Suffrage of the people 2. I have shewed instances before out of the Scripture that when a thing is done by the whole people it is usual to ascribe it unto him or them who were chief therein as elsewhere the same thing is ascribed unto the whole people THE same Authors contend that the liberty of choosing their own Officers or Elders such as it was was granted unto them or permitted by way of condescention for a Season and not made use of by virtue of any right in them thereunto But this permission is a meer imagination It was according to the mind of Christ that the Churches should choose their own Elders or it was not If it were not the Apostles would not have permitted it and if it were they ought to ordain it and practise according to it as they did Nor is such a constant Apostolical Practice proposed for the direction of the Church in all Ages to be ascribed unto such an Original as Condescension and Permission Yea it is evident that it arose from the most fundamental principles of the constitution and nature of the Gospel Churches and was only a regular pursuit and practice of them For 1. THE Calling of Bishops Pastors Elders is an Act of the power of the Keys of the Kingdom of Heaven But these Keys are originally and properly given unto the whole Church unto the Elders of it only Ministerially and as unto exercise Pastors are eyes to the Church But God and Nature design in the first place sight to the whole Body to the whole Person thereunto it is granted both subjectively and finally but actually it is peculiarly seated in the eye So is it in the grant of Church-Power it is given to the whole Church though to be exercised only by its Elders THAT the grant of the Keys unto Peter was in the Person and as the representative of the whole confessing Church is the known judgment of Austin and a multitude of Divines that follow him So he fully expresseth himself Tractat. 124. in Johan Peter the Apostle bare in a general figure the person of the Church For as unto what belonged unto himself he was by Nature one Man by Grace one Christian and of special more abounding Grace one and the chief Apostle But when it was said unto him I will give unto thee the Keys of the Kingdom of Heaven c. he signified the whole Church c. Again the Church which is founded in Christ received from him in the person of Peter the Keys of the Kingdom of Heaven which is the power of binding and loosing UNTO whom these Keys are granted they according to their distinct interests in that grant have the Right and Power of Calling their Bishops Pastors or Elders for in the exercise of that Trust and Power it doth consist But this is made unto the whole Church And as there are in a Church already constituted several sorts of persons as some are Elders others are of the people only this Right resideth in them and is acted by them according to their respective capacities as limited by the light of nature and divine institution which is that the Election of them should belong unto the body of the people and their Authoritative Designation or Ordination unto the Elders And when in any place the supream Magistrate is a Member or Part of the Church he hath also his peculiar Right herein THAT the power of the Keys is thus granted originally and fundamentally unto the whole Church is undeniably confirmed by Two Arguments 1. THE Church it self is the Wife the Spouse the Bride the Queen of the Husband and King of the Church Christ Jesus Psal. 45.10 John 3.29 Revel 21.9 Chap. 22.17 Matth. 25.1 5 6. Other Wife Christ hath none nor hath the Church any other Husband Now to whom should the Keys of the House be committed but unto the Bride There is I confess another who claims the Keys to be his own but withal he makes himself the Head and Husband of the Church proclaiming himself not only to be an Adulterer with that Harlot which he calleth the Church but a Tyrant also in that pretending to be her Husband he will not trust her with the Keys of his House which Christ hath done with his Spouse And whereas by the Canon Law every Bishop is the Husband or Spouse of his Diocesan Church for the most part they commit an open Rape upon the people taking them without their consent at least are not chosen by them which yet is essential unto a lawful Marriage And the Bride of Christ comes no otherwise so to be but by the voluntary choice of him to be her Husband FOR the Officers or Rulers of the Church they do belong unto it as hers 1 Cor. 3.21.22 And Stewards in the House 1 Cor. 4.1 the Servants of the Church for Jesus sake 2 Cor. 4.5 IF the Lord Christ have the Keys of the Kingdom of Heaven that is of his own House Heb. 3. If the Church it self be the Spouse of Christ the Mother of the Family Psal. 68.13 the Bride the Lambs Wife and if all the Officers of the Church be but Stewards and Servants in the House and unto the Family if the Lord Christ do make a grant of these Keys unto any whereon the disposal of all things in this House and Family doth depend the Question is Whether he hath originally granted them unto his holy Spouse to dispose off according unto her judgment and duty or unto any Servants in the House to dispose of her and all her concernments at their pleasure 2. THE power of the Keys as unto binding and loosing and consequently as unto all other acts thence proceeding is expresly granted unto the whole Church Matth. 18.17 18. If he shall neglect to hear them tell the Church but if he neglect to hear the Church let him be unto thee as an Heathen Man and a Publican verily I say unto you whatsoever ye shall bind on Earth shall be bound in Heaven and whatsoever ye shall loose on Earth shall be loosed in Heaven What Church it is that is here intended we have proved before and that the Church is intrusted with the power of binding and loosing And what is the part of the Body of the people herein the Apostle declares 1 Cor. 5.4 2 Cor. 2.6 SECONDLY This Right exemplified in Apostolical Practice is comprehended in the Commands given unto the Church or Body of the People with respect unto Teachers and Rulers of all sorts for unto them it is in a multitude of places given in charge that they should discern and try false Prophets fly from them try Spirits or such as pretend Spiritual Gifts or Offices reject them who Preach false Doctrine to give testimony unto them that are to be in Office with sundry other things of the like nature which all of them do suppose or cannot be discharged without a Right in them to choose the worthy and reject the unworthy as
21.17 1 Tim. 5.17 They are some of them on other accounts called Bishops Pastors Teachers Ministers Guides but what belongs unto any of them in point of Rule or what interest they have therein it belongs unto them as Elders and not otherwise Act. 20.17 18. SO under the Old Testament where the Word doth not signifie a difference in Age but is used in a moral sence Elders are the same with Rulers or Governours whether in Offices Civil or Ecclesiastical especially the Rulers of the Church were constantly called its Elders And the use of the Word with the abuse of the Power or Office intended by it is traduced to signifie Men in Authority Signeiores Eldermani in all places 2. CHURCH-Power acted in its Rule is called the Keys of the Kingdom of Heaven by an expression derived from the Keys that were a sign of Office-Power in the Families of Kings Isa. 22.22 and used by our Saviour himself to denote the communication of Church-Power unto others which was absolutely and universally vested in himself under the Name of the Key of David Revel 3.7 Mat. 16.19 3. THESE Keys are usually referred unto Two Heads namely the one of Order the other of Jurisdiction 4. BY the Key of Order the Spiritual Right Power and Authority of Bishops or Pastors to Preach the Word to Administer the Sacraments Doctrinally to bind and loose the Consciences of Men are intended 5. BY Jurisdiction the Rule Government or Discipline of the Church is designed though it was never so called or esteemed in the Scripture or the Primitive Church until the whole nature of Church-Rule or Discipline was depraved and changed Therefore neither the Word nor any thing that is signified by it or which it is applied unto ought to be admitted unto any consideration in the things that belong unto the Church or its Rule it being expressive of and directing unto that corrupt Administration of things Ecclesiastical according unto the Canon Law by which all Church-Rule and Order is destroyed I do therefore at once dismiss all disputes about it as of things Foreign to the Gospel and Christian Religion I mean as unto the Institutions of Christ in his Church The Civil Jurisdiction of Supreme Magistrates about the externals of Religion is of another consideration But that these Keys do include the two-fold distinct Powers of Teaching and Rule of Doctrine and Discipline is freely granted 6. IN the Church of England as in that of Rome there is a peculiar distribution made of these Keys Unto some that is unto one special sort or order of Men they are both granted both the Key of Order and of Jurisdiction which is unto Diocesan Bishops with some others under various Canonical restrictions and limitations as Deans and Arch-Deacons Unto some is granted the Key of Order only without the least interest in Jurisdiction or Rule by virtue of their Office which are the Parochial Ministers or meer Presbyters without any additional Title or Power as of Commissary Surrogates or the like And unto a third sort there is granted the Key of Rule or Jurisdiction almost plenipotent who have no share in the Key of Order that is were never Ordained Separated Dedicated unto any Office in the Church such as are the Chancellors c. 7. THESE Chancellors are the only Lay-Elders that I know any where in any Church that is Persons entrusted with the Rule of the Church and the Disposition of its Censures who are not Ordained unto any Church-Office but in all other things continue in the Order of the Laity or the People All Church Rulers by institution are Elders To be an Elder of the Church and a Ruler in it is all one Wherefore these Persons being Rulers in the Church and yet thus continuing in the Order of the People are Lay-Elders whom I wonder how so many of the Church came so seriously to oppose seeing this Order of Men is owned by none but themselves The Truth is and it must be acknowledged that there is no known Church in the World I mean whose Order is known unto us and is of any publick consideration but they do dispose the Rule of the Church in part into the hands of Persons who have not the power of Authoritative Preaching of the Word and Administration of the Sacraments committed unto them For even those who place the whole external Rule of the Church in the Civil Magistrate do it as they judge him an Officer of the Church entrusted by Christ with Church-Power And those who deny any such Officers as are usually called Ruling Elders in the Reformed Churches to be of Divine Institution yet maintain that it is very necessary that there should be such Officers in the Church either appointed by the Magistrate or chosen by the people and that with cogent Arguments See Grot. de Jure Potestat Cap. 8. BUT this distribution mentioned of church-Church-Power is unscriptural nor is there any foot-steps of it in Antiquity It is so as unto the two latter Branches of it That any one should have the power of Order to Preach the Word to Administer the Seals to bind and loose the Conscience Doctrinally or Ministerially to bind and loose in the Court of Conscience and yet by the virtue of that Office which gives them this power not to have a Right and Power of Rule or Discipline to bind and loose in the Court of the Church is that which neither the Scripture nor any example of the Primitive Church doth give countenance unto And as by this means those are abridged and deprived of their power to whom it is granted by the Institution and Law of Christ as it is with all Elders duly called unto their Office so in the Third Branch there is a grant of Church-Power unto such as by the Law of Christ are excluded from any Interest therein The enormity of which constitution I shall not at present insist upon But Enquiry must be made what the Scripture directs unto herein And 1. THERE is a Work and Duty of Rule in the Church distinct from the Work and Duty of Pastoral Feeding by the Preaching of the Word and Administration of the Sacraments All agree herein unless it be Erastus and those that follow him who seem to oppose it But their Arguments lie not against Rule in general which were brutish but only a Rule by external Jurisdiction in the Elders of the Church So they grant the general Assertion of the necessity of Rule for who can deny it only they contend about the subject of power required thereunto A Spiritual Rule by virtue of mutual voluntary confederation for the preservation of Peace Purity and Order in the Church few of that opinion deny at least it is not that which they do oppose For to deny all Rule and Discipline in the Church with all Administration of Censures in the exercise of a Spiritual Power internally inherent in the Church is to deny the Church to be a Spiritual Political
even the Word Command and Direction of Christ himself alone the Acts and Exercise of it in binding and loosing in remitting and retaining Sin in opening and shutting the Kingdom of Heaven are all Spiritual meerly and only Neither can there be an Instance given of any thing belonging unto the Rule of the Church that is of another nature Yea it is sufficient eternally to exclude any Power or Exercise of it any Act of Rule or Government from any Interest in Church-Affairs that it can be proved to be Carnal Political Despotical of external Operaration or not entirely Spiritual 5. THE Change of this Government of the Church fell out and was introduced gradually upon an advantage taken from the unmeetness of the People to be lead under this Spiritual Rule For the greatest part of them that made up Christian Churches being become ignorant and carnal that Rule which consists in a spiritual influence on the Consciences of Men was no way able to retain them within the bounds of outward obedience which was at last only aimed at There was therefore another kind of Rule and Government judged necessary to retain them in any Order or Decorum And it must be acknowledged that where the Members of the Church are not in some degree Spiritual a Rule that is meerly Spiritual will be of no great use unto them But principally this change was introduced by those that were in possession of the Rule it self and that on two grounds 1. Their unskilfulness in the management of this Spiritual Rule or weariness of the Duties which are required thereunto This made them willing to desert it with that perpetual labour and exercise of all sorts of Graces which are required in it and to embrace another more easie and more suited unto their Inclinations 2. A desire of the Secular advantages of Profit Honour and Veneration which tendered themselves unto them in another kind of Rule By these means was the Original Government of the Church which was of Divine Institution utterly lost and a Worldly Domination introduced in the room thereof But the brief delineation given of it before with what shall now be added will demonstrate sufficiently that all these Disputes and Contests which are in the World between the Church of Rome and others about Church-Power and Rule are utterly foreign unto Christian Religion 6. I SHALL therefore briefly enquire into these three things 1. What is the Skill and Polity that is required unto the Exercise or Administration of the Government of the Church 2. What is the sole Law and Rule of it 3. What are the Acts and Duties of it What it is conversant about especially those wherein the Office of Ruling Elders doth take place 1. THE Polity of Church-Government subjectively considered is generally supported to consist 1. In a skill learning or understanding in the Civil and especially the Canon Law with the additional Canons accomodating that Law unto the present state of things of the Nation to be interpreted according unto the general Rules of it 2. Knowledge of and Acquaintance with the Constitution Power Jurisdiction and Practice of some Law Courts which being in their original grant of Power manner of Proceeding Pleas and Censures meerly Secular are yet called Ecclesiastical or Spiritual 3. A good Discretion to understand a-right the extent of their Power with the bounds and limits of it that on the one hand they let none escape whom they can reach by the discipline of their Courts and on the other not entrench so far on the Civil-Power and the Jurisdiction of other Courts according to the Law of the Land as to bring themselves into charge or trouble 4. An acquaintance with the Table of Fees that they may neither lose their own profit nor give advantage unto others to question them for taking more than their due But in these things we are not at present concerned 8. THE skill then of the Officers of the Church for the Government of it is a spiritual Wisdom and Vnderstanding in the Law of Christ for that end with an Ability to make application of it in all requisite Instances unto the Edification of the whole Church and all its Members through a ministerial Exercise of the Authority of Christ himself and a due Representation of his Holiness Love Care Compassion and Tenderness toward his Church 1. THE sole Rule and Measure of the Government of the Church being the Law of Christ that is the Intimation and Declaration of his Mind and Will in his Institutions Commands Prohibitions and Promises an Vnderstanding herein with Wisdom from that Understanding is and must be the whole of the Skill enquired after How this Wisdom is bestowed as a spiritual Gift how it is to be acquired in a way of Duty by Prayer Meditation and study of the Word hath been intimated before and shall fully be declared in our Discourse of spiritual Gifts All Decrees and Decretals Canons and Glosses come properly in this matter under one Title of them namely Extravagant The utmost Knowledge of them and Skill in them will contribute nothing unto this Wisdom Neither are any sort of Men more strangers unto it or unacquainted with it than they are for the most part who are eminently cunning in such Laws and the Jurisdiction of Ecclesiastical Courts But Wisdom in the knowledge of the Will of Christ as revealed in the Scripture is that alone which is of use in the Government of the Church 2. A PART of this Wisdom consisteth in an Ability of Mind to make Application of the Law of Christ in all requisite Instances unto the Edification of the Church in general and all the Members of it respectively This Wisdom is not notional only but practical It consists not in a speculative comprehension of the sence of the Rule or of the Mind of Christ therein only though that be required in the first place but in an Ability of Mind to make Application of it whereunto Diligence Care Watchfulness and spiritual Courage are required Some are to be Admonished some to be Rebuked sharply some to be cut off in which and the like cases a spirit of Government acting it self in Diligence Boldness and Courage is necessary And this is one reason why the Lord Christ hath appointed many Elders in each Church and those of several sorts For it is seldom that any one Man is qualified for the whole work of Rule Some may have a good understanding in the Law of the Churches Government yet through a natural Tenderness and an insuperable kind of Modesty not be so ready and prompt for that part of this Discipline which consists in Reproofs and Severity of Censures Some may not have so great an Ability for the Indagation of the sence of the Law as others have who yet upon the knowledge of it being discovered unto them have readiness and boldness in Christ to apply it as occasion doth require All Elders therefore in their variety of Gifts are to be
FOR whereas there are three things required unto a Covenant between God and Man. 1. That it be of Gods appointment and institution 2. That upon a prescription of Duties there be a solemn engagement unto their performance on the part of Men. 3. That there be especial promises of God annexed thereunto in which consists the matter of Confederation whereof mutual express Restipulation is the form they all concurr herein 9. THIS Covenant which we intend is not the Covenant of Grace absolutely considered nor are all the Duties belonging unto that Covenant prescribed in it but the principal of them as Faith Repentance and the like are presupposed unto it nor hath annexed unto it all the promises and privileges of the New Covenant absolutely considered but it is that which is prescribed as a Gospel Duty in the Covenant of Grace whereunto do belong all the Duties of Evangelical Worship all the powers and privileges of the Church by virtue of the especial promise of the peculiar presence of Christ in such a Church 10. WHEREAS therefore in the constitution of a Church Believers do give up themselves unto the Lord and are bound solemnly to engage themselves to do and observe all the things which Christ hath commanded to be done and observed in that state whereon he hath promised to be present with them and among them in an especial manner which presence of his doth interest them in all the Rights Powers and Privileges of the Church their so doing hath the nature of a Divine Covenant included in it which is the Formal Cause of their Church Sate and Being 11. BESIDES as we have proved before there are many mutual Duties required of all which join in Church Societies and Powers to be exercised and submitted unto whereunto none can be obliged without their own consent They must give up themselves unto one another by the will of God. That is they must agree consent and engage among themselves to observe all those mutual Duties to use all those Privileges and to exercise all those Powers which the Lord Christ hath prescribed and granted unto his Church See Jerem. 50.4 5. 12. THIS compleats the confederation intended which is the Formal Cause of the Church and without which either expresly or virtually performed there can be no Church State. 13. INDEED herein most Men deceive themselves and think they do not that nor that it ought to be done and dispute against it as unlawful or unnecessary which for the substance of it they do themselves and would condemn themselves in their own Consciences if they did it not For unto what end do they join themselves unto Parochial Churches and Assemblies To what end do they require all Professors of the Protestant Religion so to do declaring it to be their Duty by penalties annexed unto its neglect Is it not that they might yield obedience unto Christ in their so doing Is it not to profess that they will do and observe all whatsoever he commands them Is it not to do it in that Society in those Assemblies whereunto they do belong Is there not therein virtually a mutual Agreement and Engagement among them unto all those ends It must be so with them who do not in all things in Religion fight uncertainly as Men beating the Air. 14. NOW whereas these things are in themselves and for the substance of them known Gospel Duties which all Believers are indispensably obliged unto the more express our engagement is concerning them the more do we glorify Christ in our Profession and the greater sense of our Duty will abide on our Consciences and greater encouragement be given unto the performance of mutual Duties as also the more evident will the warranty be for the exercise of Church Power Yet do I not deny the Being of Churches unto those Societies wherein these things are virtually only observed especially in Churches of some continuance wherein there is at least an implicit consent unto the first Covenant-Constitution 15. THE Lord Christ having instituted and appointed Officers Rulers or Leaders in his Church as we shall see in the next place to look unto the discharge of all Church Duties among the Members of it to administer and dispense all its Privileges and to exercise all its Authority the consent and engagement insisted on is expresly required unto the constitution of this Order and the preservation of it For without this no Believer can be brought into that Relation unto another as his Pastor Guide Over-seer Ruler unto the ends mentioned wherein he must be subject unto him partake of all Ordinances of Divine Worship administred by him with Authority in obedience unto the will of Christ They gave their own selves to us saith the Apostle by the will of God. 16. WHEREFORE the Formal Cause of a Church consisteth in an Obediential Act of Believers in such numbers as may be useful unto the ends of Church Edification jointly giving up themselves unto the Lord Jesus Christ to do and observe all his Commands resting on the promise of his especial presence thereon giving and communicating by his Law all the Rights Powers and Privileges of his Church unto them and in a mutual Agreement among themselves jointly to perform all the Duties required of them in that State with an especial subjection unto the Spiritual Authority of Rules and Rulers appointed by Christ in that State. 17. THERE is nothing herein which any Man who hath a conscientious sense of his Duty in a professed subjection unto the Gospel can question for the substance of it whether it be according to the mind of Christ or no. And whereas the nature and essential properties of a Divine Covenant are contained in them as such it is a Foundation of any Church State. 18. THUS under the Old Testament when God would take the postâ—rity of Abraham into a new peculiar Church State he did it by a Solemn Covenant Herein as he prescribed all the Duties of his Worship to them and made them many blessed promises of his presence with powers and privileges innumerable so the people solemnly Covenanted and engaged with him that they would do and observe all that he had Commanded them whereby they coalesced into that Church State which abode unto the time of Reformation This Covenant is at large declared Exod. 24. For the Covenant which God made there with the people and they with him was not the Covénant of Grace under a legal dispensation for that was established unto the Seed of Abraham Four Hundred years before in the Promise with the Seal of Circumcision nor was it the Covenant of Works under a Gospel dispensation for God never renewed that Covenant under any consideration whatever But it was a peculiar Covenant which God then made with them and had not made it with their Fathers Deut. 5.2 3. whereby they were raised and erected into a Church State wherein they were intrusted with all the Privileges and enjoined all the Duties which God had
should appoint in the same Church many more Teaching Elders though it is plain that the Elders intended were many I SHALL add for a close of all that there is no sort of Churches in being but are of this perswasion that there ought to be Rulers in the Church that are not in Sacred Orders as some call them or have no interest in the Pastoral or Ministerial Office as unto the dispensation of the Word and Administration of the Sacraments For as the Government of the Roman Church is in the hands of such Persons in a great measure so in the Church of England much of the Rule of it is managed by Chancellors Officials Commissaries and the like Officers who are absolutely Lay-Men and not at all in their holy Orders Some would place the Rule of the Church in the Civil Magistrate who is the only Ruling Elder as they suppose But the generality of all Protestant Churches throughout the World both Lutherans and Reformed do both in their judgment and practice assert the necessity of the Ruling Elders which we plead for and their Office lies at the foundation of all their Order and Discipline which they cannot forgo without extream confusion yea without the ruine of their Churches And although some among us considering particular Churches only as small Societies may think there is no need of any such Office or Officers for Rule in them yet when such Churches consist of some Thousands without any opportunity of distributing themselves into several Congregations as at Charenton in France it is a weak imagination that the Rule of Christ can be observed in them by Two or Three Ministers alone Hence in the Primitive Times we have instances of Ten Twenty yea Forty Elders in a particular Church wherein they had respect unto the Institution under the Old Testament whereby each Ten Families were to have a peculiar Ruler However it is certain that there is such a Reformation in all sorts of Churches that there ought to be some attending unto Rule that are not called to labour in the Word and Doctrine CHAP. VIII The Nature of Church-Polity or Rule with the Duty of Elders HAVING declared who are the Rulers of the Church something must be added concerning the Rule it self which is to be exercised therein Hereof I have Treated before in general That which I now design is what in particular respects them who are called unto Rule only whereunto some Considerations must be premised 1. THERE is Power Authority and Rule granted unto and residing in some Persons of the Church and not in the Body of the Fraternity or Community of the People How far the Government of the Church may be denominated Democratical from the necessary consent of the people unto the principal Acts of it in its exercise I shall not determine But whereas this consent and the liberty of it is absolutely necessary according to the Law of Obedience unto Christ which is prescribed unto the Church requiring that all they do in compliance therewith be voluntary as unto the manner of its exercise being in dutiful compliance with the guidance of the Rule it changeth not the State of the Government And therefore where any thing is Acted and Disposed in the Church by Suffrage or the plurality of Voices the Vote of the Fraternity is not Determining and Authoritative but only declarative of consent and obedience It is so in all Acts of Rule where the Church is Organical or in compleat Order 2. THAT there is such an Authority and Rule instituted by Christ in his Church is not liable unto dispute Where there are Bishops Pastors Elders Guides Rulers Stewards instituted given granted called ordained and some to be Ruled Sheep Lambs Brethren obliged by command to obey them follow them submit unto them in the Lord regard them as over them There is Rule and Authority in some persons and that committed unto them by Jesus Christ. But all these things are frequently repeated in the Scripture And when in the practical Part or Exercise of Rule due respect is not had unto their Authority there is nothing but Confusion and Disorder When the People judge that the Power of the Keys is committed unto them as such only and in them doth the Right of their Use and Exercise reside that their Elders have no interest in the disposing of Church Affairs or in Acts of Church Power but only their own suffrages or what they can obtain by reasoning and think there is no Duty incumbent on them to acquiesce in their Authority in any thing an Evil apt to grow in Churches it overthrows all that beautiful Order which Jesus Christ hath ordained And if any shall make Advantage of this Complaint That where the People have their due Liberty granted unto them they are apt to assume that Power unto themselves which belongs not unto them an evil attended with troublesome Impertinencies and Disorder tending unto Anarchy let them remember on the other hand how upon the confinement of Power and Authority unto the Guides Bishops or Rulers of the Church they have changed the nature of Church-Power and enlarged their Usurpation until the whole Rule of the Church issued in absolute Tyranny Wherefore no fear of consequents that may ensue and arise from the darkness ignorance weakness lusts corruptions or secular interests of Men ought to entice us unto the least Alteration of the Rule by any prudential Provisions of our own 3. THIS Authority in the Rulers of the Church is neither Autocratical or Sovereign nor Nomothetical or Legislative nor Despotical or Absolute but Organical and Ministerial only The endless Controversies which have sprung out of the mystery of iniquity about an Autocratical and Monarchical Government in the Church about power to make Laws to bind the Consciences of Men yea to kill and destroy them with the whole manner of the execution of this Power we are not concerned in A pretence of any such Power in the Church is destructive of the Kingly Office of Christ contrary to express Commands of Scripture and condemned by the Apostles Isa. 33.22 Jam. 4.12 Mat. 17.5 Chap. 23.8 9 10 11. Luke 22.25 26. 2 Cor. 1.24 1 Cor. 3.21 22 23. 2 Cor. 4.5 1 Pet. 5.1 25. 4. AS the Rule of the Church in those by whom it is exercised is meerly Ministerial with respect unto the Authority of Christ his Law and the Liberty of the Church wherewith he hath made it free so in its nature it is spiritual purely and only So the Apostle Affirms expresly 2 Cor. 10.4 5 6. For its object is spiritual namely the Souls and Consciences of Men whereunto it extends which no other Humane Power doth nor doth it reach those other concerns of Men that are subject unto any political Power Its end is Spiritual namely the Glory of God in the guidance and direction of the Minds and Souls of Men to live unto him and come to the enjoyment of him the Law of it is spiritual
judged and condemned in the Light of Nature or in the express Testimony of Scripture yea such as the Holy Ghost witnesseth that continued in without Repentance it is inconsistent with Salvation If the thing it self to be Animadverted on be dubious or disputable whether it be a Sin or no especially such a Sin either from the Nature of the Fact or the Qualifications of the Person offending or from other Circumstances so as that the guilty Person is not self-condemned nor are others fully satisfied in their Minds about the nature of it there is no room for Excommunication in such cases And if it be once allowed to be applied towards any Sins but such as are evident to be so as the Apostle says the Works of the Flesh are manifest in the Light of Nature and Express Testimony of Scripture not only will the Administration of it be made difficult a matter of dispute unfit for the Determination of the Body of the Church but it will leave it unto the wills of Men to prostitute unto litigious brawls quarrels and differences wherein Interest and Partiality may take place which is to profane this Divine Institution But confine it as it ought to be unto such Sins as are condemned in the Light of Nature or by Express Testimony of Scripture as inconsistent with Salvation by Jesus Christ if persisted in and all things that belong unto the Administration of it will be plain and easie FROM the neglect of this Rule proceeded that horrible confusion and disorder in Excommunication and the Administration of it which for sundry Ages prevailed in the World. For as it was mostly applied unto things holy just and good or the performance of such Gospel Duties as Men owed to Christ and their own Souls so being exercised with respect unto irregularities that are made such meerly by the Arbitrary Constitutions and Laws of Men and that in cases frivolous trifling and of no importance it was found necessary to be managed in and by such Courts such Processes such forms of Law such Pleadings and intricacies of Craft such a burden of Cost and Charge as is uncertain whether it ought to be more bewailed or derided 2. IT is required hereunto that the matter of Fact as unto the Relation of the Sin unto the particular Offender be confessed or not denied or clearly proved How far this is to extend and what ground of procedure there may be in Reports or Fame concurring with leading Circumstances we shall enquire afterwards And although in such cases of publick Fame a good Testimony from those of Credit and Repute in the Church given unto the supposed guilty Person is of use and sufficient in some cases singly to oppose unto publick Reports yet to require a Man to purge himself by others from any feigned scandalous imputation is an unwarrantable Tyranny 3. IT is also required that the previous process in and by private and publick Admonition and that repeated with patient waiting for the success of each of them be duly premised Whether this extend it self unto all causes of Excommunication shall be afterwards enquired into Ordinarily it is so necessary unto the Conviction of the Mind and Conscience of the Offender and to leave him without either provocation from the Church or excuse in himself so suited to be expressive of the Grace and Patience of Christ toward Sinners so requisite unto the satisfaction of the Church it self in their proceedure as that the omission of it will probably render the Sentence useless and ineffectual A crying out I admonish a First a Second a Third time and so to Excommunication is a very absurd observation of a Divine Institution 4. IT is required that the case of the Person to be censured as unto his profession of Repentance on the one hand or obstinacy on the other be judged and determined by the whole Church in love and compassion There are few who are so profligately wicked but that when the Sin wherewith they are charged is evidently such in the Light of Nature and Scripture and when it is justly proved against them they will make some profession of Sorrow and Repentance Whether this be sufficient as in most cases it is to suspend the present proceeding of the Church or quite to lay it aside is left unto the judgment of the Church it self upon consideration of present Circumstances and what is necessary unto its own Edification Only this Rule must be continually observed that the least appearance of haste or undue precipitation herein is to be avoided in all these cases as the bane of Church-Rule and Order AGAIN The manner of its Administration according to the mind of Christ may be considered And hereunto are required 1. Prayer without which it can no way be administred in the Name of our Lord Jesus Christ. The Administration of any solemn Ordinance of the Gospel without Prayer is an horrible profanation of it And the neglect or contempt hereof in any who take upon them to Excommunicate others is an open Proclamation of the nullity of their Act and Sentence And the observation of the Administration of it without any due Reverence of God without solemn invocation of the Name of Christ thereby ingaging his Presence and Authority in what they do is that principally which hath set the Consciences of all mankind at liberty from any concernment in this Ecclesiastical Censure and whence those that Administer it expect no other success of what they do but what they can give it by outward force And where this fails Excommunication is quickly laid aside As it was when the Pope threatned the Cantons of the Swissers that if they complied not with some of his Impositions he would Excommunicate them whereon they sent him word they would not be Excommunicated which ended the matter Wherefore when our Lord Jesus Christ gives unto his Church the power of binding and loosing directing them in the exercise of that power he directs them to ask assistance by Prayer when they are gathered together Matth. 18.18 19 20. And the Apostle directs the Church of Corinth that they should proceed unto this Sentence when they were gathered together in the Name of the Lord Jesus Christ 1 Cor. 5.4 which could not be without calling on his Name In brief without Prayer neither is the Ordinance it self sanctified unto the Church nor are any meet to Administer it nor is the Authority of Christ either owned or engaged nor Divine Assistance attained neither is what is done any more Excommunication than any rash Curse is so that many proceed inordinately out of the Mouths of Men. AND the Prayer required herein is of three sorts 1. That which is previous for guidance and direction in a matter of so great weight and importance It is no small thing to fall into mistakes when Men act in the Name of Christ and so engage his Authority in what he will not own And the best of Men the best of Churches are liable
ascribed unto them Ver. 5. All these things do suppose a Right and Duty thereon to Act according to their Interest in Excommunication to reside in the whole Church Wherefore 5. THERE are some Acts belonging hereunto that the Church it self in the Body of the Fraternity cannot be excluded from without destroying the nature of the Sentence it self and rendring it ineffectual Such are the previous cognizance of the Cause without which they cannot be blamed for any neglect about it preparatory Duties unto its Execution in Prayer Mourning and Admonition which are expresly prescribed unto them and a Testification of their consent unto it by their common Suffrage Without these things Excommunication is but a Name with a noise it belongs not unto the Order appointed by Christ in his Church 6. HENCE arise the Duties of the Church towards an Excommunicated Person that are consequential unto his exclusion from among them Such are Praying for him as one noted by the Church and under the Discipline of Christ avoiding Communion with him in publick and private that he may be ashamed and the like all which arise from their own voluntary actings in his exclusion and such as without a judgment of the cause they cannot be obliged unto 7. YET on the other side unto the formal compleatness of this Sentence an Authoritative Act of Office-Power is required For 1. There is in it such an Act of Rule as is in the hands of the Elders only 2. The Executive Power of the Keys in binding and loosing so far as it comprizeth Authority to be acted in the Name of Christ is entrusted with them only 8. WHEREFORE I shall say no more in answer unto this Enquiry but that Excommunication is an act of church-Church-Power in its Officers and Brethren acting according unto their respective Rights Interests and Duties particularly prescribed unto them The Officers of the Church act in it as Officers with Authority the Brethren or the Body of the Church with Power yet so as that the Officers are no way excluded from their Power Consent and Suffrage in the acting of the Church but have the same Interest therein with all other Members of the Church but the Community of the Church have no Interest in those Authoritative actings of the Officers which are peculiar unto them Where either of these is wanting the whole Duty is vitiated and the sence of the Sentence rendred ineffectual I. IT is Enquired Whether Excommunication justly deserved may and ought to be omitted in case of trouble or danger that may ensue unto the Church therein IT is usually granted that so it may and ought to be which seems in general to have been the judgment of Austin THE Troubles and Dangers intended are three-fold 1. From the Thing it self 2. From the Persons to be Excommunicated 3. From the Church 1. TROUBLE may arise from the Thing it self For there being an exercise of Authority or Jurisdiction in it over the Persons of Men not granted from the Civil Magistrate by the Law of the Land those that execute it may be liable unto Penalties ordained in such cases 2. THE Persons to be Excommunicated may be Great and of great Interest in the World so as that if they receive a provocation hereby they may occasion or stir up Persecution against the Church as it hath often fallen out 3. THE Church it self may be divided on these considerations so as that lasting differences may be occasioned among them which the omission of the Sentence might prevent FOR Answer hereunto some things must be premised As 1. HERE is no supposition of any thing sinful or morally evil in the Church its Officers or any of its Members by refusing to omit the pronouncing of this Sentence Whether there be any Sin in giving occasion unto the troubles mentioned to be avoided by an omission of Duty is now to be enquired into 2. WE must suppose 1. That the cause of Excommunication be clear and evident both as unto the merit of the Fact and the due Application of it unto the Person concerned so as that no Rational indifferent Man shall be able to say that it is meet that such an one should be continued a Member of such a Society as it ought to be where-ever Excommunication is administred 2. That sufficient Time and space of Repentance and for giving satisfaction unto the Church whereof afterwards hath been allowed unto the Person after Admonition 3. That the Church doth really suffer in Honour and Reputation by tolerating such a scandalous Offender among them I ANSWER On these suppositions I see no just Reason to countenance the omission of the Execution of this Sentence or to acquit the Church from the guilt of Sin in so doing For 1. THE first presence of Danger is vain There is not the least shadow of Jurisdiction in this Act of the Church There is nothing in it that toucheth any thing which is under the Protection and Conservation of Humane Laws It reacheth not the Persons of Men in their Lives or Liberties nor their Estates or the least Secular Privileges that they do enjoy it doth not expose them to the Power or Censures of others nor prejudge them as unto Office or Advantage of Life There is therefore no concernment of the Law of the Land herein no more than in a Parents disenheriting a Rebellious Child 2. AS unto danger of Persecution by the means of the Person provoked I say 1. The same may be pleaded as unto all other Duties of obedience unto Jesus Christ wherewith the World is provoked and so the whole profession of the Church should give place to the fear of Persecution To testify against Sin in the way of Christs appointment is a case of Confession 2. The Apostles were not deterred by this consideration from the Excommunication of Simon Magus the seducing Jews Hymeneus and Alexander with others 3. The Lord Christ commandeth and reproveth his Churches according as they were strict in the observation of this Duty or neglective of it notwithstanding the fear of Persecution thereon Revel 2.3 And 4. He will take that care of his Church in all their obedience unto him as shall turn all the consequents thereof unto their advantage 3. AS unto danger of Differences in the Church there is nothing to be said but that if Rule Order Love and Duty will not prevent such Differences there is no way appointed of Christ for that end And if they are sufficient for it as they are abundantly they must bear their own blame who occasion such Differences II. BUT it may be said What if such an Offender as justly deserves to be Excommunicated and is under admonition in order thereunto in case of Impenitency should voluntarily withdraw himself from and leave the Communion of the Church is there any necessity to proceed against him by Excommunication Answ. 1. SOME say it is enough if it be declared in the Church that such an one hath cut off himself from the