the truth and Church is bound to doe the duties of his calling notwithstanding any such former restraint or danger of disobedience to it because the power of the Church is but ministeriall under and according to God rather declarative than Soveraigne therefore what she doth tyes not men here on earth to obey it to the destruction but to the edification of the Church or at least to prevent a greater mischiefe And also because the true Church may doe no such acts of deprivation or suspension whereby to intend or effect the destruction of the Church and therefore in that case transgressing of such restraints is no disobedience to the Church but rather an obeying the intent of the same as in times of persecution we have plentifull examples specially of the Church of the Iewes against the Christians A Caveat Yet herein is to be observed that such performance of duties in that case after restraint bee done in mecke patient manner without tumults or forcible opposition of authority submitting with passive obedience where they cannot lawfully performe active This extends not to warrant any schisme or heresie that esteem themselves only to be the true Church as did the Donatists and others to oppose out of feare of their owne ruine the proceedings and restraints of the more Orthodoxe and generall body of a sound Church whose authority doth preponderate and oversway her apostating members so long as by the doctrine publikely taught in her men may be saved and built up §. 30. Against commission of evill upon any humane command or threats Fourth member about commission of evill upon humane command The fourth member of the case wherein a man ought to expose his life to death in causes concerning religion is when a man is desired commanded or threatned to doe any sinne forbidden by Gods word that then hee doe it not although he therefore doe die as Iosephs practise manifests in resisting his whorish mistris a Gen. 39.12 and the three children that would not upon the Kings command worship the golden Image to save their lives Daniel 3.18 Because it is better for us to die than deliberately and wilfully to sinne against God as the woman with her seaven sonnes did choose 2 Mach. 7. according to S. Augustines judgement who sayes that if it be propounded to a man Vt aut mali aliquid faciat aut mali aliquid patiatur eligat non facere mala quam non pati mala b Epist 204. that either he should doe some evill or suffer some calamity then let him choose rather not to doe evill than not to suffer evill Observe How we are to abhorre sin For we are ever to doe that which may most neerely unite us to God our chiefe good and to shunne what may divide us from him which nothing can doe but our sinnes specially those that consist in the transgression of the negative Commandements and are most opposite to God and incompatible with him and therefore those lawes doe binde ad semper to the alwayes observing of them and cannot be dispensed withall seeing God is unchangeable The evill of sinne should be more terrible to us than death it selfe not onely for that it is the cause of death and imbitters it but also because it deprives us of a greater good of our spirituall life that farre exceeds the naturall The beatificall object that sinne deprives us of is the infinite blessed God from whom to be separated is worse than death it self and in that respect rather than we should sinne we should choose to suffer death which is a glorious kinde of Martyrdome and a meanes of advancement to happinesse for the power and practise of the truth laying downe our lives which is a more undoubted signe of grace and salvation than is the suffering of many for holding the truth in opinion and profession Wee should choose rather not to bee than not to bee happy for the originall and end of our being is better than our being it selfe in regard that our happinesse is not of and in our selves but in and from another who is both our beginning and end §. 31. Of the kindes of sinnes of commission to be avoyded Evils of sin to be avoided These sinfull evills that wee ought thus carefully to avoid and forbeare to death are of two sorts 1. Against the law of nature First those that be directly and absolutely forbidden by the Law of nature as fundamentally unlawfull at all times and in all cases for the contrariety that they have against the nature of God and against the inbred principles of reason and conscience of which no question can be made but that wee are alwaies utterly to shun them notwithstanding any humane command or inforcement that may be to the contrary because no human power can dissolve the obligation of those ingrafted Commandements of God and nature Innata Lex Rom. 2.15 that we may be discharged in conscience from keeping of them which would overthrow both divinity and humanity neither can any free us from the punishment of the transgression of them both because equity and Law requires that the soule that sins shall die and also for that there is no power matchable with Gods and natures to protect or free us by force from their vengeance 2. Against the positive Law of God Secondly the sins that wee are to shun and not wittingly and willingly to do upon any threats or worldly danger or for any profit are those that are forbidden by the positive Law and revealed will of God the violating whereof doth wrong the soveraignty and honor of God who is the absolute and onely independant King of all the world and his will the supreame unerring rule of our obedience throughout our lives our transgression whereof is a breach of that loyalty and due subjection which wee owe to that our highest Lord. To whese positive Law conformity is more properly obedience to God than conformity to the Law of nature is by it selfe considered Because the ground of our conformity to the Law of nature is naturall inclination and Reason equally binding Heathens aswell as Christians But the ground of our conformity to the positive Law of God is principally the soveraigne Authority and Will of God himselfe which kinde of obedience is that which is properly of the Church and her members to God and proceeds from faith love feare c. Evangelicall or Thelogicall graces From which obedience to God no wight can absolve or excuse us that we may lawfully and safely subject our selves to feare to please or to obey any other in opposition or contraty to him and his will Reasons 1. Because there is none above God whose will may be preferred or equalled to his to whom all is subordinate in nature state and imployment 2. Neither is any man Lord over the Conscience either to bind or discharge it contrary to the Law or will of God that we
bringing himselfe to destruction Page 111 § 10. How indirect self-murder of commission is wrought by desperate hazard in six cases Page 112 The first case is concerning Braves and desperate undertakers Page 112 The second case is concerning purchase and reskue Page 112 The third case is concerning some souldiers Page 113 The fourth case is concerning Mariners Page 113 The fifth case is concerning Duells Page 114 The sixth case is concerning desperate attempts upon daring and wagering Page 116 § 11. Of indirect self-murder committed by covenant and society with persons destinate to destruction in three cases Page 118 1. Of Leagues Page 119 2. Of Warre ibid. 3. Of presuming into infectious places or company Page 120 § 12. Of indirect self-murder of commission by doing that which naturally procures that which kills the doer of it Page 121 § 13. Of indirect self-murder of commission by wilfully doing capitall crimes against humane Lawes and Authority Page 120 § 14. Of indirect self-murder of commission by wilfull transgression of Gods Laws after two severall waies Page 120 § 15. Of three exempt cases wherein men may expose their lives to death without danger of indirect self-murder Page 125 The first case is concerning venturing life upon lawfull calling ibid. § 16. A question or case of conscience resolved about Souldiers in danger of their lives fleeing without order Page 127 § 17. Of the second exempt case about adventuring of life without danger of indirect self-murder which is in urgent unavoidable necessity in three points Page 128 The first whereof is about both uncertaine death for certaine and necessary good ibid. And also certaine death for Superiours and for some friends Page 129 § 18. Of the second point which is concerning certaine death for certaine more publick good Page 131 § 19. Of six questions resolved that belong to this second point Page 133 The first where of is about a man-slayer what he is to do for whose sake his friends are pursued to death ibid. § 20. Of the second question which is about a man under deadly displeasure of Superiours what he is to do for to pacifie their mortall wrath reflecting for his sake upon his friends Page 133 § 21. The third question which is touching the voluntary appearing of Fellons or the like at liberty upon baile to submit to Iustice for freeing of their bailes with danger of their owne lives Page 135 § 22. The fourth question which is about what an unquestioned or unsuspected guilty party is to do for saving of a guiltlesse person that is brought to the doome and danger of death upon triall by error or misprision for the capitall fact of the former Page 136 § 23. The fifth question which is about a mans voluntary revealing to the Magistrate his owne secret capitall crimes touching his life in case of importable distresse of conscience for the same crimes by him done Page 137 § 24. The sixth question or case which is about burning or sinking a ship in a sea-sight and how farre such a fight is to be mainteyned against the Enemies without danger of self-murder Page 138 § 25. Of the third point of the second exempt case which is about venturing of life without danger of indirect self-murder for saving of soules Page 141 In two cases 1. About infectious persons ibid. 2. About publishing of the Gospell upon danger of death to the doer Page 142 § 26. Of the third generall exempt case wherein men may expose their lives to death without danger of indirect self-murder which is about religion and our owne salvation in foure points or cases Page 143 § 27. Of the first point or case which is about defence of Religion in peace and warre Page 144 § 28. Of the second point of the third case about adventuring and laying down our lives for religion without danger of self-murder which is about the publick confession or profession of the truth with danger of life Page 145 § 29. Of the third point belonging to the third exempt case which is about not-omitting doing necessary duties commanded by God in perill of life upon humane command or threats to the contrary and of the severall sorts of those duties and how farre they bind us And of the obedience and disobedience of Ministers to suspension deprivation and the like censures Page 146 § 30. Of the fourth point of the third exempt case which is about not-commission of any evill of sinne upon any command or inforcement of man threatning death to the disobedient Page 149 § 31. Of the kinds of sins of commission to be avoided to death in things determinatly evill of themselves both by the law of nature and also by the positive Law of God Page 150 § 32. Of indifferent things and how the use of them may be sinfull and in that respect then to be forborne Page 152 § 33. Of the diverse properties of an indirect self-murderer Page 154 § 34. Observations from indirect self-murder in three uses Page 155 Chap. 12. Of direct bodily self-murder § 1. What direct self-murder is both in the generall nature of it in foure things and also in the specificall nature of it remote and neere Page 159 § 2. Of the imaginary good conceited to be in self-murder Page 163 § 3. Concerning the wills object and its faultinesse Page 167 § 4. Of diverse observations from direct self-murder Page 169 § 5. Of certaine exempt cases of some that kill themselves and are not direct self-murderers Page 172 Chap. 13. Of direct self-murderers § 1. That practise and habit gives denomination and why Page 175 § 2. How it is apparent by Scripture that many men have murdered themselves with diverse observations from the same about self-murder and horrible crimes falling out in the Church Page 176 § 3. How self-murderers are apparent by Histories both prophane and Ecclesiasticall amongst heathens and Christians and the reasons of the same Page 178 § 4. That self-murderers are knowne by continued experience and of two uses of the same and how the motions of self-murder cleave to men and prevaile over them Page 181 Chap. 14. Of the meanes and method of self-murderers murdering themselves directly § 1. Of the meanes of self-murder how none is lawfull of two uses shewing how hard it is to do good and easie to do evill Page 183 § 2. The self-murderers application of the meanes of self-killing in premeditation and determination of the end and choise of the meanes to effect it with observation of three things therein and of two observations for instruction and use Page 185 § 3. Of the self-murderers method in executing murder upon themselves with observation of three things therein upon two reasons and how hardly resolved self-murder is withstood Page 187 Chap. 15. The self-murderers motives whereupon they directly kill themselves § 1. That men by abused reason do sin worst and that there is no true reason why any should kill themselves Page 189 § 2. Of motives to
self-murder there can bee none warrantably sufficient and how arguments are deemed weak or strong Page 191 § 3. Concerning the motive to self-murder from perverted Iudgement by humane lawes and customes how both prevaile against nature How the judgement of the learned and wise hath the force of Law How lawes and customes against Scripture and reason are erroneous and not to be obeyed A caveat against vaine praise of self-murderers Page 192 § 4. Of the motive to self-murder from perverted judgment by mis-understood Scripture the three causes thereof and of foure meanes or rules of right understanding the Scriptures Page 195 § 5. Of the motive to self-murder from perverted judgment by mis-construed decree and destiny and the grounds of the same the errer of grounding ill practises upon that foundation with diverse observations about that course Page 202 § 6. Of the motive to self-murder from perverted judgment by the conceited good of self-murder and how apparent good beguiles the understanding And now the will workes upon the understanding to deceive it and how self-murder blinds the mind Page 207 § 7. Of the motive to self-murder from afflictions their severall sorts whereof three are upon the body Page 211 § 8. Of the motive to self-murder from afflictions upon a mans outward estate Page 214 § 9. Of the motive to self-murder from crosses in points of honour Page 215 § 10. Of the motive to self-murder from disasters upon friends in two eases Page 216 § 11. Of the motive to self-murder from trouble of conscience the kinds and manner of the same Page 217 § 12. Of the motive to self murder from disconcentment of mind and passion of love the kinds and causes of discontentment Page 219 § 13. Of the motive to self-murder from disgrace and shame 221. the causes effects and kinds thereof Page 222 § 14. Of the motive to self-murder from feare the causes and effects of it Page 224 § 15. Of the true causes of self-murder in afflictions which are three Page 225 § 16. That Affliction is no warrantable motive for any to kill themselves shewed by foure reasons Page 228 § 17. Of certaine uses about afflicted persons Page 230 § 18. Of the motive to self-murder from anger and revenge the kindes thereof against ones selfe and others good and bad their causes and powerfull effects Page 232 § 19. Of the motive to self-murder from care of prevention of sin to come in our selves or others and how unwarrantable it is for any to kill themselves for that end Page 237 § 20. Of the motive to self-murder from ambition and excessive desire after glory praise or a better life to come after death and how unwarrantable it is for any therefore to kill themselves Page 241 § 21. Of the motive to self-murder from the motions and temptations of the devill how he suggests the same and to whom specially how knowne to be from Satan and upon what reasons to be rejected Page 246 § 22. Of the motive to self-killing from phrensie the kinds the subjects and grounds of it Page 250 § 23. Of the motive to self-murder from the examples of such as have murdered or killed themselves and of the insufficiency of that motive for any to do the like upon such presidents Page 252 Chap. 16. Of Self-murderers introduction and entrance into the practise of self-murder § 1. Of the persons most subject to self-murder who are of foure sorts Page 254 § 2. Of the entrance into self-murder by foure particular degrees where are handled two questions 1. concerning desire of death 2. about the goodnesse of being against them that wish that they had never beene borne or never had being Page 256 § 3. Of foure signes of ensuing self-murder neere approching Page 259 Chap. 17. Arguments against self-murder proving the same to be utterly unlawfull and damnable § 1. That self-murder is contrary to Religion and how where two questions are resolved 1. Whether the Supreame Magistrate may for any capitall crime done by him either kill himselfe or be put to death pon his owne command or otherwise by his people 2. How farre a man condemned to die may be active about taking away his owne life Page 262 § 2. How self-murder is against God himselfe in foure respects Page 267 § 3. How self-murder is against nature Page 269 § 4. How self-murder is injurious to mankinde Page 270 § 5. How self-murder wrongs mans selfe in doing it Page 271 § 6. How self-murder is a sinne most harmfull and to whom Page 272 § 7. How right reason condemnes self-murder by nineteene severall arguments Page 273 Wherein also is shewed the reasons why the goods of self-murderers become confiscate and Deodands Page 278 § 8. Of certaine uses about the grievousnesse of self-murder and how men should beware of it Page 286 Chap. 18. Of the finall estate of direct selfmurderers whether they be all everlastingly damned with the devils in hell or not § 1. Of the extent of self-murder to the soules hurt and how regardlesse self-murderers be of their soules Page 288 § 2. That all that kill themselves are not properly direct self-murderers nor are in their state of damnation and who be exempted and upon what grounds Page 290 § 3. That all proper and direct self-murderers are reprobates without the state of grace and are in the state of eternall damnation and the reasons thereof Page 291 § 4. That by the Testimony of the Scriptures both in doctrine and also in all examples of self-murderers recorded therein all proper and direct self-murderers are everlastingly damned Page 293 § 5. That self-murder is a transcendent sin beyond both law and mercy and subjects the doers of it to damnation ibid. § 6. That self-murderers want all true saving repentance and likewise salvation Page 296 § 7. How the Church testifies by her judgement and usage of direct self-murderers that they are all damned in hell Page 297 § 8. Of certaine uses Page 299 § 9. Of certaine objections made in favour of the salvation of self-murderers answered and first touching that which is taken from the nature of self-murder compared with other the most damnable sins committed against the Law and Gospell Page 300 § 10. The second objection answered which is made from the example of self-killers such as Sampson Pelagia and others who are saved Page 303 § 11. The third objection answered which is taken from the antecedent prayer and repentance of self-murderers for the intended fact of self-murder to come that for the same the doer of it may not be damned Page 306 Chap. 19. Antidotes for prevention of self-murder § 1. What a man is to do of and by himself to prevent self-murder in eight severall particulars Page 311 § 2. How to others wee should make confession of our temptations motives and progresse to self-murder that we may prevent the same and of the manisold caveats and observations about confession Page 317 § 3. Of the meanes to
himselfe in answering negatively Not guilty For although hee knowes and hath elsewhere confessed himselfe to bee guilty of the fact materially considered in the substance of it yet he may be ignorant as most men are whether that fact of his formally considered is or may be found to be treason felony burglary or the like as by the inditement it is charged upon him and in which respect he is to suffer death for it if he do answer affirmatively And although he should certainly know that his fact were such in construction and termes of Law as by his Inditement the same is charged upon him yet is he not to answer affirmatively because not he but the present impannelled Iury are the competent and lawfull Iudges to find or not to find it to be such in that forme and Law quality And therefore hee is bound in conscience to answer negatively Not guilty of such a fact under that forme or terme and Law notion whereby and wherefore his life in that respect may be taken away And so by pleading not guilty hee lies not nor contradicts himselfe but thereby takes the allowed benefit of putting it to a legall triall whether his fact shall bee found against him in that sense and forme as in those Law termes he is charged with the same in his inditement and in which respect onely he can be put to death for it which course if hee should not use of answering Not guilty but that he should stand mute or answer affirmatively Guilty he should be indirectly a self-murderer as hath beene shewed Repli But then it may be further replied when such a malefactor shall after his pleading to the Inditement not guilty bee publickly examined by the Iudge about his fact considered in the substance of it without the vesture of such termes or Law notions put upon it how can he answer negatively against his conscience and former confession before a Justice Answer I answer first the Iudges questions to such an one at publick triall after his negative plea to the bill of Inditement are ministred in favour of the party arraigned both that he may upon better advisement traverse his former confession by his negative answer contrary to the which confession hee is allowed at the barre to plead not guilty And also that hee may not bee cast or condemned upon any evidence or verdit of others against him before he bee heard answer for himselfe what hee can say for the negative in his owne defence against the affirmative evidence or sentence produced against him where it is to be considered that the primary intention and expectation of the Iudge in his questions at triall is that by the prisoners answers hee may the better decerne the truth or falshood of the evidence of others against him and how himselfe may proceed in accepting of the verdit and in giving judgement according to justice and not thereby to wring affirmative answers from the arraigned against their owne lives when others cannot touch them which is contrary to the Law of nature and of God Secondly it is alwaies to be observed by every malefactor that in his answers hee doe not to save his life make any lie neither directly nor yet by equivocation or mentall reservation and also that he doe not so confesse the truth against his owne life that he should thereby make himselfe guilty of indirect self-murder Both which evils hee may avoid by the medium or middle course either of traverse and demurrer delaying and putting off the Iudge and Iury from himselfe to informe themselves by other evidences than his owne or else by silence after his generall negative plea of not guilty replying nothing to such questions as the answers thereof may intangle him either in a lie or in indirect self-murder after which manner of answering nothing our blessed Saviour behaved himself before Pilate Iohn 19.9 Although that such silence or not answering directly may be construed to be an acknowledgement of the fact that he is indited for yet thereby he shall not be active but onely passive in being found guilty and so condemned to die whereby he shall be free of indirect self-murder in that respect The confession of a malefactor upon examination before a Iustice when the same is against his owne life may bee construed to have beene either rashly and unwarrantably done by the Examinate against which therefore he is allowed at his Triall to plead not guilty or else that hee did the same upon some motives and reasons of conscience for the good and salvation of his soule which are things properly belonging to another Court And therefore in humane Courts of Assize the questions and answers in this case reach not so farre as to rack or discover the conscience of a man to the taking away of his owne life by his owne confession which the Law of nature and of God binds a man to preserve Although a capitall malefactor is bound in conscience not to lie in his answers yet he is not bound to reveale all the truth he knowes against himselfe specially where hee is not tied by some speciall divine bond so to doe A negative answer at triall is as strong to save a man as his former affirmative in confession before a Iustice can be to condemne him except either he publickly at his triall acknowledge the same or that there be some other proofe or evidence against him And therefore I conclude that it is not necessary in conscience that whatsoever truth such a man in this case hath once confessed that he should every where and at all times upon interrogatories to be answered at will confesse the same with perill of his life but that hee may be silent or forbeare to answer otherwise than he is bound by the lawes of the Court where he answers For if another be bound to keepe close a mans confession made to him of his secret faults that man is not compellable to disclose the same of himselfe specially against his owne life when he cannot doe the same without being guilty of indirect self-murder as in this case I have shewed by the rules of divinity and right reason for resolving of weak consciences in this point not intermedling to argue and determine the same by the rules of the Common-law of this Kingdome which is impertinent to my profession and beyond my understanding and therefore I leave that worke to the learned of that most Honourable profession to whose cognizance this subject legally considered doth appertaine §. 7. Of indirect self-murder by commission The second degree of indirect self-murder is by commission in divers branches The second meanes of indirect self-murder is by a course of commission or of doing things unlawfully tending to bring a man to his death which is a degree grosser than the former and consists in divers branches 1. Abuse of lawfull things First by abusing lawfull things in transgressing due moderation in their use for time
so great as is sinne in respect both of the nature thereof whereby it is most contrary to God who is the greatest and chiefest good and also in regard of the merits and effects thereof procuring and imbittering all evill to those that sin For of evill properly comes nothing but evill as of nought and nought comes nothing but nought the effect cannot exceed in goodnesse the nature and vertue of its cause §. 2. Of motives in generall to self-murder there can be none warrantably sufficient Externall motives to self-murder Neither is there indeed any externall motive sufficient of it selfe to induce and perswade a man to kill himself by any true reason that can be in or from the motive to doe such an act without respect of a conceit of good ensuing upon the act of self murder to the self-murderer But in regard that these motives worke not upon all to doe that act of self-murder it is from the disposition and qualities of the persons that are therewith affected and wrought upon to doe the same and not properly from the motives themselves for then all men by the same motives should doe the same act of self-murder Divers The motives are divers that doe diversly move divers persons to kill themselves for all self-murderers do not kill themselves upon the same occasions some are not affected with one motive that are affected with another to doe that fact Arguments how weak and strong For arguments are weake or strong to severall persons as they are of deep or shallow judgement or as they stand differently affected and possessed with prejudices sutable to their humours designes and ends Whereby to some weake arguments are strong and strong are weake and by few are they apprehended according to their due worth which is the cause of much unreconcileable opposition and division in the world and of the building of weighty conclusions upon weake premises and foundations and of indivertible resolutions and practises founded more upon passionate wilfulnesse than upon judicious reasons Comparison as we see about the objects of bodily sight the which is represented and conceived by us to be according to the disposition of the medium or meane and of the organ or eye whereby wee see them Note Which shewes how needfull it is for matter of reason and judgement that wee looke upon the same as it is without all distemperature and prejudices in our mindes §. 3. Concerning perverted Iudgement by Laws and Custome These externall motives of self-murder I will for memory and method reduce into eight rankes The first motive to self-murder is error of judgement The first whereof is errour of judgement when men thinke and beleeve upon deceitfull grounds that they ought or may lawfully kill themselves either absolutely when they list or in some cases when they see it requisite in regard of some circumstances Grounds of it The unsound grounds of this perverted judgement are foure 1. Lawes and Customes First Lawes and Customes in some places seeming to require and warrant people in some cases to kill themselves As among the Heathens and Indians In India where by custome or law servants and wives in testimony of love to their Masters and Husbands were wont to cast themselves into the fire to bee burnt with the corps of their dead masters and husbands but the true cause of that Law was to restraine the frequent poysoning of masters and husbands by their servants and wives and that law and custome was practised to avoide suspition and ignominie that they lived in if they did not so kill themselves Plutarch reports of the Virgins of Lemnos In Lemnos that customarily they hanged themselves upon no other knowne cause but custome and from that vile practise could not be restrained untill the same was punished by drawing of their bodies naked through the streets after that they were dead by sensible ignominie reforming a bad and odious custome Also among the Turkes In Turkie servants in testimony of their obedience at their living masters command doe throw themselves over rocks or into rivers or the like as Baldwin a Lib. 3. cap. 4. Cas 13. circa melancholicos the Casuist reports but it is most like that they doe it to prevent a greater misery if they should disobey But they that did so were thought to doe well and were therefore commended and the parties themselves did verily thinke that either they did but their duties or that which was best for them to doe which if they did not then were they evill thought of and evill intreated The prevailing of lawes and customes against nature Thus farre doe law and custome prevaile against the light of nature among the Heathen because they knew no higher rule to examine and try their lawes by and therefore submit to humane ordinances absolutely bee they good or bad Custome which is another nature maketh it familiar and to seeme lawfull and commendable in the judgement of sense that in the judgement of right reason is most abominable Custome is a tyrant captivating both judement and practise to her lore because what by generall practise seemes to have the approbation of all is deemed best and most reasonable for peaceable conformity both in opinion and practise from which to be singular is odious The judgement of the learned hath the force of a Law That also which in this case obtains the force of a law is the judgement of the learned the practise of persons in esteem commended by posterity for the same As among the Philosophers the Stoicks did in some cases both direct commend and practise self-murder which historians and Poets magnifie in their high praises of Lucretia Cato and others for the same The high esteeme of the persons of men of that opinion and of the practisers of that act and ambition of like praises for the like thing hath forcibly driven many men contrary to their owne minde to cast themselves away upon this infernall rock The error of this ground The deceitfulnesse of this ground is that it is meerely humane against divinity and that more is attributed to it and built upon it than it can beare It is contrary to religion and reason For all lawes customes opinions and practises of men are to be regulated and ordered by sound reason according to Gods word and are subordinate to the same and thereby to be tryed and examined Note So that no law or custome no opinions or practise of any men is to be imbraced and obeyed when the same is manifestly impious or against Gods Law and right reason As we see by the practise of the Apostles Acts 4.19 For that in such cases in conforming to man we cannot be excused before God for transgressing his will An inferiour hath no power over the right of his superiour to dispense therewith Observe to examine In judgement of discretion therefore customes laws
principally for their unbeliefe as our Saviour Christ saith He that beleeveth not is condemned already a Ioh. 3.18 §. 4. Of the examples of self-murderers in Scripture 2. Reason Proving that all self-murderers are damned The second argument proving that all proper self-murderers are damned is the examples of those recorded in the Scriptures who did murder thēselves as Saul Ahitophel Zimri Iudas c. that were all reprobates and damned persons Examples For the Scripture speakes not onely of their fact of self-murder with condemning and detesting of the same but also it so describes the persons themselves that do it that it makes it apparent that they are damned and gives instance in none other that did it but reprobately damned wretches So that by induction of particular self-murderers in Scripture who were all reprobates and damned we may safely conclude that no self-murderer is or can be saved seeing there can no Authentick instance be given of any such that ever was saved And therefore we should not be conformable to those in their damnable practise with whom wee would not communicate in their last and finall estate of everlasting damnation but of this see more cap. 15. § 23. cap. 17. § 7. argument 17. §. 5. Self-murder is a sin transcendent beyond Law and mercy 3. Reason Proving that all self-murderers are damned The third reason and ground whereupon it is evident that no self-murderer can be saved but are all damned is the very nature of this horrible sinne of self-murder it selfe taken in the full latitude thereof in manner and forme of the greatest anomie and enormity of it The excessive hainousnesse of that sinne which neither can here consist with true grace in those that so perpetrate it nor will permit any that so do it to enter into Heaven in regard of the hainousnesse of it whereby it is without the pale and verge of mercy to be shewed to any that commit it Reason The reason whereof is this by the Gospell God offers mercy upon repentance to those onely that transgresse against the Law of naturall reason and of the positive Commandements of God in those kindes and degrees of sinnes the highest and most grievous whereof exceeds not nor transcends the utmost limits and bounds of that which humane reason properly and Gods Law expresly forbids and condemnes and whereof instances may be given that some in that estate or in one parallel to it have repented and beene saved The Lawes given to man have bounds Because to restraine mans presumption in evill mercy is intended and offered to penitent men for sinnes contained within certaine bounds and limits and not extended to insinitnesse of excesse or malignity with overthrow either of the universall Law of nature or of the Law whereby God is subsists and acts his works which would import that there must be neither God nor Creature These limits of mans pardonable sins are those lawes of reason or of Divine imposition which are proportionable and reciprocally proper for men binding them onely to keepe them as every kinde of creatures are bound by their owne proper lawes and the universe by the lawes that binds the whole and all its parts beyond or above the height of enormitie forbidden directly by them for men to transgresse they wrong and overthrow what they can the very being and happinesse both of the Creature and Creator in which excesse of iniquity beyond the highest kinds and degrees directly forbidden in the Law there is no salvation to be had because in that case men are without and beyond the highest expresse extent of the lawes proper to men for breaches whereof mercy may be had by the Gospell For sinnes beyond the Law no mercy For the Gospell and Law have respect thus farre one to another for their bounds and extent that the vertue and benefit of the Gospell extends onely to save those penitents that are in danger to perish by sinnes directly under and within the compasse of the law proper to man but if man do sin transcendently-presumptiously and properly against more universall or higher Lawes that concernes the being of God or of the whole frame of the creation the violating whereof naturall instinct and divine horror may make us abominate there is no comfort of the Gospell nor salvation to such as is apparent in the devils into whose qualities and order such men do degenerate by their transcendent sinnes beyond the list of those for which mercy may be had by the Gospell which respects pardon of sinnes limited only within compasse of that Law which is properly given to man and requires a modified justice sutable to the power man had at first to performe dutie Self-murder is a transcendent sinne beyond Law Now self-murder properly so called is such an extracategorian and transcendent sinne beyond or above the law of reason or of divine imposition proper to man that it violates the frame of the Creation and the Majesty of God himselfe as well as his Law in endeavouring the destruction of both from which horrible fact both naturall instinct and divine horror might restraine a man if he had not put off humanity The sinne of self-murder is forbidden by Gods Law Thou shalt do us murder Whereunto it belongs only by reduction and Analogie or proportion that it hath to murder and not properly but is a namelesse sinne properly belonging to a more universall and higher Law that concernes God himselfe and the frame of the Creation the transcendency of which sin puts the doers thereof without the pale of mercy §. 6. Self-murderers want true repentance 4. Reason Proving that all proper self-murderers are damned The fourth reason and argument whereupon it is evident that all proper self-murderers in that transcendent extent and forme spoken of before cannot be saved but are all damned is their want of true repentance for their sinnes without which there can be no salvation They want true repentance That they want true repentance and all other subsequent saving graces neither in that estate can have the same is thus apparent if they have repentance it must be either habituall and implicite in their disposition or actuall and explicite in expressions and deeds or in both But if it be neither way in them then it cannot be in them at all but it is neither way in them ergo 1. Habituall repentance First habituall repentance they cannot have because it is a penitent disposition that must be either infused by the holy Spirit or acquired and purchased by frequent acts and practise of repentance but neither doth the holy Ghost indow such with the habituall disposition of true repentante because it is an Evangelicall grace whereof sinners of that transcendencie beyond the Law are not capable and where it is it is accompanied with the body of other saving graces which all such persons do want nor yet have they got habituall repentance by their long and
nature of self-murder Objections There remaines now certaine objections to be answered which may be made in favour of proper self-murderers for their salvation which are especially three The first of them may be pretended to be taken from the nature of self-murder alledging that the same is not so hainous a sinne but that the doers thereof may bee saved 1. From the nature of self-murder First because if we consider sinnes as they are committed against the Gospell onely the sinne against the holy Ghost is called a sinne unto death a 1 Joh. 5.16 which never shall be pardoned b Mat. 12.31 Self-murder is not that sinne and therefore may seeme to bee pardonable and the doers thereof saved 2. Againe if wee do consider the sinnes committed directly agaist the Law there is none of them desperately unpardonable because they all and every of them may upon repentance be cured by the Gospell which is of equall extent to the Law to be able to repleave and save all that the Law condemnes And of the sinnes committed against the Law some as spitefull blasphemy against the Majesty of God and the like may in the true nature of them seeme to be more hainous than self-murder both in regard of their more direct and malignant opposition against God and also for their greater distance in nature from pardon Answ 1. The sin against the holy Ghost To this objection that caries with it a countenance of probability I answer first touching the argument taken from the sin against the holy Ghost it is to be considered that that sin is unpardonable and they damned that do it onely in respect of that desperate opposition whereby the committers of it do spitefully oppose and reject Christ and his Gospell the very only meanes whereby they can be saved so that there remaines no further or other way or help for salvation and also because that sinne is ever infallibly accompanied with finall impenitency which alwaies makes a man uncapable of grace and salvation which none can have but true penitents How self-murder is equivalēt to the sinne against the holy Ghost Self-murder hath that in it which is in the sin against the holy Ghost in respect whereof it damnes and is unpardonable which is both finall impenitency in regard that a self-murderer by that sinne in the perfection of the anomie of it doth so indispose himselfe and shuts up and ends his life by and in such a horrible transgression that hee cannot possibly repent nor consequently bee saved And also equivalent and answerable to that spitefull rejection of Christ his grace and Gospell in the sin against the holy Ghost by the living there is in self-murder the cutting off of one selfe by his owne hands in this death from grace and salvation to be gotten only in and by life So that in these respects self-murder is as certainly damnable and the doers thereof reprobated as is the sin against the holy Ghost and the committers thereof For although of the sin against the holy Ghost it be precisely said that it shall never be forgiven and that the committers thereof are certainely damned yet it is neither said nor is true that none but sinners against the holy Ghost have their sinnes not forgiven to them and are damned seeing the contrary is abundantly certaine and the wicked quality and impenitent disposition of some persons so depraved and vitiated by their sins makes the same to be in them unpardonable which brings them to the same finall state with sinners against the holy Ghost it matters little for a mans comfort that is to be put to death whether he be hanged for felonie or for burglarie seeing for either of them his death is the same 2. Self-murder a transcendent great sin Secondly I answer touching the comparison made betweene self-murder and other sinnes committed against the Law that self-murder is a greater sin than any that can be directly and properly committed against and within any precept of the Law for which the committers of the same may have grounded hope of forgivenesse because self-murder is a transcendent sinne as hath beene shewed in the third reason transcedents are ever larger and greater than subordinates and it is a sinne condemnable by more and stronger reasons and arguments than any other sinne committed against and within the compasse of the Law as the same is more grievously injurious to more objects and transgresses more Lawes naturall divine and humane and therefore it must needs be the greater sinne Also the estimate of the greatnesse and unpardonablenesse of sinnes as they are in offenders is not wholly to be made by consideration of their abstract nature but specially the same is to bee made by the quality and disposition of the committers of them whose personall and actionall circumstances in doing of thē much aggravats or extenuats the same For pardon or not pardon of sins depends more upon the penitencie or impenitency of the offenders than upon the nature of their sins absolutly and abstractly considered the fact of self murder is such a sinne as no man penitently disposed can commit and it cuts him that doth it off finally from all repentance and consequently from salvation Self-murder most dangerous for a mans soule Of all sinnes against the Law self-murder is most dangerous and pernicious for a mans soule to bring it to damnation both because it excludes all care and meanes of a mans salvation which if a self-murderer did regard he would not venture in the last period of his life upon a course so contrary to it and also it puts the self-murderer into such an estate and disposition of sinfulnesse and aversenesse from God and his will in pursuing of his owne wicked lust that he is not nor can be capable of grace nor is in the way of salvation whereunto self-murder is most contrary by his last act of horrible sin in the closure of his life And therefore it is apparent that for any thing in this objection alledged there is nothing from the nature of the sin of self-murder properly so called that can give any comfort of salvation to self-murderers or can warrant us to hold probably and in the judgement of charity that they are not all generally considered utterly damned §. 10. Touching Examples of self-killers 2. Object Is from examples The second objection that may be made in favour of the salvation of self-murderers is taken from examples of Sampson Pelagia and many others that in the Primitive Church killed themselves and are acknowledged to be saved Therefore it may seeme probable that some self-murderers may be saved Answers 1. That Sampson is no self-murderer To this objection I answer first touching Sampson that he was no self-murderer directly nor in that point of so dying indirectly the reasons whereof are evident Reasons 1. First because his intention will and endeavours were not directly or primarily but only
occasion of self-murder they should not be wise-mens rules Page 252 The examples of self-murder all bad Page 282 By examples of self-murderers they are all damned that murder themselves Page 293 From examples the objection of self-murderers answered Page 303 Exchange A bad exchange Page 280 Execution of self-murder Page 187 Executioners of destruction God wants not Page 56 Exercise of spirituall life preserves it Page 40 Experience discovers self-murderers Page 181 By experience the evill of self-murder is not knowne in this world Page 188 F Faith Want of faith is cause of disobedience Page 70 Faith is a help for courage Page 128 Faith overthrowne by self-murder Page 272 Faith is against self-murder Page 274 Fasting and prayer helps to prevent self-murder Page 315 Feare A man should feare himself Page 171 Of feare occasioning self-murder Page 224 How feare makes bold ibid. Feare of sin to come how it occasions self-murder Page 237 Feare how hurtfull Page 314 Fellons When fellons are voluntarily to appeare at Assizes Page 135 Fits of self-murder Page 261 Folly of self-murderers Page 186 Food a preservative of naturall life Page 12 Food neglected cause of self-murder Page 91 Fooles Of naturall fooles killing themselves Page 250 Fortune-tellers cause of self-murder Page 202 Freedome from evill is the conceited good in self-murder Page 164 Friends when and how one may die for them Page 129 How calamities upon friends may be cause of self-murder Page 216 How to friends and posterity self-murder is hurtfull Page 273 What care friends of the tempted to self-murder should have of him Page 323 G Gallants desperatly adventuring Page 112 Generall nature of direct self-murder Page 159 Glory the end of ambition Page 242 God converts man by the Gospell Page 30 Why God converts by meanes Page 31 To depend upon God Page 180 Gods secret will is the measure of his own actions and his revealed will is the rule of ours Page 205 How men blame God Page 207 Self-murder is against God himself and how Page 267 Gods glory wronged by self-murder Page 272 Godly life is a signe of spirituall life Page 38 Good A good-conscience is a ground of choerefulnesse Page 13 Good life neglected how it is cause of indirect self-murder Page 94 For publick good one may die Page 131 The imaginary good of self-murder Page 164 Good is the object of the will Page 167 The kinds of good Page 168 How to do good is hard Page 184 Of good shame Page 222 Benefit of good imployment Page 314 Goods of self-murderers confiscate and why Page 278 Goodnesse The Goodnesse of being Page 259 Both goodnesse and truth are the objects of the understanding Page 208 Gospell The Gospell how published to all mankinde Page 24 How the gospell works spirituall life Page 30 Of the malignity of the sins against the Gospell Page 76 About publishing the Gospell how to adventure Page 142 Grace Of grace habituall and actual Page 35 How grace dies by mans negligence 63 How to cherish it ibid. Of emptinesse of grace Page 218 Conceit that the time of grace is past ibid. The use of being in the state of grace Page 311 What want of grace wrought in the heathen Page 178 Grounds of deceived judgement Page 192. 195. 207. Guilty About answering at Assizes Guilty or not Guilty Page 100 To save the guiltlesse what the guilty is to do Page 136 H Habit gives denomination Page 175 Hainousnesse of self-murder Page 286. 294 Harmefulnesse of self-murder Page 272 Hazard Of desperate hazard and cases thereof Page 112 Heathen histories manifesting self-murderers Page 178 Why Heathens murder themselves ibid. Some heathens thought self-murder in some cases to be lawfull Page 178 Heaven To heaven self-murder is not the way Page 244 For heaven wee are to wait Gods time Page 245 Heresie How self-murder is Heresie Page 233 Hieroms opinion against self-murder Page 277 Historie How by histories self-murderers are discovered Page 178 Holy-Ghost Of the sin against the Holy-Ghost Page 73. 301 Holy life is good against self-murder Page 312 Holinesse is a good meanes to understand the Scriptures Page 200 Honor How affectation of honor caused Heathens to kill themselves Page 179 Calamities upon honour occasioning self-murder Page 215 Hope a preservative of spirituall life Page 41 Humility a meanes better to understand the Scripture Page 199 Humility is a good preservative against self-murder Page 312 Hurt The hurt of self-murder Page 181 288 J Jdlenesse Of idlenesse and how men mis-spend their lives therein Page 20 Idlenesse the divels advantage Page 247 Ignorants killing themselves are not self-murderers Page 173 Ignorance Mans ignorance of Gods decree Page 204 Ignorance makes way for destruction Page 210 Ilnesse of self-murder unknowne incourages to it Page 208 Image of God defaced by self-murder Page 267 Imagination by meanes of imagination man suffers Page 164 Impatiency the cause of self-murder Page 164. 225 Impenitency a sin against the Gospell Page 72 Impertinent Doing things impertinent is mis-spending of life Page 19 Imployment The benefit of good imployment Page 314 Jmpostures of Magitians Page 202 Indifferent Of things indifferent how they become sinfull Page 152 Indirect bodily self-murder defined 84. How the same in some respects is a greater sin than direct self-murder 87. Of indirect self-murder of the body 91. Why the same is treated of in the first place Page 90 Of indirect self-murder by omission 91 Physically wrought ibid. How morally wrought 94. Of indirect self-murder by commission 109. By entring covenant and societie 118. By doing that which naturally kills the doer 121. By doing capitall crimes against humane lawes 121. By transgressing of Gods Lawes Page 122 The properties of indirect self-murderers Page 154 Indowments of man do condemne murder Page 283 Infectious Of presuming into infectious places or company Page 120 About infectious persons in some cases adventuring Page 141 Infidelity its causes and cure Page 72 Innocents suffering by some mistake Page 136 Insufficiency Afflictions insufficiency to cause a man to kill himselfe Page 228 Intention Of mans intention to kill himselfe Page 160 Intention onely makes not actions good Page 241 Invasion is to be resisted Page 17 Josephus his judgement and opposition against self-murder Page 284 Judgement perverted Page 192 How the judgement of the learned obtaines the force of a Law Page 194 How judgement abused is cause of spirituall phrensie Page 251 Justice Concerning Justice 34. and how self-murder is against it Page 263 K Killing Wilfull killing of ones selfe comprehends murder in it Page 47 Knowledge incourages Page 126 Of knowledge of the Scriptures the rules Page 199 Knowledge of a mans selfe needfull to cure his pride Page 227 L Law The transgression of Gods Lawes how dangerous Page 112 Sin against the Law of nature and of God to be avoided Page 150 151. Some Lawes cause error in judgement Page 192 What humane Lawes ought to be obeyed or not obeyed Page 194 Self-murder is against Gods Law and how Page 262 The Law of nature is to be observed Page 269 Lawes of
is borne by many Be observant and helpfull 2. How men are to order themselves in afflictions The second use or observation from the point is that people in distresse do fit themselves and so order their course and behaviour as is most pertinent and best becomming their present estate that they may not be overcome by it 1. First by their care to live by faith a Habak 2.4 and not by sense and that they may ride by the anchor of hope cast upward within the vaile b Heb. 6.19 2. Secondly by humbly submitting themselves under the mighty hand of God with passive obedience rather cutting our masts of self-will and pride by the board than to hazard being over-set by a high saile in the storme of troubles 3. Thirdly they should labour to possesse themselves in patience that they may stand fast and overcome by suffering 4. Fourthly they should endeavour to be chearefull under the crosse 5. Fiftly they should not be carefull of future events so long as they walke in a good course but commend themselves by prayer to God a Phil. 4.6 Mat. 6.25 and rest confidently upon him being imployed and taken up with meditation of the gratious promises and dealing of God towards those that depend upon him By neglect of which course the Devill prevailes much against people in that estate even sometimes to self-murder §. 18. Concerning anger and revenge The third generall motive of self-murder Anger and revenge The third generall motive of self-murder is the rage of Anger and the unsatiable desire of revenge which are most furious passioÌ„s that most spoile and are least subject to the command of reason or religion and can most hardly be supprest or kept within any due compasse which when they cannot ease themselves by vent upon others will reflect upon the subject wherein they are to destroy the same Kinds of it This anger and revenge is of two sorts 1. Against a mans selfe First that which is directly against a mans owne selfe and that is either for what he hath done or else for what he presently is Sometimes men fall into that degree of anger and revenge against themselves for what they are or have done or beene that nothing will content them Propter peccata admissa For sinnes done but murdring of themselves as for some hainous crime or flagitious course of life whereby they finde themselves upon sight and sense hereof subjected either to importable shame and punishment or to intolerable griefe of conscience as those that are guilty of some horrible capitall crimes done against their consciences such as wilfull murder spitefull blasphemie against God and the like in regard of the former wee see how Indas hanged himselfe and the more secret that such crimes have beene kept and secure from the stroke of humane justice the more is man armed and bent with self-murder to destroy himselfe whom divine justice will not suffer to live Viciousnesse of nature and wicked motions Againe for the present when a man labours in a continuall conflict against the execrable viciousnesse of his nature and against the horrible motions of his minde and inclinations of his heart with much uncomfortable molestation and trouble without hope of overcomming the same finding the same more and more to prevaile against him so that hee concludes that if he doe live hee shall be quite overcome by it and caried headlong to all evill to his greater shame and eternall ruine which that hee may prevent or bee revenged upon his wretched flesh and corruption out of his furious zeale he by the instigation of Satan murders himselfe and so upon pretence of destroying sinne hee destroyes himselfe in and by the most horrible sinne of self-murder He esie Touching this killing of a mans selfe in griefe and revenge for his sinnes committed Alphonsus à Castro adversus haereses de Martyrio haeresi secunda Haeresis est quae docet cos quise pro peccatointerimunt delore Martyres numupari pro cò quod puâ—unâ—in se quod dolent commisesse sayes it is an heresie which teaches that those that kill themselves for their sinne ought to be called Martyres because they doe punish in themselves that for which they grieve that they have committed it The Author of which heresie he sayes was Petilian the Donatist against whom St. Augustine wrote which name of heresie it may well brooke if we consider the damnable danger of it specially accompanied with obstinacy in opinion against the judgement and advice of the Church Than to bee counted an heretick nothing was more odious because the same excludes a man both from the Communion and priviledges of the Church on earth and also from the fruition of glory in Heaven to which for punishment self-murder is equivalent and if in any case it bee held obstinately in opinion to bee lawfull it is directly and formally an heresie because the contrary is according to truth determined by the Church as a point concerning salvation Twofold revenge upon oxes selfe for sinne There is a twofold revenge upon ones self for sin a good and a bad 1. Good In three things The good is that whereof the Apostle speakes 2 Cor. 7.11 Behold what revenge which flowes from griefe for offending God and consists in three things 1. Mortifying humiliation First godly revenge upon ones selfe for their sinnes is in our chastising of our selves and afflicting of our soules before God in penitent manner in mortifying humiliation subduing our bodies by discipline abstinence c. whereby through Christ both the guilt and love of sinne is extinguished in us and also the power of the corruption of it is killed 2. Curbing our lusts Secondly it is in the restraining and curbing of our owne lusts and wills to subdue them wholly to the will of God which cannot bee done without both much trouble and paines and dislike to the old man of nature Cutting off the meanes of sin And also it is in the stinting or depriving of our selves of the use of those things by which the flesh hath or doth take occasion to sin against God as delights and pleasures or things above necessity when wee abuse them which is as to pluck out the right eye or to cut off the right hand 3. Strictnesse Thirdly it is in a more strict tasking of our selves to religious observances to holy duties and good life and to opportunities and offices of doing good to ourselves and others so cutting our selves short of that liberty whereby wee are apt to breake out to dishonour God and so bringing our selves under the yoake of more severe spirituall subjection and discipline to God wee shall subdue and mortifie our old man of sinne in which three points lyes the revenge here allowed The second kind of revenge upon ones self Bad. The second kind of revenge upon ones selfe for sinne is that