build upon another and a new Foundation though by them called old But Protestants agree in the same Foundations of Religion obey the same Civil Government in the same Person and same Fundamental and Civil Laws and yet some are separated for Sacrifice the Lot is cast upon them and great Rewards allowed to any that will do the Work Our Parliaments from 1673 to the last would have prevented this Ruine but for their sakes and their own Parliament is here taken Synecdochically they are now like to suffer Our last Parliaments were chosen with less Expence Debauchery Tumult or Faction than any we have known in our days Some had not been long in the House but they were driven out of their former Prejudices and Prepossessions by the clear and convincing Reasons and Debates of the House They were generally Men of the noblest Estates in their several Counties but acting as if they had nothing private or domestick and applying themselves to the Preservation of the King 's Sacred Person and of the Reformed Protestant Religion to which they are obliged by Obligations of an even lasting Effect Since their Dissolutions they cannot but be sensible how their Proceedings are confured and exposed and many either of them or of such as approved of them are put out of Commission and many that are most disaffected to them are either continued or fill up the Vacancies and these proceed upon contrary Reasons and Motives and run into contrary Methods What they would have composed and healed these do taking the opportunity of a long Vacancy of Parliament discompose with a greater Severity than at any time before And the Sufferings of the Nonconformists do clear the Members of Parliament from being Nonconformists or Fanaticks for if they were they should meet with the like Treatment and Usage and so the Sufferings of the Nonconformists serve as a Vindication of the Parliament from the censure of being such themselves All those noble and worthy Patriots are now the unsatisfied Spectators of an excessive Trouble and Charge if not irrecoverable Ruine of thousands of peaceable Subjects by which the King will never be enriched nor the Church united The inferior Rank are affected according to their differing measures of Reason and Sense of Religion and the publick Good The more Understanding and discerning enquire into the Cause of this Mischief which is the dissent of the Nonconformist's Judgment from some unnecessary and variable Impositions c. when ever the Government plenseth may be taken away without derogation of Power or loss of any Fundamental in Religion either of Belief or Practice or danger to the Government or Peace They cannot but say these matters of Dissention need not be They believe their own Senses they have neither seen nor heard of any Sedition or Tumult or Plot contrived among the Protestant Dissenters They know them to be Men of Abilities Piety Righteousness and Peace and have waded through the deep Waters of many Afflictions without sinking or drowning or overthrowing the Ship in which too many drive a Merchandize bring in Wealth and others fish for Men to save them from the bottomless Pit If they are unacquainted with the Nonconformist Preachers they are acquainted with their Hearers and know their Principles and Conversation and if they are not better they are no worse than other Men and cannot but be grieved that they lie at the Mercy of many that have no Vertue to commend them They that love Godliness and Righteousness in any in whom they believe or hope it is that are glad for the increase of Knowledg or Godliness by what Instrument soever and endeavour to be merciful as their heavenly Father is merciful are not and cannot be pleased with those Proceedings of ruining Men for Conscience These are not so subtile as to lay any great Weight upon the Distinctions which some Men invent to excuse the Severity The more unknowing and unconcern'd are in a maze wondring what kind of People these Nonconformists are what kind of thing this Nonconformity is but they know or hear that the Men are given to pray hear Sermons sing Psalms and other pious Exercises and live if not better yet no worse than many that go to Church And of these many have so much Sense that they think and say surely it is hard to drive honest Men's Cattel seize their Goods break open Houses for doing well And as many as love Ease and the World take their Ease and follow that Religion which is encouraged with Preferment and a Freedom from Charge and Molestation Some Zealots against Nonconformists are incensed against them as against Pharisees that pray to devour all as against seditious Persons and secret Traitors that want nothing but Opportunity as against the Authors of all our Unsettlements and Miseries These are for the King and who is against him These are for the Law as now established and no alteration which is to tie up the Power of the King as much as the Parliament for it is as much his Prerogative to abrogate old Laws when necessary as to make new These are for the Church of England and against all that are against it and what 's that for the Bishops and the Nonconformists never did as much as petition to take them down or diminish their Revenues they are for preaching in Churches and so are Nonconformists if they might for Allegiance to the King so are the Nonconformists for the King's Supremacy so are the Nonconformists for Ceremonies and Orders of the Church here they begin to disagree And for these things can you persecute your Brethren These Zealots are as erroneous for these things as any others are against them The most of our Conforming-Protestant Laicks are bound to bear Offices higher or lower in Cities Towns Hundreds Parishes The superiour Magistrates may forbear to break open Meetings for Religious Exercises or set others on much more to animate the Rabble to pluck down their Meeting-Houses there is no Law for it that we the unskilful in the Laws know or hear of The inferior are under Command but these are meant of only lawful Commands and legal Warrants And here is now a very displeasing Tragedy to be seen Here are Informers very Strangers in the Countries which they plague and molest that swear against some Persons by hear-say whom they do not know and these are the great Ministers of Justice they do little less nay sometimes no less than expect the Justices should take their Information without Examination of them at their time at the very nick when they please and not when the Justice pleaseth These are the Masters of the Justices themselves who must serve them or forfeit 50 l. to them and 50 l. more to him that can get it Some Justices are forward and officious in carrying on this Work of Reformation and Union they issue forth Warrants upon them that meet upon the Parish Officers that are slack some give out Warrants to break open
unordained rebellious and unreasonable Men disloyal disobedient against the King and all Government Decency and Order as if they were for all Sects and sorts of Religion allowing all Men to do what seemeth good to them But in this short Description of them you may find an Answer to vulgar and popular Objections against them and more fully spoken of in the two former Pleas. In the Second Plea p. 10 11 12. I have said that the Difference between the Nonconformist commonly but unduly and unsitly called Presbyterian and the Conformist is to be seen and gathered from the King 's own Declaration about Ecclesiastical Affairs which they would have submitted to if it had been turned into an Act of Parliament and the Act of Uniformity I shall now further enlarge upon that Notion and shew you what the King declared and what they would have accepted because many that think and speak hardly of them do not know how things stood at that time and what that Declaration is In the Year 1660 after that General Monk made Duke of Albemarle afterwards by the King declared himself for a Free-Parliament and by the Counsel and Assistance of the City of London restored the Members of the old Parliament that were shut out by some of the Army before ever they could bring about their Designs against the King's Life and there was a wise and good Council of State chosen many of the Royal Nobility and Gentry and some Divines put out a Declaration in which are these words And we do further declare that we intend by our quiet and peaceable Behaviour to testify our Submission to the present Power as it now resides in the Council of State in Expectation of the future Parliament upon whose Wisdom and Determinations we trust God will give such a Blessing as may produce a perfect Settlement both in Church and State This was subscribed by the Marquess of Dorchester and twenty Earls and Lords several Noble-Men about thirty two Baronets and Knights and between eighty and an hundred Gentlemen among whom is Mr. Roger L'Estrange then a Christian professing Reconciliation promising with the rest To speak one Language to be of one Name not Whig and Tory that all mention of Factions and Parties and all Rancor may be thrown in and buried like Rubbish under the Foundation These are the words of it but as Dr. Collings of Cambridg said once Then was then and now is now one Irish Bishop subscribed it and four Doctors of Divinity and the first of them was Dr. Morley the yet-living Lord Bishop of Winchester How gladly did all honest Men receive this Declaration as tending to a firm Reconciliation and afterwards to a lasting Union and universal Peace not so much as a name of Faction or Difference to be kept in memory neither did any suspect the meaning of burying all Factions and Animosities like Rubbish under the Foundation to be as now some Mens Actions and Writings explain it that Factions and Animosities do lie under the Foundation which is at this day shaken being so underlaid Faction and Animosity will not lie buried but rise and walk In April 1660 That hoped-for Parliament met and to the Speakers of both Houses His Majesties Letter from Breda April 14. 1660 pag. 6. His Majesty sent his Letter and Declaration from his Court at Breda in his Letter I read these Words relating to Religion And nothing can be proposed to shew our Zeal and Affection for it to which we will not readily consent and we hope in due time our Self to propose somewhat to you for the Propagation of it In his Declaration sent therewith are these words We do declare a Liberty to tender Consciences and that no Man shall be disquieted or called in question for differences of Opinion in matter of Religion which do not disturb the Peace of the Kingdom In October 25 1660 His Majesty was pleased to send out his Declaration concerning Ecclesiastical Affairs in which he was pleased to remember and repeat the fore-cited words of his Letter whereby it is clear that that which he had long in his Mind to propose for the Propagation of Religion was the Contents of this Declaration Adding in the next Sentence Pag. 4. And the truth is We do think our Self the more competent to propose and with God's Assistance to determine many things now in difference from the time we have spent and the Experience we have had in most of the Reformed Churches abroad And besides what is quoted out of it in the Second Plea pag. 65. he hath these words We must for the honour of all those of either Perswasion with whom we have conferred declare that the Professions and Desires of all for the advancement of Piety and true Godliness are the same their Professions of Zeal for the Peace of the Church the same of Affection and Duty to us the same They all approve of Episcopacy they all approve of a set Form of Liturgy and they all disprove and dislike the Sin of Sacriledg and the Alienation of the Revenue of the Church and if upon these excellent Foundations in submission to which there is such an Harmony of Affections any Superstructures should be raised to the shaking those Foundations and to the contracting and lessening the blessed Gift of Charity which is the vital part of Christian Religion we shall think our selves very unfortunate Pag. 8. We have not the least doubt but that the Present Bishops will think the present Concessions now made by us to allay the present Distempers very just and reasonable and will very cheerfully conform themselves thereto Thus the King declares his Confidence of the Bishops Compliance with his Proposal and Declaration which is thus contracted 1. Our purpose is to promote the Power of Godliness to encourage the Exercise of Religion both publick and private that the Lord's day be applied to holy Exercises that insufficient negligent and scandalous Ministers be not permitted in the Church to prefer none to be Bishops but Men of Learning Vertue and Piety that they be frequent Preachers c. 2. Because the Diocesses are too large we will appoint Suffragan Bishops for the due performance of the Work 3. No Bishops shall ordain or exercise any Jurisdiction without Advice of the Presbyters no Chancellour or Commissary shall decree any Excommunication or Absolution nor shall the Deacons exercise any Jurisdiction without the Advice and Assistance of six Ministers 4. That Cathedral Preferments shall be given to the most learned and pious Presbyters of the Diocess and that an equal number to those of the Chapter of the ablest Presbyters of the Diocess annually chosen by the major Vote of the Presbyters shall be always advising and assisting with those of the Chapter in all Ordinations and every the part of Jurisdiction and Censures 5. That Confirmation be solemnly performed by the Information and Consent of the Minister of the place who shall admit none to the Lord's Supper
best is they dissented from the Law without Impeachment of their Loyalty to the King for they would gladly have submitted to his Terms and could not obey the Law without any great Dishonour to the Legislative Power for they only dissent from a few Men who then could sway enow to do their Work They must not only do but they must subscribe Is that true of the same wise Lord Bacon Their urging Subscriptions to their own Articles is but lacessere irritare morbos Ecclesiae which otherwise would spend and crush themselves And it is true there are some which as I am perswaded will not easily offend by Inconformity who notwithstanding make some Conscience to subscribe For they know this note of Inconstancy Page 35. and Defection from what they have long held shall disable that Good which otherwise they would do When they have done this they must assent and consent c. Non consensum quaerit sed dissidium auget qui quod factis praestatur verbis exigit He seeketh not Union but Division which exacteth inwardly that which Men are content to yield in outward Action the same great Man still If some of the things themselves be small yet it is not a small thing that is required of us about them namely a Declaration and Subscription our unfeigned Assent c yea our quiet Submission to the use of them as tolerable sufficeth not as we apprehend Principles and Practices of the N.C. p. 13. c. saith the wise and holy Mr. Corbet I know all is sheltred under and fathered upon the Law but who invented who formed these things Had they the Catholick Spirit Wisdom Charity Authority of the whole Church in them to which all must yield Assent and to whom all must consent under peril they could not but know there were and would be Dissents and Disatisfactions they could not but know these Injunctions could not be so pleasing to the generality of the Kingdom and Church who had received the King's Declaration with such Applause and Gratulation And here may the fifteenth Query of the learned and judicious Sir Thomas Overbury come in Men are not Masters of their own Perswasions and can not change their Thoughts as they please He that believes any thing concerning Religion cannot turn as the Prince commands him or accommodate himself to the Law or his present Interests except he turn Atheist c. Reverend Dr. Purnet's Preface before the History of the Rights of Prince pag. 49. Whether to require Conformity in Practice where there is difference in Judgment be not to command a Man to act against Light and Conscience and consequently to sin and Query XXI c. 3. Whether it doth not imply that if a Man assent to all Articles of Faith to the Doctrine of the Apostles concerning the Authority of the Magistrate concerning Decency and Order and things indifferent and be otherwise fitted for preaching the Gospel and Administration of all Ordinances yet except he do assent and consent to all things required by some modern Bishops and Clergy-men it shall avail him nothing he shall be uncapable to officiate and whether these modern Church-men do not set up themselves above and exercise an Authority to dictate most absolute and higher than the Apostles did who were next to Christ himself 4. Suppose a Man be a lawfully ordained Minister i. e. by Bishops as many of the Nonconformists are or able and fit in respect of soundness of Faith Utterance Aptness to teach and be scrupulous of the Truth of some Proposition which is no Article of Faith or of some Ceremony and Modes of Practice is it not hard that for some Weakness of Understanding he cannot assent to what is formed by others not infallible that he should be uncapable of the Exercise of the Ministry and the Church deprived of his other Abilities for that Mistake Weakness or call it Error Our Saviour bore with his Disciples when he reproved them Are ye yet without Vndrstanding and did not turn them out 5. Whether Assent and Consent to some human Laws Rites and Ceremonies upon which neither Faith nor Unity depends be not hereby made more necessary for Exercise and Practice than the assenting to Articles of Faith or than preaching the Gospel or by consequence the Salvation of Immortal Souls It is true there is a vast difference in the nature of the things but as to Capacity and Incapacity to minister in the holy Office it is all one for a Man to refuse Assent and Consent to every thing as it is to an Article of the Creed 6. Or that Conformity to Order and the use of the Liturgy a monthly Sermon or a Homily is more for the Edification of the Church than diligent and constant preaching without a particular Assent to all every thing Which I will freely speak it can be affirmed by none but a Man that sets light by his own Salvation and never personally conversed with his own Flock or knows the Conditions of the Covenant of Grace or Eternal Life or the Practice of the Primitive Church Hitherto I have laboured to open the nature of the Cause of these Proceedings against our Protestant Brethren and it is their Nonconformity passive and active the first of which is a refusal of the modern Terms of Church-Freedom the second is a worshipping of God in Christ according to the Rule of the Holy Scripture as nearly as they can discern it and after the common either allowed or not disallowed manner of the Reformed Protestant Churches and particular this of England And in what they do they follow the same Rule and act from the same Principles which our first Reformers professed and their learned Defenders have maintained And three Questions shall take up the whole of what 's to follow 1. Whether they the Protestant Nonconformists justly deserve to be silenced suppressed and punished as they have been and are 2. Whether they are not at least to be permitted and indulged 3. Whether we ought not to unite and become one by removal or abating the things that divide and break us so that we may hold mutual and actual Communion in the same Exercises of Religion without fear of offending our Superiours thereby or any other So much hath not been spoken of the first Question in the Second Plea but that much more may be produced to encline if not draw the sensible Reader to the right side of the Question 1. It is clear that they are not deposed and prosecuted for such Crimes as were meritorious of Deposition in the Ancient Church by their Canons those Crimes were Fornication Perjury Theft Let a Bishop Presbyter or Deacon convicted of Fornication Perjury or Theft be deposed but with caution that he be not separated Canons called the Apostles Canons i. e. from the Communion of the Faithful as Balsamon expounds non segregetur adding a Reason for this Moderation that no Man be punished twice for the