contemneriches and honours and when at any time we do enioy them Only Catholike Religion teacâ—â—â— perfection of life to renounce them for the loue of Christ She counselleth fasting haire-cloath lying on the ground and other bodily afflictions wherwith the flesh is tamed and subdued to the spirit Hence commeth it to passe that there are so many in the Catholike Church who conteÌ„ning riches honors and pleasures which they either enioyed or might haue done haue forsaken the world giuing themselues wholy to austerity of life and contemplation of heauently thinges Amongst whome may are Noble men and Noble mens sonnes and daughters many gentlemen many rich men many excellent wittes many most eloquent and famous for all kind of learning This is that most worthy enfigne of diuine spirit true religion For that this religion can be no other then celestiall which thus by violence draweth mans nature froÌ„ these base earthly things wherunto it cleaueth and raiseth it vp to contemplate heauenly which van quisheth the desires of temporall things and ingrafteth the loue of eternall and to conclude which worketh such wonderfull changes in men But the tree is knowne by the fruite Now other religions of pocially Lutheran Caluinian and â—nabaptisticall of which we meane chiefly to treate and do frame this our Consultation do performe no such thing Other Religions take away desire of perfection and good workes For that they are so far from teaching austerity of life or contempt of wordly delight as they call fasting a humane tradition wherby God is honoured in vayne Abstinence from flesh they call superstition monasticall vowes they say are wicked vaine and not to be kept chastity they teach to be impossible lib. de vita coniugali all must marry and imploy their time in wyuing which as Luther saith is as necessary as to eate drinke sleep c. Out of which doctrine it followeth that none of those who follow any of these new Religions do either came their flesh by abstinence keep chastity or abstaine from marriage and fleshly pleasures or exercise pouerty for for the loue of Christ by forsaking their riches but do al imbrace a loose vulgar worldly life agreable to the inclination of the flesh and corruption of nature No man in this religion can once find in his hart to imitate an Angelicall life heere in this world as many holy men haue done before and many do at this present in the Catholike Church no man goeth about to shake of the carkes and cares of this life breaking in pieces the bands of the world that being free and discharged therof he may follow Christ our Lord imitating his most holy life and representing him in his mortall flesh for what soeuer is aboue the common and popular manner of liuing these new Religions do not allow Who then seeth not that in these there is no Christian religion For although Christ considering mans infirmity doth not commaund pouerty chastity single life contempt of ones selfe and the like yet notwithstanding doth he counsell vs and inuite vs therto with great reward giuing vs an example therof in himselfe to imitate the same So as by this his example and inuitement infinite numbers of all orders ages sexes nations and conditions being stirred vp haue attayned vnto this high sanctity and haue bin therfore admired of al the world But contrari wise these now Religions altogeather disallow the desire or study of perfection as inpossible or superstitious Neither do they alone hinder this most excellent sanctity but therwith al seeke to suppresse all other endeauours desires of good workes â—uth art 31. 36. deliber châ—â—â—tiana Calu. l. 3 Inst cap. 12. §. 4. cap. 14. §. 9. Luth in assert art 1. Calu l. 4. Inst cap. 11. §. 13. 14. cap 19. §. 2.4 7. For that they teach That man offeÌ„deth in all his works though this synne be not imputed to those that belieue Then they teach That man by any good workes whatsoeuer meriteth nothing with God is neuer the more grateful vnto him neuer the more iust nor shall haue neuer the more reward for his workes whether they be more or lesse or any at all but that only faith is esteemed and crowned with God c. This doctrine being theÌ„ once set abroach what man trow you wil be stirred vp or moued to good workes prayer almes abstinence or help of his neighbours For if in all these workes there be sinne and neither merit nor reward nor profit what should mooue meÌ„ to performe them Who will bestow his labour goods in vaine without any profit but with hindrance to himselfe So as these new religions as yow see quite take a way all good workes from men and leaue them only faith which they esteeme in place and volue of al. It is not theÌ„ credible that Christ by so many sweats and labours by such his manifold doctrine and heauenâ—â— admonitions by his bloud crosse and passion would leaue vnto vs or be the Author of so barren a Religion Neither do we any way obscure the merits of Christ by attributing the force of meriting euerlasting life by our workes as our aduersaries obiect An obiection refuted but rather do we illustrate and extoll the same For we assigne the merits of Christ to be so forcible and vniuersall that he did not only merit Eternall Saluation therby for vs but also gaue vs force and strengh to merit for our selues As for example that man should not iniure the Omnipotency of God The force of Christ merits but rather extoll it that should say that the said Omnipotency doth not only worke and produce all things but also giueth force to things created to worke and produce the like For there is nothing that doth more declare the excellency and perfection of the cause then if the cause doth not only worke or cooperate it selfe but giueth also force and strength to others to do the same Therefore wheÌ„ as we say Christ did not oÌ„ly merit for vs but gaue vs also force to merit for our selues we do far more extoll the force of his merittes then they who teach that he alone did merit all left vs no strength to cooperate to his merits Nay rather those men do greatly iniure Christ because they take away this force and efficacy from him like vnto certaine Philosophers who taught that things created had no force in theÌ„selues to cooperate but that the only increated power of God did al and therby iniured his Omnipotency as if he could not giue force to things created to worke cooperate with God For as he should iniure Christ that should attribute to man any force or strength to merit that is not deriued from the merits of Christ so also should he iniure God that should attribute any force or power to things created that is not deriued froÌ„ the omnipotency of God Furthermore as the operations of things
faith eyther for guilt or payne what should let him to commit neuer so grâ—euous or emormous wickednes What should he feare Hell or Purgatory Neyther for by liuely faith alone no syn shal be imputed to any man although it be neuer so grieuous and filthy What then Shall he feare the Diuine wrath or the subtraction of heauenly Grace No for that God doth not impute the same vnto him and for the satisfaction that Christ made he cannot be offended with him Doth he feare temporall satisfaction or Confession Neyther For that these things are taken away as superstitions What then doth this man more feare then any Atheist Or how doth he not open as wyde a gate to all wickednes impurity as the Atheist What Atheisme teacheth the Scripture witnesseth when she fayth The foole said in hic hart Psal 13. there is no God they are corrupt and are made abhominable in all their endeauours There is not one that doth good there is not so much as one And this doth Atheisme teach for so much as it taketh away the feare of Diuine punishment wherby men are held as with a bridle from synning But these Religions do no lesse take a way the feare of heauenly reueng and chastisement when as they teach that nosyn shal be imputed eyther for offence or payne nor any man punished therfore Moreouer I say that by these Religions this wholsome feare of God is sooner taken a way then by Atheisme For few Atheists do certainly belieue that there is not any God at al but many doubt it and feare the contrary and so they be not without feare of punishment of him They take away all feare of God foure manner of wayes that may in many things represse them But these Religions do for certaine without all doubt teach that synnes are not imputed to the faithfull and this they commaund to be most firmely belieued and therfore they leaue no feare but do shake of all suspition imaginatioÌ„ of punishment whatsoeuer so as they giue a far greater scope to all wickednes then Atheisme doth Neyther do they this by one manner of way only but by a fourefold First For that they teach that through saith synnes are not imputed vnto vs be they neuey so many or neuer so heynow wherof we haue spoken inough before Secondly For that they say that all those who haue true faith are predestinated Calu. l. 3. c. 2. §. 6.7.11.12.15.16 38. and that they ought to belieue the same most assuredly And if all the followers of these Sectes be predestinated and that they are bound to belieue the same most firmely wherfore then should they be sollicitous eyther to liue well or to shun the workes of the flesh which the Apostle recounteth For neyther can they doubt of their saluation or that they shall go to hell because Gods predestination is potent and immutable and those who are so predestinated cannot possibly perish Neyther can they feare the paynes of Purgatory which they beleeue not nor yet can they feare punishments in this life when as synnes are not imputed to them by God Thirdly For that they take away the liberty of Freewill and do teach Luth. in Assert art 36. l. 1. cap. 16. §. 8. that all things happen by an ineuitable necessity and that a man caÌ„not make his works better or worse For if there be no liberty there is properly no sinne like as a lyon when he demoureth a man although he committeth euill yet sinneth not because he doth it not freely but by the vehement instigation of nature nor is it in his power to moderate this his instigation Noe man shall be then worthy of punishment because that which is done by force of necessity deserueth no punishment Wherefore there shal be no hell nor any punishment at all after this life For that it should be a great and intollerable cruelty to damne a man to euerlasting torments for those things which by no meanes he could auoid Wherfore then should they feare to follow their harts desire or do any thing that may please their appetite Fourthly For that they teach all mens workes Luth. supra Cal. l. 1. cap. 17. § 5. cap. 18. §. 1. as well good as bad to haue bin preordained of God from all eternity and to that end the wills of men are by him inclined incited forced and determined to performe the same For if God do worke in vs as well bad as good there is no reason why we should endeauour to auoid euill or feare the punishment therof For that God is not the reuenger of that wherof he is the Author nor can he punish that which he will haue done in vs and causeth vs to do For that this should be more then Tyrannicall cruelty from which God is knowne to be fare off and free Here by then it is as cleare as the funne that these Religions by these foure wayes now declared do take froÌ„ the minds of meÌ„ all feare of God do giue as large a scope to all wickednes as euer any Atheisme in the world and that the more perniciously because the are not exercised in the open view and shew of impiety but vnder the colour forsooth of diuine religion and honour to wit vnder the faire titles of only faith satiffaction of Christ liberty of the new Ghospell diuine prouidence and predestination Vnder these shaddows thus couertly hid is swallowed so much venome that it wholy poysoneth the mindes and maners of men Who then that hath but the least dramme of an vpright iudgment that will thinke such Religions to come from God III. CONSIDERATION Drawne froÌ„ the Sanctity of the followers of true Religion THAT Religion is to be preferred wherin very many men haue byn famous for sanctity of life For it cannot be that a naughty religion should lead a man to sanctity or that true sanctity should abide with a naughty religion But Catholike religion hath had very many in her Church in all ages who by common confession and wittnes of all the Christian world were most holy men Amongst whome to omit innumerable others were S. Antâ—ny the great S. Hilarion S. Gregory Thaumaturgus S. Nicolas Bishop of Myra S. Athanasius S. Gregory Nazianzen S. Basill S. Simeon Stelites S. Cipryan S. Hilary S. Martin S. Ambrose S. Hierome S. Augustine S. Benet S. Gregory the Great S. Vedastus S. AmaÌ„dus S. VVinock S. Bertin S. Romwald S. VVillebrord S. Boniface S. Bruno S. Bernard S. Romuald S. Nortbert S. Dominicke S. Francis S. Themas of Aquine S. Bonauenture S. Francis à Paula and many more in our age That all these men were followers of the Catholike religion there can be not doubt aswell for that they adhering to the Roman Church did professe the faith therof wonderfully propagated the same as also for that most of theÌ„ were Monkes vowed religiou men nay all monasticall institutions professions had their begining by
therfore can be giuen why thou shouldest imbrace or prefer any one of all these religions before another for that euery one of them do both brag and boast that the word of God makes for theÌ„ that they haue the spirit of God that the sense of Scriptures is perspicious for their doctrine and what soeuer is contrary herto is false and manifestly repugnant to holy Writte Nor haue they any other proofe for all this theÌ„ that it is euident to him that hath the spirit And seing then that euery one of these Sectaries do alleage the selfe same reason for their doctrine and do build vpon the selfe same foundation it followeth therfore necessarily that thou must either imbrace all these religions or els none of them But Catholike religion doth far otherwise proue their opinions and doctrine to wit out of Holy Scripture expounded according to the common sense vnderstanding of the Ancient Fathers and by the doctours of all ages by the sanctity miracles and prophetical spirit of all such as haue imbraced this religion as also by the constancy and vniformity of doctrine in all ages by the purity of life wherunto she leadeth and lastly by the conuersion of Nations and who haue bin conuerted vnto this doctrine IX CONSIDERATION From diuers Causes and Reasons for which these new doctrines are to be suspected and shunned ALL other Religions but the Catholike and namely the Lutheran Caluinian and Anabaptisticall of which principally we treat in this place are worthily to be suspected and as hereticall sects are to be shunned for many reasons which heere I meane briefly to ponder and recount The I. Reason Deduced from Nouetty ALL Nouelty and as S. Gregory Nazianzen calleth it new Inuention in euery Common wealth but specially in matters of religion is to be shunned ChristiaÌ„ Religion is a thing most ancient solid vnchangeable and durable to the worlds end it being the forme vigour and as it were the very life of Christs Church For as flesh by life is quickened in a liuing man euen so is the Assembly of men in Christs Church by religion which otherwise of it selfe is only flesh formed into a spirituall Kingdome And againe as the Church kingdome of Christ is a thing most ancient and indeleble Against which Church the gates of hell shall not preuaâ—le Matt. 16. vlt. and to whome Christ promâ—sed his assistance to the worlds end Euen so is religion vpon which the Church kingdom of Christ doth stand firme stedfast Nouelty therfore is repugnant to the religion of Christ Now that these religions are new it is manifest First for that we can nominate and bring forth their first Authors tyme place and maner how they were brought first in and who they were that opposed themselues against them what great styrres and troubles also were raised euery where about them and lastly how and by whome they where condemned as noueltyes and heresies And what can be a more manifest signe of nouelty then this In like maner all other heresies that haue byn brought in against the Apostolike doctrine of Christ are conuinced of nouclty for that we can shew what tyme euery one of them began in what place who was the Author who were the opposers therof and lastly by whome they were condemned of nouelty Secondly before the yeare of our Lord 1517. Lutheranisme was neuer heard of in the world nor likewise Caluinisme nor Anabaptisme which are the daughters of Lutheranisme For that it is manifest out of Authors that when Luther first began to peepe out his head there was no other religion known to be exercised in the world besides the Iewish Mahometan and Pagan but the Catholike and that of the Hussites Thirdly if yow say that any of these Religions for examples sake the Lutheran alwayes was but yet lay hid then I aske in what place the same lay hid in what kingdome or towne and who were the patrons defenders therof Againe how know yow that this religion was before when as the same cannot be knowne but by some authors who do not so much as insinuate any such thing but the quite contrary Furthermore wheras in euery age and place there haue byn Inquisitours of hereticall noueltyes by what meanes then could this religion ly hid for so many ages that it should neuer be discouered or that neuer any one of the followers or teachers therof should fall into their hands and be punished Surely neuer any hereticall Sect could yet ly hid so cunningly but that she should often haue byn deprehended and publikely called into examination and question Moreouer if before Luther that Religion had byn in the world how chance that the followers therof who had hitherto layn hidden did not then come publikely forth when Luther began to preach and acknowledge him for the Doctour of their faith League-maker of their religion How hapned it then that they came not abroad in publicke and imbraced him as their fellow and Patrone who had now at last set at liberty this their Religion so long before layn hidden and oppressed in secret corners But no such appeared that were euer followers of that Religion before but that as many as ioyned themselues with Luther De Missa Angulari lib. 2. cont Zuingl did professe Catholike religion before as Luther himselfe was also Catholike before and a Friar who for 15. yeares togeather had daily and denoutly said masse as himselfe confesseth By all which it is more cleere then the sunne that Luthers Religion is altogether new and was not knowne vnto the world before his tyme nor that there was any company of men no not perhaps so much as any one particular person before Luther who professed the same Religion that is to say held all and euery of the same heads of beliefe or the same body of doctrine which Luther did And although Luther tooke some of his opinions from the old heretikes notwithstanding Lutheranisme is not therfore the same Religion with that of the old heretikes but only in part for that a Religion is the imbracing and comprehending of al the heads of beliefe which are ordayned and determined to belong to faith but none before Luther did euer teach this imbracing of opinions The same is likewise conuinced by another reason for that it is manifest that the Ancient Fathers and doctors of all ages were not of Luthers religion seing they teach Frewil necessity of good workes Merit of life euerlasting and possibility of the Diuine Law They do also allow of the Inuocation of Saints worship and honour of holy reliques Images sacrifice of masse for the quicke and dead Order of ministers in the Church monasticall vowes Euangelicall Counsells the fast of Lent and the like all which things the Lutheran Religion doth reiect as superstitions impious and iniurious to God Now that the ancient Fathers did professe and allow all these things before rehearsed is most manifest out of their owne wrytings
bee effected by the onely forces of nature Lib. 3. c. 16. § 2. sequent c. 19.6.2.4 7. but all other also vnder what specious title soeuer bee excluded by the iustice of fayth And the same he teacheth in many other places If then there bee no merit at all in good works if they make vs nothing the more accepted to God nor wee for them shall receiue any reward in heauen wherefore should we weary our selues in exercising them Wherefore should wee spend our goods in workes of mercy towards the relieuing of the poore why should wee insist and spend houres in prayer wherfore should wee fast or punish our bodyes It is a folly for vs to weary our selues out in them to be sollicitous about the exercising of them if no fruit returne vnto vs by them Who seeth not that by this doctrine all desire and care of good works is extinguished and cleane taken away Secondly for that both these Religions teach that all our good workes do not onely merit no good at all before God but further then this bee also syns and that indeed of themselues mortall though for their fayth they bee not imputed to the beleeuers And Luther in many places teacheth no lesse As when he sayth (a) In resolut contra Eckium in assert art 31. The iust sinneth in euery good work Againe (b) In assert art 32. a good worke done in the best maÌ„ner is according to gods mercy a veniall sinne but according to his iudgment a mortal sin In another place (c) In assert art 29. Our best works whereby wee labour to procure of God grace help comfort is to bee reputed vnto vs for sin as the Prophet sayth Psal 108. And his prayer be vnto him to sin The same he inculcateth in maÌ„y other places Caluin deliuereth the same doctrine For this he saith Lib. 3. Instit c. 12. §. 4. All the workes of men if they bee censured as they deserue bee nothing but foule staines and filth Neyther can any work proceed from holy men that deserueth not the iust reward of reproach The same he teacheth c. 14. els where Lib. 3. c. 14. § 9. If all our good workes bee truly sins foule staines and filth that merit Gods ire who seeth not that it is much better to abstaine from them then to do them For by forbearing them we sin not but by doing them we sin and much better it is not to sin then to sin We must therfore abstaine from giuing of almes and from doing other works of mercy yea we must cease to pray because all these as they are done of vs bee sins And how may all study and desire of good workes be better ouerthrowne then by teaching that they do not onely make vs nothing the more iust or better before God but that they bee further silth foule staynes and syns indeed Neither maketh it to the purpose that they so ofteÌ„ say that God requireth good works for a testimony of faith Whether good works be required as the signe of faith or as signs of faith sith they affirme it least they may seeme to the people to take away al good works cleare But this their pretense is vaine For how doth God require them if they be syns which vnles he of his mercy should not impute theÌ„ he should punish with euerlasting paine how doth he for a testimony of faith require those things that do rather giue a testimony of want of fayth For those who bee follicitous about the doing of good workes do ther by testifie that faith sufficeth not For if faith were inough as they will haue it and good workes auaile nothing at all how bee good workes a signe of faith Therfore the study of good works is not a signe of that speciall faith wherof they speake and whereunto they ascribe all but of the Catholike faith whereby wee beleeue that faith is not inough but that workes bee further required that bee meritorious of euerlasting life with which faith they haue nothing to do at all but reiect it wholy By what hath been sayd most euident it is that by those Religions all study and care of good workes is taken away and banished quite The IX Reason Deduced from the liberty of life which they yeald vnto THOSE Religions cannot possibly bee thought to haue been instituted by Christ that do vtterly spoile mens minds of the feare of God and do open a most wide gate to all wickednes and to all maÌ„ner of impurity of life For holy writ doth euery where inculcate vnto vs the feare of God neyther it there any thing that is more often repeated more recomended vnto vs syth therof especially dependeth all goodnes honesty of life But the Religion of Luther and Galuin both do quite thrust out of mens minds the feare of God and yeald a liberty to all manner of wickednes as far as doth Atheisme therfore neither the one nor the other can pretend Christ to bee the Author of their Religion That they do this and that by foure different and diuers wayes hath beene by vs most plainely set downe declared in the second consideration before now I will in few words againe manifest proue the same by these reasons following First for that the Lutherans Religion teacheth that the decalogue or ten Commandments appertaine not to the faythful as neither the ceremoniall and iudicial lawes also For thus he sayth in his sermon of Moyses By the Text it euidently appeareth that the ten precepts also do nothing concerne vs for as much as our Lord brought not vs but the lewes only out of Aegypt Moyses is not held in the new testament for if I should obserue him in one article I should be bound to the obseruation of the whole Law The same be teacheth in many wordes c. 4. Epist ad Galat. in c. 20. Exodi If the ten Commandments bind vs no more then the cerimoniall laws as he expresly teacheth c. 4. ad Galat. therefore as I am not bound to keep the cerimoniall law for example to circumcise the flesh to eate the Paschall â—ambe to obserue the Sabboaths c. so neither the morall law or the ten Commandments If I be dispensed from obseruation of the ten Commandements what may it not be lawfull for me to do I may then in outward shew adore Idols contemne parents make no reckoning of Magistrats commit murthers adulteryes robberyes giue false testimouies and such like that be prohibited and forbidden by the decalogue euen as I may do those thinges that haue repugnance with the cerimoniall law And though Caluin doth not in expresse maÌ„ner delyuer the same Doctrine couching the coÌ„mandements yet vnderhand he sufficiently infiâ—uateth it Lib. 2. Instit cap. 7. §. 5. First when he teacheth That it is impossible also for holy men to keep Gods law For if it be impossible it bindeth not at all sith none
the most certaine and only way to life euerlasting and none there is who strayeth out of it that is not most assured to runne into euerlasting perdition It is a Doctrine of Atheisme that euery one may be saued in his owne religion But as there is one God one Christ one truth one certitude one iustice so there is one fayth and one religion and one Church or Congregation of God and Christ out of which there can be no Saluation Let them take heede that they spoyle not themselues of so great a good eyther out of a curiosity of reading or hearing or by an improuident and vncircumspect conuersation with heretiks or out of a desire of pleasing and contenting some or for feare of some hurt in temporall life also or out of an hope of commodity and gaine or for desire of honors or for any other cause What profiteth it a man if he gayne the whole world and suffer the detryment of his soule or what exchaunge shall a man giue for his soule But he that sustayneth hurt in his religion cannot but hurt his soule withall and therefore let him not be afraid to expose all for the retayning of it the loosing and forgoing whereof is the losse of life euerlasting withall Vnhappy be those soules and vnworthy a Christian name that make but a little reckouing of the ouerthrow of the Catholike religion so they may themselues enioy temporall peace for the gathering and keeping of the poore things and trifles of this life This madnes and light estceme of so great a good will cost them deare when this short time moment of life shall be once past and they shall vpon the suddaine be brought to that eternity that neuer endeth Many seducers haue come into the world many do vnder a sheeps skyn and vnder a faire flattering shew of Gods word hide and conceale their woluish fury to the vtter ruine of Christs sheep Our Lord admonished vs more theÌ„ once to take heed of them the Apostles inculcated no lesse as did the holy Fathers also He Eccl. 13. Eccl. 3. that shall touch pitch shall be defiled of it he that loueth daÌ„ger shal perish therein The times were neuer more trecherous to mans saluation then now they be the deuill was neuer more frequent in bewitching and deceiuing men were neuer more easily caried away with the spirit of incoÌ„stancy the operatioÌ„ working of errour neuer of more force finally mens minds neuer more fouly blinded then now all these do worthily seize vpoÌ„ their minds who do make a light esteeme of that noble and great gift of the Catholike and Orthodoxe Religion prefer their temporall and externall goods before it Wherefore let them who make a reckoning of their owne saluation conserue this beauenly gemme and keep it with all diligence for that of it proceedeth life And because it is a supernaturall gift which can neyther be obtayned nor kept and held without Gods help whiles so many and so great daungers and enemyes beset vs on all sides they mustimplore and craue help at Gods hands incessantly to that end both for themselues their children and their family and seeke to appease God by almes and other offices of piety For good is prayer with fasting almes Tob. 12. and better then to lay vp treasures of gold Let them lead a life correspondent to their religion let them quench their thirst of terrene things with the expectation of the celestiall and euerlasting goods euer mindâ—ull of that saying of the Apostle 1. Timoth. 6. They that will become rich fall into temptation and into the snares of the Diuell many vnprofitable and hurtfull desires which drowne a man into destruction and perdition For the roote of all euill is desire which some coueting haue strared from the fayth and thrust themselues into many sorrowes With these helps they may walke on in safety amidst the daungers of these tymes conserue and maintayne vnstayned the gift of the true and only Religion and by it with facility and case purchase life euerlasting to which God of his infinite mercy bring vs all Amen FINIS AN APPENDIX TO THE FORMER CONSVLTATION WHETHER Euery One may be saued in his owne Fayth and Religion WRITTEN By the same Leonard Lessius of the Society of IESVS Permissu Superiorum M.DC.XVIII THE PREFACE WEe haue before in the Preface of our Consultation set downe and briefely confuted a certaine grosse error which holdeth it inough for our saluatioÌ„ to belieue in Christ and that he died for our sinnes But because it is much spread and hath sunke deeply into the minds of many I was requested to treate of the matter more at large and therefore now I will deuide it into two seuerall Questions bringing arguments for eyther part The first Question shal be VVhether it be sufficient for saluation to belieue in God and do no man iniury which is as much to say as Whether euery man may be saued in his owne Faith which he professeth if therin he endeauour to liue honestly The second Question VVhether it be sufficieÌ„t to saluatioÌ„ to belieue in Christ that he dyed for our sinnes although we belieue not many other articles of faith THE I. QVESTION CONCERNING the first Question many in these tymes do hold are of opinion that euery man may be saued in his owne religion The ground of ouâ— Aduersaries opinions their principall reasoÌ„ wherwith they are moued to this is because it seemeth vnto them incredible that al Iewes and Turkes many of whom do deuoutly worship God and deale iustly with their neyghbours should perish for all eternity only because they haue not belieued in Christ especially since for want of this beliefe they seeme not to deserue much blame they being from their infancy trayned vp in a religion different from Christianity For why say they should God who would all men to be saued so strayten the way vnto heauen why should those miserable souls who according to their capacity do their best to please him do wrong to no man and do lead a iust and honest life be condemned to eternall payne for the ignorance of that thing wherein they were neuer sufficiently instructed The I. Reason But this opinion of theirs The same refuâ—ed by foure Reasons although in naturall reason it may seeme to carry some colour of truth and equity yet considering those thinges which are reuealed vnto vs in holy Scriptures it is a meere Paradox For if euery Turke and Iew may be saued in their beliefe then iuvaine haue the Apostles and holy Fathers so much laboured in preaching planting of the Christian faith In vaine so many Martyres by all manner kind of torments haue shed their bloud and spent their life in the confession therof For they might haue abstayned from this doctrine profession without any preiudice to their saluation and haue rested contented with the Iewes in the profession and
A CONSVLTATION WHAT FAITH AND RELIGâ—â—â— is best to be imbraced WRITTEN IN LATIN By the R. Father Leonard Lessius Professour in Diuinity of the Society of IESVS AND Translated into English by W. I. IHS Permissu Superiorum M.DC.XVIII TO THE RIGHT HONORABLE THE LORD MAIOR TO THE RIGHT WORSHIPFVLL THE ALDERMEN AND TO THE RIGHT WORTHY CITTIZENS OF LONDON The Translatour wisheth all Health and Happines Temporall and Eternall RIGHT HONORABLE RIGHT WORSHIPFVLL AND RIGHT WORTHY I Was pâ—rswaded to present you with this Treatise traÌ„slated by 〈◊〉 into our mother tongue that hath appeared far better 〈◊〉 in â—â—owâ—yde it was first inuested only through the loue and respect I beare to your so we deserming persons whose speciall endeauors amidst your other sorâ—ous imployments in that famous Citty should be and I hope is the attayning of such a traffike that may more redound to the profit of your Soules then your temporall Estates since you know well that a sure and solid foundation of true Religion worketh Eternall Saluation and the contrary eternall woe and misery though otherwise one were neuer so fortunate in all worldly prosperity The worke it selfe is but of some few houres reading and the Author I hope will not be distastfull vnto yow in respect of his person though otherwise of a different Profession habit And though I doubt not but that many of your haue already seene other learned Bookes of like subiect yet because this affoardeth so great variety of forcible Motiues both singularly chosen and most aptly expressed to settle mens Consciences in so waighty an affayre as this is I haue therfore thought good to present it to your View though in a more humble and far lesse polished stile then so profitable a subiect deserueth And heerunto I was the more encouraged by vnderstanding the great fruite and profit which many haue all ready and do dayly reape by a diligent perusall of this Booke in other languages hoping for no lesse in our owne then it hath produced in the Latin French and Dutch especially in men so zealous in that Profession which hath by in these later tymes preached vnto you Which zeale of yours would no doubâ— be more feruent if Gods Grace by other mothâ—es proposed should open your eyes to see the cleernes of the Catholike Verity Neither should it offend you that your Consciences hauing byn setled these 60. yeares last past in the Faith that was then proposed vnto you now a new reuiew of matters belonging to Religion should be offered For synce the Scripture doth premonish vs that Heresies must of necessity be and false Teachers would come to disturbe the peace and vnity of the Church of which sort as is apparent by her contrary doctrines this our vnfortunate Age hath byn most fertile it is doublesse no disgrace or signe of leuity or inconstancy by a diligent and iudicious examen to try which of all these diuers spirits is of God and which is that Catholike Church so often commended vnto vs in the Scriptures as nothing more plainely and seriously In which important search the Reading of this little but golden Treatise will by Gods grace affoard such light to discerne Truth from Falshood and such meanes to find out the true gate of Catholike faith which only leadeth to saluation as may satisfy the most Iudicious especially if they reade with that humblenes of spirit as they ought to do who desyre to know the Truth In reading therfore consider attentiuely euery Passage ponder the waight and substance of ech Reason not posting the same ouer as many do transpotted with curiosity to read all new Bookes that come forth and I doubt not you will receaue aboundant satisfaction Read then most worthy Cittizens the ensuing Consultation with an indifferent and vnpartiall eye that you may enrich your soules with the treasure of true knowledg doctrine which leadeth to eternall Life and Happines Wherof I humbly beseech his diuine Maiesty to make you partakers to whom I haue heerewith dedicated both my selfe and seruice to remayne Your seruant euer in Christ Iesus W. I. This 30 of Septemb. 1618. THE TABLE OF THE CONTENTS of the ensuing Consultation THE Preface pag. 1. The I. Consideration Of the desire of Perfection wherunto Christian Religion leadeth pag. 8. The II. Consideration That Christian Religion excludeth liberty of sinning pag. 11. The III. Consideration Drawne froÌ„ the Sanctity of the followers of true Religion pag. 2â— The IIII. Consideration From the miracles wrought by the imbracers of Catholike Religion pag. 36. The V. Consideration From the Conuersion of Nations by the imbracers of Catholike Religion pag. 48. The VI. Consideration From the Name Catholike and from the thing it selfe signed or marked with this Name pag. 55. The VII Consideration From Succession pag. 59. The VIII Consideration From the consent of the ancient Fathers and Doctours of the Church and from the decision of controuersies without which there is no sodality or fellowship pag. 65. The IX Consideration From diuers causes and reasons for which these new doctrines are to be suspected and shunned pag. 74. The I. Reason Deduced from Nouelty pag. 75. The II. Reason Taken from the defect of Succession pag. 87. The III. Reason From the defect of their Mission pag. 9â— The IIII. Reason From the want of Miracles pag. 106. The V. Reason From the conditions of their liues and manners pag. 116. The VI. Reason from their errors and inconstancy in Doctrine pag. 125. The VII Reason Taken from the fraudes and deceipts which the Sectaryes commonly vse pag. 135. The VIII Reason Drawne from the ouerthrow of good Workes pag. 153. The IX Reason Deduced from the liberty of life which they yield vnto pag. 158. The X. Reason That they renew old Heresies pag. 166. The XI Reason From want of a Rule of Fayth pag. 171. The XII Reason Drawne from Absurdity pag. 181. The X. Consideration And conclusion of this Consultation pag. 189. An Appendix of the Author Whether euery one may be saued in his owne Fayth and Religion pag. 214. A CONSVLTATION WHAT FAITH AND RELIGION IS TO be imbraced GREAT is the variety of Religion in this our age and great is the contention about the truth therof Many in this point do continually wauer nor can they determine any certainty passing from one Religion to another as it were from house to house for trialls sake thereby to find tranquility of mind Others through an inconsiderate boldnes do imbrace any Religion which by chance they light vpon without either examining or vnder standing the same who when they are demanded why they preferre that Religion before others they haue no other answere but that it seemes better to them or els which commonly all do oragge of because they follow the very pure word of God This busines notwithstanding is most worthy of great deliberation and discussion seeing that heerin consisteth the very center of our saluation Euerlasting saluation or damnation is
them That they were most holy men it is the common consent of all Christian people for so many ages past that liued in their daies Neither was there euer made any doubt therof And this the heretikes themselues do also confesse of diuers of them and specially of S. Bernard S. Dominick and S. Francis For it were a great impudency to deny or call into doubt that which the consent of the whole world auerreth If these men therfore were Saintes and Catholiks as all the world doth hold them to haue byn it followeth necessarily that the Catholike Roman religion which they held imbraced is the true religion and proceedeth from the Holy Ghost First for that it is impossible that a false religion should lead to true sanctity for that religioÌ„ is the foundatioÌ„ of sanctity That heauenly edifice caÌ„not be built vpoÌ„ vanities nor vpon pernicious sacrilegious falsities as is euery falsity in religion It cannot be that a false religion should withdraw the mind froÌ„ earthly things and so fixe it vpon heauenly that being kindled with diuine loue and feruor should force the same to vndergo so great labours paines for procuring the health of her neighbours soules Not. withstanding the reâ—igion which these men imbraced did performe in them al these things and consequently it cannot be that their religion was false Secondly for that without true religion Hebr. 11. it is impossible to please God But by the consent of all these men pleased God and were his great friends and familiars Therfore their religion was the true For how could they please God who is verity it selfe by a false religion Thirdly if their religion were not true then was it from the Diuell for that he is a liar from the begining and the Father of lyes who by his lying and deceytes doth euer seeke to corrupt the true religion thereby to destroy soules If it came from the Diuell how could it then lead them to sanctity and make them enemies to the Diuell 2. Cor. â— and friends to God For what society is there betwene light and darkenes and what agreement with Christ and Belial Fourthly It is altogeather incredible that God should permit men so innocent so contemning themselues and worldly affaires so studious of his diuine glory and ardent louers of him to be deceiued for so many ages in a matter of so great moment to witt in the busines of religion and foundation of all piety Who is he that will thinke so impiously of Gods diuine goodnes They pretermitted nothing on their behalfe whereby then might please God and aduance his glory taking vpon them the greatest paines labours for the obtaining therof and wholy implying and coÌ„secrating their liues vnto him How caÌ„ it be that his diuine goodnes that true Light which enlightemeth euery man that comes into this world should not reueale the truth and his light to so worthy seruants and louers of him but should leaue them sticking fast in their blind and pestiferous errors Then is that false which our Lord so ofteÌ„ repeating promised to wit Aske and it shal be giuen vnto you seeke and you shall find Matth 7. Luc. 11. knocke and it shal be opened vnto you For euery one that asketh receaueth and he that seeketh findeth and to him that knocketh it is opened For that S. Francis S. Dominick S. Bernard S. Benet and the like lightes and wonders of the world did all their life tyme aske seeke and knocke that they might obtaine of our Lord things necessary for their health to know and fullfill his will perfectâ—ly in all things and yet notwithstanding obtayned nothing heerin False also shall that be which our Sauiour saith If yow then being naught know how to giue good giâ—â—es to your children how much more will your Father from heauen giue a good spirit to them that aske for that these men did dayly and carnestly aske this spirit and yet obtayned it not For that a good spirit can neuer be without a good Religion I omit many other things which might be brought for confirmation heerof But if it be blasphemy to say that diuine promises be false then is it necessary to confesse that these men did receiue the true faith and Religion-Wherfore seing that they imbraced the Catholike Religion and were most addicted to the Roman Church detesting and hating all other faith and Religion that was contrary to this it cannot be doubted but that the Catholike and Roman is the only true and heauenly inspired Religion And all Religions besides are false and inuented by the Diuell Finally if their Religion were not the true but rather some of the Aduersaryes the true Religion then is it necessary to confesse all the forsaid men whome the whole world hath held for Saintes not to haue byn not only holy men and friends to God but to haue byn impious and enemyes to him and so damned and adiugded to euerlasting punishments For without true Religion it is impossible to please God Neyther can it be said that they were to be excused by ignorance for that ignorance doth not excuse except in certayne secondary cases which by reason of some positiue precept are necessary but in no case doth it excuse in any fundamentall and chiefehead For otherwise any man may obtayne saluation without any knowledg of God or Christ at al which is repugnant to al Scripture But if these men erred as some of our Aduersaryes do pretend that they did then erred they in the chiefe heads First because they acknowledged not a speciall faith wherby only we are iustified and made partaker of the redemption and iustice of Christ and sinne is not imputed vnto vs as the authors of other Religions do teach Therfore they remained in sinne being depriued of the participation of the Iustice of Christ consequently were childreÌ„ of Hell Secondly because according to their judgment they were out of the true Church of Christ out of which by consent of all there is no saluation did adhere to the whore of Babylon for so do they call the Roman Church and were the chiefe ministers instrumeÌ„ts of Antichrist Thirdly because they were Idolatours adoring a creature for their Creatour to wit bread and wyne insteed of Christin the Eucharist worshipping Saintes their Images c. These thinges may not be excused by any ignorance whatsoeuer And therfore all these were wicked men and adiudged to hell torments But how improbable and incredible are all these things and against the coÌ„mon consent of all Christian men that euer were And on the contrary side in other Religions there were neuer any of famous sanctity nor can they name so much as one For that their very first Authors were giuen to temporall commodities and were followers of pleasures hauing nothing singular in their liues aboue the common sort of people but rather giuen to greater vices and wickednes But of this point we shall speake more heereafter
and human traditions and so they appeale to the word of God expouÌ„ded by themselues in their owne sense But how improbable is it thinke yow that all these Ancients writing with so great consent of one the selfe same thing and in diuers places should erre And the consent of many about one thing especially when as there hath byn no consult or comunication had therof before is a very great signe of truth drawing vnto her and as it were binding togeather in one the myndes and iudgments of many enlightened from heauen For as it is the property of Verity because she is only one to gather togeather in one consent so is it the property of Falsity because she is manifold to dissipate and separate herselfe into diuers opinions and errors Wherby it cometh to passe that Hereticks writing of one matter in diuers places do neuer lightly agree but are deuided into very many opinions among themselues when as once they haue departed from the truth Moreouer there is not one opinion of Catholike Religion which can be shewed to haue byn brought in a new into the Church by any man which is a manifest signe that it alwayes remayned in the Church and came from the Apostles For if any new opinion should haue byn so brought in after the Apostles tyme against the Apostolicall doctrine it would easily be discouered in what tyme and age the same began In what place who was the Author and who they were that opposed thâ—mselues against such a nouelty seeing that no new opinion can be brought in without great stir and contradiction For if it be so that we can shew of euery least heresy in what time and place the same began who was the Author bringer in thereof who opposed themselues against it what tumults were raised therabout by what Pope and Councell the same was condemned If all this I say can be shewed of euery heresy how much more easy were it to shew the same of the principall and chiefe heads of our Religion if any innouation had beene made therein It is therefore manifest and cleere that this our Catholike Religion doth not only agree in succession of Ministers but is continued also conioyned in consanguinity as old Tertullian speaketh with the ancient and Apostolicke Tertul. l. de Praescript as now we haue sayd That the opinions of the new reformed Religions do not agree with the ancient our Aduersaryes themselues confesse when as concerning the former beads mentioned they reprehend taxe the Ancient Doctours of superstition affirming that thy cannot be excused from error as afterwards more largely we shall demonstrate Againe concerning the Controuersyes which now and then do rise vp in the Catholike Church the continual vse and practise of the same Church doth witnes that they are soone determined and ended Controuersies quickly decided in the Catholieke Church For that this Catholike Church hath an infallible Iudge of Controuersies to wit the Pope with a generall Councell by whome all controuersyes hitherto haue quickly beene decided all heresyes that haue risen in diuers ages beene condemned and put to flight by whom Catholike people haue byn preserued in one faith one Religion and doctrine throughout the world By this meanes was condemned the heresy of Arius by the Councell of Nice vnder Pope Siluester that of Macedonius by the first Councell of Constantinople vnder Pope Damasus of Nestorius by the Ephesine vnder Pope Celestine of Eutiches by Calcedon vnder Leo the first that of the Image-breakers by the second of Nice vnder Adrian the first and to omit others that of Berengarius concerning the Eucharist by the Synods of Rome and Versells in France vnder Leo the 9. by that of Towers vnder Victor the second and by two other againe of Rome vnder Pope Nicolas the 2. and Gregory the 7. And furthermore in all reason it is required that the cause weight of Religion being common to the whole Church should not be iudged of any priuate man with hath no eminency or dignity in the Church but of the vniuersall Pastour thereof togeather with other particuler assistants and Iudges to whome the gouernement of the Church is committed who do also represent the vniuersall Church it selfe as certaine heads vnited togeather And so likewise the controuersyes that arise in a Commonwealth about Lawes and priuiledges are to be decided of no other theÌ„ the King his Counsel and chiefe Nobility of the Kingdome who represent the whole Kingdome For looke to whome it belongeth to gouerne any Community or Common-wealth either in temporall or spirituall affaires to him it belongeth also to end contentions and determine all Controuersies concerning any Matter belonging to his gouernement taking away and putting to silence all contradiction arising therabout for the tyme to come And truly vnles the Church had such power and authority it would be a very imperfect and maimed Church and more miserable then any temporall Kingdome or politicke CoÌ„monwealth For that there should neuer be any end of contention concerning the principal heads of our fayth no decision of debates and contradictions whereby it would necessarily come to passe that the sayd Church should soone be turned and deuided into a thousand seuerall sects as we see it dayly fall out in the Heretikes conuenticles Herehence it followeth that all the chiefe heads and articles of our faith are certaine and determined â—either is there any iarring or variance therabout but rather aspeciall concord and vnion amongst all Nothing certaine out of Catholike Religion Wherby is deduced an another euident consequence that so soone as euer one falleth from Catholike Religion he hath no certainty wherevpon to rest or whither to turne himselfe or to whome he may safely commit the care of his saluation For let me aske this question In this so great variety of Religions which wouldest thou imbrace The Lutheran And why not the Caluinian or the Anabaptisticall why dost thou prefer the LutheraÌ„ before the rest do not the Caluinistes and Anabaptistes alleage Scripture for their part as fast as the Lutheran doth for his Againe if thou wilt needs be a Lutheran whether I pray thee wouldst thou be a soft or riged Lutheran to wit whether wouldest thou imbrace that pure religion which Luther the Dutch Prophet deliuered or rather that which Philip Melanchthon did polish and trim anew But this also is variable for that the Confession of Augusta hath oftentimes byn changed If thou wouldest be a Caluinist why not â—ather a Lutheran seing that Luther was the first Father that begat this light of the new Ghospell to the world Againe if thou wouldest needs be a Caluinist whether then Puritan or Protestant For so much as these two being the brood of Caluinisme do not a little differ among themselues as they that liue in England do well know I omit very many differences wherin to euery one of these sects are deuided and mangled as also the Anabaptistes No solide reason
neyther can the Lutherans or Caluinistes deny the same but only say that these things were moles or blemishes amoÌ„gst the aÌ„cient Fathers Goodly moles surely superstition Idolatry Impiety But if the doctors of former ages did not professe this religioÌ„ but for the most part reproue and disallow it then is it euident that the same is not ancient but new For no religion was euer accompted in the Church for true but that which the ancient Fathers doctors of the Church did hold and professe Wherof it euidently followeth that Lutheran religion is not Christs religion For that Christs religion is not new but ancient but Lutheran religion is new as we haue shewed and not ancient Christs religion hath alwayes florished in the world euer synce the Apostles tyme but Luthers religion hath not so done but began within these 100. yeares and before that tyme we haue shewed that it was not Againe if Luthers religion be truely Christs religion then is the visible company of men that imbrace the same the true Church of Christ Therfore Christs Church was not before Luther because the Lutheran Religion which doth make the true Church was not before Luther as we haue demonstrated For if yow say that Luthers religion was in the Apostles tymes and in some of the former ages then must yow proue that there were some men in those tymes who imbraced and professed his opinions Surely we easily proue the contrary for that it is euident that Masse for the quicke and dead Order of Ministers in the Church monasticall vowes and the like which are repugnant to the Lutheran religion were in vse in the Church in the Apostles tymes and the next succeeding Ages But let vs grant that Luthers religion was in the Apostles tymes and somwhat after yet at leastwise in the third and fourth age it began to fayle fall quite away Which thing the Lutheran Doctors themselues do also confesse as may be seene by that great Centurian worke setforth by them in the 2.3.4.5.6.7.8.9.10 Century or age and 4. Chapter of euery Century Therfore by this accompt the Church of Christ at least for 1300. years hath fallen away perished for that so long tyme at the least it is euident that Lutheran religion was not but the quite contrary to haue byn extant and florished As also by this accompt the true religion was extinguished for so many ages the Ghospell obscured Christes Church ouerthrowne vntil the Dutch Prophet Luther rose vp and dispersed that lamentable darknes through the light of the Ghospell to the world and reedified the ruines of the Church This do the Lutherans often insinuate in diuers townes of Germany when as they wryte vpon the forefronts of their houses in great Capitall letters these or the like words Such a yeare c. appeared the true light of Christs Ghospell to this Citty Superstition put downe c. But if the Church of Christ perished for so many ages how then is it true that she is built vpon a rocke and not rather vpon sand How then is it said that the (a) Math. 16. Gates of hell shall not preuaile againe her How is she the house of God the (b) 1. Tim. 3. Firmament and Pillar of truth How then is the (c) Daniel 2. Kingdome of Christ which is the Church stable firme euerlasting and neuer to be ruined Againe if yow say that Luthers Church religion was in all Ages from the Apostles tymes but yet in secret and hidden besides that such a fiction wanteth an Author to affirme it the same is voyd of all probability as we haue now shewed But be it so The Church of Christ caÌ„not be hidden let vs grant that it was hidden all that while but then was it not the Church of Christ for that she is a (d) Matth. 5. Citty placed vpon a mountayne which cannot be hidden She is the (e) Isa 2. mountayne of the house of God prepared in the top of mountaynes and placed aboue the hilles cleerly seene of all men to whome all Nations in the world haue recourse She is the Kingdome of Christ that reacheth from (f) Psal 71. sea to sea and from the riuer to the bounds of the earth She is that great (g) Dan. 2. mountayne that filleth the whole earth For that the Church of Christ must be conspicuous manifest to the world that by her excelleny and comlines by her manner and outward shew she as it were may intice Gentiles vnto her so as they that will become Christians may know whither to go to whome to haue recourse and from whome to receiue instruction Likewise her Doctrine and faith must needs be also manifest or els the same would be vnprofitable to the world nor could she conuert Gentiles So as in the greatest persecutions that euer were she neuer lay so hidden but that she might be knowne to all as out of the Ecclesiasticall historyes is euident wherby it came to passe that she had so many martyrs Againe if she had layn hidden for so many ages she had byn altogeather vnworthy of the Name of a Church For how may she be called the Church of Christ that dareth not publickely to professe the true Doctrine of Christ or that she should be so faint-harted fearfull of death as to hide herselfe in a darke cormer so many ages togeather and dare to come abroad into the light least she should be seene And last of all how can she be called the Church of Christ that for so many ages hath not only hidden herselfe and suppressed the true profession of faith but hath professed also a false faith to wit Papistry adored Idols and defiled herselfe with a thousand superstitions and sacriledges For that before Luther all Christians did carry themselues outwardly in all points as Catholikes or els straight would they haue byn apprehended and accused by the Inquisitors and Bishops and punished as heretâ—kes And therfore should the Church of Christ haue byn more miserable then the ruines of the Synagoge or the lewish Sect which alwayes in some place or other had their Synagoges and free profession of their Religion nor was euer constrayned at least generally to the worship of Idols She should I say haue byn more miserable then all hereticall sects and Conuenticles whatsoeuer For that there was neuer any Sect of any name which had not her temples her religious houses her Couuents her Bishops the forme and profession of her faith that so she might be knowne of all Wherby it is manifest that nothing can be more absurdly said then that the Church of Christ hath layen hid for so many ages and therfore I do conclude with this Dilemma That the Lutheran or Caluinian religion was eyther before their Authors to wit Luther and Caluin or it was not If it were not then is it altogeather new and therfore cannot be the religion of Christ which is ancieÌ„t If it were before the
6. of Isay where the Seraphim do cry in the same manner Holy Holy Holy Lord God of Sabaoth all the earth is full of thy Glory out of with place these verses were taken and put into the Hymne of Te Deum is designed the excecation of the Iewes as is gathered out of that which followeth in the same place For that God is there prouoked in such sore that he reuengeth with condigne punishment so great wickednes impiety shewing by the beauty of his sanctity how greatly all kind of synne doth displease him And in like manner shall the Seraphim thunder out reuenge towards the end of the world Apoc. 4. And last of all if we wryte these Names according to the Hebrew by M. and not by N to wit CherubIM SeraphIM as they are truly to be written then will there arise out of that verse Three thousaÌ„d fiue hundred and 17. yeares which being ended notwithstanding shall the Cherubims Seraphims cry Holy Holy Holy but yet this voyce shall not be a reioycing or exultation for the increase of Luthers Ghospel but rather an approuing or approbation of the iust punishment wherwith he and his followers shal be tormented for all eternity The IIII. Reason From the want of Miracles THESE new Religions togeather with their authors are to be suspected Miracles necessary because they were brought in without any miracles which miracles were very necessary and that for many reasons First that they might shew they were not falsifiers but true Pastours sent from God and therby conuince that the Church ought to receiue them For wheras it is manifest out of Scripture that many false prophets were to come into the world in these last dayes Matth. 24. Marc. 13 1. Tim. 4. who should bragge that they were sent from God of whoÌ„ our Sauiour did warne vs to beware 2. Tim. â— 2. Pet. 3. Matth. 7. 24. therfore no new teacher is to be admitted but rather to be suspected that caÌ„not giue a ful testimony of his doctrine which full testimony can not any way be giuen but by diuine heauenly signes as are for example Miracles fortelling of things to come reuealing of mysteries and the like which things for so much as they do exceed the force of humane power it is mnnifest that they are from God and are as it were Patents and witnesses signed and confirmed by God wherby this diuine mission is approued Heerhence it is that so many as euer haue byn sent of God immediately to teach or instruct the people haue come endued from him with miracles or other supernaturall signes wherby their Mission hath byn made manifest to the people For so did Moyses when he was to bring the children of Israel out of Egypt and to giue them a Law come with a mighty power of miracles and wrought very many either himselfe or God by him as often as he appeared vnto him in a visible shape So did all the Prophets confirme their mission eyther with miracles or with reuelation of mysteries The same also the Lord of Prophets himselfe who although he might haue cleerly conuinced out of Scripture that he was the true Messias and that by the testimony also of S. Iohn Baptist yet notwithstanding presently in the begining of his preaching he shewed by many miracles that he was sent from God the Father for the saluation of men in so much as he said vnto the Pharisies who for hate and malice belieued him not that if they would not belieue him for his owne sake yet at leastwise being conuinced which the greatnes of his miracles they should belieue him In like manner did all the Apostles confirme their mission with miracles amongst the Iewes and gentles as also did the first preachers and Apostles of diuers nations who brought them from Paganisme to our faith religion Wherfore let these new Prophets brag neuer so much that they be sent immediatly from God except they confirme the same with miracles and supernaturall signes as all those who were sent indeed inmediatly from God haue done they be not any way to be heard or regarded Nor doth that argument any thing auayle against vs that S. Iohn Baptist wrought no miracles because God did many supernaturall things about him which wel witnessed his mission Besides the austerity and sanctity of his life was no small miracle so as no man can doubt but that he was sent of God Secondly Miracles were very necessary to haue proued that they were not only sent as correctors of manners but also as reformers and correctors of the whole religion to build vp a new the Church that was fallen to raise to life the kingdoÌ„e of Christ that was dead to make all things new againe What great miracles had there needed to haue byn to haue conuinced the world to beleeue these meruailous and wonderfull things and to haue receiued the workers therof for such For although they had raised a thousand dead men and had cuÌ„red an hundred thousand lame blind and diseased yet had it scarse byn inough to haue giuen credit to so great an innouation First because the Apostle saith Gal. 1. Although we or an Angell from heauen do euangelize vnto yow any other doctrine then that which we haue euangelized vnto yow let him he accursed And repeating the same againe for greater confirmation he addeth As we haue said before so now I say againe If any do euangelize vnto yow besides that which you haue receiued let him be accursed And if we should not belieue an Angell that should preach any least thing against the receaued saith doctrine of the Church what great need of miracles should there be to giue credit to any man that should preach so great matters as these to wit that the Church of Christ is 〈◊〉 ruinated full of Idolatry her saith extinct al her children in the state of domination that the principall heads of religion are to be reformed that â—â—ut her or Caluin were sent froth God to make this reformation Should it not be 〈◊〉 thinke yow that all the miracles of the Apostles yea of Christ himselfe should be renewed againe in such a reformer Secondly for so much as the Catholike religion which now florisheth hath byn in possession for more then a thousand yeares which our aduersaries do also confesse in such sort that the same is accompted throughout the whole world for the true religion and those that depart from her are held for heretickes therfore without very great and most euident signes it be manifest that this possession was wicked and vniust it cannot now be thrust out and owerthrowne Againe these signes must be so perspicuous for the conuincement of mans vnderstanding that there be left no place of doubt or tergiuersation for els their be not bouÌ„d to belieue but rather still to adhere to this so long possession and no wayes to forsake their religion Moreouer seing that the Catholike
religion hath shined with the greatest glory of miracles of wisdome and of sanctity of her followers throughout all former ages and doth at this day also shine it is needfull therfore of greater and more euident miracles now wherby lawfully put her out of possession and reiect her as also there is more need of greater knowledg sanctity and publike fame in the followers of these new religions now then euer was in the old And lastly if the religion of the old Testament amongst the Iewes was to be changed and that they were to passe from a shaddow to the truth or from a type or patterne to the true sampler it selfe although our Lord might most clerly haue conuinced and shewed out of the Scriptures that this mutation and change was to be made and that himselfe was sent of God for the same purpose he thought good notwithstanding to cōfirme the same with very māy most wonderfull miracles that there might be left vnto them no occasion of doubt or turning backe how greatmiracles then shall we thinke to be needfull now for the changing of religion in the new Testament when as the Scriptures do cleerly denounce that there thalbe no more changes made but that God wil be present with her for her assistance to the worlds end and that the gates of hell shall not preuaile against her For what wisdome were it for any man to belieue so great a thing so new and paradoxicall so much against Scripture and iudgment of all the ancientt Fathers without extraordinary great miracles Nay what miracles can there be great inough to make a man at least probably to belieue so strang a thing Heerhence it is manifest that we haue great cause to require of them such miracles and that they deale perfidiously with vs when as they would haue vs to giue them credit in matters of so great importance without miracles and vnlesse we do belieue all vpon their bare word they presently raise vp grieuous presecutions against vs. But they will say Whether do they proue ther doctrine out of the Scriptures We proue our opinions and doctrine out of the Scripture Be it so but yet according to your owne sense and iudgment and not according to the consent of the Ancient Holy Fathers and the receaued Doctors of the Church who liued before these our controuersies so could not be any way partial therin Againe their arguments like vnto spiders webbs are very easily dissolued by Catholike Doctors besides that there are so many new Reformers sprong vp within these 80. or 90. yeares so many repayrers of the decayed Church so māy reniuers of the extinct Religion who also be most contrary one to anothers and what one buildeth vp another pulleth downe yet notwithstanding do they all confirme their opinions out of the Scriptures all do rest vpon her testimony alone all do make Scripture the only foundation of their building and therfore the proofe of all is to be admitted or of none And lastly seing that nothing is to be belieued vnlesse Scripture say it Where I pray yow doth it say that you or he or such a one was sent of God for the reforming and restoring of the decayed Church and Religion They will say Whether it be a miracle to haue many followers perhaps that they want not miracles for that it is a very great miracle that in so short tyme so many haue imbraced this new Ghospell And this perhaps might haue some colour if their religion were more austere and strict vnto the flesh then is the Catholike But seing that this their new Doctrine doth banish all austerity and sharpnes of the Catholike Religion and giue all liberty to the flesh what miracle is it if many follow and imbrace the same what meruayle is it if weighty things fal to the ground when as their props be takē away or that riuers run into the sea their dāmes stops remoued our corrupt nature doth most of all incline to liberty which it findeth in these new religions and therfore we do the soner imbrace and follow them not because we being persuaded by the force of reason do belieue that they are more holy but because we find in them that which we sought for and that which without feare we might enioy vnder the colour of religion and piety Moreouer this miracle may aswel be brought on the behalfe of all the Sectes of all these new Reformers as of one for that many haue ioyned themselues not only to the Caluinists but also to the Lutherans and Anabaptistes and therfore they must be all holy and come from God as their Author But God cannot deny himselfe nor destroy that which he hath established and therfore cannot be Author of so contrary religions the one damning the other to the pit of hell The V. Reason From the Conditions of their Liues and Manners THE fifth reason is because that these Religions were brought in by men of bad life and such as were noted of infamy pride enuy and notorious detraction giuing shew of nothing lesse then an Apostolicall Spirit For as for Luther we know that he was somtymes a professed Monke and Priest thet by bound with a double vow of continency We know also that leauing his Monastery and casting of his habit and profession be returned to a secular life againe where ioyning himselfe to a professed Nunne whome he enticed out of her Cloister he liued dayly in her company by which fact in the iudgment of all the world he committed a twofold synne of Sacriledge and did alway reiterate the same as often as he abused her body What manner of life can be more scandalous then this Moreouer we know that he was so exceedingly giuen to good cheere and lust that he was dayly occupied in banquetting and drunkennesse (a) lib de vita coniugali affirming that a woman was more necessary then to eat drinke or sleep that it was (b) Serm. de matrimonio lawfull to vse the maid if the wife refused to do her duty The life of Caluin is written by Hieronymus Bolsecus Iulius Brigerus and others being full of most notorious wickednes to wit false accusations of others murthers robberyes filthy and lewd behauiour all which things haue byn obiected against him by diuers wryters wherunto I could yet neuer see any answere Of Luthers infamy it is manifest to all the whole world that wheras he being a professed Monke and a Priest he ioyned himselfe to a professed Nunne which fact by the iudgment of all learned Doctors purchaseth infamy For if by the Emperours lawes that man be infamous who is taken in adultery L. Palam S. Quiin adulterio ff de ritu nuptiarum how much more is he infamous that hath twice contracted sacrilegious mariage and dayly vseth sacrilegious copulation For that it is a far more filthy thing to be an Adulterer of Christ then an Adulterer of the wife or husband The infamy of
IF any of these new Religions for example that of Caluin were Christâ—true Religion besides other absurdities insinuated before this would further follow that all Catholikes which haue byn from the Apostles tymes vntill this present be damned and adiudged to paines cuerlasting for as much as according to a principall doctrine of the Caluinists they wanted iustifying faith and therefore iustice also before God whence it is that they continued in their syns and died in them For faith necessary to iustification as this religion holdeth is that whereby a man stedfastly beleeueth that himselfe is iust before God for Christs satisfaction which is to him by this faith applyed and imputed And certaine it is that this faith was vnknown to the world vntill Luthers tyme neyther doth he deny it but gloryeth rather that he notified and reuealed to the world the true manner of iustification obscured by antiquity The same is manifest by the writings of all the ancient Fathers both for that besids faith they require an inward chaung of the will and purpose of keeping the whole law and also for that they condemne that security of saluation and will haue a man to worke his saluation with feare and trembling and to be alwayes sollicitous and carefull and therefore they do all with one consent reiect that speciall Fayth by which a man certainly beleeueth himselfe to be iust as meere presumption For though we are to belâ—eue that Christ hath on his part most fully satisfied for vs yet it is not manifest vnto vs whether we haue done all that which is on our part necessary for the making of ourselues partakers of this satifaction and whether we haue not at one tyme or other lost our part in it Manifest therefore it is that all those of former tymes wanted this fayth and consequently they are all damâ—ed so many holy Fathers so many 〈◊〉 so many Virgins and Saints Irenaeus Iustine Gregory Thaumaturgus Nazianzen Basill Chrysostome Damascene Hilary Ambrose Hierome Augustine Martin Nicolas Antony Benedict Bernard Dominicke Francis Laurence Vincent Sebastian Catharine Cecily Agnes and infinite others who were admirable to the world eyther for their sanctity and miracles or for the glory of martyrdone Finally all that haue been before vs euen from the Apostles tyme till now be damned And to vse Tertullians words l. de praescript adueâ—sus haereticos In vaine hath the Gospell byn so many ages preached in vaine haue so many thousands been baptized in vaine haue so many works of saith been exercised so many vertues and so many gifts of grace to no purpose wrought so many priesthoods and so many offices admitted in vaine and to be short in vaine haue so many martyrdomes been crowned But how past beliefe absurd and blasphemous a matter is this How contrary and repugnant to the iudgement of the whole world and of all ages past Neither can it be sayd that their ignorance excused them because none can be saued without faith without the iustice of Christ without the participation of Christs satisfaction without the remission of sins as the Scripture especially of the new Testament euery where teacheth no ignorance can make or cause that any may be saued without them Wherefore there is no ouasion heere for they eyther be all damned or els Luthers and Caluins Religions be false and impious in their principall doctrine touching Iustification Loe heere 12. Reasons by which it is made plaine that these new Religions be to be shunned as false pernicious and now we come to our last Consideration X. CONSIDERATION and conclusion of this whole ConsultatioÌ„ LASTLY that Religion is to be imbraced during life that we would wish we had followed and held at the houre of our death and whereof we may be able to giue a iust accompt when we shall stand before the tribunall seat of Christ For touching what is to be done there cannot a better CoÌ„sultation be had then by the consideration of death and of the latter Iudgment namely that we make an election of that here which in the article of our death may make most to our profit and shunne that which may at that tyme procure or cause our certaine ruine perdition or at least hazard the same And such is the Catholike religion that we shal haue a will to preferre it when we come to dye is euident First by the example of very many who though they haue lyued as heretiks yet when they come to dye do desire to dy Catholikes for so to do they deeme it most for their security Secondly for that euery one then wisheth he had done many good works and that he had carefully taken heed of all sins to both whereof the Catholike Church hath effectuall iuducements and Lutheranisme and Caluinisme haue neither the one nor the other but rather bringeth in a contempt of good works and liberty of life Thirdly for that the Catholike Religion hath many remedies and preseruatiâ—es which are not in that dreadful passage to be coÌ„temned as repentance for heir sinns the absolution of Priests the Sacraments oâ— Extreme Vnction holy Eucharist which cause great comfort and confidence to the faithfull for by them Christs satisfaction is communicated vnto vs. But a naked faith is a very cold and weake help in that article For how may you in earnest perswade your selfe that Christ is propitious and mercifull vnto you that you are iust and to be by Christ saued who contemne the â—emedyes by him appointed and determine to dye out of the communion of the Catholike Church All lects of this tyme do brag of this fayth but all of them shall not be saued for as much as there is but one true religion of Christ out of which none can be saued as not only all Catholiks but Lutherans also Caluinists and Anabaptists do also teach And therfore your speciall fayth will not profit you any thing vnles you professe Christs true religion That also such as haue imbraced the Catholike fayth and perseuered in it shall easily be able to giue an accompt of that they haue done vnto the supreme Iudge and that not any daunger at all iâ— on that part to wards them is cleare For suppose that I stand before that dreadfull Tribunall and am asked wherfore I imbraced the Catholike or Papistical religion as they now tearme it and that I did not rather leauing it passe to that new religion created and reformed â—y Caluin I will with great security answere That I therfore held the Catholike sayth What a Catho like will answere at the day of â—udgment because it teacheth me to abstract my mind from â—errene things and to transferre it to the loue of câ—â—estiall It further â—eacheth me to maister and mortify my flesh and to crucify it with the nayles of the fâ—are of God to insist in good works to obay Superiors to attend to prayer and to cut off all liberty of synning Therefore I held the Catholike Religion
because in it I see very many admirable to the whole world for wisdome sanctimony miracles and the spirit of prophesy whome it is impossible to haue byn in a matter so important deceyued for that I see that God himselfe hath and doth in euery age giue testimony of it by many miâ—acles because I see Gods promises fulfilled in it as being dispersed and spread all the world ouer Vnto it haue the Gentils byn hitherto conuerted and still continually are In it there hath been in all ages exceâ—â—â—ing concord and consent of Doctors in the grounds of fayth In it hath byn and still is a perpetuall succession of the Chaire and a continuance in the ministers therof from the Aposties In it is a speedy decision of all conâ—rouersyes It hath for so many ages stood immoueable against all heresyes and persecutions of Tyrants neyther could the gates of hell any thing preuayle against it whiles all the contraryes be found in the new Religions And therefore I had no reason at all to reuolt from this religion or to make any doubt of it at all But to omit further to prosecute other things of this kind is it not inough for my security that I am sure that I haue followed that religion in which I see men of most holy life and most celebrated for miracles S. Malachy S. Bernard S. Dominicke S. Francis and alothers who were fyue hundred yeares synce by their heauenly conuersation wonderfull works an admiration to the world to haue lyued and died For most cleare it is that those celestiall soules so addicted and deuoted to God so deare and familyar to him could not possibly be deceyued in a matter of so great consequence And therefore in this cause of religion and fayth I securely follow such captaynes guides that haue gone before me But now tell me you who haue imbraced another religion what reckoning can you giue of that your deed when you shall in that dreadfull examen be asked about it You will perhaps answeâ—e the iudge What wil an Heretike answere I did therefore forsake the Catholike fayth because I thought it full of Idolatry superstitions and humane traditions because I thought that Antichrist did command and beare sway in it because I thought the Catholikes did rely vpon their owne meritts and not vpon the price of thy bloud But what if the Diuells bewitching you which now hath a possession of your mind should then be taken away you should plainely see your selfe deceyued what counsaile would you take for then there will not be any more tyme for pennance and repentance Will you peraduenture alleadge ignorance But that wil not excuse you because you might easily haue knowne the truth if you had vsed the diligence that you were bound to do in so important a matter Neyther euer wanted you iust reason of doubting which should haue moued you to seeke for resolution Wherefore as it shall not excuse the Iewes that they erred of ignorance because they might haue knowne the truth so shall it not excuse you For that you might without syn depart from the Catholike Church it was your part not only to thinke and vpon certaine light suspitions to conceyue but also most certainely to know and setting aside all affection to be most assured that there were those euills in the Catholike religion so as there might be left no further scruple in your mind nor any iust cause of doubting in the matter But you were so far from hauing such a certitude touching the Churches errors as you had not any probable reason to perswade you to the contrary For by what probability or pretence of truth could you be persuaded to thinke that that religion was obnoxious to Idolatry and to so great errors which you saw imbraced for so many ages of so many men renowned for their wisdome holynes of life Which you saw honoured with such so great and many miracles martyrdomes Which you saw spread all the world ouer In which there was an exceeding conspiration and concord of the Doctors a perpetuall succession and a most manifest and knowne continuance from the Apostles How can it possibly be that none of the Doctors nor no holy man did for so many ages togeather note and obserue this Idolatry these superstitions and errors Againe how could you perswade your selfe that that is Christs true religion that maketh God the author and mouer yea compeller to all wickednes that spoyleth men of the liberty of free will that taketh away the care of exercising of good works that openeth a most wide gate to al manner of wickednes as doth Atheisme that vnder shew of Christian liberty exempteth and freeth the subiects from the lawes and obedience to their Princes that reuiueth and bringeth many ancient and condemned heresyes to light againe the authors whereof be not recommended for any austerity conuersation or sanctimony of life nor celebrated for any miracles but meÌ„ giuen to the pleasures of the flesh couetous of things of the world ambitious foule spoken seditious infamous for Apostasy and sacrilegious Mariages giuen ouer to lust and withall wonderfully inconstant in doctrine Finally if any of these new vpstart Religions be true then there was not any religion of Christ for so many ages past Christs Kingdome was ruyned and ouerthrowne Gods promises touching the stability and continuance of his Church were made voide the gates of hell preuayled against it The Gospell was then for so many hundreds of yeares preached in vaine in vaine was it beleeued in vaine were so many conuerted from paganisme in vaine were Baptisme other Sacraments administred in vaine were fasts kept and mortifications of the flesh practised in vaine were martyrdomes endured and the bloud of so many thousands shed for the confession of Christs name Therefore all those of our religion who are gone before vs are perished so many thousands of martyrs Confessors so many soules consecrated to God celebrated for holynes miracles and the spirit of prophesy For all of them had not any part of true religion in them nor true iustice and all were giuen to Idolatry But if all this be false blasphemous and euen horrible to thinke how could it be that you could not think that those religions out of which so horrible things are manifestly deduced might be false or at least that you doubted not of theÌ„ And if you doubted wherefore laboured you not to vnderstaÌ„d the truth on which your whole soules good dependeth Our Lord admonished that we should carefully take heed of false Prophets who come vnto vs in sheepes cloathing and inwardly be rauening wolues Matth. 7. How did it not come at one tyme or other into your mind to thinke and to feare least Luther Caluin Menno and the like were of the number of them of whome our Lord premonished vs to beware For these men vnder a glorious shew of Gods word and of the pure Gospell presented themselues vnto the world
as sent of God for the sauing of the sheep and in the meane tyme they destroyed the sheep with the poysoned foode of their doctrine By their fruits sayth our Lord you â—hall know them And what fruite is this Seditions warres the spoyling and ouerthrowing of Churches and Monasteryes the ruining of Cittyes the abolishing of ancient piety and deuotion the giuing scope to all enormityes and wickednes We know by testimony of the Apostle that many heresyes shall rise in the latter tymes and that many false Prophets and seducers shall by the instigation of Sathan shew themselues Wherefore as often as any new doctrine that opposeth it self against the Church putteth the head forth we must at least suspect it together with the Author therof Wherefore I desire beseech all The conclusion of the whole worke that be out of the Catholike Church by the goodnes of God whereby we be created and by Christs bloud wherwith we are redeemed by the euerlasting inheritance which we expect in heauen and by that torrent and full measure of Diuine pleasure wherwith they shall be there made druÌ„ke who shall perseuere in truth and iustice to the end that they would apprehend and conceyue of this busynes throughly and attentiuely consider whether they stand vpon a solid and sound foundation whether they are likely to be secure touching their religion at their houre of death and when they shall stand before the Tribunall of Christ in that instant of tyme when an eternall and immutable sentence is to be receyued Let them examine this our Consultation which we haue written to that end Let them not rest vntill they shall haue duly discussed all and gotten the plaine euidency in a busynes so greatly importing them Let then thinke how great a punishment attendeth on them if the religion that they hold be heresy themselues be heretiks And that it is heresy and a most pestilent one indeed all Catholike Doctors all Vniuersityes and all the Christian world excepting those who follow it the number of whome compared with others is very little their learning very meane do hold for vndoubted and most certaine in so much as an infinite number there be who be ready to dye and to expose the euerlasting saluation of their soules for confession therof And in very deed Heresy is a most grieuous syn First How great a syn Heresy is because it is the cause that a man preferreth his owne iudgment before that of all the Fathers of all the Doctors of the Church of all Councells and of all the Bishops of the whole world For he contemneth them all as men destitute and deuoid of Gods spirit which he arrogateth to himselfe alone and to others his like and therein a wonder it is how great pride there is Secondly he censureth Christs Spouse which is the Church to haue coÌ„mitted adultery with Sathan to be the child of perdition Thirdly he chargeth it with the cryme of Idolatry and with diuers superstitions Fourthly he casteth forth many blasphemies against the holy Eucharist and Gods Saints Fiftly he handleth al holy sacred things after a most vnworthy manner Sixthly he calleth Christs Vicar on earth Antichrist calumniateth and reproacheth him a thousand wayes without any colour of truth at all The same doth he with al degrees orders of the Church To be short euery Heretike hath a good will to ouerthrow the whole Church and to extinguish al Catholike religion Thus you see that the heresy of our age contayneth extreme pride many foule blasphemyes How grieuous punishment heresie deserueth many calumnies slaunders and most iniurious proceedings many sacriledges and an extreme deadly hatred against Christs Church For all these euills and many more be intrinsecally in heresy and it habitually inclineth vnto them dayly doth euen actually moue and dryue vnto them So do all Doctors of the Catholike Church hold of Heresy and the thing is more then plaine of it selfe as experience teacheth And therefore Heresy consorted with these her Impes and ofspring is a greater syn then be an infinite number of sinnes of Catholikes And now according to what we haue said let them I beseech you dayly weigh and consider how great will be the punishment of this sinne ad Gal. 5. Col. â— 1. Cor. 6. 1. Tim. 1. c. For if but for one sinne of theft or of fornication vnles a man here help himselfe by the antidote of pennance he is to endure fire euerlasting as the Scripture teacheth what and how great paine and punishment is he to expect for the sinne of heresy which exceedeth a thousand thefts and a thousand fornications If the paine that our fire naturally inflicteth should be a thousand tymes more hoate and schorching then now it is and one were cast into it how sore incomprehensible and insufferable a paine would it be Let none flatter himselfe that there shall not be in that placee the paine of fire but onely I know not what terrors of God incensed with anger as Caluin feigneth But this assertion of his is ouer plainely repugnant to Scripture Math. 25. Marc. 9. Psal 10. Psal 20. A pocal 20. for as much as it sayth Goe yee into fire euerlasting Againe Their worme dyeth not and the fire is not quenched Againe He shall vpon sinners raine snares fire and brimstome and the spirit of tempests shall be the part of their cup. Thou shall put them as a fornace of fire in the time of thine anger Our Lord in his anger shall trouble them and fire shall deuour them The false Prophet was throwne into a poole of fire and of brimstone The same is the opinion of all the ancient doctors besides wherefore we must hold for certaine that there shal be a true fire there more intensiue and more scorching then our fire here wherein all heretiks shall burne and shall be tormented both day and night for all eternity as long as there shall be an hell as long as heauen shall stand and as long as God shall liue who dyeth not And the smoke of their torments shall ascend in the sight of our Lord for euer and euer These words be most faythfull and true Then shall they accurse them who deceiued them and their maisters by whome they were drawn and brought into that misery They shall accurse the deuill who blinded their eyes that they saw not the truth and vnder a pretence of piety diuersely bewitched them They shall also accurse themselues for giuing eare vnto them for so foolishly imbracing a new doctrine without diligently examining it before and for hauing been so blind negligent and slouthfull in discussion of a matter that so neerely concerned them Wherefore to the end they may not cast themselues headlong into this gulfe and sea of miseries let them with all care study and diligence examine this whole busines of religion and there about vse the counsaile and aduise of men of greatest wisdom learning
but in some few indifferent matters and nothing necessary vnto saluation in so much that it is all one in what religion thou liuest seing that thou maist indifferently in all of them obtayne thy saluation the which is nothingels but to open the way to Alcoran and to make Mahomet equall with Christ or rather manifestly to bring in Atheisme For to approue euery Religion is to take away all Religion and to thinke none necessary seing that the true Religion can be but one The fundamentall reason wherupon this opinion especially relieth is of no moment For first if it be not incredable that God for the space of some thousands of yeares hath left the whole word in Idolatry excepting only the Iewish nation being but a little portion or corner of the whole world and to haue permitted it to be vtterly ouerthrowne albeit there were so many rare wits among them so many diligent worshippers of God and all humane iustice and honesty it should not also seeme incredible if we say that now also he suffereth the Turkes and Iewes to perish Secondly the Turkes and Iewes are lesse to be excused now in that they do not belieue in Christ then the Heathens were in times past in not acknowledging one God to be the Creator of heauen and earth The reason is because when almost the whole world was in Idolatry the feruent heat of the common custome carried all by force away with it neyther was there any reason offered vnto priuate meÌ„ why they should greatly doubt of their religion neyther if there had byn doubt obiected vnto them could they find out any easy way to know the truth But now after that the fayth and Religion of Christ is diuâ—lged throughout the whole world and that Christians are euery where extant it cannot be but that many occasions are offered vnto the Turkes and Iewes of doubting of their Religion They are bound therfore to discusse and conferre the matter with the ChristiaÌ„s dwelling night vnto them the which if they do not but auert their minds froÌ„ these kind of thoughts by reason of the hatred they beare vnto Christian Religion or vpon some other cause they make themselues vnexcusable before God for the busines of our Religion saluatioÌ„ is of so great weyght and importance that it ought to be preferred before all other things when there is any iust reason of doubting offered it must with all diligence be examined albeit we should for that purpose be forced to go into farre countries for our resolution Lastly if there be any who haue hard nothing of Christian Religion or which do thinke that there is nothing wherby they may be iustly moued to any further inquisition those men shall not be damned for the sin of Infidelity that is to say because they haue not belieued in Christ but for some other things which they haue done agaynst the law of nature the which by help of God they might haue eschewed for God hath not left them so destitute of his prouidence and help but that they may auoid those synnes which they do commit if they would as they may ought to cooperate with Gods holy inspirations and take comfort and pleasure therin None therfore can impute his damnation vnto God albeit the way be straite to saluation but vnto himselfe to his owne negligence I say and wickednesse wherby he hath neglected Gods holy inspirations and coÌ„temned his profitable admonitions and willingly and wittingly against his owne conscience hath throwne himselfe headlong into sinne it being his vtter ouerthrow THE II. QVESTION THE other Question is whether it be sufficient to saluation to belieue in Christ and that he dyed for our sinnes albeit we will not belieue many other things Many especially of the coÌ„mon sort of people The opinion of the vulgar people do esteeme it sufficient so that those thinges be belieued which are set downe in the Apostles Creed of God and Christ other things they account indifferent and euery one may belieue what with a good faith he pleaseth but they will haue the Apostles Creed belieued of euery one in that sense which seemeth best vnto any of them They conclude therfore that any which confesseth Christ may be saued in his owne faith whether he be a Papist or a Lutheran or a Caluinist or an Anabaptist or of any other sect for all these haue the same head which is Christ Coloss 2. 1. Cor. 3. all do rely vpon the same Foundation which is Christ Iesus they cannot therfore be deceyued of their saluation albeit they disagree in all other thinges Herupon some noble men who do vse these new religions to the establishment and increase of their power and dominions doe labour very much to make one Church of the Lutherans and Caluinists and they goe about to perswade vs that there is no difference amongst them but in some small points indifferent matters But this opinion doth include in it many inconueniences The 1. Reason First because it saueth almost all the auncient Heretikes The same refuted by ten Reasons for most of them do confesse Christ and belieue the Creed in their ownesense The Arians therfore might be saued in their herefy who denyed God the Sonne to be consubstantiall with his Father The Macedonians who made the holy Ghost lesser then God the Sonne The Nestorians who affirmed there were two persons in Christ The Eutichians who held that the flesh of Christ was conuerted into his diuinity The Apollinaristes who said that the diuine Word was vnited in Christ as a reasonable soule vnited to the body The Monothelites who affirmed that there was one only will and operation in Christ The Pelagians who denied originall sinne and taught that a man by his naturall forces might deserue the grace of God and his saluation The Donatists who affirmed that the Church of God was euery where perished but only in Donatus his company The Nouatians who denyed pennance to those that had denyed their fayth The Montanists who thought Montanus to be the holy Ghost All these according to this opinion euery one in his owne fayth and heresy may be saued because they haue belieued in Christ did hold the Apostles Creed no lesse to be belieued then now adayes the Lutherans and Caluinists do But what can be sayd more absurd or more like a paradox in the Church of God For if eternall saluation may be obtayned by this kind of fayth why haue there byn holden sâ—â—any Councells against those heresies the Bishops throughout the whole world being assembled togeather with so great labour and charges why haue those heresies byn so often condemned by excommunication why haue the holy Fathers so much laboured in the extirpation threof why haue Catholikes so much detested the conuersation and company of those heretikes why would some of them rather chose to suffer banishment death and all kind of tormâ—â—ts then to subscribe vnto any of these heresies All these
law but offendeth in one he is made guilty of all for he who said thou shall not commit adultery said also thou shall not kill as if he should say he is made guilty of all and shal be punished as a breaker of the whole law because he hath despised the law maker who is the author of the whole law In like manner therfore he which shall deny one article although he belieue all the rest is made guilty of violating his whole faith and Religion because he contemneth God who is the first Truth who no lesse reuealed this then the other he conteÌ„neth the Catholike Church the spouse of Christ who is the pillar strength of Truth wherby he hath no lesse determined we should belieue this then the other And this is the reason why he is no lesse an heretike who with pertinacy denieth one point of faith theÌ„ he which denieth a hundred because in that he denieth one he contemneth God who is the first truth and did reueale it he contemneth the authority of the Church the which did propose it vnto vs he maketh the Church subiect to error and a liar wherby he is made also vncertaine of all the rest and looseth all his diuine faith for the ground of his diuine faith being takeÌ„ away his whole faith must needs perish and consequently there remaineth only an opinion or humane fayth subiect to error wherby he belieueth all the rest The 10. Reason Tenthly and lastly this opinion is very dangerous in the practise therof for it maketh a man that he careth not what religion he hold what he belieueth or not belieueth he doth not therfore seeke after the truth and he doth as easily and with as great security lay hold on false as true things yet all men not only Catholike but euen the more principal sects those which are learned wise men do absolut'y affirme that none can be saued without the true faith and religion and whosoeuer are depriued therof shall perish for euer The followers therfore of this opinion are condemned of all and they only promise vnto themselues saluation without any author testimony or reason for it relying and trusting only in their owne vain imagination of their foolish braine let then therefore heare out of S. Fulgentius what antiquity hath alwaies holden and what the Catholike Church hath taught in all ages Thus therfore he writeth setting downe the rules of our common saith in his booke de fide ad Petruin Diaconum Cap. 38. Belieue assuredly saith he and doubt nothing at all that not only all Pagans but also all Iewes Heretikes and Schismatikes who shall dy out of the Catholike Church shall go into euerlasting fire which is prepared for the diuell and his Angells And in the 39. Cap. Belieue assuredly and doubt nothing that euery heretik or Schismatik christned in the name of the Father of the Son and of the holy Ghost if he be not within the number of those which are of the Catholik Church what almes soeuer he hath made albeit he shall shed his bloud for the name of Christ can by no meanes be saued for neither baptisme nor large and charitable almes nor death it selfe suffered for Christes sake will auaile that maÌ„ who 〈…〉 vnity of the Catholik Church as long as this hereticall or schismaticall wickednes whâ—th leadeth to perdition shall continue in him This hath always byn the faith of the Catholike Church and the most certayne and vndoubted doctrine of the holy Fathers the which I would to God al those who remaine out of the Church of God would attentiuely and diligently consider they would truly and easily preceiue in how dangerous a state they continue Thou O Christ the light of the world shyne vnto their mindes and lighten their hartes Amen FINIS