deuices No no vnlesse this our garment be dipt in the bloud of Christ and so made white it will euer appeare defiled A fift obiection They tell vs that eternall life is called a reward great is your reward in Heauen Mat. 5.12 As before in answering their third obiection I sayd that not euery promise proueth that which is giuen to be merited by the worke so heere I doe auerre How life eternall is called a reward that the calling of eternall life a reward doth not euict that it is giuen in regard of the worthinesse of the worke If you demand why it is then called a reward I answere It pleaseth God not only to acquaint vs with his will that we may know what is good and what is euil but also by many arguments sometime of his power sometime of his Iustice sometime of his goodnesse to moue his people to obedience To them therefore that with more alacritie Gal. 6.10 While we haue time to do good vnto all men as the Apostle exhorteth he telleth vs that our labour shall not be without reward The like argument doth the Apostle vse to the Corinthians 1. Co. 15.58 Therefore my beloued brethren be yee stedfast vnmoueable abundant alwayes in the worke of the Lord knowing that your labour is not in vaine in the Lord. But eternall life is called a reward Be it so It is also called a Kingdome Mat. 25.34 and that prepared for Gods seruants from the beginning of the world If prepared so long since for them then not bestowed for the worthinesse of their worke If a Kingdome it is an inheritance that is giuen by grace for we are sonnes by adoption heires of God and heires annexed with Christ. Or else by election we haue this inheritance Rom. 8.17 For no man is elected to a Kengdome in regard of his merits especially so long before hee can doe any thing for it Coloss 3.24 The Apostle calleth it a reward of inheritance Ye shall receiue a reward of inheritance sayth he Howsoeuer therefore it is called sometime a reward yet is it a reward that is promised Gal. 3.29 Bel. de Iustific l. 5. c. 18. and therefore Saint Paul sayth Wee are heires by promise And therefore Bellarmine himselfe confesseth that remota promissione non tenetur Deus acceptare opus nostrum ad mercedem taking away the promise God is not bound to accept our worke to reward it Now if a father promise his sonne being yet but a childe both in strength and discretion and such children are we in heauenly matters a great reward if hee doe some small matter at his appointment yet such as hee knoweth passeth eyther his abilitie or skill whether shall we say when this recompence is giuen that it is of promise or of dutie The sonne indeuoureth as well as he can to doe it and with much adoe with continuall helpe of his father he doth it at length in some sort I hope no man will say his worke deserued it For the Father promised much for a small matter hee helpeth his sonne to doe it and beareth in the end with many wants euen so God for the little that wee can doe promiseth much and that wee doe hath many imperfections too Can wee then thinke of merit Ber in Cant. Serm. â—7 No no the Spouse of Christ doth then shew her selfe to be more full of grace when she ascribeth all to grace knowing her part is first and last Luk. 17.7 But against the meriting of the reward that parable in S. Luke is most plaine A seruant ploweth or doth any other worke in the field when hee commeth home his Master biddeth him not sit downe but willeth him to dresse meat and giue himselfe and wait and serue him teaching vs that we haue no time to bestow otherwise then vpon our Masters worke Ambros in Luke 17. Theopilact in Luk. 17. We must alwayes while wee liue be doing saith Ambrose This Parable sheweth saith Theophilact that a man must not be proud of any good worke no neyther yet in the fulfilling of all the Commandements For the seruant must doe what his Master commandeth neither must hee ascribe it to himselfe as a good worke Ambros in Luk. 7. Dionis Carthus in Luk. 17. And Ambrose gathereth the same lesson too Let no man glory of workes for we owe our seruice to the Lord. So doth the Carthusian also The seruant is tyed to this and after his worke in the field he must labour in the house that he may daily be labouring It being thus let vs consider of the conclusion of the Parable So likewise ye Luk. 17.10 when you haue done all things which were commanded you say We are vnprofitable seruants we haue done that was our dutie to doe Hieron ad Ctesiphontem Theophil in Luk. 17. No merit in this worke If that seruant were vnprofitable that did all sayth Hierom What shall we say of him that could not doe it Theophilact also in like manner If when we haue done all the Commandements yet wee haue no cause to thinke well of our doing how greatly doe we sinne when not doing the greatest part of Gods Commandements yet we are proud of our doing The Carthusian likewise If they must account themselues vnprofitable seruants who haue fulfilled all the Commandements what shall we doe who in so many things transgresse and so vnperfectly perchance keepe that we keepe that as the Prophet Esai sayth all our righteousnesse is like a filthy clout But Bellarmine telleth vs De Iustific lib. 5. cap. 5. Bernard de tripl custodia Bernard de precepto dispensatione that Christ so concludeth to teach humilitie I answere with Bernard Sanè propter humilitatem sed numquid contra veritatem True indeed for humility but is it against verity He also elsewhere thus speaketh to that seruant You are free from duty but not glorious by merit You haue escaped punishment but haue not gotten the crowne The Parable teacheth vs that all wee can doe is dutie therefore wee may not thinke of merit because whatsoeuer wee are able to performe at any time in any place by any meanes we owe all that seruice to God Lastly I come to those words of Iames in shew as contrarie to Saint Paul as can be yet because they both had one teacher both were guided in writing by one Spirit and were both of one faith and Religion we are sure both teach one Doctrine Rom. 3.28 Iam. 2.24 What Iustification is by workes Iude 4. Aug lib. 83. quaest 76. de fide operibus cap. 14. And yet Paul sayth We are iustified by faith without workes Iames sayth Wee are iustified by workes and not by faith only and both these are most true For if we speake of the cause of Iustification then must wee hearken to Saint Paul who teacheth that is by faith without workes But because many turning the grace of God
It was impossible for the Law in as much as it was weake Rom. 8.2.3 because of the flesh to free vs from the Law of sinne or of death If then our obedience be so vnperfit can wee hope to finde quietnesse in our consciences and peace with GOD when wee shall stand before him who because he is infinite in wisedome seeth all things bee they done neuer so secretly or in the darke yea hee heareth what we whisper in the eare and knoweth the most secret thoughts of the heart and because he is iust will punish transgressors and in that he is Almightie is able to take vengeance No no our best workes can in this case giue vs no securitie Then by inherent righteousnesse we haue not peace with God But that knowing our selues to bee acquited of our sinnes wee haue peace with GOD and in that sence wee take this word of iustifying it is most plaine Sinne hindreth our peace with God For first the thing that hindreth this our peace is sinne sinne I say that naughtie and noysome neighbour euen the worst neighbour that any man can dwell with It neuer resteth but eyther by faire meanes or foule it intiseth to consent to it Rom. 7.23 For what else is that Law that Paul did see in his mēbers rebelling against the Law of his mind and leading him captiue vnto the law of sinne which was in his members And when it hath preuailed Psal 51.3 it is euer before vs as a seruant of God complaineth neither will it let vs take any rest Gen. 4.7 it lyeth at the doore of our conscience alwaies accusing and bawling against vs. And marke I pray you what sowre fruit this bitter roote yeeldeth It maketh a breach betweene God and vs as the Prophet Esay telleth Gods people in his dayes Esa 59.2 Your sinnes haue separated betweene you and your God and your iniquities haue hidden his face from you that hee will not heare And by that meanes wee are depriued of many blessings which GOD vseth to bestow vpon his seruants as another of the Prophets also saith to the Iewes Ier. 5.25 Your iniquities haue turned away these things speaking of raine in due season and the appointed time of haruest and your sinnes haue hindered good things from you Leuit. 26. Deut. 8. And yet by sinne wee haue greater hurt then this For God denounceth many plagues against his people if they transgresse which also that he can powre vpon the inhabitants of the earth when in his iust iudgement hee will execute the same the drowning of the World in that generall deluge and the casting of fire and brimstone from Heauen vpon those wicked Cities of the plaine and the rooting out of that Nation which he did chuse to serue him doth sufficiently teach vs. Vntill then sinne so odious to GOD so grieuous vnto men bee taken away it is impossible there should be any true quietnesse or peace vnto men For GOD often telleth his people howsoeuer they would flatter themselues in their owne strength or in the friendship of their confederates or in their externall ceremonies and seruice of GOD in outward shew That there is no peace to the wicked Esa 48.22 Esa 50.11 Psal 14.5 1. Thess 5. ◠but they shall lye downe in sorrow and feare where no feare is because they haue promised to themselues peace and safetie without this atonement with God Out of all which it doth appeare that if wee will haue peace with God we must first haue sinne this cumbersome neighbour remoued which altogether hindereth this reconciliation whereby we haue quietnesse of consciences Therefore the Apostle telleth vs Rom. 3.24.25 that Wee are iustified freely by Gods grace through the redemption that is in Christ Iesus whom God hath set forth to bee a reconciliation through faith in his bloud Reconciliation with God by forgiuenesse of sinne Act. 13.38 Ephes 1.7 to declare his righteousnesse by the forgiuenesse of sinnes that are past through the patience of God And the same Apostle preaching at Antioch teacheth this Iustification in these words Men brethren through this man is preached vnto you forgiuenesse of sinnes as also elsewhere By Christ we haue redemption through his bloud the forgiuenesse of sinnes according to his rich grace Which great and inestimable benefit whoso feeleth hath to his vnspeakeable comfort a most sweet tast of that blessednes which the Apostle out of the Prophet Dauid mentioneth Blessed are they whose iniquities are forgiuen Ps 32.1 2. Rom. 4.7 S. Aug. de verb. Dom. Serm. 61. Hieron in Rom. 4. or whose sinnes are couered Blessed is the man to whom the Lord imputeth not sinne Fide viuenti sayth Saint Augustine soluuntur peccata He who liueth by faith hath his sinnes forgiuen him And Saint Hierome hauing written thus Per solam fidem iustificat Deus God by faith only doth iustifie doth after shew how this iustification is and in what manner Proposuit per solam fidem peccata dimittere He purposed to forgiue sinnes by faith only And thus by forgiuenesse of sinnes the cause of this dangerous iarre betweene GOD and vs being taken away we haue boldnesse to cal him Father and to stand before him pleading not guiltie But God gaue a Law to his people Exo. 23.15 Good workes That none should appeare before the Lord emptie So that being now freed from sinne yet must we be fraught and loden with holinesse and righteousnesse Well therefore doth Saint Peter out of the Psalme conioyne these two precepts Eschew euill doe good Psa 34.14 1. Pet. 3.11 But where shall this goodnesse be had Or how shall wee get any thing that may bee acceptable to God Our light is but darkenesse our righteousnesse but as stained clothes And when we haue indeuoured our selues as much as we are able to serue the Lord yet shall we find many wants much imperfection It is therefore good we doe as did Bernard who of himselfe thus writeth Ber. in Cantic ser 61. Christ alone supplyeth all our wants Ego vero fidenter quod ex me mihi deest vsurpo mihi ex visceribus Domini quia misericordia affluunt nec desunt foramina per quae effluant I sayth Bernard doe boldly take out of the bowels of the Lord that which I want of mine owne because they abound with mercie neyther want they holes by which they may gush out And after he addeth what holes these are Foderunt manus cius pedes eius latusque lancea forauerunt per has rimas licet mihi sugere mel de petra oleumque de saxo durissimo id est gustare videre quà m suauis est Dominus Psal 21.16 They haue pierced mine hands and my feet and haue opened my side with a speare and by these rifts I may sucke hony out of the rocke and oyle out of the hardest stone that is I may taste and see how sweet the Lord
perfection of righteousnesse Another obiection they haue out of such testimonies as teach that God shall reward euery man according to his worke Psal 62.12 Mat. 16.27 Rom. 2.6 Reue. 22.12 Bell. de Iustific l. 5. c. 2 Aug. Confess l. 9. c. 13 How the godly are rewarded according to workes Of which sort the Scripture affordeth vs diuers And out of those wordes Bellarmine draweth this Doctrine Secundum opera sua id est vt opera merentur According to his workes that is as his workes deserue I might answer him with that golden saying of Saint Augustine Vae hominum vitae etiam ladabili si remota misericordia discutias eam Woe to the life of man that is commendable if thou Lord setting mercie aside doe sift the same But that the absurditie of his assertion may the rather appeare it is needfull that if the reward be giuen according to the merit of the worke there should bee some equalitie of proportion betweene the worke and the reward it meriteth But what proportion can there be betweene workes so vnperfect as before I haue shewed ours to bee and that eternall glorie which is so great and excellent a reward that the Apostle describeth it in these wordes The things which eye hath not seene 1. Cor. 2.9 eare hath not heard neyther can enter into the heart of man God hath prepared for them that loue him Howsoeuer therefore Bellarmine dareth affirme Bell. de Justific lib. 5. cap. 18. That non requiritur absoluta aequaelitas inter meritum praemium a perfit equalitie is not requisite betweene merit and the reward which thing he indeed barely affirmeth without any one testimonie of Scripture or sentence of Fathers yet dare I boldly pronounce that if any man saith that eternall life is giuen as workes deserue and yet that there is no proportion betweene eternall life and the worke hee speaketh most absurdly making merit no merit and deseruing no deseruing whereas in all reason and learning how much a worke wanteth of the equalitie with the reward which is to be giuen for doing it so much it lacketh of meriting that reward Very well therefore S. Bernard after he hath shewed That mens merits are not such Bern. Serm. 1. de Annunt that eternall life is of right due to them or that God should doe wrong if he so giue it not because euen our merits are Gods gifts and therefore we are rather bound to God for them then he to vs asketh this question Quid sunt merita omnia ad tantam gloriam What are all merits to so great glory As if he had said There is no proportion no equalitie This then which Bellarmine heerein hath taught is as absurd as if a man should affirme that hee doth not sell twelue penny-worth of ware or doe twelue penny-worth of worke must be deemed to haue truly deserued twelue pence I trow Bellarmine would not well like of such penny-worthes Not as workes merit One other argument I will produce which plainely enough confuteth that which Bellarmine sayth that According to the worke must be expounded as the worke meriteth Consider of the Parable of the Labourers in the Vineyard Mat. 20.1.3.5.6 whereof some went to their labour at the dawning of the day others at the third houre but some were not called to worke before the sixt or ninth houres yea other about Sunne-setting that is at the eleuenth houre The Master of the Vineyard when euen was come sent for the Labourers and as hee promised to the first paid to euerie one a pennie But they who came first 12. pleaded that they had borne the burden and heat of the day and therefore thought as our Papists doe they deserued more then the rest But the master of the Vineyard answered they had their due and what hee promised if hee gaue other more that hindred not them Now I would that our Romish Catholikes would answere truly to this question If paiment should haue beene made according to the merit of the worke who deserued most I suppose they will answere for otherwise they cannot truly answere that they who came first to their labour deserued best payment Yet wee see the last had as much as they Therefore it is plaine payment was not made to them nor shal be to vs as our worke meriteth but according to promise For euerie one had his pennie Hill in Mat. Can. Merces quidem nulla est ex dono quia debetur ex opere sed gratuitam Deus omnibus ex fidei iustificatione donauit 20. There is no wages of gift sayth Hilarie for it is due by the worke but God hath giuen a free reward vnto all by Iustification of faith The penny in the Gospell Prosper de vocat Gent. lib. c. 17. Thereby prouing that this penny was not as wages but a free reward not for the worke but giuen in promise Notably therefore sayth Prosper who wrote about that time Saint Augustine did who gathereth out of this parable Operarios accepisse donum gratiae non mercedem operis that these workemen receiued a gift of grace not a reward or wages for their worke But Bellarmine contending for merits would faine remoue this blocke out of the way Hee feareth lest some of his friends stumbling thereon should reele from the Romish Church He therefore out of Augustine and others telleth vs that denarius diurnus Bell. de Iustific li. 3. c. 16 li. 5. cap. 6. this penny for the day worke is aequalitas aeternitatis non gloriae equaelitie of eternitie not of glorie But our controuersie is not what this penny is but in what respect it is giuen whether for the worthinesse of the worke or not If he say for the merit of the worke the Parable is against his opinion therein If he say it is of promise as elsewhere he seemeth to affirme wee haue that we seeke Bell. de Iufic l. 5. c. 19. Wee see saith he the whole penny giuen to them who had not laboured the whole day and the Lord himselfe sheweth in these words I will giue to him as to thee c. that this was done not of dutie but of liberalitie Heere our aduersary confesseth the reward not to be as the labour merited Therefore to omit that needlesse question what this pennie is let vs heere remember that it is not giuen for the worthines of the worke For Bellarmines answere seemeth to mee much like as if I aske which way I may goe to London and he answere me it is a faire Citie Seeing then the reward is of mercie and not of merit let not vs by ascribing that to our workes which is giuen freely in grace be vnthankefull vnto him who so loued vs that he dyed for vs as Saint Hierom exhorteth vs yeelding this reason Ierom vpon Gal. 2. Abiecta est gratia si mihi sola non sufficit Grace is but cast away if it only suffice me