eternall guilt of these their sinnes is neuer imputed to them as I haue formerly proued therefore a particular actuall repentance for them is not necessarily and absolutely required for to saue them and â—…ree them from damnation Christ had made them free from the law of sinne and 〈◊〉 before being made a curse for them that they might bee made the righteousnesse of God in him therefore they might bee saued without this this actuall and particular repentance Secondly These their sins as I haue formerly proued did not put the Saints into the state of damnation and therefore a particular repentance for these sinnes of theirs is not absolutely necessary to saluation Thirdly a particular and actuall repentance for these sinnes is not required as absolutely necessary to saluation because a generall repentance and an inward disposition of the soule without this particular outward and actuall repentance will serue the turne If a
for that was not in danger to be lost for any former sinnes The holy spirit of God therefore continuing still in Dauid it is certaine that he did not fall totally from the state of Grace by these sinnes of his Fourthly if Dauid had fallen quite away from the state of grace he could not haue repented so soone as now he did For no sooner had Nathan told him thou art the man but presently Dauid he doth confesse his sinne to God I haue sinned saith he against the Lord and presently vpon this confession of his God returnes him this answer by Nathan the Lord also hath put away thy sinne thou shalt not die whence he records it of himselfe Psal. 32. 5. I acknowledge my sinne vnto the Lord and my iniquitie haue I not hid I said I will confesse my transgression to the Lord and thou gorgauest the iniquitie of my sinne Certainly if Dauid had beene dead in sinnes and trespasses if he had had no life of grace within him he had not beene so soone awaked and reuiued as now he was he could not haue penned such a passionate and true poenitentiall Psalme as this I will not stand to argue that Dauid was borne of the immortall seed of grace and therefore he could not sinne vnto death because the seed of grace remained in him and because he was borne of God or that he could not fall from grace because the Lord sustained and vpheld him with his hand the former reasons are sufficient for to doe it Now that Dauid did not fall totally from grace nor yet lose the Spirit of God by this his fall we haue the testimonies of Irenaeus lib. 4 adu Haereses cap 45. Of Origen hom 4. in Psal. 36. of Basil Scholia in Psa. 50. alias 51. Of Chrisostome Hom. 44. in 1 Cor. 16. Of Augustine de Doctr Christ lib. 3. cap. 21. and Comment in Psal. 50. alias 51. Of Anselme Com in Hebr. 6. Of Bernard de Natura dignitate amoris diuini cap. 6. Of Luther in Psal. 51. vers 11. 12. Of Caluin in Psa. 51. vers 11. 12. Of Bucer in Psal. 1. and in Rom. 8. Of Marlorat Exposit in Psal. 51. 11 12 13. and in 1 Iohn 39. Of Musculus in Psal. 51 Oâ—… Tyndall in his Treatise of the manner of Election Of Abbot Benefield Scharpius Prideaux Zanchius Beza Bastingius and all other moderne Protestant and Orthodox writers Tertullian Cyprian and the other ancient Fathers they onely make mention of Dauids sinne and repentance but speake not that he fell from grace and therefore there is no great question but that Dauid continued still in his estate of grace notwithstanding that he fell into these sinnes As for that which is objected by our Antagonists that Dauid prayes to God to create in him a cleane heart therefore his heart was wholly polluted before and he was fallen quite from grace I answer that this word create though in its proper acception it signifies to make a thing out of nothing yet here it signifies no more then to renew as the most and best expositers on this Psalme agree which is euident by the words which are coupled and conjoyned with it for saith the Psalmist create in mee a cleane heart O Lord and renew a right spirit within mee now if Dauid had not intended meerely a renouation but a new creation of his heart and graces he would haue vsed onely these words create in me a new heart omitting these subsequent words and renew a right spirit within mee for else there were a contradiction in them For creation is to make a thing out of nothing renouation is to repaire and renew a thing that was in being before and therefore Dauid joyning them both together his meaning is no more but this Lord repaire the breaches of my heart and soule and renew those graces of thy Spirit in me which my sinnes haue blurred and dâ—…aced take then these words in their naturall and proper sense and then they make for me not against me Secondly I answer that Dauid was here deeply affected with his sinnes and hee beheld a great deale of filth of sinne of flesh and corruption in his heart and therefore out of a godly zeale and feruencie and a detestation of his sinne he prayes to God to giue him a new heart and to create in him such an heart as might be cleane and free from all corruption and this hee doth not because there was no synceritie and grace in his heart before for then it is certaine that hee could not haue prayed thus to God but because he did desire to haue his heart better then it was before So that these words of Dauid being but a prayer they doe not necessarily implie that Dauid had no grace in him before I would aske our Antagonists but this question Whether this prayer of Dauid be not the daily prayer of euery true regenerate man Doe not those who are in the state of grace pray earnestly to God To create in them a new heart and to renew a right spirit within them to make them new men and new creatures and will you then conclude that because these true regenerate Saints of God doe vse this prayer that therefore they are not in the state of grace If you should doe so you would but make your selues ridiculous and therefore if you cannot conclude that those Saints of God which vse this prayer as well as Dauid are not in the state of grace because they vse it neither can you conclude that Dauid was not in the state of grace because he vsed it You know it is the vsuall custome of the Saints of God to humble and debase themselues in the sense and feeling of their owne corruptions Iacob he confesseth that the dayes of his pilgrimage were but few and euill Holy Iob the most just and vpright man vpon the earth he confesseth himselfe to be vile and therefore he abhors himselfe and repents in dust and ashes the holy Prophet Isaiah he cries out Woe is me for I am vndone because I am a man of vncleane lips Peter he falls at Iesus feet saying depart from me for I am a sinfull man O Lord and holy Paul records it of himselfe Wee know that the law is spirituall but I am carnall sold vnder sinne for I know that in me that is in my flesh dwelleth no good thing and therefore he cries out O wretched man that I am who shall deliuer mee from the body of this death I thinke now that no man will bee so vncharitable or absurd as to say that Iaacob Iob Isaiah Peter and Paul had no grace at all within them that they were in the state of death and damnation because they vse these words of themselues And againe I suppose that no man will be so ridiculous as to affirme that euery one which doth vse the Lords prayer is not in the state of grace and
translated and taken out of the world being made men of another world those who are translated from death to life and shall not come into condemnation it is impossible for them either totally or finally to fall from grace But all those who are once tâ—…uly râ—…generated and ingrafted into Christ they haue ouercome the world 1 Ioh. 4. 4. Yee are of God little children and haue ouercome them because greater is hee that is in you then hee that is in the world cap. 5. 4 5. Whosoeuer is borne of God ouercommeth the world and this is the victory that ouercommeth the world euen our faith Christ hath ouercome the world for them Io. 16. 33. And God hee giueth them victory through the Lord Iesus Christ 1 Cor. 15. 57. They are quite translated and taken out of the World They are redeemed from the earth and from this present euill world and made men of another world their hearts and soules their thoughts their affections desires and conuersationâ—… are in heaueâ—… Io. 15 19. cap. 17. 11. 16. Reu 14. 3. 4. Phil. 3. 20. They are translated from death to life and shall not come into condemnation Io. 5. 24. Verily verily I say vnto you hee that heareth my word aâ—…d belâ—…eueth on him that sent me hath euerlasting life and shall not come into condemnation but is past from death vnto life Rom. 8. 1. There is no condemnation to those that are in Christ Iesus who walke not after the flesh but after the spirit Col. 1. 13. who hath deliuered vs from the power of darknesse and hath translated vs into the Kingdome of his deare Soâ—…ne and 1 Io. 3. 14. Wee know that wee haue passed from death vnto life because wee loue the brethren Therefore it is impossible for them either finally or totally to fall from grace Sixtly those who are partakers of the first resurrection those who are dead to sinne those who haue put off the old man called vs with an holy calling Tit. 3. 5. According to his mercy hee saued vs by the washing of regeneration and renewing of the holy Ghost Yea they are saued to the vttermost Heb. 7. 25. they are saued in the Lord with an euerlasting saluation they shall not bee ashamed nor confounded world without end Isai. 45. 17. they are passed from death to life and shall not come into condemnation Iohn 5. 24 And they haue euerlasting life in present possession hee that beleeueth on me he that eateth my flesh and drinketh my blood hâ—…h euerlasting life Christ doth not say he shall haue it but hee hath euerlasting life Iohn 3. 16. 18. 36. ca. 5. 24. c. 6. 27. 39 49 47 50 51 54 57 58. Christ hath giuen euerlasting life to all those that are his sheepe Iohn 10. 28. Euery true beleeuer hee hath the Sonne of God dwelling in him and therefore he cannot choose but haue euerlasting life Hee that hath the Son hath euerlasting life within him 1 Iohn 5. 11 12 13. Yea this is life eternall to know God to bee the only true God and Iesus Christ whom he hath sent Iohn 17. 3. and 1 Iohn 5. 13. 20. Therefore it is impossible for them to fall finally or totally from grace This is an argument which in my iudgement cannot be answered or euaded Ninthly all those who are once truly regenerated and ingrafted into Christ are called iustified and sanctified they are made the members of Iesus Christ and they are made Kings and Priests for euer vnto God the Father which yeelds vnto vs this ninth argument Those that are once truly called iustified and sanctified those that are once become the true and liuing members of Iesus Christ and are made Kings and Priests for euer vnto God the Father it is impossible for them to fall finally or totally from grace For first those that are called effectually by God they are called to saluation and to the obtaining of the glory of the Lord Iesus Christ 2 Thes. 2. 13 14. They are called vnto Gods kingdome and glory 1 Thes. 2. 12. They are called to lay hold of eternall life 1 Tim. 6. 12. therefore they cannot fall from grace for then they should loose the end of their calling Secondly all those that are iustified they are freed from condemnation and they are iustified only to this end and purpose thâ—…t they might not bee condemned Rom. 8. 1. 33. 34. and Iohn 5. 24. Therefore they cannot fall from grace for then they should loose the benefit and fruite of their iustification Thirdly all those who are sanctified they are therefore sanctified that they might bee glorified and saued Rom. 8. 30. 2 Thes. 2. 13. Tit. 3. 5. 1 Pet. 1. 3 4 5. Fourthly all such as are the true and liuing members of Iesus Christ Christ giâ—…es vnto them eternall life Iohn 10. 28. and 1 Ioh. 5. 11 12 13. Though they were dead before yet they shall liue in him and when they doe liue once in him they shall so liue that they shall neuer die death shall haue no more dominion and power ouer them John 11. 25 26. and Rom. 6. 9 10 11. Christ Iesus who is the head will neuer suffer any of his liuing true and faithfull members for to perish he will keepe them and preserue them so that none of them shall be euer lost or broken or cut off from him Psal. 34. 20. and Iohn 17. 12. Where Christ himselfe is there they shall alwayes be they in him and hee in them Iohn 17. 23 24. Fiftly all such as are Kings and Priests vnto God for euer they cannot fall finally nor totally from grace for then they should cease to be Kings and Priests and could not be such for euer But all those who are once truly regenerated and ingrafted into Christ they are truly called iustified and sanctified Rom. 8. 29 30 1 Cor. 6. 11. Ephes. 1. 18. cap. 5. 26. 27 2 Thess. 2. 13. Christ Iesus is made vnto them of God righteousnesse iustification sanctification and redemption 1 Cor 1. 30. They are the true and liuing members of Iesus Christ Ephes. 5. 30. Wee are members of his body of his flesh and of his bone Christ is the Vine they are the branches Iohn 15. 5. Hee is the head and body they are the members 1 Cor. 6. 15. Ephes. 4 16. and Col. 2. 19. And they are made Kings and Priests for euer vnto God the Father to offer vp spirituall sacrifices vnto â—…im 1 Pet. 2. 5. Reu. 15. 6. and cap. 5. 10. Therefore it is impossible for them to fall finally or totally from grace Tenthly the true regenerate Saints of God they haue their names written in heauen and in the Booke of liâ—…e which doth suggest vnto vs this tenth Argument They whose names are written in heauen and ingrauen in the Booke of life it is impossible for them to fall quite away from grace First because that God himselfe hath promised that hee will neuer blot out the names of those who are
beene lately pressed and propounded in another manner I will propound it in the same manner as it was then vrged and so will answere it A true regenerate man and a member of Iesus Christ may lie long in a grosse and knowne finne without any actuall repentance as Dauid and Salomon did therefore hee may fall totally if not finally from the state of grace The argument they proue to bee true by this reason The true regenerate Saints of God committing any grosse and knowne sins and lying in them without repentance from the time of these sinnes committed to the time of their actuall repentance of them are not in the state of grace but in the state of damnation which they proue by these two reasons First because these sinnes are mortall in themselues and exclude men quite from heauen as appeares by Ezech. 18. 20. the soule that sinneth it shall dye and by the 1 Cor. 6. 9 10. those that commit â—…nch things and sinnes as these shall not inherit the kingdome of God Secondly because these sinnes of theirs are not forgiuen before their actuall repentance of them so that if they should die before their actuall repentance of them they should be damned for them so that in that Interim and space of time betweene the sinne committed and their actuall repentance they are in the state of damnation and not in the state of grace because their sinnes are not forgiuen and therefore the Argument followes For answer to this maine Objection which is the very summe and substance of all that can be objected and the very basis and foundation of our Antagonists Error I shall denie the ground and reasons which support this argument First I shall denie that the Saints of God committing any grosse and knowne sinne and lying in it for a time without any actuall repentance are during the space and time of this their impenitencie in the state of damnation And secondly I shall denie that a particular repentance is absolutely necessarie to saluation after euery particular grosse and knowne acte of sinne which the Saints of God commit and that those sinnes of theirs cannot bee pardoned before their actuall and particular repentance For the first of these it will be plaine and manifest if wee consider how farre those men must goe that will sinne vnto death or sinne so farre as to put themselues into the state of damnation He that will sinne vnto death or sinne so farre as to put himselfe into the state of damnation must sinne so farre as vtterly to separate and cut off himselfe from Christ vtterly to extirpate all the seeds and habits of true and sauing grace which are within him and wholly to emancipate and inthrall himselfe to the seruice of sinne and Sathan For as long as any man abides in Christ and is not seuered or cut off from him as long as any man hath any habits and seeds of true and sauing grace within him and is not wholly inthralled and imbondaged vnto sinne and Sathan so that the whole intire wrath of God cannot light and fall vpon him he is not in the state of damnation but in the state of grace Now none of the true regenerate saints of God can sin so far as vtterly to seuer cut off themselues from Christ or vtterly to roote out the very habit and seed of those true and sauing graces that are within them and to inthrall themselues wholly to the seruice of sinne and Sathan so that the whole intire wrath of God cannot arise against them therefore they can neuer sinne so faire as to put themselues into the state of death and damnation This is euident by diuers pregnant places of Scripture and by diuers reasons First it is euident that a true regenerate Saint of God can neuer sinne so farre as to put himselfe into the state of death and damnation no not for a time because he can neuer sinne so farre as to bee vtterly cast downe from the state of grace to be vtterly cut off from Christ and to be vtterly depriued of the life of grace Dauid he informes vs that a good man though hee fall yet he shall not be vtterly cast downe for the Lord vpholdeth him with his hand and Paul he assures vs that hee shall be holden vp for God is able to make him stand The Saints of God they may be troubled on euery side by reason of sinne but yet not distressed they may be cast downe by sinne but not destroyed they may be as dying men and yet behold they liue as chastened yet not killed as sorrowfull yet alwayes reioycing as poore yet making many rich as hauing nothing and yet possessing all things they may be like the man that went downe from Ierusalem to Ierico and fell among theeues euen wounded and halfe dead with sinne their graces like those of the Church of Sardis may be ready to die the Saints of God and their graces they may suffer a winter of temptation they may bee sicke and languishing by reason of sinne they may bee semianimes as Cyprian stiles them halfe dead and halfe withered but yet they are neuer wholly dead in sinnes and trespasses when they are at the worst and lowest ebbe they are but bruised reedes and smoaking flaxe they are neuer vtterly broken neuer vtterly quenched and put out there are still some breathings of grace and spirituall life within their soules there are graces alwayes mixed with their sinnes there are still some good things in them of which God takes speciall notice there is still a little strength within them wherby they are inabled to recouer themselues againe to keepe the word of God and not to denie his name and therefore by the voyce and testimonie of all these Scriptures the true regenerate Saints of God doe neuer sinne so farre as to put themselues into the state of death and damnation because they neuer sinne so farre as to be vtterly cast downe from the state of grace to be vtterly cut off from Christ or to be wholly depriued of the life of grace Secondly the Saints of God when as they fall into any sinnes they neuer goe so farre as to put themselues into the state of death and damnation by these their sinnes because the seed of grace doth still abide within them this is St. Iohns reason in the 1 Iohn 3. 9. and cap. 5. 16 17 18. Hee that is borne of God doth not commit sinne for his seed remaineth in him neither can hee sinne that is hee cannot sinne vnto death because he is borne of God The seed of grace it is an immortall seed 1 Pet. 2. 23. it is a diuine nature 2 Pet. 1. 4. it will quench all the fiery darts of the wicked Ephes. 6. 16. and it cannot bee quenched or drowned Cant. 8. 7. it is an annointing that abideth in men 1 Iohn 2. 27. it is such a seed as can die no
Cor. 3. 16 17. cap. 6. 19. Heb. 3. 6. 1 Pet. 2. 5. and cap. 4. 17. the whole Trinitie the Father Sonne and holy Ghost abide and dwell in them for euer Ps. 68. 16. 2 Chron. 7. 16. Reu. 21. 3. Ephes. 2. 22. Iohn 14. 16 17. Math 28. 20. 1 Iohn 3. 24. Ephes. 3 17. and Col. 1. 27. and therefore when as they sinne against the Lord and lie in any knowne and scandalous sinne without repentance they are not in the state of death and condemnation but in the state of life and grace True it is that the members of Iesus Christ they may be feeble sicke and languishing for a time by reason of sin but yet they neuer die of sinne they are not seuered from their head and they neuer cease for to be members Christ Iesus himselfe he is their life their liues are inuolued and treasured vp in his Col. 3. 3 4. Iohn 11. 25 26. and 1 Iohn 5. 11 12 13. Christ Iesus hee is their life and liueth in them and the life which they now liue in the flesh they liue by the faith of the Sonne of God Gal. 2. 20. and therefore Christ himselfe must cease to liue which cannot be because hee being raised from the dead dieth no more death hath no more dominion ouer him ere the Saints of God who are his mèmbers and haue him for their life and soule can die and perish in their sinnes This I can with boldnesse testifie and affirme to the infinite and vnspeakable joy and comfort of euery true and faithfull member of Iesus Christ that it is as impossible for any one that is a true and liuing member of Iesus Christ to die and perish and to be broken off from him againe as it is for Christ himselfe to die or perish or to cease to bee For there is the same reason of the immortality and perpetuitie of euery faithfull Christian and member of Iesus Christ as there is of Christ himselfe The reason why the humane nature of Iesus Christ is immortall and perpetuall and can die no more is because it is vnited and knit vnto the Deitie because it is animated quickned and inliuened by the eternall Spirit of God Now euery true regenerate Saint of God is vnited and knit vnto the Deity it selfe as well as Christs humane nature through the humanitie of Christ though not in the same degree as wee may see expresly Ephes. 2. 20 21 22. cap. 4. 13. 16. Col. 2. 19. and 2 Pet. 1. 4. The selfe-same Almightie power of God that raised vp Christ from the dead and the very selfe-same Spirit of God which did animate quicken and inliuen Christ himselfe doth raise vp animate quicken and inliuen euery true and faithfull member of Iesus Christ euen as the same soule doth animate and informe euery part and member of the same body and as the selse-same sappe doth nourish the grift and the branches which doth nourish the stocke and the roote as wee may reade in expresse tearmes Ephes. 1. 19 20. cap. 2. 18 cap. 4. 4. 1 Pet. 3. 18 19. 1 Cor. 6. 17. Rom. 8. 2. 9. 11. 1 Iohn 4. 17. Gal. 2. 20. 1 Cor. 1 2. 4 5 6. 2 Cor. 3. 18. Iohn 1. 4. 16. cap. 17. 21. 22. 23. and infinite other places and therefore seeing that all such as are the true and faithfull members of Iesus Christ haue the same vnion with the Deitie the same life soule and spirit to animate and quicken them as the humanity of Christ hath seeing that Iesus Christ himselfe is their life and that they liue and moue in him and by him seeing they are the house and remple the habitation and dwelling of the whole Trinitie it is certaine that no sinnes which euer they doe commit can euer raze them or destroy them can euer seuer or cut them off from Christ can euer wholly extinguish the life of grace within them or cast them downe from the state of grace into the state of death and damnation no not for one minute noâ—… for that scantling of time which comes betweene their sinne and their actuall and particular repentance for it Let all the diuells in hell combine and plot together they cannot solue or answere this reason here alledged But now here comes in a threefold and 〈◊〉 objection First that those sinnes which the Saints of God commit they are mortall and deadly in themselues Secondly that they are not forgiuen to the Saints before that they haue actually and particularly repented of them Thirdly that the Saints of God may dye and perish in them before any actuall and particular repentance for them and therefore the Saints of God so long as they lye in their sins without any actuall and particular repentance for them are in the state of death and damnation and not in the state of life and grace To the first of these I answer that it is true that the sins of the Saints of God are mortall and deadly in themselues and that they are so to all carnall and vnregenerate men who doe commit them but yet they are neuer mortall and deadly to the Saints If you consider the sinnes of the Saints as sins or as they are abstracted from the Saints then they are mortall and deadly and haue damnation attending on them but if you consider them as they are the sinnes of the Saints and as they haue their existence and being in the Saints they are not mortall and deadly effectiuè vnto them First because these sinnes of theirs as I haue formerly proued are not imputed to them but they are alwaies imputed to done away in Christ. Secondly because the sting and venom of these sinnes of theirs is taken away in Christ for as the sting of death is sinne so the strength of sinne is the law without which 〈◊〉 it selfe is dead Now Iesus Christ by his death and passion hath fulfilled and abrogated the law for all his Saints hee hath redeemed them from the curse of the Law being made a curse for them he hath blotted out the hand-writing of ordinances that was against them and taken it out of the way nayling it to his Crosse hee hath freed them from the law of sin and death and hath taken away the poyson the strength and sting of sinne and death as we may reade Gal. 4. 5. cap. 5. 1. Rom. 8. 2. cap. 10. 4. Col. 2. 14. 15. Heb. 2. 14. and 1 Cor. 15. 57. and therefore they can boldly and victoriously cry out O death where is thy sting ô sinne where is thy victory and thy poyson becanse that Christ hath pulled out the sting of sinne and allayed the poyson that was in it so that it cannot hurt or kill him Thirdly though the sins of the Saints are mortall in themselues yet God will take no aduantage against them for them hee will pardon and forgiue them hee will passe them by and remember them no more and hee will
body of sinne are wholly destroyed by the passion of Christ to no other end and purpose but that their consciences might beo purged from dead workes to serue the liuing God that they being dead vnto sinne might liue vnto righteousnesse and bring fotth fruites vnto God that they might liue together with Christ and vnto Christ alone and not vnto themselues that they might bee a peculiar people vnto God zealous of good workes that they might serue him in holinesse and true righteousnesse all the dayes of their liues that Christ might present them vnto himselfe a glorious and holy Church without spot blemish or wrinckle it is altogether impossible that they should euer finally or totally fall from grace because else Christ should dye in vaine and not obtaine the end the fruite and substance of his death and passion But out of all those that are once truly regenerated the workes of Satan are vtterly destroyed 1 Iohn 3 8 the power of 〈◊〉 and the body of sinne are quite destroyed by the death and passion of Christ. Hebr 2 14 15. Rom 6 6 and their soules are purified and washed from their sinnes by the blood of Christ. Reuel 1 5. Tit 3 5. to the onely end and purpose that their consciences might be purged from dead workes to serue the liuing God Hebr 9 14 that they being dead vnto sinne might liue vnto righteousnesse and bring forth fruite vnto God Rom 7 4. 1 〈◊〉 2 24 that they might liue together with Christ and vnto Christ alone and not vnto themselues or sinne Rom 6 6. 2 Cor 5 15. 1 Ephes 5 10 that they might be a peculiar people vnto God zealous of good workes Tit 2 14. That they might serue him in holinesse righteousnesse without feare all the dayes of their liues Luke 1 74 75 that they might liue and dye vnto the Lord and that both liuing and dying they might bee his Rom 148 that Christ might present them vnto himselfe an holy Church without spot or blemish or wrinckle Ephes. 5. 26 27. and so it is altogether impossible that they should euer totally or finally fall from grace Secondly as the death and passion of Christ so likewise his perpetuall intercession vnto his Father for all his true and faithfull members may assure us of the truth of this positition from which I frame this second argument Those for whom Christ himselfe doth make perpetuall intercession to his Father that they may continueally perseuere it is altogether impossible for them either finally or totally to fall from grace But Christ himselfe doth make perpetuall intercession to his Father for all those that are once truly regenerated and ingrafted into him that they may alwaies perseuere therefore it is altogether impossible for them either finally or totally to fall from grace For the Maior proposition no man can deny it vnlesse he will maintaine as the Rhemists did in their conference at Hahge that God doth not alwaies heare the intercession of Christ and grant him his requests which is blasphemous in it selfe and contrary to the Scripture For Iohn 11. 41 42. Christ doth giue thankes vnto his Father for that he hath heard him and I know saith he Father that thou hearest me alwaies â—…oubtlesse if God will grant vs whatsoeuer we our selues shall desire and pray for in the name of Christ as he hath promised to doe Iohn 14. 13 14. Cap. 16. 23. 24. much more then will he grant that thing which Christ himselfe shall petition to him for And if God should not alwaies grant whatsoeuer Christ should now desire and request of him Christs intercession would be fruitlesse and to little purpose and we our selues should haue but little benefit or comfort from it Now for the Minor proposition that Christ doth alwaies make intercession to his Father for all those who are once truly regenerated and ingrafted into him it is plaine and euident by Iohn 16. 26. Rom. 8. 24. Hebr. 2. 17. cap. 4. 14. 15 16. cap. 7. 25. and cap. 9. 24. And that this his intercession is for their constant continuall perseuerance it is euident Luke 22. 32 33. where Christ tells Peter that he had prayd for him that his faith might not faile which prayer of Christ extends to all his faithfull member aswell as vnto Peter by that of Iohn 14. 15. 16. where Christ himselfe doth certifie vs that he will pray vnto his Father for all his Saints and that he shall giue them another comforter which shall abide and dwell and be in them and with them for euer and also by that prayer of his Iohn 17. 11 15 21 23 24. where hee prayes thus for his Apostle and afterwards for all true beleiuers Holy Father keepe them thorough thy owne name those whom thou hast giuen vnto mee that they may be one as we are one I pray not that thou shouldest take them out of the world but that thou shouldest keepe them from euill and that they may all bee one as thou Father art in me and I in thee that they also may be one in vs. I in them and thou in me that they may be made perfect in vs and that the world may know that thou 〈◊〉 sent mee and hast loued them as thou hast loued me Father I will that those also whom thou hast giuen mee be with me where I am that they may behold my glory which thou hast giuen me This is also intimated by the Apostle Hebr. 7 25. where speaking of Christ he saith thus of himselfe wherfore hee is able also to saue them to the vttermost that come vnto God by him seeing hee euer liueth to make intercession for them Those for whom Christ himselfe doth pray and interceede they shall be saued to the vttermost no man shall condemne them or seperate them from the loue of God which is in Christ Iesus their Lord because that Christ himselfe is euen at the right hand of God alwaies making intercession for them Rom. 8. 33. to the end of the chapter Christ hath prayed heretofore and doth now continually make intercession to his Father for all such as are once his true and faithfull members that they may alwaies perseuere continue constant in the state of grace and therefore it is altogether impossible for them either finally or totally to fall from grace If it be obiected that this prayer of Christ doth onely tend to keepe them from a finall but yet not from a totall fall from grace I answere that it is not so but that this prayer of Christ extends to preserue them from a totall aswell as from a finall fall First because Christ doth pray that their faith might not faile now if they might fall totally from grace then their faith should faile yea that numericall faith which once they had should vtterly be lost for that faith which they haue by their new inscision into Christ is not the same numericall faith which they had before for that
20. 9. Christ doth leade them in the way of righteousnesse and in the middest of the paths of iudgement Prou. 8. 20. The loue of Christ doth euen constraine them for to please him so that they cannot but speake and doe the things which they haue seene and heard 2 Cor. 5. 14. Acts 4. 20. They are vessels vnto honour sanctified and meetâ—… for their masters vse and prepared vnto euery good worke 2 Tim. 2. 21. the whole frame and disposition of their soules is bent and set only vpon that which is good so that they cannot choose but serue obey and please the Lord continually in all things They cannot doe the euill and commit the sinne they would They are good trees of the Lords owne planting therefore they cannot bring forth euill fruite Math. 7. 18. they are borne of God therefore they cannot sinne 1 Ioh. 3. 9. They haue put off their coate of sinne how then shall they put it on they haue washed their feete how shall they then defile them Cant. 5. 3. They are dead to sinne and how can such as are dead to sinne liue any longer therein Rom. 6. 2. The sheepe of Christ they will not follow a stranger but they flee from him for they doe not know his voyce Iohn 10. 5. They walke in the spirit so that they cannot doe the things they would nor yet fulfill the lust of the flesh Gal. 5. 16. 17. The word of God doth cast downe their sinfull imaginations and euery high thing that exalteth it selfe against God and bringeth into captiuitie euery thought to the obedience of Christ 2 Cor. 10. 5. So that they cannot doe the euill that they would And againe they cannot sinne vnto death because their seed remaineth alwaies in them and because they are borne of God 1 Ioh. 3. 6. 9. and c. 5. 16 17 18. Therefore they cannot possibly fall finally or totally from grace How this argument can be answered or â—…uaded I cannot yet conjecture Thirteenthly the Saints of God they cannot be separated from the loue of God which is in Christ Iesus they are married 〈◊〉 and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 vnto God for eâ—…er God â—…ath 〈◊〉 tâ—…em to be his people and they haue chosen him to be their God which yeelds vs this thirteenth Argument Those that cannot possiblie bee separated from the loue of God which is in Christ Iesus those that are married espoused and betrotheâ—… vnto God and Christ for euer those whom God hath chosen for to be his people and hath likewise caused them to choose him for their God and to ioyne themselues vnto him in such an euerlasting Couenant as shall neuer be forgotten it is impossible that they should euer finally or totally fall from grace But all those who are once truly regenerated and ingrafted into Christ they are married espoused and betrothed vnto God and Christ for euer Hosea s. 19. 20. I will betroth theâ—… vnto mee for euer yea I will betroth thee vnto me in righteousnesse and iâ—… iudgement and in louing kindenesse and in mercies I will euen betroth thee vnto meâ—… in faithfulnesse and thou shalt know the Lord God will marry himselfe to them and them vnto himselfe â—…e will be their husband and they shall be his Spouse Psal. 45. 10. 11. Isai. 54. 5. Ier. 3. 14. cap. 31. 32. Math. 19 5. 6. Christ and they are become one flesh and one spirit Eph. 5. 28. ver 33. 1 Cor. 6. 17. They cannot possibly be separated from the loue of God which is in Christ â—…sus their Lord by any thing or creature whatsoeuer Rom. 8. 34. to the end God hath chosen them to bee his people and hath also câ—…sed them to choose him for their God Psal. 4 3. Ier. 31. 33. vers 38. Isai. 43. 1. Ezech. 11. 20. Tit. 2. 14. Hebr. 8. 10. and 1 Pet. 2. 6. And hath also caused them to ioyne themselues vnto him in such an euerlasting league and couâ—…nant as shall 〈◊〉 be forgotten Ier. 50 5. Therefore it is impossible that they should euer finally or totally fall from grace Fourteenthly those who are established settled grounded in grace those who are so rooted and grounded in grace that they cannot bee remoued or cast downe those who are as pillars in the house of God and shall goe out thence no more and those who are the very inheritance of the Lord himselfe it is impossible for them either finally or totally to fall from grace But all such as are once truly regenerated and ingrafted into Christ they are established settled and grounded in grace Iob 36. 7. Hee withdraweth not his eyes from the righteous but he doth establish them for euer 2 Cor. 1. 21. He which establisheth vs with you in Christ is God See Psa. 89. 36 37. Rom. 16. 25. 1 Cor. 16. 13. Ephes. 3. 18. cap 6. 10 11. 1 Thes. 3. 13. 2 Thes. 2. 15. 17. Col. 1. 11. cap. 2. 57 and 1 Pet. 5. 10. They are so rooted and grounded in grace that they can neuer be remoued or cast downe Psal. 37. 27. Psal. 112. 6. Ps. 125. 1. Prou. 10. 30. Math. 7. 24. 25. Eph. 2 21. Heâ—… 12. 28. and 1 Pet. 2. 6 They are as pillars in the house of God and shall goe out thence no more Reu. 3. 12. Yea they are the Lords owne inheritance Deut. 4. 20. Psal. 78. 71. Psal. 2. 8. Psa. 79. 1. Therefore they must indure for euer For an inheritance is not of any transitory and fading thing but of such things only as are perpetuall and indure for euer Therefore it is impossible for them either finally or totally to fall from grace Lastly the true regenerate Saints of God they haue all the inward and outward meanes and helpes that may be to preserue and keepe them in grace they haue the Word and Sacraments the communion company of the Saints and they haue the prayers of all the Saints on earth and they haue the continuall presence and protection of God himselfe they haue Iesus Christ and the holy Ghost dwelling and residing in their hearts and they haue the intercession and mediation of Iesus Christ From whence I frame this fifteenth and last argument in this kinde Those who haue all the inward and outward meanes that may be to preserue and keepe them in the state of grace those who haue the Word and Sacraments the Communion companie and prayers of the Saints the continuall presence and protection of God himselfe those who haue Iesus Christ and the holy Ghost dwelling and residing in their hearts continuâ—…lly and those who haue the perpetuall intercession and mediation of Iesus Christ it is impossible for them either finally or totally to fall from grace But all those who are once truly regenerated and ingrafted into Christ they haue all the inward and outward meanes that may be to preserue and keepe them in the state of grace they haue the Word and Sacraments the Communion company and prayers of the Saints the continuall presence
more death hath no more dominion ouer it Iohn 11. 25 26. and Rom. 6. 9. 10. 11. 14. it is a seed that proceeds from the very power of God and of the holy Ghost Rom. 15 13. 1 Cor. 2. 5. it is wrought in vs by the selfesame almighty power of God which raised vp Iesus Christ from the dead and set him at the right hand of God in heauenly places Ephes. 1. 19. 20. and cap. 3. 20. therefore it cannot bee vanquished or destroyed by all the power and strength of sinne or Sathan the gates of hell cannot preuaile against it Math. 16. 18. this power and grace of Christ in vs is sufficient for vs it is stronger then sinne or Sathan it is able to vanquish and subdue them and to treade and bruise them vnder our feet 2 Cor. 10. 4. 5. cap. 12. 9 10. Rom. 16. 20. Ephes. 6. 16. 1 Iohn 4. 4. and cap. 5. 4 5. No sinne that the Saints of God commit doth vtterly destroy and roote this seede of Grace out of their hearts it still abides within them and therefore they neuer sinne so farre as to put themselues into the state of damnation or to fall wholly or totally from the state of grace Hee who amidst the very greatest of his sinnes doth retaine the very habit and seed of grace within him it is certaine that he falls not wholly from the state of grace for for any man to fall totally from the state of grace and yet to retaine the very habit and seed of grace within him still is a plaine and manifest contradiction But the true regenerate Saints of God and such as are truly borne of God euen amidst the very greatest of their sinnes doe still retaine the habit and the seed of grace within them as is euident by the premises therefore it is certaine that they fall not wholly from the state of grace by these their sinnes Thirdly a true regenerate man can neuer sinne so farre as to fall totally from grace and to put himselfe into a state of death and damnation because he neuer sinnes so farre as to make himselfe a slaue or seruant vnto sinne though sinne be in him yet it is in him as a tyrant and a rebell not a King or a friend it rules and reignes not in him he obeyes it not in the lusts thereof he neuer yeelds vp himselfe as a seruant or a subject to it Rom. 6. 12. to 23. 2 Pet. 2. 19. Iohn 8. 34. though he walkes after the slesh or rather is drawne violently after the flesh sometimes yet he wars not after the flesh 2 Cor. 10. 3. hee is so farre from warring after it that he alwaies wars and fights against it the very sinne and euill which he doth commit is the sinne and euill which hee would not doe Rom. 7. 15. to the end and Gal. 5. 17. hee neuer sinnes with a full intire compleate resolued and deliberate will he neuer yeelds a full and perfect assent vnto his sinne there is a reluctancie reuitancie dislike and hatred of it in his soule and it his inner man and therefore he neuer sinnes so farre as to cast himselfe wholly downe from the state of grace and to put himselfe into the state of death and damnation Fourthly Regenerate men they neuer sinne so far as to fall totally from the state of grace no not for a time because they neuer sinne so farre as to seuere and cut off themselues from Christ. Those who euen then when as they do commit sinne and whiles they haue the remainders of the old man and of the body of sinne continuing in them continue still in Christ it is certaine that they are in the state of life and grace and not in the state of death and dà mnation because he that is in Christ the spring and fountaine of all grace and life hath grace and life within him and he is wholly freed from the law of sinne and death Iohn 5. 24. 1 Iohn 5. 12. and Rom. 8. 2. But the true regenerate Saints of God euen then when as they doe commit sinne and whiles they haue the remainders of the old man and of the body of sinne continuing in them continue still in Christ as is euident by Rom. 7. 15. to the end compared with Rom. 8. 1 2. where Paul making mention of that perpetuall combate which is betweene the flesh and the spirit in euery true regenerate man who did with their minde serue the law of God but with the flesh the law of sinne he concludes it with this Corollarie or inference There is therefore now no condemnation to those who are in Christ Jesus who walke not after the flesh but after the spirit for though there be much sinne and corruption in them yet the law of the Spirit of life hath made them free from the law of sinne and death There is now no condemnation to them euen now whiles there is much sinne and corruption in them because they striue against this sinne and corruption they hate it and are grieued vnder it they obey and serue it not because there is an inner man a regenerate and sanctified part within them which God doth most respect which is alwaies grapling and contending with those corruptions and because they are still in Christ who hath freed them from the law of finne and death Therefore because the regenerate Saints of God euen then when as they doe commit siâ—…ne and whiles their corruptions are hanging on them are still in Christ Therefore it is certaine that they are in the state of life and grace and not in the state of death and damnation Fiftly the true regenerate Saints of God when as they commit auy grosse and knowne sinne euen before their actuall and particular repentance for it are still in the state of life and grace and not in the state of death and damnation because they are still the elected Saints and the adopted sonnes of God and their names are still inrolled in the book of Life Those who are still the elected and adopted sons of God and haue their names inrolled in the Booke of Life it is certaine that they are alwaies in the state of grace and life and not in the state of death and damnation because their election and adoption they are altogether immutable they cannot be altered or changed no more then God himselfe But all those who are once truly regenerated and ingrafted into Christ they are still the elected and adopted sonnes of God and their names are alwayes inrolled in the booke of Life Rom. 8. 29. 30. Ephes. 1. 3 4 5. Luke 10. 20. Phil. 4. 3. Heb. 12. 13. Reu. 13. 18. and infinite other places Therefore it is certaine that they are alwayes in the state of grace and life and not in the state of death and damnation yea euen then when as they lie in any grosse scandalous and knowne sin without any particular and actuall repentance Sixtly the true regenerate Saintâ—… of God
onely meanes to keepe men from committing sinne should cause them for to sinne with greater boldnesse and security Is it not grace that only that restraines and keepes men backe from sinne Is it not grace and that onely which makes men to detest abhor and vtterly renounce all sinne and dare you then affirme that perseuerance in the state of grace will imbolden and incourage men to rush into all kinde of sinne doubtlesse you are much mistaken and deceiued in affirming it and it is an infallible argument that you are so â—…arre from hauing any truth of grace within you that as yet you know not what this true grace is of which wee now dispute Secondly regenerate men they are dead to sinne they haue crucified the flesh with the 〈◊〉 and lusts thereof and therefore though they cannot sall from grace yet they cannot yet they dare not sinne against the Lord. This is Pauls reason Rom. 61 2. What shall wee say then shall wee continue in sinne that grace may abound God forbid how shall wee that are dead to sinne liue any longer therein the true regenerate Saints of God they are dead to sinne therefore they cannot liue any longer to it they haue put off their coate how then shall they put it on they haue washed their 〈◊〉 how then shall they defile them they are regenerated sanctisied and dead to sinne therefore they cannot therefore they will not runne into it though they cannot fall from grace Thirdly the true regenerate Saints of God they are redeomed from their sinnes that they might no longer liue vnto them but liue vnto the Lord they are now made Kings and Priests vnto God the Father to offer vp spirituall all sacrifices vnto him they are now quite other persons then they were before and therefore they scorne now to stoope to those base and filthy sinnes which might defile their soules and 〈◊〉 their professions they are now the sonnes of God and heires of heauen they are now the vessels and â—…emples of the holy Ghost and they haue vowed to foâ—…sake their sinnes and lusts and to keepe themselues vnspotted from the world and therefore now though they cannot fall from grace yet there is such an holy ingenuity and magnanimitie wrought within them that 〈◊〉 they scorne for to how and yeeld to sin or to sell themselves as slaues and 〈◊〉 to it Fourthly the true regenerate Saints of God they hauethe loue of God which is shed abroade in their hearts by the holy Ghost which loue is preserued and increased in their hearts and soules by the assurance of their constant and finall perseuerance in the state of grace Now this loue of God doth so worke vpon their hearts and soules and so awe and curbe them that they dare not sinne against the Lord for feare of greeuing offending him though God would neuer disinherite them for their sinnes A dutifull and louing fonne that honours and respects his father though he be sure of his fathers loue and fauour to him yet hee dares not to offend him because hee honours and respects him God is an exceeding good gracious and louing Father vnto all his Saints and they are exceeding dutifull and louing vnto him yea they estimate his louing kindnesse better then life it selfe Psal. 63. 3. and therefore though they cannot fall from grace yet they dare not yet they will not sinne against him for feare of greeuing and offending him Fifthly the true regenerate Saints of God they haue the holy Spirit of God within them who doth sway and ouerrule their wills their hearts and soules and will not so much as suffer them to doe the sinne and euill that they would when they haue any euill and sinsull lusts or thoughts arising in their hearts the holy Ghost doth crush and quell them when they are running on to any sinfull actions the holy Ghost doth pull them backe and quite restraine them causing them to walke in his statutes and to keepe his commandements and doe them so that they cannot will or doâ—… the euill that they would as you may reade Ezech. 32. 6. 27. Rom. 7. 25. c. 8. 1 2 13 14. Gal. 5. 16 17 25. 1 Iohn 3 9. and 5. 18. therefore though they cannot fall from grace yet they will not yet they cannot rush more boldly into sinne Sixthly the true regenerate Saints of God though they cannot fall from grace because God will preserue them and cause them for to vse the meanes which should preserue them in the state of grace yet they know that they cannot perseuere but by vsing of the meanes they know that sinne will hinder them much in this their perseuerance and therefore though they cannot fall from grace yet because they must vse the meanes to perseuere in grace they dare not plunge themselues presumptuously into any sinne Seuenthly though the Saints of God can neuer fall from grace yet they dare not to allow themselues in any sinne because they know that euery sinne the which they doe commit it doth wound and pierce the sides of their gracious and louing Sauiour and crucifie him afresh they know that hee is wounded payned and grieued with their sinnes and therefore they dare not to commit them but pray against them as Dauid did Psal. 19. Lord keepe meâ—… from presumptuous â—…nnes When any good Christian is tempted vnto any sinne though the sinne iâ—… selfe could neuer hurt him yet hee reasons thus with himselfe What hath not my blessed Sauiour been crucified already for my sinnes haue I not wounded and grieued him enough already but I must wound and grieue and crucifie him yet once againe O no I will not nay I dare not doe it though I might gaine a thousand worlds I will not shew my selfe such a gracelesse and vnthankfull wretch I will rather die I will rather doe or suffer any thing then sinne against him This is the resolution of euery Christian soule and therefore though he cannot fall from grace yet hee dares not yet he will not sin Lastly to omit all other reasons The true regenerate Saints of God though they cannot fall from grace yet they dare not sinne against the Lord. For though the Lord hath promised neuer to disinherite or cast them off neuer to take away his graces or his euerlasting mercies from them yet if they sin against him he hath threatned and hee will performe it that hee will chastise them with the rod of men and with the stripes of the children of men that he will visite their iniquitie with rods and their sinne with stripes 2 Sam. 7 14 15. and Psal. 89. 30. to 34. God will chastise them as sonnes though he condemnes them not as enemies and rebells this his fatherly correction and chastisement then is sufficient to keepe them from presumption and to restraine them from rushing into sinne though God neuer disinherits or casts them off And so you see what a false what a