〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 imports not accidents but a substance accidents are not a body neither are these converted but remain Is it the Body of Christ That is not in the Eucharist till all the words be uttered it is not there at the pronouncing of the first word this the Proposition is not identical the words run not thus my body is my body neither if they did could they any more work a conversion than a thing can be turned into it self Is it an substantia vaga an indefinite substance such as is neither Bread nor the Body of Christ This is such a vagrant that all the world knows not where to find it Christ did not take bless break give an indefinite substance but the Bread It remains therefore that the Bread is the thing pointed at The words in effect are thus the Bread is the Body of Christ and then as Bellarmine himself confesseth De Euch. lib. 1. c. 1. the words must be taken tropically or else they are plainly absurd and impossible The Copula is doth in Propositions import such a conjunction as the subject and predicate coupled together are capable of when it stands between the sign and the thing signified it is not to be taken essentially but significatively the sign is not the very thing but a sign In Scripture we read not of a sign turned into the thing signified but we ordinarily find the name of the thing signified given to the sign Circumcision is the covenant Gen. 17.10 That is a sign of it as the next verse tells us The Lamb is the passover Exod. 12.11 that is a sign of it The Cup that is the Wine in in it is the New Testament 1 Cor. 11.25 that is it is Sacramentally such after the same manner the Bread is the Body of Christ that is it is significatively such this is the plain natural interpretation of the words Vsher An. to a Jes 61. Hence in the ancient Fathers the Bread is called the figure memorial symbol image type sign similitude of Christs Body It is the excellent observation of St. Austin That Sacraments should not be Sacraments unless they did resemble the things signified and for that resemblance they do often bear the names of the things themselves Epist 23. Secundum quendam modum Sacramentum Corporis Christi Corpus Christi est Sacramentum Sanguinis Christi Sanguis Christi est after a certain manner the Sacrament of Christs Body is his Body the Sacrament of his Blood is his Blood The Bread and Wine are figuratively and sacramantally such Two things may be noted touching the Doctrine of Transubstantiation The one is this It is a Doctrine cross to the description of the Eucharist which we have in 1 Cor. 11. The Bread was not blessed that it might be destroyed nor given to be eaten that it might cease to be before it was eaten Never did God put forth his miraculous power to make his command impossible such as the eating of Bread which is not must needs be in those words this is my body in which if in any Transubstantiation may be found there is no imperative word no mention at all of conversion which yet being a very wonderful thing would in all reason if it were true be fully opened it is not only said this is my body but it is added which is broken for you this do in remembrance of me In the Eucharist Christs Body is not considered as a glorious Body but as broken and crucified neither is there only his Body but the memorial of it And how should there be a conversion of the Bread into the Body A conversion of it into the glorious Body doth not sute with the Sacrament a conversion of it into a broken crucified Body doth not sute with a state of glory or if there were a conversion how should there be a memorial the Bread which is not cannot be a memorial of the Body neither can the Body be a memorial of it self after all it is no less than three times called Bread to assure us that it is Bread after consecration as well as before The other is this It is a Doctrine attended with very great absurdities it puts things into such a posture as here follows Here 's a Sacrament without a sign It is essential to a Sacrament that there be an earthly part as well as an heavenly somewhat for the body as well as for the soul but here 's a Sacrament of meer accidents no Bread no Wine to figure out the body and blood of Christ no corporal nourishment to signifie a spiritual one Here 's accidents without a subject the bread vanisheth but the accidents remain and face our senses yet they stand all alone without a substance to inhere in under their roof is no less than the body of Christ yet they lean upon nothing Here 's a thing made which before was made which is all one as if a Father should beget a Son already begotten or an Architect build an house already built the body of Christ which was before the Conversion is produced by turning the bread into it he that was conceived by the Holy Ghost and born of the Virgin is made again by pronouncing a few words to make that which is made is impossible Bellarmine to salve this saith De Euch. lib. 3.18 That it is not conversio productiva sed adductiva which distinction overturns it self if it be only adductive it is no conversion if Christ had only destroyed the substance of the Water and set Wine that was extant before in the room of it there had been no conversion no more is there if the bread cease to be and the body of Christ that was before in being came in the room of it Here is no Transubstantiation but Translocation only Here 's a body in many places the body of Christ is intire in Heaven it is also intire in the Eucharist it is therefore above it self below it self at a distance from it self all which are impossible Here 's a mistake of the Senses the bread appears to be bread it looks touches smells tastes like bread yet it is not so in other things our senses are right but in the Eucharist in which the design is by sense to lead our Faith to spiritual objects they are in a fatal error much less tolerable than if there were a mistake about other objects it being not in a thing meerly natural or speculative but in a sacred or practical sign ordained on purpose to figure out and exhibit Christ unto us Thus much touching the Doctrine of the Papists in this point The Lutherans assert a corporal presence upon account of an Ubiquity in Christs humane nature They explain themselves more fully thus Two things may be noted touching this Presence the Will of Christ and his Power Touching his Will it appears in the words of Institution This is my body that is in with and under this bread is my body this
might unite us to him being God-man in one Person that the same Spirit which sanctified his humane nature might sanctifie us members of him It may yet further be observed that that very Spirit which as St. Austin speaks Spiritus Sanctus ineffabilis est quaedam Patris Filiique communio Aust de Trin. lib. 5. cap. 11. Insinuatur nobis in Patre authoritas in Filio nativitas in Spiritu Sancto Patris Filiique communitas in tribus aequalitas quod ergò commune est Patri Filio per hoc nos voluerunt babere communionem inter nos secum per illud donum nos colligere in unun quod ambo habent unum hoc est per Spiritum Sanctum Deum Dei donum Aust de Verb. Domini in Math. Ser. 11. is the communion of the Father and the Son doth unite us to Christ If we put all together we shall see the Spirit to be a most excellent bond In the Trinity it is the communion of the Father and the Son in Christ it is that which united the two natures and sanctified the humane in us it is that which unites us to Christ This is the primary Bond between Christ and Believers Touching this bond it is first to be noted that in Scripture not only the graces of the Spirit but the Spirit it self is said to be communicated to Believers To quote some places for this The love of God is shed abroad in our hearts by the holy Ghost which is given unto us Rom. 5.5 He that raised up Christ from the dead shall also quicken your mortal bodies by his Spirit that dwelleth in you Rom. 8.11 As many as are led by the spirit of God they are the sons of God verse 14. The spirit it self beareth witness with our spirit that we are the children of God verse 16. Know ye not that your body is the temple of the Holy Ghost which is in you 1 Cor. 6.19 God hath sent forth the spirit of his son into your hearts crying Abba Father Gal. 4.6 In these Texts two things may be observed The one is this the Spirit it self is meant it is the Spirit it self which sheds abroad the love of God in the heart which quickens the mortal body which leads the sons of God which beareth witness with our spirit the Text is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the Spirit it self in express terms it is also the Spirit it self which hath a Temple in us which makes us cry Abba Father The other is this The Spirit it self is communicated it is given to us it dwelleth in us it leads and acts us it bears witness with our spirit it is in us as in its Temple it is sent forth into our hearts all which do import communication Also we may note as much in that Apostolical Prayer The grace of our Lord Jesus Christ and the love of God and the communion of the Holy Ghost be with you all Amen 2 Cor. 13.14 Here are all the persons in the Sacred Trinity named here the Holy Ghost must needs be the Spirit it self none other but he is capable of being ranked with the Father and the Son yet there is a 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 a communication of him Also we may gather the same thing from the Promises of the Spirit made by our Saviour in the 14 15 16 Chapters of St. John there it is the Spirit it self which is promised it is the comforter the spirit of truth it is that spirit which proceedeth from the Father which teacheth all things and bringeth all things to remembrance which convinceth of sin and glorifies Christ which takes the things of Christ and shews them unto men all which shew that it is the Spirit it self Also there it is promised to be communicated it was to be sent to them to guide them into all truth to dwell in them to be in them to abide with them for ever all which do shew a communication of it When the Greeks erroneously held That the Spirit did proceed not from the Father and the Son but from the Father only one argument used against them was this If the Spirit was sent from the Father and the Son then it did proceed from both To this the Greeks replied That this sending meerly concerned the gifts of the Spirit not himself but this is directly contrary to the scope of those chapters in St. John if the Spirit be sent meerly because we have his gifts then the Father which we no where read may be said to be sent because we have his gifts when the Scripture saith that the Son was sent it was himself not meerly his benefits in like manner when it saith that the Spirit is sent it is himself not meerly his gifts I may here add somewhat out of the Fathers Ignatius tells them that they were blessed being 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Epist ad Ephes such as carried God the Spirit a Temple within them St. Ambrose saith that the Holy Spirit dwells in us as in his Temple Non quasi Minister De Spir. Sancto lib. 3.13 sed quasi Deus inhabitat he dwells in us not as a Minister but as a God St. Austin speaking of the gift of the Spirit saith De fide sym cap. 9. that God doth not give seipso inferius donum a gift less than himself And again Euch. cap. 37. that the Spirit is donum aequale donanti a gift equal to the giver And in another place That the Spirit seipsum dat sicut Deus De Trin. lib. 15. cap. 19. In Oct. Pasc Serm. 1. gives himself as God St. Bernard hath this passage Est enim Spiritus ipse indissolubile vinculum Trinitatis per quem sicut pater filius unum sunt sic nos unum sumus in ipsis the Spirit it self is that indissoluble bond by which as the Father and the Son are one so also are we one in them I might add much more out of the Schoolmen but this may suffice It seems by these things to be clear that the Spirit it self is communicated to Believers neverthelss it is a Quaere how or in what sense the Spirit it self is communicated to them In answer to this I shall first take notice of three memorable expressions in Scripture That is the sending of the Spirit the giving of the Spirit the dwelling or inhabiting of the Spirit in us The first expression is the sending of the Spirit It may seem strange that an Almighty Alwise Alpresent Spirit should be sent but this mission is not per imperium as from one more potent than himself commanding him he is as high in power and majesty as the other two persons are it is not per consilium as from one more wise than himself counselling him he is one of the Domus judicii as some Rabbins call the Trinity one of the Three who fit in counsel together in Heaven Here is no local motion which cannot be
all these glorious appearances operate intimately and immediately he penetrates into the inmost spirit and is more intimate to it than that is to it self he operates not only by an immediation of virtue but by an immediation of essence for his virtue is not distinct from his essence Thus there is a communication of the Spirit an excellent operative intimate presence with Believers as if he were a kind of soul to them to quicken them unto every good work But alas how short are our thoughts in this point how little a portion of it do we know The Master of the Sentences out of St. Chrysostom asserts That we cannot comprehend how God is every where much less can we comprehend how he who is every where is in a special manner in Believers I verily think that those Phrases of Scripture which express the Spirit to be communicated to them have in them a mystery much deeper than we can dive into I shall therefore make no further answer to the Quaere it is enough for me to say with Fulgentius That the inhabitation of the Holy Trinity in us De Pers Christ is non localis sed immensa non comprehensibilis cogitatione sed venerabilis fide not local but immense not comprehensible in thought but venerable in Faith I conclude with that of Zanchy De trib El. lib. 4. cap. 1. Spiritus Sanctus quia immensus est ideo ubique est maximè in omnibus fidelibus speciali quodam sed incomprehensibili modo The Holy Spirit because he is immense therefore he is every-where most of all he is in all the faithful after a certain special but incomprehensible manner The next thing which comes to be considered in this discourse is the Operations of the Spirit I touched upon this before but now I will speak a little more to it It 's true these Operations being among the opera ad extra are common to the whole Trinity yet in Scripture they are in a peculiar manner attributed to the Spirit the reason of which is because of that order which is among the persons in the Sacred Trinity the Father is of himself fons Deitatis the fountain of the Deity the Son is from the Father lumen de lumine light of light the Holy Spirit is from the Father and the Son he proceeds by an eternal spiration from both of them And as is the order of subsisting so is the order of operating the Father operates from himself the Son from the Father the Holy Spirit from both Hence in the three great Works of God Creation which is the first rise of things out of nothing is in a special manner attributed to the Father Redemption which helps up a poor fallen creature is in a special manner attributed to the Son Sanctification which perfects the redeemed is in a special manner attributed to the Holy Spirit Hence in the great Work of Salvation the Father laid the counsel and platform of it the Son carries on the work in a middle mediating way the Holy Spirit according to his place in order consummates it by working Faith and all other Graces But this is only by the way In treating of these Operations I shall note two things that is what is in them of respect to union with Christ and what is in them of respect to the Inhabitation of the Spirit or which is all one to the Inhabitation of the whole Sacred Trinity The first Operation of the Spirit in Believers is this He forms all holy Graces in them he draws the very Picture of Christ upon them in humility love meekness mercy goodness heavenliness patience this operation is requisite upon a double account One that Christ may have a seed the Father promised him a seed he himself merited one yet a seed he could not have unless the Spirit did work these Graces which make us to bear a resemblance of him Another that God might have a Temple under the Old Testament he had an outward Temple but even then he would have an inward one a Sanctuary in the heart under the New Testament he had a Temple in the humane nature of Christ but even in that he aimed to have a Tabernacle in men but this could not be unless the Spirit did come and turn the heart into an holy place for him As touching this Operation the holy Graces may be considered under a double notion either as they make us to have one common nature with Christ and thus they import union with him or else as they are tokens of the divine Presence and thus they import the Inhabitation of God in us These Graces make us to have one common nature with Christ and thus they import union with him there is as the learned Camero observes a double union one ab uno communi simpliciter from one common nature simply considered thus all men are united there being one humane nature in them another ab uno communicato from one nature communicated thus a Father and a Son are united the Son having the same nature communicated from the Father To apply this distinction First Believers have one common humane nature with Christ not only in that large sense in which all men have the same nature with him but in a more strict sense peculiar to believers only He that sanctifieth and they who are sanctified are all of one Hebr. 2.11 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 of one not of one God so Angels also are not of one Adam so wicked men also are but of one nature and condition Christ hath an humane nature sanctified by the Spirit and so have Believers this is one peculiar thing in which he and they meet there is no other holy flesh in all the world but what is in him and them This tells us that they are so united to him in one common nature as no other creature in Heaven or Earth is Angels are not so they are holy but not flesh unregenerate men are not so they are flesh but not holy Believers only have as Christ hath an humane nature sanctified by the Spirit Further which advances the Union they have this sanctified nature from him we are members of his body of his flesh and of his bones Eph. 5.30 In this sanctified nature there are two things a carnal substance and an holy quality as to the carnal substance he is of our flesh and of our bones he did partake of flesh and blood with us As to the holy quality we are of his flesh and of his bones by him we are partakers of the divine nature Thus believers are joyned to him as to the Fountan of their Sanctity their holy Graces all hang upon him as beams upon the Sun If the Children of Reuben and Gad had been asked What part have you in the Lord they would have shewed the pattern of the Altar If Believers be asked What part have you in Christ they can shew forth their holy Graces These are Copies drawn after him
your eyes upon them in their pure spiritual glory Spiritual objects being represented under sensible are much better attempered unto our minds than they would be if set forth in a more proper dialect only Moreover Metaphors are of excellent use to make us seek after the things above did our minds indeed take in and digest the sacred similitudes in Scripture the very objects of sense would prompt us to be heavenly outward things being but the shadows would lead us to the true substance The Sun would tell us that there is a more glorious one above which shines with healing under his wings The Wind would remember us that the best Gales come from the holy Spirit The Fountains would mind us that there is a Well of water which springs up into life everlasting The old creation would be a gloss and paraphrase upon the new every where we should meet with Christ and holy mysteries The duct and tendency of these holy Metaphors is such that a due improvement of them must needs render our minds very spiritual and Divine In particular The Holy Ghost in Scripture sets forth the mystical union by many resemblances Christ saith St. Chrysostom unites us to him In 1 Cor. hom 8. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 by many patterns and then he goes on he is the head we the body he the foundation we the building he the vine we the branches he the husband we the spouse he the shepherd we the sheep he the way we the walkers we are the temple he the inhabitant he is the first-born we brethren he the heir we coheirs he the life we the livers he the resurrection we the raised he the light we the inlightned and after all he concludes thus 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 all these things declare union My first work shall be to consider the chief resemblances by which this union is set forth in Scripture Certain it is that the holy Ghost uses no Metaphors or similitudes in Scripture but such as have an aptitude and fitness to manifest the mysteries thereby shadowed out to us he is so wise that he knows what forms of speech are most adapted to promote our knowledg of spiritual things and so good that he will in no forms but such declare his mind unto us Touching these resemblances I shall first note two things in common to them all There is an Analogy between the mystical union and the other unions which resemble it There is an excellency in the mystical union above all the other There is first an Analogy between them somewhat in the earthly unions resembles the mystical one somewhat in the mystical union answers to the earthly pattern there is a correspondence between them This must needs be so because in all Scriptural Metaphors touching this or any other mystery the Holy Ghost always speaks aptly and truly When there is no propriety in the words there is an aptitude in the things to shadow out the mystery when there is no truth in the proper sense there is a truth in the metaphorical one because of the similitude which is between the earthly pattern and the heavenly mystery If the Scripture say that the internal work of grace is a new birth or a resurrection or a new creation it is sure that there is some act of power which makes good the resemblance if it say that Christ is to believers a king or an husband or a foundation or a root or an head or spiritual meat and drink it is sure that there is somewhat of law or love or supportance or vital influence or intimate conjunction which makes good the Analogy Two things may be noted touching the Analogy the one is this there is a necessity of it otherwise the holy Spirit in such Metaphors should not speak aptly or truly not aptly there being no proper aptitude in the very words the aptitude must be in the things or no where take away the Analogy and there will be no aptitude at all the words which cannot befall so wise a speaker as the holy Ghost is will be insignificant and to no purpose nor yet truly there being no truth in the proper sense the truth must be in a metaphorical one or no where Take away the Analogy which makes the Metaphor a Metaphor and there will be no truth at all the words which cannot befall so true a speaker as the Holy Ghost is will be false and delusive For instance our Saviour saith I am the bread of life Joh. 6.48 I am the door of the sheep Joh. 10.7 The first words are apt and true because by him believers are spiritually nourished to life The second are so because by him believers go in and find pasture of comfort but take away these things in which the similitude consists and the words will not be apt or true The other is this there is a very good use of the Analogy to be made it serves being duly and regularly taken according to the line and level of Scripture not only for illustration but for very good proof also For instance St. Paul sets forth the union of Christians among themselves by the union of the members in the natural body 1 Cor. 12. And from thence he argues strongly that Christians should not differ and despise but accord and have a care one of another the eye cannot say to the hand I have no need of thee nor the head to the feet I have no need of you if one member suffer all the members suffer with it if one member be honoured all the members rejoyce with it Also the Apostle sets forth the Union of Believers with Christ by the union of the members with the head Eph. 4.16 and Col. 2.19 And from thence he argues strongly that Believers have a near conjunction with Christ and admirable communications from him there are joints and bands there is a body fitly joyned and compacted there is nourishment ministred there is an effectual working in the measure of every part there is an increasing with the increase of God all these are rationally drawn from the Analogy Thus we see the Analogy is of use not only for illustration but for proof only we must by no means stretch it beyond the scope of Scripture The next thing is There is an excellency in the mystical union above all and every one of the other unions which resemble it It is more excellent than any one of them singly taken The Holy Ghost doth not shadow it out by one or two resemblances but by many and those resemblances do not all point it out in one or two respects but in more and various ones if one resemblance or respect might have reach'd it there would have been no use or need of any more It is also more excellent than all of them put together they are but shadows and resemblances the mystical union is the truth and substance of them all in them meer creatures and those upon earth are united together in
such an one though he know it not is indeed in union with Christ our Saviour pronounces him a blessed man one to whom the Kingdom of Heaven belongs which could never be in a state separate from him who purchased it for us there are some rayes of Faith in him which unite him to Christ some touches of the Holy Spirit which make him look towards salvation The next mark of this union is an high estimation of Christ In the Spouses eye he is white and ruddy the chiefest among ten thousand altogether lovely Cant. 5.10 and 16. To them that believe he is precious 1 Pet. 2.7 every thing in him is attractive He is precious in his person he is Immanuel God and man in one his Deity is infinite perfection his humanity is full of the rich anointings of the Spirit the union of the two natures is a pledg that God would be at one with us the rich anointings of the Spirit make his humane nature to be a fountain of Grace to run over and fill all the Believers in the world every thing in his person is amiable none neglect him but those that are at a distance from him all that are in union with him set the highest rate upon him in their eyes other things are but dross in comparison of him they put by all the world to set their hearts upon him they cast away all their Idols to make room for him in their inner man they part with carnal self to espouse him in the highest love they chuse him not meerly for his excellent benefits but chiefly for his incomparable person they rest not in his choicest gifts but lift their affections up to him the great donor nothing is so valuable to them as he He is precious in his active and passive obedience he fulfilled righteousness and bare the curse for us he did bleed and dye upon a Cross to make an atonement for us his sufferings being by his Deity elevated into a kind of Infinity were of value enough to pay for the sin of a world he hath satisfied Justice to the full and withal hath opened a door of mercy to us And what things are these how highly to be valued to slight them is to say we have no part in them all who by union with him share in them prize them above a world the very life of their souls is bound up in them here 's their refuge against the storm of wrath which hangs over them as sinners here 's the only plea to the Law which pronounces a Curse on them as transgressors here 's the only compensation for sin the only sat is faction to justice here 's their trust confidence prop center of rest no tears prayers services good works nothing can satisfie their hearts but that which satisfied Gods Luther said That Christ was as fresh to him now acâ—si hâc horâ fudisset sanguinem as if he had shed his blood this very hour Those that are in Christ find as much sweetness in his blood as if they had stood by the Cross and seen the shedding of it for them He is precious in his Words Neverman spake as he did what he declared was brought down out of the Fathers bosom his mysteries are heights and depths his commands all rectitude and equity his promises the effluxes of infinite grace and mercy every thing that dropt from his lips was divine not to taste such things as these is to be without sense those that are in Christ set an high rate upon them they sit at his feet to hear him they do not only hang his words about their heads but keep them in the midst of their hearts as being their life they hold them and will not let them go no not in suffering times in which their own lives may be called for to be laid down in pawn for them The high Mysteries which are above the sphere of their reason are meat for their faith the righteous commands which the carnal heart would turn off are the only Canon of their lives the precious Promises though chiefly they concern the things of another world are to them as so many Honey-combs of grace to sweeten every condition every truth of Christ is dear to them He is precious in the influences of grace he received gifts to give them out to men he had the Spirit above measure that he might communicate it to them He is an Head ever working in his members a fountain of grace ever running out towards them Those that are separate from him make nothing of this but all that are joined to him highly esteem of it He is to them as the wind to the sails to fill them with holy gales and as the Sun and rain to the flowers to make a spring of graces in them Whilest he is influencing on them all is well they live and their holy Principles are in motion Should he withdraw from them there would be nothing but dying and withering they would soon be as a branch without a root or a member without an head The influences of grace from him are as dear to them as the breath in their nostrils He that thus values Christ may be sure that he is in him none that are out of him do so Another mark of this Union is a tender respect to the bonds of it The Spouse in the Canticles held Christ and would not let him go St. Paul did follow after to apprehend that for which he was apprehended of Christ Phil. 3.12 Those that are in union with him are unwilling to leave him In him they have light life grace peace salvation heaven and where can they be better It is in their heart never to part with him but always to abide in him To this end they make it their care to maintain the bonds of union they carry a tender respect to faith and to the holy Spirit They have a tender respect to faith it is not enough to them to have faith but they use all means to strengthen it they are much in the Scriptures to refresh it there they go to the Lords-Supper to feed it there they cry out in ardent devotions for the encrease of it they put forth often acts of it to make it more vigorous and all this is because it is the choice unitive grace the golden pipe that lies at the fountain of grace the sacred bond that tyes them to the Head in Heaven Should this fail they would be broken off from Christ it would be all one with them as if there were no Christ no fountain or head of grace as if there were no influences or streams of grace from him What Julian the Apostate in a scoff said of the faith of Christians Naz. Orat. 1. in Jul. That it was their only wisdom that they find true in good earnest Faith is their great concern to strengthen it is their daily work They call upon their souls to adhere unto Christ for ever they cry