love saith the Apostle He will remember the good works of men borne of God at the great day of judgement The good workes of some are manifest before-hand and they that are otherwise cannot be hid 1 Tim. 5.15 They cannot for ever be hid because God will make mention of them at that day But hee hath engaged himselfe by oath to remember our sins and sinfull actions Hebr. 8. And therefore the works of the spirituall man are not sin or sinfull Arg. 8. There is no law against the workes of a spirituall man or the fruits of the spirit of grace and therefore they are not sin because where there is no law there is no transgression But there is no law against these This is plain by that passage of the Apostle Gal. 5.22 The fruit of the spirit is love joy peace long-suffering gentlenesse goodnesse faith meeknesse temperance against such there is no law Object They are here considered as they are precisely the fruits of the spirit and as they ought to be done by us and so they are no sins but consider them as acted by us even with the spirits assistance and so they are defective and sinfull Answ The Apostle doth not speake of the fruits of the spirit as Tully of his Oratour Plato of his Common-wealth Moor of his Utopia as of things no where to be found But be speaks of the spirit as in us and the fruits of it as in us And doth plainly tell us that if we are led by the spirit we are not under the law and that there is no law against the fruits of the spirit But I shall have occasion hereafter to speake more fully of some places where the Apostles and servants of God doe speak plainly of these works as done in us that so I may break the neck of this distinction which is made as a Catholicon or salve for every sore Arg. 9. God doth give a testimony concerning his Saints that they are righteous and holy which is spoken in reference to their spirituall nature and actings and therefore they are righteous and holy The judgment of God is according to truth hee being the God of truth Doth not God give this testimony of Job Job 1.1 That he was a perfect man and upright one that feared God and eschewed evill And though man may oppose this yet it feemeth by Gods speech to Sathan that the Devill could not contradict it Job 2.3 And the Lord said unto Sathan hast thou considered my servant Job that there is none like him in the earth a perfect man upright one that feareth God and escheweth evill Did any thing which was sin or sinful procure this honourable title to David that he was a man after Gods owne heart 1 Sam. 13.14 Doth not the Scripture of truth inform us concerning Zacharias and Elizabeth his wife that they were both righteous before God walking in all the Commandements of God blamelesse Luke 1.6 They did not onely walk in the great Commandement of God concerning faith for Justification but in all the Ordinances and Commandements of God Is not Lot called a just and righteous man who was vexed with the filthy conversation of the wicked 2 Pet. 2.7 And was his sinfull soule vexed with their evill deeds or his righteous soul speak in the language of Gods Word and ye must acknowledge that it was his righteous soule vers 8. God is not like unto some indulgent parents who by their fond indulgency doe account that to be a vertue which is the fault of their children and them to be vertuous who are vile God calleth nothing righteousnesse which is sin or sinfull Nor those to be perfect and upright which are not so indeed and therefore seeing God doth call his children righteous holy and perfect wee may not be affraid to call them so unlesse wee will be affraid to follow his judgment Object They were righteous before God by Justification and before men by holy walking Ans We deny not their justification before God by faith but with all we affirme that they were righteous before him by their holy walkings As these places doe sufficiently prove with others which we shall hereafter speak of Let us not delude ous soules to think that righteousnesse sanctification is to the eye of men only The purest sanctification of a Saint is not so visible to men as unto God Pure religion and undefiled before God and the Father is this to visite the fatherlesse and Widowes in their affliction and to keepe himselfe unspotted from the world which will be further manifested by our next argument Arg. 10. Almighty God is a God of pure eyes who cannot behold any iniquity any sinfull thing or sin with an eye of approbation But this God who cannot approve what is sin and sinfull this God approveth and professeth that he is well pleased with the performances of his Saints therefore the performance of the Saints cannot be sin or sinfull The Apostle in Philip. 4.18 Professeth that the worke of the Philippians in sending to relieve his wants was an odour of a sweet smell a sacrifice acceptable well pleasing to God God hath pure eyes and pure nostrils and therefore if it had been sin or sinfull it could not have pleased his eye nor have beene an odour of a sweete smell unto his nostrills Object They are so but not in their owne nature Answ If they be not so in their own nature they are filthy and odious in their own nature and yet accepted by grace If one thing which is filthy and odious in its owne nature be accepted why should not other things which are filthy and odious in their owne nature be accepted for good workes If this can be made good Whoredome and Adultery will prove good works which hath been asserted by some who have said that the filthinesse of whoredome being done away the action is well-pleasing to Almighty God as well as any good work Arg. 11. One end and intention of God in electing of us was that he might make us holy that he might make us good trees to bring forth good fruit Though God doth not elect us because wee doe believe or because wee doe love yet hee hath elected us that wee may believe and that we may love So that wee frustrate one end that God hath in electing us if we doe not grant that God gives us a new nature and new hearts According to that of the Apostle 2 Thes 2 13. We are chosen unto salvation through sanctification of the Spirit and belief of the truth And in Eph 1.4 He hath chosen us in him that we should be holy and without blame before him in love Object We doe apprehend our election imperfectly which is the cause of the sinfulness of our works Answ By reason of that which is in the flesh we cannot so perfectly see our election as wee shall doe hereafter Yet in the spirit for the present we doe so fully apprehend it
away from grace and thus some have been too bold with me in this particular And when I have proved the law to be uselesse unto us in many particulars they have concluded that I did totally deny the use of the Law which hath been the ground of this groundlesse aspersion unto which I think it needlesse to give any larger answer Concerning the 3. other branches in this Article to wit that it is no rule for a Christian to walk by nor to examine his life by and that Christians are freee from the mandatory power of it I can either affirm or deny them all I doe acknowledge that in a sence we may be said to be under the rule and power of the Law and in a sence it is true that we are not under the rule and power of it which if it be well weighed by the ballance of right reason whether these who have charged me with this not stateing the question as I did when I delivered my judgment and suppressing my meaning in their Article may be justified in this action I leave it to any man truly rationall and unprejudiced concerning me yea to themselves when God shall awaken their consciences to judge Wherefore that the truth of God and my meaning may be more evident I shall present to the view of the Reader the distinctions which I made use of in the handling of this controversie The first distinction is this that the Law may be considered as delivered in Sinai Sion Gal. 4.24 As the covenant of Sinai or as a part of the covenant of Sion Isa 2.3 For out of Zion shall goe forth the Law and the word of the Lord from Jerusalem 2ly As 1. delivered by the hand of Moses 2. by the hand of Christ And though this distinction hath beene branded by some of the learned Teachers of our times in their Pulpits and Presses with the infamous mark of Antinomianisme yet I doe not doubt but that I shall easily prove it to be a Scripture distinction This is the meaning of that speech of John Joh. 1.17 The law was given by Moses but grace truth came by Jesus Christ By Moses that is by the hand of Moses As it is plain by Lev. 26.46 These are the laws which the Lord made between him and the Children of Israel in mount Sinai by the hand of Moses So grace and truth is given by the hand of Jesus Christ Christ is stiled the Mediator of the better Covenant Heb. 8.6 And as he is the Mediator of this better Covenant he doth give the law to the Saints by his hand in this Covenant This distinction is frequently used by Zanchius 4. Tom. operum delege Translata est lex a Mose ad Christum e manu Mosis in manum Christi veri mediatoris sicut et sacerdotium ab Aarone ad Christum verum aeternumque Pontificem translatum est Translato autem sacerdotio necesse est inquit Apostolus ut et legis translatio fiat The law saith hee is translated from Moses to Christ out of the hand of Moses into the hand of Christ the true Mediator as the Priest-hood is translated from Aaron to Christ the true and eternall high Priest For the Priest-hood being changed it is needfull saith the Apostle that there be a change of the Law And in the same booke he hath afterward these words Dicimus legem quatenus fuit in manu Mosis abrogatam jam esse per Christum fidelibus sed quatenus jam est in manu Christi confirmatam esse constabilitam We say that the Law as it was in the hand of Moses is now abrogated to believers by Christ but as it is in the hand of Christ it is confirmed and established Brethren give mee an answer in the spirit of love and meekenesse to this question why should you censure me to be an Antinomian for makeing use of this distinction seeing ye account Zanchius to be a sound and orthodox writer who maintaineth the same thing Having premised these distinctions I shall answer plainly to these severall branches and not be affraid to owne what I have delivered because I am still confident that it is the truth of Christ 1. The law as delivered by Moses is not the rule by which a believing Christian doth walk but as it is delivered unto him in the covenant of grace by the hand of the Lord Jesus I shall prove this by this argument A covenant of works is not the rule by which a believing Christian doth walk The law as delivered in Sinai by the hand of Moses is a Covenant of works Therefore the law as delivered in Sinai by the hand of Moses is not a rule by which a believing Christian doth walk I doe suppose that you will not deny the major proposition You will not say that a covenant of workes is the rule of a Christian for then a Christian should worke that hee might live whereas a true Christian doth work because he doth live and hath life without works If ye shall deny the minor or second proposition I shall prove it by these reasons which are drawn from Scripture Reas 1. The Apostle doth frequently oppose the righteousnesse of the law and the law to the righteousnesse of grace the covenant of grace which hee could not doe if the law were a covenant of grace 1. Hee opposeth the righteousnesse of the Law and Gospel Rom. 10.5.6 Moses describeth the righteousness which is of the Law that the man which doth those things shall live by them But the Gospel-righteousnesse is the righteousnesse of faith vers 6. Observe the Apostles words well he doth not say that the Law requireth doing and working for justification according to the false glosses and interpretations of the Pharisees as some Writers of late with the Papists of old have asserted But Moses describeth the righteousnesse of the law so 2 ly He opposeth the law and the Covenant of grace Rom. 6.14 Sin shall not have dominion over you because ye are not under the law but under grace What sence can you make of these words if ye shall assert the law to be a covenant of grace for then this will be the meaning of the words Sinne shall not have dominion over you because ye are not under the law or covenant of grace but under grace Reas 2. The Apostle doth affirme that no flesh shall be justified by the law because by the law is the knowledge of sinne Rom. 3.20 But if the law were a covenant of grace a man might be justified by it And therefore I conclude that it is not a covenant of grace Reas 3. The Apostle affirmeth that if righteousnessE come by the law then Christ is dead in vaine And shall wee say that that is the covenant of grace by which righteousnesse cannot come unto us Reas 4. The Apostle plainly saith that the law is not of faith but the man that doth them shall live in them Gal. 3.12
the whole law Cum sophista intelligit legem abrogari eamque ceremonialem tu potius intellige Paulum quemlibet Christianum universae legi abrogari Simplicitur mortuus sum legi hoc est nihil plane commercij est mihi cum lege Luth. I am dead to the law that is I have nothing to doe with the law Est autem mori legi lege non tencri sed liberum esse a lege et nescire eam To be dead unto the law is not to be held by the law but to be free from the law and not to know it Reas 4. If we preach consolation and doe exhort people to expect comfort from God we may bid them put away the law and their confidence of expecting comfort by it The law worketh wrath Rom. 7. and therefore it doth not worke joy The spirit of joy is not received by the workes of the law but by the hearing of faith We receive the promise of the spirit through faith Gal. 3.14 Res 5. Though the law requireth holiness yet it doth not make us holy A man that will be truely fanctified must not live under the Law but under the Gospel This is the argument of the Apostle Rom. 6.14 Sinne shall not have dominion over you because ye are not under the law but under grace Must not the law in some sense be put away that we may not be under it Let my arguments be well weighed and I am contented to be censured In the meane while I shall comfort my selfe in this that I am not the first of Saints who have been reproached and persecuted as an enemy to the law The false witnesses which were set up against the Proto-martyr Stephen did bring in this against him that he spake blasphemous words against the law Acts 6.13 And it is probable that some such thing was charged upon Paul by the Jewes as we may gather by his defence for himselfe before Festus where he professeth that hee had not offended against the law of the Jewes Acts 25.8 His proposing and clearing objections so frequently in his Epistles when he speaketh of the Law and Gospel lest hee should be traduced as an enemie to the law doth sufficiently prove what was in the hearts and tongues of men who were opposers of that doctrine of free grace which he preached I shall shut up my reply to this Artitle with the words of this chosen Vessell spoken by him in the like case Acts 24.14 This I confesse that after the way which they call heresie so worship I the God of my Fathers believing all things which are written in the law and the Prophets Sect. 3. The next Article which the Subscribers doe bring against me as matter of errour which they have received from the penne of the same witnesse is that horrid speech of mine as they were pleased to call it The law cuts off a mans legs and then bids him walke Reply When these Articles were brought against me it being demanded of me whether I would owne them as my tenents and opinions I doe well remember that I gave them this answer after I had read them over That I had made use of some phrases and expressions which were in that paper and that some things which were therein being understood in a right sense sano sensu might passe for the blessed truths of the Lord Jesus But as they lay in the paper which was given unto me so I did not own them as my tenents and opinions because those things which were in my Sermons and discourses which held forth light for the understanding of them were not conjoyned with them in that paper And that answer may more especially reach these particular words I am not ashamed to acknowledge that in a Sermon I did make use of these expressions speaking of the impossibility of our fulfilling the law for justification the irritating power of the law by which sinne is stirred up in us we by accident being made worse by it and while the law commandeth men who are under it to yeild personall and perfect obedience unto it though it giveth us no power to doe what it commandeth us And I doe not doubt but in the strength of grace I shall free the expressions from that horridnesse which the Subscribers following Mr. Gataker have put upon it or else I shall willingly acknowledg that it was a rash inconsiderate yea horrid expression which fell from me But before I come to defend the innocency of the expression I cannot but stand still a little and pause upon it wondering that so many men who by their profession are tyed and engaged to the study of the Scriptures should be so little acquainted with the language of the Scriptures that they should not be able to remember one Scripture expression among so many which are like unto it to free it from that horridnesse which they would put upon it Friends consider what you doe If ye censure my expressions as horrid which the holy Spirit will justifie by the like expressions of his owne in Scripture take heed that ye doe not censure the Spirit as well as me and strike at the truth through my sides It is the speech of Plutark The thick clouds do often darken the Sun and the cloud of passions the light of reason 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 And thus I am apt to think it is with you Your passions certainly are high or else how could you be so low in your reasons so unadvisedly to condemn that as an horrid speech which by warrant from Scripture I shall prove to be harmlesse But in the first place let us enquire where this horridnesse doth lie I am ready to believe that ye are not such enemies to the law to assert the latter part of the speech hath any thing horrid in it Yee will not say that it is horrid to say that the law bids men to walke The horrid treason then of the speech must lye in the former part of it 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 I have found I have found out the horridnesse of it It is horrid to affirme that the law doth cut off a mans legges Let us bring it to the bar of truth to be tryed and if it cannot bring speeches in Scripture like unto it where the Apostle is speaking of the same points which I handled when I delivered it let it be stil branded with the hot iron of the Subscribers and passe for an horrid errour 1. Let us compare this speech with that of Paul 2 Cor. 3.6 The letter kiâ—â—eth Which Expositors with one consent uno ore doe expound to be meant of the law and which the words following of the Apostle do so plainely prove that it is bootlesse and in vaine for any man to deny it wee shall take it therefore for granted That the law killeth and this is Pauls or rather Gods assertion who gave this law Now let the indifferent Reader judge whether it be more horrid to say
that the law killeth a man or cutteth off his legs Friends I am perswaded that some of you have experimentally found as I have done that the law killeth And when ye were slaine and killed by the law were you freed presently from the mandatory power of it I am perswaded that some of you can professe in truth with mee that ye were not The law then did command you to doe and walke What horridnesse is there more in this if I may make the comparison to affirme that the law cutteth off a mans legs and then biddeth him to walke then in this To affirme that the law killeth a man doth yet bid him to doe it and walke Object But some may say that Paul saith that the letter killeth because it giveth not strength to fulfill it Litera occidit nempe quia non consert vires ad praestandum Answ I spake it in this sense too and is it not lawfull for me to imitate Pauls expressions Unlesse the ignorant world must be made to believe that my speeches and exclamations are horrid and blasphemous I might multiply arguments from this Chapter if I should runne over all the expressions of the Apostle especially these where he calleth the law 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 A ministration of death a ministration of condemnation 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 a thing to be abolished or abolished and done away And whatsoever is spoken by any of the godly for the making good of these expressions I might make use of the same for the justifying of mine seeing I spake them in the same manner as Paul did But that it may appeare that I speake not this for the reproaching of you but the vindicating of wronged abused truth and knowing that a word is sufficient to a wise man when a thousand stripes will not enter into a foole I shall not insult over your weakenesse but rather cover it as farre as I may without injury to the truth Let mee only leave this word to your consideration which in this place is very seasonable to wit That it is the mind of God that we should be as favourable in interpreting the expressions of spirituall men in their writings and speakings now as in interpreting the expressions of those spirituall men who are now with the Lord knowing that they both speak by the same spirit which spirit doth retain his liberty to speake in us as it did in them 2. Compare this speech with that of the Apostle Rom. 7.5 The motions of sinne which were by the law which will sound as harsh as to affirme that the law doth cut off the legs of sinners But if some say this is only occasionally and accidentally men running the more into sinne by how much the more they are forbidden to commit sinne According to that of the Poet. Tendimus in vetitum wee have a tendency in us to that which is forbidden I answer that the same exposition will sufficiently qualifie my speech to take away from it the least appearance of evill The law doth cut off a mans legs occasionally and accidentally A man by reason of the corruption which is in him findeth by experience that he is of lesse strength to run in the wayes of God the more he doth endeavour to get strength by the law of workes Musculus compareth it in this respect to a chaste Matron in a Brothel-house which by her good advice doth prove an occasion to some impudent whores to be more bold and shamelesse in their impiety Had the spirit of love without which wee are nothing taught you something concerning this speech you would have been favourable in interpreting it and not rigidly censorious in condemning it Oh that you who seeme to he zealous for the law would consider that this commandement to wit that we should love our neighhour as our selves is one of the great Commandements upon which all the Law and Prophets doe hang Mat. 22.40 And then how would you dare to be so rigid and uncharitable in your censuring of your Brethren If indeed you have received the law from Moses may I not say as my Saviour did to the Jewes John 7.19 Did not Moses give you the law and yet none of you keepeth it And then remember what the Apostle saith Rom. 2.13 That not the hearers or preachers of the law are just before God but the doers of the law shall be justified Brethren I am not such an enemie to the law but I can with freedome of spirit make use of that pertinent portion of Scripture unto you Jam. 2.8 9. If yee fulfill the royall law according to the Scripture Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thy selfe yee doe well But if ye have respect to persons in your censuring judging them And the same thing in effect delivered by one man shall be accounted sound by you and shall be a horrid error if delivered by another man ye commit since and are convinced of the law as transgressors 3 dly Looke seriously upon those words of Paul Rom. 5.20 The law was given that the offence might abound And then tell me whether there be not the same figure in my expression which is in Pauls And why may I not make use of a figurative expression as well as Paul expounding my meaning more plainly afterwards as he doth which I also did in my discourse Calvin saith that by these words Paul doth simply signifie the encreasing of the knowledge and pervicacy Designatur hic simpliciter incrementum notitiae et pervicaciae And another saith that it it said that it aboundeth by the law because it aboundeth in our knowledge of it ut abundare agnoscetur And will not this which is usually spoken upon this place by Expositors make our speech passeable too And as Paul saith that the Commandement which was to life he found to be unto death Rom. 7.10 So may not I say that the law which was for holy walking I found to cut off my legs because being under it I was no more able to walke in the way of it than a man is able to walke without legs I leave it to the spirituall man who judgeth all things 1 Cor. 2.15 to judge of this thing betweene us And that you may not any farther to the dishonour of God and your profession the prejudicing of the worke of the Lord in my Ministery vent forth slanders and reproachas against me I do professe that I am not conscious to my selfe of denying the use of the law in any way in which it is held forth in the new Testament But know that the law is good if a man use it lawfully Knowing this that the law is not made for a righteous man but for the lawlesse disobedient for the ungodly and for sinners for the unholy and prophane for murtherers of fathers and for man-slayers for whoremongers for perjured persons and lyars and if there be any other thing that is contrary to sound
sight of himselfe his sonne and grace the mouth of conscience is stopped and wee see all our sins swallowed up in his love Shew us the Father and it sufficeth us saith Philip. Joh. 14.8 When God sheweth us himselfe our spirits are at rest When Grace is discovered and Gods light doth shine upon the soule Sin death damnation cannot terrifie the soule But they are filled with a spirit of joy in beleeving their free justification who before through feare of death were subject to bondage Heb. 2.15 Grace appeareth greater and stronger to bring salvation then sinne powerfull to bring damnation Our sins the sins of all the man of the world being the acts of creatures are finite but grace that justifieth us is the grace of an infinite God and is boundlesse and infinite Men are unassured of their salvation unlesse this Grace be presented to the eye of their spirits And men and Devills cannot prevaile against us to enforce us to question our justification and salvation when wee looke upon it That peace which the world cannot take from us nor give unto us that joy which neither the Law nor the workes of the Law can convery unto us nor bereave us off that salvation which damned Feinds can never rob us of is communicated to us by the beholding of Gods grace in the face of the Lord Jesus The soule when it hath a sight of this grace it stands with boldnesse at the Throne of Grace and though it feele hellish sin in it selfe yet it is able to dispute with all the Divels in Hell and to maintaine the freenesse fulnesse and compleatnesse of its own justification from all sin by the grace of God in Jesus Christ If the Divell shall then suggest this to a man that he is a sinner The beleeving soule will make this answer It is true I am a sinner but I am not terrified to desparation because I am ungodly but I rejoyce in this that God justifieth the ungodly by his grace Rom. 4.5 If the Divell shall reply But thou art a great sinner and there is a great damnation The believing soule will returne I am not tormented by the great damnation prepared for great sinners but comforted by the great salvation Heb. 2.3 which is for the greatest and cheifest of sinners by Gods grace in Jesus Christ 1 Tim. 1.15 If the Divell shall still assault a man to perswade him that he is a damned soule having mispent his time and strength in the service of sin having no good workes to commend him unto God that he may finde favour from him The beleeving soule will be easily able in the strength of God when it is upon the mountaine of his Grace to silence the Accuser by lying downe in the lap of that God who maketh him the object of his Grace who worketh not for justification Rom. 4. but beleiveth in God who justifieth sinners in his Grace without workes And because wee are justified and comforted in the Court of our owne Consciences by grace The spirit which is given forth in the Ministry of the Gospel is called a spirit of grace It being the worke of the Spirit to reveale the grace of the Father for the comfort of his children according to that of the Apostle 2 Thess 2.16 17. Our Lord Iesus Christ himselfe and God even our Father which hath loved us and given us everlasting consolation and good hope through grace comfort your hearts Heere the Apostle sheweth us that the Saints have consolation and that this consolation is everlasting and that this everlasting consolation is only by grace Goe to all the true Saints in the world and aske them how they received the Comforter whether by the observation of moral precepts or by the doctrine of grace they will informe you that they received him by the Gospel of grace and not by the law of works Some Saints are able to acquaint you with their own experience can tell you how they laboured for holiness to bring them to happinesse to love God that they might assure themselves that they were in the love of God and that they found darknesse instead of expected light death instead of life horrour bondage instead of joy and liberty untill they were enabled to come unto God as sinners without workes disclaming their owne righteousnesse deserts and endeavours and laying the head-stone of their peace and happinesse in the free favour of God crying Grace Grace Zech 4 7. Exalting the free grace of God in their justification and overthrowing overturning their own works and legal righteousnesse It is grace and grace alone which bringeth salvation Tit 2.11 and therefore not our workes Grace and workes are inconsistent in this point of justification they can no more stand together then the Arke of God and Dagon Let grace stand up in its glory workes will quickly be overthrown and set up works and yee destroy the doctrine of grace By eternall grace wee were elected and made vessells of mercy from eternitie by grace we were saved before God in heaven in the presence of the Lord Iesus by grace wee were saved in the person of Christ before faith By the revelation of grace unto us through faith wee are saved in foro conscientiae in the Court of our owne consciences By grace salvation is inchoated here and compleated and perfected hereafter Rom. 6. ult The gift of God is cternall life through Jesu Christ our Lord. The word is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 which signifieth a gift flowing from Grace or free favour In these severall acceptations of the word grace we are saved by grace I might now lay downe many reasons for the proofe of this poynt but those which I gave to proove that wee are not justified by workes will bee sufficient for the confirmation of this And when I shall handle the doctrine of beleiving some reasons will fall in which will more fully illustrate this truth I shall therefore for the present onely present unto you a reason or two and hasten to the use 1 Reason First it being supposed that man is a sinner it is impossible that man should bee saved by any thing but by the knowledge of Grace The Law in this particular would not deale with us considering what good hath bin done by us but what evill And therefore when the Apostle had proved Bom. 3.23 that devout Jews as well as prophane Gentiles had sinned and come short of the glory of God he takes it for granted as a thing undeniable and unquestionable that wee are justified freely by his grace through the redemption that is in Iesus Christ And if we could bring our selves into a state of perfection after we have once sinned wee could not be justified by that perfection in us which is required by the Law but should be condemned for our sinnes and imperfections in breaking of the Law If a man have done good service for the Common-wealth and yet be found guilty
fearing our rejoycing our praying If so then are we in this working either perfect or imperfect Agents If perfect agents then is there no ignorance in our understandings no depravation in our wills no perversenesse in our affections The contrary whereof all the truly faithfull find by experience and the Scripture abundantly testifieth But if we be imperfect agents then cannot perfection come out of imperfection no effect can be better than its cause Ans 1 The efficiency of the first cause doth not take away the efficiency of the second cause In God we live move yet it is not God that moveth he though he moveth all things cannot be moved himself immobilis movens omnia Aug. So it is not God that repenteth but we repent The ignorance of which truth hath been the cause of the wicked mistery of Familisme which my soule abhorreth And therefore we shall agree in the truth which is implicitely laid down in the first part of your Dilemma 2ly Whereas you say that all the faithfull grant that man is an imperfect agent I answer that if we take perfect here in this point as it is opposed to that which is sinfull so many Saints doe grant and all should and will as more light is beamed into their soules grant it that the sanctified and spiritual man considered as farre forth as he is a spirituall man doth work as a perfect Agent not as an unholy but an holy man And therefore according to your rule his action must be spirituall and holy And this may give an answer to that argument which is brought from Job Who can bring a cleane thing out of an uncleane Job 14.4 3ly Whereas you say that no effect can be better than its cause c. This is not universally true A man imperfect by the want of his armes or legs may beget a childe which is perfect and hath its limbs But this not being much to the purpose I shall not contend about it Arg. 12. If the new man never sin Christ came not to save the new man for he came only to save sinners Answ The new man taken in this spirituall and theologicoll sence is not the object of salvation but an elect person guilty and sinfull in himselfe And the new creation is a blessed consequent of our redemption by Christ but I have sufficiently answered this before Arg. 13. That which is not in its owne nature agreeable to the holy law of God is not perfect and without sin for sin is the transgression or disagreement with the law of God 1 John 3.4 But the best of a regenerate mans actions are not agreeable to the law of God being not done with all the heart with all the soule with all the understanding and with all the strength Mat. 22.37 Deut. 6.5 Ans 1. By this argument you would bring the spirituall man to judge himselfe by the law or old covenant but hee is better taught by the Spirit And as hee doth not put his person under the old covenant so doth he not judge his actions by the old covenant but by the new covenant of grace According to that of the Apostle Gal. 5.18 If ye are led by the Spirit ye are not under the law And thus looking upon what is wrought by the Spirit under the new covenant he seeth it in its own nature agreeable to the law as it is delivered unto him in the hand of the Lord Jesus Not that Christ doth require lesse holinesse than is required in the old covenant but because he giveth us more grace enabling us to keepe his Commandements by the keeping of which we known in the light of the Spirit that we truly know him And the Commandements of Christ are kept by the Saints Evangelically two manner of wayes 1. By believing for justification 2. By holy walking for sanctification not that we can keep them by holy walking but as we walk in the light of our justification And thus he is as well able to keep the commandement of love as the commandement of faith Suppose a King should pardon a Traytor and should give him an assurance of pardon for all future Treason which he might run into and had power to enable him in some things and sometimes to be obedient unto him as a loyall Subject would you not say that this Subject were a loyall Subject all his trayterous acts forgiven and his loyall obedience to the command of his Soveraigne being accepted Thus it is between God and us He forgiveth all the treasons of the flesh and accepteth of the obedience of the spirit God doth account that all the commands of the Law are fulfilled by us when that which is not done is pardoned Omnia tunc facta deputantur cum id quod non fit ignoscitur which is true in a sense in reference to sanctification as well as to justification And a spirituall man thus looking upon himselfe in the glasse of the covenant of grace doth know that he is a keeper of the Commandements of God and can say with the Psalmist Ps 119.10 With my whole heart I have sought thee O let me not wander from thy Commandements All his defects and imperfections with the committing of evil and omitting good in the flesh are done away and that which is good is accounted so by the law of God as it is presented unto him in this Covenant So speake ye and so doe as they that shall be judged by the law of liberty saith James Jam. 2.12 As God doth judge our persons by the law of liberty or the law of the new Covenant so he doth judg our actions and thus they are perfect And the law of the new Covenant is not only faith for justification but love for sanctification And thus this place is expounded by the learned Paraeus Arg. 14. Paul did not think himself to have fully apprehended or to be already perfect but strove forward Phil. 3.12 13. which cannot be said of the olde man but only of the new man for the old man doth not strive forward for the prize of the high calling Answ Though Paul had not attained to that perfection which he looked for at the resurrection Yet hee had attained to a perfection of parts which is opposed to sinfulnesse Which doth appear by what followeth in the 15. vers of the same Chap. where he doth acknowledg the Saints in this sence to be perfect with which verse I shall put a period to my answers to your objections As many as be perfect be thus minded if in any thing ye be otherwise minded God shall reveale even this unto you Vse 2. The lessons which God hath taught me from these meditations have beene very powerfull by his grace for the convincing mee of sin in a Gospel-way and for the humbling of my soule under his mighty hand by seeing the huge masse of corruption which is in the flesh that little quantity of pure gold which is in the Spirit It
curse But for believers Christ was made a curse and hath freed them from the curse of the law Gal. 3.13 And therefore they are not lyable unto any punishment as it is a curse Arg. 9. Sin the cause of legall punishments being taken away the effects of it are taken away But Christ hath taken away finne which is the cause of legall punishments And therfore he hath taken away the effects which are legall punishments and therefore one speaking of the afflictions of Saints saith that they are medicines not punishments Medicinae non paena naturam obtinent The truth of this argument is built upon the known axiome The cause being taken away the effect is taken away Sublatâ causâ tollitur effectus Arg. 10. That being taken away which doth binde over a man to legall punishment the legall punishment is taken away But guilt which bindeth a man over to legall punishment is taken away And therefore the legall punishment is taken away Arg. 11. God doth as fully forgive us our trespasses as he would have us to forgive the trespasses of men against us But when we do forgive their trespasses we are not afterward to inflict any vindicative punishment upon them And therefore God doth so fully forgive us our trespasses that hee doth not afterward inflict any vindicative punishment This is the argument of a learned writer Deus debita nostra non minus gratuito et plene nobis dimittit quam docuit nos debitoribus nostris dimittere God saith he doth no lesse freely and sully forgive us our debts than he would have us to forgive our debters I might multiply sentences of Writers who with one consent do under-write to this truth Polanus saith That they who are temporally punished for sin here are to be punished to eternity Qui temporaliter puniuntur in aeternum puniendi sunt And that chastisement is not so much for the purging of sins past as to teach to avoid sin for the future Non adhibetur pro purgandis praeteritis peccatis sed pro futuris vitandis Pol. synt l. 6. c. 4. Willet hath many speeches to this purpose in his Synopsis Davenant writing on this point against the Papists saith what is it to remit the sin or the fault then not to punish a man any more for it Quid aliud est peccatum sive culpam remittere quam illud ad poenam hand amplius imputare But I study brevity knowing how distastfull long controversies are to the pallats of men of these times And therefore in few words to put a period to what I intend to speak concerning the first branch of this Article I conceive that man may be considered two manner of wayes First as hee is in the first Adam and so all afflictions are properly punishments and curses of the law unto him 2 dly In the second Adam and thus the nature of afflictions and chastisements for sinne are changed unto him The sting is taken out of death and every affliction Afflictions are benedictions to him Afflictiones benedictiones Bern. Not curses but blessings unto him And therefore 2 ly God will chasten his justified people in his fatherly love to them and displeasure against sinne that they may be partakers of his holinesse Heb. 12.10 by the spirit of sanctification as they are partakers of Christs righteousnesse in their Justification which maketh true Saints not only to beare afflictions patiently but to glory in tribulation Rom. 5.3 And though in a sence they are afflicted neither for sin that it is not to satisfie Gods justice which is already satisfied by Jesus Christ nor from sin as some speak for the blood of Jesus Christ cleanseth us from all sin Yet God doth afflict us that in the afflictions he may powre forth his Spirit upon us for the removing of sin out of our spirits which doth grieve his Spirit and out of our conversations which doth dishonour his name And for the preventing of sinne for the future the Prodigall will take heed how hee doth runne from his Fathers house when hee hath beene among the Swine And the soule beloved of Christ when she is forsaken of all lovers and in misery will resolve to returne unto her first love and say for then was it better with me than now Hos 2.7 And thus much briefly by way of answer to the first branch of this Article The second branch of this article is this That the Land is not punished for the sins of Gods people What hath been spoken concerning the precedent branch of this Article for the clearing of this As no legall punishment properly so called can be inflicted upon the person of a believer for his sinne so no punishment can be inflicted upon the Land in which he liveth for his sinnes Yet I doe not deny but that God who punisheth the unjustified persons of a land in his wrath for their rebellions and transgressions may chastise some of his people by a nationall calamity and affliction for their humiliation and reformation But though in a nationall visitation the same affliction if it be materially considered may be laid upon a believer which is laid upon unbelievers yet the affliction which is laid upon a Saint is formally distinguished from that which is inflicted upon unjustified persons the one flowing from the love of a Father the other from the wrath of an enemie The least of these is properly materially formally a legall punishment the other materially a judgment or punishment but formally a fatherly chastisement and a pledg of Gods love to a Saint Sect. 5. THere is yet one Article more which the Subscribers have taken out of Mr. Gataker page 16. That if a man by the Spirit know himselfe to be in the state of grace though hee be drunke or commit murther God sees no sinne in him If I should but name the man who brought in this Article against me it were enough to acquit me from the charge in the judgment of those who know him But I am resolved that the world shall see that I study not revenge but the clearing and vindication of truth in my answer When one in the Star-chamber demanded of me whether an Article something like unto this were my tenet and whether I had delivered it in such words I did reply that I might affime of it what Martiall did of his poem that it was his as made composed and delivered by him but it ceased to be his and became the repeaters when it was evilly repeated by another Sed male dum recitas incipit esse tuum So the truth contained in this Article to wit That God sees no sinne in his justified children in the sence in which I delivered it it is my tenet or rather Gods truth But while it is repeated with some words of the accuser to bring an odium upon the truth and that being not mentioned which was largely laid downe in my discourse to give light unto it I doe affirm that
in Christ And so the Apostle saith Tit. 3.5 Not by workes of righteousnesse which wee have done but according to his mercy he saved us that is according to his eternall mercy and grace he shewed favour and compassion to us and pardoned our sins And the expression of the Apostle is worth observing Epes 1.4 where speaking of the eternall grace of God hee saith That God placed his grace upon us that wee should be holy and without blame before him in love He doth not say that God elected us because wee would be holy and without blame but He elected us that wee might be holy and without blame before him in love good workes are not the cause but the consequents of Grace Nay I add more that as God did not foresee our good workes so not our faith neither faith is not the cause of grace but grace is the cause of faith God therefore enables us to believe in time because God loved us from eternity The Apostle speaking of them of Achaia saith that they believed through grace and Apollos helped them much that believed through grace Acts 18.27 It is by grace that we beleeve it is not by faith that we are made partakers of Grace Thus we are saved by grace in the purpose of God from eternity in the eye and sight of God who seeth all things absent as if they were present and speakes of things before they are done as if they were done In the next place grace in Scripture is confidered not onely as it is in God and as it is as eternall as God himselfe but the Scripture speaks of the grace of God as it is manifested forth to us in Jesus Christ and so wee are saved by Grace God discovering his grace to us in his Sonne Jesus Christ So the Apostle speaking of grace 2 Tim. 1.10 saith But now is manifested to us by the appearing of our Saviour Jesus Christ who hath abolished death and hath brought life and immortality to light through the Gospel Hee speakes first of grace as it is in God and as it is as eternall as God himselfe then he speakes of eternall grace manifested to us in the Gospel of his deare Sonne It is by the preaching of the Gospel that the eternall grace of the Father in the Sonne is made known to us And this grace is called sometimes the Grace of God the Father Rom. 1.7 Sometimes it is called the grace of Jesus Christ and sometimes the grace of them both because Jesus Christ is God one God in one divine essence with his Father And as God in his grace is said to forgive sinnes Mica 7. who is a God like unto thee that pardoneth sin saith the Prophet So Jesus Christ is said to forgive sinnes the Apostle bids us to forgive one another as Christ hath forgiven us Col. 3.13 As there is grace in the Father to forgive sinnes so there is the same grace in the Sonne The Apostles doubted not but that they should be saved by the grace of Christ as well as those that were circumcised Act. 15.7 And by this grace we are saved God discovering now his grace to us in his Sonne Jesus Christ the eternall Sonne of the eternall Father This grace in Scripture is made known to us as the sole cause of our justification and salvation Grace is so held forth for justification that all things besides grace are excluded Wee are justified by grace exclusively all other things being shut out When God justifieth a man he eyes that man onely in his owne grace and when God justifieth a man in the Court of his owne Conscience he strips him of all his own workes of his owne love to him and to the brethren and gives him onely a sight of owne grace This grace doth exclude all merit if there were any merit in the creature man could not be saved by Grace the Apostle cleares it to us by that passage Rom. 4.4 To him that worketh the reward is not reckoned of grace but of debt If a man could worke or merit any thing toward his justification and salvation then it were not of grace saith the Apostle the reward is not of grace but of debt If a man worke then he expects wages as due to him he may by right and justice clayme what he deserves so if wee did worke for salvation wee might require God to bestow and give us what wee had wrought for But true grace shuts out all merit and workes in the creature if we could bring any merit of the creature to joyne with his grace grace should be no more grace as the Apostle Rom. 11.6 If wee looke upon Grace as it is in God so before God wee were saved in his eternall thoughts he in his own purpose and Grace having elected us to justification and eternall salvation in Glory by his Sonne Jesus Christ Yet he never holds forth his Grace to us but in the countenance of his Sonne Jesus Christ in whom the glory of his justice shines bright with the glory of his grace He shewes us that he hath laid all our sins on his Sonne that his justice hath received full satisfaction from the sufferings of his Sonne for all our sinnes and so comes to discover his grace to us in the pardon and forgivenesse of our sinnes Thus Christ and the Apostles constantly in their preaching discovered the grace of the Father in the Son As our Saviour to Nicodemus God so loved the world that he gave his onely begotten Sonne that whosoever beleeveth on him should not perish Joh. 3. And the Apostle to his Corinthians God was in Christ reconciling the world to himselfe 2 Cor. 5. God doth not make knowne his love for the forgivenesse of sinne but by Jesus Christ I confesse that wee are saved by grace in respect of God before wee know the Grace of God in Jeius Christ But wee cannot see this grace untill wee behold it in the face of the Lord Jesus Wee behold the love of God in giving the Lord Jesus to be the atonement sacrifice and propitiation for our sins before wee can read the everlasting love and favour of the Father to us in his Sonne Eternall love is the primarie cause of our salvation and justification but it cannot be apprehended by us untill we apprehend in the first place our Redemption in Jesus Christ And when Christ is embraced as a Saviour in the Armes of Faith wee rise higher in our thoughts by the power of the Spirit and are brought to look upon the eternity of love And have liberty to read every line in his eternall volume which doth concerne our eternall life and salvation and are fully confirmed in the point of Gods eternall election without the prevision of good works which should be wrought by the Creature As the Apostle doth prove at large in the 9th to the Romans And if any man will dispute or rather cavill against this truth I shall say with the Apostle Rom.
9.20 O man who art thou that repliest against God who hath mercy on whom be will have mercy and whom he will he hardeneth And though men unacquainted with this truth may account this rather a shift or evasion then an answer to their carnall objections against election and reprobation yet I shall not be ashamed of my answer It is an excellent Speech of Augustine Christs great Champion against Antigratians in his time Absit ut pudeat nos hoc respondere quod respondisse videmus Apostolum Far be it from us to be ashamed to give the same answer which was given by the Apostle Who art thou that repliest against God c. In the next place wee are to consider that in Scripture salvation is taken either negatively or affirmatively And take salvation in either of these acceptions And it will be evident that wee are saved by grace In the first place if we take salvation negatively as it is a deliverance or freedome from all evill and in this sence wee are freed from evill onely by grace It is a true rule Gratiam Christi nihil praecedit humani Nothing in man doth precede or prevent the Grace of God The light and beames of Grace do dispell the clouds of our sins Not for our sakes but for his Name sake he covereth our sins It is Gods prerogative to free us from sin by Grace and to remove them far from us Psal 103.12 As far as the East is from the West so far he removed our transgressions from us He onely can remove sin against whom it is committed He onely can cast sin into the depths of the Sea who hath an Ocean of Grace in himselfe in which he swalloweth them up Micah is spiritually transported beyond himselfe in admiring this incommunicable prerogative of the God of Grace Micah 7.18 Who is a God like unto thee that pardoneth iniquity c And who can think that he will part with this priviledge which is his delight For so it followeth in the same verse He retaineth not his anger for ever because he delighteth in mercy Secondly If wee take salvation affirmatively for the instating of men into a condition and enjoyment of all happiness and felicity so wee are saved by grace Wee are made happy brought from a cursed condition into a blissfull condition from horror to joy from hell to heaven from the state of nature to the state of Glory onely by the grace of God It is onely by Grace that wee are what wee are By Grace our sins are pardoned by Grace wee have an inheritance with the Saints by Grace wee are the high born sonnes of the great King of heaven and earth by Grace wee are blessed and loaded with all spirituall and temporall blessings in Jesus Christ and are brought to the enjoyment of eternall felicity happinesse and blissfulnesse Thus wee are saved by grace and by grace alone One of the Ancients doth speake excellently to this purpose Nemo se palpet de suo Satanas est de deo beatus est quid est enim de suo nisi peccatum suum Let no man boast of himselfe for of a mans selfe he is a Devill by God a man is made happy What is a man of himselfe but sin Yee are saved by grace Againe salvation in Scripture is taken for salvation before God in the Court of heaven And it is taken for the saving of a partie in his own spirit and conscience if wee take it in the first sence a man is saved in the Court of heaven onely by grace What is the Reason that the accusing mouth of the Law being stopped no Bill no enditement can be brought against the Elect in the Court of Heaven Is it not this because God in his grace justifieth them This is the Apostles argument Rom. 8.33 Who shall lay any thing to the charge of Gods Elect It is God that justifieth them 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 who can implead or bring an action against them before God for breaking his Law He that is the Judge of the Elect is their justifier Grace hath cast out of Heaven the accuser of the Brethren which accused them before God night and day Rev. 12.10 The accuser can bring no enditement complaint or accusation against the Saints there There is no sin in our consciences that can be heard to accuse us in heaven because there is grace for our justification God beholds his Sonne Jesus Christ before his eye upon whom he hath laid all our sins The bloud of Christ doth with powerfull and undeniable arguments plead for those for whom it was shed The straying and stragling sheep which are within the reach of Gods eternall Grace cannot be condemned because the good Shepheard hath given his life for the sheep Joh. 10.11 God knoweth that he hath received satisfaction before hand for their sins by the hand of the Lord Jesus who is not now to pay any thing but hath already made payment for all their debts and is become the Mediator of the new Covenant of Grace which is sealed in his own bloud under which Covenant upon this consideration there can be no remembrance of sin Heb. 10.14 God beholding his Elect in their propitiation and alwayes hearing the sweet voice of their wrath-appeasing advocate making an heavenly melody in his eares And alwayes beholding our happinesse before himselfe in heaven lying wrapt up in his own grace doth acquaint us in his word of truth That wee are saved by grace Secondly If we take salvation in the other sence for salvation in our spirits and consciences and in this sence we are saved by grace There can be no salvation brought home to our hearts but by the sight of grace If wee had the sanctification of all the Saints which have lived since the fall of Man and should looke upon it all as ours to give comfort to our soules and to assure us that wee are in a state of salvation and should not looke above it to behold Gods grace and our sanctification in it and from it it would not give us any solid comfort or assurance of our falvation Nothing can shine in the heart to give it any comfort but what doth shine and give light in the light and beames of this grace Wee never come to see our selves in a condition of safety till wee see the grace of God Looke unto mee and be saved all the ends of the earth for I am God and there is none else Isaiah 45.22 None but God can save us and nothing but the sight of God can bring salvation to us Still wee have some objection or other against salvation and justification till God silence all objections by the sight of his own grace There is that onely in God and in Jesus Christ that will silence all objections If our conscience flie in our faces and tell us that wee have committed many thousands of sins more then wee can reckon or number up yet when God gives us a
consideration that if there were any thing in the reason or understanding of man which might further him in this work of faith then it would follow that those men who are the most acute men the most learned men the wisest and most rationall men would prove the best Christians and the most faithful men but we finde it quite contrary There are none commonly more ignorant of Christ then they who are most learned The worlds wise-man is Gods foole It were an easie matter to prove this by running over the severall ages of the world It was the complaint of a good man long since The unlearned saith hee doe arise and take â—eaven by force while we learned men are cast 〈◊〉 hell surgunt indocti rapiunt coelum â—um nos docti detrudimur ad gehennam but I snail confine my selfe to Scripture This is proved 1 Cor. 1.26 27. You see your calling brethren how that not many wise men after the flesh not many mighty not many noble are called But God hath chosen the foolish things of the world to confound the wise and the weake things of the world to confound the things which are mighty The wise men and great men of the world have not generally embraced Christ but rather the worlds fools have been made wise by the knowledge of him The learned Pharisees did reproach Christ and his Doctrine with this Ioh. 7.48 Have any of the Rulers or Pharisees beleeved on him but this people who knoweth not the Law are cursed They looked upon his followers as a cursed company of ignorant people unacquainted with the Law which they taught for Justification and supposed that the Rulers and Pharisees had so much wit wisedome and learning that they would give no credite to his Doctrine Therefore seeing those who are most learned wise and acute by rationall parts gifts and abilities are commonly most averse and opposite to the knowledge of the Gospell it follows that it is not by any thing that is in the reason or understanding of man by which one man is made more capable of faith then any other man but God giveth the gift of faith freely to whom hee pleaseth The fourth may be drawne from the consideration of persons before their conversion as they are descyphered to us and characterized forth in the word of truth The Scripture calls them dead men they are rather Carkasses then men they have the shapes of living men but they are but dead men No more then a Carkasse is a man no more is an unconverted man a man in the scriptures sence As a dead man is able to do nothing to regain life so we who are dead in sins and trespasses are able to doe nothing towards our own conversion This phrase we have in the precedent words Eph. 2.1 You hath he quickned that were dead in sins and trespasses And the same Apostle saith Coll. 2.13 That when we were dead in sins and the uncircumcision of our flesh that then God quickned us with his Son having forgiven us all our trespasses A dead man heares nothing sees nothing there is no motion in him at all so it is with a man that is dead in sins he heares not the things of grace hee heares but he heares not hee sees not the things of grace he sees and he sees not hee is not able to move one foote by faith toward heaven and happinesse Unbelieving men are dead if wee view them in reference to the principle of life or the faculties of a living man or the operations of life Christ is the principle of life Colos 3.3 When Christ who is your life shall appeare then yee also shall appeare with him in glory They are without Christ and therefore without a principle of life 2ly In reference to faculties which are in living men they are dead Faculties are known and distinguished by their acts operations Potentiae distinguuntur et cognoscuntur per actus And therefore wee may speak of these two joyntly and together As in a living man there are faculties and operations of life So there are faculties and operations of life in a man who is spiritually alive Hee is nourished 1 Pet. 2.2 groweth Psal 22.6 heareth seeth smelleth Cant. 1.3 tasieth the sweetnesse of Christ and the like but it is not so with one dead in sin and unbeliefe hee hath no spirituall faculties and operations of life he lyeth rotting in the grave of sin without these If wee play upon Instruments of Musicke or shoot off guns in his eares he heareth it not If God thunders from sin in the Law or commeth from Zion with the musicke of the Gospell he heareth it not Refusing to live to God by faith in Christ he is dead Qui titi recusat vivere mortuus est August Men without Christ take them in their best estate and thus it is with them with his morall embellishments and ornaments he is but like a dead body stuck with flowers or an embalmed carkasse The whole world of unbelievers is but a Golgotha or Charnel-house of drye bones The man that wandreth out of the way of understanding shall remaine in the Congregation of the dead Pro. 2.6 Though thou art a professor of Christ yet without Christ thou art dead 1 Tim. 5.6 The Widow that professeth Christ living in pleasure is dead while she liveth As Seneca passing by the house of an Epicure said Hic situs est He that liveth here is dead and buryed here So we may say of all prophane men ignorant men civilized men without Christ formalized professors they are there dead where they live And being dead who will so far lay aside his reason to affirme that they are able to quicken themselves to a spirituall life Againe as the Scripture sets them out to us as dead men so the Scripture presents them to us as men that are in a sleep Wee have this expression Ephes 5.14 Awake thou that sleepest and arise from the dead and Christ shall give thee light The knowledge that a man hath of Jesus Christ before his conversion it is rather as the dreame and fancy of a sleeping man then the true knowledge of a waking man A man may dream he is a King thinkes that he hath all the riches in the world but when he awakes he hath nothing because he did but dreame that hee was rich So it is with men that have a knowledge of Christ but not wrought in their hearts by the operation of the spirit they may be in a dreame and have false perswasions that Christ is theirs that heaven is theirs with all the glorious things of eternity but they are but beggars and poor slaves all the while They are likewise compared to mad men who may think that they are Monarchs and in a Palace when they are miserable creatures chained in a Bedlam So carnal men may have false perswasions concerning their happinesse but true faith is only wrought by the spirit of truth And as
words though I know that there are many adversaries and opposers of this truth 2 Cor. 4.13 We believe therefore we speak saith the Apostle So I doe in spirit belive what I shall speake and therefore I am resolved to speake it forth plainly and you are engaged to heare me patiently The words are a conclusion drawn from preceding premises In the precedent words the Apostle delivered two propositions First That hee that committeth sinne is of the Devill Secondly That Christ hath appeared to destroy the workes of the Devill from whence he concludeth that he which is born of God cannot sin not having his being in the Devill but in Christ who destroyeth sin In this verse there are these particular observations which at the first view may present themselves unto us 1. A character of a true Christian He is one who is borne of God 2. The property of this man who is borne of God He doth not commit sin 3. A reason why he cannot commit sin to wit because his seed remaineth in him 4. His purity He doth not only not commit sinne but he sinneth not at all 5. This asserted by laying down the impossibility of his sinning 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 He cannot possibly sinne 6. This is further proved by his excellent glorious condition He cannot sin because he is borne of God First From the person who is here spoken of The man who is borne of God We may take notice of the folly and Bedlam-madnesse of some who would be accounted professors and Preachers of a spirituall Gospel whose Gospel and mystery of error doth make the man born of God to be God Confounding the glorious nature of the Father Word and Spirit with the new Creature The Apostle doth plainly overthrow this Bedlam-Divinity by these expressions In which hee doth make a difference between God and the man who is born of him That which is born of God is borne in time But God is from eternity And therefore that which is born of God cannot be God The place which they pervert is in the 1 Cor. 6.17 He which is joyned to the Lord is one spirit Answ Christ and the man joyned unto him are one not by confounding of the person of Christ with the person of a Believer but by the union of these two in the Spirit As the members are one with the head and yet the head is not the members nor the members the head Secondly In this objection as they destroy the personall being of a Believer so they destroy the personall being of Christ as he is the Word made flesh There Christ is nothing but God they apprehending that Christ hath offered up his humane nature wisedome and righteousnesse as things of the first creation and that hee hath no being now but in spirit which they call Christ in the Spirit the spirituall man or God I shall therefore in few words deliver the truth of God concerning the man who is born of God This phrase is taken first largely and so every Creature may be said to be of God because every creature is the workmanship of God and hath its being from God And in this sence all wicked men are called the Off-spring of God Acts 17.28 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Secondly It is taken strictly And so it is to be understood not of those who have their being from God by creation but by spirituall regeneration And thus it is here taken and in other places John 3.5 Except a man be borne of water the Spirit he cannot enter into the kingdome of God John 1 13. In this sence neither God Christ or the Spirit are the new man or the man born of God But the speciall and gracious presence of God through Christ by the spirit doth make a man a new Creature 1 Cor. 1.30 John 1.13 2 Cor. 5.17 If any man is in Christ he is a new Creature He doth not say that if any man is in Christ that then hee is Christ or that Christ is the new creature but that man who is in Christ he is the new creature Having shewed you who the new man or the man born of God is who is here spoken of and freed the Text from famelisticall blasphemies I shall desire that you may be acquainted with this truth Every true Saint is a man born of God 1 Consid It will not advantage a man to make a profession of Christ and to submit to all the outward Ordinances of Christ unlesse a man be made a new creature by Christ Gal. 6.15 In Christ Jesus neither Circumcision availeth any thing nor uncir cumcision but a new creature We must be borne againe or else it had been better for us never to have been borne Christ will not own any for his or approve them as his Disciples whatsoever prosession they doe make of him unlesse he be formed in them 2 Cor. 13.5 Know ye not that Jesus Christ is in you except ye be unapproved They are the Devils children who are not borne of God John 8.44 2 Consid God hath engaged himselfe in the Covenant of grace that those who are his shall be borne of him Ezek. 36.26 A new heart will I give you and a new spirit will I put within you and will take away the stony heart out of your flesh and give you an heart of flesh As a Carver when he maketh an Image doth begin at the outside of the Timber and cuts shaves and smooths that So hypocrites doe begin at the outside and doe smooth themselves in their outward conversation to men-ward And so there is but an image insteed of a new creature But true Saints are made new inwardly Some say that the heart is the first thing which hath life Cor est primum vivens It is true in the new creation God doth give unto the vessels of his grace new hearts Rom. 10.10 With the heart man believeth unto righteousnesse Jer. 32.39 3. Consid Men who are not borne of God cannot haue fellowship with God If we say that we have fellow ship with him and walk in darknesse we lye 1 John 1.6 But true Saints have fellowship with the Father and his Sonne Jesus Christ 1 John 1.3 And therefore they are borne of God 4 Consid God is to be known served and worshipped by true Saints but we cannot truly know him serve or worship him so long as we are old creatures in the state of nature and therefore it cannot be denyed that true Saints are borne of him An old creature is spiritually dead and cannot see God A dead creature cannot performe the actions of a living creature And a sinner cannot serve the living God and performe that spirituall worship which God doth require of those who are quickned to spirituall worship by Jesus Christ 5. Consid The new Heaven and the new Earth is only provided for new creatures but it is provided for Saints and they expect it 2 Pet. 3.13 And therefore they are borne
believing from a dunghill to a Throne from everlasting wrath to never-ending glory and immortality I might speak more fully of this concerning which no man can speak sufficiently But my intention was not to speak of this but rather of that which is principally intended in the words to shew you the sinlesse condition of the man which is borne of God And therefore give me leave to leave this point that I may briefly open the words which follow in the Text that so I may draw the marrow and substance of them into a short conclusion the illustration confirmation and amplification of which by the grace of God shall be the subject of my ensuing discourse I doe finde that the godly-learned doe not agree in their expositions of these words I shall therefore acquaint you with their severall expositions and shall enlarge my thoughts in the amplifying of that which I doe apprehend in truth to be the meaning of the Apostle in these words First Some say that he cannot commit sin That is Non potest operam dare peceate He cannot make sin his work trade or employment and this is a truth The rode of prophanesse and wilfull sinning hath never been the way in the which the Saints have walked Their path is the path of purity and uprightnesse But this doth not seeme to be the meaning of the Spirit in this place For the Apostle doth not only say that he cannot commit sin but hee cannot sin Secondly Others say that he cannot commit sin as a servant of sin As though our Saviours words were a sufficient exposition of these Joh. 8.34 Whosoever committeth sinne is a servant of sin 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 He doth not doe sin as his worke as a servant doth work by the appointment and commandement of his Master I question not the truth of this Sinne shall not have dominion where Christ is Lord and Master in the soule He taketh our soules in unto himselfe by conquest and will not suffer those who commanded us before his conquest to rule over us now he hath subdued them As a conquering King will not suffer conquered Rebels to command his Subjects But the Apostle doth not seeme to drive only at this because as it hath been observed he saith afterwards that he cannot sin Thirdly Some say that he cannot sinne because he cannot commit the unpardonable sin And these goe as far as the end of the Epistle for an exposition Chap. 5.17.18 All iniquity is sinne and there is a sinne not unto death Wee know that whosoever is borne of God sinneth not But hee that is borne of God keepeth himselfe and the wicked one toucheth him not Thus they affirme that he finneth not because hee sinneth not unto death This which they say is likewise an undenyable truth in it selfe but not all that the Apostle intendeth in these words Which will evidently appear if we look seriously upon the precedent words Where the Apostle doth set downe the Antithesis and opposition between the man borne of God and the naturall man And doth make this the characteristical difference between the man borne of God and the man of the Devill vers 6 7 8. That the one doth sinne and the other doth not sinne Every one that abideth in him sinneth not he that sinneth hath not known him or seene him And as no man will say that the difference in this place between the carnall and spirituall man is this That the one doth not commit the unpardonable sinne and the other doth For then this absurdity will necessarily follow that every carnall man doth commit the unpardonable sin For the Apostle saith that every carnal man is of the Devill and sinneth that is against the holy Ghost if we take their exposition So no man may affirme that this is the meaning of these words which are laid downe in way of opposition to the precedent that he that committeth not sin doth not commit the unpardonable sin for then this absurdity will follow that every man who committeth not the unpardonable sin is born of God And this is evident by the subsequent words where he saith vers 10. That in this the children of God and the children of the Devill are manifested To wit that the one doth not commit sin and the other doth commit sin Take the words according to their exposition and this is the sence of them In this the Saints and carnall men are distinguished that the Saints doe not commit the unpardonable sin and that all carnall men doe commit the unpardonable sin Of the absurdity of which tenet contrariety to Scripture and daily experience I leave the spirituall man a judge 4. Others say that he sinneth not That is in his justified state and condition he sinneth not Because he is free from sin and the condemnation of the Law And this is a truth likewise full of comfort and sweetnesse That the believer or man borne of God doth not sin in reference to justification Their meaning is that there is no sin from which a believer is not justified But the Apostle doth not speake only of this for he speaketh of his working of righteousnesse by love in this place and through the whole Epistle as well as of believing And of such workes which Saints are to doe by which they may be justified before men as these men doe grant themselves and therefore this is not to be taken so strictly in reference to our justification through faith only As these words do declare it sufficiently Every one that worketh not righteousnesse is not of God and hee that loveth not his brother vers 10. Doth he pray for such whom he thought were no where to be found or for all true Saints whom he did know did love the Lord Jesus in corruption Reply If they be considered as they ought to be done so they are not evill but as they be done by us So the holy Ghost is not affraid to call them menstruous rags even our very righteousnesse not our old man only Isa 64.6 from the better part And therefore the Scripture doth call us Saints or holy men Ephes 1. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 because we are spiritually regenerated or made new creatures though much of the flesh doth remaine in the best of us And this I doe apprehend to be the meaning of God in this place So Cajetan upon the words Hee doth saith he understand it formally that is in as much as he is borne of God for our new creation from God doth not suffer us to sin Intelligit formaliter hoc est quatenus ex Deo natus Nativitas enim ex Deo non dat peccare So likewise that faithfull Martyr Tyndall speaketh in the opening of these words God and the Devill are two contrary Fathers two contrary fountaines two contrary causes the one of all goodnesse the other of all evill And they that doe evill are borne of the Devill and are first evill by that birth before they
A new heart will I give you and a new spirit will I put within you and I will take away the stony heart out of your flesh and will give you an heart of flesh And I will put my Spirit within you and cause you to walke in my Statutes and ye shall keepe my judgements and doe them The new heart of flesh is a good soile And because God doth promise his Spirit and a new heart therefore see what shall follow the good fruit spoken of We shall keep his judgements and doe them Arg. 2. God cannot be the Author worker of that which is sin but God doth professe himselfe to bee the Author of good workes wrought in the Saints and therefore these workes are not sin Isa 26.12 The Saints doe profes that God hath wrought all their works in them And this likewise is the argument of the Apostle who doth prove that doing of evill is sinne because it is of the Devill and that working of righteousnesse is good because it is of God Object These things are not sinne in their whole morall nature but per accidens by accident through the defect of some circumstance Answ Every morall action commanded or forbidden of God is either good or evill If these are good and no sinne then I have what I contend for If evill acquit God from being the author of evill who doth professe himselfe to be the Author of these things in opposition to Satan and his workes If you say that they are neither good nor evill or both good and evill and prove it by Scipture I shall hearken unto you But you say they are sin by accident and if they are so by accident they are sin and still you make God the Author of sin but I affirme that they are neither sin in their nature nor by accident but good and therefore untill you prove what you say I doe not see but that my argument is unshaken by this objection Object 2. Faith and love in their whole morall abstract nature are not sin but considered in the Concrete and acted by us Answ The Apostle doth speake of them in the Concrete as acted by us and doth bid us try our selves by our faith love and working of righteousnesse and saith vers 19. That hereby we assure our selves before God therefore this distinction is of no validity in this place though some thinke that it will answer all our arguments Argu. 3. The olde man and the new man are distinguished by their contrary natures and operations But if the new man were sinfull and his operations sinfull The new man would be confounded with the old man who is sinfull in himselfe and his operations but this is contrary to Scripture The old man is corrupt according to deceitfull lusts but the new man after God is created in righteousnesse and true holinesse Eph. 4.22.24 And speaking of these in the Concrete as in us Eph. 5.8 9. he saith to them Ye were sometimes darknesse but now are ye light in the Lord walke as children of the light For the fruit of the Spirit is in all goodnesse and righteousnesse and truth Argu. 4. Those works which are commended by Jesus Christ for good works are good works but the workes of the Saints are commended for good works therefore they are good Revel 2.2 Our Saviour saith that he knoweth the workes of the Angel of the Church of Ephesus and his labour and patience that is he approveth or commendeth his workes and so Rev. 3.8 It would be a disparagement to the judgment of Christ to commend sin or sinfull works for good workes And therefore I conclude that they were good works And by consequence that the works which are wrought by a man borne of God are good works Obj. They were washed from their pollution in the blood of the Lamb. Answ When we speak of the new man and his works we look not upon him or his works but in Jesus Christ And thus he is washed from all the sins of the flesh and the works of God in us are well pleasing unto God the worker through Jesus Christ through whom hee did work them in us Arg. 5. Christ doth not present that which is sinne or sinfull to the Father to be accepted but he presentech our workes 1 Pet. 2.5 Wee offer up spirituall sacrifice acceptable to God by Jesus Christ If Christ did present any work that were sinfull he might present our sinful works It is evident therefore that there is something which is good which is presented as well as something in us which is sinfull which is forgiven Malum ex quolibet desectu The lesse defect doth make a thing evil and if there be such a defect in the work of the man who is born of God to make it sin and evill what reason can any man give from Scripture why every sinne should not be presented and accepted as well as those sins which they call good works Arg. 6. The Scripture calleth the works of the man born of God neither sinfull or sinne but works of righteousnesse Faith is called righteousnesse Rom. 4. and Rom. 5. the last Paul calleth the sincerity which was in him speaking of it in the Concrete godly sincerity 2 Cor. 1.12 Paul prayeth that grace may be with all them who love the Lord Jesus in corruption 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Doth he pray for such whom hee thought were no where to be found or for all true Saints whom he did know did love the Lord Jesus in incorruption Reply If they be considered as they ought to be done so they are not evill but as they be done by us so the holy Ghost is not affraid to call them menstruous rags even our very righteousnesse not our old man only Isa 64.6 Answ The Prophet doth not speak here of the righteousness of a man under the Covenant of grace considered under that Covenant For in the precedent verse he doth acknowledge that the righteousnesse of such a man is not as a menstruous ragge Thou meetest him that rejoyeth and worketh righteousnesse But he speaketh of men as looked upon under the olde Covenant and of their works as done under and to be judged by that Covenant which appeareth by the following words Our iniquities like the wind have taken us away And there is none that calleth upon thy Name that stirreth up himself to take hold of thee For thou hast hid thy face from us and we are consumed because of our iniquities We must not judge of this truth by expressions which holy men have made use of in confessing the sins of the whole nation of the Jews in the language of the Jewish nationall Covenant but by those passages of Scripture in which God doth speake of a man as under the Covenant of grace with his works wrought by the spirit of grace 7 Arg. God doth remember the workes of his Saints Heb. 6.10 God is not unrighteous to forget your worke and labour of
thy sight But suppose wee should grant you this it doth still stand true that our service is in holinesse and righteousnesse And can any man be so blinde to thinke that a man shall serve in righteousnesse under Gods protection that hee should not see the righteousnesse which iâ— wrought under his protection and if it be righteousnesse which he seeth then it is righteousnesse before him or in his sight Arg. 15. To deny the purity of the man born of God is to deny one end for which Christ dyed for Christ dyed to bring us to be partakers of a pure Divine nature in which pure nature we are to live move and act holily The place by which I shall confirme this is in Heb. 9.14 The blood of Christ who through the eternall spirit offered himselfe without spot God shall purge our consciences from dead workes to serve the living God We are therefore washed from sin in our Justification that we may serve God by Sanctification And what spirituall man will call that the service of God which is sin or sinfull For to doe that which is sin or sinfull is to doe the Devils service or else I am to learne that which we need not be taught to wit what it is to doe the Devils service Arg. 16. The resurrection of Christ doth teach spirituall men to act purely in their new nature to the glory of their Father Rom. 6.4 As Christ was raised from the dead by the glory of the Father so we should walke in newnesse of life To walk in newnesse of life is it to walk in the oldnesse of that which is sin or sinfull let any Spirituall man judge Arg. 17. We may draw another argument from the Kingly office of Christ He as a King hath a command over his Subjects but he hath not the command over us when we doe that which is sin or sinfull and therefore wee doe something good as his Subjects in obedience to his commands bona bene Good things must be done well And therefore Christ doth not onely enable us to doe that which is righteous but hee doth enable us to doe it righteously Why is Christ King but that we should live under his commands Why are we his subjects why are we his servants but because wee are under his commands and under his laws You know the Jewes said they would not have Christ to be their King but the voyce of every Christian is to cry up Christ to proclaime him King and to owne him only as their Ruler And Christ being King rules and reigns in the hearts of his people by lawes and commandements and precious statutes worthy of such a King Now Christ gives us not a law as Moses gave a law that was grievous to those that heard it but Christ gives a law of love a lawâ— of sweetnesse by which hee rules in the midst of his enemies in our hearts what is in the flesh in us is an enemie to Jesus Christ but Christ Jesus sitting upon his Throne as King in our renewed regenerated and enlightned spirit rules in the midst of our sins his enemies which oppose him Christ is not such a King as other Kings other Kings make lawes and adde penalties to their laws for those that break them but they have no power to enable their Subjects to keep them But here is the priviledge and prerogative of our King when Christ makes lawes he doth not only give us lawes and bid us keepe them but he hath power in himselfe by which he enableth us to do that which he commands us to doe If Christ should command us to love should not enable us to doe that which he commands he should be such a Law-giver as Moses that gave a Law but gave no power to doe it But Christ is not such a Law-giver as Moses As he is not a rigid Law-giver to bid Saints doe it upon penalty of damnation or to worke for life and salvation so neither is he like Moses who could give them no power but there is a power and strength goes with Christs commands to enable us to doe what Christ the King commands Therefore if any of you give Christ the glory of his grace by believing that he hath abolished all your sins by his death be not dismayed at the sight of your corruptions Fight the good fight of faith Greater is he that is in you than he that is in the world Christ that commands you to obey his Father will enable you to obey his Father Christ reignes in the hearts of his people not only by making known to them the covenant of his owne grace but by supplying them with strength to doe his will Lord give what thou commandest said one and command what thou wilt Christ commands us what to doe and gives us power to doe that which he commands Such a King is Christ that frees his people not onely from the condemnation of sin but from the power and dominion of sin in their spirits lives and conversations Blessed be God saith the Apostle that ye were the servants of sin Are they so still now they are under grace No but being made free from sin ye are the servants of righteousnesse sinne shall not have dominion over you why ye have a new King ye are under grace ye are under King Jesus If a Tyrant should tyrannize over Subjects and depose their lawfull King if this King afterwards should overthrow this Tyrant and deliver his Subjects from tyranny and bondage by overcomming the Tyrant would hee suffer this Tyrant to tyrannize over them or his people to be under the lawes of the Tyrant We were under Satan the Tyrant under his lawes and commands under the law of sinne and concupiscence but Christ comes and overcomes the Tyrant that ruled tyrannically in our hearts and will hee suffer that Tyrant still to rule us by those commands which he gave us when wee were in bondage to him No we shall not be under the bondage of the flesh if we understand the liberty of grace and of the Spirit The Apostle saith that we doe not live nor eate nor drinke nor doe any shing to our selves because Christ dyed and rose and revived that he might be Lord of quicke and dead Rom. 14.8 9. Christ dyed and rose that he might be Lord and King and reigne and set up his Scepter of holinesse in the hearts of his people This was prophesied in Psal 110.3 Thy people shall be willing in the day of thy power When Christ as King comes with power his people shall be willing Christ bids them believe and they believe he bids them love and they doe love they run through fire and water they lay downe their honours and riches at his feet and love not their lives unto the death Object The enabling of Christ in working is not of the same extent with his command Answ In the spirituall and regenerate part the power of Christ is as large as
his command The fayling is not from the new but the olde man The whole man or person is under the command so that a man yea every man doth sin because he doth not doe in his person as he is a man what is commanded Charge the fault where it is to be charged upon the flesh which is the cause of a mans sin and then look upon grace which hath abolished sin and you shall finde the new man conformable to the will of God and the man good and holy in part to wit in his regenerated part It is further objected that Christ biddeth us to cleanse our selves from all filthinesse of flesh and spirit which no man doth It is granted and therefore we deny not but that every man sinneth if we take him physically But as farre as we are in the Spirit Wee are cleansed from all filthinesse of flesh and spirit so that the new man doth fulfill it and Christ doth reign in him though the flesh prove a Traytor and rebellious against his commands Arg. 18. Another argument may be brought from the consideration of the Image of Christ If this were true that all the works of the Saints were in their formalitie sinne this would follow that the Image of Jesus Christ were an Image of unholinesse and sin I ground my argument upon that place of the Apostle 2 Cor. 3.18 Wee all with open face beholding as in a glasse the glory of the Lord are changed into the same Image from glory to glory even as by the Spirit of the Lord. Here the Apostle shewes that the Saints are changed into the Image of Christ Now if there were nothing but sin and unholinesse sinfulnesse in those who are looked upon as spirituall as some conceive it wil follow that the Image of Christ into which they are changed must be an image of unholinesse If my love be unholinesse I am changed to that image of love which is in Christ and so it would follow that the Image of Christ doth consist in unholinesse Object If there be perfect sanctification in the new man then wee may bee justified by it Answ I deny that it doth not follow We shall have perfect sanctification at the resurrection and yet you will not say that we shall be acquitted from our sinnes by it which wee have committed upon earth but by the grace of God in the blood of Christ 2. We are justified before sancification and therefore it will not follow that we are justified by it Because that is done before the other is wrought in us 3. That a man may be justified by his sanctification It is necessary that a man should be so wholy sanctified that there should be no sin in the man Our good works will not make satisfaction for our bad works A Traytor for an act of treason might be condemned by his Prince though he hath done him much good service If a man would seeke justification by the law who is sanctified in part the law would condemn him for his sin in his unregenerated part taking no notice of any sufficiency in his sanctification to free him from condemnation for his sinne in the unregenerated part Arg. 19. This opinion that the good works of the justified man are sin or sinfull do make divers places of Scripture irreconcileable Men shall never be well able to reconcile many places of Scripture who swallow this as a trueth that whatsoever workes are now done in the Saints are nothing but sinne or sinfull For instance in one place we are bound to disclaime our works and to account all our righteousnesses as filthy ragges to believe in him that justifieth the ungodly And in another place we are said to be redeemed from all iniquity that we might be zealous of good workes Tit. 2. And we are the work manship of God created in Christ Jesus to good workes Eph. 2. By what I have delivered they are easily reconcileable To wit by distinguishing as the Scripture doth concerning good works thus That all the works of man under the Law are but splendid and shining sins and that the spirituall workes of a spirituall man are good and not sin or sinfull in their nature Not that the Scripture makes these good workes that flow from the spirituall man the cause or the matter of our justification but the fruits of the Spirit and the consequents of our justificationâ— It is a speech of Luthers worthy to be writteâ— in letters of gold that the whole world with all the riches of it are of no worth in comparison of good works flowing from faith and wrought by the Spirit of God in the hearts of his people Which how it can be made good I know not if that be true which he and some other Protestant Writers affirme that Omnâ— bonum secundum judicium dei est mortale peccatum every good worke of a regenerate man according to the judgment of God is a mortall sin That which is morally evill is not so good as any thing which is not morally evill That being the greatest evill which is morally evill I have known some professors of the Gospel who have fallen to Familisme and Atheisticall opinions and being asked why they did leave the Gospel they have answered that they could never reconcile the Scriptures concerning works to other places while they were professors of the Gospel Their meaning is while they were professors upon these principles by which they were taught to look upon the works of the spirit in them as sin and sinfull That which is frequently asserted by some Mr. Eatoon Honycomb and others that they are good to men-ward will not make up the breach The Apostle Peter speaking of a meeke quiet spirit which is the ornament of the hidden man of the heart saith that it is of great price in the sight of God 1 Pet. 3.4 The Apostle speaking of his sincerity in preaching the Gospel is not affraid to bring it into the sight of God 2 Cor. 2.17 And John saith 1 Joh. 3.22 That whatsoever we aske we receive of him because wee keepe his Commandements and doe those things which are pleasing in his sight And that he doth not meane believing only is plain by the next verse where he saith That this is his Commandement that wee believe on the name of his Sonne Jesus Christ and love one another And to stop the mouth of the objection which is usually brought against this truth to wit that he speaketh of doing as in Gods precept or command and not as done by us He saith that we receive what we aske because wee doe what is pleasing in his sight I must professe to the glory of God that this distinction hath given me a great light in the understanding of the Scripture And by this I am informed that I am justified without holiness or sanctification and yet that without holiness no man shall see the Lord Heb. 12.14 Arg. 20. This opinion that the good worke
of a man born of God are sin or sinfull doth overthrow the distinction which is warranted by many thousand places of Scripture between good works and bad works and doth draw a curse upon the doer of it Can evill be good or good evill Woe unto them that call evil good and good evill that put darknesse for light and light for darkenesse that put bitter for sweet and sweet for bitter Isa 5.20 What else doe they doe who plainley averre that every good work is evill Object Doe we deny the difference betweene white and blacke because we say that in most white bodies there is a mixture of some blacknesse with the whitenesse c. Answ If it could be proved that there were a mixture of that which is of the spirit and that which is of the flesh that that which is spirituall should be made fleshly by it there would seeme to be some strength in this objection But untill that such a mixture bee proved by plaine Scriptures we shall think it sufficient to affirme that such similitudes which have not their foundation upon a principle of truth do prove nothing Arg. 21. It taketh away the difference between a sanctified and unsanctified man which is a distinction which doth stand firme upon the basis of the Scripture of truth The Apostle doth plainly lay downe this distinction 1 Cor. 6.11 Where hee informeth us of the condition of the Corinthians before conversion to wit that they were thieves adulteresses and the like such were some of you and then setteth forth their blessed condition after conversion But ye are washed but ye are sanctified And doth second this truth with his owne experience acknowledging that there was a real change wrought in himself after conversion by sanctification 2 Tim. 1. I was saith he a persecuter a blasphemer injurious but the grace of our Lord was exceeding abundant with faith love which is in Christ Jesus not with faith only but love also If God hath pulled you out of the fire of sinne and drawne you as fire-brands out of Hell and brought you into the glorious kingdome of his Son ye are able to professe the same sanctified change in your selves It is a dead faith which is not accompanied with sanctification and good works As soon may a dead horse carrie a man as a dead faith save him Object This is a slander wee doe not deny sanctification Answ If yee acknowledge sanctification and a sanctified change yee contradict your selves For how can that make a sanctified change in us which is nothing else but sin or sinfull I shall be glad if you will stand to an inward change by love and sanctification But some there are who have affirmed that the distinction between a regenerated an and unregenerated man is but a legall distinction Arg. 22. The holy Spirit which is promised to us and dwelleth in us doth plainly demonstrate this point For as the Spirit is holy formally in it selfe in its owne nature essence and being so it is effectively holy because it makes that man holy who was formerly sinfull If thou be nothing but darknesse if God convert thee thou wilt have a glorious light in thine understanding if thou have nothing but unholinesse in thy will if the Spirit of God live in thee it will be a Spirit of holinesse a Spirit that will shew thee what is of the flesh and what is of the spirit a spirit checking thee if thou step aside into the way of the flesh and a spirit leading thee into the paths of holiness As the Psalmist saith Thy Spirit is good lead me into the land of holinesse and uprightnesse Therefore those that doe not find that Spirit leading them into the paths and wayes of holinesse those men have received a counterfeit spirit to delude them and not the true Spirit of the Lord Jesus Object The spirit is good but our actions are evill by the adherence of sinne in us That holy things may be defiled is plaine by Exod. 28.36.38 Aaron having his plate upon his forehead was to beare the iniquity of the holy things Answ 1. Though sin and holinesse be in the same man yet I deny that sinne by any adhering to holinesse in us doth change holinesse into the nature of it But what is of the Spirit in us doth retaine its spirituall nature and what is of the flesh doth retaine its fleshly nature 2. The Scripture produced doth prove that in doing of holy duties we sin and that Jesus Christ doth beare those sins which wee have granted unto you before But that the fruits of the Spirit in us are those sinnes cannot be proved from this place of Scripture nor from anyother Scripture which I know this still doth remaine to be proved Arg. 23. There may bee another argument drawne from that place of the Apostle when hee saith The Spirit beareth witnesse with our spirits that we are the children of God Rom. 8.16 The Spirit cannot beare witnesse to our old darke prophane spirits for the naturall man receives not the things of the Spirit for they are foolishnesse to him therefore it must be to our spirit enlightned renewed and filled with the Spirit of God And therefore there is somthing in a Saint besides that which is sinne and sinfull Object This is true but we are not renewed perfectly which is the thing to be proved Answ Perfection in Scripture is opposed to that which is more perfect And in this sence wee doe not affirme that a man is so perfectly renewed as he shall be 1 Cor. 13. 2. Perfection is opposed to that which is sinfull Luke 1. And in this sence we say that he is perfectly renewed that is he is holily not sinfully renewed Arg. 24. I doe ground my next argument upon the words of the Apostle Rom. 14. last Whatsoever is not of faith is sinne And therefore that which is done in faith is not sin If we deny this we shall take away the difference between doing good works in faith and doing good works without faith if both of them be alike sinfull or sinne And therefore I conclude that the work of the Spirit which is done in faith is not sin Without faith it is impossible to please God and therefore by faith it is possible to please him by doing good works Arg. 25. Another argument may be drawn from that place 2 Cor. 13. where the Apostle makes the comparison betweene faith hope and love and prefers love before faith hope for this reason because love is more permanent and of longer continuance than faith and hope when a man comes to heaven hee ceaseth to live the life of faith for then he shall live the life of sight and vision he ceaseth to hope for he enjoyeth that which he hoped for but love shall continue Therefore he saith that love that is the fruit of faith is greater than faith in respect of its continuance That which remaines and endures after this life
formam et finem Arg. 4. Sanctification in the feare of God is alwayes perfecting whilest we live here in this life 2 Cor. 7.1 and therefore it is not perfected untill the life to come Answ Sanctification is said to be perfecting here in reference to that which is in the flesh which is to be put off that sanctificaiion may come in the place of it not in reference unto that which is already wrought as though that sanctification were not already perfect if we take perfection as it is opposed to that which is sinfull 2. It is said that our Saviour encreased in wisdome Luk. 2.52 will you say that his wisedome was sinfull at first because he did encrease and grow in it You may as well say so as conclude that our sanctification is sinne or sinfull because it doth grow or increase to a greater perfection Arg. 5. If our workes be in themselves perfect then might Paul have desired to have been found in them before God Answ I deny the consequence For these good workes are not wrought in us that they may be the cause or matter of our Justification and therefore Paul will not appeare before God in them for Justification But Paul and every true Saint being justified by faith without them doth dare to bring them in the presence of God as secondary evidences of Gods love to him According to that of John 1 John 3.14 We know that we have passed from death to life because we love the Brethren hee that loveth not his brother abideth in death ver 19. And hereby wet know that we are of the truth and shall perswade our hearts before him Which you maintaining them to be sin and sinful doe not doe Arg. 6. If the new man doth not sinne then he is not the man who is pronounced to bee a blessed man Psal 32. Rom. 4. Answ This is a plaine fallacy You take the new man here physically whom wee take according to Scripture Spiritually and Theologically Justification to speak properly is neither of the new man nor old man but of the person in whom there is an old man and a new man And this man is justified from the sinnes of the old man by the work of the spirit in the new man which doth carry him to the grace of God in Jesus Christ Arg. 7. Pauls best workes were accounted by him but as drosse dung therfore they were not perfect Phil. 3. Answ 1. This may be very well understood of his workes done under the Law As the preceding words do seeme to hold it forth where he speaketh of his Jewish priviledges and Pharisaicall righteousnesse And secondly the words following will seem to carry it this way because hee saith that hee accounteth all things dung for the excellent knoweldg of Christ by which is evident that he speaketh of all things as they stand in opposition to the knowledge of Christ 3. This argument maketh nothing for you because you account this knowledge sinfull But let us take it as you do and an answer is presently at hand to wit that the Apostle doth not speake these words absolutely but comparatively They are all dung in comparison of Christ and in reference to their uselesnesse to justification Dung will as soone justifie a man from sin as that love which floweth from faith Arg. 8. This that the new man sinneth not doth in a very high measure if not altogether overthrow all the offices of Christ 1. His Kingly office as having none to rule not the old man for hee savoureth not thet hings of God he is not subject to the Law of God neither indeed can be not the new man for he needs not the government of Christ hee is already perfect and cannot sin 2. His Priestly office which is to make propitiation for the sins of those which shall be saved now the new man who only shal be saved never did nor could not commit any sinne 3. His Propheticall office For whom should he teach the new man needs not his teaching seeing he with all his works is already perfect and can be no otherwise The olde man is not capable of his teaching Answ I have already detected the fallaciousnesse of this argument in answering to the 6th Argument Yet give mee leave to prove in few words that this doctrine doth magnifie Christ in the glory of his spirituall offices First in his Kingly office the glory of a king doth lye in subduing his enemies And in this the glory of Christ considered as a King doth appeare that hee doth vanquish the enemies of us his Subjects by ruling in our hearts with his Scepter of righteousnesse According to that of the Psalmist that hee shall rule in the midst of his enemies By this wee see his regall power over the old man Again the glory of a King is wrapt up in the willing obedience of his Subjects and this is made good in the new man His people being made willing in the day of his power For what is here objected that the new man needs not the government of Christ It is as if one should say that a man doth make void and overthrow royall government because he maintaineth that the Kings Subjects are willingly obedient unto him But you say that they are perfect and therefore his government is needlesse The spirits of just men are made perfect Heb. 12. And will you therefore conclude that the government of Christ over them is needlesse But to passe this by 2. It will appeare that the Priestly office of Christ is not overthrown but established rather by this doctrine for first we hold that no man liveth as a new man who doth live under the guilt of sin and therefore by the eye of the new man wee are daily to looke upon Christ as a Priest in whom is no finne who by one offering hath perfected for ever them that are sanctified Heb. 10.14 Again the Priest was to offer up the sacrifices of the people for them and by this doctrine we establish Christ in his Priestly office which we could not do if we should say that there were nothing in us but what is sinne and sinfull in us The people were to bring something which was good to be offered up by the Priest to God The blinde lame and sicke were not to be offered unto God Mal. 1.8 Neither is that which we doe that is sin or sinfull offered up by Jesus Christ to the Father but that which is good And thus wee establish Christ in his Priestly office by affirming that there is something good in the new man which is the matter of acceptance 3. Wee doe not overthrow his Propheticall office by this truth For he doth daily teach us in the new man Whereas you say that he needs not his teaching wee say that the new man hath his dependance upon Christ for wisedome knowledg and understanding And as a burning Lampe doth daily stand in need of oyle to be powred into
have seene thy salvation Or else such musick will bee in your hearts as was in Stephens when he prayed Lord Jesus receive my spirit yee shall have peace at the last which shall bee everlasting The life of grace shall be lengthned out with an eternity of glory which God and the Father grant unto you in the riches of his grace through his sonne our blessed Jesus and Redeemer Amen Christs Title to the dead bodies of Saints maintained SERMON II. CHrist is a Christians shield and buckler so that none can strike at a Christian but through the sides and loynes of his Saviour We cannot wrong Saints unlesse we injure the King of Saints Christ and his people have the same Enemies This is evident in the opposers of the resurrection who as they are enemies to Christians so they are to Christ and they doe not so much wrong to his people as they offer violence unto him as they would bereave his members of the happinesse of their resurrection so they would rob him of his limbs members and glory And therefore as I have pleaded against the living adversaries of dead Saints so I shall now plead the cause of Christ against those enemies of Christ who in denying the resurrection deny the raising of his mysticall body which doth fight against that truth which doth next present it selfe unto us in the text in these words My dead body shall they arise I must speak something for the exposition something by way of amplification of that which I apprehend to be the truth of God mainly pointed at in the words Together with my dead body shall they rise So it is in our translation and those that carrie it thus they make this to be the meaning of the words that the bodies of the Saints shall be raised together with the body of the Lord Jesus And if the Holy Ghost did point at this then the first thing that should be observed would be this that Christ Jesus had a body a naturall body If it doe not clearely appeare from this place yet it doth from others for it is said he was made of the seed of David according to the flesh And likewise Joh. 1. The word was made flesh And great is the mystery of godlinesse God manifested in the flesh 1 Tim. 3.16 which will overthrow that which some Familisticall spirits dare to assert in our times that the Lord Jesus Christ never had any naturall bodie allegorizing the whole history of the incarnation life and death resurrection and ascension of the Lord Jesus But secondly if it be thus expounded as some learned men doe expound the words the next observation will be this that This bodie of Christ was a dead body Revel 1.18 I am he that liveth and was dead The true Christ in his body was once dead his body was a crucified body He his own self saith Peter in his owne body bare our sinnes upon the Crosse 1 Pet. 2.24 He was wounded for our iniquities his body was bruised for our transgressions Isa 53. Thirdly that The dead body of the Lord Jesus was raised with my dead body they shall rise it is supposed that this dead body spoken of shall arise and this is that that is so frequently preached by the Apostles who were witnesses appointed by God to testifie that the Lord Jesus did rise from the dead The Devill knew what a truth this was how much life glory sweetnesse and power there is in it therefore he imployed his instruments the Scribes and Pharisees to doe what they could to smother this truth of the resurrection of the Lord Jesus What lies did they not make what stones did they not turne what paines did they not take that they might possesse the people with this perswasion that the Lord Jesus Christ did never rise out of the grave but that his Disciples came and stole him away But brethren Christ is risen and those that rightly understand this doe find what sweetnesse and consolation comes to their hearts by believing this point There is so much in it that Paul professeth he desired to know nothing but Christ and him crucified Phil. 3.10 the power of his resurrection and the fellowship of his sufferings And Peter 1. Pet. 1.3 saith that God hath begotten us againe to a lively hope through the resurrection of the Lord Jesus The hope of the Disciples was almost dead and extinguished when the Lord Jesus lay in the grave but now Christ is risen and hath discovered his power in vanquishing his and all our enemies now we have a lively hope in us that believe the resurrection of Christ for in the believing of his resurrection we have a sweet and comfortable assurance of our owne resurrection from the dead Fourthly with my dead body shall they rise Christ as I hinted before did all things and suffered all things as a publick personâ— he died not for his owne but for our sinnes Qâ—i non habuit propria portavit aliena Fulâ— He that had no sinnes of his owne did beareâ— the sinnes of other men he rose not so much for his owne as for our Justification He died for our sinnes Rom. 4. the last and he rose for our Justification So that when Christ did rise we rose And he that believes this in the spirit sees that he himselfe is risen with the Lord. There is is a two-fold resurrection A resurrection by Faith when we doe believe that we are risen in Christ our King head and leader and there is a resurrection in our owne persons when we shall be raised in our owne bodies Christ did rise for the good and in the behalfe of all his people and Christ keepes possession of Heaven after his resurrection for us in whose person we are already risen and in this respect it may be said that together with his dead body we shall arise Fiftly with my dead body shall they rise Some interpret it thus by the power of the Lord Jesus Christ they shall rise that is there shall come at the last day a power from the Lord Jesus Christ to raise up the Saints to enjoy glory with the Father But because I doe not find these two words in the Hebrew Together nor with therefore be pleased to let me passe by these observations and to give you what I doe apprehend to be the plaine meaning of the text and to read the words thus My dead body shall they rise They are the words of the Lord Jesus delivered by him for the comfort of his people assuring them that they shall be raised as his body And though some doe understand them concerning the restauration of the Jewes and the bringing in of them unto Christ yet I apprehend that this is the true spirituall meaning of God in the words which I have opened to you this day The point then will be this the dead bodies of the Saints which shall be raised are the dead bodies of Christ himselfe 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉
in his person we see that wee are conquerours over the Devill in him yet we meet with the Devill his fierie temptations darts and arrowes which he shooteth into our spirits so that he oft-times causeth us to walke something sadly occasioning troubles which Jerome calleth tempestates mentis the tempests of the mind As Paul tells us that he was buffeted by the messenger of Satan But then this wicked Fiend shall be so chained up that he shall never be let loose upon us again Then he shall be so under our feet that hee shall never have any liberty given him to tempt us any more The accuser of the Brethren is cast out of heaven Revelation 12.10 His accusations and complaints against them cannot be heard by the eare of God to prejudice their Justification but he doth persecute the woman upon the earth Rev. 12.13 He afflicts the Church and brings much trouble oft-times to the Saints but at the generall resurrection we shall be freed wholly from the Devill from all temptations from all troubles all enemies that can be thought upon so that then things shall be fully accomplished and compleated for our good The Apostle though he telleth us that Christ for the present hath abolished death and sinne to us 2 Tim. 1.10 and destroyed him who hath the power of death who is the Devill Heb. 2.14 yet he informeth us that the promises of God made to us in Christ are not fully accomplished compleated and perfected till the resurrection as wee may see by that place 1 Cor. 15.54 then shall be fulfilled that saying speaking of the resurrection day Death is swallowed up in victory then if shall be said O death where is thy sting O grave where is thy victory 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Then shall it be that is it shall be in the full accomplishment wee have now what is there promised in the promise of God by Faith then wee shall have what is in the promise in the actuall fruition of the thing promised So that in this respect there will be great joy because then every Saint shall ride in a Chariot of triumph as a Conquerour of all enemies in his own person And as Christ in his owne body and Spirit did ride to Heaven and triumph over the power of Hell Death sinne curse and condemnation and as the life that we live for the present is by beholding this victory of the Lord Jesus Christ with the eye of Faith so at the generall resurrection all the Saints shall imitate the Lord Jesus Christ and in their owne persons shall ride as Conquerours triumphing over all enemies and shall live the life of vision seeing the same thing done in their owne persons which now by Faith they see done for them in the person of Jesus So that all cause and occasion of trouble and sorrow being taken away there must needs be great joy at the resurrection of those who are raised by the Lord. In the next place as the occasions and causes of all sorrow shall be taken away so likewise all things all objects that may move spirituall joy shall be presented to the Saints to raise their spirits to a spirituall joy who shall be raised and made happy with the Lord Jesus whatsoever it be that can be thought upon that can make any one happy that the Saints shal enjoy they shal enjoy God in a full measure and the Lord Jesus Sweet streames of joy will flow into their spirits because God will make himselfe the Author and worker of their joy Sing O daughter os Sion saith the Prophet Zeph. 3.14 Be glad and rejoyce O daughter of Jerusalem But why must Zion sing and shout behold the reason in the 15. verse The Lord is in the midst of thee and in the 17. ver He will rejoyce over thee with singing There is the chiefe ground of their joy laid downe So the 12. of Neh. 43. it is said the people rejoyced for God made them rejoyce with great joy So at the resurrection God shall make them to rejoyce they shall be alway then at the Fountaine at the Well-head In thy presence is fulnesse of joy at thy right hand saith the Psalmist Psal 17.11 there are pleasures for evermore All the Saints shall then bee in the presence and at the right hand of God where there shall be pleasures for evermore they all shall be in the glory of the Lord Jesus God shall emptie himselfe and the rivers and streames of joy which are in himself into their hearts and spirits so that they shall be swallowed up into those streames and rivers of joy and pleasure which are in the enjoyment of a God Macarius speaketh of 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the ebriety of the Spirit They then shall be inebriated with the fulnesse of a spirituall joy If there be such rejoycing here in the spirit of a Saint when he hath a light from God to see something of God in the face of Christ what spirituall joy shall there be when our joy shall be at the full If there be such joy in the ebbing of the Spirit here what joy will there be when we shall enjoy the high-tyde of the Spirit in the vision of Gods grace and glory hereafter when wee shall eat of the tree of life when wee shall drinke our fill of those rivers of pleasures which runne in the Paradise of God And if there be so much sweetnesse in spirituall joy here what tongue can expresse or heart conceive what there shall be in that joy that shall be hereafter Great glorious and high are the expressions by which Saints doe set forth the joyes that they feele here but no Saint can tell what the joyes shall be hereafter at the resurrection Psal 94.19 In the multitude of my thoughts within mee thy comforts delight my soule the delight is such here that David had rather have the light of Gods countenance in a Spirit of joy upon him then to enjoy all the glory and great things in the world Thou hast put greater joy into my heart then when the corne and wine of wicked men is increased Psal 4. and in Psal 84. One day in thy house is worth a thousand If there be such joy in the presence of God here in the beholding of his grace in the kisses of his mouth in the imbraces of his Sonne when he doth now sprinkle us with his grace O what joy shall there be when God shall poure out the Spirit of grace and sweetnesse into our soules when he shall open all the treasures of his Spirit and love when hee shall more freely and fully shew us the things that neither eye hath seene nor eare hath heard neither hath it entred into the heart of man to conceive what they are 1 Cor. 2. Wee have seene great things in the world Crownes Scepters riches worldly pomp and glory but what are all these things they doe not shadow forth the things that wee see here in the Spirit