then that will intrust his liberty or estate to the judgment of a few puny Novices rather then the sage Baristers of the Law And what shall we intrust our Faith and in that our Souls to the opinions of Fanatick Enthusiasts and not rather to the Religious Pastors of the Church and faithful Preachers of the Gospel Yea let me propose it to the judicature of your own reason whether it be equal when any ware hath been judged warrantable or sophisticate by any of your companies that then the judgment of some puny Journeymen should be preferred The like case is in the Controversies of the Church and what will you have more regard to your wares then to your Faith to your commodities then to your Salvations and allow that in the Church which you will not admit of in your shop I urge this the rather because though we may say of our Church what Lyrinensis does of Origens family Vincent Ly◠cont Donat. c. 23. that it is illustrata mantyrio made glorious by Martyrdom such Martyrdom as no Church in the World can out-vy in its Crown of Glory yea beautified with the richest and most magnificent furniture of all kinde of learning yet as Iraeneus tells us of the Hereticks of old Iren. l. 3 c. 1. That they took upon them to be Emendatores Apostolorum Reformers of the Apostles so since that the Romanists have took upon them to be Emendatores Patrum Reformers of the Fathers witness their Index Expurgatorius yea we have them rose up amongst us who will be Emendatores Reformatorum such as reform our Reformers calling into question that Gold which the whole Company of Goldsmiths have tryed by the Touchstone Those Doctrines our Church hath examined and determined according to Gods Word and given Testimony too to those Truths sealing them with their blood Wherefore seeing in the publick ruptures of our Church Heresies and Schisms as in the broken Walls of a Palace Adders and Serpents do breed and multiply that you may avoid their infection and sting 1 John 4.1 Believe not every Spirit Non omni quia omni Believe not every Spirit because it will be every thing any thing but what it ought to be Eph. 4.4 believe that Spirit which is but one but one Spirit as but one Truth One truth delivered us by the faithful Pastors of the Church as by one mouth whereas the factious and heretical they are divided in their spirits Tert. de praescript c. 42. and their opinions so that Schisma est unitas ipsis as Tertullian tells us their unity is that of Schism not of Faith not of Faith for that hearkens to the voice and Ministry of the Church delivering the Word and Truth of God in which we are taught whatsoever Christ hath commanded In the farther prosecution of the two parts of our Saviours Instruction establishing to us the Authority of the Scriptures and the Doctrine of his Church we will resolve you three seasonable questions and clear unto you two vulgar Errors 1. Resolve you three seasonable questions which are these 1. What is the Authority of the Church compared with the Scriptures 2. How do we come to believe that the Scriptures are the Word of God 3. In doubtful cases how may we best interpret the Scriptures First What is the Authority of the Church compared with the Quest 1 Scriptures I answer Answ The Church of England keeps the middle path betwixt two extreams both by ways of Error she gives due honor to the Catholick Church but cheif honor to the sacred Scriptures whereas the Romanist exalting the Churches dignity debaseth the Scriptures Authority and the Sectary advancing the Scriptures Authority debaseth the Churches dignity Avoiding then the Errors of Papism and Faction we acknowledge with St. Paul Eph. 2.20 Quippè illud 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 tam de doctrina quà m de persona intelligendum Ambros de Fid. l. 1. c. 4. That the Church hath its Foundation fixt upon the Scriptures and from thence we infer infallibly the Scriptures cannot have their Authority derived from the Church And therefore St. Ambrose makes his challenge to the Emperor Gratian Nolo argumento credas sancte Imperator nostrae disputationi Scripturas interrogemus in terrogemus Apostolos interrogemus Prophetas interrogemus Christum quod multum Patrem interrogemus cujus honori studere se dicunt I desire not O sacred Emperor that thou shouldst believe our Argument and Dispute let us ask the question of the Apostles of the Prophets of Christ What shall I say more Let us ask the Father whose honor they say being Arians they contend for And we hearken with consent of judgment to that known resolution of Faith given by St. Augustine Audi non dicit Donatus hear Aug. ep 48. it is not said Thus saith Donatus thus saith Rogatus or thus saith Vincentius or thus saith Hilarius or thus saith Austine no but Thus saith the Lord. It is the Authority then of the Scripture which gives firmness of truth to the Doctrines of the Church Yet again we acknowledge what St. Paul affirms 1 Tim. 3.15 That the Church is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the pillar and stay of truth in that as the Edicts of Kings are fastned unto Pillars so the Word of Truth the Gospel of Christ is committed unto the Church to be held forth in its genuine sense and proper interpretation to the view of all as the sole object of Faith So that the seat of saving Truth the custody of the Gospels promises the treasury of spiritual riches in a word the faithful depositary of Gods Word is to be found in Sion the City of the living God the Church of Jesus Christ And thus the Church does not give Authority to the Scriptures yet declares the Authority of the Scriptures she doth not impose a sense but expounds it So that the Church is the Heavenly Orbe in which the glorious light of saving Truth and Gospel Mysteries shines forth unto the Faithful Secondly How do we come to believe that the Scriptures are the Quest 2 Word of God In answer to this observe Answ Ep◠3.10 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 The Mysteries of the Gospel contain such a manifold wisdom as is the Angels astonishment so that needs must they be the Council of Gods Bosom not the invention of mans brain However then the Grammatical sense and Logical connexion of words and phrases be discerned by the common light of Humane Reason yet that of our Saviours 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 conviction of the Spirit John 16.8 1 Cor. 2.4 2 Cor. 4.2 and St. Pauls 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 demonstration and manifestation of the Spirit is a work transcending the skill a wonder surpassing the discovery of natural men here Omnis Platonicorum caligavit subtilit as Cypr. de Sp. Sancto All the subtlety of Plato's School is put to silence A Deo then
discendum quod de Deo intelligendum as Hilary speaks we must learn from God what we may understand of God even as we discover the Body of the Sun by the light of its own beams yea God it is who prepares the eye of the practical judgment and proportions the palate of the rectified will to discern the evidence and rellish the sweetness of supernatural Truths and he does it in this order The Church by a Ministerial Manuduction and Ecclesiastical dispensation to those matriculated by Baptism born in her Lap and bred in her Bosom tutored to a reverend esteem of her Maternal Authority to them she transmits this indubitate principle of Christian Verity That the sacred Scriptures are the Word of God But to them who are without the Infidel and Heathen the Church hath her arma praelusoria her preparatory Arguments of Right Reason to fit the minde for a candid reception and diligent examination of the Scriptures And upon this the Spirit of Truth comes in with Conviction to the Conscience perswading the Soul to this assent of Faith that they are the Word of God Wherefore besides the Ministry and Manuduction of the Church there must be an illuminating power of the Spirit yea a power rectifying and raising the minde to a capacity of supernatural light otherwise the Mysteries of Grace to the Natural man will be as the varieties of colours to the blinde the colours are not discerned till the faculty be restored nor are those Mysteries understood till the minde be healed And when thus by the Spirit of God the minde is fitted to the Word and the Word revealed unto the minde then does the Soul discern an excellency in the sacred Scriptures above what is in Humane Writings with as sure a distinction though not so clear an evidence as the eye does discern a beam of the Sun from the blaze of a Candle Quest 3 Thirdly In doubtful cases how may we best interpret the sacred Scriptures Answ I answer That Interpretation of Scripture is best which holds conformity to the Analogy of Faith and consent with the judgment of the Church two sure rules of Scripture interpretation approved and observed by the ablest Expositors of Gods Word 1. Which holds conformity to the Analogy of Faith Rom 12 6. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Which Analogy of Faith is none other thing then that summary and fit proportion which is in the general principles of Christianity and cheif mysteries of Grace plainly set down in the sacred Scriptures A sum whereof we have in our publick Confessions of Faith the Decalogue the Lords Prayer and the Doctrine of the Sacraments seeing then it is the Scripture phrase to be built up in our holy Faith As that stone Jud. 20. which holds not proportion with the rest of the building is either fitted or rejected by the Architect so that interpretation of Scripture which holds not Analogy with the received Doctrines of Faith it must be either amended or cast away by the Religious And in doing this the Faithful of Christs Church they shall according to St. Pauls precept 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Phil. 3 16. walk orderly by one and the same rule and so preserve the unity and peace of the Church in being of one and the same minde 2. Consent with the Judgment of the Church For that no Scripture is of private interpretation 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 2 Pet. 1.20 to be interpreted by a mans own wit fancy or reason but by the enlightning power of the Spirit of Truth for as the Scriptures came not by the proper will Vers 21. so nor are they to be interpreted by the private judgment of men but the same Spirit who is the Author must also be the Interpreter And where may we with more confidence rest assured that this holy Spirit is then where Christ did expresly promise he should ever be with his Church Matth. 28.20 John 16.13 And especially with the Pastors of his Church to whom our Lord gives the promise that His Spirit should lead them into all truth But here it may be demanded what I call the Judgment of the Church I answer The antient perpetual and universal consent of holy Doctrine received at all times in all places and of all the faithful But especially do we fix upon that judgment of the Church in the antient perpetual and universal consent of holy Doctrine collected out of the most consonant Writings of the Primitive Fathers and the sacred Decrees of the first Councils For that without controversie even by confession of all parties in that time were the most Eminent Saints for holiness of life excellency of learning purity of doctrine and constancy of martyrdom And he that will think to go to Heaven in any other path then what these blessed Saints have trod before him I say to him as Constantine to Acesius Erige scalam ascende solus Raise thy self O man a Ladder and climb up alone Now this antient perpetual and universal consent of holy Doctrine collected out of the most consonant Writings of the Primitive Fathers and the sacred Decrees of the first Councils This is that we may call in the language of St. Ambrose Liber Sacerdotalis Ambr. de fid ad Grat. l. 3. c. 7. That Sacerdotal Book signatus a confessoribus multorum Martyrio consecratus signed by the confessions of the most eminent Saints and consecrated by the blood of the holiest Martyrs As then the Authority of the sacred Scriptures gives us the sure rule of Faith so the judgment of the Universal Church gives us the right line of interpretation according to which two it is well worthy our observation the Church of England did exactly draw the platform of her Reformation And this is evident in her Doctrine and Practice 1 In her Doctrine Art 20. amongst many other instances see it in her Book of Articles expresly acknowledging the Church to be the witness and keeper of the sacred Oracles and in her Book of Canons as expresly denying any doctrine necessary to be religiously held and believed which the Catholick Fathers and old Bishops of the Primitive Church have not collected out of the Scriptures And 2 that her practice is suitable to her Doctrine appears by her owning the four General Councils the Apostles Nicen and Athanasian Creeds And in all her disputes against the now silent adversary otherwise too busily employed the Jesuite justifying her reformed estate as conformed to the Primitive Church within the first five Centuries of years And here give me leave to observe unto you how the Presbytery laid the way to their own and our Churches ruine even by setting up private interpretation of Scripture in opposition to the received judgment of the Universal Church For do not the Brownists the Anabaptists under the name and notion of Independents presently beat them with their own weapon The Presbyterian abolisheth the Publick Liturgy and takes away Regular Ordination
brings in the Directory and sets up Lay Elders and all upon this ground That what they did was conformed to the Doctrine of the Scriptures of whose interpretation themselves would be Judges But at the heels of the Presbyterian follows close the Independent and treading in his steps at last over-teacheth him in his design and carries away his Helena from him he pulls down the Classes and the Synod as humane inventions and remains of Antichrist denying That by the Scripture any Presbyters or persons whatsoever ought to have power over the Churches of Christ which are by Scripture-rule Independent in their Government to any Secular or Ecclesiastical power whatsoever And for this they urge their Scripture Texts with much heat of contention against the Presbytery pleading this their common ground of interpretering Scripture by the Spirit whose inspirations and revelations they pretend to above what the Presbytery dare own or acknowledge As then in joyning the Authority of the Scripture with the judgment of the Church was our Reformation so is it Satans subtlety and the Jesuites design both acting by the Enthusiast That in dividing the judgment of the Church from the authority of the Scriptures may be our ruine To the prevention whereof what God hath joyned together let no man put asunder The Word of God and the Ministry of the Church for so faith Christ in Instruction to his Apostles Go ye disciple all Nations 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Baptising and teaching Teaching whatsoever I have commandâ—d you 2 Having resolved you the three seasonable Questions we proceed to clear unto you two Vulgar Errors no less dangerous then epidemical as mischievous in their consequents as spreading in their infections First That the sacred Scriptures are the onely rule of all mens actions Secondly That every man may be an Interpreter of sacred Scripture Which two make up that 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 that grand and primary falshood which laid the ground for all that division and disobedience which hath of late broken forth into violence and blood both in Church and State 1. That the sacred Scriptures are the onely rule of all mens actions 1. Vulgar Error An opinion however made plausible yet is it indeed pernicious To state the case right That the Sacred Scriptures are our perfect rule of direction as to the knowledge of supernatural Truths in the objects of divine Faith and the exercise of supernatural Graces in the duties of Evangelical obedience we willingly acknowledge and therefore reject all humane Traditions urged by the Romanist as supplements to the Doctrine of Faith and Codicils to the Testament of Christ But now that the sacred Scriptures are our onely rule of direction in matters Civil or Natural especially as extended by the Brethren of the Separation to indifferent actions whereas indeed this opinion makes no actions to be indifferent all being commanded by the Word of God This we can by no means admit of it being an opinion which makes an inâ—et to all Schism and Sedition For Beloved upon diligent search and judicious observation you may finde That in the Controversies of this last age since the Reformation they who have so earnestly preached printed and what not for the change of Church Discipline and Government they have certainly made this the head Theorem of all their Pulpit discourse the very Corner stone of all their Babel-argumentation That simply whatsoever we do and are not thereto commanded and directed by the Word of God it is sin As if when God gave his Scriptures he then made null the Law of Nature and of Right Reason which Law of Nature and Right Reason imprinted in our hearts is as truly and indeed the Law and Word of God as that written and printed in our Bibles And therefore Non differet Scripturâ an ratione consistat Tert. de cor Miâ— c. 4. so Tertullian it will not matter much whether our warrant be from Scripture or from Reason both being the Word of God onely with this difference That Humane Reason is subordinate to Divine Revelation Besides if the Scriptures are the onely rule of all our actions then where there is no Scripture there should be no rule and where no rule no Law But to the Gentiles having no Law written in Tables there is a Law written in their hearts Rom. 2.15 and according unto this Law their Consciences do either accuse or excuse them And thus If the Gentiles have a Law then have they a rule of their actions and that to excuse too and so not every thing which is done without direction of the Scriptures is therefore sin nor yet the written Word the onely rule of what is Natural and Civil To say as some do to mitigate the rigidness and harshness of this opinion to say That the Scriptures are the rule of all mens actions in those general maxims dispersedly and occasionally set down of doing unto others Matth. 7.12 as we would they should do unto us and of doing all things decently 1 Cor. 14.40 Rom. 15.2 Phil. 4.8 orderly and to edification and the like especially of doing whatsoever things are true whatsoever things are honest whatsoever things are just whatsoever things are pure whatsoever things are lovely whatsoever things are of good report c. This were indeed to the purpose if those maxims known principles of Nature and Reason had never been heard of but by Scripture Revelation But in that holy Scripture points us expresly to those maxims in general it withal directs us implicitely to the use of Nature and Reason in all ordinary affairs in particular To convince you more fully of the great danger see the evil consequents of this Erroneous opinion which are especially these three 1. An unavoidable guilt of Superstition 2. A vexatious perplexity of Conscience 3. A seditious contempt of Humane Laws whether Civil or Ecclesiastical First An unavoidable guilt of Superstition For that this opinion takes away the indifferency of things and actions making all necessary as commanded or else to be sinful So that it is well observed the Romanist and Separatist as they go upon contrary grounds yet both false so they run into quite contrary errors yet both superstitious The error and superstition Affirmative on the one hand that 's the Romanists who cutting short the Scriptures perfection impose Humane tradition with an opinion of absolute necessity and divine authority The Error and Superstition Negative on the other hand that 's the Separatists who extending too long or rather laying too low the Scriptures perfection they condemn Natural and Civil Actions with a censure of being sinful which yet the Word of God condemneth not And thus to take away what is indifferent in its self by commanding it as absolutely necessary or forbidding it as absolutely unlawful is Superstitious By commanding it as necessary when Gods Word requires it not and by forbidding it as unlawful when Gods Word condemns it not Secondly A vexatious perplexity
Not onely yearly or monethly but even daily new Doctrines of Faith and all from the pretended new Revelations and new discoveries of the Spirit Yea from the influence of this Vulgar Error it is That the meanest Artisans become the chief Preachers the Day-laborer in the Brick a Master builder of the Temple from hence it is That Sacriledge is expunged the Decalogue the Lords Prayer and the Creed banished the Church and all disorder and confusion breaks in like a flood That you may know then we heartily desire to preserve your common right and special blessing of reading the sacred Scriptures against the Papists as well as prevent the particular abuse and fatal mischief of corrupting the holy Word by the Factious Observe We acknowledge that the holy Scriptures in Truths absolutely necessary to Salvation they are plain and easie but 2 Pet. 3.16 in Mysteries excellently profitable for edification they are in many places dubious and difficult to be understood Wherefore we allow every private person a Judgment of Discretion to apply what is easie and plain but not a Power of Interpretation to expound what is difficult and dubious Certainly John 5.39 2 Pet 3.18 every man is bound to search the Scriptures that he may know and improve that knowledge too of Gods will Yea bound he is to apply what he reads and reading understands for the ordering his conversation in Truth and Holiness in Faith and obedience Thus then you see we by no means like that Popish stupidity that you should live like Horse and Mule without understanding No more then we like that factious frenzy that every man should think himself more then Doctor of the Chair to interpret Scripture by his private Spirit Wherefore for the true Interpretation of Scripture observe We admit the Judgment of the Church as a Trusty Guide and the Opinion of the Learned as a Rational Argument but we approve the Scripture it self as an Infallible Rule clearing those Texts which are dark and doubtful by those places which are more plain evident being still careful to keep close to the Analogy of Faith consisting in those principles of Christianity which are clearly set forth in Scripture and generally receiv'd of the Church What think you now then Beloved he who is not acquainted with the Judgment of the Church and so wants his Trusty Guide he who is not acquainted with the Opinions of the Learned and so wants his Rational Argument he who is not well instructed in the Principles of Religion and so knows not the Analogy of Faith he who is not skilled in the Language and Phrase and Method of the Scripture and so wants his Infallible Rule is such a person however he may pretend to the Spirit is such a person think you fit to be an Interpreter of the Word Wherefore to interpret Scriptures by the Spirit not being qualified as to the use of means for right Interpretation it is certainly most certainly plain Enthusiasm A phanatick presumption the greatest evidence of the Spirit of Error being so opposit in act and operation to the order and method of the Spirit of Truth Object But here the Enthusiast to prove his interpeting Scripture by the Spirit to be lawful and right he urgeth that of St. Paul as his Herculean Argument 1 Cor. 2.14 That the Spiritual man 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 intelligit ac discernit as Beza renders it he understands and discerns Judicat as the Vulgar Latin and our English he judgeth and that all things in matters of Faith and of Manners of Doctrine and of Conversation So that what needs more to interpret Scripture then to have the Spirit the case seems clear if St. Paul may decide the Question Answ But stay no Triumph before Victory To this I answer The same Apostle who saith The spiritual man judgeth all things says also 1 Cor. 14.32 The Spirits of the Prophets are subject to the Prophets where by Prophets are especially intended the Interpreters of the Scriptures and that the Enthusiast himself will readily acknowledge Now then observe If the Spiritual man will interpret Scripture by the Spirit he must remember That his spirit must be subject to the Prophets submit unto the Judgment of the Church in those holy Interpreters which have gone before him or which are now surviving with him Otherwise he is not spiritual but carnal carnally puft up with the pride of his own spirit which he blasphemously calls the Motion of Gods Spirit Thus then to interpret Scripture by the Spirit according to St. Pauls direction taking the Church for our Guide holy Expositors for our Instruction there can be no just quarrel at our Interpretation For that we keep to the right Rule and Line to the Polar Star and the skilful Pilot the happy Union of what the Text hath joyned the Word of God and the Ministry of the Church for so is the Instruction of our Saviour in his Commission to his Apostles Go ye disciple all Nations Teaching them to observe whatsoever I have commanded you 1. By vertue of our Ministerial charge we do here Applic. in foro Conscientiae in the Court of Conscience arraign and condemn the Heresies and Schisms of our present times of that so horrid though so common sin of Scripture-Sacriledge men surreptitiously stealing away the true meaning or prophanely corrupting the proper phrase of Gods Word thereby making the Delphick Oracle 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the sacred Scriptures I mean to speak that sense which the Spirit of Error hath imposed not the Spirit of Truth revealed Church-Sacriledge and Scripture-Sacriledge they commonly go together they who will prophane the House of God will not stick to corrupt the Word of Christ and they who will not spare to defile his Worship will not care to pervert his Truth Wherefore 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Naz oâ—at 36. Rev. 22.18 19. as for the Sacrilegious invaders of the Holy Scriptures whether they be such as violate the Letter or such as pervert the Sense let them see the guilt of their sin in the horror of its punishment denounced by St. John saying I testifie unto everyman that heareth the words of the Prophecy of this Book If any man shall adde unto these things God shall add unto him the plagues that are written in this Book And if any man shall take away from the words of the Book of this Prophecy God shall take away his part out of the Book of Life and out of the Holy City and from the things which are written in this Book O dreadful Commination God will assuredly cut him off from benefit by the Testament of Christ who shall by Heretical forgery either detract or corrupt it The Gospel of Christ is his Testament and if it be but a Mans Testament how much more when it is The Testament of God being confirmed 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 being by Legal Authority ratified and declared Authentick No man disannulleth Gal.
Pious and most of the Orthodox so prophanely impious but I have soon silenced those thouâ—hts and husht that wonderment When I apprehend how it is Satans master-peece of subtlety to blast the honor of the true Faith by an open prophaneness and to set off the credit of Heresie with a form of Holiness Besides Luxury Drunkenness Whoredome the too too common sins of prophane persons otherwise Orthodox in the faith they are sins truly bestial but as for Pride Malice Envy the common though close sins of Heretical persons Formal in Holiness they are sins right Diabolical And it is our Saviours resolution Matth. 21.23 That Publicans and Harlots enter the Kingdom of God that is are wrought upon to Conversion before Pharisaical Hypocrites and Formal Hereticks Wherefore when according to our Saviours rule Matth. 7.15 16. we judge of false Prophets by their fruits we must not onely examine the fruits of manners because their Hypocrisie may for a time deceive us but also the fruits of their doctrine whether what they teach us tend to the violation of divine Charity the dissolution of holy Unity or the breach of publick Peace again whether that they teach us tend to the prophaning Gods worship the depressing his grace and the diminishing his glory Are these the fruits of their doctrine to destroy Magistracy in the State and Government in the Church To bring neglect of Gods worship and contempt of his Ordinances to promote Licentiousness countenance Disorders and hasten on Confusion If so notwithstanding their plausible pretences of the Kingdom of the Lord Jesus The Throne of Christ the Liberty of the Gospel the Discoveries of Grace the Breathings of the Spirit the Outgoings of the Lord and the like Notwithstanding all these plausible pretences yet by their fruits we know them know them to be Ministers of Satan taking upon them to be Ministers of Righteousness 2 Cor. 11.15 and though with the Prince of darkness they are transformed into Angels of Light yet their cloven foot discovers them their Doctrine which still ends in deformity and division That all this is infallibly true finde it attested by St. Peter and St. Jude in their several Epistles We will close then with St. Augustines observation That the Devil seeing his Temples forsaken and his Oracles silenced he subtlely deviseth to make a new supply to his Kingdom by having his Ministers still in and about the Church Qui sub vocabulo Christiano Doctrinae resisterent Christianae who under a Christian name should resist the Christian Doctrine and under the shew of sanctity seduce into the way of Heresie No wonder then if St. Paul to put his Corinthians upon their stricter guard does give them the emphatical Premonition of a 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 There must be also Heresies among you Quest To propose then and resolve this Quaere That seeing Satan arms his Instruments with his own arts and instructs Hereticks with a sleight and cunning Eph. 4 14. even to a 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 an art and method of deceiving Seeing it is thus How may we know the deceitful workings of Heresie by what means and in what manner does it instil its poyson Answ and spread its infection Answer 1 By pretending and perverting the sacred Scriptures The Spirit of delusion still brings Scripture in the front of his temptation not to instruct but to deceive And as it was with the Master so is it with the Schollers the Hereticks mouths are full of Scripture Matth. 22.29 yet we may truly say of them what our Saviour said of the Sadduces They erre not knowing the Scripture They have the Words indeed but not the Sense the Letter but not the Spirit however they boast themselves with confidence of both Iren. l. 1. c. 1. But as Irenaeus gives us the apt Simile comparing Hereticks to the maker of Molten Images who taking the Golden Statue and Image of a King and transforming it into the shape and Image of a Wolf he may by a fallacy affirm This is the Kings Image Now by the like couzenage and deceit the Heretick perverting the precious Word of God and framing from thence his Heretical opinions may say This is the Word of God True this Heretical doctrine is said to be the Word of God right as that Image of the Wolf is said to be the Royal Statue and Image of the King materially but not formally so There is the same Matter but not the same Form the same Word but not the same Sense And the true Believer whilst he acknowledgeth the mettal he discerneth the shape the mettal that of the Kings the shape that of the Wolfs The words those of Scripture sacred and true but the sense that of Heresie perverted and false 2. A vain gingling and jugling of words I cannot call it a wily Sophistry but a witless Vanity yet like the cantings of the Gypsies it takes the ignorant An instance and example of this Epiphanius gives us in the Arians who denying Christ to be the eternal Son of God Epiphan Haeres 69. they say of him That he is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 a Creature but not as one of the Creatures a work but not as one of the works begotten but not as one of the begotten Here that of Nazianzen is very apt 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 In these follies to cure their Brains is to confute their Arguments Hellebore is the best Syllogism Anticyrae the fittest Schools This of the Arians a Creature but not as one of the Creatures begotten but not as one of the begotten A â—han cont Arian râ—n 1. orat 3. Athanasius answers with a 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 as if a man should speak without speaking and understand without understanding 2 Tim. 2.16 This right that 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 that vain babling which Timothy must avoid as being proper for them Whose words increase unto more ungodliness whereas that Faith and Love which is in Christ Jesus hath still its form of sound words 2 Tim. 2.13 its proper phrase to express plain truth Yea besides their 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 words of vain babling it is ordinary with the Hereticks of late as once with the Valentinians and Gnosticks of old they have their 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 their words of new coyning such as neither themselves nor their followers ever understood Yet these simple Souls because they understand not they admire and admiring they are seduced to believe what they do not understand 3. A busie Tongue and Pen always prating and printing As they swell big with self-conceit so Emperick and Mountebank like they are still professing their art and prescribing Receipts yea the very Women as Tertullian speaks of old how malepert how confident Tere. de Prae script c. 41. and daring even to teach to dispute and that with the ablest Divines as some of them have sent their challenge Nazian Orat. 51. And
of Conscience Oh how is a conscientious man intangled in a snare of perplexities surrounded with a maze of distractions Who cannot in his ordinary affairs of life be quieted in his Conscience in the resolution of things lawful and expedient without Scripture proofs to determine it The rule of Reason That is readily applied by a man of ordinary prudence but the rule of Scripture is not to be applied to every action by the ablest Textuary in the World he stands in need to carry a Concordance in his hand who makes the Scripture the onely rule of all his actions and yet not avoid perplexity of Conscience neither Thirdly A seditious contempt of Humane Laws whether Civil or Ecclesiastical This opinion is that which will break the bonds of all subjection and temporal obedience both of children to Parents of servants to Masters and of subjects to Soveraigns who will by influence of this Error question when they should obey and call into dispute when they should put in practice the lawful commands of their Superiors As for these kinde of men who will not obey Magistrates forsooth but in a Gospel-way upon a Scripture proof for every Law I call the whole World to witness whether ever yet they proved themselves good subjects and sure we are according to that maxim of antient and known experience Qui nescit servire nescit imperare He that knows not how to serve knows not how to govern they will never make good Masters who themselves never were good servants Thus having discovered to you the dangerous falshood and evil consequents of this Vulgar Error That the sacred Scriptures are the onely rule of all our actions give me leave to answer the Objections urged by the Brethren of the Separation the first broachers and the continued abettors of this Error Their main Arguments and Objections are drawn from that of the Apostle Whatsoever ye do 1 Cor. 10.21 do all to the glory of God And again that Whatsoever is not of Faith Rom. 14.23 is sin The first Argument is framed thus We must do all to Gods glory but Object 1 that cannot tend to his glory which is not directed by his Law and therefore in every thing we must be directed by his Law seeing in every thing we are to aim at his glory Answer All this is true and yet the Error remains which is this Answ That the sacred Scripture alone is this Law whereas God in his providence hath ordained several Laws distinct in nature and degree but in subordination the lower to the higher and all to him the supream Lawgiver So that to measure all mens actions by one kinde of Law were to confound that sacred Order of divine Providence in which his Government of the World is so eminently glorious Some actions are within the bounds of nature as we are Creatures for these we have a Law natural some are within the limits of Reason as we are men and for these we have a Law rational Some within the verge of Secular community as we are Subjects for these we have a Law politick some within the sphere of Faith as we are Christians and for these we have a Law divine Lastly some within the orbe of External communion as we are visible Members of the Church and for these we have a Law Ecclesiastical And such is the sweet order of these several Laws in the constitution of Providence that neither opposeth other but all consent in an harmonious subordination unto God and Christ in the Government of the World and of the Church So that we may say of Law Mr. Hoâ—ker Eccles Polit. she is sacred her seat is the Throne of God her voice the Harmony of the World all things in Heaven and in Earth do her homage the very least as feeling her care and the greatest as not exempted from her power Angels and men and the whole number of the Universe though in different manner yet in uniform consent they reverence and admire her they obey and extol her as the Mother and Nurse as the Queen and Patroness of their Peace and Joy Object 2 The second Argument is framed thus Whatsoever is not of Faith is sin Rom. 14.23 but where there is no Word there can be no Faith and therefore whatsoever action hath not warrant from the written Word of God commanding it it must needs be sinful Answ Answer This Argument however it may seem to set forth the perfection of Gods sacred Law yet does it indeed destroy much of Gods sacred Truth For what St. Paul means by Faith we see plainly from the context is neither fides quae creditur nor fides quá credimus neither the object nor the act neither the doctrine nor the belief of Supernatural Revelation Which Revelation we acknowledge perfect in order to eternal life in the sacred Scriptures But by Faith most evident it is the Apostle means an inward perswasion of minde believing That what we do may lawfully be done whereas to do any thing of which we are not thus perswaded it is sin So that by Faith here the Apostle does not mean the doctrine of Scripture but the dictate of Conscience and most certain it is Let the light and information of Conscience be from Reason as well as from Scripture the dictate of Conscience cannot be resisted without sin against God whose Vicegerent it is in the Soul of Man In things then ordinary quotidianae incursionis of daily incursion yea in matters Civil debitae subjectionis of due subjection Our warrant is sufficient as to Conscience if we know no Law of Scripture to contradict it though we know none in particular to confirm it So that it is the inverted order of right Argumentation to say this or that we may not do because Gods Word does not command it whereas we should rather say this or that we may do because Gods Word does not forbid it For observe What things are indifferent in their own nature as being neither directly expressed in the Word nor necessarily deduced from it nor any way opposit to the Word or inconsistent with it those things we acknowledge left to the prudence of Governors for the preservation of order and unity in the Church which things indifferent in their nature do by the command of lawful Authority become necessary in their use And upon this firm ground upon this sure basis are fixt those Ecclesiastical Laws and Ceremonies of our Church which have been so loudly decryed and so hotly pursued 2. 2. Vulgar Error That every private person who pretends to the Spirit may be a fit Interpreter of sacred Scripture From this evil principle it is that as Hilary complained of of old Annuas atque menstuas fides habemus Every year every moneth produceth some new Doctrine of Faith This is somewhat modest and fair to our Factions and Frenzies in which we have Non modo annuas aut menstruas sed vel diurnas fides
shall come in Who is the King of Glory The Lord strong and mighty the Lord mighty in Battel Lift up your heads O ye gates even lift them up ye everlasting doors and the King of glory shall come in Who is the King of Glory The Lord of Hosts Jesus the Son of God he is the King of Glory Now the King of Glory Christ Jesus blessed for ever he being entred behold the Father entertaining him with a plenary grant of his Petition in that consecratory Prayer before his Passion John 17.45 Father says he I have glorified thee on Earth I have finished the work which thou gavest me to do And now O Father glorifie me with thine own self with the glory which I had with thee before the world was In full answer to this Petition says the Father unto Christ when entred into glory Sit thou on my right hand Psal 110.1 until I make thine enemies thy footstool And our Lord and Saviour being thus exalted All the Angels of God all the Host of Heaven they pay him homage they acknowledge him their King they fall down and worship him Heb. 1.6 worship him as the Head of the Body the Church who is the beginning the first-born from the dead that in all things he might have the pre-eminence for it pleased the Father that in him should all fulness dwell Having done with the first branch of Divine Mysteries How Christ is said to be the Head of the Church we proceed to the second What the Church is of which Christ is said to be the Head And for the Explication of this we shall speak of the Church in these three particulars its larger acception it s nearer relation and its different adjuncts 1. It s larger acception as the Church of the Elect. 2. It s nearer relation as the Church of the Redeemed 3. It s different adjuncts as visible and invisible 1. What the Church is of which Christ is said to be the Head Explic. in its larger acception as the Church of the Elect. In this extended sense the Church compriseth the heavenly orders of the Angelical Hierarchy who being of the Elect of God 1 Tim. 5.21 Col. 2.10 are also of the Church of Christ who is therefore called The Head of all principality and power The Elect Angels receiving their confirmation as the Elect. Saints their Redemption by Jesus the Mediator True it is as concerning the Angels that Christ he assumed not their nature in his Conception and so neither did he sustain their person in his Passion He took not on him the nature of Angels Heb. 2.16 but the seed of Abraham 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 He took not hold on Angels a Metaphor signifying an eager following after and laying hold on one running away to bring him back or a catching him that is faln to recover him from the pit This Christ did do for men this this he did not do for Angels but as those which fell sinned without a tempter Ambr. Ser. 8. in Psal 119. so they perish in their sin without a Saviour But as for the Elect Angels St. Ambrose tells us that they needed Christ to preserve them from falling into sin as men did need him to free them from sin into which they were faln and in this St. Bernard joyns issue with St. Ambrose Bern. Tract de dilig D. affirming Qui hominibus subvenit in tali necessitate Angelos servavit a tali necessitate He that succored men in such a necessity saved the Angels from the like necessity Aug. Enchir. c 62. To all this add we that of St. Augustine Quod in Angelis lapsum ex hominibus redditum the number of those Angels which are faln shall be made up by those men whom Christ hath redeemed all which expressions and opinions are several descants and glosses upon the Apostles words in his 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 telling us Eph. 1.10 Of all things gathered together in one even in Christ the Head of all Excellency and the Center of all Unity Angels and Men were indeed created happy in that natural blessedness of Spiritual contemplation but not in that supernatural bliss of the beatifical Vision Which beatifical Vision being the last end of the rational and intellectual Creature could not be attained by any ordinary work of nature but by some extraordinary act of grace for to be and to be blessed is one and the same in none but God And therefore to be is from nature but to be perfectly blessed is from grace as the last end of being in a perfect communion with God through Christ by love So that it is consonant to the Analogy of Faith to believe and affirm That the estate of the now blessed Angels was at the first mutable and subject to alteration and that presently by the supererogating grace of God thorow Christ they became no longer subject to mutability and change now inseparably adhering to God and so possessing perfect happiness Matth. 18.10 of whom our Saviour hath said 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 They always behold the face of his Father which is in Heaven This benefit then the Angels have by Christ that they are confirmed in their full and perfect union with God Heb 1.6 Wherefore Let all the Angels of God worship him yea and joyn we too with the Angels in that worship as having communion with them in the same Head even Jesus the Mediator who is the beginning the first-born from the dead that in all things he might have the pre-eminence c. 2. What the Church is of which Christ is said to be head in its nearer relation as the Church of the redeemed and redeemed not onely in the infinite sufficiency but also in the actual efficacy of his merit yea and effectual sanctification of his grace For observe Christ he is according to the promise Gen. 3.15 the Seed of the woman not in a common and carnal generation but in a proper and spiritual conception conceived by the Holy Ghost And therefore Christ is not properly the Head of all mankinde but of that part which is regenerated by the same Spirit by which he was conceived So that 1 Cor 1.2 Rom. 8 30. it is effectual calling which constitutes the Church of Christ in actual being as to its internal and essential form Which Church is diversly defined and described by divers men according to the difference of their faiths or fancies To omit then the needless and avoid the curious we may thus define the Church of Christ to be The whole company of Gods Saints called of God in Christ out of the state of sin and death into the state of grace and glory And this in the Language of the sacred Scriptures this is Christs Spouse this the Kings Daughter this the Mount Sion this the Heavenly Jerusalem this the Mother of us all Virgo virtute mater prole so St. Ambrose a Virgin indeed for purity