Inadvertency in compleat Acts of crying Sins Secondly There is no pretence for Inadvertency if we had any Misgivings within or Warnings without concerning that particular Sin into which we fell afterwards much less if we cherish ill Motions till they grow too strong for us And Last of all if we repeat the same Sin frequently and contemptuously And to this I may add he cannot be said to Sin through Surprise who throws himself into the Way of Temptation even though he be conscious of his own Infirmity 3ly As to those Moral Defects which flow from natural Infirmity they will not destroy us if the Infirmity it self be pardonable There are Infirmities which we acquire Infirmities which grow stronger by Indulgence Infirmities which continue meerly because we do not take Pains to subdue them Our Moral Defects must not flow from these kinds of Infirmities but from such as considering Human Nature and the State of this World 't is impossible utterly to root out These moral Defects will do us no harm if First we take Care to settle in our Minds the Habits of those Vertues that are directly opposite to them Secondly If we watch and fight against our natural Infirmities and endeavour to reduce our Appetites even our natural Appetites within strict and narrow Bounds Thirdly If we wash off the Stains of our Slips and Defects by a general Repentance For upon the Notion I have here given of Venial Sin Repentance appears to be very necessary for I require in them something of Voluntary someting of Freedom enough to make an Action sinful though not to prove the Heart corrupt or wicked And because the Degrees of Voluntary and Involuntary are not so easily distinguishable from one another 't is plain our best security against any ill Consequence of our Defects and Frailties is a Godly Sorrow And therefore I wonder not if David charge himself more severely than God does my Sins are more in number than the hairs of my head this was a Confession that became the Humility and Sollicitude of a Penitent That became the Reflections of a wise and Perfect Man and the Corruption of Human Nature the Alloy of Human Performances the slips and Defects the Interruptions Neglects and Deviations of the best Life CHAP. VI. Of Liberty as it imports Freedom or Deliverance from Mortal Sin HERE I will Enquiry into three Things 1. What Mortal Sin is or what kind of Sins they be which are on all hands acknowledg'd to be Inconsistent with a state of Grace and Favour 2. How far the Perfect Man must be set free or deliver'd from this kind of Sins or how remote he is from the Guilt of them 3. Which way this Liberty may be best attained S. 1. The First thing necessary is to state the Notion of that Sin which passes under the Name of Mortal Wilful Presumptuous or Deliberate Sin For these in Writers are equivalent Terms and promiscuously used to signifie one and the same thing Sin saith St. John 1 Ep. 3.4 is the Transgression of the Law This is a plain and full Definition too of Sin For the Law of God is the Rule of Moral Actions 't is the Standard and Measure of Right and Wrong of moral Good and Evil whatever is not within the Compass of the Law is not within the Compass of Morality neither whatever cannot be comprehended within this Definition cannot have in it the entire and compleat Notion of Sin or which is all one it cannot be Sin in a strict proper and adequate Sense of the Word Hence St. John in the same Verse tells us That whosoer sinneth transgresseth a Law and St. Paul Rom. 4.15 where there is no Law there is no Transgression Sin then must alwaies suppose a Law without which there can be neither Vice nor Vertue Righteousness nor Wickedness For these are nothing else but the Violation or Observation of the Law of God or Habits and States resulting from the one or the other But this is not all Two Things more must be remark'd to render this Definition which the Apostle gives us of Sin clear and full First The Law must be sufficiently reveal'd Secondly The Transgression of it must be truly Voluntary 1. By sufficient Revelation of a Divine Law every one understands That the Law must be so publish'd to the Man who is to be govern'd by it that the Authority and Sense of it may be if it be not his own fault render'd evident to him If the Divine Authority of any Rule or Precept be doubtful and uncertain the Obligation of it will be so too And it is as necessary that the sense of the Law should be evident as its Authority The Law that is pen'd in dark and ambiguous Terms is properly speaking no Law at all Since the Mind of the Law-giver is not sufficiently made known by it Whatever is necessarily to be forborn or done by us must be fully and clearly prescribed in the Law of God and if it be not it can never be necessary Men through Weakness or Design may Enact Laws that are but a heap of Letters a Crowd of dubious Delphick Sentences But God can never do so because this is repugnant both to his Wisdom and Goodness and to the very End of a Law too which is to be a Rule not a Snare 't is to give Understanding to the Simple to be a Light to our Feet and a Lamp to our Paths not like an Ignis fatuus to betray us into Brakes and Precipices and Ruin and Death 2. Transgression must be a Voluntary one And this imports two Things 1. A Knowledge of Law 2. A Consent to the Breach of it First As to the Knowledge of the Law All that I have to say here in few words is That Ignorance of the Law excuses a Transgression when it is it self excusable but if the Ignorance it self be Criminal the effect of it must be so too We must never think of excusing our Sins by alledging an Ignorance into which not our own Incapacity or any other reasonable Cause but Neglect or Contempt of the Truth or some other vicious Lust or Passion has betray'd us Secondly As to the Consent of the Will This is necessary to demonstrate any Action sinful or vertuous without this the Mind will be no Partner in the Sin and by Consequence cannot be involved in the Guilt of it Whatever we cannot help is our Misfortune not our Fault Actions meerly natural or meerly forc'd can neither be good nor evil The concurrence of Reason and Choice is indispensably necessary to the Morality of an Action All this is plainly taught us by St. James 1.14 15. But every Man is tempted when he is drawn away of his own Lust and enticed then when Lust hath conceived it bringeth forth Sin and Sin when it is finished bringeth forth Death Which words do certainly imply That the Spring and Principle of Sin is within our selves That 't is our natural Corruption that entices
the contrary consist in being able not only to will but to do good in obeying those Commandments which we cannot but acknowledge to be holy and just and good And this is the very Notion which our Lord and Master gives us of it Joh. 8. For when the Jews bragg'd of their Freedom he lets them know that Freedom could not consist with Subjection to Sin he that committeth Sin is the Servant of Sin ver 34. That honourable Parentage and the Freedom of the Body was but a false and ludicrous Appearance of Liberty that if they would be free indeed the Son must make them so ver 36. i. e. they must by his Spirit and Doctrine be rescued from the Servitude of Lust and Errour and be set at Liberty to work Righteousness If ye continue in my word then are ye my Disciples indeed and ye shall know the Truth and the Truth shall make you free ver 31 32. Finally not to multiply Proofs of a truth that is scarce liable to be controverted as the Apostle describes the Bondage of a Sinner in Rom. 7. so does he the Liberty of a Saint in Rom. 8. For there ver 2. he tells us That the Law of the Spirit of Life has set the true Christian free from the Law of Sin and Death And then he lets us know wherein this Liberty consists in walking not after the Flesh but after the Spirit in the Mortification of the Body of Sin and Restitution of the Mind to its just Empire and Authority If Christ be in you the Body is dead because of Sin but the Spirit is Life because of Righteousness ver 10. And all this is the same thing with his Description of Liberty Chapter 6. where 't is nothing else but for a Man to be made free from Sin and become the Servant of God Thus then we have a plain account of Bondage and Liberty Yet for the clearer understanding of both it will not be amiss to observe that they are each capable of different Degrees and both the one and the other may be more or less entire compleat and absolute according to the different Progress of Men in Vice and Vertue Thus in some Men not their Will only but their very Reason is enslaved Their Vnderstanding is so far infatuated their Affections so entirely captived that there is no Conflict at all between the Mind and the Body they commit Sin without any Reluctancy before-hand or any Remorse afterwards their sâ—ared Conscience making no Remonstrance inflicting no wounds nor denouncing any Threats This is the last Degree of Vassalage Such are said in Scripture to be dead in Trespasses and Sins Others there are in whom their Lust and Appetite prevails indeed but not without Opposition They Reason rightly and which is the natural Result of this have some Desires and wishes of Righteousness but through the Prevalency of the Body they are unable to act and live conformable to their Reason Their Vnderstanding has indeed Light but not Authority It consents to the Law of God but it has no Power no Force to make it be obeyed it produces indeed some good Inclinations Purposes and Efforts but they prove weak and ineffectual ones and unable to grapple with the stronger Passion raised by the Body And as Bondage so Liberty is of different Degrees and different Strength For though Liberty may be able to subsist where there is much Opposition from the Body yet 't is plain that Liberty is most absolute and compleat where the Opposition is least where the Body is reduced to an entire Submission and Obsequiousness and the Spirit reigns with an uncontroul'd and unlimited Authority And this latter is that Liberty which I would have my Perfect man possessed of I know very well 't is commonly taught by some that there is no such State But I think this Doctrine if it be throughly considered has neither Scripture Reason nor Experience to support it For as to those Places Rom. 7. and Gal. 5. urged in favour of an almost Incessant strong and too-frequently prevalent lusting of the Flesh against the Spirit it has been often answered and proved too that they are so far from belonging to the Perfect that they belong not to the Regenerate But on the contrary those Texts that represent the Yoke of Christ easie and his burden light which affirm the Commandments of Christ not to be grievous to such as are made Perfect in Love do all bear witness to that Liberty which I contend for Nor does Reason favour my Opinion less than Scripture For if the Perfect man be a New Creature if he be transformed into a New Nature if his Body be dead to sin and his Spirit live to Righteousness in one word if the World be as much crucified to him as he to it I cannot see why it should not be easie for him to act consonant to his Nature why he should not with Pleasure and Readiness follow that Spirit and obey those Affections which reign and rule in him Nor can I see why a Habit of Righteousness should not have the same Properties with other Habits that is be attended with ease and pleasure in its Operations and Actions 'T is true I can easily see why the Habits of Righteousness are acquired with more Difficulty than those of any other kind but I say I cannot see when they are acquired why they should not be as natural and delightful to us as any other Lastly how degenerate soever Ages past have been or the present is I dare not so far distrust the Goodness of my Cause or the Vertue of Mankind as not to refer my self willingly in this point to the Decision of Experience I am very well assured that Truth and Justice Devotion and Charity Honour and Integrity are to a great many so dear and delightful so natural so easie that it is hard to determine whether they are more strongly moved by a sense of Duty or the Instigations of Love and Inclination and that they cannot do a base thing without the utmost Mortification and Violence to their Nature Nor is all this to be wondred at if we again reflect on what I just now intimated that the Perfect Man is a new Creature transformed daily from Glory to Glory that he is moved by new Affections raised and fortified by new Principles that he is animated by a Divine Energy and sees all things by a truer and brighter Light through which the things of God appear lovely and beautiful the things of the World Deformed and worthless just as to him who views them through a Microscope the Works of God appear exact and elegant but those of Man coarse and bungling and ugly My Opinion then which asserts the absolute Liberty of the Perfect Man is sufficiently proved here and in Chap. the first And if I thought it were not I could easily reinforce it with fresh Recruits For the glorious Characters that are given us in Scripture of the Liberty of
Matter of Fact that the most Perfect upon Earth are not without Frailties and Infirmities and such Infirmities as discover themselves in actual Slips and Errors But the Question is whether these are to be accounted Sins I must confess if we strictly follow the Language of the Scripture we should rather call them by some other Name for this does so generally understand by Sin a Deliberate Transgression of the Law of God that it will be very difficult to produce many Texts wherein the Word Sin is used in any other sense As to Legal Pollutions I have not much considered the matter But as to Moral ones I am in some Degree confident that the word Sin does generally signifie such a Transgression as by the Gospel Covenant is punishable with Death and rarely does it occur in any other sense I say rarely for if I be not much mistaken the Scripture does sometimes call those Infirmities I am now talking of Sin But what if it did not 'T is plain That every Deviation from the Law of God if it has any Concurrence of the will in it is in strict speaking Sin and 't is as plain that the Scripture does frequently give us such Descriptions and Characters and such Names of these Sins of Infirmity as do oblige us both to strive and watch against them and repent of them For it calls them Spots Errors Defects Slips and the like But what is Lastly most to my purpose it is plain That this Distinction of Sins into Mortal and Venial or Sins of Infirmity has its Foundation in express Texts of Scripture Numerous are the Texts cited to this purpose But he that will deal fairly must confess that they are most of them improperly and impertinently urged as relating either to Falls into Temporal Calamity or to Mortal not Venial Sins or to the Sins of an unregenerate State or to a comparative Impurity I mean the Impurity of Man with respect to God a Form of Expression frequent in Job I will therefore content my self to cite three or four which seem not liable to these Exceptions Deut 32.4 they have corrupted themselves their Spot is not the spot of his Children They are a perverse and crooked Generation Here two things seem to be pointed out to us plainly First That the Children of God are not without their Spots Secondly That these are not of the same Nature with those of the wicked in comparison with whose wilful and perverse Transgressions the Children of God are elsewhere pronounced blameless without Offence without Spot Psal 19.12 13. Who can understand his Errors cleanse thou me from secret Faults keep back also thy Servant from presumptuous Sins let them not have dominion over me then shall I be upright and I shall be innocent from the great Transgression Here again the Psalmist seems to me to place Uprightness in Freedom from Deliberate or Mortal Sin and to admit of another sort of Transgressions into which even upright Men slip sometimes Nor does the Psalmist here only assert Venial Sins but he seems to me to suggest the Springs and Sources of them namely some secret Dispositions in our Nature to Folly and Error which he prays God to cleanse and free him from more and more cleanse thou me from secret Faults The word Fault is not in the Original but something of that kind must be supplied to render the sense entire in our Language The words of Solomon Prov. 20.9 seem to relate to this Corruption lurking in us and never utterly to be extirpated Who can say I have made my Heart clean I am pure from my Sin For if this should be applied to Mortal Sin every one sees that it will contradict a hundred places in Scripture which attribute to Righteous Men Purity of Heart and Deliverance from Sin Lastly James 3.2 we are told plainly that in many things we offend all 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 not Sinners only but Righteous and Upright Men have their Defects and Slips And accordingly there is not any Life which we have the History of in Scripture how excellent soever the Person be but we meet with some of these recorded as will appear from those several Instances I shall produce when I come to describe the Nature of these Sins And certainly when David says of himself my Sins are more in number than the hairs of my head He that shall interpret this Place of Mortal or Presumptuous Sins will both contradict the Scriptures which acquit him except in the matter of Vriah and highly wrong the Memory of David making him a Prodigy of Wickedness instead of a Saint Nor does that make any thing against me which he adds in the next Words my heart fails me or that in the foregoing Verse mine Iniquities have taken hold upon me so that I am not able to look up For I do not affirm that the Psalmist here has regard only to Sins of Infirmity exclusively of others no he reckons all together and so discerns the one aggravated by the other and the Guilt of all together very far enhansed Nor do I Secondly interess my self here in that Dispute between Protestants and Papists whether Sins of Infirmity are not damnable in their own Nature though not imputed under the Covevenant of Grace Nor do I Lastly examine what a vast Heap of Sins of Infirmity may amount to though the Gilt of this or that alone were not so fatal I have then I think proved the matter in Question having shewed both from the Experience of Mankind and the Scripture That the best Men have their Infirmities and Defects And that these may properly enough be called Sins I think it superfluous to prove that they consist with a state of Salvation since 't is not by any that I know of denied and may be easily enough made out from what I have already said I am now to Enquire S. 2. What these Sins be and how distinguished from Mortal or Damnable ones To this purpose we may distinguish Human Actions under which I comprise both Internal and External into three sorts Voluntary Involuntary and Mixt. § 1. There are Actions properly and truly Voluntary such are those deliberate Transgressions of a Divine Law which Man commits in Opposition to the direct Remonstrances of Conscience he knows the Action is forbid he sees the Turpitude and Obliquity of it he is not ignorant of the punishment denounced against it and yet he ventures upon it This is plainly Mortal Damnable Sin and I cannot think that any Circumstance or Pretence whatever can render it Venial And therefore I must be pardoned if I cannot be of their Opinion who supposed that the smalness of the Matter the Reluctancy of Conscience or the Length and Force of a Temptation can so soften and mitigate a Voluntary Transgression as to diminish it into a Sin of Infirmity 1. As to the smalness of the Matter Some cannot but think those Transgressions Venial which are for the Matter of them so
and allures us and 't is our Consent to its Enticements that gives Being to Sin and defiles us with Guilt From all this now put together 't is easie to conclude what sort of a Description we are to form of Mortal Sin 'T is such a Transgression of the Law of God as is vicious in its Original deliberate in its Commission and Mischievous in its Tendencies or Effects The Heart is corrupted and misled by some Lust or other and so consents to the Breach of the Moral Law of God a Law of Eternal and Immutable Goodness or if the Sin consists in the Breach of any Positive Law it must yet imply in it some moral Obliquity in the Will or in the Tendency of the Action or both So that Presumptuous or Mortal Sin call it by what Name we Will is a Deliberate Transgression of a known Law of God tending to the Dishonour of God the Injury of our Neighbour or the Depravation of our Nature Such are those sins which the Prophet Isaiah exhorts those who will repent to cease from And such are those we have a Catalogue of Eph. 5. Gal. 5. and elsewhere Now the Works of the Flesh are manifest which are these Adultery Fornication Vncleanness Lasciviousness Idolatry Witchcraft Hatred Variance Emulations Wrath Strife Seditions Heresies Envyings Murders Drunkenness Revellings and such-like These are the sins of which as of so many Members the Body of sin consists These constitute the old Man These are sometimes called the filthiness of the Flesh and Spirit Vngodliness Wickedness Iniquity the Lusts of the Flesh worldly Lusts and such-like These and the like sins have as I said in them very apparent Symptoms of Malignity and Mortality They are always the Effect of some carnal and worldly Lusts prevailing over the Law of the Mind and they imply a contempt of God Injustice to our Neighbour and some kind of Defilement and Pollution of our Nature And that these are the plain Indications of such a Guilt as excludes a Man from Heaven and the Favour of God is very plain from the account which the Scripture gives us both of the Origine and Influence of sin from the Care it takes to fortifie the Heart against all Infection from the constant Representations it makes us of the shamefulness and the Mischief of sin even in Reference to this World as well as the other I cannot see any thing further necessary to the Explication of Deliberate or Presumptuous sin unless it be here fit to add That it is Mortal though it proceed no further than the Heart There is no need at all that it should be brought forth into Action to render it Fatal and Damnable This is evident not only from the Nature of Divine Worship which must be entire sincere and spiritual and therefore can no more be reconciled to the Wickedness of our Hearts than of our Actions but also from the express words of our Saviour Out of the Heart proceed Fornication Adultery Theft c. And elsewhere he pronounces the Adultery of the Heart Damnable as well as that of the Body Mat. 5.28 But I say unto you that whosoever looketh upon a Woman to lust after her hath committed Adultery already with her in his Heart S. 2. I am next to give some account of the Liberty of Perfect Man in reference to the sin I have been discoursing of I shall not need to stop at any General or Preliminary Observations as That Abstinence from sin regards all the Commandments of God alike and to do otherwise were to mutilate and maim Religion and to dishonour God while we pretend to worship and obey Him For the Breach of any single Commandment is a manifest Violation of the Majesty and Authority of God whatever Observance we may pay all the rest For he that said do not commit Adultery said also do not kill Now if thou commit no Adultery yet if thou kill thou art become a transgressor of the Law Jam. 2.11 That the Restraints Man is to lay upon himself relate no less to the Lusts of the Soul than the Actions of the Body Except your Righteousness exceed the Righteousness of the Scribes and Pharisees you shall by no means enter into the Kingdom of Heaven Mat. 5.10 That to begin well will avail us little unless we finish well too Universality Sincerity and Perseverance are generally acknowledged to be essential and indispensable Properties of Saving Justifying Faith These things therefore being but just mentioned I proceed to the Point to be enquir'd into and resolve 1. To be free from the Dominion and Power of Mortal Sin is the first and lowest step this is indispensable to sincerity and absolutely necessary to Salvation Let not Sin reign in your mortal Bodies to fulfil the Lusts thereof Rom. 6.12 And the advancing thus far does I acknowledge constitute Man in a state of Grace For in Scripture Men are Denominated righteous or wicked not from single Acts of Vice or Vertue but from the Prevalence and Dominion from the Habit or Custom of the one or the other know ye not that to whom ye yeild your selves Servants to obey his Servants ye are to whom ye obey whether of Sin unto Death or of Obedience unto Righteousness Rom. 6.16 But then I must here add two Remarks by way of Caution 1st We must not presume too soon of Victory over an Habitual Sin An evil Habit is not soon broken off nor is it an easie Matter to resolve when we have set our selves free from the Power of it Sometimes the Temptation does not present it self as often as it was wont or not with the same Advantages sometimes one Vice restrains us from another sometimes worldly Considerations or some little Change in our Temper without any thorough Change in our Minds puts us out of humour for a little while with a darling Sin and sometimes the Force and Clearness of Conviction produces some pious Fits which though they do not utterly vanquish a Lust do yet force it to give way and retreat for a while and interrupt that Love which they do not exstinguish All this may be and the work not yet be done nor our Liberty yet gain'd If therefore we fall though but now and then and though at some Distance of time into the same sin we have great reason to be jealous of its Power and our Safety Nay though we restrain our selves from the outward Commission of it if yet we feel a strong Propension to it if we discern our selves ready to take fire on the Appearance of a Temptation if we are fond of approaching as near it as we can and are pleas'd with those Indulgencies which are very near a kin to it we have reason to doubt that our Conquest is not yet entire Nay the Truth is we cannot be on good Grounds assured that we are Masters of our selves till we have a setled Aversion for the sin which before we doted on and shun the Occasions which before
the Children of God and the blessed Fruit of it Peace and Joy in the Holy Ghost would easily furnish me with invincible Arguments Nor would the contrary Opinion ever have been able to have kept the Field so long as it has done had it not been favoured by a weak and decayed Piety by the Fondnesses of Men for themselves in spight of their Sins and Frailties and by many mistaken Texts But that this Matter may if possible be freed from all Objections 1. I here distinguish between Inordinate and Natural Affections By Inordinate Affections I mean the Tendencies of the Soul towards that which is Vnlawful by Natural its Propension to the Body with which it is invested the Desire of its Health and Ease and the Conveniencies and Necessaries of Life for this end Now when Religion enjoyns Repugnances to the former Appetites the Obedience of the Perfect Man has no Reluctancy in it but when it enjoyns things as sometimes occasionally it does which thwart and cross the latter here the Obedience even of Christ himself could not be exempt from Conflict for our Natural Appetites in this sense of them will never be put off till our Bodies be I think this is so clear it needs not be illustrated by Instances or else 't were easie to shew that though good men have practised Temperance Chastity Charity and other Vertues of this kind with ease and pleasure too yet has Nature shrunk and startled at Persecution and Martyrdom though even here too the Courage and Resolution of some hath appear'd to be much above what Human Nature ever seem'd capable of 2. I do not in the least suppose that Nature is so changed but that the Inclinations to sinful Pleasure or Profit or any other forbidden Object will soon revive again even in the Perfect Man unless he keep a watch and guard upon himself and pass the time of his sojourning here in fear Not to be subject to disorderly Desires not to be liable to irregular Motions is the Priviledge of Souls when stript of a Mortal Body or cloath'd with an Immortal one Till then the Conjunction of Flesh and Blood will ever render the poor Soul obnoxious to carnal and worldly Appetites And the natural Appetites of the Body do so easily pass those Bounds that divide them from sinful ones that the best of men can never be secure but when the Mind is taken up in Contemplation Devotion good Works or engaged in the Prosecution of some just and honest Design or amused by some innocent Recreation for in these Cases the Body is either made the Instrument of Righteousness or at least wise 't is innocently busied and diverted from those Objects to which it has too too impetuous a Tendency I have now I think sufficiently stated the Notion of true Liberty and I hope sufficiently guarded it And have nothing to do but to proceed to the Fruits of it Which will serve for so many Motives or Inducements to its Attainment § 2. Of the Fruits of Liberty These may be reduced under four Heads 1. Sin being a great Evil Deliverance from it is great Happiness 2. A second Fruit of this Liberty is Good Works 3. It gives us a near Relation to God 4. The great and last Fruit of it is Eternal Life These are all comprised by the Apostle in Rom. 6.2.1 22 23. What fruit had ye then in those things whereof ye are now ashamed For the end of those things is death But now being made free from Sin and become Servants to God ye have your fruit unto Holiness and the end everlasting Life For the wages of sin is Death but the Gift of God is Eternal Life through Jesus Christ our Lord. And these are the great Ends which the Gospel that perfect Law of Liberty aims at and for which it was Preached to the World as appears from those Words of our Lord to St. Paul Acts 26.17 18. unto whom now I send thee to open their Eyes and to turn them from darkness to light and from the power of Satan unto God that they may receive forgiveness of Sins and inheritance among them which are sanctified by Faith that is in me I will here insist on these Blessed Effects of Christian Liberty not only because the Design of the Chapter demands it but also to prevent the being obliged to any tedious Repetition of them hereafter under every distinct Branch of Christian Liberty § 1. Sin is a great Evil and therefore Deliverance from the Dominion of it is a great Good To make this evident we need but reflect a little on the Nature and Effects of Sin If we enquire into the Nature of Sin we shall find that it is founded in the Subversion of the Dignity and defacing the Beauty of Human Nature and that it consists in the Darkness of our Understanding the Depravity of our Affections and the Feebleness and Impotence of the Will The Vnderstanding of a Sinner is incapable of discerning the Certainty and Force of Divine Truths the Loveliness of Vertue the unspeakable Pleasure which now flows from the great and precious Promises of the Gospel and the incomparably greater which will one day flow from the Accomplishment and Fruition of them His Affections which if fix't and bent on Vertue had been Incentives as they were designed by God to noble and worthy Actions being biass'd and perverted do now hurry him on to lewd and wicked ones And by these the Mind if at any time it chance to be awakened and render'd sensible of its Happiness and Duty is over-power'd and oppress'd If this were not the true State of a Sinner if the strength of Sin did not thus consist in the Disorder and Impotence of all the Faculties of the Soul whence is it that the Sinner acts as he does Is it not evident that his understanding is infatuated when he lives as if he were meerly wholly Body As if he had no Soul or none but one resulting from and dissolv'd with its Temperament and Contexture One designed to no higher purpose than to contrive minister to and partake in its Sensualities Is it not evident that He has little expectation of another World who laies up his Treasures only in this and lives as if he were Born only to make Provision for the Flesh to fulfil the lusts thereof 'T is true all Sinners are not equally stupid or obdurate but even in those in whom some sparks of Vnderstanding and Conscience remain unextinguished how are the weak Desires of Vertue baffled and over-power'd by the much stronger Passions which they have for the Body and the World Do they not find themselves reduced to that wretched state of Bondage wherein the good that they would do that they do not but the evil that they would not do that is present with them 'T is plain then that Sin is a Disease in our Nature that it not only extinguishes the Grace of the Spirit and obliterates the Image of God stampt
10.13 There hath no temptation taken you but such as is common to Man but God is faithful who will not suffer you to be tempted above that you are able but will with the temptation also make a way to escape that ye may be able to bear it The Design of which Words is certainly to encourage Christians against the bigest Temptations by an Assurance of Relief from God proportionable to our Necessities and consequently must imply that if we yield to a Temptation 't is our own fault God expects we should stand firm under the highest Trials Be thou faithful unto death and I will give thee a Crown of Life Rev. 2.10 To him that overcometh will I grant to sit with me in my Throne even as I also overcame and am set down with my Father in his Throne Rev. 3.21 But whosoever shall deny me before Men him will I also deny before my Father which is in Heaven Matt. 10.33 If therefore by Sins of Infirmity Men mean such as are consistent with the state of Grace i. e. such as good Men may frequently fall into without forfeiting the Peace of Conscience and the Favour of God I cannot possibly think that any Deliberate Sin can be such upon the score of the Temptation or that any of those Sins reckoned in the Catalogue Gal. 5. and Eph. 5. can be such on the account of the Violence or Perseverance with which they attack us But Secondly if by Sins of Infirmity they mean such Sins as Righteous Men are liable to I know not what they are from which they are exempted But if Lastly by Sins of Infirmity they mean such for which God is more easily entreated then there is no Question to be made but that there is a Difference in Sins which is to be estimated by the different Measures of Grace and Knowledge by the different Degrees of Deliberation and Surprise and by the Force or Weakness the Continuance or Shortness of a Temptation And Finally by the different Effects and Tendencies of Sins To all which I do not question but that the Spirit has regard in those Directions which it gives us for our Behaviour towards such as fall Gal. 6.1 Brethren if a Man be overtaken in a fault ye which are spiritual restore such a one in the Spirit of Meekness considering thy self lest thou also be tempted And of some have compassion making a difference And others save with fear pulling them out of the fire Jude 22 23. § 2. A Second sort of Actions are such as we call Involuntary that is those wherein we exercise no Deliberation no Choice Some have reduced Sins of Infirmity to this Head but with what Colour of Reason any one may judge For since Actions truly Involuntary are neither the Object of the Understanding nor Will 't is hard to conceive what Morality there can be in them The Grounds on which this Opinion is built are such as these First the Measure say they of Good and Evil is the Law of God But Involuntary and unavoidable Actions are not a proper Subject of Laws for to what purpose is it to prescribe Rules or to propose Rewards and Punishments to such Actions as are no way subject to our Choice Secondly they tell us 't is inconsistent with the Goodness of God and the Riches of Gospel Grace to impute those things to a Man as Damnable Sins which fall not within the Compass of his Power of Deliberation Now I must confess I am so far from denying any Actions that can lay a just claim to this Apology to be Venial that I cannot forbear thinking that they are not sinful For where there is no Law there is no Transgression But how does this way of arguing for the Excusableness of Involuntary Transgressions consist with those other Doctrines which they maintain concerning them namely That we are bound to Repentance for them That these Sins are not Venial in their own Nature but only through the Favour of God For the Law taken in its Rigour denounces Death against all Sin in general without Limitation or Exception so that if God should judge rigorously even Involuntary Sin would fall under that Sentence the wages of Sin is Death This I must confess seems to me very incoherent For if an Action be of that Nature that it cannot properly be the Matter or Subject of a Law how can it fall under the Condemnation of Law If it be of that Nature that it is incapable of any Moral Regulation nor subject to the Influence of Reward or Punishment how can it be meer Matter of Grace that a Man is not Damned for it In a word if an Action be truly and properly Involuntary it can by no means be Sin and if it be Voluntary it is subject to the Regulation of Laws 'T is a proper Instance of Deliberation and Freedom and capable of Rewards and Punishments And the Truth is the one needs no Apology and the other is not capable of any the one is a Mortal Sin and the other no Sin at all And therefore we must look for Venial Sin in some other Species of Action § 3. The last Class of Actions are those which are of a mixt Nature partly Voluntary and partly Involuntary And here I think we must place Sins of Infirmity by whatever Names we may call them For these surely if they are be rankt as by all they are amongst Actual Sins must be such Actions as have in them something of Voluntary something of Involuntary much of Human Frailty and something of Sinful much of unavoidable and something of Moral Obliquity These are the Transgressions which the Scripture seems to me to intend by Errors Defects Slips Motes the Spots of God's Children and these certainly if any must be the Sins that can consist with a state of Grace For these do not imply a Deliberate Wickedness in the Will much less an Habitual one nay they do not include in them any Wickedness at all strictly speaking but are truly the Effects of Human Frailty and the unhappy Circumstances of this Mortal Life Thus then I describe a Venial Sin it has in it so much of Voluntary as to mak it Sin so much of Involuntary as to make it Frailty it has so much of the Will in it that it is capable of being reduced and yet so much of Necessity in it it is never utterly to be extirpated it has some thing in it Criminal enough to oblige us to watch against it repent of it and yet so much in it pitiable and excusable as to entitle us to Pardon under the Covenant of Grace And thus I distinguish Venial from Mortal Sin Mortal Sin proceeds from a Heart either Habitually corrupted or deceived and captived for the time but Venial Sin results from the Imperfections and Infelicities of our Nature and our State Mortal Sin is truly Voluntary and Deliberate in the Rice and Birth of it and mischievous and injurious in its Consequence But
4thly If the Duties of Religion be very troublesome and uneasie to a Man we may from hence conclude that he is not Perfect For though the Beginning of Wisdom and Vertue be generally harsh and severe to the Fool and Sinner yet to him that has Conquered the Yoke of Christ is easie and his Burden light to him that is filled with the Love of God his Commandments are not grievous hence is that observation of the Son of Sirach Ecclus. 4.17 18. For at the first she will walk with him by crooked ways and bring fear and dread upon him and torment him with her discipline until she may trust his Soul and try him by her Laws then will she return the straight way unto him and comfort him and shew him her secrets The reason of this Assertion is palpable it is the nature of an Habit to render difficult Things easie harsh Things pleasant to fix a floating and uncertain Humour to Nurse and Ripen a weak and tender Disposition into Nature And 't is as reasonable to expect these effects in Religious as in any other sorts of Habits Lastly He who does not find Religion full of Pleasure who does not Glory in God and rejoyce in our Lord Jesus he who is not filled with an humble Assurance of the Divine Favour and a Joyful expectation of Immortality and Glory does yet want something he is yet defective with respect either to the brightness of Illumination the Absoluteness of Liberty or the Ardor of Love he may be a Good Man and have gone a great way in his Christian Race but there is some thing still behind to Compleat and Perfect him some Error or other creates him groundless Scruples some Incumbrance or Impediment or other whether an Infelicity of Temper or the Incommodiousness of his Circumstances or a little too warm an Application towards something of the World retards his Vigour and abates his Affections I have now finished all that I can think necessary to form a general Idea of Religious Perfection For I have not only given a plain Definition or Description of it and Confirm'd and Fortified that Description by Reason and Scripture and the currant Sense of all Sides and Parties but have also by various Inferences deduc'd from the General Notion of Perfection precluded all groundless Pretensions to it and enabled Men to see how far they are removed and distant from it or how near they approach it The next thing I am to do according to the Method I have proposed is to consider the Fruits and Advantages of Perfection A consideration which will furnish us with many great and I hope effectual Incitements or Motives to it and demonstrate its Subservencie to our Happiness CHAP. IV. A General Account of the Blessed Effects of Religious Perfection THE Glorious and Delightful Fruits of Religious Perfection may be reduc'd to these four Heads First It advances the Honour of the True and Living God and of his Son Jesus in the World Secondly It promotes the Good of Mankind Thirdly It produces in the Perfect Man a full Assurance of Eternal Happiness and Glory Fourthly It puts him in Possession of true Happiness in this Life Of the two former I shall say nothing here designing to insist upon them more particularly In the following Section under the Head of Zeal where I shall be oblig'd by my Method to consider the Fruit of it only I cannot here forbear Remarking That Perfection while it promotes the Honour of God and the Good of Man does at the same time promote our own Happiness too since it must on this account most effectually recommend us to the Love of the One and the Other Them that Honour me saith God I will Honour 1 Sam. 2.30 And our Saviour observes that even Publicans and Sinners love those who love them Matth. 5.46 Accordingly St. Luke tells us of Christ Luk. 2.52 That Jesus increased in Wisdom and Stature and in favour with God and Man and of those eminently Devout and Charitable Souls Act. 2. that they had favour with all the People so resistless a charm is the beauty and loveliness of Perfect Charity even in the most deprav'd and corrupt Times And what a Blessing now what a Comfort what a Pleasure is it to be the Favorite of God and Man The Third and Fourth I will now discourse of and that the more largely because as to Assurance it is the foundation of that Pleasure which is the richest Ingredient of Human Happiness in this Life And as to our present Happiness which is the fourth Fruit of Perfection it is the very thing for the sake of which I have ingag'd in my present subject And therefore it is very fit that I should render the tendency of Perfection to procure our present Happiness very conspicuous Beginning therefore with Assurance I will assert the Possibility of attaining it in this Life not by embroiling my self in the Brakes of several nice and subtle Speculations with which this subject is over-grown but by laying down in a Practical manner the Grounds on which Assurance depends by which we shall be able at once to discern the truth of the Doctrine of Assurance and its dependance upon Perfection Now Assurance may relate to the time Present or to Come For the Resolution of two Questions gives the Mind a perfect ease about this Matter The first is am I assured that I am at present in a state of Grace The second am I assured that I shall continue so to my Life's end To begin with the first the Answer of this Enquiry depends on three Grounds First A Divine Revelation which declares in General who shall be Saved namely They who Believe and Repent Nor does any Sect doubt but that Repentance towards God and Faith in our Lord Jesus Christ as St. Paul speaks are the Indispensable Conditions of Life 'T is true the Notion of Repentance is miserably perverted by some and that of Faith by others But what remedy is there against the Lusts and Passions of Men The Scripture does not only require Repentance and Faith but it explains and describes the Nature of Both by such Conspicuous and Infallible Characters that no Man can be Mistaken in these two Points but his Error must be owing to some Criminal Prejudices or Inclinations that Byass and pervert him Good Men have ever been agreed in these Matters And Catholick Tradition is no where more uncontroulable then here the General Doctrine of all Ages hath been and in this still is that by Repentance we are to understand a New Nature and New Life And by Faith when distinguished from Repentance as it sometimes is in Scripture a Reliance upon the Mercy of God through the Merits and Intercession of Jesus and Atonement of his Blood Heaven lies open to all that perform these Conditions every Page of the Gospel attest this this is the Substance of Christ's Commission to his Apostles that they should Preach Repentance and Remission of
Sins through his Name amongst all Nations And this is one Blessed advantage which Revealed Religion has above Natural that it contains an express Declaration of the Divine Will concerning the Pardon of all Sins whatsoever upon these Terms Natural Religion indeed teaches us that God is Merciful but it teaches us that he is Just too and it can never assure us what Bounds God will set to the Exercise of the one or the other and when Justice and when Mercy shall take Place What Sins are and what are not capable of the benefit of Sacrifice and Repentance And this uncertainty considering the Sins of the best Life was ever naturally apt to beget Despondencies Melancholy and sometimes a Superstitious dread of God The Second Ground of assurance as it relates to our present State is an Application of the Condition of Life laid down in the Gospel to a Man 's own Particular Case thus They that Believe and Repent shall be Saved I Believe and Repent therefore I shall be Saved Now that a Man upon an Examination of himself may be throughly assured that he does Believe and Repent is evident from Scripture which does not only exhort us to enter upon this Examination but also assert that Assurance Joy and Peace are the natural Fruits of it But let a Man examine himself and so let him eat of that Bread and drink of that Cup 1 Cor. 11.28 Examine your selves whether ye be in the Faith prove your own selves Know ye not your own selves how that Jesus Christ is in you except ye be Reprobates 2 Cor. 13.5 But Sanctifie the Lord God in your Hearts and be ready always to give an answer to every Man that asketh you a reason of the hope that is in you with meekness and fear 1 Pet. 3.15 And hereby we do know that we know him if we keep his Commandments 1 Joh. 2.3 Beloved if our Hearts condemn us not then have we confidence towards God 1 Joh. 3.2 'T is true Men do often deceive themselves and entertain a more favourable Opinion of their state then they ought But whence proceeds this Even from too Partial or Superficial Reflections on themselves or none at all And therefore the Apostle teaches us plainly that the only way to correct this Error is a Sincere and diligent search into our selves For if a Man think himself to be something when he is nothing he deceiveth himself But let every Man prove his own Work and then shall he have rejoycing in himself alone and not in another Gal. 6.3 4. But it is Objected against all this that the Heart of Man is so deceitful that it is a very difficult Matter to make a thorough discovery of it We often think our selves Sincere when the success of the next Temptation gives us just reason to call this Sincerity into question such is the contradictions Composition of our Nature that we often act contrary to our inward Convictions and frequently fail in the execution of those designs in the performance of those resolutions which we have thought very well grounded and this being not to be charged upon the Insufficiency of God's Grace but the Levity or Insincerity of our own Hearts how can we safely frame any right Opinion of our Selves from those affections and purposes which are so little to be rely'd upon To this I Answer First We are not to conclude any thing concerning our Progress or Perfection too hastily we are not to determine of the final Issue of a War by the success of one or two Engagements but our Hopes and Assurances are to advance slowly and gradually in proportion to the abatement of the Enemy's Force and the increase of our own so that we may have time enough to examine and prove our own Hearts Secondly A Sincere Christian but especially one of a Mature Vertue may easily discern his spiritual state by the inward movings and actings of the Soul if he attend to them For is it possible that such a one should be ignorant what Impressions Divine Truths make upon him Is it possible he should be ignorant whether his Faith stand firm against the shock of all Carnal objections whether he earnestly desire to please God as loving him above all things whether he thirst after the Consolation and Joy of the Spirit more then after that of sensible things Is it possible the Soul should bewail its Heaviness and Driness which the best are liable to at some season or other Is it possible that the Soul should be carried upwards frequently on the Wings of Faith and Love that it should maintain a familiar and constant Conversation with Heaven that it should long to be delivered from this World of trouble and this Body of Death and to enter into the Regions of Peace of Life and Righteousness Is it possible I say that these should be the Affections the Longings and Earnings of the Soul and yet that the Good Man the Perfect Man who often enters into his Closet and Communes with his own Heart should be ignorant of them It cannot be In a word can the Reluctances of the Body and the Allurements of the World be disarm'd weaken'd and reduc'd Can the Hunger and Thirst after Righteousness be very eager the relish of spiritual Pleasure brisk and delightful and the contempt of worldly things be real and thoroughly setled and yet the Man be insensible of all this It cannot be But if we fell these Affections in us we may safely conclude that we are Partakers of the Divine Nature that we have escaped the corruption that is in the World through Lust and that the New Creature is at least growing up into a Perfect Man to the Measure of the Stature of the fulness of Christ Thirdly The surest Test of a State of Grace is our abounding in Good Works You shall know the Tree by its Fruit is our Masters own Rule and it can never deceive us He that doth Righteousness is born of God If then we be frequent and fervent in our Devotion towards God if we be modest and grateful in the Successes Patient and Resigned Calm and Serene under the Crosses and Troubles of Life If we be not only Punctual but Honourable in our dealings if we be Vigorous and Generous in the Exercises of Charity if we be not only just and true but meek gentle and obliging in our Words if we retrench not only the sinful but something from the innocent Liberties and Gratifications of Sense to give our selves more entirely up to the Duties and Pleasures of Faith If finally we never be ashamed of Vertue nor flatter complement nor wink at Vice if we be ready to meet with Death with comfort and retain Life with some degree of Indifference If these things I say be in us we have little reason to doubt of the goodness of our State For Good Works being the natural Fruit of Grace it is impossible we should abound in the one without being possessed
we courted till we be possess'd of a Habit of that Vertue which is a direct Contradiction to it and take as much pleasure in the Obedience as ever we did in the Transgression of a Divine Command 2ly There are some Sins of that provoking Nature so criminal in their Birth and mischievous in their Consequences That one single Act or Commission of one of these is equivalent to a Habit of others such is Murther Idolatry Perjury Adultery these cannot be committed without renouncing Humanity as well as Christianity without resisting the Instincts and Impulses of Nature as well as the Eight of the Gospel and the Grace of the Spirit We must break thorough a great many Difficulties and Terrors e're we can come at these Sins we must commit many other in order to commit one of these we must deliberate long resolve desperately and in Defiance of God and Conscience and what is the Effect of Habit in other Instances is a necessary Preparative in these that is Obduration In this Case therefore the unhappy Man that has been guilty of any one of these must not look upon himself as set free when he is come to a Resolution of never repeating it again But then when he loaths and abhors himself in Dust and Ashes when he has made the utmost Reparation of the Wrong he is capable of when if the Interest of Vertue require it he is content to be oppress'd with Shame and Sufferings when in one word a long and constant Course of Mortification Prayers Tears and good Works have washed off the Stain and Guilt 2. We must be free not only from a Habit but from single Acts of deliberate presumptuous Sin The Reason is plain Mortal Sin cannot be committed without wounding the Conscience grieving the Spirit and renouncing our Hopes in God through Christ for the time at least The wages of Sin is Death is true not only of Habits but single Acts of Deliberate Sin Death is the penalty the Sanction of every Commandment and the Commandment does not prohibit Habits only but single Acts too Nor is there indeed any room for Doubt or Dispute here but in one Case which is If a Righteous Man should be taken off in the very Commission of a Sin which he was fallen into Here indeed much may be said and with much Uncertainty But the Resolution of this Point does not as far as I can see minister to any good or necessary End and therefore I will leave it to God In all other Cases every thing is clear and plain For if the Servant of God fall into a presumptuous Sin 't is universally acknowledg'd that he cannot recover his Station but by Repentance If he repent presently he is safe but if he continue in his Sin if he repeat it he passes into a state of Wickedness widens the Breach between God and his Soul declines insensibly into a Habit of sin and renders his Wound more and more incurable 'T is to little purpose I think here to consider the vast Difference there is in the Commission even of the same sin between a Child of God and a Child of Wrath because a Child of God must not commit it at all if he do though it be with Reluctancy though it be as it were with an imperfect Consent and with a divided Soul though the Awe of Religion and Conscience seems not utterly to have forsaken him even in the midst of his sin though his Heart smite him the very Minute it is finish'd and Repentance and Remorse take off the Relish of the unhappy Draught yet still 't is Sin 't is in its Nature Damnable and nothing but the Blood of Jesus can purge the Guilt 3. The Perfect Man may be supposed not only actually to abstain from Mortal Sin but to be advanced so far in the Mortification of all his inordinate Affections as to do it with Ease and Pleasure with Constancy and Delight For it must reasonably be presumed that his Victory over ungodly and worldly Lust is more confirm'd and absolute his Abhorrence of them more deep and sensible more fixt and lasting than that of a Beginner or Babe in Christ The Regenerate at first fears the Consequence of sin but by Degrees he hates the Sin it self The Purity of his Soul renders him now incapable of finding any pleasure in what he doted on before and the Love of God and Vertue raiseth him above the Temptations which he was wont to fall by old things are past away and all things are become new 4. Lastly The Perfect Man's Abstinence is not only more easie and steady but more entire and compleat also than that of others He has a regard to the End and Design of the Law to the Perfection of his Nature to the Purity and Elevation of his Sowl and therefore he expounds the Prohibitions of the Law in the most enlarg'd Sense and interprets them by a Spirit of Faith and Love He is not content to refrain from Actions directly criminal but shuns every Appearance of Evil and labours to mortifie all the Dispositions and Tendencies of his Nature towards it and to decline whatever Circumstances of Life are apt to betray the Soul into a Love of this World or the Body he has crucified the World and the Body too That Pleasure that Honour that Power that Profit which captives the Sinners tempts and tries and disquiets the Novice is but a burthen a trouble to him he finds no Gust no relish in these things He is so far from Intemperance so far from Wantonness so far from Pride and Vanity that could he without any Disadvantage to the Interest of Religion he would imitate the Meanness the Plainness the Laboriousness the Self-denial of our Saviour's Life not only in Disposition and Affection of his Soul but even in his outward State and Deportment and would prefer it far above the Pomp and Shew of Life In one word he enquires not how far he may Enjoy and be Safe but how far he may deny himself and be wise he is so far from desiring forbidden Satisfactions that he is unwilling and afraid to find too much Satisfaction in the natural and necessary Actions of an animal Life I need not prove this to any one who has read the foregoing Chapters for it is what I have been doing throughout this Treatise It is nothing but what is consonant to the whole Tenour of the Scripture and to the Example of the best Times And 't is conformable to what the best Authors have writ who have any thing of Life and Spirit in their Works or have any true Notion of the great Design of Christian Religion which is an heavenly Conversation Let any one but cast his Eye on St. Basil or any other after him who aim'd at the same thing I now do the promoting Holiness in the World in the Beauty and Perfection of it and he will acknowledge that I am far from having carried this matter too high I