nourishing the once kindled Flame so long as the Materials shall be able to last or endure and that in Men and Beasts is their old and decrepit Age and the utter Expence of that Humidum Radicale whereby their Flammula Vitalis might be nourished and maintained or that it be corrupted and vitiated by other noxious Humours and thereby rendred improper for the Purposes to which it was designed In Men and Beasts it seems there is a Material Spirit kindled and enflamed and thereby attenuated to so great a degree of Subtilty as to become Invisible and so asserts My Lord Bacon in the Place before quoted And so our Author Pag 72. says Some think that the Soul is Material yet of a purer Substance than things visible and thus thought Tertullian and almost all the Old Greek Doctors of the Church that write of it and so most of the Latines or very many Some thought the Soul an Igneous Body such as we call Aether or Solar Fire or rather of a higher purer Kind and that Sensation and Intellection are those Formal Faculties which specifically difference it from inferiour meer Fire or Aether And there are few of the Old Doctors or Fathers who thought it not some of these ways Material And to all this we do willingly subscribe and agree believing as the Primitive Fathers of the Church both Greek and Latine have by our Author 's own Testimony thought and taught before us And we conceive that the Beasts have a like Material Spirit inflamed lambently but whether altogether so fine and subtile as that in Humane Bodies we find not Ground enough to assert or determine But Solomon tells us what befalls Men befalls Beasts As one dies so dies the other Yea they have all one Breath and a Man hath no Preheminence above a Beast their Bodies go all to one Place they are of the Dust and turn to it again and who knows the Difference of their Spirits that of a Beast goes downward to the Earth viz. dies with the Body and turns to Dust and who knows that the Spirit of a Man doth not do so but goes upward Hence it seems there was an Opinion at that time amongst the Jews that the Souls of Men did not die with their Bodies like the Beasts And we find Solomon in the Close of this Book saying upon a Mans Death The Dust shall return to the Earth as it was and the Spirit shall return to God who gave it Now whether he was better resolved in the Point at this time or that he used this Expression to comply with the Opinion of his Countrey we will not pretend to determine But it seems plain that amongst Men and Beasts there is a great Congruity in their Parts Frame and Composition as that all have different Members acting sutable to their Kinds as Head Feet Back Belly and Inward Parts as Heart Liver Lungs Spleen Brain and all the Organs of Sense and Nerves Veins Arteries Ventricles Muscles Joynts and the same Nature of Flesh Bones Blood and Breath which shall be left here and changed for the Consideration of their Internal Powers of Sense Motion Phancy Memory Intellect and of their Affections Passions and Powers of Perception Utterance and the like Faculties Concerning such Faculties we begin from the Senses and do find the Beasts have all the same with those of Men and that they can make as accurate and beneficial Use of them as any Men can do and in the Perceivance by them divers Beasts do excel Men some in the Use of one Sense and some of another and every Beast and Bird have Voices Tones and Notes all serving to warn and direct their Young ones to call for their Food or complain for the Want of it to give warning of Weather or Danger to call for Company of their own Kind to threaten and terrifie their Inferiours in Strength the Birds also to vie with one another in Melody delighting therewith the Ears of other Creatures that can perceive the Suavity and Variety of them The Affections and Passions in Beasts are the same with those in Men. We have named five Principals of them viz. Ambition Covetousness Lust Wrath and Fear the three last of which are altogether as eminent and active in Beasts as in Men. Ambition is not so and yet Beasts and Birds of all Kinds will fight without giving quite over until there be an acknowledged Mastery amongst them the Stronger will compel the Weaker to give Way and to follow and observe him Nor is Covetousness in Beasts any thing comparable to that in Man some of them do hoard up Provision for their Support in Winter and others for whom it is proper will steal it from them or fight for it if there shall be an Occasion So as in Beasts these Affections are but very feeble in comparison to what they are in Man Whereas Lust Wrath and Fear are equally potent and prevalent in the one Kind as in the Other And for Proof that Beasts have Phantasies their Dreams are Evidence in which sometimes they are vehemently agitated and affected and that they have Perfect Memories is proved by a Horses learning to know a Way but once gone and sooner than ordinary Passengers do by a Cows returning to the Place where her Calf was parted from her although she be driven away many Miles from it by the Docility of Horses Camels Dogs Apes Elephants most knownly but truly of many other Creatures And there seems to be no sufficient Doubt of finding all other Powers that are in Man resident in some Beasts except that of his Intellect which he can imploy in framing many Notions or Propositions and drawing Consequences and Conclusions such we do not know that any Beasts can do nor have they Means of making them known to us Sometimes we light upon Effects which carry a great Semblance of Proceeding from such Causes as in Dogs their Kindness to the Bodies of their dead Masters and discovery of their Murtherers That of Sabinus supported his Master's dead Body in the Tiber till he sunk with it Alexander's Elephant who would never take Food after the Royal Harness was taken from him and put upon another but starved and died upon it Androgeo and his Lion are reported and made famous in divers Roman Histories and other-like Effects are related that might serve to this Purpose but too long and circumstantial to be here related But from the Docility of Creatures Beasts we may with some certainty collect that they have an Intellect of simple or single Notions what and when and how their Directors will have them to act And Hares and Foxes do it seems invent Means to deceive and baffle their Pursuers But of Complex Notions Discourse or Reasoning in their Minds we do not perceive that any Beasts are capable although they are notable Observers of their Masters Eyes and can perceive their Pleasure or Displeasure in them and act according as by them directed Yet that they
other Things that are of a Different Nature from themselves viz. in those Things which Men call Substantial Forms and Real Qualities or Qualifications which many perswade themselves are resident and to be found in the Nature of Bodies or Things Nor how such Substantial Forms or Qualities have the Force and Power to excite Local Motion in other Bodies We know it says he to be the Nature of our Souls that different local Motions are enough for the Stirring and Excitation of all our Senses and that Bulk Figure and Motion act upon our Sensual Organs and this Act or Motion passes from them to the Brain and in external Objects we do not perceive any thing but the various Disposition of the Objects which affect our Nerves in various Modes or Manners All this seems to import no more concerning the Soul but that Men have a Substantial Form called by the Name of Soul My Copy of Des Cartes is in 8o. printed Lond. 1664. and contains his Principles and Diopticks his Meteors and De Passionibus We proceed to his De Methodo There Sect. 4. P. 21. he draws in somewhat abruptly a farther Consideration concerning the Soul Pag. 22. He derives his Knowledge thereof from his own prime Invention of Cogito ergo sum viz. Existo And no wonder that he thence derives his Knowledge of the Soul since he dare pretend to derive from thence the Knowledge also which he hath of God As if the Four Rivers of Paradise might competently be expected to flow from the Narrow and Shallow Fountain of his Cogitation But intending to fix his Anchors upon this Axiom as on a Rock He pretends to overthrow by his bare Authority his Ipse dixit all the Ancient Grounds of Humane Sense and Nature by believing that he hath no Body for the feigning without believing it would be but a Dream and unfit for his or for any Purpose Then by believing that there is no World or Place for a Body to be in why cannot I as well feign or believe that I have not a Being as that I have not a Body or that there is neither Place nor World You cannot do it says he so long as you are thinking but if you slacken the Reins and give over Thinking but for one Moment you can have no Reason to believe your own Existence during the time of your Vacation from Thinking how short or long soever that Time may be And hence says he I know my self to be a Substance whose whole Nature and Essence consists in Thinking Whence he seems to collect that this Thinking Substance hath no need of Place nor Dependence upon any other Material Thing Upon this I demand how he knows or can demonstrate that he could think at all without a Body and the Spirits and Organs thereof this he hath not attempted to do and I take it for an Impossibile upon him And till that be done I hold it fit and reasonable to reject his utterly unproved Assertions viz. That the Soul is plainly distinct from the Body more easy to be known than the Body is and would be the same that she is if she had not a Body These as they are barely asserted by him are as easily rejected and denied by me with a Cujus Contrarium Verum He proceeds to declare by what Degrees he derives the Knowledge that God is and what he is from the Fundamental Rock of his own Cogitation My Design is not Opposition to him or his pretended Alterations or Modes of Learning but only in Things concerning the Soul and therefore what he delivers concerning God and his Cogitative Knowledge of that Tremendous Majesty we will not offer to examine therefore we go over him till he return again to the Soul which he doth Pag. 25. He pretends to tell us the true Reason why many perswade themselves that the Existence of God and the Nature of Humane Souls are Things very difficult to be known The Reason says he is this those Men do not separate their Minds from their Senses nor raise them enough above Corporeal Things believing the Old Philosophical Maxim viz. Nothing can come into the Intellect but by the Passages of the Senses by which Passages neither God nor the Soul are ever like to get into the Intellect whence it need be no Wonder that they are no better or more easily understood We grant his Reason to be good viz. That because God and Spirits come not ordinarily by the Senses into the Intellect therefore they are Things very difficult to be apprehended and understood by Men but that Men shall be able by forsaking the Assistance of their Senses and giving themselves up to unguided and random Cogitations to obtain a more full or true Knowledge of God or Mens Souls I must take leave to deny We are told how God first instructed the first People to know obey and worship him He conversed with our first Parents in the Garden and drave them thence by an Angel He gave Commands for Worship and Obedience sutable to the Patterns imprinted upon Mans Reason at his Creation he reproved Cain sensibly and so translated Enoch directed Noah saving him and drowning all others in a visible miraculous Manner and so was Sodom destroyed so Abraham called and supported Isaac and Jacob chosen and supported Joseph sent into Aegypt Moses preserved and what was done at Sinai and the Journey out of Aegypt filled that Nation and all their Borderers with Acknowledgments Wonder and Terrors the Works and Wonders done for Jehoshaphat Hezekiah for Nebuchadnezzar Belteshassar and Daniel for Cyrus Alexander and the Foretellings of their Actions Then the Angelical Preparatives for our Lord 's Coming his Extraction Miracles Resurrection Ascension Mission of his Spirit to the Eyes and Ears of many Nations resident in Hierusalem and Witnesses each to their own People Then all the Apostles the Seventy Disciples the Seven first Deacons and their Disciples were inspired to prophesie speak with Inspired Tongues cast out Devils and to do miraculous Cures These Acts testifying a Superior and Supernatural Power to the Senses and Perceivings of Mankind suted to the Doctrines therewith delivered fill'd the Earth with the Knowledge of God as the Waters cover the Sea Now to the contrary where shall Men find so much as one single Person before Socrates who attained to so true a Knowledge of God as to determine That he was but One. All the roving Cogitations of Mankind never attained to so much Truth concerning God as this one most plain and single Assertion except in those Families or People where God by miraculous Means had made himself perceptible to the Senses of Men and by them made himself Way to Humane Understanding and Intelligence And from these things all true and irrefragable it seems we may conclude that to know God or any Spirit are things of very great Difficulty None knows the Father but the Son and he to whom the Son will reveal him And God revealed himself to
〈◊〉 〈◊〉 but gives no Aswer to it Says Plato Origen and many Hebrews held Opinion the Adam's Soul and all other Souls did and do pre-exist and are thence called down as new Bodies require viz. from Superior Regions But this he says is both false and absurd And to prove this by Reason he says Pag. 619. cites Aristotle That the Soul is Actus Corporis Organici and therefore the Soul cannot be before the Body To this we easily assent and add That when the Body dies this Actus Corporis must cease for the same Reason He argues also That the Soul is a Spiritual Substance and it was not needful or proper to put that up at the Nostrils and that seems true but makes against his former Assertions Still there rises a new Difficulty viz. Whether this Soul if then created were created first within the Body or first without the Body and then was breathed or blown in The Text favours the later but the Author favours the former to the Intent that Men may not think Souls are still first created and then infused but think rather as he doth that Souls are created in their Bodies and to this end he approves Lombard's Invention of Creando infunditur Cites Essay 2.22 Cease ye from Man Cujus Anima in Naribus ejus est which we read whose Breath is in his Nostrils Pag. 620 The Soul of Man came to him from without although created within him He will have from without to signifie of another Nature or kind of Thing and not proceeding from the Body as the Beasts do But this he only says without offer of Proof for it Says The whole Soul comes together viz. Vegetative Sensitive and Rational whence it must come into the Body at the first Original of Life and there seems no doubt but there is a Vegetative Power and Principle in the Seed and likely for the Sensual and there appears no Reason against a like Course in the Rational these three being all Faculties of the same Soul from which none of them are separable Pag. 621. The Word signifying Spiraculum Vitarum is used as well concerning Beasts as Men. Pag. 624. Souls of Brutes are sometimes called Spirits in Scripture but never said to return to God Pag. 625. As God breathed into Adams Body the Breath of Life who thereupon rose from the Earth where he lay so shall his Breath effect Life in Bodies which shall rise at Sound of the Last Trumpet And as we read Ezek. 37. Pag. 667. Cites Gen. 1.28 God blessed the Man and Woman and said Be fruitful and multiply and replenish the Earth as Ver. 22. he had said to other Creatures This seems to import Men do generate their Like as the Beasts do and the Creation of Souls for every fruitful Coition by Adultery Incest or Buggery is but a Fiction and not a likely or reasonable Contrivance Lib. 2. Cap. 1. Pag. 683. Mans Life consists in Heat and Moisture not simply but in Temperament with Cold and Dry and from the Four Elements The Four Complexions of Phlegm Sanguine Cholerick and Melancholy Health and Sickness Life and Death consist in a good and fit Temperature of these Humors and the Soul uses these as Instruments for Conservation of the Compositum the General Parts are Bones with their Nerves knitting them together and the Flesh with its Veins through which the Blood returns and Arteries through which the Vital or Animal Spirits have their Courses and God hath given to Men a more delicate Flesh and more Nice and tender Skin than to Beast Pag. 685. And the Temperament and Complexion of their Bodies are much finer Pag. 686. There are Three Principal Faculties of the Soul viz. Vegetation Sense and Motion 3. Intellect The Two later viz. Sense and Intellect are chiefly placed and acted in the Head and thence grow the Nerves passing to every Bone and Member Pag. 687. All Anatomists confess That in an Humane Body there are Innumerable Parts and Things which Men cannot find out and which are known only to God Pag. 689. The Common or Internal Sense cannot act without the Animal Spirits and the Soul uses these Spirits both for Understanding and for its other Actions which are to be performed in the Head and the Nerves which serve both for Sense and Motion through the whole Body have their Original from the Brain and are fixed in it or to it There the Soul reigns most effectually and who can express the various Instruments which God hath there provided for her Use Pag. 693. The Heart is the Original and Prime Instrument of Vegetation and Life which it communicates to the whole Body by its Intense Heat Motion and Rarefaction of the Blood and specially it communicates to the Head the Animal Spirits whereby Motion Sense and Cogitation are received and acted Thirdly The Heart is the Seat Fountain and Cause of all the Affections and there are two Principal Motions in it viz. that of the Systole and Diastole or of the Pulse effecting and Declaring Life the other Motion is of the Affections following the Conceptions or Intellect either with extraordinary Dilatation in the whole Body as in Accidents pleasing and joyous or with a like Compression or Contraction in Case of Accidents sorrowful or dspleasing Whence as Motion Sense and Intellect have their Original and Activity from and in the Brain and Head So Life and all the Affections are derived and acted from and in the Heart And betwixt the Heart and Head there is a wonderful Correspondence and Agreement to the Good and Benefit of the whole Compositum From the Heart Vital Spirits ascend to the Brain where they become Animal Spirits and by these Intelligence Cogitations and Notices of Things arise in the Mind from whence again such Cogitations and Notices strike upon the whole Heart exciting and stirring there the Affections and other Vegetative and Natural Motions which are either pleasing or displeasing tending to or towards Joy or Sorrow the one a great Help to and Supporter of Health and Life and the other great Hinderance to or a Destroyer of them both Pag. 694. The Liver is the Fountain of all the Veins and the Arteries through which the Vital Spirits do pass are always and in all Places conjoined with the Veins and upon them depend the Life and Motion of the Animal and the Soul uses the Blood and Spirits to such Purposes The Liver communicates Blood to the Heart and that again Vital Spirits to the Liver Pag. 195. And as Blood is never in the Veins without some Spirits so neither do the Spirits flow through the Arteries without some thin Rivage of Blood with them and as the Veins have need of the Arteries to stir the Blood in them so the Arteries of the Veins for Nourishment of the Spirits Pag. 696. Spirits of the Body are Vital or Animal and the Spirit is a Vapor drawn by Heat and Concoction of the Heart out of the purest Parts of the Blood
help of other Circumstances of Time Place or Persons c. This we leave as doubtful Pag. 740. There are in Animals Three Sorts of Motion 1. Vital 2. Commanding or Stimulating 3. Prosecuting or Endeavouring That Commanding Force is in the Sensitive Appetite from whence all our Affections do arise and they reign and command in Animals Beasts and Men as Animal and act to Motion the whole Body or the several Members of it The Prime Vital Motion is that of the Pulse placed in the Heart the Seat of Life and Vital Motion acted by the Soul Pag. 741. The Actors in this Motion are the Inward Heat and Spirits viz. the Vital Spirits When this Motion ceases all Animals die and the Vital Spirits vanish But says he it doth not therefore follow that the Soul dies If he had proved or shall prove that there is a Soul in Man which did ever live doth live or can live in Separation from the Body we will admit of this Caution of his and not infer Death of such a Soul by the Ceasing of this Vital Motion in the Body Palpitations of the Heart agitated by the Affections and the Faculty of Respiration are also Vital Motions Appetive commanding Motion Pag. 724. is Vegetative Sensitive and Intellective It consists in prosecuting things liked and avoiding things disliked with Passion or at Leisure cites Matth. 15. They all proceed from the Heart and have their Rise from the Affections although many Causes may work in and upon them viz. Complexion of the Body Education Conversation Examples Doctrines c. their general Aspect is upon Pleasure or Pain to follow or avoid the Vigor of their Motion grows from Lust Wrath and Fear or present outward Sense greatly affected the Affections are not ill in themselves but useful helpful necessary for nothing is from God or Nature which is not Good the Evil which they produce is but by Accident Pag. 744. The Prosecutive Power lies in Local Motion This hath its Root in the Brain whence the Nerves and their Power and Motion are derived animated and enlivened by Spirits from the Heart This says he Galen teaches who is in that Point to be preferred before any other Testimony But it seems both he and Hyppocrates his Master were mistaken concerning Man's Compages of Body and Soul if our Author fall out to be right The Powers moving the Nerves and in them are the Vital and Animal Spirits and thence Motion is derived to the Muscles Bones Joints and every Member These Spirits which are partly Corporeal and partly quasi Incorporeal or Spiritual excited by the Soul omitting how or by what Means these Spirits move and guide the Nerves which are like Reins to the whole Body and they quicken and guide the Muscles and the small Cords or Strings which reach to them By these are the Bones Joints and Members of the Body moved And thus the moving Power of the Soul prosecutes the Mandates of the Appetite and Affections this seems a weak or foolish Sort of Soul that will or must use its Motive Powers to satisfie those Affections which drive to Action against the Will and Dictates of the Soul it self Whence we conclude it more likely that all these Motions are Natural and Animal that Intellect or Reason is one Natural Faculty in Man and that it is Chief and hath a Priority of Order and Power in him that Sense and the Affections are another Natural Faculty in Man and that Vital Inclinations and Powers of Vegetation are another Natural Faculty in him not divided by so many Souls but that one Soul serves all these Faculties viz. that Flaming Spirit or Principle of Life Motion and Action first breathed into Man by his Creator and once quite extinguished can never be again rekindled but from Heaven by miracle A Vital Spark or Origine of this Fire likely may be kindled in Heat of Coition lodged in the Matter by Ordinance of Nature and her Director This hath its appointed Natural Times and Means first of Vegetation and Motions then of Sense and Affections and lastly of Intellect and Reason The Matter Shape and Organs of the Body do by Degrees enlarge themselves and grow and they increase the Blood and Humors which nourish continually the Vital Active Flame whence the Increaseof Body and Soul goes on together till they arrive to their Fullness of Stature Proportions and Activities and in Ordinary Course of Nature they grow stand and decay together This Active is the Motive Principle enlivening and quickening all Man's Faculties to act according to their Natural Powers Propensities and Appointments If any Organ or Part of Matter be out of Order this Active Power not being Rational but in the proper Place for that Faculty cannot remedy that Want but can only put on to Action all that is in the Body fit for it inclining and helping them to and in the Actions that are proper or peculiar to them in the Heart the Primum Vivens and most Vital Part of the Body This Flame and Heat is most Predominant and Intense there the Blood is purified and ratified and refined there the Vital Spirits are generated and thence they are dispersed to several Parts of the Body but chiefly to the Head In the Heart therefore we place the Chief Seat of Life and Vegetation for whose Defence each other Part will be ready to expose it self knowing and feeling that the Loss of that Fort destroys the Microcosm The Place of next Value to this but of much greater Activity is the Head for there reside the Senses both Internal and External and there resides also the Rational Faculty viz. the Intellect and the Judgment so as these two Faculties of Sense and Reason are very close and near Borderers upon one another and although our Author go with the Stream of deriving Mens Affections all from the Senses therein seems to be an apparent Mistake for as we do allow to the Intellect a Will as well as to the Senses an Appetite so there must be allowed to Reason a Power of making and gaining the Affections of equal or greater Potency and Might then that which is attributed to the Senses Whence in Contests betwixt Reason and Sense or Will and Appetite that Part which prevails upon the Affections must be Victor over the other for the Affections stirred and gained excite move and sway the Heart which is drawn and bent by them to resolve and execute accordingly and there appears no such Difference between the Prevalency of either of these Faculties as that Men can determine which doth oftnest prevail or which of them is naturally endowed with the most strong and prevalent Power each have a Power in some Persons more than in others and in all Persons more at one Time or upon one Occasion then upon another In no Persons naturally doth the Stream run one Way but as S. Paul says 'T is not of willing or running but God gives the Victory perhaps often But
by something in us and that is some Substance and this we call the Soul it is not nothing and it is within us Thus he tells us a Humane Soul is an Immortal Spirit That being denied he neither proves it nor offers to do it but instead thereof he offers Proof that it is a substance for says he it moves and acts within us and it is not nothing This we grant but take it for no proof at all of the separated subsistance of a Soul for the Heart Brain Blood and Spirits and Breath are continually moving and acting within us and each of them are substances but have no subsistance in their Motions separate from the Body but all Die with it and so may that which is called by the names of Soul or the Form of a Humane Body or the Vital Principle of it Pag. 14. He Confesses That God is the continued First Cause of all Beings and that the Branches and Fruit depend not as effects so much upon their Causes the Roots Stocks and Branches as the Creature doth upon God whence it seems clear That God can make an Automaton moving and living by ways which Men may not be able to find out or understand and perhaps the Life and Actings of Animals may be such a Secret and because Men cannot find out how the Blood Spirits Nerves Arteries Veins Muscles and other Vital Parts are acted or moved nor the adequate or precise manner how they are all Excited and Actuated by that Flame and Glowing of that which is called the Flammula Vitalis not quite extinguished in Animals but with the Life how by the Unctuous Spirits rising from the Blood Urine and Humours of the Body this Flame is perpetually nourished and maintained and fanned and kept alive by continual and lively respiration nor how the Spirits raised and kindled in and about the Heart mount continually to the Head where in the Brain and the Ventricles of it and Motion or Conveyance of the Arteries thereunto belonging the Common Sense is furnished and excited to Act upon all Objects presented and to Lodge them in the Phantasie and the Memory whence they may be recalled and presented again to the common Sensorium or Judicial Power that it may consider them better or work with them or upon them as far as its own Capacity or Intellect can advance it self in the Powers and Practices of Arts and Sciences Such things we find are transacted and done in the Brain and Body of Man and we cannot pervestigate with any exactness how by the Vital Parts and Spirits of the Body such effects are particularly and properly Produced and this is more hard to be done because Men can never Compass the sight of a Dissected Body in the full Life Vigour and Motion of the Blood Spirits Humors Parts and Members of it but must be content with the view of them all Dead Cold Clammed whence they may have good pretences to conclude it very unlikely that the Powers of Sense Phantasie Intellect and Memory should be Actuated by such Materials or the Conjunction or Operation of them not enough considering that the Flamula Vitalis which is the Acter and Life of them all is extinguished before the beholders can be admitted to the sight and consideration of the Vital or Principal Parts of a Dissected Body And yet it seems from this want of Conception how the Parts and Spirits of the Body do or after what manner they can Act after and in performance of the Faculties of Sense Motion Intellect Phantasie Memory c. Men take their Principal or even only Reason to Introduce or Invent a Forreign Government and Governor for every Animal or at least Humane Body viz. a Spiritual Substance as our Author calls it Pure Invisible Immortal others add Indiscerptable and it will not be Difficult for Men to add and ascribe to it whatsoever their fancies happen to Invent in Cases where we can never expect to have any likely Trial of the Truth but this savours of expounding Obscurum per Obscurius or the stopping one Hole and making many Wherefore as to our not conceiving how the Animal Parts can Work and Act all those Parts which we know are performed amongst us wee seem to have ground enough to refer them to the Power and Will of our Creator That he can by such means effect all Mens performances no Man makes doubt and to many and learned Persons it seems likely that he hath done so and for those who meerly upon the fore-named reason will take the boldness to impose a Super-Humane or Spiritual Empire upon the Bodies of all Men we request them to take as the Acter or Imposer ought to do upon themselves the Onus Probandi and that they first prove to us concerning the Power intended by them to be Introduced amongst and over us which they call an Immortal Spiritual Substance 1. Quod sit 2. Quid sit 3. Quale sit 4. Quando Ingreditur 5. Vbi residet 6 Quomodo gubernat agit viz. That there is in Nature such a Humane Soul able to subsist in Seperation from the Body 2. What it is in its own Nature and whether it do pre-exist a Mundo condito or be derived ex Traduce from the Seed of the Parents or that Infundendo Creatur be Created by Gods Power upon every Fruitful Copulation 3. With what Qualities such Souls are indowed whether they are all well inclined or some ill or meeterly Whether all are of like Power or some more others less potent Whether they may cause or can help or hinder any Bodily Pains or Diseases Whether they can leave their usual place of Residence and go into other Parts of the Body or go quite out of it a wandring in the World and yet return to it again Whether they feel share of the Bodies Maladies and will not willingly consent to have Limbs cut off or to take strong Purges or Vomits for fear of being disturbed in their places of Residence Whether they are more pleased or have a greater desire to be in the Body or out of it Whether the Body be as a Prison to Souls and they be confined to it or that they chuse to be there and leave it unwillingly And if they be there confined by what Power or means are they so and what other Qualities of Souls they think fit to communicate to us 4 When it is that the Soul enters into the Body Whether before or after the Births and if before then how long after the Conception Whether it enter in its full Dimensions or grows larger as the Child grows or suffer detriment by sickness of the Body or its Consumption or Age Also when it leaves the Body finally Whether its leaving do kill or that it stay till the Flamula Vitalis be quite extinct and the Body dead Or If this Flame be suddenly extinct by the violent motion of a blow upon the Head Whether doth the Soul strive to re-kindle this Flame or
him Art 11. We do not well understand nor so as to say he is right or wrong in it Art 12. and 13. We observe in the 13. that he says The Motions of the Brain do excite divers Senses in the Soul This I deny and he offers no Proof of any thing that he says but goes on and says That besides exciting Senses in the Soul these Spirits can without the Soul move the Muscles and Members of the Body He offers our Winking in Proof of this but I deny his Assertion and judge his Proof very insufficient Art 16. Says All our Motions which are common to us with Beasts may be done by us without the Soul by a common Temperament of the Body and the Members and Organs of it acted by the Animal Spirits derived from the Heart and directed in the Brain All this I grant and do take these to be the main Ingredients for the Frame of a Material Spirit Art 17. Says He hath now left nothing for the Soul save only Cogitare-Cogitations he divides into two Sorts one of Actions the other of Passions or Affections the Actions are what the Soul wills to do the Passions are a sort of Perceptions or Apprehensions found in us which the Soul doth not make but receive from Representations of outward Things All these Cogitations of our Author we do reject and say That whilst the Man continues to be so the Soul and Body neither do nor can act or suffer Separately but always in Conjunction one with the other Art 18. and 19. He divides his Cogitative Wills and Perceptions as he pleases Art 20. and 21. And so for his Sorts of Imaginations and so on to Art 25. There he says The Perceptions or Passions of Joy Fear Anger and the like are referred only to the Soul either not considering or not enough rembering that these Passions are as fully visible in Beasts as in Men and if they be referrable only to the Soul then such a Soul as Beasts have may serve well enough for the Subsistence and Acting of them Art 28. Says No other Perceptions do so much agitate and shake the Soul as these Passions do but Beasts are as much transported by them as Men. Art 30. That the Soul is united to every Part of the Body and to all Parts of it Conjunction is granted And how this is done in the Case of a Material Soul is plain and easie but not how done in an intire Spiritual Substance for that is not yet declared by our Author and we know not that it is Intelligible For he says truly Such a Soul cannot be conceived by Parts nor what Extension it hath or consequently where it is and where it is not Art 31. But yet he says There is a Special Part in the Body where the Soul doth exercise her Functions more perceivably than in all the rest of the Body Some have thought this Place to be the Heart and others to be the Brain but our Author upon accurate Examination evidently knows it not to be in either of these but that it is in one Part of the Brain only viz. the Middle or most Inward Part of it There says he is a very small Glandula or Kernel seated in the Middle of the Brain hanging in the very Channel or Course of the Animal Spirits so as the smallest Motions of this Kernel can do much in altering the Course of these Spirits and the Mutations of the Soul by the Courses of the Spirits do help much to change the Motions of this Kernel Parturiunt Montes We see here what our Authors vast Cogitations concerning the Soul hath brought forth viz. a Glandula admodum parva a very small Kernel to be the Chair of State or the Prime Seat of Judgment for his Imagined Soul This seems to fall far short of our Flammula Vitalis which with the Blood pervades the whole Body and actuates the Heart the Brain and every other and most minute Parts of it living with and in the Animal and not quite extinguished but with our latest and last Breath He offers us not one Word concerning the Immaterial Soul of which if he had any thing to say though but out of his own Cogitations this were the proper Place and this Time his Kue to produce them but his Silence gives consent to an Assertion That he knows nothing of it neither Quod sit Quid sit Quando nor Quomodo to the Vbi only He offers this Guess under the Terms of his believed evident Knowledge His Friend Dr. More doth profess to disbelieve him in it and places the Seat of the Soul in the Fourth Ventricle of the Brain by divers Arguments which I who believe neither of them will not spend Time to examine Art 34. Now let us imagine says he as his Mode of Cogitation that the Soul hath her Seat principally in this Kernel and thence sends forth her Rays to all the rest of the Body by Activity of the Animal Spirits hence whatsoever the Soul her self may be her Rays are not an Immaterial but Material Spirits and one would think her Rays should he like her self Well but says he This Kernel which is the Principal Seat of the Soul can move these Spirits and can be moved by the Soul which is of such a Nature that she can receive into her self various Impressions viz. she may have so many Perceptions as there can be various Motions made in this Kernel Art 35. The Animal having two Organs for Seeing and Hearing and two Hands Arms Legs and Feet the two Organs for Sense receive each the Object which goes double towards the Brain till they come to this Kernel and there they join in one and the Kernel working immediately in the Soul shews it the Figure as now it is become one Object All this seems to shew no more but the Products of his own Imagination led by the Affection which now he bears to this Kernel as the Embrion of his own Brain and Invention Art 36. If the Objects perceived shew Danger they excite the Passion of Fear in the Soul Upon this I demand where Fear is excited in the Beasts which have not such Souls and by what other Means then it is excited in Men Art 38. By Motion of this Kernel Fear is induced into the Soul and though the Legs may run away without Knowledge of the Soul yet this violent Motion of them makes another Motion in the Kernel by whose Help the Soul is made acquainted with its Body's running away Behold the Natural and Remarkable Effects of Dividing the Soul from the Body and ascribing some Actions to the one and some to the other separately and without Concurrence of the other Art 40. The Principal Effect of Passion in Man is to incite and dispose him for Self-preservation either by Fight or Flight He might have omitted the Words in Man for the Case is the very same with Beasts Art 44. The Soul by Help of his Kernel can move the
and then in kindled or inflamed first for Conserving of Life and next for being a Principle of Motion in the Animal extending to every Member and Part of it stirring them up and inabling them to the Performance of those Duties for which they were by God intended and ordained The Vital Spirit is Flammula quaedam bred in the Heart out of the purest Blood and thence by Vital Heat communicated and conveyed to the rest of the Members imparting Power and Activity to them by their Natural Heat and Motion and stirring them to act and perform those Duties for which by Nature and Creation they were ordain'd and made The Organs for conveying this Vital Spirit into all Parts and Members of the Body are the Arteries The Animal doth no otherwise differ from the Vital Spirit save that in being transferred to the Brain that hath Power to rarify and make it more Lucid and Subtil and then being from thence infused into the Nerves it incites and enables them to exercise their Faculties Powers and appointed Offices of Sensation and Motion And by both these sorts of Spirits the Principal Actions of Animals and even of Humane Bodies are effected Namely Life is preserved and thence proceed Nutrition Generation Sense Motion Cogitations and Affections Hence it hath come to Pass that some have thought these Spirits to be the very Soul it self or at least the immediate Instruments to it by which the Body both lives and moves Hoc postremum says our Author verum est To which we do not assent but rather hold with the former Lib. 2. Cap. 2. Pag. 697. Treats Ex Professo de Anima and cites out of Tully That Dicaearchus a Peripatetick Philosopher and Scholar to Aristotle held there was no more Soul in Man than in Beasts This says our Author though it should be the Opinion of all Philosophers we ought not to follow or believe them in it because the Scriptures says he are against it Pag. 69â— He takes it pro confesso as agreed on all hands that Souls of Beasts do die with their Bodies without a Principle of separately Subsisting after Death of the Body but there are many Disputes concerning Humane Souls 1. What a Humane Soul is 2 Concerning its Nature and Operations 3 Concerning its Original Whether by continual New Creations or that it grow Ex traduce from Generation or be pre-existent And if newly created then whether first created and then infused or be created within the Body Whether the Vegetative the Sensitive and the Rational be all one same Soul in Man or that they be so distinct as that the two first may die and the third only be that which can separately subsist but the Question of the Souls Nature est per Difficilis per Obscura Tertullian S. Austin and Greg. Nyssen have written of it largely and Pomponacius and Simon Portius two famous Italian Philosophers have since taught That Aristotle held the Soul to be Mortal and that its Immortality cannot be proved by any sufficient Reasons But Men must be left to the Evidence of Faith for that Point and many there are who think there is not enough Evidence to be a sufficient Ground for that Faith Pag. 699. He therefore proposes his first Enquiry viz. What is the Nature and Essence of the Soul Upon this Query he propounds the Definitions made of the Soul by three Ancient Philosophers and very learned Men viz. Plato Aristotle and Galen the great Latin Physician but none of them come up to this Point and therefore he rejects them all especially that of Galen who says The Soul is but a Temperature and sutable Proportion of the Parts and Humours whereby the Animal hath Life and the Vse of all its Faculties And this Opinion he took from his Master Hyppocrates and endeavours to confirm it with divers Reasons and of this Opinion was then Dynarchus the Philosopher and Simmias and divers others The Author brings three Arguments against this Opinion but they are rather Sophistical than Solid He rejects also those of Plato and Aristotle But in lieu of them all he gives us one of his own Pag. 705. viz. A Humane Soul is a truly Spiritual Substance Incorporeal and Immaterial Upon this last Word he lays a great Stress For says he the Souls of Beasts are Essential Forms but drawn out of Matter from which they cannot be separated And there are those who think the Soul which is the Form to our Body to be neither Accident nor Body and that yet it is Material so as to depend upon Matter from which it cannot be separated and therefore must extinguish with Death of the Body Upon this therefore the whole Stress of the Question lies concerning the Mortality or Immortality of the Soul Whence says he this our Definition ought to be well and fully proved Says Humane Souls have the same Essence with Angelical Spirits their only Difference being that the one is Form to a Humane Body and the other not His Proofs he begins from Texts of Scripture but we yet in the Bounds of Nature and Reason will pass them over Animo revertendi and consider here his Arguments from Reason only to which he comes Pag. 709. 1. He says The Soul governs the Body and resists the Passions Complexion excites and begets Passions Here is the Soul contending against Passions and Natural Inclinations supporting them Ergo here is a Substantial Soul In Answer I say The Soul hath no greater Share in the Resisting than in the Exciting of Passions But that the Soul is the living and moving Principle in every Part and Member of the Body understanding and perceiving and remembring in the Head affecting and passionate in the Heart feeling and moving in the whole Body and in every member of it The Souls Regard and Care is for the whole Compositum to chuse the beneficial and to avoid the hurtful Things Hence Intellect and Passion are not one of them of the Soul and the other not the Soul but both are Faculties of the same Soul The Heart desires one thing as vitally Good or abhors it as Harmful The Intellect from common Sense and Understanding often opposes such Desires or Fears from Considerations more percipient and duly weighed and the Contest rises most often from the Nearness or Distance of what they contend about viz. Present or Future one Faculty affixing chiefly upon the Enjoyment and the other contemplating the Consequence withal Now if the Soul did govern the Body as our Author faith it doth the Contest could not be maintained against it by the Passions which should naturally be ordered to yield an easie Submission to it whereas it is too evident that the Passions do often over-power and over-rule the Intellect And as Aristotle hath told us their Contest is more like a Game at Tennis than a Government sometimes one of them prevails and sometimes the other So they look not like a Governor and a Governed but rather like Equal
Sense viz. Brutes and Men live Really and Intentionally God and Angels Intentionally this says our Author is a feigned Invention Fol. 50. N. 3. Says The Soul doth concur both effectually and immediately in the Exercising of its own Operations The Soul deserves well or ill according to the good or ill Will and the Effects of it whence it is the Soul that it free and not the Will Merit and Demerit grows from a Liberty to do or suffer or not and therefore this Liberty belongs immediately and principally not to the Will but to the Soul so the Soul in truly free and hath Power to determine its own Efficiency and Operations agreeing with what we have before spoken concerning it N. 5. The Will is Coeca Potentia and cannot work but as it is determined by Knowledge and the Knowing Principle is that which is free formally Fol. 52. N. 7. Says The Soul hath no Parts but the whole concurrs to every Vital Action in Hand Head Feet c. This I say is the inconvenient Result of Framing the Soul to be an Immaterial Substance and impartible Hence follows our Author's Assertion That the whole Soul must be undividably acting in all Parts at once and wholly in every Part which to unprejudiced Persons looks very like unintelligible N. 11. The Soul is the formally intelligent Principle Fol. 53. N. 14. He says The Senses in Man are subjected in Matter as the proper Subject where it is inherent That the Soul is not a proper Subject for its Inhesion for Material Accidents cannot be produced out of a Spiritual Subject Matter united to a Sensitive Soul is not therefore Sensitive nor for being united to a Rational Soul is it Rational but the whole Compositum is by Force and Power of its Form Sensible or Rational N. 17. And the Material Sensations are united to the Soul which is the Principium Sentiens and yet may not be a Recipient of the Sensations N. 17. For the Soul informs Matter in which it is not inherent but united to it N. 19. Though a Form be united to a Subject without being inherent in it yet no Form can be inherent in a Subject to which it is not united and therefore Sensation received in Matter and united to the Form must be likewise united to the Matter Fol. 54. N. 21. Sensations of Brutes are both subjected and united in their Souls but Sensations of Men are only united to their Souls because that is here taken for an Immaterial Spirit whence Material Agencies cannot arise Productive Fol. 54. N. 1. It is says he a great Question amongst the Learned Whether the Faculties such as Nutrition Generation Sense Intellect be really distinct from the Soul or not Some say that they are not and some that they are Others that the Vegetative viz. Nutritive and Generative are really the same with that sort of Soul but that the Sentient and Intelligent Faculties are really distinguished from those Souls N. 3. The Will if divided from the Soul or Intellect cannot have Knowledge and therefore not Freedom of Acting nor is any thing essentially Subsisting of it self N. 4. but dependently upon the Intellect or Judgment and that is most knowng and free and by that Voluntary Faculty is determined Fol. 56. N. 11. Begins to cite Arguments for proving that the Faculties or Powers are distinct from the Soul and answers them Fol. 58. N. 1. He raises another Question viz. granting such Faculties really Identified or to be really undistinguished from the Soul Whether then they be not formally distinguished from it N. 2. He says they first are formally distinguished from one another and then that every one of them is so distinguished from the Soul at least inadequate Fol. 59. N. 9. Questions if there can be an Intellective Faculty without the Voluntary attending it Fol. 65. N. 1. Anatomists do find that from the outward Organs of the Sense there go Nerves which lead to the Brain by which the Vital Spirits represent the Images received unto the common Sense or inward Faculty that can discern Dogs cannot bark without Sensation thin in their Sleep cannot be outward therefore they do so by Force of their Sense Internal N. 2. Says There is in Man a Sensual Appetite besides his Will And if so says he there must be also a Knowing Principle or Power to guide it And this he says is the Common or Inward Sense But to this I do not agree but say The Contest doth not seem to be betwixt the Will and the Appetite but betwixt Reason and the Affections and Passions each endeadeavouring to incline the Judicial Faculty to pass Sentence on their behalf And the Passions as Wrath and Fear do even strive by their Violence to over-power and compel the Judgment to pass its Sentence on their Side that the Compositum may obtain a present Quiet which without giving some Degrees of Satisfaction to those rebellious and potent Contestors it is not likely to do But upon a Consent obtained the Voluntary Power call it Will or Appetite is readily subservient to such Agreement of the Judgment and hath no Power in Nature to resist such a Decree its Dependence being upon the Judgment as upon its Natural Guide and Director without whose Consent she neither will or naturally can act so as there is no need to make the Intellect Guide to the Will and the Common Sense Guide to the Appetite but the one Guidance of Judgment will serve them both or there is in truth no real Difference between them Fol. 65. N. 3. There are divers Acts of the Sense or Senses Internal 1. It is Perceptive of the Objects delivered by the Senses and thence is called the Common Sense 2. It conserves the Species so delivered Revolvendo and is called the Imagination 3. It can know them and distinguish them one from another and thence is called the Affirmative Power 4. It can compound and join these Species together with what Coherence or Incoherence it pleases or as may happen and this is called the Phantasy 5. It records and remembers such Objects and conserves Things apprehended for Future Times and Uses and this is called the Memory Doubt may be whether a Power or Faculty shall be constituted for Performance of every one of these Offices or that one Common Power shall be said to perform them all Our Author defends There is but one Common Internal Sense acting in all these Performances if in truth they be distinct or several they all may proceed from one Power and it is not reasonable to multiply Powers more than is needful especially for Men of his Judgment which was That there were no Powers in the Compositum which were really distinct from the Soul And in all this I am at Agreement with him viz. That there are no Powers or Faculties so really distinct from the Soul as that they can act to Effect without the Excitation and Assistance of the Soul Hence the Soul moves the
such Exceptions against your Deductions as you are not able to give clear Answers unto nor can you make plain to Reason the particular Mode of the Operation of the Senses less concerning the Imagination Memory Intellect and Affections We will not stick to grant all this and yet reply by repeating what we have said Let the Dr. or any for him shew the particular Reasons and Causes and Manner of Working how and why Apple-trees bring forth Apples of such different Kinds yet constant each to his own Kind And why and how a Pear-tree is terminated to her Sort and Sorts in like manner Why and how a Thorn must needs bear Haws and a Vine Grapes c. Why and how some Plants and Flowers are sweet others stinking or without Smell Let them answer to the Queries before made concerning a Leaf and so as Men cannot make material and just Exceptions to their Deductions and then they may more reasonably pretend to bring in a Self-subsisting Soul to the actuating of the Senses in Animals and the Guiding and Conduct of their other Faculties And till then it is to be hoped they will allow Men to think that the Animal Spirits of a Sensitive Animal may have Activity Mettle and Power enough in them to move and employ the Brain the Senses the Body and all their Organs or Instruments whatsoever without the Government or Assistance of a Self-subsisting Soul or any Extraneous Spirit whatsoever Notice must needs be taken of an Objection which our Dr. himself makes or frames against his own Opinion Pag. 238. says he There will be an envious Objection cast in our Way Observe his Epethite is very sharp but the Strength of the Objection was the Occasion viz. Men will say that all our Demonstrations are meer Sophisms because some of them and the not of the least Validity do prove that Souls of Brutes are Substances Incorporeal and Self-subsisting after Death of the Body and consequently That they have a Pre-existence before their coming into the Body and that the Souls of Men have also the same Pre-existence Pag. 240. The Dr. owns these Opinions and says they are all true Pag. 241. And that the Deriving Souls ex traduce viz. from Seed of the Parents is a plain Contradiction and so impossible for a Body to beget an Immaterial Spiritual Substance The third Conceipt That God creates Souls to supply every Adulterous Incestuous Buggering successful Coition or for Monstrous Deformed Productions is too Indignous to be imposed upon his Majesty And there are but these Three Ways for Production of Souls and therefore they must pre-exist à Mundo Condito when many Miriads of Souls were created to serve in all Future Ages Pa. 447. Of this Opinion says the Jews Cabbala was Moses And he names here Seventeen more Ancient Philosophers who were of this Opinion and adds Origen and later Writers Pag. 245. says That all Philosophers of Note in all Ages who have held the Soul of Man Immortal and Incorporeal have likewise held the Pre-existence of it and this must hold for Beasts as well as for Men. Pag. 266. As the Souls of Men pre-existing slide down out of the Air into fitly prepared Matter so do the Souls of Brutes also Pag. 271. The Souls of Men and Brutes inhabit Air in a Terrestrial Vehicle Pag. 302. Hence Men will say the Souls of Brutes will live and enjoy themselves after Death To which our Dr. dares boldly answer That it is a thousand times more reasonable that they should be believed to do so than that the Souls of Men do not Pag. 304. There is no Reason to think Brutes cease to be alive after they are separated from their Bodies Our Author Baxter following it seems our Dr. holds the like Opinion and perhaps doubting to prejudice the Opinion of a Humane Soul's Self-subsistance Pag. 20. He says Chambre and some others make Brutes a lower Rank of Rationals and Man a higher Rank Pag. 38. Though it be but an Analogical Reason that Brutes have yet the Difference betwixt Man and them it more in the Objects Tendency and Work of Reason than in our Reason it self as such Pag. 201. Men conclude basely of the Souls of Brutes as if they were not an enduring Substance without any Proof or Probability Pag. 303. Some think too basely of Sense because they find it in lower Creatures they might accordingly deny Substantiality to Spirits because Brutes are Substances Pag. 380. The Sensible Souls of Brutes are Substance and therefore are not annihilated after Death It seems this Tenet of the Maintainers of a Separate Subsistence of a Humane Soul is calculated for the Solution of an Objection which they foresaw would arise from that Power which Beasts evidently have and exercise in the Use of their Senses Affections Fancies Memories and Intellect of Simple Notions whereby their Actions may be and are directed How sufficient the Effect of this Tenet will prove for the solving or opposing an Argument drawn from this Ground will best appear when the Argument it self shall have been produced in which we shall proceed as we have done before in the Case of Trees Plants and other Vegetative Creatures We say then That the Beasts are indowed with the like Faculties and Powers that are found in Men they have a Local Motion as Strong Vigorous and Swift as Men and so for every Limb Joynt Muscle Nerve and Sinew of their Bodies acting as Spontaneously therein as can be done by Men They use and govern the same Five Senses that are in Man and enjoy and act them to as great Perfection and Effect as Men ordinarily do and some of them exceed Men in the Natural Effect Use and Vigor of some of those Senses They have the same Affections and Passions reigning in their Minds Inclinations and Bodies as those that appear in Men and their Lust Wrath and Fear are as Strong Vigorous and Vehement as they are in Men. They have very apt and tenacious Memories and have signs of Active and Moving Phantasies the full truth operation and extent whereof we are not able to discover for want of Dialect in the Beasts to discover them to us an Intellect also the Beasts are evinced to have by their perceiving Mens temper of displeasure or kindness in their Eyes Looks or Gestures by their slinking out of sight crouching and dejected Looks or Behaviour when they have done a Mischief a sign they use reflection upon themselves and so much of judgment as to be under Fear and Expectation of Punishment for the same even as we find the Servile People amongst Men will do a Vivacity also of their Intellect shews it self in their Docility inabling them to practice such Postures and Actions as some more stupid People could hardly or never attain to perform to their degrees of Perfection in the knowing understanding observing and obeying of a Sign a Nod a Gesture a Look the Moving of an Eye or by an angry or pleased Composure
Body whereas the Intellect is separable from the Body and then when it hath obtained Knowledge that being Actu in the Soul which before was there but Potentially the Intellect can understand it self and by it self the Difference made betwâ—â—â— Thing and the Essence of that Thing is but notional for â—â—…hing is thereby changed substantially Plato placed Intellect in the Brain Senses in the Heart and the Vegetative Power in the Liver This was an Error of putting the Thing in one place and the Essence of it in another whereas Aristotle makes the Difference amongst those Faculties but Notional and not Real as the different Places would make them And as things that are Real may by Conception be abstracted from Matter and made Notional so may the Intellect be separated It is still a Doubt whether the Intellect be a Simple and Impassible Thing or not seeing that Intelligere est pati quiddam for in Vnderstanding there is something common between the Intellect and that which it apprehends It seems if the Intellect can understand it self it should always be so employed We may observe Aristotle continues still in his former Doubt concerning the Subsistence of a Soul in a State of Separation from the Body Either it hath something common with the Body or it hath not or it uses and needs the Body or not and if it neither use nor need the Body nor have any Common with it it self may subsist in a State of Separation not so if it have Need or Vse of the Body or have any thing common with it Cap. 6. Because that universally in Nature there is always something like the Matter or Subject and another thing which hath the Force of Efficiency and works as the Cause of what is produced like as the Case stands betwixt Art and Matter it seems in the Soul there must be the like different Principles Hence he devises a Difference in the Intellect or Soul it self viz. that there is an Intellectus Agens and an Intellectus Patiens of the Suffering Intellect he spake in the preceding Chapter Calls it here the Means whereby Acts are produced But the Active Intellect is the Force Impulsive why Acts are produced in nature of an Habitual Activity as the Light causes or produces Colours This Active Intellect he says is separable from the Body is an Act Essential not mixed but pure and impatible For the Efficient is ever of more Value than the Patient and the Active Principle than the Material Where Power towards an Act and the Act it self are in uno in one Subject or Being there the Power must precede as to Time but if they be not respected as in uno the Power hath no Precedence at all of the Act not so much as in Time but is every way Inferior to the Act. This Act or Active Intellect being separated from the Body all that can be said of it is it is that which it is and that only is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Immortal anti Eternal but because this Intellect is impatible it cannot have Memory For the Patible Intellect without which the Active Part could not understand Worldly Matters perishes in Bâ— We may observe what is common in the World Men confess God in their Words but in their Works they deny him So Aristotle seems to do with the Intellect or the Soul First he divides it according to the Old Rule Divide Impera then he appropriates all Ways and Means of Knowing or Knowledge to the Suffering Part of it and this Part together with the Senses Affections Phantasies and Memory do all perish in Death What is there then left to subsist in a State of Separation after Death Why there is still left an Active Intellect Essential Pure Impatible Immortal and Eternal If you enquire what manner of Thing this is He answers I can tell you no more of it but it is that which it is and nothing else and this only which is so is Immortal and Eternal This which hath neither Sense Affection Phantasy Memory nor Means of Understanding this for which he knows neither Name nor Nature that can neither remember nor account for any thing that is impatible and can suffer nothing nor feel or desire any thing this unintelligible Spark of Activity is the only thing which is in Man capable of Separate Subsistence after his Death and is his only Immortal and Eternal Part or Principle Cap. 7. Simple Apprehensions of the Intellect are commonly true but in Compounding them the Verity and Falsity is soon attendant and if the Time of Things be considered it adds to the Composition and to Compositions Falshood is commonly Incident That which compounds and makes one Proposition out of many Parts is the Intellect A Thing may be Individuum potentially or actually that which is Actu individuum may be considered in an Individual Time but if actually divided it hath a double Consideration and a like Time unless a Compositum be made of them That which is Individuum by Reason of its Natural Form without Respect to its Bulk is understood in Individual Time and by an Individual Part of the Soul viz. the Intellect Things Naturally Indivisible as a Point are known as Privations are known viz. by their Contraries ut malum ex privatione boni Now that which can so understand viz. one Contrary by another must be one in it self and have both the Contraries potentially in it and must be the Suffering Intellect for that only hath Knowledge of the other Contrary and is potentially all that can be known Apprehensions of the Intellect are not all true yet where it apprehends Simple Objects it seldom fails but often in Compounds just as it fares with the Senses in like Cases We may observe Aristotle divides his Individuum into Three Kinds viz. the Bulkily so the Formally so or so by their Indivisibility Little we meet with here that concerns the Souls Being Nature or Operations and might have spared much of this Chapter Cap. 8. To be Perceiving by Sense is a Simple Act and is in Truth but so to perceive with pleasure or trouble is like an Affirmation or Negation and induces to follow or flie from the Object or to feel Pleasure or Pain is only to be drawn by Sensible Means towards Good or Evil and to pursue or flie accordingly And like to such Sensible Objects are the Phantoms of the Rational Soul and this sort of Soul never understands without assistance of the Phantasmata The Common Sense is but One and that which terminates the Five and they by this Proportion and Unity are made agreeable in One So doth the Intellect deal with the Species amongst the Phantasmata and thence makes her Judgment what to seek and what to avoid And though the Senses have not perceived the things yet if they rise and grow up in the Phantasie or may be collected from what appears to the Senses the Intellect is moved and affected accordingly Men see a
we cannot confide that so it shall be always nor can by Nature be expected often He who thinks he stands may be nearer a Fall than he is aware of These two Faculties have a natural and durable Contest from Sun-rising to Sun-setting from the Cradle to the Grave sometimes one prevails and sometimes the other according as Moses's Hands are held up or let down whence the Inference seems both easie and strong That there is no likelihood of a Rational immaterially Spiritual Power or Government in Man For it seems such a Power or Government would easily and speedily put an End to such Contests and not suffer them to continue Mens whole Lives nay and from Generation to Generation and in all Ages Aristotle compares the Contest to a Game at Ball for the Uncertainty of its Event and so we find it still the Case is nothing altered which is a plain Argument the Thing is Natural for Naturalia non Mutantur We do not hold fit to make strong or positive Conclusions in Things of much less Moment and Doubt than the present Question and therefore shall leave Perusers to draw out of the Premises such Conclusions as themselves think reasonable Pag. 742. Our Author goes on and says There is a very near Likeness betwixt the two Faculties Sensitive and Intellective so as the Old Philosophers have called the Intellect by Name of the Internal Sense so did the Platonicks and Peripateticks And thence our Author collects such a Similitude between them that he resolves so to divide the Intellective Powers as he had done the Sensitive Thus we see the Ground upon which he goes in groping out a Means to say what he pleases of the Intellect He says The Intellect hath two Parts or Faculties viz. the Aprehensive and the Motive in the first it joins with the Memory in the other with the Will and these two Apprehension and Motion are necessary in all Animals Pag. 745. There is a two-fold Force in a Humane Intellect one that it hath Power to understand Intelligible Things the other is the actual and effectual understanding of them This Difference seems Airy for Nature doth not act frustra but if it give a Power it always provides an Act or Effect of it He means by Intelligible Things Abstracted Substances and Universalities the same Things which he spake of at the Beginning Pag. 746. under the Name of a Double Intellect viz. Agentis Patientis understood a Double Power by one of them it understands by the other it doth re-act and judge of its own Understanding Pag. 747. Says The Passive Intellect is a Part of the Intellect that it neither needs nor has any Material Organ Yet he allows the Intellect and all its Powers are in the Body but not affixed to any Organ or using any I demand how doth he know or can prove that Says he By way of Reason If it were any way tied to Organs it would perish and extinguish with those Organs This I grant and partly believe that it doth so But says he farther If the Case were so then as the Organ grows old and infirm the Intellect's Operations should fail accordingly which we see saith he it doth not Which we see say I it doth evidently I grant it lasts as long as any other Faculty and longer than the most of them do Arist De Anima Lib. I. Cap. 5. hath it both Ways First he says The Intellect is not spoiled by Age and therefore that if an Old Man had a Young Eye he would see as well as when he was Young of which there is little Certainty Then it follows in the same Chapter Intellect and Contemplation its Prime Part do decay in Man 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 by the Failing or Corruption of other inward Parts as is clear and apparent in such as live to extream Age and till their Organs or Spirits are by such Age either wasted or corrupted In Fools and Mad-men he grants the Fault grows by Defect or Disorder of the Organs But this says he is only in the Phantasy and that the Phantasy is a necessary Organ for the Soul to work by whilst she is in the Body And it doth not yet appear that she hath any other State nor that by her own any thing Being or Power without Bodily Organs she either understands her self or any other Thing although the Author doth here make bold to assert all this without other Proof than just before mentioned and answered Pag. 748. The Active Intellect our Author says is the Splendor of the Soul creating Intellectual Power as Light enables Men to judge of Colours Then he cites Aristotle's high Expressions concerning this Part of the Soul and yet he refuses to agree with Aristotle that this Part only of the Soul is Immortal but he will have the Suffering Part also to be Immortal being resolved it cannot possibly be so by halves let Aristotle say what he will but for Reasons he gives none relying upon what he had said before Pag. 749. Divides the Intellect into Practical and Speculative Says God when he creates a Soul puts two Principles or Sorts of Notions into it one a Power to discern and distinguish Good from Bad the other a like Power of discerning Truth from Falshood But we neither consent to his imagined Creation of Souls nor that there are such distinct Powers or Principles in it but do conceive both these Abilities of Distinguishing to arise indifferently out of the Humane Faculties of Common Sense and Reason Pag. 720. He says There is a Memory peculiar to the Intellect and not fixed or placed in any Organ nor of any Material Nature But for maintaining this Dogma he neither gives Reason nor cites Authority therefore it may pass with us for a Figment of his own Brain and without any more Consideration He says The Will is the Intellectual Appetite not fixed or placed in any Organ And says That even the Sensual Appetite is not without Reason for its Guide and Men have Reason for Guide of all their Actions And to this we agree but do say that in the Intellect resides the Reason or the Intellect is the Humane Reason or Rationality residing in the Head and amongst the Organs of the Brain assisted by the Common Sense Phantasy and Memory fixed in the same Region and amongst the same Organs used by them That the Power which it hath amongst them is not Compulsory but Swasive or at the highest but Judicial There seems in the Faculty of Reason to be a Judicial Power and that both Will and Appetite if that be any real Distinction are attendant upon this Power and that neither of them do or can move towards Execution before they have obtained a Sentence from the Judgment upon their Side The Affections principally Ambition Covetousness Lust and the Passions Anger and Fear and all their Dependents plead for their Satisfactions and offer their Reasons and their Violences and Dissatisfactions and Desires in
nor understand but in the Intellect nor determine but in the Judgment viz. cannot act but in and by its proper Organs of the Body and as they are by Nature and Primary Creation appointed to be thereunto qualified attendant and sufficient each for their proper Performances so as although the Soul do enliven and quicken the whole Body and act in and by every Part and Member of it yet without the Body it seems it cannot subsist nor in the Body can act but by the Bodily Organs and according to their Aptitude and Powers and the Strength or Weakness which it finds in the Bodily Organs And this seems to evince with some Clearness the strict and necessary Union of the Body and Soul and that they cannot act or even subsist but in and by the Dependance which they have one upon the other Fol. 66. Nu. 8. Our Author says The Seat of Common Sense is in the Brain as Galen hath shewed Fol. 67. Nu. 3. He says There is but one Internal Knowing Power in Man and therefore but one Appetite in him N. 4. And this he says resides in the Head against the Opinions both of Aristotle and Galen who place it in the Heart Fol. 72. N. 2. Says The Distinction of the Intellect into Active and Passive seems not real but only formal the same Faculty appearing Active in order to some things and Passive in order to other things Fol. 73. N. 3. It s Agency lies 1. In taking a View the Idea's in the Phantasy 2. In putting them into an Intelligible Frame 3. In collecting a Result from them Fol. 75. N. 2. Those who do not distinguish betwixt the Soul and the Intellect do say as they must needs that the Intellect resides in the whole Body but says he the Intellective Faculty is not in the whole Body for the Soul hath not Sense in the Bones nor doth it understand in the Foot and it is by Organs that the Soul acts the Intellect and in it And this says he proves the Dependance which the Soul hath upon Matter for the Exercising of its Operations and therefore the Soul unites to it self the Intellect in that Part of the Body in which it finds the proper Dispositions which are sutable and expedient for the Exercise of that Power or Faculty and therefore that Faculty is in the Brain and not in the whole Body Some Folio's raises and answers Objections concerning the Intellect Fol. 82. N. 1. Divers Philosophers he says and most Divines do say That there is an Intellective Memory Others say Memory doth properly belong to the Common Sense only and to the Intellect but improperly Others say It doth properly belong to the Intellect for that the Act of Memory doth more properly belong to the Powers of the Intellect than to those of the Common Sense N. 2. But for himself who doth not realy distinguish betwixt the Faculties and the Soul it self he doth likewise not distinguish between the Intellect and the Memory any otherwise than is distinguished amongst the Senses Phancy Will and like other Faculties not really but formally Fol. 85. N. 16. The Soul whil'st united to the Body uses the Intellect in Perception of Objects dependently upon the Phantasy and the External Senses and perceiver more clearly Things which have come from the Senses to the Phantasy than those which are framed by the Phantasy it self Fol. 86. N. 1. Many hold That the Intellect doth first apprehend Vniversals and then Singulars and as many hold That Singulars are first understood and then Vniversals Fol. 92. N. 9. The Intellect and Will in Creatures existing are radically but the same things and differ only in Name and Opinion And yet some Things are understood in order to be desired or avoided and require Execution to be followed by the Will accordingly other Things may be also understood which neither excite nor incline the Will one Way or another so pass in the Intellect without Need or Use of a Voluntary Faculty Fol. 103. N. 1. Acts of the Intellect are Apprehension Judgment and Discourse by Apprehension the Object is only perceived and known Judgment is a Sentence pass'd upon the Object grounded upon such Knowledge Fol. 142. N. 1. It is says he a certain Rule That the Act of the Will depends upon the Knowledge or Judgment But it is doubted whether this Dependence be only for its Illumination or both for that and its Efficacy or Operations And he says it is only directed by the Judgment to which it hath a Moral Application not determined by it N. 2. The Will depends upon Knowledge as its Guide for that it self is but a Blind Power but the Concurrence of the Knowing Powers seems not of Necessity for its Operations N. 5. And yet the Will is specificated from the Sorts of Knowledge whereby it is guided N. 1. Nihil Volitum quin Praecognitum the Will follows not an Unknown Object but is directed by Knowledge and grows from the same Intrinsick Principle with Knowledge Whence the Will cannot naturally be otherwise but dependent upon Knowledge or Judgment And this he says is an undoubted Rule Fol. 144. N. 4. It is morally impossible for a sober Person and not surprised willingly to fall into Ways or Means of Execution fir doing or obtaining any Thing without a Judgment preceding upon that Thing both concerning the Beneficialness Fitness and Feasibleness of the Thing which is intended to be effected Fol. 145. N. 5. There is no other Act of the Intellect required for setting the Will on work besides the Apprehension or Judgment N. 7. whose Empire he is not willing to extend so far as to take away all Freedom from the Will And I do not see how that Conclusion is or can be avoided viz. That the Freedom often applied to the Will is Originally and Really in the Judgment upon whose Guidance and Government the Will is Dependent Fol. 146. N. 7. This is apparently to take away all Freedom from the Will and to put the Reins say I into the right Hands and Power N. 8. There is no Act of Empire in the Intellect other than the Judgment Yet he will not grant to the Thomists That the Empire of the Judgment is of such Nature as to take away all Liberty from the Will but says it is rather a Guide to the Will than a Predeterminer of it And we do not pretend to a Violence of Power or Empire in the Judgment but to a Natural or Easy Power where the Sway and Guidance is such as it determines according to Nature without imposing upon the Will any Restraint or Constraint obeyed freely by the Will to which it leaves all the Liberty and Freedom which is Natural to it Fol. 155. N. 1. He says Acts of Natural Power or Command though they are Efficacious in their Nature yet they do not infringe the Liberty of the Powers acted by them or that act under them This he quotes as a more late Opinion
and then condemned it His Son Constantius forbad it in places where he was or had full Power whence in that Empire this Practice fell to decay and in time became quite abolished The Christian Religion hath opposed and overcome it in all places of its Plantation and finally it is now come to be rooted out of all the known World And we know of no Nation in Europe Asia or Africa where shedding of Blood is used in Sacrifice to their gods Here is a great and evident Change of the most Antient and Universal Practice that ever was in the World concerning Religion and no Man will pretend to say that this Change was for the worse but for the better although it had God's Approbation by Moses and is not positively forbidden in any part of the New Testament The Apostles after Our Lords Death used it Acts 21.20 Thousands of Believing Jews were yet Zealous of the Law verse 26. Paul went to the Temple with the Four Men that had a Vow and attended till an Offering should be offered for every one of them And yet we see this Practice now utterly abolished and we give God thanks for the performance of it as I think there is great reason and by the change of this most Antient Universal Practice in Religion I pretend to have raised an eminent Impeachment to the force of our Authors Argument from the Antiquity and the Universality of the Immaterial Opinion We know the Papists Plead in like manner against the Reformation intended to be put upon their Errors though Antient and very generally received heretofore into the Christian Churches of the Dark Ages passing from Anno 600 even down to the Times of Luther and other Reformers then arising but we do not accept their Plea of Antiquity and Universality as sufficient for the Justification of their Errors I will but nominate Dr. Comber's Plea for a Divine Right of Titles by force of the same Argument because I have answered it in a particular Treatise not yet Published But upon the whole Matter I think it reasonable to conclude that an Argument drawn from the Antiquity and Universality of an Opinion is but an Argument to that Favour viz. that it ought to be well Weighed and throughly Considered before it be changed and not at all to be changed except there appear sufficient and convincing Proofs that the same ought to be done but not to be reputed of such Force or Power as to silence all Arguments which may be made against it or to stop all manner of Proceedings towards a Conviction thereupon To stop the Press from Publishing such Arguments I do not allow but the way fully to stop silence them is to make Rational and Substantial Answers to them which I profess my self now and ever willing to receive and embrace with all Sincerity according to the Merit which to my Understanding shall appear in them Thus far I have gone out of my ordinary Way of making Strictures upon our Authors Pages that I might make the more full Answer to this grand Argument of Antiquity and Universality offered on behalf of the Souls Immateriality Pag. 105. Says One Man is of more worth than all the Inferior Creatures This I do not grant Pag. 106. His Discourse here imports That there is no means of a Future State but by the Souls Immortality an Error which hath generally misled the World before him Pag. 107. I say to this The Resurrection will satisfie Mens Desires of Immortality if they be rightly Grounded Pag. 108. To it I say The return of Souls into Bodies once Dead seems the re-kindling of the Flame of Life by an Act of Divine Power He confesses That when Bodies have been restored to Life in this World as he here cites divers that there was no Sense or Apprehension in such Souls returned of the place or state they were in during their Separation but that there is a perfect forgetfulness of all that they saw and felt in a State of Separation He gives a Reason for this both Foreign to the purpose and weak but to me this seems a very likely Proof that in such their Separation they neither saw nor felt any thing at all but that rather they were in Death Extinguishable and in Life again re-kindled From hence to Page 117. is all answered by the Resurrection Pag. 117. He says He cannot But I suppose he will not imagine how there can be a Resurrection without a Soul once Separated entering into the same Body that died I say one shall be as much the same as the other shall be 1 Cor. 15.37 As Wheat growing out of Wheat sown so shall the Body be with a Flame of Life kindled in it sutable to its Powers and to that Flame which before was born with it He says If it be so the Sins of the Old Man cannot be put to the New Mans Account I say they may justly be so and the rising Person is so much the same with the dying Person as to be accountable for his Actions viz. effectually the same Body Members Flame of Life Senses Affections Phancy Understanding Memory and Judgment and shall so awake and rise as if he had fallen asleep but a few hours before And his Supposition is but the proper Effect of his own mistaken Doctrine concerning the Creation of Souls for if that were true and the Old Soul did not subsist Separately there must be another viz. a New One be Created but my sort of Soul requires no such thing Pag. 119. Says There are Acts performed by the Soul whilst it is in the Body in which it makes no use at all of the Body He instances in Self-Intuition and Self-Reflection I say These Acts cannot be done without the Brain Phancy and Memory and for Raptures they are but Impressions upon and Revelations unto the common Sense Understanding or Phancy recorded upon the Memory Also that Phancy may be Transported to things without the Body and the limits of Reason yet act by the assistance of proper Organs without which the Soul cannot act any thing Life it self cannot be acted but by the Vital Organs and yet without Life there can be no Apprehension Self-Intuition or Reflection but all Mens Thoughts perish Pag 189. Cites Heb. 12.29 We are come to Angels and to God the Judge of all and to the Spirits of just Men made perfect and to Jesus the Mediator He bids us note these Words They are not says he shall come after the Resurrection or General Judgment I say not after our Deaths but intends we are come to them in Faith and Expectation to a Doctrine which declares such things to us and which we may believe and expect as surely as if we were now in the Possession of them but not a word of coming to them presently after our Deaths as he not only endeavours to Insinuate but expresly affirms And Pag. 192. He says These Enjoyments will not be deferred till the Resurrection but
Calamos cera conjungere plures instituit Lastly I have chosen the Organ as that Instrument whereunto Mankind may most sutably be compared and from hence shall begin to make general Observations upon these Instruments and Creatures comparando As the Whistle and Horn have no great Variety in their Sounds so have the Insects but something analogous in them to them to Flame and Blood and therefore may rather be counted Animata than Animalie and we shall but little insist upon them but chuse to observe rather upon our Third Instrument the Penny Pipe which can make a Variety of Sounds by several Stops upon it First it appears that this as all our other Instruments this and they all are acted and made sounding by one same Actor or Principle viz. Breath or Wind inspiring them And I say the like of the small Animals compared to it viz. Mice Moles c. we say that they as all other Animals are framed and acted after a similar Manner and as the rest of the greater Animals are and as Man their Supream also is for each of these small Animals have Skin Bone Flesh Blood Sinews Nerves Muscles Joints Heart Brain and Breath as well as the Horse or the Elephant or even as Man himself and act their Five Senses and Vital Faculties as other Animals do and have a Flame of Life or Glowing in their Flood which makes it Circulate Active and Moving as is done in other more large and potent Animals in a Proportion and Nature sutable to their beings The thing is all of a hind in them all as the Wind and Breath in the Musical Instruments the Wind in them doth not make a like Sound or Musick in them all but according to the structure and capacity of every one of them Now give a Penny Pipe into the best Artists hand and who hath a very good Breath yet he shall be able to make but very mean Musick with it sutable to the mean capacity of the Instrument and this is the Case of the Mouse or the Mole amongst Animals though they in their Structure Parts and Spirits are of the same Nature with the greater Animals yet such Spirit and Flame can do no more in those small and weak Bodies than the Capacities and Organs of them will extend unto and those Degrees of Power proportionate to its own Strength Nature and Constitution And so it is in every Degree of Animals one above another the Flame or Material Spirit of Life works in each of them proportionably to act and perform such things and in such manner as the Structure of their Bodies and the Figure Power and Order of their Members make them able and inclinable to act and gives them a Power to execute And just as in the Wind Instruments one sort of Spirit acts them all and one sort of Materials viz Hard Materials Wood or Metâ—al make the Body or gross and palpable parts of them and yet there is that vast Variety in the Musick and Sounds of them as if they were not at all of kin one of them to the other but rather as if they were quite different things in their Nature which plainly they are not for the Matter and Spirit in them all are alike It is true they are different Instruments and make very different Sounds and Sort of Musick And it seems the Case is the same amongst Animals Matter and Spirit are of like Nature in them all Man himself though Sanctius his Animal Mentisque capacius altae his Genus is the same with theirs he is Animal let the differentia be what it will Rationale or Religiosum Man is of the same Kind with the other Animals and is compared by David to the Beasts that perish utterly and so should Man have done unless God had promised and appointed a Resurrection for him and a Judgment upon him But all our Maintainers of the Immateriality exclaim and declaim upon the transcendent advantages which Men have over and beyond the Beasts in the Power and Activity of their Rational Faculty which mistakingly and yet generally they call the Soul of Man and seem so to esteem and think of it but to me it seems there is not a greater difference in Nature or Power betwixt Men and Beasts then in Musick there is between the Organ and the inferiour Instruments from the Trompet to the Penny Pipe or Whistle There is as great a transcendency in the Organ over or and above each of the other Instruments in the Musical Use of them as there is in Men over and above Beasts in the several Kinds of them These Machines viz. the Organ and the Man the one amongst Wind Instruments and the other amongst Animals must evidently be accounted for Superlative and Supream with whom none of the Inferiour Animals or Instruments can hold a reasonable Comparison but Ocularly visible it is that the Organ hath no other Spirit or Cause of its Sound Musick and Harmony but the same that acts in all the Inferiour Instruments And semblably it seems that although Man be a Superlative and Supream Animal yet he may be and is acted by a like Flame or Spirit as we agree doth actuate and enliven the other Animals of an Inferiour Nature or Degree inabling for Acts of Life and Vegetation Nourishment Digestion and Generation stirring their Affections of Lust Wrath and Fear Moving and acting their Five Senses to perceive their several Objects And all these and their Local Motions are as vigorous and perfectly acted in Beasts as in Men and this sort of Soul acts also in Brutes an Understanding Phancy Judgment and Memory true in their Kind but to a very low Degree in comparison with Faculties of those Kinds found amongst Men for that the Humane Head and Organs there placed are far more advantageously framed and fitted for such purposes And thus it seems there is set forth and shewed an apparent and pregnant likeness or similitude between the Correspondence which the Organ hath with the Inferiour Wind Instruments and that which Man hath with the Inferiour Animals And that this Comparison or Similitude may be helpfully used towards the Discovery of the Nature and Operations of an Humane Soul and some farther Assimilations may be made of Man to an Organ viz. First That as in an Organ the Wind cannot command or alter the Sound of any of the Pipes so as to make the Treble Mean Tenor or Bases sound otherwise than that Artist who made them intended them for So it is in Man his Spirit or Soul cannot act any of his Senses or Faculties to other then those very purposes for which the Divine Artificer made and intended them it cannot make the Hand see nor the Foot hear the Shoulders understand nor the Buttocks digest but it can only act every Part Member and Organ to those purposes intended by him that made them Secondly As when any of the Pipes in an Organ are ill made cracked or otherwise harmed the Wind cannot