But to those wordes of our Sauiour S. Basill doth aunswere saying Nihil aliud ijs recepi verbis intelligi Bas in Ethicis quam quod humanis traditionibus ad mandatum Dei reprobandum obsequendum non sit that nothinge else is meante by those wordes then that wee ought not obey such traditions as are repugnant to Godes lawes as many obseruations of the Iewes and alsoe of the pharisies were then and the like traditions of heretiques are nowe yet we ought to obey the custome of the church otherwise wee should be counted by the wordes of Christe as Ethnicks and Publicans But the traditions deliuered to vs by the pastors and fathers thereof which are the foundation of our faith and which are not repugnant to Godes precepts nor to his lawes or scriptures but doe rather confirme the same are not meant by those wordes for Godes worde doth not consiste onlie of the scripture Vppon what occasion heraesie did growe but also of tradition for such as were old heretiques did not gainsaie the written word but because they did not beleue the tradition of the church and the definition thereof they were soe counted and accursed 2. That the sonne is of the same substance with the father the catholique fathers haue defined by godes word but because the heretiques did not finde the same written they would not beleue the church which did grant it was nor written but deliuered by tradition Soe as you may see the difference betwixt the heretique and the catholique Felix Pontifex writinge to Benignum 130. yeares before the councell of Nyce saith that it was an Apostolicall tradition that the sonne was of one substance with the father and that the holie Ghoast is to be adored as the father and the sonne and that he is of the same substance with the father and when the same heretiques did aske where it was written the church did answere them that it was deliuered vnto them by tradition which two pointes continued afterwardes by the 2. councell of Nyce and Constinople Articles of faith by traditions Also in the councell of Ephesus that the blessed Virgin Marie should be called the mother of God In the councell of chalcedon that there are two natures in Christe In the 3. councell of Constantinople that there are in him two wills and two operations In the second councell of Nyce against heretiques that the church should vse Images In the generall councell of florence that the holy ghoast proceedeth from the father and the sonne And when heretiques did relie all vpon the scripture the catholique fathers did conuince their interpretation of scriptures by tradition of the successiue doctors and fathers in all ages The tradition also that easter daye should be obserued vpon the sondaie next after vnto the 14. daie of the new Moone as some doe write S. Peter and S. Paule ordained so as in all pointes of doctrine wee recurr to the tradition of our ancestors and when you teache that all thinges are â—on by necessitie not by the free will of man wee recurr vnto the successiue age and wee find out that the first author was Symon magnus next vnto him was Marcion next vnto Marcion was Manichaeus next vnto him was Petrus Adelhardus Next vnto him was Iohn Wicklief Next after whome followed your great master Martyne Luther so that we find in all antiquitie of tymes that this doctrine was detested by the holy doctors that liued in those ages 3. Againe when you obiect vnto vs your tradition of your imputatiue iustice where you say that our faith is imputed vnto vs by the iustice of Christ as if it had bene our owne iustice as also that euery one vnder paine of damnation is bounde to beleue Tradition of protestantes and to be certaine that his sinnes be forgiuen him that he should not mistrust his proper infirmitie therein also that not any one is iustified but he that beleues for certaine that he is iustified and that his iustification and absolution of his sinnes is effected by faith onlie without any relation to the Sacraments and that euerie one is bound to beleue that he is in the number of those that are predestinated and that by all infallible certitude he hath the guifte of perseuerance to be the true seruante of God vnto the last gaspe of his life this and such like wee can not find in the scriptures nor in the fathers nor in the doctors of the churche but rather the contrarie and that which the holie catholique churche calles pennaunce All things peruerted by the protestants you call terror of conscience and that which she calles Sacraments and sacrifice you call it the Lords supper wee search the fathers and wee can finde noe such wordes and although somtimes they make mention of the supper yet more often doe they call the same a sacrifice Did not S. Paule wish Timothy to keepe his depositum to auoide the prophane nouelties of voices and oppositions of false tearmed knowledge For the scripture is not subiecte to loftie skill or arrogant or presumptuous mindes who I pray hath greater skill or knowledge and vnderstandinge of the scriptures then the deuilles and yet it auaileth them nothinge because their mindes are possessed with malice and their hartes are emptie of charitie soe as men doe not sinne so much by the ignorance of the vnderstanding as by the malice of the will Aug. de doctrina Christi an cap. 35. and accordinge to S. Augustine the summe scope of all the scriptures is charity whosoeuer saith he that seemes to vnderstaÌ„d the scripture or any parcell thereof soe that his vnderstandinge doth not edifie that knott I meane the loue of God and our neigbors he hath not as yet vnderstoode the scriptures 4. Now all your manner of administration and ministerie is your owne tradition and inuention without scripture or warrant of godes worde but the traditions of the Apostles and ancients and all the preceptes of holie churche were comauÌ„ded to be kepte and they are not prescribed by man only but are made by the holie ghoast ioyninge with our pastors in the regimente of the faithfull Luc. 2.37 Matt. 18. where Christe saith he that heareth you heareth me and he that despiseth you despiseth me they are made by our mother the churche which whosouer obeieth not wee are warned to take him as a heathen 2. Cor. 3. S. Paule willed the people to keepe the decrees that were decreede by the Apostles and auncientes at Ierusalem he commaunded the people to keepe the precepts of the Apostles You are saith he written in our hartes not written with Incke but with the finger of the holy ghost S. Paule wrote many thinges not vttered in any epistle as some of the Apostles wrote the christian religion in the hartes of their hearers Wherfore Ireneus saith Iren. l. 3.4 what if the Apostles also had lefte noe scriptures ought wee not to followe
both a sacrifice and a Sacrament fol. 286 CHAP. III. Whether the Catholique Church commit offence in leaning to the litterall sense of Christs wordes in the blessed Sacrament of the Altar fol. 318 Lib. VI. CHAP. I. That there is a purgatory which is proued aswell by Scriptures and auncient Fathers as also euen by testimonies of Protestants themselues fol. 350 CHAP. II. Touching the Popes Authority in releasinge of soules out of purgatory fol. 359 CHAP. III. Whether it be against the lawe of God to forbid Priestes to marry and whether vowes and votaries are rather the inuentiōs of men then the ordinance of God fol. 363 CHAP. IV. Whether we ought to confesse our sinnes to priests and whether that priests cannot remitt or forgiue them fol. 372 CHAP. V. Whether fasting from one sorte of meate more then from another or for to vse any obseruation therein be superstitious according as protestants doe affirme fol. 377 Lib. VII CHAP. I. Whether the Protestant assertion be true which affirmeth that generall councells can erre fol. 386 CHAP. II. That the catholique church in those things shee doth propound to the christians to beleeue whether they be contained in the Scriptures or not cannot erre fol 395 CHAP. III. Whether Catholiques are to be charged with arrogancie for thinking that their church cannot faile fol. 396 CHAP. IV. That this Church which shall neuer be hid but remaine visible is manifest by the parable of Christ our Lord. fol. 402 CHAP. I. Li. VIII Whether that papistes doe amisse in hauinge their churches and monasteries soe sumptuous their alters and ornamentes so riche and ecclesiasticall possessions so great the poore wanting the same fol. 407 CHAP. II. Of the vnhappy endes and other punishments by which God doth chastice those that presume to robb Churches or otherwise to prophane and abuse sacred things fol. 416 CHAP. III. A prosecution of the last chapter fol. 426 CHAP. IV. Whether the kinge may take away church liuinges at his pleasure And whether as he is absolute kinge of the temporall goodes of his subiects he be so also of the Churche churche liuinges fol. 440 Lib. IX CHAP. I. That the protestant religion whose principall foundation and groundes are these articles aforesaid is nothing else then a denyinge of all Religion and piety and a renewinge of all heresies fol. 447 CHAP. II. That no iot or sillable of Christian religion ought to be counted a thinge indifferent or of smale moment and that whosoeuer doth not agree with the Catholique church in all pointes of beleefe cannot be saued fol. 459 CHAP. III. That the new Religion for that it takes away all religion is worse then that of the Turckes and Gentiles fol. 452 Lib. X. CHAP. I. An answer vnto Protestants barking against the religious institutions of holy Orders saying that religious vocations were not instituted by our Sauiour fol. 467 CHAP. II. That the Apostles and their followers in the primitiue church followed this estate of perfection fol. 473 CHAP. III. Of the increase of religious orders and how the same continued from time to time vntill our dayes fol. 476 CHAP. IV. That preestes in the primitiue churh euen from the Apostles time were religiouse and obserued religious order of life fol. 486 CHAP. V. Of the multitude of religious persons fol. 491 CHAP. VI. Of many great and eminent men who forsooke and contemned the world to become religious fol. 499 CHAP. VII Of Emperors Kinges and Princes who forsooke the world to become religious fol. 504 CHAP. VIII Of Empresses Queenes and Princes who likewise forsooke the world to become religious fol. 518 CHAP. IX How greatly religious people fructify vnto God and to his Church and that they are the best labourers which are therein fol. 525 Lib. XI CHAP. I. The name of those that suffred death by the Gewses of Flanders where the protestantes are soe called fol. 534 CHAP. II. Certaine cruell and bloody factes committed in Fraūce against the Catholikes by those that the vulgar sorte doe cal Hugonotes from the tyme that they stirred rebellion against the kinge Anno 1562 fol. 544. A Catalogue of those that suffered death as wel vnder king Henry as Queene Elizabeth and king Iames from the yeare of our Lord 1535. and 27. of king Henryes raigne vnto the yeere 1620. fol. 555 CHAP. III. A Compendiū of the martyrs and confessors of Ireland vnder Queene Elizabeth fol. 569 Lib. XII CHAP. I. Euery sect of heresies challinging vnto thēselues the trewe and Catholique church there is here set downe the true notes and markes by which the same may be discerned fol. 587 CHAP. II. That there are many excellencies and effectes which should allure euery one to follow and imbrace the Catholique religion And contrariwise many inconueniences and blasphemies which the new religion houldeth and teacheth The first excellencies fol. 609 CHAP. III. The 2. excellency is the pure and hollie doctrine which it professeth fol. 610 CHAP. IV. The 3. Excellencie is most diuine Sacraments which confer grace fol. 613. CHAP. V. The 4. Excellencie is to fauor the good and to punish the wicked fol. 616. CHAP. VI. The 5. Excellencie is the conuersion of all nations vnto Christe and driuing Idolatrie out of the world ibid. CHAP. VII The 6. Excellencie of the catholique Religion is that the same is proued and auerred by so many good witnesses as sacred and learned doctors blessed saincts martyrs and generall counsells fol. 617. APPROBATIO Hic Liber cui Titulus The Theater of Catholicke and Protestant Religion nihil continet quod fidei vel moribus aduersatur quin potius multa quae tam ad fidem Catholicam stabiliendam quam ad haereses huius temporis impugnandas optimè inseruiunt Matthaeus Kellisonus S. Theol. Doct. WHETHER THE RELIGION WHlCH Protestants professe be a new Religion or whether the Romish Religion be new and that of the Protestant be ancient and ould CHAPTER I. 1. IF Protestants were of sound iudgment or nott distracted of their wittes they would neuer suppose much lesse auerre so manifest an vntruth as that the religion of the church of Rome is a new religion or defend an absurditie so egregious as Protestant religion to be the more auncient Wherfore this first assertion being so euident and knowen an vntruth such as doe follow are the lesse to be beleeued 2. It is well knowen that before these 80. or 100. yeares all Christendome did imbrace the catholike Roman religion so that it was terra vnius labii Gen. 11. Act. 4. as it is written in Genesis a countrie of one language and one speeche and as we reade of the christians in the Actes of the Apostles that first beleeued in Christ that they were of one hart and of one accord and as one God was honored and worshipped of all soe one faith was embraced of all they obserued one order of administration of the Sacraments they vsed and kepte one obseruation of ceremonies all were called Christians
the order of the tradition which was then deliuered vnto them to whome they comitted the church to the which many nations of those barbarous people that haue beleeued in Christe doe consente without letter or inke hauinge saluation written in in their hartes and keepinge diligentlie the tradition of our elders and soe S. Hier. saith cont Heres 9. The creede of our faith and hope which beinge deliuered by tradition from the Apostles is not written in paper and Incke but in the tables of the hearte and this is in the church booke also wherby wherein shee keepeth faithfully all trueth in the hartes of those to whome the Aposles did preach And therfore S. Paule saith 2. Thes 2.15 Brethren stande hold the tradition which you haue learned whether it be by worde or by epistle not only the thinges written and sett downe in the hollye scriptures but all other truethes and pointes of religion vttered by worde of mouthe and deliuered and giuen by the Apostles to their schollers And so S. Basil saith thus I accompte it Apostolique tradition to continue firmlie euen in vnwritten traditions and to proue this he alleadgeth this place of saint Paule â—n the same booke cap. 17. and saith if wee once goe aboute to reiecte vnwritten customes as thinges of no importance wee shal ere wee beware endamadge the principall partes of our faith and bringe the preachinge of the ghospell to a naked name and so example of these necessarie traditioÌ„s he named the signe of the Crosse prayinge towardes the easte the wordes spoken at the eleuation or shewinge of the holy Euchariste with diuers ceremonies vsed before and after baptisme with three immersions in the fonte the wordes of abrenunciation and exorcismes of the partie that is to be baptised and what scripture saith he taught these and such like None trulie all cominge by secret and silent traditions c. S. Hierome reckneth vpp diuers such like traditions Hieron in dialogo Lucife c. 4. epist com Luci 28. willinge men to attribuit to the Apostles such customes as the Church hath receaued by Christians of diuers Countrie 5. S. August ad Genn saith Let vs holde faste those thinges that are not written but are deliuered vnto vs which beinge generally obserued in all places of the worlde wee must thincke them to come from the Apostles or from the generall councells which oughte to be of greate authoritie in the churche of God and whosoeuer will dispute hereof ought to be counted of most insolent madnes S. Hier. ad Luc. wee must obserue the traditions of our Ancestors S. Paule comaunded vs to submitt our selues to our pastors and teachers S. Augustine saith wee learne by tradition that children in their infancie shoulde be baptized de gen ad liter 101. 23. Tradition caused him to beleeue that the baptized of heretiques should not be rebaptized by tradition onlie he and others condemned Heluidius the heretique for denyinge the perpetuall virginitie of our Ladie and without this noe Arrian noe Macedonian noe Pelagian noe Caluin will will yealde Wee must vse tradition saith Epiph for the scripture hath not all thinges and therfore the Apostles deliuered certaine thinges by tradition S. Iren. lib. 3. 14. saith that in all questions wee must haue recourse to the traditions of the Apostles teachinge vs withall that the waie to true apostolicall tradition and to bringe it to the fountaine is by the apostolicall succession of Bishoppes but especially of the apostolicall church of Rome declaring in the same place that there are manie barbarous people simple for learninge but for constancie in the faith moste wise which neuer had scriptures but learned onlie by tradition Tert. lib de corn reckoneth vpp a great number of christian obseruations or customes as S. Cyprian in mannie places doth whereof in fine he concludethe of such and such If thou require the rule of scriptures thou shalt finde none tradition shal be alleadged the author custome the confirmer and faith of the obseruer Orig. he mil. 5. proueth the same Dyonisius Areopag referreth the oblation and prayinge for the death in the lyturgie or Masse to an Apostolicall tradition Soe doth Tertull Aug. Chrys Damasc alleadge Also wee mighte add that the scriptures themselues euen all the bookes of the Byble be giuen vs by tradition else should wee not take them as they be indeede for the infallible worde of God noe more then the worcks of S. Ignat. S. Aug. S. Dion and the like 6. The true sense alsoe of the scriptures which Catholiques haue and heretiques haue not remayneth still in the Church by tradition the Creede is an Apostolicall tradition Ruff. in expo simb ad principium Hier. Epist. 61. cap. 9. Ambr. ser 38. Aug. de Simb ad Cath. lib. 3. cap. 1. Alsoe it is by tradition wee hould that the holie Ghost is God therfore Macedonius was condemned in the 2. Naz. lib. â— Theol. councell of Constantinople for an heretique for that he denyed the same because in the scripture this name is not giuen vnto him for in the scriptures manny thinges are said to be such by Metaphors which are not soe indeede as that God is a sleepe that he is angrie that he is sorrye although noe such thinge is in God as alsoe manny thinges that are such and yet are not mentioned in the scriptures God to be ingenitus with manny such attributes as Trinitie parson consubstantialitie hypostasis vnto hypostatica homousion and because the Arrians did not yelde vnto the same not findinge them in the scriptures they were in the councell of Nyce condemned for heretiques And althoughe the verie wordes be not in the scripture yet they be collected of the sence of the scriptures And soe S. Cyrill Cyrill l. 1. dialogoruÌ„ de trinit of that place of scripture Ego sum qui sum I am the same that is doth gather that the sonne is consubstantiall with the father although the worde consubstantiall is not founde in the scriptures So the catholique Church in all ages out of the sense of the scripture doth gather that wee oughte to pray vnto Sainctes to pray for the deade that there is a Purgatorie althoughe the verie wordes themselues be not there And when S. Paule did speake of the holy Eucharist he broughte noe scriptures to proue it I haue receaued of our Lord saith he that I deliuered vnto you he alleadged nothinge but tradition which he had receaued from our Lorde that a woman ought not teache in the Churche that a womaÌ„n ought to be couered that the man oughte to be bareheadded that the Bishoppe ought to be husband of one wife he alleadginge nothinge but the custome if any man would be captious or contentious he did oppose against theÌ„ the custome of the Churche saying wee haue noe such custome nor the Church of God and whosoeuer despiseth these thinges he doth not despise man but God And therfore wee are referred by the holie
and euer shining bringing forth the holy of holies Thou ô h S. Greg. in 1. Reg. mountaine which far surpassest in height all height of creatures Thou i Rup lib. 3. in cant in heauen the queene of Sainctes in earth the queene of Kingdomes Finallie thou art she then which k S. Chry. ser de Natiuit nothing was euer seene more noble or more excellent thou art she who only surpassest heauen and earth what can be more holie then thou Not Prophets not Apostles not Martyrs not Patriarkes not Angels not Dominations not Seraphins not Cherubins nor any thing amongst the visible or inuisible creatures can be found more excellent then thou ô Marie for thou art his mother who was begotten of his father before all begininges Will we know therfore how far thou excellest all celestiall powers These with feare and trembling stand hiding their face but thou doost offer vp mankind vnto him whome thou hast begotten by whom we obtaine the pardon of our offences I therfore thy humble and most vnworthy suppliant doe here present and offer vnto thy protection this worke and labor though far vnworthy of thy patronage beseeching thee that through thy fauorable assistance O most glorious virgin it may serue for the reclayming of deceaued soules into the sheepfould of Iesus Christ for the confusion of Heretiques and consolation of Catholiques for the detection of falsitie and aduancement of verity and lastlie for the greater honor and glory both of thee and of thy B. Sonne our Lord and Sauiour Iesus to whom with the Father the Holy Ghost be honor and glory world without end Amen THE PREFACE TO THE READER 1. A Certaine Protestant gentle Reader quassinge and caurroussinge in a place cried out against the Pope which is a custome nowe a dayes aswell with the meanfest as with the greatest cheefest personages hauing their ministers at their elbowe when they are at meate to sclander the Pope Priestes and Catholikes I woulde they had read and obserued the verse of S. Augustine Quisquis amat dictis absentum rodere vitam Hanc mensam vetitam nouerit esse sibi Who soe speakes ill of those that absent be Forbidden is this tables companie But these men when they are in their greatest dissolution then they raile against religion which should bridle and restraine them from their riotous and wanton excesse This partie being reproued by a certaine Catholike gentleman that was at the boorde began presently to defend his liberty and licentiousnes by holy scripture and by the wordes of our Sauiour mistaken ill applied answered that whatsoeuer enteretd into the belly doth no harme to the soule but that which cometh from the harte This is noe newe practise in the malignant Church as Eusebius saith of the Heretike Cerinthus who because he was giuen to the bellye and beastly pleasures framed holy scripture accordinge to his sensualitie as this protestant alleadged Scripture against fastinge and began to prouoke the Gentleman to dispute with him who answered him that it was not his part to reason or iudge of holy Scripture being soe mysticall and so far exceedinge his capacity especially in such disordered places amoungest the cuppes the fruite whereof would rather tende to confusiō then to edificatiō or deuotiō The Protestante replyed that if any man could answeare to his demaundes or questions at the full and satisfie him truly and effectually he would become Catholike the Gentleman said he would doe his endeuour to propounde such demaundes to others and soe he went vnto the cheefest protestants of that place who haue sett downe these challenges deliuered thē vnto the said gent. who deliuered them vnto me beinge in one house with him 2 These propositions were nothinge else but the old heresies of auncient hereticks and were long since condemned and anathematized by the auctority of the Catholike Churche in all ages wherein those heretikes did springe vp As by S. Peter against Simon Magus By Liberius the Pope S. Athanasius and S. Hillary against Arrius By S. Damasus S. Gregory Nazianzen S. Basil against Macedonius By S. Celestinus Pope and S. Cyrill of Alexandria against Nestorius By S. Leo against Eutiches By Irenus against Valentine By Tertulian against Marcion By Origine against Celsus By S. Cyprian against Nouatus By S. Hierom against Heluidius Iouinian Vigilantius Luciferans By S. Augustine against Donatists Pelagians By Agath against Montolistes By Tarasius against Imadge breakers By Lanfrancus Guitmundus and Algerius against Beringarius By Petrus Cluniacensis against Henricians and Petrobrusians and against Adelhard By S. Bernard against Thomas Waldensis and Witcleefe By the Bushoppe of Rochester as well by his bookes as by his blood against Luther and Zuinglius By Kinge Henry the 8. himselfe against the said Luther whose booke I haue Finally by soe many generall Councells of the world in all ages and by the most famous generall Councell of Trente which sate vpon this matter the space of 16. yeares 3. Touching the aforesaid propositions truly ◠was loath though earneastly entreated by the Gentleman to trouble myselfe to answere them and that for many causes First for that Protestantes are voide of all humility whose religion is nothing elce thē a peruerse and self-wild denial of religiō neuer learning the trueth simply but oppugning it wilfully The second because whatsoeuer Protestants write they doe it not nether for gods sake or for their owne edification but for the destruction and confusion of others as Luther himselfe their Author did confesse disputinge with Eckius who said that it was not for godes sake he tooke that matter in hande and therfore none more maleparte or sawcie then they be Osuis lib. 1. de here Sur. hist Anno. 1519. Beza in pref noui testam An 1565. Tom. 2. Lib. 3. Regem Angliae to 5 ad Galat. c. 3. Beza act c. 10. in pref noui test Mus in locis cōmunib c. 10. Bren. in Apolo conf wittenb c. de cōcil Calu. de vera eccl reformat Musc de comm loc c. de ministrat inter prep locor commu Martyr de votis Illir pref noui testa Pet. in pref 1. cor Humfred in vit Iuelli par 212. Calu. in pref instit ad Regem Galli Martyr de votis pag. 566. 10. res Camp 5. ratio Beza exempla Theologica for they denie all groundes of disputation all traditions of the Apostles Doctors Councells and testimonie of holy Martyres For as when S. Augustine and the holy Doctors of the Church reasoned with the Donatists Arrians Maniches and others and vrged them with the aucthoritie of godes Church with the iudgmente of the sea Apostolique with the succession of Bishoppes in the same with the Councells and finallie with the name Catholike those heretikes quite reiected all those groundes and meanes of tryall euen so Luther the captaine and ringleader of these late heretiques said I set not by a thousande Augustines and a thousand Cyprians alleadged
the body in which it is norished a certaine disease that doth penetrate the intralles and doth corrupt and infest the soules of Christians and not only doth kill with her touche as the Viper doth or with her sighte as the Basilike or with her belching as the dragon but after all these fashions and many more doth destroy confounde and cast away all that approache it neither is there any other remedie but to flie nor any other refuge then to departe from such a one as is intangled with it no other security then to be far from such an infernall and contagious mischeefe which with the name of Christe destroieth Christ in our hartes and vnder the pretence of faith destroyeth faith And S. Augustine saith let euery Catholike flie and abhor them with whom the Church communicateth not for we ought not saieth he to haue parte with them that haue no participation with themselues and which are not vnited to the body of the whole Church and to conclude with our Sauiour one should neuer otherwise accompte of them then as of heathens and publicans and his holy Euangelist S. Iohn forbiddeth vs to salute them 11. Therfore gentle Reader these be sufficiēt reasons wherfore we should be loath to dispute with Protestantes which through their fall from godes Church are voide of all humility intoxicated with pride and are so blinded with malice that they cannot learne or imbrace the trueth or haue any trewe wisdome For as the holly scripture saith into a malicious soule wisdome shall not enter For in all ciuill conuersation or disputation especially in matters of religion we should intend nothinge els but the consolation of our soules and the edification of our neighbours and as the Apostle saith Non nosmetipsos sed Iesum Christum praedicamus not our selues or our owne glory should we ayme at but that of Christ Iesu whose cote without seame is rente in peeces by so many wilfull inuēted opinions of protestāts whose mysticall body I meane his Church is despised forsaken persecuted the fruite of whose doctrine and the proiect of their strange deuises tendes to nothinge els then to shake the very pillars stroungest foundations and fortresses of all Christianity and at lenght to bringe in all coldnes and doubtfulnesse in our beleefe and misbeleefe in the principaleste misteries in our Catholike religion plaine Athesime and confusion of all Christian piety a gate for all disorders and dissolution of life and manners a shipwreacke of Conscience and other marckable and sutable effectes to their doctrine and behauiour which are practised by them daily in all places where they beare sway And although euery man as S. Naz. saith may thinke of God but not euery man dispute of him so euery man ought not to dispute or doubte of the cheefest misteries of Catholike religion but beleeue them simply with the vniuersall Church which is accordinge the Apostle the firmamente and foundation of trueth and therfore can not in any sorte deceaue vs. Lib. I. CHAPTER I. WHether the Religiō which Protestants professe be a newe Religion or whether the Romish Religion be new and that of the Protestants be ancient and ould CHAPTER II. The occasion of Luthers and of other heretiques fal from the Catholike Church fol. 13 CHAPTER III. By what deceite hypocrisie and dissimulation this heresie crept in to other Countries by what periurie and forgerie they were deluded by it and what destruction and desolation it brought with it fol. 21 CHAPTER IV. That heresies are the cause of Reuolutiō of Countries and destruction of state fol. 30 CHAPTER V. A prosecution of the laste Chapter that heresies are the causes of troubles and disquiettnes fol. 49 CHAPTER VI. That God doth extende the rodde of his wrath vpon Princes and common welthes infected with heresies fol. 43 CHAPTER VII Of the miserable death and endes of such as deuised and defended the protestant Religion as also other heresies fol. 61 Lib. II. CHAPTER I. Whether there be nothing that the Protestantes affirmatiuely beleeue confesse and professe but the Church of Rome doth beleeue the same and cannot be denied by Catholiques but that they are most auncient and consonant to the word of God fol. 71 CHAPTER II. A further Confirmation that these new ghospellers tende directly to Turcisme f. 83 CHAPTER III. Whether Papist Priestes do amisse in taking any thinge for their Masses fol. 86 CHAPTER IV. Of prayinge vnto Saints And whether the Church doth offend in praying vnto them fol. 91 CHAPTER V. Whether Papistes doe err in worshipping and adorning the reliques of Saints whether they sell their Masse and praiers for tēporall gaine fol. 102 CHAPTER VI. Whether Papists do commit Idolatrie in worshipping the Crosse of Iesus Christ f. 129. Lib. III. CHAPTER I. Whether Papistes blaspheme against God in sayinge that any man can merite fol. 150 CHAPTER II. Protestants say that a Christian though neuer so vertuous or so acceptable to God hath no grace or vertue inherent in him because they would haue no good acte to come from man by reason of that grace fol. 157 CHAP. III. In that heretiques reprehend the Catholique Church yea cōdemne her of great folly for endeuouring her selfe to receaue godes graces they by this meane take away free will from man and all due preparation and disposition to receaue godes grace and diuine influence fol. 161 CHAP. IV. Whether we derogate from the merites of Christ in making our merites partakers of his merits fol. 169 CHAP. V. The absurdity of this doctrine that euerie one should assure himselfe that he it predestinated vnto life euerlasting and that we ought to be as certaine thereof as we should not once feare the contrary or to misdoubt the same is discussed fol. 186 Lib. 4. CHAP. I. Whether the holy scriptures be for Protestantes and not for Papistes and whether we rely vpon traditions not warranted by holy Scripture fol. 193 CHAP. II. Whether euery man ought to be iudge of the scripture and rely altogether vpon his owne iudgement touching the interpretation therof being inspired by the holly ghost concerning the same fol. 208 CHAP. III. How heretiques would faine take away all tradition alleadging for their purpose that of S. Math. 15. In vaine you worship me teaching for doctrine mens precepts fol. 213 CHAP. IV. Certaine obiections answered against traditions taken out of the first Chapter of S. Paule to the Galathians fol. 231 CHAP. V. Whether we prohibit the scriptures to be translated into the vulgar tounge fol. 234 CHAP. VI. Whether we forbid the ignorante to pray in a languadge which they vnderstand f. 240 CHAP. VII Whether a man ought not to pray either by himselfe or by another but in a language he vnderstandeth fol. 251 Lib. V. CHAP. I. Whether the Church vniuersall can be charged with errors contrary to the first institution of the blessed Sacrament of the Eucharist fol. 259 CHAP. II. Whether the Catholique Church doth add to this Sacrament in making it
so other doctors doe speake to this effect 7. Caluine your cheefe prophet when he oppugneth our religioÌ„ he saith plainly Calu. l. 2. instit 2. parag 2. se toti â—ntiquitati repugnaturum That he opposeth himselfe against all antiquitie saith that he will admitt no auncient Father but S. Augustine And in another place he reprehendes S. Augustine himselfe for sainge that our willes doe cooperate with the grace of God For God made all thinges perfecte Lib. 2. c. 3. in coÌ„plete order but innouatioÌ„ came by the diuell Wee read in the ghospell that after the good seede was sowen by God Matt. 13. the diueâ—l did sowe darnell cockle euen so after the trewe christian religion was sowen by the Apostolicall and catholicke Pastors in euery place of the worlde the enemy of mankinde by Martyn Luther an Augustine Frier did sowe and teach the darnell of absurde daungerous and damnable heresies anno 1517. beinge the first author of the protestant religion So wee knowe the author of the Arrian heresie to be one Arrius a Priest of AlexaÌ„dria in Egypte anno 324. Of the Nestorian heresie to be Nestorius Archbishop of Constantinople who taught his heresie in Thrasia anno 431. as the other also haue taughte the one in Egypte first the other in Saxonie afterwardes Wee knowe the author of the catholicke religion to be Christe from whence wee are called christians in all ages before Luther first inuented the name of Papistes for that wee obey and embrace Christs vicar generall our holy Father the Pope the successor of S. Peter vnto whom Christ committed the regimente of his church feedinge of our soules and the charge of his flocke Matt. 16. This christian religion was first preached in Iurie the 15. Ioan. vlt. yeare of Tyberius Cesar as alsoe wee knowe that the same was oppugned and gainsaid first by the Scribes and Pharises afterwardes by the Gentyles and with all penall statutes of forcible lawes made by the Romaine Emperours other potentates of the worlde which were practised and put in execution for the space of 300. yeares to supplant and deface the same This christian religion was vpholden and defended by all the Popes and confirmed by all the generall approued councells that euer were But the protestant religion was disproued and condemned for heresie by Leo the tenth and by the generall Councell of Trent and by all Catholick vniuersities of the worlde as the Arrian heresie was contradicted and condemned by Syluester then Pope and by the generall Councell of Nice by S. Athanasius and Hillarius and other holye Doctors as the Nestorian heresie alsoe was reiected by Pope Celestinus and the Councell of Ephesus S. Cyrill others So that though wee haue shewed your authors or ofspringe the time place when it began and where it began yet the like you cannot once nominate of vs since Christe and his Apostles who are the only authors of our beleefe and religion 6. You affirme that the protestant religion was since Christe and his Apostles in the world but it was hidden I answere that seeinge the Church and religion of Christe ought to be a cittie placed vppon a mountaine or hill to be seene of euerie one as in many places the holye scripture doth proue it ought not to be hidden but manifest to the whole worlde otherwyse it shoulde not be the religion of Christ Matt. 5. Isa 2. Psal 71. Daniel 2. soe that I must coÌ„clude with S. Hierom saying Breâ—em tibi apertamque animi mei sententiam proseram in illa Ecclesia esse permanendum quae ab Apostolis fundata vsque ad diem hunc durat Dial. lucifer in fine I must be plaine and declare my mynde sincerely that wee must abide in that Church which was founded by the Apostles and continewed vnto this verie daye If you shall heare such as be christians to be nominated rather of some other head then of Christe Marcianistes Valentinians Montanistes know then they oughte not to be called the church of Christe but the synagoge of Antechriste euen so such as are nominated Gospellers Caluinistes and Lutherans c. which are the founders of your religion and the inuentors of strange newe and deuised opinions contrarie to the vniuersall catholicke church and to the auncient Doctours thereof ar rather as S. Hierom saith members of that synagoge then of the church of Christe and as they were most peruerse obstinate in their doctrine soe they were most shameles and licentious in their liues and as the tree beareth in his braunches the corrupte humours that they drawe from the roote as the vertue of the cause is knowen by the effecte and the nature of the springe doth shewe it selfe in the brooke and as the springe beinge vncleane the brooke cannot be cleere and the roote beinge withered the braunches can beare noe fruite so Luther Caluine beinge your roote and of-springe and beinge vncleane filthie leacherous and altogether wedded to carnalitie and licentiousnes beinge rebellious apostates noe doubte of such as shall followe or embrace them no better fruite can be expected of them hence Zuinglius himselfe did coÌ„fesse Zuing. c. 2. Resp ad Luth. that as soone as he did embrace this ghospell of Luther he was attached with the raginge flames of fleshly concupiscence and sensualitie The occasion of Luthers fall and of other heâ—tikes from the Catholike Churche CHAPTER II. 1. WEE may applie S. Augustine his senteÌ„ce vnto this subiect Ang. serm de tempo 44. that there are two rootes plaÌ„ted in two fieldes by two tillers or husbadmen the one Christ doth plant in the hartes of the good the other the deuill planteth in the hartes of the wicked And as this is Couetousnes which is the roote of euill 1. Tim. 6. Ephes 3. soe tho other is charitie beinge the roote and of-springe of all goodnes accordinge to the saying of the Apostle that wee should be planted and rooted in charitie for as no euill can springe from charitie so no goodnes can come from couetousnes soe that you may perceaue from which of these rootes Luthers cause proceeded and which of these husbandmen did plante the same For not obtayninge the promulgating of certaine indulgences whereby he hoped to gett money first he rayled against them who denied him the same then he was infected with a desire of vaine-glory thirdly with a desire of reuenge for that he had a repulse from the Pope called Leo the tenth afterwardes pricked forward with a most filthie appetite of fleashlye concupiscence beinge a professed frier fifteene yeares he came out of his monasterie and tooke with him a professed Nunne wherby he might satisfye his filthie luste withall so that he committed such sinne sacriledge by breakinge and violatinge his vowes that all the world were scandalized therat And so far did he defend his riotousnes and beastlie debauchednesse therin as to teach that a woman was as necessarie
not thincke that euer his doctrine was of God for in his disputation against Eckius he fell into such rage and furie that being admonished Hosius lib. 1. de heresi Zurius hist Anno 1519. forasmuch as the cause of God was handled he should not transgresse the boundes of modestie he answered that this matter as it was not begunne for godes sake soe it should not be ended for his sake for that truly not charitie but enuye and malice was the motiue and cause of Luthers doctrine against the Pope and Churche of Christ The malediction of Luther Theod. co 4. operum Lutheri in Ioel. For when he euen departed from his disciples he was wont to saye Benedicat vos pater caelestis omni benedictione odio Papae The celestiall Father blesse you with all benedictâ—on and with the hatred of the Pope soe as you may perceaue of what spirit he was For I am sure you would not thinke that spiritt to be of God which dissolueth the vnion of the bodie of IESVS Christ but of Antechriste for whosoeuer endeuors to disioyne the Church from Christe or to dismember himselfe from the said Churche Aug. trac in epist. Iohn Ephes 5. or goeth aboute to deuide and seperate the Church in herselfe as S. Aug. saith he dissolueth diuides IESVS and his Church which Christe boughte with his pretious bloode who declared in his death how displeasant diuision and dissention should be vnto him soe as without any other scripture as Theodoretus saith Impia execranda dogmata per se sufficiunt ad suum patrem ostendendum wicked and execrable opinions are sufficient of themselues to declare vnto the world their father and patrone 4. In the last of these lameÌ„table examples I ought not to lett slippe that of Constance the vncle of Michaell Paleologus Emperor of Constantinople who puttinge away his married wife married his daughter in in lawe for which he was excomunicated by Ignatius the Patriarch of that Cittie of Constantinople and the Emperor and his vncle beinge offended therwith Photius was inuested in that Sea and soe to maintayne himselfe in that dignitie he said that the Pope was an hereticke and that the whole latine Church erred soe as you see lust and enuie brought in heresie heresie other mischeefes and wickednes into the world By what deceite hypocrisie and dissimulation this heresie crept into other Countries by what periurie and forgerie they were deluded by it and what destruction and desolation it brought with it CHAPTER III. 1. AS in the tyme of the Romaine Emperor Heraclius Gusp in mahometo one Mahomett a souldior did combine with others against the said Emperor by the craftie deuises of which companion many Prouinces banded themselues againste him That league was renewed first betwixt the lantgraue and other princes 22 of DeceÌ„b. 1530. and afterwardes the 29 of March 1531. against Charles the 5. Sleyd l. 18 where vpon ensued a suddaine decaye both in the ecclesiasticall ciuill gouernment of the Easte euen so Luther no sooner had hatched his heresie but that he procured by his deceite and hipocrisie the Princes of Germanie to enter into the like combination or conspiracye againste Charles the fift at Smacalde notwithstandinge they swoare allegeance vnto the said Emperor which Luther said was not lawfull to be obserued or performed So Sleydan a protestant writer saies that because Cesar went aboute to hinder the religion which they lately brought in he gaue them cause in conscience to oppugne him where vppon there followed a cruell and bloody warre betwixt Cesar and the Protestants Surius An. 1525. Michell ab Iselt in sua hist 1525. which brought many prouinces to ruyne and destruction besides the miserable thraldome and slauerie of the Turcks vnder whose dreadfull yoke Hungarie and other Prouinces adioininge therunto doe lye grouelinge at this daye 2. At that tyme also Thomas Monzer priest by Luthers instigation did stirr vpp a weake and slenderrable of Peasantes against the nobilitie and Cleargie soe as there were slaine of them more then an hundreth thowsand in Germanie that yeare He burned 200. Castells and monasteries murthered the Earle Heluesten with manny other nobles soe as Germanie suffred more calamities that present yeare of the Lutheranes then they receaued of the Spaniardes and French men the space of 10. Surius An. 1525 yeares before Alsoe the Duke of Lorrayne slewe in one Daye 27. thowsand Peasantes that made insurrection against him by the said Luthers procurement in Franconia 200. Castles and and Monasteries were burned by those rebells The like hauoke they made at Francfort Mongontia and Collen The like garboiles combustion and bloody tragedies surpassinge the other in horrour and detestation in all other Countries where this Hydria and infernall heresie once got footinge was stirred vpp and enkendled as in Sauoy Scotland France Flanders and in other borderinge Countries and by what falshoode periurie and dissimulation yt infected Flanders you shall imediatly see 3. First this heresie was neuer knowen in Flanders before Anna Saxonia Michell ab Iselt in hist Surius historia Florentius vander Haer de initijs tumuâ—tuum BelgioruÌ„ a woman of Saxonie who was infected with Luthers heresie was married to the Prince of Aurenge as other noblemen in Flanders vnhappily were married to other weomen heretikes as Herman was married with Count Hermans sister Florentius Pallentius the Counte of Cullenburge and William Counte of Herenberge all which were married to women of Germanie Idem in sua hictoria By these women the wicked people called the Geuses of Flanders made their insurrection againste Margarett de Austria Duches of Parma and gouernesse of Flanders who was faine to flye from them as being ouer stronge for hir But yet to putt her in some comfort one of her nobilitie said vnto her Non non Madame ne craigne pas les Geux that is to say do not feare these wicked people from which tyme the hereticks of Flanders were called Geuses that is to say a sorte of ragamuffines or miscreantes The prince of Aurenge the enginer of all the troubles of FlaÌ„ders whom the said Prince of Aurenge made his instruments to make a stronge rebellion in Flanders against Philipp the 2. king of Spaine by whome he was made Gouernor and deputie of Hollande by whose father the Emperor Charles the fifte he was made soe great as he was 4. This rebellious prince of Aurenge vnder pretence of deliueringe Flanders from the bondage of Spaine as he alleadged broughte this heresie into that Countrie which was the cause of all the troubles of Flanders for the space of 60. yeares but by what dissimulation periurie and deceite the said Prince of Aurenge did infect Flanders with this heresie the Chanceler of Lone doth witnesse Epistola Michaell Baysane Loua de vnione statuum An. 1578. I was present saith he when the Prince of Aurenge the cause of all the troubles of
destroied by the heresie of Pelagius giue a Moncke of Bangor for chastisment wherof almightie God suffred the Englishmen to turne the edge of their sworde vppon those that sent for them for their defence Vortiger was the leader of the Church when old Britans weare destroyd and dispossessed them of their Countrie and made themselues Lord thereof called Brittanie Englande by their owne name soe that heresie did soe increase in that kingdome about the tyme that S. Gregorie did send S. Augustine and other holy mounckes thither to preach the Catholick faith therein that 9. hereticall bushoppes beinge there before them no one catholick bishopp was found Ireland alsoe when the Englishe in kinge Henry the 2. gott footinge therein did little esteeme the sacred censure of holly Church Bern. in vita Malachiae Dolman Lib. 2. and the noblemen of that kingdome did vsurpe Church liuinges as may appeare by S. Bernard Edward the 3. beinge a most glorious kinge his end was pittifull his heire kinge Richard after infinitt sedition contention and blood-shedd of the nobilitie and others was deposed and made away the bloody diuision of the howse of lancaster yorcke came in and endured almoste one hundreth yeares with the ruyne not only of the royall lyne of LaÌ„caster by whom especially Iohn Wittcliffe a peruerse hereticke condemned in the Councell of Constance was fauored at the beginninge but with the ouerthrowe of many other Princes and families and most pernicious warres and garboyles continued both at home abroade with the losse of all the states and Prouinces of France Thomas Walsingham settes downe the Commotion of King Richard the 2. his time againste the nobilitie and Cleargie vnder their seditious Captaines Iacke Strawe Watt Tyler and the rest soe againe vnder other kinges whilest this heresie lasted and namly against the two most valiant Catholicke Princes Henry the 4 and 5. his sonne in the first yeare of whose rayne to witt kinge Henry the fift Iohn Stowe wryteth thus That the fauorers of Wiâ—cleefe his secte did nayle vpp scedulles vpon the Church doores of London containinge that there were an hundreth thousand readie to rise against all such as could not awaye with their secte The first tumuâ—tes of Pollardes and Wicliffians in England were Anno 1414. and hereon followed the open rebellion of Sr. Iohn old Castle and Sr. Roger Acton and others in S. Giles fâ—lde by Holborne neuerthelesse this secte could neuer take hold or preuaile in England neither then or after vntill foure pointes thereof beinge renewed by Luther and Zuinglius the later I meane Zuinglius his secte was admitted in kinge Edward hâ—s dayes 5. Did not the kinge of Denmarke bringe the people of Thretmarse which were a free state into a vilde thraldome after they were Lutheranes whereas as longe as they were Catholicks they were a free state of their owne Ces to 4. An Christi 379. S. Amb. in libris ad GratianuÌ„ Caes Baro. to 4. 379. S. Ambrose also doth proue the same as Caesar Baronius doth alleadge and saith Vna cum haeresi in regna cladem inuehi cum fide catholica salutem ferri c. that noe sooner heresie was broughte in then presentlie the kingdomes where it crepte in were ouerthrowen and quickly destroied and were againe restored and established by Catholique religion This he spake of the Empire of the easte sicque in occidente accumulari victorijs Gratianum that in the weast by the Catholique religion Gratianus the Emperor did encrease in many victories Cum in castris excubant cum gratia atque precibus Sacerdotum sancta religio when the priestes in the Campe did watch in prayers and other exercises of sacred religion Contrariewise you shall see the happie and florishinge Empire to decay and cast topsie turuie when the Emperor did fauor heretiques or at leaste when they were slacke in defendinge the Catholicque religion adeo saith he vt perspicuè intelligas claram victoriam religionem penitus consequi hereses tristes erumnas euocatas ab inferis secum ducere soe as you may plainly perceaue that by religion victorie was gotten and alsoe by heresie woe and wreake and all other dolfull calamitie and hellish confusion was broughte to the woâ—lde The like assertion hath holie Basill Basil ep 69 Caes Bar. to 4. An. Christi 363. quod enim comune est ciuitatibus omnibus vt cum semel hereticis aurem praebent mox vna cum heresi dissentiones rixae ac mala omnia sugata recta â—ide paceque subintrent ita planè Neocesarientibus accidit that which is incident to all Citties when once they giue eare vnto hereticques presently trewe faith beinge once abandoned dissentions debates and all other mischeefes will creepe in as wee see an euident example to those of Noecessaria what heresie saith he but which was contraire to the traditions of S. Gregorie the greate his wordes be these aduersaria traditioni magni reuera Gregorij 6. tomo 4. An. Christi 371. many heresies in the East The like miserie yow may read by the Epistles of those holy Sainctes videlicet Mileâ—itaâ—us Eusebius and Basilius to the Bushoppes of Italie and France and related by Caesar Baronius in which he wrote as followeth Miserandus status orientalis ecclesiae c. The state of the Easte Church is to be pitted for not onlie two or three Churches haue fallen vnto this dangerous tempest but that mischeefe of heresie hath extended her selfe from the bondes of Illiâ—ia vnto Tebaira the seede of which was first sowed by Arrius and afterwarde was gathered by wicked people who haue broughte forth wicked and pernitious fruites and discipline and doctrine of pietie and goood life is ouerthrowen all bondes and obligation of honestie and charitie is confounded and decaide none hath sway ouer others but he that is most wicked whose rewarde is the gouernment of others and he that exceedes others in blasphemies exceedes all in the episcopall dignitie The grauitie of Bishopps is lost the honestie of Pastors is gone the holy Canons of the Church are troade vnderfoote the releefe of the poore is altogether abused to their filthie vse The occasions of all such mischeefes are laide open by Saincte Optatus Milenitanus who hauinge reckoned the bloody and cruell actes of the heretickes called Donatistes he applied that place of the scripture vnto them Veloces pedes eorum ad effudendum sanguinem Cruelty of heretiques Mauritaniae videl the sea coast of Affrique next vnto Europe their feete are verie swifte to shedd blood And then addeth In Maritaniae ciuitatibus c. In the Citties of Mauritania by your procuremente they were affrighted with many garboiles Children were kilde in their mothers bellies men were murthered and torne in peeces matrons were violated infantes were slaine by riping vp their mothers bellies behould this your Church which was mantained vpholden by cruell and bloody Bishoppes whose greatest furie and vildest facte although in their estimation
I shall not bewaile trulie at lenght after all their great security they shall haue a sudden fall and let them take example by the dolefull ouerthrowe of others that haue lead their liues in pleasures and haue abused their power againste godes Church and the members thereof let all men knowe that all heresies be fatall ominous and vnfortunate especially to the first professors thereof Vltio sanguinis seruorum tuorum qui effusus est introcat in conspectu tuo gemitus compeditorum Psal 7. Whether there be nothing that the Protestants affirmatiuely beleeue confesse and professe but the Church of Rome doth beleeue the same and cannot be denyed by Catholiques but that they are most auncient and consonant with the word of God CHAPTER I. 1. ALl Heretiques say as Lactantius reportes that their owne religion is verie good and agreable to the word of God Lib. 4 diuinist cap. vlt. and better then others It is naturall to euerie beast according to Pliny to thinke his owne shape more beautifull then the rest Plin. lib. 8. cap. â—4 Plin. ibid. yea such as are most deformed thinkes themselues most beautifull as the Apes doe which though they do counterfeit mens shapes or gestures neuer so much cannot be said to haue the forme of men so these sectaries though they like Apes in imitation haue taken from vs some partes out of the Masse as may appeare and in their spirituall courtes visitations conuocations and excommunications although in deede none ought to excommunicate but he that can absolue they by their owne doctrine cannot absolue therfore they cannot excommunicate yet for all that they cannot be said to haue the trewe forme of Religion or the trewe Church for the ecclesiasticall forme and gouernment of your Protestantes is reiected by the Puritantes contemned by the ministers of Caluine and Beza and other Hugonottes of France as part of the reliques of Antechrist your common praier booke being called by them in contempt the missall of England Yf such as yow yourselues cales protestants do disprooue your Religion to be altogether against the woord of God how much more will the Romish Church say the like who doe differ from yow almost in euerie point 2. In the Booke of dangerous positioÌ„s in the 9. chapter set forth Anno 1593. by Doctor Bancraft of Canterburie it is alleadged that the Puritants do say of the comon booke of publick praiers videlicet that it is full of corruption and that many of the contentes thereof are against the woord of God the sacramentes wickedly mangled and prophaned therin the Lordes supper not eaten but made a pageant and stage play that their publique baptisme is full of childish superstitious toyes so many Puritants did write against it that England will neuer do well vntill that booke be burned 1. admonitio ad Parla pag. 9 41. 43. Also the superintendeÌ„t of Rateburge and the cheefest ministers in Germanie hauing read Caluines woorckes printed An. 1592. at Francfort In timore Domini saith he legi relegi dico in Christo Iesu c. Caluinistarum lib. 3. in pref Apost lib. 1. a. 2. fol. 9. I haue read and perused them the space of 23. yeares I auoutch it before IESVS Christ saith he that all the Caluinistes do nourish in their breastes the Aryan Turkish ympietie and that they open windowes and gates for Arianisme and Mahometisme as our bookes publickly set forth do manifest the same and so brought an example of Adam Newser the cheefe Pastor of the Church of Hedelberge Ibid. f. 9. who from a Zuinglian be came an Arian and afterwardes a Turcke which three sectes I meane Caluinisme Arianisme and Mahometisme Iohn Schutz in lib. 50. Causarum causa 48. another protestant Doctor calles them three briches of one cloathe and that fellowe hauinge gone vnto Constantinople Anno 1574. did writt that none became an Arian which first was not a Caluinist and brought example of Seruetus Blandrata Alciatus Franciscus Dauidis Gentilis Gribaldus Siluanus and others 3. There was printed a booke 1586. at Iena in Saxony by a Lutheran minister the Tittle whereof was An admonition from the woord of God that Caluinistes be not Christians but Iewes and baptized Mahometts Also 2. yeares afterwards another was set fourth at Tubinge by Philipp Nicholas minister the tittle whereof was a detection of the Caluinian sect to agree with the Arians and Nestorians in the groundes and foundations of their religion and that no Christian can ioyne with the Caluinistes but that he must defend the Arians and the Nestorians Sleid hist lib. 19. An. 47. Bernardinus Ochinus being the first principall Apostle of England in kinge Edwardes his dayes with Peter Martyr Martyne Buzer Okinus in lib. dialog Zanchius de vno Deo Beza ep 1. par 11. Bal. in pref act Rom Pontific Calu. lib. 1 de scandalis pa. 136 An. 1593. pag. 44. and Paulus Phalangius vnto whose direction both the vniuersities of England were comitted did oppugne the blessed Trinitie the deitie of Christ and of the holy Ghost so as Beza called him the fauorer of the Arian heresie and a scoffer at all Christian religion yet neuerthelesse one Iohn Bale somtimes Bishopp of Ossorie in Ireland calles this Bernardin and Peter Martyr the light of the Ghospell of England and Caluine saith that the said Bernardine was borne for the happines of England It is said also in the suruey of the pretended holy discipline printed at London that the sect of Caluinistes is a cancker and another Thalmud which by their wicked rebellion against their lawfull Princes haue founded their ghospell and Church which by their intollerable arrogancy do oppose themselues against all sacred Doctors against all venerable Councells and against all the florishing Churches that euer were from Christ his tyme vntill our dayes that there is no place of Scripture which they do not wrest from the lawfull sense thereof neuer before knowen by the Church of God and that it had beene good for England that none brought vpp in the filthie schoole of Geneua or Scotland had euer entred into England 4. Conradus a Protestant writeth that Caluine sayeth that the merittes of Christ cannot preuaile against the iudgment of God Also he affirmed Caluine to write that the blood of Christ was of no force to blott out sinnes and that aboue 1500. yeares it was putrified fo 84. 85. 87. Curaeus in spongia fol. 250. Erast pag. 29. Fridericus Borussius pag. 45 Osiander in confess haue written the like impietie with many other blasphemies which yow may read in the Caluini Turcismo lib. 4. c. 22 Other Lutheran writters make bookes of the contradictories and contradictions of Caluine Caluini Theolog. lib. 1. f. 85 Luth. lib. de Sacrament fol. 376. Orthodox Conf. en le Tigurine tract 3. fol. 127. Luth. tom 6. Ienues Germa fol. 257. the tittle whereof is called Laberinthi inextricabiles contradictionum The intricatt Laberinthes of contradictions
which wee be ordained to life euerlasstinge there will be in him a fountaine of water issuinge to life euerlasting And in another place he said Ioh. c. 7. whosoeuer beleeueth in me there shall flowe fountaines of water of life out of his bellie this he said of the spiritt that the faithfull should receaue I meane of the spiritt that should sanctifie iustifie vs inwardly and further vs to worke and to fructifie to life euerlastinge Ioh. 3. And as it is said he that is borne of God doth not comitt sinne against him because his seede remaynes in him which is the grace of God fructifyinge and buddinge forth to life euerlasting Bellarmine Ozius bringe many places to proue this amoungest many I will alleadg a fewe S. Basill Basil lib. de Spiritu sancto cap. 29. Gratia Spiritus in eo quireâ—â—pit illam est c. the grace of the spiritte who so receaues the same is as the eye-sight in a sound eye and as an arte in him that workes by arte and S. Ambrose doth compare that grace to a figure or a beautified Image Wherfore he saith Doe not blott any beautifull picture not framed in waxe but in grace Cyrill lib. 4. in Isayâ— oratione 2. and as S. Cyrill saith that the iust is framed by grace to be the child of God In the same manner doe speake Ireneus Cyprianus Hieron S. August and other fathers 2. This is confirmed by verie reason for if a man be not saued by godes grace inherent in him but only by this that God doth couer and hide our offences and that he doth not impute vnto vs our said offences and trespasses then it followeth that that they be not blotted or taken away by the meritts of Christs passion which is most false and against the scripture for S. Iohn saith Ioh. 1. Hebr. 9. beholde the Lambe of God that takes away the offences of the worlde and in another place The blood of Iesus Christ doth clense vs from all our sinnes and S. Paule saith the blood of Christ doth purge vs from deadlie workes that is to say from wicked desires to serue the liuinge God which was offred to abolishe our offences This is proued for the passion of Christ should be of greater excellencie and efficacie to disroote blott and take away altogether our sinnes and the blemishes therof restoringe vnto vs by grace an inherent qualitie of godes inspiration then if he should couer or hide them onlie therfore in not grauntinge this you derogate from the passion of Iesus Christ 3. Another absurditie doth followe that one iust parson hath no more iustice or grace then another and that all in the kingdome of heauen shall haue equall glorie which is against S. Paule sayinge that as one Starr excelleth another in brightnesse soe one iust doth excell another in iustice and grace Hence followeth also that noe iust man by godes grace meritts by any good worke that he doth and that those that are predestinated neuer comitt any deadlie offence all which notwithstandinge so great absurdities and damnable heresies yet hereticks doe graunt them and builde their beleefe vpon them In that heretiques reprehend the Catholick Church yea condemne her of great folly for endeuouringe her selfe to receaue godes grace they by this meanes take away free will from man and all due preparation and disposition to receaue godes grace and diuine influence CHAPTER III. 1. LVther as the holy Martyr Roffensis said in his 36. articles doth barke and speake many blasphemies against contrition the feare of hell the endeuours in his saluation yea he said the more wicked you be the neerer you are to gett the fauour of God Lutherus de piscat 〈◊〉 and if you adorne your selfe with good workes you preuaile nothinge with God But the holy catholique church hath condemned these wicked propositions as damnable and execrable heresie both repugnant not onlie to the holie scriptures but also contrarie to good manners ciuill honestie For God doth exhorte and comaund sinners that they should conuert themselues vnto him and that they should prepare their hartes that he might confer his grace and his iustice vnto them Zach. 1. Conuertimini c. Turne vnto me with all your harts and I will turne vnto you the Councell of Trentt saith when God saith turne you vnto me Sess 6. â— 5 and I will turne vnto you wee are admonished of our owne libertie in this matter and when wee saie Turne vs to thee wee are putt in minde that God by his grace doth preuent and helpe vs and as it is the worke of Gods grace to rayse and eleuate our soules to receaue the influence thereof soe it pertaynes to the wil of man so raysed and eleuated by godes motions and inspirations to consent therunto and to turne to God almightie 3. Reg. 7. And as it is said if you will returne from your harte take awaie strange godes from your hartes and prepare your hartes to our Lord. And it is said also Prou. 16. hominis est praeparare Lett man prepare his soule qui timet c. Whosoeuer feares God they shall prepare their hartes and in his presence they shall sanctifie their soules Ezech. 18. Cum auerterit se impius ab impietatâ— sua c. when the wicked man shall turne from his impietie and shall doe iudgment and iustice Iohn 6. he shall sanctifie his soule And make to your selues a newe harte and a newe spiritt All you that haue heard the the Father and learned from him let him come vnto me Ad. Phi. 2 Cant. Apoc. 3. Worke your saluation with feare and tremblinge My sister and my spouse come vnto me c. Behold I stand at your doore and knocke at your gate if any man will open I will enter c. In which and other places wee are bidd to turne to God and to clense our hartes from the filth of sinne And as God giues vs his helpe soe wee receaue the same without resistance and yealde our harts and resigne our thoughts vnto him Wherfore S. Augustine saith the beginninge of our saluation wee haue from the mercie of God but to condiscend to his hoalsome inspiration it is in our owne choise or power Aug. li. de ecclesiasticis dogmaetibus cap. 21. lib. de Spiritu litera cap. 34. lib 1. retract cap. 22. And in another place in all thinges godes mercie doth preuent vs but to condescend to godes vocation or to disagree from the same it is in our will It is in mans power to change his will into better but that power is nothinge vnlesse it be giuen of God And the same holie doctor comparing Pharao with Nabuchodonosor said that in all thinges they were all a like Aug. de praedest grat c. 15. Aug li de ciuit c. 6. and that both of them were equallie preuented by godes diuine mercie yet notwithstandinge they had different
meane vnderstandinge and will for it is not the action of God immediatlie but the action of man of whome immediatlie and next it is produced for it is not said that any other creature doth loue God but man when man doth loue God and therfore you must not saie that man beleeuinge hopinge in God and louinge God are not the actions of man when he hath the principles I meane vnderstandinge and will out of which they procede Whether wee derogate from the merittes of Christ in making our meritts partakers of his meritts CHAPTER IV. 1. GOd forbid that the merittes of the iust should derogate from Christs B. passion or should be iniurious vnto him they rather are a great glorie vnto Christe beinge the fruicts of the merittes of his passion which of themselues haue noe valour or excellencie but as they are bedewed and sprinckled with the blood of Christe vnto whome wee owe the merittes of them by his grace and not vnto our selues as Albertus magnus saith Iustitia meritorum Christ fulgeâ— in virtutibus sanctorum Albett ar 3. q. 2. in 29. d. The iustice of the merittes of Christ doth shine in the vertues and woorks of the Sainctes Take awaie this iustice from them and they may be condemned yea they cannot be saued Therfore wee saie that a reward is giuen vnto them not as they come from vs but as they come from his grace which worketh in vs. And he himselfe saith Matt. â— Merces vestra copiâ—sa est in Caelis your reward is great in heauen which reward is giuen vnto our workes by Christ whoe makes our workes worthie thereof 2. This argument is weake Christ sufficientlie merited for man therfore a man ought not to meritt anie thinge himselfe Christ prayed Christ suffred Christ preached Christe fasted and offred himselfe vnto God for our sinnes therfore wee should not merite wee should not praye nor suffer nor preach nor faste nor offer our selues to God Whereas Christ merited prayed fasted suffred and offered himselfe that I should merite fast praie suffer c. When as the actions of Christe are our instructions and although Christ suffred for all yet he left vs as S. Peter said an example to followe his stepps And though the meritts of Christs passion are of themselues sufficient to purchase and merite life euerlastinge for all men yet he would not haue the efficacie thereof to be applied vnto vs vnlesse wee would endeuour by his grace to ioyne also our meritts therunto which yet derogates nothinge from the passion of Christ for it is more excellent to obtaine glorie by deserts then without the same and therfore our meritts are not required for the insufficiencie of the meritts of Christ but rather are required for the great excellencie of the meritts of them and of his great loue and charitie towardes vs. 3. Wee saie with the whole catholique church the good workes of iust persons if they proceede of the grace of God doe deserue and meritte life euerlastinge which doth consiste in the cleere vision and fruition of God this is proued by many places of scripture Gode giues euerie man accordinge to his workes and in the Apocalips I come and my reward is with me to giue euerie man as his worke shal be Psal 65. Matt. 16. Rom. 2. 1. Cor. 3. with the Apostle Euerie man shall receaue accordinge to his owne labour where in trueth he spoke of the reward of life euerlastinge And when our Sauiour saith blessed be the poore in spiritt blessed be the poore in hart he concludes reioice and be glad Matt. 5. for your reward is great in the kingdome of heauen in another place he saith Come yee blessed of my father Matt. 25 I haue bene hungrie and you gaue me to eate come and possesse the kingdome of heauen And as the Apostle saith Gal. 8. qui seminat in Spiritu he that soweth in the spiritt or spirituall workes he shal purchase life euerlastinge if you will enter into life keepe the comaundements Euerie one that shall forgoe howse c. he shall receaue an hundreth fould and he shall possesse life euerlastinge Matt. 19. Blessed is that man that suffers tentation c. when he shal be tried he shall receaue a crowne of life which God promised to those that loue him The Apostle saith pietie is profitable to all thinges hauinge promise of the life that now is and of that to come 4. Some heretiques aunswere these places that God giues life euerlastinge to those that worke well vnto the end but not that our workes deserues the same Vnto this I replie when it is said that life euerlastinge is the reward of good deedes and that by the promise of God it is giuen to those wotkes it is sufficiently explicated that good workes doe merite life euerlastinge Merites and rewardes are correlatiues which are said to be the promise hire or recompence that are giuen for works the verie woord is declared by S. Paule Heb. 13. And beneficence and communication doe not forget Eccles 16. for with such hostes God is promerited and it is said in another place all mercie maketh place to euerie one accordinge to the merittes of his woorks Con. AraÌ„ cap. 16. It is auouched by the counsells Debetur merces bonjs operibus si fiant sed gratia quae non debetur praecedit vt fiant Reward is due vnto good workes if they be done but grace which is not due doth goe before that they may be done Lateran sub Innocent 3. By the councell of Lateran cap. firmiter de summa trinitate Omnes iusti cuiuscunque conditionis sunt statim per opera bona praelucentes Deo merentur ad aeternam vitam peruenâ—re All iust men of whatsoeuer condition they be Con. Floren in decreto de purg Con Trid. sess 6. cap. vlt. shininge by theire good works before God they deserue to come to euerlastinge life The councell of Florence saith that by diuersitie of workes one sees God more cleerer theÌ„ another This is proued by al the fathers Ignatius Ireneus Iustinus Origines Basil Chrisost Nazian and Nisse Tertul Cyprian Hillar Ambro August Paulinus Prosper Gregorius Papa Bernard as Cardinall Bellarmin cites 5. S. Augustine saith Sicut merito peccati tanquam stipendium redditur mors ita merito iustitae tanquam stipendium redditur vita aeterna As sinne is rewarded with death soe iustice is rewarded with life euerlastinge Ad Epis Galliae cap. 12. and as Celestinus saith Tanta erga homines est bonitas Dei vt nostra velit esse merita quae sunt ipsius dona Soe great is the goodnes of God towardes men that he would haue to be our desertes which are his guifts He that laboures in the seruice of any man whatsoeuer he is promised by his bargaine he ought to receaue the same accordinge to the promise made but the iust people doe labour in godes
quod in eis non bene intelligitur etiam temerè audacter asseritur heresies and other peruerse opinions infectinge and intanglinge our soules euen to the deepe pitt of confusion doe springe of noe other roote then when good scriptures are ill vnderstoode and the badd vnderstandinge therof is bouldly and rashlie applied S. Ambrose doth likewise declare the same sayinge Ambr. 3. ad TituÌ„ S. Hil. in lib. ad Const Haeretici per verba legis legem impugnant by the wordes of the lawe it selfe the heretiques doe impugne the lawe S. Hillarius also saith Neminem haereticorum esse qui se non secundum sacras scripturas praedicare eas quae blasphemat mentiatur there is noe heretique that doth not alleadge falsy the scriptures for his blasphemies Also he saith de intelligeÌ„tia heresis sit Lib. 20. de Trinit non de scriptura sensus non sermo fiat crimen heresie is of the vnderstaÌ„ding not of the scripture the fault is in the sense and not in the word Hiero ad Lucif vnto which agreeth S. Hierom Neque sibi blandiantur c. Lett them not flatter themselues if they alleadge or affirme any thinge of the scriptures when euen the deuill hath alleadged the scriptures for his purpose The scriptures saith he doe not consiste in readinge of them but in vnderstandinge of them Origines also declareth the same Orig hom 9. in Exo saying Non rarò c. Somtimes the diuill doth wreast godes wordes from many for that there is nothinge soe holie but the enemie of mankinde doth abuse the same to the destruction of man Tertulian also saith de scripturis agebant De prefâ—cript her de sciptuâ—is suadebant c. They pleade the scriptures they persuade the scriptures they inculcate the scriptures vnto this they moue some at the first dashe they wearie the stronge they coÌ„nfound the weake and men of indifferent iudgment they dismisse with scrupules Thus far Tertulian soe the Arian heresie the Macedonian the Nestorian Eutichian and all other old heresies would allowe nothinge but scripture and last of all these newe phantasticall heresies doe grounde all their turbulent spirittes and singuler maleperte and headie deuises vpon holie scriptures 2. For example Luther in his first booke against Zâ—uinglius saith that amoungest Zuingilans the Zuinglians themselues concerninge these 5. wordes there arose tenn seuerall sects of different religion I meane 270. sects of heresies in this time Lib de here fabulis hoc est enim corpus meum Stanislaus Rescius hath deuided the hereticall sects of this tyme into two hundred and 70. different heresies euerie one alleadginge scripture for his owne fancie Theodorus did reckon 76. heresies in his owne tyme. Aug. lib. de heres S. Augustine also did reckon 88. heresies vnto his owne tyme. And vnto Luther his tyme there were 290 sortes of heresies all which did alleadge scriptures Yea was there euer any heresie that did alleadge more scriptures for herselfe then that of the Arians did not the Iewes alleadge scriptures against Christ that he should not be holden for a Prophett saying Iohn 7. Scrutate scripturas vide quia a Galilea propheta non surgit search the scriptures saie they and behould that a prophett doth not arise from Galile and by scripture they did endeuour to proue that he was worthie of deathe Iohn 19. Wee haue a law say they and by our lawe he ought to die because he made himselfe the sonne of God Did not Iulian the apostate alleadge scripture as S. Cyrill saithe lib 10. in Iulianum for visitinge Martyrs Reliques alleadginge that place of S. Mathewe 23. that the Scribes Pharisies and Hipocritts are like to white monuments and they ought not to visitt them c. Also he alleadged many places of scripture as Math. 5. Ro. 12.1 Cor. 6. Math. 10. against the christians for repininge against him for takinge away their goodes but to beare all tyrannicall oppressions patientlie Did not Osiander a cheefe secretarie alleadge 20. different opinions touchinge the article of Iustification and at last he cited his owne opinion contrarie to them all 3. Of all these sectes it is saide Obscurum est insipiens cor eorum dicentes se esse patientes stulti facti sunt Their foolish hearte is darkned sayinge themselues to be wise but they be made fooles for heretiques can neuer haue the knowledge of the scriptures In maleâ—olam animam non introibit sapientia Sap. cap. 1 nec habitabit corpore subdito peccatis true knowledge shall not enter into a wicked soule nor lodge in a bodie subiect to sinne Therfore the prophett saithe Discam in via immaculata I will learne in an vnspotted waie and when heretiques through pride and malice haue most maliciouslie opposed theÌ„selues against the catholique church the piller and foundation of all trueth and haue sought by all wicked and malicious meanes to deface the same wee must not thinke they haue had any true knowledge or perfect wisdome for if once a foundation of a house or a rocke vpon which are builded manie chambers do fall all those chambers cannot stand vpp the catholique church is the firme rocke vpon which the faithe of euerie christian is builded if he once fall from the church he hath no faith nor any vnderstandinge of the scriptures and therfore S. Augustine saith he would not haue beleeued the ghospelll without the authoritie of the church which beinge inspired by the holie ghoast hath taught thinges which the scritures haue taught the contrarie as that wee should not obserue the old lawe nor obstaine from thinges suffocated or straungled and such like for the letter saith S. Paule killeth 1. Cor. 3. but the spiritt quickneth And as the letter in the old lawe not trulie vnderstoode nor referred to Christ did by occasion kill the carnall Iewe so the letter of the newe testament not truly taken nor expounded by the spiritte of Christe which only is in his church killeth the heretique who also being carnall and voide of spiritt gaineth nothinge by the scriptures but rather taketh hurte by the same Aug. to 10. de teÌ„pore li. de Spiritu litt c 5. 6. 2. Pet. 3. 2. Tim. 3. as S. Augustine auoucheth for in the newe testament saith S. Peter are certaine thinges hard to be vnderstoode which the vnlearned and vnstable depraue as also they do the rest of the scriptures to their owne perdition of whom S. Paule himselfe saith alwaies learninge and neuer attayninge vnto the knowledge of the truth men corrupte in mind reprobate concerninge the faith but they shall prosper noe further for their folly shal be made manifest to all and as Iames and Mambres resisted Moyses soe they alsoe resiste the truethe 4. If Daniell after that God had reuealed vnto him thinges to come concerninge the militant church saith Ego audiui non intellexi I haue heard but I vnderstood not the Angell said vnto
Daniell vade quia clausi sunt signatique sermones vsque ad praefinitum tempus Goe your wayes for these speeches are shutt vpp and sealed vntill the time appointed if soe great a Prophett heard and vnderstoode not what he heard what will heretiques and wicked arogant presumptuous people make glosses vpon euerie â—illable of holie scripture Aug. Con. ep c. 4. Wherfore S. Augustine saith Sacra scriptura c. The holie scripture are not knowen to the proude nor manifest or playne to boyes in the begining therof it is easie but when you enter into it it is loftie and couered with misteries and I was not of that capacitie that I might intermedle therin Aug. lib. de vtil cred c. 7. And in another place he perswaded a yonge man learned in humanitie and Philosophie and other liberall sciences that he should not rasâ—lie reade holie scriptures sayinge to set vpon Maurus a Comedian or TereÌ„ce because thou hast noe skill in poetrie thou darest not without a master and to vnderstand him beinge a comon poett thou searchest the commentaries of Asper Cornutus Donatus and infinitte others and darest thou without a guide or iudge venture vpon holie scripture which as S. Paule speaketh in â—js qui pereunt velatum est 2. Cor. 4. in them that perishe is hidd in quibus Deus huius seculi excaecauit sensum incredulorum in whome the God of this worlde hath blinded the myndes of the infidles that the illumination of the ghospell of the glorie of Christe might not shine in them and as S. Iohn saith Ioh. 1. the light shined in darcknes and the darcknes did not comprehende it the heretiques hauinge not the light of Christes spiritt which is giuen to the church not true humilitie by which they should obeie the same cannot haue the shininge light of Christ his ghospell nor the true vnderstandinge thereof Credite intelligetis saith the Prophett beleue the church and you shall vnderstaÌ„d the scriptures Esa 7. vnto whom almightie God hath giuen the true interpretation thereof and to noe particuler spiritt 5. S. Hierom beinge soe well learned as he was and furnished with the knowledge of all the tongues did stumble in many thinges Lib. 1. de Doctr. chr c. 6. for he sweateth in explayninge the prophetts the same difficultie S. Augustine had as he himselfe declares when he would expounde that place of scripture of the sinne against the holie ghoast and when he alleadged many places he was not satisfied in them all so he saith that many obscure places be in the scriptures almightie God ordayninge the same to abate the pride and arrogancie of man and to submitt his priuate spiritt to the vniuersall spiritt of Christ his church therfore Tertul. saith Fides te saluum fecit non exercitatio scripturae it is thy faith that saueth thee and not the readinge or exercise of scriptures the misteries wherof are hidden from the wicked for they be like Margarittes and pretious stones and which ought not to be giuen to swine noe more ought they to be common to euerie one and as a holy man saith Non intelligendi viuacitas sed credendi simplicitas te saluum fecit it is not the quicknes of vnderstandinge but simplicitie of beleeuinge that shall saue thee Omnis prophetia saith S. Hierom in Ezech 45. prophetts are obscure what the disciples doe heare inwardlie the comon people knowes not what is said in them and accordinge to this the prophett saith tenebrosa aqua in nubibus aeris obscure water in the cloudes of the aier the ordinarie gloss in that place hath obscura doctrinae in prophetis the prophets are full of darke and difficult doctrine 6. Was not the Eunuch Threasurer to the Queene of Ethyopia exercised in the scripture and yet he confessed he could not vnderstand them Act 8. Did not Christe interpreate the scriptures to the Iewes and his disciples Luc. vlt Act. 8. Luc. vlt. S. Iohn Chrisostom vpon that place scrutamini scripturas Christus saith he Iudeos c Christe did not referr the Iewes vnto the bare and naked readinge the scriptures but vnto the diligent examination and inuestigation thereof S. HieroÌ„ saith Lib. 1. praef comment in epist. ad Alga q. 2. that all the Epistles of S. Paule to the Romaines be verie obscure and intricate Luther himselfe vpon the Psalme 88. Thronus eius sicut dies caeli his throane is like the daie of heauen saith I would haue noe man to presume in my behalfe that I can vnderstand the Psalmes in their lawfull sense which was neuer performed of anie though neuer soe learned or soe holie for the scriptures must be considered either litteralie in themselues or accordinge to their methode and sense for in themselues they speake and containe things supernaturall and misticall which are hidden from the capacitie of the vulgar sorte or if they should be considered accordinge to their methode or sense they should be deuided into foures kindes of senses vnderstandinge as sensus Anagogicus which is called the celestiall sense The scripture hath 4 senses or vnderstanding Allegoricus which is the spirituall sense Tropologicus which is the morall sense and Historicus which is the litterall sense Therfore the prophett cried out vnto God sayinge da mihi intellectum c. giue me vnderstandinge and I will searche into thy lawe faciem tuam illumina super seruum tuum Domine Illuminate my vnderstandinge with thy grace ô Lord that I may vnderstand thy word sacrae scripturae saith Hylarius non in legendo sed intelligendo Lib. ad Constan. non in praeuaricatione sed in charitate the holy scriptures doe not consiste in readinge of them but in the true sense and meaning of them not in corruptinge or in preuarication of them but in the charitable interpretation of them And when S. Augustine did see the manifest and false applyinge of them by the PellagiaÌ„s he did appeale to the Bishopes both of the east and weast 7. Caluine saith of the protestantes that they would haue the scriptures to patronize and support their errours sayinge In praefat ad lectores ex Phyco Ibi quid non â—nuertunt quid non deprauant what is there but they peruert and depraue Lutherus in hist Sacrament foll 22. Luther would not admitt any translation of scripture but his owne translation noe more would Zuinglius his aduersarie Zuingl to â—2 resp ad Luth. Luther was offended with the printer that did send him Zuinglius his translation who would not once peruse it and so Zuinglius with Luther Kinge Henry the 8. after he made himselfe head of the Church he caused the scriptures to be translated into English which afterwards he suppressed and inhibited Fox in Henri 8. in fine hist. Afterwardes he caused another translation to be made by the authoritie of the parlament Anno regni sui 34. and proclaymed vnder paine of death that noe other translation should
be vsed but that and this he did to mantayne his opinion Also when his children kinge Edward and Elizabeth came to the Crowne and held contrarie opinions they caused contrarie translations to be published Fox ibid. Vulgar translations of scriptures profitts nothinge vnlesse wee knowe the true sense of them as for the true sense the protestantes giue vs no rule at all for the same For in England they cannott iudge of the controuersie of religion by the scriptures because they are bouÌ„d by their â—awes to beleue according to the will and decree of the parleament howse and of the kinge And in other protestant countries where the parleament or the wil of a prince is not of force there are so many sects and heresies as they cannot be reclaymed euerie one wreasting the scriptures to his owne priuate and fantasticall opinions for the Protestants doe not care for the vulgare translation vnles they may peruert the sense thereof according to their owne turbulent braines 8. Neither is there any people that doe reuerence and honor the scriptures more then those of the Catholick religion Which as S. Paule saith 2. Cor. 4. doth renounce the adulterating of the word of God wicked constructions deceitfull interpretations and sinister application thereof which is common to heretiques as Luther affirmeth that the roote of all heresies hath bene the scriptures yea he added that the scriptures ought to be called the booke of heretiques There is neither iott nor sillable in the scripture but the catholique church doth imbrace allowe the same as written and sett downe by the holie ghoast and although the priuate spiritt of some haue thought some bookes of the sacred scriptures not to be canonicall yet the whole catholique church hath receaued them hath taken awaie that doubte Touchinge the bookes of the old testament videlicet Iudith Tobyas the booke of wisdome Ecclesiastes the two first bookes of the Machabees and of Baruch as alsoe of the newe as the Apocalips the Epistle of S. Paul to the Hebreues the Epistle of S. Iames the 2. of S. Peter the 2. and 3. of S. Iohn and therfore the heretiques of this time doe not allowe those for that some in tymes paste haue doubted thereof Did not S. Tho doubt also of Christs resurrection and therfore ought he or wee doubt thereof still Christ hauing manifested his scarres and his woundes vnto him Euen soe though some learned men haue doubted of those bookes yet by the vniuersall consent of the church these bookes were made knowen to be Canonical scripture As concerninge the booke of Iudith the councell of Carthage vnder Aurelius Bishopp thereof Innocentius the first Geâ—asius with 70. Bishoppes the councell of Florence vnder Eugenius the 4. haue pronounced it to be canonicall as also of the booke of Tobie Ecclesiastes and wisdome As for the two bookes of Machabes the Canons of the Apostles the author whereof is said to be S. ClemeÌ„t in the ende thereof the two bookes of the Machabees are inserted as Canonicall those two bookes are confirmed by Innocentius the first and by the councell of Carthage and confirmed by the 6. Generall councell in such like manner the said 2. bookes are coÌ„firmed both by the two generall councells of Florence Aug. li. 18 de ciuit Dei c. 16. con Gaud. epist lib. 2. cap. 23. and Trentt and as S. Augustine saith that the Churche and not the Iewes doth allowe the Machabees for canonicall and not onlie S. Augustine doth produce wittnesse out of them but also Ireneus Tertul. Cyprian Chrysost and others soe as to doubte of these bookes is rather the infidelitie of the Iewes then the faith of the Christians especially when the Church hath once decreede the same and soe are all the rest of the said bookes made Canonicall by the Church and by her determination which is of greater force to allowe or disalowe of them as also of the true interpretation of them then all the priuate spirittes in the world vnto whome all priuate mens iudgment ought to submit themselues Basill the greate and S. Gregorie Naz. being the cheefest diuines amoungest the Grecians and hauinge cast awaie all other bookes they recollected themselues to studie the holie scriptures the true meaninge and interpretation thereof as Ruffinus testifieth Ruff. lib 2. cap 9. in Eccl hist they gathered out of the authoritie and comentaries of their predecessors not of their owne priuate presumption or proper imagination Gal 2. Aug. lib. 28 in Faust c. 4. 9. Did not S. Paule beinge an Apostle before he preached the Ghospell goe vpp to Hierusalem that he might confer with S. Peter Lucc 22. Iames and Iohn and especiallie with Peter touching the preaching and expoundinge of the Ghospell for that our Sauiour did praie particulerlie for S. Peter that he should not faile in his faith vnto whome he promised the assistance of his holie spiritt If this soe great a doctor beinge illuminated by Christe and receauinge his ghospell froÌ„ him did neuerthelesse conferr the same with S. Peter the foundation of the ecclesiasticall Hierarchy the Pastor of Christs sheepe the captaine of his armie the sonne that shineth in this hemispher of christendome and heade of the misticall bodie of Christe which is his church how much ought others to doe the like which haue not so much securitie nor soe good a warrant to be fauored and inspired of God as he had Howe can wee thinke or beleeue that heretiques can vnderstand the scriptures who haue not the spiritt of God to instruct them in the knowledge thereof For as no member of the bodie hath the spiritt of the bodie vnlesse it be vnited and ioyned to the bodie soe noe member of the misticall bodie of Christ which is his church hath the spirite thereof that is separated froÌ„ the same Wherevpon S. Augustine saith nihil magis debet christianus formidare c. there is nothinge that a christian ought to feare more Aug trac â—7 in Iohn then to be separated from the bodie of Christe for if he be separated and disunited from the bodie of the church he is not a member thereof and if he be not a member of the same he is not quickned by her spiritt and whosoeuer hath not the spiritt of Christe as the Apostle saith he is not his it is the spiritt that quickneth the flesh auaileth nothinge Therfore you beinge not in the Church vnto whome the spiritt of God is promised to direct her in all trueth and to guide her from all errors and heresies wee ought not to beleue that you haue the knowledge of the scriptures or the true vnderstandinge or interpretation thereof for it cannot stande with any reason or rule that this spiritt of trueth can be in turbulent mindes or malicious heades as hetiquees be Esa 66. qui non requiescit nisi super humilem mansuetum trementem sermones suos neuer resteth but vpon the humble and meeke
and tremblinge at his wordes and speeches Whether euery man ought to be iudge of the scripture and to rely altogether vpon his owne iudgment touching the interpretation therof being inspired by the holly ghoast concerning the same CHAPTER V. 1. THis is the assersion of William Whitakers in his booke against Cardinall Bellarmin for that saith he councells fathers and popes be men And the scripture auerreth all men to be lyeares and so no man can be assured his faith to be certaine and infallible Wherto I answer that no priuat man can be assured of the certitude of an infallible faith and therfore nott of the good spiritt rather then of the badde by whose suggestiō many are intoxicated with dangerous and damnable opinions for according to the Apostle 2. Corint Sathan often times transfigureth himselfe into an Angell of light and the fore the holy scripture willeth vs 1. Ioh. 4. Th 4. to be very carefull in discerning of the spiritts and nott to beleue euery spiritt for it is the holy catholicke church that wee ought to beleue and obey 1. Tim. 3. which the scripture beareth wittnesse to be the piller and firmament of trueth but it giueth no certitude or euidence of any priuat spiritt or pecular iudgment of any one in particuler and therfore the holy councell saith It seemeth good to the holy ghost and to vs Act. 15. which holy ghoast is said to be nott with euerie particuler man but with the church in generall and with those that haue charge and direction therof Ero vobiscum vsque ad consummationem seculi euen to the consummatiō of the world Matt. 28. And vnto S. Peter his successors is said I haue praid for you that your faith may not fayle Luc. 22. and seeing this priuiledg is giuen to S. Peter for the good of the church as the first and cheefe pastor therof vnder Christ and to no other in particuler as long as the church shall continewe the praiers and intercession of Christ shal not be frustrated And therfore S. Cypriā affirmeth the fountaine of all heresies to haue proceeded for that one priest for the time being one iudg for the time being vnder Christ is not regarded For which way saith he can heresies be preuented that they spring nott or being sprong already that they be nott extended or encreased wher there are so many masters as disciples so many iudges as barristers And for this cause S. Hierom saith against Iouinian amoungest 12. one is chosen that a cheef being ordained occasion of scisme should be taken away 2. The tables of both the testaments referred vs ouer to no particuler iudgment but altogether to the small decree and arbitrement of the high priest Deut. 17. as it is saied If there be any hard or doubtfull iudgment amongest you goe to the priest of the Leuiticall stocke and to the iudge that shall be ordained for that time and he shall enforme you of the trueth Whose lippes according to Malachias Mal. 2. shall keepe wisdome because he is the angell of the Lord of hoastes if he will not hearken vnto the Church Matt. 18. lett him be vnto you an ethnick and a publican And in the newe testament our Sauiour appointed one pastor aboue the rest vnto which he hath committed the feeding of his flocke which should haue beene friuolous if the flocke would nott receaue food from him Ephes 4. Afterwards he ordained pastors and doctors in his church which should be also a friuolous ordinance if euerie one should be a proper pastor and doctor to him self And although councells fathers and popes are men so the testimonies of the scriptures may also be taxed with the imputation of humane errors so were the Apostles and prophets men also yett wee ought to beleue them because the holly ghost was not a lyar that spake in them And so the ecclesiasticall councells fathers and popes being lawfully assembled together and assisted by the holly ghoast Matt. 28. which in such a case is promised vnto them did not erre 3. Another obiection they bring Ioan. 14. saying S. Peter was nott promised vnto the Church to direct the same butt the holly Ghost which should direct and instruct all the Apostles and nott S Peeter I answer that God promised the holie ghoast as an inuisible and internall doctor and director S. Peter his visible and externall doctor he left in his church And therfore S. Augustine saith Aug. in Ioh. 14. after promising the holly ghoast lett no man thincke that he shall so giue the holly ghoast vnto his church in his owne place is though him self also would nott be with the same for he auowtched he would nott leaue them orphanes but would come vnto them 4. And althoughe the holy ghoast was promised to instruct the Church in all trueth yett not without the Father and the sonne for their externall worcks are indiuisible for there is but one indiuisible substance and because the Church is a visible body so it ought to haue a visible viccar vnder Christ the inuisible head therof And therfore he saide vnto S. Peter Ioh. 11. Simon of Iohn louest thou me more then these feed my lambes which he repeated thrise first commending vnto him his lambes afterwards his litle ones the third time his sheepe and so expoundeth S. Ambrose in cap. vlt. Luc. 5. Nowe the power and iurisdiction which was promised vnto S. Peter Math. 16. that the Church should be builded vpon him that the keyes of the kingdome of heauen should be also giuen vnto him is accomplished and performed in the 21. of S. Iohn feed my sheep of whom he is actually made the generall pastor and viccar 6. And although the rest of the Apostles were lightes and priests and had authoritie also in the 20. of S. Iohn yet theirs was extraordinary which should end with them selues and whatsoeuer authority they had was by the sacraments by which they remitted sinne S. Peter had authoritie to bind and loose immediatly and by him the the Apostles as depending vpon him as S. Thomas saith in 4. dist 19. q. 1. art 3. and so he maketh a distinction of the two powers videl of order and iurisdiction the first was equally giuen to all the Apostles Iohn 20. and consequently to all priests but the secōd power was principally giuē to S. Peeter and from him to be deriued vnto the rest of the Apostles How heretiques would faine take awaie all tradition alleadginge for their purpose that of S. Math. 15. In vaine you worshipp me teachinge for doctrine mens precepts CHAPTER III. 1. THis is it saith S. Augustine that all heretiques doe bragge of Lib contr Maximū if I should aunswere all such trifles I should neuer make an ende saith he soe as he would not aunswere to this place for he saith that the traditions of the Apostles ought to be of as great force as the holie scriptures
scriptures to our auncestors to aske knowledge of them Interroga patres tuos Deut. 32. Eccles 8. dicent tibi c. aske thy Fathers and they shall declare vnto thee and thy auncestors Eccles 8. and they will tell thee Non te praetereat narratio seniorum ipsi enim c. Omitt not to heare thine elders for they haue learned of their parents that of them you may learne vnderstandinge Prou. 2â— Non transgrediaris terminos antiquos quos posuerunt parentes Doe not you transgresse the old limittes which your pareÌ„ts haue prescribed Are not the Rechabites praised for followinge the tradition and preceptes of Ionadab Haec dicit Deus exercituuÌ„ Hier. 35.18 pro eo quod obedistis praecepto Ionadab patris vestri c. Thus saith the Lord of hoastes because that you haue obeyed the precepte of Ionadab your father and haue kepte all his commaundements therfore the Lord of hoastes the God of Israell saith there shall not faile one of the stirpe of Ionadab the sonne of Rechab that shall stande in my presence 7. In the dolfull and damnable debate and discorde that Martyne Luther Caluine and others haue raised vp by which they plunged themselues and the worlde into such an intricat laberinth of errors and heresies where shall the poore silly sheepe haue resolution of their doubts but of their parentes and pastors which God hath placed in his churche to gouerne and directe his flocke from all errors shall not the children beleeue their fathers and the sheepe their pastors Wee must not only flie vnto the scriptures as S. Vincentius Lyrinensis saith Vincent 9 â—eres c. 1. but vnto traditioÌ„ of the catholique church notwithstandinge saith he in that place that the scriptures are of themselues sufficient yet saith he because all men doe not conceaue the loftines of the scripture a like but accordinge to euery mans phantasticall censure and humorous passion as soe many heades soe many mindes for men as they be deuided in sects or factions soe they deuide the sense of the scriptures Nouatianus Photinus Sabellius Donatus Arrius Eunomius Macedonius Apollinaris Priscilianus Iouianus and Pellagius haue eche of them grounded their proper heresies vpon the scripture Nan videas eos volare per singula quaeque sanctae legis volumina sacrae scripturae You may see them flie ouer all the bookes of the holie lawe both in publique and priuate in their sermons in their bookes in their banquettes in tauernes in the streate nothinge did they euer produce which was not shadowed by the scriptures for they knewe verie well that their errors coulde neuer be pleasing vnto the people without the scriptures with which as with sweete water they sprinckle the same euen as soure drincke is teÌ„pered with sweet honny so as when children drincke therof hauinge once felte the sweetnes they haue noe loathsomnes of it though neuer soe bitter But the more scripture they bring the more wee ought to feare them saith S. Vincentius and to shunne them Magnopere curandum est in ipsa Ecclesia Catholica vt id teneamus quod vbique quod semper quod ab omnibus creditum est For in the catholique church wee must alwayes beware that wee keepe that which is beleeued alwayes euerie where and of euerie body haec est verè propriè Catholica which is properlie and trulie catholique And in the 9. chapter he saith Quo quisque religiosior est eò promptius nouellis adinuentionibus contrariatur the more vertuous that a man is the more prompte ready he opposeth himselfe against newe inuentions and soe he saith our maister S. Stephen in his epistles to the Bishoppes of Affricke touching rebaptisinge of infants that were baptized by heretiques nihil innouandum est nisi quod traditum est Apud Cypri li. 2. cap. 7. the good and religious man would haue vs children to inuente noe religion but what wee haue receaued of our fathers and whose steppes he would haue vs to followe in all thinges 8. This said author expoundinge 1. Timoth. depositum custodi keepe in depositum what I haue left in your custodie the religion and the obseruation thereof that I deliuered vnto you shunninge prophane noueltie of voices he doth not saye shunn antiquitie or ancientie or continuance but noueltie and innouation of thinges nam si vitanda est nouitas tenenda est antiquitas c. For if wee oughte to auoide noueltie wee shoulde imbrace antiquitie if noueltie be a prophane thinge antiquitie is a sacred thinge keepe the depositum saith he which is giuen vnto thee and to the whole church to be kepte from theeues and enemies least they should sowe cockell or darnell amouÌ„gest the cleane wheate The depositum which you haue receaued not which you haue inuented The deposituÌ„ which is not coyned by thy witt but deliuered by my doctrine Not any mans priuate vsurpation but the common and vniuersall tradition in which you are not the author but the keeper not the instituâ—or but the follower not the mayster but the disciple The depositum saith he Catholicae fidei talentum keepe the talent of the catholique religion vnspotted Exod. 36. inuiolable and vndefiled by you saith he the rosarie of the spirituall tabernacle Pretiosas diuini dogmatis geÌ„mas exculpe fideliter comptè VinceÌ„tius cap. 27. adoâ—â—a sapienter adijce splendorem gratiam venustatem do you garnish turne faithfully and adorne with the pretious Iewell of the diuine decree doe you add therunto splendor grace and beautie 6. All this I haue alleadged out of Vincentius Lyrinensis word by word for his whole booke against heresies hath noe other obiecte but the tradition of our auncestors by which he confuteth and conuinceth the prophane noueltie of heretiques and their arrogant insolent ostentation of scriptures vpon which they grounde all their hereticall cauillation which as all our forfathers before vs soe wee after them doe finde by experience that the interpretation and meaninge thereof as they doe produce them is of greater difficultie then the controuersie it selfe the fathers did vrge them with a shorter way by askinge Hil. 2. ad Const Aug. lib. â— de trinitate cap. 3. quid prius posterius what is first and laste for that heresie is grounded in noueltie and euer cometh after the Catholique trueth first planted And for that euerie heresie pretendeth his heresie to be auncient and from the Apostles the fathers doe alleadge that this trueth muste not onlye be eldeste but also must haue continewed from tyme to tyme at the leaste with the greatest parte of Christians Tertul. li. aduers prax c. 20 And therfore Tertulian saith lib. De praescriptione quod apud multos vnum inuenitur non est erratum sed traditum that wherin moste men doe agree vppon it is not an erronious opinion but a common tradition For the Church of God is a most liuely ghospell for with the Apostles there was the Church of
Christe before the ghospell was written sith none of the Euangelists did write vntill 18. yeares after Christs assention With Abraham Isaacke Iacob was a true Churche in the faith of one creator and redeemer to come when there was noe scripture Moyses the first that wrot Euseb li 9 c. 4 li. 10 cap 3 praeparationis Euangelicae for Moyses was the first that comitted the word of God to inke and paper hauinge written the same in the Hebrewe tounge which was the first that inuented characters or letters as Eusebius doth wittnesse c euen by the testimony of prophane writers themselues and haue taught the people beinge rude and ignorante to vse them Moyses beinge dead Cadmas in the daies of Iosue did firste inuente greeke characters 10. The holy scriptures doe testifie as also prophane histories Ioseph 1 â—pionem grammaticam Iosue c. 15 Iudic. 1. that learninge and philosophie came from the Phenicians Assirians Chaldeans and Aegipte vnto Greece and the same doth Iosephus teach The first vniuersitie that euer was was Cariath Sopher in the lande of Canaan in Asiria it was called the cittie of learninge neere vnto the cittie of Hebron longe after the Gretians begann to haue lettres and learninge and Origines saith none amoungest the Grecians did register or write any thinge of the actes or monuments of the Grecians before Homer and Hesiodus which were 400. yeares after Moyses and if there were any thing written of the Assyrians or of the Phenicians before Moyses they did perishe the holie scriptures by godes diuine prouidence beinge reserued safe and before any scripture there was the Church for betwixt Moses and our first Father was more then 2. thowsand yeares in all which time there was noe lawe written but the lawe of nature the word of God which he signified vnto Adam Noe Abraham or what otherwise he did inspire into the hartes of the Patriarches by tradition onlye it came to the posteritie and to Moyses himselfe soe as tradition was before the scripture more then 2000. yeares the lawe of grace which was by a liuely voice deliuered by Christe to his Apostles was not written by him nor commaunded by him to be written and therfore shall not the Christians beleue the same because he commaunded not it should be writteÌ„ or should the Christians which did beleue the Apostles before the same lawe was written be reputed fooles for beleeuinge the same before it was written For our Sauiour did not say Scribite Euangelium sed praedicate Euangelium omni creaturae write the ghospel but preach the ghospel to all creatures how many thowsandes be there in the worlde that cannot write nor read the scriptures and yet shall they not beleue them deliuered vnto them by the tradition and preachinge of the church sicut praedicauimus sic credidistis 1. Cor. 15. saith the Apostle as wee haue preached soe you haue beleued he did not say as wee haue written 2. Tim 3. Tu vero c. Doe you abide in those thinges that you haue learned knowinge or whome you haue learned them Act 15. 1. Cor. 11 soe it seemeth good to the holly ghoaste and vs if any man be contentious wee haue noe such custome He did not obiect scripture but custome and tradition 2. Thes 2 Horm in diacetis Cap 25. q. 1. therfore he said state in side stande fast to your faith and keepe the traditions Therfore it is inserted in the Cannons of Hormista prima salus est rectae fidei regulam custodire in constitutis patrum nullatenus deuiare it is the beginning of our saluation to obserue and keepe the rule of right faith and not to goe one steppe away from the decree and ordinance of our ancestors Certaine obiections answered against traditions taken out of the first Chapter of S. Paule to the Galathians CHAPTER III. 1. ALthough saith S. Paule wee Galat. 1. or an Angell from heauen euaÌ„gelize beside that which wee haue euangelized to you be he anathema or accursed This verie place is cited by S. Athanasius in the defense and confirmation of traditions sayinge If any man will cite out of scriptures any texte againste the decree or determinations of the churche and councells let him be accursed and although he alleadge all the scripture in the worlde against that which alreadie wee haue receaued wee must not beleeue him for children as Athanasius saith ought not to iudge of the decree of their parentes vnles they would haue themselues to be bastardes 2. Yet notwithstandinge wee must distinguishe the wordes of S. Paule which may be vnderstoode two manner of wayes as S. Augustine hath vnderstoode the same saying Aug. trac 96 super Iohn Aliud est euangelizare preterquam quod accepistis aliud est euangelizare plusquam accepistis euangelizare preterquam accepistis est transgredi regulam fidei recedere a via euangeliij semel per Apostolos praedicata for it is not all one to say to euangelize otherwise then you haue receaued and to euangelize more then you haue receaued for to euangelize otherwise theÌ„ you haue receaued is to transgresse the rule and limittes of faith and to departe from the decree of the Apostles which is a detestable thinge and therfore to euangelize more then you haue receaued is not S. Paules meaninge otherwise he should be repugnante to himselfe who desired to come to Thessalonica that he might supply what was defectiue and lackinge of other mens faith For when the Apostles vttered these wordes from Ephesus to Galatia the ghospells of the 4. Euangelistes were not written and specially the ghospell of S. Iohn For it is not all a like the ghospell and the writtinge of the ghospell the first that was written was the ghospell of S. Mathewe and S. Luke did supplye what was wanting of the same and S. Iohn in his ghospell did add in many thinges which was not writen in the other 3. Euangelistes And soe S. Paule himselfe in his Epistles did expresse many thinges which were not soe plaine in anye of the â— Euangelistes 3. Lastlie accordinge to the declaration of alâ— the doctors of the church especially Ireneus Tertulian Cyprian Hierom Augustine and others many thinges were deliuered vnto vs by the tradition of the Apostles which are not expreslie and maninifestly in the scriptures Basil in homil Sabel Arc. And therfore S. Basil saith Te paratum reddat traditio Dominus ita docuit Apostoli praedicauerunt patres custodierunt confirmauerunt martyres c. Let tradition please thee wee are soe taught by our Lord the Apostles haue soe preached vnto vs the fathers haue soe kepte the same and the same was confirmed by the Martyrs And in another place he further saith Basil ep ad Antiochenum Ecclesiae Fidem nos neque ab alijs scriptam nobis recentiorem susceptimus neque ipsi mentis nostrae germina tradere audeamus wee neither receaue a later faith written for
vs by others neither doe wee presume to deliuer euerie phantasie that springes out of our owne braine least matters of religion should be thoughte to be mens fictions or inuentions Whether we prohibit the scriptures to be translated into the vulgar tounge CHAPTER IV. 1. TRulye the Catholique Church doth nott altogether forbide vulgar translations of holly Scriptures althoughe shee would not haue euerie bodie at his pleasure to read the same or to make glosses thereon The councell of Trentt in the table of prohibited bookes and 4. rule permitted the vse of the vulgar translations to them whome the Bishopp or inquisitor with the licence of the pastoure shall thinke to be such as will reade them to their edification and not to their damadge Malmsburie affirmeth out of S. Bede that there was somtimes permitted vulgar translations in Englande The French alsoe had their French Bibles a long time and soe the Englishe catholiques by permission from Rome had the newe testamente in English 2. After the retourninge of the children of Israell from Babylon the diuine office the holly scriptures were read vnto the people in the Hebrewe tounge not withstandinge the Siriac or the Chaldean language was their vulgar tounge for the Hebrewe was not al that time vulgare otherwise the people should not haue had neede 2. Esd 8.13 of an interpretor when the lawe was read of Esdras as alsoe when Moyses and Iosias did propose the same vnto the people Againe the Apostles did write their ghospell in noe other languadge but in Hebrewe Greeke and Latine for Peter and Iames did write vnto the Iewes dispersed throughout the whole world in the greeke tounge as S. Iohn did write vnto the Persians 3. In Affricke as longe as the Christian religion was there the latine tonge was in vse as S. Aug. and S. Cyprian doe wittnesse Aug. de doctrina Christiana who also say that the psalmes were sounge in that languadge and in the Masse Sursum corda habemus ad Dominum gratias agamus Domino Deo nostro c. Isid lib. 2. de diuinis officijs cap. 2. Conc. Toll 4. Bed lib. 1. hist suaegent VVal to 3. de sacramentalibus Rab 2. de instit Cler. Rup de diuinis officiis That the latine tonge was vsed in Spaine in their churches it is wittnessed by S. Isidorus aboue 900. yeares a goe it was also decreed in the councell of Tollet that order should be obserued in singinge the spalmes In englande aboue 1000. yeres the seruice was in latine as Beda and Thomas Waldēsis doe wittnesse In Fraunce also the same tonge was in vse in their churches as Alcumus de diuinis officijs doth witnesse and Amallaricus Treuirēsis de officijs ecclesiasticis who saith that in all the weast the office of the church was in latine In Germanie the same also was obserued as Rabanus doth wittnesse and Rupertus 4. The Apostles as Iustinus Martyr doth obserue did celebrate and singe the psalmes to the gentiles conuerted to the faith in the greeke tonge notwitstandinge there were diuers tounges as of the Parthiās Medes Elamitans and such like neither yet in the vulgar greeke but in the Atticke which was the more common and more learned soe that the languadge which the greeke priests doe vse at Masse sacrifice is not the same that the vulgar sorte did vse Gregorie the 7. denied the kinge of Bohemia licence to translate the holy Bible into the vulgar tonge soe denied Innocentius the 3. longe requested therunto by the Bishopp of Mentes for these good fathers would not haue such profound misteries of the scripture to be in contempte and subiect to the crosse sense of the vulgar sorte for some simple religious persons readinge the holy scriptures did read of godes eyes armes and feete and such like which indeede ought to be vnderstoode not litteraly Cassiod colla 10. c. 2. 3. 4. 5. but metaphoricallie and therupon thought God to be a corpulent bodye or palpable subiecte 5. Dauid George the Hollander by readinge the scripture alsoe in the hollandish languadge found that the trewe Church should neuer fayle and because he found by experience that noe other church continewed soe longe as the Church of Rome he denied Christ to be the true Messias so that beinge subuerted and carried away by the sectaries of these daies he thought the Church of Rome not to be the true churche vnto which rather then he would yelde any beleefe he denied Christ to be God and soe denied the church of Rome to be true the churche And a certaine wooman in Englande hauinge heard the 25. Chapter of Ecclesiasticus read by the minister against women said it was the word of the diuill and not the word of God Bell. to 1. l. 2. c. 15. 6. Who can giue greater euidence of the inconuenience of readinge the scriptures more then the heretiques of this time euery one groundinge their heresies and absurdities vppon scriptures falslie applied and ill vnderstoode wherfore reason it self without other aucthoritie should perswade the church to haue the scriptures and her seruice in a certaine languadg otherwise there could be noe vnitie or communication of churches for none either learned or vnlearned should frequent any churches or heare seruice but in his owne Countrie where he should heare his owne vulgare languadge neither could there be generall councells for all the fathers that comes thither haue not euerie one of them the gifte of tonges and therfore this is the cause that the Apostles for the moste parte did write all in greeke for that at that tyme it was the commonest languadge of all as Cicero saith Oratione pro Archia poeta the greeke tounge is read almost amoungest all nations but the latine is restayned within her smale bondes and limittes but when the Romaine Empire beganne to florish the latine alsoe florished especially amoungest the learned as in Italie France Spaine Affrique and in other nations and therfore in respect that it is now the commō language the scriptures and seruice of the Church ought to be in the same 7. If any reason should moue the church to haue the scriptures in the vulgar tonges it is for that the simple people should vnderstande them but they cannot vnderstande the psalmes nor the prophetts nor many other bookes of the scripture neither by readinge them take much fruite thereby but rather great harme for if they should read in the prophett Osee Goe and make vnto yourselues children of fornications the adulterie of Dauid the incest of Thamar the lies of Iudith and how that Ioseph made his brethren druncke and how that Sara Lia and Rachell gaue their hand-maides as concubines to other men they would ether despise the Patriarches or imitate them in those thinges and when they should see soe many contradictories accordinge to the litterall sense which the rude cannot resolue they woulde be in a confusion or bringe the scriptures to manifest contempt 8. Also in
respecte that kingdomes and nations are subiecte to conquestes and inuasion of strange nations which alwayes for the most parte bringe with them their languadge vtterly defacinge the languadge of the country conquered soe also in these countries there muste be alterations of trāslations of scriptures which cannot be done without great danger of the corruption thereof either in respect of the ignorance or malice of the trāslators especiallie if they be heretiques which neuer translated the scriptures trulie being carried away by their passsionat affection of their heresie And therfore S. Hierom founde great faulte Hier epist ad Paulinum that the scripture should be soe common and in contempte for saith he talkatiue ould women and doting ould men the cauelinge Sophiste all men doe presume to speake of scripture they rent the scriptures in peeces they teach it before they learne it When S. Basil heard the cheefe cooke of the Emperor in his presence to speake of scriptures he reprehended him sayinge Tuum est de pulmentis cogitare non dogmata diuina decoquere it is thy office to thincke vppon thy cooquerie not to play the Cooke in diuine misteries I am sure if these fathers were liuinge in this wicked age to see the Cobler the Tailor the Tapster speake and dispute of scriptures and alsoe to preach in the pulpitt they would sharplie reprehend them Whether we forbid the ignorante to pray in a languadge which they vnderstand CHAPTER V. 1. Cor 14. 1. THe heretiques obiect vnto vs the wordes of S. Paul saying he that speaketh with the tongue let him pray that he may interprete for if I pray with the tonge my spirite prayeth but my vnderstandinge is without fruite I answere that although it be not fruitfull for his vnderstandinge yet it is fruitefull for his deuotion for here is noe mention made of any other tonges but of such as men did speake in the primitiue churche by miracle as of spirituall collations and exhortations which the christians were wont to make to praise God and not of those lāguadges which were then common to all the world as Hebrewe greeke and latine in which the scriptures both olde and newe were written For it is a palpable and grosse deceit and cogginge of the heretiques to say that the vertue and efficacie or the Sacramentes and sacrifice oblations prayers and religion dependeth vppon the peoples vnderstandinge hearing or knowledge the principall operation and force therof and of the whole misterie of the Church consistinge especially in the verie vertue of the worcke and the publicke office of the priestes who are appointed by Christe to dispose the misteries to our saluation The infant innocente idiott and vnlearned takinge noe lesse fruite by baptisme and all other diuine offices then the learnedest clearcke yea more if they be more humble charitable deuoute and obedient and perhappes wee see more often the simple to be more deuoute and the learned more rechles and more colde for deuotion doth not consiste in the vnderstandinge vnles the will be well affected 2. S. Augustine said of the common people non intellgendi vluacitas sed credendi simplicitas tutissimum facit It is not quicknes of vnderstanding but simplicitie of beleefe that shall saue vs And in another place he saith Si propter solos eos Christus mortuus est sui certa intelligentia possunt quae ad fidem pertinent discernere penè frustra in Ecclesia laboranus If Christe had died onlie for such as can vnderstand well the misteries of our faith in vaine well should labour in godes church for God doth rather respect your simple beleefe then your deepe vnderstandinge the affection of the will concerning your faith then the hawtie knowledge of your loftie minde Charitas aedificat scientia inflat as the Apostle saith charitie doth fruictifie to edification when science serueth for the moste parte to ostentation soe as our Sauiour did speake vnto the common people in parables whose simplicitie and godly affection did proffitt more therby then the wordlie wisdome and proud knowledge of the arrogant and swellinge Scribes and Pharesies 3. Doe you thincke that the children of the Hebrewes did vnderstande when they cried in the Temple Osanna filio Dauid Or that our Sauiour was displeased therby for that they vnderstoode it not but the priests and scribes were much confounded therby saying Audis quid isti dicunt truly our Sauiour was not discontented at the prayses of those littles ones for then the prophesie was fulfilled ex ore infantium lactentium c. thou makest an instrument of the tender infante and suckinge babe to magnifie and praise thy name to the confusion and ouerthrowe of thine enemies seinge the ende of all the scriptures and of the lawe of God and man and of the science and knowledge thereof is true and perfecte charitie inflaminge and inkendlinge our hartes with the firie loue both of God and our neighbors flowinge and florishing abondantlie with all fruitfull exercises and worckes of mercie pietie and religion as the Apostle saith plenitudo legis est dilectio the fulnes of the lawe is charitie 4. The experience of the catholique flocke in agreeing and submittinge themselues to the seruice of the church in the vniuersall and common languadge thereof and of their great increase and charitie pietie deuotion religion therby as their shinning resplendent vertues of their godly conuersation and their externall worckes of mercie may wittnesse and confirme the same and the example of the contrarie practise in fewe yeares paste of these new euangelistes or pretended reformers as in disagreeing from the common vse and custome of the whole churche and reuoltinge from the obedience thereof auoucheth no lesse as also the smale or noe fruite at all that their vulgar and confused translations haue brought both vnto themselues and to their miserable and scabbed flocke which like giddy heades and itchinge braines were not contented nor setled therein but conceaued great loathsomnes thereof like the children of Israell who hauinge soe earnestlie sought vnto themselues a kinge yet when he did raigne ouer them nothinge was more toilsome vnto them Puritants cares nott for prayers soe as nothinge is more troublesom vnto your carnal appetites then any sett prayers or seruice in your vulgar translations which the puritantes doe protest to be collected out of the Popes portuis Masse Admonitio parleamenti and consequentlie verie distastfull vnto them Admonition parl pag. 45. and for this cause by the protestants of englande are censured as scismatickes Was euer their stinge more venemous or their bookes more exasperatinge or more vehement against the seruice of the church in the latine tounge then it i◠this day against the booke of comon prayer set forth in the englishe tonge and set seruice in your owne churches I haue reade the slanderous and bitinge booke of Thomas Cartwrithe oppugninge the same against doctor White-guifte Bishopp of Canterburie for defending it
there-you may see with what inuectiue stiles redoublinge withall oprobrious tearmes they doe entertaine one another and what a generall reuolte wee see nowe a dayes from this vulgar translation of sett prayers order sett downe in that booke and comaunded to be putt in continuall practise into Caluinisme and Puritanisme yea and at last vnto plaine athisme who will haue noe set prayers or common seruice at all sauinge some lasciuious and wanton psalmes of Geneua rather for fashion sake or some carnall delight then for any spirituall deuotion I haue seene a pamphlett in printe which was exhibited to the parlament that it was not lawfull for christians to say our pater noster or the creede yea not in our vulgar tongue 8. God doth knowe and wee ought not to be ignorant that your vulgar and false translation of scriptures or set prayers is not for edification but rather for cauillation though you inculcate the same soe ofteÌ„ your selues not restinge therein but slidinge from it againe In the kingdome of Ireland you comaund the englishe Bible and the english common prayer booke to be obserued in all the churches of that poore kingdome coÌ„pellinge the prisoners to buy those bookes which themselues coulde not vnderstande yea not one person amoungest 40. when that comauÌ„d was giuen forthe could speake or vnderstande the english tonge And now in the kinges raigne you cause those bookes to be set forth in the Irishe tonge compellinge euerie parish church to pay 10. shil for an Irishe Bible when one amoungest a 100. cannott read them or vnderstand them and therfore an Irish protestant Bishopp did laugh at this strange kinde of alteration and said to some of his frindes in Queene Elizabeth her time wee had englishe Bibles and Irish ministers but nowe said he wee haue ministers come out of england vnto vs and Irish Bibles with them 6. Are not for the most parte all the benefices and church liuinges of that kingdome bestowed vpoÌ„ English Scotish ministers not one of them hauinge three wordes of the Irish tonge and although in the English pale and in porte townes the inhabitants especially the best sorte caÌ„ speake Englishe yet fewe of the common sorte except it be betwixt Dublin and Drodach and in 3. barronies in the country of Wexforde can speake any worde of Englishe and truly I thinke that the Irish Bibles haue as many faultes errors in theÌ„ as the translation Martine Luther made of the Bible in which Hieronimus Enser found more then 1000. errors which he set downe in the translation that he made 1522. And not only catholiques haue charged him with those errors but also Zuinglius who made another kind of translation disagreeing from that of Luther The same is also witnessed by your variable traÌ„slations of your English Bible the first not agreeing with the last nor With the seconde In the conference had at Hampton courte the English Bible was censured to be ill translated and containing very partiall vntrue and seditious notes and too much sauoringe of dangerous and traiterous conceites and soe order was taken to make a newe translation How can the true sense and meaninge of the oracles of God be imbraced if they be tossed and corrupted with euerie vulgar tongue which oughte to be a sufficient cause that it should be preserued in those languadges in which it was first set forth by the Apostles and fathers of the primitiue church Cor. 14 7. S. Paule did forbid a womaÌ„ to speake in the church but nowe euerie woman amoungest the protestants is a mistris of scripture are all men Apostles all Euangelists all doctors saith the Apostle but nowe this vulgar translation or rather corruption or prophanation all Shoomakers Coblers Tailors Tauernors yea and lasciuious wanton women yea the most ignorant of all are Apostles prophetts euangelists and doctors so as they take away all order and forme of discipline from godes church and in the place of Hierusalem which ought to be a cittie well ordered withall vnformitie both of doctrine and discipline there is a Babilon builded where there is nothinge but a sauadge and barbarous confusion Soe as wee may perceaue that this inordinate desire of knowinge the hidden and secrett misteries of God which he woulde not haue to be abused by these contemptuous spirittes brought such fruite vnto the worlde as that disordered greedines of our first parentes touching the knowledge of good and euill therfore wee are warned not to knowe to much but rather to feare least wee should abuse our knowledg and therfore the holly ghoast doth aduise vs Eccle c. 3. not to be curious in searching things aboue our capacitie and beyond our reache 8. The beginninge and end of Ezechiel as S. Hierom wittnesseth was read by noe man before he was 30. yeares of age Hier. in proemiâ— Ezech. Baptisme was vealed in the read sea the Eucharist in the paschall lambe in manna and in Melchisedeks bread and wine the trinitie was not knowen to any but to the prophetts and the highe priestes S. Paule calleth the incarnation misterium absconditum à saeculis A misterie hidden from ages for the word misterium is not to be made knowen or diuulged to euerie one Dion lib Eccles Hier. c 1. Orig. hom 5. in cant Hier. ep 81. ad Pamachum as Dyonisius and Origenes doe counsel Did not the Apostles forbide to write the creede that noe man might learne it but by word of mouth of the Christians S. Ambrose alsoe saith lib. de ijs qui initiantur cap. 9. lib. 6. de Sacra c. 4. that ineffable misteries must be kept silent And therfore in the latine translation of the scripture wee retaine many Hebrew wordes and not without great cause are they reserued in the very hebrew it selfe which cannot be soe well translated into the latine much lesse to any other languadge as Alleluia Osanna Amen Emanuell Rabbi Abba as also greeke wordes Kyrie eleison Psalmum Christum Baptismum Episcopum Diaconum Eucharistiam Euangelium which are greeke voyces and when the Pope doth celebrate the Ghospell and the Epistle are read in greeke before the latine in the churche of Constantinople those were read first by the grecians in latine and afterwardes in greeke and soe the latine was interpreted by the greeke and this as Remigius declareth was done to shew the vnitie of faith in those two churches and that greeke in which the priests in Grecia doe celebrate or say Masse is not the same which the vulgaâ—e people doe vse but farr different from it which only the learned sorte of people doe vnderstande euen as the latine tonge is not the vulgare tonge of the latines but the Italian tonge for the latine is only knoweÌ„ to the learned For as S. Basil saith Basil lib. de Spiritu sancto Num. 5. it is not a misterie if it be commoÌ„ to the vulgar sorte for in the olde lawe all the vessells of the tabernacle were couered
giuen also to others but Christ did not forbidd those to whome he comitted the gouernment of his church to denie it also to other some as it is said in the scripture Genes 9. that God hath giuen all cattle and beastes to the vse of man yet by that graunte or donation he hath not forbidden the superiors for disciplines sake to forbid their subiects in certaine tymes the vse of certaine meattes as God in his lawe by speciall commaundemente did forbidd the children of Israell all vncleane beastes and such that were strangled which neuerthelesse the church nowe doth teach and preach not that herein shee doth against Gods lawe or his precepte but that beinge taught by the holy ghoast shee doth interprete godes meaninge in the lawe For the positiue lawe of the church is nothing else then a certaine prescription of godes lawe and a certaine determination of that which is giuen in common God almightie commaunded vs in generall to praie to doe pennaunce to receaue the Eucharist but the church according to her wisdome and discretion respectinge rather the intente of the lawe-giuer then the lawe it selfe did prescribe both the tyme manner wherein and by which wee ought both to receaue the blessed Sacrament and to doe pennance and praie for the vulgar sorte yea and men of great learninge and science vnlesse they had bene endued with great charitie without these particuler determinations and comaundements of the Church would not keepe these generall comaundements Luther saith Luth. in lib. de formula missa lib. de Cōfessione parte 3. para 14. that the had noe other cause or any sufficient motiue to giue the Chalice to the laytie but that the church and the fathers did comaund the contrarie And in another place he dissuaded Christians from confession and from the Euchariste in time of easter because that the Pope commaunded it I will not obey his commaundemente saith he I will doe it saith he another tyme accordinge to myne owne pleasure but not accordinge to his precepte But Luther and all his malitious and turbulent followers ought to embrace the counsell that the Angell gaue to Agar the woman seruante Genes 16. Reuertere ad domum tuam humiliare suv◠manu illius retourne to thy house and humble thie selfe vnder her power This was spoken litterallie of Agar that shee should obey Sara and returne to her house which is allegorically spoken of the church vnderstoode by Sara and of the congregation of heretiques meante by Agar as S. Augustine doth teach vs. Whether the Catholicke Church doth add to this Sacramente in makinge it both a sacrifice and a Sacramente CHAPTER II. Cypr. epist 66. Chrysost hom 11. Damasc serm de cana 1. I ' Answere that the Catholique church doth add nothinge nor inuente any sacrifice but that which Christe instituted for a Sacramente which is our spirituall foode and may be said to be our daylie bread as also the great sacrifice of the newe testamente and soe Christ is said to be offered for vs two manner of wayes videlicet bloodilie and vnbloodilie In the first manner he offered himselfe for vs in ara crucis vpon the alter of the crosse which oblation the paschall lābe without spott which was offered by the Iewes did signifie In the second Cyrill ad Hebr. 9. Hier. cap. 9. ad Titum he offred himselfe in his last supper and nowe his priests doe offer him vpon the alter for the quicke and for the dead that accordinge to S. Cyrill the oblation of Melchisedech who did offer bread and wyne should be accomplished and that he should remayne a true priest accordinge the order of Melchisedech and that his priest hoode which is according to his humanitie and not accordinge to his diuinitie might endure for euer Soe as the Eucharist amongest other Sacraments of the old testamente hath this priuiledge How the Eucharist is a sacrifice and a Sacramēt and prerogatiue that it is a Sacramente when it is receaued by the faithfull and a sacrifice in asmuch as it is dailie offred for our offences to the eternall father And although euerie sacrifice be a Sacrament because it is a sacred thinge religiously instituted to sanctifie our soules notwithstādinge euerie Sacrament is not a sacrifice because it is not offred vnto God vnto whome sacrifice is offred and a Sacramente is ordained for men Soe as the Eucharist is of greater value and vertue as it is a sacrifice then as it is a Sacramente as Ioannes Roffensis saith in his articles against Luther and vpon this place related by Alfonso Salmeron Salmer tracta 16. in Ioannē That the Eucharist is a sacrifice of the newe lawe it is proued most aboūdantlie both by scriptures fathers and by councells 2. The first is by Malachias the prophett who did prophesie of this sacrifice after this manner Mal. c. 1. Psal 112. Non est mihi voluntas in vobis c. I haue noe likinge of yow and I will not receaue a gifte from your hand ab ortu solis vsque ad occasum c. from the risinge of the sunne vnto the goinge downe thereof magnum est nomen meum in gentibus in omni loco sacrificatur offertur nomini meo oblatio mūda quia magnum est nomen meum in gentibus my name is great amoungest the gentiles and in all places they doe sacrifice and offer vnto my name a cleane oblation This said the Lorde of hoasts he said that his name should be great amoungest the gentiles of whome this oblation should be offred for before the ghospell of Christe was preached vnto them noe oblation of theirs was lawfull neither the oblatiō of the Iewes was cleane it selfe but accordinge to the faith and deuotion of him that did offer the same besides they could not offer but at Hierusalem onlie and consequentlie it was not in all places of the worlde as it is mente heere from the easte to the weaste Neither can it be meant of a spirituall sacrifice either of prayers faith mercie or a contrite harte which in scriptures are called sacrifice as the Augustane Apologie doth interprete for manie reasons because that all these be not one sacrifice but many sacrifices as also because they doe not scceede the old sacrifices for in the old testament there was vse of those kinde of sacrifices as with vs and moreouer because they were not properlie called sacrifices but metaphoricallie neither are they offered in all places because they be spirituall thinges which needes noe place And much lesse are they vnderstoode of the preachinge of the ghospell as Bucerus writinge to Latonius doth interprete because preachinge is not properly called a sacrifice neither succeedeth it the olde sacrifices Neither the conuersion of the gentiles by the preachinge of the ghospell is this sacrifice as Aecolampadius doth expounde vnto the Senate of Basil for this is called an improper sacrifice neither one sacrifice but many
it it is found oute how such a footestoole of our Lord should be adored and worshipped and that wee doe not only not sinne in aâ—oringe and worshipping it but wee sinne in not adoringe and not worshippinge the saâ—e Therfore when thow dost bowe downe and prostrate thie selfe vnto any such earth doe not behould it as earth but behould that holie one whose footestoole that is which thou doest adore and worshipp because for his sake thow dost adore worshipp it Aug. cont Iul. Pela lib. 1. Amb. de ijs qui misteriis initiantur cap. vlt. 12. S. Ambrose that blessed Bishopp of Millane of whome Sainct Augustine saith Veneror vt patrem in christo c. I reuerence him as a father for he through the ghospell in Christe Iesu begott me doth plainly confirme this truethe saying Ipse clamat Dominus Iesus Hoc est corpus meum c. Our Lord Iesus himselfe crieth This is my body before the benediction of those heauenly woordes another kinde of nature is named after consecration the bodie is signified or mentioned he himselfe called it his blood before consecration it is named an other thinge after consecration it is called blood And thow saidst therunto Amen that is to say it is trewe let thie inward minde confesse that which thie mouth speaketh and let thie affection thincke that which thy speech soundeth And in that chapter he saith But perchaunce yow will saie I see an other thinge with myne eyes how then doe yow tell me that I receaue the bodie of Christe this then remaineth yet by vs to be proued how many examples therfore doe wee vse to shewe that this is not that which nature formed but that which benediction consecrated And that the power of benediction is greater then the power of nature for so much as nature it selfe is changed Moises held in his hand a rodd he cast the same foorthe and it was made a serpent againe he tooke vpp the serpent by the taile and the same retourned to the nature of the rodde yow see then by the grace giuen to that prophett that nature both in the rodd and serpent was twice changed the riuers of Egipt rann with pure and cleane water blood sodainlie brake out from the springes and fountaines there was drinke to be hadd out of the riuers and at the prophetts prayers the blood of the riuers ceased the nature of the water retourned All the rest of the holie fathers and doctors that liued before these and such as came after doe confirme with one vniforme consent this sacred doctrine 13. S. Andrewe the apostle as Aloysius Lipomanes a moste graue and learned aucthor doth gather out of the approued aucthors when he was to be crucified said these wordes Ego omnipotenti Deo c. I doe daylie sacrifice to the omnipotent God the vnspotted lambe who beinge trulie sacrificed and his fleash also eaten of the people remaineth both sounde and aliue Ignat. ep ad Smyrnenses S. Ignatius which was disciple vnto S. Iohn the Euangeliste writing against the heretiques Symonianus and Menandrianus who as they denied the Incarnation of Christe soe they did alsoe denie the misterie of this blessed Sacrament Sic ait Eucharistias oblationes non admittunt quod non confiteantur Eucharistiam esse carnem saluatoris c. Soe they doe not admitt eucharistes and oblations because they doe not confesse the Euchariste to be the flesh of our Sauiour which flesh did suffer for our offences Theo dialog 3. which the Father accordinge to his benignitie hath raised vpp this place is cited by Theodoretus Tertull. lib. 2. ad vxorem in libro de Idolatria Tertulian also reprehending wicked priests exclaymeth against them sayinge Semel Iudei Christo manus intulerunt vos c. The Iewes did offer violence vnto Christe but so yow doe also violatt and handle his bodye moste irreuerentlie such irreuerent handes should be cutt of c. And how should he saie these wordes if he should thincke that in the Eucharist should be only the figure of Christs bodie So Orig. homil 13. in Exod. expoundinge the 25. of that booke homil 7. libr. numeri in caput Math. 26. Math. vbi sic legimus homil 7. Leuit. homil 9. in Leuit. concita in cap. 15. Matth. So Cyp. who suffred death Anno Domini 259. sermone de lapsis So Athanas who is citted of Theodoretus Theod. 2. Dialog Cyrillus Hieroso initio Cathechesis 4. mistagogice in tota ferè Cathechesi Greg. Nyss in lib. de vita Moysis So. S. Optatus Milleuitanus which did florish in sanctitie and learninge in one tyme with S. Ambrose Quid enim est tam sacrilegum what is more detestable then to destroie and defile the alter on which somtimes yow haue offred your selues in which the desires of the people and the members of Christe are carried and a little after what is the alter but the seat of the bodie and blood of Christe S. Naz. liuinge also in the same tyme Nazianz. oratione de Pascha absque confusione dubio c. without confusion and doubt we eare his bodie and drincke his bloode 14. S. Ephrem the familiar frinde of S. S. Hieron in Cathalogo scrip Basill of that authoritie that in the church after the scriptures his woorks were read as S. Hero doth wittnesse saith Quid scrutaris c. whie should yow search the inscrutable thinges of God if you curiously search them yow ought not to be accompted a faithfull christian but a curious companion be faithfull and innocent be pertaker of the vnspotted body of oure Lord and assured with a sounde faith that yow eate whole the lambe himselfe S Epiphanius which was a familier frinde of S. Athanasius doth compare the heretiques that denie Christs bodie to be in the Sacramente with Aesops dogge who hauinge a peece of flesh in his Iâ—wes passinge ouer a riuer and behoulding the shadowe thereof in the water did let goe the trewe flesh striuinge by duckinge vnder the water to gett only the shadowe and soe he had neither the one nor the other soe the heretiques let ts goe the trewe flesh of Christe only for a figure and soe they haue neither benefitt by the one nor by the other Io. Diaco lib 2. vitae sanctit q. Sainct Gregorie as Ioannes Diaconus doth write did proue by a miracle that was don that the bread was turned into Christs fleshe Damascen which liued in the tyme of Leo the Imadge breaker in the yeare of our Lord God 740. saith Panis vinumique c. Bread wyne and water by the inuocation of the holy ghoste are supernaturally turned into the bodie and blood of Christe and they are not two but one and the selfe same thinge bread and wyne are not the figure of the bodie and blood of Christe God forbid but it is the selfe same bodie of our Lord deified Theophil in cap. Math. 26. Vnto this agreeth
are christians who hauing the keies of the kingdome of heauen doe in some sorte iudge vs before the day of iudgment Vict. 2. pers Vand. recounteth how wheÌ„ the priests were banished by the ArriaÌ„s the catholique people cried out moste lamentably to whome doe yow leaue vs miserable whiles you goe to your crownes who shall baptise these little ones with the fountaines of euerlastinge water who shall giue vs the guift of pennaunce and free vs from the baundes of sinne by the indulgence of reconsiliation because to yow it is said Whatsoeuer yow shall loose vpon earth shall be loosed in heauen Our Sauiour gaue to his Apostles consequentlie to S. Peter power to remitte sinnes whose sinnes yow forgiue c. and seinge the Pope is the lawfull successor of S. Peter it followeth that he succeded to him in his authoritie And although the heretiques doe aunswere that this power was giuen them by baptisme and preachinge yet it sufficeth not because this pouer was giuen them in distinct places from the place alleadged to witt in the last place of S. Mathewe and S. Marcke his ghospell and although by baptisme preachinge the Prieste in some sorte remitteth sinnes yet he cannot remitt the sinnes comitted after baptisme which cannot be reiterated and neither by baptisme or preachinge can he be said to retaine sinnes Whether fastinge from one sorte of meate more then from another or for to vse any obseruation therin be superstitious accordinge as protestants doe affirme CHAPTER V. AErius the heretique Aug lib. de heres cap. 33. Epiph. heres as S. Augustine and S. Epipha say defended this doctrine against the catholique churche as Luther and his followers doe now a daies for that say they they would not submitt themselues to any thinge that the churche comaunded Matt. 15. Mar. 7. They alleadge scriptures for themselues as the wordes of our Sauiour not that which entreth into the mouth defileth a man c. Aso they alleadge for themselues for breakinge of fasts the 14 chapter of S. Paule also S. Paule to Timothy In the last tymes men shall departe from the faith attendinge to spiritts of error and doctrine of deuills speakinge lies in hipocrisie forbiddinge to marrie and abstaine from meates which God created c. Aug. lib. de morib Ecc. Cath. cap. 33. To all which I aunswere with S. Augustine that catholiques doe not abstaine from certaine meates for that they esteeme any meat vncleane either by creation or by iudaicall obseruation but they abstaine for chastisinge of their concupiscence It is sinne only which properly defileth man and meates of themselues or of their owne nature doe not defile but by accident they make a man to sinne as the disobedience of Gods comaundements or of our superiors who forbidd some meates for certaine times and causes is a sinne as the apple which our first parents did eate though of it selfe it did not defile them yet beinge eaten against the precepte it did defile for neither flesh nor fish of it selfe doth defile Genes 3. Chrys homil 12. in 1. Timoth. but the breach of the churches precept is it which defileth And as for S. Paule he speaketh as S. Chrsostome said of the Manichees Eucratites and Marcionistes Epiph. here 45 26.6â— Hier. contra Iouin cap. Aug heres 25. and S. Ambrose addeth vppon this place the Patritians also S. Epiphanius S. Hierom S. Augustine and generally all antiquitie affirme the same both of them and also of the heretiques called Apostolici Ebiointes and the like whose heresie about marriadge was that to vse the act of matrimonie was of Sathan 2. Touching the prohibition of meates or vse of certaine creatures made to be eaten there were many opinions the first was of Philosophers Pithagoras Empedocles Apollinaris Porphirius and others who condemned the vse of meates as of beastes for that they thought that al beastes had reasonable soules and that they passed from bodie to bodie The second was of heretiques which condemned the vse of these meates for that they said they were câ—eated of the diuill and not of God as Marcion Tatian and Manichees against whome S. Paule his meaninge is to be constâ—ued in the said place of Timothy 1. Tim. 4. as it is declared in the Canons of the Apostles and in the councells of Ancira Gangrensis Epiph. heres 42.47 the fâ—rst of Toledo and Braga as also by Epipha The third opinion touchinge prohibition of meates was of certaine christians in the beginninge of the churche and after the publishinge of the ghospell who thought that christians were bound to abstaine from such meates as were prohibited by the old lawe of which opinion S. Paule speakes in the 14. chapter to the Romaines which he disproues aswell there as in the Actes of the Apostles Act. 10.15 Soe that by these places of scripture misaplied they goe about to abolish all fastinge which our Sauiour and all holie people as many as euer were in this world did obserue Matt. 4. and begon and finished their heroicall workes withall for our Sauiour fasted 40. dayes S. Iohn did abstaine from all delicate meates and drinckes Mat 3.11 Mar. 1. Num 6. Iere. 35.14 Iona 3. Mat. 9.14 the Recabites and Nazaretts are comended in holy scripture for their fastinge also the Niniuites for their fastinge were pardoned S. Iohns disciples fasted and Christ said to his disciples that they should obserue the same after his departure from them 3. Now the difference of the fast of the churche of God Aug. li. 5. contra Faustum cap. 5. Theod. in Epito diuinorum decretoruÌ„ c. de abst and of heretiques Saint Augustine declareth and Theodoretus also S. Bernard supra Cant. ser 66. Epipha in lib. de compend doctrinae catholicae for he saith that in the church there was great difference of fastinge accordinge either to the vowe or mortification of euerie one some fasted froÌ„ all kinde of fleash some fasted from eggs and all white meates some from any thing that should be fodd and from all kinde of fruictes for before the flood noe wine was droncken noe fleash was eaten And all the poore people either in the old lawe or in the lawe of grace did obserue this faste Moises and Elias fasted 40. dayes ether of them Samuell was comaunded he should drincke noe wine All the priestes that were imploied in the misteries of the church were forbidden to drinke any wine or any thinge else that should distemper them Iudith Hester Daniell and the Machabees by their fastinge haue atcheeued and perfourmed those worthie exploites which are registred in holie scriptures Againe wee are bid by Ioell to turne to God by fastinge Ioel. 1. Psal 68. Dauid said that he couered his soule with fastinge The iustification of a christian in this life as S. Augustine saith is fastinge Aug. in Psal 4.2 prayers and almesdeedes and therfore the catholique church as she ordained certaine times of
Ierusalem but the vniuersall church cannot erre therfore the generall councells cannot erre For Atha S. Epipha Euseb S. August doe call the generall councells the congregation of the whole world and the consent of the vniuersall churche All such places of scripture as doe proue that the Pope cannot err in the definition of faith proues also that the generall or nationall councell assembled by his authority cannot erre Also such places of scripture as proues and teaches that wee ought to reuerence Bishopps as Pastors to heare them as maisters followe them as captaines he that heareth yow heareth me c. obey your rulers be subiect vnto them and imbrace their doctrine with many such places all which doe argue that they cannot deceaue vs or if they doe wee may attribut the blame to our Sauiour that bids vs to obey them and imbrace their doctrine Atha epi. Epist. Epiph heres 77 Aug. 162. Nemo ca. de summa trinit fide catho Gela ep ad Episc Sardinia 5. This same is proued by the fathers that the difinition of a generall councell is the last iudgment of the church from which there is noe appellation as Athana and Epiphanius and others with S. Augustine doe affirme and soe Leo the Pope requested the Emperor Martianus saying that the definition of the generall councell should neuer be brought in question which the said Martianus established by lawe The same also Gelasius the Pope decreed in the councell of Ephesus circa finem and in the councell of Calchedon Act 5. Canone vlt. Moreouer the fathers and all councells doe teach that they are excomunicated and ought to be countted heretiques that doe not rest themselues vpon generall councells and therfore all generall councells doe pronouÌ„ce Anathema I meane the sore censure of excommunication against such as doe contradict the finall decree of generall councells as Athanasius doth wittnesse of the couÌ„cell of Nice Athan in epist ad Episcopos Afriâ—ae S. Grâ—gor Nazianz. in epistola priori ad ClidoniuÌ„ Leo epist ad Anatâ—lium and soe it is in all other councells Grego Nazianz. doth write when the Apolinaristes denied that they were not heretiques and that they were receaued in a catholique councell said let them shewe this and wee wil be contented S. Leo writinge to the emperor or Leon said they ought not to be accounted catholique that doe resiste the councell of Calcedon And soe he writes the like to Anatolius and S. Basil writes that they ought to be suspected of heresie Basil ep 78. that doe cal in question the determination of the councell of Nice S. Augustine did excuse S. Cyprian of heresie Aug. li. 1. de bap ca. 18. because noe generall councell defined any thinge to the contrary towchinge the baptisme of heretiques Also S. Gregorie pronounced excommmunicatioÌ„ against all that would not receaue the decree of generall councells Greg. li. 1. epist 24. Constantine the great in his epistle to the churches Apud Euseb l. 3. de vit Const Atha ep ad Episc Africanos Cyrill l. 1. de trinit Leo epist 53. ad AnatoliuÌ„ 54 ad MartianuÌ„ ep 37. ad LeoneÌ„ Auâ— Gre. lib. 1. ep 14 Nice epist ad MichaeleÌ„ Ambros epist 32. called the decree of the councell of Nice celestiall preceptes Athanasius also said that the decree of the church was the diuine precept which should remaine for euer S. Cyrill calles it the diuine iuste and holie oracle S. Leo saith that the Canons thereof were ordained by the holie ghoast and that the councell of Calcedon was assembled by the holy spiritt S. Gregorie also saith that he reuerenceth the first 4. generall councells as the 4. Euangelistes Nicholaus the first also saith that the decrees of generall councells are inspired by the holy ghoast S. Ambrose doth affirme that wee should rather die than wee should departe from the definitions of generall councells I will saith he followe the decree of the councell of Nice from the which neither death not sword shall separat me S. Hillarie suffred banishment for the faith of the councell of Nice Hilar. in fine lib de Synod Victor in libris trib de perâ—ec Vandalic Hier. lib. cont Luciferanos Victor Africanus describeth many worthy martires which suffred for the decree and definition of the faith sett downe and explicated in the councell of Nice S. Hierom also speakinge of Athanasius and S. Hillarie and other holy confessors saie How could they doe any thinge against the councell of Nice for the which they suffred banishment 6. This is proued by reason for first if the generall couÌ„cells should err ther should be noe certaine or setled iudgment in the church by which controuersie should be determined and descided and by which the vnitie and concord of the church should be preserued for which generall councells were ordained Secondly if there were not an infallible iudgment of these generall councells then the Arians had not bene condemned for heretiques for sayinge the councell of Nice did erre nor Macedonius for an heretique for sayinge the councell of Chalcedon did err nor Nestorius for an heretick for sayinge the councell of Ephesus did err nor Eutiches for sayinge the councell of Chalcedon did erre Thirdly wee should haue noe certaintie of many bookes of the holie scriptures as of S. Paule to the Hebrewes the 2. epistle of S. Peter the third of S. Iohn S. Iames his epistle S. Iude and the Apocalipes they beinge called in question vntill the trueth of them was made knowen by generall councells That the catolique church in those thing shee doth propound to the christians to beleeue whether they be contained in the Scriptures or not cannot erre CHAPTER II. THis is proued by scripture Ad Tim. 3 Ephes 5. Apoca 21 Psal 79. Isa 2. Matt. 13. 1. Cor 12. Ephe. 1. for that the church of Christe is the firmament and piller of truethe the spouse of Christe the holly cittie a fruitfull vineyarde a highe mountaine a direct way the only doâ—e the kingdome of heauen the bodie of Christe and multitude vnto whome the holie ghoaste is promised is gouerned of Christe beinge her head and of the holy ghoast beinge her soule as it is sett downe by S. Paule saying Ephe. 4. He gaue him as a head aboue euerie church which is his bodie And in another place he said one head and one spirite and he said as the husbaÌ„d is the head of the wife soe also Christ is the head of his church for if the church had bene impeached of error that imputation should be saide on Christe and the holie ghoaste therfore Christ did instruct her by his said holie spirite sayinge the spirite of trueth shall teach yow all trueth Ioh. 16. Againe wee are bounde vnder paine of excommunication to beleue the church in all things as may appeare by S. Math. If he will not heare the church Matt. 18. let him be vnto you as an ethnick and a
publican Further more wee say that the church is holie both in her profession and in the assertion of her faith therfore christian profession ought to containe nothinge but that which is trewe and holie touching faith Lastlie the fathers in all their doubtes and controuersies towching faith and religion did submitt themselues to the arbitrement of the church which they would not doe if they thought the church did err for S. Augustine saith Aug. epi. 118. l. 1. contra Crescentiū cap. 33. it is an insolent madnesse to dispute against any thinge that the vniuersall church decreede And in another place he saith Wee haue the trueth of holy scriptures when wee doe that which pleaseth the vniuersall churche And our Sauiour saith Luc. 10. Matt. 23. whosoeuer heareth yow heareth me c. whatsoeuer they comaund yow doe it c. Whether Catoliques are to be charged with arrogancie for thinkinge that their church cannot faile CHAPTER III. 1. WEe ought not to be cōuinced of arrogancie to affirme that Christe did not lie when he said that the gates of hell should not preuaile against his churche Matt. 16. Heauen and earth shall passe Matt. 24. Matt. 28. Ioh. 14. but his wordes shall not passe what woorde but that which is vniuersally preached by the catholique churche when he saith behold I am with yow to the worldes ende Ephes 5. The spiritt of trueth faileth not for euer Christ praieth that the faith of Peter should neuer faile 1. Tim. 1. she is his spouse and the kingdome of heauen wherfore should shee then faile beinge the piller of truethe shee cannot faile shee beinge his wife his doue his kingdome his portion his vineyarde his inheritance his dwellinge howse for the which he suffred his passion he died and shed his pretious blood shee cannot faile Contra Gent. 2. This was a cheefe argument by which S. Chrisostome did proue against the Gentiles that Christ was God by reason of his power in settinge foorth his church by poore and simple people and the continuance thereof in full force and authoritie notwithstandinge all the power and plotts of Sathan and all the might and strenght of earthlie potentates with the imploimēt of all their malice and strange pollices which were combined and conioined together for her direction If S. Chrisostome did proue the diuinitie of Christe by the continuance of his church 400. yeares how much more a minori ad maius should we proue the diuinitie and power of Christe not against gentiles as S. Chrisostome did but against worst infidels as caluinistes and other heretiques who with greate malice and more cunninge deuises seeke to ouerthrowe the church of God then all the enemies thereof as Iewes Goathes Hunnes Gaules Vandals Sarasins Longobards Bolgares Turcks and all other infidels and yet she is preserued now these 1620. yeares and shall allwaies continewe in full force authoritie to the worldes ende Psal 87. 3. The continewance of godes church is sett downe by the prophett Disposui testamentum electis meis what testament saith S. Aug. in enarrat ibid. but the newe testament I haue sworne vnto my seruant Dauid what is this that God bindeth with an oath that the seede of Abraham shall continewe for euer euer Ad Gal. 3 And soe saint Paule saith If yow be of Christ yow are the seed of Abraham inheritors of that promise this is the church saith saint Augustine not that fleash of Christ taken of the blessed Virgin but all wee that beleue in Christe And in another psalme he saith I will dwell in thy tabernacle wherfore S. Augustine saith that his church shall not be for a time but shall continewe for euer vnto the ende of the worlde And in the 14. our Lord hath bene mindfull of his testament and of the word that he comaunded to a thowsand generations Psal 14. and giuen to Abraham that which he did also sweare vnto Isaac and apointed for a lawe Matt. 24. He said his word should neuer passe away what word but that which did not only continewe duringe the Apostles time but that word and sacrifice which shall continewe to the worldes end Matt. 28. S. Leo prius epi. 3◠ad Pulcher. Aug. Leo 2. epist ad Constan our Sauiour plainlie declaringe the same I wil be with yow vnto the worldes ende as S. Leo the first and Leo the second writes Also when S. Paule Ephes 4. makes mention of soe manny dignities of ecclesiasticall order in Christ his churche as Apostles Prophetts Euangelists Pastors and Doctors he saith that they should continewe to the worldes end as the Prophett saith August Deus fundauit eam in eternum God founded the same for euer Psal 47. I meane his church as S. Augustine expoundeth and this is proued by the 91. chapter of Isay Luc 4. which chapter is vnderstoode of the churche of the newe testament as our Sauiour taughte 4. The same is also proued by the psalme 88. His throne shal be like the sunne in my presence Psal 88. and like a perfect Moone for euer and I will put his seate and his throne as the day of heauen Daniel 2. Daniell also doth manifest the same saying In the dayes of these kingdomes God shall raise vpp the kingdome of heauen which shall neuer be dispersed and his kingdome shall not be giuen to another nation And accordinge to saint Luke of his kingdome there shal be noe end Moreouer that psalme doth say if her children will offend and shall not keepe my lawes and comaundements c. yet I will visitt in a rodd their iniquitie and their sinnes in scourges I will not for all that put away my mercie from the same which place saint Cyprian aswell in this psalme as also in the 2. of Daniell doth expound to be mēt of the afflictions and tribulations of the churche In Cant. serm 79. S. Bernard also in illud tenui eum nec dimittam I held him and I will not let him goe c. neither then nor after the christian stocke shall not faile neither faith from the worlde neither charitie from the churche Lett all the raginge fire all the tēpestuous waues insult freate against her they shall not caste her downe because she is builded vpon a firme rocke and the rocke is Christe which neither by the pratinge of Philosophers or the cauillation of heretiques or by the sworde of persecutors can or shal be seperated Illir Glos in Math. cap. 2. 5. Illiricus a protestant writer saith that the trewe church in the middest of all persecutions destructions of citties comon wealthes and people is preserued miraculously by godes speciall protection and assistance This is also proued by Oecolāpadius vppon Isay cap. 2. by Melancthone in locis communibus cap. de ecclesia editione 1561. by Brentius vppon S. Luc cap. 17. homil 19. Luth. tomo 4. in Isa cap. 9. by Bullenger in Apocali Canc. 72.
vs all feare of God or of hell and soe giueth a scope to all mischeefe That the comaundements pertaines not to the christians That there is noe sinne but incredulitie and that all are deceaued if they thincke to be saued by good woorcks with many such vild and absurde doctrines which make a man careles of his saluation rechles of his behauior and nothinge willinge to doe anny good when neither he that doth them is not recompensed or rewarded or God offended or displeased by the saide doings For as by the catholique religion Christ reformed the wicked inclination of man gaue hoalsome precepts and councells to amend his desolute misdeamenor instituted also SacrameÌ„ts to cure all diseases of our soules and to purge our conscience from all filth of sinne now by these carnall and wicked doctrine all ragged conuersation and discomposed misbehauiour is reuiued and as Ouid saieth Iâ— quorum subiere locum fraudesque dolique Metamorphose Insidiaeque vis aâ—â—â— sceleratus habendi In place of simple dealinges and honestie Were brought into the world by heresie â—eceite couetousnes and leacherie 18. The 12. note is the perfecte rule that the Catholique church Io. 20. Luc. 10. Matt. 23. Matt. 19. Iacob 4. and Catholiqueâ— haue to direct them in their faith for the church of Christe hath the holy ghoaste to instruct her in all trueth and to guide her from all errors Iohn 14.16 and wee Catholiques beleeuinge the church as wee are taughte in the Creede when wee saye I beleeue in the holy Catholique church obeyinge her in all thinges as wee be comaunded by our Sauiour wee cannot be deceaued by her nor is it possible we can offend God in submittinge our selues to her doctrine Matt. 18.3 Reg. 4. Actor 15 beinge comaunded by God to hearcken to her and as Rebeca vnder tooke for Iacob to rid him of his fathers malediction if he should followe her aduise soe the Catholique church which Rebecca figured shall deliuer vs from the enormitie of godes malediction if wee shall obey her But the protestants haue noe rule of their faith for they doe not beleeue the churche neither the traditions and generall councells thereof neither the auncient holye doctors of the same The onlie rule they as themselues saie is the scripture But this is noe certaine rule for that wee are bounde to beleeue manny thinges which be not in the scripture Matt. 13. Hebr. 13. yea that which the scripture doth teach the contrarie as the obseruation of the saboath daye and thinges strangled Againe in many places the holy scripture doth wante explication of manny thinges 2. Petr. 3. for saint Peter saith that the epistles of saint Paule are verie hard to be vnderstoode which the vnlearned and vnstable depraue as alsoe the reste of the scriptures to their owne perdition Alsoe all heretiques doe alleadge the scriptures for themselues as saint Augustine sayes Aug. li. 1. de Trin. Hier. aduersus Lucifer for as saint Hierom saith the scripture doth not consiste in readinge but in the sense and vnderstandinge thereof and as for the vnderstandinge and sence of the same there may be a thowsand controuersies as for the trewe sense of these woordes Hoc est corpus meum this is my bodie I am sure Luther and Caluine are against one another touchinge the sense a and meaninge of those woords Therfore S. Augustine saith he would not beleeue the ghospell had he not bene moued therunto by the auctoritie of the churche 19. Soe as these protestants forsakinge the church they haue noe rule of their faith as may appeare by the deadly contention and debate which is daily betwixt them as betwixt Lutherans Caluinists and Anabaptistes for they charge on an other with heresies soe as each of these sectes is diuided into manny sectes for there are 13. sects of Lutherans differinge in opinions one from the other Also amoungest the Caluinists there are many as the world can tell for some of them would haue the kinge to be supreame head of the church others doe repine against it as the puritans doe The Anabaptistes are diuided vnto 14. sects and eche of them haue seuerall and contrarie opinions touchinge the principall pointes of their faith how can two lawiers pleadinge one against the other and ech of them alleadginge lawe for himselfe determine the righte of the cause and the sincere meaninge of the lawe without there were some iudge vnto whome they should referr the controuersie to be decided and debated And because these sectaries will haue noe other iudge but the scripture ech one alleadginge and interpretinge the sense thereof accordinge to his priuate opinion and corrupt affection their controuersie can neuer be decided nor their faith can neuer be setled or made certaine 20. The 13. note is the lawfull authoritie and mission of catholique pastors and preachers whereof the Protestants are wholie destitute no heretique being euer able to shew his next predecessor For as the holie doctors affirme There is no accesse to God but by Iesus Christ No accesse to Iesus Christ but by the church No accesse to the church but by the Sacraments No accesse to the Sacraments but by a Priest None can be a Priest vnles he be ordained by a Bishopp Neuer was there lawfull Bishopp ordained out of the catholique roman church Wherfore as saint Ierom said vnto his aduersarie you are out of the communion of the church of Iesus Christ because you haue not a priest of the order of the Mediator This marke of the vocation and perpetuall succession of pastors in the church of Christ hath euer ben most terrible vnto all heretiques for euen as Baptisme is the only doore to enter into all other Sacraments a Sacrament not reiterable and whose character is indellible euen so this Sacrament of holie Orders and of entring into steward-ship ouer the flock of Iesus Christ was ordayned by our Sauiour as necessarie for distinguishing and discerning such as be vsurpers and robbers from true and lawfull pastors then the other of Baptisme to knowe and discerne sheepe from Wolues and Christs flock from the troupes of infidels 21. This argument doth so gaule and pinche the Protestants that they are forced to fetch all the authoritie they haue for their vocation only from the temporall prince alledging the wordes of saint Paul that all authoritie is from God then saint Matth. that wee must giue vnto Cesar that which is Cesars then saint Peter that wee should be subiect to euerie humaine creature for godes sake all which places aswell the puritantes as the Catholiques doe interprete and vnderstand of temporall authoritie only for gouerning the common weaâ—th and not of spirituall direction and instruction of our soules in articles of our faith and saluation for that all Princes and kinges were then and 300. yeares after Christs passion infidels and especially the Romaine Emperor of whome this was principally intended Otherwise saint Peter and the Apostles who were
themselues to their definition and determination Acto 15. Chal in epist ad LeoneÌ„ 6. Synodus act 17. Celest papa epist ad Conc. Eph. Tolet. 3. Soe in the actes where the first christian councell was held and afterwardes in euerie age as occasion serued the councell of Chalcedon and the six generall councells and S. Celestine the Pope auerreth that generall councells are by manifest declaratioÌ„ shewed by Christ in these wordes Math 15. whensoeuer two or three shal be gathered together in my name there I shal be in the middest of them The Apostles which were replenished with the holy ghoaste did celebrate the first councell by the inspiration thereof when they said Acto 15. It seemeth good vnto the holie ghoaste and to vs. 2. There are four sortes of councells some whereof be generall some nationall Aug. li. 2. de bapt some prouinciall and some diocessiall Of the three formest S. Augustine makes mention of the laste the councell of Tollet The generall councells are such as when all the Bishopps and prelates of the whole world vnlesse they be lawfully letted doe assemble and the Pope or his legate ought to be President Nationall is when the Prelates of one kingdome and the Primate and Patriarche of that kingdome doth assemble together Prouinciall is of one Prouince Diocesiall is of one Diocesse General councells approued are reckned 18. in number The firste is of Nyce which was celebrated from the yeare of our Lord 328. vnto the yeare of our Lord 330. which was the 15. of Siluester the Pope and the 20. of Constantine the Emperor in which there were 318. Bishopps The second councell of Constantinople which was celebrated against Macedonius that denied the deitie of the holie ghoaste S. Damasus beinge Pope and Theodosius the great Emperor Prosper in chronico There were 105. Bishopps and 4. Patriarches Nectarius of Constantinople Timotheus of Alexandria Miletius of Alexandria and Cyrillus of Hierusalem Anno Domini 383. The 3. of Ephesus Celestinus beinge Pope and Theodosius the yonger Emperor Bishopps 200. Patriarches 3. vid. S. Cyrill of Alexandria that was the Pope his Attourney Iohn of Antioche Prosper in Chron. Socrates lib. 7. Iuuenall of Hierusalem against Nestorius Bishopp of Constantinople Anno 434. The 4. of Calcedon against Eutiches Leo the first beinge Pope and Matianus Emperor 454. accordinge the computation of Mathewe Palmer Bishopps there were 630. The 5. of Constantinople Vigilius being Pope and Iustinian Emperor Paulus Diaconus in vita eiusdem The 6. of Constantinople Agatha beinge Pope Constantine the 4. Emperor Anno 681. against those that held one nature only in Christe The 7. of Nice Adrian beinge Pope against Imadge breakers Ibid. lib. Rom. rer Anno Domini 781. in which there were Bishopps 360. The 8. of Constantinople Adrian the 2. beinge Pope and Basilius Emperor Anno Domini 87. The 9. of Lateran Celestine the 2. being Pope and Harrie the 5. Emperor wherin there were 900. Bishopps Anno 1123. for the recouering of the holy land The 10. Lotherius 2. wherin there were a thowsand Bishopps Anno 1237. Innocentius beinge Pope and Lotherius the Emperor The 11. of Lateran Alexander the 3. Pope and Fredericke the first Emperor for the reformation of the church against Waldenses Anno 1558. The 12. of Lateran against many heresies Innocentius the 3. being Pope and Fredericke the 2. Emperor for the recoueringe of the holie land The 13. of Lyons against the Emperor Fredericke the 2 Innocentius the 4. beinge Pope and for the recoueringe of the holie lande The 14. of Lyons wherin there were a thowsand fathers amoungest which there were 500. Bishopps Anno Domini 1274. against the errors of the Greekes Gregorie 5. beinge Pope and Rodolph Emperor The 15. of Viena Clement the 5. Pope and Henry the 7. Emperor against many heresies Bishopps there were 300. Anno 1311. The 16. of Florence against the errors of Greece Eugenius the 4. Albert Emperor 1489. The 17. of Lateran against scisme in the time of Iulius 2. Leo 10. Maximilian Emperor The 18. of Trentt which was begon Anno 1545. ended 1563. against the heresies of Luther Caluine and others in the time of Paulinus 3. Iulius 3. and Pius the 4. Charles the 5. and Ferdinand Emperors There were present 6. Cardinales 4. Legates 3. Patriarches 32. Archbishopps 208. Bishopps But all heretiques refuse generall councells as the Protestants doe and as the councell of Trent saith noe otherwise then wicked theeues refuse the triall of indifferent iurie 3. But we say that the holy councells of Gods church lawfully assembled by S. Peters successors not only by their personall presence Matt. 18 but also by their legates and substitutes in the definition of faith or good manners cannot erre For when our Sauiour said whensoeuer two or three shal be assembled together in my name there I wil be in the middest of them he added afterwardes of a man that is incorrigible tell the church thereof and if he will not heare the church let him be as an ethincke or publican I meane without faith and without grace He added moreouer in that chapter whatsoeuer yow shall binde in earth shal be bound in heauen and if two or three being lawfullie assembled together in Christs name Christ be in the middest of them vid. to assist them by his councell and light of vnderstandinge in those things that are necessarie for them how much more all Bishopps and Prelates which God hath appointed to gouerne and rule his churche shall obtaine of God knowledge and vnderstandinge for that function This argument the councell of CalcedoÌ„ did vse in an Epistle to Leo the Pope Concil Chalc. act 6 con act 17. Io. 16. Io. 14. saying Our Sauiour did promise to send the holie ghoast that should teach the Apostles all trueth and that he meant allâ—o the same to the successors of the Apostles he said that the holie spirite shall remaine in his churche for euer but the holie ghoast doth not teach the Bishopps in priuate or disioyned therfore when they be gathered together and therfore they say it pleaseth the holie ghoaste and vs which holie ghoaste is noe lesse necessarie for the conseruation of the churche nowe then in the begininge for the fondation thereof and therfore our Sauiour saith Mat. vlt. I wil be with yow vnto the consumation of the world and the gates of hell shall not preuaile against the church which as S. Paule saith 1. Tim. 3. is the firmament and piller of truethe 4. The generall councell representeth the vniuersall church 3. Reg. c 8. Athan. in epist de Synodis Arimin Seuleuciae ep ad Episcopos Affricanos Epiph. in fine Ancorat Euseb lib. 3. de vit Const Aug. li. 3. cont Donatist c. 18 Ephes 4. Act. 20. Luc. 10. Hebr. 13. 1. Tim. 3. Tit. as the assemblie that was made by Salomon in the Temple represented the whole church of