Commission that Christ gave a Pastoral Relation or Presbytership which was included in their Apostleship and Exercised toward the Church of Jerusalem Such Presbyter-ship John and Peter both had Hence there remains no other Successors jure to the Apostles but ordinary Pastors and Teachers These are relative Officers and are always in and to some particular Congregations we know of no Catholick visible Church that any Pastors are ordained to 1. The Scripture speaks of no Church as Catholick visible 2. The thing it self is but a Chimaera of some Men's Brains it 's not in rerum naturâ for if a Catholick visible Church be all the Churches that I see at a time I am not capable of seeing much more than what can Assemble in one place And if it be meant of all the Churches actually in being how are they visible to me where can they be seen in one place I may as well call all the Cities and Corporations in the World the Catholick visible City or Corporation which all rational Men would call Nonsence Besides if all Organized Churches could be got together it 's not Catholick in respect of Saints Militant much less of Triumphant for many are no Church Members that are Christs Members and many visible Members are no true Members of Christ Jesus Where is any such Church capable of Communion in all Ordinances in one place and the Scripture speaks of no other Organized visible Church Again to a Catholick visible Church constituted should be a Catholick visible Pastor or Pastors for as the Church is such is the Pastor and Officers to the Mystical Church Christ is the mystical Head and Pastor he is called the chief Bishop and Shepherd of our Souls 1 Pet. 2.25 hence the uncalled are his Sheep as John 10.16 but to all visible Churches Christ hath appointed a visible Pastor or Pastors and where is the Pastor of the Catholick visible Church he is not to be found unless it please us to take him from Rome To say that all individual Pastors are Pastors to the Catholick Church is either to say that they are invested with as much Pastoral Power and Charge in one Church as in another and then they are indefinite Pastors and therefore all Pastors have mutual Power in each others Churches and so John may come into Thomas his Church and exercise all parts of Jurisdiction there and Thomas into John's or a Minister to the Catholick Church hath an universal Catholick Power over the Catholick Church if so the Power and Charge which every ordinary Pastor hath is Apostolick Or lastly he is invested with an Arbitrary Power at least as to the taking up a particular Charge where he pleaseth with a non obstante to the Suffrages of the People for if he hath an Office whereby he is equally and indisputably related to all Churches it 's at his liberty by virtue of this Office to take where he pleaseth But every Church-Officer under Christ is a visible relate and the correlate must be such whence the Church must be visible to which he is an Officer It 's absurd to say a Man is a visible Husband to an invisible Wife the relate and correlate must be ejusdem naturae It 's true Christ is related to the Church as mystical Head but it 's in respect of the Church in its mystical Nature for Christ hath substituted no mystical Officers in his Church There is a great deal of difference between the mystical and external visible Church though the latter is founded upon it and for the sake of it It 's founded upon it as taking its true spiritual Original from it deriving vital Spirits from it by a mystical Vnion to and Communion with Christ and his Members and it 's for the Sake of it all external visible Assemblies Ministers Ordinances are for the sake of the mystical Body of Christ for calling in the Elect and the Edifying of them to that full measure of Stature they are designed unto But the different consideration lies in these Things 1. That the mystical Church doth never fail neither is diminished by any Shocks of Temptation or Suffering that in their visible Profession any of them undergo whereas visible Churches are often broken scattered yea unchurched and many Members fail of the Grace of God by final Apostasy Likewise Christ's mystical Church is many times preserved in that State only or mostly when Christ hath not a visible organized Church according to Institution to be found on the Face of the Earth so it was with his Church often under the Old Testament-Dispensation as in Aegypt in the Days of the Judges when the Ark was carried away by the Philistins in the Days of Manasseh and other wicked Kings and especially in Babylon In such times the Faithful Ones were preserved without the true Sacrifices the teaching Priest and the Law. So hath it been in the days of the New Testament in divers places under the Draconick Heathen Persecutions and afterward in the Wilderness-state of the Church under the Anti-Christian Vsurpations and false Worship Which mystical State is the place prepared of God to hide the Seed of the Woman in from the Dragons Rage for the space of One thousand two hundred and sixty Days Again Vnto this Mystical Church is only essentially necessary a mystical Vnion unto the Lord Jesus Christ by the Gift of the Father Acceptation and Covenant-undertaking of the Son the powerful and efficacious Work of the Spirit of the Father and the Son working true saving Faith in the Lord Jesus Christ and sincere Love to him and all his True Members Whereby as they have a firm and unshaken Vnion so they have a spiritual Communion though without those desirable Enjoyments of external Church Privileges and means of Grace which they are providentially often hindred from Visible Churches being but Christ's Tents and Tabernacles which he sometimes setteth up and sometimes takes down and removes at his Pleasure as he sees best for his Glory in the World. But of these he hath a special regard as to their Foundadation Matter Constitution and Order he gives forth an exact pattern from Mount Zion as of that Typical Tabernacle from Mount Sinai of Old. The Foundation part of a visible Church is the credible Profession of Faith and Holiness wherein the Lord Jesus Christ is the Corner Stone Eph. ij 20 Matth. xvi 18 This Profession is the Foundation but not the Church it self It 's not Articles of Faith or Profession of them in particular individual Persons that make an organized visible Church We are the Houshold of Faith built upon the Foundation c. 2. It 's Men and Women not Doctrine that are the Matter of a Church and these professing the Faith and practising Holiness The Members of Churches are always called in the New Testament Saints Faithful Believers They was such that were added to the Churches neither is every Believer so as such but as a professing Believer for a Man must appear
some Instances of the things wherein the Office-Duty of Pastors of the Church doth consist They are but some of them and those only proposed not pursued and pressed with the consideration of all those particular Duties with the manner of their performance way of management motives and enforcements defects and causes of them which would require a large Discourse These may suffice unto our present purpose and we may derive from them the ensuing brief considerations 1. A DUE meditation and view of these things as proposed in the Scripture is enough to make the wisest the best of Men and the most diligent in the discharge of the Pastoral Office to cry out with the Apostle and who is sufficient for these things This will make them look well to their Call and Entrance into this Office as that alone which will bear them out and justify them in the susception of it For no sense of insufficiency can utterly discourage any in the undertaking of a Work which he is assured that the Lord Christ calls him unto For where he calls to a Duty he gives competent strength for the performance of it And when we say Under a deep sense of our own weakness who is sufficient for these things he doth say My Grace is sufficient for you 2. ALTHOUGH all the things mentioned do plainly evidently and undeniably belong unto the discharge of the Pastoral Office yet in point of Fact we find by the Success that they are very little considered by the most that seek after it And the present Ruine of Religion as unto its Power Beauty and Glory in all places ariseth principally from this cause that Multitudes of those who undertake this Office are neither in any measure fit for it nor do either conscientiously attend unto or diligently perform the Duties that belong unto it It ever was and every will be true in general like Priest like People 3. WHEREAS the account which is to be given of this Office and the discharge of it at the last day unto Jesus Christ the consideration whereof had a mighty influence upon the Apostles themselves and all the Primitive Pastors of the Churches is frequently proposed unto us and many warnings given us thereon in the Scripture yet it is apparent they are but few who take it into due consideration In the great day of Christs Visitation he will proceed on such Articles as those here laid down and others expressed in the Scripture and not at all on those which are now enquired upon in our Episcopal Visitations And if they may be minded of their true interest and concern whilst they possess the places they hold in the Church without offence I would advise them to conform their Enquiries in their Visitations unto those which they cannot but know the Lord Christ will make in the great day of his Visitation which doth approach This I think but reasonable In the mean time for those who desire to give up their account with joy and confidence and not with grief and confusion it is their Wisdom and Duty continually to bear in Mind what it is that the Lord Christ requires of them in the discharge of their Office. To take Benefices to perform legal Duties by themselves or others is not fully compliant with what Pastors of Churches are called unto 4. IT is manifest also from hence how inconsistent it is with this Office and the due discharge of it for any one Man to undertake the relation of a Pastor unto more Churches than one especially if far distant from one another An evil this is like that of Mathematical Prognostications at Rome always condemned and always retained But one view of the Duties incumbent on each Pastor and of whose diligent performance he is to give an account at the last day will discard this practice from all approbation in the Minds of them that are sober However it is as good to have Ten Churches at once as having but one never to discharge the Duty of a Pastor towards it 5. ALL Churches may do well to consider the weight and burden that lies upon their Pastors and Teachers in the discharge of their Office that they may be constant in fervent Prayers and Supplications for them as also to provide what lies in them that they may be without trouble and cares about the things of this Life 6. THERE being so many Duties necessary unto the discharge of their Office and those of such various sorts and kinds as to require various Gifts and Abilities unto their due performance it seems very difficult to find a concurrence of them in any own person in any considerable degree so as that it is hard to conceive how the Office it self should be duly discharged I answer 1. The end both of the Office and of the discharge of it is the due Edification of the Church This therefore gives them their measure Where that is attained the Office is duly discharged though the Gifts whereby Men are enabled thereunto be not eminent 2. Where a Man is called unto this Office and applieth himself sincerely unto the due discharge of it if he be evidently defective with respect to any especial Duty or Duties of it that defect is to be supplied by calling any other unto his Assistance in Office who is qualified to make that supply unto the Edification of the Church And the like must be said concerning such Pastors as through Age or Bodily weakness are disabled from attendance unto any part of their Duty for still the Edification of the Church is that which in all these things is in the first place to be provided for 7. IT may be enquired what is the State of those Churches and what Relation with respect unto Communion we ought to have unto them whose Pastors are evidently defective in or neglective of these things so as that they are not in any competent measure attended unto And we may in particular instance in the first and the last of the Pastoral Duties before insisted on Suppose a Man be no way able to Preach the Word unto the Edification of them that are pleaded to be his Flock or having any ability yet doth not will not give himself unto the Word and Prayer or not labour in the Word and Doctrine unto the great prejudice of Edification And suppose the same Person be openly defective as unto an exemplary Conversation and on the contrary layeth the stumbling block of his own Sins and Follies before the eyes of others what shall we judge of his Ministry and of the state of that Church whereof he is a constituent part as its Ruler I Answer 1. I DO not believe it is in the power of any Church really to conferr the Pastoral Office by virtue of any Ordination whatever unto any who are openly and evidently destitute of all those previous Qualifications which the Scripture requireth in them who are to be called unto this Office. There is indeed a Latitude to be allowed
in judging of them in times of necessity and great penury of able Teachers so that Persons in holy Ministry design the Glory of God and the Edification of the Church according to their Ability But otherwise there is a nullity in the pretended Office. 2. WHERE any such are admitted through ignorance or mistake or the Usurpation of undue Power over Churches in imposing Ministers on them there is not an absolute nullity in their Administrations until they are discovered and convicted by the Rule and Law of Christ. But if on evidence hereof the people will voluntarily adhere unto them they are partakers of their Sins and do what in them lies to Vn-Church themselves 3. WHERE such Persons are by any means placed as Pastors in or over any Churches and there is no way for the Removal or Reformation it is Lawful unto it is the Duty of every one who takes care of his own Edification and Salvation to withdraw from the Communion of such Churches and to join with such as wherein Edification is better provided for For whereas this is the sole end of Churches of all their Offices Officers and Administrations it is the highest folly to imagine that any Disciple of Christ can be or is obliged by his Authority to abide in the Communion of such Churches without seeking Relief in the ways of his Appointment wherein that end is utterly overthrown 4. WHERE the generality of Churches in any kind of Association are headed by Pastors defective in these things in the matter declared there all publick Church-Reformation is morally impossible and it is the Duty of private Men to take care of their own Souls let Churches and Church-men say what they please SOME few things may yet be enquired into with reference unto the Office of a Pastor in the Church As 1. WHETHER a Man may be ordained a Pastor or a Minister without Relation unto any particular Church so as to be invested with Office-Power thereby IT is usually said that a Man may be Ordained a Minister unto or of the Catholick Church or to Convert Infidels although he be not related unto any particular Flock or Congregation I SHALL not at present discuss sundry things about the power and way of Ordination which influence this Controversy but only speak briefly unto the thing it self And 1. IT is granted that a Man endowed with Spiritual Gifts for the Preaching of the Gospel may be set apart by Fasting and Prayer unto that Work when he may be orderly called unto it in the Providence of God. For 1. Such an one hath a Call unto it materially in the Gifts which he hath received warranting him unto the exercise of them for the Edification of others as he hath occasion 1 Pet. 4.10 11. 1 Cor. 14.12 Setting apart unto an important Work by Prayer is a moral Duty and useful in Church Affairs in an especial manner Act. 13.12 2. A publick Testimony unto the Approbation of a Person undertaking the Work of Preaching is necessary 1. Unto the Communion of Churches that he may be received in any of them as is occasion of which sort were the Letters of Recommendation in the Primitive Church 1 Cor. 16.3 2 Cor. 3.1 3 Joh. 9. 2. Unto the safety of them amongst whom he may exercise his Gifts that they be not imposed on by false Teachers or Seducers Nor would the Primitive Church allow nor is it allowable in the Communion of Churches that any Person not so testified unto not so sent and warranted should undertake constantly to Preach the Gospel 2. SUCH Persons so set apart and sent may be esteemed Ministers in the general notion of the Word and may be useful in the calling and planting of Churches wherein they may be instated in the Pastoral Office. This was Originally the Work of Evangelists which Office being ceased in the Church as shall be proved elsewhere the Work may be supplied by Persons of this sort 3. NO Church whatever hath power to Ordain Men Ministers for the Conversion of Infidels Since the Cessation of extraordinary Officers and Offices the care of that Work is devolved meerly on the providence of God being left without the verge of Church-Institutions God alone can send and warrant Men for the undertaking of that Work. Nor can any Man know or be satisfied in a Call unto that Work without some previous guidance of Divine Providence leading him thereunto It is indeed the Duty of all the ordinary Ministers of the Church to diffuse the knowledge of Christ and the Gospel unto the Heathen and Infidels among whom or near unto whom their Habitation is cast and they have all manner of Divine Warranty for their so doing as many worthy Persons have done effectually in New England And it is the Duty of every true Christian who may be cast among them by the providence of God to instruct them according unto his Ability in the knowledge of the Truth But it is not in the power of any Church or any sort of ordinary Officers to Ordain a Person unto the Office of the Ministry for the Conversion of the Heathen antecedently unto any designation by Divine Providence thereunto 4. NO Man can be properly or compleatly Ordained unto the Ministry but he is Ordained unto a determinate Office as a Bishop an Elder a Pastor But this no Man can be but he who is Ordained in and unto a particular Church For the contrary practice 1. WOULD be contrary to the constant practice of the Apostles who Ordained no ordinary Officers but in and unto particular Churches which were to be their proper charge and care Act. 14.23 Tit. 1.5 Nor is there mention of any ordinary Officers in the whole Scripture but such as were fixed in the particular Churches where-unto they did relate Act. 20.28 Phil. 1.1 Revel 2.3 Nor was any such practice known or heard of in the Primitive Church Yea 2. IT was absolutely forbidden in the Ancient Church and all such Ordinations declared null so as not to communicate Office-Power or give any Ministerial Authority So it is expresly in the First Canon of the Council of Chalcedon and the Council Decrees That all Imposition of Hands in such cases is invalid and of no effect Yea so exact and careful were they in this matter that if any one for any just cause as he judged himself did leave his particular Church or Charge they would not allow him the Name or Title of a Bishop or to Officiate occasionally in that Church or any where else This is evident in the case of Eustathius a Bishop of Pamphilia The good Man finding the discharge of his Office very troublesome by reason of Secular Businesses that it was incumbred withal and much opposition with Reproach that befell him from the Church it self of his own accord laid down and resigned his Charge the Church choosing one Theodorus in his room But afterwards he desired that though he had left his Charge he might retain the Name Title
judgment who have most weighed and considered the nature of these things do assert the necessity of many Elders in every particular Church which is the common judgment and practice of the Reformed Churches in all places 13. AND some there are who begin to maintain That there is no need of any more but One Pastor Bishop or Elder in a particular Church which hath its Rule in its self other Elders for Rule being unnecessary This is a Novel Opinion contradictory to the sence and practice of the Church in all Ages And I shall prove the contrary 1. THE pattern of the First Churches constituted by the Apostles which it is our Duty to imitate and follow as our Rule constantly expresseth and declares That many Elders were appointed by them in every Church Act. 11.30 Chap. 14.23 Chap. 15.2 4 6 22. Chap. 16.4 Chap. 20.17 c. 1 Tim. 5.17 Phil. 1.1 Tit. 1.5 1 Pet. 5.1 There is no mention in the Scripture no mention in Antiquity of any Church wherein there was not more Elders than One nor doth that Church answer the Original Pattern where it is otherwise 2. WHERE there is but one Elder in a Church there cannot be an Eldership or Presbytery as there cannot be a Senate where there is but one Senator which is contrary unto 1 Tim. 4.14 3. THE continuation of every Church in its original State and Constitution is since the ceasing of extraordinary Offices and Powers committed to the Care and Power of the Church it self Hereunto the Calling and Ordaining of ordinary Officers Pastors Rulers Elders Teachers do belong And therein as we have proved both the Election of the People submitting themselves unto them in the Lord and the solemn setting of them apart by Imposition of Hands do concurr But if there be but One Elder only in a Church upon his Death or Removal this Imposition of Hands must either be left unto the People or be supplied by Elders of other Churches or be wholly omitted all which are irregular And that Church-Order is defective which wants the Symbol of Authoritative Ordination 4. IT is difficult if not impossible on a supposition of One Elder only in a Church to preserve the Rule of the Church from being Prelatical or Popular There is nothing more frequently objected unto those who dissent from Diocesan Bishops than that they would every one be Bishops in their own Parishes and unto their own People All such pretences are excluded on our principles of the Liberty of the People of the necessity of many Elders in the same Church in an equality of Power and the Communion of other Churches in Association But practically where there is but One Elder one of the extreams can be hardly avoided If he Rule by himself without the previous Advice in some cases as well as the subsequent consent of the Church it hath an eye of unwarrantable Prelacy in it If every thing be to be Originally Transacted Disposed Ordered by the whole Society the Authority of the Elder will quickly be insignificant and he will be little more in point of Rule than any other Brother of the Society But all these Inconveniencies are prevented by the fixing of many Elders in each Church which may maintain the Authority of the Presbytery and free the Church from the Despotical Rule of any Diotrâ—phes But in case there be but one in any Church unless he have Wisdom to maintain the Authority of the Eldership in his own Person and Actings there is no Rule but Confusion 5. THE nature of the Work whereunto they are called requires that in every Church consisting in any considerable number of Members there should be more Elders than One. When God first appointed Rule in the Church under the Old Testament he assigned unto every Ten Persons or Families a distinct Ruler Deut. 1.15 For the Elders are to take care of the Walk or Conversation of all the Members of the Church that it be according unto the Rule of the Gospel This Rule is eminent as unto the holiness that it requires above all other Rules of moral Conversation whatever And there is in all the Members of the Church great Accuracy and Circumspection required in their walking after it and according unto it The Order also and Decency which is required in all Church-Assemblies stands in need of exact care and inspection That all these things can be attended unto and discharged in a due manner in any Church by One Elder is for them only to suppose who know nothing of them And although there may be an appearance for a season of all these things in such Churches yet there being not therein a due compliance with the Wisdom and Institution of Christ they have no present Beauty nor will be of any long continuance THESE considerations as also those that follow may seem jejune and contemptible unto such as have another frame of Church-Rule and Order drawn in their Minds and Interests A Government vested in some few Persons with Titles of Preheminence and Legal Power exercised in Courts with Coercive Jurisdiction by the Methods and Processes of Canons of their own framing is that which they suppose doth better become the Grandeur of Church-Rulers and the State of the Church than these Creeping Elders with their Congregations But whereas our present enquiry after these things is only in and out of the Scripture wherein there is neither shadow nor appearance of any of these practices I beg their pardon if at present I consider them not 10. WE shall now make Application of these things unto our present purpose I say then 1. Whereas there is a Work of Rule in the Church distinct from that of Pastoral Feeding 2. Whereas this Work is to be attended unto with diligence which includes the whole Duty of him that attends unto it And 3. That the Ministry of the Word and Prayer with all those Duties that accompany it is a full Employment for any Man and so consequently his principal and proper Work which it is unlawful for him to be remiss in by attending on another with Diligence And 4. Whereas there ought to be many Elders in every Church that both the Works of Teaching and Ruling may be constantly attended unto 5. That in the Wisdom of the Holy Ghost distinct Works did require distinct Offices for their discharge all which we have proved already our enquiry hereon is Whether the same Holy Spirit hath not distinguished this Office of Elders into those two sorts namely those who are called unto Teaching and Rule also and those who are called unto Rule only which we Affirm THE Testimonies whereby the Truth of this Assertion is confirmed are generally known and pleaded I shall insist on some of them only beginning with that which is of uncontroulable evidence if it had any thing to conflict withal but prejudices and interest and this is 1 Tim. 5.17 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 is Praesum Praesidio to Preside to Rule Praesident
have to do and the manner how they are to do it is altogether unreasonable and senceless unto them who have another Idea of Church-Affairs and Rule conceived in their Minds or received by Tradition and riveted by Interest And on the other hand those who know little or nothing of what belongs unto the due Edification of the Church beyond Preaching the Word and reaping the Advantage that is obtained thereby cannot see any necessity of the distribution of these several Works and Duties unto several Officers but suppose all may be done well enough by One or Two in the same Office. Wherefore it will be necessary that we treat briefly of the Nature of the Rule of the Church in particular and what is required thereunto which shall be done in the close of this Discourse 9. THE Exceptions which are usually put in unto this Testimony have not the least countenance from the Text or Context nor the matter treated of nor Confirmation 〈◊〉 any other Divine Testimony It is therefore in vain to contend about them being such as any Man may multiply at his pleasure on the like occasion and used by those who on other considerations are not willing that things should be as they are here declared to be by the Apostle Yet we may take a brief Specimen of them Some say it is Gifts absolutely without respect unto distinct Offices that the Apostle Treats of which hath been disproved from the Text and Context before Some say that Rule is included in the Pastoral Office so as that the Pastor only is here intended But 1. Rule is not his principal Work which he is to attend unto in a peculiar manner with diligence above other parts of his Duty 2. The care of the Poor of the Flock belongs also to the Pastoral Office yet is there another Office appointed to attend unto it in a peculiar manner Act. 6. 3. He that Ruleth is in this place expresly distinguished from him that Exhorteth and him that Teacheth Some say that he that Ruleth is he that Ruleth his Family But this is disproved by the Analysis of the Chapter before declared And this Duty which is common unto all that have Families and confined unto their Families is ill placed among those publick Duties which are designed unto the Edification of the whole Church It is objected that he that Ruleth is here placed after him that giveth that is the Deacon I say then it cannot be the Pastor that is intended if we may prescribe Methods of expressing himself unto the Apostle But he useth his Liberty and doth not oblige himself unto any Order in the annumeration of the Offices of the Church see 1 Cor. 12.8 9 10 28. And some other Exceptions are insisted on of the same nature and importance which indeed deserve not our consideration 10. THERE is the same Evidence given unto the Truth argued for in another Testimony of the same Apostle 1 Cor. 12.28 God hath set some in the Church First Apostles Secondarily Prophets Thirdly Teachers after that Miracles then Gifts of Healings Helps Governments Diversities of Tongues I shall not insist on this Testimony and its Vindication in particular seeing many things would be required thereunto which have been Treated of already Some things may be briefly observed concerning it That there is here an Annumeration of Officers and Offices in the Church both extraordinary for that season and ordinary for continuance is beyond exception Unto them is added the present exercise of some extraordinary Gifts as Miracles Healing Tongues That by Helps the Deacons of the Church are intended most do agree because their Original Institution was as helpers in the Affairs of the Church Governments are Governours or Rulers the Abstract for the Concrete that is such as are distinct from Teachers such hath God placed in the Church and such there ought to be But it is said that Gifts not Offices are intended the Gift of Goverment or Gift for Government If so then these Gifts are either ordinary or extraordinary if ordinary how come they to be reckoned among Miracles Healing and Tongues if extraordinary what extraordinary Gifts for Government were then given distinct from those of the Apostles and what instance is any where given of them in the Scripture Again If God hath given Gifts for Government to abide in the Church distinct from those given unto Teachers and unto other Persons than the Teachers then is there a distinct Office of Rule or Government in the Church which is all we plead for 11. THE Original Order in these things is plain in the Scripture The Apostles had all Church-Power and Church-Office in themselves with Authority to exercise all Acts of them everywhere on all occasions But considering the nature of the Church with that of the Rule appointed by the Lord Christ in it or over it they did not they would not ordinarily exercise their power by themselves or in their own persons alone And therefore when the First Church consisted of a small number the Apostles acted all things in it by the consent of the whole Multitude or the Fraternity as we have proved from Acts the First And when the number of Believers encreased so as that the Apostles themselves could not in their own Persons attend unto all the Duties that were to be performed towards the Church by virtue of Office they added by the direction of the Holy Ghost the Office of the Deacons for the especial discharge of the Duty which the Church oweth unto its poor Members Whereas therefore it is evident that the Apostles could no more personally attend unto the Rule of the Church with all that belongs thereunto without an entrenchment on that labour in the Word and Prayer which was incumbent on them than they could attend unto the Relief of the Poor they appointed Elders to help and assist in that part of Office-Work as the Deacons did in the other THESE Elders are first mentioned Act. 11.30 where they are spoken of as those which were well known and had now been of some time in the Church Afterwards they are still mentioned in conjunction with the Apostles and distinction from the Church it self Acts 15.2 4 6 22. Chap. 16.4 Chap. 21.18 Now the Apostles themselves were Teaching Elders that is such as had the Work of Teaching and Rule committed to them 1 Pet. 5.1 2 Joh. 1. And these Elders are constantly distinguished from them which makes it evident that they were not Teaching Elders And therefore in all the mention that is made of them the Work of Teaching or Preaching is no where ascribed unto them which at Jerusalem the Apostles reserved to themselves Act. 6.2 3. but they are every where introduced as joining with the Apostles in the Rule of the Church and that in distinction from the Church it self or the Brethren of it Yea it is altogether improbable that whilst the Apostles were at Jerusalem giving themselves wholly unto the Word and Prayer that they
cases Dubious and Disputable wherein Right and Wrong are not easily determinable unto all unprejudiced persons that know the Will of God in such things Nor is it to be admitted when the matter of Fact stands in need of Testimony and is not proved by Two Witnesses at the least 2. ALL Prejudices all Partiality all Provocations all Haste and Precipitation are most carefully to be avoided in this Administration for the Judgment is the Lords Wherefore 3. WE are continually in all things that tend unto this Sentence and eminently in the Sentence it self to charge our Consciences with the Mind of Christ and what he would do himself in the case considering his Love Grace Mercy and Patience with instances of his Condescension which he gave us in this World. 4. THERE is also required of us herein a constant Remembrance that we also are in the Flesh and liable to Temptation which may restrain and keep in awe that forwardness and confidence which some are apt to manifest in such cases In all these things a watchful Eye is to be kept over the methods of Satan who by all means seeks to pervert this Ordinance unto the Destruction of Men which is appointed for their Edification and too often prevails in that Design And if by the Negligence of a Church in the management and pursuit of this Ordinance he gets advantage to pervert it unto the Ruine of any it is the fault of that Church in that they have not been careful of the Honour of Christ therein Wherefore 1. AS Excommunication by a cursed Noise and Clamor with Bell Book and Candle such as we have instances of in some Papal Councils is an horrible Anti-christian Abomination So 2. IT is an undue Representation of Christ and his Authority for persons openly guilty of profaneness in sinning to Excommunicate them who are blameless in all Christian Obedience 3. ALL Excommunication is Evangelically null where there is wanting an Evangelical frame of spirit in those by whom it is Administred and there is present an Anti-evangelical Order in its Administration 4. IT is sufficiently evident that after all the Contests and Disputes about this Excommunication that have been in the World the Noise that it hath made the horrible Abuses that it hath been put unto the wresting of all Church-Order and Rule to give countenance unto a corrupt Administration of it with the needless Oppositions that have been made against its Institution there is nothing in it nothing belongs unto it nothing required unto its Administration wherein Mens outward Interests are at all concerned and which the smallest number of sincere Christians in any Church-Society may not perform and discharge unto the Glory of Christ and their own Edification IT is the Mystery of Iniquity that hath traversed these things into such a state and posture as is unintelligible unto spiritual Wisdom unpracticable in the Obedience of Faith and ruinous unto all Evangelical Order and Discipline CHAP. XI Of the Communion of Churches CHURCHES so appointed and established in Order as hath been declared ought to hold Communion among themselves or with each other as unto all the ends of their Institution and Order For these are the same in all Yea the general end of them is in Order of Nature considered antecedently unto their Institution in particular This end is the Edification of the Body of Christ in general or the Church Catholick The promotion hereof is committed jointly and severally unto all particular Churches Wherefore with respect hereunto they are obliged unto mutual Communion among themselves which is their consent endeavour and conjunction in and for the promotion of the Edification of the Catholick Church and therin their own as they are Parts and Members of it THIS Communion is incumbent on every Church with respect unto all other Churches of Christ in the World equally And the Duties and Acts of it in all of them are of the same kind and nature For there is no such disparity between them or subordination among them as should make a difference between the Acts of their mutual Communion so as that the Acts of some should be Acts of Authority and those of others Acts of obedience or subjection Where ever there is a Church whether it be at Rome or Egubium in a City or a Village the Communion of them all is mutual the Acts of it of the same kind however one Church may have more Advantages to be useful and helpful therein than another And the abuse of those Advantages was that which wrought effectually in the beginning of that disorder which at length destroyed the Catholick Church with all Church-Communion whatever For some Churches especially that of Rome having many Advantages in Gifts Abilities Numbers and Reputation above many above most Churches for usefulness in their mutual Communion the Guides of it insensibly turned and perverted the Addresses made unto them the Advises and Assistances desired of them in way of Communion or their pretences of such Addresses and Desires into an Usurpation first of a primacy of Honour then of Order then of Supremacy and Jurisdiction unto the utter overthrow of all Church-Order and Communion and at length of the whole nature of the Catholick Church as stated and subsisting in particular Churches as we shall see ALL Churches on their first institution quickly found themselves indigent and wanting though not as unto their Being Power and Order yet as unto their well-being with their preservation in Truth and Order upon extraordinary Occurrences as also with respect unto their usefulness and serviceableness unto the general end of furthering the Edification of the Church Catholick The care hereof and the making provision for this defect was committed by our Lord Jesus Christ unto the Apostles during their Lives which Paul calls 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 2 Cor. 11.28 The care of all the Churches For what was only a pressing care and burden unto them was afterward contended for by others as a matter of Dignity and Power the pretence of it in one especially being turned into a cursed Domination under the Stile and Title of Servus Servorum Dei. BUT if a Thousand pretences should be made of supplying Churches defects after the decease of the Apostles by any other Order Way or Means besides this of the equal Communion of Churches among themselves they will be all found destitute of any Countenance from the Scripture Primitive Antiquity the nature use and end of Churches yea of Christian Religion it self Yet the pretence hereof is the sole foundation of all that disposal of Churches into several stories of Subordination with an Authority and Jurisdiction over one another which now prevails in the World. But there is no place for such Imaginations until it be proved either that our Lord Jesus Christ hath not appointed the mutual Communion of Churches among themselves by their own consent or that it is not sufficient for the preservation of the Vnion and furtherance of the
from the Scripture in Doctrine or giving Counsel as unto practice Synodically unto them whose proper Representatives are present in it whose Decrees and Determinations are to be received and submitted unto on the evidence of their Truth and Necessity as recommended by the Authority of the Synod from the promised Presence of Christ among them is suitable unto the Mind of Christ and the Example given by the Apostles Act. 15. HENCE it is evident that in and after such Synods it is in the power of Churches concerned humbly to consider and weigh 1. The evidences of the Presence of Christ in them from the manner causes and ends of their Assembling and from their Deportment therein 2. What regard in their Constitutions and Determinations there hath been unto the Word of God and whether in all things it hath had its due preheminence 3. How all their Determinations have been educed from its Truth and are confirmed by its Authority WITHOUT a due exercise of judgment with respect unto these things none can be obliged by any Synodical Determinations seeing without them and on the want of them many Assemblies of Bishops who have had the outward Appearance and Title of Synods or Councils have been Dens of Thieves Robbers Idolaters managing their Synodical Affairs with fury wrath horrible craft according to their Interests unto the Ruine of the Church such were the Second Ephesine the Second at Nice and that at Trent and others not a few HENCE nothing is more to be feared especially in a state of the Church wherein it is declining in Faith Worship and Holiness than Synods according to the usual way of their calling and convention where these things are absent For they have already been the principal means of leading on and justifying all the Apostasy which Churches have fallen into For never was there yet Synod of that nature which did not confirm all the Errors and Superstitions which had in common practice entred into the Church and opened a Door to a progress in them nor was ever the pretence of any of them for outward Reformation of any use or signification 2. THE Authority of a Synod determining Articles of Faith constituting Orders and Decrees for the conscientious observance of things of their own appointment to be submitted unto and obeyed on the Reason of that Authority under the penalty of Excommunication and the trouble by Custom and Tyranny thereto annexed or acted in a way of Jurisdiction over Churches or Persons is a meer Humane Invention for which nothing can be pleaded but prescription from the Fourth Century of the Church when the progress of the fatal Apostasy became visible THE proof of both these Assertions depends on what was before declared of the nature and use of these Synods For if they are such as we have evinced no other Power or Authority can be ascribed unto them but that here allowed Yet the whole may be farther illustrated by some brief considerations of the Assembly at Jerusalem in the nature of a Synod Recorded Act. 15. 1. THE occasion of it was a difference in the Church of Antioch which they could not compose among themselves because those who caused the Difference pretended Authority from the Apostles as is evident v. 1. and 14. 2. THE means of its convention was the desire and voluntary reference of the matters in debate made by the Church at Antioch where the difference was unto that at Jerusalem whence as it was pretended the cause of the difference arose unto the hazzard of their mutual Communion to be consulted of with their own Messengers 3. THE Persons constituting the Synod were the Apostles Elders and Brethren of the Church at Jerusalem and the Messengers of that Antioch with whom Paul and Barnabas were joined in the same Delegation 4. THE matter in difference was debated as unto the mind of God concerning it in the Scripture and out of the Scripture On James's proposal the determination was made 5. THERE was nothing imposed a new on the practice of the Churches only direction is given in one particular instance as unto Duty necessary on many accounts unto the Gentile Converts namely to abstain from Fornication and from the use of their Liberty in such instances of its practice as whereon scandal would ensue which was the Duty of all Christians even before this determination and is so still in many other instances besides those mentioned in the Decree only it was now declared unto them 6. THE Grounds whereon the Synod proposed the Reception of and compliance with its Decrees were Four 1. That what they had determined was the mind of the Holy Ghost It pleased the Holy Ghost This mind they knew either by Inspiration or immediate Revelation made unto themselves or by what was Written or Recorded in the Scripture which on all other occasions they alledged as what was the Word and spoken by the Holy Ghost And it is evident that it was this latter way namely a discovery of the mind of the Holy Ghost in the Scripture that is intended However it is concluded that nothing be proposed or confirmed in Synods but what is well known to be the mind of the Holy Ghost in the Scripture either by immediate Inspiration or by Scripture Revelation 2. The Authority of the Assembly as convened in the Name of Christ and by virtue of his Presence whereof we have spoken before It pleased the Holy Ghost and us 3. That the things which they had determined were necessary that is antecedently so unto that determination namely the abstaining from the use of their Liberty in things indifferent in case of scandal 4. From the Duty with respect unto the Peace and mutual Communion of the Jewish and Gentile Churches Doing thus say they ye shall do well which is all the Sanction of their Decree manifesting that it was Doctrinal not Authoritative in way of Jurisdiction 7. THE Doctrinal Abridgement of the Liberty of the Gentile Christians in case of scandal they call the imposing of no other Burden in opposition unto what they rejected namely the imposing a yoke of Ceremonies upon them v. 10. So as that the meaning of these Words is That they would lay no Burden on them at all but only advise them unto things necessary for the avoidance of scandal For it is impious to imagine that the Apostles would impose any yoke or lay any burden on the Disciples but only the yoke and burden of Christ as being contrary to their Commission Matth. 28.19 20. HENCE it will follow That a Synod convened in the Name of Christ by the voluntary consent of several Churches concerned in mutual Communion may declare and determine of the mind of the Holy Ghost in the Scripture and Decree the observation of things true and necessary because revealed and appointed in the Scripture which are to be received owned and observed on the evidence of the mind of the Holy Ghost in them and the Ministerial Authority of the Synod it self FINIS ERRATA PAge 16. line 31. for to read do p. 23. l. 34. r. state p. 27 l. 2. r. believers be p. 31. l. 11. r. Mat. 20. p. 40. l. 23. r. if so be p. 41. l. 25. r. we enquire not p. 47. l. ult r. these p. 53. l. 6. Ephes. 4.7 p. 71. l. 33. r. Light. p. 72. l. 8. r. mere p. 103 l. 33. r. Auricular p. 112. l. 29. r. Conc. p 117. l. 9. after publickly add Read. p. 119. l. 22 r. their mixed p. 129. l. 5. for 18 r. 28. p. 132. l. 9. for 9. r. 3. p. 141. l. 30. read over you p. 147. l. 25. for 39. r. 38. p. 168. l. 20. for 24. r. 21. p. 186. l. 20. r. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 p 192. l. 14. r. will fully p 205. l. 35 r. this p. 228. l. 21 r. do p. 244. l. 9. r. furnace p 256. l. 15. r. probable Psal. 15.1 2 3 4 5. Psal. 24.3 4. Psal. 93 5. 2 Cor. 8.23 Ephes. 5.27 2 Tim. 3.1 2 3 4 5. Ezek. 22.26 Joh. 3.3 Tit. 3.3 4 5. Joh. 3.5 Act. 2.38 1 Pet. 3.21 Phil. 3 18 19. Tit. 1.15 16. Act. 15.8 Revel 2.23 Act. 8.13 1 Cor. 6.9 10 11. Phil. 3.18 19. 2 Thes. 3.6 2 Tim. 3.5 Rom. 9.6 7. Tit. 1.16 Mat. 18.16 17 18. 1 Cor. 5.11 Rom. 10.10 2 Cor. 8.5 Chap. 9.13 Matth. 10.32 33. Luke 9.16 2 Tim. 2.12 Rom. 15.9 Joh. 12.42 1 Joh. 4.2 3 15. Matth. 28.18 19 20. 2 Cor. 8.5 Matth. 10.37 38 39. Mar. 8.34 38. Luke 9.23 Phil. 3.18 Act. 4.10 11 20. Act. 24.14 Matth. 28.19 20. 1 Cor. 10.32 Phil. 1.10 ☞ ☞ Matth. 18.1 2 3 4. Chap. 23.7 8 9 10 11. Luke 22.24 25 26 27. 1 Pet. 5.1 2 3 4 5. 2 Joh. 9.10 Act. 20.18 29. 1 Pet. 5.2 3. Cant. 1.7 Jerem. 13.17 Chap. 23.2 Ezek. 34.3 Gen. 49.24 Psal. 23.1 Psal. 80.1 Joh. 10.11 14 16. Heb. 13.20 1 Pet. 2.25 Chap. 5.4 ☜ ☞ Jam 5.16 Joh. 17.20 Exod. 32.11 Deut. 9.18 Levit. 16.24 1 Sam. 12.23 2 Cor. 13.7 9. Ephes. 1.15 16 17. Ch. 3.14 Phil. 1.4 Col. 1.3 2 Thess. 1.11 ☞ ☜ ☞ ☞ ☜ ☞
Authority is constituted in the Church only the Work and Duty of it is cast into such an Order as the very light of nature doth require BUT there is not any intimation in the Scripture of the least imparity or inequality in Order Degree or Authority among Officers of the same sort whether extraordinary or ordinary The Apostles were all equal so were the Evangelists so were Elders or Bishops and so were Deacons also The Scripture knows no more of an Arch-Bishop such as all Diocesan Bishops are nor an Arch-Deacon than of an Arch-Apostle or of an Arch-Evangelist or an Arch-Prophet Howbeit it is evident that in all their Assemblies they had one who did preside in the manner before described which seems among the Apostles to have been the prerogative of Peter THE Brethren also of the Church may be so multiplied as that the constant meeting of them all in one place may not be absolutely best for their Edification Howbeit that on all the solemn occasions of the Church whereunto their consent is necessary they did of old and ought still to meet in the same place for advise consultation and consent as was proved before This is so fully expressed and exemplified in the two great Churches of Jerusalem and Antioch Act. 15. that it cannot be gain-said When Paul and Barnabas sent by the Brethren or Church at Antioch v. 1 3. were come to Jerusalem they were received by the Church as the Brethren are called in distinction from the Apostles and Elders v. 4. So when the Apostles and Elders assembled to consider of the case proposed unto them the whole multitude of the Church that is the Brethren assembled with them v. 6 12. neither were they mute Persons meer Auditors and Spectators in the Assembly but they concurred both in the debate and determination of the Question insomuch as they are expresly joined with the Apostles and Elders in the advice given ver 22 23. And when Paul and Barnabas returned unto Antioch the multitude unto whom the Letter of the Church at Jerusalem was directed came together about it ver 23.30 Unless this be observed the Primitive-Church-State is overthrown But I shall return from this Digression THE first Officer or Elder of the Church is the Pastor A Pastor is the Elder that Feeds and Rules the Flock 1 Pet. 5.2 that is who is its Teacher and its Bishop 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Feed taking the oversight IT is not my present design nor work to give a full account of the Qualifications required in Persons to be called unto this Office nor of their Duty and Work with the Qualities or Vertues to be exercised therein It would require a large Discourse to handle them practically and it hath been done by others It were to be wished that what is of this kind expressed in the Rule and which the nature of the Office doth indispensably require were more exemplified in practice than it is But some things relating unto this Officer and his Office that are needful to be well stated I shall treat concerning THE name of a Pastor or Shepherd is Metaphorical It is a Denomination suited unto his Work denoting the same Office and Person with a Bishop or Elder spoken of absolutely without limitation unto either Teaching or Ruling And it seems to be used or applied unto this Office because it is more comprehensive of and instructive in all the Duties that belong unto it than any other Name whatever nay than all of them put together The Grounds and Reasons of this Metaphor or whence the Church is called a Flock and whence God termeth himself the Shepherd of the Flock whence the Sheep of this Flock are committed unto Christ whereon he becomes the good Shepherd that lays down his Life for the Sheep and the Prince of Shepherds what is the interest of Men in a participation of this Office and what their Duty thereon are things well worth the consideration of them who are called unto it Hirelings yea Wolves and dumb Dogs do in many places take on themselves to be Shepherds of the Flock by whom it is devoured and destroyed WHEREAS therefore this Name or Appellation is taken from and includes in it Love Care Tenderness Watchfulness in all the Duties of going before preserving feeding defending the Flock the Sheep and the Lambs the Strong the Weak and Diseased with accountableness as Servants unto the chief Shepherd it was generally disused in the Church and those of Bishops or Overseers Guides Presidents Elders which seem to include more of Honour and Authority were retained in common use that though one of them at last namely that of Bishops with some elating compositions and adjuncts of power obtained the preheminence Out of the Corruption of these Compositions and Additions in Arch-Bishops Metropolitans Patriarchs and the like brake forth the Cockatrice of the Church that is the Pope BUT this name is by the Holy Ghost appropriated unto the principal Ministers of Christ in his Church Ephes. 4.11 And under that name they were promised unto the Church of old Jerem. 3.15 And the Work of these Pastors is to feed the Flock committed to their charge as it is constantly required of them Act. 20.29 1 Pet. 5.2 OF Pastoral Feeding there are two parts 1. Teaching or Instruction 2. Rule or Discipline Unto these two Heads may all the Acts and Duties of a Shepherd toward his Flock be reduced And both are intended in the term of feeding 1 Chron. 11.2 Chap. 17.6 Jer. 23.2 Mic. 5.4 Chap. 7.14 Zech. 11.7 Act. 20.28 Joh. 21.14 1 Pet. 5.2 c. wherefore he who is the Pastor is the Bishop the Elder the Teacher of the Church THESE Works of Teaching and Ruling may be distinct in several Officers namely of Teachers and Rulers but to divide them in the same Office of Pastors that some Pastors should feed by Teaching only but have no right to Rule by Virtue of their Office and some should attend in exercise unto Rule only not esteeming themselves obliged to labour continually in feeding the Flock is almost to overthrow this Office of Christs Designation and to set up two in the room of it of Mens own projection OF the call of Men unto this Office so many things have been spoken and written by others at large that I shall only insist and that very briefly on some things which are either of the most important consideration or have been omitted by others As 1. UNTO the call of any person unto this Office of a Pastor in the Church there are certain Qualifications previously required in him disposing and making him fit for that Office. The outward call is an act of the Church as we shall shew immediately But therein is required an obediential acting of him also who is called Neither of these can be Regular neither can the Church act according to Rule and Order nor the person called act in such a due Obedience unless there are in him some previous Indications
got a pretence of its Power administred by such ways and means as wherein the Consciences of Men neither of those by whom it is Administred nor of those unto whom it is Applied are any way concerned with respect unto the Authority or any Institution of Jesus Christ. FROM an observation hereof and a desire to vindicate as well Christian Religion from such a scandalous Abuse as Mankind from Bondage to such a monstrous fiction as is the present power and exercise of it some have fallen into another extream denying that there is any such thing as Excommunication appointed or approved by the Gospel But this neither is nor ever will be a way to reduce Religion nor any thing in it unto its Primitive Order and Purity To deny the Being of any thing because it hath been abused when there could have been no abuse of it but upon a supposition of its Being is not a rational way to reprove and convince that abuse And when those who have corrupted this Institution find the insufficiency of the Arguments produced to prove that there never was any such Institution it makes them secure in the practice of their own Abuses of it For they imagine that there is nothing incumbent on them to justify their present possession and exercise of the Power of Excommunication but that Excommunication it self is appointed in the Church by Christ whereas the true consideration of this Appointment is the only means to divest them of their power and practice For the most effectual course to discharge and disprove all corruptions in the Agenda or Practicals of Religion as the Sacraments publick Worship Rule and the like is to propose and declare the things themselves in their Original simplicity and purity as appointed by Christ and recorded in the Scriptures A real view of them in such a Proposal will divest the minds of Men not corrupted and hardened by Prejudice and Interest of those erroneous conceptions of them that from some kind of Tradition they have been prepossessed withal And this I shall now attempt in this particular of Excommunication THERE hath been great enquiry about the nature and exercise of this Ordinance under the Old Testament with the Account given of it by the latter Jews For the Right and Power of it in general belongs unto a Church as such every Church and not that which is purely Evangelical only This I shall not enquire into it hath been sifted to the bran already and intermixed with many Rabbinical conjectures and mistakes In general there is nothing more certain than that there was a doublâ— Removal of Persons by Church-Authority from the communion of the whole Congregation in Divine Worship The one for a Season the other for Ever whereof I have given Instances elsewhere But I intend only the consideration of what belongs unto Churches under the New Testament And to this end we may observe 1. THAT all lawful Societies constituted such by voluntary confederation according unto peculiar Laws and Rules of their own choice unto especial Duties and Ends have a Right and Power by the Light of Nature to receive into their Society those that are willing and meet ingaging themselves to observe the Rules Laws and Ends of the Society and to Expel them out of it who wilfully deviate from those Rules This is the life and form of every lawful Society or Community of Men in the World without which they can neither coalesce nor subsist But it is required hereunto 1. THAT those who so enter into such a Society have Right or Power so to do And many things are required unto this end As 1. That those who enter into such a Society be sui Juris have a lawful Right to dispose of themselves as unto all the Duties and Ends of such a Society Hence Children Servants Subjects have no power in themselves to enter into such Societies without the interposition of and obligation from a power Superior unto that of Parents Masters or Princes namely that of God himself 2. That the Rules Laws and ends of the Society be lawful good and useful unto themselves and others For there may be a confederation in and for evil which is a combination that gives no Right nor Power over one another or towards others that enter into it 3. That it contains nothing that is prejudicial unto others in things Divine or Humane 4. Nor oblige unto the omission or neglect of any Duty that Men by virtue of any Relations Natural Moral or Political do owe unto others Nor 5. Is hurtful unto themselves in their Lives Liberties Names Reputation usefulness in the World or any thing else unto whose preservation they are obliged by the Law of Nature Nor 6. Can be or are such Persons obliged to forsake the conduct of themselves in things Divine and Humane by the Light of their own Consciences by an Ingagement of blind obedience unto others which would render every Society unlawful by the Law of God and Light of Nature 7. Least of all have any Persons Right or Power to oblige themselves in such Societies unto things Evil Sinful Superstitious or Idolatrous THESE things are plain and evident in themselves and every way sufficient to divest all the Religious Societies and Fraternities that are erected in the Church of Rome of all that Right and Power which belongs unto lawful Societies constituted by voluntary confederation And if any thing inconsistent with these principles of Natural Light be pretended in Churches it divests them of all Power as to the exercise of it by virtue of any compact or confederation whatever 2. IT is required that a Society by voluntary consent vested with the Right and Power mentioned do neither give nor take away any Right Privilege or Advantage to or from any Members of the Society which belong unto them Naturally or Politically but their Power is confined unto those things alone wherein Men may be benefited and advantaged by the Society And this is the foundation of all political Societies Men for the sake and benefit of them may and ought to forego many particular Advantages which without them they might make unto themselves But they cannot forego any of those Rights which in their several Relations are inseparably annexed unto them by the Law of Nature nor give power over themselves in such things unto the Society So is it with Churches the power of expulsion out of their Society extends only unto the Benefits and Advantages which the Society as such doth afford and communicate Now these are only things Spiritual if Churches be an institution of him whose Kingdom is not of this World. The power then that is in Churches by virtue of their being what they are extends not it self unto any outward concernments of Men as unto their Lives Liberties Natural or Political Privileges Estates or Possessions unless we shall say that Men hold and possess these things by virtue of their Relation unto the Church which is to overthrow
judged and condemned in the Light of Nature or in the express Testimony of Scripture yea such as the Holy Ghost witnesseth that continued in without Repentance it is inconsistent with Salvation If the thing it self to be Animadverted on be dubious or disputable whether it be a Sin or no especially such a Sin either from the Nature of the Fact or the Qualifications of the Person offending or from other Circumstances so as that the guilty Person is not self-condemned nor are others fully satisfied in their Minds about the nature of it there is no room for Excommunication in such cases And if it be once allowed to be applied towards any Sins but such as are evident to be so as the Apostle says the Works of the Flesh are manifest in the Light of Nature and Express Testimony of Scripture not only will the Administration of it be made difficult a matter of dispute unfit for the Determination of the Body of the Church but it will leave it unto the wills of Men to prostitute unto litigious brawls quarrels and differences wherein Interest and Partiality may take place which is to profane this Divine Institution But confine it as it ought to be unto such Sins as are condemned in the Light of Nature or by Express Testimony of Scripture as inconsistent with Salvation by Jesus Christ if persisted in and all things that belong unto the Administration of it will be plain and easie FROM the neglect of this Rule proceeded that horrible confusion and disorder in Excommunication and the Administration of it which for sundry Ages prevailed in the World. For as it was mostly applied unto things holy just and good or the performance of such Gospel Duties as Men owed to Christ and their own Souls so being exercised with respect unto irregularities that are made such meerly by the Arbitrary Constitutions and Laws of Men and that in cases frivolous trifling and of no importance it was found necessary to be managed in and by such Courts such Processes such forms of Law such Pleadings and intricacies of Craft such a burden of Cost and Charge as is uncertain whether it ought to be more bewailed or derided 2. IT is required hereunto that the matter of Fact as unto the Relation of the Sin unto the particular Offender be confessed or not denied or clearly proved How far this is to extend and what ground of procedure there may be in Reports or Fame concurring with leading Circumstances we shall enquire afterwards And although in such cases of publick Fame a good Testimony from those of Credit and Repute in the Church given unto the supposed guilty Person is of use and sufficient in some cases singly to oppose unto publick Reports yet to require a Man to purge himself by others from any feigned scandalous imputation is an unwarrantable Tyranny 3. IT is also required that the previous process in and by private and publick Admonition and that repeated with patient waiting for the success of each of them be duly premised Whether this extend it self unto all causes of Excommunication shall be afterwards enquired into Ordinarily it is so necessary unto the Conviction of the Mind and Conscience of the Offender and to leave him without either provocation from the Church or excuse in himself so suited to be expressive of the Grace and Patience of Christ toward Sinners so requisite unto the satisfaction of the Church it self in their proceedure as that the omission of it will probably render the Sentence useless and ineffectual A crying out I admonish a First a Second a Third time and so to Excommunication is a very absurd observation of a Divine Institution 4. IT is required that the case of the Person to be censured as unto his profession of Repentance on the one hand or obstinacy on the other be judged and determined by the whole Church in love and compassion There are few who are so profligately wicked but that when the Sin wherewith they are charged is evidently such in the Light of Nature and Scripture and when it is justly proved against them they will make some profession of Sorrow and Repentance Whether this be sufficient as in most cases it is to suspend the present proceeding of the Church or quite to lay it aside is left unto the judgment of the Church it self upon consideration of present Circumstances and what is necessary unto its own Edification Only this Rule must be continually observed that the least appearance of haste or undue precipitation herein is to be avoided in all these cases as the bane of Church-Rule and Order AGAIN The manner of its Administration according to the mind of Christ may be considered And hereunto are required 1. Prayer without which it can no way be administred in the Name of our Lord Jesus Christ. The Administration of any solemn Ordinance of the Gospel without Prayer is an horrible profanation of it And the neglect or contempt hereof in any who take upon them to Excommunicate others is an open Proclamation of the nullity of their Act and Sentence And the observation of the Administration of it without any due Reverence of God without solemn invocation of the Name of Christ thereby ingaging his Presence and Authority in what they do is that principally which hath set the Consciences of all mankind at liberty from any concernment in this Ecclesiastical Censure and whence those that Administer it expect no other success of what they do but what they can give it by outward force And where this fails Excommunication is quickly laid aside As it was when the Pope threatned the Cantons of the Swissers that if they complied not with some of his Impositions he would Excommunicate them whereon they sent him word they would not be Excommunicated which ended the matter Wherefore when our Lord Jesus Christ gives unto his Church the power of binding and loosing directing them in the exercise of that power he directs them to ask assistance by Prayer when they are gathered together Matth. 18.18 19 20. And the Apostle directs the Church of Corinth that they should proceed unto this Sentence when they were gathered together in the Name of the Lord Jesus Christ 1 Cor. 5.4 which could not be without calling on his Name In brief without Prayer neither is the Ordinance it self sanctified unto the Church nor are any meet to Administer it nor is the Authority of Christ either owned or engaged nor Divine Assistance attained neither is what is done any more Excommunication than any rash Curse is so that many proceed inordinately out of the Mouths of Men. AND the Prayer required herein is of three sorts 1. That which is previous for guidance and direction in a matter of so great weight and importance It is no small thing to fall into mistakes when Men act in the Name of Christ and so engage his Authority in what he will not own And the best of Men the best of Churches are liable