administer justice impartially though any or all of them may faile in the discharge of their duty The King being a persecutor of the christian people instead of being their nursing Father the Father leaving his children to the wide world and the Judge taking bribes and being prepossessed with prejudices If mens sins should exempt exempt them from their duty a wicked mans duty should be never to be converted None will say 't is not the duty of a Governor of a strong hold to defend it although he lets in the enemy without resistance That 't is not the office of a Magistrate to look to the safety of the high wayes because he either neglects that care or conniveth at such as doe commit robbery For the second ground Suppose that the Soveraigne Power doth not impose any Law or rather suppose his Lawes are unjust shall a man under such a power live lawlesse or shall not rather such a man being a Christian be tied to be a Law unto himselfe or rather to make the word of God a Law to his conscience Sure such a man must not expect the commands of the Soveraign Power to abstain from stealing or fornication which may be are authorised by Law but must avoid these not for wrath that is not for fear of punishment but for conscience sake as the Apostle speaketh thus when Christ commandeth the Ministers to preach baptise c. and the people not to forsake their mutuall Assembly no doubt but that both the Christian Pastor and people are bound to all Church duties though they have the Soveraign power opposite and threatning all kind of punishment to those that exercise them If those in authority be wanting to their duty I have no reason or ground to be deficient in mine As for the third ground concerning meetings assemblies c. I say that they may be such as though it should be granted on all sides that the Church and States Jurisdiction were but one that the very Soveraign power needs not to pretend to have an eye over them It being a kind of right of nature for Merchants trading in the same commodity to meet for acquaintance to appoint a Randezvous A man being a feciable creature it is no marvell if men are naturally desirous to converse together without expecting any order for so doing Were not the Heteries and Meetings of the ancient Christians of the same nature And upon that account I see not but the Meetings of congregations of those called Independents are very commendable and not to be enquired after by the Soveraigne Magistrate nor by Synods which cannot be proved to be of Divine institution but have taken their originall from those kinds of naturall and innocent meetings which when they were about things which were neither plots nor conspiracy to disturb the peace of the State needed not to be looked after by the Magistrate except when being converted to the Christian Religion he became himself a principall member of those meettings for then specially when the meetings are not onely in houses but in publick places and are tending to have the holy Ordinances set up and published as the main rule of life and ground-work of humane society his chief duty was to govern the Empire as Christian contributing his whole endevour towards the defence maintenance and encrease of the Christian Religion Thus Leo Bishop of Rome Ep. 75. to Leo the Emperour Debes incunctanter advertere Regiam potestatem tibi non solum ad mundi regimen sed maxime ad Ecclesiae praesidium esse collocatam Thou oughtest soberly to consider that the Royall power is not onely committed to thee for the Government of the world but chiefly for the defence of the Church Letter ALL the difficulty then is concerning the Orthodox Magistrate and one that is endowed with the true knowledge of God such as by the mercies of God the Magistrate of England is upon that the fifth Article saith that the Reformers have indeed purged the Popish Doctrine but have reserved to themselves the Soveraigne cognizance of the actions they call Ecclesiasticall challenging the power of the Keyes which when all is said is reduced to this sentence that God must be rather obeyed then men The Authour of the Articles thinks that the Reforming Pastors in retaining the power of the Keyes have not obeyed God he doth indeed acknowledge that under a Prince of contrary Religion the Christian people have done well to establish a government which they call purely Ecclesiasticall and create Elders who are deputies of the people but he is of that opinion that where the Magistrate is of the same Religion with the body of the people there ought not to be any further distinction of Jurisdiction the Church and State concurring into one Christian common-wealth To be short all his discourse is tending to that viz. that in a State where the Magistrate is Orthodox the Keyes and power which the Pastors had under Magistrates of contrary Religion doth no longer belong to them but doth onely belong to the Soveraigne Magistrate whose power is over all persons and things and that in all Assemblies Synods and Classes the conclusions have no force if they be not ratified by the will of the Supreme Magistrate by whom they usually are assembled Consideration VVHat he saith from the Author of the articles that where the Supream Magistrate becomes Orthodox the power of the Keyes doth no longer belong to the Ministers ought to be understood with some explication for the power of the Keyes is still and ought to be the same whether the Magistrate be orthodox or no there is not in the Ministers any addition of that power under the heathen Magistrate nor any substraction of it under a Christian suppose that the Christian Magistrate and Orthodox should turn Apostate I do not conceive that it follows thereupon that the power which the Christian Magistrate hath over the Church is through his Apostacy devolved unto the Ministers for that Legislation or Iurisdiction practised in Christian Congregations Synods or Assemblies under the heathen Magistrate is no more then a harmony of minds affections and actions to holy ordinances and orders by which Christians may worship God more purely and walk more closely with him which ordinances are either Gods word or such as encrease the power of piety and as they are published by common consent as the best rule to walk by so are they in the practise of them willingly and unanimously consented unto and every member of a Christian society submitteth himself to the rules exhortations and censures of that society or Church not being awed or compelled by any coercive power which they cannot avoid if they listed but led by voluntary submission to which by promise and pact they are in a manner already engaged Besides suppose that the Magistrate doth not impose any Lawes to restrain ungodlinesse or the currant sins in the world yea suppose that vices are authorised by Law doth either
wrath sets the most contemptible amongst men and children for Kings even children in judgement over the people that they may depend more on the King of Heaven Yet the most part what they want in personall abilities to act of themselves they recompence in judgement and discretion about the choice of Counsellours many unlearned Fathers and unacquainted in the wayes of education of children will have a good sagacity in choosing able Tutours for their children In like manner the Soveraigne Magistrate may wisely order the course of Law Sciences Arts Trades Manufactures though he be litttle or nothing versed at all in any of them And if it were required that the Soveraigne power should be exactly conversant in all the actions they order there had need to be in a State so many Soveraigne powers as there be acts and disciplines and were they never so capable yet they will do wisely to choose able Counsellours much more in a matter of so high importance as is the deciding of controversies in Religion and ordering the actions belonging to the Kingdome of heaven ubi magna negotia magnis egent adjutoribus and amongst those Counsellours none will be so fit as Divines men of Learning Gravity and Piety Thus if the Soveraigne power goeth about to reform the abuses of severall Professions and Arts within his Dominions as for example of Physick no doubt but he will joyn with his Counsell the most skilfull of that Art But that the Pastours or Ministers are not the fittest to have a Supream Iurisdiction over persons and causes they call Ecclesiasticall reason and the sad experience of former times teacheth us for were they endowed with knowledge by Revelation and had Ecclesiasticall Assemblies compounded meerely of Divines a non-erring gift not communicable to any other Assemblies of men I should willingly and necessarily admit that Divines ought to be assisting the Christian Magistrate not onely as Counsellours but also as Iudges coequall to them yea Superiours in that Iurisdiction which they challenge to themselves but the gifts of Government being not inseparably joyned with those of preaching and the Ministers not being endowed with 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 or infallibility more then those that sit at the Stern of the State can be I do not see but that their proper place and employment is to be counsellours to the Soveraigne power in matters belonging to the Kingdome of heaven But being falne insensibly upon the rank and station that Ministers ought to keep in a Christian Common-wealth because it is a matter complicate with the question in hand concerning the pretended Ecclesiasticall Jurisdiction distinct from the Civil it will not be amisse to discusse which of the Governments either by Bishops or onely Presbyters is most consistent and compatible with the peace and safety of a Christian Protestant State If it be admitted on all sides that there is but one power of Legislation and Jurisdiction in all causes and over all persons belonging to the Supream Magistrate I conceive that then Bishops overseers set over many Congregations besides that they are more agreeable with the Primitive institution will much ease the Supream power of the care they must take in ordering persons and causes nearer concerning the Kingdome of heaven for his inspection being but over the Bishops Factions and Heresies will not so easily spread among the multitude of the Christian people as if he were immediately to overlook the actions of the great body of Presbyters who being numerous may easily escape his eyes and have a greater freedome to innovate Therefore Moses being Supream in all causes and over all persons It was a wise counsel of Jethro his father in Law to wish him to set under him men over the people who besides that they bore the burden with him those men being far lesse for number then the people it was easie for Moses to oversee them But under those Magistrates who should condescend to a divided and distinct Iurisdiction one being civill and exercised by themselves the other Ecclesiasticall and of Divine right belonging to the Ministers of the Gospell In that case I do conceive that few Bishops set over Presbyters and being Independent from any other power have a greater opportunity to Lord and tyrannize over the Christian people then a numerous company of Presbyters of the same rank and equall Authority can have Letter NOw for that the Author of the articles would have this distinction of civill and spiritual abolished 't is a thing very hard to change and alter the nature of things as if one would take away the distinction betwixt black and white Let men doe what they can and say what they will the questions about Faith will be still spirituall things and suites in Law for money or houses will be still civill and temporall matters If we change the words the nature of things cannot suffer alteration Consideration THe Magistrate is no more head of two things Church State then of thousand kinds of actions in a Christian Common-wealth which for every one of them needs not a particular Soveraign a Power Now these two things Christian Church and Common-wealth cannot be so much as conceived to have a reall being without each other for as every man is a reasonable creature and every reasonable creature a man so every Christian Common-wealth is a Church and every Christian Church a Common-wealth I speak of those Churches that have as large and spacious extent of place as the Common-wealth it selfe for in some other sence a family in a house is called a Church and according to that acception every Church should not be a Christian Common-wealth I think the Church is not different from the Christian Common-wealth more then the understanding is from the Soul for as powers and faculties are believed by great Philosophers not to be distinguished really from the Soul however though there should be a difference it cannot be so distinct as that the power can have a distinct being from the Soul but that at least all powers are subaltern and subordinate to the chief power called 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 which sits at the stern of all faculties and directs and modifies all actions though never so severall contributing as well to ratiocination and vision as to the coction and expulsion In the like manner that Soveraigne power in a State though one in essence hath its severall faculties or powers from which severall actions do stream tending to the ordering of the whole man in his being and well-being as well in things of the inward man as the outward And to follow he analogy between the body of man and the State it is no little illustration to beget belief that as the primum movens or Soveraigne power is one and extends it self as far as it is circumscribed by the cuticula or thin skin there being not one Soveraigne power for the head another for the lower regions and a third for the hands and feet So in
a State bounded as England by certain limits no doubt if it be one State or Comon-wealth it hath one Soveraigne power reaching as well to Cumberland as to Kent and Cornwall over all persons actions and causes for if some persons or causes were exempted as for example the persons and causes they call Ecclesiasticall within the same limits of Land I do not conceive that there can be any such power nor can I Imagine where that power in matters Ecclesiasticall or ordering Church wayes should reside by which the Supreame Civill Magistrate is bounded but there may be as well ten thousand Supream powers and Courts Ecclesiasticall within England as one single generall power for the Civill Magistrates Jurisdiction being distinct from the Ecclesiasticall he may not hinder that multiplication of powers every one of these powers assuming to be sui Juris in sacred things or if he hinders it and prevaileth to have but one Soveraign power in Church matters in all his Dominions this very act of prevailing will be a sufficient demonstration that there is but one Soveraigne power over all causes and persons Ecclesiasticall and Civill indeed the taking away the branch of the Jurisdiction and power of the Christian Soveraign Magistrate in things pertaining to the Kingdome of heaven is as much as to destroy all Ecclesiasticall power and Jurisdiction for besides that this makes the Magistrate but a cipher or zero in sacred things it abolisheth all Ecclesiasticall Discipline Parish meetings publick and uniforme exercises of the ordinances which cannot be performed but by the supreame Magistrates ordering permission or at least connivence and it reduceth all Church wayes to the congregational which way though it cannot be disproved all men naturally having a power to associate themselves upon their ordinary affairs without the Supreame Powers leave or ordering much more when those meetings are pious innocent and without danger to the publick weale yet if there be no other Church-way within all the Dominions of the Soveraigne Magistrate then the Congregationall not onely all Power of the Keyes and Jurisdiction in Church-matters is quite taken away from the Christian Magistrate but also all Presbyteries Classes Synods and with them their Power and Jurisdiction vanisheth and comes to nothing and in truth it will come to nothing if you doe not make that publique ordering of Church-way setting up of Ordinances uniformity of Catechising confession of Faith discipline censures to be a branch of the Legislation and Jurisdiction which the Soveraign Christian Magistrate is to have over all causes persons and actions for in Gods name where can that Power in Church matters be seated but in the Christian Magistrate May be you will seat it in all the Christian people within the Magistrates Dominions But by this the Christian people having the Soveraign Power in Ecclesiasticall shall have the liberty not onely as I said before to make as in England either one two or more yea ten thousand Nationall Churches as far differing one from the other in Rites and Constitutions as the Scottish Church is from the English and the English from the French the word of God not stinting whether associated Christians ought to be many or few in one body or whether many bodies or few in one Nation as England and whether they must be a collection of Churches joyned in one body of a Nationall Church or not And which is more this absurdity and great inconvenience will follow from this dividing of Powers that it will be free for Christians to erect in two contiguous Countryes under two distinct Magistrates as France and the Territory of Geneva one collective body of Churches ruled by the same Synods and Decrees under one Soveraigne Power in Ecclesiasticall and thus shall you have not Imperium in Imperio but Imperium in duobus Imperijs a confusion of Empires for who may have right to keep them from so doing If you say that both the neighbour Soveraigne civill Powers may hinder them to that I say either it is an usurpation in them to doe so or if not then that Power by which the Church is ordered is subordinate to the Soveraigne Christian Magistrate which is all I intended to make good But it may be said againe that all the Christians or all the Congregations who are big enough to make a Church such as the little number of two or three of Christ in the Gospel gathered together in Christs name within the Dominions of the Soveraign civill Power will have that humane wisedome as to erect but one Nationall Church and of the same latitude and extent that the Dominions are To that I say that this very liberty and humane wisedome which they make use of without a certaine prescript from God doth sufficiently evidence that they make use of the same guide which the Supreame Power doth imploy in the governing of the State and that since humane wisedome must be be called to help for the ordering of these two things they will have to be distinct viz. the Church and State none can be better trusted with them then the Supream Power of the State where the Church must be constituted and indeed the Christian Emperours have always modelled the Church after the fashion of the State or if you will the State after the Church because they were to depend of one supreame Power for as they had Bishops in every City whose bounds and extent was called 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 a Parish so had they a Defensor Civitatis and in every Province the Arch-bishop or Metropolitan was answerable to the Praeses or Proconsul and in every Diocesse the Primate or Patriarch was like the Lieutenant or Vicarius or Legatus To summe up all as the primum movens in the naturall body extendeth it selfe to all parts and functions of the body so the Soveraigne Power in a State hath an equall Jus Imperij in Ecclesiasticall and civill matters And as the sensitive and vitall parts are equally extended and circumscribed by the same limits so all the causes of what kind soever they be are bounded by the same supreame Power within the same limits of land as if on the North side Barwick is the bound of the civill Power of England so is it of the Ecclesiasticall But it may be demanded how the soveraigne Power may be said to have Jus Imperij in Divine Lawes I answer that properly the office of a Soveraigne Power is only ministeriall and in regard of God it is rather an administration then a power but in regard of men because it bindeth to obedience 't is a Power and Authority Now his Law is either just or unjust if unjust yet the obedience to it being not sinfull it must be obeyed as a Law in force for the strength of a Law doth not consist in that it is just but in this because 't is a Law ordained by him who hath Authority Now if this Law be just it must be obeyed for two reasons
constrained to obedience but as they were ratified by the seale or supreame will of the Soveraigne Magistrate who usually did call and dissolved them VII Although all power and jurisdiction in all things be annexed to the Soveraigne Magistrate by that we doe not meane to diminish any thing of the nature of the Empire and jurisdiction which the Lord Iesus Christ even in this world hath over his Church whose members he knoweth by name and which he doth governe by his Word and Spirit VIII But to beleeve that the body of those that make an externall profession of the true Religion must be governed by Lawes made by persons distinct in jurisdiction or legislation from that power which belongeth to the Soveraigne Magistrate t is a thing which cannot be found in the Scripture where we doe read that the Church and Kingdome of the Iewes were the same thing and that in the Synedrium all causes were decided and all kinds of persons convented IX These things being premised as afore t is not understood that the government by Presbyteries Synods Classes or even by Bishops must therefore be abolished but onely that all their jurisdiction is like a branch or rivolet streaming from the fountain of power residing in the Soveraign Magistrate X. Neither is it understood that the Magistrate ought to give orders or preach the Word although magistracy and ministry be things very consistent no more then to create Doctrors of physick or the like but onely that the power to exercise any profession or calling externally is conferred by him and cannot be done without him XI That the calling of Lay-Elders is not of necessary use in a Country where the Magistrate is of the same Religion with the body of the people it being more then reasonable that so much or more power be granted to the Orthodox Christian Magistrate then they yeeld to the Elders in France XII Now because some think it unfit that the ministers and the causes which they maintaine to be of their cognizance should in all things be subalterne to the Soveraign Magistrate the only expedient if we beleeve them to make the Church and State to be one Christian Common-wealth under one Soveraigne power were that the Rulers and Over-seers of the Church as Ministers and Elders should have also the Common-wealth committed to them in the manner as the Waldenses or Albigenses were governed for it seemeth that such Ministers would be contented that the Church and Common-wealth were one so that they might have the whole rule and Government but rather then to misse a share they become strong assertors of a distinct jurisdiction whereof they may appropriate one unto themselves Sic hisuperiorem illi parem non ferunt A Letter Examining the foregoing Positions Sir YOu sent me certaine articles touching the Ecclesiastical policy and thereupon are earnest to know my opinion the which I was long in debate whether I should deliver or no questioning whether the declaring of my sence in this matter be of any weight or moment but since by your last you presse it further upon me telling me that some persons of wisdome and gravity and in authority in the state are earnest to know my sence and opinion thereon I have at length given way to your importunity leaving to your discretion either the suppressing of this writing or making of it publike The two first articles do lay down for a foundation that all humane actions ought to be done in faith and referred to the soveraign end which is to glorifie God and to obtaine salvation and that the duty of the soveraign visible power is to declare unto the people the will of the great Legislator and that the laws of the said soveraign power ought to be conformable at least no way repugnant to the Law of God All this is just and honest and it were a sinne against piety to contradict it The second article saith that the soveraign Magistrate hath right to regulate all humane actions which are tending to that soveraign end and that he alone ought to sway and preside over all meanes Lawes offices places and persons appertaining to the said actions else if there were two supreme Magistrates one over the actions they call Ecclesiasticall and another over the civill a great deal of confusion would ensue And that heresies schismes and wars did arise for the most part from the Popes dividing the said actions challenging to themselves the regulating of one part of them leaving the other to the Emperour and Kings thus setting up Imperium in imperio I am of opinion that there cannot be in a well composed State and so doth the scripture teach us more then one soveraign power and that all persons of what quality and condition soever are subject to the soveraign Magistrate and that the Pastors of the Church cannot be excepted or exempted from that subjection their duty being to exhort and dispose the people to be faithfull and obedient to that power by Gods providence set over them and chalk them the way by their example 1. Iosh all the people the Levites and the Priests being comprised speak thus to Ioshua All that thou commandest us will we do and whithersoever thou sendest us we wil go 1 King 1. v. 33. David saith to Bethsheba Take with you the servants of your Lord. The context shewes that Zadok the high Priest was of the servants of the King 2. King 23. v. 4. And the King commanded Helkiah the high Priest and the Priests of the second order And there he chideth them for not obeying his command in repairing of the temple S. Paul doth appeal to Cesar acknowledging him his Iudge Consideration NOte that S. Paul appeales to Caesar as to the supreme competent Iudge not onely in relation to his private person and cause but the cause of the Gospel for the question was whether there was any crime in preaching the Gospel and the Apostles acknowledge the worst of the Emperours the supreme power and Iudge Had Festus not been a competent Iudge in Ecclesiasticall matters but onely in civill instead of saying I am judged for the hope c. that is for the resurrection of the dead the chief point of Christianity he would have said I am not to be judged before thee in these matters Letter THe same Apostle Rom. 13. enjoyneth that all persons be subject to the higher powers acknowledging the powers that have the present rule to be given of God that is such as by a speciall act of his providence have the soverain power in hand St. Pet. 1.2 v. 13. Submit your selves to every ordinance of man for the Lords sake and note that the Emperour to whom obedience is commanded to be rendred was a tyrant and a most wicked man Nebuchadnezzar had subdued Iudea and lead the Iews captives yet Ieremiah speakes thus to the remnant of the Iewes not yet transported Submit your neck under the yoak of the King of Babylon and serve him
which of them the Temple and Priesthood did belong Letter GRegory of Tours who wrote about the yeare of our Lord 585. the historie of France in the 18 chap. of the 5 book speaks thus to the King Chilperick If any of us O King go besides the path of righteousnesse thou mayest redresse him but if thou dost transgresse who shall be able to correct thee we speak to thee and thou hearest us but if thou wilt not who shall have the power to condemne thee but he that is Iustice it selfe At that time the Bishop of Rouen named Praetextat was in great reputation yet was this Bishop being accused to have adhered to Meroue who rebelled against Chilperick clapt into prison by the Kings command and sore beaten and banished to Garnsey Consideration ALL this is sufficient to prove that the Soveraigne power of the State hath alwayes challenged power over Ecclesiasticall persons by that which follows it will be as clear that they challenge likewise the cognizance and ordering of Ecclesiasticall causes and actions Letter THE Greek Emperours have called all the oeconomick Councells not expecting the consent of the Bishop of Rome and often against his consent as the first Councell of Constantinople and of Chalcedone Yea in matters of Religion and Ecclesiasticall policy one cannot deny but that the Soveraign power of the State hath made orders David made twenty foure ranks of Priests Salomon had the chief oversight of the building of the Temple and bringing in all the vessels We see in the Code of Iustinian great number of Lawes concerning not only the policy of the Church but also the purity of the doctrine as be the titles de summa Trinitate fide Catholica de Episcopis Clericis ne sanctum Baptisma iteretur By which Lawes it appeareth that the Emperours had power to punish the Bishops namely by the 123 Authentick chap. 1. the Emperour speaketh thus Si quis autem extra memoratam observationem Episcopus ordinetur jubemus hunc Episcopatu depelli Yea he there addeth pecuniary Fines Consideration AS by these Lawes in the code of Justinian it appeareth that the Emperours had power to punish the Bishops as the Letter saith so doe they much more clearely assert the right and power which the Supreame Magistrate hath not only over all causes they call Ecclesiasticall but to make Lawes and Constitutions of the same nature as the causes be Letter A Great part of the Capitularies of Charles the great and of Lewis le Debonnaire are Laws Ecclesiasticall like those we read in the Councels of those dayes The Councell of Meyns held in the yeare 813. begins thus Carolo Augusto verae religionis Rectori Defensori Sanctae Ecclesiae And the second Councell of Meyns speaks thus to Lewis le Debonnaire at the opening of it Domino Serenissimo Christianissimo Regi Ludovico verae religionis strenuissimo Rectori Defensori Sanctae Ecclesiae I doubt not but these Emperours made those Lawes by the counsell of the Bishops and Prelats within their Dominions But they were willing to have them currant under the name of their Imperiall Lawes and the stamp of their Authority for the Soveraign Magistrate is the servant of God appointed by God to see the Law of God observed amongst men and the pure worship of his name set up Consideration THe Soveraigne Power is constituted by God to the end that men might live godly justly soberly and peaceably A Heathen could say that in a Common-wealth the first care must be Religion the 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Arist And there is good reason that the Soveraign Magistrate should seeke after that which he is in the first place to ask for which is the Kingdome of Heaven being the basis of humane society so saith Cicero Religio est humanae societatis fundamentum But that the duty of the Supream Power is equally to order the religion and the civill government St. Austin doth plainely set it downe in the third Book against Cresconius Grammaticus In hoc Reges sicut eis divinitus praecipitur Deo serviunt in quantum Reges sunt si in regno suo bona jubeant mala prohibeant non solum quae pertinent ad humanam societatem verum etiam quae ad divinam religionem In that Kings as they are injoyned by God doe serve God as they are Kings if within their Kingdom they command good things and forbid evill things not onely in things belonging to humane society but also to divine religion Letter ANd I doe not believe that in England there is any Minister of the Word of God found who doth not acknowledge a subjection to the Sovereign Magistrate but is rather exceeding joyfull that the holy Ordinances are setled by publick authority and therefore there is no feare that any of them should goe about to perswade that there must be an Ecclesiasticall Common-wealth differing from the civill and one Common-wealth within another 'T is all the fault we finde with the Pope and his Clergy that they have made Imperium in Imperio and that the Clergy by his Lawes cannot be convented before the Royall Judges for they have Courts of Judicature and Prisons severed from the civill they have their appeales to the Roman Court and are freed from taxes and impositions Consideration THat power which the Ministers doe challenge in censuring and punishing of offenders suspending from the communion or excommunicating as inherent and intrinsecall to the Ministers of the word and not being a branch depending of the jurisdiction of the Soveraign Christian Magistrate that power I say thus challenged is as much as to constitute one Common-wealth within another Letter FOr I doe not thinke that Bishops or Ministers ought to render themselves Judges in any cause civill or capitall to punish the offenders by imprisonment taxes or bodily penalties Jesus Christ never authorized them so to doe for he would not so much as accept of being an arbiter in sharing of an Inheritance For these reasons I doe not believe that those in whose hands God hath now entrusted the Soveraign Power in England shall have any ground of fearing that the Ministers so long as they discharge their calling making use of that authority that Jesus Christ hath given them have any intention to intrench upon the Power and Authority of the Soveraign Magistrate But because the third Article attributing to the Supream Magistrate a right to order all humane actions tending to the Soveraign end which is the glory of God and the salvation of souls might seem to draw this consequence that the soveraign Magistrate is judg of all actions about Ministry and the Preaching of the Word therefore the article addeth a prudent cautition viz. That we must obey the Soveraign Magistrate so long as his commands are not repugnant to Gods commands for if he should command the abjuring of the Christian Religion or bowing before an Idol or should introduce another propitiatory sacrifice for sinnes
besides the death of Christ then such commands were not to be obeyed Nor doe I say that therefore the State must be embroiled and the Magistrate resisted but that one is rather to endure martyrdome or all kind of persecution then to lose his soule in giving obedience to such commands Thus have the three friends of Daniel done and all the faithfull martyrs We see in the Apologetick of Tertullian that in his time the Christians did fill the greatest part of the Roman Empire which might have been very empty had they gone about to flee for persecution into a remote Country Read St. Austin upon the 124 Psalme Valentinian the II. was laboured to take away the Temples from the Orthodoxes and give them to the Arrians but Ambrosius Bishop of Milan withstood him but how he tels you himselfe Dolere potero potero flere potero gemere adversus arma milites Gottos lachrymae meae arma sunt talia enim sunt munimenta Sacerdotis aliter nec debeo nec possum resistere To this exception I would adde another that the Magistrate must be obeyed in the actions in which he acts as Magistrate and for such a one taken For if a Soveraign Prince be in a Ship and a storme happens I doe beleeve that the Master Pilot ought rather to follow the rules of his art than the will of the Prince who is not versed in navigation The Magistrate indeed may forbid the mariners to lanch out of the Port and to saile into Spain or the Indies or to import or export such and such wares but it doth not belong to him to order how the Ship must be steered or the sailes hoised up Thus a Prince learning to ride ought if he meanes to learn to obey the Master of the horses yea as a Saveraign Prince he hath power over the person life and goods of the Master of the horses yea I say that the yielding of the Prince to the Rider is a kind of a command to the Rider so to deale with him I say the same of a Magistrate sick obeying the prescripts of a Physitian he doth obey as a man and not as a Magistrate whereupon a question may be moved whether the Magistrate being at publique prayers and partaker of the Sacraments is there as a Magistrate or as a Christian Consideration THis similitude or relation betwixt a Prince in a storm and the Pilot and betwixt a Prince sick and a Physitian is very pertinent to declare that the power of the Pastor over the Soveraign Magistrate is of the same nature and proportionable to that power which the Physitian hath over the Soveraign Prince being sick or that of a skilfull Pilot in a storme over him who may be his King but unskilfull in the art of navigation This power is rather a friendly counsell though exercised and uttered in a commanding way specially in the mouth of a Minister who in the name of God may command a Soveraigne Prince to redeem his sins by a speedy repentance for in effect 't is but declaring unto him what be the commands of God for the good of his soule Thus a Physitian following the rules of his art and his long experience may charge a King his patient as he tenders his owne health which he must not obstinately cast away to refraine from such and such meates and doubtless that King would grievously sinne against God who rejecting the counsell of the Physition and wilfully obeying his owne lust and appetite should thereby fall into a relapse It might happen in a storme or shipwrack that the Pilot should use a kinde of compulsion and violence towards his Soveraign pulling him as it were out of danger and forcing him to hearken to the meanes of his preservation for which he ought not to be blamed Letter I Think also that we should make a distinction between a Magistrate that is faithfull and orthodox and one that is an Ethnick or an Heretick for under a heathen Magistrate I doe not see how it can belong to any but the Pastors of the Church to manage the Church for shall a heathen Magistrate and persecutor be a judge of the articles of the Christian faith or make use of suspension or excommunication Whence it followeth that the state of the Church may subsist although the power of the Keyes and the governing of the Church be not in the Magistrate If the heathen Magistrate should forbid the Pastors upon paine of death to hold councels or Ecclesiasticall assemblies or to preach the Gospel or if there be such an urgent necessity of calling a Councell to stop the current of a pestilentiall heresie or to degrade some Pastors that disturbe the peace of the Church or that have crept in forcibly may the Pastors be condemned if they doe privately convene themselves contrary to the will of the Magistrate Consideration THis is one of the strongest arguments that can be alledged for the power of the Keys and Ecclesiasticall Courts and Jurisdiction different and independent from the civill Magistrate because there hath beene sometimes Church-government calling of Synods and exercise of Jurisdiction against the will of the soveraigne Power and not complicate with the civill Power But in mine opinion it hath no strength all for first I lay down this for a ground that the Magistrate whether Orthodox or not doth retaine still the same supream power over all persons and causes of what kind soever Secondly that in all persons and actions of men under the soveraigne Power this grand rule must be first observed that God must rather be obeyed then man Thirdly that many actions of all kinds naturall or voluntary even meetings assemblies and orders obliging some men or society may be done without the cognizance of the soveraigne Magistrate For first If heathenisme or heresie could devest a man of the power he hath over all persons and causes by that unjust lawes should be no lawes a diseased man by the same reason should cease to be a man and a wicked Emperour as Heliogabalus should not have beene ranked among the Emperors nor acknowledged for the supreame Judge of the Land because a bad one I confesse that a Heathen or hereticall Soveraigne cannot but judge amisse of persons and causes either out of ignorance or malice but ignorance of what is right doth not devest him of his right neither doth a wicked managing of his owne right hinder it to be a right still Depraved actions in nature continue to be actions still An Orthodox Soveraign Magistrate falling into heathenisme or heresie as Julian the Apostate loseth no part of his supreame power he that over all causes and persons no more doth the Soveraigne Magistrate get any addition or extent of power if from heresie or heathenisme he is converted to the Christian Religion 'T is the duty of a Magistrate to defend and propagate Christian Religion It is the Fathers duty to provide for his children the part of the Supreame Judge to
Pastors or society of Christians get an increase of power of Jurisdiction and Legslation if they be a Law unto themselves and practise the duties of piety and exhort one another so to do Plinius the younger in the 97 Epistle to Trajan and the tenth book where he speaks of Christians saith that one of their crimes was that they joyned themselves in a covenant to live unblameably not to steal not to commit fornication not to defraud his neighbour and the like I believe that none will from that practise of the Christians argue that they took upon them more power for so doing then they durst under a Christian Magistrate except he were of the mind of some of late in Authority in England who disliked and endeavoured to suppresse all godly private meetings under pretence of Factions Sure if I mistake it not it will be found that the Pastors power of the Keyes had no life to compell the disobedient to Gods ordinances till they received it from the Soveraigne Magistrate when he gave his name to Christ who both more honoured and exalted Gods ordinances raising them from the dust and added weight to the heavenly messages by the mouth of the Ministers by being a terrour to the evil and punishing the ungodly To the power of persuasion and declaration he addeth that of coaction in which the Pastors have nothing to do The Bishop saith Saint Paul must not be a striker 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 And hereupon Chrysostome saith well If a man is drawn from the faith the Priest must undertake with patience to exhort him for he cannot redresse him by force onely he must strive to perswade him to bring him to the right Faith Pastors saith the same Father are appointed to preach 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 not to rule or command with authority Letter HEre I dare say that the Reformers of the Doctrine of the Pope have not retained the Keys that were under Popery In reforming the Doctrine they have also reformed the abuses cleaving to the Keyes which are abominable for in the Romish Church they extend the power of the Keyes so farre as pardoning sinnes in a judiciall way saying to the sinner I absolve thee from thy sinnes The Priest renders himself Judge in a cause wherein God is the party offended By vertue of these Keyes the Pope drawes souls out of Purgatory he looseth those he never bound and which are none of his flock he doth loose under earth because Jesus Christ hath said what ever you shall bind on earth he doth loose and dispence with oaths and vows and freeth Subjects from the obedience due to their Soveraigne Prince he separates marriages exempting also children from the obedience they owe to their Father and Mother These holy men of God who have reformed the Doctrine have left off those Keyes and kept those which Jesus Christ hath given to his Disciples and their successors I will give thee the Keyes of the Kingdome of heaven it was also impossible to reform the Doctrine without reforming the Keyes since those Keyes are a part of the Doctrine they have retained to themselves the power to bind and loose which Jesus Christ gave to his Disciples Math. 16. Whatsoever thou shalt bind on earth c which power goeth no further then Ecclesiasticall censures as the Lord Jesus Christ teacheth in the same place giving to understand that by this binding the rebellious sinner is put among the Publicanes and sinners who were excluded from the Communion of the Church Thus we must understand the power of remitting or reteining sinnes given by Jesus Christ to his Disciples The faithfull Pastors do remit sinnes when they release men of Ecclesiacall penalties and receive to the Communion of the Church the repenting sinner who was excluded Consideration THe Reformers have done as Richard the third in usurping a power which yet he exercised with moderation and making of good Lawes so did Augustus Caesar and some more Thus the Reformers have reteyned the Keyes to which they had no more right then the Pastors of the Romish Church but have taken away those adjuncts of abuses and abominations adhering to the power of the Keyes In that sence as Richard the third may be said to have usurped the Crowne as well as he who to usurpation hath added a tyrannicall Government and making of wicked and unjust Lawes so may it be said that the Reformers in reforming the Doctrine have reteined the power of the Keyes the Article thus speaking having no further meaning then to say that the Reformers in reforming the Doctrine have still challenged to themselves an Ecclesiasticall Iurisdiction not belonging to the Civil Magistrate even as the Pastours of the Romish Church have donc though not the same for qualifications As for the meaning of the words dic Ecclesiae tell it unto the Church it cannot have much strength what ever interpretation one may give to the words whether by the word Church we understand a Synagogue or judicatory as was that of the Iewes amongst which there was no difference between Church and State or Common-wealth or a society of faithfull men and though by the Church Pastours should be understood I do not see here any Iudiciall sentence binding him that trespasseth against his neighbour but still he may if he will hearken without fear of any coercive power seated in the Ministers and the words Let him be to thee a heathen or a publican have no further meaning then have him for such a one in thy thoughts and estimation a Publicans office was lawfull neither yet could he be excluded from the communion nor from the congregation the very heathen not being excluded from the latter for how else could they have been converted Letter THE Reformers then in reforming the abuses in the Doctrine and Keyes have retained the Keyes and power to bind and unbind committed to them by Jesus Christ The Author of the Articles acknowledgeth that the Pastors of the Church have well done to retain that power under the heathen Emperors that is almost for the space of 350 yeares from Christ to Constantine the first Christian Emperour since which Emperour the said Author thinks that the Bishops and Pastors were to part with that Power and that the Soveraigne Power of the Keyes did no longer belong to them but that they were to desert it in obedience to God which yet they have not done for all the ancient Councels although convened by the will of the Emperours are full of penitentiall canons prescribing the forme time and degrees for publique pennances in the execution of which canons the consent of the Emperours nor of their Lieutenants was never expected Consideration WE have seen before that the power of the Ministers is neither increased nor diminished whether the Magistrate be Orthodox or no and that the power of the keyes given them by God hath more lively actings under the Orthodox Magistrate To that part of the Letter which saith that in
THE POVVER OF THE Christian Magistrate in Sacred things Delivered In some Positions sent to a Friend upon which a returne of his opinion was desired With some considerations upon the Answer and a Digression concerning Allegiance and submission to the Supreame Magistrate By Lewis du Moulin History-reader of the University of Oxford LONDON Printed by G. Dawson for FRANCIS EGLESFIELD at the Marygold in Pauls Church-yard 1650. To the Right HONORABLE Bulstrode Whitelocke Esquire Rich. Keble Esq Sergeant at Law John Lisle Esquire Lords Commissioners for the Custody of the Great Seal of England My Lords I Pretend not by this Dedication to loosen any one link of the chains of Civilities and unmerited favors whereby I am bound unto your Lordships But rather finding my selfe insolvent as a stranger destitute of other Sureties I have taken the occasion to give publick suretyship of my profest beholdingnesse Besides this personall motive there was another reall for intending this discourse onely as a Hue and Cry after truth which the self interest of some hath lurched from the knowledge of other Christians I should wrong this same truth if I did not entitle your Lordships to her patronage who are upon all occasions her so zealous abettors Your known goodnesse requires I presume no Apologie for the incongruous addresse or composure of a stranger I pretend to truth and if she be not as shee ought to be I am sure my English is starke naked in which condition if you please to cast over her the mantle of your protection the stormy age wherein we live shall no more hinder her production then abate the zeal of Your Lordships most devoted Servant LEWIS du MOULIN To the Reader HAving occasionally made some Considerations upon the ensuing Letter which gave me in one place pag. 20. c. a faire insinuation to speak of the Allegeance due by Subiects to the present power by Gods providence set over them I was the more willing to insist a little upon it and particularly upon the late Engagement which being tendred me in Oxford by order of the State by whose favour I am a member of that University I frely acknowledge I was not so scrupulous as many of my brethren of the University were men otherwise of known piety and integrity but have subscribed unto it for which undergoing various censures by many who either are not yet perswaded to subscribe or are engaged otherwise and being not conscious to my self that herein I have done against my duty or disobeyed Gods word or been prepossessed with particular interest I thought my selfe obliged to give publickly an account from what Scripture reason and humane authority I have received satisfaction and encouragement to subscribe thereby hoping even from the most averse either to be pardoned or excused Errata Pag. 81. lin 24. read 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 p. 107. l. 9 Acts read Arts. p. 110. l. 13. 14. read over few Bishops Positions concerning the Power of the Christian Magistrate in Church matters I. THat all humane actions Naturall or Voluntary even the most mechanick and servile so they be necessary and not sinfull must be done in faith and are to be referred to the Soveraign end which is to glorifie God by words and deede and to obtain the Summum bonum of men which is the love of God and union with him II. That the principall duty of the Soveraigne visible Power in regulating the actions of mens society is not to make new Lawes but to declare the will of the Grand Legislator even God in his Word for the right governing of that society according to his divine will making Lawes agreeable or not repugnant to it holding forth to the people for a soveraign Law that God must be rather obeyed then man III. That since the Soveraigne Power hath right to regulate all humane actions which doe tend to that Soveraigne end he alone must preside over all Orders Lawes Offices Places and Persons which have any reference to the said actions Else if two Supreame Magistrates were constituted sharing betwixt them the Supreame power the one being over certain actions they call Ecclesiastical the other over the Civill such a State cannot be conceived without a great deal of confusion Humane actions of what kinde soever they be having so neare affinity among themselves and being included one within another IV. That for the most part the causes of Heresies and Wars which have troubled the World came from the Popes dividing the said actions vindicating to themselves the regulating of one part of them leaving the ordering of the other to the Emperour and Kings and thus erecting Imperium in Imperio and not only so but by reason of the great affinity there is betwixt humane actions reducing almost all of them under his cognizance V. That the Reformers have indeed repurged the doctrin from Popery but still have kept to themselves the Soveraign cognizance of the actions which they call Ecclesiasticall assuming to themselvs the power of the Keyes which in truth is restrained to this sentence That God must be rather obeyed then man and therefore when the Magistrate was unwilling to have a hand in the Reformation or the exercise of the true Religion as in the primitive times or in France they have done well even without or against the liking of the Magistrate to make a body of Congregations giving it an order which they call purely Ecclesiasticall Likewise they did well to create Elders who are the Deputies of the people for otherwise the word could not have been preached the Sacraments administred and the soules saved But where the Soveraigne Magistrate is of the same Religion with the body of the people these words Ecclesiasticall Civill Spiritual Temporall Clerck and Lay ought to cease and with them the diversity of legislation and jurisdiction and under such a Magistrate the Common-wealth is a Christian Visible Church these words having but an accidentall difference but yet such as have caused a reall difference Now such distinction of words which parts things that should not be divided ceasing the originall of all order and power over all actions and things is seated on the Soveraigne visible power and doth extend to and over all kinds of persons none being exempted nor any thing excepted if it be not contrary to Gods commands In summe the Supream Magistrate is none other then the Minister of God for the good and salvation of those that are under government VI. These things being so and the Christian visible Church being an assembly of good bad which have need to be governed for their temporall and eternall good it is manifest that under other words it is the same thing with the words of Christian Common-wealths and that the legislatiō jurisdiction which the Soveraigne Magistrate hath over it is extended over all persons and causes and in all Assemblies Synods and Classes for even the conclusions and canons of the ancient Councels had no force which
that their duty is not onely to render him his own but also instruct him and make him know the extent of his power and tell him his duty is to throw his scepter at the feet of Christ and mainly seek and care for the things pertaining to the Kingdome of God And likewise if the said Magistrate upon deliberation takes that charge upon him who doubts but that although the duties of the Pastours be never the lesse their burden is so much the lighter and that they have lesse to care for The civil Lawyers tell us that if a man by Will is appointed Guardian to a Pupil and cannot produce the Will the soveraign Magistrate may ordain any one to be Guardian till the Will be produced This is the very case and the application is easie that the Soveraign Magistrate is set Tutour over the Christian people by the will of God now the while a Will is concealed it is well if some body takes care of the Ward and it matters not much who be the Guardian so that the Ward do not suffer dammage in his person or estate but when the Will is produced to the Supream Magistrate good reason then he should discharge the part of a faithfull Tutour and the maine trust laid on him and intended in the Will which is that those that are under his tuition may inherit the Kingdom of heaven To that purpose the Author of the book de regimine Principum ascribed to Thomas Aquinas hath a golden saying The end which principally the King must intend in himself and Subjects is eternall beatitude which consisteth in the vision of God and because that vision is the most perfect good every King or Lord is chiefly to endeavour himself that his Subjects may attain to that end Letter ANd since the Scripture saith the Church is made up of two kinds of persons viz. Shepherd and sheep he should have declared whether he ranked the Magistrate amongst the Pastours or Sheep Consideration THE Magistrate is among the Sheep in relation to the Pastour as he is a Patient in respect of his Physician and a Disciple in respect of his master teaching him Arts and Sciences in a ship he is but one of the vectores in relation to him that guideth the Ship and sits at the stern Beside in some regard the Soveraign Magistrate is the Pastor as David is so called and the Christian people the Sheep these relations being mutable accidents and not inseparable properties do not in themselves either abase or elevate the nature of the Subject Letter THis also is a point worthy the consideration If when a Magistrate liveth disorderly and is guilty of enormous crimes the Pastour may not deal with him with reprehensions and admonitions and when the Pastour seeth apparantly that such a Magistrate cannot be partaker of the holy Supper of the Lord but to his condemnation whether he may let him perish without reproving and advertising of him Consideration AS a Magistrate being sick is subject to the orders of the Physician so as a Sheep he is no lesse yea more subject to the power of the Keyes then the meanest of the flock for the more he is exposed to contagious vices which he doth countenance by his example the more need hath he of antidotes and preservatives It was an old and true saying miser est Imperator cui vera reticentur The power of the Keyes declaring from God a message no doubt but the Soveraign Magistrate is equally concerned to heare God speaking as any one of the common people Letter ANd since the Authour of these Articles saith that the Soveraign Magistrate ought to have in all causes and actions and over all persons an absolute power so that he commands not any thing contrary to the word of God for in these cases he holds disobedience to be just it had been needfull that the said Authour had told us who shall be Judge whether the Magistrates commands are repugnant to Gods commandements in case any difference be moved thereupon Consideration TO this question I answer that none can be a visible Judge but he that is the Soveraigne power of the Common-wealth and though he judgeth erroneously and partially he hath onely God that shall judge him Pastors or Congregations must either acquiesce to his judgement and decision as being onely legall or they must suffer for righteousnesse sake Now if one saith the Pastours must be Judges this Judgement must be either of authority or of discretion This latter judgement is that by which every man having reason and conscience is able to discern what is true what is false what is fit and usefull and what is unprofitable and hurtfull by this judgement every Pastor yea any other man may judge of the wrong wayes the Magistrate takes and the Pastour may go yet further for being convinced in his judgement and conscience that the Magistrate liveth in an ungodly way he may and must presse unto his conscience Gods word and his Iudgements but by the first kind of judgement which is of Authority I do not conceive the Pastors can judge the Soveraign Magistrate only they must strive to perswade him counsell him and use no other forcible arms then prayers to God and tears Lachrymae meae arma sunt saith St. Ambros to the Emperor Valentinian II. for it cannot be conceived that two soveraign powers can stand together in a State and Civilians have ever so contrived Laws and Courts as they do not justle and clash one against another Thus though paternall right is most naturall and ancient yet have they alwayes subjected it to the Soveraigne Magistrate and make that yield to this Now as they make three kinds of actions Ecclesiasticall Iudiciall and Military suppose the Soveraigne power Ecclesiasticall should bid a man to go to Church the second power should bid him to go to the market and the third power to the Leaguer I demand how shall this man be able to fulfill all these commands at once belike he will obey none for as saith Tacitus ubi omnes praecipiunt nemo exequitur when all do command there is none that obey therefore there must bee an order among the powers one being subaltern to the other else you can no more conceive a parity of powers then two Gods in the world Letter ANd because ofttimes dicussions may happen in the discussion of the true Doctrine and upon points of great concernment to the Christian Religion the authour of these Articles should have declared whether he understands that the Soveraigne Magistrate is to decide those controversies and whether his meaning is that the Supream counsel be made up of Divines expert in these matters Consideration THough the Soveraigne power should have little or no insight in things pertaining to the Kingdome of heaven yet being by Gods providence the Supream Iudicature of the Countrey this must be taken for a Iudgement of God who as it is said in the 4th of Daniel in his
viz. first for conscience sake and for wrath that is the tye of every Christian in all the commands of the Magistrate is to obey God and doe whatsoever just and honest thing lies in ones power then for feare of punishment for any precept though morall and never so just although it bindes the conscience yet 't is no Law binding to obedience in foro humano till it be reduced into a Law by the Legislative Power of the Soveraigne Magistrate for even the supream power though Christian and godly cannot punish a theife for transgressing the commandement Thou shalt not steale except this Law be also a Law of the State But againe it may be demanded what authority and power doe you entitle on the Ministers of the Gospel to whom the Scripture committeth the power of the Keyes and giveth high Titles Names and Eloges I answer that still they have the highest honour in the world even higher then the Magistrates and Kings higher then Judges for all men shall be judged by their Gospel they are Ambassadours from Christ to earthly powers as the Kingdom committed to them is not of this world so their weapons are not earthy but spirituall and sharper then any two edged sword they condemn when they doe denounce the judgments of God to impenitent sinners they pardon declaring the mercies of God to penitent and mourning sinners they rebuke all kinds of men teach exhort admonish and have a kind of power and authoritie binding as much or more to obedience then the commands of the Soveraigne Magistrate for a man once convinced by the preaching of the word the word of of the Minister apprehended to be the truth of God or a command from God will be like the Intellect which being enlightened doth more powerfully work upon the will to act then when it is compelled by an externall agent and even civilly the respect one hath to an Artist binds in a manner to follow his prescriptions 'T is no marvell then if Theodosius being rebuked sharply by Ambros yielded to a censure rather coming from God which he was willing to undergo being conscious of his sinfulnesse and deserts then that it proceeded from a man endowed with a coercive power of excommunication to which not to yield had been a rebellion against God as Christ alone is the true spirituall Legislatour so he alone doth either withold or remit sinnes Solus saith Hilarius the Deacon peccata dimittit qui solus pro peccatis nostris mortuus est and the words of Lombard are very expresse to shew the extent of the power of the Keyes Sacerdotibus tribuit Deus potestatem solvendi ligandi id est ostendendi homines solutos vel ligatos God giveth the Priests power to loose and bind that is to make known they are either tied or loosed li. 4. dis 18. Saint Hierome upon the 26. of Matth. teacheth us what this potestas Clavium is as the Priest makes the Leprous either clean or unclean so doth the Bishop or Priest bind or unbind and saint Cyprian lib. de lapsis and other where saith that by the preaching of Ministers men receive not forgivenes of sins but are brought by it to be converted by getting a Knowledge of their sins And saint Augustine in many places saith that the Minister is some body in the administring of the Sacraments and dispensing the word but no body for the Iustification of a sinner and for working inwardly except he that made man worketh in the man Were the nature of Christs Kingdome well understood I suppose that the power of the Keyes would be easily stated I mean that Kingdome and power by which Christ worketh by his word and spirit upon the spirits of men inclining them to do his will by perswading and not constraining them by any coercive power delegated to the Apostles and their successors in the Ministery Christ himself saith he is not come into the world to Iudge the world but that the world should be saved by his preaching And the comparing of Christs Kingdome to a grain of Mustard seed and to leaven hid in the dough sheweth manifestly that this Kingdome is propagated by secret perswasions and workings and not by a Iudiciall external power seated in the Ministers constraining to obededience upon bodily or pecuniary penalties Were the visible Kingdome of Christ a different Kingdome from that of the Christian Magistrate we should read in the Gospel of some Lawes besides those about the sacraments for the regulating of the said Kingdome The precepts to believe to repent and to be baptised are no such Lawes that for the non-performance of them men should incurre punition or damnation for the not obeying of the Evangelicall precepts is an argument that the wrath of God is upon the transgressors and not an effect following upon the transgression He that doth not believe in Christ is condemned already man refusing to accept of the remedy in the Gospel is left to his former miserable estate and the Law onely takes hold of him Now this Law denouncing both temporall eternal punishment to the transgressors it is evident that the power to judge in the world according to that Law in ordering all causes and punishing all kinds of persons transgressing doth belong only to one Soveraigne power subaltern not to Christ as the Soveraigne Preacher and Mediatour but as God in Trinity and Trinity in unity or as God Creatour and Supream Governour over all causes persons estates and conditions temporall or eternall Letter A Midst all these difficulties it will be a work pleasing to God to find a mean to keep the caling of the Ministery of the Gospell in the posture and condition as it was established by Jesus Christ without any abating and diminishing of the dignity and power of the Soveraigne Magistrate and I believe that just and easie means may be found out Consideration THere is but one means which is that of Queene Elisabeth King James and of Hooker in his book of Ecclesiasticall polity wherein under the words of Royall power Crown and dignity he teacheth us that all power and Iurisdiction Ecclesiasticall is derived from the Supream power of England and is upholden and defended by him The words of the Act Elizab. 1. cap. 1. are very expresse omitting nothing which can be of Pastours and Synods cognizance which be not mentioned to be of the Iurisdiction of the Supream Magistrate All Ecclesiasticall and spirituall Jurisdiction is annexed to the Crown to visit reform redresse order correct and amend all such heresies schismes abuses offences contempts and enormities whatsoever which by any manner spirituall or Ecclesiasticall power authority or Jurisdiction can or may be lawfully reformed In the same statute it is enacted and ordained that no opinion shall be judged or determined to be heresie but by the high Court of Parliament of the Realm Letter WE have already laid down for a firme and constant ground and ordained by God that all Ecclesiasticall
and over all persons no prophet in his time prophesied but the 70 Elders who yet prophesied by the spirit of Moses communicated to them In Joshuah's time the Regall or Civill Supreame Power was joyned with the Sacerdotall and seated in Eleazar as we may read Numb 27. vers 18 19. c. And St. Peter in his 1 Epistle chap. 2. vers 9. he coupleth them together or rather maketh but one of them calling the Common-wealth of Israel a Royall Priesthood That these Powers were no lesse divided in Samuel appeareth by the word of God to him 1 Sam. 8. ver 7. They have not rejected thee but me as if he should have said this people is weary to be under thy government they must needs have a King of their owne but in so doing they have not so much cast thee off as me who had set thee over them After Saul the High Priests attempted nothing except it were by a speciall command of God without the Kings consent Thus when the Booke of the Law had been a long time lost and then found the Priests enquired of the Lord concerning that Book by the command and direction of Josias so that the supreame visible authority to judge whether the Booke found was to be received for the Law of Moses and the word of God did only belong to the King as we see in the 2 Book of King chap 22. 23. where we read that the King called together all sorts of men viz. Elders Priests Prophets and all the people and read the Book of the Law before them all and withall was the author of the Covenant to which all the people stood under the word people all ranks of men being comprised After the return from the captivity it is knowne that the Sacerdotall Kingdome was againe set up as it was in Joshuah's time and under the Judges Letter IN the 10th Article he saith it is not understood that the Soveraigne Magistrate ought to give orders which concession will serve to keep a part of the authority belonging to the Ministers for if the ordination doe belong to none but the Pastors only it followeth that to them only belongeth the degrading and exauctorating of Ministers which are either vicious or hereticks or yet uncapable They may take away what they have given but still the punishing of them for crimes is in the power of the Soveraign Magistrate Consideration THere might be yet a question made whether when the Supreame and Regall Power is set in it hath not much of the Ministeriall and Sacerdotall Office annexed to the Regall calling and paternall Right for 1500 yeares together the Soveraigne Power was joyned with the Sacerdotall and among the chiefe Cities of Greece the Kings were Priests omnino apud veteres saith Cicero qui rerum potiebantur iidem auguria tenebant ut enim sapere sic divinare regali ducebant The division that was made to Aaron was not of the Soveraign Power but of the exercise of the Office Besides Aaron was an expresse figure of Christ our great High Priest which office near the time of Christ even soone after the Captivitie was againe confounded with the Regall but not to make use of this plea I say it is of ordination as of taking of the degree of Doctor of Physick or Law in an Academy This co-optation though made without the speciall privacie of the Supream Power yet in generall 't is not done without his consent permission he hath stil an inspection over the man quatenus Physitian or Lawyer and so long as he exerciseth the profession In like manner though the Soveraigne Power doth not ordaine this particular man yet is ordination of his appointment and one of his Lawes though it comes first from God for so doth the morall Law which notwithstanding after it hath been published under certaine penalties becomes the Law of the Supream Legislator of the State we have amongst the Constitutions of Justinian some bearing that title De ordinatione Episcoporum Clericorum Letter NOw if the Orthodox Magistrate under whose shadow the Church subsisteth and the true Religion maintained should transgresse the limites vindicating to himselfe more power over the Church then God hath given him in his Word I shall alwayes give counsell to the Pastors of the Church and to the people to beare that yoake with patience without murmuring giving thankes to God for bestowing Magistrates who are conservators of the purity of the Gospel under whose shelter and protection the souls are directed to the way that leads to salvation Consideration I Conceive that if the Soveraigne Magistrate takes upon him the care of ordering Church matters that the Pastor and Church have a yoak so much the lighter and therefore have need of lesse patience to beare it then if they carried it themselves neither doe I conceive that the transgression here mentioned in the Letter can be any trespasse in the Magistrate and though it were one that it is not much materiall nor of any dangerous consequence he having as the Letter saith the maine qualification required in a Magistrate which is to be conservator of the purity of the Gospel and besides the main end being obtained which can ever be desired and aymed at in any government which is to be directed to the way that leads to salvation But suppose that the Magistrate abuseth his own power over the Christian people in ordering the things which concern the Kingdome of God I doe likewise conceive that here the Magistrate does trespasse as a tyrant and not as an usurper and is like him that is drunke with his owne wine and not with anothers in which there is yet a double trespasse the one against his owne body the other against the good creature of God which he spils to no purpose But as they say by way of proverb right is right still and wrong wrong in what ever disguise they appeare So mischiefe is a mischief still and as great a mischief in the Soveraigne Magistrate whether his power exceedeth in things they call Civill or things which pertaine to the Kingdome of heaven though the inconvenience be farre greater in mis-ordering the latter God having equally entrusted him over all persons and causes in a Christian Common-wealth In the discharge of which trust it were to be wished that all Christian Magistrates would governe without that distinction of Powers Ecclesiasticall and Civill FINIS February 25. 1649. Imprimatur Nathaniel Brent