to their authority and the exercise of it over their Brethren CHAP. XXI Of Religious Worship and the Sabbath Day THE light of Nature sheweth that there is a God who hath Lordship and soveraignty over all is good and doth good unto all and is therefore to be feared loved praised called upon trusted in and served with all the heart with all the soul and with all the might a Ro 1.20 Act 17 14 Psa 119.68 Jer 7.10 Psal 31.23 Psal 18.3 Ro 10.12 Psal 62.8 Josh 24.14 Mar 12.33 But the acceptable way of worshiping the true God is instituted by himself so limitted by his own revealed wil that he may not be Worshiped according to the imaginations and devises of men or the suggestions of Satan under any visible representation or any other way not prescribed in holy Scripture b Deu 12.32 Mat 15.9 Acts 17.25 Mat 4.9.10 Deut 4.15 to 20. Exod 20.4 5 6. Col 2.23 II. Religious Worship is to be given to God the Father Son and Holy Ghost and to him alone c Mat. 4.10 with John 5.23 and 2 Cor 13.14 not to Angels Saints or any other creature d Col 2.18 Rev 19.10 Rom 1.25 and since the fall not without a Mediatour nor in the mediation of any other then of Christ alone e Joh 14.6 1 Tim. 2.5 Eph 2.18 Col 3.17 III. Prayer with thanksgiving being one special part of Religious worship f Phil 4.16 't is by God required of all men g Psa 85.2 and that it may be accepted it is to be made in the name of the Son h John 14.13 14. 1 Pet 2.5 by the help of his Spirit i Ro 8.26 according to his will k 1 Joh 5.4 with understanding reverence humility fervency faith love and perseverance l Psa 47.7 Eccl 5.12 Heb 12.28 Gen 18.27 Jam 5.16 Jam 1.6 7 Mar 11.24 Mat 6.12 14 15. Col 4.2 Eph 6.18 and if vocal in a known tongue m Cor 14.14 IV. Prayer is to be made for things lawful n Joh 5.14 and for all sorts of men living or that shall live hereafter o 1 Tim 1.1 2. Joh 17.20 2 Sam 7.29 Rut 4.12 but nor for the dead p 2 Sam 12.21 22 23. with Luke 16.25.26 Rev 14.13 nor for those of whom it may be known that they have sinned the sin unto death q 1 Joh 5.5 V. The reading of the Scriptures with godly fear r Act 15.21 Rev 1.3 the sound preaching Å¿ 2 Tim 4.2 and conscionable hearing of the Word in obedience unto God with understanding faith and reverence t Jam 1.22 Acts 10.33 Mat 13.10 Heb 4.2 Isa 66.2 singing of Psalms with grace in the heart u Col 3.16 Eph 5.19 Jam 5.13 as also the due administration and worthy receiving of the Sacraments instituted by Christ are all parts of the ordinary Riligious Worship of God w Mat 28.19 1 Cor. 11 23 to 29. Acts 2 12. beside Religious Oaths x Deut 6.13 with Neh 10.29 Vows y Isa 19.21 with Eccles 5.4 5. Solemn Fastings z Joel 2.12 Esther 4.16 Matth 9.15 1 Cor 7.5 and Thanksgivings upon special occasions a Psal 107. throughout Esth 9.12 which are in their several times and seasons to be used in an holy and religious manner b Heb 12.28 VI. Neither prayer nor any other part of Religious Worship is now under the Gospel either tyed unto or made more acceptable by any place in which it is performed or towards which it is directed e Joh 4.21 but God is to be Worshiped every-where d Mal 1.11 1 Tim 2.8 in Spirit and in Truth e Joh 4 23 24. as in private Families f Jer 10.25 Deu. 6.6.7 Job 1.5 2 Sam 6.18 20. 1 Pet 3.7 Acts 10 2. daily g Mat. 6.11 and in secret each one by himself h Mat 6.6 Eph 6.18 so more solemnly in the publick Assemblies which are not carelessly or wilfully to be neglected or forsaken when God by his word or providence calleth thereunto i Is 56.6.7 Heb 10.25 Pro. 1 20.21 24. Acts 13.24 Luk 4.16 Acts 2.42 VII As it is the Law of Nature that in general a due proportion of time be set apart for the Worshiping of God so in his Word by a positive Moral and perpetual Commandment binding all men in all Ages he hath particularly appointed one day in seven for a sabbath to be kept holy unto him k Exo 20.8.10.11 Isa 56.2 4 5 6 7. which from the beginning of the World to the resurrection of Christ was the last Day of the week and from the resurrection of Christ was changed into the first day of the week l Gen 2.2.3 1 Cor 16.1 2. Acts 20.7 which in Scripture is called the Lord's Day m Rev 1.10 and it to be continued to the end of the World as the Christian Sabbath n Exod 20.8 10. with Mat 5.17.18 VIII This Sabbath is then kept holy unto the Lord when men after a due preparing of their hearts and ordering of their common affaires before hand do not onely observe an holy rest all the Day from their own works words and thoughts about their worldly imployment and recreations o Ex 20.8 Exod 16.23 25 26 29.30 Exod 31.15 16 17. Isa 58.13 Neh 13.15 16 17 18 19 21 22. but also are taken up the whole time in the publick and private exercises of his Worship and in the duties of necessity and mercy p Isa 58.13 Mat 12.1 to 13. CHAP. XXI Of Religious Worship and of the Sabboth Day examined IN the foregoing Chapters you gave us a scantling of your faith and here you exhibite a view of your piety or Religion but as your faith was many wayes unsound so your Religion for the greatest part will prove a will worship and both it and the time you allot thereunto are so ungrounded that we can neither Sabbatize in your worship nor worship your sabboth with you You have here touched many things that concern that worship as the object the rule the part or subject with which the supposed matter the Place and time of it after your manner but we cannot but wonder at four things first your strange omissions secondly some truths which break from you at unawares contradicting what you said before thirdly your gross mistakes and lastly your confident affirming of things most false and destitute of foundation For the first it is no small matter of wonderment to us that you neither shew us what the worship of God is nor of what latitude in the general nor how many kinds there be of it nor wherein Gods principal eternal and saving worship lieth especially since the holy Scriptures are so clear in all the four which set forth unto us First that to worship God is all one as to fear him serve him and glorifie him Mat. 4.10 It
him into life but there was no prescript or set form of outward worship enjoyned to the sons of men till the dayes of Moses nor then to any others but the Israelites and that when they were mad upon outward things witness their making of the golden Calf True it is That the holy Prophets and Saints of the primitive Church shortly after the Apostles dayes seeing that the people then were grown outwardly minded also did for unity and edification sake bring in a form of Divine Service called the Liturgy which was both pious and very profitable and how far it may oblige us to observe it we will not here dispute But the forms of worship that now are in the reformed Churches are but prudential and not Jure divino Secondly whereas you make thanksgiving and prayer to be a part of Gods set solemn primary and prescript worship We grant that thansgiving shall be a part of Gods everlasting worship in Heaven but prayer with the reading of the holy Scriptures sound preaching and conscionable hearing of the word the holy administration and receiving of the Sacraments the singing of Psalms extraordinary fasts oaths vows c. all which you make parts of Divine worship are onely holy duties and means appointed by the Lord for the begetting and edifying of his Church but no parts of any set or prescript worship as you imagine yet are they piously and often to be used Thirdly you are mistaken not onely in the matter but in the time which is by you set a part thereunto that being left to the care piety prudence and convenience of the Churches Heb. 10.25 Acts 20.7.8 1 Cor. 5 4. 1 Cor. 11.18 20. Nor doth the fourth Commandment as it is positive bind any but the Israelites nor was the seventh day or the last day of the week to be kept as a Sabboth from the creation till the resurrection of Christ For that which is spoken Gen. 2.3 That God blessed the seventh day and hallowed it may be two wayes understood First by way of Anticipation a thing usual in the Scriptures Exod. 18.33 34 35. Gen. 1.27 Or Secondly it may be spoken of Christ in whom the Father hath rested from all his works and whom he hath blessed and sanctified for ever Neither was that day from the resurrection of Christ changed into the first day of the week by Christ or his Apostles as you affirm His arising upon that day or his appearing to his Disciples upon or shortly after that day without a Commandment to observe it do not any way enforce the observation of it The two places to which you refer us carry also little force with them for that in the Acts Chap. 20.7 We say that the occasion of that meeting was extraordinary to wit Paul being ready to depart the next day and not likely to see them any more sent for them and their meeting was not till the first day of the week was ended for it was in the night that they met And the other place 1 Cor. 16.1 2. not speaking of a publick contribution to be made upon the first day of the week but of a private laying a part of some money for such publike uses rather proves that day to be a working day when the Saints were to begin their next weeks work then an holy day Nor finally is it clear that this day is called the Lords Day and muchless that it was instituted for a perpetual holy day or Christian Sabbath for that place Revel 1.10 seems not to speak of any outward time for when the Prophets and Apostles purpose to intimate the time when they received the word of the Lord they never omit the yeer or moneth as John doth so that if he here would hiâ—t the time it may rather seem he speaks of the annual day of Christs resurrection whose mouth was then well known then of the weekly day But there is an inward and spiritual day of the Lord and so a true and spiritual Lords Day which the Saints hoped for and this as it seems was now appeared unto John Heb. 10.25 But exhorting one another and so much the rather as you see the day approaching 1 Cor. 1.7 8. So that you come behinde in no gift waiting for the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ who shall confirm you unto the end that ye may be blameless in the day of our Lord Jesus Christ 2 Pet. 1.19 Vntill the day dawn and the day Star arise in your hearts of which coming of his as Christ had given his promise to all his disciples Joh. 14.18 I will not leave you Orphans I will come again unto you So he in special intimates that John should live to see the same and share therein John 21.22 Jesus speaking of John saith thus to Peur If I will that he shall tarry till I come what is that to thee which coming of Christs can be no other then that his spiritual coming promised John 14.21 25. And indeed those latter words Rev. 1.10 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 in the Lords day seem to expound the former words I was in the spirit and to declare what measure and degree of the spirit he had then attained when he received that revelation Howsoever most certain it is that the observation of our Lords Day was first taken up by the voluntary and prudential act of the Primitive Churches and afterwards that day with Wednesday and Friday were commanded to be dayes of holy Assemblies by Constantine the great and other holy Emperors as Ecclesiastical Hystories testifie with one consent and the greatest part of modern writers confess So that your propositions in the seventh Section which we have denyed are very rash and bold assertions some whereof are also very injurious for how can those countreys which have either a perpetual day or a perpetual night for many moneths together every yeer punctually observe such an outward Sabboth as you impose We grant that the fourth Commandement is moral as well as the rest but the morality of it lyeth not in appointing one day in seven for a publike outward worship nor was it appointed for that end by Moses though after he returns from Babylon in part so used but rather for a figurative rest but in resting from our own finful thoughts words and works through the help of Christ in keeping Gods Judgements and Commandements through his assistance and in seeking our eternal sanctification life and rest in him as Clemens Alexandrinus Hieronym and almost all the ancients with the best of our modern writers unanimously agree Christ saith that he Gave the Sabboth to be a sign that he is the Lord that Sanctifieth us Exod. 31.13 Ezek. 20.12 and Saint Paul saith That not only the other holy dayes but even the Sabboth were a shadow in the old Testament and the body of them is in Christ Col. 2.16 yea that the Sabboth which is spoken of Esai 58.13 is Christ whom we must not trample under foot by
speaking our own words thinking our own thoughts and doing our own pleasure as the said Fathers expound the place In your last Section as your Sabboth it self so your sanctification of it is an humane devise any day may be so sanctified But for a conclusion of this Chapter we offer five things to your better consideration First whether Gods will is since changed who at the first created man after his own Image and established him in all righteousness that he might worship him therein Secondly whether he would be worshipped at our hands one day in seven or all the dayes of our lives See Luk. 1 71 75. before cited Rev. 7.15 Therefore are they before the throne of God and serve him day and night in his Temple and he that sitteth upon the throne shall dwell among them Thirdly whether the thoughts words and works which are called our own and from which we are commanded to rest that we may sanctifie the Lords Sabbath be those which are necessarily employed about the honest duties of our lawful callings or our sinful thoughts words and actions See Isaiah 55.7 Let the wicked man forsake his way and the unrighteous man his thoughts Isaiah 58.6 7 8. Their works are works of Iniquity and the act of violence is in their hands their feet run to evil and they make hast to shed innocent blood their thoughts are thoughts of iniquity wasting and destruction are in their paths Jer. 3.5 Behold thou hast spoken and done evil things as thou couldest Fourthly whether the Lord would rather have an outward day or time which is one of the most transient and fluxible things of this world or his everlasting light life and rest Christ Jesus honored by us See Psal 97.7 Worship him all yee Gods Mat. 17.5 And behold a voice out of the cloud which said this is my beloved Son in whom I am well pleased hear ye him Joh. 5.23 That all men should honor the Son as they honor the father Isa 58.13 And shall honor him where the Sabboth mentioned in the beginning of the verse is turned into a person the person of the Lord Jesus Christ who by our sinning against him is troden or trampled under foot Heb. 10.29 and therefore it is not without cause that we are here Isa 58. commanded to turn or keep our feet from the Sabboth that is from trampling upon Christ Fifthly whether we shall attain those high things promised Isa 58.14 to wit to be fed with the heritage of Jacob our Father c. by forbearing the works of our lawful callings one day in seven or by abstaining and resting through the help of Christ from our own wicked thoughts words and works all the dayes of our life that so we may keep Gods judgements and commandments which are his lesser Sabboths Isaiah 56.2 and finde all righteousness rest and life in Christ the great Sabboth and Lords Day or Day of the Lord in his spirituall comming Yea we would entreat you to examine your selves impartially in or about those six things ensuing First whether you do not worship God in vain here teaching for doctrines the precepts of men Matthew 15.9 for the Lord hath neither instituted these duties for a set and solemn outward worship which you make the several parts of his outward worship nor hath he appointed any other worship but the serving him in spirit and in truth John 4.23 24. And although the duties you insist upon are appointed by him as helps and furtherances to the attaining of that grace whereby we may so worship God and may in that sense pass for a secondary worship yet are they not limitted by him to any set time but rather are lest to the Churches convenience and care to her piety and prudence Secondly whether you do not with the prodigall feed your selves and others upon huskes while you rely thus upon the outward Sabboths which are shels and shadows Galatians 4 9 10 11. But now after yea have known God or rather are known of God how turn ye again to the weak and beggarly elements whereunto ye desire again to be in bondage ye observe dayes and moneths and yeers I am aâ—raid I have bestowed upon you labour in vaine If ye fay that ye keep not the Jewish Sabboth but have turned that into the Lords Day to be Rept after the same manner Then in the third place may it not be said unto you by the Lord as it is Isaiah 1.12 When ye come to appear before me who hath required these things at your bands c. Yea fourthly is it not some kinde of superstition and Idolatry against the second Commandement when God hath removed a ceremonial and figurative worship for you now of your own heads and in his name to set up another solemn and prescript outward worship as if God were a visible and corporeall God or one that took more delight that men should speak and hear discourses concerning his everlasting righteousness then to be worshipped therein See Isaiah 38.1 2 3 4 c. See Isaiah 28.1 2 3. Yea fifthly when God hath abolished one shadow or Image to wit his seventh dayes Sabboth which as was said before was not at the first instituted for a day of worship but a figurative day of rest for you to make another like it and as from God to set it in its stead to be honoured without any warrant or command from him what is this but to set up 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 an image like the former and a very Idol of your own brain or at the best with Jeroboam to offer unto the Lord on that day which ye have devised of your own heart 1 Kings 10.33 Not but that this day or any other may be lawfully and profitably spent in such holy duties as you speak of being observed as an ordinance of the Church or the civil Magistrate so it be not imposed upon men as a Commandement of the Lords as you obtrude it For therein you with the Judayzing zealots Acts 15.10 would put a yâ—ke upon the neck of the Disciples which neither we nor our fathers were able to bear And there in so doing how far you tempt God your selves may advisedly confider Lastly Wherein doth your righteousnesse exceed the righteousnesse of the Scribes and Pharisees Mat. 5.20 for they not only kept the outward Sabboth of the fourth commandment most severely but made long prayers fasted often preached diligently administred the Sacraments yea compassed Sea and land to make a Proselite or convert to their Religion Matthew 12.1 2 3. Luke 18.10 11 12. Mat. thew 23.1 2 3. CHAP. XXII Of Lawful Oaths and Vows ALawful oath is a part of Religious worship a Deu 10.20 where in upon just occasion the person swearing solemnly calleth God to witness what he asserteth or promiseth and to judge him according to the truth or falshood of what he sweareth b Exod 20.7 Lev 19.12 1 Cor. 1 13. 2 Chr 6.22 23.
second Section to wit to Elders and Governours called of God but not of man alone but that remitting and retaining of sins is both ministerial under the Lord Jesus and principally placed in the Church representative or the Superiours and Elders acted by Gods spirit and both fitted and called to that high office Mathew 16.19 Mathew 18.17 18. John 20.20 21.22 In your third Section you lay down good grounds why there should bee Ecclesâ—astical or spiritual censures in use and therein you seem to lay no small or weak foundation of reducing the true Saints now dispersed into congregations under spiritual able and faithful Overseers and those under some superintendent chosen of God of which some may be found if well sought out Your fourth and last Section by Officers right Overseers and Governours such as we have described being understood we willingly imbrace with this caution That you will with St. Jude verse 23. rather pull men out of the fire then persecute them with a faggot for difference of Judgement CHAP. XXXI Of Synods and Councels FOR the better Government and edification of the Church there ought to be such assemblies as are commonly called Synods or Councels a Acts 15.2 4 6. II. As Magistrates may lawfully call a Synod of Ministers and other fit persons to consult and advise with about matters of Religion b Isa 49.23 1 Tim 2.1 1. 2 Cro 19.8 9 10. 2 Chro 29.30 chapt Mat 2.4.5 Pro 11.14 so if Magistrates be open enemies to the Church the ministers of Christ of themselves by vertue of their Office or they with other fit persons upon delegation from their Churches may meet together in such assemblies c Acts 15.2 4 22 23 25. III. It belongeth to Synods and Counâ—els ministerially to determine controversies of Faith and cases of conscience to set down rules and directions for the better ordering of the publick worship of God and government of his Church to receive complaints in cases of male administration and authoritativly to determine the same which decrees and determinations if consonant to the word of God are to be received with reverence and submission not onely for their agreement with the word but also for the power whereby they are made as being an Ordinance of God appointed thereunto in his word d Acts 15.15 19 24 27 28 29 30 31. Acts 6 4. Matth 18 17 18 19 20 IV. All Synods or Councels since the Apostles dayes whether general or particular may erre and many have erred Therefore they are not to be made the rule of Faith or practise but to be used as an help in both e Ep 2.20 Acts 17.1 1 Cor 2.5 2 Cor 1.24 V. Synods or Councels are to handle or conclude nothing but that which is Ecclesiastical and are not to intermedle with Civil affaires which concern the Common-wealth unless by way of humble petition in cases extraordinary or by way of advise for satisfaction of Conscience if they be thereunto required by the Civil Magistrate f Luke 12.13 14. Joh 18.36 CHAP. XXXI Of Synods and Councels Examined IN complyance with your first Section we grant that there may be great cause of spiâ—itual consultations and that either about temporal things as Moses went twice to the Lord about the daughters of Zelophebad Numbers 27.1 2 3 c. and Numbers 36.1 2 3 c. or in things of Religion as Moses required what should be done first to him that blasphemed the name of the Lord Leviticus 24.12 and secondly to him that gathered sticks on the Sabboth day Numb 15.32 33 c. But it is the Lord that is to be consulted with in those great difficulties and that either immediately as Moses did in the places aforesaid and Daniel with the other three Children Dan. 2. or else by some person who hath the judgement of Vrim and is acted by the spirit of God Numb 27.21 Ezra 2.63 1 Maccab. 4.4 especially if any such person be to be found of which there have been some in all or most ages if the Authour of the book of wisdom speaks true chap. 7.27 And in all ages wisdom entering into holy souls maketh them friends of God and Prophets which is consonant to what the Father promiseth Isa 29.21 and to our Saviours engagement Mat. 28.20 Behold I am with you to the end of the world but in case no such person may be found there may be Synods and Councels called for consultation sake and if the matter be still too difficult it must be reserved for Gods future resolution Ezra 2.63 As to your second Section we grant that Magistrates may call a Synod of Ministers or other fit persons especially of those that are spiritual and wise and it were good that persons of all different mindes in Religion might be freely heard and their arguments well weighed and full answer given in writing to all that are in the wrong that our controversies might grow to an end and so truth with love and peace take place but in this case if any inspired Prophet may be had at home or consulted abroad it is safer to receive resolution from the mouth of the Lord by him which we might easily do in this age either by word or writing then to rely upon the judgement of an hundred ordinary Divines often producing the letter of the word but wresting or mistaking the sense We grant likewise that such ordinary ministers and persons may be sent from their own to other Churches yet can they act onely within their own Sphere as rational learned or devout persons not as inspired men But that ordinary ministers may by their office when the Magistrate is an enemy call each other or assemble into a publick Synod we doubt yet doubtless they may meet privately and advise yea pray together To your third Section we grant that Synods may handle controversies of fact and cases of conscience direction for an outward worship and the better governing of a visible Church as also hear complaints in cases of male administration and determine them or some of them authoritate sibi commissa especially according to the measure of Faith and Regeneration whereunto they have attained which decrees and determinations if consonant to the word are to be received for the words sake more then for their authority they not being a divine but an humane ordinance only for the meeting of the Apostles and Elders at Jerusalem to which the Churches at Antioch and thereabouts appealed was an assembly of men acted by the Holy Ghost as themselves set forth Acts 13.28 and differs far both in warrant and authority from our Synods and Assemblies neither doth the first make the last to be Gods ordinance And in your fourth Section you confess no less where you acknowledge that all Synods and Councels since that might erre and that many have erred and so have you in many things but as your Confession here is ingenious so we hope you will not take
then for you to have pressed the necessity of the first resurrection for all fallen and corrupted men Revel 20.6 Blessed and holy is he that hath his part in the first resurrection on such the second death hath no power CHAP. XXXIII Of the last Judgment GOD hath appointed a day wherein he will judge the world in righteousness by Jesus Christ a Acts 17.30 to whom all power and judgement is given of the Father b Joh 5.22 27. In which day not only the Apostate Angels shall be judged c 1 Cor 6.3 Jude 6. 2 Pet 1.4 but likewise all persons that have lived upon earth shall appear before the tribunal of Christ to give an account of their thoughts words and deeds and to receive according to what they have done in the body whether good or evil d 2 Cor 5.10 Ec 12.14 Rom 2.16 Ro 14.10 12. Mat 12.36 37. II. The end of Gods appointing this day is for the manifestation of the glory of his mercy in the eternal salvation of the elect of his justice in the damnation of the Reprobate who are wicked and disobedient For then the righteous go into everlasting life and receive the fulness of joy and refreshing which shall come from the presence of the Lord but the wicked that know not God and obey not the Gospel of Jesus Christ shall be cast into eternal torments and be punished with everlasting destruction from the presence of the Lord and from the glory of his power e Mat. 25.31 to the end Rom 2.5 6. Rom 9.22 23. Mat 25 2â— Acts 5.19 2 Thes 1.7 8 6 10. III. As Christ would have us to be certainly perswaded That there shall be a day of judgement both to deter all from sin and for the greater consolation of the godly in their adversity f 2 Pet 3.11.14 2 Cor 5.10 11. 2 Thes 1.5 6 7. Luke 21.27 28. Rom 8.23 24 25. so will he have that day unknown to men that they may shake off all carnal security and be always watchful because they know not at what hour the Lord will come and may be ever prepared to say Come Lord Jesus come quickly g Matth 24 36 42 43 44. Mark 13.35 36 37. Luke 1â— 35 36. Rev 22 20. Amen CHAP. XXXIII Of the last Judgement Examined THis argument de rebus novissimis is a good subiect for you and us to close with but as you want some light in the beginning so we cannot commend your discerning or Judgement in your end You by your Scriptures to which you referr us confounding so many kinds and times of Judgment very different in themselves First you might have observed that Christs office of Judicature is twofold the one in the Saints and the other outward over all persons of Angels and men The former of these his inward and spiritual office Christ executes two wayes at two distant times yea in two several degrees The first is when he judgeth betwixt them and their spiritual enemies and not only delivers his servants from them but guideth and ruleth them according to his Lawes and Will Thus as types of Christ Othnicl Gedion Jephtha and the Judges of old were said to judge Israel and sutably hereunto David speaks thus of Christ Psal 72.4 He shall judge the poor of his people he shall save the children of the needy and break in peices the oppressors and Christ himself saith John 12.31 Now is the judgement of this world now is the Prince of this world cast out Christs second way of judging in his Saints is when he riseth up in them in fulness of light and power after they are dead with him in which day and coming of his he manifests unto them truth and errour light and darkness life and death yea every Councel of their own hearts even as the light of the Sun laies all open to the eye 1 Cor. 4.5 Therefore judge nothing before the time until the Lord come who both will bring to light the hidden things of darkness and will make manifest the counsels of the heart and then shall every man have praise of God for this very cause the Apostle would have all men forbear judging till that time but not until the general day of judgment now the outward judging of Christ is either in this life or the other in this life he judgeth and punisheth persons nations yea and sometimes the whole earth as he did in the daies of Noah After this life he first judgeth every man at his death Heb. 8.27 It is appointed unto all men once to die and after that cometh the judgement and then as you have here set it forth all men and Angels at or in the last day Thus then is a manifold day or time of Christs coming to judgement spoken of Matth. 24. and 25. Chapters and elsewhere First His particular coming to every man at his death Matth. 24. Secondly His coming to judge and punish the nation of the Jews Matth. 24.23 which came to pass about 38 yeers after his death Thirdly His coming to punish the fals proud and Apostate Jerusalem of the Gentiles a work now in hand Matth. 24.3 20 36 37. Fourthly Christs inward and spiritual coming promised to his Apostles and Disciples John 14.19 20. and spoken of 1 Corinth 1.7 Heb. 10.36 37. Jam. 5.7 which spiritual coming of his was after a time to cease in the Church by reason of mens Apostacy and the departure away from the true faith Luke 17.12 The daies will come when ye shall desire to see one of the daies of the Son of man and shall not see them Fifthly There is Christs second coming and his spiritual entrance into his Church in the same kinde called also the day of the Lord of which 2 Thes 2.2 in which the man of sin the son of perdition that mystery of iniquity should be revealed yea and destroyed by the brightness of his coming which coming of his brings the Gospel with it that was to be preached unto all Nations Matth. 24.30 And then shall appear the sign of the Son of man in Heaven and then shall all the Tribes of the earth mourn and they shall see the Son of man coming in the Clouds of Heaven with power and great glory and he shal send his Angels with a great sound of a Trumpet the Gospel aforesaid and they shall gather together his Elect from the four winds which time is by Zachariah described to be a gracious time chap. 12.10 11.12 and wished and longed for by St John Revel 1.7 22. This seems to be that blessed time wherein Christ shall come in the spirit but not in the body as many Chiliasts dream to errect a Kingdom throughout the earth in the hand of his Saints Dan. 7.13 14 27 28. which kingdom shall continue a thousand years Rev. 3.4 5 6. yea some are so bold as to say that this comming of Christ is the great day of judgment spoken of Acts 17.30 and elsewhere wherein Christ cometh spiritually with all his Saints to give a true and upright sentence concerning all spiritual things good and evil for which purpose they alledge that text 1 Thes 3.13 But St. John describes another judgement which shall follow after the thousand years are ended Rev. 20.7 8.15 which seem to be that very judgement which you aim at in this chapter And so sixthly and lastly There is Christs day or time of his last coming to keep a great and general Assizes Thus much in reference to your first Section especially In your second Section we admit your reasons produced to shew why there should be such a judgement with the proceedings then and the several events by you set forth and the rather because you there in the manifestation of the glory of Gods justice against there probates seem to lay their own condemnation upon their own disobedience and demerit and no way ascribe it to Gods absolute preterition or soveraignty to the want of means or sufficient grace for their effectual calling as you have done heretofore Lastly For a peaceable and friendly conclusion we grant you that which you assume in your third and last Section namly that Christ would have us certainly perswaded of a general judgement to deter all men from sin and for the greater consolation of the godly yet would he have us as well assured of our personal and particular going to judgement for the same ends so he would not have us ignorant of his spiritual coming but hope thereupon prepare our selvs thereunto 1 Thes 5.23 and though to take away security make us watchful he would have the day and hour both of our particular and his general judgment unknown unto us yet by such foregoing tokens and Characters as he hath set forth in his word we should learn to know his approaching judgements and commings and order our selves accordingly Matth. 24.32 33. Now learn a Parable of the Fig tree when its branches are yet tender and pntteth forth leaves you know that summer is nigh so likewise you when ye shall see all these things know that it is neer even at the door Against your 15. Article by you revised and here published we have not much to say but what hath been spoken upon those heads and should have had the less if you had left them all standing in statu quo prius And therefore we will here exhibite no articles against them as being more Orthodox then your selves though you hold them not for oracles We have here endeavoured to follow the Councel of St. Jude verse 3. Earnestly to contend for the faith which was once given to the Saints If any will be contentious against the truth we have no such custome nor the Church of God 1 Cor 11.16 But beloved building up your selves in your most holy faith praying in the holy Ghost keep your selves in the love of God looking for the mercy of our Lord Jesus Christ unto eternal life Now unto him that is able to keep you from falling and to present you faultless before the presence of his glory with exceeding joy To the onely Wise God our Saviour be Glory and Majesty Dominion and Power Now and ever Amen Jude 20 21 24 25. FINIS
by his prayer to God Gen. 17 20 21. that he carried the type of those who should not be heirs of life Gal. 4.22 c. and peradventure the like may be said of the person of Esau who at the meeting of his brother Jacob was turned into another man Gen. 23.4 and did ever after sweetly accord with him although Hebr. 12.16 he carries the type of a spiritual fornicator and profane person that sels his eternal birthright for a morsel of meat here in this world and of him that losing his first grace or blessing obtaines not a second But here we would not be misunderstood for though we brought Isaac as an instance of a typical or representative seed which he was in opposition to Ishmael Rom. 9.6 7. yet we do not deny but that he was one really elected out of Gods special foreknowledge nor do we doubt but Ishmael might be so likewise howsoever he was generally and conditionally elected as was also Cain Gen. 4.6 7. where the Lord saith unto him Why art thou wroth And why is thy countenance fallen If thou doest well shalt thou not be accepted c. Eighthly Betwixt these that are unchangeably designed to life or death out of foreseen faith or unbelief perseverance or Apostacy and those that are absolutely and peremptorily without any condition or respect to standing or falling rising again through grace or lieing still retaining or losing grace received For after this last manner none are irrevocably designed either to life or death from all eternity among Angels or men Ninthly Betwixt a soveraign power invested in a most wise just gratious loving and merciful Prince which may be used to his greater glory and the same placed in a rigourous and cruel Tyrant which last to affix upon God is no small degree of blasphemy Tenthly Betwixt an absolute preterition of some from eternity before they have done or thought good or evil yea had any being which is not found in God towards any of his future rational creatures and a passing over of some in time for their personal ingratitude and contumacy against him as the fallen Angels are declined after their fall and some men after grace often refused and others after grace abused are lest to walk in their own wayes Eleventhly Betwixt the not extending of grace at all after a needless and wilful Apostacy as the Lord dealt with the proud and presumptuous Angels which fell and the withholding of mercy from some persons which were not so strongly and well situated in grace and which fell through the temptation of others and thus God withholds not his first grace which iâ— also a sufficient grace from any of the sons of men though they are fallen in Adam Twelfthly Betwixt the withholding the first or converting grace from fallen men which is not kept back for any till they resist it and the withdrawing of his second or subsequent grace from such as have wilfully cast off the first in the just requiring of it and so do despite of the Spirit of Grace These few necessary distinctions being first premised we proceed Now for your errors and mistakes in your several Sections First we say that your assertion in the second Section is very false and erroneous where you say That Although God knows whatsoever may or can come to pass upon all supposed conditions yet hath he not decreed any thing because he foresaw it as future or as that which should come to pass upon such conditions For did not the Lord foresee that if he created the Angels free Agents some would fall and others stand still in their integrity That if he created our first parents with liberty of will that they would fall That if he offered fallen men his grace to help them up again some would embrace it and some refuse it That his offered grace being conditional some which received it would persevere and fulfil those conditions and some would fail in the performance after they had begun well That Judas being returned to his former covetousness would betray his Master for gain That the Jews out of obstinacy and envy would condemn and deliver Christ to the Gentiles That Pilate out of favour to men would yeeld him up to be scourged and crucified All which and a thousand things more the Lord foresaw would conditionally or supposedly come to pass and did thereupon decree or determine that they should so do because he could turn them to his glory yet do we not say that the Lord was necessitated so to do alwayes but when he foresaw that the effects and productions arising out of such supposed conditions were not conducible to his wise and holy ends he both could and in time did put a stop thereunto at his pleasure Thus he foresaw that the men of Keilah out of their wicked and ingrateful disposition being left to themselves would deliver and betray David into the hands of Saul and therefore he did both decree not to permit it and did actually hinder it by advertifing David of it that he might timely escape In your third Section there is truth and error to be found accordingly as your words are taken for you speak generally and ambiguously saying By God's Decree for the manifestation of his glory some men and Angels are predestinated unto eternal life and others fore-ordained to everlasting death To which we answer thus First That men and Angels are not in all things and every way disposed of alike in God's eternal Decree For though no fallen Angels are ordained to life yet by your own confession many fallen men are appointed to salvation in Jesus Christ Secondly We say that all both men and Angels are first predestinated to eternal life in case they should continue in their first created estate by answerable obedience The truth whereof appears sufficiently in the confirmation and blessing of those holy Angels which persisted in their allegiance who are therefore called the Elect Angels Thirdly We affirm that all men though fallen are appointed to restauration and life by grace conditionally that they beleeve on that grace and obey its requiring Ezek. 18.23 have I any pleasure at all that the wicked should die saith the Lord and that not he should return and live Ezek. 33.11 Say unto them as I live saith the Lord I desire not the death of the wicked 1 Tim. 2.3 4. For this is good and acceptable in the sight of God our Saviour who would have all men to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth Whereunto add that of Tit. 2.11 12. which holds forth both the universality of grace it self and its condition For the grace of God that bringeth salvation hath appeared to all men Teaching us that denying ungodliness and worldly lusts we should live soberly righteously and godly in this present world But lastly we grant notwithstanding that some both Angels and men were appointed for destruction yet conditionally through their own default and disobedience as
last Election hath foregoing works for his motive Revel 3.4 Thou hast a few names even in Sardis which have not defiled their garments and they shall walk with me in white for they are worthy and Rev. 7.14 15. These are they which came out of great tribulation and have washed their robes and have made them white in the blood of the Lambe Therefore they are before the throne of God and serve him day and night in his Temple c. In your Sixth Sextion you affirm That as God hath appointed the elect unto glory so he hath by the eternal and most free purpose of his will fore-ordained the means thereunto Which is true of all those that in mankinde are elected in general as well as of the special elected or chosen ones But whereas you add these words Wherefore they who are elected being fallen in Adam are redeemed by Christ are effectually called unto faith in Christ by his spirit working in good season are justified adopted sanctified and kept by his power through faith unto salvation This part of the Section taken conjunctively cannot be verified of any elected ones but those which are the final and special chosen aforesaid Thus far the words of this Section wisely and warily understood may pass for truth but the last words of all contain manifold falsehoods which words are these Neither are any others redeemed by Christ effectually called justified adopted sanctified and saved For though it be true that none are saved but onely the Elect yet all the â—est of that complexed speech being resolved into several propositions will prove so many false positions For first Many others are redeemed by Christ besides the Elect which shall be saved 2 Pet. 2.1 But there were false prophets amongst the people even as there shal be false teachers among you who privily shall bring in damnable heresies even denying the Lord that bought them and shall bring upon themselves swift destruction Yea all mankinde is redeemed by Christ 1 John 2.1 2. And if any man sin we have an advocate with the Father Jesus Christ the righteous and he is the propitiation for our sins and not for ours onely but for the sins of the whole world Yea he came to redeem Singula generum every man in particular Hebr. 2.9 That by the grace of God he should taste death for every man Secondly Many others besides those special elected ones are called Mat. 20.16 and Mat. 22.14 For many are called but few are chosen Thirdly some are justified for a time that is have their sins purged away and forgiven and yet by new rebellions and Apostacy perish afterwards Mat. 18.32.33.34 Then his Lord after he had called him said unto him O thou wiked servant I forgave thee all that debt because thou desiredst me shouldest thou not have had compassion on thy fellow servant even as I had pitty on thee And his Lord was worth and delivered him to the tormentors till he should pay all that was due unto him 2 Pet. 1.9 But he that lacketh these things is blinde and cannot see afar of and hath forgotten that he was purged from his old fins Lasty Some are sanctified in some measure yet afteâ—wards fall away and so come short of salvation 2 Pet. 2.20 21 22. For if after they have escaped the pollutions of the World through the knowledge of the Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ they are again intangled therein and overcome the latter end is worse with them then the beginning For it had been better for them not to have known the way of righteousness then when they have known it to turn from the holy commandements delivered unto them But it is happened unto them according to the true proverb The dogg is turned to his own vomit again and the sow that was washed to her wallowing in the miâ—e In your seventh Section you come to Gods preterition saying The rest of mankinde God hath pleased according to the unserchable councel of his own will whereby he extendeth or withholdeth mercy as he pleaseth for the glory of his soveraign power over his creatures to pass by and to ordain them to dishonour and wrath for ther sin to the praise of his glorious justice Here We pray you give us leave to propound these Queries to you First who are the rest of mankinde of whom you speak Are they all those who are not elected But we have shewed before that all are elected in general upon condition Did not God make his Covenant of Grace with all mankinde in Adam after his fall and afterwards for them with Noah Gen. 9.8 9. Yea he covenanted with Abraham for all generations and Nations and People Gen. 12.3 and 18 18. and that with an oath Gen. 22 16 17 18. Acts 3.24 Gal. 3.8 Whereupon all Nations yea all people are called upon to praise the Lord for this his great merciful kindness and for the truth of his promise which endureth for ever Psal 117.1 2. which being undoubtedly true there can be none of mankinde passed over from eternity But if you mean that All but those final and special chosen ones before mentioned are passed over from eternity without any purpose of grace or mercy to be extended towards them in Jesus Christ your assertion is not onely false but most dangerous For God is the Saviour of all men but especially of those that beleeve 1 Tim. 4.11 Secondly If Gods counsel herein be unsearchable how came you to know it Thirdly Since it is clear that Gods merciful kindness is towards all men as before and that he hath concluded all in unbelief that he might have mercy upon all Rom. 11.32 who are they from whom he withholdeth or to whom he extendeth not mercy Surely they can be no other but such as thrust it away from them first or last at least wise in its conditions and requiring Acts 13.46 Then Paul and Barnabas waxed bold and said It was necessary that the word of God should first have been spoken to you but seeing you put it from you and judge your selves unworthy of everlasting life we turn to the Gentiles Prov. 1.24 5 26. Because I have called and ye refused I have stretched out my hand and no man regarded but ye have set at nought all my counsel and would none of my reproof I will also laugh at your calamity I will mock when your fear cometh c. See Psal 8â— 8 9 16. Isa 48.17 18 19. Hos 7.1 and 11.1 2 3 4. Mat. 23.37 38 Heb. 4.1 2. Heb. 6.4 5 6. and 10.26 27 28. 2 Cor. 6.1 2 3. Fourthly Is not God's Soveraign power placed in one that is both most righteous and also most merciful and not in tyrannical hands Fiftly Is not that soveraign power most glorified in punishing offendors after mercy hath been offered and contemned or rejected Sixthly If these be passed over for their sins as you affirm How could this preterition be from eternity For men sinned not till they were
Isa 48.10 which with Paul have fought their good fight 2 Tim. 4.7 8. and so may fully expect their reward because God is faithful who hath promised see Hebr. 6 12 and 10 36. For ye have need of patience that when ye have done the will of God ye might receive the promise Jam. 1.12 Blessed is the man that endureth temptation for when he is tryed he shall receive the crown of life which the Lord hath promised to them that love him But these and the like promises are made but conditionally unto others Object 8. Rom. 9.7 Neither because they are the seed of Abraham are they all children but in Isaac shall thy seed be called Where the Apostle alludeth to Gen. 17.18 19 20 21. It may seem then that onely Isaac and not Ishmael was chosen Answ Isaac alone was chosen to be the representative seed of God he being a type first of Christ in whom God hath made his Covenant and secondly he being a seed born by Sarah who represents faith out of the promises rather then by the strength of nature and so is a figure of the Spiritual seed of Abraham which are begotten or born by vertue of the promises For so the Apostle explaines himself vers 8. That is they which are the children of the flesh of whom Ishmael carried the type these are not the children of God but the children of the promise are counted for the seed As for Ishmael who was begotten by the strength of nature and according to the flesh of Hagar which represents the Law Gal. 4.21 31. he figured forth those which would be saved not by the grace of the promises but by the works of the Law a people with whom God hath not erected his Covenant that they should be saved in that way But though Ishmael carried the figure of such it was without any prejudice to his eternal election or salvation For Abraham praying thus for him Gen. 17.18 Oh that Ishmael might live before thee or in thy presence The Lord answered vers 20. As for Ishmael I have heard thee c. His being such a type was no more prejudicial to him then that Moses and Aaron were debarred entrance into Canaan they therein being a figure of those that should be shut out of Gods kingdom for unbelief without any hazard to their own salvation as hath been said before Object 9. Rom. 9.10 11. It is said That there is a purpose of God according to election not of works but of him that calleth Answ Though Election there seems to import nothing but Gods grace as the explanation following not of works but of him that calleth will in some sort evict yet we grant that there is a purpose of God both according to Election of persons and things and that either general or special as hath been by us already often acknowledged And the eternal election of persons in mankinde now fallen whether general or particular is out of grace and not by their own works wrought by the strength of nature Howbeit in that special or particular election arising out of the special fore-knowledge of God works of grace and perseverance therein are looked upon as a means and way to life yea as a condition fulfilled and a motive both in that and the final election of the Saints which we called the election out of the fornace Rev. 3.4 Thou hast a few names in Sardis which have not defiled their garments and they shall walk with me in white for they are worthy Rev. 3.8 Behold I have set before thee an open door and no man can shu it For thou hast a little strength and hast kept my word and not denyed my name Read more at large Rev. 7.13 14 15 16 17. Object 10. Rom. 9.10 11 12. For the children not being yet born it was said that the elder should serve the younger Where Jacob and Esau are disposed of before they were born Answ First it is granted that all men may be so yea are so both for their temporal estates here and eternal condition hereafter but in a most wise and just way Secondly We have shewed before that the Apostle relating to Gen. 25.23 doth not speak of the persons of Esau and Jacob but of their two seeds the Nations of the Edomites and the people of Israel Thirdly It is not their eternal estate that is there spoken of but their rank and place in this world Now as it is lawful for the Lord to make some Governors and superiours and others inferiour or subjects so it was not any injustice in him to make the seed of Jacob the greater and superiour kingdom For even the Edomites were appointed to a good and comfortable condition Fourthly The Apostles mentions this disposal of them beforehand to prove that Jacob's or Israel's preferment was of meer grace and so the Argument was apt for his discourse in that book where he asserts God's grace against our own natural works and merits Lastly there is in this subordination of Esau to Jacob a spiritual document shewing that no natural or earthly man must be subject to the spiritual or heavenly man for Edom signifies earthly Object 11. Rom. 9.13 As it is written Jacob have I loved but Esau have I hated It should seem then that the person of Esau was hated before hand and Jacob alsâ— loved before they were born Answ Some indeed have so understood the Apostle and have run themselves and others thereby upon dangerous rocks not considering those things First Where those words are written to wit not Gen. 25.23 as the other is but Mala. 1.1 2 3 4. Secondly That the Prophet spake not of the person of Jacob where he saith to Israel vers 1 2 3. I have loved you and again yet I loved Jacob but of the seed and posterity of Jacob. Thirdly That in the third verse the Lord speakes of the posterity of Esan in that very age and not of the person of Esau Where he saith And I hated Esau and laid his mountains and his heritage waste for the dragons of the wilderness Fourthly That the Lord shews the cause in the 4. ver why he hath hated Edom at this time It was for their incorrigible wickedness saying Whereas Edom saith we are impoverished but we will return and build the desolate places They shall build but I will through down and they shall call them the border of wickedness and the people against whom the Lord hath indignation for-ever Lastly That the Apostle alledgeth this place to shew that what God had spoken concerning Israel's preheminence above Edoms Gen. 25.23 was now fulfilled they continuing to be his people when the other were cast off for their obstinacy Object 12. Rom. 9.14 15. What shall we say then Is there unrighteousness with God God forbid For he saith to Moses I will have mercy on whom I will have mercy and I will have compassion on whom I will have compassion It seems then that there are some
upon whom the Lord will not have compassion Answ It is true there are some such persons and such were the incorrigible Edomites before spoken off yet note three things First That the Apostle preoccupates an Objection which some might make out of Gods mercy continued still to Israel but withdrawn from Edom as before What shall we say then Is there unrighteousness with God Secondly That the Apostle answers it not onely with a detestation saying God forbid but also with a Scripture taken out of Exodus 33.9 And I will be gratious to whom I will be gratious and I will shew mercy to whom I will shew mercy Thirdly That the Lord speakes there of continuing and enlarging his after mercies and favours to those that walk humbly faithfully and answerably to his first mercy or grace as Moses had done then when he begged of the Lord that he would shew him his glory And not of his first grace withholden from none Whereby the contrary it may be gathered that God will withhold his second mercies from some who refused his first grace as the Edomites had done or should abuse the same afterwards by turning his grace into wantonness Jude 4. Object 13 Rom. 9.16 So then it is not of him that willeth nor of him that runneth but of God that sheweth mercy Our salvation then is of meer mercy Answ It is granted so to be yet by the way note that man can both wil and run in some sort as this Scripture imports Object 14. Rom. 9.17 18. For the Scripture saith unto Pharaoh even for this same purpose have I raised thee up that I might shew my power in thee and that my name might be declared throughout all the earth Therefore hath he mercy on whom he will have mercy and whom he will he hardeneth Answ First note that here the Lord doth not say for this same purpose have I created thee but raised thee up or brought thee upon the stage Secondly That Pharaoh was known to the Lord to be a proud and obstinate Rebel before he thus called him out Exod 5.2 And Pharoah said who is the Lord that I should obey his voice to let Israel go I know not the Lord neither will I let Israel go Thirdly That yet the Lord gives him to know his will and gratiously shews him the danger of his disobedience before he sends his plagues upon him Fourthly That he leaves him not till he made him of unwilling willing to let his people go Fifthly That God did not harden Pharaohs heart by infusing any hardness into it but rather used means to soften and bend his heart to obedience Lastly That the Lord destroyed him not till his heart byased and wilfully revolted from that inclination of letting Israel go to which the Lord had brought and wrought him So that the Lords pleasure in hardning whom he will must out of this example be understood of such as are first or last refractory against his grace and gratious requirings monitions c. Object 15. Rom 9.19 Thou wilt say why doth he yet finde fault Who hath resisted his will It seems then his will in condemning the wicked is irresistable Answ The will of God is manifold First voluntas signi that which he would have done by men and that may be resisted or disobeyed Secondly voluntas beneplaciti that which he is pleased to effect and that either absolutely to be done by himself alone or with others which cannot be withstood or conditionally in case the creature will act his part This conditional will may also be repugned so that wicked men cannot excuse themselves by the irresistibility of the first or last mentioned will There is also the unchangeable will of God's irrevocable decree at length passed upon the obstinate and incorrigible sinner which like his powerful or efficacious will is inexpugnable But it is the obdurate mans refractory and inflexible will that hath now made this will or decree of God so peremptory against him So that God hath just cause to fault and blame the man that perisheth but not è contra Object 16. Rom. 9.20 Shall the thing formed say to him that formed it why hast thou made me thus Whence it may seem to follow that God makes the lost ones such as they are Answ Paul intends nothing less then to lay any such aspersion upon God who is onely the Author of their deserved punishment but not of their sins unless of such as are just and severe compensations of their former contumacies Indeed the Apostle here first takes up these murmurers for their audacious and presumptuous obloquies against their Maker in this verse Nay but O man who art thou that replyest against God Shall the thing formed say to him that formed it Why hast thou made me thus And then in the three next verses for the total silencing of their obmurmuration he asserts first Gods soveraign power vers 21. and then his justice vers 22. with his mercy also vers 23. If the wicked then finding themselves lost at length should cavil against God and say why did he create me with liberty of will and so with a power of falling It is answered that this faculty might be improved to the salvation of the creature as well as to the glory of Gods grace vers 23. Or why did God give us any being since we must be wretched and unhappy for ever It is answered vers 22. that it coming to pass meerly through their own default and wilfulness it was free for our Soveraign Lord thus to glorifie his power and justice against such rebels yea and his incurable enemies also Object 17. Hath not the Potter power over the clay of the same lumpe to make one vessel unto honour and another unto dishonour It seems then that God makes some vessels of purpose unto dishonour Answ I. It is certain that God is a wise Potter and not a workman that never had wisdom or hath lost his witts Now such a Potter though he as the event falls out afterwards makes many vessels to be broken yet forms none of set purpose for destruction as we said before Some vessels indeed are made by him for more honourable uses as Salt-sellers drinking-cups c. and some for more dishonorable uses for Chamber-pots the like but none to be destroyed for that were to lose his labour And so hath the Lord appointed both in Church Common-Wealth some to be superiours and some inferiours as hath been shewed but none of the sons of men hath he made of purpose to perdition II. It is evident enough that the Apostle alludeth to Jeremie 18. verse 3.4 5 6. Where observe these things First That the Prophet being sent to the Potters house he found that the vessel in the Potters hand first miscarried and was marred representing man not in the pure but corrupt mass Secondly That the Potter took pains to make it up a new or other vessel Thirdly That the Lord expostulates with Israel
that I have not done in it Wherefore when I looked that it should have brought forth grapes brought it forth wild grapes Unto which interrogatories the church if they had believed your doctri◠might have answered thus Thou mightest have done much more for thy vineyard then thou hast done if thou hadst created us all in Gods Image as thou didst our first parents a thing very easie unto thee And how wouldest thou O wise and righteous Lord expect that we should bring forth any other fruit but wild grapes since by our depravation derived from our first parents we are a meer wild vine But as the choisest vine with which God planteth his vineyard is Christ from our creation planted in us being called Ja. 1.21 The ingrafted word which is able to save our souls so this vineyard is our heart or inward man into which al are hired or sent by the Lord to work therein to keep dress the same from the 3. unto the 11 hour yet some at one hour and some at another are more excited to labour therein Matth. 20.1 2 3 16. And the wickedness which by our fall from God we have brought in and planted is the vine of Sodom that is of their secret or foundation of which the Lord complains Deut. 32.32 For their vine is of the vine of Sodom and the fields of Gomorrah their grapes are grapes of gall their clusters are bitter A seventh place which lets his voyce be heard without fear is that of Jeremiah 2.21 where the Lord justifies himself but justly blameth Israel Yet I had planted thee a noble vine wholly of a right seed How then are thou turned into the degenerate plant of a wild vine unto me Now the whole nation of Israel was yet never thus planted any other way but by an upright creation for they were not all made such by way of regeneration in any age or generation which was heretofore Eighthly when God by the same Prophet expostulates with them about their falling from him and not rising again and returning chapt 8. verse 4 5. doth not the Lord implie that they once stood before they fell yea and that they had not yet lost all abilitie of returning when by precedent grace they where excited thereunto Moreover thou shall say unto them Thus saith the Lord shall they fall and not arise Shall he turn away and not return Wherefore is this people of Jerusalem slidden back by a perpetual back sliding They bold fast deceit they refuse to return Ninthly the Lord in Hosea chapter 3. verse 9. laies Israels destruction upon her self and not upon her first parents O Israel thou hast destroyed thy self but in me is thy help and so he doth their fall likewise chapter 14. verse 1. O Israel return unto the Lord thy God for thou hast fallen by thine iniquity Tenthly doth not our Saviour declare the state of children both to be innocent and blessed when first he makes it terminus ad quem unto which in our conversion and regeneration we must return and then tels us that the kingdom of Heaven belongs unto such and is replenished with such saying Matth. 18.3 Verily I say unto you except ye be converted and become as little children ye shall not enter into the Kingdom of Heaven And again Matth. 19 1◠he saith Suffer little children to come unto me and forbid them not for of such is the Kingdom of Heaven Eleventhly doth not the Apostle Paul remove not onely from children malice but all evil of iniquity when he would have the Corinthians in that behalf conformed unto them 1 Cor. 14.20 saying Brethren be not children in understanding Howbeit 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 in malice or iniquity be children but in understanding be perfect or of a ripe age Lastly to omit many other Scriptures which might be produced upon this account the Apostle James affirms that men are still created after Gods Image chap. 39. saying Therewith to wit with the tongue bless we God even the Father and therewith curse we men which are made after the similitude of God If it be here objected that the Apostle here ment onely such as were regenerate we reply these three things First that the verb here used signifies to create or make but to create or make but not to regenerate without some other exprssion in the text so to limit it Secondly that the Saints to whom St. James did now write do not use to curse each other Thirdly without doubt the holy Apostle and Disciple of Christ here restraining and reproving the cursing of men would make his restraint as large as his master did who would have us to love all mankinde even our enemies and not curse any of them but to bless and benefit them all herein following the example of our Hevenly Father Mat. 5.44.45 But I say unto you love your enemies bless them that curse you do good to them that hate you and pray for them that dispitefully use you and persecute you that ye may be the children of your Father which is in Heaven For he maketh his Son to rise on the evil and the good and sendeth rain on the just and on the unjust It is all mankinde therefore that James would exempt from being cursed and consequently no less number that are made after Gods Image Thus we have proved that neither the guilt of our first parents sin was imputed nor their spiritual death in sin and corrupted nature was conveyed to all their posterity or to any one of them by ordinary generation contrary to your assertions in your third Section And though this your doctrine hath gone from hand to hand a long time by tradition yet neither did the Scribes and Pharisees nor yet the Disciples of Christ and much less Christ himself hold forth any such doctrine nor were any of them leavened with this opinion of yours and your long mistasten predecessors for the Pharisees with the Jewes being highly displeased with him who was born blind and whose eyes Christ had opened for defending his Saviour and blessed Occulist said thus unto him John 9.34 Thou wast altogether born in sin and dost thou teach us Whence it is evident that they did neither conceive all men in general nor yet themselves to be by propagation conceived and born in sin And when Christs Disciples asked him saying John 9.23 Master who did sin this man or his parents that he was born blinde Jesus answered neither hath this man sinned nor his parents but that the works of God should be made manifest in him Where according to your doctrine our Saviour should have answered positively that both he and his parents with all his progenitors even as far as Adam had sinned and were all as many descended from Adam by ordinary generation from one generation to another conceived in sin and brought forth in iniquity But our Saviour taught no such doctrine nor did his Apostles when rightly understood hold forth any thing
all and every one to be sinners by the first individual mans disobedience but grant that the word many in both parts of this 19. verse must be explained by the word all how clear then without any darkness is the meaning when it is said by one mans disobedience namely the natural Adam 's disobedience all are made sinners because all that ever sin sin in that natural Adam for John 3.9 he that is born of God sâ—â—neth not neither can he sin because he is born of God Hence by the obedience of one that is the heavenly Adam many that is all are made righteous according to that Cor. 15.48 As is the earthy so are they that are earthy and as is the heavenly so are they that are heavenly and therefore as we have borne the Image of the earthy by our disobedience so let us seek to bear the Image of the heavenly That as Rom. 5 19. by one mans disobedience we all may be made righteous Thus we hope it plainly appears that no place in the fifth of the Romans asserteth the imputation of the first mans sin to all posterity though it do affirm that by one man sin entered into the world which must be understood of the one natural man or common Adam in and upon us all according to that 1 Cor. 15.22 For as in Adam all die so in Christ shall all be made alive That is as all die in the earthy Adam that do die so all that live are made alive in Christ the Heavenly Adam We come now to answer the arguments brought à simili whereby you deceive your selves and others As first It is usually said That Traytors are not onely punished themselves for their Treason but their posterity also have their blood tainted and deprived of their inheritance But we demand by what Law Is this by Gods Law and Command that the posterity of a Traytor should be so tainted and deprived or by mans law without warrant from Gods Law If so That doth not argue God will deal with Adams posterity to taint them for his sin and deprive them of an inheritance immortal which the Lord giveth and not man for the first mans sin But to apply our selves to your simile We answer That none but the fathers are punished with death for that sin their children are onely disinherited of the lands and honours which are hereditary but are not made uncapable of new and though all this be done In terrorem yet it leaves Traytors life and being with manyfold capacities of well being but you leave a great part of Adams posterity for his sin by you imputed to them no hope of salvation yea you expose them to eternal destruction for that same they never consented unto nor could avoid Another Objection à simili is this That as the soâ—â— of Achan Josua 7.24 perished with him for his sin so may we justly perish with the first Adam for his sin We answer First Achan's sons being acquainted with the hidden Treasure and approving the thest as it is probable they might were involved in the fin and worthy to be partaker of the punishment Secondly It was but a temporal death which his sons suffered and not an eternal destruction Lastly It is objected That as young Vipers or Serpents are killed with the old ones because we know they have the poysonous nature in them So may Adams posterity â—e destroyed with him We answer That the similitude cannot hold for as we have proved already Adam's posterity are created innocent yea righteous still even in the nautral man besides a spiritual Adam that lieth hidden in all men True it is That by a voluntary fall and the addition of manifold rebellions many men as John calleth them Matth. 3.7 make themselves a generation of vipers but they are not so born by their descent from the first finful Adam Thus we need not throw dirt in the face of our first parents nor transfer the guilt of our fall to those which lived almost six thousand years before us if we rightly understood what we our selves have done yea if we understand that one man before spoken of Rom. 5.12 to the end of the chapter to be opposed unto or paralleled with Christ in a contrary way or course then we may conceive that one man as properly if not more truely to be meant of one personal yet common Adam as of our first progenitors to defame him which will be more fully declared when we speak of Christ the other member of the collation or parallel in the 5. chapter that is concerning Christ the Mediator We beseech you to pardon this our long aboad upon your third Section because we know by experience our opposing the tradition of original sin in children will be most stumbled at and wondered at by them that never surveyed the Scriptures about it In your fourth Section you proceed and say From this original corruption whereby we are utterly indisposed disabled and made opposite to all good and wholly inclined to all evil do proceed all actual transgressions Where to your former error of deriving both the guilt of Adams fall and the corruption of nature to his posterity you add three more according to the multiplying nature of error But first you will not deny that Adam was in the estate of regeneration before he begat any of his children and what true reason can there be given why grace and the renewed Image of God being inherent and connatural should not be derived to his seed as well as his corruptions which were not either universal or perfect in degree even before he by grace was renewed again as we have already proved but of that enough before II. How do you prove that the first fall which we call original sin whether happening in Adam or our selves doth presently render us both unable yea and altogether indisposed and opposite to any good For the whole Image of God is not blotted out at once Doth not the Lord testifie of Jeroboams son-who was sick That there was some good thing left in him towards the Lord and therefore he is taken away before that those last sparkes be extinguished 1 Kings 14.13 III. As the Image of God is defaced gradually so corruption is contracted by degrees so that all men are not corrupted in every part nor alike deeply corrupted so Judah by continuance in sin in process of time had more polluted her self then Samaria her elder sister or Sodom her pounger Ezek. 16 45 46 47. c. The last age of the old world upon which the deluge was sent was more corrupt then any that went before it and thereupon it was destroyed Therefore that which the Lord speaks in complaint of that age is not equally applicable to all ages and muchless to all persons Although that is true of all grown men which the Lord speaks Gen. 8.21 That the imaginations of mans hears are evil from his youth that is from the first times of his
the unbeleeving guids shut out of Canaan And are not these things writen for our instuction See Heb. 4.12 Let us therefore fear least a promise being left us of entering into his rest any of you should seem to come short of it for to us was the Gospel preached as well as unto them but the word preached profited them not being not mixed with faith in them that heard it CHAP. VII Of God's Covenant with Man THE Distance between God and the Creature is so great that although reasonable Creatures do owe obedience unto him as their Creator yet they could never have any fruition of him as their blessedness and reward but by some voluntary condescention on Gods part which he hath been pleased to express by way of Govenant a Isa 40.13 14 15 16 17. Job 9.32 33. 1 Sam. 2.13 Psal 113.5 6. Psal 100.2 3. Job 22.2 3. Job 35.7 8. Luke 17.10 Act. 17.24 25. II. The first Covenant made with man was a Covenant of works b Gal. 3.12 wherein life was promised to Adam and in him to his posterity c Ro. 10.5 Rom. 5 1â— to 20. upon condition of perfect and personal obedience d Gen. 2.17 Gal. 3.10 III. Man by his fall having made himself uncapable of life by that Covâ—â—ant the Lord was pleased to make a second e Gal. 3.21 Ro 3.20 21. Gen. 3.15 Isa 42.6 commonly called the Covenant of Grace Wherein he freely offereth unto sinners Life and Salvation by Jesus Christ requiring of them faith in him that they may be saved f Mark 16.15 16. John 3.16 Ro. 10.6 9 Gal. 3.11 and promising to give unto all those that are ordained unto life his holy Spirit to make them willing and able to beleeve g Ezek. 3.6 26.27 John 6.44 45. IV. This Covenant of Grace is frequently set forth in Scripture by the name of a testament in reference to the death of Jesus Christ the Testator and to the everlasting inheritance with all things be longing to it therein bequeathed h Heb. 9.25 16 17. Heb. 7.22 Luk. 22.20 1 Cor. 11.15 2 Cor. 3.6 7 8 9. V. This Covenant was differently administred in the time of the Law and in the time of the Gospel i Vnder the Law it was administred by promises prophesies sacrifices circumcision the Paschal Lamb and other types and ordinances delivered to the people of the Jews all fore-signifying Christ to come k Heb 8.9 10. Chapters Rom 4.11 Col 2.11 12. 1 Cor 5.7 which were for that time sufficient and efficacious through the operation of the Spirit to instruct and build up the Elect in Faith in the promised Messiah l 1 Cor 10.1 2 3 4. Heb. 11.13 John 8.16 by whom they had full remission of sins and eternal salvation called The Old Testament m Gal 3.7 8 9 14. VI. Vnder the Gospel when Christ the substance n Col. 2.17 was exhibited the ordinances in which this Covenant is dispensed are the preaching of the Word and the administration of the Sacraments of Baptism and the Lords supper o Ma 28.19 20. 1 Cor 14.23 24 15. Which though fewer in number and administred with more simplicity and lesse outward glory yet in them it is held forth in more fulness evidence and spiritual efficacy p Heb 12.22 to 28. Jer 31.33 34. to all nations both Jewes and Gentels q Mat 28.19 Eph 2.15 16 c. and is called the new Testament r Luke 22 20. There are not therefore Two Covenants of grace differing in substance but one and the same under various dispensations Å¿ Gal 3.16 17. Rom 1.21 22 23 â—0 Psal 3â— 1 with Rom. 4.3 6 16 17 23 24 Beb 13 8. Acts 15.21 CHAP. VII Of Gods Covenant with man examined WE will not say that you have made a Covenant with death or an agreement with hell but in this tract of the Covenant you do not alwayes keep league with truth for though you beging plausibly in the first Section yet both there and elswhere you affirm many things untruly As first when you say That the distance between God and the creature is so great that though all reasonable creatures do owe obedience unto him as their Creator yet they never could have any fruition of him as their blessedness and reward but by some voluntary condescension on Gods part which he hath been pleased to express by way of Covenant For do not the elect Angels from their first creation by their first constitution see God in his own light and participate of his blessedness in wisdom holiness power life peace and glory And if the Lord did not create our first parents in so ful a fruition of blessedness yet he could have so beatified them if he had pleased without a precedent covenant And was not the humanity of Christ in his inward man placed in that communion and fruition of God from the beginning of his incarnation though his outward man was subject to mortality and misery Yet you make us some peece of amends in your second section saying That the Lord made a Covenant of works with mankinde at the first wherein liâ—e was promised to Adam and in him to his posterity upon condition of personal and perfect obedience Where by the way you tacitly grant two truths by your selves denyed and by us asserted Chapter the third so powerful is truth in it self that oft times it breaks forth from men de improviso though they have gain said it before the which two truths are these First that all men in Adam were appointed or ordained to life if the Covenant of life was made to him and all his posterity For God works all things in time according to the eternal counsel of his will as we said before out of Ephes 1.11 And secondly That this decree was conditional also for so you confess the first Covenant to have been and so are all subsequent Covenants likewise or the far greatest part of them which are given by God himself to mankinde In your third Section you are more defective and erroneous for though you say truly in the beginning of it That man by his fall having made himself uncapable of life by the Covenant of works the Lord was pleased to make a second Covenant commonly called the Covenant of grace wherein be freely offereth unto sinners life and salvation by Jesus Christ Yet herein you faile in that you do not set forth that this Covenant was universal for all sinners as indeed it was For it was made with all mankinde in our first parents and as all that fell had need of the same and were by creation alike related to God so he had compassion upon all impartially being no accepter of persons and appointed one mediator alike neer to all men betwixt him and us even the man Christ as we shewed before out of Rom. 3.22 23 24 c. Rom 10.11 12 Rom. 11.32 Gal. 3.22 â—8 1 Timo.
dispenced are the preaching of the word and the administration of baptism and the Lords Supper we grant it to be true if those be administred by such persons to whom Christ is truely come in his light spirit and power Otherwise for men to preach a self-conceived Christ whom they have learned by reading or tradition from their blinde guides or to administer the Sacraments without any due understanding of the Baptism flesh and blood of Christs these are not Gods ordinances but mens usurpations Thirdly we grant you that where the Covenant of grace is set forth by men so taught and acted by the Spirit of Christ as we have described there it is held forth in more evidence spiritual efficacy and fulness then it was in Moses his literal services But this will not be equally verified of those that preach a misconceived Christ without true light or life Lastly whereas you conclude That there are not then two Covenants of grace one under the old Testament and another under the new we will from this your confession inferr that the first Covenant of grace made was unto and for all mankinde because the Gospel by Christs express command is to be preached to every humane creature and hath universal but conditional salvation annexed unto it Mat. 28.19 Mark 16.15 16. What then will become of your doctrine of Gods preterition of particular redemption of some men onely of the effectual calling of this and that elected one onely and many other points wherein with Herod you imprison John that is you confine the grace and mercy of God CHAP. VIII Of Christ the Mediator IT pleased God in his eternal purpose to choose and ordain the Lord Jesus his onely begotten Son to be the Mediator between God and man a Isa 42.1 1 Pe 1.19 20. Joh 3.16 1 Tim 2 5. the Prophet b Act 3.22 Priest c Heb 5.5 6 and King d Psal 2.6 Luk 1.33 the head and Saviour of his Church e Eph 5.23 the heir of all things f Heb 1.2 and judge of the world g Act 17.31 unto whom he did from all eternity give a people to be his seed h Joh 17.6 Psa 22.30 Isa 53 10. and to be by him in time redeemed called justified sanctified and glorified i 1 Tim. 2.6 Isa 55.4 5. 1 Cor. 1.30 II. The Son of God the second person in the Trinity being very and eternal God of the substance and equal with the Father did when the fulness of time was come take upon him mans nature k 1 Joh 1.14 1 Joh 5.20 Phil 2.6 Gal. 4.4 with all the essential properties and common infirmities thereof yet without sin l Heb. 2.14 16 17. Heb 4.15 being conceived by the power of the Holy Ghost in the womb of the Virgin Mary of her substance m Luk 1.27 31 35. â—al 4.4 so that two whole perfect and distinct natures the Godhead and the Manhood were inseparably joyned together in one person without conversion composition or confusion n Luk. 1.35 Col 2.9 Rom 9.5 1 Pet 3.18 1 Tim. 3.16 which person is very God and very man yet one Christ the onely Mediator between God and man o RoÌ„ 1.3 4. 1 Tim 2.5 III. The Lord Jesus in his humane nature thus united to the Divine was sanctified and annoynted with the Holy Spirit above measure p Psal 45.7 Joh 3.34 having in him all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge q Col 2.3 in whom it pleased the Father that all fulness should dwell r Col. 1.19 to the end that being holy harmless undefiled and full of grace and truth Å¿ Heb 7.16 Joh 1.14 he might be throughly furnished to execute the office of a Mediator and surety t Act 10.18 Heb. 22.24 Heb 7.22 which office he took not to himself u Heb 5.4 5. but was thereunto called by his Father who put all power and judgement into his hand and gave him commandment to execute the same * Joh 5.22 27. Mat 28 18. Act 2.36 IV. This office the Lord Jesus did most willingly undertake x Psal 40.7 8 with Heb 10.5 10 11. Joh 10.18 Phil 2.8 which that he might discharge he was made under the Law y Gal. 4.4 and did perfectly fulfill it z Mat 3.17 Mat 5.15 endured most greivous torments immediately in his soule a Mat 25.37 38. Luk 22.24 Mat 27.46 and most painful sufferings in his body b Mat 26.27 chap. was crucâ—fied and dyed c Phil 2.8 was buryed and remained under the power of death yet saw no corruption d Act 2.3 21 27. Act 13.37 Rom 6.9 On the third day he arose from the dead e 1 Cor. 15.23 4. with the same body in which he suffered f Joh 20.25 27. with which also he ascended into heaven and there sitteth at the right hand of his Father g Mark 16.19 making intercession h Rom. 8.34 Heb 9.24 Heb. 7.25 and shall return to judge men and Angels at the end of the world i Rom 1â— 9 10. Heb. 7.25 Rom. 1â— 9 10. Act 1.11 Act. 10.42 Mat. 13.40 41 42. Jud. 6. 2 Pet. 2.4 V. The Lord Jesus by his perfect obedience and sacrifice of himself which he through the eternal Spirit once offered up unto God hath fully satisfied the justice of his Father k Ro. 5.19 Heb 9.14 16. Heb. 10.14 Ephes 5.2 Rom. 3.25 26. and purchased not onely reconcilation but an everlasting inheritance in the Kingdom of Heaven for all those whom the Father hath given unto him l Dan 9.24 26. Col 1.19 20. Ephes 1.11 14. Joh 17.2 Heb 9.12 15. VI. Although the work of redemption was not actually wrought by Christ till after his Incarnation yet the virtue efficacy and benefits thereof were communicated unto the elect in all ages successively from the beginning of the world in and by those promises types and sacrifices wherein he was revealed and signified to be the seed of the woman which should bruise the serpents head and the Lamb slain from the beginning of the world being yesterday and to day the same for ever m Gal. 4.4.5 Gen. 3.15 Rev. 13.8 Heb. 13.8 VII Christ in the work of mediation acteth according to two natures by each nature doing that which is proper to it self yet by reason of the unity of the person that which is proper to one nature is sometimes in Scripture attributed to the person denominated by the other nature o Acts 20.28 Joh. 3.13 1 Joh. 3.16 VIII To all those for whom Christ hath purchased Redemption he doth certainly and effectually apply and communicate the same p Joh. 6.37.39 Joh. 10.15 16. making intercession for them q 1 Joh. 2.1 Rom. 8.34 and revealing unto them in and by the word the mysteries of salvation r Joh. 15. â—3 15. Eph. 1.7 8 9. Joh. 17.6 effectually perswading them
all sinners as we have proved by manifold Scriptures it is not by him applyed unto all men as your selves will confess but if we here take up the inward and spiritual redemption of Christ that is not purchased for us but we are rather purchased by it and in the very working of it it being an inward work of Christs it must needs be effectually applyed also Secondly Whereas you say That Christ makes intercession for all such as he bath redeemed it is false also for some deny even him that bought them and that in an Apostatical way and by bringing in damnable heresies whereby they bring upon themselves swift destruction 2 Pet 2.1 But we justly doubt you whether you understand aright what the intercession of Christ doth mean For his intercession at large comprehends his whole office of mediation Isa 53.12 and Heb. 7.25 but to take his intercession for his supplicative office as you here intend it consists principally if not alone in the spiritual intercessions which he makes unto God for in his Saints by his holy spirit Ro. 8.26 27. As for his intercession at large of which we conceive the Apostle speaketh Rom. 8.34 Christ useth or imployeth that for none other but those whom the Father hath called and given unto him and for them also so long as they continue with him For the Lord is with us while we are with him 2 Chron. 15.2 1 Chron. 28 9. The like we say of his revealing his Mysteries unto them whether by the word or without it and of his effectual perswading of them by his Spirit to beleeve Where again you are mistaken for God onely illuminates and makes known his truth unto us but it is our part to set to our seal thereunto in our power to withhold the same What you speak also of Christs governing the hearts of all those whom he hath redeemeed by his word and spirit and of the overcoming of all their enemies by his almighty power and wisdom in such manner and wayes as he sees good all these may be true or false according to the limitations aforesaid Yet here you tacitely grant or imply Christs inward or spiritual mediation though you own it not for such a work Yea which is more to be wondered at you here import that Christ by his almighty power doth overcome and subdue in and unto his redeemed people all their enemies to wit Satan and their corruptions which elsewhere you hold to be unconquerable here or not wholly to be subdued in this life But truth is so evident and forcible that where it is not narrowly watched and suppressed it will break forth at unawares By all this which in this Chapter we have set forth if the Lord open your eyes rightly to read it we hope you will be brought to acknowledge that the predictions of Christ and his Apostles concerning the departure from the faith are already come to pass and that forewarning of his that there should arise false Christs and false Prophets is fulfilled and consequently that there should be great need and cause for the Gospel to be preached anew to all the world as Christ himself foretold Matth. 24.14 and that mercy or blessing was foreshewed to John Revel 14.6.7 For even those Authors whom ye counted the greatest lights of this last age have very little sight or knowledge of that great Mystery Christ Jesus in you the hope of glory Colos 1.27 Yea they have been all the publishers of a false conceived Mediator or Christ CHAP. IX Of Free-wil GOD hath indued the will of man with that natural liberty that it is neither forced nor by any absolute necessity of nature determined to good or evil a Mat 17.12 Jam 1.14 Deut 30.19 II. Man in his state of innocency had freedom and power to will and to do that which was good and wel-pleasing to God b Eccl. 7.29 Gen 1.26 but yet mutably so that he might fall from it c Gen 2.16 17. Gen 3.6 III. Man by his fall into a state of sin hath wholly lost all ability of will to any spiritual good accompanying salvation d Ro 8.7 John 15.5 so as a natural man being altogether averse from that good e Rom 3.10.12 and dead in sin f Ep 2.1 5. Col 2.13 he is not able by hiâ— own strength to convert himself or prepare himself thereunto g John 6.44 65. Eph 2.2 3.4 5. 1 Cor 2.14 Titus 3.3 4 5. IV. When God converts a sinner and translates him into the state of grace he freeth him from his natural bondage under sin h Ga 1.13 John 8.34 36. and by his grace alone inables him freely to will and to do that which is spiritually good i Phil 2.12.13 Ro 6.18 21. yet so as that by reason of his remaining corruption he doth not perfectly nor onely will that which is good but doth also will that which is evil k Gal 5.17 Rom 7.15 18 19 21 22 V. The will of man is made perfectly and immutably free to good alone in the state of glory onely l Eph 4.13 Heb 12.23 John 3.2 Jude v. 24. CHAP. IX Of Free-will Examined ALthough man be alwayes a free Agent in some measure yet is he not at all times such a patient nor can we expect you here to be voluntary sufferers But if you will give us leave to be free with you we must acquaint you that even in this short Chapter there are many things though freely spoken by you yet but gratis dicta And especially in the three last Sections but we fear that you have granted more truth in the first Section then upon the view you will own again For you say That God hath endued the will of man with such natural liberty that it is neither forced nor by any absolute necessity of nature determined to good or evil for you seem in the first Section of the next Chapter directly to contradict yourselves saying That in our effectual calling God doth not onely renew our wils but determines them to that which is good by his Almighty power And that which you speak in the second Section That man in his state of innocency had freedome and power to wil and do that which was good well-pleasing to God but yet mutably so that he might all from it seems to us in some sort to hold true stil of all men as they are now born till they have personally and actually sinned And that Scripture to which you reser us Eccles 7.29 it speaking of mankinde in general and not of our first parents onely evicts so much in the very words saying Lo this onely have I found that God hath made man upright but they have found out many inventions To which others may be added as Jer. 2.21 For I had planted thee a noble vine wholly a right seed how then art thou turned into the degenerate plant of a wild vine unto me But that
place in which the Lord speakes of a child shortly to be born unto the Prophet and to be called Immanuel as some most learned expositors affirm Isa 7.14 15 16. Therefore the Lord himself shall give you a signe Behold a Virgin or a young woman for the word signifies both shall conceive and bear a son and shall call his name Immanuel Butter and hony shall he eate that he may know to refuse the evil and chuse the good for before the child shall know to refuse the evil and chuse the good the land that thou abhorrest shall be forsaken of both her Kings Here you may please to observe these things with us First That though this place be commonly understood of our Saviour yet it is a great mistake for his proper name was Jesus and not Immanuel Secondly This child was to be born shortly after this prophecy and is given to the Jewes as a sign and token of a sudden deliverance from Rezin and Remaliah before the child should be of age and knowledge to refuse the evil and chuse the good And thirdly The prophet in the next Chap. triumphing against the enemies of the Church alludes to this very name as if the child were then in being Isa 8.10 saying Take counsel together and it shall come to nough speak the word and it shall not stand for God is with us Where it is in the original Immanuel The second thing to be observed is that this child even from iâ—s insancy according to the common state of mankind should have the knowledge and ability to refuse the evil and chuse the good a faculty spoken of in two verses together as before But to come to your third Section where our main contest begins Besides a mistake in the very first entrance Man that is fallen into sin being by you taken for all mankinde no smal mistake as we have proved before You are first defective in that you distinguish not of the different states of sin And secondly to maintain that which is true in it self viz. that the faln man cannot without preventing grace by his own strength convert himself or haply prepare himself thereunto you lay such grounds as are either false or at leastwise improper of which anon But first you speak of a state of sin into which man is faln as though there were but one such whereas there is a manifold state in sin one against God the Father another against the Son and a third against the holy Ghost Mat. 12.32 There is a state of sin before regeneration and another under grace Rom. 7.9 14. there is a state of sin before mans first conversion and another after their final falling away 2 Pet. 2.21 22. as there is a threefold degree of righteousness and grace wherein some are Babes some youngmen and some old men so there is a threefold state or age in sin So the Lord saith to Abraham Gen. 15.16 That the iniquity of the Amorites is not yet full and complaines Jer. 9.3 That the sinners proceeded from evil to worse finally there is a sin unto death and a sin which is not unto death 1 John 5.16 Now the false grounds aforesaid which you lay for the establishing of a truth are these That the faln man hath lost all ability of wil to any spiritual good accompanying salvation That a natural man is altogether averse from from any such good The ground that you here improperly apply is That the man is dead in sin For the first of these t is a rash and ungrounded asseveration for you will not deny That to become a Christian to have our wicked thoughts forgiven us to hear the word preached to eat and drink at Christs table to keep the commandements of the second Table as they are commonly called and finally to dye the death of the righteous are all of them spiritual good things and such as accompany salvation But we finde all these things wished for and desired by those which you count unregerate for King Agrippa hearing Saint Pauls defence had more then a velleity some good measure of inclination to become a Christian Act. 26.28 Simon Meâ—us entreated the Apostles to pray for him that his wicked thoughts might be pardoned and that none of the evils they had spoken of might happen unto him to hinder his salvation Act. 8.24 Our Saviour tels us Luk. 13.26 That many will plead before him at the latter day that they had heard him teaching in their streets and had eaten and drunke at his table The young man who enquired of our Saviour what good thing he should do to inherit eternal life had from his youth kept the precepts of the second table aforesaid Mat. 19.20 Yea our Saviour looked upon him and loved him on that behalf Mar. 10.21 Finaily Balaam desired to dye the death of the righteous and that his latter end might be like his Num. 23.10 For the second ground that the natural man is altogether averse from any thing that is good it is alike erroneous with the former whether we take a natural man for the earthly man as he is still created of God in innocency or for the faln man in his unregenerate estate as you mean For in the first notion the natural man can both will and act according to his first integrity till he disables and corrupts himself by falling as Esau or Edom a type of this man did seek to please and observe his father And you may remember that the Apostle would have us in malice and naughtiness to be like children 1 Cor. 14.20 But many natural men taken in your own sense are not utterly averse from all good things even Herod himself heard John the Baptist gladly and not only willed but did many things according to his Doctrine and precepts Mark 6.20 And Moses having set before all Israel life and blessing with death and cursing Deut 30.19 he there expresly commands them to chuse life That both they and their seed might liâ—â— Isa chap. 1.19 20 elicites and excites this freewilling faculty saying If ye be willing and obedient ye shall eat the good of the land but if ye refuse and rebel ye shall be devonred by the sword for the mouth of the Lord hath spoken it Yea the very name of freewill offerings so oft mentioned in the Scriptures argues some competent remainder of that faculty unless ye would subjectum tollere but consider we pray you these two things which we have partly touched before First That all faln men are not alike extensively corrupted that is they are not all alike enclined to all fins but some to voluptuousness and prodigality more then to covetousness or the like And though David a King prayeth thus against covetousness Encline my heart to thy Testimo nies and not to covetousness Psal 119.36 Yet Luther saith That he was never tempted to that sin Whence it will necessarily follow that such a man is not equally averse to all good but to
perverseness he saith But none that is very few of the stubborne ones saith where is God my maker who giveth songs in the night Who teacheth us all mankinde more then the beasts of the earth and maketh us Wiser then the foul of Heaven How can the wicked say to the almighty Job 21.11.22 17. depart frou us we desire not the knowledge of thy wayes if he were not present with them at times teaching rebuking drawing and calling them that he might turn them to him yea with their wills from their wiked and destructive wayes doth not wisdom utter her voice to all the fallen race of mankinde Prov 8.4 5. Unto you O men I call and my voice is to the sons of men O ye simple understand wisdom and ye fools be ye of an understanding heart yea is not her invitation as universal and particular also Prov. 9.4 11. as the call and seductive allurements of folly is verse 16. for each of them useth the self-same words Whoso is simple let him turn in hither c. yea what is the true cause that wisdome saith Prov. 1.28 29. Then shall they call upon me but I will not answer they shall seek me early but they shall not finde me But this which followeth there verse 29 30 31. For that they bated knowledge and did not chuse the fear of the Lord They would none of my counsel they despised all my repreof Thus of our first assertion come we now to the second That some of those which stand out are more earnestly and industriously called by the Lord then many true converts which continue stedfast with the Lord for which purpose take these places First Gods gracious and effectual dealing with Cain when his wrath and envy was kindled against his brother What could the Lord without offering violence to his will do more to him then he did saying Gen. 4.6.7 Why art thou wrath And why is thy countenance fallen If thou dost well shalt thou not be accepted and if thou dost not well sin lieth at the door And then it follows as one both judicious and skilful in the original hath it Idque a te pendebit tuque ei imperabis And in thee shall be the will or desire of it and thou shalt have dominion over it viz. if thou wilt seek that grace Did not the Lord also complain that he had striven with the men of the old world till he was weary again Gen. 6.3 And the Lord said my spirit shall not alwayes strive with man for that be also is flesh yea were not their spirits or human souls cast into the prison of Hell for their disobedience and refractoriness 1 Pet. 3.19 20 doth not the Lord say also Isa 5.4 What could have been done more to my vineyard which I have not done unto it Wherefore when I looked that it should bring forth grapes brought it forth wild grapes you will say Is not God almighty Could he not have compelled them Answer Yes but he will not violate the order which he hath set in our creation he will not force the will but deals with man as a free agent by commands promises threatnings rebukes chastisements allurements and rewards So true is that of the Father Nemo invitus fit bonus To conclude this point what can be more express then those three ensuing texts among many others Ezek. 3.6 7. Thou are not sent to many people of a strange speech and of an hard language whose words thou canst not understand Surely had I sent thee to them they would have hearkened unto thee but the house of Israel will not hearken unto thee c. Matth. 11.21 Woe unto thee Chorazin woe unto thee Bethsaida for if the mighty works which were done in thee had been done in Tyre ond Sidon they would have repented long ago in sackcloth and ashes Of which text we spake before upon the last occasion Finally That of Matth. 12.21 brings full conviction with it The men of Niuive shall rise in judgement with this generation and condemn it because they repented at the preaching of Jonah and behold a greater then Jonah is here If you demand here what 's the cause that these obstinate men do not answer Gods call and return We answer It is not want of illumination and instruction as we have shewed nor want of reproof as we have proved but this let lies in mens abuse of their free-will as we heard before Prov. â— 29 30. Not that mens wils are inflexible when God first cals them as we have evicted at large in the foregoing chapter but some men are self wise and self-righteous already through the illusion of Satan and think that they need no repentance or conversion to any better thing aâ— the Scribes and Pharisees were in the daies of our Saviour who taught them with power and authority Matth 7.29 and whose doctrine was confirmed sufficiently by miracles also And others which know and acknowledge that they are evil doers yet do defer their return till it be too late as Prov. 1.28 29. Psal 32.6 aforesaid Hence it is that they shall be filled with weeping and mourning for the opportunity which they have lost as the other shall be with envy and gnashing of teeth the concomitant of pride and self-wisdom Matth. 8.12 Luke 13.25 26 27 28. And these are Satans two wayes of destroying men he either casts them into the sin of contention wrath and envy through the riches of their self knowledge self-holiness and self zeal or into the stolen and pleasant waters of voluptuousness or worldly cares therein detaining them till they be drowned in sensuality see Mark 9.22 But now to return to our first task back again The third falshood which you affirm in you first Section is That God calleth all his predestinate only by his Word and Spirit where we must grant you that his Spirit is alwayes the cheif actor and that oft times God is pleased to use his word whether written or spoken as an instrument in that work but not alwayes as yourselves after confess Section the third Besides the Lord hath many other instruments and means to call and convert men besides his word as Elihu shews at large Joh. 33.14 29. of which also we speak before Yet are none more general or more effectual then Gods chastisments both inward and outward Psal 94.10 He that chashseth the Heathen shall not he correct Psal 119 67. Before I was afflicted I went astray but now have I kept thy word For whomsoever God loveth as he loveth all mankinde he chasteneth and scourgeth every son whom be receiveth Heb. 12.6 7 8 9 10. see Job 5.17 Behold happy is the man whom God correcteth therefore despise not thou the chasining of the Almighty Pro. 3.11.12 Psal 94.12 13. Isa 27.7 8 9. Isa 9.13 Isa 28.23 24 25 c. 38.16 By this was Pharaoh wrought to obey the will of God for the present though he afterwards rebelled and perished If this will not
bow us we are incorrigible and deplorate Isa 1.5 6. Isa 9.13 yea and are sure to perish in the end Prov. 29.1 He that being often reproved hardneth hss neck shall suddenly be destroyed and that without remedy Other means are named and commended unto us in the word which shall work upon some when the word will not As the good conversation of the wife towards an unbelieving husband or disobedient to the word 1 Pet. 3.1 2. But Gods most usual and powerful way of converting sinners is by his spirit and severe chastisements those especially upon mens consciences which we elsewhere call the work of the Law though ofttimes wrought without the written Law or Word of which the Psalmist speaks Psal 94 13. A fourth mistake of yours there is That you say all men are by nature in the state of sin and death For we have already proved that to be false And doth not the Apostle say Rom. 2.27 That if the uncircumcision which is by nature fulfil the Law taking it for granted that some may do so he shall judge thee who by the letter and circumcision dost transgress the Law True it is that the word nature is not always taken in one notion by the Apostle himself but as by nature here he understands a state of men without the written word so by nature Ephes 2.3 where he saith that we were by nature the children of wrath as well as others he intends either corrupt nature or a reality of the thing as Gal. 4.8 you did service to them which by nature are no Gods that is not really such 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 for 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 A fifth errour of yours in that Section is that you say God in this his effectual calling of men determines the will to that which is good wherein as we said before he should overthrow that course and order which himself hath set up making us free Agents and leaving our wills free and interminate Yet we grant that the Lord bowes and inclines the wils of men from evil to good by illumination in the understanding and working upon the judgement as we said before but he laies no violent hands upon the will immediately Finally you have other mistakes in the first Section also as when you say that God in his effectual calling of men takes away the stony heart and gives them an heart of flesh for that is not wholly done in our first conversion but in process of time by our cleansing from sin and renewing in Jesus Christ according to the Covenant Ezek 36.25 26 27. Nor are all converts brought to Jesus Christ at the first as you here dream for the father hath his work of regeneration upon us ere we are brought to know or beleeve on the Son for his worke of spiritual redemption which is the second step or degree of our regeneration as we shew in the sequel of this tractate Yea whosoever resists the father in his work or doth not continue in it he is not brought by the father to the son to be saved by him from sin and Satan John 6.44 Nor is your second Section so sound or Orthodox in all points as we could wish it For you say there but not truly That he who is called of God is altogether passive until quickned and renewed by the holy Ghost For though in the works of illumination correction and reproof he is passive yet afterward in the turning of his will and desires to God and goodness he is active as the Apostle speaks 1 Thes 2.19 For they themselves shew of us what mannor of entrance we bad unto you and how ye turned to God from Idols to serve the living and true God So Acts 11.21 And the hand of the Lord was with them and a great many beleeved and turned to the Lord. Wherefore doth the Lord require this motion at our hands so often if we cannot turn after inlightning and convincing grace Ezek. 18 30. Wherefore repent ye and turn ye from all your transgressions and verse 32. Wherefore turn ye and live see Eze. 33.11 Joe 2.12 13 14 c. In your third Section you abate something of your wonted rigour in saying That all other elected persons besides infants who are uncapable of being outwardly called by the ministry of the word are regenerated and saved by Christ through the Spirit who worketh when and where and how he pleaseth If you grant then that there is an elect people among all nations as John saw an infinite or innumerable company of such standing before the throne of God and before the Lamb cloathed with white rober and palms in their hands Re. 7.9 you have here yeilded that they may be called without the ordinary means of the word and this is no other thing in effect then what ye have here maintained For if the Lord could do this in Elihu Job Rahab the widow of Zarephta and Paul all which were converted without the word what hindereth but that he can do the like all over the world in all ages and generations of mankinde if they obstruct not his working In this Section we pass over that which you spake in the beginning of it concerning elect infants because we know no other sort of infants And that such need no regeneration we have shewed before In your fourth and last Section you have heaped up together many untruths as these by name First That there are some persons that are not elected which being understood of a special and final election is true but being taken of Gods general and conditional election is false as before Secondly You say That such as are not elected and so not saved though they may be called by the ministry of the word yet they receive onely the common operations of the spirit It is most certain that many who are not finally elected and saved besider a true and effectual calling vouchsafed from the father have in some measure received a true faith bringing forth repentance for a time a true love turning them to God and bringing forth a temporary obedience a true hope which brought forth patience yea and some proportion of purifying and sanctfying grace as is evident out of these Scriptures and others 1 Tim. 1.19 and chapt 5.12 and chapt 6.10 Heb. 6.4 5 6. and chapt 10.28 29. 2 Pet. 2.20 21 22. Thirdly You say That such never came truly unto Christ and therefore cannot be saved where it is true that such can never be saved from the power of their spiritual enemies who never came to Christ nor Christ to them yet many of them which were never chosen out of the furnace nor in the end partake of eternal life yet were brought for a time both to beleeve in Christ and in some measure to obey him who yet afterward fel from him and lost all that which they had wrought with their future hopes of which number were those apostate Disciples of Christ mentioned John 6.66 with Judas Demas
further recite in this Chapter must be necessarily thus understood to wit conditionally of those that are but inchoatively adopted and absolutely of such onely as have accomplished the conditions of the premises And therefore you have here adopted many errours for truth though you have spoken some truth also at unawares as That all those that are justified God vouchsafeth in and for his onely Son Jesus Christ to make partakers of the grace of Adoption This is most true of those whom God hath justified in our sense that is purged from all corruption by the blood and spirit of Jesus Christ for such and such onely are absolutely and finally adopted and enjoy all the liberties and prerogatives here by you set forth But if you here understand initiated adoption it precedes justification taken both in your sense and ours and so your affirmation is erroneous It is true also that all they who are adopted in any measure are taken into the number of Gods Children for the present but the younger and weaker sort may by their unthankfulness for so great a grace by their future rebellions and Apostacy be abdicated and cast off for ever 1 Chronicles 28.9 Romans 11.22 Behold therefore the goodness and severity of God on them that fell severity but toward thee goodness if thou continue in his goodness otherwise thou shalt be cut off Deuteronomy 32.19 When the Lord saw it he abhorred them because of the provoking of his sons and daughters Thus the Lord maketh all the regenerate partakers of the grace of conditional adoption but onely the third sort of final adoption yet all these are protected by the Father and provided for as children while they continue children but not otherwise all likewise have access to the throne of grace which is Christ Jesus who are brought to know him and beleeve in his name and who persist in that their faith and in good will but none other neither they which yet know him not nor such as by apostacy crucifie him afresh Acts 6.6 Hebrews 10.27 28 29. Wherefore Let all those who are incoatively adopted bless God for that estate and rejoyce in it Galatians 4.6 And because ye are sons God hath sent forth the spirit of his Son whereby ye cry Abba Father 1 John 3.1 Behold what manner of love the Father hath bestowed upon us that we should be called the sons of God Yet let us remember it is but a conditional estate at the first and a long time after Rom. 8.15 16.17 For ye have not received the spirit of bondage to fear again but the spirit of adoption whereby ye cry Abba Father The spirit it self beareth witness with our spirits that we are the the children of God and if children then heirs heirs of God and joynt heirs with Christ if so be that we suffer with him that we may also be glorified with him And to the end that we may obtain a final and absolute adoption â—et us fulfil the condition thereunto required 2 Corinthians 6.17 1â— Wherefore come ye out from among them and be ye separate saith the Lâ—â—d and touch not the unclean thing and I will receive you and I will be a father unto you and 〈◊〉 shall be my sonnes and daughters saith the Lord Almighty See also what the Apostle infers thereupon 2 Corinthians 7.1 2 Having therefore these promises my beloved let us cleanse our selves from all filthiness of the flesh and spirit perfecting our holiness in the fear of God CHAP. XIII Of sanctification THEY that are effectually called and regenerated having a new heart and a new spirit created in them are further sanctified really and personally through the vertue of Christs death and resurrection a 1 Cor 6.11 Acts 20.32 Phil 3.10 Ro 6.5 6. by his Word and Spirit dwelling in them b Joh 17.17 Eph 5.26 2 Thes 2.13 the dominion of the whole body of sin is destroyed c Rom 6.6.13 and the several lusts thereof are more and more weakned and mortified d Gal 5.24 Rom 8.13 and they more and more quickned and strengthened in all saving graces e Col 1.11 Eph 3.16 17 18. to the practice of true holiness without which no man shall see the Lord f 2 Cor 7.1 Heb 12.13 II. This sanctification is throughout in the whole man g 1 Thes 5.23 yet imperfect in this life there abideth still some remnants of corruption in every part h 1 Joh 1.10 Rom 7.18 23. Phil 3.12 whence ariseth a continual and irreconcileable War the flesh lusting against the spirit and the spirit against the flesh i Gal 5.17 1 Pet 2.11 III. In which war although the remaining corruption for a time may much prevail k Rom 7.23 yet through the continual supply of strength from the sanctifying Spirit of Christ the regenerate part doth overcome l Ro 6.14 1 Joh 5.4 Eph 5.4 16. and so the Saints grow in grace m 2 Pet 3.18 perfecting holiness in the fear of God n 2 Cor 7.1 CHAP. XIII Of Sanctification examined HAving already spoken of Justification this whole Chapter of sanctification which is but the Christening of the same thing with a new name as we have shewed before might have been superseded and as the whole discourse is superfluous so many of your erroneous and unsanctified assertions such as those which follow might profitably have been omitted As first where you say in the first Section That all they who are effectually called and regenerated have a new heart and a new spirit created in them whereas many are called and that earnestly and effectually on the Lords part as we have shewed â—lready who admitt of no change of will and affections through their own obstinacy and though all that are truly changed receive at the first a new frame of heart will and disposition yet they do not by and by receive a new heart and a new Spirit in the sense of the holy Prophets for Ezekiel shewes That not onely clean water must be poured down upon us but that we must be cleansed from all our filthiness and abomination before we can have a new heart and a new spirit created in us nor is the stony heart wholly taken from us and an heart of flesh wholly given unto us till then But this is the peculiar estate of such Saints or sanctified ones as have attained the third and last degree of regeneration when Christ according to the spirit is risen up in them as we shewed before See Ezek. 36.25 26. Of these the Apostle speaks 2 Cor. 5.17 Old things are passed away behold all things are become new See Revel 21.3 4 5 of those to whom the new Jerusalem is come Secondly whereas you say That such persons are sanctified through the vertue of Christs death it is another great mistake for though the vertue of his death is great and of inestimable value to take away the guilt of sin and remove the curse from us
the holy Ghost Thus speaks our Saviour to Peter when he had through faith confessed him to be the Son of God Matth. 16.19 Blessed art thou Bar-Jonah for flesh and blood hath not revealed this unto thee but my Father which is in Heaven It is the Father that must draw us unto the Son to seek and expect redemption internal and external from him John 6.44 45 46. Christ indeed is called 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Heb. 12.1 2. That is He is the first Captain and Ring-leader of ouâ— faith for he is gone before us in the same way of trust and confidence to be holpen by the Father in all his distresses and raised up again after he had been obedient to the death And secondly He is the fulfiller of our faith or of that which we by our like faith while we follow him in the same race expect from him according to the promises But whether the first word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 be well translated Author That be is the Author of our Faith except it be understood of his joynt working with the Father and the Holy Ghost we will leave the learned to judge for our selves dissent That also which follows in the same Section must be understood of such a ministry as is called and enabled by the Lord for that work and of prayer made with understanding and affection for the increase of that grace where you say That Faith is ordinarily wrought by the ministry of the word by which also and by the administration of the Sacraments and prayer it is increased and strengthened for such Ministers as teach vain Doctrine and administer the Sacraments with ignorance and errour beget an answerable faith and perswasion in their hearers who give ear and credit unto them as your Authors and Teachers have done in some of you but this must here also be remembred that the Lord can and often doth when and where he pleaseth beget faith even faith in Jesus Christ by the sole illumination and teaching of the holy Ghost as he did in Job among the Heathen Job 19.25 26. and in Paul among the Jewes Gal. 1.15 16. For to one is given by the Spirit the word of wisdom and to another the word of knowledge by the same Spirit to another faith by the same Spirit 1 Cor. 12.8 9. And for this work sake he is called the Spirit of faith 2 Cor. 4.13 In your 2. Section you confirm what we said before of historical faith that it is an ingredient into true saving faith where you say ' By this a Christian beleeveth to be true whatsoever is revealed in the word you mean so far as men are enlightned to the understanding of it otherwise there is more repeated in the word then most men do or can understand while they are in the state of Faith but here you should have added this also to your former words that the servantâ— of God beleeve also whatsoever God is pleased to reveale unto them besides the word which yet is not contrary to the word Thus Paul beleeved that which God had shewed unto him concerning the preservation of himself and those that were with him in the ship Acts 27.25 And St. John gave respect and credit unto all that was shewed unto him in the Revelation where by the way you may observe how God is the Author of Faith to wit by revealing his saving counsel and will unto us which by nature and much more in our corrupt estate we are in a great measure ignorant of And how far faith lies in our own hand and power viz. onely to assent unto that which is so revealed and made known out of grace Thus there is an assenting or dissenting faculty in all men See Acts 9.29 Psalm 106 12. Then beleeved they his word and sang his praise with verse 24. Yea They despised the pleasant Land they beleeved not his Word Acts 17.4 And some of them beleeved and consorted with Paul and Silas verse 5. But the Jewes which beleeved not were moved mith envy c. John 3.32 33. And what be hath seen and heard that he testifieth and no man receiveth his testimony be that receiveth his testimony hath set to his seal that God is true And accordingly as men stand affected to the person reporting or the thing revealed so are they apt to credit or discredit the same Facilè eâ—im credimus quae volumus c. è contrà Hence it was that some persons who were wel inclined to the leaving of sin and the seeking of righteousness and consequently in a good order and posture towards eternal life did easily and joyfully receive the word preached by Paul and Barnabas when others who were more engaged to their sins self-wisdom and false righteousness beleeved not but contradicted and blasphemed Acts 13.44 45 â—6 c. Hence it is also that after Gods grace was made known unto men they were commanded to repent and believe the Gospel Mar. 1.15 And that others are complained of for their unbelief Hebrews 4.2 For unto us was the Gospel preached as well as unto them but the word preached did not profit them being not mixed with faith in them that heard it For the Lord never requires more then either by his preventing or assisting grace men can perform nor yet complaines of them but where they are some wayes deficient in acting their part Secondly What you there speak of faith's different actings in relation to the commands promises and threatnings recorded in the word is true also as to the inhibitions and narrations found there but herein you are defective First in not declaring by what form or vital principle faith becomes so active to wit by love Gallatians 5.6 Without which faith is dead James 2.14 15 16 17. And secondly In passing over the acts and offices of faith in God the Father and of faith in the Holy Ghost both which have an eye to sanctification and eternal life as well as faith in Christ though this last named seeks that which we called justification more especially from Christ But if Gods eternal decree be so absolute as you speak of before what need is there that saith should be moved with threatnings or promises For your third and last Section It may be wholly admitted with this caution That faith at length gets the victory and growes up to a full assurance if men persevere in love and obedience to God and fervently seek that victory and the assurance also from the Lord and his power But both time and the use of all good means are required thereunto and as faith is weak in its first beginning so when it hath gotten some strength yet by neglect of the means aforesaid and by wilful disobedience it may not onely be much weakned but wholy lost as we see in the parable of the Sower Matth. 13. Yea the Aposte tells not onely of women that had forsaken their first faith 1 Tim. 5.12 But of men also who by putting away
contradict your selves in other places yet you have here and there your illegalities and mistakes also in this Chapter In your first Section you truly say That God gave to Adam and all his Posterity such a Law and covenant of works as you describe with power and ability to keep it And is he not the same God still in wisdom mercy and justice requiring nothing at any mans hand but what he will enable him to doe by his preventing or assisting grace if hee seek it In your second Section you say and that truly That the Law given to Adam being the same in effect with the Moral Law delivered upon mount Sinai continued to be a perfect rule of Righteousnesse Nor must the Israel of God think to obtrude upon the Lord any other acceptable righteousnesse for ever then is therein required and described Deut. 6.24 25. And the Lord commanded us to doe all these statutes to fear the Lord our God for our good alwayes that he might preserve us alive as it is this day And it shall be our righteousness if we observe to doe all these Commandments before The Lord our God as he hath commanded us Psalm 119.144 the righteousnesse of his testimonies is everlasting For the performing of which righteousnesse because it was become impossible to the fallen Man Christ is freely bestowed upon us Rom. 8.3 4. And so it is the end and drift of the law to send us unto Christ to seek our power wisdom and righteousnes from him Rom. 10.4 Gal. 3.22 23 24. But whereas you say in the end of that Section That the four first Commandments contain our duty toward God and the six last our duty to Man Perhaps it will prove a distribution more common then sound For as the whole Law is spirituall Rom. 7.14 so it seems first to require duty toward God in all the ten Commandments and then to call for Service toward men in the second place For the first four Commandments which St Augustine and some of the Ancients reduce to three only your selves doe not deny it Let us then take a view of the rest Doth not the fifth Commandment enjoyn us first of all to honour our heavenly Father and the Wisdom or Hierusalem from above our spirituall Mother 1 Sam. 2.20 For them that honour me I will honour Mal. 1.6 If I then be a Father where is mine honour Matth. 11.19 But Wisdome is justified of her children so Luke 7.35 Gal. 4.26 But Jerusalem which is from above is free which is the Mother of us all Prov. 7.4 Say unto Wisdom thou art my Sister and call understanding thy Kinswoman Doth not the sixth Commandement forbid spiritual murther in the first place to wit the killing of Christ the quenching of the Spirit and the destroying of the inward messengers and motions Jam. 5.6 Ye have condemned and killed the just one and he resisteth you not Eph. 4.30 And grieve not the holy Spirit 1 Thess 5.19 Quench not the Spirit Thus the Apostles complaines of the Apostates that they crucifie afresh the Son of God and put him to an open shame Heb. 6.6 Doth not the seventh Commandement first prohibite spiritual whoredom against God Hos 4.15 Though thou Israel play the harlot yet let not Judah offend Jam. 4.4 Yee adulterers and adulteresses c. Doth not the eighth precept first restrain us from theft and robbery against God Malac. 3.8 Will a man rob God but ye have robbed me Rom. 2.22 Thou that abhorrest Idols dost thou commit sacriledge See Act. 12.22 in Herods example Doth not the ninth also first inhibit a false testimony against the Lord Jeremy 5.12 They have belyed the Lord and said it is not he 1 Cor. 15.15 Yea and we are found false witnesses of God c. Yea though the tenth commandement may seem to lay restraint upon us only in the behalf of our neighbor yet who hath so neer vicinity to us as God in whom we live move and have our being so that not only an open these against him in taking that which belongs to him as Achon did but even to assume or once desire that which belongs unto the Lord is impious as we see in Herod who took and consequently affected the glory that was due to God Acts 12.22 23. Nor doth the Lord want a house Isa 56.7 Mat. 21.12 13 14. Nor is he destitute of a wife Ezek. 16.8 And I sware unto thee and entered into a Covenant with thee saith the Lord and thou becamest mine See Re. 2. or of men servants and maid servants Psa 116.16 Truly O Lord I am thy servant and the son of thine handmaid Nor is he without his Oxen and Asses 2 Cor. 9.10 Mat. 21.1 2 3 4 5. which if they be alienated from him in our desires it is a sin of concupiscence-against the last Commandement So that it is most true in this regard which Saint James speaks chap. 2.10 For whosoever shall keep the whole low and yet offendeth in one point is guilty of all for any one sin against God breaks all the Commandements It is Idolatry witcheraft murther adultery c. 1 Samuel 5.15.23 And as the six last first oppose sin against God so the four first in the second place restrain sins against man Thus we may not impose a false God upon our neighbor nor set up a false worship before him nor swear falsly to his hurt nor by prophaning the Lords Sabbath or everlasting rest before our neighbor insnare his soul And what we speak of the negativepart is true of the affirmative or possitive throughout all the Commandements so that the great duty of love to God and our neighbor seems to run through the veins of every Commandement And as these two are inseperable in the new creature so the whole Law by the Apostles own Testimony is fulfilled in this one Commandement Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thy self Rom. 13.8 Gal. 5.14 which cannot hold true except the Lord be our first neighbor who is to be loved in the first place and surely if we should not offer that wrong to God which we would not admit were we in his stead we should not sin as we do In your third Section you set not forth the whole extent of the Ceremonial Law which was to represent Christs inward death and sufferings as well as his outward He being the Lamb slain in us from the foundation of the world Rev. 13.8 and to be a document unto us shewing how we must follow him unto eternal life Howbeit you seem to go too far in saying It is wholly abrogated now under the new Testament for though the costly and burthensome yoke thereof is taken from the Gentiles yet some part of it by the words of the Prophets may remaine in use among the Jews after their calling and restauration Isa 66.23 And it shall come to pass that from one new moon to another and from one Sabbath to another shall all flesh come to worship before
of his spiritual ordinances epecially and these are first the commandments of the morall Law and then his other precepâ— subservient thereunto as the Scripture every where cals them Gods ordinances 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Exod. 18.20 2 Kings 11.37 but not of the preaching of mans doctrine the administring the Sacraments not without ignorance perhaps some superstition and confusion as you often do and which you account to be the main if not the only ordinances of God Thus we fear that will finde you guilty of which the Prophet complaines Isa 24.5 The earth is defiled under the inhabitants thereof because they have transgressed the Laws changed the orâ—iâ—ancâ—â— broken the everlasting Covenant c. For what ordinances do you speak of to the people but of your way of preaching and administring the Sacraments c. In your Directory for worship you have omitted the ten Commandements Gods principal ordinances but highly magnified your kinde of preaching which hath more of art then of the spiritual gift of Prophecy in it your keeping of an outward day in every week holy with your self chosen worship and other meer humane â—rdinances Is not this to change the ordinances as Isaiah speakes In your fourth which is your last Section You first set out the respective duties of Subjects to Magistrates well and truly Secondly you rightly affirm That neither difference in religion no nor Infidelity it self do make void the Magistrates just and legal authority nor free the people from their due obedience to him If Infidelity it self cannot do this what other thing can Yet it must be granted that when Magistrates are esective and chosen conditionally the breaking of a fundamental condition may disanull his place and claim Thirdly you say here That Ecclesiastical persons are not exempted from their obedience which is but true in part in regard of civil honor obedience and all needful assistance especially where the Magistrate is no more but civil But in matters of faith salvation and damnation the consciences not only of Ecclesiastical persons as you call them but of laicks themselves are exempted from his tyranny and force therein they are only the subjects of Christ Yea in these things some persons may have authority over the Magistrate himself in the Lord though that Magistrate be a Christian also to wit such persons as are inspired and sent of God to be his mouth as Naâ—han and Gâ—d were to David and John Baptist was to Herod and diverse other Prophets were to their respective Princes and Governors Lastly you justly shut out the Pope and his jurisdiction from us as those which have taken the oath of supremacy but here you are too general in your affirmatives for want of due distinction or limitation for in some parts of Italy which are the Popes inheritance he hath power and authority over his subordinate officers and the people as other Princes have and may justly deprive those that are under him of dominions and lives when they break such capital Laws as deserve death confiscation and disinheriting but he may not do this to forraign Princes and States nor to their people who are not under his lawful jurisdiction whether upon the pretence of heresie or any other like pretext Yet some Papists are confident of this that now you have deprived the Pope of his deprivative authority over Princes you will assume it to your selvs or bestow it upon your friends when and where you think good to serve your own turns CHAP. XXIV Of Marriage and Divorce MArriage is to be between one man and one woman neither is it lawful for any man to have more then one wife nor for any woman to have more then one husband at the same time a Gen 2.24 Mat 1.19 56. Prov 2.17 II. Marriage was ordained for the mutual help of husband and wife b Gen 2.18 for the increase of mankind with a legimiate issue and of the Church with an holy seed c Mal 2.15 and for preventing of uncleanness d 1 Cor 7.2 9. III. It is lawful for all sorts of people to marry who are able with judgement to give their consent e Heb. 13.4 1 Tim 4.3 1 Cor 7.36 37. Ge 24.57 58. yet it is the duty of Christians to marry only in the Lord f 1 Cor 7.39 and therefore such as profess the true reformed Religion should not marry with Infidels Papists or other Idolaters neither should such as are godly be unequally yoked by marrying with such as be notoriously wicked in their life or maintaine damnable heresies g Gen 34 14. Exod 34.16 Deu. 7.3 14. 1 Kin 11.4 Neh 13.25 26 27. Mal 2 11 12. 2 Cor 6.14 IV. Marriage ought not to be within the degrees of consanguinity or affinity forbidden in the word h Lev 18 c. 1 Cor 5.2 Am 2.7 nor can such incestuous marriages ever he made lawful by any law of man or consent of parties so as those persons may live together as man and wife i Mar 6.28 Levit 18.23 25 26 27 28. The man may not marry any of his wives kindred nearer in blood then he may of his own nor the woman of her husbands kindred â—eerer in blood then of her own k Lev 20.19 20 21. V. Adultery or fornication committed after a contract being detected before marriage giveth just occasion to the innocent party to dissolve that contract l Mat â— 18 19 20. in the case of adultery after marriage it is lawful for the innocent party to sue out a divorce m Mat 5.31 32 and after the divorce to marry another as if the offending party was dead n Mat 19.9 Rom 7.2 3 VI. Although the corruption of man be such as is apt to study arguments unduely to put asunder those whom God hath joyned together in marriage yet nothing but adultery or such wilful desertion as can no way be remedied by the Church or civil Magistrate is cause sufficient of dissolving the bond of marriage o Mat 19 8 9 1 Cor 7 15 Mat 19 6 wherein a publike and orderly course of proceeding is to be observed and the persons concerned in it not left to their own wils and discretion in their own tase p Deu 14 1 2 3 4 CHAP. XXIV Of Marriage and Divorce examined IN this tract of marriage and divorce the path is so trite that it is no wonder if you deviate not as you have done hitherto yet are you sufficiently deficient in many things and in some other mistaken here also Your defects are these among others First since those that marry shall have trouble in the flesh as Saint Paul speaketh 1 Cor. 7.28 and marrying brings with it of necessity many avocations lets and distractions from attending upon Gods service and the seeking of his kingdom 1 Cor. 7.32 33 34. you might very seasonably in these calamitous times wherein the people like the generation before the flood are mad upon
marrying have shewed that as omnia prius tentanda quam belle expertendum so all means should be used first to get the gift of continency before people incurre the wants cares burthens sorrows and distractions of the marriage yoke Secondly since our first parents were not joyned together till both were settled in the Image of God that the Lord might have a godly seed upon earth Mal. 2.15 you might have declared that not only maturity of judgement but that grace and regeneration especially in the Church of God is first to be sought before an husband or wife that they may live in the fear of God together and bring up their seed in that fear Thirdly you speak nothing of the advise and consent which children should ask of their wife and godly parents and guarcians before they dispose of themselves in marriage Fourthly in setting forth the ends why marriage was Instituted you have omitted the maine which the old rejected Liturgy did not forge to wit that it was ordained for a figure and representation of the mistical union betwixt Christ and his Church and that therein it is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 a great mystery a kinde of Sacrament of which hereafter Fifthly you are silent concerning the reciprocall duties of the marryed persons such as cohabitation 1 Pet. 3.7 mutual benevolence 1 Cor. 7.2 3. of abstinence sometimes either by consent 1 Cor. 7.5 or by injunction from the Lord Levit. 18.19 nor do you set forth either the duties of husbands to their wives or of wives toward their husbands in their specials or particulars Lastly you set not forth this That persons may commit spiritual adultery against God even in marrying while their hearts are more set upon the pleasures of carnall copulation then upon spiritual communion with God The mistakes which we would represent unto you are these First you say That those which profess the true reformed Religion should not marry with Infidels where we desire your advised resolution to these two things since there are several Religions each by their own respective professors accounted the true reformed Religion which of these will you pitch upon Lutheran Calvinistical Socinian Attainian the English formerly established by law all which are different To say nothing of the subordinate Sects of Antinomians Seperatists Anchaptists Independants Levellers Illuminates Ranters or Gods of Godmanchester with their adherents Secondly wherein doth he that professeth the reformed Religion and yet is in the state of unregeneracy and unbelief yea perhaps of a most profane heart and life deserve so well that he may not marry with an Infidel many of the Heathen whom you account infidels being men of better life and more truly conscientious though they know not Christ in the flesh then thousands that are called Christians and living in the Cities and Countries of the reformed as you call them Secondly you say That such professors of the true reformed Religion may not intermarry with Papists Why we pray you Because the Lord reproves Judah for marrying the daughter of a strange god Mal. 2.11 But do not the Papists believe in the same God with the Protestants even in the Father the Son and the holy Ghost though they differ in some articles or branches of articles of their belief and in their way of worship Yea are not some of the Papists regenerate conscientious and vertuous persons If then the Protestant and Papists be both Saints or sanctified persons then they have both one Father in Heaven If they be both unregenerate the divel is yet father to them both But you will say that difference in judgment must needs breed alienation in affection disturbance in the service of God if not seducement We answer that first it is the similitude of natures and dispositions which conciliates love Secondly they may take one another upon those termes of not intermedling with each others Religion Thirdly why may there not be a toleration of different judgements in the family as well as in the Church or Commonwealth Lastly you say that those professors of the true reformed may not marry with any other Idolaters Do you mean any other Idolaters then themselves for all men till by regeneration they be brought to know God and serve the living God in his living righteousness are Idolaters Is not Satan the God of this world 2 Cor. 4.4 The Covetous man is an Idolater Eph. 5.5 So are they that make their belly their God Phil. 3.19 as some of the Clergy themselves do serving their own bellies and not the Lord Christ and the Apostle saith That they which cause divisious and offences are of that number Rom. 16.17 18. All that serve the pleasures and desires of the flesh more then God are Idolaters Eph 2.3 Tit. 3.3 may not the people make an Idol of Monarchy or some other Government of a King a Parliament of an Army or any other civil thing Yea may not a jealous people and religious in their way make an Idol of a Shepherd or teacher See Zac. 11.17 may they not make an Idol of an outward day as outward worship or the like but peradventure you can espie Idolatry no where but in the Mass or the worshiping of Saints or of Images made of wood stone gold silver c. if these Idolaters be so frequent ubiquitary where shal the professors of the reformed Religion marry and yet shun Idolatrous yoak fellows must they go out of the world as the Apostles speaks 1 Cor. 5.10 For those that worship the living God in spirit and truth are very rare persons though some such are to be found even among Jews Turks and Heathens CHAP. XXV Of the Visible Church THE Catholick or Vniversal Church which is invisible consists of the whole number of the Elect that have been are or shall be gathered into one under Christ the Head thereof and is the Spouse the Body the fulness of him that filleth all in all a Ephes 1. ◠10 22 23 Ephes 5.23 27 32. Col 1.18 II. The Visible Church which is the Catholick or Vniversal under the Gospel not confined to one Nation as before under the Law consists of all those throughout the World that profess the true Religion b 1 Cor 1.1 1 Cor 12.12 13. Psal 2.8 Rev 7.4 Ro 15.9 10 11 12. and of their children c 1 Cor 7 14. Acts 2.39 Ezek 16.20 21. Rom 10.16 Gen 3.15 Gen 17.7 and is the Kingdom of the Lord Jesus Christ d Mat 13 47 Isaiah 9.7 the House and Family of God e Thes 2.19 Thes 3 15. out of which there is no ordinary possibility of Salvation f Acts 2.47 III. Vnto this Catholick Visible Church Christ hath given the Ministery Oracles and Ordinances of God for the gathering and perfecting of the Saints in this life to the end of the World and doth by his own presence and spirit according to his promise make them effectual thereunto g 1 Cor 12.18 Eph 4.11.12
mystery of iniquity verse 7. that is such a work of iniquity and error as passeth man for wisdom truth and righteousness from above as many mens faith religion and zâ—al doth this day which yet is meer delusion and from the father of lies 12. That he is called 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the wicked one 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 which can be no other then he that is quite opposite to the righteous one even Christ and as Chirst is the first born of God so is this the first born and chief master piece of the divel transforming himself into an Angel of light 13. That his coming is not only with lying signes and wonders but with all deceivableness of unrighteness obtruding that for truth which is falshood commending that for vertue or holiness or righteousness which is iniquity and abomination before God verse 3.10 14. Out of the same verse it is clear that this Antichrist is an inward person agent or evil worker because it is said that he comes with all deceivableness of unrighteousness in them that perish 15. This Antichrist is fent by way of wrath and vengeance upon those that received not the love of the truth Lastly he is called in the next verse the strong delusions of Satan in making them to receive and believe lies For the other text Rev. 13.11.12 13 14 c. you may please to observe First That this beast the wisdom and holinesse of the flesh ariseth out of the earth or naturall man Secondly That he hath some semblance of the Lambe and two hornes with him with which he will seem to push against some sins of both Tables Thirdly That yet he speaks like the Dragon both against all that differ from him in opinion way and worship and especially against the true Saints of Christ Fourthly That he exerciseth all the power of the first beast which is voluptuousne ss or sensuality or the open iniquity for a false holiness retaines or entertaines a new the former corruptions which were in men without mortifying or resisting them to purpose and so the last beast which is the false wisdome and holiness aforesaid makes men to serve and worship the first beast which was the open or manifest iniquity in covetousness ambition sensuality c. Fifthly Though the former beast was wounded by repentance and reformation for a time and had one of his heads which is covetousness broken yet this makes him to live again in men and causeth an Image or the like resemblance to the first beast to be set up in man yea he gives life quickning and power unto it Thus also that first wicked beast bein in some measure wounded by Christ and his Apostles in the Primitive Church through the Apostacy of men and the errors and false holiness which crept in was healed and revived to the full yea his image hath been more and more worshipped to this day Sixthly That this hypocritical beast bringeth fire from heaven that is he kindles a fiery zeal in men for the maintaining of their own tenets and the opposing of others and their devotions and sacrifices are often filled with fervency as it were fire from Heaven Lastly He causeth al that hearken to him both bond and free rich and poor to receive a mark in their right hand or forehead which is unrighteousness it self or unfaithfulness in their dealings with God and men this is the grand mark of the old beast though one peculiar mark whereby this last beast is known is enviousness against others James 3.14 15. Thus brethren we have given you some hints of the true Antichrist it is for certain none of Satans least policy to divert our thoughts and eys from beholding this Antichrist within us and to incense us against our own flesh and blood the Pope or some other whom we are commanded to love as our selves Oh how invisible hath Satan and his first born within us passed while he hath directed and pointed us to a false and imagined Antichrist yea so far hath he bewitched many that they can find no Devil to declaim against but the Pope nor any kingdom of hell errors or wicked things to write or preach against but the doctrine ceremonies and practises of the Church of Rome be they right or wrong wherein notwithstanding many things are very faulty but not all that some men boggle at or ball against CHAP. XXVI Of the Communion of Saints ALl Saints that are united to Jesus Christ their head by his spirit and by faith have fellowship with him in his Graces sufferings death refurrection and glory a 1 Joh 1.2 Eph 3.1 16 17 18. Joh 1.16 Eph 2.5 6. Phil. 3.10 Ro 6.5 6. 2 Tim 2.12 and being united to one another in love they have communion in each others gifts and graces b Eph 4.15 16. 1 Cor. 12. y. 1 Cor 3.21 22 23 Col 2.19 and are obliged to the per formance of such publike and private duties as do conduce to their mutual good both in the inward and outward man c Thess 5.11 14. Ro 1.11 1â— 14. 1 Joh 3.16 17 18. Gal 6.10 II. Saints by profession are bound to maintain an holy fellowship and communion in the worship of God and in performing such other spiritual services as tend to their mutual edification d Heb 10.24 25. Act. 2.42 46. Isa 2.3 1 Cor 11.20 as also in relieving each other in outward things according to their several abilities and necessities which communion as God offereth opportunity is to be extended to all those who in every place call upon the name of the Lord Iesus e Act 2.44 45. 1 Joh 3.17 2 Cor 8.9 c. Act 11.29 30. III. This communion which the Saints have with Christ doth not make them in any wise partakers of the substance of his Godhead or to be equal with-Christ in any respect either of which to affirm is impious and blasphemous f Col 1.18 19. 1 Cor 8.6 Isa 42.8 1 Tim 6.15 16. Psa 45.7 with 8.9 nor doth their communion one with another as Saints take away or infringe the title or property which each man hath in his goods and possessions g Exo 20.15 Eph 4 28. Act 5.4 CHAP. XXVI Of the communion of Saints examined IN your two first Sections here you speak positively and in your last negatively of the communion of Saints where we hold faire correspondence wâ—th you in many things but not communion with you in all For first you distinguish not of the several ages formes or degrees of the Saints but joyning them altogether you rather bring in a confusion then a true communion of Saints And secondly you tumble duties and priviledges possibilities and possessions together For first as we said before there are 3 degrees of Saints First Saints in God the Father such as are only called and sanctified by him which was the common state of the Saints in the old Testament Deut. 33.3 1 Sam 2.9 See Psal 31.33
Covenant of grace a Ro 4.11 Ge 17.7.10 immediately instituted of God b Mat â—8 19 1 Cor 11. to represent Christ and his benefits to confirme our interest in him c 1 Cor 10 16. 1 Co 11.23 25 26. Gal 3 17. as also to put a visible difference between those that belong unto the Church and the rest of the world d Ro 15.8 Exo 12.48 Gen 34 14 and solemnly to engage them to the service of God in Christ according to his word e Ro 6.3.4 1 Cor 10.16.21 II. There is in every Sacrament a spiritual relation or sacramental vnion between the sign and the thing signified whence it comes to pass that the names and effects of the one are attributed to the other f Gen 27.10 Matth. 26.27 28. Titns 3.5 III. The grace which is exhibited in or by Sacraments rightly used is not conferred by any power in them neither doth the efficacy of a Sacrament depend upon the piety or intention of him that doth administer it g Rom 2.28 29. 1 Pet. 3.21 but upon the work of the Spirit h Mat. 3.11 1 Cor 12.13 and the word of institution which contains together with a precept an authorizing the use thereof a promise of benefit to worthy receives i Mat 26.27 28. Mat 28.19 20. IV. There be onely two Sacraments ordained by Christ our Lord in the Gospel that is to say Baptism and the Supper of the Lord neither of which may be dispensed of any but by a minister of the word lawfully ordained k Mat. 28.19 1 Cor. 11.20 23. 1 Cor 4.1 Heb 5.4 V. The Sacraments of the Old Testament in regard of the Spiritual things thereby signified and exhibited were for substance the same with those of the new l 1 Cor 10.1 2 3 4. CHAP. XXVII Of the Sacraments in General examined IN this your general Doctrine of the Sacraments you have in a general manner kept the road of truth though here and there you deviate following your misleading guides but first we allow you the retention and use of the word Sacrament though not found in the Scriptures because the thing thereby signifyed is frequent there and the term hath not onely been long retained in the Church but was at the first borrowed from a military oath obligeing the Souldier to obedience and faithfulness towards their general to express our like oligations to God and his Christ Then as to your several Sections we take no acceptions at all to your second but must crave leave to certifie you somewhat in most of the other As first in the first Section where you setting forth the ends of the Sacraments do put that in the last place which was the first and principal end of their institution that is solemnly to engage men to the service of God in Christ for it is evident that Circumcision was ordained for that end mainly Gen. 17.10 This is the Covenant which you shall keep between me and you and thy seed after thee that every man child among you shall be circumcised Deut. 10.16 Circumcise therefore the fore-skin of your heart and be no more stiff-necked Jer. 4.4 Circumcise your selves to the Lord and take away the fore skin of your bearts ye men of Judah and inhabitants of Jerusalem the like we finde written concerning the Passover Exod. 12.17 And ye shall observe the feast of unleavened bread for in this self-same day have I brought your armies out of the land of Egypt therefore shall ye observe this day in your generatious for ever 1 Cor. 5.8 Therefore let us keep the feast not with the old leaven neither with the leaven of malice and wickedness but with the unleavened bread of sincerity and truth And as the Sacraments of the Old so those of the New Testament are instituted to instruct us in duty also Hence Baptism is called the Baptism of Repentance Mark 1.4 And Christ in the institution of the Lords supper saith do ye this in remembrance of me 1 Cor. 11.24 and verse 26. As oft as ye eat this Bread and drink this Cup shew ye the Lords death till his coming viz. That spiritual coming which he promised John 14.19.23 Howbeit we do not deny but that spiritual benefits are to be expected in the performance of these duties so the repentance taught by Baptism hath remission of sins annexed to it Mark 1.4 and the spiritual body and blood of Christ of which we shall have occasion to speak in the 29. chapter are in the Sacraments of the Lords Supper assured to those that are mindful of his death and suffer with him in resisting temptations by which they are enabled to hold out and overcome when they are tempted but these benefits are signified and sealed unto us but conditionally and in the second place onely Your third use of that distinction between the people of God and the world we also allow but you have omitted one main end which the Lord had in instituting the Sacraments which was thus even by degrees to build up his Tabernacles of righteousness that was fallen down to wit the first part of it in Circumcision the second in the Passover as also in the Lords Supper and the third in his breathing upon his Disciples and saying unto them Receive ye the Holy Ghost John 20 22. For which last end both the feast of weeks in the Old Testament and Baptism in the name of the Father Son and Holy Ghost were instituted in the new especially that third part of Baptism Secondly Whereas you say in your third Section That the efficacy of a Sacrament doth not depend at all upon the piety and good intention of him that doth administer it you therein speak very unadvisedly For wheras the efficacy of a Sacrament is either obligement unto duty or the assurance of grace and help are not both obstructed by him that administers it if he be ignorant and not able to declare the Mystery of the Sacrament or if he administers the same in a profane and absurd manner or to other ends then it is ordained for or being a wicked person hath his prayers for efficacy rejected And on the contrary do not the spiritual abilities of the Minister his piety and fervent payers conduce much both to the edifying of the people in that service and the drawing down a blessing upon himself and them therein Thirdly Though we must grant you in the fourth Section that there are but two proper and compleat Sacraments in the New Testament yet there are many as it were semi Sacraments to be found there which are holy signes instituted by God in the time of the Gospel or before of which some represent our duties some the grace of God and some both such is the washing and wiping of the Disciples feet John 13.4 15. Secondly The anointing with oyl such as were sick and to be healed by the Disciples and Elders of the Church Mark 6.13 And they cast
out many Devils and anointed with oyl those that were sick and healed them James 5.14 Is any man sick among you let him call for the Elders of the Church and let them pray over him anointing him with oyl in the name of the Lord. Thirdly Imposing of hands in a threefold case First In the way of healing Mark 16.18 They shall lay their hands upon the sick and they shall recover Secondly In confirming new Disciples and communicating the Holy Ghost Acts 8.17 and 19.6 And thirdly In ordaining either Deacons or Ministers for the Churches Acts 6.6 Acts 13.1 2 3. or Bishops themselves 1 Tymothy 4.14 2 Tymothy 1.6 Fourthly The near union betwixt the Husband and the wife with their reciprocal duties figuring forth Christ and his Church Genesis 2.21 24.2.19 20. Ephes 5.25 32. Finally Some adhere the Ceremony of the Husbands praying and prophesying with his head uncovered because a cover is a token of uncleanness and he represents Christ the Head of the Church who is holy and pure but of the Wives praying and sitting to hear Prophesyings with their head covered both in token of subjection and to shew that the man her Head is through the fall unclean which things is now neither observed nor regarded in the reformed Churches See Corinthians 11.2 16. Yet let us consider advisedly whether the Apostle would spend half a Chapter about a needless thing which might be observed or omitted at pleasure To those perhaps some might be added But secondly whereas you say here in this fourth Section That the two Sacraments of the Gospel were both instituted by Christ our Lord. You are much mistaken for though the Lords Supper was so yet Baptism was ordained by God the Father who sent John the Baptist by his Doctrine and Baptism to make way for Christ his Doctrine and Office John 1.33 Lastly You truly affirm in the close of the same Section That neither of these two Sacraments may be dispensed by any but by a Minister of the Word lawfully called But here we pray you consider seriously of it whether the bare calling of man be he the Civil or Ecclesiastical Governour or both be a sufficient commission to dispense the Word and Sacraments by Perhaps in a formal Church of Professors the whole Frabrick being humane it may suffice but to administer these among the Saints and houshold of God who onely are the true Church as we said before peradventure it requires an higher call even Gods own authority or commission as the places of Scripture to which you point or some of them plainly intimate to wit Matth. 28.19 20. 1 Cor. 11.20 23. 1 Cor. 4.1 Heb 5.4 Finally Whereas you say in you fifth and last Section That the Sacraments of the Old Testament were in regard of the things signified for substance the same with these of the New it is not every way true for circumcision the initiatory Sacrament in the Old Testament did set forth the first part of regeneration especially but Baptism in or unto the name of the Father Son and Holy Ghost represents all the three parts of the new birth and the Passover though it imported to eat Christs flesh yet it was ordinarily but a communicating in one kinde whereas the Lords Supper communicates in both kindes and holds forth the Blood of Christ as well as his flesh for the strengthening of those that follow Christ into his death CHAP. XXVIII Of Baptism BAPTIM is a Sacrament of the New Testament Ordained by Jesus Christ a Mat. 28.29 not onely for the solemn admission of the party baptised into the Visible Church b 1 Cor 12.13 but also to be unto him a sign and seal of the Covenant of Grace c Rom 4.11 with Col 2 11.12 of his grafting into Christ d Gal. 3.27 Rom 6.5 of regeneration e Tit. 3.5 of remission of sins f Mark 1.4 and of his giving up unto God through Jesus Christ to walk in newness of life g Ro 6.3 4 which Sacrament is by Christs own appointment to be continued in his Church until the end of the World h Mat 28.19 20. II. The outward Element to be used in this Sacrament is Water wherewith the Party is to be baptised in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Ghost by a Minister of the Gospel lawfully called thereunto i Mar 3.11 John 1.33 Matth 28.19 19. III. Dipping of the person into the Water is not necessary but baptism is rightly administred by pouring or sprinkling Water upon the person k Heb 9.19 20 21 22. Acts 2. Acts 16.33 Mar 7.4 IV. Not onely those that do actually profess faith in and obedience unto Christ l Mark 16.15.16 Acts 8.37.38 but also the infants of one or both beleeving Parents are to be baptised m Gen 17.7 9. with 17 12 Gal 3.9.14 Gol 2.2 Acts 2.38 39. Rom 4.11.12 1 Cor 7.14 Mark 10.13 14 15 16. Luk 18.15 V. Although it be a great sin to contemn or neglect this Ordinance n Luk 7.30 with Exo 4.25 26 27. yet Grace and Salvation are not so inseparably annexed unto it as that no person can be regenerated or saved without it o Ro 4.11 Acts 10.2 4 â—2 31 45 49. or that all which are baptised are undoubtedly regenerated p Acts 8.13 23. VI. The efficacy of baptism it not tyed to that moment of time wherein it is administred q John 3.8 yet notwitstanding by the right use of this Ordinance the grace promised is not onely offered but really exhibited and conferred by the Holy Ghost to such whether of age or infants as that Grace belongeth unto according to the counsel of Gods own will in his appointed time r Galat 3.17 Titns 3 5. Ephes 5.25 Ephes 25.26 Acts 2.38 VII The Sacrament of baptism is but once to be administred unto any person Å¿ Titus 3.5 CHAP. XXVIII Of Baptisme examined ALTHOUGH some passages here are foul enough yet they have some of them been washed before As first That where in your first and last Section you would have the first and main thing signified by this Sacrament to be the spiritual grace contained in the Covenant as regeneration and remission of sins Whereas the first and principle scope in this and all other Sacraments is to inform us in and oblige us unto duty as appears out of the words of Ananias unto Paul Acts 22.16 And now why tarriest thou Arise and be baptized and wash away thy fins by calling upon the name of the Lord. See also Rom. 6.2 3 4 5 6. How shall we that are dead to sin live any longer therein Know ye not that so many of us as were baptised into Jesus Christ were baptized into his death Therefore we are buryed with him by baptism into death that like as Christ was raised up from the dead by the glory of the Father even so we also should walk in newness
betwixt the second and the third because the Apostle speakes of the Doctrine of Baptismes Hebrews 6.2 as also for that some were said to be Baptized for the dead 1 Corinthians 15.29 the former of which places implies that the acts of Baptism might be a plurality though all at one time successively performed The other That some were Baptized to become dead with Christ which we take to be the genuine meaning of that Text and that the Baptizer there paused if he went any further at that time The other is Whether those that were ignorant of what was done to them in their Infancy by death of Parents or Sureties may not lawfully be Baptized again at the time of their Repentance and Conversion to God and that for their further edification or comfort though otherwise we neither see what necessity there can be of Persons once Baptized and knowing they were so to be rebaptized or what warrant the Anabaptists have from God or men to reiterate this Sacrament or administer it at all CHAP. XXIX Of the Lords Supper OVR Lord Jesus in the night wherein he was betrayed instituted the Sacrament of his body and blood called the Lords Supper to be observed in his Church unto the end of the world for the perpetual remembrance of the Sacrifice of himself in his death the sealing all benefits thereof unto true Beleever their spiritual nourishment and growth in him their further ingagement in and to all duties which they owe unto him and to be a bond and pledge of their communion with him and with each others as members of his mystical body a 1 Cor 11.23 24 25 26. 1 Cor 10.16 17 21. 1 Cor 12.13 II. In this Sacrament Christ is not offered up to his Father nor any real Sacrifice made at all for remission of sins of the quick and dead b Heb 9.22 25 26.28 but only a commemoration of that once offering up himself by himself upon the Cross once for all and a spiritual oblation of all possible praise unto God for the same c 1 Cor 11.24 2â— 26 Matth 26.26 27. So that the Popish Sacrifice of the Mass as they call it is most abominably injurious to Christs one onely Sacrifice the alone Propitiation for the sins of the Elect d Heb 7.23 24 27. Heb 10.11 12 14 18. III. The Lord Jesus hath in this Ordinance appointed his Ministers to declare his word of institution to the people to pray and bless the Elements of bread and wine and thereby to set them apart from a common to an holy use and to take and break the bread to take the cup and they communicating also themselves to give both to the Communicants e Mat 26.26 27 28. Mark 14.22 33.24 Luke 22.19 20. with 1 Cor 11.23 24 25 26. but to none who are not present in the Congregation f Act 20.27 1 Cor 11.20 IV. Private Masses or receiving this Sacrament by a Priest or any other alone g 1 Cor 10 6. as likewise the denial of the Cup to the people h Mark 14.23 1 Cor 11.25 26 27 28 29. worshiping the Elements the lifting them up or carrying them about for adoration and the reserving them for any pretended religious use are all contrary to the nature of this Sacrament and to the institution of Christ i Mat 15. â— V. The outward Elements in this Sacrament duly set apart to the uses ordained by Christ have such relation to him crucified as that truely yet Sacramentally onely they are sometimes called by the name of the things they represent to wit the body and blood of Christ k Mat 26.26 27 28. albeit in substance and nature they still remain truly and onely bread and wine as they were before l 1 Cor 11 2â— 27 28. Mat 26.29 VI. That Doctrin which maintains a change of the substance of bread and wine into the substance of Christs body and blood commonly called transubstantiation by consecration of a Priest or by any other way is repugnant not to the Scripture alone but even to common sense and reason overthroweth the nature of the Sacrament and hath been and is the cause of manifold superstitions yea of gross Idolatries m Acts 3.21 with â— Cor 11.25.26 Luke 24.26 39. VII Worthy receivers outwardly pertaking of the visible Elements in that Sacrament n 1 Cor 11.28 do then also inwardly by faith really and indeed yet not carnally and corporally but spiritually feed upon Christ crucified and all the benefits of his death the body and blood of Christ being then not corporally or carnally in with or under the bread and wine yet as really but spiritually present to the faith of beleevers in that ordinance as the Elements themselves are to the outward senses o 1 Cor 10.16 VIII Although ignorant and wicked men receive outward Elements in this Sacrament yet they receive not the thing signified thereby but by their unworthy coming thereunto are guilty of the body and blood of the Lord to their own damnation wherfore all ignorant and ungodly persons as they are unfit to injoy communion with him so are they unworthy of the Lords table and cannot without great sin against Christ while they remain such pertake of the holy mysteries p Cor 11.27 28 29. 2 Cor 6.14 15 16. or be admitted thereunto q 1 Cor 5.6 7 13. 2 Thes 3.6 14 15. Matth 7.6 CHAP. XXIX Of the Lords Supper examined BRETHREN to give you your due you have here truly set forth the Author of this Sacrament the time of its institution with some of the ends for which it was ordained in the first Section and some part of the Ministers duty in the right administration of it in the third Section you have learnedly detected and confuted many of the gross abuses of the Papists in or about this Sacrament in your second fourth fifth and sixth Sections endeavoured to comfort the receiver of it in the seventh and set Railes about the Communion Table in the eighth Section to keep back ignorant profane and unworthy Communicants but if we here convince your selves with your Authors and guides of gross ignorance and error in the main Mystery of this Sacrament we hope you will the sooner yeeld that it was possible for you to erre in other things even in the most of these we have mainly challenged you for yea peradventure you will be hereupon induced to beleeve these things That there is a departure from the faith come into the Church 1 Tim. 4.1.2 2 Thes 2.24 That the man of sin errour and delusion is crept in 2 Thes 2.3 4 That much saving truth hath been lost for many hundred years That your Authors were not sent of God to preach the true Gospel which they never understood rightly in its chief mysteries concerning Christ That it was needful that the Gospel should be preached a new to the whole world before the end of the
to â— the end with Inde verse 23. IV. For the better attaining of those ends the Officers of the Church are to proceed by admonition suspension from the Sacrament of the Lords supper for a season and by excommunication from the Church according to the nature of the crime and demerit of the person d 1 Thess 5.12 2 Th 3.6 14 15. 1 cor 5.4 5 23. Matth. 18.17 Thus 3.10 CHAP. XXX Of Church Censures examined HERE Brethren if we first agree what the true Church is that have power to censure and then who are those Governours or Superiours in whose hand especially that power lies we shall not we hope be thought over censorious in other things It is true then which you speak in the first Section That the Lord Jesus is King and head of his Church and of no other though the Lord of all creatures and such an head he is both of the universal Church whether upon Earth alone or in Heaven also and of each particular Church yea of every member of those Churches which are in Christ or are brought to beleeve on him obey and serve him in holiness and righteousness of truth but those Saints or Churches which are onely begotten in God the Father and not as yet taught led to the Son have the Father only for their Head and king for the present It is true also That Christ appointed a Government distinct from that of the Civil Magistrate in and for his true Church which consists not of formalists and outward professors for the greatest part but of true Saints which obey and follow Christ daily in his active and passive obedience but he hath ordained no such thing in his Gospel for national and visible Churches whose religion stands in outward professions and formalities mainly or onely Therefore the outward Government of such Churches whether Episcopal or Presbyterian or mixt of both are but prudential and humane although it is evident out of both the Epistles to Timothy that to Titus and many other Scriptures that there ought to be not onely a Presbytery or joynt society of Elders in compleat congregations of such Saints but if they be great a superintendent Bishop over them if we will follow the constitution and patern of Christ and his Apostles in the pure Primitive Churches so that both these in their right State were Jure Divino Thirdly It is not to be denied that this Government is left or to be placed in the hands of some special members or society of the Churches rightly called and constituted but we rather call those Governours or Overseers with the Apostles then Officers as you do for that word among Governours signifies Agents Instruments and Ministers under others or inferiours rather then Superiours Howbeit Christ hath thousands of Saints in several nations which living dispersedly here and there either conveniently cannot or actually do not reduce themselves into one or more Congregations and so want the benefit of that Government and other means of comfort and edification likewise And this is the common state of the Saints in Europe and elsewhere who nevertheless are members of the invisible and true Church of Christ we know notwithstanding that there are some Congregations that by consent meet together and erect a Government among themselves the greatest part of which are but formalists and as their Doctrines and Administrations are none of the purest so their Government is but arbitrary or prudentiall also But here Brethren you are very defective in three things among others First In not shewing what Officers or Governours each true Congregation in Christ should have Secondly By whom they should be chosen And thirdly By whom the respective censures of the Church should be administred For the first we find That a compotent congregation in one City or place had their Elders as Teachers Councellors and Rulers appointed over them Act 14.23 And when they had ordained them Elders in every Church c. we read also Acts 6.16 That when the number of the Disciples was increased at Jerusalem and some of the widows had been neglected in the daily ministration of almes and distributions there were Deacons men of honest report and full of the holy Ghost and of wisdom chosen to be both treasurers and dispensers of the almes and so were assistants to the Apostles and Elders of the Church in providing for the poor especially yet did they upon occasion declare the true Faith and Doctrine of Christ also And afterward in the absence of the Apostles there were superintendent Bishops set over the great Churches as James at Jerusalem Acts 21.18 And the day following Paul went in or unto James and all the Elders were present and Tymothy at Ephesus as appears out of the tenor of both the Epistles writ unto him by St. Paul and the subscription to the second And finally Titus over the Churches in Crete a very spacious Iland Titus 1.5 As to the second thing the Elders and Officers of the Church are not to be chosen by the congregation but by the Superiours both in growth and place and such as were first called and chosen by the Lord. Thus Paul and Barnabas ordained Elders in all the Churches which they had converted as before Acts 14.23 and the superintendent Bishops had the same power Titus 1.15 For this cause left I thee in Greet that thou shouldst set in order the things that are wanting and ordain Elders in every City See 1 Timothy 3. throughout 1 Timothy 5.22 And though the Apostles gave leave to the congregation to chuse out wise and faithful men of which things they could judge to be trusted with the keeping and dispensing of the treasures of the Church under themselves especially as almoners yet they gave them that authority by laying their hands upon them Acts 6.2 3 4 5 6. Nor doth it follow from hence that the Congregation of Saints should choose their Teachers and Elders and much less that the Vulgar in every Parish should make their Election of ministers for then there would be many a weak if not a wild and mad choice in too many places or Parishes As to the third the Elders are to be admonished or rebuked by the Bishop 1 Timothy 5.1 19 20. the Elders are to be suspended by those who ordained them to wit the Bishop and Presbytery 1 Timothy 4.14 2 Timothy 1.6 The common people are to be admonished according to their several ages and degrees either by the Bishop 1 Timothy 5.1 2 3 or by the other rulers and Elders Or finally By the Congregation 1 Timothy 5.14 15. but excommunication or delivering up to Satan should be executed by the whole body though considered and resolved upon by the Bishop and Elders first 1 Cor. 5.3.4.5 and the like we say of absolution or receiving into the Church again 2 Cor. 21.12 These things premised we may admit that which you speak of the committing of the keyes of the Kingdom of Heaven in your
and Psal 34.9 O fear the Lord all ye his Saints for there is no want to them that fear him Secondly there are Saints in God the Son who are called to know him and believe on him for salvation from their spiritual enemies deliverance from the curse Jude 1. To them that are sanctified by God the Father and preserved in Jesus Christ and called which is the common Classis of the Saints in the new Testament Rom. 1.6 7. 1 Cor. 1.2 And thirdly there are Saints in the holy Ghost as the Apostles were made in the day of Pentecost when they were filled with the holy spirit of promise Act. 2.1 2 3 c. Secondly All those have neither the same degree of fellowship with God nor with each other but have their respective communion either with the father alone as the first or with the Father and the Son as the second or with the Holy Ghost also and so with the whole Trinity as the third John 14.25 Jesus answered and said unto him If a man love me he will keep my words and my Father will love and we will come unto him and make our abode with him See 1 John 1.3 4 5. And as the Saints have different degrees of communion with God according to their several ages and growth so they all have not alike fellowship with each other in communicating spiritual guifts for the Saints in Christ Jesus can condiscend to those in God the Father and those in God the Holy Ghost can stoop to both the other to do them service but the first cannot communicate much in spiritual things to the second nor either the first or second to the third though all may in outward things be serviceable to each other upon earth These things premised for order and distinction sake We finde then in your first Section these three errors First That you make none to be Saints but those that are actually united unto Jesus Christ their head hereby excluding out of that number and communion all those who as yet are onely bgotten by God the Father as were Cornelius Act. 10.1 2 3. and many other Secondly You untruly affirm that all those which are united to Christ by his spirit and saith have actual communion in his sufferings death resurrection and glory for none of them have fellowship in his resurrection and glory till they be dead with him and that the holy Ghost be poured down from Heaven upon them as he was upon the Apostles Act. 2. See Ro. 6 5. For if we have been planted in the likeness of his death we shall be also in the likeness of his resurrection 2 Tim. 2.11.12 neither have all that beleeved in Christ for the present proceeded so far as to suffer with him and much more to pertake with him in his death he is a good proficient in Christianitie that knows what Christ hâ—th suffered in him and for him and is come to suffer with him not onely outward afflictions but inward sorrows in resisting temptations without yeelding to them in their solicitations wherein lies the main part of our fellowship of Christs sufferings And as for our becomming wholly dead with Christ you your selves hold it a thing not fully attainable in this life wherin you greatly wrong the grace and power of Christ in his saving work and office and are not onely injurious to others who give ear unto you but fall short of that happy conquest and salvation ensuing which is held forth unto you in the Gospel almost everywhere as hath been shewed before See Luke 1.74.75 Rom. 6.5 and 14. Ephes 5.25 26 c. Titus 2.11 12 13. Rev. 16.7 11 17.26 and Revel 7.14.15 c. And thirdly you here make no distinction betwixt interest and actual communion where you say That the Saints have communion in each others graces which is true of the first not of the last where the place which you cited out of Epbes 2.5.6 speaks of the Apostles high attainments rather then of the present state of the Ephesians and other common beleevers In your second Section you seem tacitely first to imply that there are two sorts of Saints the one by profession onely such as the members of your Church Catholick were in your former Chapter and some that are really such but we are sure that the Lord admits of no Saints for his Church or people but such as are truely sanctified and continuing such he rejects them not Secondly You truly say that Saints are bound to maintain an holy communion in the worship of God but this must be understood with diverse limitations to fence it from error For first it must not be Saints living remotely from each other Secondly It holds not concerning an outward worship unless the Church set up one that is pious and profitable or lawful at the least for Christ himself hath instituted no such worship as we said before Thirdly Yet must all the Saints wheresoever they live joyn in one true spiritual worship of the living God in his living righteousness Lastly We grant notwithstanding that such as conveniontly can come together ought as frequently as their occasions and safety will bear to meet together for the edification and comfort of each other and especially if the Christian Magistrates and spiritual Governours command such meetings But the residue of this Section about the relief of the Saints is sound and good In your third and negative Section you truly and upon good grounds disavow two things First That the Saints are coequal with Christ for no creature in his highest perfection can be equal to Christ the one being finite the other infinite in his divine essence And Secondly that the Communion of Saints upon Earth doth not abolish no nor infringe the title or propriety which each man hath in his goods and possessions which is clearly imported in those Scriptures of Exod. 20.15 Ephes 4.28 and Acts 5.4 which you point us unto as also in many other places of the Old and New Testament But whether that estate which the Saints attain at length when with the Apostle they are raised up together with Christ and made sit together with him in the Heavenly places or things Ephes 2.5 6. be a bare quality or accident or whether it be a spiritual life power and substance we will not dispute sure we are the Apostle calls it the divine nature 2 Pet. 1.4 and our Saviour or Wisdom calls it substance in one notion or other Prov. 18.21 And I will cause them to inherit substance whatsoever that estate is the Platonists called him that had attained it not onely 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 but 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 a deified man and not onely some of the modern but even of the ancient writers of the Church use the word codeifying in a good sense of such as are made pertakers of the Divine nature according to the capacity of creatures CHAP. XXVII Of the Sacraments SAcraments are holy Signes and Seales of the