sinner but that the wicked turne from his way and liue they turne from their euill waies and returne to God by a true amendment of life and so be saued I should want time if I would make a catalogue of all the benefits that Christians obtaine by the reading of the holy Scriptures If some haue thence taken occasion to sowe and disperse their heresies If others haue made a rampier or fortresse a retraite and place of refuge for their sinnes it hath beene their fault the ficklenes and inconstancie of their braine their ambition and the malice of their harts not the fault of the Scripture And yet they for the most part yea almost al haue been of the learned sort and not ignorant and simple e Alphons de Castro lib. 1. â—eraetic cap. 13. Pauci fuerunt idiotae heraesiuâ— authores of whom few haue been authors of heresies but how many thousand millions haue been instructed in the true faith reformed and saued by the reading of the Scripture By them f Matth. 4.4 Christ refuted the diuell and made him fire thence the Church hath alwaies tooken stones with the which she hath stoned the heretickes that indeuoured to defend themselues by the same Scriptures the abuse of the wicked not hauing the power to hinder the vniuersalitie of the Church from vsing them aright for if that we ought to abstaine from good things for the scandall of the wicked Christ ought not to haue preached because the people said g Iohn 8.48 he had the diuell and were often scandalised and offended at his words and the Gospell should not be preached because h 2. Cor. 2.16 it is the sauour of death vnto death to them that perish and to speake of humane things we should forbid men the vse of wine because it is the drinke of many drunkards CHAP. III. I. The Scripture is perspicuous and plaine to be read of all II. How we ought to vnderstand that there are obscure and difficult things in the Scripture III. The perspicuitie and plainenesse of the Scripture prooâ—ed by the Fathers IIII. An answer to the first allegoricall obiection taken from the Scriptures V. Answere to the second allegoricall obiection taken out of the same Scriptures VI. Answere to the words of Saint Hierom alleaged against the reading of the Scriptures VII All ought to reade the Scriptures according to Saint Hierome VIII Which is proued by reason BVt the a Bell de verbo Dei lib. 2 cap. 15. 16. lib. 3. cap. 1. Scriptures are so obscure that the vnlearned lay-men cannot â—â—â—erstand them O impietie that Christ who is the b Malacb 4.2 Sun of Iustice and c Iohn 8.12 the light of the world should be accused either of ignorance for that he could not speak plainely or of malice in that he would not speake so and that the witnesse which he hath giuen to his word calling that of the old Testament d Psal 119.105 a lampe vnto our feete and a light vnto our paths e 2. Pet. 1.19 and a light that shiueth in a darke place and that of the new Testament the light of the Church f 2 Cor. 4.3.4 which is not hid but to them that are lost in whom the god of this world hath blinded the mindes of them which beleeue not lest the light of the glorious Gospell of Christ should shine vnto them that so the Sonne of God should bee made so weake and vnable and be so belied by the calumnies of men O intolerable blasphemy II. Notwithstanding it is true that there are some very difficult things and deepe points in the Scripture to vnderstand as the mysterie of the Trinitie Christs Incarnation the Resurrection of the flesh the last Iudgement to come but the words by which these points are described in the holy Scripture are as plaine and perspicuous as the Sunne all the obscuritie and darkenesse is in men of whom they that are g Ephes 5.8 without Christ are nothing but darkenesse h 1. Cor. 2.14 receiue not and perceiue not the things of the Spirit of God neither can they know them because they are spiritually discerned They that are in Christ i Ephes 5.8 are light in the Lord and therefore doe comprehend and apprehend them according to the measure of the enlightning some more some lesse all but in part witnesse the Apostle writing of himself and of all like him k 1. Cor. 13.9 We know in part and we prophecie in part and notwithstanding all sufficiently to saluation III. l In Mat. cap. 4. contra Celsum The Scriptures saith Origen are the fountaine of Iacob The learned drinke as Iacob and his children and the simple and ignorant also as the cattell of Iacob m Gegor 1. They are saith another a riuer wherein an Elephant may swimme and a Lamb may wade ouer A third saith n Isidorus lib. 1. de summo bono cap. 〈…〉 That the Scripture is like Manna common to the perfect ones and to the young ones and doth accommodat her selfe to euery one according to the capacitie of euery ones vnderstanding and iudgement o Fâ—â—â—gent Serm. de confess A fourth compares it vnto a rich banquet wherein are meats for all ages milke for the sustenance of babes and strong meate for them that are of full age and so speake all the Fathers Seeing therefore that all are called to the reading of the Scriptures as to a great feast where the rich man hath prepared meates for all ages surely they that would exclude them and depriue them thereof are mortall enemies of Gods glory and of mans saluation vnto whom will sort well the sentence of execration pronounced by Dauid and Paul but badly applied by the Author of the Pastorall letter p Psal 69.23.24 Rom. 11.9.10 Let their Table become a snare before them and that which should haue been for their welfare let it become a trap let their eyes be darkened that they see not and make their loynes continually to shake Or rather we may apply that vow vnto them that is to say the curse denounced by our Sauiour Iesus Christ against their Grand-fathers for the like matter q Mat. 23.13 Woe vnto you Scribes and Pharisees hypocrites for ye shut vp the Kingdome of heauen against men for ye neither go in your selues neither suffer yee them that are entring to goe in IIII. The Pastorall letter produces Pag. 4. and brings forth allegories against all this not hauing learnt of r Thomas in sum part 1. quaest 1. artic 10 Omnes sensus fundantur super vnum scilicet literaleÌ„ ex quo solo potest traâ—i argumentum non autem ex his quae secundum allegoriam dicuntur Thomas who learned of S. Austin that arguments are onely drawne from the literall sense and not from that which is said by allegorie It presupposeth that which is true That we must reade the Scriptures
in this Citie of Bourdeaux Two Virgins daughters of an honourable Citizen of the Romish religion withdrew themselues from the obedience of their father and mother to follow a Religion of a new stampe and edition called Of the Vrselines This fact being found strange of many learned men and others of the said Religion Cardinall Sourdis took vpon him to defend it by writing and I was requested to vndertake the refutation thereof which I not being able to refuse to those that requested of mee this piece of seruice I tooke in hand this worke some fourteene monethes agoe But I perceiued by the prosecution and sequell of this worke that I should labour in vaine if I refuted not in order all the principall arguments which the Church of Rome doth alleage in fauour and defence of the Monkish life which I haue done according to the method I haue here summarily and briefly set downe beginning first with the holy Scriptures because the author of the Pastorall letter begins with that point My discourse shall bee truth the fountaine thereof shall be charity the end thereof shall be the glory of God the edificatioÌ„ of his Church the conuersion of those that walke in darknesse and in the shadow of death to the true light and the discharge of my conscience before God and my Church to the which I would giue an account of my studies if she receiue any edification thereby I shall remaine fully satisfied THE SVMME OF THIS FIRST VOLUME THE FIRST BOOKE Of thâ— holy Scripture Chap. 1. Of the necessity and sufficiencie of the Scriptures Chap. 2. All men ought to reade the Scriptures Chap. 3. The Scriptures are perspicuous and plaine to bee read of all men Chap. 4. They are to be read with the same spirit wherewith they were written Chap. 5. 6. 7. What is the authority of the Fathers in the interpreting of the Scriptures Chap. 8. Of the Iudge of the sense and meaning of the Scriptures THE SECOND BOOKE Of Euangelicall Counsels Chap. 1. The holy Scripture makes no mention of Counsels which they terme Euangelicall Chap. 2. They are neither of the Law nor of the Gospell The difference betweene the Law and the Gospell Chap. 3. They are falsly termed Counsels of Perfection There is no other perfection then charity which is commanded to all men Chap. 4. The Monkes and Friers doe speake in vaine of keeping Counsels seeing there is no man liuing can keepe the Commandements Not the vnregenerate man that wants all the conditions required to the doing of a good worke Chap. 5. Nor the regenerate man who is imperfect and defectiue in his most holy actions Chap. 6. Which is proued by the examples of the holy men of the old Testament Chap. 7. And by them of the new Testament Chap. 8. Whence all their sinnes are mortall in their nature though veniall by grace Chap. 9. An answere to the two first obiections concerning that God doth promise to circumcise our hearts that wee should loue him with all our heart and the testimony giuen to many that they haue kept the Law and loued God with all their heart Chap. 10. An answere to the third obiection touching those that are called perfect Chap. 11. An answere to the fourth obiection accusing God of crueltie if he haue giuen an impossible Law How and to whom the Law is possible and impossible Chap. 12. Answere to the fifth obiection that Gods commandements are not grieuous Answere to the sixth obiection whosoeuer is borne of God sinneth not Chap. 13. An answere to the 7. obiectioÌ„ that all Gods workes are perfect An answere to the 8. obiection that we must not do good works if they be sins we must doe good workes and for what cause Chap. 14. Foure reasons why God doth not perfect our regeneration in this life Chap. 15. An answere to the 56. chapter of Isaias and to the 3. chapter of the booke of Wisdome where mention is made of Eunuches Chap. 16. An answere to an obiection drawne from the parable of the sower and the seede bringing forth an hundreth threescore thirtie fold and to that which the Lord saith of those which haue made themselues Eunuches for the kingdome of heauens sake Chap. 17. An exposition of Christs words Goe and sell all that thou hast Chap. 18. An answere to the obiection taken out of 1. Cor. 7. Chap. 19. An answere to that which the Apostle saith He hath preached freely 1. Cor. 9. Also to that which is in the Reuelation chap. 14. concerning the 144000 Virgins Chap. 20. Answere to the example of those that haue liued in the state of Virginitie The end of the Contents AD MONACHOS Admonitio HIc discipatis nubibus Sol enitet Non iste lucem corpori qui sufficit Sed qui tenebras mentis illico fugat Hic scena fraudum tota hic mysteria Reclusa fictae sanctimoniae patent Deuota turba belluae teterrimae Quae vaticani montis incubat iugo Exosa coelo orbigranis grata inferis Procul hinc facesse Nam tibi certissima Mors hic paratur Ista si perlegeris Dâ—lâ—re victa non potes non emori IACOBS VOW OPPOSED TO THE VOWES OF MONKES AND FRIERS THE FIRST BOOKE CHAP. I. Of the holy Scriptures I. We cannot learne what seruice is acceptable vnto God but of God himselfe II. God teacheth it vs within by his holy Spirit and without by his holy Word III. The whole Word of God necessarie and sufficient vnto saluation is comprehended in the holy Scriptures WHat a Iob 36.22 teacher is like God said Elihu in his conference with Iob the same say we here where the question is betweene vs of Gods seruice of that seruice which he approues and to the which hee hath annexed a gratious promise of ample remuneration who then can better tell vs what he is then he himselfe Both we and they seeke for eternall life and desire to finde the way that leades vs vnto it it is God that hath giuen it vs who then shal shew vs the way of life but God Our b Col. 3.3.4 life is hid with Christ in God yea Christ is our life and c John 14.6 10 7. as hee is our life so is he the way of life the doore by the which the sheepe doe enter and there is none other then he d Heb. 10.20 that hath consecrated for vs a new and liuing way through the vaile that is to say his flesh As he hath consecrated it so hath he shewed it vnto vs by his truth e Iohn 17.17 His word is his truth and he himselfe is that truth f Iohn 14.6 I am saith he the way the truth and the life no man commeth vnto the Father but by me * August in Joan tract 22. Ambulare vis ego sum via falli non vis ego sum veritas mori non vis ego sum vita hoc dicit saluator tuus non est quò cas nisi
The Emperour of heauen the Lord of Men and of Angels hath sent his Patent to saue thy life and notwithstanding honoured sonne thou makest no account to reade it with diligence studie therefore I pray thee and meditate daily the words of thy Creator learne to know Gods heart by Gods words that you may the more earnestly sigh after heauenly and eternal things that your vnderstanding may be inflamed with a greater desire of the heauenly Kingdome c. This is according to that that the Apostle exhorts the Colossians vnto f Col. 3.16 Let the word of Christ dwell in you richly in all wisedome and that said he g Espencaeus comment in Tit. ca. 2. to all the faithfull vnto whom he wrote exhorting them to ' haue h Hieron in Col. 3.16 not onely sufficiently but also plentifully the knowledge of the Scriptures and to this ende i Chrysost in Col. 3.16 Occum ibidem to reade them not sleightly and negligently but with great diligence Hence we conclude that the Scriptures were indifferently read of all before Christs time in Christs time and in the dayes of the Apostles wee could proue the same in the time of the ancient and Primitiue Church many ages after the Apostles by the proofes and euidences of the sentences of the Fathers who did exhort the Secular the Lay-people as they cal them al men and women to buy the Bible to reade the holy Scriptures and complaine of them and blame them for that they did not reade them And surely with good reason for it is not of holy writers as of a Plato or an Aristotle these haue written but to a few persons those haue k Espencaeus commint in 2. Tim. cap. 3. Non scripser unt pane is sed vninersâ— populâ— written to the whole multitude to all ages l 1. Iohn 2.1 12 13 14. to young babes to little children to young men to fathers vnto all whom Saint Iohn writes VVhat are wee not men like them Christians like them Gods children like them guided and gouerned by the holy Ghost that is to say true Christians as well as they why therfore may not we reade the Scriptures as well as they IIII. For feare say they m Bellar. deverbo Dei lib. 2. cap. 15. § 28. Quid. lest in stead of profiting wee receiue hurt and dammage for we should easily take occasion of erring both in regard of the doctrine of faith as also in regard of the rule of life and manners all heresies being sprung vp from the Scripture not wel vnderstood for if the rude ignorant people should reade or heare read in the vulgar tongue of Dauids adultery Thamars incest Iudiths lie either he would contemne and despise the holy Patriarchs or els he would imitate their vices O blasphemy God hath said that n Iohn 20.31 faith is conceiued and engendred by the Scriptures and men say that heresies are engendred by them God hath said that o Iohn 5.39 in them and by them we haue life eternall and men say that by them wee haue eternall death God saith that p Rom. 15.4 they haue been giuen vs to teach vs and to comfort vs and men say that they serue to peruert and destroy vs God saith that q Deut. 31.13 by them we may learne to feare him and men say that by them wee learne to offend him God saith r Psalm 119.9 a young man shall cleanse his way by taking heede thereto according to Gods word and men say that if hee take heede to the Scriptures they will misleade and peruert him and make him to become incestuous an adulterer a drunkard yea that he is danger to beleeue nothing and to become an Atheist God saith that Å¿ 1. Cor. 15.33 euill communications and speeches corrupt good manners and men say that good words the words of God the words of the euerlasting God t Psalm 12.6 that are pure words as siluer tried in a furnace of earth purified seuen times withdrawes men from godlinesse and drawes them to vice And that is the reason why they instruct their children in the knowledge of euill discourses of men reade vnto them a Martial a Catullus the incests fornications contentions and all the fables of the false Gods of whom God hath said u Exod. 23.13 You shall make no mention of the names of other Gods neither let it be heard out of thy mouth And Dauid accordingly to that x Psal 16.4 I will not take vp their names into my lipps On the other side they forbid them to reade the words of God vnto the which God himselfe hath giuen this testimonie and witnesse declaring that y Psal 1.2 Blessed is that man whose delight is in the Law of the Lord and meditates in his Law day and night And concerning that part of the Scripture which is the most obscurest he saith z Reuel 1.3 Blessed is he that readeth and they that heare the words of this prophecie and keepe those things that are written therein It is not the Scripture but the ignorance of the Scripture that breedes heresies a Hieron in Mat. 22.29 as Christ saith to the Saddâ—ces great hereticks yee doe erre not knowing the Scriptures nor the power of God And Saint Chrysostome b Chrysost in praesat ad epist ad Rom. conformably to this truth of God saith Innumerable mischiefes are sprung vp from the ignorance of Scriptures thence commeth the great plague of heresies thence the dissolute life thence vnprofitable toyle and labour for euen as those that are depriued of this light cannot goe aright so they that haue no regard vnto the reasons of diuine Scriptures are compelled to fall immedâ—atly many waies like them that walke in palpable darkenesse There the ignorant shall finde what to learne the man of little faith wherewith to stirre vp himselfe to vertue the sinner wherewith to call him to repentance the theeues shall finde there the examples of Gods iudgements executed against Achan the fornicators affrighted by the example of the Israelites they which couer bad things will learne there to mortifie their flesh they see there the sinnes of holy men that they may know that all haue sinned and that they haue been saued by the mercies of God in Christ Iesus and therefore doe not trust in and to their owne merits by pride but humbly seeke their whole saluation through the all perfect merit of Christ Iesus In a word the greatest sinners shall see there Dauid a murtherer and an adulterer repenting of his sin and entreating pardon of the same the sinful woman weeping and obtaining mercy the thiefe on the crosse crying to Christ for grace Christ answering him c â—â—ke 23.43 Verily I say vnto thee today shalt thou be with me in Paradise that so they being instructed and taught by these examples that the d Ezeâ—h 33 1â— Lord takes no pleasure in the death of a
complaines of those that reade and speake of them Let them defend them and forbid them with threatnings I will not feare what man can doe to me but knowing that the word of God is of such vertue n Psal 119.130 that the entrance of his words giueth light and giueth vnderstanding vnto the simple I will loue it I will put it close to my heart I will take in it all my delight and pastime his words shall be folkes of my counsell I will alwaies adhere and sticke fast vnto them that I may say in good conscience vnto my God with Dauid o Psal 119.97 O how loue I thy Law it is my meditation all the day CHAP. IIII. I. The Scripture is to be read with the same Spirit wherewith it was written II. The proofes which the Pastorall Letter alleageth are nothing to the purpose III. The Philosophers iustly blamed by Saint Hierome for that they did frame and apply the places of Scripture vnto their sense and opinions IIII. This blame pertaines and belongs vnto the Author of the Pastorall Letter V. Two true reasons why the Scriptures cannot be vnderstood but by the same Spirit they haue been indicted with VI. The Spirit of God is in the Church in generall and in euery member of the same according to the measure of the gift and grace of Christ. SAint Peter speaking of the writings of the Prophets saith that the a 2. Pet. 1.21 prophesie came not in old time by the will of man but holy 〈◊〉 of God spake as they were moued by the holy Ghost Out of these words of Saint Peter the Author of the Pastorall Letter inferres that we must reade the Scriptures with the same spirit that they were written by which is the Spirit of charitie a pure Spirit a cleane Spirit we adde to this that b Iohn 15.16 he is the Spirit of truth and so we say Amen to this doctrine II. But not to the proofes thereof that are allegoricall or false or corrupted and peruerted That which is said of the commandement giuen vnto him that preacheth the Gospell that he should gâ—â— vp to the mountaine of vertue is allegoricall and repugning to the sense of the Scriptures In like manner that which is added that no beast way approch vnto this mountaine that is to say no carnall sense or meaning and that haue we seene in the Chapter going before The second proofe taken from c Genes 6.3 that of Genesis is false God saith there My Spirit shall not alwaies striue with man for that he is also flesh and the meaning is that God will no longer beare with the malice of men because they are nothing but flesh that is to say finne and corruption but hee will destroy them from the face of the earth if they repent not in the space of an hundred and twentie yeeres Here is therefore no question of the abode of Gods Spirit in men but of the strife that God hath with men obstinatly hardned and not harkning vnto his admonitions but taking occasion by his blessings to liue according to the flesh The third proofe is mained and defectiue Saint Paul saith that d Rom. 15.4 Whatsoeuer things were written aforetime were written for our learning that we through patience and comfort of the Scriptures might haue hope In the Pastorall Letter these words are thus changed Pag. 6. cut off and falsified The whole Scripture is giuen of God for our instruction that so by the example that we imbrace in seeing the recompence of the verâ—â—ous and the punishment of the wicked we comfort our selues in hope to attaine vnto the inestimable goods that are promised there So that whole comfort of the Scriptures is falsely referred and applied to the example that we take of the recompence of the good and the punishment of the wicked whereas it doth altogether consist in the death and passion of Christ Iesus in whose blood al those good men e Reuel 7.14 haue washed their long robes hauing all of them been iustified and graciously saued by the blood of him on the crosse and not by the merit of any vertue that was in them Whence the Lord is called f Luke 25. the Consolation of Israel namely of all the Saints the peace comfort and ioy of whom is wholy limited and stinted in him and to the witnesse that Gods Spirit beareth to their spirit and consciences by the holy Scriptures that God hath reconciled them to himselfe in him not imputing to them their sins where with ioy they crie out with the Prophet Dauid a man according to Gods heart g Psalm 32.1.2 Blessed is hee whose transgression is forgiuen whose sinne is couered Blessed is the man vnto whom the Lord imputeth not iniquitie But not being of a subiect and matter to examine this place any more I doe approue the conclusion that is drawne from hence for seeing the Scripture hath been giuen vs for our instruction and consolation we ought not alter it or diuert it to our destruction III. Neither ought we to imitate those of whom Saint Ierome complaines h Hieron that comming to the holy Scriptures after the studie of the Sciences of this world doe imagine that all that they say is the Word and Law of God and take not the paines to search and examine diligently what the Prophets and Apostles haue said but doe frame vnto their sense the places of Scriptures which haue no resemblance agreement or relation vnto it being like the Israelites in this who made a golden Calfe of the treasures they brought out of Egypt whereas they that vse holily humane Sciences making them serue and attend on Diuinitie are like those that did imploy the iewels and riches of the Egyptians towards the building of the Tabernacle and entertainement of Gods seruice IIII. But when they say Pag. 7. that parents which binde their children to the obedience of the commandement they giue them to stay with them to serue them and not to enter into such or such a cloister are like those first that they doe subuert all order imagine they ought to preferre their commandement before Gods commandement their wills before the Euangelicall Counsels against the expresse Texts of the Gospell the example of Saints the interpretations of all the Fathers and the decisions of the holy Canons They charge them with a false blasphemie wherewith the Author of the Pastorall Letter shall finde himselfe touched and tainted who takes violently by the haires as we say the places of Scripture and the interpretations of the Fathers and frames them after his owne imagination wherewith they haue no resemblance or relation as we shall see in the Chapters following V. Notwithstanding this remaines as true that the same Spirit which hath indicted the Scriptures and giuen it to bee written ought and doth vnfold and giue vs the sense and meaning thereof The reason is in them or in vs In them their
6.44.45 man can come to me except the Father which hath sent me draw him It is written in the Prophets And they shall be all taught of God euery one therefore that hath heard and hath learned of the Father commeth vnto me They that thus heare and learne thus of the Father doe not stand to their owne sense nor are not wedded to their owne humours but are directed by the holy Spirit to the sense and meaning of the Scripture as much as is necessarie for them that they suffer themselues not to be distracted and with-drawne from the saluation which is in our Lord Iesus by the deceit of men II. The Pastoral Letter vnderstands not so the words of Micah and acknowledgeth none to be the mountaine of Sion Pag. 7. but the ancient Fathers and those of these times Pastors and Doctors there is difference saith he betweene one heretick and another which interprets the Scripture according to his sense the one with more the other with lesse obstinacie and wilfulnesse but both of them are alike in error To be like an hereticke is to make himselfe like the diuell and to beare his image This is his argument they are hereticks which do interpret the Scripture according to their owne sense wee ought not to resemble hereticks wee ought not therefore and must not interpret the Scripture according to our senses The Canon Law defineth an heretick thus g 24. q. 3. Can. 27. Haeresis quicunque aliter scripturam intelligit quà m sensus spirituâ— sancti flâ—gitat quo scripta est licet de ecclesia non recesserit tamen haereticus appellari potest Whosoeuer vnderstandeth the Scripture otherwise then the sense of the holy Spirit by the which it hath been written requireth although he hath not with-drawne himselfe from the Church he may be cald an hereticke is to be vnderstood if he be obstinate and being conuicted of error by the truth will not leaue his error to embrace the truth h 24 q. 3. can dixit For they which maintain and defend their false and peruerse opinion without any stubbornes and obstinacy being ready willing to be corrected are not to be reckoned amongst hereticks but i 24. q. 3. can 31. Qui in ecclesia they which being in the Church of Christ haue any contagious and peruerse opinion if being reproued of it that they may knâ—w and acknowledge that which is sound and right they resist with stubbornnesse and contumacie and will not reforme and correct their pâ—stilent and mortall opinions and doctrines but persist to defend and maintaine them they become heretickes And if we will know who are they which haue a bad and peruerse opinion and doctrine Leo the first will tell vs that k 〈◊〉 epist 10. ad FlauianuÌ„ est 24. q. 3. can 30. quid autem those fall into this furie and madnesse who being hindred by some obscurenes and darkenes to know the truth haue not their recourse to the voice of the Prophets to the Epistles of the Apostles and to the authorities of the Gospell but to themselues and therefore are masters of errors not hauing been disciples of truth All these conditions being put and laid together hee is an hereticke who despising all admonitions doth maintaine obstinatly an error contrary to the doctrine of the Prophets and Apostles contained in the holy Scriptures Of such a one the Apostle faith l Tit. 3.10.11 A man that it an herericke after the first and second admonition reiect knowing that he that is such is subuerted and sinneth being condemned of himselfe I desire the Reader to marke and remember this definition to the ende he may iudge by the same of the truth and false-hood of the matters debated in our writings and finde and hold for an hereticke the one of vs who being an Idolater of his owne sense and opinion defends with obstinacie a sense contrary to the holy Scripture For as Tertullian saith m Tert. de praes aduers haeret cap. 38. Inde scripturarum expositionum adâ—lteratio deputanda est vbi diuersitas inuenitur doctrinae There is the corruption of the Scriptures and of Expositions where the diuersitie of doctrine is found and else where The n Ibidem ca. â—2 Hereticorum doctrina cum Apostolica comparant ex diuersitate contrarietate sua pronunciabit neque Apostoli alicuius authoris esse neque Apostolici doctrine of heretickes compared with that of the Apostles will pronounce by her difference and contrarietie that she hath not for her author any Apostle or any Apostolick person The Pastorall Letter will not haue nor permit vs to make this comparison of the writings of men with those of the Apostles but binds vs to depend altogether on that which the holy Fathers and our spirituall Fathers which haue lawfull succession will tell vs and reach vs. III. Pag. 7. The Christian saith the Letter ought per omnia assimilari Christo in all things be made like vnto Christ who for our example said in Saint Iohn o Iohn 7.16 Mea doctrina non est mea sed eius qui misit me My doctrine is not mine but his that sent me In another place p Iohn 15.15 Omnia quaecunque audiui à patre nota feci vobis Al things that I haue heard of my Father I haue made knowne vnto you euen so you ought not to speake of the Scriptures but sicut audiui à patre as the holy Fathers doe expound This reason may be reduced to this forme The Christians ought to be like vnto Christ in all things but Christ hath said nothing but that which he hath heard of his Father therfore we ought not to say any thing of the Scripture but that we haue heard of our fathers or as they expound it Who seeth not that here are foure termes as Schoolemen speake and that the conclusion sayes more then the premise doe afforde let vs make a new this Syllogisme All Christians ought to be like vnto Christ in all things but Christ hath said nothing hath done nothing but that which his Father hath told him and commaunded him the maiden daughters therefore of whom the question is ought to say nothing to doe nothing but that which their father hath told them and commanded and consequently they ought not nor may not enter into the new religion and religious House or Cloister of Saint Vrsula the Virgin because their father hath told them and commaunded them not to doe it Let vs make it of another fashion All Christians must be like vnto Christ in all things but Christ hath spoken of all those things which he hath heard of his Father who is God the true One and holy One Therefore we must hold all that we haue heard of our Fathers of whom he most holy is but man and not God is a sinner q 1. King 8.46 for there is no man that sinneth not and a lyer
as it is written r Rom. 3.4 Let God bee true but euery man a lyer We see therefore that the word father is taken ambiguously by the Author of the Pastorall Letter and that from this ambiguitie a thousand impertinent false blasphemous conclusions might be inferred Moreouer the proposition is false if it bee not limited for can we be God like Christ Can we be Prophets Priests and Kings of the Church as Christ is In a word can wee bee mediatour betweene God and man as Christ is what are not these things proper to Christ and vncommunicable to all creatures IIII. The resemblance likenes which we must haue with Christ is in the holinesse of his life in that which concernes his godlinesse towards god and his charitie towards men according to the Law Å¿ Ephes 4.24 Col. 3.10 The new man which is renewed in knowledge righteousnesse and true holinesse after the image of him that created him The argument then will be good in this sort if we say that euen as Christ hath been so conscientious so scrupulous and holy in his vocation that hee hath not taught any thing but that which he hath heard of God his Father so our Pastors and Doctors ought not to teach any thing but that which they haue heard of God their Father that is to say that which is contained in the holy Scriptures And againe as Christ although authorised in his doctrine by that heauenly voice t Matth. 17.5 Heare him submits his doctrine to the touch-stone of the Scriptures and exhorts the people to examine it by the Scripture saying u Iohn 5.39 Search the Scriptures they are they which testifie of me Our Teachers and Doctors which haue not such an authoritie and should resemble Christ in humilitie and reuerence towards the Scripture ought and must submit their doctrine to the like examination and exhort the people to search the Scriptures to see and examine if it be so And if the people ought not to heare any other doctrine then that of their Father contained in Scripture remembring that notable sentence of Saint Augustine x August contra lit Petilia lib. 3. c. 6. Si angelus de caelo vobis annunciauerit preteâ—quâ—â— quod in Sâ—xipturiâ— legalibus Euangelicis accepisti anathema sit If an Angell from heauen preach vnto you otherwise then that which you haue receiued in the Scriptures Legal or Euangelicall let him be accursed V. Let vs now retort and returne the argument against the Author of the same and say VVe may not speake of the Scripture otherwise then we haue heard of our Fathers we haue no other Father then God therefore we may not speake of the Scripture then as we haue heard it of God the Maior is his as we haue seene the Minor is his also For by this argument hee proues that children desirous to dwell in a cloyster ought not to obey their carnall parents which thwart their desires saying to the fathers Know yee not Pag. 20. that God forbids in Saint Matthew y Matth. 23 9. Nolite vobis vocare patrem super terram vnus enim pater est vester qui est in caelis Call no man your Father vpon the earth for one is your father which is in heauen The conclusion therefore is good according to his arguing and according to truth and therefore we wil heare none but God speaking to vs in the Scripture and will not heare the Fathers be they neuer so holy if they preach not to vs the word of God contained in the Scriptures VI. For so hath God expressely commanded vs in his word saying z Ezech. 20.18.19 Walke ye not in the statutes of your fathers neither obserue their iudgements nor defile your selues with their Idols I am the Lord your God walke in my Statutes and keepe my Iudgements and doe them Conformably to this an ancient Father saith a Hier. in Ier. cap. 7. nec parentum nec maiâ—rum error sequendus est sed authoritas scripturarum c. We must not follow the errors of our fathers nor of our ancestors but we must follow the authoritie of the Scriptures And another b Bernard ad Abbat epist 91. Auant and farre from me and you let them be which say we will not be better then our forefathers The former saith againe of himselfe c Hier. contra Iouini As often as I do not interpret the Scriptures but that I speake freely of mine owne sense and reason let who will reprehend and reproue me Saint Austin said as much of Saint Hierome of all Catholike authors and particularly of himselfe as we haue seene in the Preface he tells vs ouer and besides of himselfe d August de Trinit lib. 3. in proaem Doe not thou subiect and submit thy selfe to my letters as to the Canonicall Scripture Of Saint Cyprian e Idem contra Crescou lib. 2. cap. 32. I account not the letters of Cyprian as Canonicall but I examine them by the Canonicall Scripture That which in them is conformable to the authoritie of the holy Scripture I receiue it with his praise and commendation that which is not conformable to it I reiect it with his good liking Of S. Ambrose and of the rest of the Doctors that were before him f Idem Epi. 112 Doe not thinke that wee must follow the sense and opinion of any man as the truth of the Canonicall Scripture Of all them which haue written from the Apostles time to his time g Idem contra Faustum Mani lib. 11. c. 5. In the small bookes or short Treatises of them which are come since the Hearer or Reader hath his free iudgement to approoue that which is pleasing and good or to reprooue that which is vnpleasant and offensiue Cardinall Caietan the most learned of all the Cardinals and Bishops of his time hath the like speech in his preface on Genesis for hauing said h Caiet praefat in 5. lib. Mos That this authoritie is reserued only to the sole authors of the holy Scripture that we beleeue the thing to be so because they haue so written it layes downe this principle and maxime i Deus non alligauit expositionem scripturaruÌ„ sacrarum priscorum doctorum sensibus that God hath not tied the exposition of the holy Scripture to the sense of the ancient Doctors k Si quando occurrerit nouus sensus textui conformis quanquam à torrente doctorum alienus aequos se praebeant censores And therefore he intreates them which shall find in his Commentaries a new sense or meaning conformable and agreeable to the text to iudge iustly and vprightly although it bee against the torrent and streame of the Fathers l Andrad defens Synod Trident. lib. 2. Andradius maintaines the selfe same principle and improues the allegoricall expositions of the Fathers reprehends many expositions that they giue of the literall sense pronounces that they
20.3 Till the thousand yeeres should be fulfilled Who would now suffer himselfe to be swaied and caried away with this error should with good reason bee held and condemned for an heretick Doth not Stapleton tell vs y Staplet lib. â— de authorit Scripturae c. 2. §. 5. that Clement the Roman Tertullian Origen Irenaeus Chrysostome Theodoret Oecumenius Theophylact Ambrose Bernard were of opinion that the soules doe not enioy the vision of God before the day of iudgement Another adds to these z Senens lib. 6. annot 345. Iustine Martyr Lactance Victorinus Prudentius Arethas Iohn Pope of Rome Is not this an horrible errour VI. a Canus locorum Theolog. lib. 7. c. 1. num 1. §. Sancti namque Canus expounding S. Pauls words b Rom. 5.12 In whom all haue sinned saith that from these words All the Saints doe affirme with one consent that the Virgin Marie was conceiued in sinne Chrysostome Eusebius Remigius Ambrose Austin Bernard Bede Anselme Erardus Martyr Saint Antonie Doctor Bonaâ—enture Thomas of Aquin Vincentius Hugo de Sancto Victor why then doth not he himselfe follow this consent and opinion Let he himselfe say why Although no author hath contradicted it Infirmumest tamen ex omnium patrum consersu argumentum The argument notwithstanding taken from the consent of all the Fathers is weake and the contrarie opinion is more probably and holily held and maintained Of late then and newly haue they left and forsaken the vniuersall beleefe of all the Saints the space of 1400 yeeres and c Salmeron Iesuit in Rom. c. 5. disp si §. Deinde Salmeron the Iesuite tells vs that we must answere to this whole multitude that which one alleages and obiects that which is written of Gods word d Exod. 23.2 Exod. 23. Thou shalt not follow a multitude to doe euill neither shalt thou speake in a cause to decline after many to wrest iudgement Let this suffice for an answere to those that say we may not speake of the Scripture but onely as the holy Fathers expound it for if it were so we ought and should be Millinaries with many of the holy Fathers we should beleeue against all Scripture that the soules of the faithfull departed see not God vntill the vniuersall resurrection with the Fathers wee should race out of the catalogue of festiuall dayes that of the conception of the Virgin Marie the mother of Christ and hold with the Scripture that she was conceiued in sinne for so all the holy Fathers haue held VII The Romish Church should giue vnto the people the Eucharist vnder both kindes for so haue they beene instituted and giuen by the Master receiued and recommended by the Apostles celebrated by all the Fathers and of the whole Christian Church the space of 1400 yeeres wee ought to detest the new Fathers of Constance who haue presumed against Christs institution the doctrine of the Apostles the practice of the whole Church for so many ages to take away the cup to bereaue and depriue the Christians of the Sacrament of the bloud which the Sonne of God hath shed for them in the remission of their sinnes VIII To crie out alwaies the Fathers the Fathers to make great shew of the Fathers to relie on them to shelter themselues vnder the exposition of the Fathers and yet not follow the Fathers is to doe like e Matth. 26.49 Iudas which betraied Christ in speaking to him with great reuerence and kissing him or like the souldiers f Mat. 27.18.30 who hauing clothed our King and Sauiour Christ with a scarlet Robe and giuen him in his hand a Reede in stead of a Scepter they bowed their knees before him made a shew to adore him but forthwith did spit vpon him tooke the Reede and smote him on the head with it CHAP. VII I. What opinion wee are to haue and what iudgement to make of the Fathers in what and how farre they are to be beleeued II. The Author of the Pastorall Letter tyes and bindes the exposition of the Scriptures vnto the Pastors and Doctors hauing lawfull succession III. What is their authoritie charge and dutie IIII. They are not to bee heard vnlesse they speake according to the Scriptures V. Many vnder the Law and vnder the Gospell High-Priests Bishops and Popes hauing succession haue been Idolaters Hereticks Sorcerers VI. The obiection taken from the words of Malachie is contrary to the opponent I Doe not pretend to abate or diminish in any wise the authoritie of the Fathers I say that they haue been great men of God that they haue serued God and his Church in their time with great profit that their writings are of great vse and that by the reading of them a man may become wiser and holier And I hold for certaine that they are bound in the bundle of life and doe raigne in heauen with Christ Iesus their King for whose sake God hath been mercifull vnto them But when men make a buckler of their errors and when men say that we may not speake of the Scripture but as they are interpreted by them we are inforced to say the truth that first they all were men and not God secondly they were all disciples of the truth and not Author of the same all Interpreters of the law not Law-giuers all our fellow-Brethren and fellow-Seruants and not our Masters Thirdly that we ought to beleeue them in matters of fact or of things done in their time and that which they assuredly know when they speake of things not by heare-say but which themselues haue seene and knowne these certain things Fourthly that in matters of faith they are not to bee beleeued if they proue not their doctrine by the bookes of faith because as a Canus cent 3. sequent c. 4. Canus saith All the Saints those onely excepted who haue digested and committed vnto writing the Canonicall bookes haue spoken by human spirit and haue sometimes erred in things which appertaine to faith The reason is b 1. Cor. 13.9 They knew onely in part and prophesied in part c Gal. 5.17 The flesh lusteth against the Spirit and the Spirit against the flesh in in them as well as in vs. The Apostles onely were priuiledged with an extraordinarie measure of the holy Ghost to leade them without any imperfection d Iohn 16.13 in all truth Fifthly that the Spirit of Christ Iesus is not dead with them but is as yet in his Church enlightning it in the truth and sanctifying her by the truth in so much as although there were no writings of the Fathers the people of God for all that should not leaue to know vnderstand the Scriptures to know the voyce of Christ and follow it Sixthly that the writings of the Fathers are as much or more obscure then the holy Scriptures if it might bee said without blasphemy that there were obscurenesse in those bookes which were dictated by him e Iohn 1.9 Who is the light
perfect heart to Hebron to make Dauid King ouer all Israel Euen so whosoeuer warring against his infirmities addicts himselfe to seeke the Lord with a simple and sincere heart and indeuours the best he can according to the measure of the grace of Iesus Christ in him to loue God with all his heart God accepting of so holy an indeuour for the effect and pardoning him all that is wanting for Iesus Christs sake whose member he is he holds him reputes him names him as if hee had done whatsoeuer the Law requires and it is in this regard that hee is called Righteous For euen as he which meditates proiects designes the euill takes pleasure in it is called p Mat. 9.11 a sinner in the highest degree and is said q 5. Iob. 3.8.9 to commit sinne although God either foreslowes or hinders or dissipates his most wicked and wretched plots and proiects because it is not long of himselfe that he puts not in execution the pernicious designes of his hart God who r Iob 10.4 hath not the eyes of flesh nor seeth as man seeth Å¿ 1. Sam. 16.7 For man looketh on the outward appearance but the Lord looketh on the heart holdeth and accounteth for done that which hee would haue done termes him a sinner and committing sinne as if he did alwaies sinne in effect as well as he sinnes in affection According to this the Lord saith to Iudas who had resolued in himselfe to betray him t Iohn 13.27 That thou doest doe quickly In like manner hee which according to the ordinarie course of his life walkes in the feare of the Lord in his Law doth meditate day and night and all his delight is in the same is called u 1. Iohn 3.7 righteous and doing righteousnesse although the Diuell the World and his Flesh doe hinder him often to doe the good hee would and doe alwaies hinder him to perfect it and to doe it so holily as hee would God x Psal 7.9 who trieth the hearts and reines accepteth his good affection and as his Father in Christ Iesus and now no more his Iudge giues the title and name of righteousnesse to his sanctified his holy and religious will holding and reputing as done the good which he would haue done VI. So Dauid protests often that he hath kept the Law as we may reade in the 119. y Psal 119. Psalme because he had determined in himselfe to keepe it because he indeuoured and stroue with might and maine to keepe it and applied himselfe vnto it with great zeale and deuotion as hee declares it in the same Psalme z Vers 8. c. I will keepe thy statutes vers 8. I haue chosen the way of truth thy iudgements haue I laid before me vers 30. I haue said O Lord that I would keepe thy words vers 57. I haue sworne and I will performe it that I will keepe thy righteous iudgements vers 106. This is his resolution grounded vpon the loue of the Law I haue reioyced in the way of thy Testimonies as much as in all riches vers 14. I will delight my selfe in thy Statutes I delight in thy word Vers 16. My soule breaketh for the longing that it hath vnto thy iudgements at all times Vers 20. O how loue I thy Law it is my meditation all the day vers 97. c. This affection bred this resolution to keepe it and this resolution was followed with the effect he saith Thy testimonies are my delight and my counsellers vers 24. I remembred thy iudgements of old O Lord and haue comforted my selfe vers 52. I made haste and delaied not to keepe thy Commandements vers 60. The Law of thy mouth is better vnto me then thousands of gold and siluer vers 72. It is my meditation all the day vers 97. I haue not departed from thy Iudgements for thou hast taught me vers 102. Thy Word is a Lampe vnto my feete and a light vnto my path 105. Thy Testimonies haue I taken as an heritage for euer for they are the reioycing of my heart vers 111. My soule hath kept thy Testimonies vers 169. c. But this effect and worke is not perfect for there was as yet darkenesse in his vnderstanding and therefore hee prayes Open thou mine eyes that I may behold the wondrous things of thy Law vers 18. Giue me vnderstanding and I shall keepe thy Law yea I shall obserue it with my whole heart vers 34. Teach me good Iudgement and knowledge vers 66. Deale with thy seruant according vnto thy mercy and teach me thy statutes vers 124. There was some opposition in his heart therefore he prayes to God to encline his heart vnto his Testimonies and not to couetousnesse vers 36. He that prayeth so hath not attained vnto perfection notwithstanding he saith that he hath kept the Law that he hath done the Commandements as he himselfe expounds it saying I haue inclined mine heart to performe thy Statutes alway euen vnto the ende vers 112. VII The ancient Fathers haue thus expounded these places of Scripture as indeede they cannot be otherwise expounded then so considering the sinnes of the holiest which haue often tript and stumbled in the Law Saint Bernard shewes in what sense the Scripture termeth Christians Saints a Bernar. serm 3. Ad fratres in quo verbo non te terreat sanctitatis nomen quando non secundum meritum sed propositum non secundum affectionem sed secundum intentionem sanctos vocat Let not the name of holinesse amaze thee for God calls not his Saints according to their merit but according to his purpose not according to their affection but according to his intention Which he proues by the examples of Dauid and of Saint Paul who had not as yet apprehended that holines which men iudge it to be he adds afterwards And thou also if thou hast resolued in thy selfe to decline from euill and do that which is good hold fast that which thou hast receiued and continually profit better and better and then if thou doest something lesse vprightly according to humane frailtie not to persist in it but to repent and amend thy selfe according to thy power b Ibid. Eris sine dubio sanctus tâ— doubtlesse thou shalt also bee holy Prosper Aquitanus rendring a reason why the righteous which haue alwaies in them things from the which they desire to be freed and released are not called sinners but righteous but Saints sayes c Prosper in Psal 105. Scriptura peccatores non leuium culparum homines sed multorum facinorum profunde iniquitatis hoc nomine appellare consueuit That although the righteous and they which liue praise-worthy are not without sin the Scripture termeth commonly sinners not those which commit slight faults but those which commit many crimes and hainous sinnes and are profoundly wicked S. Austin declaring why being sinners they are named Saints saith
ye might haue life through his name In a word art thou desirous willing to to know al the Counsell of God touching thy saluation b Acts 20.27 I haue not shunned to declare vnto you all the Counsell of God saith Saint Paul to the Pastors of Ephesus and of Miletus but we haue not heard Saint Paul wilt thou say as they haue heard him but a little patience and heare him making this solemne protestation c Acts 26.22 witnessing both to small and great saying none other things then those which the Prophets and Moses did say should come and confessing himselfe to haue been d Rom. 1.1.2 put apart to preach the Gospell of God which he had promised afore by his Prophets in the holy Scriptures Thinke now with thy selfe and vpon these two true reasons and arguments of Saint Paul inferre and make this true conclusion All that which Saint Paul hath preached touching saluation hath been written by Moses and the Prophets Now that which Saint Paul hath preached is the Gospell yea all the Counsell of God therefore all the Gospell all the Counsell of God hath been written by Moses and by the Prophets and if by them how much more by the Euangelists and by the Apostles who haue written downe the accomplishment and fulfilling of all those things that the Prophets had foretold and prophesied of and that with more perspicuitie and plainenes Let vs therefore conclude that the holy Scripture is all true all necessarie all perfect in all her parts both essentiall and integrall all sufficient for him that liues in this world concerning those things that hee must beleeue that hee must hope for and that he must doe and in a word in and for all things that are requisite to attaine to saluation And therefore in all matters of faith and of manners wee must alwaies aske counsell at the mouth of the Lord speaking to vs at this time in the holy Scriptures by his Sonne which Scripture saith c Athan. de interpr Psal Diuina scriptura est magistra vitae verae fidei Athanasius is the Schoole-mistres of vertue and of true faith f Idem cont Idol Sufficiunt per se sacrae diuinitùs inspiratae scripturae ad veritatis indicationem and so sufficient of it selfe for the demonstration of the truth it being holy and diuinely inspired g Idem ad Seraph solum ex sacris literis condiscas that we neede studie no other thing then that The Author of the Pastorall letter hath seene it and being conuicted in his soule and conscience is constrained to vnderprop and sustaine his pretended counsels on certaine places of the holy Scripture in the producing and alleaging whereof is happened vnto him that which wrongfully he chargeth those withall who grounded on the Law of God and of Nature doe cancell and annull the vowes made by their children without their knowledge and approbation and that which Saint Peter condemnes in those that depraue the Epistles of Saint Paul saying h 2. Pet. 3.16 that the vnlearned and vnstable wrest them as they doe also the other Scriptures vnto their owne destruction CHAP. II. I. The Preface of the Pastorall letter forbids the Vulgar the reading of the Scriptures II. By the words of the Preface it is proued that all ought to reade the Scriptures III. The same is verified and iustified by the Scriptures IIII. A refutation of the blasphemie of those that maintaine the reading of the Scriptures to bee dammageable and dangerous BVt before he comes to the point he makes a preface in the which he handleth three points first to whom it appertaines to reade the Scriptures Secondly with what spirit they must be read Thirdly vnto whom the expounding and interpreting of the Scriptures appertaine And all to this end that hauing giuen them to vnderstand beleeue that it is not for all men to reade the Scriptures and that they must receiue the interpretation and sense of the Scriptures of those whom hee calles Our spirituall Fathers Pastors and Doctors wee beware to imitate the couragious men of Berea who hauing heard the preaching of Saint Paul a Acts 17.11 receiued the VVord with all readinesse of minde and searched the Scriptures daily whether those things were so and that so wee may liue on the faith of our Curats as the prouerb is and ground all our beliefe on the speculations of men whereas Saint Paul writes that b Hab. 2.4 Rom. 1.17 Gal. 3.12 Heb. 10.38 the iust shall liue by his faith and the same is said to bee grounded and c 1. Cor. 2.5 to stand not in the wisedome of men but in the power of God Notwithstanding let vs examine his words and if they are accompanied with reason let vs follow them if not let vs shun them and follow reason II. Concerning the first point Pag 4. he writes that the Scriptures may be compared to a wedding banquet they that will come vnto it and enter in must bee called and those that haue not the wedding garment who throng and thrust in themselues too impudently are to be thrust out and reiected That which he saith touching the wedding garment sheweth that he makes allusion to the banquet of the marriage of the Lambe whereof S. d Matth. 22.2 Luke 14.16 Matthew and Saint Luke make mention but all were inuited and bidden to this feast the poore and the maimed and the halt and the blind good and bad Now if we apply this similitude and comparison it will follow that euen as all were inuited to that feast Iewes and Gentiles poore and rich the learned and the ignorant men and women great and small in a word all are inuited and bidden to the reading of the Scripture without any exception of qualitie condition name calling sexe or age And againe euen as the great King published that they that would not come vnto his supper were not worthie pronounced that none of those men should taste of his supper and destroyed those murderers of his Seruants euen so they that refuse to reade the Scriptures and vse spitefully those that do inuite them to the reading of them shall neuer taste of the conlations contained in them but shall miserably perish hee that was cast into vtter darkenesse was not reiected and thrust out for his entring and comming in for he was inuited and called with the rest but he was reiected because he brought not with him a wedding garment according to the Kings words c Mat. 22.12.13 Friend how camest thou in hither not hauing a wedding garment bind him hand and foote take him away and cast him into vtter darkenesse Loe how that which Eliphas said to Iob is happened and befallen vnto Cardinall Sourdis Arch-Bishop of Bourdeaux f Iob 15.6 Thine owne mouth condemneth thee and not I yea thine owne lippes testifie against thee He did not thinke so his intention was to maintaine their common
maiestie i 1. Cor. 2.6 7 8 9. They containe the wisedome not of this world nor of the Princes of this world that come to nought but the wisedome of God which none of the Princes of this world knew but as it is written eye hath not seene nor eare heard neither haue entered into the heart of man the things which God hath prepared for them that loue him They being of God k Matth. 11.27 none can know them but God and vnto whom God will reueale them For as amongst men none knowes the things of man saue the spirit of man which is in him l 1. Cor. 2.11 Euen so the things of God knowes no man but the Spirit of God For this first reason God must reueale them vnto vs by his Spirit m 1. Cor. 2.10 For the Spirit teacheth all things yea the deepe things of God The second reason is our incapacitie and insufficiencie for not onely haue we our eyes obscured and darkned with some certaine cloudes of ignorance but we haue them also so blinde that the Scripture calles vs n Ephes 5.8 darkenesse and plainely saith of vs and of the fairest and best things we haue by nature that o 1. Cor. 2.14 The naturall man receiueth not the things of the Spirit of God for they are foolishnesse vnto him neither can he know them because they are spiritually discerned VVhere the Spirit of God chargeth vs with two things o 1. Cor. 2.14 the priuation and want of all facultie aptnesse and abilitie to vnderstand and comprehend the things that are of God Secondly an euill and peruerse disposition and inclination for wee cannot only not comprehend the things of God but also we esteeme them foolishnes according to that which the Apostle saith p Rom. 8.7 The carnall minde is enmitie against God and therefore hee addes that q 1. Cor. 2.14 15 these things are spiritually discerned and that he which is spirituall iudgeth all things Dauid wrote that it was so when he prayed vnto God saying r Psal 119.18 Open thou mine eies that I may behold the wondrous things out of thy Law when Saint Peter confessed the Lord to Å¿ Matth. 16.16 be Christ the sonne of the liuing God The Lord presently taught him that it was so saying t Matth. 16.17 Blessed art thou Simon Bar-Iona for flesh and blood hath not reuealed it vnto thee but my Father which is in heauen The Apostle hath confirmed the same where he prayes God in his Epistles to giue his Spirit vnto them vnto whom hee writes that they may comprehend these things and assuring vs that u 1. Cor. 12.3 no man can say that Iesus is the Lord but by the holy Ghost VI. But here is the question for they demaund Where is the Spirit In whom is the Spirit A question easie to bee resolued for as if one aske where the soule and life of man is a child would answere that it is in mans body and in euery part of the body though more sensibly and with more efficacy in one part of the body then in the other euen so when they demaund Where is the Spirit of Christ The childe of God will presently answere that it is in the body of Christ which is the Church vnited to Christ his head and in euery member of this body x Iohn 3.34 In Christ who is the head without measure in the other members with measure in some extraordinarily as in the Prophets and now ordinarie in all those that are come since in these a greater measure in those a lesser measure in some more in some lesse y Rom. 12.3 according as God hath dealt to euery man the measure of faith To doubt therefore if any one hath the Spirit of Christ in him is to doubt if he be a member of the body of Christ that is to say if he be a Christian for no man is a Christian but by the holy Spirit vniting him to Christ and inspiring him and quickning him that he liue to Christ CHAP. V. I. The words of Micah vnfitly and to no purpose alleaged cannot bee vnderstood by allegorie but of the Church in generall whose children are directed by the holy Spirit in the vnderstanding of the Scriptures II. Hee is an Heretick who obstinately defends a sense contrary to the Scriptures III. The argument whereby the Letter binds vs to depend and relie on the interpretation of the Fathers because Christ hath said nothing but that he hath heard of God his Father is impertinent and ridiculous IIII. In what consisteth our conformitie with Christ V. The argument retorted against the Author thereof VI. It is proued by the Scriptures and Fathers that wee are not to relie on the exposition of the Fathers WHen as therefore the Author saith in his Pastorall Letter that wee must not stand to our owne sense to know the sense of the Scripture Pag. 7. but follow the counsell of the Prophet Micah saying a Mica 4.2 Come and let vs go vp to the mountaine of the Lord and to the house of the God of Iacob and hee will teach vs of his waies and we will walke in his pathes Although that these words of Micah are to bee vnderstood literally of Sion and of the Citie of Ierusalem as it appeares by the words following For the Law shall goe forth of Zion and the word of the Lord from Ierusalem If by the mountaine of the Lord and the house of the God of Iacob hee vnderstands the Church of Christ Iesus it is most certaine that we ought to go and retire there to haue the sense meaning of the Scripture For there is the Scripture and there is the Spirit inspiring the whole Church in generall and euery true member of the same in particular according to the gift and wil of euery one When therfore the Scripture is read by a true member of Christ or is preached vnto him he hath the holy Spirit on his right hand and in his heart inspiring the true sense and meaning thereof and this inspiration is no other thing but that which S. Paul names b Ephes 1.18 the eyes of our vnderstanding enlightned to see comprehend the mysteries propounded in the Scriptures as it happened vnto Lydia c Acts 16.14 whose heart the Lord opened that she attended vnto the things which were spoken of Paul And it happens vnto all the Saints according to that which the Apostle saith d 1 Cor. 2.12 We haue receiued not the spirit of the world but the Spirit which is of God that we might know the things that are freely giuen to vs of God And S. Iohn writing to young babes young children young men and fathers e 1. John 2.20 Ye haue an vnction from the holy One and ye know all things The one and the other after their Maâ—â—er who hath decided this controuersie with this notable sentence No f Ioh.
spake not oracles in the expounding of the Scriptures that for not hauing the vse of a good Translation they haue often straied and swarued from the true meaning of the holy Ghost that many things in Moses and the Prophets are better and more exactly expounded in our age then they had euer beene before Others haue said and written as much CHAP. VI. I. There is none of the Fathers that hath not erred none of them therefore that can alone be iudge of the sense of the Scripture II. No more can the consent of the greater number of them because all haue erred together in the same points of doctrine either in mens opinion or in truth III. All the Fathers haue diuided the first Table of the Law in foure Commandements and are reiected two onely haue reduced it to three and are receiued of the Romane Church IIII. The opinion of Saint Austin alone to be preferred before that of Saint Hierome and of the number and multitude of the Fathers touching Saint Peter reprehended by Saint Paul V. The ancient Fathers for the most part were Millenaries or Chiliastae and thought that the soules saw not not God before the resurrection VI. All the Fathers haue beleeued for the space of 1500 yeeres that the Virgin Marie was conceiued in sinne their consent and agreement in the same is condemned by the Church of Rome VII The whole ancient and Primitiue Church for 1400 yeeres did celebrate the Eucharist vnder two Elements that is now adaies heresie in the opinion of the Romish Church VIII To make a shew of to relie on or shroud himselfe vnder the exposition of the Fathers and yet to refuse and forsake them is to make a mocke of the Fathers THe a Bellar. de concil writings of the Fathers are no rules and haue no authoritie to binde vs by the proper confession of them which bindes the consciences of the children of God of the co-heires of Christ vnto their authoritie take euery one of them apart take the greatest number of them consider them altogether and you will finde that it is so He on whose iudgement my conscience ought to rest must be indued with such a perfection that he cannot be allured nor induced to any error and cannot seduce nor misleade me by any errour it behoues that God giue him this testimony in the holy scriptures which giue this prerogatiue to none but to the Prophets and Apostles Let vs take the others one by one b Bellar. de verbo Dei lib. 3. c. 10. §. 21. Dices although they haue had the gift of interpreting in an high degree and haue beene spirituall yet is it certaine that the chiefest amongst them yea all of them haue erred and haue fallen into grosse faults and grieuous errors c Canus lib. 7. de locis Theolog. cap. 3. yea and sometimes doe engender monsters II. If all together or the greater number against the lâ—sse as ordinarily they hold and maintaine yet thus do they not receiue them d Maldon in Matth. 19.20 Maldonat expounding the historie of the rich man that said to our Sauiour that he had kept all the Commandements from his youth vp saith Some Fathers Hilarie Ierome Ambrose Austin Theophilact Beda and others say that this young man lied notwithstanding I rather like and approue saith he the opinion of Basil Euthymiâ—s Chrysostome and so preferres the lesser number before the greater III. All the Fathers haue deuided the ten Commandements placing foure of them in the first Table and sixe in the second except e Clemens stromat lib. 6. Clement Alexandrinus who hath acknowledged but nine And Saint f August qu. 71 in Exod. Austin ioyning the second with the first hath reduced the foure of the first Table to three seeking in it the mysterie of the Trinitie and hath made two of the last of the second Table Notwithstanding the common diuision of g Phil. de Dialogo Philo h Ioseph antiq lib. 3. c 4. Ioseph and of i Aben Ezra in Exod. 20. all the Iewes of k Greg. Nazianz in vers de decalogo Gregory Nazianzen l Origen in Exo. hom 8. Origen m Athanas in Synopsi sacrae scripturae Athanasius n Chrysost operis imperfect in Mat. hom 49. Chrysostome amongst the Greekes of o Hieron in epist ad Ephes cap. 6. Saint Hieromie p Ambros in epist ad Ephes cap. 6. Saint Ambrose and of q Aug. qu. vet noui Test cap. 7. Saint Austin himselfe if 〈…〉 Author of the questions of the old and new Testament is reiected of the whole Romish Church and that opinion of Saint Austin contradicting himselfe is receiued and that not without cause IIII. There was a great contention betweene Saint Ierâ—â—â— and Saint Austin concerning the rebuke that Saint Paul made to Saint Peter before the whole Church of Antioch Saint Ierome held that Saint Paul did dissemble with Saint Peter that he did vse an officious lie and an honest dispensation and did quote and alleage for himself many Fathers of whom hee made so much that he feared not to say r Hyeron Aug. If thou dost blame and 〈…〉 as one that erres 〈◊〉 me 〈…〉 them that are such Saint Austin held that Saint Paul rebuked Saint Peter in earnest and saith that if hee had read much hee might haue found as many Fathers on his side Å¿ August epi. 19. But faith he I haue for them all and aboue them all the Apostle Paul I haue my refuge to him I appeale from all them which haue expounded his writings and thinke otherwise to him I aske and demâ—â—â—â— himselfe c. and I heare him crying with a religious voice in the exordium and beginning of this narration Concerning the things I write vnto you Behold I say before God that I lie not let those that thinke otherwise pardon me I had rather beleeue so great an Apostle taking his oath in his writings and for his writings then any man bee hee neuer so learned disputing of other mens writings Doe not we hold now adaies that Saint Austines opinion was sounder and truer then that of Saint Hierome and of his adherents Medina t Medina de sacror hom orig lib. 1 c. 5. hath not doubted to affirme that Ierome Sedulius Primasius Theodoret Austin Chrysostome Theophylact haue held that the order of Bishops and of Priests is one and the selfe same order They that beleeue that now adaies are held for heretickes of the Romane Bishops and of their clients and followers V. The u Greg. Valent. Jes lib. 8. anclys c. 8. Senens bibl lib. 3. annot 237. ancient Fathers for the most part were Millenaries Papius an Auditor of the Apostle Saint Iohn Apollinaris Irenaeus Tertullian Victorin Lactantius Seuerus Sulpicius and a great number of Catholicks Iustin Martyr all of them deceiued for not vnderstanding well that which is written in the Reuelation x Reuel
which lighteth euery man that commeth into the world Seuenthly that the fathers are so many in number their writings in like manner that though a man had an iron body he could not take the paines to reade them all and though he had a memory of steele he could not remember the expositions of all of them that there is no man liuing which hath them all no man liuing which hath read all those we haue yea I suppose and presume that I may say truely that all the liuing together haue not read them all whereas all can and may reade the Scripture ouer and ouer euery one oftentimes learne by it with prayer and labour all that is necessarie for their saluation Eightly lastly that the Scriptures are snatched out of the peoples hands deteined in such a brutish ignorance that they cannot know if the things written by the Fathers are of the Scripture or no the meanes to reade the Fathers is taken away from them so that they cannot know how they expound the Scriptures and therefore it is a meere mockerie to send the ignorant to the Fathers which they haue neuer read which they cannot reade though they would and dare not reade them though they could and whom they cannot vnderstand though they should reade them and therefore are taught to referre themselues in all these things to that which their Pastors and Doctors will make them beleeue II. This is the sense of that which followeth in the Pastorall letter where to that which hath been said that we ought not to speake of the Scriptures otherwise then the fathers expound them is added And besides your spirituall Fathers Pastors and Doctors that are instituted of God grounded on the lawfull succession of the Apostles to expound and interpret it to you f Malach. 27. Labia Sacerdotis custodient scientiam ex ore eius legem requirent The Priests lipps shall keepe knowledge and they shall seeke and aske the Law at his mouth III. We ought not to take away from the true Pastors and Doctors any thing of that which God giues them Saint Paul saith of himselfe and of all g 1. Cor. 4.1 Let a man so account of vs as of the Ministers of Christ and Stewards of the mysteries of God and elsewhere h 2. Co. 5.19.20 God hath committed vnto vs the Word of reconciliation We therfore are Ambassadours for Christ as though God did beseech you by vs. We ought then to account and esteeme of them and to put them in another ranke then priuate persons are we are to heare them with attention and reuerence in the declaration of their commission And if we honour the Ministers and Ambassadours of a Prince for the Princes sake who sends them how much more shall we honour and reuerence the Ministers of Christ Iesus who is the i Acts 3.15 Prince of life and hath written on his thighe k Reuel 19.16 The King of Kings and Lord of Lords for Christ Iesus sake But they ought also to know that they are but Ministers of Christ therfore are not Lords and Masters ouer the Church which is the body and spouse of Christ that they are the Ministers of Christ therfore are called administerium non ad magisterium to serue and that with labor and paines like those which row in shipps 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 as the Greeke word beareth and not to gouerne and play the Regent according to their owne fancie and affection that they are stewards of the great mysteries of God of the great mysteries of the Gospel the which they must distribute that is to say preach and apply it to the vse and saluation of the Saints That they are the Ambassadors for Christ and therefore they ought to produce their letters and patent of their commission and declare faithfully the substance of the same without any addition diminution or changing thereof They are no more priuiledged then Saint Paul was who l 1. Cor. 11.23 receiued of the Lord that which he deliuered vnto them and m Acts 26.22 Rom. 1.22 hath giuen nothing but that which was written touching the substance of the doctrine And of that whereof euery one had the copie in hand to examine if he kept himselfe in the precincts and compasse of his charge and commission as n Acts 17.11 they of Berea did with praise and commendation IIII. Therefore the Apostle hauing declared what is their charge and function and the dignitie or excellencie thereof giues them this admonition o 1. Cor. 4.2 Moreouer it is required in Stewards that a man be found faithfull faithfull in care in labor and especially in the preaching of the will of God in purenesse and simplicitie without any mixture of humane traditions his will say we wholy comprehended in the Scriptures of the which God will that all should haue copie as being all his children and hauing right and reason to know the contents of his Testament to the ende that if they which are but his Teachmen and Heralds doe interpret other language then his relate and deliuer otherwise then that which he hath giuen in writing and hauing sent the copies throughout all the world they be not heard what succession soeuer they pretend Aaron from and by whom the Leuiticall succession began p Exod. 32.4 made a golden calfe and notwithstanding the Leuits who were inferiour vnto him would not be partakers of his sinne q but obserued the words of God and kept them If a prophet or a dreamer of dreames did arise amongst the people and made signes and miracles and hee say let vs goe after other Gods and let vs serue them God commanded to put such a one to death and saith to the people r Thou shalt not hearken vnto the words of that prophet or dreamer of dreames c. Yee shall walke after the Lord your God and feare him and keepe his commandements and obey his voyce and you shall serue him and cleaue vnto him In like manner the Prophet Isaiah sends them to ſ Isai ◠20 the Law and to the testimony saying If they speake not according to this word it is because there is no light in them Saint Peter also to the Pastors and Ministers t 1. Pet. 4.11 If any man speake let him speake as the oracles of God And Saint Iohn writing to a woman and in her person to all u 2. Iohn 10. If there come any vnto you and bring not this doctrine receiue him not into your house neither bid him God speede V. Neither is there any succession that is free or can priuiledge them Vriah the high Priest descended by succession from Aaron builds contrary to Gods commandement an Altar according to the patterne of that of Damascus and sets it in the Temple x 2. King 16.11 according to all that the King Ahaz had sent from Damascus Caiphas hauing the succession with the Scribes and
Iudge must bee present and visible we answere that that is not necessarie How often doe Emperours decide controuersies new sprung in their Prouinces by the authoritie and Iurisdiction of the Soueraigne Court without budging from their place How often haue the Popes remaining in Rome or in Auignon ended the differences of Christians a great distance from them by their Decreâ—all Epistles and doe as yet make knowne their will vnto al the world by their Bulls without stirring from their seate The King whom God preserue and blesse with all temporall and spirituall blessings for his glory is the supreme and Soueraigne Iudge of all this Kingdome although he be visibly and corporally but in one place of the same at one time from the place where hee is hee signifies by his Proclamation what his pleasure is vnto the which all his subiects must yeeld and agree A King who is but a man hath such a power and shall not the King of Kings haue it a mortall man absent in body shall bee acknowledged of all his good subiects for supreme Iudge and his will declared in writing shall bee a Law vnto them and shall not the Lord Iesus God-Man and Man-God be accepted of for Soueraine Iudge nor his writings for lawes vnlesse he make and shew himselfe visible and present What impietie But God be thanked our Iudge conteined indeede in heauen in regard of his bodie Acts 3.21 is alwaies euery where with his Church in regard of his Deitie and God-head alwaies present in the same in common and generall and in euery member of the same in particular by his holy Spirit by his grace by his vertue by his counsell by his helpe and assistance by his conduct and guiding and by his holy and wholesome word so farre forth that hee saith m Matth. 28.20 Lâ—e I am with you alwaies euen vnto the end of the world for * Matth. 18.20 faith he where two or three are gathered together in my name there am I in the midst of them It is he then that iudgeth vs by his word which is his voice which all they that are his sheepe heare which they know and follow n Iohn 10.27 My sheepe heare my voice saith Christ and I know them and they follow me And doe not thinke that he speakes there onely of his sheepe of then or that time when he fed them with the foode and refection of his mouth he speakes of all those that shall be gathered together vnder his Sheepe-hooke vntill the ende of the world according to that he said before vers 16 Other sheepe haue I which are not of this fold them also I must bring and they shall heare my voice and there shall be one fold and one shepheard They that are not contented with this voice and heare it not they would not onely not heare our Lord Iesus although he should returne here in the flesh but also they would crucifie him againe as the Priests Scribes Pharisees and the Elders of the people did for if that so he should returne here on earth hee would say no other thing then that which he hath said alreadie and would not speake more plainely and perspicuously then he hath spoken in the holy Scriptures Therefore according as he hath commanded vs to call none our Doctor o Matth. 23.10 For one is our Doctor and Master euen Christ we will adhere and sticke fast vnto him alone and will say vnto him with Saint Peter and the other disciples Iohn 6.68 Lord to whom shall wee goâ— thou hast the words of eternall life and wee beleeue and are sure that thou art that Christ the Sonne of the liuing God V. The publike ministeriall Iudge is he which hath a publike and lawfull calling and authoritie from God to iudge not of the Scripture nor of the sense thereof for being immediatly from God the Law of the supreme Iudge and the most perfect rule of all godlinesse whereby all men are iudged and ruled it cannot be iudged of men by any meanes but of the doctrines of men the which he examines by the touchstone of the Scriptures and by them markes and considers if they are of God or no such are Pastors and Doctors considered apart in their Schooles and Churches and together in the Presbyterie Synods Councels Nationall and Occumenicall whose whole authoritie is limited by the holy Scriptures against and besides which they may not ordaine any thing Gal. 1.8 being to speake properly and fitly Clerks Truch-men Heralds Messengers and Ambassadours of God towards their brethren and not Iudges their iudgement being of seruice not of soueraigntie of direction not of authoritie compelling p Ephes 2.20 For we are built vpon the foundation of the Apostles and Prophets and not vpon the hand of humane opinions Wherefore if Christ Iesus himselfe hath confirmed his doctrine by the Scriptures q Luk. 24.27 beginning at Moses and all the Prophets r Act. 15.16.17 If the Apostles assembled together in Ierusalem refuted by the Scripture the heresie of those which mingled the Law with the Gospell If Saint Paul Å¿ Act. 17.2.3 Act. 26.22 Act. 28.23 proued his Gospell by the writings of Moses and of the Prophets surely they that are not furnished with such authoritie are bound to iustifie their doctrine by the Scriptures without the which t Orig. in Hierem â—om 1. our sense meanings and interpretation are not faith In regard of which the Apostle saith that the Spirit of Prophets are subiect to the Prophets 1. Cor. 14.32 And u Gerson de exam doctri Consid 5. num 17. Gersâ—â— saith That we must giue more credit and beleeue soeuer a simple man not authorized excellently skilled in the Scriptures then the declaration of the Pope for it is certaine that we must soâ—â—er beleeue and rather giue credit vnto the Gospell then vnto the Pope x Panerm in cap. significat extra de electiâ— Panâ—rmus saith In matters which concerne our faith the saying of a prâ—â—ate man is to be preferred before the Popes saying if it be confirmed with the best reasons of the old and new Testament Another most excellently and euidently y Picus Mirand de fide â—rd cred Theâ—re 6. A simple peasant or swaine a childe an old woman are more credible and 〈◊〉 to her beleeued thou the grand Prelate or Pope and a thousand Bishops of these speake contrary and against the Gospell those for and according to the Gospell The reason is verie good the Gospell is of the Master and ought to bee receiued with all obedience of faith by whomsoeuer it is preached the Pope and the Bishops are but seruants in the Masters house where they haue no other charge then to serue the children of the house according to the will of the heauenly Father comprehended in the Scriptures otherwise they are no Pastors but Impostors VI. As the publike ministerial iudgement is without proportion and measure inferior to
that of God reuealed in the Scripture so the priuate iudgment is inferior to the ministerial for it comes not out in publike with a publike calling and authoritie but keepes and containes it selfe in the conscience for her rest and peace and doth not extend or spread her selfe further then the calling of him which hath receiued this gift of God This is common to all true Christians who being all spirituall man haue receiued and had of God the eyes eares taste heart and iudgement of the spirituall man to see heare taste know iudge loue and affect the things of God z 1. Cor. 2.15 The spirituall man faith the Apostle discerneth and iudgeth all things euery Christian is spirituall he which is not spirituall is no Christian for to be a Christian is nothing else then to be spirituall euery Christian therefore knoweth and discerneth the things of his saluation Christians are the sheepe of our Lord Iesus As therefore a naturall sheepe can by the principle of nature make choise of that herbe which is the most wholesome to her and in feeding passe by that which is contrary to her nature so the spirituall sheepe by the principle of grace can iudge betweene the true passages and places vnto the which she is brought and led by her true shepheard and the bad pasture wherewith the stronger would infect and poyson her This doctrine is of Christ Iesus and of his Apostles Christ hath said that a Iohn 10.4.5 the good shepheard putteth forth his owne sheepe and goeth before them and the sheepe follow him for they know his voice and a stranger will they not follow but will flee from him for they know not the voyce of strangers The Apostle requires of all men that b Heb. 5.14 they haue their senses exercised to discerne both good and euill he exhorts them saying c 1. Cor. 14.20 Brethren be not children in vnderstanding howbeit in malice be ye children but in vnderstanding be men d 1. Thess 5.20 Proue all things hold fast that which is good Saint Iohn tells them that it is their dutie e 1. Iohn 4.1 Beloued beleeue not euerie spirit but trie the spirits whether they are of God because many false prophets are gone out into the world They will not place the particulars in the pulpit to preach but they place them at the chaires foote to heare with iudgement and discerne between the true Doctor and the false seducer to follow that man and to take heed of this man according to Christs admonition f Matth. 7.15 Beware of false prophets which come to you in sheepes clothing but inwardly they are rauening wâ—lues yee shall know them by their fruits He presupposeth therefore that they shall haue iudgement to know them but this iudgement being a gift of God a gift grace not of nature a gift proper vnto the spirituall man vnknowne to the naturall the Apostle prayes to God to giue it vs g Phil. 1.9.10 I pray that your loâ—â— may abound yet more and more in knowledge and in all iudgement that yee may approue things that are excellent that ye may be sincere and without offence till the day of Christ VII Iudge we then of what spirit are they which of spirituall sheepe would deforme vs and transforme vs into brutish sheepe and destituted of reason doe prohibit vs to speake of the things of our God Creator Father and Sauiour but as they list Let vs compare their spirit with that of Christ and of the Apostles Christ would that we should iudge of him by the Scriptures and not simply by his saying said vnto the people h Iohn 5.39 Search the Scriptures And these would haue vs to iudge of them by their bare saying and not by the Scriptures do blame and condemne vs for the diligent search of the Scriptures The Apostle said to the Corinthians i 1. Cor. 10.15 I speake as to wise men iudge yee what I say These feare nothing so much as vnderstanding men to keepe and deteine the world in ignorance they crie out it is not for you to iudge of what we say If the spirit wherewith Christ and the Apostles were guided â—â—d led was the holy Ghost what manner of spirit can this be which leader these men A spirit which would make vs like to painted clouds in a Church or like vnto those little court-cupbord gods of whom it is written k Ps â—15 5 â— They haue months but speake not eyes haue they but they see not they haue eares but they heare not noses haue they but they smell not they haue hands but they handle not feete haue they but they walke not neither speake thâ—y through their throat they that make them are like vnto them so is euery one that trusteth in them And therefore the spirit of darkenesse who detaines the Christians in darkenesse to the ende he may draw and bring them to the gulfe of outward darknesse with himselfe as it is written l Io. 3.19 20. 21 This is the condemnation that light is come into the world and men loued darkenesse rather then light because their deeds were euill for euery one that doth euill hateth the light neither commeth to the light lest his deeds should be reproued but he that doth truth commeth to the light that his deeds may be made manifest that they are wrought in God Let him therefore that will walke in darknesse As for vs that m Ephes 5.8.11 were sometimes darknesse but now we are light in the Lord we will walke as children of light and will haue no fellowship with the vnfruitfull workes of darkenesse but rather reproue them reioycing and taking pleasure in the light of the Scriptures without and in the direction and conduct of the holy Spirit within vs vntill n Iames 1.17 the father of lights who by his grace o Col. 1.13 hath deliuered vs from the power of darknesse and hath translated vs into the kingdome of his deare sonne p Phil. 1.6 finishing that good worke which he hath begun in vs q Col. 1.12 make vs meete to be partakers of the inheritance of the Saints in light r 1. Iohn 3.2 where wee shall bee like to him and shall see him as he is Amen The ende of the first Booke OF EVANGELICALL COVNSELS The second Booke CHAP. I. I. The Iewish Church hath been of old troubled by false prophets who pretended the name of the word of God and laid claime to it in their false lies II. Saint Peter prophesied that the like should happen vnto the Christian Church by false doctors III. Of this number are they which exalt with puffing words the Monasticall life IIII. Making the people beleeue that it is grounded vpon Euangelicall Counsels whereas there is no such Counsell in the whole Scripture THe Church of the Iewes was very much troubled abused and seduced in her time by the false prophets They saith God
they Counsels of perfection If there bee any they are of God or of men If from God all men must follow the for if the requests and desires of Kings are commandements as an Heathen man saith how much more then are the Counsels of the King of Kings and the Lord of Lords who looketh vnto none but such e Esay 66.7 as tremble at his word Christ Iesus said to the Church of Laodicea f Reuel 3.18 I counsell thee to buy of me goldâ—â—ied in the fire that thou maiest bee rich and white â—â—â—ent that thou maiest bee clothed and that the shame of thy unkednesse doe not appeare and anoint thine eyes with eye-salue that thou maiest see This is the onely place of the whole Scripture in the old and new Testament where God giueth counsell vnto man the Creator to his creature the Lord to his seruant the King of heauen to his subiects dwelling on earth And this Counsell is such an expresse commandement that the Lord hath spewed that Church out of his mouth for not following of the same for he that giues counsell to another desires and wishes that hee would conforme himselfe to it and is sorry yea angry and much offended when it is reiected when especially it is a good and wholesom counsell giuen by the superiour to his inferiour by the father to the son the King to his subiect to hasten to end and to vrge this we say al men are bound g Rom. 12.2 Ephes 5.17 to know and proone what is that good that acceptable and perfect will of God to doe the fame according to the prayer which euery one makes vnto God Thy will be done on earth as it is in heauen All the Counsels of God are the will of God wherefore all men are bound to vnderstand them to proue and doe them All that which wee are bound vnto to doe is a commandement the Counsels of God are things that wee are bound to doe therefore the Counsels of God are commandements Againe God wills and requires that all men practise his Counsels God wills not and requires not that all men should shut vp and mew themselues in a cloister abstaine from marriage carrie a wallet or scrip and go like vagabonds from dore to dore from towne to towne to begge and craue almes for such a life would bee the ruine and destruction of the Commonweale and of the Church Therefore to abstaine from mariage liue in pouertie nourish and sustaine himselfe with the labour and sweat of other men to mew himselfe vp in a Monastery separated from the company of men is not a Counsell of God VIII There are Counsels of perfection If there bee all must aspire vnto them euery man is inclined to it by nature euery one tends and inclines vnto perfection by a naturall principle and instinct euery Christian tends and makes towards the Christian perfection by a spirituall instinct by a principle of grace euery Christian is bound to it by commandement is drawne to it by promise is incited and incouraged by the example of all the Saints h Phil. 4.8 9. Brethren saith the Apostle whatsoeuer things are true whatsoeuer things are honest whatsoeuer things are iust whatsoeuer things are pure whatsoeuer things are louely whatsoeuer things are of good report of there bee any vertue and if there bee any praise thinke on these things Those things which yee haue both learned and receiued and heard and seene in me doe and the God of peace shall be with you If the Counsels are of this ranck and number the Apostle commaunds all men and women to doe them to them that doth them hee makes a promise from God that the God of peace shall be with them If they are not of this number they are neither true nor venerable nor iust nor pure nor louely nor of good report there is no vertue nor praise in them And therefore they are not to bee done but to be eschewed and auoided This is the expresse commandement of our Master Doctor and Sauiour Iesus Christ i Matth. 5.48 Be perfect euen as your Father which is in heauen is perfect this is also the expresse commaundement of Saint Paul k 2. Cor. 13.11 Bee perfect l Heb. 6.1 Let vs goe on vnto perfection To this ende the Scripture hath beene giuen vs m 2. Tim. 3.17 That the man of God may be perfect throughly furnished vnto all good workes For this ende the Lord hath giuen vs Pastors and Doctors n Ephes 4.13 till wee all come in the vnitie of the faith and of the knowledge of the Sonne of God vnto a perfect man vnto the measure of the stature of the fulnesse of God S. Paul made towards this perfection and laboured to come to it by o Phil. 3.13 14. forgetting those things which are behind and reaching forth vnto those things which are before he pressed towards the marke for the price of the high calling of God in Christ Iesus Noah Iob Abraham all the Saints of the old and the new Testament haue done the like for which cause the Scripture termes them perfect God who accepts in his children the will and willingnesse the pronenes of their mindes and forwardnesse for the deede honouring their holy indeuor and affection with the name of perfection which they did aspire vnto and now enioy and possesse Wee â—ake now if the perfection of Counsels bring to the Monkes and Friers any greater perfection then the measure of the stature of the fulnesse of Christ vnto which all Christians shall attaine and come vnto a perfect man If that cannot bee what vse haue Counsels If it can be there will be some perfection out of Christ and without Christ and some greater perfection then the perfect stature of Christ which is impossible We aske againe if a man in this life can attaine vnto a greater perfection then that which was in Noah Iob Abraham Moses in the Patriarches the Prophets and Apostles If any man shall bee aduanced and exalted in glorie aboue them in the life to come If this be absurd and false to what end and purpose is this warbling and pratling of Counsels which brings to no man any greater excellencie aduantage then that which infinite Saints haue attained vnto which haue neuer bin Monks neuer made vow of continencie neuer carried the bag and wallet neuer followed the Monasticall deuotions Abraham Isaac Iacob Noah Moses c. were great men and rich and liued in the state of matrimony The holy Apostles haue neuer followed any other rule then that which is common to all Christians Pouertie and the forsaking of their goods was neuer imposed to them by Christ and they neuer bound themselues to it by vow as the whole history of the Gospell teacheth vs and p Extrâ—â— Iob. 22. Tit. 14. c. 5. Quia quorundam neque Christum exprepriationem praedictam â—mnis iuris cuinâ—cunque rei proprietatem eius vsuÌ„
then as the seede of God remaines in him that is borne of God hee commits not sinne but in as much as there are tares and darnell in him he sinneth In like manner Saint Austin We are saith he the children of God and the children of this world n August de Peccator merit lib. 2. c. 8. Per quod filij dei sumus per hoc peccare omnino non possumus per quod adhuc filij saeculi sumus per hoc peccare adbuc possumus By that whereby wee are the children of God wee cannot sinne after a sort c. By what wee are the children of the world we can yet sinne In another place hee expounds this sentence by another where the same Apostle saith o 1. Iohn 4.7 Loue is of God and euery one that loueth is borne of God and knoweth God p August de gratia Christi contra pro lib 1. Cor. 2.1 According to this loue saith hee this sentence may bee better vnderstood He that is borne of God doth not commit sinne and thinkes not on euill Therefore when a man sinnes he sinnes not according to charitie and loue but according to lust according to which he is not borne of God Their resolution and answere is that man as he is regenerate cannot sinne and sinnes not as he is not regenerate he sinnes VI. We adde a second answere He sinnes not malitiously and with a full and whole consent of the will he makes not a trade of sinne q Psal 1.1 He walkes not in the counsell of the vngodly nor standeth in the way of sinners nor sitteth in the seate of the scornefull The Scripture termes such as spend their dayes in wickednesse r Mat. 7.23 workers of iniquitie Å¿ Prou. 4.16.17 They sleepe not except they haue done mischiefe and their sleepe is taken away vnlesse they cause some to fall for they eate the breade of wickednesse and drink the wine of violence The man that is borne of God is no such man for the seede of God the gift of regeneration that is in him preserueth him from sinnes committed by insolency and arrogancie that he neuer withdrawes himselfe from Gods loue and from faith His sinnes are sins of infirmitie and he commits them vnwillingly ouercome by some sudden passion of the flesh as it happened to Dauid and Saint Peter when the one committed adulterie and murder the other denied his Master and Sauiour for the spirituall man warring against the flesh it oftentimes borne downe but the blowes he receiues makes his courage to swell so that he riseth vp incontinently and returnes to the combat armed with flame and fire hee buckleth and grapleth with his enemie and angrie with himselfe to haue been thus foiled he beates his brest and cries Haue mercy vpon me miserable sinner as Dauid did he goes speedily out of Caiphas house and weepes bitterly and returnes with the Saints as Saint Peter did he is like vnto that braue Romane Captaine Marcellus who though often beaten did alwaies returne to the combat could not endure to be ouercome neuer gaue ouer neuer left his enemie in rest till he had ouercome him The seede of God that is in him giues him alwaies courage and strength After this manner saith Saint Iohn t 1. Iohn 5.18 We know that whosoeuer is borne of God sinneth not but hee that is begotten of God keepeth himselfe and that wicked one toucheth him not CHAP. XIII I. The seuenth Obiection All God workes are perfect II. The first Answere That which God doth perfectly man comprehends it imperfectly III. The second Answere God perfectth not our regeration but successiuely and by degrees IIII. The third Answere All the workes which God makes alone are perfect but he makes good workes in vs and by vs. V. The last Obiection If good workes are sinnes we must not doe good workes VI. We must doe good workes and for what cause VII Good workes are not sinnes VIII Notwithstanding are not perfectly good because they are tainted and soiled by the flesh XI God forgiuing the regenerate man the imperfection of them accepts of them for Iesus Christ his sake X. According to his mercie and not for our merit THis should content the most contentious but because they seeke themselues and not the truth of God in their disputations nothing can content and satisfie them Obiection 7 And therfore they obiect againe that all Gods workes are perfect as it is written a Deut. 32.4 He is the rocke his worke is perfect Regeneration and the good workes that flow from thence are workes of God they are therefore perfect and if perfect then they which doe them keepe perfectly the Law II. I answere to this obiection three manner of waies First that which God doth perfectly is imperfectly comprehended of vs we are alwaies children alwaies disciples and do learne imperfectly and with great difficultie the perfect lesson of our Master The documents and precepts of Iesus Christ were perfect b Iohn 15.15 All things saith he that I haue heard of my Father I haue made knowne vnto you but the Apostles could not conceiue and vnderstand them but successiuely by little and little one after another and had neede after their regeneration that the c Luk. 24.45 Lord should open their vnderstanding a new that they might vnderstand the Scriptures and that yet after all he should send the comforter which saith he is the holy Ghost d Iohn 14.26 he shall teach you all things and bring all things to your remembrance whatsoeuer I haue said vnto you e Iohn 16.13 and will guide you into all truth III. Secondly although that which God doth is perfect in his degree ranke and that our regeneration is perfect in regard of the perfection of parts he works but successiuely by degrees in vs because that being a free agent he doth al things in all men according vnto the counsell of his good will To be borne deformed blind crump-shouldred a cripple c. is a defect an imperfection in comparison of Moses that was f Acts 7.20 borne exceeding faire yet notwithstanding he which is so borne is the worke of Gods hands and a perfect worke in that perfection which the eternall wisedome of God hath intended to conferre and giue him God who created our first father created him a perfect man in the full measure of age and stature but he hath determined that all they which descend from him should be borne babes and should grow from age to age vntill they came to mans estate the first age being imperfect in comparison of the second and so consequently vnto the declining age g Eccles 12.3 When the euill daies come and the yeeres draw nigh when thou shalt say I haue no pleasure in them Notwithstanding euerie age is perfect in his degree Euen so it fareth with vs in regard of our spirituall new birth h 1. Pet. 2.2 First
ser 50. Nec latuit praeceptorem praecepti pondus hominum excedere vires sed iudicauit vtile ex hoc ipso suo illes insufficieâ—tiae admoneri vt scirent sanè ad quem iustitiae finem niti pro viribus oporteret Ergo mandando impossibilia non praeuaricatores homines fecit sed humiles c. The Master was not ignorant saith Saint Bernard that the burden of the Commandement did surpasse the strength of man but hee thought it good and necessarie that by the very same they should be warned of their insufficiencie that they might know to what ende and marke of righteousnesse they ought to make towards with all their strength and power commanding therefore things impossible he hath not made men preuaricators but humble that euery mouth may be stopped and all the world may become subiect to the iudgement of God because that by the workes of the Law there shall be no flesh iustified in his sight for receiuing the CoÌ„mandements and feeling our defect and want wee will crie vp to heauen and God will haue mercy vpon vs and wee shall know in that day that hee hath saued vs not by the workes of righteousnesse that wee haue done but according to his mercie Secondly because he vnderstands not the language of the Scripture hee restraines the choice to voluntarie and free things to the obseruation of the which man is not bound and compelled by any Law Hee might haue read the words of the Prophet Moses saying to the people of Israel touching the Law x Deut. 30.19 I call heauen and earth to record this day against you that I haue set before you life and death blessing and cursing therefore chuse life that both then and thy seede may liue As also Ioshuahs words to the same people y Ioshua 24.15 If it seeme euill vnto you to serue the Lord chuse you this day whom ye will serue Conformably to this Dauid saith z Psal 119.30 I haue chosen the way of truth thy iudgements haue I laid before me And Saint Cyrill expounds the Prophets words of them which chuse and retaine Christs Testament as Lyrinensis of those that liue righteously and vprightly with their neighbour VII He expounds as falsely these words I will giue vnto them a name better then of sons and of daughters a Bellar. de monach c. 9. parag 3. 9. maintaining that by sons and daughters God meanes those good and godly persons that are married which are Gods sons and daughters and that God promiseth to those which are virgins a greater good and a greater glory then to these What could he say more impertinently then this For to be a sonne and a daughter of God is the common name of all the faithfull and their highest and most excellent title and degree of honour from whence depends all their prerogatiue glory ioy and consolation both in life and death and it is not a name of an inferiour qualitie appertaining onely to some lesse priuiledge Witnesse our Sauiour Christ when he saith To as many as receiued him to them b Iohn 1.12 gaue he power to become the sonnes of God euen to them that beleeue in his name Witnesse God himselfe saying by his Prophets and by his Apostle c Isa 52.11 Ierem. 31.1.9 2. Cor. 6.17.18 Come out from among them and be ye separate saith the Lord and touch not the vncleane thing and I will receiue you and will be a Father vnto you and ye shall be my sonnes and daughters saith the Lord Almightie d Rom. 8.17 And if children then heires heires of God and ioynt-heires with Christ saith the Apostle What may we What can we hope desire wish more It is that which is giuen to honest and good men married persons by Bellarmines confession what remaines then to the Monkes what haue the Friers else a name saith he more excellent then of sonnes of God why then they are not sonnes of God And to maiden Virgins a name better then of daughters of God why then they are not Gods daughters what other name shall we giue them for he which is not the childe and sonne of God is the sonne of rebellion the childe of wrath whose father is the Deuill a name saith he better then of sonnes What greater or better name I pray you can wee haue on earth then to bee sonnes and heires of a King except we were Kings And what better or greater name in heauen then to bee Gods sonne and heire without being God The Angels are called e Iob 1.6 2.1 the sonnes of God The Saints are called the sonnes of God he which is the Sonne of God by nature was manifest in the flesh that we might be made the sonnes of God by grace The holy Ghost is sent into our hearts to assure vs that wee are the sonnes of God f Rom. 8.15.16 Ye haue receiued the Spirit of adoption whereby wee cry Abba Father The Spirit it selfe bearâ—th witnesse with our spirit that we are the children of God And there is no name in the Scripture so expresse so significatiue and of so large extent for it comprehends in it all the good that God bestowes on his elect and chosen people vnto whom he giues all his blessings in the name title and state of children and out of this state and condition he giue them no spirituall wholesome and sauing blessing VIII Now we shall finde the true sense and meaning of this place if wee adde thereunto that which goes before and that which followes after which hath been industriously and wittingly omitted by Bellarmine lest it should haue hindred hiâ— bad cause The words going before are Let not the sonne of the stranger that hath ioyned himselfe to the Lord speake saying The Lord hath vtterly separated me from his people neither let the Eunuch say Behold I am a drie tree Here then the stranger and the Eunuch fearing God are ioyned together both of them bewailing their miserie The one because he was separated from Gods people The other because he was a drie tree The Eunuch is first comforted by the wordes of this place whereupon Bellarmine grounds his Counsels The stranger is comforted in the verses following in these words Also the sonnes of the stranger that ioyne themselues to the Lord to serue him and to loue the name of the Lord c. euen them will I bring to my holy mountaine and make them ioyfull in my house of prayer c. The Gentils called by the Prophet the sonnes of the stranger g Ephes 2.12 were at that time without Christ being aliens from the Common-weale of Israel and strangers from the couenants of promise hauing no hope and without God in the world As for the Iewes God made a promise to Abraham their father saying h Gens 22.17 In blessing I will blesse thee and in multiplying I will multiply thy seede as the starres of the heauen and as the sand
greater reward There were certaine heretikes in Saint Austins time g August eâ—â—st 89. quast 4. which taught that a rich man remaining in his possessions and riches cannot enter into the Kingdome of Heauen although he hath done the Commandements of God with his riches Saint Austin answeres and refutes them by the examples of Abraham Isaac and Iacob Our Fathers Abraham Isaac and Iacob that are departed out of this world so long before haue escaped the disputations of these men for all these had nâ— small riches as the most faithfull Scripture witnesseth it and notwithstanding euen he who being truely rich became poore for vs hath foretold by a most true promise h Mat. 8.11 Non supra ipsos vel extra ipsos sed cum ipsis that many shall come from the East and West and shall sit downe in the Kingdome of Heauen not aboue them nor beyond them but with them These words doe minister vnto me a second argument That which being obserued brings not a greater glory then if it were not obserued is no Counsell but to sell all that we haue and giue to the poore procures not a greater glory then is that of Abraham Isaac and Iacob which haue not sold that which they had Therefore to sell what we haue and giue to the poore is not a Counsell The Maior is grounded vpon the definition of a Counsell such a one as is in the Pastorall Letter The minor is of the Scripture witnessing that none shall haue a greater glory then Abraham Isaac and Iacob who haue liued and died abounding in great wealth and substance because as Saint Austin hath obserued They which shall come from the East and West of what qualitie and condition soeuer they be shall be in heauen with them and not beyond them nor before them Therefore the conclusion is necessarie III. Nay furthermore although it were a Counsell all the world may see that the Author of the Pastorall Letter alleageth it against himselfe and ouerthroweth that which he pretends to build by it for if to sell all that we haue is a Counsell of perfection meritorious and worthy of a greater reward and glory why doth he not it himselfe why giues he not ouer his Cardinals Hat why desires he to be called any longer the Prince of the Church with what conscience doth hee possesse and enioy the reuenew of two thousand pounds yeerely why sells hee not all giues not all takes not the scrip and so follow Christ The Pope abounding more in gold and siluer then any King in Christendome the Cardinals whereof some of them are richer then any Prince or Lord in Christendome the Bishops and other Ecclesiasticall persons that are ouerwhelmed in riches and pleasures why doe they not as much Saint Peter of whose succession the Pope boasts i Act. 3.6 had neither siluer nor gold Saint Paul was so poore that k Act. 18.3 20.34 1. Cor. 4.12 1. Thes 2.9 2. Thes 3.8 he got his liuing by making tents The other Apostles were no better at ease l Mat. 19.27 Behold say they vnto Christ we haue forsaken all and followed thee Where shall we finde any of their Bishops which maintaine that they are their successors any one of them that forsaketh his riches to follow Christ who amongst them would be Bishop but to haue riches who amongst them would burden and charge himselfe with that office if that office were not charged with many fat and great benefices These are notwithstanding they who liuing in the world and in pleasure as much as any of the world doe preach pouertie and extreme miserie vnto others like the Pharisees in this point of whom Christ Iesu our Master said m Math. 23.4 They binde heauie burdent and grieuous to bee borne and lay them on mens shoulders but they themselues will not moue them with one of their fingers IIII. As he condemnes himself in alleaging this pretended Counsell as a greater louer of the perishable riches of this world then of the greatest glory of heauen n Mat. 6.20 Where neither moth nor rust doth corrupt and where theeues doe not breake thorow nor steale Euen so he ouerthrowes his cause which he would recommend He threatens with excommunication â— father and a mother that haue opposed themselues that their daughters should not resort nor giue themselues to the Vrselines It must bee a matter of very great importance for the which a man is excommunicated that is to say cut off from the Communion of Saints and deliuered vnto Satan What haue they done They haue laboured to hinder their daughters entring into the Couent of the Vrseline Nunnes Is that a sinne worthie of excommunication He that opposeth himselfe against the obseruation of the Counsels of Christ is worthy of execration I will say with Saint Paul o 1 Cor. 16.22 Let him bee Anathema maranatha I will say vnto him as Saint Paul did to Elymas p Act. 13.10 O full of all subtiltie and all mischiefe thou childe of the deuill thou enemie of all right cousnesse wilt thou not cease to peruert the right waâ—â—s of the Lord But where are these Counsels Behold here one Goe and sell that thou hast c. Is this Counsell giuen to the Vrselines is it followed and done by the Vrselines Do they sell all that they haue to giue to the poore Doe they not take away and conuey their wealth with them into the Cloyster of the Vrselines Doe they not robbe their fathers and mothers and parents by an impious barbarous and cruell deuotion to inrich the Vrselines Are the Vrselines those poore of whom Christ saith and giue it to the poore Here I appeale vnto the conscience of Monkes Is there any of them all that selles all that he hath an giues it to the poore They which begge among them and others become Monks or are often compelled by their fathers and mothers to become Monkes that their goods and patrimonie remaine in the house to entertaine the greatnesse and honour thereof and enrich their eldest brother Others transporte their patrimony with them into the corporation of the Cloister and make good cheare therewith Is that a selling of all that they haue giuing it to the poore Therefore it is a pure mockerie yea they gull the world by preaching so much the Counsel of Christ and couering with so faire a name the hypocrisie of those which doe not Christs words which sell nothing giue nothing to the poore which seeke all meanes to enrich themselues by making many families poore Such are the Iesuites and such would the Vrselines be shortly if men would let them doe it V. I haue sufficiently proued that Christs words to the rich man are no Counsell in the sense wherein this word is taken in this disputation I will make you now see by the true exposition thereof that they are a particular precept giuen vnto this young Lord. The Euangelists doe declare
that wee haue to our neighbour and keepe nothing for our selues but wee keepe this Commandement if we giue partly and retaine in part But Bellarmine dissembleth to say that in the Commandement Thou shalt loue thy neighbour as thy selfe the word As doth not signifie the quantitie measure and rule of our charitie but onely the qualitie thereof for we loue our selues without measure and limit and God will not haue vs to loue our neighbour in this manner Furthermore if the loue we beare to our selues were the rule of our charitie towards our neighbour the common prouerb would be true that charitie begins at her selfe But reason and experience sheweth that to be false for we are bound to loue Father Mother our King our Country the Church of God more then our selues The Scripture saith that Å¿ 1. Cor. 13.5 Charitie seeketh not her owne and according to that giues vs this expresse Commandement t Phil. 2.4 looke not euery man on his owne things but euery man on the things of others wherefore this As is not a marke of equalitie but of similitude and signifies the truth and sinceritie that ought to be in our charitie for as wee loue our selues in truth and without dissimulation or reseruation so ought we to loue our neighbour u 1. Iohn 3.18 not in word neither in tongue but in deede and in truth saith Saint Iohn The rule and measure of our loue towards our neighbour is the loue of Christ towards vs x John 13.34 A new Commandement I giue vnto you that ye loue one another as I haue loued you that yee also loue one another Now his loue consists in this that he died for vs therefore ours also towards our neighbours ought to consist in this if God call vs therevnto y 1. Iohn 3.16 Hereby perceiue we the loue of God because he laid downe his life for vs and we ought to lay downe our liues for the brethren If our liues how much more all our goods that are not so much as our life is Secondly Iesus Christ commanding this rich man to sell all that hee had did not bid him giue all to the poore to become a beggar a vagabond and a wallet bearer for in the Text there is but and giue to the poore Now he could haue giue of his all without giuing all But because Christ would haue made him a Disciple and one of his attendants and followers during the dayes of his flesh and afterwards a Preacher of his Gospell in those places where it would haue pleased him to haue sent him he commands him to ridde himselfe speedily of his possessions that they might not with-hold nor hinder him to follow Gods calling and to giue liberally to the poore but hee commaunds him not to giue them to the poore without reseruing any thing for his need and there is nothing in the Text from whence they can gather any such either Commandement or Counsell Thirdly it is true in generall that charitie requires not of vs that wee giue all we haue to the poore without any reseruation for our selues neither also that wee sell all that we haue for ordinarily this sentence of the Apostle takes place a 2. Cor. 8.13 I meane not that other men be eased and you burthened but by an equalitie But such a time may happen that a man shall be called of God to lay downe not all his goods onely but his life also for his brethren then such a one receiueth of God a true Commandement to doe so if he doth not so he transgresseth the Commandement of God and becomes guiltie before God It is not a generall Commandement to euery man to goe out of his Countrie to serue God and to offer vp to God his children to obey God Notwithstanding this was a particular Commandement giuen to b Genes 12.1.4 Genes 22.2.3 Abraham which Abraham could not haue refused to doe without shewing himselfe an hypocrite without offending God Thus although it be not a generall Commandement of charitie to sell all that wee haue and to giue it all to the poore yet was it a Commandement of charitie particularly giuen and in expresse termes from Christs owne mouth to this young Ruler who for not obeying thereunto is by the Lord declared to be excluded out of the Kingdome of heauen This I say presupposing with the most part that it was inioyned him as well to giue all as to sell all XIIII The other Commandement is And come and follow me expresly added to the first c August epist 89. quaesâ— 4 Deinde addidit veni sequere me ne cuiquam quando haec feâ—â—rit aliquid prodesse existimetur si non sequitur Christum to the end saith S. Austin we think not that it can profit any body when he shall haue done these things when he shall haue sold all that he hath and shall haue giuen it to the poore if he follow not Christ This commandement is tearmed by Bellarmine d Bellar. de Monach c. 9. §. 41.6 Obiection A Counsell of obedience A Counsell saith he and no Commandement because it is giuen but to him to whom it hath been said Goe and sell all that thou hast And this is his sixth obiection whereby hee pretends to proue the obedience which the Monks yeeld and giue to their Abbot Prior Generall or other Superiour Nothing can bee more ridiculous as if an Abbot were Iesus Christ and to follow an Abbot were to follow Christ Iesus said And follow me and did not command this yong man to become a Monke and to ranke himselfe vnder the obedience of an Abbot in a Monasterie Friers Abbots Cloisters and Monasteries were things vnknowne in those times and a long time after To follow Christ is taken diuersly in Scripture Sometimes it is referred to the time onely wherein our Sauiour Christ was in the flesh and to the attendance of his person in which sense he said vnto one of his Disciples that asked him leaue e Mat. 8.22 to goe and buriâ— his father Follow me and let the dead bury their dead and vnto Matthew sitting at the receit of custome f Mat. 9.9 Follow me and he arose and followed him As much said g Iohn 1.43 he vnto Philip. To follow him was to accompany Christ froÌ„ place to place to become his disciple for to be after imployed by him in the ministerie of the holy Gospell Thus all the Apostles except Paul haue followed Christ not by counsell but by expresse commandement Thus would Christ haue had this yong man to haue followed him corporally and accompanie him wheresoeuer hee went And in this manner hee commanded him to follow him not by a commandement common to all men but by a personall commandement directed and giuen but to a few persons For our Sauiour Christ refused to take to his corporall attendance some men that would haue ranked themselues thereunto h Mat. 8.19 A
if it belongs to the father to giue his virgin in marriage or not to giue her in marriage he hath plaied the tyrant to haue handled so rigorously a father and mother that practised on their daughters virgins that lawfull power and authoritie which nature hath giuen vnto them the Scripture hath authorized and the right of Nations hath confirmed vnto them But we will speake of this here below as also of the intention of the Apostle in this Chapter VII The which I will but touch cursarily in this place the Corinthians asked the Apostle if it was expedient for a Christian to marrie He answeres f 1. Cor. 7.1 Now concerning the things where of yee wrote vnto me it is good for a man not to touch a woman calling good that which is commodious profitable and as he himselfe expounds it vers 35. expedient or comely he giues the reason saying that they that marry shall haue trouble in the flesh vers 28. It is therefore good to bee vnmarried by reason of the charges and troubles of marriage and of the disturbance that it bringeth to the free confession of the Gospell in time of persecution as he saith vers 26. I suppose that this is good for the present distresse and necessitie For then the persecutions were so hot and violent that they which were without wife and children were freed from a great burden hauing nothing to care for but Gods seruice and themselues Those during that present necessitie did well not to marrie This is the Apostles aduice yet not absolutely but with a restriction of the gift and vocation of God saying that marriage is necessarie for them that haue not receiued the gift of continencie g 1. Cor. 7.2 Neuertheles to auoide fornication let euery man haue his owne wife and let euery woman haue her own husband Bellarm. saith that it is a Counsell which is against himselfe for if it bee a Counsell to marrie to auoide fornication hee that marrieth to this ende shall haue a greater merit and consequently a greater glory then he that marrieth not But the words are of the imperatiue moode and binde all those which haue not the gift of continencie to marry He repeates them againe and saith If they cannot containe let them marry for it is better to marry then to burne Concerning those that haue the gift of continencie he saith h Vers 8. It is good for them if they abide euen as I yea he commaunds them so to remaine if they feele in themselues that they are called to it of God i Vers 17. As God hath distributed to euery man there is the gift yea as the Lord hath called euery one there is Gods calling so let him walke Now where there is the gift and calling of God to a thing there is a necessitie to doe it and a punishment for him that doth it not k 1. Cor. 7.24 Brethren saith he let euery man wherein hee is called therein abide with God If then a man hath receiued the gift of continencie and is called thereto by God he ought to follow his calling But if he burnes and feeles that the gift is taken away God calles him to marriage It is a Commandement on the one and the other side and not a Counsell VIII The conclusion is added to the one and to the other l 1. Cor. 7.38 So then he that giueth her in marriage doth well but hee that giueth her not in marriage doth better To wit because that this man lookes better to his virgin in not giuing her in marriage in so dangerous and troublesome a time it being presupposed that she haue the gift of continencie then doth that man In like manner the widow m Vers 40. is happier if she so abide happier indeede not towards God who is not moued with these outward things wherein godlinesse consisteth not but in respect of men and of the domesticall life in so much as being a widdow she hath not such care nor so many distractions in the time of persecution as the married woman hath But what serues all this to the cause of the Vrselines and the Counsels of the Monkish life for the father that gaue not his virgin in marriage kept her at home And the widdow remaining so did serue God in her house This ought to be obserued euery where For there is not to bee found any place of Scripture what sense soeuer they coine and make thereof that concludes any thing for the Monkish life and therefore that can be alleaged by them to the purpose in this controuersie CHAP. XIX I. The eight obiection Saint Paul by a worke of supererogation hath preached the Gospell freely and frankely 1. Cor. 9. II. This obiection is nothing to the purpose is false and contrary to all Saint Pauls doctrine III. The true meaning of the Apostles words IIII. In preaching for nothing hee aimed not at any greater perfection and reward in heauen and did nothing but that which he ought to haue done V. The ninth obiection taken out of the Reuelation Chap. 14. touching the hundred foure and fortie thousand virgins VI. This is a fond and vaine obiection and which draweth with it many falsehoodes and inconueniences VII The true exposition of this place according to Origen Ambrose Austin BEllarmine setteth downe his eight obiection The 8 obiection saying a Bellar. de Monach c. 19. §. 61. that Saint Paul in the whole ninth Chapter of his first Epistle to the Corinthians doth indeuour to shew that hee hath done more then he was commanded to doe and therefore hath merited a singular and speciall glory of God for the Lord hauing ordained that they which preach the Gospell should liue of the Gospell Paul had rather preach the Gospell without charge and so doe a worke of supererogation b 1. Cor. 9.15.16.18 It were better for me to die then that any should make my glorying voide for saith he though I preach the Gospell I haue nothing to glorie of for necessitie is laid vpon me and woe vnto me if I preach not the Gospell What is my reward then verily that when I preach the Gospell I may make the Gospell of Christ without charge II. c Iob 15.2.3 Should a wise man vtter vaine knowledge and fill his belly with the East-winde should hee reason with vnprofitable talke or with speeches wherewith he can doe no good Yes for in all his discourse and purpose there is nothing that serues to the purpose whereof the question is For Saint Paul was no Monke nor Frier hee preached not the Gospell gratis and without cost by any counsell hee receiued of the Lord who contrariwise declared that d Mat. 10.10 the workman is worthy of his meat He preached not for nought by any vow For he should haue broken his vow hauing e Phi. 4.15 c. receiued maintenance abundantly of the Philippians f 2. Cor. 11.8 and of
lib. de vera virginitatâ— man euen like God though Saint Basil saith so Virginitie also is not the image and resemblance of Christ as Saint Cyprian affirmeth Holinesse alone makes man like God and this holinesse may be in as great a measure in them which are married in Abraham in Saint Peter in the Brethren of our Lord as in the eleuen thousand Virgins It is vnto the married folkes and not vnto any virgins by Counsell and by Vow that God saith in his Law Yee shall be holy for I am holy b Leuit. 11.44 It is vnto all both married and vnmarried that Peter speakes c 1. Pet. 1.15 As he which hath called you is holy so be yee holy in all manner of conuersation and the image of Christ consisteth in d Colos 3.10 knowledge e Ephes 4.24 righteousnesse and true holinesse saith Saint Paul and this knowledge righteousnes and true holinesse hath been as great in Adam and Eue in Noe in Abraham and Sarah in Isaac and Rebecca in Iacob and Rachel in Moses with whom God spake face to face and who hath had testimonie Numb 12.3 to haue been very meeke aboue all the men which were vpon the face of the earth in Ioshue g Iudg. 4.4 in Deborah the wife of Lapidoth and notwithstanding a Prophetesse in Samuel in Dauid in Iosias in h 2. Chro. 34.22 Huldah the Prophetesse the wife of Shallum in Isaiah and his wife who also was i Jsai 8.3 a Prophetesse in the k 1. Cor. 9.5 Brethren of our Lord in Cephas and the other Apostles which did leade with them their wiues and it may be yet as great as it hath euer been as it can be euer in any virgin or vnmarried person l Deut. 10.17 Act. 10.34 God is no respecter of persons m Iob 34.19 for they all great and little married and vnmarried are the worke of his hands If it were otherwise if virginitie were the image of Christ the Vestall virgins should haue been like vnto Christ n Clement Alexand strom .. lib. 3. Qâ—â—â— et 〈…〉 à cibis veâ—ere abstâ—â—ent Certe Magis quoque curae est qui angelos daemones colunt simul à vino animatis rebus abstinere venereis They which adore idols saith Clement doe abstaine from meates and carnall lust now the Apostle saith that the Kingdome of God is not meate and drinke surely the Sorcerers which adore the Angels and the Diuels doe abstaine altogether from wine from liuing things and from women Where shall we finde any in the most austere Cloister which doe as much The Fathers then haue mistaken when they haue established the image and resemblance of God in that which was to bee found in the Heathen and is to be found in these daies among the Turkes with a great deale more excesse of seueritie then among all the Monkes of Christendome IX The third example is of the beginning of the Primitiue Church Pag. 11. for our Author of the Pastorall Letter saith This Counsell had so penetrated and passed through in the beginning of Christianitie as Saint Iâ—rome obserues it eloquently vpon the Acts of the Apostles Post crucem Christi statim vna domus Philippi quadrigam producit virginum filiarum That after the Crosse of Christ presently the house of Philip yeelds foure daughters virgines X. What could the Author of the Pastorall Letter haue alleaged worse against his cause and intention he hath heretofore spoken of an Euangelicall Counsell recommending single life and voluntarie pouertie and now he speakes of o Act. 21.8.9 Philip the Euangelist keeping house in Cesarea married and hauing his daughters with him in his house Philip then hath not kept the Euangelicall Counsels and hath not been lesse perfect for all that I hope then the perfectest Monke or Frier Secondly hee will proue that the daughters ought to leaue father and mother and withdraw themselues into a Monasterie to keepe there their virginitie and that the fathers and mothers ought to consent thereunto and hee sets vs downe the example of foure daughters virgines dwelling in their fathers house and liuing there as Christianly as any cloisterly Nunne Thirdly hee presupposeth against the truth of the historie that these maides haue perseuered in their virginitie al their life time For the Scripture saith it not and Clemens Alexandrinus saith the coÌ„trary writing against the hereticks hertofore meÌ„tioned and asking them p Clemens Alexand strom lib. 3. An etiam reprobant Apostolos Petrus enim Philippus filios procrearunt Philippus autem filias quoque suas viris tradidit Euseb lib. 3. Eccles hist cap. 27. Doe they reproue the Apostles also for Peter and Philip haue begot children and Philip hath giuen his daughters in marriage They were then virgins when Saint Paul passed by that way but they ceased to be virgins when they were maried Bellarmine answereth q Bellar. de monach c. 10. §. 2. that we ought to beleeue that they haue beeue perpetually virgins and by election because that Saint Luke relates that as a great matter to wit that one man had foure daughters virgines Now what great matter is it to haue foure daughters virgines which being mariageable did marrie But Saint Luke recites not as a great matter that Philip had foure daughters virgines but that he had foure daughters virgins r Act. 21.9 which did prophesie A thing recommendable and worthy to be registred to posteritie that one man hath had in his house foure daughters virgins which being Prophetesses the prophesie of the Prophet Ioel hath been fulfilled Å¿ Joel 2.28 your sonnes and your daughters shall prophesie XI The last example is of the Church in the time of Cypriaâ— and Iustine Martyr Cyprian saith of his time t Cypri de habitu virg The world is filled with those which can comprehend continencie which liue like Eunuches for the Kingdome of God u Iustin Apolog 2. Iustin elder then hee faith Surely many of the one and of the other sexe of sixtie and seuentie yeeres of age remaine Eunuches and Virgines and in this state haue kept the discipline of Iesus Christ euen from their youth vp and I glory that I can shew such among all the sexes of those of our religion Behold the first fruites of the Gospell saith our Author of the Pastorall Letter Pag. 11. XII The fruit of the Gospell is the fruit of the Spirit x Gal. 5.22.23 loue ioy peace long-suffering gentlenesse goodnesse faith meekenesse temperance c. Of these fruits are not virginitie nor marriage but chastitie in the one and in the other state is a true fruite of the Spirit and is comprehended vnder the vertue Temperance Iustin and Cyprian say not that virginitie is a fruit of the Gospell for that which is common to Christians and Heathens is not of the Gospell but they recommend those which in so wofull a time wherein the