monitions commandements and requirings you seem to lay some default upon God himself saying That he withholdeth that grace from them whereby their hearts that is their wils and affections might have been wrought upon which both derogates from Gods mercy and is inconsistent which innumerable Scriptures testifying the contrary as Esai 5.4 What could I have done more for my vineyard that I have not done Mat. 23.37 How often would I have gathered thy children as a ben gathereth her chickens under her wings but see would not Acts 7.51 Ye stifnecked and uncircumcised in heart and eares ye do alwayes resist the holy Ghost as did your Fathers so do yee CHAP. VI. Of the fall of man of Sin and of the punishment thereof OVR First Parents being seduced by the subtilty and temptation of Satan sinned in eating the forbidden fruit a Gen 3.13 2 Cor 11.3 this their sin God was pleased according to his wise and holy counsel to permit having purposed to order it to his own glory b Ro 11.32 II. By this sin they fell from their original righteousnesse and communion with God c Gen 3.6 7 8. Eccl 7.29 Ro 3.23 and so became dead in sin d Gen 2.17 Eph 2.1 and wholy defiled in all the faculties and parts of soul and body e Tit 1.15 Gen 6.5 Jer 17.9 Ro 3.10 to 19. III. They being the root of all mankinde the guilt of sin was imputed f Ge 1.27 28. and Gen. 2.16 17. and Act 17.13 with Ro 5.12 15 16 17 18 19. and 1 Cor 15.21 22 25. and the same death in sin and corrupted nature conveyed to all their posterity descending from them by ordinary generation g Psa 51.5 Gen 5.3 Job 14.4 Job 15.14 IV. From this original corruption whereby we are utterly indisposed disabled and made opposite to all good h Ro 5.6 Rom 8.7 Rom 7.18 Col 1.21 and wholly inclined to all evil i Gen 6.5 Gen 8.21 Rom 3.10 11 12 do proceed all actual transgressions k Jam 1.12 15. Eph 2.2 3. Mat 15.19 V. This corruption of nature during this life doth remain in those that are regenerated l 1 Joh 1.8 to Rom v. 14.17 18 23. Jam 3.2 Pro 20.9 Eccl 7.20 and althoug it be through Christ pardoned and mortified yet both it self and all the motions thereof are truely and properly sin m Ro 7.5 7 8 25. Gal 5.17 VI. Every sin both original and actual being a transgression of the righteous Law of God and contrary thereunto n Joh 3.4 doth in its own nature bring guilt upon the sinner o Rom 3.9 19. whereby he is bound over to the wrath of God p Eph 2.3 and curse of the Law q Gal. 3.10 and so made subject to death r Ro. 6.23 with all miseries spiritual Å¿ Eph. 4.18 temporal t Rom. 8.20 Jam. 3 39. and eternal u Matth. 25.41 2 Thess 1.9 CHAP. VI. Of the fall of man of Sin and of the Punishment thereof examined IN this Chapter of mans fall you have given sufficient evidence of it for except the first and last Sections all parts of it are a resemblance of the depraved man you spake of sufficiently corrupted In the second Section these are your words By this sin they that is our first parents fell from their original righteousness and communion with God and so became dead in sin and wholly defiled in all the faculties of soul and body In which words we finde the fruits of the forbidden tree evil as well as good error as well as truth That they fell from their former communion with God from some degree of original righteousness and that they became dead that is liable to eternal death we grant you but that they fell wholly from original righteousness at the first Act of their Apostacy or that they presently became so wholly defiled as you speak are great mistakes As to the first of these did not the Image of God in which they were created consist in holiness and righteousness Now you know habits are not lost by one act or two Again the thing that God threatned was a gradual punishment as well as a certain In dying ye shall die Furthermore those that fall away from inchoated grace and that renued Image of God which is not at first so strong and vigorous as Gods similitude was in the first man though they die and being in a great decree of languishing are said to be dead yet they die but gradually after great debilities and decay may be kept alive and recovered Rev. 3.1 2. I know thy works that thou hast a name that thou livest and art dead Be watchful and strengthen the things which remain that are ready to die for I have not found thy works perfect before me Now as for the second that they became wholly defiled in all parts and faculties no Scripture speaks it nor could it be till the whole Image of God was extinguished by contrary corruptions True it is that if the Lord had wholly left them to themselves as he did the rebellious and backsliding Angels it would have fared no better with them in the end then you speak of but the father of mercies was pleased to appear unto them in the cool and declination of the day before it was dark night with them and by his covenant of grace to help them up again In the third Section you say They being the root of all mankinde the guilt of the sin was imputed and the same death in sin and corrupted nature corveyed to all posterity descending from them by ordinary generation where that they were the root of all mankinde is undoubtedly true but all the rest of that Section may be justly questioned And first that passage where you tacitely exempt Christ from the imputation of this sin made unto him for doubtless that with all other sins of ours were laid upon him But secondly it may be upon good ground hoped that it neither was nor shall be imputed to any of their posterity who are not the imitators of the same in actual rebellion for that just Lord doth not onely forbid the punishing of the children for the iniquity of their parents even with temporal death Deut 24.18 but he swears also by his own life that he will not do that thing Ezek 18.1 20. Then what you there affirm in the second place is more improbable then the other to wit That the same death in sin and corrupt nature is conveyed to all their posterity descending from them by ordinary generation is yet more improbable For first that some men are sanctified from the womb as Jeremiah and John the Baptist were and the Virgin Mary might possibly be none will deny And secondly that all others are still created innocent in some measure of Gods image there are not a few Scriptures which seem to testifie it of which Genesis the 9.6 is one where the
whereof take these few John 1.13 Which were born not of bloud nor of the will of the flesh nor of the will of man but of God John 3.6 That which is born of the flesh is flesh and that which is born of the spirit is spirit 1 Cor. 2.14 15. For the natural men perceiveth not the things of the spirit of God for they are foolishness unto him Neither can he know them for they are spiritually discerned But the spiritual man discerneth all things but is discerned of none 1 Cor. 15.22 For as in Adam all die so in Christ shall all be made alive and verse 45 46 47 48 49. As it is written the first man was made a living soul but the second Adam was made a quickening spirit Hewbeit that was not first which is spiritual but that which is natural and then that which iâ— spiritual The first man is of the â—â—rth earthy the second mâ—n is the Lord from heaven as is the earthy such are they that are earthy and as is the heavenly such are they that are heavenly and as we have born the image of the earthly so must we bear the image of the heavenly c. More particularly we answer That this one by whom sin entred into the world is not meant our first parent Adam but our own earthy or natural man which is called Adam and Edom from the earth of his foundation For the apostle shews that Adam our progenitor was not the original or first sinner 1 Timothy 2.14 For Adam was not deceived but the woman being deceived was in the transgression according then to your Doctrine the apostle should have said By one Woman sin entred into the world But you hear before how Solomon Eccles 7.29 and the Lord himself Hos 14 1. scribe our fall to our selves This is yet clearer out of the 14. verse here where the apostle speaks of some who sinned after the similitude of Adams transgression but makes mention of none that sinned in him where he had fair occasion to speak of it yea if he had been of your belief he had committed a grievous neglect totally to omit it in silence Secondly here by the world into which sin entered we must understand the world of fallen and corrupt men as our Saviour doth Joâ—n 3.16 17. and John 15.17 18. and not all mankinde as you do c. Thirdly by death is not meant the bodily death which doth not presently ensue upon our fall no more then it did upon our first parents but a death unto righteousness or the life of innocencie with the contrary body of sin and so obnoxiousness to eternal death is hear meant Fourthly these words and death passed upon all men 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 are thus to be rendered in as much or so far forth as all have sinned and as Moses in the 14. verse is not he that was the Lawgiver but the work of the Law drawing us to God so neither is this man the litterall Adam For Paul here saith That death reigned from Adam to Moses which must be understood necessarily thus from the fall of our natural Adam till the work of the Law came For otherwise the extent of the reign of sin should reach from the first man to the last and not to Moses onely Which thing the 13. ver holdeth out more plainly that he meant by Mose the Law For it is there said That until the Law sin was in the world which must be conceived that until the work of the law sin is in the world that is likewise in the faln corrupted men undiscovered which is plain from the latter part of the 13 verse where it is said sin is not reputed nor regarded as the word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 signifies and so Coverdel translates it and not imputed when there is no Law for that is false that sin was not imputed when there was no Law extant for it was imputed to Cain Gen. 4. and he was punished So to the old world and they punished Gen. 6 so to Babels builders and they punished Gen. 11.7.8 so it was imputed to Sodom and Gomorrab and they punished Gen. 19. when there was none of Moses law extant but it is a very truth that sin is not reputed not regarded when there is no work of the Law discovering sin unto the man so St. Paul saith of himself Rom. 7.9 that he was alive without the Law and verse v. he saith he had not known lust but by the Law and Rom. 3.20 it is said that by the Law cometh the knowledge of sin Thus you see how death raigned from Adam to Moses yet not from the first individual Adam to Moses the Law-giver but in the 2. part of the 14 ver it is not affirmed that any sinned in the first individual Adam for he saith Some finned not after the similitude of Adams transgression over whom notwithstanding death reigned Now that expression hinteth these two things First Some sinned like Adam not in Adam others sinned not after the similitude of his transgression but some other way as after Esau's transgression Hebr. 18.16 17. or the like according to that Eccles 7.29 Surely if the Apostle had beleeved any such thing as the raigning of death over all men by the first mans sin he would not have omitted that and onely mentioned from Adam to Moses for all may perceive his main designe is from verse 12. to the 15. to set forth the inlet and extent of deaths reigning over sinners therefore he would have used the fullest and plainest expression serving to that purpose but the 19. verse is more plain against universal corruption by the first mans disobedience for there the Apostle useth the word many and saith by one mans disobediene many not all were made sinners Therefore all fell not in the first individual Adam If any yet reply That many in that place is tant ' amount and equivalent to the word all We Answer That then by the same reason the word many in the latter part of the verse must have the same latitude allowed for the Apostle setteth down a full comparison of equals in that verse here the verse must be thus interpreted That as by one mans disobedience all were made sinners so by one mans obedience all are made righteous If any yet reply and say By one mans obedience all that repent and beleeve are made righteous then by the same inter retation By ones mans disobedience all are made sinners that imitate him and sin like him after the similitude of Adam 's transgressions Thus all men may see there is nothing gained by interpreting the word many by a Synecdoche for all are made sinners by one mans disobedience for the latter part of the verse must have the word many so explained which to affirm namely that all are righteous by Christ by an absolute and uniuersal Justification is accounted as detestable an Heresy as it hath been hitherto to deny that
Inâ—rdinate affection evil concupiscence and coveâ—ousness c. This is that Earth which is opposed to be the Heaven of Gods holiness Eccles 5.2 For God is in Heaven and thou upon the Earth For the Lord is present in this outward Earth aswel as we in this Earth all men sin but there are some places in the new Testament also which you oppose us with as first that Luke 17.10 So likewise you when ye have done all these things say ye are â—â—p ofitable servents But this place if well considered makes more against you then for you for our Saviour there implyes that we may do all things which are commanded to wit through his grace yet having so done we are unprofitable servants to God for we have done but our duties and that through grace also and so have added nothing to the Lord. But a second and a grand objection is made out of Rom. 7.14 15 16 17 18 19. c. For the Law saith the Apostle is spiritual But I am carnal sold under sin Answer Although this place is commonly taken as if the Apostle spoke here of his own personal and present estate yet it is certain he did not first because elsewhere speaking of that estate he contradicts what is here spoken by him as 1 Cor. 4.4 For I know nothing by my self but here the person spoken of knowes much evil by himself and Phil. 4.13 I can do all things through Christ which strengtheneth me but he that is here intended though to will is present with him yet findes no means or power to do any good yea that which the Apostle speaks of his present estate chap. 8. of this Epistle to the Romans verse 2. is directly opposite to what is complained of verse 23 of this 7 chapter for in that 23. verse the complaint speaketh thus But I see another law in my members warring against the law of my minde and bringing me into coptivity to the law of sin which is in my members Oh wretched man that I am who shall deliver me from this body of death But Rom. 8.2 Paul saith For the law of the Spirit of life in Christ Jesus hath made me free from the law of sin and death what can be more contradictory then this last place is to the former So that of necessity the fist place must be understood of babes in Christ whom Paul here personates instructs and comforts and the latter of his own present condition and victorie as Occumenius and others well observe and what was more usual with the Apostle then to speak of that which concerns others in his own person 1 Cor. 4.6 And these things brethren I have in a figure transferred to my self and Apollos for your sake 1 Cor. 13.11 c. When I was a child I spake as a child c. Thirdly You alledge against us and this truth the words which the Apostle speaks to the Galatians chap. 5. verse 17. For the flesh lusteth against the spirit and the spirit against the flesh and these are contraeâ—y the one to the other so that ye cannot do the things that ye would Here say you the Apostle describes that combat betwixt the flesh and the spirit which must continue while we endure in the body Answer But where do you read that this conflict must last so long The Apostle saith a good space before his death 2 Tim. 47. I have fought a good fight I have finished my course I have kept the faith Were not the Galatians Babes in Christ so young and weak that the Apostle had no sooner left them then they were ready to be drawn away from Christ by the false Apostles See Gal. 1.6 with 3.1 2. Now to make their estate the highest pitch growth of a Christian in this life is as if we should take the scantling of a child and conclude that it is the full stature of mankinde and that no man is or can be of a taller groth Fourthly You object what St. James writes chap. 3.2 For in many things we offend all where you imvolue him and his fellow Apostles in that plural number To which we answer That the Apostle can no more be there implyed then in the 9 verse where he saith again and that plurally With the same tongue we bless God even the Father and with the same tongue we curse men which are made after the similitude of God Was James or the Apostles now of the number of those that still cursed men But it is frequent for lenity sake and in a winning way for the Prophets and Apostles of Christ to speak in the plural and sometimes in the singular number those things which concern not themselves but their hearers onely Nebem 5.10 I pray you let us leave of this usury saith the man of God who was no wayes guilty of that sin Isa 59.10 the Prophet speaketh this We groap for the wall like the blind and we groap as if we had no eyes Lastly It is objected out of 1 John 1.8 That the Apostle saith directly If we say that we have no sin we deceive our selves and there is no truth in us Answer The same Apostle implyes ch 4 17. that he and his fellow Apostles were now without sin Herein is our love made perfect that we might have boldness in the day of Judgement because as he is so are we in this present world There is no fear in love but persect love casteth out fear The Apostle therefore speaks the former words to those that were young in Christ and yet imperfect as is evident chap. 2. verse 1. My little children these things write I unto you that ye sin not c. Yea he explains himself so Chap. 1. verse 10. that he may be safely taken into the number If we that say we have not finned we make him a lyar and his word is not in us And thus much of your first erroneous proposition in your 5th and last Section Your other Thesis wherein you affirm That though this corruption remains in the regenerate during life yet it is actually pardoned is false also and contradictory to these ensuing and many other Scriptures Prov. 28 13. Luke 24.47 Acts 8.20 Acts 26.18 or as we shall shall shew at large chap. 11. by Gods assistance Now for a conclusion of this last Section give us leave to propound these Queries unto you First whether those ten unbeleeving spies did not highly displease God and much hinder injure and prejudice the people which hearkened unto them who cryed that there were such Anakiâ— in the way that they could not be subdued by them and Cities so high that they were walled up to Heaven and therefore not 〈◊〉 be scaled Numb 14. Did not the people too slothful and averse before to fight the Lords battail against the Canaanites become therethrough wholy unbeleeving even despairing of victory and altogether indisposed to the fight enjoyned by the Lord Were not both they and those their leaders
2.3 4 5 6. 2 Pet. 3.9 Secondly you are here deficient in setting forth Gods stipulation in this Covenant for you say That God requires faith in Christ that men may be saved but the Lord insists not onely upon faith but upon obedience also to all his commands yea obedience unto the death to wit the death of sin Mark 16.16 Act. 2.38 39. Act. 3.19 Heb. 5.9 Rom. 6.8 2 Tim. 2.11 12. Rom 2.7 8.13 Matth. 24.13 Revel 27.11 17 26. Revel 12.5 Thus of your defects here but whereas you say in the close of that Section That God promiseth to give unto all those that are ordained unto life his holy Spirit to make them willing and able to believe it is not true we would gladly have you produce anyone such promise yet dowe grant that the Lord is pleased to enlighten and teach all sinners that are out of the way and capable of instruction in the way to life again so that they may believe repent and turn if they will Psal 25.8 Good and upright is the Lord therefore will he teach sinners in the way The text to which you refer us Ezek. 36.25 26. is a promise made to the house of Jacob in the latter dayes and that of such a clensing from sin as you will not believe or admit but not of faith though the work of regeneration there promised implyeth a precedent faith and therein both illumination on Gods part and assent or credence to the truth revealed on ours In the fourth Section you say That this Covenant of grace is frequently set forth in Scripture by the name of a Testament and so is the Covenant upon Mount Sinai likewise Gal. 4.24 for those saith the Apostle are the two Testaments But secondly whereas you add That this name is given to that Covenant onely in reference to the death of Christ the Testator and to the everlasting inheritance with all things belonging unto it therein bequeathed You herein fall short again for the believer who is the other party to the Covenant must in following of Christ dye with him and there must follow the death of this Testator likewise Rom. 6.8 For if we be dead with him we believe that we shall live with him Rom. 8.13 For if we live after the flesh we shall dye but if we mortifie the deeds of the body by the spirit we shall live So 2 Tim. 2.11 12. In your fifth Section you are defective likewise in two things and mistaken in a third For first whereas you say That this Covenant was differently administred in the time of the Law and of the Gospel your saying is true but much too short to express the various administrations of the Covenant for it was administred after one manner before the Law after another under the Law after a third under the prophets and all this before the time of the Gospel before the Law as it was at the first made with Adam and renewed with Noah but more solemnly reinstituted with Abraham for the blessing of all Nations and generations of mankinde so all this time it was administred without outward ceremonies and services more then commemorative sacrifices of Christs inward sufferings That Lambe slain from the beginning of the world Rev. 13.8 which yet were intentive likewise to a dying with Christ unto all sin and wickedness but under the Law as you truly speak it was administered by promises prophecies the Paschal Lamb and other types and ordinances delivered to the people of Israel in general and not to the Jews alone as you set forth And it was partly set forth as a Covenant of works if not to mind us of original innocencie yet to be our Schoolemaster to Christ shewing us our inability in our selves to keep the law with our sins and miseries and what manifold need we had of Christ Gal. 3.24 and partly as a Covenant of grace also finally under the prophets it was dispensed principally by promises and predictions Isa 9.6 Isa 11.1 2. Jerem. 31.34 35 36. Jerem. 32.38.39 Ezek. 11.18 19 36 25 26 c. But as you were defective in saying That those types sacrifices and services under the Law did onely figure out Christ to come whereas they did teach the Israelites the whole way to life also in following of Christ so you are in saying that the Covenant of grace in regard of the former dispensations is called the old Testament as you do also in saying That in the Gospel it being under other dispensations is called the new Testament in the sixth Section For according to the Scripture and the minde of God the Old and New Testament are thus to be distinguished The whole word of grace whether administred by Prophets or Apostles is the Old Testament that is a foregoing Testament administred by true Elders but the work of grace in purging out sin renewing us in righteousness writing the Law of God in our hearts and sealing the everlasting forgiveness of sins unto us is the new Testament So that the Old Testament is the Covenant which we should observe and keep or endeavor so to do but the new Testament is the work of grace which God hath promised in and through Christ Thus Christ is called the mediator of the new Testament Heb. 9.15 and his spirit blood the blood of the new Testament Mat. 26.28 Yet we do not deny but that both the Prophets and Apostles were able Ministers of the new Testament as true publishers of this promised grace and not of the letter onely as were the Scribes and Pharisees 2 Corin. 3.6 Not that the writings of Moses and the Prophets comparatively to the writings of the Apostles are or should be called the old Testament as they seem to be termed 2 Cor 3.12 for this we say that the writings of the Apostles may be so called likewise and are no other in relation to the promised work of cleansing and renewing grace which God alone both can and must effect Howbeit we do not condemn the common distinction and distribution of the books written before and since Christs incarnation by the penmen of the Holy Ghost into those of the old Testament or instrument and the other of the new because they set forth the new Testament more plainly In you sixth and last Section besides the mistake before touched we crave leave to rectifie you in these ensuing things First whereas you say That now in the new Testament Christ the substance is exhibited If you conceive that the incarnation of Christ is the substance of all that was foreshewed required or promised in the times of the Law and the Prophets it is a great mistake for not onely his sufferings and resurrection but our conformity in following him with the whole process and work of salvation was thereby set out manifoldly and clearly under the Administrations of those times Secondly whereas you say That now under the Gospel the ordinances under which the Covenant of Grace is or ought to be
the seeking of them Rom. 10.14 15 c. A second let is a depraved judgement Act. 26.9 for I verily thought with my self thâ—t I ought to do many things against the name of Jesus A third impediment is the want of due remembrance and serious consideration of what we know in generall Lam. 1.9 He filthiness is in her skirts she remembred not her latter end A fourth bar is the power of Temptation of which the Apostle complaines 2 Cor. 12.7.8 A filth and a powerful obstacle is habit and custome in sin of which that is verified Qui non est hoâ—iè erà s minùs aptus erat Lastly Gods final desertion one of the heavyest of Judgements is an unremovable obstacle to the willing of good because seconded with Satans power Hence we may take a view how far the faln man can will good convert himself or prepare himself thereunto namely so far forth as men have some light of nature left or new illumination and convincing grace the which of all other is most necessary for the work of a true conversion Jer. 23.24 O Lord I know that the way of man is not in himself it is not in man that walketh to direct his steps Secondly This may be done with the more facility so far as they are chastned by the hand of the Lord and make a good use of it which made the Prophet Jeremy to pray as he doth Jer. 10.24 Correct me O Lord yet in judgement and not in thine angor lest thou bring me to nothing Howbeit in all this the Lord seems to lay no violent hand upon the will but works upon it by understanding judgement and reason with the use of sense and because he is the Author of the new understanding and judgement which leads and drawes the will he is said to work the will also Phil. 2.13 for Causae causae est etiam causa causaei But the main way whereby the man after illuminating or preventing grace can prepare himself to turn his heart or will is by frequent meditation and deep consideration of what he knows by grace or nature In your two last Sections First according to an ordinary distribution you distinguish the condition of converted sinners into a State of Grace and a State of glory but albeit there be different degrees in their new Metamorphosis or change yet their least estate in regeneration is a State of Glory as on the contrary the highest degree of that change and exaltation is a state of Grace For the proof of the first of these consider what the Apostle speaks 2 Cor. 3.18 But we all with open face beholding as in a glass the Glory of the Lord are transformed into the same Image from Glory to Glory as by the spirit of the Lord. 2 Pet. 1.3 Through the knowledge of him who hath called us unto Glory and Vertue And for the evidencing of the latter weigh well what Saint Peter writeth 1 Pet. 1.14 wherefore gird up the loins of your minde be sober and hope to the end for the Grace that is to be brought unto you at the Revelation of Jesus Christ See also 1 Pet. 3.7 as heirs together of the Grace of life But more particulary for your fourth Section As in the beginning of it you attribute too much to the first work or degree of our regeneration so you detract too much from the last and highest period of the same in the end of that Section For first you say but not truely That when God converts a sinner and translates him into the State of Grace he presently freeth him from his natural bondage under sin and by his grace alone enables him to will and to do that which is spiritually good Here brethren you go too far for the Apostle in the behalf of the young Babes or converts complains thus Rom. 7.8 9. For to will is present with me but how to perform that which is good Lâ—nde not for the good that I would I do not and the evil that I would not that do I. How then are they freed when the Apostle saith ver 23 He findes another Law in his members not only warring against the Law of his minde but bringing him captiue to the Law of sin in his members whereupon he cryes out verse 24. O wretched man that I am who shall deliver me from this body of deaâ—h Is a bondage then against your wils no captivity yea it is the most grievous bondage of all others in our sense and feeling though not so perilous to the soul as a willing subjection unto sin Indeed it is true of the young in Christ which the Apostle writs to them of that age 1 John 2.14 I have written unto you young men because ye are strong and the word of God abideth in you and you have overcome the wicked one But the Babe in Christ cannot attain thereunto while he is a chide Now in the close of that Section you flag and fall as much too short saying That this convert at his highest pitch for so you mean by reason of his remaining corruption doth not perfectly nor only will that which is good but willeth that which is evil also The which though it be true of the Infants aforesaid and perhaps may sometimes be verified of the middle ort yet it is not true of the old or aged men in Christ such as the Apostles themselves were as we have proved before In your last Section you do as you are wont wholly transferring the state of Glory in which the will of man is made immutably good out of this world but herein you are some what mistaken if we may give credit to these Scriptures Rev. 3.12 21. C. 1.2.3 4 5 6. CHAP. X. Of effectuall calling ALL those whom God hath predestinated unto life and those onely he is pleased in his appointed and accepted time effectually to call a Rom 8.30 Rom 11.7 Eph 1.10 11. by his Word and Spirit b 2 Thes 2.13 14. 2 Cor 3.6 out of that state of sin and death in which they are by nature to grace and salvation by Jesus Christ c Rom. 8.2 Eph 2.1 2 3 4. 2 Tim. 1.9 10. inlightning their minds spiritually and savingly to understand the things of God d Act 16.18 1 Cor 2.10 12. Eph 1.17 18. taking away their heart of stone and giving unto them an heart of flesh e Ezek 36.26 Eze 11.19 Phil 2.13 Deut. 36.6 Ezek 36.27 renewing their wils and by his Almighty power determing them to that which is good f and effectually drawing them to Jesus Christ g Eph 1.19 John 6.44 45. yet so as that they come most freely being made willing by his grace h Cant. 1.4 Psal 110.3 John 6.37 Rom. â— 16 17 18. II. This effectual call is of Gods free and special grace alone not from any thing at all foreseen in man i 1 Tim 1.9 Tit. 3.4 5. Eph 2.4 5 8 9. Rom â— 11. who is
for as Job said Chap. 27.5 God forbid that I should justifie them I will not leave my innocency till I dye But I humbly offer this and my self in all just obedience and subjection to you the Supream Authority of the Nation and Subscribe my name W. PARKER To the Assembly of Divines who were Convocated by Authority of Parliament at Westminster Men Brethren and Fathers LEast we should seem any way to detract from your worth we freely confess these things following both concerning you that are here the Confessors and your faith which you have confessed That though you are not all the most learned men in this Nation yet many of you are men of much Learning and abilities we confess likewise That for life and conversation many of you are grave sober Religious and devoute persons in your way having a zeal of God though in many things not according to knowledge as will appear That this Treatise of yours may in some tolerable sense be called a Confession of Faith faith being sometimes used for our present perswasion be it right or wrong as the Apostle intimates Rom. 14.23 And he that doubteth is damned if he eat because he eateth not of faith for whatsoever is not of faith is sin That the errors and mistakes failings and misperswasions found in this your Confession of Faith by you presented to the Parliament are not originally yours as if you first introduced them but you learned them of your Teachers and usually of your Authors whom you read without serious pensitation or due animadversion and to whom ye give too light and sudden credulity That yee err not alone but have many men of note and some whole nominal Churches who walk and wander with you in the same aberrations And finally that ye will not as we trust prove pertinatious in your errors but if the Lord shall vouchsafe to open your eyes and discover your erring paths unto you ye will turn from them and readily embrace the truth We hope you will not take this Examen in evil part when ye reflect upon these very words of yours Cha. 31. Sect. 4. All Synods and Councels since the Apostles dayes whether general or particular may err and many have erred Therefore they are not to be made the rule of faith or practice but to be used as an help in both To the end therefore that yee and all men may the better perceive that there hath been a great Apostasie and departure from the faith as the holy Apostles forewarned us 2 Thess 2.5 Except there come a falling away first 1 Tim. 4.1 Now the spirit speaketh expresly that in the latter dayes some shall depart from the faith giving heed to seducing spirits and doctrines of Devils That the Lord Christ in his late spiritual coming as himself foretold it should come to pass Luk. 18.8 Did scarcely finde the true faith in the earth That many times that which is highly esteemed with men is an abomination in the sight of God Luk. 16.15 And finally that it may be seen not only what erratick lights the common people have followed but also what weak and unexpert Councellors the Princes and States of the world have chosen to advise and assist them in their reforming enterprizes yea how little truth or infallibility is found in your Authors whom you so Idolize and how great a part of the modern Christians as well as the present Church of Rome is still captived with error and unbelief We will here modestly out of zeal of truth and we hope the truth of zeal reveal many sacred mysteries of Christ which were long hidden from us as wel as others but are through his rich grace made known unto us and many more unworthy ones and detect the contrary mistakes that God may be glorified and the Nations healed with the leaves of the tree of life Amen Courteous Friends I Was in Holland the last yeer and I received from a worthy friend these Latin verses which because they are pertinent to many things in the said Examen I have caused them to be Printed with the Book and they are translated into English for the capacity of them that understand not the Latin In Belgarum Synodum Dordrecti habitam funesto illo anno orbique tremendo 1618. Paulo post subortum cometam insignem irae divinz mundique flagellandi nuntium Pacifici cujusdam neutiquam indocti viri carmen posthumam BElgarum Clerus tristis comitesque cometae Dordrecti coeunt conciliumq vocant Turba gravis paci sibi cum posuere tribunal Arminio litem pars Gomarhaea movet Dordrectum roctum didicisset ab Amstelodame Prater ubi sidei jus toleramen habet At Synodo nodus restat solvendus utrisque Arbiter ecquis iis Aeacus aequus erit Scripturam dicis trahit hanc pars utraque secum Interpres loquitur litera sacra silet Est aliudque canon ubi stat sententia clara In dubiis aliud judicis officium Ominis incerti varioque interprete nutans Ductilis huc illuc nemo sequester erit Judicibus ratio rationi competit auris Num mens scripturae quae capit aure capit Atvobis aderit judex celesia Quaenam Vin Lutheranam nolumus inquis eam Romanam malles sed ferri malleus adstat Gens Jesuitarum gens inimica tibi Elige Dominicos Dominos at in omnibus istos Admittes Nego nos discrepat inter ubi Visn ' Anabaptistas quorum tibi copia Belga Non emergendi copia forsan ais Arbiter ipsus eris Gomarhaec Quid Hostis in hostem Judice me supero tu cadis Hostis ait Arminius tibi fit judex sub judice lis sit Illius arbitrio stésve cadásve placet Convocet is Synodum jam jam Gomarhaee secundam Is litem moveat te peragátque reum Siquis erit dubito Gomarhaeos Vorstius inter Interdictus eat magna pericla creet Examen cruciet monstrum hoc qui cunque remonstre Hunc Hispanorum carnificina probet Haereseos signes Gomarhaeam stigmate gentem Schismatis insimules parcere parce viris Damnetur Gomárhaea cohors cum cive Gomorrhae Tollite Damnandi munus ab Artifice Quid verum falsumve siet decernite tuti Vos penes arbitrium est Arminiana domus In lucem tenebras fidei pro dogmate profer Sit mundo fidei regula vestra fides Civilémque acuas gladium cum spirituali Ad Christi causam militis adfer opem Nil horum fieri tibi vis Gomarhaee per hostes Talia cur hosti feceris ipse prior Lege peris propriâ nec lex est justior ulla Arte tuâ captus fossus ense tuo Cymmeriis tenebris Gomarhaei dogmata nigrent Navis 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 migrat ad Armeniam Quis litem dirimat nisi venerit alter Elias Qui numen prodat coelitus igne dato Defecâ—t dudum Gomarhaee prophetia dicis Ergo prophetarum nullus es ipse choro â—essabit tandem si teste prophetia Paulo Cessat cognitio cessat
fal for so they then begin to be True it is that the great wickedness which the Psalmist complains of in his enemies and the persecutors of Gods people Psal 14 1 2. and Psal 36.1 2 c. as also that which Isaiah confesseth to God Chap. 59.2 3 4 c. is to be sound in too many and that not alone in those that are meer strangers unto God but in many members of the visible Church and therefore the Apostle applies those sayings to the Jews to prove them guilty of sin and death as well as the Gentiles Rom. 3.9 10 But though it must of necessity be granted which the Apostle affirms there afterwards Rom. 3.23 That all both Jews and Gentiles since the fall have sinned and come short of the glory of God Yet it will not follow from hence that all are alike deeply corrupted as they imply And this is your second mistake in this Section Lastly Whereas you say in the close of this Section That all actual transgressions do proceed from this original corruption of which you here speak It is false undoubtedly For Satan tempts men to many sins whereunto they have no previous inclination and suggests unto some of Gods servants such blasphemies as they abhor so far are they from being natural or familiar to them cannot that subtile powerful adversaries now tempt men aswel without corrupt inclinations as he did our first parents in their innocency Lastly to take a view of your fifâ—h Section you do not only affirm gross untruths there but seem to contradict your selves also As first That this corruption of nature doth remain in the regenerate during this life of which afterwards And then you adde Though it be in Christ both pardoned and mortified What do you say brethren Is it mortified by Christ and yet doth it remain Secondly Is it pardoned and yet doth it abide still in us For the first of these must it remain in us all our life time when then must it be quite purged out Must it be done in Purgatory hereafter or must men carry the remainders of sin with them into Gods Kingdom whereinto no unclean thing can enter Rev. 21.27 Surely you did not foresee what a world of absurdities would follow hereupon Must we not be implanted into the similitude of Christs death his total death that we may be implanted into the likeness of his resurrection Rom. 6.5 Certainly as the pattern was not a bare wounding or an half death in Christ so must our mortification be no less then a full death likewise Can Christ also be frustrate of the end of his coming who gave himself for his Church that he might sanctifie and cleanse it with the washing of water by the word That he might present it to himself a glorious Church not having spot or wrinckle or any such thing but that it should be holy and without blemish Ephes 5.25 26 27. Since this washing as the Apostle speaks must be by the water of the word surely it must be effected in this life Thirdly Is corruption a thing so well pleasing to God and his Chirst that he will not depart with it or wholly lose the presence and society of it See 2 Cor. 6.14 15 16. For what fellowship hath righteousness with unrighteousness and what communion hath light with darkness and what concord hath Christ with Belial and what agreement hath the temple of God with Idols Is not sin and corruption an enemy to Christ as well as death Now the Apostle faith That the last enemy which shall be destroyed is death If death then be the last enemy then of necessity sin must be destroyed before But since you are wont to object many things against this Let us take a view of your objections First you say That as the Canaanites were left to prove the faith and obedience of the Israelites Judg. 3.1 so the Lord in the beginning of our regeneration leaves many corruptions to exercise our faith love and obedience likewise Answer It is true that they are left at the first for that end But would the Lord have them alwayes to continue in us On no For as the Lord was displeased with his people Israel for permitting those Nations still to dwel among them when they should have subdued them or cast them out Judg. 2.1 2. so will the Lord be highly offended with us if we roote not out these wicked Nations through the help of his Christ 1 Cor. 15.25 It is certain that David a man after Gods own heart subdued all the Canaanites so that when Solomon succeeded him there was neither enemy left nor evil occurrent 1 King 5.4 And so hath Christ the promise that all his enemies shall be his foolstoole Psal 110.1 Acts 2 34. Yea he is given to us for our final deliverance from them and conquest over them Luk. 1.71 John 3.8 Secondly You say That corruption is lest to keep us humble least we grow proud Answer If all corruption were purged out what should become of pride Are not the Angels and Saints in Heaven most humble Thirdly you alledg that which Salomon speakes 1 King 1.48 's For there is no man that sinneth not Answer peradventure it may be granted that there is no man that ordinarily lived to mans estate who hath not often sinned Christ excepted Howbeit it doth not follow from hence that the regenerate shall always do so for St. John 1 Epist cap. 2. ver 1. writes to the Saints not to sin see also cap. 4. vers 17. Fourthly You are wont to urge that place Prov. 20.9 who can say I have made my heart clean I am pure from my sin Answer First that kind of interrogation doth not always imply a nullity but sometimes a paucity onely as Isa 53.1 who hath beleeved our report Secondly No man can say that he hath done this by his own strength Fifthly Some also object that place Prov. 24.16 the righteous falleth seven times and riseth again Answer The words following shew that this is to be understood of affliction not of sin which words are these But the wicked fall into mischief Sixthly That place Eccles 7.20 is much insisted upon For there is not a just man in the earth which doth good and sinneth not which place may be three wayes answered and yet the saying hold true First That though there were no such man in Solomons time being the infancy of the Church yet after-times might bring forth many such when a fuller dispensation of grace should come James 4.6 and Hebr. 11.40 God having provided some better things for us that they without us should not be made perfect Secondly It is not improbable that there hath been no man in any age Christ excepted who hath not sinned or done that which is good continually as we said before Thirdly There is an Earth of sin and corruption in which there is no man but sinneth often Colos 3.5 Martifie therefore your members which are upon earth Fornication Vncleanness
by his Spirit to believe and obey and governing their hearts by his word and spirit Å¿ John 14.16 Heb. 12.2 2 Cor. 4.13 Rom. 8.9 14. Rom. 15.18 19. Joh. 17.17 overcoming all their enemies by his mighty power and wisdom in such maner and wayes as are most consonant to his wonderful and unsearchable dispensation t Psal 1â— 1 1 Cor. 15.25 26. Mal. 4.2 3 Col. â— 15 CHAP. VIII Of Christ the Mediatour Examined WHen the foundation of the second Temple was laid as the younger sort shouted for joy so those that had seen the former house wept And though some younglings in the faith may rejoyce at this groundwork which you have laid yet were there any such here who had seen the house of God built in the Apostles dayes they could not refrain from teares beholding your ungrounded ground-work True it is which the Apostle speakes 1 Cor. 3.10 11 13 c. That other foundation can no man lay then that which is already laid by them even Jesus Christ But as all materials are not apt for building so both matter and workmanship bewray the workmans skil or unskilfulness And truly you brethren discover sufficiently what manner of builders you are who upon the foundation Jesus Christ have built so much wood hay and stuble but so little of gold silver or precious stones But since the word of God is compared to a fire Jerem. 23.23 Let us try what stuffe of yours will abide the fire that you may receive a reward and what must of necessity burn that though you suffer loss therein your souls may be saved In your first Section then besides many omissions concerning Christ as that he is the wisdom and power of God 1 Cor. 1.24 The brightness of his glory and the express image of his person the creator and upholder of all things who purgeth our sins by himself Heb. 1.2 You speak somethings of the Father and him ignorantly preposterously and untruly also For first you say That the father hath given him a people from all eternity which being understood of an actual gift is false for then there was no people to be bestowed upon him If you here meant that this was done by design and decree only why did you not so express your selves True it is by the confession of Christ himself that there are some which are given unto him by the father which also come unto him at least wise for a time Joh. 6.39 But these are they who are taught by the Father first and actually brought to know Christ and beleeve on him Joh. 6.39.40 44 45 c. Joh. 17.11 12. Thus was Judas also given unto him Joh. 17.12 Secondly you say That these are given to him first to be redeemed then called thirdly justified fourthly sanctified and lastly glorified by him Where first you may take notice of your preposterous disorder for all that are given or brought to Christ are a people first called by God the Father Joh. 6.44 And though Christ invites them to come unto him for release from their spiritual burdens Mat. 7.28 29. Yet untill the father hath called them they cannot be sensible of such burdens Thirdly whereas you say that he should first redeem against the Apostles order 1 Cor. 1.30 then justifie after sanctifie and lastly glorifie them you may please to take notice in the sequel of this book that inward or spiritual redemption in the Apostles sense is al one with justification that justification sanctification differ not And as for outward redemption the benefit of it accrues to no man till he be first â—anctified and hath put away his sins that they may be pardoned Lastly you here name but one sort of people who are to be saved by Christ to wit those which are faln in Aâ—am but Christ saveth Infants also as we have showed He being the onely tree of life in the whole paradise of God Rev. 2.7 In your second Section you make so clear a confession of Christs two natures united into one person of his conception by the Holy Ghost of his birth of the Virgin Mary in the fulness of time c. as will vindicate you from the errours of many hereticks which heretofore troubled the Church But is it sufficient to salvation think you to be no Arrian Nestorian Eutychian or the like heterodoxe or is there no other union betwixt Christ and our humanity but that hypostatical union at which you point here to be thought upon by us or finally is there not a spiritual conception and birth of Christ within us necessary for all faln men who would be saved If there be such an union and conception why have you made no mention of the one nor of the other As for the former of these we have shewed already in part that Christ is in every man by creation which may be further cleared by these Scriptures John 1.20 26 27 28. John answered them saying I baptise with water 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 But there standeth one in the midst of you whom ye know not he it is who coming after me is preferred before me whose shoes latchet I am not worthy to unloose These things were done in Bethabara beyond Jordan where John was baptizing Here observe that if Christ had been present John would have pointed unto him as he did the next day vers 29. which declares thus The next day John seeth Jesus coming unto him saith Behold the Lamb of God which taketh away the sin of the world Wherefore this place must be understood of Christs inward presence To like effect the Apostle speaks Acts 17.26 27 28. That Christ the Creatour of the world hath made of one blood all nations of men for to dwel on all the face of the earth and hath determined the times before appointed and the bounds of their limitation that they should seek the Lord if haply they might feel after him and finde him though he be not far from every one of us for in him we live and move and have our being This is that word which St. James cals 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the implanted â—â— ingrafted word which is able to save our souls ch 1.21 But that place Joh. 1.9 is like the argument that it speaks of full of light and clearness to this our purpose This is that light which lighteth every man that cometh into the world For the 2. omission viz. Of the necessity of Christs new conception birth in us you may take notice of these places that he is called Immanuel especially for his spiritual incarnation in us And in the same regard his true disciples are called his mothers Mat. 12.50 Rev. 12.1 5. John beheld the Church bringing forth a man-child which should rule all nations Gal. 4.19 the Apostle cries out â— my little children of whom I travel in birth again until Christ be formed in you Yea so necessary is this spiritual conception of Christ for us men now faln and
as is hinted in the name of Moses which also is the time of Gods delivering his Israel from under the spiritual Pharoah Thirdly That men are not said here to sin in Adam to wit our first fathers transgression but after the similitude of it Fourthly There are some which sin not after that patern but another way as we have shewed before concerning Edom the same name with Adam in the Hebrew consonants and consequently in signification also Fifthly That there is an Adam which is or was the figure of Christ and that is our personal Adam also of whom the Apostle speaketh thus 1 Cor. 15.49 And as we have born the Image of the earthy so we also shall bear the Image of the heavenly Lastly That though Christ be already come in the flesh yet here in this 14. verse he is spoken of as one yet to come which doubtless is Christs coming in the spirit John 14.21 Now for our second task You may please advisedly to consider these two things First That the Apostle at the 17. verse speaketh thus How much more shall they that receive abundance of grace and of the gift of righteousness raign in life by one Jesus Christ Now since we cannot enter into life but by a personal obedience as we shewed before for what other intent should the abundance of grace in Christ be more needful for us then for the performing of that obedience through which we attain unto the Kingdom and righteousness of God And so by one mans obedience even that of Christ within us are many made not putatively but really righteous according to verse 19. Secondly That the Prophets and Apostles speak frequently of Christs obedience in us but nowhere of his obedience for us more then of his suffering in our stead or his setting of us a patern to be followed Isa 26.12 Thou Lord wilt ordain peace for us for thou hast wrought all our works in us Jer. 31.33 I will put my law in their inward parts I will write it in their hearts Heb. 13.20 21. Now the God of peace that brought again from the dead our Lord Jesus Christ that great Shepherd of the sheep through the blood of the everlasting Covenant make you perfect in every good work to do his will working in you that which is well-pleasing in his sight through Jesus Christ 1 Cor. 15.10 But I laboured more abundantly then they all yet not I but the grace of God that was with me Phil. 1.10 Being filled with the fruits of righteousness which are by Jesus Christ unto the glory and praise of God Phil. 4.13 I can do all things through Christ who strengtheneth me Rom. 8.4 That the righteousness of the Law might be fulfilled in us c. Now if the righteousness of the Law may be fulfilled in us through the grace and help of Christ as the Apostle expresly affirms it there what great need was there that it should be fulfilled for us Frustrà fit per plura c. Furthermore as our disobedience was both begun and perfected with our own consent endeavours though not without the leading instigation and power of Satan is it not meet that our obedience likewise should be both enterprized and accomplished with our wills and best concurrences though guided and carried on yea accomplished also by the grace of God and the power of his Christ Is not that which is done in us or by u◠though in the strength of Christ in obedience to Gods Law and requiring much more acceptable unto him then that which is done without us without our knowledge endeavour or consent We in the mean time remaining enemies and rebels or but lazy and loytering servants Indeed the outward and personal obedience of Christ as it was active was necessary in him as a Mediator not onely as our 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 or foregoer but in order also to his suffering for us for had he failed in his obedience to the Law he might have suffered afterwards for his own sins but could not have satisfied for ours And as Christ could not by his outward and personal obedience satisfie the Fathers justice for that personal obedience which we out selves ought and which by his grace and help we may perform so he did not by the same obedience purchase a reconcilement between us and God as you here affirm Amos saith chap. 3.3 Can two walk together except they be agreed Although God affects us as a work of his hands yet so long as the body of sin which is enmity against God remains in us we can neither be reconciled unto him nor he to us For what fellowship hath righteousness with unrighteousness and what communion hath light with darkness 2 Cor. 6.14 Therefore it is said in the foregoing Chapter 2 Cor. 5.19 20. That God was in Christ reconciling the world unto himself not imputing their prespasses unto them and bath committed unto us the word of reconciliation Now then we are Embassadors for Christ as though God did beseech you by us we pray you in Christ's stead be ye reconciled to God Where we pray you to observe two things First That Christ is not said to have done the work to wit by his obedience or sufferings as you conceive but to be doing of it still viz. by his grace and spirit slaying the enmity aforesaid in and for those who beleeve aright on him and follow him in his like obedience and sufferings Secondly That the ground of the emnity between us and God lieth on our part who hate him his ways and righteousness through the sin that dwelleth in us And therefore the Apostle prayes us yea in a beseeching manner to be reconciled unto God And though two places at the first view upon which you mainly ground may seem to favour your assertion yet being rightly understood they do not patrocinate the same at all the first is Ephes 2.16 And that he might reconcile both unto God in one body by the Cross having slain the emnity thereby But here you may take notice that the body spoken of is his mystical body and the cross whereby the emnity is slain is his spiritual cross like patience or sufferance for by that we overcome every temptation of sin according to that of the Apostle James 1.4 But let patience have her perfect work that ye may be perfect and entire wanting nothing This is that cross and not afflictions themselves as the world conceives which Christ commandeth those that will follow him into life to take upon them for the denying of themselves or the putting off the old man Matth. 16.24 Hebr. 12.1 Wherefore seeing we also are compassed about with so great a cloud of witnesses let us lay aside every weight and the sin which doth so easily beset us and let us run with patience the race that is set before us Your other place upon which you rely is that of Col. 1.20 21 22. And having made peace through the blood of his
altogether passive therein untill quickened and renewed by the Holy Spirit k Cor 2.14 Rom 8.7 Eph 2.5 he is thereby inabled to answer this holy call and to embrace the Grace of God offered and convyed in it l Joh 5.25 Elect Infants dying in Infancy are regenerated and saved by Christ through the Spirit m Luk. 18.15 16 and Act 2.38 39 Joh 3.35 John 5.11 and Rom 8.9 compared who worketh when and where and how he pleaseth n Joh 3.8 So also are all other Elect persons who are uncapable of being outwardly called by the Ministry of the Word o 1 Joh 5.12 Act 4.12 III. Others not elected although they may be talled by the Ministry of the Word p Mat 22.14 and may have some common operations of the Spirit q Mat 17.22 Mat. 13.20 21. heb 6.4 5. yet they never truly come unto Christ and therefore cannot be saved r Joh 6.64 65 66. Joh. 8.24 much less can men not professing the Christian Religion be saved in another way whatsoever be theynever so diligent to frame their lives according to the light of nature and the Law of that Religion they do profess Å¿ Act 4.12 Joh 14.6 Eph 2.18 Joh. 4.22 John 17.13 and to assert and maintain that they may is very pernicious and to be detested t 2 John 9.10 11. 1 Cor 16.22 Gal 1.6 7 8. CHAP. X. Of effectull calling examined AS you had no calling to deliver many things here uttered by you so they are not very effectual or true In which kind the first Section is not the least culpable for therein you deliver these paradoxes among others First That God is pleased in his appointed and accepted time to call all those effectually whom he hith predestinated unto life the which is not true For as thousands dying in their Infancy never fell which thing we have before sufficiently proved so such neither need nor have any such calling as you here describe For though our Saviour speake thus of all faln men Mat. 18.3 Verily I say unto you Except ye be converted and become as little children ye shall not enter into the Kingdom of heaven yet children have no need to be conformed to such converts for of them and with such as they are is the Kingdom of heaven replenished Mark 10.14 Secondly You say with no less untruth That God calleth only those effectually whom he hath predestinated unto life which in your sense are the smaller part of men But as you make the universal father and common Saviour of all mankinde a partial God in his decree of election or predestination so you make him an accepter of persons in his calling of sinners to repentance both contrary to manifold and cleare Scriptures Here then we must assert those two things against you for the vindicating of Gods honor and the stopping of all mouths First That the Lord cals unto him all the sons of men who are faln from him and that with sufficient though not alwayes with a successful calling Secondly That he calls some of these which retain not with more industry and earnestness then many that come unto him continue with him and are saved in the end for the first of those we will here say nothing of that which our Saviour speaks Matth. 22.14 That many be called but few are chosen which though it overthrow the last Section yet it comes not up to a full proof of what we are now to maintain an universal and particular call of all men that are faln from God and who are capable of instruction But these following texts will carry it before them 1 Tim. 2.3 4. where the Apostle would have all men in general and in particular who have not sinned that sin unto death prayed for upon this ground For this is good and acceptable before God who would have all men saved and come to the knowledge of the truth If he would have it so what hinders but that he both may and doth bring all men to the knowlekge of so much truth as whereby they may be saved To this agree the words of the same Apostle Rom. 2.8 where he shews the true and onely cause why all that are lost do perish But to those that are contentious and disobey the truth and obey unrighteousness shall be indignation and wrath which is the same in effect with what he had before delivered Chap 1 18. For the wrath of God is revealed from Heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men who withhold or suppress the truth in unrighteousness If you reply that the Apostle in the former place of 1 Tim. 2.4 speaks de generibus singulorum That God would have some of all kinds and sorts of men saved and come to the knowledge of the truth We must here again urge the place of St. Peter Epist 2 Chap. 3.9 which undoubtedly speaks universally in the negative and the affirmative and so de singulis generum Not willing that any should perish but that all should come to repentance Doth not Elibu speak thus of Gods gratious dealing with all mankinde that are gone astray Job 33.14 15 16 17 18. For God speaketh once yea twice yet man perceiveth or regardeth it not In a dream in the visions of the night when deep sleep falleth upon men in slumbring upon the bed Then he openeth the eares of men and sealeth their instruction That he may withdraw man from his purpose and hide pride from man He keepeth back his soul from the pit and his life from perishing by the sword And having named many other means which God useth for the self-same end ver 29.30 thus he sums up all and concludes the point Loe all these things God oftentimes worketh with man to bring back his soul from the pit to be enlightened with the light of the living And Job 34.23 For he will not lay upon man more then is right that he should enter into judgement with God which thing according to the doctrine all the sons of Adam might do for having his sin imputed to them before they were actual sinners and in him being deprived not onely of all wisdom holiness and power but every way blinded and depraved and that without a sufficient help of grace to ridd and deliver them as to the greatest part of them And verse 26 27. he shews the cause why he strikes wicked men even for this refractory opposition apainst his teachings and calls He striketh them as wicked men in the open sight of others because they turned back from him and would not consider any of his wayes whereas it was our duty to say to the Lord as often as he teacheth and chastiseth as it there followes verse 31.32 It is meet to be said unto God I have born Chastisement I will not offend any more That which I know not teach thou me if I have done iniquity I will do no more And chap. 35.10 11. complaining of mans
ye are sanctified but ye are justified in the name of the Lord Jesus and by the Spirit of our God Was not new righteousness put into these men And were they not thereby washed sanctified and justified these three words expressing one and the same thing see also Tit. 3.4 5 6. But after the kindness and love of God our Saviour unto man appeared not by works of righteousness which we have done but according to his mercy he saved us by the washing of regeneration and the renewing of the Holy Ghost which he shed on us abundantly through Jesus Christ our Saviour that so being justified by his Grace we should be made heirs according to the hope of eternal life Where you see again that the Apostle makes regeneration in Christ and justification to be the self same thing as we intimated in the foregoing Chapter Yea in the whole dispute about justification by Christ the Apostle Paul useth the word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 to justifie either for that part of justification which we commonly call mortification or that other part which we usually term vivification or for both as Rom. 6.7 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 For he that is dead to wit with Christ is justified freed or purged from sin In this notion doth the Apostle use the word Act. 13.39 And by him all that believe are justified or cleansed from all things from which they could not be justified by the Law of Moses Rev. 22.11 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 that is He that is unjust will be so let him be unjust still and be which is filthy let him be filthy still and he that is or will be righteous let him be justified or righteous still and that is holy let him be sanctified still Where justification and sanctification are the same thing so Isa 45.24 25. Surely shall one say In the Lord have I righteousness and strength even to him shall men come and all that are incensed against him shall be ashamed In the Lord shall all the seed of Israel be justified and shall glory Where righteousness and strength being joyned together the words must be understood of an internal righteousness through which our sins and corruptions are purged out And therein lies our justification as the next verse imports Yea if mortification be not comprehended under the word justification it is wholly left out in that golden chain so much spoken of and so little understood Rom. 8.30 Moreover whom be did predestinate them he also called and whom he called them he also justified and whom he justified them he also glorified In this sense Cyprian useth the word frequently and among prophane authors Catullus thus Justificam nobis mentem avertere deorum And so must the word of necessity be meant by the Apostle Rom. 5.8 as appeareth there by the opposition of our state as sinners to our justified estate But God commendeth his love towards us that while we were yet sinners Christ dyed for us much more being now iustified by his blood we shall be saved from wrath thruogh him And so must the same word be taken Rom. 3.24 25. Gal 2.17 We grant indeed that the word is a 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and variously used as for defending our selves or others as just Luke 16.15 Ye are they which justifie your selves before men c. for absolving or declaring one just Rom. 8 33 34. It is God that justifieth who is he that condemneth for predicating or magnifying some person or thing Mat. 11.19 But wisdom is justified of her children But all these are founded upon that moral sense of being just or made just or of being free from unrighteousness which is the Apostles sense in all his discourse of justification by Christ Thirdly you say positively That God justifieth by pardoning of sins but though 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 is used sometimes for the puting away of sins and that by regeneration Luk. 1.77 Eph. 1.7 and elswhere as well as for the pardon of sins Yet justification in Saint Pauls sense lieth not in remission of sins Fourthly you say positively also That God justifies men by accounting and accepting their persons as righteous and you mean he doth so while they are otherwise both in heart and life But God accounts of every man as he is and though he is so gracious as to pardon the guilt of sins forsaken and repented of and ready also in Christ both to cleanse us and renew us because he would not have us dye in our iniquities yet as he speaks to Moses he will by no means clear the guilty or such as continue in evil Exod. 34.7 He is a God of purer eyes then to behold iniquity Hab. 1.13 Doth not he search the heart and try the reines that he may give to every man according to his wayes and according to the fruit of his doings Jer. 17.20 See what he saith Micah 6.10 11. Are there yet the treasures of wickedness in the house of the wicked and the scant measure that is abominable shall I count them pure with the wicked balances and the bag of deceitful weights God indeed is said to justifie the ungodly Rom. 4.5 Yet not by accounting him righteous when he is wicked but by cleansing and renewing him and so making him of ungodly a godly and righteous person Fifthly you say God justifies them not for any thing that is wrought in them which is false for it is by something wrought in us that we are justified and sanctified and by something wrought in us also that we are justified that is declared just before God and men in Jesus Christ Sixthly you say That such are justified for Christs sake alone which is true of Christ and his work within us but not of Christ and his obedience without us as you mean it But why do you in these two last passages oppose that which is wrought in us to Christ as if the father and his Christ with the Holy Ghost were not the makers of every good work in the unregenerated Seventhly you say That God in this work imputeth not faith or the act of believing unto us for righteousness contrary to express Scriptures Is it not written Gen. 15.6 Rom. 4.3 Gal 3.6 that Abraham believed God and it was imputed unto him for righteousness that is the Lord accepted his believing whereby he gave him that honor of his truth omnipotency and faithfulness as an acceptable duty at his hand and rewarded it with the promised righteousness as St. James speaks chap. 2.23 Yea doth not the Apostle speak thus expresly Rom. 4.23 24. Now it was not written for his sake alone that it was imputed to him but to us also to whom it shall be imputed if we believe in him who raised up our Lord Jesus from the dead Eighthly you say That God doth not impute any other Evangelical obedience to men for their righteousness wherein you run full butt against the whole stream of the Scriptures of the Old and New
them onely that are justified in facto vel potius perfecto Thirdly whereas you grant That persons justified may by their sins fall under Gods fatherly displeasure and not have the light of his countenance restored unto them until they humble themselves confess their sins beg pardon and renew their faith and repentance This is true yet not of those perfect or consummate ones who fall not so either into sin or Gods displeasure but of the younger sort onely in the time of their progress and growing up who may not only so faile and suffer as you have affirmed but possibly may through a wilful revolt both fall away totally and remain under indignation finally As to your sixth and last Section because we have described the way and means of justification more groundedly then ye have done we can truely speak it in your words but not in your sense That the justification of beleevers in the Old Testament was in all these respects one and the same with the justification of beleevers under the New Testament But before we leave this subject give us leave to inform you of two things The first is That the means of our justification or spiritual redemption in Christ Jesus is principally his blood the blood of the everlasting Covenant his promised spirit Romans 3.24 25. Ephesians 1.7 Colossians 1.14 Hebrews 9.14 15. 22. compared with Jeremy 31.32 33 Ezekiel 36.25 26 c. Hebrews 10.29 chap. 13.20.21 Rev. 7.14 1 Joh. 1.7 9. The second is that remission of sins wherein you place justification for the main is to be had after sin is put away by sanctification and amendment and not before as you fondly dream both here and elsewhere For which purpose take these ensuing Scriptures Proverbs 28.13 He that covereth his sin shall not prosper but but whoso confesseth and forsaketh them shall have mercy Jeremy 33.8 And I will cleanse them from all their iniquities whereby they have sinned against me and I will pardon all their iniquities whereby they have sinned against me Mark 1.4 John preached the baptism of repentance for the remission of sins Luke 24.47 And that repentance and remission of sins should be preached in his name among all Nations Acts 5.32 Him hath God exalted with his right hand to be a Prince and a Saviour for to give repentance unto Israel and remission of sins Acts 26.17 18. Vnto whom I now send thee to open their eyes and to turn them from darkness to light and from the power of Satan unto God that they may receive remission of sins and an inheritance among them that are sanctified by faith that is in me 1 Cor. 1.30 Of him are ye in Christ Jesus who of God is made unto us wisdom righteousness sanctification and redemption Hebrews 10.14 For by one offering hath he perfected for ever those which are sanctified To all which we could adde that the blessedness which David speakes of Psal 32.2 lies first in the putting away of sins by sanctification as the last words there import and the rest will bear it and then in having them or the guilt of them pardoned in Jesus Christ which words may be thus rendered O the blessedness of the man whose transgression is taken away and whose sins are covered or buryed with the like death of Christ O the blessedness of the man to whom the Lord imputeth not iniquity by letting him dye in his sins as one filthy and unpurged and in whose spirit there is no guile CHAP. XII Of Adoption ALL those that are Justified God vouchsafeth in and for his only Son Jesus Christ to make partakers of the grace of Adoption a Eph. 1.5 Gal 4.4 5 Ro 8.17 by which they are taken into the number and enjoy the liberties and priviledges of the children of God b Joh 1.12 have his name put upon them c Jer. 14.9 2 Cor 6.18 Rev. 3 12. receive the spirit of Adoption d Ro. 8.15 have access to the Throne of Grace with boldness e Eph. 3.12 Rom. 5.2 are inabled to cry Abba Father f Gal. 4.6 are pitied g Psal 103.13 protected h Prov. 14.16 provided for i Mat 6.30.32 1 Pet. 5.7 and chastened by him as a Father k Heb 12.6 yet never cast off l Lam 3.31 but sealed to the day of redemption m Eph 4 20. and inherit the promises n Heb 6.12 as heirs of everlasting salvation o 1 Pet 1.3 4. Heb 1 14. CHAP. XII Of Adoption examined ERROR and misconceptions in you here as elsewhere Hydra like multiplies heads needlessly for this argument of Adoption is the same with effectual calling in some measure and the self-same with that election of God which is in time of which we spake before And as that is twofold the first conditional the second final and absolute so is this and though all the children of God are capable of these your priviledges or most of them in time if they continue in their filial faith and obedience yet are not they so at the first yea some have by their faithful walking proceeded so far by Gods grace that they have left some of the lesser and foregoing prerogatives behind them Therefore you have first committed great disorder and confusion in attributing all these alike unto all not shewing which priviledges belong to all Saints and which but to some who may absolutely expect all or most of them and who may expect the same conditionally onely Secondly You take the high way here as you have done elsewhere to fill many who are not yet past danger with security and presumption For the first of these There are three degrees of Gods name Image or like being The first Which is the fathers name is written upon those that beleeve on him love and obey him The second Which is Christs powerful and saving name becomes written upon such as are brought to know him to trust in his saving office and to seek his help against their enemies and who persist so seeking The third Which is the name of the holy Ghost and the new Jerusalem with the new name of Christ is engraven onely upon those that have overcome all their enemies through the power of Christ Revel 3.12 These last are they that are never cast off and who inherit the promises as heirs of salvation But the other two If they abide not in the Father and in Christ after they know him may fall short of the promises and be rejected Those of the third form are past Gods fatherly chastisements because they now sin not 1 John 3. but the other two are not so As for the other You tell us that all which are adopted to be the children of God are sealed to the day of redemption but none are so sealed finally and absolutely save the third sort of whom we spake before the rest are but sealed conditionally yet left in good hope Yea all those priviledges which you
23 24. In your fifth Section the better to colour over your own faults as it may seem you asperse the best Churches saying The purest Churches under heaven are subject to mixture and error what say you then to the two Churches the one of Smyrna Rev. 2.8 9 10 11. the other of Philadelphia Rev. 3.7 8 c. with neither of which Christ finds the least fault but highly commends them both True it is if we look into the Churches there is mixture of the inferior members and they are subject to such errors but there are preadventure some such members to be found in some of those two Churches if not elswhere as are no more subject to error then the Prophets and Apostles were certain it is there is such a doctrine discipline from the immediate mouth of God to be found in one of those Churches that no reformers have need to seek any further where also the true Church is fully discovered and all causes of discord and controversie are in that behalf taken away But whereas you add in the same Section and that most truly that some Churches have so degenerated as to become no Churches but Synagogues of Satan you do here necessarily grant what you elswhere deny that some of the Saints and called ones may fall finally from grace for none other are the members of the true Church general or particular among men grown but such We will here charge you with that which you at unawares and unadvisedly affirm in the close of that Section That there shall be alwayes a Church on earth to worship God according to his will for that implies that the earth and the Church there inhabiting shall continue for ever which we conceive is no article of your belief In your sixth and last Section you truly affirm That there is no other head of the Church but the Lord Jesus Christ but you in your next words have rather deserved the Popes Bull then his Benediction if he may be Judge For first If a Church be that which yee describe it A Congregation of those which profess the true Religion Why might not the Bishop of Rome a least wise in the Primitive times before that Church fell away be in some sence a subordinate head of that Church under Christ or an earthly or Ecclesiastical head as Paul was over the Churches of the Gentiles That the Pope should be an Antichrist which of many Popes and of the state of Papacy is and may be truly affirmed among many other we grant but that he or the succession of Popes or the whole Hierarchy as they are called should be that man of sin and son of perdition which sitteth in the Temple of God exalting himself above and against all that is called God 2 Thess 23.4 8. is doubtless a great though a common mistake for as to the successors of Popes they are many but the Antichrist is one individuum if they all should perish which no charitable man will affirm they should be called not one son of perdition but sons of destruction But to pitch upon the person of the Pope as one individual and single Antichrist out of such a numerous company of Popes which will you single out one past present or to come Certain it is first that the Antichrist of which Saint Paul speaks is a man of sin composed altogether of iniquity and not of flesh and blood as each Pope is Secondly That he is a mystery of iniquity into which none but very spiritual men can see of which none of you or any of your authors or their adherents have yet a true sight Thirdly that the Antichrist exalts himself above all that is called God or is worshipped and so doth not the Pope directly do who acknowledgeth God Christ the Holy Ghost yea Angels and Saints to be above him Fourthly Antichrist sits in the middle of the Temple of God so doth not the Pope in your sense of the Temple for he pretends to be head of the Roman Church especially Fifthly he doth not say that he is God as Antichrist doth Sixthly All Popes came not with signs and lying wonders nor with all the deceiveableness of unrighteousness as Antichrist comes Lastly Antichrists coming is inward and not outward 2 Thess 2.9 10. and deceives all which receive not the love of truth but the Pope could never decive all such But what may this Antichrist be then Answer first the Temple of God is mans heart or soul where he sits Secondly As Christ is the true unction there so Antichrist is a contrary unction of false and erroneous wisdom righteousness and zeal which sets it self as if it were the holy Ghost and his works opposeth the truth and Kingdom of God and not only allows but hides fosters and cherisheth iniquity in men where he raigneth In a word if the Lord give you spiritual eyes to read the two texts 1. that of 2 Thess 2.3 4 5 c. and then that of Revel 13.11 12 c. to both which you refer us you may by Gods grace make a discovery of Antichrist as one neerer you then the Pope of Rome and one more endangering your souls and learn truly to know and hate him which mercy the Lord grant unto us all Concerning the first text you may observe these things First it is evident that this Antichrist takes his beginning and rise from mens Apostacy or departure from the true faith love and godliness which was fet up by Christ and his Apostles and that in all that fell away 2 Thess 2.3 So that he must needs be the succeeding falshood error hypocrisie and ungodliness Secondly that he is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 a man composed of nothing but sin Thirdly That he must therefore needs be a child yea the son of perdition Fourthly That he opposeth himself to all that is called God that is to God and all goodness verse 4. Fifthly That he exalts himself above all that is called God or worshipped even the Father Son and holy Ghost All which is true of the false wisdom and holiness which Satan begets in men to delude them there with and to oppose the truth kingdom and work of Christ thereby Sixthly That he sits in the temple of God which is our heart or inward man Seventhly That there he shews or gives forth himself for a God as this deceitful work of errour and delusion saith it is the presence and work of the Holy Ghost Eighthly That he cannot well be known but by spiritual revelation vers 6. Ninthly That there is one tha what he can hides him keeps him close maskes covers him and lets or hinders his revealing or disclosure and that is Satan verse 6.7 Tenthly That as he came in by mens departure from Christ his spirit and kingdom so by Christs spiritual presence and comming again in his brightness power and glory he shall be both revealed and destroyed by the spirit of his mouth 11. That he is called the
the representing of your errours in worse part then it is meant your better information and the saving of your souls and others Finally Since you have set so good bounds between the Civil Magistrate and your selves in your last Section we will not remove the Landmark CHAP. XXXII Of the state of men after death and of the resurrection of the dead THE bodies of men after death return to dust and see corruption a Gâ—n 3 19 Act 13.36 but their soul which neither die nor sleep having an immortal subsistance immediately return to God who gave them b Lu 23.43 Eccl 12.1 the souls of the righteous being then made perfect in holiness are received into the highest Heavens where they behold the face of God in light and glory waiting for the full redemption of their bodies c Heb 12.13 2 Cor 5.16.8 Phil. 1 23â— Acts 3.20 Eph 4.10 And the souls of the wicked are cast into Hell where they remain in torments and utter darkness reserved to the judgement of the great day d Luke 16.23 24. Acts 1.25 Jude 1.6 7 1 Pet 3.19 Besides these two places for souls separated from their bodies the Scriptures acknowledg none II. At the last day such as are found alive shall not die but be changed e 1 Thes 4.15 1 Cor 15.5 2. and all the dead shall be raised up with the self-same bodies and none other although with different qualities which shall be united again to their souls for ever f Job 19.26 27. 1 Cor 15.42 43 44. III. The bodies of the unjust shall by the power of Christ be raised to dishonour the bodies of the just by his Spirit unto honour and be made conformable to his own glorious body g Acts 24.13 John 5.28.29 1 Cor 15.43 Phil 3.21 CHAP. XXXII Of the state of men after death and of the resurrection of the dead Examined HERE we could revive a manifold resurrection by you buried in silence one of internal both righteousness and unrighteousness discovered and raised up at our first humiliation by the spirit of God and the work of his Law Rom. 7.7 8 9. Another of men raised up by a work of regeneration some to honour as those that persevere and others to dishonour as those that fall away again Dan. 12.2 Thirdly A spiritual resurrection with Christ after we have been dead with him to sin Rev. 20 6. And lastly the raising up the souls again at our dissolution that it may go to judgement which is called a resurrection Catechristically but because you are now drawing towards a conclusion we shall have the less cause to contest or debate with you These violent motions should grow more remisse and gentle towards the latter end Your first Section comprehends many Propositions which we dare not deny nor shall we much alter them That the bodies of men after death return to dust That then they see corruption That the Soul whether a distinct part from the spirit or no hath an immortal subsistence That the soul sleeps not though many of them be at rest That the spirit returns to God that gave it Ecclesiastes 12 7. That the souls go to God immediately to receive their doom That the souls of the righteous after death are made perfect in happiness not without some access of holiness That those so made perfect are received into the Highest Heaven or into Paradice That those which are so received behold the face of God in life and glory waiting for the full redemption of their bodies That the Souls of the wicked are cast into Hell where they remain in torments and utter darkness reserved to the judgement of the great day yet we could tell you of some no contemptible Authors and those no Papists who maintain a twofold delivery out of Hell the one made by Christ of the men of the old world at the time of his resurrection for which they alledge Zech. 9.11 and 1 Pet. 3.19 20. and 1 Pet. 4.6 The other to be made at the end of the Chiliasts term of their thousand years Rev. 20.5 But the rest of the dead lived not till the thousand years were ended That besides these two places of the souls separatd from the bodies the Scripture for ought we yet finde makes no cleer mention of any other yet are we not altogether ignorant of what some have written concerning Limbo nor that some which favour not the Church of Rome as Jacob Behman for one do assigne a third place namely the Region of the Land of Canaan to be an Elysian field for the souls of departed Saints because the Lord sware to give the Land to Abraham and his seed for ever But whether the souls of the just shall dye imperfect and have their perfection adjourned to another world as you mean is a quere of some importance and to hold that it must be so positively may prove a dangerous errour For our parts we acknowledge that the Saints in Heaven do obtain no small access and increase as of light and wisdom so of power love holiness peace and joy also for the Apostle saith Phil. 1.21 For me to live is Christ but to die is gain To which that seems to agree which the Apostle speaks 2 Cor. 5.1 2. For we know that if our earthly Tabernacle of this house were dissolved we have a building given us of God not made with hands but eternal in the Heavens But that the body of sin may and should be destroyed the workmanship of Satan abolished the righteousness of the law fulfilled and the Jerusalem that comes down from Heaven be fully sought and attained by us through the grace of Christ even in this life we have sufficiently proved before It remains then that we all take heed to the Apostles charge 2 Cor. 7 1.2 Having therefore these promises dearly beloved let us cleanse our selves from all filthiness of the flesh and the spirit perfecting our holiness in the fear of God yea let all those that would be counted faithful Ministers in Christ Jesus labour with St. Paul Colos 1.28 to present every man perfect in Christ Jesus As to your 2d Section although the Apostle in that great larger chapter of the resurrection 1 Co. 15. seems to speak onely of the resurrection of the just yet we must grant that all the dead shall be raised according to other Scriptures and namely that of John 5.28 29. Marvel not at this for the hour is coming in the which all that are in the graves shall hear his voice and shall come forth they that have done good unto the resurrection of life and they that have done evil unto the resurrection of condemnation But for a conclusion of this chapter may not some be mistaken in thinking the first resurrection which comes not to any till they be first dead with Christ Rom. 6 5. is past already see 2 Tim. 2.18 yea to make our future happiness sure what had been more needful here