imitation not to be Adored for Religion that at the Communion Table they were named but not Invocated And again you see the head of the most renowned Empire stooping with his Diadem and Praying at the Sepulchre of Peter the Fisherman namely 't is to God himself that he Prayes though at the Tomb of Peter Epiphanius reproving as he calls it the Womens Hoeres 79. adver Collyridian Heresie who were wont to offer up a Cake to the Blessed Virgin hath these words Let Mary be in Honour but let the Father and the Son and the Holy Ghost be Worshipped and to shew us what a very ill opinion he had of that at least Superstitious practice he six times repeats in that tract Marian medies â—roskyneito Let no Man Adore Mary To name no more Tertullian in his Apology for the Apol. c. Sect. 30. 2. 3. Christians thus expresses himself after he had set down the many great Blessings the Christians thought themselves ever oblidged to beg for their Emperours As long life and Valiant Armies and a Faithful Senate and Loyal Subjects and a peaceable Reign these things saith he I may not Pray for from any other but from him of whom I know I shall obtain them because both it is he who is alone able to give and I am he to whom it appertains to obtain that which is requested being his Servant who observe him alone VII That the Doctrine and Practice of Saint-Invocation is Impious and Idolatrous THis I think will be fully made out from these three particulars 1. This ascribes to Angels and Saints the Attributes and Perfections that are solely proper and peculiar to God viz. his Omniscience and Omnipresence for not only when Mental Prayers as the Church of Rome directs but since the blessed Spirits above can't be supposed to espouse the cause of an insincere Votary when vocal Prayers also are offered up to them it supposes them Privy to the very thoughts and acquainted with the Hearts of Men again when innumerable Prayers and Supplications from Millions of places at the greatest distance from one another are at the same time immediately put up to them it supposes in like manner that they are present in all places and at the same time can give Audience to all their Petitioners Now what more or greater can be said of God Is not this that infinite knowledge that Omnipresent Power and never absent Nature that the Scriptures solely attribute to the Creator of all things and have denied to any of the highest Form of the Creatures And although I will not undertake to describe to you the exact bounds aad Measures of the Angelical Nature and Perfections how perspective their Knowledge is How piercing their understanding How swift their motion Yet sure I am that neither they nor any other the most elevated part of Gods Creation can by their Natural Power know the Hearts of Men and be in all places at one instant of time It is God alone whose understanding is infinite who looks down from Heaven beholds all the wayes of the Sons of Men He even he knoweth all the Hearts of the Children 1 King 8. 27. of Men. 'T is he that seeth in secret And God challenges it as a peculiar to himself The Heart is Matt. 6. 4. Jerem. 17. 9. 10. deceitful above all things and disperatly Wicked who can know it I the Lord search the Heart and try the Reins By this Argument the Fathers Triumph'd over the Arrians and Macedonians in proving the Divinity of the Son and the Holy Ghost which yet would have been no Argument at all had not this Knowledge been an Incommunicable perfection in the Divine Nature But 't is said that 't is God indeed that only Naturally and of himself knows the Hearts o Men but this hinders not but that others his Saints and Angels may know them by Communication from him viz. Either by Revelation from God or by the Beatifick Vision Seeing all things in God who sees all things In answer to this not to mention how it contradicts the express words of Scripture which without any distinction or limitation does as plainly assert as words can do it That God only knows the Heart not to mention the many disputes the Romanists have among themselves which way is to be chosen as the most probable and after what manner is either way this knowledge is derived and past from God to them these things may be said 1. That God hath no where declared that he hath Communicated this Priviledge and Prerogative of his Nature to Saints and Angels or that he does any way make visible or known to them the Hearts and the Requests of Men and now if what is not of Faith is Sin we having no Text of Scripture to Build our Faith upon in this particular must of necessity Sin in Praying to them on that supposition and commit that very sin too which we doubt whither we so doing commit or no nay the silence of the Scripture in this particular has in a manner determined the point and we may conclude that the most jealous God has reserved the Honour of Intimation to himself alone since he has no where given us the least hint or intimation of leave to pray to them 2. We are informed in Scripture that the Saints departed do not particularly know or mind what 's done 2 Chron. 34. 28. here below God tells Josiah thou shalt be gathered to thy Grave in Peace neither shall thine Eyes see the Evil I will bring upon this place The Dead know not any thing that is of the affairs of this World saith the Eccl. 9. 5. Preacher His Sons come to Honour and he kneweth it not and they are brought low and he perceiveth it not of them sayes Job of Man in the other State When 2 Kings 2. 9. Elijah was about to be taken up into Heaven he thus spake to Elisha Ask what thou wilt before I am taken from thee Strongly implying that when he was once gone 't was in vain to ask any thing of him Elijah was immediately taken up into Heaven made no stay by the way in Limbo as the Romanists themselves agree being in Heaven his Love to Elisha could not be forgot nor his Interest in God lessened but rather both by being exalted thither very much encreased and augmented so that no reason can be given why he should limit and fix his making his desires known to him to the time of his abode with him on Earth but only this his perswasion that in the other State he should not be capable to hear his requests and so all his future addresses to him would be ineffectual To these we may add that known place in Isaiah Abraham doth not know us and Israel is ignorant of us from whence St. Austin concludes that if those great Men Isa 63. 16. and Founders of their Nation were ignorant of what was done in after Ages to their
not this the declared reason why the Church of Rome gives Religious Worship to Angels and departed Saints Because of a middle sort of worth and excellency that is in them that 's neither infinite as the divine nor so low as the humane but Spiritual and Supernatural whereby approaching near to the Divinity they have great interest in the Court of Heaven and ought as Celsus said of their Daemons to be Prayed unto to be favourable and propitious to us So exact you see is the parallel betwixt them Now against this Daemon-Worship the Fathers replied that whatever great and supernatural excellencies were to be found in the Spirits above ought indeed to have an Acknowledgement and Honour paied to them both in Mind and Action proportioned and Commensurate to such excellencies but yet they were not to be esteemed inwardly as Gods nor to be Worshipp'd with any outward Act of Religious Worship be it erecting Altars making Vows or puting up Prayers to them as if they were such For all and every part of that was solely due to God and not to be given to any the highest Created Excellency As you may see their minds more fully in the next particular 4. The Fathers positively assert that none but God ought to be invocated And the first I shall mention is that advice Ign. Ep. ad Philadelph which Ignatius gave the Virgins of his time not to direct their Prayers and Supplications to any but only to the Blessed Trinity Oh ye Virgins have Christ alone before your Eyes and his Father in your Prayers being enlightned by the Spirit Irenaeus in his first Book taking notice of some Persons who had entertained strange fancies concerning the Power of Angels accordingly gave Divine Worship to them tells us plainly that the Doctrine and Practice of the Iren l. 2. c. 57. Church in his dayes was far otherwise and that throughout the World it did nothing by Invocation of Angels nor by Incantations but purely and manifestly directs her Prayers to God who made all and calls upon the Name of our Lord Jesus Christ Feuardentius in his notes upon the place would have the words of the Father to be understood only of Prayers made by Evil Spirits and angels but then why did not the Father express it so Why does he exclud all Angels without distinction from Divine Worship when he sayes the whole Church every where called only upon God and his Son Christ Jesus Eusebius in his History hath set down a long Prayer of the of the Holy Martyr Polycrap which he uttered at the time of his Suffering wherein there is not any one Petition put up to Saints but every one directed to God through the Meditation of Christ closing his Prayer with Euseb l. 4. c. 15. this Doxology Therefore in all things I Praise thee I Bless thee I Glorify thee through the Eternal Priest Jesus Christ thy Beloved Son to whom with thee Oh Father and the Holy Ghost be all Glory now and for ever To which we may add what also is Recorded by the same Author that when the Church of Smyrna desired the Body of their Martyred Bishop to give it an Honourable Inteâ—ment and was denyed it by the Governour upon the unworthy suggestion of the Jews that they would Worship it they thus replied We can never be induced to Worship any other but Christ him being the Son of God we adore others as Martyrs and his sincere Disciples we worthily Love and Respect and that which here deserves a particular observation is what the Learned Primate of Armagh hath pointed out to us viz. that what in the Original Greek Sebein Religiously to Worship is in the Latin Edition that was wont to be read in all the Churches of the West rendred precem Orationis Ex passion M. S. 7. Kalend. Febr. in Bib. Eccl. Sarish Dom. Rob. Cotton impendere to impart the Supplication of Prayer The nexâ— Testimony I shall produce is that of Origen who is very full to this purpose in his Writings against Celsus he tells us We must endeavour to please God alone and labour to have him propitious to us procuring his good will with Godliness and all kind of Vertue and if Celsus will have us to procure the good will of any others after him that is God ovâ—â— all let him consider that as when the Body is moved the motions of the shadow thereof doth follow it so in like manner having God favourable to us who is over all it followeth that we shall have all his Friends both Angels and Spirits loving to us and whereas Celsus had said of the Angels that they belong to God and in that respect were to be Prayed unto that they may be favourable to us he thus sharply replies Away with Celsus's Council saying that we must Pray to Angels for we must Pray to him who is God over all and we must Pray to the Word of God his only begotten Son and the first born of all Creatures and we must intreat him that he as High Priest would present our Prayer unto his God and our God And when Celsus Objected that the Christians did not keep to their own rule of Praying to and Worshipping none but God since they gave the same Honour to Christ whom they knew to be a Man he replies that Christ was God as well as Man one with the Father and proves it from Miracles and Prophesies and Precepts that this Honour was given to him to be Worship'd as they Worship'd the Father Had Celsus Objected that the Christians Worship'd Angels and Saints departed it had been laid right and would have born hard upon them and he had inferred strongly that they might as well Worship their Inferiour Deities but Celsus Objects no such thing but only their Worshipping of Christ which Origen was well provided to answer and this is an evident proof that the Christians were not guilty of it Had there been but the least ground to suspect them for it it would have been so hugely serviceable to his cause and with so much force have rebounded back upon the Christians that 't is not to be imagined so industrious and spightfull an Adversary as Celsus would have omitted with the greatest Insult and Triumph to have laid it at their Door To these we might add the Suffrages of many more St. Cyprian who have written set Treatises of Prayer teaching us to regulate all our Prayers after that most perfect Pattern of our Lords and ever to direct our Petitions to our Heavenly Father only Gregory Nyssen saith we are taught to Worship and aktiston physin Cont. Eunom Tom. 2. Orat. 4. Oâ—at 3. Contr. Arrian De ver Relig. c. 55. de civit Dei l. 22. c. 10. Ep. 42. Adore that Nature only that 's uncreated Athanasius That God only is to be Worshipped that the creature is not to Adore the creature St. Austin sayes expresly that the Saints are to be Honoured for
were their Prayers which were offered up in vertue of their Sacrifice And therefore Isa 56. 7. Mat. 21. 13. 1 King 8. this is a peculiar name for the Temple that it was the House of Prayer Here GOD was more immediately present to hear those Prayers which were offered to him according to Solomons Prayer at the Dedication of the Temple It is true the devout Jews did pray to God where ever they were though at a great distance from the Temple whither in the land of Canaan or out of it but then there are two things which shew that relation their prayers had to the Temple Worship 1. That their stated hours of prayer were the hours of Sacrifice which plainly signified that they offered up their Prayers in conjunction with those Sacrifices which were at that time offered in the Temple and therefore that they prayed only to that GOD to whom they sacrified for we must consider that the constant morning and evening Sacrifices were not particular sacrifices but were offered for the whole Congregation of Israel and therefore every man had a share in them Hence the time of offering the Sacrifice is called the hour of Prayer Thus Peter and John went up into the temple at the hour of Prayer being the ninth hour that is the time of the Evening Sacrifice Hence are such expressions as that of the Psalmist Acts. 3. 1. Let my Prayer be set before thee as Incense and the lifting up of my hands as the Evening Sacrifice Nay it is most probable that when Jerusalem and the Temple were destroyed and the people carried captive into Babylon and the daily Sacrifice ceased yet the devout people observed the hour of Sacrifice for the prayers Thus Daniel prayed three times a day which most likely were Evening and Morning and Noon Where Evening and Morning no doubt signifie the time of the Evening and Morning Dan. 6. 10. Psal 55. 17. Sacrifice and we are told that the Angel Gabriel came to Daniel while he was praying and touched him about the time of the Evening oblation But 2ly besides Dan. 9. 21. this when they offered up their Prayers to GOD in other parts of the Nation or in other Countries they prayed towards Jerusalem and the Temple of God as we now lift up our eyes to Heaven where God dwells Thus Solomon in his Prayer of Dedication does not only beg of God to hear those Prayers which were made towards it as the words must signifie in several places In general he prays Hearken thou to the Prayer of thy servant and of the people Israel when they shall pray 1 King 8. 30. towards this place The word in the Hebrew may signifie both in and towards this place and includes both as appears from the following instances which refer both to Prayers made in the Temple and to those prayers which were made towards the Temple by persons who were at a distance Thus in what ever part of the Nation they wanted rain which might be at a great distance from Jerusalem they were to pray towards this place ver 35. The same was to be done in case of Famine and Pestilence c. or if they were besiged in any of their Cities when they could not go to the Temple to pray Nay What Prayer or supplication soever shall be made by any man or by all thy people Israel which shall know every man the plague of his vers 37. ver 39. own heart and spread forth his hands towards this house then hear thou in Heaven thy dwelling place and forgive Thus when they went out to battle they were to pray towards the City of Jerusalem and towards the Temple vers 44. And when they were carried captive into their enemies land they were to pray to God toward the land which God had given them towards the Holy City and towards the Temple And accordingly it was the constant practice vers 48. of Daniel when he was in Babylon to pray three times a day to God with his windows open in his chamber toward Dan. 6. 10. Jerusalem So that though the Temple were not the only place where they might lawfully pray to God yet all their Prayers were to be directed to the Temple and receive their vertue and acceptation from their relation to the Temple and the Temple-worship This was a standing rule for the whole Jewish Nation that whenever they prayed they offered up their prayers in the Temple or towards it and this is generally observed by them to this day For the reason why they generally now turn themselves toward the East when they pray is not out of any respect to the rising of the Sun but because they live in Western Countries and so by turning to the East they look towards Jerusalem and the place where the Temple stood And this is as plain an evidence that all Buxtorfii Synag Jud. p. 222. their prayers as well as Sacrifices were to be offered onely to that GOD who dwelt in the Temple And therefore as they are commanded to pray to God and this is made the peculiar attribute of God that he heareth Psalm 65. 2. Josh 23. 7. prayers and therefore unto him shall all flesh come so they are expresly commanded not to make mention of the name of the Heathen gods that is not to pray to them the prayers of the Heathens consisting of a frequent repetition of the names of their gods as we see in the priests of Baal who cried from morning till evening saying O Baal hear us 1 Kin. 18. 26 Thus the Jews were commanded to bring all their Vows first Fruits Tythes and offerings to the Temple which is a plain sign to whom they were offered The Seventh-day-Sabbath was a sign that they worship'd that God who created the world in six days and rested on the seventh and delivered them from their Egyptian Bondage and gave them rest in that good Land both which reasons are assigned by Moses and therefore God command them by the prophet Ezekiel Nallow my sabbaths Ezek. 20. 20 and they shall be a sign between me and you that ye may know that I am the Lord your God They had but three solemn Festivals every year and they were all in remembrance of the great Works of God and all the Males were to go up to Jerusalem to keep these Feasts and therefore alâ— these were the Feasts of the Lord Jehovab And as they were to pray only to God so they were onely to swear by his Name which is another part of Religious Worship and therefore to swear by the Lord of Hosts is called Deut. 10. 21 Isa 12. 1â— the Language of Canaan So that all the parts of the Jewish Worship were appropriated to the Lord Jehovah he was the only object of their dread and fear and religious Adorations And when we consider that God had chosen them to be a peculiar people to himself that the
then the whole Christian worship which was signified and prefigured by these Types must be peculiar and appropriate to the one Supreme GOD. As for instance I have already proved at large that the Jews were to worship but one God because they had but one Temple to worship in and all their worship had some relation or other to this one Temple and therefore all their worship was appropriated to that one God whose Temple it was now we know Gods dwelling in the Temple at Jerusalem was only a Type and Figure of Gods dwelling in Humane Nature upon which account Christ calls his body the Temple and St. John tells us That the word was made flesh and dwelt among us es kenosen en hemin tabernacled 2 Joh. 19. 21. 1 Joh. 14. 2 Coloss 3. among us as God formerly dwelt in the Jewish Tabernacle or Temple and St. Paul adds That the fulness of the Godhead dwelt in Christ bodily somatikos realy substantially as an accomplishment of Gods dwelling by Types and Figures and shadows in the Jewish Temple Now if all the Jewish worship was confined to the Temple or had a necessary relation to it as I have already proved and this Temple was but a figure of the Incarnation of Christ who should dwell among us in humane nature then all the Christian worship must be offered up to God through Jesus Christ as all the Jewish worship was offered to God at the Temple for Christ is the only Temple in a strict and proper sense of the Christian Church and therefore he alone can render all our services acceptable to God So that God who is the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ is the only object of our worship and Christ considered as God Incarnate as God dwelling in humane nature is the only Temple where all our worship must be offered to GOD that is we shall find acceptance with God only in his name and mediation we must worship no other Beeing but only the Supreme God and that only through Jesus Christ Thus under the Law the Priests were to interceed for the people but not without Sacrifice their Intercession was founded in making atonement and expiation for sin which plainly signified that under the Gospel we can have no other Mediator but only him who expiates our sins and interceeds in the merits of his Sacrifice who is our Priest and our Sacrifice and therefore our Mediator as St. John observes If any man sin we have 1 Joh. 2. 1 2. an Advocate with the Father Jesus Christ the righteous and he is the propitiation for our sins The Law knew no such thing as a Mediator of pure intercession a Mediator who is no Priest and offers no Sacrifice for us and therefore the Gospel allows of no such Mediators neither who mediate only by their prayers without a Sacrifice such Mediators as the Church of Rome makes of Saints and Angels and the Virgin Mary but we have onely one Mediator a Mediator of redemption who has purchased us with his Blood of whom the Priests under the Law were Types and Figures Thus under the Law none but the High Priest was to enter into the Holy of Holies with the blood of the Sacrifice now the Holy of Holies was a Type of Heaven Heb. 1. 12. and therefore this plainly signified that under the Gospel there should be but one High Priest and Mediator to offer up our Prayers and Supplications in Heaven He and He only who enters into Heaven with his own Blood as the High Priest went into the Holy of Holies with the blood of the Sacrifice There may be a great many Priests and Advocates on Earth to interceed for us as there were under the Law great numbers of Priests the Sons of Aaron to attend the Service and Ministry of the Temple but we have and can have but one Priest and Mediator in Heaven Whoever acknowledges that the Priesthood and Ministry of the Law was Typical of the Evangelical Priesthood and Worship cannot avoid the force of this argument and whoever will not acknowledge this must reject most of St. Paul's Epistles especially the Epistle to the Hebrews which proceeds wholly upon this way of reasoning Now this manifestly justifies the worship of the Church of England as true Christian worship for we worship One God through one Mediator who offered himself a sacrifice for us when he was on Earth and interceeds for us as our High Priest in Heaven which answers to the One Temple and the One High Priest under the Law But though the Church of Rome does what we do worship the Supreme GOD through Jesus Christ yet she spoils the Analogie between the Type and the Antitype the legal and Evangelical worship by doing more when she sends us to the Shrines and Altars of so many several Saints surely this cannot answer to that one Temple at Jerusalem where God alone was to be worshipped there are many Temples and Mercy-seats now as there are Shrines and Altars of Saints and Angels by whose Intercession we may obtain our requests of God When she advances Saints and Angels to the Office of Mediators and Intercessors in Heaven this contradicts the Type of One High Preist who alone might enter into the Holy of Holies which was a type of Heaven for there is some difference between having one Mediator in Heaven and there can be no more under the Gospel to answer to the Typical High Priest under the Law and having a hundred Mediators in Heaven together with our Typical High Priest To have a Mediator of pure Intercession in Heaven who never offered any Sacrifice for us cannot answer to the High Priest under the Law who could not enter into the Holy of Holies without the blood of sacrifice The High Priests entering but once a year into the Holy of Holies which was typical of Christs entering once into Heaven to interceed for us cannot be reconciled with a new succession of Mediators as often as the Pope of Rome pleases to canonize them So that either the Law was not typical of the state of the Gospel or the Worship of Saints and Angels which is so contrary to all the types and figures of the Law cannot be true Christian Worship Sixthly I shall add but one thing more that Christ and his Apostles have made no alteration in the object of the worship appears from hence that de facto there is no such Law in the Gospel for the worship of any other Beeing besides the One supreme God There is a great deal against it as I have already shewn but if there had been nothing against it it had been argument enough against any such alteration that there is no express positive Law for it The force of which argument does not consist meerly in the silence of the Gospel that there is nothing said for it which the most Learned Advocates of the Church of Rome readily grant and give their reasons such as they are why
would inquire into the lawfulness of such things as appertain to Divine Worship we must apply our selves to the Holy Scripture being in matters of that nature to determine of Right and Wrong Lawful and Unlawful according to the Directions Commands and Prohibitions of it If we would be satisfied about their Expedience we must consider the Nature Ends and Use of what we inquire about This therefore is a proper method for the Resolution of the foregoing Question But because the Apostle in his Discourse upon this Subject 1. Corinthians 14. doth argue from the ends and use of the several Offices belonging to Divine Worship and because the like Order may give some light and force to what follows I shall first of all I. Treat of the Ends for which Divine Worship and the several Offices of it were instituted II. Consider whither those Ends may be attained when the Worship is performed in a Tongue not understood III. Whither the worship so performed as to leave those ends unattainable will be accepted by GOD IV. I shall consider the Apostle's Discourse upon this Argument and whither it can be reasonably concluded from thence That Divine Worship so administred as not to be understood of the people is unlawful I. In the first of these the Masters of Controversie in the Romish Church do proceed with great tenderness and no little obscurity For would we know what the Worship is they would have in an Unknown Tongue they answer it is the publick only they defend For as for private saith one It is lawful for P. Sancta not in Epist P. Molinaei c. 17. n. 6. T. G. First reply to Dr. Stelingfleet sect 3. every one to offer his lesser Prayers to GOD in what Tongue soever he pleaseth And saith another All Catholicks are â—aught to say their private Prayers in their Mother Tongue As if it were possible to assign such a vast difference betwixt them when the Dispositions Reasons and Ends required and intended are the same that what is lawful expedient and necessary in the one is unlawful inexpedient and unnecessary in the other Or as if the saying private Prayers in Latin was never heard of practiseâ— or encouraged in their church Again Would we understand to what purposes the Divine Offices do serve and whither the Edification Instruction and consolation of the people be not some of those Ends. Bellarmin answers De verbo l. 2. c 16. Sect obj quart 1. That the principal end of Divine Offices is not the instruction or consolation of the People but a worship due to GOD from the Church As if there were no regard to be had to the special ends of those Offices such as the Instruction and Consolation of the people Or as if GOD could be honoured by that Worship where those ends are not regarded 2. The Rhemists add That Prayers are not made to teach make learned or increase knowledge Annot. 1. cor 14. P. 63. though by occasion they sometimes instruct but their especial use is to offer our Hearts desires and Wants to God c. As if there were no Offices in God's Worship appointed for Instruction and increase of Knowledge and which are performed in an Unknown Tongue amongst them as well as Prayer Or as if their Adversaries did either deny it to be the special use of Prayer To offer our hearts c. to God Or did affirm that the special use of it is To teach make learned and increase knowledge as they with others Censur proposit Erasmi prop. 5. Poncet dis cord de L' Auvis ch 1. do falsly suggest and would fain have believed But to set this in a better light and that we may understand what are the Ends and Uses for which Divine Worship was appointed and after what manner they are to be respected It is to be observed 1. That Divine Worship in its first notion respects God as its Object and so the end of it in general is the giving Honour to him by sutable Thoughts Words and Actions 2. That he hath appointed several wayes and Offices by which he will be so honoured and in which as the Honour doth terminate in him so there redounds from thence benefit to the church 3. That the Benefits redound to the church according to the nature of those Offices and the special Ends they were designed unto As the Word of God is for our instruction and comforâ— c. The Lord's Supper for the increase of Faith in God and love to him through Jesus Christ The praising of God is to raise our Affections and to make us more sensible of his goodness and to quicken us in our duty The special use of Prayer that I may use the Words forecited Rhem. Annot. is to offer up our Hearts Wants and Desires to God and that by conversing with him Part. 4. c. 2. Sect 7. 8. we may be the more ardently excited to the love and adoration of him as the Trent Catechism doth express it 4. That those Offices are to be performed so as may effectually answer those Ends and as we may receive the benefits they were appointed for From whence it follows 5. That if the Offices of Divine Worship are to be performed by Words those Words and that Tongue in which they are administred must be such as will not obstruct but promote and in their nature are qualified to attain those Ends. And if those Ends cannot be aâ—â—ained without the Tongue in which the service is performed be understood It makes that means as necessary in its kind as the End and it is as necessary that the Tongue used for those Ends in Divine Worship be understood as that those Ends should be respected or that there should be a Tongue used at all For it is not God but Man that is immediately respected in the Words since there is no more need of Words to GOD then of Words that are vulgarly understood and so it is not for him but Man that this Tongue or that or indeed that any Tongue at all is used And if it be requisite that there be a a Tongue and Words used in publick Worship and which all persons present are supposed to joyn in and receive benefit by then it is as necessary for the same reason to use Words significant and understood as to De Doct. Christ l. 4. c. 19. use any Words at all For saith S. Austin what doth the soundness of speech profit if not followed with the Understanding of the â—earer seing there is no reason at all for our speaking if what we speak is not understood by them for whom that they might understand we spoke at all From what hath been said we may be able to vindicate such Arguments of the Protestants Divine service in a known and vulgar Tongue as were taken from the Ends of worship against the replyes made to them by their adversaries of the Romish Church As 1. The Protestants argue in general that
their Addresses to one Saint rather then to another according as in this World they were famous either for some eminent Grace shining in them or for some strange cure or extraordinary deliverance wrought by them but onlie that they believe and trust that those who did such great things on Earth are much more willing and able to do them now they are in Heaven where while other Graces cease Charity and Beneficence are perfected and abide for ever Thus because St. Roch was signally Charitable in assisting those who were infected with the plague therefore do they call upon him in times of infection because St. Appollonia had all her Teeth struck out for her undaunted Confession of the Faith of Jesus therefore do they fly to her for ease against the Rage of Teeth because St George was by profession a Souldier and renowned for wonderful Atchievements therefore have they recourse to him for assistance against Enemies 'T is true was it Lawfull to Address to any at all this might be a sufficient reason why they Address to this rather then to another Saint because his or her former actions or sufferings do best suit and befit their present case but being not sure that these and such like Canoniz'd Saints of the Romish Church are Saints in Heaven being sure if they are they can't hear us nor know our particular State much less bestow health and deliverance upon us whilest we Love and Honour the Memory of Saints indeed we ought to call only upon God who only is a present help in time of need and the Saviour of them that put their trust in him But to put this out of doubt it will not be amiss to set down some of their forms of Devotion to Saints departed And here not to rake for them in some obscure Authors that have privately stole into the World I shall need go no farther then the present Roman Breviary Corrected and Published by the Decree and Order of the Council of Trent The blessed Virgin is there Invocated in the Feast of the Assumption For strength against Enemies and in the Hymn frequently used in her Office she is not only called the Gate of Heaven but intreated to loose the bonds of the Guilty to give light to the blind to drive away our evils to obtain good things for us and to shew her self to be a Mother that is as the Mass-Book of Paris 1634 interprets it * O foelix puerpera nostra pians scelera jure matris impera Redemptori Dall de cultu Latin lib. 3. c. 4. p. 359. Not denied by Natalis Alexander though he answers this Citation of Dalle only sayes Nec est ab ecclesâ—â— probata quibusdam tantâ—m missalibus â—lim inserâ—â— est Hisâ— Eâ—â—l sec 5. dissert 5. p. 343. 347. in right of a Mother to command her Son In another place she is sued to for help to the Miserable for strength to the Weak for comfort to the Afflicted and that all that Celebrate her Festivals may feel her assistance And but that I said I would not hunt for matter I could send you to Authors of theirs and not of the least note where we may read such Blasphemy as this †Biel. in Can. mis sect 80. That God hath given the Virgin Mary half of his Kingdom * Salmeroâ— in Tim. 1. 2. disc 8. That the Prayers made to and by all Saints are better then those made by Christ †Carol. scrib in Amph. hon Com. p. 29. Châ—â—â— exemp Invocat Sanct. p. 146. That the Mothers Milk is equally to be esteemed with the Sons Blood This you may take for a tast of that Hyperdulia that super-refin'd service which they put up to the blessed Virgin and yet that to the Apostles and other Saints of less magnitude comes not much behind it St. Peter is intreated by the power given to him To hear their prayers to unty the bonds of their iniquity and to open the Gates of Heaven all the Apostles to absolve them from their sins by their command to heal all their spiritual maladies and to encrease their vertues St. Andrew is supplicated for patience to bear chearfully the Cross of Christ St. Francis for deliverance from the drudgery and bondage of sin St. Brigit for Wisdom against the snares of the World St. Nicholas for courage against the assaults of the Devil St. Agnes for the chiefest of Graces that of Charity and St. Catharine for all Graces We are taught to pray to be delivered from Hell and to be made partakers of Heaven by their merits to fly to them as our Patrons and Advocates to put confidence in their intercessions Breviar â—â—ss and to ascribe our mercies and deliverances to their Power and Interest in God In the office of Visitation of the Sick the Priest laying his right hand upon Rituâ—l de Visit Infirm the head of the Sick Person prayes that Jesus the Son of Mary and Saviour of the World would for the Merits and Intercession of his Apostles Peter and Paul and all saints be gracious Merciful to him in another place in the same office that through the intercession of the blessed Virgin all saints he might obtain Eternal-Life these are enough but I Merits and intercessione S. S. Ritual Rom. de Sacram. poenit cannot omit one more which is a flower indeed in the office about the Sacrament of Penance there is found this remarkable Prayer The Passion of our Lord Jesus Christ the Merits of the blessed Virgin Mary and of all saints and whatsoever good thou hast done and whatsoever Evil thou hast suffered be to thee for the remission of sins the encrease of grace and the reward of Eternal Life And now let the Reader judge if this be not to give the Creature that Worship that 's due only to the Creator and to seek to obtain those blessings from finite Beeings and through their procurement which only Almighty God and his blessed Son Christ Jesus can give unto Men. 3. 'T is the Doctrine of the church of Rome that Mental Prayers as well as Vocal are to be put up to Voce vel mente Supplicare Saints departed So the Trent-Council decreed so their Bishops and Pastors are enjoyned to teach the People and so they practise this being a form of Prayer to Saints in frequent use amongst them With the desire of our Hearts we pray unto you regard the ready service of our minds So that according to them Saints departed do not only hear our Prayers but know our Hearts also and indeed this is necessarily implied in every Prayer that 's made to them viz. That they not only hear the Prayer but know the disposition of the Heart from whence it proceeds otherwise the Hypocritical Supplicant must be supposed as likely to obtain their favour as the Sincerest Votary 4. They not only Pray to them with Mental and Vocal Prayer but They confess their sins to
Militant in general but in particular for those whose persons and conditions were well known to them on Earth and these are cunningly shufled in by the Romish Doctors as proofs for invocation of them with a design to impose on the unwary vulgar who are supposed not to take notice of the difference but 't is a wonder if they should not for 't is wide enough betwixt their Praying for us and our Praying to them Neither is this the only instance wherein those cunning Sophisters play this game First alter the Nature of the Question and then where they have no Adversary to Triumph in demonstrating the truth of it If the Question be whither the Bishop of Rome be the Supreme head of the Church and has an absolute Jurisdiction and Monarchy over all other Bishops and Churches they shall bring Bellar. de Rom. Pont. l. 2. c. 15. 16. you a number of Testimonies out of both Greek and Latin Fathers to prove St Peter had a Primacy of Honour and Authority If the be Question be whither the Bread and Wine in the Sacrament be Substantially turned into the body Bellar. de Euchar l. 2 and blood of Christ they shall write a whole Volum to prove the Truth and Reality of Christ's presence in it which we own as well as they but after a Spiritual manner not corporally and by the way of Transubstantiation If the Question be about Purgatory a place prepared for the Purification of those Souls that depart hence not quite cleansed they shall alledge you Fathers and those St. Ambr. Hil. Orig. Hierom. c. not a few of unquestionable name to prove the utter Consumption of all things by Fire at the end of the World So here when the Question is whither we ought to Pray to Saints departed they bring innumerable Fathers to prove that the Saints departed do Pray for us hence we hear of that of St. Ignatius My spirit salutes you not only Epist ad Tral now but also when I enjoy God and of St. Chrysostom in his Oration to those that were to be Baptized Remember me when that Kingdom receives you 4. They produce the sayings and practices of some few in the Church for the general and allowed Doctrine and Practice of the whole Church If the story should be true that Justina a Christian Virgin did in great distress jointly supplicate the blessed Virgin with God and Christ does it follow that it was the practice of all to do so It cannot be denied but that many of the Fathers let slip in the heat of their Affection and Oration many unwary speeches to this purpose and that many otherwise good Men were guilty of this excess of Devotion to the Martyrs the many miracles God was pleased to work at the Memorials of the Martyrs for the Honour and Confirmation of the Faith reasonably begat a custom amongst Christians to resort to those places and there to offer their Prayers to God and thinking it may be they could not easily honour those too much whom God was pleased after so wonderful a manner to declare his esteem of from Praying to God at their Tombs they began to Pray to them themselves But now We are to distinguish betwixt the speeches of some particular Fathers and the general Doctrine of the Church betwixt what they express in Rhetorical strains to move affection and what they lay down in plain terms to inform the judgement betwixt what comes from them in the heat of their Discourses and popular Orations and what in cool and deliberate debates they set down for the truth of Christ it 's generally confest that the Fathers of times hyperbolize particularly S. Chrysostom and we must not take their flights of Fancy for the Doctrine of the Church We are to distinguish also betwixt what the Church did teach and allow and what she only tolerated and was forced to bear with the Bishops and Governours of the Church being many times engaged in weightier mattersin defending the Christian cause again Heathens and Hereticks were not alwayes at leisure to reform abuses and irregular practices but were forced too often to connive at those Faults which they had not time and opportunity to redress St. Austine complains much of this piece S. Aust de morib Eccles c. 31. tom 1 Epis 119. ad Janu. approbare non possum liberius improbare non andeo of superstition in his dayes that it had got such an head that the good Father wanted power to give a check to it I can no way allow them sayes he and yet I dare not freely reprove them lest I either offend some good Men or provocke some turbulenâ— spirits 5. They cite the practice of the Ancients Praying to God that for the Intercession of those Holy Men that had died in the Lord he would grant them their requests as a good proof for direct Praying to them The Ancients generally believing that the Saints and Martyrs in the future state did continually Pray to God in behalf of the Church Militant on Earth and some that their Souls were present at their Shrines and Tombs and did joyn their Intercessions with those Prayers of the Christians that were there offered up to God were wont in their addresses to mention the Martyrs and to beg the effects of their Intercessions that God would be moved by their supplications as well as their own to grant a supply of their wants and necessities but this is no more Praying to them then Moses may be said to Pray to Abraham Isaac and Jacob when he besought God to remember them in behalf of the People of Israel then we may be said to Pray for help to that part of the Church of Christ that is at a great distance from us when we desire God to hear the Prayers of his Church Catholick disperst throughout the whole World in the behalf of all Christian people that in all places call upon him Thus it 's said by the Historian that the Emperor Theodâ—sius Ruâ—â—in Hist l. 2. c. 33. when Eugeniâ— and his Complâ—ces raised that dangerous Rebellion against him repaired With his Clergy and Laity to the Oraâ—ories and Chapples and Sanctorum intercessione there lyâ—â—g Prostrate before the Tombs and Monuments of the Aposties and Marâ—yrs begged aâ—d and succour by intercession of the Saints He did not pray to any Saintâ—r Saints he did not beg help of them but supposing they Prayed with him and for him he prayed unto God that he would send him help for the sake of their Inâ—eâ—cession in his behalf This is also the meaning of those expressions in St. Austin that They ought to commend themselves to the Prayers of the Martyrs and frequent Aug. de Cur. promort c. 4. their tombs with a Religious Solemnity that they may become partakers of their Meâ—its and be helpt by their Prayers that is not by praying to them bâ—â— holding as was then commonly believed that when Christians came to
their Tombs the blessed Martyrs joyned their Supplications with them by Praying to God to afford them the benefit of their Prayers and that their Petitions might succeed the better for the sake of their requests put up in conjunction with their own The same account may be given of St. Basils words in his Oâ—aâ—â—on on the forty Martyrs He that is in distress flies to them and Baâ—il Hom. 20. in 40. Mart. he that is in Prosperity runs to them the one that he may have his condition changed the other that he may have his continued but now to fly and to run unto them signifies no more then to fly and run to the Churches and â—omb where they lie interr'd for so it follows here a Woman Praying for her Son is heard and here let us together with those Marâ—yrs pour forth our Prayers Supposing it's likely as was mentioned before that the Marâ—yrs Souls were continually about their Tombs and Prayed for all that came thither to Pray for themselves the Father exhorts Christians to go thither not to Pray to them but to joyn with them in Prayer unto God 6. They tell us of many miracles wrought by God upon addresses made to Saints and in this they triumph as an undeniable proof that God approves of such addresses God heareth not Sinners neither will he give his Glory to another and therefore were Prayers made to Saints a sin of that sacrilegious nature as to rob God of his Honour 't is not to be thought that he 'd give suchcountenance to them against himself as to Crown them with success To this it may be answered It 's certain that at first God was pleased upon the Prayers of Christians put up to himself to work many miracles for the Confirmation of the Faith but that any were wrought in answer to such Prayers that at those places were in after Ages made to the Martyrs is very uncertain August de Civit Dei l. 22. c. 8. and much to be suspected St. Austin names but two instances of this kind that I have met withal and at the same time he mentions them blasts their credit by telling us he had no undoubted Authority for the Truth of them St. Chrysostom not only declares that miracles in his time were ceased but hath wrot a Discourse on purpose â—o give us the reasons why they are so so that all the miracles the Church of Rome pretends to on this account are either delusions of Satan which God sometimes permits him to work for the Tryal of his people or else Cheats and Impostures performed by cunning Men of their own to wheedle and impose on the easie and credulous Vulgar V. That there is full and evident proof in Scripture against it IF that general rule of St. Austin's be allowed off that God is so to be Worship'd that is as to all the Aug. de consen Evang. l. 1. c. 18 Essential parts of it as he himself has commanded to be Worship'd then all those places of the Scripture that command us to direct our Prayers only to God and only in the Name and Mediation of Jesus Christ do with equal force forbid us to direct our Prayers to any other object or to use any other Name and Mediation Now Texts to this purpose are inumerable Oh thou that hearest Prayers unto thee shall all Flesh Psalm 65. 2 come Call upon me in the time of trouble and I will deliver Psalm 50. 15 thee Come unto me all ye that labour and are heavy laden and Matt. 11. 28 I will give you rest Whatsoever ye shall ask the Father in my name he will John 16. 23. give it you In every thing by Prayer and supplication with Thanksgiving Phil. 4. 6. let your requests be made known unto God If any of you lack Wisâ—om let him ask it of God who Jam. 1. 5. gives to all Men liberally c. How shall they call on him in whom they have not believed Rom. 10. 14. Now if none but God is to be believed in none but God is to be called upon These are very plain and convincing and no others need to be produced but because the Romish Authors have been practising upon some others endeavouring to obscure and weaken their evidence which are yet no less clear and full I shall bring them forth also and not only wip off the dust that has been cast upon thèm but restore them to their own natural sense and Prespicuity They are chiefly these Four The First is Luke 11. 2. When ye Pray say Our Father which art in Heaven c. For thine is the Kingdom the Power and the Glory for ever and ever Now the meaning of this precept must be one or both these two things either that we should use this form of words when we Pray or that we should compose all our Prayers after this pattern take which we will in either sense they oblidge us to direct all our Prayers to our Heavenly Father whose is the Kingdom Power and Glory whensoever we repeat this form of Prayer we address to God as the Object saying Our Father and if no Prayer is to be made but after this pattern then still it follows that no other ought to be the Object of them but he who is Our Heavenly Father 'T is generally concluded on all sides that in this absolute and perfect form of our Lord's Prayer is contained a Summary of what ever ought to be the subject matter of a Christians Prayer now since every Petition in it is directed immediately to God our Heavenly Father it follows that when ever we Pray we are not only to Pray for no other things but these blessings but also to begg them of no other Beeing but him But to put by the force of the Argument taken from this command of our Lord's When ye Pray say or Spenc. Script mistaken by Protest p. 57. after this manner Pray ye the Romanists tells us that 't is true we are to imitate this Prayer of Christ's in composing our own as to it's brevity and compendiousness as to the subject matter of it as to the the Catholickness of its Spirit oblidging us to Pray for others at the same time when we Pray for our selves saying Our Father but not as to the Object to whom our Prayers are to be addrest for then by the same Argument we may exclude the Second and Third Persons in the Blessed Trinity as well as Angels and Saints to this it 's no hard matter to give an answer And 1. It must be confest that the word Father in this Prayer is to be mean'd chiefly though not solely of the first person in the Sacred Trinity he being the Root and Fountain of the Deity and the prime Original of all our happiness may in special be called upon by us so far as is consistent with our acknowledgment of the equal Divinity of the other Two Persons for though