and such is the end of the Apostolical Presidency even the preventing Schism and the preserving Order and Unity in the Church A Prudential Experience doth tell us it is with Christs Church as with Davids Harp in all a parity of office is as far from peace as the unison of strings is from harmony subordination in some and superiority in others is as requisit to Ecclesiastical as Civil Polity without which Schism becomes as fatal to the Church as Rebellion is to the State So that we must subscribe to the grave sentence and judgment of St. Hierome unless the Episcopal pre-eminence of Authority and Office be preserved Hieron Dialog Adv. Luciferian Tot in Ecclesiis efficientur Schismata quot Sacerdotes There will be as many Schisms in the Church as there are Presbyters especially if every Presbyter hath power of Ordination intrinsecal to his Office by the Divine Right of Apostolical Institution For what then would be the use of Ordination but chiefly to propagate Schism But some may say to prevent this Though the power of Ordination be common to all yet the act of ordaining is restrained to a few Presbyters But I ask by what Authority of Scripture they do it and what Primitive patteâ—n they have for their practise Besides to exclude their Brethren from the exercise of what they acknowledge is proper and intrinsecal to their office is a manifest injury and violation and if all should exercise what is their right of office and cannot be taken from them this would be a strange disorder and confusion Wherefore Beloved in what we have asserted the Apostolick Constitution and the Churches practise doth engage our consent of judgment and conformity of obedience upon a double tye of Reason and of Religion So that if we be either prudent men or pious Christians we must submit to the truth of this assertition That by imposition of hands to ordain into the Ministry is not in the power nor belongs to the office of any meer Presbyter Acts 20.17 28. Phil. 1.1 But what do we not finde that frequently in sacred Scripture Presbyters are called Bishops and are they not therefore one in office being one in name and not to be differenced in the Church not being distinguished in the Scripture To this so specious an Argument we answer our adversaries That as we are not so ignorant as from the name to prove the office of Bishop so nor should they be so erroneous as from the community of name to prove the identity of office in Bishop and Presbyter We finde in the Acts and Epistles those sacred Records which give us the first path of Ecclesiastical Government not so obvious to the eye as when Church practise had trod it out into a beaten road we finde I say in the Acts and Epistles the same persons sometimes called 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Ministers sometimes 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Presbyters sometimes 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Bishops so that by the signification of name it is clear we have not the distinction of office 1 Pet. 5.1 2 John 1. And therefore Presbyter being spoken of the Apostles as well as Bishop of Presbyters As from hence That the Apostles were called Presbyters we may not conclude That Presbyters are no less then Apostles so nor from this That Presbyters were called Bishops may we conclude That Bishops are no more then Presbyters It is easie to observe how words common at the first became appropriate in their use and so in some process of time even within one Century of years after Christ the distinction of office became commonly known by distinction of name Bishop being appropriate unto him who had an Apostolical presidency of Ordination and Jurisdiction in the Church We close then with this sure inference from the premisses That this late Schism in our Church of meer Presbyters ordaining to the Ministry as it hath not any clear Text of Scripture to warrant it nor any allowed practise of the Church to approve it so nor hath it any argument of Reason to abet it as being contrary to that Mission constituted by our Saviour in his 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Go ye disciple all Nations Baptising them in the Name of the Father and of the Son and of thy Holy Ghost teaching them to observe all things whatsoever I have commanded you Applic. 1 Cor. 9.16 1. You see Beloved what is our Mission Christ hath bid us go and a necessity is laid upon us Wo unto us if we preach not the Gospel But then much more wo unto them who stop our mouths that we cannot preach or that binde our feet that we cannot go Let such dread Jeroboams judgment their arm withering 1 King 13.4 their power shrinking and wasting with a curse God did bear long with Judah but when they came to this That they mocked the Messengers of God 2 Chron 36.16 17 c. despised his words and misused his Prophets then there was no remedy his mercy had borne so long that his justice could bear no longer but wrath does arise against his people to captivity and to desolation Oh Beloved the Ministers souls lie at stake for the peoples if we warn you not your perishing through our default is a default whereby we perish Oh the blood of Souls how loud does it cry for vengeance when spilt by the hand of ignorance error slothfulness or cowardice in the Minister See in the course of our Ministry Christ gives us our Mission to go O let us not through your perversness and obstinacy in sin go upon thorns and bryars finde torture and trouble of Soul in our service but in your obedience of Faith to the Gospel of Christ O make beautiful our feet make pleasant our paths Sure there is no greater joy and blessed even thrice blessed be God I can call it much my joy there is no greater joy in the service of our Ministry then to preach the Gospel to a willing and reverent Auditory But oh Beloved and my dearly beloved in the Lord this this is too too much the disparagement of your profession and the discouragement of my Ministry that your holiness of life and righteousness in the world answers not your reverence in the Church your zeal for the Church O that he who gave me my Mission to preach would give you his Grace to practise 2 Cor. 3.3 that I might say of you what St. Paul says of his Corinthians Ye are the Epistle of Christ ministred by us known and read of all men The Epistle of Christ such in whom he hath imprinted the truth and holiness of his Gospel which hath been preached unto you This this would very much seal the lawfulness of my Ministry even its efficacy in your lives which though it is not the most infallible yet is it the more comfortable seal of Christs Mission in his 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Go ye disciple all Nations c. 2. As I have shewed
Aerium 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 That order which is Generative of Fathers Presbyters may beget Sons by Baptism but not Fathers by Ordination and Consecration This is the Bishops peculiar as Successor to the Apostles in that full Ministry which is perpetuated in the Church That the Seventy Disciples had not this full Ministry nor Presbyters the Successors to those Disciples who have power to Preach to Baptize and Consecrate the Eucharist that they have not this full Ministry is the evidence of sacred Scripture and Church History And we will now make the evidence clear as to that main particular the power of Ordination in which we have the Doctrine of the Scriptures to approve the practise of the Church and the practise of the Church to interpret the Doctrine of the Scriptures Consult we then 1 The Sacred Scriptures And the first Ordination we meet with is that of those Seven Acts 6. commonly called Deacons and here we finde no hands but those of the Apostles The second Ordination is that of Presbyters Acts 14.23 and this we finde to be by the hands of Barnabas and Paul Which two when separated to the work of the Ministry if we may call it an Ordination it is by the hands of Simeon Lucius and Manaen Apostolick-men Acts 13.1 2 3. Prophets ministring to the Lord who as Church History tells us were Bishops of Syria The last Ordination we meet with in Scripture actually executed it is that of Timothy 1 Tim 4 14. which though by the hands of the Presbytery yet is not that Presbytery without an Apostle even the laying on of the hands of St. Paul 1 Tim. 1.6 From Scripture practise pass we on to Scripture precept and for this consult we the Epistles to Timothy and Titus in which we have the exact platform of the Churches Ministry as communicated and perpetuated from the Apostles Behold we then the Church of Ephesus and the Churches of Creet in them we finde many Presbyters and above those Presbyters in dignity and office Timothy and Titus and that Timothy and Titus were in dignity and office above those Presbyters appears plainly by that power they had of enacting Ecclesiastical Laws of passing Church censures and of ordaining by imposition of hands in which is the work and the office proper and peculiar to Timothy and Titus above those Presbyters which were in their Churches And observe those instructions given by St. Paul to Timothy and Titus in their particular persons have been and yet are continued in the Church as sacred Rules to regulate for ever the Function and Office of an Episcopal presidency 1 Tim. 5.22 Tit. 1.5 1 Tim. 5.19 Tit. 3.10 which Function and Office extends it self not onely to the ordaining of Presbyters but also to the exercising a Disciplinary power and an Ecclesiastical Jurisdiction over them as appears by many plain Texts given by the Apostle But 2 from the Scriptures Authority pass we on to take a short view of the Churches History Which History from the most sacred and inviolable Records tells us of many Bishops seated by the Apostles yea many successively continued during the lives of the Apostles And strange it were that St. John who tells us of so many Antichrists 1 Joh. 2.18 should not tell us of Episcopacy being Antichristian if he had had the Spirit of our present times to have believed it such which â—rer l. 3. c 3. sure we are he did not believe for that Irenaeus assures us 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 in his yonger years he saw Polycarpe Bishop of Smyrna whom he knew to be so constituted by the Apostles and amongst those Apostles Tertullian Tert. de P aescript c. 32. is express that St. John himself was one After Tertullian consult we St. Basil and he calls Episcopacy 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the Apostolical prefecture and presidency August Ep. 44. yea St. Augustine he informs us That Radix Christianae societatis per sedes Apostolorum successiones Episcoporum certa per orbem propagatione diffunditur the Root of Christian communion hath branched and spread it self in a certain propagation throughout the world by the Apostolical Seats and Episcopal Successions which propagation to the spreading Church-fellowship and communion how hath it been transmitted but by Ministerial Ordination Which Ordination was so universally and assuredly owned and acknowledged to be proper to the Episcopal order that Aerius pertinaciously asserting the contrary was by St. Augustine yea by the Catholick Church says Epiphanius condemned of Heresie Further they are known examples which we have of Musaeus and Eutychianus two Grecian Presbyters who having ordained without the Bishop and themselves not being Bishops their Ordination is declared by the Council of Sardis about eleven years after Constantine the Great to be null Concil Sard. can 19. and those they had ordained are reduced to the state and condition of Laicks 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 as such who had dissembled and forged their Ordination Again we read of Ischyras ordained by Colluthus 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 one who strongly yet vainly fancied himself a Bishop being indeed a meer Presbyter But as concerning Ischyras the Synod of Alexandria reduceth him to Lay-communion and determines concerning Colluthus that 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 whatsoever Ordinations he had made they should be all void and invalid To close then we have made good unto you by infallible proofs that imposition of hands in Ordination so plain and evident in the planting is requisit and necessary in the propagating the Church of Christ as being productive of issue and succession in the Ministry which Ministry shall continue in the Church whilest the Church continues in the world And now seeing that onely Apostles and Apostolick-men did ordain and that no meer Presbyters in all the Scriptures are exprest nor in all Church History allowed we see by what Ordination we receive our Saviours Mission here of a 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Go ye Disciple all Nations Baptising them c. But before we pass this point it will be some further confirmation and much more illustration of the truth that we give you some plea of Divine Reason to make good the equity of our present assertion Know then in the Apostles times and Infant-state of the Church Parishes were not divided nor Congregations with their particular Ministers fixt and setled but in one City there were many Presbyters and still as Believers increased their Meetings and Assemblies being in several places they had several persons assigned them for the service of the Ministry which how could it be well ordered without confusion but by the Authority and Presidency of some one above the rest Which Presidency the Apostles during their over-sight over the Churches they retained in themselves but upon their remove they committed to some Apostolick-men as their Successors And indeed it is most agreeable to right reason that that office should not expire whose end did continue
Ministers of Error and Schisms Teachers of Heresie and Blasphemy They go before they are sent Jer. 14.14 23.21 they will run before they are bid go But stop we them here in their haste and question we their Commission Dear Brethren ye that are so hasty to be Preachers tell us by what hand are you sent You will say by the Spirits Mission I ask then What is the outward Testimony and Warrant You answer You look not further then the inward call Strange that men dare pretend to a call beyond that of Timothy and Titus yea of Paul and Barnabas who though inwardly called yea extraordinarily immediately yet they had their outward Testimony their Ecclesiastical Warrant Acts 13.2 3. their Apostolical Mission and this by imposition of hands But further Some others there are who will not go but as sent and sent by Ordination too but tell us Dear Brethren by what hands are you ordained by what authority are you sent The former go without Mission you go but is it not by a forged Mission Those usurpe the Office Ministerial in execution do not you in execution and ordination too And where then is the greater guilt of iniquity but in the greater violation of the Ministry Wherefore to give you our Explication full I have three particulars to insist upon First That our Lord Jesus Christ did constitute a Ministry to be perpetuated in the Church Secondly That there is no admission into this Ministry but by imposition of hands in Ordination Thirdly That this admission into the Ministry by imposition of hands in Ordination was * Viz For the space of above 500 years after Christ never in the power of any meer Presbyter And these being proved it will easily appear from what hand to receive Ordination our lawful Mission into the Ministry our 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Go ye 1. Our Lord Jesus Christ did constitute a Ministry to be perpetuated in the Church Our Lord and Saviour as it was prophesied of him so it was performed by him the Government was upon his shoulder Isa 9.6 He the founder of Ecclesiastical polity the constitutor of Order and Government in his Church as being our Apostle sent from God our Prophet our great High Priest the Shepherd and Bishop of our souls the Head and King of his Church whose Ministerial Government shall continue 1 Cor. 15.24 till he come to give up the Kingdom unto his Father and God be all in all Now as the Father sent Christ Joh. 20.21 so Christ hath sent his Apostles and sent them to be a standing Ministry by a communicated power not seated in the people but in the Pastors of the Church who are to continue unto the end of the World even to the fulness of Christ and his Church as in the close of my Text and in the Epistle to the Ephesians Eph. 4.11 12 13. is most plain and evident If a Gospel Ministry was not established successive in the Church to what purpose did the Apostles themselves ordain and leave in charge to those Apostolick-men which came after them that they should ordain For so St. Paul left in charge with Titus for Creet and Timothy for Ephesus yea to what purpose hath the Spirit dictated St. Paul penned and the Church preserved the particular instructions who are to be admitted to Ordination if none were to be ordained How frivolous and useless were the Apostles setting down the Deacons and Bishops qualifications 1 Tim. 3. Tit. 1. Rev. 2.1 if they were to receive no Ordination And sure the Angels of those Churches were approved in their Ministry by Christ who held them as Stars in his right hand And that of the Psalmist Psal 45.16 St. Hierom. in loc Instead of thy Fathers shall be thy children St. Hierome applies to the Apostolical prefecture and presidency in Bishops Quia Apostolis à mundo recessis habes pro illis Episcopos filios Because the Apostles as Fathers being dead the Church hath her Bishops as Sons surviving in their stead 2. No admission into this Ministry but by imposition of hands in Ordination We read of Paul and Barnabas Acts 14.23 that they ordained Elders in every Church And for this purpose Tit. 1.5 St. Paul left Titus in Creet that he should ordain Elders in every City And that this Ordination had its outward ceremony of Imposition of hands nothing is more plain from Apostolical practise in Scripture and the continued custom of Christs Church But because men little regard the Churches custom we will wave that to insist upon the Apostolical practice Act. 6.6 Thus those seven persons commonly called the seven Deacons they are ordained to their intended Ministration by the Apostles And how Why by Prayer and Imposition of hands Acts 13.3 Again Paul and Barnabas are separated to the work of the Ministry and how with Fasting and Prayer and laying on of hands Again Timothy is received into the Ministry and though it be 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 by prophecy 1 Tim. 4.14 yet is it 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 with the laying on of hands Object 1 But some may say True as to the higher acts and offices of the Ministry as Baptism and the Lords Supper to be admitted to the dispensing of these Ordination may be requisite but not to the Preaching of the Word Answ I answer If Commission and Ordination be required for Baptism much more for Preaching the Word 1 Cor. 1.17 for this St. Pauls prefers before Baptism as being the more honorable and more weighty part of the Ministry And indeed most needful it is that none be admitted to publick Teaching but he that can declare his lawful Call and Ordination seeing upon this depends so very much the truth and peace the life and health the being and the welbeing of the Church yea of Christianity it self For if the office of publick Teaching lie open to all invaders and who pretends to the Spirit may take upon him to Minister the Word it will soon appear what Harvest we shall reap from such Seedsmen what mischiefs and miseries what Heresies and Schisms shall arise from such Teachers whose ignorance and boldness qualifies them for nothing more then Errors and Impieties Such as is the Teaching such will be the Church a Synagogue of Satan if taught by a spirit of Error and the spirit of Error still accompanies the spirit of Pride and a broaching of Heresie attends an invading the Ministry I ask the question then Is Publick Teaching a proper office of the Ministry that it is so sacred Scripture the Churches authority and divine Reason all prove and evidence St. Pauls testimony is plain and full when he tells us of publick offices given by Christ unto the Church Eph. 4.11 12. amongst which are Pastors and Teachers and these For the perfecting of the Saints for the work of the Ministry for the edifying of the Body of Christ Now if
publick Teaching be a proper office may any enter it without Admission To do this were an absurdity against the very light of nature and Law of Nations which will have no man to admit himself into office but he must receive his admission from some intrusted with power and authority and in this case of publick Teaching the power and authority is intrusted with those who admit not but by Imposition of hands in Ordination Object 2 But it may be further objected That the Brethren dispersed upon the persecution raised about Stephen Acts 8.4 11.19 they are said To go about preaching the Word To this I give a twofold answer Answ and either of them full and satisfactory 1 I say they were such as had received the Holy Ghost Chap. 3 31. and so their call as well as their work was extraordinary and this witnessed by their gift of healing intimated in Chap. 11. 21. where it is said The hand of the Lord was with them to which some Copies adde says learned Diodate for to heal them Or 2 observe What is here said of these scattered Brethren extends not to publick Teaching in the Church which publick Teaching is peculiarly Ministerial but to publish declare divulge the Gospel where Christ was not yet known no Church yet gathered no Disciples yet made And this we deny not to be lawful to any man yea we acknowledge it a duty where God so gives the opportunity To declare the Gospel then to unbelievers is common to all as Christians but to make Disciples by Baptism and to instruct the discipled and baptized by publick Doctrine is proper to the Minister of the Word by vertue of his Mission and Commission from Christ the same which he gave here to his Apostles Go ye disciple all Nations Baptising them c. Again one Objection more there is which appears big Object 3 but its strengths but small 1 Cor. 14.31 viz. The Apostle seems to tell the whole Corinthian Congregation That they may all prophesie one by one I answer True indeed all may prophesie Answ yet can it not then be understood but of those that were Prophets Vers 6. as he instanceth in himself that he speaks in the Church as by knowledge so by prophesying Knowledge that is doctrine obtained by premeditation Prophesying here is doctrine delivered by sudden inspiration as appears Vers 30. Prophesying was of old Preaching moved by divine rapture now Preaching is prophesying attained by diligent study Even by attending unto reading and to meditation 1 Tim. 4.13 15. as St. Paul exhorts Timothy These Prophets St. Paul speaks of were a peculiar office in the Church so reckoned with Apostles and Evangelists Eph 4.11 and of those there were many at Corinth as we finde many at Antioch Acts 13.2 and these 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 too Ministring unto the Lord. Now to these Prophets saith the Apostle to preserve order in the Church Ye may all prophecy one by one And thus is the Giant slain the great Argument and Objection cleared from what some would pretend to a liberty of prophesying to all in the publick Congregation 3. To admit into the Ministry By Imposition of hands in Ordination was never in the power of any meer Presbyter Our Lord and Saviour did constitute Twelve Apostles Matth. 10.1 2. Luke 10 1. in degree and office above the Seventy Disciâ—les Which holy Apostles that they were to have their Successors is evident from the promise here of Christ Behold I am with you unto the end of the World Which promise extends to the whole Ministry of the Church the Apostles having all authority Ecclesiastical and every office Ministerial virtually and eminently in themselves Most certain and plain it is our Saviours promise could not be meant of the Apostles persons it must be then interpreted of their Function And of their Function not in its extraordinary priviledges but its ordinary Ministrations not in its extraordinary Priviledges as that their Mission was immediate from Christ their operations miraculous by the Spirit and their jurisdiction unlimitted as to place These were all temporary expiring with their persons being necessary onely to the planting not the perpetuating of the Church But the sacred Apostleship in its ordinary Ministrations as Preaching the Word Discipling by Baptism Consecrating the Eucharist Excommunicating the Scandalous Absolving the Penitent Governing by Discipline and Ordaining to the Priesthood These even all these received by Commission from Christ were to be continued by Succession in the Church as without which the welbeing of the Church in its Ministry and Government could not stand Successors then there must be to the Apostles invested with the Authority and Office of the foregoing Ministrations Now our inquiry then is who these Successors are And for this we finde in Scripture Acts 12.17 15.13 21.28 1 Tim. 1.3 3.15 2 Tim. 1.6 Tit. 1.5 Rev. 2. 3. James Bishop of Jerusalem Timothy of Ephesus Titus of Creet yea the seven Angels Presidents and Bishops of the seven Churches spoken of in the Revelations Besides these we finde in the undoubted History of the Church Mark Bishop of Alexandria Epaphroditus of Philippi Archippus of Coloss Clemens of Rome Ignatius of Antioch these and others too in the Apostles times and ordained by the Apostles hands were the received Successors in the ordinary Ministry of the Apostleship And that this was so Theodor. in Phil. 2â—25 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 is evident from that which is given us by Theodoret 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Those very persons were called Apostles whom by usage of speech the Church now calls Bishops And why was this but because they were generally owned by the Church as the Apostles Successors in the ordinary Ministrations of their Apostleship But now Time the great mint and master of words least community of names should beget a confusion in things Time I say did appropriate the name of Apostle to the immediate Apostles of Christ and the name of Bishop to their Successors whose particular Succession in their full Ministry and Office incommunicable to any meer Presbyters though of never so eminent abilities and high esteems is upon undeniable record in the Churches Histories And though I might heap up the unquestionable testimonies of the Ancients yet that one full witness and quaint expression of Tertullian may be here sufficient Who writing within one hundred years after St. John and so the Succession of Ministry not very long setled in the Church after the Apostles he tells us Tert. de Praescript c. 32. speaking of some Metropolitan Churches Exhibent quos ab Apostolis in Episcopatum constitutos Apostolici seminis traduces habent They exhibite and produce those persons constituted by the Apostles to be Bishops who by vertue of an Apostolical Seed do transmit a Succession of Ministry in the Church And thus Episcopacy becomes what Epiphanius elegantly stiles it Epiph Haeres 75. cont