off all Religion He that unworthily useth or performs any part of Religion is in an evil and dangerous condition but he that casts off all Religion plungeth himself into a most desperate state and does certainly damn himself to avoid the danger of damnation Because he that casts off all Religion throws off all the means whereby he should be reclaimed and brought into a better state I cannot more fitly illustrate this matter than by this plain Similitude He that eats and drinks intemperately endangers his health and his life but he that to avoid this danger will not eat at all I need not tell you what will certainly become of him in a very short space There are some conscientious persons who abstain from the Sacrament upon an apprehension that the sins which they shall commit afterwards are unpardonable But this is a great mistake our Saviour having so plainly declared that all manner of sin mall be forgiven men except the blasphemy against the Holy Ghost such as was that of the Pharisees who as our Saviour tells us blasphemed the Holy Ghost in ascribing those great miracles which they saw him work and which he really wrought by the Spirit of God to the power of the Devil Indeed to sin deliberately after so solemn an engagement to the contrary is a great aggravation of sin but not such as to make it unpardonable But the neglect of the Sacrament is not the way to prevent these sins but on the contrary the constant receiving of it with the best preparation we can is one of the most effectual means to prevent sin for the future and to obtain the assistence of God's grace to that end And if we fall into sin afterwards we may be renewed by repentance for we have an advocate with the Father Jesus Christ the righteous who is the propitiation for our sins and as such is in a very lively and affecting manner exhibited to us in this blessed Sacrament of his body broken and his bloud shed for the remission of our sins Can we think that the primitive Christians who so frequently received this holy Sacrament did never after the receiving of it fall into any deliberate sin undoubtedly many of them did but far be it from us to think that such sins were unpardonable and that so many good men should because of their carefull and conscientious observance of our Lord's Institution unavoidably fall into condemnation To draw to a conclusion of this matter such groundless fears and jealousies as these may be a sign of a good meaning but they are certainly a sign of an injudicious mind For if we stand upon these Scruples no man perhaps was ever so worthily prepared to draw near to God in any duty of Religion but there was still some defect or other in the disposition of his mind and the degree of his preparation But if we prepare our selves as well as we can this is all God expects And for our fears of falling into sin afterwards there is this plain answer to be given to it that the danger of falling into sin is not prevented by neglecting the Sacrament but encrcased because a powerfull and probable means of preserving men from sin is neglected And why should not every sincere Christian by the receiving of this Sacrament and renewing his Covenant with God rather hope to be confirmed in goodness and to receive farther assistences of God's grace and holy Spirit to strengthen him against sin and to enable him to subdue it than trouble himself with fears which are either without ground or if they are not are no sufficient reason to keep any man from the Sacrament We cannot surely entertain so unworthy a thought of God and our blessed Saviour as to imagine that he did institute the Sacrament not for the furtherance of our Salvation but as a snare and an occasion of our ruine and damnation This were to pervert the gracious design of God and to turn the cup of Salvation into a cup of deadly poison to the souls of men All then that can reasonably be inferred from the danger of unworthy receiving is that upon this consideration men should be quickned to come to the Sacrament with a due preparation of mind and so much the more to fortifie their resolutions of living sutably to that holy Covenant which they solemnly renew every time they receive this holy Sacrament This consideration ought to convince us of the absolute necessity of a good life but not to deter us from the use of any means which may contribute to make us good Therefore as a learned Divine says very well this Sacrament can be neglected by none but those that do not understand it but those who are unwilling to be tyed to their duty and are afraid of being engaged to use their best diligence to keep the commandments of Christ And such persons have no reason to fear being in a worse condition since they are already in so bad a state And thus much may suffice for answer to the first Objection concerning the great danger of unworthy receiving this holy Sacrament I proceed to the 2. Second Objection Obj. 2. which was this That so much preparation and worthiness being required to our worthy receiving the more timorus sort of Christians can never think themselves duly enough qualified for so sacred an Action For a full Answer to this Objection I shall endeavour briefly to clear these three things First That every degree of Imperfection in our preparation for this Sacrament is not a sufficient reason for men to refrain from it Secondly That a total want of a due preparation not only in the degree but in the main and substance of it though it render us unfit at present to receive this Sacrament yet it does by no means excuse our neglect of it Thirdly That the proper Inference and conclusion from the total want of a due preparation is not to cast off all thoughts of receiving the Sacrament but immediately to set upon the work of preparation that so we may be fit to receive it And if I can clearly make out these three things I hope this Objection is fully answered 1. That every degree of imperfection in our preparation for this Sacrament is not a sufficient reason for men to abstain from it For then no man should ever receive it For who is every way worthy and in all degrees and respects duly qualified to approach the presence of God in any of the duties of his Worship and Service Who can wash his hands in innocency that so he may be perfectly fit to approach God's Altar There is not man on earth that lives and sins not The Graces of the best men are imperfect and every imperfection in grace and goodness is an imperfection in the disposition and preparation of out minds for this holy Sacrament But if we do heartily repent of our sins and sincerely resolve to obey and perform the terms of the Gospel and of
him or to let him die for his own interest So he that trusts the care of his soul with other men and at the same time by irrevocable Deed settles his understanding upon them lays too great a temptation before them to seduce and damn him for their own ends And now to reflect a little upon our selves What cause have we to bless God who are so happily rescued from that more than Egyptian darkness and bondage wherein this Nation was detained for several Ages who are delivered out of the hands of those cruel task-masters who required brick without straw that men should be religious without competent understanding and work out their own salvation while they denyed them the means of all others the most necessary to it who are so uncharitable as to allow us no salvation out of their Church and yet so unreasonable as to deny us the very best means of salvation when we are in it Our Fore-fathers thought it a mighty privilege to have the Word of God restored to them and the publick prayers and service of God celebrated in a known Tongue Let us use this inestimable privilege with great modesty and humility not to the nourishing of pride and self-conceit of division and faction but as the Apostle exhorts Let the word of God dwell richly in you in all wisedom and let the peace of God rule in your hearts unto which ye are called in one body and be ye thankfull It concerns us mightily with which admonition I shall conclude both for the honour and support of our Religion to be at better union among our selves and not to divide about lesser things and so to demean our selves as to take from our Adversaries all those pretences whereby they would justifie themselves or at least extenuate the guilt of that heavy charge which falls every whit as justly upon them as ever it did upon the Scribes and Pharisees of taking away the key of knowledge and shutting the kingdom of heaven against men neither going in themselves nor suffering those that are entring to go in FINIS Books Printed for Brabazon Aylmer THE Works of the Learned Dr. Isaac Barrow late Master of Trinity College in Cambridge Published by the Reverend Dr. Tillotson Dean of Canterbury in Four Volumes in Folio The First containing Thirty two Sermons preached upon several Occasions an Exposition of the Lord's Prayer and the Decalogue a Learned Treatise of the Pope's Supremacy a Discourse concerning the Vnity of the Church also some Account of the Life of the Authour with Alphabetical Tables The Second Volume containing Sermons and Expositions upon all the Apostles Creed with an Alphabetical Table and to which may be also added the Life of the Authour The Third Volume containing Forty six choice Sermons upon several Subjects with an Alphabetical Table which are the last that will be printed in English of this Learned Authour The Fourth Volume containing his Opuscula viz. Determinationes Conc. Ad Clerum Orationes Poematia c. Sermons and Discourses upon several Occasions in Three Volumes in 8o. By Dr. Tilloâ—son Dean of Canterbury The Rule of Faith or an Answer to the Treatise of M. J.S. entituled Sure-sooting c. THE Doctrines and Practices of the Church of Rome truly Represented in answer to a Book intituled A Papist Misrepresented and Represented c. An Answer to a Discourse intituled Papists Protesting against Protestant Popery being a Vindication of Papists not Misrepresented by Protestants and containing a particular Examination of Monsieur de Meaux late Bishop of Condom his Exposition of the Doctrine of the Church of Rome in the Articles of Invocation of Saints and the Worship of Images occasioned by that Discourse An Answer to the Amicable Accommodation of the Difference between the Representer and the Answerer 4o. A View of the whole Controversie between the Representer and the Answerer with an Answer to the Representers last Reply in which are laid open some of the Methods by which Protestants are Misrepresented by Papists 4o. The Doctrine of the Trinity and Transubstantiation compared as to Scripture Reason and Tradition in a new Dialogue between a Protestant and a Papist in Two Parts Wherein an Answer is given to the late Proofs of the Antiquity of Transubstantiation c. And the Doctrine of the Trinity shewed to be agreeable to Scripture and Reason and Transubstantiation repugnant to both 4o. An Answer to the 8th Chapter of the Representers Second Part in the first Dialogue between him and his Lay-Friend Of the Authority of Councils and the Rule of Faith By a Person of Quality with an Answer to the eight Theses laid down for the Trial of the English Reformation in a Book that came lately from Oxford A Sermon Preached at the Funeral of the Reverend Benj. Calamy D. D. and late Minister of St. Lawrence Jewry London Jan. 7th 1686. By William Sherlock D.D. Master of the Temple and Chaplain in ordinary to His Majesty The Necessity Dignity and Duty of Gospel Ministers discoursed of before the University of Cambridge A New and easie method to learn to Sing by Book whereby one who hath a good Voice and Ear may without other help learn to sing true by Notes Design'd chiefly for and applied to the promoting of Psalmody and furnished with variety of Psalm Tunes in Parts with Directions for that kind of Singing The Parsons Counsellor with the Law of Tithes or Tithing In two Books The first sheweth the Order every Parson Vicar c. ought to observe in obtaining a Spiritual Preferment and what Duties are incumbent upon him after the taking the same and many other things necessary for every Clergy-Man to know and observe The second shews in what manner all sorts of Tithes Offerings Mortuaries and other Church Duties are to be paid as well in London as elsewhere c. A Letter to a Friend reflecting on some Passages in a Letter to the D. of P. in Answer to the Arguing Part of his First Letter to Mr. G. THE END
that is this That there is some way to discern mere pretenders to Inspiration from those who are truly and Divinely inspired And this is necessarily implied in the Apostles bidding us to try the Spirits whether they are of God For it were in vain to make any trial if there be no way to discern between pretended and real Inspirations Now the handling of this will give occasion to two very material Enquiries and useful to be resolved I. How we may discern between true and counterfeit Doctrines those which really are from God and those which only pretend to be so II. To whom this judgement of discerning doth appertain I. How we may discern between true and counterfeit Doctrines and Revelations for the clearing of this I shall lay down these following Propositions I. That Reason is the faculty whereby Revelations are to be discerned or to use the phrase in the text it is that whereby we are to judge what Spirits are of God and what not For all Revelation from God supposeth us to be men and to be indued with Reason and therefore it does not create new Faculties in us but propounds new Objects to that Faculty which was in us before Whatever Doctrines God reveals to men are propounded to their Understandings and by this Faculty we are to examine all Doctrines which pretend to be from God and upon on examination to judge whether there be reason to receive them as Divine or to reject them as Impostures 2. All supernatural Revelation supposeth the truth of the Principles of Natural Religion We must first be assured that there is a God before we can know that he hath made any Revelation of himself and we must know that his Words are true otherwise there were no sufficient reason to believe the Revelations which he makes to us and we must believe his Authority over us and that he will reward our obedience to his Laws and punish our breach of them otherwise there would neither be sufficient obligation nor encouragement to Obedience These and many other things are supposed to be true and naturally known to us antecedently to all supernatural Revelation otherwise the Revelations of God would signifie nothing to us nor be of any force with us 3. All Reasonings about Divine Revelations must necessarily be governed by the Principles of Natural Religion that is by those apprehensions which men naturally have of the Divine perfections and by the clear Notions of good and evil which are imprinted upon our Natures Because we have no other way to judge what is worthy of God and credible to be revealed by him and what not but by the natural notions which we have of God and of his essential perfections which because we know him to be immutable we have reason to believe he will never contradict And by these Principles likewise we are to interpret what God hath revealed and when any doubt ariseth concerning the meaning of any divine Revelation as that of the Holy Scriptures we are to govern our selves in the interpretation of it by what is most agreeable to those natural Notions which we have of God and we have all the reason in the World to reject that sense which is contrary thereto For instance when God is represented in Scripture as having a humane shape eyes ears and hands the Notions which men naturally have of the Divine Nature and Perfections do sufficiently direct us to interptet these expressions in a sense worthy of God and agreeable to his Perfection And therefore it is reasonable to understand them as rather spoken to our capacity and in a Figure than to be literally intended And this will proportionably hold in many other cases 4. Nothing ought to be received as a Revelation from God which plainly contradicts the Principles of Natural Religion or overthrows the certainty of them For instance it were in vain to pretend a Revelation from God That there is no God because this is a contradiction in terms So likewise to pretend a command from God That we are to hate and despise him because it is not credible that God should require any thing of Reasonable Creatures so unsuitable to their Natures and to their Obligations to him Besides that such a Law as this does tacitly involve a contradiction because upon such a supposition to despise God would be to obey him and yet to obey him is certainly to honour him So that in this case to honour God and to despise him would be the same thing and equal contempts of him In like manner it would be vain to pretend any Revelation from God That there is no life after this nor rewards and punishments in another World because this is contrary to those natural apprehensions which have generally possest mankind and would take away the main force and sanction of the divine Laws The like may be said concerning any pretended Revelation from God which evidently contradicts those natural Notions which men have of good and evil as That God should command or allow Sedition and Rebellion Perfidiousness and Perjury because the practise of these would be apparently destructive of the peace and happiness of Mankind and would naturally bring confusion into the World But God is not the God of Confusion but of Order which St. Paul appeals to as a Principle naturally knowu Upon the same account nothing ought to be entertained as a Divine Revelation which overthrows the certainty of the Principles of natural Religion because that would take away the certainty of Divine Revelation it self which supposeth the truth of those Principles For instance whoever pretends any Revelation that brings the Providence of God into question does by that very thing make such a Revelation questionable For if God take no care of the World have no concernment for humane affairs why should we believe that he makes any Revelation of his Will to men And by this Principle Moses will have false Prophets to be tried Deut. 13.1 If there arise among you a Prophet and giveth thee a sign or wonder and the signor the wonder come to pass whereof he spake unto thee saying Let us go after other Gods and let us serve them thou shalt not hearken unto the words of that Prophet And he gives the reason of this ver 5. Because he hath spoken unto you to turn you away from the Lord your God which brought you out of the Land of Egypt Here is a case wherein a false Prophet is supposed to work a true Miracle to give credit to his Doctrine which in other cases the Scripture makes the sign of a true Prophet but yet in this case he is to be rejected as an Impostor Because the Doctrine he teacheth would draw men off from the worship of the true God who is naturally known and had manifested himself to the people of Israel in so miraculous a manner by bringing them out of the Land of Egypt So that a Miracle is not enough to give credit to a
Virtue is Vice and Vice Virtue he would hereby take away the very foundation of Religion and how can I look upon him any longer as a Judg in matters of Religion when there can be no such thing as Religion if he have judged and determined right Secondly The Scripture plainly allows this liberty to particular and private Persons to judg for themselves And for this I need go no farther than my Text which bids men try the Spirits whether they be of God I do not think this is spoken only to the Pope or a General Council but to Christians in general for to these the Apostle writes Now if St. John had believed that God had constituted an infallible Judge in his Church to whose Sentence and Determination all Christians are bound to submit he ought in all reason to have referred Christians to him for the trial of Spirits and not have left it to every man's private judgment to examine and to determine these things But it seems St. Paul was likewise of the same mind and though he was guided by an infallible Spirit yet he did not expect that men should blindly submit to his Doctrine Nay so far is he from that that he commends the Bereans for that very thing for which I dare say the Church of Rome would have check'd them most severely namely for searching the Scriptures to see whether those things which the Apostles delivered were so or not This liberty St. Paul allowed and though he was inspired by God yet he treated those whom he taught like men And indeed it were a hard case that a necessity of believing Divine Revelations and rejecting Impostures should be imposed upon Christians and yet the liberty of judging whether a Doctrine be from God or not should be taken away from them Thirdly Our Adversaries themselves are forced to grant that which in effect is as much as we contend for For though they deny a liberty of judging in particular points of Religion yet they are forced to grant men a liberty of judging upon the whole When they of the Church of Rome would perswade a Jew or a Heathen to become a Christian or a Heretick as they are pleased to call us to come over to the Communion of their Church and offer Arguments to induce them thereto they do by this very thing whether they will or no make that man Judge which is the true Church and the true Religion Because it would be ridiculous to perswade a man to turn to their Religion and to urge him with Reasons to do so and yet to deny him the use of his own judgement whether their Reasons be sufficient to move him to make such a change Now as the Apostle reasons in another case If men be fit to judge for themselves in so great and important a matter as the choice of their Religion why should they be thought unworthy to judge in lesser matters They tell us indeed that a man may use his judgement in the choice of his Religion but when he hath once chosen he is then for ever to resign up his judgment to their Church But what tolerable reason can any man give why a man should be fit to judge upon the whole and yet unfit to judge upon particular Points especially if it be considered that no man can make a discreet judgment of any Religion before he hath examined the particular Doctrines of it and made a judgment concerning them Is it credible that God should give a man judgment in the most fundamental and important matter of all viz. To discern the true Religion and the true Church from the false for no other end but to enable him to chuse once for all to whom he should resign and inslave his judgment for ever which is just as reasonable as if one should say That God hath given a man eyes for no other end but to look out once for all and to pitch upon a discreet person to lead him about blindfold all the days of his life I come now to the III. Thing I propounded which is To Answer the main Objection of our Adversaries against this Principle and likewise to shew that there is no such Reason and necessity for an universal Insallible Judge as they pretend Now their great Objection is this If every man may judge for himself there will be nothing but confusion in Religion there will be no end of Controversies so that an universal infallible Judge is necessary and without this God had not made sufficient provision for the assurance of men's Faith and for the Peace and unity of his Church Or as it is expressed in the Canon Law aliter Dominus non videretur fuisse discretus otherwise our Lord had not seem'd to be discreet How plausible soever this Objection may appear I do not despair but if men will lay aside prejudice and impartially consider things to make it abundantly evident that this ground is not sufficient to found an Infallible Judge upon And therefore in answer to it I desire these following particulars may be considered Firft That this which they say rather proves what God should have done according to their fancy than what he hath really and actually done My Text expresly bids Christians to try the Spirits which to any man's sense does imply that they may judge of these matters But the Church of Rome says they may not because if this liberty were permitted God had not ordered things wisely and for the best for the peace and unity of his Church But as the Apostle says in another case What art thou O man that objectest against God Secondly If this reasoning be good we may as well conclude that there is an universal infallible Judge set over the whole world in all Temporal matters to whose Authority all mankind is bound to submit Because this is as necessary to the peace of the World as the other is to the peace of the Church And men surely are every whit as apt to be obstinate and perverse about matters of Temporal Right as about matters of Faith But it is evident in fact and experience that there is no such universal Judge appointed by God over the whole World to decide all Cases of temporal Right and for want of him the World is fain to shift as well as it can But now a very acute and scholastical man that would argue that God must needs have done whatever he fancies convenient for the World should be done might by the very same way of Reasoning conclude the necessity of an universal infallible Judge in Civil matters as well as in matters of Religion And their aliter Dominus non videretur fuisse discretus otherwise God had not seem'd to be discreet is every whit as cogent and as civil in the one Case as the other Thirdly There is no need of such a Judge to assure men in matters of Religion Because men be sufficiently certain without him I hope it may be certain
or any man else could tell me but I took him to conduct and direct me the nearest way to York And therefore after all his impertinent talk after all his Motives of Credibility to perswade me to believe him and all his confident sayings which he gravely calls Demonstrations I stand stifly upon the shore and leave my learned and reverend Guide to take his own course and to dispose of himself as he pleaseth but firmly resolved not to follow him And is any man to be blamed that breaks with his Guide upon these Terms And this is truly the Case when a man commits himself to the Guidance of any Person or Church If by virtue of this Authority they will needs perswade me out of my senses and not to believe what I see but what they say that Vertue is Vice and Vice Vertue it they declare them to be so And that because they say they are Infallible I am to receive all their Dictates for Oracles tho never so evidently false and absurd in the Judgment of all Mankind In this case there is no way to be rid of these unreasonable People but to desire of them since one kindness deserves another and all Contradictions are alike easie to be believed that they would be pleased to believe that Infidelity is Faith and that when I absolutely renounce their Authority I do yield a most perfect submission and obedience to it Upon the whole matter all the Revelations of God as well as the Laws of men go upon this presumption that men are not stark fools but that they will consider their Interest and have some regard to the great concernment of their eternal salvation And this is as much to secure men from mistake in matters of Belief as God hath afforded to keep men from sin in matters of Practice He hath made no effectual and infallible provision that men shall not sin and yet it would puzzle any man to give a good Reason why God should take more care to secure men against Errors in belief than against sin and wickedness in their Lives I shall now only draw three or four Inferences from this Discourse which I have made and so conclude 1. That it is every mans Duty who hath ability and capacity for it to endeavour to understand the grounds of his Religion For to try Doctrines is to inquire into the grounds and reasons of them which the better any man understands the more firmly he will be established in the Truth and be the more resolute in the day of Trial and the better able to withstand the Arts and assaults of cunning Adversaries and the fierce storms of Persecution And on the contrary that man will soon be moved from his stedfastness who never examined the Grounds and Reasons of his belief When it comes to the Trial he that hath but little to say for his Religion will probably neither do nor suffer much for it 2. That all Doctrines are vehemently to be suspected which decline Trial and are so loath to be brought into the light which will hot endure a fair Examination but magisterially require an implicite Faith Whereas Truth is bold and full of courage and loves to appear openly and is so secure and confident of her own strength as to offer her self to the severest Trial and Examination But to deny all liberty of Enquiry and Judgment in matters of Religion is the greatest injury and disparagement to Truth that can be and a tacite acknowledgment that she lies under some disadvantage and that there is less to be said for her than for Error I have often wonder'd why the People in the Church of Rome do not suspect their Teachers and Guides to have some ill design upon them when they do so industriously debar them of the means of Knowledge and are so very loath to let them understand what it is that we have to say against their Religion For can any thing in the world be more suspicious than to perswade men to put out their eyes upon promise that they will help them to a much better and more faithful Guide If any Church any Profession of men be unwilling their Doctrines should be exposed to Trial it is a certain sign they know something by them that is faulty and which will not endure the light This is the account which our Saviour gives us in a like case It was because mens deeds were evil that they loved darkness rather than light For every one that doth evil hateth the light neither cometh he to the light lest his deeds should be reproved But he that doth the truth cometh to the light that his deeds may be made manifest that they are wrought in God 3. Since Reason and Christianity allow this liberty to private persons to judg for themselves in matters of Religion we should use this priviledg with much modesty and humility with great submission and deference to our Spiritual Rulers and Guides whom God hath appointed in his Church And there is very great need of this Caution since by experience we find this liberty so much abused by many to the nourishing of Pride and Self-conceit of Division and Faction and those who are least able to judge to be frequently the most forward and confident the most peremptory and perverse and instead of demeaning themselves with the submission of Learners to assume to themselves the authority of Judges even in the most doubtful and disputable matters The Tyranny of the Roman Church over the Minds and Consciences of men is not to be justified upon any account but nothing puts so plausible a colour upon it as the ill use that is too frequently made of this natural Privilege of mens judging for themselves in a matter of so infinite concernment as that of their eternal happiness But then it is to be consider'd that the proper remedy in this Case is not to deprive men of this Privelege but to use the best means to prevent the abuse of it For though the inconveniences arising from the ill use of it may be very great yet the mischief on the other hand is intolerable Religion it self is liable to be abused to very bad purposes and frequently is so but it is not therefore best that there should be no Religion And yet this Objection if it be of any force and be pursued home is every whit as strong against Religion it self as against mens liberty of judging in matters of Religion Nay I add farther that no man can judiciously embrace the true Religion unless he be permitted to judge whether that which he embraces be the true Religion or not 4. When upon due Trial and Examination we are well setled and established in our Religion let us hold fast the prosession of our Faith without wavering and not be like Children tossed to and fro and carried about with every wind of Doctrine through the sleight of men and the cunning craftiness of those who lye in wait to deceive
afterwards upon their posterity in this world And does not this agree well enough with the first and most obvious sense of these words I am the God of Abraham Isaac and Jacob that is I am he that was their God while they were alive and am still the God of their posterity for their sakes I say because the three former Considerations are liable to this Objection which seems wholly to take off the force of this Argument therefore for the full clearing of this matter I will add one consideration more Fourthly then we will consider the general importance of this Promise abstracting from the particular persons specified and named in it viz. Abraham Isaac and Jacob and that is that God will make a wide and plain difference between good and bad men he will be so the God of good men as he is not of the wicked and some time or other put every good man into a better and happier condition than any wicked man so that the general importance of this promise is finally resolved into the equity and justice of the Divine Providence And unless we suppose another life after this it will certainly be very hard and I think impossible to reconcile the History of the Old Testament and the common appearances of things in this World with the Justice and Goodness of God's Providence It cannot be denied but that Abraham Isaac and Jacob and several good men in the old Testament had many signal Testimonies of the Divine favour vouchsafed to them in this world But we read likewise of several wicked men that had as large a share of temporal blessings It is very true that Abraham Isaac and Jacob had great estates and were petty Princes But Pharoah was a mighty Prince in comparison of them and the Kingdom of Egypt which probably was the first and chief seat of Idolatry was at the same time one of the most potent and flourishing Kingdoms in the world and was blest with a prodigious plenty whereby they were furnished with store of corn when good Jacob and his Family had like to have perished by famine 'T is true Joseph was ad anc'd to great power in Egypt and thereby had the opportunity of saving his Fathers house by setling them and feeding them in Egypt But then it is to be considered again that this cost them very dear and their coming thither was the occasion of a long and cruel bondage to Jacob's posterity so that we see that these good men had no such blessings but what were common with them to many others that were wicked and the blessings which God bestowed upon them had great abatements by the intermixture of many and sore afflictions It seems then upon the whole matter to be very plain that the Providences of God in this world towards good men are so contrived that it may sufficiently appear to those who wisely consider the works of God that they are not neglected by him and yet that these outward blessings are so promiscuously dispensed that no man can certainly be concluded to be a good man from any happiness he enjoys in this life And the prosperity of good men is usually on purpose so shadowed and mixed with afflictions as may justly raise their hopes to the expectation of a more perfect happiness and better reward than any they meet with in this world And if so then the general importance of this Promise that God will be the God of good men must necessarily signifie something beyond this world Because in this world there is not that clear difference universally made betwen good and bad men which the Justice of the Divine Providence doth require and which seems to be intended in the general sence of this Promise For if this Promise though personally made to Abraham Isaac and Jacob be intended as the Scripture tells us it was for a standing encouragement to good men in all Ages then it must contain in it this general Truth that God will some time or other plentifully reward every good man that is he will do something far better for him than for any wicked man But if there be no life after this it is impossible to reconcile this sense of it with the course of God's Providence and with the History of the Bible And to make this out fully and at once I will only produce that single Instance of Abel and Cain Abel offered to God a more excellent sacrifice than Cain and he had this testimony that he pleased God which was in effect to declare that God was the God of Abel and not of Cain so that by virtue of the general importance of this Promise it might justly be expected that Abel's condition should have been much better than Cain's But if there be no happiness after this life Abel's was evidently much worse For upon this very account that he pleased God better he was killed by Cain who had offered to God a slight and contemptuous offering And Cain lived a long time after and grew great and built Cities Now supposing there were no other life after this this must have been a most horrible Example to all Ages from the beginning of the world to the end of it and have made men for ever afraid to please God upon such hard terms when they were sure of no other reward for so doing but to be oppress'd and slain by the hands of the wicked So that if this were really the Case it would puzzle all the Wit and Reason of mankind to vindicate the equity and justice of the Divine Providence and to rescue it out of the hands of this terrible Objection And thus have I as briefly as I could endeavoured to clear to you the force of this Argument used by our Saviour for the Proof of the Resurrection And have the longer insisted upon it because at first appearance it seems to be but a very obscure and remote Argument And yet so much the more necessary to be clear'd because this in all probability was that very Text upon which the Jews in our Saviours time grounded their belief of a future state in opposition to the error of the Sadduces and which they call'd by way of eminency the promise made of God unto the Fathers As will plainly appear if we consider what St. Paul says to this purpose when he appeals so often to the Pharisees for his agreement with them in this Article of the Resurrection and likewise in the ground of it from the promise made of God unto the fathers Act. 24.14 15 But this I confess unto thee that after the way which they call heresie so worship I the God of my Fathers believing all things which are written in the Law and the Prophets and have hope towards God which they themselves also allow that there shall be a resurrection of the dead From whence it is clear that they both grounded their hope of the resurrection upon something written in the Law and the Prophets and
Friend How can he possibly use him more barbarously than to feast upon his living flesh and bloud It is one of the greatest wonders in the world that it should ever enter into the minds of men to put upon our Saviour's words so easily capable of a more convenient sense and so necessarily requiring it a meaning so plainly contrary to Reason and Sense and even to Humanity it self Had the ancient Christians owned any such Doctrine we should have heard of it from the Adversaries of our Religion in every page of their Writings and they would have desired no greater advantage against the Christians than to have been able to hit them in the teeth with their feasting upon the natural flesh and Bloud of their Lord and their God and their best Friend What endless triumphs would they have made upon this Subject And with what confidence would they have set the cruelty used by Christians in their Sacrament against their God Saturn's eating his own Children and all the cruel and bloudy Rites of their Idolatry But that no such thing was then objected by the Heathens to the Christians is to a wise man instead of a thousand Demonstrations that no such Doctrine was then believed 3. It is scandalous also upon account of the cruel and bloudy consequences of this Doctrine so contrary to the plain Laws of Christianity and to one great end and design of this Sacrament which is to unite Christians in the most perfect love and charity to one another Whereas this Doctrine hath been the occasion of the most barbarous and bloudy Tragedies that ever were acted in the World For this hath been in the Church of Rome the great burning Article and as absurd and unreasonable as it is more Christians have been murthered for the denyal of it than perhaps for all the other Articles of their Religion And I think it may generally pass for a true observation that all Sects are commonly most hot and furious for those things for which there is least Reason for what men want of Reason for their opinions they usually supply and make up in Rage And it was no more than needed to use this severity upon this occasion for nothing but the cruel fear of death could in probability have driven so great a part of mankind into the acknowledgment of so unreasonable and senseless a Doctrine O blessed Saviour I thou best Friend and greatest lover of mankind who can imagine thou didst ever intend that men should kill one another for not being able to believe contrary to their senses for being unwilling to think that thou shouldst make one of the most horrid and barbarous things that can be imagin'd a main Duty and principal Mystery of thy Religion for not flattering the pride and presumption of the Priest who says he can make God and for not complying with the folly and stupidity of the People who are made to believe that they can eat him 4. Upon account of the danger of Idolatry which they are certainly guilty of if this Doctrine be not true and such a change as they pretend be not made in the Sacrament for if it be not then they worship a Creature instead of the Creatour God blessed for ever But such a change I have shewn to be impossible or if it could be yet they can never be certain that it is and consequently are always in danger of Idolatry and that they can never be certain that such a change is made is evident because according to the express determination of the Council of Trent that depends upon the mind and intention of the Priest which cannot certainly be known but by Revelation which is not pretended in this case And if they be mistaken about this change through the knavery or crossness of the Priest who will not make God but when he thinks fit they must not think to excuse themselves from Idolatry because they intended to worship God and not a Creature for so the Persians might be excus'd from Idolatry in worshipping the Sun because they intend to worship God and not a Creature and so indeed we may excuse all the Idolatry that ever was in the world which is nothing else but a mistake of the Deity and upon that mistake a worshipping of something as God which is not God II. Besides the infinite scandal of this Doctrine upon the accounts I have mentioned the monstrous absurdities of it make it insupportable to any Religion I am very well assur'd of the grounds of Religion in general and of the Christian Religion in particular and yet I cannot see that the foundations of any revealed Religion are strong enough to bear the weight of so many and so great absurdities as this Doctrine of Transubstantiation would load it withall And to make this evident I shall not insist upon those gross contradictions of the same Body being in so many several places at once of our Saviour's giving away himself with his own hands to every one of his Disciples and yet still keeping himself to himself and a thousand more of the like nature but to shew the absurdity of this Doctrine I shall only ask these few Questions 1. Whether any man have or ever had greater evidence of the truth of any Divine Revelation than any man hath of the falshood of Transubstantiation Infidelity were hardly possible to men if all men had the same evidence for the Christian Religion which they have against Transubstantiation that is the clear and irresistible evidence of sense He that can once be brought to contradict or deny his senses is at an end of certainty for what can a man be certain of if he be not certain of what he sees In some circumstances our senses may deceive us but no Faculty deceives us so little and so seldom And when our senses do deceive us even that errour is not to be corrected without the help of our senses 2. Supposing this Doctrine had been delivered in Scripture in the very same words that it is decreed in the Council of Trent by what clearer evidence or stronger Argument could any man prove to me that such words were in the Bible than I can prove to him that bread and wine after consecration are bread and wine still He could but appeal to my eyes to prove such words to be in the Bible and with the same reason and justice might I appeal to several of his senses to prove to him that the bread and wine after consecration are bread and wine still 3. Whether it be reasonable to imagine that God should make that a part of the Christian Religion which shakes the main external evidence and confirmation of the whole I mean the Miracles which were wrought by our Saviour and his Apostles the assurance whereof did at first depend upon the certainty of sense For if the senses of those who say they saw them were deceived then there might be no Miracles wrought and consequently it may justly be
to importune them to their interest and with great earnestness to persuade them to that which in all respects is so visibly for their advantage Chuse you therefore this day whom you will serve God or your lusts And take up a speedy resolution in a matter of so great and pressing a concernment chuse you this day Where there is great hazard in the doing of a thing it is good to deliberate long before we undertake it but where the thing is not only safe but beneficial and not only hugely beneficial but highly necessary when our life and our happiness depends upon it and all the danger lies in the delay of it there we cannot be too sudden in our resolution nor too speedy in the execution of it That which is evidently safe needs no deliberation and that which is absolutely necessary will admit of none Therefore resolve upon it out of hand to day whilest it is called to day lest dny of you be hardened through the deceitfulness of sin In the days of your youth and health for that is the acceptable time that is the day of salvation Before the evil day comes and you be driven to it by the terrible apprehension and approach of death when men fly to God only for fear of his wrath For the greatest Atheists and Infidels when they come to dye if they have any of that reason left which they have used so ill have commonly right opinions about God and Religion For then the considence as well as the comfort of Atheism leaves them as the Devil uses to do Witches when they are in distress Then with Nebuchadnezzar when they are recovered from being beasts they look up to heaven and their understanding returns to them Then they believe a God and cannot help it they believe and tremble at the thoughts of him Thus Lucretius one of their great Authors observes that when men are in distress Acrius advertunt animos ad Religionem The thoughts of Religion are then more quick and pungent upon their minds Nam verae voces tum demum pectore ab imo Eliciuntur eripitur persona manet res Mens words then come from the bottom of their hearts the mask is taken off and things then appear as in truth they are But then perhaps it may be too late to make this choice Nay then it can hardly be choice but necessity Men do not then chuse to serve the Lord but they are urged and forced to it by their fears They have served their lusts all their life long and now they would fain serve themselves of God at the hour of death They have done what they can by their insolent contempt and defiance of the Almighty to make themselves miserable and now that they can stand out no longer against him they are contented at last to be beholding to him to make them happy The mercies of God are vast and boundless but yet methinks it is too great a presumption in all reason for men to design before-hand to make the mercy of God the sanctuary and retreat of a sinfull life To draw then to a Conclusion of this Discourse If safety or pleasure or liberty or wisdom or vertue or even happiness it self have any temptation in them Religion hath all these baits and allurements What Tully says Philosophy is much more true of the Christian Religion the Wisdom and Philosophy which is from above nunquam satis laudari poterit cui qui pareat omne tempus aetatis sine molestia degere possit We can never praise it enough since whoever lives according to the rules of it may pass the whole age of his life I may add his whole duration this life and the other without trouble Philosophy hath given us several plausible rules for the attaining of peace and tranquility of mind but they fall very much short of bringing men to it The very best of them fail us upon the greatest occasions But the Christian Religion hath effectually done all that which Philosophy pretended to and aimed at The Precepts and Promises of the Holy Scriptures are every way sufficient for our comfort and for our instruction in righteousness to correct all the errours and to bear us up under all the evils and adversities of humane life especially that holy and heavenly Doctrine which is contained in the admirable Sermons of our Saviour quem cum legimus quem Philosophum non contemnimus whose excellent discourses when we reade what Philosopher do we not despise None of the Philosophers could upon sure grounds give that encouragement to their Scholars which our Saviour does to his Disciples take my yoke upon you and learn of me and ye shall find rest to your souls For my yoke is easie and my burthen is light This is the advantage of the Christian Religion sincerely believed and practised that it gives perfect rest and tranquillity to the mind of man It frees us from the guilt of an evil conscience and from the power of our lusts and from the slavish fear of death and of the vengeance of another World It builds our comfort upon a rock which will abide all storms and remain unshaken in every condition and will last and hold out for ever He that heareth these sayings of mine and doth them saith our Lord I will liken him to a wise wan who built his house upon a rock In short Religion makes the life of man a wise design regular and constant to its self because it unites all our resolutions and actions in one great end Whereas without Religion the life of man is a wild and fluttering and inconsistent thing without any certain scope and design The vicious man lives at randome and acts by chance For he that walks by no rule can carry on no settled and steady design It would pity a man's heart to see how hard such men are put to it for diversion and what a burden time is to them and how solicitous they are to devise ways not to spend it but to squander it away For their great grievance is consideration and to be obliged to be intent upon any thing that is serious They hurry from one vanity and folly to another and plunge themselves into drink not to quench their thirst but their guilt and are beholding to every vain man and to every trifling occasion that can but help to take time off their hands Wretched and inconsiderate men who have so vast a work before them the happiness of all eternity to take care of and provide for and yet are at a loss how to employ their time So that Irreligion and Vice makes life an extravagant and unnatural thing because it perverts and overthrows the natural course and order of things For instance according to nature men labour to get an Estate to free themselves from temptations to rapine and injury and that they may have wherewithall to supply their own wants and to relieve the needs of others But now the
time I have purposely reserved this for the last place because it is their last refuge and if this fail them they are gone To shew the weakness of this pretence we will if they please take it for granted that the Governours of the Church have in no Age more power than the Apostles had in theirs Now St. Paul tells us 2 Cor. 10.8 that the Authority which the Apostles had given them from the Lord was only for edification but not for destruction And the same St. Paul makes it the business of a whole Chapter to shew that the performing the publick service of God and particularly Praying in an unknown Tongue are contrary to edification from which premisses the conclusion is plain That the Apostles themselves had no Authority to appoint the service of God to be performed in an unknown Tongue and surely it is Arrogance for the Church in any Age to pretend to greater Authority than the Apostles had This is the summ of what our Adversaries say in justification of themselves in these points And there is no doubt but that men of wit and confidence will alwaies make a shift to say something for any thing and some way or other blanch over the blackest and most absurd things in the world But I leave it to the judgment of mankind whether any thing be more unreasonable than to tell men in effect that it is fit they should understand as little of Religion as is possible that God hath published a very dangerous Book with which it is not safe for the people to be familiarly acquainted that our blessed Saviour and his Apostles and the ancient Christian Church for more than six hundred years were not wise managers of Religion nor prudent dispensers of the Scriptures but like fond and foolish Fathers put a knife and a sword into the hands of their Children with which they might easily have foreseen what mischief they would do to themselves and others And who would not chuse to be of such a Church which is provided of such excellent and effectual means of Ignorance such wise and infallible methods for the prevention of knowledge in the people and such variety of close shutters to keep out the light I have chosen to insist upon this Argument because it is so very plain that the most ordinary capacity may judge of this usage and dealing with the souls of men which is so very gross that every man must needs be sensible of it because it toucheth men in the common rights of humane nature which belong to them as much as the light of heaven and the air we breath in It requires no subtilty of wit no skill in Antiquity to understand these Controversies between Us and the Church of Rome For there are no Fathers to be pretended on both sides in these Questions They yield we have Antiquity on ours And we refer it to the common sense of Mankind which Church that of Rome or Ours hath all the right and reason in the world on her side in these debates And who they are that tyrannize over Christians the Governours of their Church or ours who use the people like sons and freemen and who like slaves who feed the flock of Christ committed to them and who take the Childrens bread from them Who they are that when their Children ask bread for bread give them a stone and for an egg a serpent I mean the Legends of their Saints instead of the holy Scriptures which are able to make men wise unto salvation And who they are that lie most justly under the suspicion of Errours and Corruptions they who bring their Doctrine and Practices into the open light and are willing to have them tryed by the true touchstone the Word of God or they who shun the light and decline all manner of tryal and examination and who are most likely to carry on a worldly design they who drive a trade of such mighty gain and advantage under pretence of Religion and make such markets of the ignorance and sins of the people or we whom malice it self cannot charge with serving any worldly design by any allowed Doctrine or Practice of our Religion For we make no money of the mistakes of the people nor do we fill their heads with vain fears of new places of torment to make them willing to empty their purses in a vainer hope of being delivered out of them We do not like them pretend a mighty bank and treasure of Merits in the Church which they sell to the people for ready money giving them bills of Exchange from the Pope to Purgatory when they who grant them have no reason to believe they will avail them or be accepted in the other World For our parts we have no fear that our people should understand Religion too well We could wish with Moses that all the Lord's people were Prophets We should be heartily glad the people would read the holy Scriptures more diligently being sufficiently assured that it is their own fault if they learn any thing but what is good from thence We have no Doctrines or Practices contrary to Scripture and consequently no occasion to keep it close from the sight of the people or to hide any of the Commandments of God from them We leave these mean arts to those who stand in need of them In a word there is nothing which God hath said to men which we desire should be concealed from them Nay we are willing the people should examine what we teach and bring all our Doctrines to the Law and to the Testimony that if they be not according to this Rule they may neither believe them nor us 'T is onely things false and adulterate which shun the light and sear the touchstone We have that security of the truth of our Religion and of the agreeableness of it to the word of God that honest confidence of the goodness of our Cause that we do not forbid the people to read the best Books our Adversaries can write against it And now let any impartial man judge whether this be not a better argument of a good Cause to leave men at liberty to try the grounds of their Religion than the courses which are taken in the Church of Rome to awe men with an Inquisition and as much as is possible to keep the common people in Ignorance not onely of what their late Adversaries the Protestants but their chief and ancient Adversary the Scriptures have to say against them A man had need of more than common security of the skill and integrity of those to whom he perfectly resigns his understanding this is too great a Trust to be reposed in humane frailty and too strong a temptation to others to impose upon us to abuse our blindness and to make their own ends of our voluntary Ignorance and easie credulity This is such a folly as if a rich man should make his Physician his heir which is to tempt him either to destroy
the Sacrament set himself seriously to be humbled for his sins and to repent of them and to beg God's grace and assistance against them and after the receiving of it does continue for some time in these good resolutions though after a while he may possibly relapse into the same sins again this is some kind of restraint to a wicked life and these good moods and sits of repentance and reformation are much better than a constant and uninterrupted course of sin even this righteousness which is but as the morning cloud and the early dew which so soon passeth away is better than none And indeed scarce any man can think of coming to the Sacrament but he will by this consideration be excited to some good purposes and put upon some sort of endeavour to amend and reform his life and though he be very much under the bondage and power of evil habits if he do with any competent degree of sincerity and it is his own fault if he do not make use of this excellent means and instrument for the mortifying and subduing of his lusts and for the obtaining of God's grace and assistence it may please God by the use of these means so to abate the force and power of his lusts and to imprint such considerations upon his mind in the receiving of this holy Sacrament and preparing himself for it that he may at last break off his wicked course and become a good man But on the other hand as to those who neglect this Sacrament there is hardly any thing left to restrain them from the greatest enormities of life and to give a check to them in their evil course nothing but the penalty of humane Laws which men may avoid and yet be wicked enough Heretofore men used to be restrained from great and scandalous vices by shame and fear of disgrace and would astain from many sins out of regard to their honour and reputation among men But men have hardned their faces in this degenerate Age and those gentle restraints of modesty which governed and kept men in order heretofore signifie nothing now adays Blushing is out of fashion and shame is ceased from among the Children of men But the Sacrament did always use to lay some kind of restraint upon the worst of mer and if it did not wholly reform them it would at least have some good effect upon them for a time If it did not make men good yet it would make them resolve to be so and leave some good thoughts and impressions upon their minds So that I doubt not but it hath been a thing of very bad consequence to discourage men so much from the Sacrament as the way hath been of late years And that many men who were under some kind of check before since they have been driven away from the Sacrament have quite let loose the reins and prostituted themselves to all manner of impiety and vice And among the many ill effects of our past confusions this is none of the least That in many Congregations of this Kingdom Christians were generally difused and deterred from the Sacrament upon a pretence that they were unfit for it and being so they must necessarily incur the danger of unworthy receiving and therefore they had better wholly to abstain from it By which it came to pass that in very many Places this great and solemn Institution of the Christian Religion was almost quite forgotten as if it had been no part of it and the remembrance of Christ's death even lost among Christians So that many Congregations in England might justly have taken up the complaint of the Woman at our Saviour's Sepulchre they have taken away our Lord and we know not where they have laid him But surely men did not well consider what they did nor what the consequences of it would be when they did so earnestly dissuade men from the Sacrament 'T is true indeed the danger of unworthy receiving is great but the proper inference and conclusion from hence is not that men should upon this consideration be deterred from the Sacrament but that they should be affrighted from their sins and from that wicked course of life which is an habitual indisposition and unworthiness St. Paul indeed as I observed before truly represents and very much aggravates the danger of the unworthy receiving of this Sacrament but he did not deter the Corinthians from it because they had sometimes come to it without due reverence but exhorts them to amend what had been amiss and to come better prepared and disposed for the future And therefore after that terrible declaration in the Text Whosoever shall eat this bread and drink this cup of the Lord unworthily is guilty of the body and bloud of the Lord he does not add therefore let Christians take heed of coming to the Sacrament but let them come prepared and with due reverence not as to a common meal but to a solemn participation of the body and bloud of Christ but let a man examine himself and so let him eat of that bread and drink of that cup. For if this be a good reason to abstain from the Sacrament for fear of performing so sacred an action in an undue manner it were best for a bad man to lay aside all Religion and to give over the exercise of all the duties of piety of prayer of reading and hearing the Word of God because there is a proportionable danger in the unworthy and unprofitable use of any of these The prayer of the wicked that is of one that resolves to continue so is an abomination to the Lord. And our Saviour gives us the same caution concerning hearing the Word of God take heed how you hear And St. Paul tells us that those who are not reformed by the Doctrine of the Gospel it is the savour of death that is deadly and damnable to such persons But now will any man from hence argue that it is best for a wicked man not to pray nor to hear or read the Word of God lest by so doing he should endanger and aggravate his condemmation And yet there is as much reason from this consideration to persuade men to give over praying and attending to God's Word as to lay aside the use of the Sacrament And it is every whit as true that he that prays unworthily and hears the Word of God unworthily that is without fruit and benefit is guilty of a great contempt of God and of our blessed Saviour and by his indevout prayers and unfruitfull hearing of God's Word does further and aggravate his own damnation I say this is every whit as true as that he that eats and drinks the Sacrament unworthily is guilty of a high contempt of Christ and eats and drinks his own Judgment so that the danger of the unworthy performing this so sacred an action is no otherwise a reason to any man to abstain from the Sacrament than it is an Argument to him to cast