of the day at Evening is ratified by the fourth Commandement a morall and perpetuall precept founded on the very course and Lâ—w of nature at the Creation as most assert Gen. 2. 1 2. 3. For this Commandement enjoyning men b To keep holy the Sabbath day to do no manner of work upon it and to labour six dayes and do all their worâ— For in six dayes the Lord made heaven and earth the Sea and all that in them is and rested the seventh day wherefore the Lord blessed he Sabbath day and hallowed it doth herâ— in apparently confirm for ever the beginning â—nd and limits boâ—h of dayes and weeks as they were â—â—ttled at the Creation For this precept having a retrospect to Gods six dayes work and his seventh dayes rest when he created the world and enjoyning men to work six dayes to rest the seventh day and keep it holy as God did then doth apparantly intimate that these foresaid seven dayes were as so many royall Standards of time by which all subsequent dayes and weeks must be measured which must begin end and have the same dimenâ—ions with that originall week and those first seven dayes Wherefore since they began and ended at Evening then as I have proved all other dayes likewise must do so by vertue of this command The rather because it prescribes men to finish all their work in six dayes and then to begin their rest when their work ends as God did his but their six dayes work usually c ends at Evening therefore their six days also should then dâ—termine and their Sabbath or seven dayes râ—st begin and so by consequence all the six dayes the Sabbath day and so all dayes for ever should commence and end at Evening so long as this commandement is in being or dayes and weeks shall last Fourthlv The beginning of dayes must needs be immutable because the alteration of it from Evening to morning or midnight which thwarts the Scripture computation would falsisie corrupt many Passages and Texts of Scripture call into question the truh of our Saviours Resurrection on the third day and somewhat alter the Scripture Chronology which is most exact and punctuall neither of which are sufferable by God or Christians Lastly this beginning and close of dayes hath an influence into Gods worship who as he hath prescribed men how so likewise when to worship him to wit especially on the Sabbath which he hath appropriated to himself stiling it his own Sabbath and holy day Exod. 16. 23 25. Levit. 23. 3. Deut. 5. 14. Neh. c. 14. Isa. 58. 13. Exod. 20. 10 c. 31 16. The sanctification therefore of the Sabbath being a part of Gods worship and the Sabbath his own peculiar day * which most hold Christ and his apostles and the Primitive Christians by Gods warrant translated to the Lords day that beginning and limits of it which God hath fixed must not be changed but by God because it would alter both Gods day and worship too To prevent which inconvenience God hath given not onely generall commands to sanctifie this day but likewise a speciall precept to begin and end it at Even Levit. 23. 32. From Even to Even you shall celebrate your Sabbath there being no such particular precept given for the limits of other dayes which are bounded out in more generall termes it being both dangerous and absurd to leave the inception or bounds of the Sabbath arbitrary unto men to begin and end it when they please the day being Gods not theirs the sanctification thereof a speciall part of his service which men have no power to alter or diminish and whatsoever in Godâ— service is not of faith warrantted or prescribed by his word being sinne and will-worship Rom. 14. 23. Col. 2. 18. 20 21 22 23. From all which I may safely affirm that this beginning and ending of dayes at Even especially of the Sabbath day is immutable and so my fourth Conclusion undeniable For the fifth That Christs Resurrection in the morning did no wayes alter the beginning or end of dayes nor yet translate the inception of that day whereon he arose From Evening to morning it is unquestionable First Because this commencement and conclusion of dayes at Evening is immutable as I have manifested in in the fourth Conclusion therefore not altered by Christâ— Resurrection Secondly because Christs Passion and Resurrection abolished or changed nothing but that which was typicall and ceremoniall witnesse Gal. 4. 9 10 11. Col. 2. 14. to 22. Acts 15. 24. 28 29. Heb. 9. 10 11. c. 10. 1. 2 9. with the unanimous suffrage of all Divineâ— But the beginning and end of dayes at Even was no wayes typicall or ceremoniall but rather naturall and morall being instituted at the Creation ratified by the fourth Commandement and immutably fixed for ever as the premiseâ— testifie Therefore it was not abolished or translated by Christs Resurrection or Passion from Evening to morning Thirdly Christ abrogated or changed nothing but what was necessary to be abolished or altered upon warrantable reasons and substantiall grounds See Heb. 8. 6 7 8. c. 9. 9. to 16. c. 10. 1. to 11. Col. 2. 16 17 22 23. Ephes. 2. 15. Gal. 5. 1. to 7. Acts 15. 10. 28. But there was no necessity reason cause or ground at all of altering this begining and end of dayes at Evening therefore Christs Resurrection did not alter or abolish it Fourthly the alteration limitation of times dayes and seasons is a Peculiar Prerogative of God the Father reserved in his own power not in Christs as is manifest by Acts 1. 7. Matth. 24. 36. Mark 13. 32. Levit. 23. 2. c. Psal. 118. 23 24. Exod. 13. 2 3 6 14. Exod. 20. 1 8 10 11. compared with Daniel 2. 20 21. Psal. 74. 16 17. Jer. 33. 20. c. 31. 35. Psal. 136 1. 7 8 9. upon which Priviledge Royall none anciently durst encroach but that presumptuous Horn typifying the Papacy Dan. 7. 25. Christ therefore by his bare Resurrection made no such alteration of the dayes inchoation having no speciall Commission from his Father so to do Fifthly there is not one word or sillable in all the Scripture which either affirms or intimates that Christs Resurrection made any mutation of the beginning or end of dayes neither can any man produce one substantiall reason grounded on Scripture why Christs resurrection should cause such a change as this or why his resurrection should do it rather than his Nativity Passion or Ascension Therefore I may safâ—ly conclude that it made no such change untill the contrary can be proved Sixthly the Scripture is expresse that Christs Resurrâ—ction did no wayes change either the order name or nature of that day whereon he arosâ— For all the Evangelists speaking of it as Christs Resurrection day in their Histories of the Resurrection penned some space after it ever stile it The first day of the week Math. 28. 1. Mark 16.
in times of Popery all of them resolving the fourth Commandement to be Morall still in force obliging all Christians under the Gospel to the weekly observation and sanctification of the intire Lords-day That TOTVS ILLE DIES TVTALITER DIVINO CVLTVI APPLICANDVS EST NIHIL ALIUD AGENDUM NISI DEO VACANDUM and that because DIES INTEGER SABBATUM TOTUM cultui divino SACRATUR not two or three hours of it onely devoted to the publick exercise of Gods worship in the Church as some new * Doctors assent who allot the rest to Sports Pastimes and wordly labours or affairs being more licâ—ntious and prophane than Papists in this point who are generally as strict as the greatest Puritane writers in their Doctrines for their intire sanctification of the Lords day and against the use of all ordinary labours sports pastimes dancing enterludes and carnall pleasures on it or any part thereof even from Evening to Evening when they begin and end it Now if the Lords-day it self be thus to be sanctified and solemnized by Christiaans even by the equity and Morality of the fourth Commaudement it self literally commencing onely the sanctification of the seuenth day Sabbath which began and ended alwayes at Evening Then it must by the very equity and morality of the sourth Commandement be sanctified and solemnized by Christians from Evening to Evening as the seventh dae Sabbath was both by Jews and Christians heretofore by vertue of this Precept which Reason our Opposites can no wayes evade 6. Our opposites themselves apply all Texts and precepts in the Old Testament for the sanctification of the seuenth day Sabbath unto the Lords-day Sabbath as being all one with it in substance Why then should they or any other reject that Text of Levit. 23. 32. From Even to Even ye shall celebrate your Sabbath refuse the usuall Scripture computation of the beginning and ending all dayes all Festivalls at Evening and affix a new incepâ—ion or â—nd to the Lord-day and all other dayes too at Morning or midnight which the sacred Writ doth no wayes warrant As therefore they apply most other things concerning the seventh day Sabbath to the Lords day so must they now the time and Texts for its beginning too unlesse they can give good Scripture reasons for it which no man can do 7. The beginning of the Lords-day and Sabbath at Evening as soon as the Sun sets or the Evening-star begins to shine as it is most certain whereas the beginning of it from the hour or moment of Christs Resurrection which is not certainly known nor expressed by the Evangelists is arbitrary and uncertain and so not to be embraced so is it mâ—st consonant to that rest or Sabbath in heaven of which these Sabbaths are a reall type Heb. 4. to 11. For our heavenly Sabbath ever begins in the very Evening and Sunset of our dayes when death puts a period to them Rev 14. 13. Job 3. 17 18. or at least at the Evening and period of this world when dayes shal be no longer Rev. 10. 6 7. Therefore by the analogy of the type to the substance those Sabbaths should begin at Evening too when the day-light ends the rather because the Evening usually puts an end to our Labours and begins our ordinary rest as death the Evening of our dayes concludes our earthly toyls and travels and commenceth our heavenly rest Rev. 14. 13. 8. This beginning of the Sabbath and Lords day at Evening doth best prepare men for the sanctification and duties of it and most of all prevent the profanation of it For first it makes men to put a timely period to their weekly labours on Saturday Evening and then to begin the sanctification of it with private meditations prayer singing of Psalms reading the Scriptures catcchifing of their children and families examination of their own hearts and wayes and such like holy duties where as the Doctrines of its beginning at midnight or morning light as wofull evperience witnesseth makes many spend a great part of the Satturday Evening and night when the Sabbath and Lords-day begin in true calculation especially in Cities and market Towns in buying selling drinking gaming whoâ—ing and such like worldly or carnall imployments which this Doctrine of its commencement at Evening would easily redresse 2. It causeth men to go to bed and take their rest In due season to rise the more early in the morning to come to the publick duties of Gods Worship with greater chearfulnesse and better Preparation and so to receive more profit by them to resort more timely to the Church to dispatch their own private devotions before they go to the publick Assemblies and to be every way more holy and active wheras the other Midnight or morning inception of it makes Trades men others to set up Saturday nights as we erroneously both call and repute them very late about secular or viâ—ious sinfull imployments there being more sinnes for the most part and disordrs committed that Evening and night then on any or all the other six to lie long in bed the Lords day morning to come very late to Church or not at all to repair to publick duties without any or at least with small preparation bringing along with them heads and hearts full of worldly cares of sinfull thoughts of unlamented iniquities and as full of deadnesse and drowsinesse which makes them either to sleep out prayers and Sermons too or not to observe and mind them as they ought all which the Evening beginning thereof would readily best prevent Wherfore I may safely conclude that the Sabbath and Lords-day ought of right to bâ—gin at Evening since God being * only wise would certainly institute such an inchoation of them as might best prepare and enable men to their Sanctification and most anticipate their prophanation the cause why he prescribed the celebration of the Sabbath from Even to Even Levit. 23. 32. if I righly conjecture 9. It is confessed by all that in the Scripture and Israelites account all dayes began at Evening as I have proved at large before It is likewise most certain that Christ and his Apostles being Israelites did ever constantly observe the Scripture and their own nationall computation of the beginning and end of dayes it being that which Christ himself and all the Evangelists follow as I have evidenced at large in the third and fifth Conclusions neither is it any way probable that Christ and his Apostles or the Primitive-Church and Christians who were in all things guided by them did or would alter this their Nationall and divine beginning or concluding of dayes there being no ground or reason for it for ought that yet appeares If therefore the Lords-day were instituted and consecrated for a Sabbath by Christ himself as many or by his Apostles as most or by the Primitive Church Christians onely soon after the Apostles time as others affirm one of which three opinions is and
day according to the Commandement And when the Sabbath was past writes o St Mark Mary Magdalene and Mary the mother of James and Salome had bought sweet spices that they might come and anoint him And very early in the morning the first day of the week they came unto the sepulchre at the rising of the Sunne as it began to down saith p Saint Matthew whiles it was yet dark writes q Saint John and they found the stone rolled away from the Sepulchre By all which it appears That the Sabbath begun and concluded at Evening For first Saint Luke saith the Sabbath drew on when Christ was taken down from the Crosse about the Evening implying that it was then almost ready to begin Secondly they took him down them because he should not hang upon the Crosse any part of the Sabbath Thirdly the women shortly after their return from his buriall began their Sabbath dayes rest Fourthly The Sabbath was past the first day begun and our Saviour risen before the women came to his Sepulchre yet they came thither at day-dawning whiles it was dark and their apparelling themselves their buying of spices and coming from their houses or lodgings to the Sepulchre all after the Sabbath was fully ended would take them up some hours time perchance or more It is apparent therefore by all these particulars that the Sabbath even in the Evangelists account both at and after our Saviours Passion and Resurrection commenced and ended at Evening So that Saint r Matthews In the end of the Sabbath as it began to dawn towards the first day of the week which some object to the contrary as if the Sabbath then ended not till the morning must be interpreted by Saint Å¿ Marks after the Sabbath was ended and the other t Evangelists On the first day of the week that being the true sence and scope of his words else Christ in his account did rise again upon the seventh-day Sabbath not on the first day of the week and so by consequence upon the second not the third day after his Passion which is directly contrary to all the other Evangelists and Scriptures to the Article of our Creed and to Christs own predictions of his rising again the third day recorded thrice by Saint Matthew himself Mat. 12. 40. c. 16. 21. c. 27. 63 64. which he would never contradict in the history of his resurrection Fifthly it is certain by the constant practise of the Jewish Church who both before and since Christs time even to this present day did ever begin and end their Sabbath at Evening Witnesse Josephus that famous Jewish Historian Contra Apionem l 1. c 833. Hierom comment in Jonam c. 2. Tom. 5. p. 137. Eusebius de Praeparat Evangel l. 8. c. 2. Tom. 1. p. 141. S. Augustine de Tempore Serm. 251. Chrysostome Homil. 4. in Genes Tom. 1. Col. 26. B. Hom. 62. in Matth. Tom. 2. Col. 559. B. Anastatius Sinaita Anagogicarum Contemplationum Heâ—am l 2 Questio 152. 153. Eibl. Patrum Tom. 6. pars 1. p. 634. E. 794 795. Hospinian de Oâ—igine Festorum fol. 31. 72. b. 68 69. 161 162. Marlorat in Matth. 28. v. 1. Joseph Scaliger de Emendatione temporis l. 92. 6. p 119. 532 533. God win his Jewish Antiquities â— 3. c. c. 3. p. 131. Ainsworth his Annotations on Genesis 1. v. 5. Levit. 22 32. together with most ancient and modern Commentators upon Gen. 1. 5. 9. 13. Levit. 23. 32. Exod. 12. 18. Matth. 12. 40. c. 16. 21. c. 28. 1. Mark 16. 1 2 9. Luke 23 54 55 56. c. 24. 1. John 20. 1. Acts 10. 40. 1 Cor. 15. 5. with those Authours quoted in my Histriomastrix p. 643 644. and u others in the margent who all subscribe with one consent that the seventh day Sabbath and all other dayes else in the Scripture and Jewish account did ever begin and determine at Evening This second Conclusion therefore is past all question For the third That the same first day of the week on which our Saviour rose again began at Evening in divine computation it is most certain 1. Because all dayes in Scripture account did then begin as the Premises evidence Therefore this day too Secondly because that seventh day Sabbath on which our Saviour rested in his grave began and endâ—d at Evening as is clear by Matthew 28. 1. compared with Levit. 23 32. and other fore quoted Scriptures by the joynt attestation of all divines and Expositors on these Scriptures and by the second Conclusion Therefore it must necessarily begin at Evening when this Sabbath ended else the Evening may and night between the end of the Sabbath and our Sâ—viours resurrection should be part of no day at all like that of Job Job 3. 3 6. being no parcell of the Sabbath nor yet of that first day of the week on which Christ arose which can-not be Thirdly All the Evangelists with one consent record that our Saviour rose again upon the first day of the week very early in the morning whiles it was dark before the women came to his sepulchre and after the Sabbath was past Mark 16. 1 2 9. Matth. 28. 1 2. Luke 23 56 c. 24. 1 2. John 20. 1 2. the chief reason alledged by all especiaâ—ly by our opposites in this Controversie why Christians solemnize this day as their Sabbath If then he arose upon the first day the day was certainly begun some space before his resurrection else he must rise with it or before it not upon it Neither did or could this day-begin at Morning day-dawning or Sun-rising in divine compute because our Savior was risen and the women were come to the grave before that time as these Texts affirm and yet then the x Sabbath was past and this first day begun which could not be if the day commenced not before the morning begining but at break of day or Sun-rising nâ—ither did it begin at midnight because the Scripture Jews and Ecclesiasticall Writers know no such naturall or divine incepâ—ion of the day therefore questionlesse it began at Evening as the generality of Expositors on these Texts acknowledge it being the true time of the dayes Inchoation in divine accompt Fourthly Mat. 12. 4 c. 16. 21. c. 27. 63. Mark 8. 31. c. 14 58. Luke 13. 32. Hosea 6. 2. Acts 10. 40. 1 Cor. 15. 4. and all our Creeds assure us that our Saviour rose again the third day from his Passion which he predicting to his Disciples useth this expression Matth 27. 63. and Mark 8. 31. After three dayes that is after the beginning of three dayes or of the third day from my Passion not after three dayes ended for then he had risen again upon the fourth day not the third I will rise again which Phrase being all one in sense with upon the third day I will rise again as appears by Matth. 16. 21. implies that a good part
beginning of that day whereon he arose from Evening to Morning Therefore the Lords-day ought to be kept from Evening to Eâ—vening not from morning to morning or midnight to midnight What can be truly and substantially replyed to these five Arguments I cannot conjecture they being of sufficient weight to oversway the ballance of this Controversie Now to clear this truth more fully I shall to these five Arguments accumulate ten reasons more proving that the Sabbath and Lords day ought to begin at Evening First because this inception of the Sabbath and Lords day is most suitable to the nature of these dayes For the Sabbath being nothing else in proper speech but a day of rest and being oft times stiled in Scripture a Sabbath of rest Exod. 16. 23. c. 23. 12. c. 31. 15. c 34. 21. c. 35. 2 Levi. 16. 31. c. 23. 3. 32. c. 15. c. 25. 21. c. 34. 21. Deut. 5. 14. both man and beast being enjoyned to rest from their labours on this day it is most agreeable to reason and the equality of the day that this resting day should begin at Evening when men naturally and customarily begin their rest and end their labours rather than at morning when they commonly begin their work or at Midnight when as they are in the midâ—est of their rest and slâ—ep For when can a day of rest so aptly commence as when men begin their rest their resting on it from other labors being one part of the solemn zation of it This therefore being the fittest time to begin the day no doubt but God who doth all things wisely and in the * aptest season hath ordered that it should then commence â—s I have manifested in the foregoing Conclusions it being most proportionable to the nature of the day Secondly this commencement is most agreeable to Gods own example and to the fourth Commandement for God began his seven dayes rest i so soon as ever he ceased from his six dayes works of Creation Gen. 2. 1 2. 3. Exod. 20. 9 10. yea the fourth Commandement prescribing us to labour six dayes and to do all our work and to rest the seventh day implies that we should bâ—gin our Sabbath dayes rest when as we finish our six dayes woâ—k and that is at Evening not at morning or midnight Therefore we should then commence our sanctification of it and rest upon it Thirdly this beginning of the Sabbath and Lords-day is every way best for men as most consonant to the course of nature and their common practise for men naturally and customarily and that by Gods own appointment and the Scriptures approbation end their weekday labours at Evening and bâ—gin their rest at k or night witnes Ps. 124. 22 23. The Sun ariseth man goeth forth unto his work and to his labour untill the Evening John 9. 4. I must work the works of him that sent me whiles it is called to day the night cometh when no man can work Judg 19. 16. Behold there came an old man from his work out of the field at Evening Zâ—ph 2. 7 In the houses of Askelon they shal lie down in the Evening 1 Thess. 5. 7 Those that sleep sleep in the night together with Gen. 19. 1 2. Exod. 18 14. Gen. 2â— 11. Numb 29. 19. Levit. 19. 13. Nâ—b 4. 21 Judg. 19. 4. 11. Eccleâ— 2. 23 Num 22 21. Judg. 9. 33. c. 20. 19. c. 19. 8. Hos. 7. 6. Is 5. 11. whereas as by a natural instiâ—ct and Gods command they usually begin their work in the morning not their rest as is evidâ—nt by Eccles 11. 6. In the morning sow thy seed Mat. 20. 1 2 3. The Kingdome of heaven is like to a man that is an housholder which went out early in the morning to hire Labourers into his vineyard and by Gen. 19. 15 c. 28. 24. 54 44. 3. Exod. 20. 1. c. 18. 14. Judg. 20. 19. Ruth 3. 13 14. Psal. â— 27. 2. 1 Chron. 23 30. Mat. 27. 1. Psal. 104. 22. 23 Now the Sabbath being a day of rest from labour and being likewise made for man noâ—man for it Mark 2 27. and men naturally and ustomarily in all ages all â—lâ—ces by Gods own ordination determining their weekly labours and beginning their rest at Evening it is most fit moâ—â— proper and convenient in respect of men and this their naturall use that the Sabbath and Lords day should begin at Evening when as they voluntarily and naturally ceâ—se their secular labours and devote themselves to râ—st But most unsuitable and inconvenient to begin it in the morning the time when work begins or at midnight when half their rest is past Neither is this reason to be slâ—ighted For all things being made l for man and the Sabbath too no doubt but God did accommodate and suit them in such manner as should be most commodious and convenient for men and most consonant to the naturall course of their affairs This Inchoation therefore of the Sabbath and Lords-day being most proportionable to the naturall order of mens working and rest and so the more easie and possible to be observed by them is no doubt the truest the properest of all others and therefore ought to be embraced 4. That the beginning of the Sabbath and lord-Lord-day which is easiest for Christians to observe and doth best of all begin the sanctification of them is questionlesse the best the truâ—st But this beginning them at Evening is such 1. Because men then naturally end their worldly imployments and begin their rest â—ven of their own accord without constraint and what so easie as that which is naturally and voluntary 2. Because all men that have any Religion or shew of Christianity in them do then constantly fall to their private devotions and family duties the Evening being a fit time for holy meditations prayers and religious exercises Gen. 24. 63. 1 Chron. 16. 14. 2 Chron. 13. 11. Psal. 55. 47. Psal. 65. 8 Dan. 9. 21. Now what time so fit to begin the Sabbath and Lords-day appropriated n wholly to Gods worship as that whereon most Christians voluntarily and constantly apply themselves unto his immediate Service in their closets or in their familie devotions 3. These dayes are dayes of o holynesse and being such ought alwayes to begin and end with holy duties Every Christian will grant it fitting and convenient if not necessary that the Lords day should be begun and ended with private and continued with holy publick exercises suitable to the day Which being so if it should begin and end at Midnight what Christians usually do or can conveniently begin end it thus they being then at rest yea * fast asleep in their beds that by the course of nature and Gods own appointment without any sinne at all 1 Thes. 5. 7. Mat. 25. 5 6. c. 26. 45. And for men to be tied to rise up at midnight or to sit up til then to begin then the Lords-day
on the first day in point of constituting either of them for a Sabbath or Holy day as all acknowledge But Gods resting on the seventh day was onely the originall impulsive not the immediate efficient constitutive cause of the seventh day Sabbath for it was not a Sabbath as soon as God began to rest or only because he rested on it but because he blessed and consecrated it for a Sabbath and commanded Adam and his posterity to sanctifie it for a Sabbath as is clear by Gen 2. 2 3. Exod. 20. 7. to 12. for he sanctified it for a Sabbath because he had rested on it so that his rest was onely the occasion why this dâ—y was consecrated for a Sabbath rather than any of the other six but that which made it a Sabbath was Gods peculiar blessing consecration and institution of it for a Sabbath So Gods passing over the Isâ—aelites and slaving the Egyptians was the occasion why the 14. day of the first Moneth was solemnized â—or a Passâ—ovâ—r-day but that which constituted it to be such a day was not his passing over the Israelites but his expresse command to them to observe it throughout all their generations Exâ—d. 12 4. to 40. The Jews deliverance from Haman and thâ—iâ— other Enemies was the cause or reason why they * annually observed the fourteenth and fifteenth dayes of the Moneth Adar as solemn Festivals and the deliverance from the a Gunpowder-Treason the occasion why we observe the fifth of November as an annuall Festivall which Feast we generally begin at Evening since we then usually begin to ring our bells in memory of our deliverance the morning following but the immâ—diate efficient constituting cause of these dayes for Holy-dayes was neither the Jews deliverance nor ours but the Law and ordinance of the Jews Esth. 9. 20 to 29. and the Staâ—ute of 3 Jacâ—biâ—c 1. which ordained those dayes to be solemnized and kept holy So it is in all other dayes solemnities whatsoever not the occasion of their celebration but the authority and command to sanctifie them is that which b constitutes them Holy-dayes therefore by the self same reason Christs bare Resurrection was onely the occasion why the Lords-day was afterwards sanctified and observed but that which constituted and made it a Lords-day or Christian Sabbath was some Precept or Ordinance of Christ or his Apostles or of the Primitive Church without which it had not been actually a Lords-day or Sabbath in point of sanctification though Christ did rise upon it 2. If Christs bare Resurrection without more Ceremony did actually consecrate that very first day on which he arose and all others for a Sabbath or Lords-day what need then those many large Discourses of Divines concernning the time when the persons by whom or the Authority by which the Sabbath was translated from the seventh day to the first or this instituted for a Lords-day Certainly if the very Resurrection of Christ did actually perform all this that very morning on which he arose all these disputes were at an end But few or none have been so absurd as to make Christs bare Resurrection the immediate constituting cause of the first day for a Sabbath or Lords-day much lesse of that very day upon which Christ arose which all the a Evangelists stile the First day of the week Even as it was Christs Resurrection day which shews that it was not then actually constituted for a Sabbath or Lords-day but continued an ordinary week-day as before Therefore it is not probable that it made â—uch a change or consecration of that very day 3. None of the Evangelists in their Histories of Christs Resurrection make mention either in direct terms or by way of necessary inference that our Saviours bare Resurrection consecrated that very first day whereon he arose or any succeeding it for a Sabbath or Lords-day much lesse that it changed the beginning thereof from morn-ning to Evening Therefore certainly no such alteration as is suâ—mised was actually effected by it 4. Had Christs Resurrection actually constituted that day on which he arose and all other fiâ—st dayes ensuing for a Sabbath or Lords day without further Ceremony even on that day when he arose then that day had been consecrated for a Sabbath or Lords-day and the seventh day Sabbath hadbeen translated to it before any man did or could take notice oâ— this alteration before any knew this day was instituted for a Sabbath or â—ords-day yea before it was known or believed that Christ was risen again to or by his Disciples For the b Scripture is expresse that he appeared not unto them till towards the Evening of that day at which time Thomas was absent and some of them doubted whether he were risen again or whether it was he or no so that it is certain they observed not that first day as a Sabbath or Lords-day in memory of his Resurrection But it is altogether improbable that Christ would consecrate that day for a Sabbath or Lords-day before his Disciples or any other knew of it or that he would make an alteration of the Sabbath which so much concerned the Apostles and Church in private without their presence or pâ—ivity oâ— that he would consecâ—ate that day for a Sabbath or Lords-day in memory of his Resurrection before it was certainly known that he was risen or before he had shewed himself to his Disciples after he was risen or before any did know it to be a Lords-day or Sabbath it being made so only for man Mar. 2. 27. not for Christ himself or Angels who were onely present with him when he arose For Christ being onely wise did all things in b the fittest season and in a publick manner in the presence of his disciples who were to be witnesses of all his actions speeches Acts 1. 2 3 c. 2. 32. c. 10. 40 41 42 43. 1 Johnâ— 1 3. 2 Pet. 1. 16 17 18. Luke 1. 2. Therefore he would not he did not institute that very day whereon he arose for a Sabbath or Lords-day at the time when he arose which the Evangelists certainly would have mentioned being a matter of such moment to the Church and Christians had it been done in truth as pretended onely but not proved neither in truth can be If therefore the Objectors affirm that Christs Resurrection was the cause of the Lords-day as a Lords-day that is an immediate constituting cause of it and that at the very moment when he arose then it is a palpable untruth as the premises manifest If they mean by cause onely the impulsive cause or originall occasion of its future consecration or institution for a Sabbath or Lords-day then their Argument is but this Christs Resurrection the occasion of Christians solemnizing the Lords-day as a Lords-day or Sabbath was in the morning Ergo the Lords-day must being at morning which is but a meere Non sequitur because the occasions of sanctifying any dayes for Sabbaths or Holy-dayes do not
to reply to one grand Exception against that place of Levit. 23. 32. From Evening to Evening yâ—u shall celebrate your Sabbath a principall Text to prove that the seventh day Sabbath and so our Christian Lords-day or Sabbath as it is called ought to begin and end at Evening To which some reply that this Text speaks onely of the Sabbath of attonement which was but Ceremoniall not of the seventh day Sabbath therefore it is no Argument or Proof at all that the seventh day Sabbath or Lords-day succeeding it should begin and end at Evening To which I reply First that it is true this Text is meant more particularly of the Sabbath of attonement to which it is here specially applyed but yet it extends withall to the seventh day Sabbath which all confesse did ever begin and end at Evening from whence it received both its name of Sabbath and its limitation too both for the manner and time of its sanctification as is clear by verse 27 28 29 30. 31 32. compared together For 1. This Sabbath of Attonement was to be a Sabbath and so the same in appellation as the seventh day Sabbath verse 27 28 32. 2. It was to be but a Sabbath of one dayes space and no more to wit the tenth day of the seventh moneth verse 27. as the seventh day Sabbath was 3. It was to be sanctified and solemnized in the same manner as the seventh day Sabbath For 1. It was to be an holy Cnnvocation unto them v. 27. that is they must meet and keep publick religious holy Assemblies on it do holy duties as the seventh day Sabbath was verse 2 3. 2. They must rest and do no manner of work upon it verse 28 30 31 32. as they were commanded to do on the seventh day Sabbath Exod. 20. 9. 10 c 23. 12. c. 31. 15. c. 35. 2. Dâ—ut. 5. 13 14 15. neither might themselves or the strangers within their gates do any work thereon Levit. 16 29. as they might nâ—t do on the seventh day Sabbath Exod. 20. 10 11. 3. They must offer a burnt offering to the Lord on this Sabbath verse 27. as they were to do every seventh day Sabbath Numb. 2â— 9 10. 4. This Sabbath of Attonement was to cleanse them from all their sins before the Lord and make them holy Levit 16. 31. as the seventh dâ—y Sabbath was both a means and sign of Gods fanctifying them Exod. 31. 13. Ez. ch. 20. 22. 5. He that did any work on this Sabbath of Attonement was to be cut off from his people verse 30 as he was to be that did any work on the seventh day Sabbath Exod. 31. 14 15. Num. 15. 32 35 36. 6. On this Sabbath of Attonement they must afflict their souls v. 27. 32. as on thâ—seventh day Sabbath they were to do though not so solemnly as on this by confessing their sinnes and by not doing their own wayes nor finding or doing their own pleasure thereon Isa. 58. 13. By all which particulars it is manifest that this Sabbath of Attonement was in most things most exactly squared regulated by the seventh day Sabbath as the Sampler by the Copy or the picture by the person drawen participating with it both in its name use sanctification The sole Querie or doubt remaining to be cleared is when all this is to be done or at what time of the day this Sabbath of Attonement should begin and end God therefore resolves this scruple in the words alledged From Even to Even shall ye rest or celebrate your Sabbath that is in effâ—ct you shall keep it from Evening to Evening as vou do the seventh day Sabbath which begins and ends at Evening so that the seventh day Sabbath being here propounded for the onely pattern by which this Sabbath of Attonement was squared and this being to begin and end at Even because the seventh day Sabbath did as all acknowledge and I have provâ—d this Text in my conceit is a pregnant unavoidable Argument for the seventh day Sabbaths solemnization from Evening to Evening as well as for the Sabbath of Attonements beginning and concluding at Evening whence Saint Augustine with sundry Councels and Authorities forequoted apply this Text to the seventh day Sabbath and Lords-day as setting out bounds to them as well as to the Sabbath of Attonement 2. I answer that this Sabbath of Attonement was confined to the tenth day of the seventh moneth verse 27. and to be kept upon that day since therefore it was confined to that very day and to be solemnized from Evening to Evening it is apparant that that day as a naturall day began and ended at Even in Divine accompt and if that day as a naturall day began and ended at Even then by consequence all other dayes being all of one proportion and one ever beginning when the other ends began and ended at Evening Therefore the seventh day Sabbath too appropriated to the seventh day So that take it which way you please it is an unavoidable proof that all Sabbath dayes and the seventh day Sabbath begin and end at Evening in Divine Computation therefore the Lords-day must do so too being a Sabbath of sacred rest as all our Opposites resolve and confined to the first dayes limits which as a naturall day commenceth and determines onely at Even in naturall divine and true accompt and as a sacred day of Pâ—est â— denoted to Gods service I have now as succinctly and perspicuously as I could waded through this present Controversie At what time the Lords-day ought to begin and end and if my Judgement fail me not I conceive I have sufficiently manifested it to commence and conclude at Evening immediately after Sunset or so soon as the Evening-star begins to appear not at morning or midnight If the Truth shall prove on my side upon the debate I desire it may captivate the contrary mistakes and certifie both the judgement and practise of all such zealous Christians who are yet differently minded If the error be on my side as I am yet fully resolved it is not I shall be glad to be first informed then reformed by men of graver judgements desiring a to do nothing against but for the truth for which I shall ever contend to which I shall ever subscribe reputing it my greatest felicity to conquer with it or to be conquered by it and if occasion require to suffer chearfully gladly for it FINIS Errata PAge 2. l. 3 4. at Evening in pag. 10. l. 34. dele may pag. 12. l. 10. dele but part pag. 21. l. 6. r. is l. 36. read quality pag. 23. l. 29. dele the l. 36. naturall pag. 25. l. 36. r. of p. 26. l. 13. applicas l. 21. r. Summa l. 33. Cordubiensis l. 36. Covarravias p. 27. l. 21. pauper l. 26. totaliter l. 31. r. assert p. 28. l. 3. r. commanding p. 31. l. 11. ages p. 37. l. 24 r. eiâ— p. 44. l. 12. r. noctem p. 50.
â—stendit Vocatur enim Agape id quod penes Graecos dilectio est Non prius discumbitur quam oratio ad Deum praegustetur Editur quantum convenientes capiunt bibitur quantum pudiâ—is est utile ita saturautur ut qui meminerint etiam PER NOCTEM adorandum sibi Deum esse which shews that they began their Feasts and Christian exercises which he here conjoyns at Evening and continued them all night as Saint Paul and the Disciples at Troas did Which meetings Theophilus Alexandrinus in his Epist. Paschalis 3. 3. Bibl. Patrum Tom. 4. p. 723. calls Vespertina congregatio Post aquam manualem ac LVMINA which manifests they kept their Assemblies by Candle light and so begun them at Evening ut quisquis de scripturis sanctis vel de proprio ingenio potest provocatur in medio Deo canere which a Plinie the second stiles carmenque Christo quasi dicere secum invicem hinc probatur quomodo bibent Aâ—què oratio convivium diâ—imit Inde lis disceditur non in catervas caesionum neque in Classes discursationum nec in â—ruptiones laseivorum sed ad eandem â—uram modestiae pudicitiae ut qui non tam coenam coenaverint quam disciplinam Which usage well explains this place of the Acts It being apparent then as the subsequent Antiquities will more abundantly manifest that this meeting of the Disciples at Troas and Pauls preaching to them began at Evening The sole doubt will be what evening this was whether that which we call Sunday night as many erroneously mistake or Saturday night which is the Lords-day night if any For my own part I conceive clearly that it was upon Saturday night as we falsely call it not the ensuing Sunday night For admitting the Lords-day was then instituted for a Sabbath which those of the opposite opinions grant and I consent to there will be no great question of it 1. Because if the Christians at Troas observed this first day of the week as their Sabbath no doubt but this their meeting to solemnize it and receive the Sacrament on it was rather that Evening which began than that which ended the Lords-day in their account else they should have begun its solemnization onely when it ended whiâ—h is improbable But our Sunday Evening on which some affirm this meeting ended not commenced the Lords-day in their account they ever beginning their dayes the Evening before as the premises manifest Therefore this Assembly was on our Saturday Evening there being no mention of any meeting the day or Evening before 2. Because the Christians in the next succeeding ages as I shall prove by the following testimonies did ever begin their Lords-day assemblies and solemnities on Saturday Evening solemnizing it from Evening to Evening because the first observers of it did so Therefore it is more than probable that these Christians at Troas did so too 3. Because Saint Luke records that it was upon the first day of the week when this Meeting was and this Sermon of Pauls made therefore it must needs be on the Saturday not on our Sunday Evening since the Sunday Evenning in S. Lukes and Scripture account was no part of the first but of the second day the day ever beginning and ending at Evening in their computation as the premises evidence 4. All my opposites confesse that the Disciples met at this time upon the first day of purpose to sanctifie it for a-Sabbath and can they then think that they would defer their meeting till our Sunday Evening when all the day in their accompt and the best the chiefest part of it in their compute who begin it at midnight or morning was expired Certainly this had been to make the Lords-day no Festivall day at all or at most not so much as an half-holy day which we cannot presume these Disciples and S. Paul would dodid they observe it as their Sabbath From all which reasons I may more then probably conclude that it was the Saturday Evening when the Lords-day began not the Sunday night when it ended when this Divine Assembly was kept the rather because they received not the Sacrament nor brake this bread till after midnight as the Text affirms and so after the Lords-day ended even in the accompt of such who affirm it ends at midnight And because this beginning of their Assembly when the day begins makes most for the Apostolical divine Institution and sanctification of the Lords day for the which this Text will little avail if this Assembly on it were on our Sunday night when the day was either wholly or for the most part expired and so this meeting no warrant for its totall sanctification But against this it will be objected First that Saint Paul departed from Troâ— the very next morning at day-break which he would not have done had it been part of the Lords-day for he would not have taken this journey then lâ—st he should have prophaned it Besides the Text saith That he was ready to depart on the morrow which signifieth another day not the same therefore this night must needs be our Sunday night his departure being on the morrow to wit on our Monday the next day after it To this I answer First that it is clear by Acts 20. 6. that Saint Paul â—ame to Troas upon the Lords-day For he stayed there seven dayes And upon the first day of the week he thus preacheth till midnight ready to depart in the morning so that the first day was the last of those seven dayes and the first day of the week preceding it the day on which he came to Troas Paul therefore might as well depart on this day from Troas as he came unto it thereon And that without prophanation of the day for he came and went by ship verse 6. 13 14. and so might sanctifie the rest of the day a ship board as our marriners and passengers who sail on the Lords-day as well as other dayes use to do because the wind and â—ide then serving and the ship in which he was to sail being to depart that morning there was a necessity for him then to go a ship board else he might have lost his passage which necessity and circumstance of saiâ—ing away that day made this his departure on it no violation of the day works of necessity being no breach of the Sabbath as a Christ himself and all Divines resolve the rather here because he might preach and spend the rest of the day in the ship as profitably as on the shore and the Mariners might likewise now set sail the wind and weather serving without prophanation of the day as they still usually do in all places 2. I answer that the Morrow hath a double signification in Scripture Sometimes it is taken for the next b Evening or naturall day Other times it is taken for the next morning or day-light or that which we usually call day in opposition to the
night not for the next naturall day which begins at Evening but the next artificiall day of twelve houres day light which begins at Morning In this sense it is used most commonly in Scripture witnes Levit. 22. 30. When ye will offer a sacrifice of thanksgiving to the Lord aâ— your own will on the same day it shall be eaten up ye shall leave none of it untill the morrow compared with Levit. 7. 25. which speaking of the same offering saith He shall not leave any of it till the morning See Exod. 12. 10. c. 16. 19 23 24. where there is the same expression In which Texts the Morrow is nothing else but the morning following for had this offering been at Evening or night when the naturall day begins in Scripture accompt yet they might not have reserved any of it till the Morning for that had been to morrow as morrow is opposed to the night not to the naturall day So in 1 Sam. 19. 11. Saul sent Messengers to Davids house that night to watch and to slay him in the morning and Michall told him saying if thou save not thy life to night to morrow thou shalt bâ— slain Where morrow is not put for another naturall day that morrow in Scripture and the Jews account being part of that naturall day of which this night was the beginning but onely for the day-light or artificiall day being the same naturall day on which these words were spoken Thus it is used in 2 Sam. 11. 9 12 13 14. Esther 2. 14. So Zeph. 3. 3. Her Judges are Evening-wolves they gnaw not the bones till the morrow that is till the morning following And Acts 23. 31. 32. Then the Souldiers took Paul by night and brought him to Anâ—ipatris on the morrow they left the horsemen to go with him In all which places the morrow is put onely in opposition to the preceding night and for the day light following which night and morrow make up the same naturall day not for the beginning of the next enâ—uing naturall day or for another day Hence the Scripture useth this phrase The morrow after that day or after the Sabbath Levit. 23. 11 15. Josh 5. 12. 1 Chron. 29 21. because there is a morrow opposed to the night wherein a thing is done or spoken which is a part of the same naturall day that the night is In this sence morrow must needs be taken here for this meeting beginning but at night and Paul continuing his Preaching untill midnight following ready to depart on the morrow this morrow was nothing but the next morning which was a part of that fiâ—st day on which the disciple met as it was a naturall day consisting of twenty four houres and beginning but that Evening not another day of the week or our Monday morning as some affirm This morrow therefore being but the next morning and opposed to the night onely not to the naturall day on which this Assembly was kept at Troas and this night being part of the fiâ—st day of the wâ—ek which as a natural day in Scripture accompt bâ—gan at Evening could be no other but the Lords-day morning not the Monday following and this meeting â—s the promised Reasons prove could be no timâ— else but our Saâ—uâ—day night notwithstanding this Oâ—jâ—ction So that I may safely conclude that Saint Paul and the Christians of Troas the fiâ—st solemnizers of the Lords-day that we â—ead of did begin its solemnization at Evening not at morning or Midnight Wherefore we ought to begin it then This is my first Authority in point of practise to prove that the Primitive Christians began the Lords-dayes sanctification at Evening My next evidence is that of a Plinie the second who writes thus to the Emperour Trajan concerning the time and manner of the Christians solemnization of the Lords day Soliti erant STATO DIE ANTE LUCEM CONVENIRE carmenque Christo quasi Deo dicere secum invicem Seque SACRAMENTO non in scelus aliquod astringere sed ne furta ne latrocinia ne adulteria committerent ne fidem fallerent ne depositum appellati denegarent c. By which it is evident that the Christians in that age a time of persecution and after ages too did b usually meet together to receive the Sacrament and perform their holy Exercises at night when it began to grow dark and concluded them at day-light or about day-break as the disciples did at Troas Acts 20. 7. to 12. which Assemblies some Ecclesiasticall Histories call Antelucani coetus Night-Assemblies or meetings before day light not because they began in the morning about day-break as some would have it but because they both began and ended beâ—ore day-dawning the Christians in that time of persecution not daring to meet publickly in the day time for fear of apprehension Now this set night on which they kept those Assemblies was not our Sunday but our Saturday night on which our Saviour arose whiles it was dark and in Honour of his Resurrection did they begin and keep their Lords-day solemnization on this night not the night ensuing as is evident by Justin Martyrs second Apology with other ensuing testimonies And these their night conventions were the Occasion of those slanderous imputations which the Gentiles cast upon the Christians c that after their Exercises of Religion ended they did use to put out the lights used to expell the darknesse of the night Acts 20. 8. and then couple promiscuously one with another yea murther and eat up children and commit all manner of villany Since therefore they began their Lords-day exercises at Evening before day light began as this Heathen Authour and all Ecclesiasticall Historians writing of this age accord we need not doubt but the day in their accâ—mpt did then begin since they would not begin the exercises of the day till in truth it began My third Authority is that of Tertullian about 200 years after Christ in his Aâ—olâ—gy for the Christians c 38 39. the words whereof I have already alledged and de Corona militis c. 3. where he writes thus Eucharistiae Sacramentum in tempore victus mandatum à Domino ANTELVCANIS CAETILVS nec de aliorum manu quam praesidentium sumimus wch expresly shews that the Christians of that age did begin their publick Lords day meetings and Love feasts in the Evening and spending the Saturday night as we falsly deem it in Gods worship receiving the Sacrament and other holy duties which night assemblies he stiles b Nocturnae Convocationes because they spent the greatest part of that night in them nocturnae properly not morning or early risings and meeâ—ings before day but a watching or fitting up all night without going to bed or taking rest as the common proverb Nocturnae lucubrationes periculosissimae sunt compared with its opposite Adagie Diluculo surgere saluberimum est and Isa. 30. 29. Luke 2. 8. c. 5. 5. c. 6. 12. John 3.
bound out the beginning or end of the dayes for then these days must begin and conclude when the occasiâ—ns of their solemnization do But on the contrary tâ—e dayes do ever limit the occasions and Fâ—stivalls which must begin and end with the dayes to which they are confined This I shall make maniâ—est by examples and make good by unanswerable reasons For Examples we have all the Festivalls in Scripture which together with their occasions are restrained to the bounds of dayes not the limits of dayes to them To instance in particulars When God himself instituted the seventh day for a Sabbath because on it he had rested from all his works of Creation he confined the Sabbath and his rest to the seventh day not the seventh day to it blessing the seventh day and hallowing it not changing the beginning ending limits or order of it in the week but the use Gen. 2. 2 3. Exod. 20. 7. to 12. When God instituted the fourteenth day of the Moneth Abib for a Passeover day in memory of his passing over the Israelites and slâ—ying the Egyptians at Midnight he ordained that Feast to begin at Evening because the day to which this Festivall was confined did then begin not at Midnight whâ—n the occasion of its solâ—mnization happened Exod. 11. 4. c. 12. 3 6. 12. 10 40. Lev. 23 5. Numb. 9. 11. Deut. 16. 4. Josh. 5 10. So all the other Jewish Feasts * began and ended at Evening as the dayes on whiâ—h they were solemnized did the limits of the day being the bounds of the Festivalls not the Festivalls or their occasions the boundaries of the day a Festivall or Holy day being none other but a common day set apart and dedicated to Gods speciall honour and service Therefore being but a common day consecrated must needs begin and end â—s the day doth This is manifest by Exod. 12. 18. c. 13. 3 4. c. 14. 30. c. 35. 2. Levit. 23 3 to 43. Numb. 29. 1. Josh. 10. 12 13 14. Judges 5. 1. 1 Sam. 14. 23. Neh 8 9 10 11. Esth. 8. 12. c 9. 17 18 19 22. Psalm 81. 3. Psal. 118. 24. Isa. 22. 12. Matth. 28. 1. Mark 16. 1. Luke 23. 56. c. 21. 1. Wherâ— all Festivalls Fasts and memorable occasions are regulated by dayes not dayes by them the Festivalls and Feasts ever beginning and ending with the dayes to which they are appropriated not the dayes or Festivalls or Fasts with the occasions of their solemnization So in all annual or weekly Holy-dayes Feasts or Fasts instituted by men let the occasions of their institution happen what houre or time of the day they will at morning noon or afternoon yet we still begin the solemnization of them when the day begins For Example our Saviours Passion on the Crosse was not till about three of the clock in the afternoon John 9. 14 Mark 15. 34. Yet we solemnise our Goodfriday in memory of his Passion from the time the day begins So our Saviours Ascension as is probable by Acts 1. 9 10 11 12. 13. Luk. 24. 50 51 52. was about Noon or after yet we begin the Festivall of his Ascension with the dayes inception whereon it was So the descent of the Holy Ghost upon the Apostles in cloven tongues ' was about nine of the clock in the monring Acts 2. 15. Yet we solemnize our Whitsonday in memory thereof from that dayes inception Our deliverance from the a Gunpowder Treason on the fifth of November was about nine or ten in the morning or after when the King Queen Prince Lords and Commons should have mâ—t together in the Lords-house though suspected and in part discovered ten dayes before and actually detected at Midnight yet we begin the solemnization of it from the foregoing Evening with ringing of Bells and the like The Birth of many of our Princes hath been about noon or after and their Coronations about that time yet we solemnize their Birth-dayes and Coronation-dayes from those dayes beginnings The Crown descended to our present Soveraign King Charls in the afternoon yet we solemnize not that day from Noon to Noon but from Evening to Evening because the day doth then commence and end and so the solemnity confined onely to that day that whole day not to part of it and part of the ensuing day If then all Festivalls whatsoever begin and end with the dayes beginning and end on which they are kept not at the very time of those dayes when the occasions of their solemnization happened as these and other infinite other examples testifie Why should not the Lords-day begin at Evening though Christs Resurrection the chief cause of its sanctification was not till morning because that day as a day doth then begin and determine Certainly whatever the Opposites conceipt it must needs do so and that for these unanswerable Reasons First because God himself at the very Creation hath set inviolable bounds for the beginning and end of daves and weeks appointing them to be as so many Royall Standards for the limiting or measuring out of all Festivall occasions happening on them and reducing them to a certainty as I have manifested at large in the fourth Conclusion wherefore no event or Festivalls happening on those dayes can alter the limits or beginning of them nor make them longer or shorter no more than the Corn to be measured by the peck or bushell or the cloth to be measured by the yard can alter limit or measure out the quantity of the peck bushell or length of the yard Secondly because every occasion that may cause a subsequent consecration of a day for a Sabbath or Holy day and so Christs Resurrection doth only dedicate that day yea all that day on which it falls not part of that day and part of the day ensuing on which it did not happen therefore consecrating onely that very day all that day and no other day but that it must needs begin and end when that day doth Now that very day on which our Saviour arose began and ended at Evening as I have proved his Resurrection therefore being the cause of consecrating all that day not part of it and part of the following day for the Lords-day this day as a Lords-day must necessarily begin and conclude at Evening Thirdly because no occasion of consecrating the day on which it falls extends in point of Consecration further than that very day which is set as the utmost limits of it But should the Lords-day begin and end at morning or Midnight not at Evening Christs Resurrection the cause of its consecration should extend beyond the bounds of the day to consecrate half or at least a quarter of the second day for a Lords-day on which he arose and besides it should not consecrate all that day on which it happened but that part onely which ensued not that which preceded it since that day began at Evening as I have proved Both which were absurd to affirm Therefore it must