that so they may watch over them as those that must giue account for them unto God Act. 20.28 Heb. 13.17 1 Pet. 5.1 4. V. Neither can the Churches or members thereof be so well instructed governed and edified in faith and mutuall loue as if this order and practise be observed For which see also the Scriptures aforesaid and the like But if the church in any city be more large as often commeth to passe and is usuall in great cities then that it can conveniently and ordinarily meet together in one place then is it to be considered whether it should not be distinguished and distributed into divers particular Churches or parishes Which may everie one of them severally haue their owne peculiar place of meeting together their owne Pastour other ministers Elders and Deacons their ovvn meetings and all publick actions duly orderly performed among themselues for the reasons here before alledged and other the like To vvhich end may also be observed hovv at Ierusalem vvhere the great Synedrion of the Iewes was by the Lord appointed to be yet notvvithstanding there vvere in that one city many Synagogues And all the Synagogues also had their ovvn rulers ministers as may appeare by such other Synagogues as are particularly spoken of in the Scriptures Mar. 5 22. with Luke 4 16 20 31 33. and 12 11. and 21 12. with Mat. 10 17. and 23 34 Luke 13 14. vvith Act. 13 14 15. and 18 4 7 8 17. Here moreover about the estate and distinction of churches are two things carefully to be observed First As did the seuen churches of Asia c. Rev. 1 2 and 3 chap. that all particular churches vvith their Pastors as is noted here before do stand immediately under Iesus Christ the Archpastour vvithout any other straunge ecclesiastical power and authoritie interposed betvveen whether it be of the Prelates as of Diocesan Provinciall or Oecumenicall Bishops or of their unlawfull usurping Synods or any such like invented by men and brought into the church Secondly that notwithstanding the estate distinction aforesaid yet all the churches and ministers of them should be alway ready and vvilling with their mutuall ayde counsel assistance and all lawfull maanes to help comfort advise strengthen and build up one another in the truth vvhich is according to godlines in Iesus Christ Ephes 4.4 16. Rom. 12 3 8. 1 Cor. 12 4 27. Col. 2 5 19. and 4 16 17. Act. 15 2 23. with Psal 12 2 3. Sal. Song 8 1. c.. And so to this end and in this manner may be had a lavvfull and profitable use of Synods Classes Assemblies or Councels for mutual help advise in cases of question controversie and difficulties about religion to as alvvaies it be provided that they doe not challenge or usurpe any unlavvfull jurisdiction or power over the particular churches or their pastours and governours to whom their ovvn povver under Christ the Lord is alvvay to be reserved and to be kept whole and intier according to the vvord of God Like as may be seen in all the churches planted by the Apostles and particularly in those seuen of Asia standing not farre asunder to whom Christ vvrote his several letters directed to the Angels or Pastors of everie of them in particular and not to any one of the churches or Pastors more theÌ„ another as having authoritie over the rest nor to any Diocesan Provinciall or Oecumeniall Bishops set over the churches and Pastors thereof Which kind of Prelacie Office government if it had ben ordeyned by Christ and planted by the Apostles in those churches there had novv ben fit and necessarie occasion specially when Christ vvrote about the corruptions of those churches both to haue blamed those Bishops for neglect of their duetie as he doth the Angels of the particular Churches and to haue directed his letters unto them as being the next chiefest in ecclesiasticall authoritie under him to oversee and governe those churches if then there had ben any such among them by the ordinance of Christ Rev. 2 1.8.12 18. and 3 1.7 14. compared vvith ch 1.4.12.13.20 and vvith the estate and constitution of all other churches planted by the Apostles For vvhich see the Scriptures here beâ—â—â—â— alledged pag. 250. And of this also see more hereafter in the fift 〈…〉 here follovving If any aske to whom then the churches shal be subject if there be no Diocesan or other like Prelates set over them I answer that the churches and all the Officers members thereof are to be subject to the Princes States and magistrates under whom they liue according as the Apostles doe teach us saying Let every soul be subject to the higher powers c. Reâ— 13.1 Submit your selues to every ordinance of man for the Lords sake whether it be to the king as supreme or unto governours as unto them that are sent by him for the punishment of evill doers and for the praise of them that doe vvell 1 Pet. 2 13 14. vvith Tit. 3 1. The magistrates are under the Lord to be the keepers of both the Tables of the Law of God To whom al persons ought to be subject euen for conscience sake to yeeld obedience unto them yet alwaies in the Lord and not against the Lord by any meanes Deut. 17 18 19 20 Rom. 13 1 7. with Mat. 22 21. Dan. 3 14 18. Act. 4 18 19 20. Rev. 12 10 11. CHAPTER III. Touching the right and power of particular churches VVHether †everie Church haue not right and power graunted by the Lord to chuse their ovvn Pastours other Ministers Elders Deacons and Deaconesses making choise of meet fit persons as also to * use the ministration of the vvord Sacraments Censures and vvhole ecclesiastical administration being careful stil to haue al things done according to the ordinance of God prescribed in his word Mat. 28 18 20. with 〈◊〉 Act 6 3 5. and 14 23. compared with Act. 1 15 23 26. and 2 41 42 46. 11 22. 15 22 25. 1 Cor. 16 3. 2 Cor. 8 19. Gal. 1 1. 1 Tim. 3 1 15. 5 9 10 11 17 â—2 6 13 14. Ezec. 33 2. Lev. 8 2 3 4 5. Num. 8 9. Deut. 1 13 16 18. with Joh. 13 20. 1 Cor. 4 1. 2 Cor. 5 19. Heb. 5 4. Also * Act. 1 2 3 14 15. 15 2 6 23 30 and 20 7 17 18. 21 18 23. Rom. 12 6 7 8. 16 1 2. Mat. 18 17 18 19 20. and 28 18 19 20. 1 Cor. 4 17. 5 ch 10 16. and 11 23 26. and 12 ch Epist to Timoth. Tit. Rev. 2 3 ch with 1 Tim. 6 13 14. I. Because the Primitiue churches planted by the Apostles had this right and power at the beginning as may be seen in the Scriptures here before alledged II. And the Congregation of Israel had of old likewise their right in the election of their officers and other such
which were before you Mat. 5 11 12 A Table of some principal things conteyned in these Treatises The first Trtatise Touching the Anabaptists CHAP. I. OF the baptising of children pag. 1 Objection 1. That there is not in the Nevv Testament mention of any child so baptised pag. 4 Object 2. out of Act. 16.32.34 that the Iaylour with his household beleeved in God pag. 7 Object 3. out of Mat. 28 18 19. that Christ commanded the Apostles first to teach and then to baptise pag. 8 Object 4. Of the reasoning from circumcision to baptisme pag. 11 Object 5. Of the difference between the Iewes estate ours their ministration of circumcision to the males onely and on the eight day c. pag. 13. Object 6. Of the Iewes and Proselytes that were both circumcised and baptised pag. 20. Object 7. That Christ was not baptized till he was about thirty yere old pag. 21 Object 8. That children understand not the mysterie of Baptisme pag. 23 CHAP. II. Touching Originall sinne in children p. 23 CHAP. III. That Baptisme received in the church of Rome or other apostatical churches is not to be repeated pag. 27 Object 1. That it is not true baptisme but an Idoll and lying signe c. pag. 30 Object 2. Of the corrupt ministration thereof and erroneous opinions held therabout pag. 37 Object 3. That there are divers sorts of Idols and both kinds in the popish baptisme pag. 41 Object 4. That Israell in their apostasie were not the Church and people of God but divorced from him having the covenant also brokē on the Lords part c. Where also are handled the Scriptures alledged hereabout 2 Chro. 15.3 Ier. 3 8. Hos 2 2. and 13 1. Numb 23 1. c. p. 57 c. Object 5. That Israel are called the people of God because they had ben so before though now they were not so in their apostasie c. where also is treated of the Scriptures here alledged Hos 1.9 and 2.2.7.18.19.20.23 2 Chron. 15.3 Mic. 2.7.8 Ioh. 10.16 c. p. 97 c. Object 6. That if Israel were the church and people of God then none might leaue them but they should fall into schisme pag. 116 Object 7. That the Church of Rome is not the church of God nor under his covenant neyther hath any of the Lords posts and ordinances left in it but is divorced from the Lord c. where also is treated of 2 Thes 2.3.4 and Rev. 11.1.2 and of the Temple of God there spoken off and of Iudah and Antiochus c. pag. 119. c. CHAP. IIII. Replies and Answers concerning churches in apostasie and more particularly touching the church of Rome c. pag. 139 Where again 2 Thes 2.3.4 the Temple of God is further treated off pag. 142 Also of the Beast the great City Babylon c. spoken of Rev. 11. and 13. 17. c. pag. 152 Of Gods people in Babylon spokē of Rev. 18 4. where also is treated of the Baptisme had in the Church of Rome c. pag. 166 Of Israell heretofore and Christian churches synce being in defection pag. 171 Of a double regard to be had of Churches in apostasie pag. 176 183. c. Of M. Iunius his judgment touching the Church of Rome pag. 182 Testimonies of older and later Writers touching Antichrists sitting in the Temple of God spoken of 2 Thes 2 3 4. pag. 211 Touching the Church of England in particular pag. 215 The second Treatise Touching the Remonstrants called Arminians Of the decree of Gods Electiō ch 1. p. 221 Of Gods decree of Reprobatiō ch 2. p. 224 Touching generall redemption ch 3. p. 229 Of free will or power in our selues unto good since the fall ch 4. pag. 233 Of the Saints perseverance ch 5. pag. 240 The third Treatise Concerning the Protestants and Reformed Churches Touching book prayer chap. 1. pag. 245 Of the constitution of particular churches chap. 2. pag. 249 Of the right and power of particular churches chap. 3. pag. 252 Of the Pastors other Officers administration chap. 4. pag. 255 Of the distinction of the Pastors and Teachers Offices chap. 5. pag. 259 Of the having of one or moe Pastors in particular churches also of Diocesan Provincial Bishops c. chap. 6. pag. 261 Of the Teachers Ministers of the word in generall c. chap. 7. pag. 278 Touching the exercise of prophecy pag. 281 Of the ministration of the Sacraments to al persons generally chap. 9. p. 282 Touching the maner of administratiō of the Sacraments where also touching the crosse in Baptisme and kneeling at the Lords supper c. chap 10. pag. 284 Of the disposing blessing breaking distributing of the bread wine ch 11. p. 285 Of the Ministers cōmunicating with the rest of the church chap. 12. pag. 286 Of the Ruling Elders Deacons or common people ministring the sacraments p. 287 Touching the often celebrating the Lords supper And of the time of the day whether morning or euening ch 14. p. 289 Touching having of a Fast the Lords supper together on one day ch 15. p 292 Of Loue Feasts chap. 16. pag. 293. Of the observation of other Holy daies besides the Lords day where also of Christmas and Easter c. ch 17. pag. 294 Of dealing with sinners for their reclayming or censuring where also is treated of Suspension Excōmunicatiō c. p. 300 Of the exposition of those words of Christ Tel the church Mat. 18. ch 19. p. 306 Of the maintenance of the Ministers and other officers of the church ch 20. p. 316. Touching the remnants and monuments of Idolatrie chap. 21. pag. 318 Touching the solēnizatiō of mariage p. 319 Of the generall duety of all churches and people touching religion ch 23 pag. 320 THE FIRST TREATISE Of some questions concerning the Anabaptists CHAPTER I. Whether Baptisme is to be administred to Infants being the children of the faythfull or not THE Anabaptists misunderstanding some Scriptures and not finding in the New Testament mention of any children by name that were baptized hold therefore that infants are not to be baptized though they be the children of such as doe beleeue The errour of which opinion appeareth by these Scriptures and reasons deduced from them other the like Gen. 17.7.12.13.14.26.27 Exo. 12.48.49 Zach. 2.11 Eph. 3.6 with Act. 2 38 39. 3 25. and 16 15 31 33. 1 Cor. 1 16. and 7 14. and 10 1 2. Rom. 4 11 16 17. 15 4 8 9 10. Gal. 3 8 29. Eph. 4 4 5 6. Col. 2 8 12. Psal 22 30 31. Esa 54 10. Zach. 13 1. Mar. 10 13 16. I. Because it is the ordinance commandement of God to giue the signe and seale of his covenant of grace to his people and their seed in their infancie throughout their generations Gen. 17 7 12 13 14. Exo. 12 48 49. with Act. 2 38 39. 3 25. 16 15. Col. 2 10 11 12. Which ordinance of the Lords
being desirous that the trueth and vvill of God herein may vvhat in us is be found out and observed I am not unvvilling to note downe some fevv things that I haue observed from the word of God hereabout leaving them to be examined by the Scriptures and both other things also to be annexed and these things withall to be further or otherwise observed as shal be found to be most according to God and godlynes And these they are viz. That no churches of God are to be left though having or falling into errors and corruptions 1. If their constitution be such as the Churches and Pastors thereof stand as touching their ecclesiasticall estate immediately under Iesus Christ as did each of the churches of Asia with the Angels thereof and all the other Primitiue Churches planted by the Apostles c. Rev. 2 1 7 12 18. and 3 1 7 14. Act. 14 23. and 20 17 28. with the churches at Rom. Cor. Gal. Eph. Phi. Col. Thes c. 2. If they also haue and reteyne povver vvithin themselues to redresse any errour or corruption and to receiue any truth of God as it shal be revealed unto them and they perswaded thereof by the vvord of God As may be seen also in the Churches aforesaid 3. And if the Ministers and other members of the church be not urged in their owne persons to any thing wherein they should sinne and transgresse the lavv of God but be left free for themselues and their owne practise to keep the lavves and ordinances of God according to their places and occasions As may be seen in the church of the Iewes wherein vvere corruptions sundry times and of sundry sorts vvhere yet the Prophets and other godly persons in divers ages and Christ himself his disciples thus lived among theÌ„ See 1 Kin. 14 21-24 and 15 1 2 3. c. with 2 Chron. 12. 13. and 14 ch c. For vvhich see the historie and estate of the Iewes in the time of the Judges and of Rehoboam Abiiah c. Also Esa 1 1. c. Ier. 1 1 2 3. c. Ezech. 1 and 2 and 3 and 16. and 20 ch c. Dan. 1 1 8. and 9 23. Mic. 1 1 11. c. Zeph. 1 1 c. Hag. 1 1 c. Zach. 1 1. c. Mal. 1 1. c. with the historie in Ezra and Nehemiah And Matt. 3 ch and 4 23. and 23 ch and 26 17 20. Luke 1 5 6 8 9 10 21. and 2 21 22 23 24. and 4 16 20. and 21 37 38. Joh. 2 13 23. and 6 4. and 11 55. and 13 1. Act. 13 14 14. and 17 1 2 3. 4. Lastly if they doe not obstinately refuse the truth way God wheÌ„ it is manifested unto them perversely withstanding it themselues speaking evil thereof before others reviling persecuting such as teach or receiue it c. As may be seen in the said Church and Synagogues of the Ievves vvhich were not left untill they came to this untoward and perverse estate and condition For which see the historie of the Euangelists and Acts of the Apostles particularly Act. 2 40. and 7 51 52. and 13 14 45 51. and 18 6. and 19 8 9. and 28 23 28. 1 Tim. 6 3 4 5. and 2 Tim. 3 1 5 11. c. But if any churches fall into apostasie and become so degenerate as they their Pastors come to stand under an Antichristian hierarchie or popular anarchie and reteyne not power vvithin themselues according to the word of God to receiue any trueth shewed unto them and to redresse any error or corruption arising among them but that the ministers and members are urged in their ovvn persons to such actions and duties as they cannot performe without sinne neyther can be suffred to keepe vvhatsoever Christ hath commaunded them but must hold such a faith performe such a worship obserue such an order as is prescribed or allowed by Princes Prelates people c. that now any vvho knowe the trueth and discern the corruptions of such churches should still remaine Ministers or members thereof in such estate and so liue and dye I wish that such as are thus mynded or inclining this vvay vvould plainely set downe their opinions and reasons from the Word of God concerning this matter Or if they like not of this maner of propounding of it as here I haue done that themselues vvould distinctly set down their owne opinions hereabout alvvaies keeping to the points in controversy and insisting upon the things called in question omitting to speak of such things whether touching faith worship or order as are agreed upon on all hands And thus much for the present touching the Objection aforesaid novv I proceed to the next and last concerning these matters OBIECTâ—ON VII But †The Anabapt The Charact of the bapt p. 48. M. Ains Animad p 98-76 98. c. the Church of Rome whereunto many things are applyed that are taken from Israell is not the Church of God nor under the covenant of God nor hath any of the Lords posts or ordinances left in it but is divorced from the Lord c. Neyther is the church of England the Church of God having his covenant but is likewise divorced from the Lord c. Therefore also the baptisme had in those Churches and the like is not true baptisme but an idoll Iustif p. 121 278. 461. others a fiction a lying and deceitfull signe a cursed and detestable sacrament c. ANSWER This objection is of much like sort with those which we had before touching Israell and the circumcision thereof Whereunto therefore like ansvver may be giuen in sundry respects so as the former answers and reasons many of them may hither likewise be referred Neyther the things onely that are spoken of Israel but those also vvhich concerne Iudah in her apostasie and defection whereunto the estate of the Christian apostate church may fitly haue reference in divers respects Which would be long to rehearse and insist upon in particular The indifferent Reader vvill carefully obserue it And the point it self is plaine ynough and undenyable by the reference vvhich the Scripture in sundry things maketh thereunto 2 Thes 2 4. 2 Pet. 2 1. Rev. 11 1 6. and 12 5 6 14. and 13 5 6. and 14 1 15. and 16 12 16. and 19 1. c. Yet considering the objection here made together with the continuall urging thereof and how piteously the Anabaptists and others are by this meanes overcaried with prejudice and drawen from the vvay of trueth to great error and iniquitie I haue thought it not amisse to note also somevvhat hereabout And first to speak of the church of Rome in particular I pray all to take knowledge that my mynd and desire in my self is and I trust shal be alway to plead against the present estate of that church and not for it acknovvledging it to be fallen into most sinful and deep defection and
Papists themselues concerning the church of Rome and ought a thousand fold more to be urged in behalf of the church of England vvho can be ignorant The Lord himself who is the husband Lord of his church hath the povver and knoweth his owne purpose time meanes for the disanulling of churches removing of his Candlesticks giving his bill of divorce c. Which when and as it pleaseth him to reveale it by his word is by all religiously to be regarded Otherwise there are no mens sayings though never so peremptorie that can carry away such matters It is onely the Word and vvork of God that herein is to be observed relyed upon And thus much concerning these objections CHAPTER IIII. Replies Answers concerning Churches in apostasie and the church of Rome more particularly c. NOvv moreover seing that by this occasion we treat both of this matter and of the Scriptures aforesaid whereabout there hath ben and still is so very great opposition made it is needfull and being thus provoked I am not unvvilling for the better fynding out and clearing of the trueth in this behalf somevvhat more to insist hereupon For although their errors and evasions abuse of Scriptures other absurdities vvho deny or labour to obscure these things what they can are so very many as every page yea almost every sentence aboundeth therevvith and withall so very shifting frivolous as in them selues they are not worth the naming much lesse vvorth the refuting yet considering that many in simplicity or othervvise some not of the worst disposed are greatly overcaried hereabout whether by prejudice of the matter it self or by admiration of the mens persons that oppose or by some other sinister respect themselues know best I haue therefore thought it good here to giue the Reader some tast of the Opposites dealing in this behalf that so they may set themselues more unpartially to consider of these things and more soundly to judge thereof according to the word of God Now then whereas concerning this question there had ben speach vvriting and my self in answer thereof had written thus †In answer of M. A. letter as may be set in M. Châ—t Advertis p. 58 59. As touching the Church of Rome there being speach about it to be the church of God I did alledge the saying of the Apostle that Antichrist should sit in the Temple of God as the Apostle expressely teacheth 2 Thes 2 4. And by the Temple of God understanding the church of God it will follovv that Antichrist should sit in the church of God and is there to be sought and found and not among the Jevves Turks Pagans or the like as the Papists and others would perswade us neyther that Antichrist takes away vvholy the church of God and every trueth and ordinance of the Lord as Anabaptists and such as are herein Anabaptistically inclined vvould beare us in hand Thereupon one of these Opposites replying first of all layeth this for a ground that ‘ M. Ain Aâ—mad p. 76. the church of Rome is acknovvledged by all that fear God to be the throne of Antichrist I ansvver First if it vvere so that all would say this as here is set downe yet we would hear Thus saith the Lord. Secondly although that this being but generally spoken and in a good understanding might be admitted yet when men doe so speak and understand it as therevvithall to imply or infer that the church of Rome is not the Temple and church of God we must take heed hovv we admitte it considering vvhat consequences follow thereupon for the upholding of Anabaptistrie and other erroneous opinions thereabout and seeing also the Scripture teacheth that the Beasts throne in deed is that vvhich was the * Rev. 13 2. Dragons throne and was by the Dragon giuen unto him which this man himself acknovvledgeth †Pag. 79. here a litle after applieth unto Antichrist is ‡ Rev. 17 9 10 18. that great city which in Iohns time reigned over the kings of the earth which is built on seuen hâ—â— and had seuen kings or kinds of regiment vvhereof fine were fallen when Iohn wrote c. which particulars vvith other the like are al found to be thus in the city not in the church of Rome Of vvhich point I shall haue occasion to speak more hereafter Besides that ‡ M. Bright maÌ„ on Rev. 13 2. and 16 10. and 17 ch c. good writers also and men fearing God understand the Scriptures here alledged to speak of the city of Rome Thirdly it is also â—rue that Antichrist sitteth in the Temple of God and so in the church of Rome and polluteth it as Antiochus did Gods Temple at Ierusalem Yet his sitting in Gods Temple makes not it to be his throne 2 Thes 2 4. Lucifer the king of Babylon boasted of his sitting in the mount of the Congregation on the sides of the North meaning the Temple of God at Ierusalem Yet Babylon vvas his throne not the Temple on mount Sion Esa 14.12 13. The Dragon is in heauen yet heauen is not his throne Rev. 12 3. In the dayes of Manasseh Zedechiah Antiochus and others there vvere idols of sundry sorts set in the Temple of God at Ierusalem Yet was not Gods Sanctuarie therefore the throne of idols but it vvas still Gods house and Gods seat though thus polluted and was so called and acknowledged by the Prophets notwithstanding 2 King 21 7. Ezec. 8 3 5. vvith ver 14 and 16. Dan. 11 31 38. In deed the church of Rome properly taken being in the city of Rome men may mistake or be mistaken and may the more be borne vvithall and such speaches better be admitted when things are not yet called in question and when men in simplicity speak generally as I said and not by way of opposition carping cavilling reviling oppugning c. as also if by such speaches men simply mean that Antichrist sitteth in the church of Rome and yet deny it not therefore to be the church and Temple of God notvvithstanding Another ground he would take froÌ„ some vvords of mine that I wrote heretofore viz. ‘ In answeâ— to M. Jacob pref sect 6 that the hierarchie and church constitution of Antichrist is the most detestable annarchie of Satan that ever was And then also I vvished the Reader as still I doe †Ibid. secâ— 1. to try what I vvrite by the word of God and as it agreeth therevvith so to receiue it and no further nor otherwise So let this be my answer once for all touching any thing objected that I haue vvritten about this or any other matter Secondly I doe still professe that the hierarchie of Antichrist both is of Sathan is an apostasie most detestable But this now further vvithall that popular anarchie also is most sinfull and miserable They are both of them extreems and religiously to be avoyded The middle vvay is the right
Doctor whom here he citeth let us heare himself speak His words are these That which is †Note thes◠particulars the temple of any idol or Divell the Apostle would not call †Notethes◠particulars the Temple of God Whereupon some will haue in this place not the Prince himself but after a manner his whole body that is the multitude of men perteyning unto him together with himself under the Prince understood to be Antichrist And more rightly they think it also to be said in Latin as in the Greek that he sitteth not in the Temple of God but for the Temple of God which is the †Notethes◠particulars church As we say he sitteth for a friend that is as a friend August de civit Dei lib. 20. c. 19. Where note how farre differing Augustine is from this man that citeth him 1. Augustine speaketh not onely of the Temple as he doeth here but of the Temple of God keeping the Apostles vvords 2. Augustine saith expressely the Apostle would not call that the Temple of God which were the Temple of an idol or of the Divel whereas this man everie foot calleth it ‘ Animad◠p. 78 82 94 c. an idoll like Antichrist himself the church and Temple of Antichrist the Synagogue of Sathan such as the type thereof should be fetched not from the Temple of God at Ierusalem but from Jeroboams Temple and Bels Temple in Babylon yea such as is no more the Temple of God then the Divel which appeared to the vvitch at Endor was Samuell c. Would the Apostles think vve or Augustine eyther cal these or such like the Temple of God 3. Nay Augustine relating here the opinions of others about this and the translation vvithall notes expressely and takes it for granted that the Temple of God is the Church Which this man oppugneth 4. Or doth Augustine expound it of Christ himself as here he applyeth it Other particulars I insist not upō of the translation interpretation I haue spoken here before leaving it so to be considered of as shal be found most agreeable to this other Scriptures compared together Novv vvhere he saith that Antichrist the Pope proclaimeth himself to be the bridegrome of the church which is the office of Christ to be the Greatest high-prist to haue power aboue all power as well of heauen as of earth c. these things plainly perteyne to those clauses of the Apostle where he describeth Antichrist vvith his hierarchie to the man of sinne the sonne of perdition who opposeth and exalteth himself aboue all that is called God c. and so touch not in deed the point of the controversie betvveen us vvhich is not of Antichrist that sitteth c. but of the Temple of God vvhere he sitteth Onely note this withal that it is in some respect against himself may also giue some light to the question in hand inasmuch as these things by his ovvne graunt here are ascribed to Antichrist and the Pope by vvhom there is no doubt but he meaneth the Pope of Rome Whereupon it will follow that if there we fynd Antichrist the man of sinne thus set there also must be sound the Temple of God vvherein thus he sitteth Next he saith that secondarily the Temple figured the Church but first the catholike or universall Church Ephes 2 21. then every particular Church †Note this for proportion kept with Israel which whē we speake of it he oppugneth Animad p. 15. c. by proportion 1 Cor. 3 16 17. And both these are the church or Churches of God as appeareth by the Scriptures here cited by himself Thus also it is plainly manifest that they who in this place apply it to the Church of God understand it not othervvise then as himself graunts the type figure may lead unto But yet of neyther of the tvvo would he haue it here to be understood therefore bringeth exceptions concerning both Which let the Reader well obserue and remember And the rather because that euen here a litle after he saith expressely that †Animad pag. 80. when the Apostle telleth us that Antichrist sitteth as God in the Temple of God it is to be understood of their invading and destroying of Gods church and people as the heathens of old dealt vvith Jerusalem and dwellers therein Hovv contradictorie these are the one unto the other vvho can not discerne and hovv novv will he reconcile these two together that by the Temple of God is meant here Gods Church invaded and destroyed by Antichrist and yet that by the Temple of God here is not to be understood the church of God neyther universall nor particular But he saith we shevv not which of these two we intend Neither doeth he himself when he saith here presently after that Antichrist invaded and destroyed Gods church here meant by the Temple of God Neyther did he it heretofore when vvriting against M. Sm. he taught that †M. Ain def of Scri. p. 14 15. by the court and holy city spoken off Rev. 11 2. is signified the Church of God And if thus he could haue rested it had ben somewhat But now to destroy that vvhich he built before he sets himself to perswade that it can neyther be understood of a particular Church nor of the catholick or universall So as I might leaue him to mainteyne or to reverse his ovvne exposition hereof vvhether he thinks to be best and in the meane time to consider how all this treatise vvhich he intended against us fals upon his owne head and if he think there be any waight in it is in deed against himself But because the point is of so great moment although in respect of these Opposites I need not yet in other respects I am not unwilling to note somevvhat more hereabout leaving it still to myne ovvn others further consideratiō as shal be found most agreable to the word of God and to his vvork by the event of things alreadie done and yet further to be accomplished By the Temple of God properly taken is usually meant the Temple that was at Ierusalem And this vve haue heard did primarily figure out Christ and secondarily the Church both the catholick and universall particular Churches likewise Whereunto may be annexed also that it figured †1 Cor. 6 19. vvith 2 Cor. 5 1. and 6 16. 1 Pet. 2 5. so may here also in 2 Thes 2 4. particular Christians and in severall respects both their bodies and their soules and consciences Moreover in that Temple at Ierusalem there vvas the Courts the holy place and the most holy place Which sometimes all of them together sometimes some of them more particularly are called the Temple And so this word is diversely used and applied as I haue shevved ‘ Pag. 128. before Which therefore for the right understanding of the Scriptures and touching the question in hand is carefully to be observed
then apply it unto that vvhereof it vvas a figure and accordingly understand it Or may not vve so understand and apply it as the Apostle doeth vvho as himself saith here applies it to a particular church 1 Cor. 3 16 17. vvith which place may be joyned 2 Cor. 6.16 though that may also be further extended Besides was not the Temple in Israell for any and every Synagogue familie and person among them And may not we now accordingly apply it to the Churches and Christians of the Gentiles And that the more seeing that then also it vvas for them coÌ„ming to the faith of Israel vvhether mo or fevver Or vvere not the Ievves distributed into severall and particular Synagogues which being joyntly considered vvere and might be esteemed as one people And are not the Christians euen those among whom Antichrist hath most prevayled distributed likewise into particular churches or parishes Which if any would in some good respect consider joyntly as one people vvho would striue about it so as it were not any way abused for maintenance of any errour against the trueth or vvord of God But of this I will not insist neyther alledge other things that here might be observed That alone may suffice vvhich I noted here before By reason whereof also I need not stand on that vvhich he speaketh about the catholick or universall church seing it is ynough for the matter in hand to find it in the particular churches so as is aforesaid Yet some things by this occasion may here be noted vvithall As namely that the Church of Christ is sometimes accounted as one ‘ Sal. Song 4 12 16. and 5 1. 6 2 11 garden being considered joyntly in one sometimes as many or sundry * Sal. Song 4 15. 6 2. 8 13 gardens in respect of the divers particular congregations thereof Each of which particular ones both is a garden it self and is also a part of that one or universal garden of the Lord. So as he vvhich dwelleth the trees herbes vvhich grovv in any one of these may be said to dwell and grovv not onely in that particular garden alone but also in the general or universall garden as it compriseth al the particular gardens within it they being al of them parts of the generall Likevvise the Church is sometimes resembled by ‘ Exod. 25 31. 2 Chr. 13 11. Zac. 4 2 11. one Candlestick having one shank or shaft out of which come divers branches vvherein are * Exod. 25 37. with Rev. 1 11 12 20. and 2 3 ch seuen severall lampes so as the light vvhich is set in any one of the lampes standeth not onely in that particular lampe but in the generall candlestick sometimes by “ 2 King 7 49. 2 Chron. 4 7. ten candlesticks sometimes by ‡ Rev. 11 4. two c. so noting both one catholick Church in generall divers particular Congregations in speciall sometimes moe sometimes fewer yet so as they are alwaies parts and members of the generall or universall vvhether they be moe in number and more florishing or fevver more decaying Where note moreover that the Candlesticks and Lampes were set in the Temple of God and that the church of Rome vvas a golden Candlestick as well as the rest of the Primitiue Churches that this man himself saith definitely †Animad p. 103. the true churches were many of them apostate when John wrote whom yet notwithstanding the Scripture calleth Christ acknowledgeth them to be †Rev. 1 11 12 20. and 2 1. golden candlesticks In any of vvhich if Antichrist the man of sinne had sit as in the church of Rome I suppose this man vvould not deny but his fitting then should haue ben in the Temple of God whether it vvere coÌ„sidered as a particular Lampe and Candlestick it self ’‘ M. Brig on Rev. 11 4. or as a branch also and part of the great and generall Candlestick vvhich is †Rev. 1 11 12 20. and 2 1. observed in the respects aforesaid to be a type both of the Catholick church and of the particular Congregations thereof like as here the Temple is by this man himself acknowledged and rightly also to be a type of both Animad pag. 78. As for the catholick or universall Church which the Pope claymeth for his Temple what is that to us vvho speak of the Temple of God spoken off by the Apostle 2 Thes 2 4. And vvhereas he vvould be taught hovv that vvhorish company that worship the Beast and Dragon can be the true catholike church spouse of Christ although that which I haue noted before be sufficient for the point in hand neither meane I now to insist on other things yet seeing thus he speaketh here let him first remember hovv but a litle before he told us ‘ Animad p. 77. the catholike church of the novv Romish religion as themselues describe it hath one part thereof on earth another under the earth and a third part in heauen now here himself speaketh onely of such as are on earth and those also such as vvorship the Dragon and the Beast spoken off Rev. 13 4. whereas the Catholick Church in deed conteyneth al the Churches and people of God that haue ben from the beginning of the world before ever there vvas a church yea or a city at Rome and that shal be to the end of the vvorld in any and every age thereof and in another respect all and onely the elect of God both Angels and men 2. And let himself now tell us vvhether he think there was no other church or churches of Christians catholick or particular vvherein Antichrist sate synce the apostasie of the Man of sinne but such as worshipped the Dragon which gaue power unto the Beast and the beast also himself withall Rev. 13 4. And who then were the Tabernacle those that dwelt in heauen whom the beast blasphemed and the Saints with whom he made vvarre tvvo and fourty moneths Rev. 13 5 6 7. and of vvhat church or churches they were considering also that the apostasie began so soone and spread so far and continued so long 2 Thes 2 3 7. with Rev. 11 1 2 c. 3. Let him also remember how Ierusalem came to be ‘ Ezec. 16 2 35 c. and 23 2 43. c an harlot old in adulteries and the Ievves to be †Esa 1 4 5 c. a sinfull nation laden with iniquitie forsaking the Lord and revolting more and more yea * Esa 57 3 4 5. c. sonnes of the soâ—ceresse the seed of the adulterer and the whore “ Esa 65 2 3 c. a rebellious people which walked in a way not good after their ovvne thoughts ‡ 2 Chron. 36 14. c. transgressing after all the abominations of the heathen and polluting the house of the Lord which he had hallowed in Ierusalem c. vvhenas yet they vvere
clause vvhich he savv I mentioned about Antichrist that he takes not away wholly the church of God c. Is it because he can fynd no answer and yet vvill not yeeld to the trueth and therefore rather then he vvill not oppose useth these shifts and slye conveyances thinking that his followers vvil not obserue these sleights of his Hovv ever it be let the reader obserue that himself seeth the heathens haue not the church of God as the church of Rome vvhere Antichrist sitteth hath and that therefore fetching his answer from the heathens he doth vvholly leaue out this clause of the Church of God which they haue not among them in their estate and so in deed giues us the cause whiles he would seem to oppugne it And whereas he saith the Divel hath not taken avvay vvholly every trueth ordinance of God among the heathens it is nothing to the purpose seing they are not the church and people of God under his covenant neyther doe so enjoy any of them Take an instance in one of the particulars which he mentioned before where he said that the heathens reteyne baptismes or washings among them yet vvhen any of them leaue that estate and come to the faith and church of Christ they are to be baptized into the Lords name and to receiue the seale of his covenant giuen to his church vvhich they had not before But so may not be done vvith those that haue received baptisme in the church of Rome or any other apostate churches when they leaue such estate because they are already baptized into the name of Christ and haue in those Churches received the seale of Gods covenant which the heathens haue not As I haue shewed ‘ Pag. 27 c. here before more particularly And this is alwaies a sure ground and firme rule to be observed The Lord shevveth his vvord unto Jacob his statutes and his judgements unto Israel He hath not dealt so vvith any nation and as for his judgements they haue not knovven them Psal 147 19 20. That which he saith he noted here before is †Pag. 94 c. before ansvvered vvhither I refer the Reader And vvhere he saith next that the Divel and Antichrist so much as in them lay and as stood vvith the safetie of their deceitfull kingdome haue sought wholly to take avvay the church and trueth of God and to put lyes in the place this is against him self both implying that it vvas not vvholly done which is the thing that vve say and he oppugneth and manifestly shevving that Gods goodnes and power superabounded aboue all the malice and iniquitie of the Divell and Antichrist vvhich therefore vve should all obserue vvith thankfulnes to God not obscure or oppugne as the Anabaptists this man doth what they can Besides that Gods goodnes and power did yet more appeare in nourishing the vvoman his church in the vvildernes from the presence of the serpent Rev. 12 14. Like as before the Lord measured the Temple and Altar and vvorshippers therein vvhich were most inward and secret to himself vvhenas he gaue the Court of the Temple resembling the outward visible estate of the church into the hands of the Gentiles the Antichristian apostates and persecuters and the holy City to be troden upon by them which Court City notwithstanding vvere stil the Lords though thus exposed dealt vvith for the time appointed Whereabout I haue noted some fevv things ‘ Pag. 128 129 130 c. here before which the Reader may make use off concerning this matter Other things that might be observed thereabout I doe not now enter into or insist upon For the last thing which he alledgeth out of that which I vvrote heretofore euen in it also there is sufficient for confirmation of this matter against himself for us inasmuch as the apostasie of Antichrist the man of sinne ‡ Answ to M. Ja. p. 137. could not justly be accounted a mysterie of iniquitie and truely said to speak lyes in hypocrisy also privily to bring in damnable heresies and to haue a shew of godlynes if they did absolutely and vvholy depart from the faith and not onely from some points thereof c. And hitherto of the understanding of the Apostles vvords where he speaketh of Antichrists sitting in the Temple of God 2 Thes 2 4. and of the tvvo inferences thereupon against the Papists Anabaptists c. In all which this man opposeth what he can thus chusing rather to strengthen such in their errors then he vvill seem to haue erred himself or cease to oppose us thereabout Of Gods people in Babylon spoken off Rev. 18 4. Next I observed ‘ Advert pag. 59. here againe as I had done before concerning the baptisme had in the church of Rome that which is said Rev. 18 4. Goe out of her my people and partake not in her sinnes c. Whereupon I inferred that those words my people imply the covenant of God continued among them For thus is the covenant taught and set down unto us in the Scripture I will be your God and you shall be my people c. This also he setteth to oppose in words but confirmeth it in deed though against his will For vvhat doth he ansvver †Animad p. 80. These very words saith he are taken from Ier. 51 45. My people goe out of the midst of her where by my people the church of Babylon is not meant but the Israelites c. Very vvell But are not those words My people the words of the covenant as I said And vvere not that people now in Babylon the church people of God under his covenant Had not that people also polluted the Temple of the Lord and fallen into notorious idolatrie apostasie and other iniquitie for vvhich they vvere giuen by the Lord into the hands of the Babylonians and vvere they not still the Lords church people his vineyard and heritage notvvithstanding 2 Chron. 36 14 20. with Jer. 12 7 10. and 20 4. Lamen 1 3 8 10 14 15. c. Esa 63 10 17 18 19. Is there not difference moreover to be put betweene the people of God in Babylon and between Babylon it self How els vvill he make this speach and case in the Revelation to accord with that other spoken of by the Prophet from vvhence himself saith these very words are taken if that there be not novv as there vvas of old in Babylon of Chaldea the people of God under his covenant continued among them in the mysticall Babylon of the Beast whether it be applyed to the city of Rome the throne of Antichrist and jurisdiction thereof or to the apostasie of the church of Rome vvherein the man of sinne sitteth and dominereth Whereabout see more ‘ Pag. 152 153 154 c. here before And to make this matter yet more plain obserue moreover in the Prophet Zacharie how afterward he speaking of the same matter and same
Thus you see by the most best approved Authors judgment Antichrist should sit in the church of God If then it be the church of God haue they nothing in deed but the Synagogue of Sathan D. Willet he saith ‡ Synopsis Papismi Cōtr. 2. of the church q. 5. par 2. utterly denyeth that they are a true visible church of Christ But doe any of his arguments proue it Let the Reader consider mark it with judgment Again he saith * Ibid. Cōtrov 4. q. 10. part 5. 2 Thes 2. he shall sit in the Temple of God that is the visible church that which sometime vvas a true visible one as the Church of Rome and after should so be taken reputed and challenged as it is at this day by the Papists Yet a litle after in the same place he saith Paul speaketh not here of any materiall Temple but of the church of God neyther doth S. Paul in this sense refuse to use the name of Temple as 1 Cor. 3 16. and 6 19. and in other places Now if the name of the Temple of God be so used by the Apostle in the other place of 2 Thes 2 4. as it is here in these places 1 Cor. 3 16. and 6 19. and otherwhere then it signifieth the church and Temple of God not onely that is so taken and reputed but that is so in deed For so in these other places it is understood Moreover when M. Willet proveth the churches of the Protestants and namely the church of England to be true visible churches he useth this for his first argument †Ibid. cōtrov 2 q. 5 part 2. That church which sendeth sorth Martyrs as Christs faithfull souldjours is the true church This Proposition saith he I think is not doubted off for out of the church there are no Martyrs If this then be an undoubted argument eyther he must shevv that the church of Rome affordeth no Martyrs against the Turks and other professed enemies of the Christian faith or if it do he yeelds it must needs be the church of God M. Bale noteth divers things vvhich †Image of both churches in the Prof. apperteyn to the man of sinne plainly shew that the Pope is Antichrist As vvhere he saith The Pope maketh his boast that he is the high Priest he is of equal power with Peter he cannot erre he is head and spouse of the Church c. But difference is to be put betweene the Temple of God and Antichrist the man of sinne sitting therein c. as hath ben often shewed here before pag. 125 137 183 c. Besides speaking of the Turk he saith he will in no case grant Christ to be the sonne of God nor that he dyed here for mans redemption Yet both these are acknovvledged by the church of Rome as I haue shewed here before by their ovvne profession Pag. 122. Other things that might further be observed out of those mens writings about the assertions aforesaid I will not insist upon It may suffice that M. Ainsvv himself saith here †Animad pag. 105. it is not to be marveled at though vvise and godly men be mistaken for in many things we sinne all Jam. 3 2. And good it were for this man himself and his followers that they had this wisedome and godlynes in synceritie and humblenes of mind thus to think acknowledge of themselues that they are mistaken and sinne in many things then would they not be so stif and self conceited in their fore-conceived opinions former practises euen vvhen better is shewed unto them by the vvord of God Now having thus treated of the points aforesaid and of the understanding of that Scripture 2 Thes 2 4. touching Antichrist sitting in the Temple of God I vvill by this occasion yet further before I conclude annex herevvithall the judgment and testimonie both of auncient and later Writers concerning these things not naming all that might be alledged but a few onely of each sort as follovveth Testimonies of auncient Writers Chrysostome speaking of Antichrist saith He shall sit in the Temple of God not that which is at Ierusalem but in the Temple of the church Chrysost homil 3 in Epist ad Thes 2. Theophylact saith Not in the Temple which is at Ierusalem specially but simply in the churches and in every Temple of God In 2 Thes 2. Oecumenius hath likewise He saith not the Temple of Ierusalem but the churches In 2 Thes 2. Item Severianus apud Oecumenium ibid. Theodoret saith He calleth the Temple of God the churches in which Antichrist shall arrogate unto himself the chief seat In 2 Thes 2. Augustine saith The Temple of any Idoll or Divell the Apostle would not call the Temple of God De civit Dei l. 20 c. 19. Whereof also see here before p. 147. Ambrose likewise saith So that in the house of God he sitteth in the seat of Christ In 2 Thes 2. Testimonies of later Writers c. Calvin saith Paul placeth not Antichrist any otherwhere then in the verie Sanctuarie of God 2 Thes 2 4. Of which also see more here before pag. 164. Hemmingius saith By these marks spoken off 2 Thes 2 4. is signified that Antichrist is not any one properly out of the visible church Ibid in 2 Thes 2. Iunius saith That the papacie is in the church as the order or estate of apostasie in the house of and city of God is as certaine as that of the Apostle is certain 2 Thes 2. that the man of sinne the sonne of perdition sitteth in the Temple of God with his whole order or estate of apostates Lib. singulari de Ecclesia contra Bellarm. cap. 17. In fol. pag. 1020. Of which poynt and many other things concerning this matter see more here before pag. 183. c. Zanchius saith I agree not vvith them that think the church of Rome hath ceased to be the church of Christ aswell as the east churches which afterward became Mahumetane What church ever was more corrupt then the church of the ten tribes Yet by the Scriptures we haue learned that it vvas the church of God And how hath Paul cald the Church wherein the said Antichrist should sit the Temple of God Neyther is it Baptisme that is administred out of the Church of Christ Neyther doth a wife cease to be a vvife because she is an adulteresse except she be manifestly divorced being deprived of the ring the pledge of the mariage covenant The Church of Rome therefore is yet the church of Christ But vvhat a church So corrupt so depraved and oppressed with such tyrannie as vve neither can with good conscience pertake of their holy things nor safely dwell among them In Praefat. librorum de Natura Dei. Polanus saith A particular church is either pure or impure A pure church is a companie of such as haue the true religion uncorrupted c. It is very commonly called a true church but by a Synecdoche For
haue also shevved that euen the church of Rome is the church and Temple of God as Iudah likevvise and Israell of old vvere in the time of their apostasies How much more then should we so esteem of the church of England yea and of the Lutherans vvho haue in so many things novv left the apostasie of the church of Rome and haue received the doctrine of justification by faith in Christ alone vvith many other precious doctrines of truth that are yet still miserably depraved and corrupted among the Papists But hereupon some object and say If they be the church of God none may leaue them it is schisme for any to leaue those that are the churches and people of God and vvhy then doe you not continew Ministers and members there still c. First to this objection I haue ansvvered before pag. 116 c. To vvhich I referre the Reader as also to that which M. Iunius hath written concerning this matter as may be seen here before pag. 184 186. Secondly if this objection were sound then might none leaue the present estate of the church of Rome seeing they are the church and Temple of God as before hath ben declared Yet the men that doe thus object haue many of them left it themselues And M. Iunius shevveth that both these may stand vvel together to esteem it to be the church of God and yet to leaue forsake it in their estate yea that it is our duty so to doe But in deed to note this by the vvay wel may it be that some Protestant writers otherwise of great good judgment haue heretofore the more denied it to be the Church of God because they thought if that were granted it vvould then follow to be schisme for any to leaue it as the Papists themselues are vvoont usually to object But the consequence is not good as is shewed before by the Scriptures and examples both in Iudah and Israell c. Pag. 116. Thirdly in a Church there are tvvo things specially that are still to be respected the faith and the order thereof Col. 2 5. For touching the worship of God therein it may in divers respects be referred to the one or to the other or to both of them Novv for the Faith which is in Christ alone to salvation we acknowledge that they professe it soundly and in the unity thereof vve also hope our selues to be saved with them and therefore albeit they intreat deale yll with us sundry vvaies yet we hold them to be our brethren in the Lord and in the faith of his Gospell But as for the churches order worship and government ecclesiasticall vve hold and professe that they stand yet still greatly corrupted and transgressing the second commandement many waies As namely ‡ Of these more particularly see in the Apologie and other Treatises of ours also in the Treatise here following touching the reformed churches in their Prelacie and inferiour ministerie in their Canons Constitutions and Worship devised and imposed by man especially in the Book of common prayer according to which all the ministers and people of that Church are enjoyned to minister and partake of the holy things of God had among them vvherein are corruptions not a few that are also observed and written against †The Abridgement of the Ministers book of Lincolne Diocesse The Survey of the book of Common praier c by divers of themselues besides the refusal opposition persecution of the trueth vvhich hath now a long time very often many vvaies benshewed unto them c. And yet more specially that the particular churches ministers thereof stand not as the primitue Churches and Pastors did immediately under Iesus Christ the Archpastor as touching their ecclesiasticall constitution but under another spirituall authoritie and Prelacie devised by man neyther haue povver in themselues as now they stand to receiue and practise all the ordinances of God to redresse all errors and corruptions that are manifested unto them by the vvord of God as the Pastors and Churches aforesaid had Which things standing thus hereby may appeare that none can stand Ministers or members of the Church aforesaid in their estate and performe the dueties thereof according to the Lavves and Constitution thereof but they shall sinne and transgresse the second Commandement Which the Lord that is a jelous God accounteth to be hatred of him and hath threatned severely to punish as on the contrarie he hath promised to shew mercy graciously to them that loue him and keep his commandements Exod. 20 4 5 6. compared with Lev. 10 1 2. Deut. 4 1 2. 2 King 10 18 31. 2 Chron. 19 2 3. Luke 19 27. Psal 119 126 127 128. Esa 29 13. and 65 2. Mal. 1 6 14. Mar. 7 4 6 7. c. Col. 2 20 23. Rev. 14 9 12. and 22 18 19. Fourthly which commeth to a like end vvith the former reason but yet vvill make it more plaine there are two things concerning the vvorship and service of God which we ought alwaies carefully to remember and obserue One that we ought to leaue and forsake all the inventions of men and more specially al the mixtures and corruptions of Antichrist the man of sinne in the service and worship of God And this not onely in things concerning the faith but in such also as concerne the order of the church Exod. 20 4 5. with Deut. 12 32. Iudg. 8 27. 1 Chro. 13. 15 2. c. 2 Chron. 33 17. Psal 119 101 113 128. Esa 30 21 22. Ezech. 43 8. Mal. 1 6 14. Matt. 15 9 13 14. Rom. 16 17. Rev. 14 9 12. and 22 18 19. The other is that vve obserue and practise all the commandements and ordinances of the Lord vvhich he hath once for all giuen unto his church vvhether concerning the faith or the order of the church and so consequently the Churches government vvorship ministerie ministration of all every of the holy things of God according to his vvord Exod. 20 6. compared with Deut. 12 32. Matth. 28 20. Gal. 3 15. Jude v. 3. 1 Tim. 6 13 14. 2 Chron. 13 8 12. and 19 8 11. Psal 119 101 128. Esa 30 21. and 33 22. Rev. 14 12. Which two things seeing that in the present estate of the church of England neither ministers nor members can obserue them nor be suffred peaceably so to vvalke hovv can it be but we must needs leaue that estate unlesse vve should still continew in sinne against the Law of God And hovv can that justly be counted schisme vvhich is our bounden duty to the Lord vvherein vve ought to obey God rather then Man Fiftly to make the matter yet more plaine let us put the case that some Kings and States vvould permit the Churches in their dominions peaceably to enjoy the ministerie of the word and the Baptisme of elder people among them but not of children urging those words according to the letter Make disciples
and baptise them Matt. 28 19. Or if of younger persons also yet vvould not suffer any to haue the Lords supper at all because of the many questions and troubles that haue ben and yet are among the Papists Lutherans and other Protestants thereabout Novv hereupon I would aske vvhether it should be sinne and schisme to leaue such an estate and to obserue also Gods ordinance of the Lords supper according to his institution Or if any vvould permit the use of it but onely under one kind Or if in both kinds to wit both with bread wine yet vvould not admit it vvithout the acknowledgment of Transubstantiation or at least of Consubstantiation pressing still those vvords This is my body c. Matth. 26 26. Or would not haue it administred according to the simplicity of the Gospell but as Princes or people did themselues like best to haue it Or admitting both preaching of the vvord and ministration of the Sacraments yet would haue al though never so profane and notoriously vvicked to be partakers of the Lords Table and not to be censured admonished debarred excommunicated c. Or would not suffer the people to chuse their ovvne Officers according to the word of God or the Officers not to performe the dueties vvhich God requireth at their hands but at the pleasure of man Princes or people or at least of the greater part of the people urging those vvords Tell the church c. Matth. 18 17. and All things are yours c. 1 Cor. 3 21 22 23. Or finally and summarily vvould not suffer the Churches the ministers and people to obserue whatsoever Christ hath commanded Matth. 28 20. but if they had the word preached would not suffer the seales of Gods mercy the Sacraments one or both to be enjoyed or if they had both these vvould not permit the Lords discipline to be had the censures and sanctions of his judgment according to his word and instistution c. Whether novv I say in these and such like cases we should not obey God rather then man and whether it be schisme and sinne so to doe Sixtly the church of England it self and all the reformed churches and Protestants at this day are charged by the Papists to be schismaticks for leaving the present estate of the church of Rome But are they therefore so in deed Sundry Protestant Writers haue shewed good reasons to the contrarie divers of vvhich being indifferently vveighed may be applied to the points case now treated off albeit withal I acknowledge great and unspeakable difference to be between the estate of these churches blesse God daily for the many good things had in the church of England for that they haue left the church of Rome For which see particularly of our ovvn countreymen D. Raynolds sixt Conclusion eyther in Latin or as it is in English joyned with his Conference vvith Hart pag. 666 667 c. And D. Willets Synopsis Papismi in fol. pag. 608 609. c. Lastly vvhereas Conformity is much urged and such as doe not conforme themselues are charged vvith schisme vvhether they remayne in that church or leaue the present estate thereof that they may keep the ordinances of God according to his vvord vve are still to remember that there is a double Conformitie touching the outward worship of God The one is that Conformitie of rites and order which the Lord requireth and prescribeth in his word The other is the conformity vvhich the lavves and constitutions of men ordeyn and require To the former all are bound and unto it the Lord hath giuen his promise Matth. 28 18 19 20. 1 Tim. 6 3 4 5 13 14. compared with Exod. 20 4 5 6. Deut. 12 32. Mal. 1 7 14. Where Piscator well observeth that in the outward worship of God there is required both a conformitie of rite agreeing with the prescript of Gods commandement and synceritie in all which performe that worship to the Lord. Piscat Observ in Mal. 1 7 c. To the latter we are bound no further or othervvise then as it agreeth with the conformitie prescribed by the Lord himself because vve must worship the Lord onely as he hath appointed in his vvord and as we haue the promise of his acceptance and blessing therewithall For which see the Scriptures aforesaid and Deut. 4 1 2. Psal 119 101 128. Esa 29 13. 30 21 22. Matth. 15 9. Hos 4 15 17. Amos 5 4 5. 2 Cor. 6 14 15 16 17. Col. 2 23. Rev. 22 18 19. Some other things perteyning hereunto see also before pag. 116 117 c. and in the third Treatise here following Now if any aske vvhether that Christians and Churches may not and ought not to beare one with another in their differences of this also I haue spoken here before pag. 118 and 119 c. the brief summe whereof is this that we may and should so doe vvhen the Churches and Pastors thereof professing the faith of Christ stand in their ecclesiasticall estate immediately under Iesus Christ having libertie power in themselues to receiue any truth and redres any error or evil as they shal be perswaded thereof and in the meane time doe not urge others to sinne in their owne persons but suffer them peaceably to practise and walk in the vvay and order which the Lord hath prescribed in his word Which if it vvere the estate dealing of the churches in England and other the like at this day the question would in divers respects be othervvise for esteeming of them and vvalking with them then novv it is And these are the things which I thought here to note by this occasion touching the church of England in regard of the points in question betvveen us the Anabaptists others to much overcaried that way Other things there are also good to be considered off as namely the divers degrees of Gods manifesting the truth and consuming of Antichrist with his apostasie the different estate and proceeding of the Angels spoken off Rev. 14 6 8 9 15 17. c. and 15. and 16 chap. c. the difference of ordinarie and extraordinarie estate and calling the divers consideration of spirituall and bodily or personall communion the distinction of Provinciall Diocesan and particular churches vvith the Bishops thereof Also whether the particular churches among them be not become parts and members of the Diocesan and Provinciall churches in their estate Whether the prelates bereaue not the particular churches of many rights perteyning unto them more particularly take away from them some speciall rights and dueties of the Pastors ruling Elders people and in some respects of al estates generally among them Finally whether such Ministers as haue left the corruptions of that estate and liue in Churches rightly established may not yet notvvithstanding upon occasion †1 King 13 chap. Hos 5 9. 7 12. Amo. 7 13 Rev. 14 6. c. preach in the other churches aforesaid both to
violent death but shal vve therefore match them together as like touching eternall death 3. Difference also is to be put betvveene the revealed and the hidden vvill of God so to call it As may be observed in the Lords dealing with Abraham Ezechiah and others God biddeth Abraham take Isaac his sonne sacrifice him yet Gods purpose vvas but thus to trie Abrahams faith and obedience vvhich purpose of God was as yet concealed from Abraham till God did afterward manifest it Gen. 22 1 2. c. The Lord also biddeth Esaiah goe tell Hezekiah that he should then dye when God notwithstanding doeth afterward adde fifteene yeres more to his life which as yet was concealed from Hezekiah Esa 38 1. c. Yet this double will so to call it is but in respect of us and the manifestation thereof unto us For otherwise in respect of God himself he never would any other thing but that vvhich also he doth 4. Again difference is to be put between willing as delighting with willing as decreing Otherwise if God simply would not none should dy at al. 5. Obserue vvithal vvhether in the places aforesaid the Prophet speak not of the vvicked converting to the Lord and not of the Reprobate whereabout the question novv is For which consider that vvhich is vvritten in Ezech. 18 21 22 27 28 c. 6. Finally the right translation understanding here is thus †Or I am not delighted with I haue no pleasure saith the Lord in the death of the wicked c. Whereupon obserue againe that God delighteth not in the death of a sinner in one respect as it is the destruction of his creature Ezech. 18 23. and 33 11. But he delighteth in it in another respect as it is his just punishment of sinne Psal 37 13. vvith 2 4 5 12. Prov. 1 26. Ezech. 21 17. And here see Piscat in Ezech. 18 23 32. and 33 11. Also Piscat Resp. ad duas disputat Taufreri Resenij pag. 38 100. Object III. But the doctrine of Gods predestination especially of Reprobation should not be taught or at least not be taught unto the common people c. Ansvv 1. Why then doeth the Scripture teach it the Prophets Apostles and Christ himself The Prophets Gen. 25 23. vvith Rom. 9 12. Exod. 9 16. and 33 19. vvith Rom. 9 15 17 18. Ier. 6 30. Mal. 1 2 3. vvith Rom. 9 13. Prov. 16 4. vvhere it is expressely said that the Lord hath made all things for himself yea euen the vvicked for the day of evill And Christ himself also teacheth the same when he saith †or I confesse to thee I thank thee O Father Lord of heauen and earth because thou hast hid these things the mysteries of the kingdome of heauen from the vvise and prudent and hast revealed them unto babes Euen so Father for so it seemed good in thy sight Mat. 11 25 26. Where it is evident that Gods decree not onely of election but of reprobation also dependeth meerely on Gods good will and pleasure Also Matt. 13 11. And again when he saith in his prayer to the Father Those that thou hast giuen me I haue kept and none of them is lost but the sonne of perdition meaning Iudas John 17 12. Like as Antichrist also is called the sonne of perdition 2 Thes 2 3. that is appointed to perdition and condemnation As by the sonnes of death is understood also such as are appointed to dye Psal 79 11. and 102. 20. And the Apostles teach it in like sort namely the Apostle Paul Rom. 9 11 23. and 11 chap. 2 Tim. 2 19 20. Ephes 1 3 11. 1 Thes 5 9. where the Apostle having said Let us not sleep as doe others but let us that are of the day be sober putting on the brestplate of faith and loue and for an helmet the hope of salvation then presently annexeth For God hath not appointed us to vvrath but to obteyne salvation by our Lord Jesus Christ And Peter likewise who teacheth out of the Prophets that Christ is a stone of stumbling and a rock of offence to them vvhich stumble at the word being disobedient vvhereunto also they vvere appointed 1 Per. 2 8. And Iude the Apostle saying There are certain men crept in unavvares vvho vvere of old foreordeyned to this condemnation c. Jude ver 4. Thus doe the Prophets Apostles Christ himself plainly and purposely teach this doctrine And should not then the ministers of Christ tread in their steppes being still carefull to teach it wisely and soundly according to the Scriptures For vvhatsoever things are vvritten aforetime they vvere vvritten for our learning that we through pacience and comfort of the Scriptures might haue hope Rom. 15 4. 2. Moreover this doctrine is both lawful and good to be taught in the church 1. Because it glorifyeth God ascribing and yeelding to God the glorie of his mercie justice wisdome and povver over all Ioh. 16 14. Rom. 9 22 23. and 11 33 36. II. Because it stirreth up to holynes of life prayer thanksgiving good vvorks searching and relying on the word of God c. 1 Thes 5 6 9. Mat. 11 25 26. Act. 4 24 28. c. Ephes 1 3 12. and 2 10. Rom. 15 4. 2 Tim. 3 15 16 17. 2 Pet. 1 3 10. III. Because it assureth us of the certaintie of our salvation being grounded in the eternall and unchangeable counsell of God It teacheth us to cast off all confidence in our selues and to ascribe our salvation onely to the grace of God acknowledging and admiring the riches of Gods mercy vvho of his free grace hath chosen us to life and salvation in Christ It comforteth us against distrust despaire and other manifold tentations arising by meanes of troubles and adversities that befall us in this life teaching us in all things paciently to rest in the work of God and particularly it strengtheneth us against the grief and offence that otherwise we might take at the iniquitie and evill dealing of hypocrites and other wicked persons in the church or out of the church in asmuch as we knovv that God is the disposer of all things that they come to passe according to his eternall and most certain and determinate counsell vvho therefore will vvork all things for good unto us in Christ 2 Tim. 2 19 20. Rom. 8 28 39. and 11 33 36. 2 Sam. 16 10 11. and Iob 1 21. Mat. 11 25 26. and 20 15. John 17 12. Act 2 23. and 4 27 28. 1 Pet. 2 6 7 8. Jude ver 3 and 4. Rev. 13 8. and 17 8. 20 15. and 21 27. 3. It giueth us good necessarie occasion to put difference between Gods decree of election reprobation which was before all beginning and betvveen the execution thereof vvhich succedeth in time aftervvard And thereupon to obserue that many things come betvveen the decree it self and the execution thereof which are due meanes causes of
them to make prescribe or use them in such sort as churches and people now dayly doe Or hovv shall we assure our selues or others that it is not a will vvorship deviâ—ed by man and displeasing to God IX Yea and let it be vvell considered vvhether it be not a part of the apostasie of Antichrist and such as mainteyneth superstition in some churches an Idoll and dumbe ministerie and nourisheth the people still in ignorance of the nature and right use of prayer c. D. Raynolds writing against Bellarmine hath this general proposition that to worship God after an unlawfull manner is superstition as †Col. 2 23 Paul witnesseth and †In 2 a. 2 a. quaest. 92. 93. Aquinas and superstitious zeale is preposterous as the * Rom. 10 2. Aquin. in Rom. 10 lect 1. same persons testifie because it is not ordered by a right knowledge Rayn de Rom. Eccles Idolat contra Bellarminum lib. 1 cap. 5. sect 9. X. If such books of prayer so used be the leitourgie and worship vvhich the Lord hath appointed then ought all Churches and people on earth to use that service and maner of vvorship Mat. 28.20 1 Tim. 6.13.14 Rev. 22.18.19 And who then shall make such books for all churches and people in the vvorld Or who can shevv that the Primitiue Churches planted by the Apostles recorded in the Scriptures had any such books of prayer prescribed unto them Or that the Christians in that age did read their prayers out of such books and so vvorship God Fynd vve not mention of their prayers divers times recorded Mat. 14 28 30. Luk. 17 5. Act. 1 24 25. and 4 24 30. And doe not the Apostles in their writings Paul Iames Peter Iohn and Iude everie of theÌ„ in their Epistles speak of prayer and of the manner use thereof yet where doeth any one of them teach the Churches or particular persons to vvhom they write to read their prayers out of a book and so to use set formes of prayer devised by men for their spiritual worship of God making their requests known unto him Let the Scriptures here noted before in the 7 section and all their vvritings throughout be searched hereabout XI Finally if such book-prayers be the ordinance of God and lawfull to be used in such sort as is aforesaid then might one man knovve and set downe anothers prayers aforehand and all men might buy their prayers at the book bynders shops and carry them in their pockets and so out of their pockets take their prayers c. Whereas right and true spiritual prayer is the work of Gods spirit in our hearts stirring teaching and inabling us to povvre out our soules and prayers unto God in all our necessities and occasions and so to offer up spiritual sacrifices acceptable to God by Iesus Christ as is aforesaid Rom. 8 15 26 27. Ephes 6 18. Phi. 4 6. Jâ—de v. 20. 1 Sam. 1 12 15. Zach. 12 10. 1 Pet. 2 5. Rev. 8 3 4. Divers objections and exceptions made hereabout I haue treated of †Quaest de precibus p. 12. c. otherwhere in particular To vvhich I refer the Reader as also to the writings of others heretofore concerning the same argument For which see M. Greenvvoods treatise of read prayer c. besides the handling of this question in two epistles betvveen M. Carp my self p. 11 12 c. CHAPTER II. Touching the constitution of particular Churches VVHether by the ordinance of God there should be any set ordinarie churches novv but onely particular churches And vvhether the constitution of al the particular churches should not be such as each of them may ordinarily come together in one place for the performance of the vvorship of God and all other dueties apperteyning unto them by the word of God I. Because the Primitiue churches vvere thus planted and constituted by the Apostles And this also approved and stablished by Christ our Lord. As may be seen in the seuen Churches of Asia spoken of in the Revelation Rev. 1 4 12 13 20. vvith ch 2 1 8 12 18. 3 1 7 14. And in the other like churches at Ierusalem Act. 1 13 14 15. and 6 2 5. and 15 22 23. and 21 18 22. at Lystra Iconium and Antioch Act. 14 21 23 27. and 15 30. at Troas Act. 20 7 8. at Ephesus Act. 20 17 28. Rev. 2 1. vvith 1 Tim. 1 3. and 3 15. and 5 20. at Rome Rom. 12 3 8. at Cenchrea Rom. 16 1. at Corinth 1 Cor. 1 2. and 4 17. with chap. 5 4. and 10 16 17. and 11 20 22 23. and 12 18 19 27. and 14 23 33 40. In Galatia Gal. 1 2. at Philippi Phil. 1 1. at Colosse and Laodicea Col. 4 16 17. at Thessalonica 1 Thes 1 1. vvith ch 5.12.13.14.27 c. II. Thus also the particular churches of Christians are still ansvverable in this behalf to the particular Synagogues of the Iewes Luke 4 16 20 31 33. 7 5. Act. 13.14.15 and 17.1 and 18 4 7 8 27. And as the house where the Iewes met was called a Synagogue Luke 7 5. so the Apostle now also calleth the meeting of Christians together a Synagogue Jam. 2 2. Neither this onely but seeing novv everie particular constituted church hath right and povver vvithin it self to celebrate the Lords supper vvhich is answerable to the Passeover that vvas kept at Ierusalem this shevveth moreover that now everie particular church is to be esteemed as Ierusalem and so to stand immediately under Iesus Christ the Archpastor of his sheep and the high Priest of our profession 1 Cor. 10 16 17 18. and 11 23. c. Act. 2 42. and 20 7 17 28. compared with Deut. 12 5 6 7 13 14. and 16 â— 5 6. 2 Chron. 29. and 30. and 35 ch Ezra 6 18 19. Esa 66 19 23. Ier. 3 15 16 17. Rev. 21 1 2. c. III. Neyther els can the Pastor of each particular Church stand immediately under Christ the Archpastor Nor can the Ministers and Elders jointly together vvith their flock sanctify the Lords day nor feed the Church over vvhich the holy Ghost hath made them Overseers nor performe any other publick action with them unto them before them duly and orderly vvhether it be the ministration of the vvord or of the Sacraments or Censures or any actions that are publikely joyntly together to be performed according as was done in the Synagogues of the Ievves and in the primitiue churches For which see the Scriptures here before alledged and other the like as Mark 13 34 37. Luke 4.16 20. 12 42. Act. 20. â— 28. Rom. 12.4 8. 1 Cor. 4.1 and 14.23.33 40. Col. 4.17 1 Pet. 5.1 4. 1 Tim. 5.17.20 Heb. 13.7.8.17 IIII. Nor can they well otherwise know of certaintie vvhether the members of the Church be present or absent at their publike meetings for the vvorship of God or other dueties there to be performed
Mat. 5.14.22 10 17. 13.24 18.15 20. 1 Cor. 5 13. with Deu. 17.2.7 21.18 21. Rom. 12.3 8. 1 Cor. 12 20 27. vvith 3.21.22.23 and 4.17 and 5 ch and 11.23 26. and 14.33 1 Tim. 1.3 with 3.15 The Spirit of God hath spoken alike to all the seuen Churches and to each of the Angels thereof and all that haue eares to heare are vvilled to hearken what the Lord saith Rev 1 4.11 and 2 3 chap. Mat. 13.43 VII The Prophets also foretold that under the Gospel everie place of Mount Sion and the assemblies thereof should haue the like gracious presence light glorie and protection of God as Israel had when the Lord brought them out of the land of Egypt Esa 4 2 4 5. with Exod. 13 21. VIII Finally Churches els should not haue povver from Christ in time of persecution or after the apostasie of Antichrist to reteine reviue and obserue the Apostolike ordinances once for all delivered to the Church Which were contrarie to Mat. 28.18.19.20 Act. 5.28.29 Phil. 1.1.28.29.30 Col. 2.5 1 Thes 3 2.3 2 Thes 2.3 15. 1 Tim. 6.13.14 Iude v. 3. Rev. 13. and 2. and 3 ch and 14.12 and 18.4 and 22 16.-19 CHAPTER IIII. Touching the Pastors and other Officers administration VVHether it lye not upon the Pastors and all others that beare office in the church of God to fulfill their Ministerie and to performe al things perteining to their office according to the word of God And not according to the Statutes or Edicts of Princes and States the Canons of Prelates the Constitutions of Synods the pleasure or voyces of the people or any other vvay invented or obtruded upon them by men 1 Cor. 4 1 2. Col. 4 17. Act. 20 17 24 32. vvith 13 24 25. Rom. 12 7 8. 1 Thes 5 12 13 14. 1 Pet. 5 1 4. with Mat. 28 18 19 20. and 6 24. The Epistles to Timothee and Titus Heb. 3 1 2 3. and 13 7 17. Ioh. 15 14 15 16. Gal. 1 8 9 10. Rev. 2 and 3 and 14 4 6 9 12. compared with Lev. 10 1 2 3. Deut. 4 2. 12 32. 33 8 11. 2 Sam. 6 6 7. 2 Chron. 26 16 21. 1 King 22.13 14. Psal 19.7 8 9. and 119. and 132.9.16 Prov. 30 5 6. Esa 8 11 20. and 33.22 and 55 4. Ier. 1 17 18. 19. and 6 13 14 16. and 23 ch Ezech. 2 6 7 8. and 3 chap. Mich. 2 11. and 3 5 8. Rev. 22 18 19. I. Because the Pastors and ministers of the church are by Christ giuen to the church for the vvork of the ministerie and are by their office the household stevvards and dispensers of the mysteries of God And it is required in stewards that a man be found faithful Eph. 4 11 12 13. 1 Cor. 4 1 2. Luk. 12 42 48. and 19.12 26. 1 Tim. 3 15. and 5 17 21. 2 Cor. 5 20. Col. 4 17. II. And Christs commission and charge which he hath straitly giuen to his Ministers is to teach and obserue al things whatsoever he hath cōmanded them neither to adde thereunto nor to diminish therefrom but to keep this his commandement vvithout spot and unrebukeable untill that his glorious appearing To which commandement also he hath annexed a promise of assistance and blessing to such as shal be syncere faithfull herein and a denunciation of judgment and curse upon such as are unfaithfull and disobedient hereunto Mat. 28.20 1 Tim. 6.13.14 Ezec. 2.6.7.9 and 3.10.11.17 c. Mat 25.14 30. Col. 4.17 1 Tim. 5.17 Rev. 2. and 3 ch and 22.18.19 III. The ministers of Christ must therefore euen unto kings princes to Priests and people to high and low of all estates and conditions make knovvne the will of God shevv them their sinnes denounce Gods judgments against them and in all things fulfill and execute all the dueties of their office and functions as there is need and just occasion So far ought they to be from performing their ministerie and dueties of their calling according to the prescription or pleasure of man but onely according to the will and word of God And that so as we ought not to be moved with any afflictions or troubles in this behalf neyther to count our liues deare unto us so as vve may finish our course with joy the ministerie vvhich vve haue received of the Lord Iesus to testifie the Gospell of the grace of God not shunning to declare the whole counsel of God that we may be pure from the blood of all men Ier. 1.17.18.19 Ezech. 3.16 21 Hos 5.1 1 Sam. 15.13 23. 2 Sam. 12.1 14. 1 King 18.17.18 and 21.17 24. 2 Chron. 26.16 20. with Deut. 33.8 11. Mat. 10.16.17.18.28.32 33.37 39. and 14.3.4 and 23.13 39. Act. 9.15.16 and 20.24 28. 1 Tim. 1 3. ◠and 5.1.2.20.21 and 6.13.14.17 2 Tim. 4.1 5. Tit. 2.15 Rev. 2 and 3 ch and 12. 8 11. c. And if all that vvill follovv Christ must cast their account what it will stand them in so to doe must neither loue father nor mother wife nor children brethren nor sisters lands nor goods no nor their ovvne life in this behalf but must be content to leaue and forsake all if they vvill be Christs disciples how much more should the Ministers of Christ be carefull hereof who are to be guides examples to the flock of all godlines pacience and faithfulnes to the end Luk. 14 26 33. 18.18 30. with 1 Tim. 4.12 16. 2 Tim. 2.1.2 3. and 3.10 12. and 4.5.7.16.17.18 1 Pet. 5.1 4. Rev. 2.8 11. IIII. And herein vve haue the examples of the godly ministers and servants of God in all ages who being faithfull to God and performing the dueties of their calling according to his vvord received comfort strength and blessing from the Lord in the midst of all the opposition made against them by any meanes 1 King 22 13 28. 2 Chron. 16 7 10. 24.17 22. and 25 14.15 16. and 26 17 20. Ezra 9. and 10 ch Esa 8 11 20. and 50 4 9. Ier. 15 10-21 and 26 8 24. and 37 6 21. and 38 ch and 39 11 12 14. and 40 1 6. Micah 3 8 12. Zach. 3 ch Act. 4. and 5 and 12 and 16. ch c. 2 Tim. 4 6 7 8 16 17 18. Rev. 2 7 10 13. and 7 7 10 11 12. and 17 14. For vvhich also see the histories of the Martyrs Besides the contrarie examples of such as being not careful or faithful to God in his seruice to minister according to his word haue had heavie judgements come upon them Which also are written for instruction and example to all others Lev. 10 1 2 3 Num. 16 ch 1 Sam. 2 13-36 3 4 ch 2 Sam. 6 6 7. 1 King 13 chap. Jer. 28 and 29 ch Hos 4 6 7 8 9 10. Amos 7 10 17. Mal. 1 6 14. and 2 1 9. Mat. 23 13 36. 2 Cor. 11 13 14 15. 2 Pet. 2 1 2 3
c. And memorable is the example of Saul though a king who doing that vvhich pleased the people and seemed good in his own eyes contrarie to the word of God is therefore sharply reproved by Samuell the Prophet and severely punished by the Lord. 1 Sam. 15 13 24. V. Moreover the Scriptures alone are sufficient for the direction of the Pastours and other officers administration being giuen by inspiration of God and profitable for doctrine for reproof for correction for instructioÌ„ in righteousnes that the man of God may be perfit throughly furnished to everie good work 2 Tim. 3 15 16. Psa 19 7 8 9. And Christ himself vvho alone is the head and Lavvgiver of his church hath left sufficient direction in his vvord both for the faith and for the order of his church Neither may any men vvhosoever super ordeyn to his Testament nor any vvay disanull it or adde thereunto Mat. 28 18 19 20. Ephes 1 22 23. Col. 2 2 23. Esa 33 22. Heb. 3 1 2 3. and 12 25 29. with Gal. 3 15. and Rev. 22 18 19. VI. Otherwise the Pastors and other Officers of the Church should sinne not onely against God but also against themselues and against the Princes Prelates and people whomsoever whose prescription pleasure they should so follovv And that both in making them to be the Lords of our religion and in corrupting them or suffering them to be corrupted by themselues and others in religion and conversation and so to be in continual daunger to be seduced and dravven into errors heresies superstititions and iniquities c. Whereas the Ministers Officers of Christ should in all things be careful so to walk as they may be meanes and instruments under God to bring them to the obedience of Christ in this life and to eternall salvation by him in the life to come Ezec. 3 16 21. 33 1 9. Mark 8 34-38 1 Sam. 2 12 36. and 4 chap. 2 King 16 10 16. vvith 2 Chron. 28 23. Dan. 6 10 22. Psal 2 10 11 12. and 132 9 16. Deu. 33 8 9 10. 〈◊〉 1 17 18. Mal. 1 6 14. and 2 1 9. 1 Cor. 4 1 2. Gal. 1 10. 1 Tim. 4 16. VII Neyther should they els be blamed as they are for the neglect hereof if it vvere not their duetie in the povver of their office to performe and fulfill it in the Lord. Rev. 2 12 14 15 18 20. c. with 1 Sam. 3 13 14. and 2 12 36. Ezech. 13 and 33 and 34 ch Hos 4 6 8 9. Mal. 1 6 14. 2 1 9. and with 2 Chron. 26 16 20. Luk. 12 42 48. Act. 13 25. Col. 4 17. VIII Els also the ministers and other Officers of the church should not now at this time be as straitly bound to be faithfull to the Lord in their functions and in the ministration thereof * Heb. 3 1 2 3. 13 7 8 17. with Deu. 33 8 9.12 Mal. 1 6 14. and 2 7. as were the Priests and other Officers of Israel heretofore Nor as vvere †Act. 20 17 28 32. Cal. 4 17. 1 Tim. 6 13 14. 1 Pet. 1 1 4. Rev. 2 and 3 chap. the ministers other officers in the Primitiue churches vvhiles the Apostles lived Which is contrarie to the Scriptures IX Lastly they could not els discharge the dueties which God hath laid upon them so as to giue account thereof vvith comfort to God at that day vvhen the Lord vvill graciously revvard all such as haue ben faithfull unto him and severely punish them that haue dealt unfaithfully in his service and work committed unto them Mat. 25 14 30. 2 Cor. 5.9 10 11. 2 Tim. 4 1 2. Heb. 13 17. 1 Pet. 5 1-4 Dan. 12 3. Rev. 2 10 22 16-20 Chrysostome speaking to those that ministred the communion saith No small punishment hangeth over you if knowing any man to be wicked you suffer him to be partaker of this Table His blood shal be required at your hands If he be a Captain a Consul or a crowned King that commeth unworthily forbid him and keepe him off thy power is greater then his And againe I will yeeld my life rather then the Lords body to any unworthy person and suffer my blood to be shed before I will grace that sacred blood to any but to him that is worthy Chrysost homil 83. in Mat 26. Many the like things about the Sacraments and censures might be shewed out of the auncient writers But to let them alone the Scripture is evident and undeniable that Iehojadah the Priest set porters at the gates of the Lords house that none vvhich vvas uncleane in any thing should enter in 2 Chron. 23 19. Also that Azariah the chief Priest and the other Priests with him vvould not suffer Vzziah the king of Iudah to burne incense to the Lord yea and vvhen he was stricken vvith leprosie thrust him out of the Temple 2 Chron. 26 16 20. Thus the Apostle likewise chargeth Timothee before God and the Lord Iesus Christ and the elect Angels that he obserue the things prescribed in that Epistle without preferring one before another and vvithout partialitie 1 Tim. 5.21 And that he should keep this commandement without spot and unrebukeable untill the appearing of our Lord Jesus Christ 1 Tim. 6 13 14. Which Timmothee could not doe in his owne person being but to serue his time and then to depart out of this life but thus the Apostle taught that those coÌ„mandements vvere prescribed not for him onely but for those also that should succeed afterward in the ministerie government of the church untill the appearing of Christ our Lord euen to the ende of the world Which yet further appeareth in that Christ doeth so plainly and particularly blame the Angels and Pastors of the Churches in Asia because they â—uffered false teachers and corrupt livers in the churches and did not restreine and represse them as they ought to haue done according to the duetie and power of the office laid upon them by the Lord. Rev. 2 14 20 c. with Act. 20 17 28 30. 1 Tim. 1 3. and 5 17 25. and 6 13 14. Tit. 2 15. But of these things I haue spoken before and shall haue occasion hereafter to note somewhat more againe thereabout CHAPTER V. Touching the distinction of the Pastors and Teachers offices VVHether vve should not in * I speak not here of Schooles or Vniversities in particular the church put difference betvveen the Pastors and Teachers offices I. Because the Pastors and Teachers now in the church are ansvverable to the Priests and †The Leviticall teachers Levites in Israell for sundry things of perpetual equitie and moralitie and are sometimes by the Prophets accordingly styled and signified by their names Esa 66 21. compared with Ephes 4 11 12. Rom. 12 7 8. 15 16. 1 Cor. 9 13 14. And al acknowledge that the Priests and Levites had not the same peculiar
these allegations out of the Scripture Another allegation about the matter aforesaid is taken out of auncient writers Park Polit eccles p. 236. c. shewing that in some churches heretofore there were two Bishops or Pastors in one and the same office in one church at once As namely that there vvas in the church of Ierusalem at once Narcissus and Alexander and in the church of Hippo Valerius and Augustine in Rome Felix Liberius in Nazianzum Gregorie the father Gregorie the sonne c. Euseb l. 6. c. 7.9.10 Sozomen l. 4. c. 14. August epist 110. Gregor Nazianz. epist ad Gregor Nyssenum Whereabout may be considered I. Whether this vvas ordinarie or extraordinarie If ordinarie how is it then that the same other auncient vvriters doe usually still make mention but of one in one church at one time as in their vvritings everie vvhere may be seen If extraordinarie and upon some speciall occasions what then vvas the ordinarie course that vvas otherwise kept and observed usually II. By the instances alledged it appeareth that there were but two of these Bishops in these churches at those times Whereas by the Scriptures alledged and the generall acknovvledgement almost of all there may be many Elders or Bishops in a church and far moe then tvvo Yea if there were but one pastor one teacher one ruling Elder in a church there vvould yet be moe Elders or Bishops then two at once III. The tvvo aforesaid also vvere both of them teaching Elders and Ministers of the vvord and Sacraments vvhereas the Scriptures shevve that there vvere and should be in the Church both teaching and ruling Elders IIII. The vvriters vvhich mention these note some special occasions thereof as that it was in case of old age or sicknes or special good liking and approbation of the parties and returning to the churches and places from which through troubles or otherwise they had some vvhile ben absent or other the like and some difference vvithall observed betvveene some of them Which is also duly to be regarded For vvhich see the â—â—ters and places aforesaid V. The time moreover is to be noted when this vvas done Which by the instances alledged appeareth to be some good vvhile after the Apostles dayes Whereas the question is concerning the primitiue institution and practise from the beginning VI. Also if such examples in later times so recorded by these writers should be respected vvhy should not then the other examples of former times recorded by the same and other Writers likewise VII And finally the onely sure ground of truth and end of controversies in Religion is the word of God vvherevvith so far as the auncient Writers accord their testimonies vvritings may in their place well be regarded According to it therefore I leaue these things vvith the other before alledged out of the Scriptures to be considered discussed And hitherto of the latter braunch of this question Novv furthermore note withall that how ever it be for the matter in hand touching the Pastors and other Elders of particular churches yet still it lyeth on them who receiue or plead for Diocesan and Provinciall churches Pastors or Bishops that they shevv such churches and Pastors planted by the Apostles at the beginning For if it cannot be shevved that the Apostles by vertue of their commission from Christ established such Diocesan and Provincial churches and Bishops who then may establish or submit unto them If they vvho were the Master-builders under Christ did not set them up vvhat povver then is there under heauen that may erect them and what homage is it that a Christian soule can with good conscience yeeld unto them in this behalf 2. The churches must be such and so established as the Lord appointeth and approveth in his vvord Revel 1 12 20. And everie officer in the church must in a due regard be counted a meÌ„ber in the body of Christ Rom. 12 3 8. 1 Cor. 12 12 28. Ephes 4 4 16. And none may set members in the body of Christ but the Lord himself 1 Cor. 12 18 28. c. Euen as on the coÌ„trarie none may keep out despise or abandon those vvhom the Lord hath appointed to be in his church and to continevv therein to the end of the vvorld Rom. 12.6.7.8 Ephe. 4 11 12. with Esa 66 21. 1 Tim. 3.1 15. and 5 3 9 17. with 6 13 14. and with Mat. 28.18.19.20 Luke 10.16 and 12 42 43. Ioh. 13 20. 1 Pet. 5 1 4. Rev. 1 16 20. and 2 1 8 c. 3. Moreover the functions duties of such Prelates if they be members of the body of Christ are to be shewed out of the word of God as vve see done for the Officers of particular churches Rom. 12 6 7 8. Ephes 4.11.12 vvith Esa 66.21 1 Thes 5.12.13.24 1 Tim. 5.17 Rev. 2.1.8 c. and as vvas in Israell for the hy Priest and for the other Priests and Levites besides that vvhich was in their cities and Synagogues Exod. 28. and 29. Lev. 1 16 chap. c. Num. 3 and 4 and 8. Deut. 16 19 chap. Josh 21 chap. 1 Chron. 23 26 ch Luke 4 16 20. Act. 13.14.15 c. 4. The place also and manner vvhere and hovv such Bishops doe and can meet together with the rest of the body whereof they are members that is with their Diocesan and Provinciall churches is to be shewed in their practise agreable to the Scriptures as may be done for the Pastors of particular churches and their assemblies Rev. 1 20. and 2 and 3 ch vvith Acts 20.17.28 Rom. 12.4 8. Col. 4.16.17 1 Thes 5.12.13.14.27 Heb. 13.7.17.24 Jam. 2.2 vvhere the Apostle calleth the assemblies of Christians Synagogues vvhich as I noted before may haue reference to the Synagogues of the Ievves Mat. 4 23. Luke 4 16 20. Acts 13.5.14.15.42 and 14.1 and 17.1.2 and 18.4.7.8 c. As also Ierusalem was the place whither the Iewes were bound to come thrise a yere and where the high Priest and the other Priests and Levites that ministred there were bound to sacrifice and performe the other duties of their callings for the vvhole church from time to time according as the Lord particularly appointed in his word 5. Yea the higher and greater that the members and functions are which the Lord hath set in his church the more undoubted it is that they are specially described in his word and the more needfull both for the church and the Officers themselues to haue certain knowledge and assurance thereof As was for the chief Priests other officers of the church of Israell Necessarie therefore it is that the Diocesan and Provinciall Churches if any such vvere planted by the Apostles and the office entrance administration of Diocesan and Provinciall Bishops vvhich challenge to be chief in the church and distinct from the Pastors and Bishops of particular churches should be shewed out of the Scriptures by such as hold would uphold them if they
could The Catholike church of Rome as they call it and the universall Bishop thereof I omit as being Antichristian most of all and justly left by the Protestants and Reformed churches Though yet far more in some respects might be pretended for this from the state of Ierusalem the High Priests that vvere for the universall church then for the Diocesan or Provinciall churches and Bishops If any alledge in this behalf as some use to doe the examples of Timothee abiding at Ephesus and Titus left at Crete by the appointment of the Apostle for the oversight and government of those churches c. the subscriptions also of those Epistles vvherein both of them are styled the first Bishops of those churches let these things be observed thereabout 1. That those subscriptions are Apocryphall and not part of the Scripture it self 2. That some Greek copies and the Syriack and old Latin translation also haue not this style or title at all 3. That Timothee and Titus were Euangelists vvho were sent appointed by the Apostles sometimes to one place sometimes to another as they had occasion 2 Tim. 4.5.9 Tit. 1.5 and 3.12 whereas the Pastors Bishops vvere appointed to their peculiar flock and seat Act. 20.17 28. 1 Pet. 5.1 4. Rev. 1.20 and 2.1.8 c. If eyther of these were so particularly employed afterward it helps not the matter 4. The first Epistle of Timothee hath not this in the subscription And in the latter Epistle where the subscription styleth Timothee the first Bishop of the church of the Ephesians there doth Paul in the same Epistle both terme him an Euangelist and exhorte him to doe the work of an Euangelist 2 Tim 4.5 yea and call him from the church of Ephesus which was in Asia to come unto him to Rome which was in Italie 2 Tim. 4 9 21. if the subscription be right Likevvise in the Epistle to Titus vvhere the subscription styleth him the first Bishop of the church of the Cretians there doth Paul in the same Epistle call him from Creta in Greece to Nicopolis in Armenia Tit. 1 5. vvith 3 12. And these things may be observed in those Epistles themselues vvhere these subscriptions are besides that other Scriptures doe also shevve hovv they vvere sometimes in one part of the world and sometimes in another sometimes in Asia and sometimes in Europe doing the duties of their office As that Timothee vvas in Asia in divers countreyes and parts thereof in Phrygia Galatia Mysia Ionia c. And in Europe also in Macedonia Achaia Italie c. And in these countreyes and nations sometimes in one city and with one church sometimes vvith another for divers occasions purposes as namely at Thessalonica at Athens at Corinth at Ephesus at Rome at Philippi c. For al vvhich see these Scriptures Acts 16 ch and 17 14 15. and 18 5. and 19 22. and 20 4. Rom. 16 21. 1 Cor. 4 17. and 16 10 11. 2 Cor. 1 19. Phil. 1 1. and 2 19 22 23. 1 Thes 3 1 2 6. with both the Epistles to Timothee And that Titus likevvise was sometimes in Europe at divers places as at Corinth in Achaia at Rome in Italie in Creta and Dalmatia in Greece c. And sometimes in Asia as at Jerusalem in Iudea at Nicopolis in Armenia c. As is evident by these Scriptures 2 Cor. 8 23 24. and 12 18. Gal 2.1 2 Tim. 4.10 Tit. 1 4 5. and 3.12 vvith the whole Epistle to Titus By vvhich also appeareth that Timothee and Titus were Euangelists so imployed by the Apostle Paul sundry times and in sundry places 5. Besides the church of Ephesus vvas a particular not a Diocesan or Provinciall church as may appeare both by the places vvhere it is particularly spoken off Acts 20 17 28. Ephes 1.1 1 Tim. 1.3 and 3.15 Rev. 1 11.12 and 2.1 by the like estate of the other Churches of Asia written unto by Christ Rev. 1.4.11.12.13.16.20 and 2.8.12.18 and 3.17.14 compared vvith Col. 4.16 And so this toucheth not the point in hand Creta in deed is an Iland wherein were divers cities but in every of them were Elders and Bishops ordeyned as is here plainly expressed Tit. 1 5 6 7. c. And by this Scripture it seemeth that when the Apostle departed from thence all things vvere not yet finished among them vvhereupon he left Titus behind him to set in order the things that were wanting and to ordeyne Elders and Bishops in every city Wherein vvhat other thing did Titus then vvhat any other Euangelist so left there might haue done Which also the Apostle himself might and vvould haue done if he had remayned there longer and yet haue ben an Apostle still though for the time or by that occasion he had ben so particularly imployed there And when this was done there by Titus Paul called him from thence to come unto him to Nicopolis as vve haue noted here before out of the same Epistle Tit. 3 12. 6. Moreover the vvord Bishop or Overseer is sometimes used generally and very largely so as the office of an Apostle is sometimes so called Acts 1 20. 7. And lastly vvhy might not the Euangelists being in an office superiour to the Pastors or Bishops of particular churches haue and supply their place in any Church vvhere they came and remayned yet this be no ground or warrant of Diocesan or Provincial Bishops churches any more then Iames so being at Ierusalem who othervvise vvas an Apostle Act. 21.18 Euseb l. 2. c. 23. l. 3. c. 11. l. 7. c. 18. For the further consideration vvhereof besides that vvhich hath ben said before I will here propound two things in an other †Reasons touching cōmunicating with the Minist of the church of Engl. p. 26. c. treatise mentioned heretofore vvhich as they shal be found to haue waight may giue more light to these and other points sometimes called in question 1. The first is this Whether the Lords ordinance in his church be not such as the higher offices conteyne in them and comprehend the inferior offices so as they vvhich be in the greater offices haue besides their ovvne peculiar function vvhereunto they ought to attend povver and authoritie both themselues to performe the duties of the inferiour offices when there is needfull occasion and to look that they be performed by all such as they are specially layd upon for the better service of the Lord and his church therein As may be observed both by the estate of Israell heretofore in the Priests and Levites c. and by divers things written concerning the Apostles Euangelists Pastors and other Elders in sundry cases For example that the Apostles who were in the greatest ecclesiasticall office ordeyned by Christ under the Gospell had besides the peculiar office of Apostleship the povver also and authoritie of the offices of the Euangelists Pastors Teachers Elders Deacons both to performe them upon just occasion
themselues to see them performed by others as is aforesaid In like sort that the Euangelists besides their own peculiar office and function had in them the povver and authority of the inferior offices of Pastors Teachers and Elders c. And likevvise that the Pastors besides their own peculiar function haue in them the power and authoritie of the Teachers and other ordinarie offices for performance and oversight of them as is aforesaid Also that the Elders besides their ovvne speciall function haue in them the povver and authoritie of the Deacons office for the doing and overseeing thereof as was said before and so forth in the rest For all vvhich see Acts 2 40 41 42. and 4 34 35. and 6 1 6. and 8 14 25 26 35 38. vvith 21 8. and 11 29 30. and 14 7 23. 15 6 22 32 35 36 40 41. and 16 4.40 and 20 7 11 17 28 29 30. 21 18 25. vvith Mat. 28 18 19 20. Ioh. 20 21 22 23. and 21 15 16 17. 1 Cor. 4 15 17 22. and 5 3. and 9.7.16.17 and 10.16 and 12.28 and 16 3.4.10 2 Cor. 1.19 and 8. 16.17.23 Ephes 4.11.12 Phil. 1.1 and 4.3 1 Thes 3.2 and 5.12.13.14.27 Hebr. 13.7.17 1 Pet. 5.1 4. Rev. 2.1 c. 2. The second is this Whether on the contrarie the apostasie of Antichrist be not such as touching the ministerie and government of the church as therein they vvhich be in the lesser and inferiour offices haue power authoritie vvith them to exceed the dueties of the office which Christ hath appointed and to performe the duties apperteyning to the higher offices by meanes vvhereof both Antichrist hath risen up to so great a height and so many orders and degrees of superior and inferior ministers haue ben received stil are reteyned in that degenerate estate and apostasie of the man of sinne as is come to passe As namely when the pastors and bishops of particular congregations came to haue power authoritie over many churches over the Ministers people therein in a kind of resemblance of the extraordinarie offices of the Apostles and Euangelists alreadie ceased vvhen now the foundation was layd Contrarie to that which is written Rom. 17 3 8. Rev. 1 11 12.13 16 20. with 2 1 8 12 18. and 3 1 7 14. Ephes 4 11 12 13. Act. 20 17 28. Phil. 1 1. and 4 3. 1 Pet. 5 1 2 3 4. And that the ruling Elders or Presbyters did the ministeriall duties of the Pastors and Teachers in the particular Congregations Contrarie to 1 Tim. 5 17. Ephes 4 11 12. Rom. 12 7 8. 1 Cor. 12 28. And that the Deacons also baptise and became ministers of the word in the office of Deaconship vvhich the Apostles did expressely oppose to the duties of that office at the institution thereof Act. 6.2.3.4 So as of these things and the like in that estate it may be said as Christ did in another case From the beginning it was not so Mat. 19.8 These things and the like may be noted about the points questions aforesaid Which being not vvell observed in former ages a way vvas made for the Popes supremacy by the steps of the Diocesan and Provinciall Prelacy whiles each Pastor kept not his place within his bounds under Christ the Archpastor nor the other Officers theirs nor the Churches that order vvherein they vvere set by the Apostles at the beginning Which being novv in this latter age observed and discovered we should set our selues to reject and witnesse against the Antichristian apostasie of the man of sinne and all the aberrations and iniquitie thereof And be carefull on the other hand to returne to the auncient simplicity of the churches of Christ as they were planted in the beginning alvvaies obserueing good order in all things and that vvay of government of the church which is appointed by the vvord of God CHAPTER VII Touching the Teachers office more particularly and the Ministers of the word in generall VVHether there be not tvvo sorts of Teachers or Prophets which the Lord hath giuen for the work of the ministerie or at least a two fold duty and divers function or ministration thereof One of such as are peculiarly appointed to the teaching of particular churches Of whō see here before in the fift Question pag 259. The other of such as doe either †1 Sam. 19 20. 2 King 2 3 5 7 15. and 4 1. and 6 1. and 9 1. with Amos 7 14. Luc. 2 46. and Act. 5 34. vvith 22.3 in the Schooles and universities interpret the Scriptures train up the students in Theologie or doe ‡ Deut. 33 8 10. Nehem. 8 1 8. 2 Chron. 17 7 8 9. Prov. 1 20 21. and 8 1 2 3. and 29 18. Esa 30 10 20 21. and 57 19. and 59 21. Ier. 18 18. Hos 5 9. and 7 12. Amos 2 12. and 7 12 13. Mic. 3 11. Ezech. 22 25 28. and 13 and 14 chap. Jer. 14.13 Mat. 5 1 2. and 9 37 38. and 13 1 2 52. and 22 35. and 23 34. Luke 5 17. Act. 13 1 15. and 15 35. Rev. 11 3. and 18 24. vvith Act. 11 19 24. Rom. 10 14 15 17. 1 Cor. 12 28 29. and Ephes 4 11 12. othervvhere privately and publikly in houses streets ships armies garrisons or other assemblies any where instruct the people in Religion and al duties of godlines commō or speciall as there is just occasion Also vvhether these Teachers should minister the Lords supper is vvithal to be considered and examined by the Scriptures Seeing the Levites in Israell vvere not suffered to come to the Altar or holy things of God no nor to flay the sacrifices unlesse in a speciall case when there were not Priests ynough Num. 18 3. and 3 10. and Levit. 1 6. vvith 2 Chron. 29 34. Which is the more to be noted because the Levites vvere by the ordinance of God joyned to the Priests in the Ministerie of the Lords house and for teaching Israell the Lavv of God c. who yet notwithstanding might not doe all things perteyning to the Priests office Numb 18 2 3. and Ezech. 44 13 14 15 16. with Num. 3 5 10. c. and 16 chap. By vvhich also appeareth that some Ministers may be imployed in some works of the Ministerie vvho yet notwithstanding may not lavvfully do all things that perteine to the holy ministration and to some other Offices appointed thereunto And that the Pastors Teachers now are ansvverable to the Priests and Levites in Israell vvas noted before out of Esa 66 21. compared vvith Ephes 4 11 12. As touching the election or calling of these Teachers I spake here before of the calling of those which are of the former sort as touching their choise to particular congregations as may be seen in the third Question pag. 252 c. Now touching the calling of the Teachers of the latter sort whether they be such as are Professors in Vniversities
sometimes to the Lord himself or to his Ministers and Officers in church or common vvealth for hearing examining deciding giving sentence executing judgment concerning persons and causes civill or ecclesiasticall Gen. 18 25. Exo. 18 13 16 21 22. Deu. 1.16 17. and 16 18. and 17 9. 19 12 17 18. with Num. 35 12 24. Deu. 25 1 2. 2 Sam. 8 15. 2 Chron. 19 5 6. Psa 82 1 2 8. and 122 5. Esa 1 23 26. Ier. 21 11 12. and 22 1 2 3. Eze. 44 15 23 24. Micah 3 1 11. and 4 3. Act. 16 4. and 18 15. 1 Cor. 5 12 13. and 6 1. c. and sometimes to the people for consenting approving executing resting in that vvhich is judged done according to the sentence giuen by the Lord or the Ministers and Governours under him 1 Cor. 6 2 3. with 5 12 13. Act. 26 10. with 22 20. and Act. 21 25. with 15 6 22. and with 16 4. c. 8. Lastly Christs reproving of the Angels Ministers of his churches for suffering evill persons and corruptions among them Revel 2 14 15 20. c. Which necessarily implyeth that the Lord hath giuen an ordinance to his church for the restreyning repressing and abandoning of such Els why should they be blamed for that which perteyned not unto them or vvere not in their povver to redresse and amend The like also may be observed by Christs speach commission giuen to his Apostles and by their execution thereof Mat. 16 19. Joh. 20 22 23 with 1 Cor. 4 1 2 21. and 5 3 4 5. and 2 Cor. 10 4 5 6 8. and 13 2 3 10. 1 Tim. 1 20. And by the exhortations and instructions that are giuen to Timothee and Titus in Pauls Epistles unto them and to the Elders of Israell and the Primitiue churches recorded in the Scriptures both of the old new Testament 3. And for the maner of proceeding if the course aforesaid be rightly observed thus shall matters and persons be orderly and peaceably heard discussed and judged the governours and government according to the ordinance of God regarded and al good meanes used for the churches good and peaceable estate for the preventing and suppressing of manifold evils and for the benefit and reclayming of sinners such as are found to be obstinate in iniquity shal by publik authority be censured and excommunicated and that also with knowledge and assent of the church the exceptions of al if any be brought being heard as is meet and in such cases to be done And so shall the church be purged from evill the holy things of God kept from the pollution and profanation of such wicked persons the sinners themselues made more ashamed being made knowen unto all and avoyded by them till they repent and the rest that remayne shall all heare and learne and feare and commit no more any such evill among them For vvhich also see the Scriptures before alledged and Deu. 4 1 2. and 13 chap. and 16 18. and 19 19 20. 2 Thes 3 6 14 15. 1 Tim. 5 17 19 20. and 6.13 14. 2 Tim. 3 1 5. Rev. 2 14 20. c. 4. Furthermore as in all other affaires of the church so in these also according to the severall nature of them may the benefit of Gods ordinance thus be enjoyed and all things done in order so as none be prejudiced but that every one may performe their duety enjoy their right and liberty and that both the corruptions of the Popish prelacy and the defects of the Protestant reformed churches and al popular confusion disorder and anarchie may be shunned redressed taken away Col. 2 5. 1 Cor. 4 17. and 11 2 16. and 14 33 40. compared vvith 1 Chron. 13 ch and 15 2 13. and the other Scriptures here cited before And because in this matter there hath ben and still is great question and controversie among Christians both Papists Anabaptists and Protestants of all sorts about the understanding of the words of Christ Tell 〈◊〉 unto the church and if he neglect to heare the church let him be unto thee as an heathen man and a Publicane Mat. 18 17. it shall not be amisse here also to inquire further into the meaning hereof Which therefore I wil novv speak off more particularly in the chapter following CHAPT XIX Of the exposition of those words of Christ Tell the Church c. Mat. 18.17 VVHether those words of Christ Tell it to the Church c. Matt. 18 17. may not be applied to the estate of the Ievves as it was when Christ thus spake and to the estate of Christians succeeding aftervvard I. Of the Synedrion or Congregation of Elders And first applying it to the estate of the Iewes whether they may not then be understood of the Synedrion or Congregation of Elders had in Israel for these reasons follovving 1. The like use of the word in other places of the Scripture where the speach is of matters concerning government controversie complaint or pleading about sinne or the like as there is here in this place For vvhich see Psal 82 1. Num. 25 12 24 25 29. with Deut. 19 11 12 16 17. Iosh 20 4 5 6. Mat. 18 17. with 5 22. and vvith 1 Sam. 2 25. Num. 27 1 2. vvith 36 1. and Josh 17 3 4 c. Neyther is it of any waight herein that some excepting say the Elders of Israell were civill governours and dealt in civill causes c. For Israell was the Church of God asvvell as vve Act. 7 38. with Deu. 33 4. and their Elders dealt in causes of sinne and in the matters of the Lord as vvell as ours 1 Sam. 2 25. 2 Chron. 19 8 11. and the question is whether the phrase may be understood of an assembly of Elders whether civill or ecclesiasticall vvhether in Israell or with us Mat. 18 17. vvith 5 22. and Deut. 19 16 17. and 21 20. Psal 82 1. Ier. 19 1. and Christ and the Apostles reason often from the estate of the Governours and people of Israell to ours novv applying the things that are spoken thereof to the kingdome and church of Christ under the Gospell Iohn 10 34.35 36. compared vvith Psal 82 6. Mat. 21 42. vvith Psal 118.22 Act. 1 20. with Psal 69 26. and 109 7. 1 Cor. 5 6 13. vvith Exod. 12 15. and Deu. 17 7. 19 19. 1 Cor. 9 13 14. with Deu. 18 1. c. 1 Cor. 10 1 18. Rom. 15 4. 2 Tim. 3 16 17. 2 Pet. 1 19 20. c. Not to speak of that which the Apostle expressely writeth to the church of Corinth touching the judgments of things perteyning to this life 1 Cor. 6 4 5. 2. The vvord is not Kabal as †M. Iac. Divine Institution of a ministeriall church Argum. 3 Signature Bâ—s c. some haue thought but Ghnedah or Ghnidtah in the Syriack the tongue then used by the Iewes Christ himself Which all graunt is often
vvere not excluded but might come heare except assent vvitnesse execute c. And that therefore the Elders sate publikely in the gates Councill houses Synagogues c. For which see the Scriptures cited before in this and the former chapter 2. That in these cases the Scripture useth diversity of words as sometimes Elders Judges Governours Overseers c. Deu. 1 16. and 16 18. and 19.17 and 21 19. and 22.15 2 Chron. 19 5. Act. 20 17.28 Rom. 12 8. 1 Cor. 12 28. 1 Tim. 5 17. Heb. 13 17. 1 Pet. 5 1. sometimes the Synedrion or sitting of the Elders the Presbyterie or company of Elders c. Mat. 5 22. Luke 22.66 Act. 22 5 30. and 23 1 6 15 28. and 24 20. 1 Tim. 4 14. and 5 17. sometimes the church the congregation the assembly the Synagogues c. Iosh 20 3 4. Num. 35 12 24 25. Deu. 23 1 2 3 8. Psal 26 4 5. and 82 1. Prov. 26 26. Mat. 10 17. with 18 17. 3. That the people in Israell executed and inflicted punishment on those whom the Governours by the Lavv of God adjudged to death scourging banishment c. Lev. 74 14 23. Num. 15 33 36. Deu. 17 7 12. and 19 16 19. and 21 18 21. and 22 15 21. and 25.1 2 3 9. 1 King 21 11 12 13. Ezra 7 25 26. vvherevvith also note and compare 1 Cor. 5 3 4 5 6 11 12 13. 4. That in cases vvhere things are expresly referred to the judgment of the Elders as in Deu. 25 5 7 c. yet in the practise and observation thereof vve find the people also to be present and according to the present occasions to assent and beare witnesse c. Ruth 4 2 9.10.11 c. 5. That the Apostle wrote to the church of Corinth concerning the incestious person how he had judged in the Name of our Lord Iesus Christ when they vvere gathered together and his spirit vvith the povver of our Lord Iesus Christ to deliver him unto Sathan 1 Cor. 5 3 4 5. And vvhen he vvas rebuked by many upon his repentance also to forgiue him and comfort him and confirme their loue unto him c. 2 Cor. 2 6 7 8. c. 6. That neyther the authoritie of the Elders should abridge the libertie of the people nor the libertie of the people disanull or vveaken the authoritie of the Elders but that both should be preserved and caried in good sort For vvhich see the Scriptures here before alledged 7. And finally that all things of publike nature apperteyning to the publike be orderly and according to the nature of them publikly caried and handled and duely also made knowen unto all reserving and leaueing to every one both Governours and people their right power interest duty liberty about the hearing examining judging vvitnessing assenting excepting approving executing c. so as is meet and right according to the vvord of God as was in Israell and the Primitiue churches heretofore Thus vvhether the vvords aforesaid be understood of the Ievves Church or of the Christians since or both vvhether of the Assembly of the Elders not hindring or infringing any right or libertie of the people or of the Congregation of Elders and people so it be according to good order and the rules of government M. Clift Advertis pag. 96. it cometh to a like end being rightly understood as upon occasion hath els vvhere ben shewed heretofore And this clause of being rightly understood is very needfull to be annexed observed because divers of good judgment think that these words are not to be understood of the whole Congregation as by some of the testimonies †Pag. 312 313. here before alledged may appear also because it should wel be considered hovv these vvords may fitly so be understood or could so be in Israel in such cases as here is spoken off about hearing complaints and judging of cases of sinne between brother and brother c. and specially because that othervvise if they be not rightly understood with due caution and limitation carefully divers errours abuses and erroneous courses * M. Ains M. Rob. M. Jacob. M. Smith c. by divers haue ben gathered received pleaded for and urged ernestly hereabout As namely 1. that this speach of Christ may not be understood of the Ievves Synedrion nor of the Christian Presbyterie or Congregation of Elders novv but that so to understand it is errour sinne 2. That an Elder cannot with good conscience governe and performe his duety in a church that is perswaded so to vvalk Their errours abuses sinfull courses c. 3. That it taketh avvay the power of the Church 4. That it is to be understood of men women and children in their owne persons that can sorrow rejoyce who are also bound in their owne persons to be present to hear judge of causes and controversies between brother and brother 5. And that the people are to haue voyces in excommunications and in judging of causes and persons as in election of their Officers 6. That in a controversie the sentence is to goe out according to the number of the voyces of the greater part of the people though al the Elders and other brethren be against them 7. That the greater part of the people is the church here spoken off though they be in errour and though that al the Elders other brethren be against them therein as is aforesaid 8. That the members of any one church are to haue voyces in every Church vvhere they come in the elections and excommunications thereof c. 9. That the government is popular by the multitude 10 That the kingdome of heauen is a terme peculiar onely to the churches of the Gospel and not perteining to the church of the Iewes Contrary to Mat. 22.2 21.43 8.12 c. That the Elders may not admonish a sinner though obstinate in transgression whereupon to proceed against him without first taking the peoples consent so to admonish and proceed vvith him 11. That it is a nevv rule which could not be kept in Israel when Christ spake it 12. That the people now haue more povver in the government of the Church then they had in Israell heretofore 13. That they could not in Israel forgiue one anothers sinne as vve can now 14. That the people novv are ansvverable to the Elders of Israell then 15. That cases of sinne and controversie between man man are to be heard and judged by the church on the Lords day and as a part of Gods vvorship vvhich †M. Ains Defence of Script pag. 10. with his Annot. on Exo. 20 10. themselues graunt was not so in Israell 16. That the churches government is not Aristocraticall 17. That the Elders may not heare and determine the cases aforesaid unlesse the people be present although the parties and vvitnesses be there ready to haue their matters heard judged 18. That the raynes of government in
the church are not committed to the Elders 19. That the Saints as kings rule the visible Church 20. That the Eldership is not the head in respect of the other brethren as Paul speaketh of the head 1 Cor. 12 21. 21. That the people are Rulers properly and the Governours of the Elders 22. That persons will not accept of the admonitions giuen by the Pastour or other Elders but say if the Church admonish them they will rest 23. That they wil not giue honour to such erroneous government 24. That the Ministers and Officers of the church are forreigne Ministers a forreigne ayde and assistance an unnaturall monstrous and adulterous interposition 25. That ecclesiastical officers haue not offices of authority 26. That the order of Saints or Saintship in the church is an order superiour unto and aboue the order of Officers or of Bishoprick or Eldership 27. That the order of Saints is an order of kings which is the highest order in the church sitting upon the thrones of David for judgement 28. That Suspension is a corruption and devise of men 29. That the Church of Israell had not power to cast out offenders 30. That if there were amongst the Ievves in Christs time a distinct ordinance of excommunication ecclesiasticall it vvas a Ievvish devise without ground of the Scriptures 31. That no good writers use the vvord ECCLESIA for the Congregation of Elders As if the Septuagint were not good vvriters or that this may not be a Synechdochicall speach as there are many in the Scriptures Gen. 3 20. and 9 6. Exod. 20 18 19. with Deu. 5 23. Lev. 9 1 3. in the Septuagint 1 Sam. 8.4 7. c. 2 Sam. 7 7. with 1 Chron. 17 6. Mar. 16 15. Col. 1 23. Iohn 9 22. c. or that GHNIDTAH were not the word used in the Syriack or that it were never used for the assembly of governors 32. That this place may be understood †The Prelates c. of one alone as of the Pastour or Bishop 33. That by these opinions Gods ordinance of the Synedrion Consistorie or Presbyterie is lost and abrogated 34. And the difference between the Synedria or the Councils and the Synagogues annihilated or taken avvay 35 That seeing the Elders are not called ARCHONTES in all the New Testament therefore they are not to rule the church of God 36. That if the Elders be stewards onely over the servants and not Lords over the vvife the church then is not the church to obey or submit unto them And that therefore it is a fallacie a conjunctione divisione to reason thus All the particular members must obey the Elders in their lavvfull instructions their wholsome admonitions severally Ergo the vvhole body or whole flock must joyntly obey the voice of the Elders c. These and other like errours false doctrines and sinfull courses haue ben conceived and urged by divers not all by any one but some by one some by others their toungues being exceedingly divided among themselues about these things By vvhich also may appeare how needfull it is to search out the meaning of this Scripture and carefully to obserue it still looking unto Israell and to the right understanding thereof what we can And this the more considering that †M. Ains his followers c some are so very peremptorie stifly conceited in their opinions concerning these things as they fear not to make schismaticall divisions and notorious scandals thereabout contrarie to the doctrine vvhich vve haue learned of the Prophets and Apostles For vvhich cause they are to be marked and avoyded of all that loue the trueth and seeke their conversion and amendement Rom. 16 17. with 1 Cor. 11 18 19. Gal. 5 19 20. Ephes 5 11. Iude ver 19. CHAPTER XX. Of the maintenance of the Ministers and other officers of the church VVHether it be not the duty of all Churches and of the members thereof every one according to their abilitie to giue maintenance unto their Ministers and as there is occasion to the Elders also that rule the church to the Deacons Deaconesses that serue minister therein 1 Cor. 9 7 14. Gal. 6 6. Rom. 15 27. 1 Thes 5 12 13. 1 Tim. 5 3 17 18. compared with Exod. 20 12. Prov. 3 9 10. Lev. 24 8 9 Num. 18 8 32. Deu. 12 19. and 16 16 17. and 18 1 8. Josh 21 ch 1 Sam. 9 6 7 8. 2 King 4 8 9 10 22 23 42 Luke 8 1 2 3. and 21 1 4. 2 Chron. 31 2 21. Neh. 10 32 39 Esa 30 20 24. Ezec. 44 28 29 30. Mal. 3 8 9 10. 1. Because the Lord hath ordeyned that so it should be 1 Cor. 9 13 14. Gal. 6 6. 1 Thes 5 13. 1 Tim. 5 3 17 18. compared with Numb 18 8 32. Deu. 18. 1 5. and 25 4. 2 Chron. 31 2 21. 2. And thus we shall honour the Lord vvith our substance which hath the promise of blessing from the Lord. Prov. 3 9 10. Ezec. 44 30. Mal. 3 8 12. with Exod. 20.12 and 1 Tim. 5 17. 3. Besides that it is no great thing but our duty to minister unto them in carnall things of whose spirituall things vve are made partakers 1 Cor. 9 11. Rom. 15 27. Gal. 6 6. 1 Thes 5 13. 4. Yea vvho planteth a vineyard and eateth not of the fruit thereof Or who fedeth a flock eateth not of the milk of the flock 1 Cor. 9 7. c. 5. Finally the Apostle teacheth expressely Let the Elders that rule well be counted worthy of double honour especially they who labour in the word and doctrine For the Scripture saith Thou shalt not mousell the oxe that treadeth out the corne and The labourer is vvorthy of his reward 1 Tim. 5 17 18. vvith Deu. 25 4. 1 Cor. 9 8 9 10. Mat. 10 10. But vvhere any churches are poore and not able to maintaine themselues their Officers or poore among them that there they should be holpen by other churches of better meanes and greater abilitie according to their several estate and occasions 2 Cor. 8 and 9 cha Act. 11 27 30. Rom. 15 25 26 27. Gal. 2 9 10. and 6 10. Phil. 4 10 19. together vvith the Scriptures aforesaid It doth in deed lye also upon Kings and all other Magistrates within their dominions cities jurisdictions to haue special care of the estate of the ministers and churches under them as of all other duties concerning religion apperteyning unto them after the example of Hezekiah king of Iudah and Nehemiah the Prince and other the like 2 Chron. 31 2 21. vvith 29 and 30 chap. Nehem. 10 32 39. and 12 44 47. and 13 10 14. vvith Deu. 17 18 19 20. Yet notvvithstanding this should not hinder the foresaid duty of the churches and people themselues but should rather further it and that not onely in affording help where there is want but also in requiring of such as are able that this