love saith the Apostle He will remember the good works of men borne of God at the great day of judgement The good workes of some are manifest before-hand and they that are otherwise cannot be hid 1 Tim. 5.15 They cannot for ever be hid because God will make mention of them at that day But hee hath engaged himselfe by oath to remember our sins and sinfull actions Hebr. 8. And therefore the works of the spirituall man are not sin or sinfull Arg. 8. There is no law against the workes of a spirituall man or the fruits of the spirit of grace and therefore they are not sin because where there is no law there is no transgression But there is no law against these This is plain by that passage of the Apostle Gal. 5.22 The fruit of the spirit is love joy peace long-suffering gentlenesse goodnesse faith meeknesse temperance against such there is no law Object They are here considered as they are precisely the fruits of the spirit and as they ought to be done by us and so they are no sins but consider them as acted by us even with the spirits assistance and so they are defective and sinfull Answ The Apostle doth not speake of the fruits of the spirit as Tully of his Oratour Plato of his Common-wealth Moor of his Utopia as of things no where to be found But be speaks of the spirit as in us and the fruits of it as in us And doth plainly tell us that if we are led by the spirit we are not under the law and that there is no law against the fruits of the spirit But I shall have occasion hereafter to speake more fully of some places where the Apostles and servants of God doe speak plainly of these works as done in us that so I may break the neck of this distinction which is made as a Catholicon or salve for every sore Arg. 9. God doth give a testimony concerning his Saints that they are righteous and holy which is spoken in reference to their spirituall nature and actings and therefore they are righteous and holy The judgment of God is according to truth hee being the God of truth Doth not God give this testimony of Job Job 1.1 That he was a perfect man and upright one that feared God and eschewed evill And though man may oppose this yet it feemeth by Gods speech to Sathan that the Devill could not contradict it Job 2.3 And the Lord said unto Sathan hast thou considered my servant Job that there is none like him in the earth a perfect man upright one that feareth God and escheweth evill Did any thing which was sin or sinful procure this honourable title to David that he was a man after Gods owne heart 1 Sam. 13.14 Doth not the Scripture of truth inform us concerning Zacharias and Elizabeth his wife that they were both righteous before God walking in all the Commandements of God blamelesse Luke 1.6 They did not onely walk in the great Commandement of God concerning faith for Justification but in all the Ordinances and Commandements of God Is not Lot called a just and righteous man who was vexed with the filthy conversation of the wicked 2 Pet. 2.7 And was his sinfull soule vexed with their evill deeds or his righteous soul speak in the language of Gods Word and ye must acknowledge that it was his righteous soule vers 8. God is not like unto some indulgent parents who by their fond indulgency doe account that to be a vertue which is the fault of their children and them to be vertuous who are vile God calleth nothing righteousnesse which is sin or sinfull Nor those to be perfect and upright which are not so indeed and therefore seeing God doth call his children righteous holy and perfect wee may not be affraid to call them so unlesse wee will be affraid to follow his judgment Object They were righteous before God by Justification and before men by holy walking Ans We deny not their justification before God by faith but with all we affirme that they were righteous before him by their holy walkings As these places doe sufficiently prove with others which we shall hereafter speak of Let us not delude ous soules to think that righteousnesse sanctification is to the eye of men only The purest sanctification of a Saint is not so visible to men as unto God Pure religion and undefiled before God and the Father is this to visite the fatherlesse and Widowes in their affliction and to keepe himselfe unspotted from the world which will be further manifested by our next argument Arg. 10. Almighty God is a God of pure eyes who cannot behold any iniquity any sinfull thing or sin with an eye of approbation But this God who cannot approve what is sin and sinfull this God approveth and professeth that he is well pleased with the performances of his Saints therefore the performance of the Saints cannot be sin or sinfull The Apostle in Philip. 4.18 Professeth that the worke of the Philippians in sending to relieve his wants was an odour of a sweet smell a sacrifice acceptable well pleasing to God God hath pure eyes and pure nostrils and therefore if it had been sin or sinfull it could not have pleased his eye nor have beene an odour of a sweete smell unto his nostrills Object They are so but not in their owne nature Answ If they be not so in their own nature they are filthy and odious in their own nature and yet accepted by grace If one thing which is filthy and odious in its owne nature be accepted why should not other things which are filthy and odious in their owne nature be accepted for good workes If this can be made good Whoredome and Adultery will prove good works which hath been asserted by some who have said that the filthinesse of whoredome being done away the action is well-pleasing to Almighty God as well as any good work Arg. 11. One end and intention of God in electing of us was that he might make us holy that he might make us good trees to bring forth good fruit Though God doth not elect us because wee doe believe or because wee doe love yet hee hath elected us that wee may believe and that we may love So that wee frustrate one end that God hath in electing us if we doe not grant that God gives us a new nature and new hearts According to that of the Apostle 2 Thes 2 13. We are chosen unto salvation through sanctification of the Spirit and belief of the truth And in Eph 1.4 He hath chosen us in him that we should be holy and without blame before him in love Object We doe apprehend our election imperfectly which is the cause of the sinfulness of our works Answ By reason of that which is in the flesh we cannot so perfectly see our election as wee shall doe hereafter Yet in the spirit for the present we doe so fully apprehend it
fearing our rejoycing our praying If so then are we in this working either perfect or imperfect Agents If perfect agents then is there no ignorance in our understandings no depravation in our wills no perversenesse in our affections The contrary whereof all the truly faithfull find by experience and the Scripture abundantly testifieth But if we be imperfect agents then cannot perfection come out of imperfection no effect can be better than its cause Ans 1 The efficiency of the first cause doth not take away the efficiency of the second cause In God we live move yet it is not God that moveth he though he moveth all things cannot be moved himself immobilis movens omnia Aug. So it is not God that repenteth but we repent The ignorance of which truth hath been the cause of the wicked mistery of Familisme which my soule abhorreth And therefore we shall agree in the truth which is implicitely laid down in the first part of your Dilemma 2ly Whereas you say that all the faithfull grant that man is an imperfect agent I answer that if we take perfect here in this point as it is opposed to that which is sinfull so many Saints doe grant and all should and will as more light is beamed into their soules grant it that the sanctified and spiritual man considered as farre forth as he is a spirituall man doth work as a perfect Agent not as an unholy but an holy man And therefore according to your rule his action must be spirituall and holy And this may give an answer to that argument which is brought from Job Who can bring a cleane thing out of an uncleane Job 14.4 3ly Whereas you say that no effect can be better than its cause c. This is not universally true A man imperfect by the want of his armes or legs may beget a childe which is perfect and hath its limbs But this not being much to the purpose I shall not contend about it Arg. 12. If the new man never sin Christ came not to save the new man for he came only to save sinners Answ The new man taken in this spirituall and theologicoll sence is not the object of salvation but an elect person guilty and sinfull in himselfe And the new creation is a blessed consequent of our redemption by Christ but I have sufficiently answered this before Arg. 13. That which is not in its owne nature agreeable to the holy law of God is not perfect and without sin for sin is the transgression or disagreement with the law of God 1 John 3.4 But the best of a regenerate mans actions are not agreeable to the law of God being not done with all the heart with all the soule with all the understanding and with all the strength Mat. 22.37 Deut. 6.5 Ans 1. By this argument you would bring the spirituall man to judge himselfe by the law or old covenant but hee is better taught by the Spirit And as hee doth not put his person under the old covenant so doth he not judge his actions by the old covenant but by the new covenant of grace According to that of the Apostle Gal. 5.18 If ye are led by the Spirit ye are not under the law And thus looking upon what is wrought by the Spirit under the new covenant he seeth it in its own nature agreeable to the law as it is delivered unto him in the hand of the Lord Jesus Not that Christ doth require lesse holinesse than is required in the old covenant but because he giveth us more grace enabling us to keepe his Commandements by the keeping of which we known in the light of the Spirit that we truly know him And the Commandements of Christ are kept by the Saints Evangelically two manner of wayes 1. By believing for justification 2. By holy walking for sanctification not that we can keep them by holy walking but as we walk in the light of our justification And thus he is as well able to keep the commandement of love as the commandement of faith Suppose a King should pardon a Traytor and should give him an assurance of pardon for all future Treason which he might run into and had power to enable him in some things and sometimes to be obedient unto him as a loyall Subject would you not say that this Subject were a loyall Subject all his trayterous acts forgiven and his loyall obedience to the command of his Soveraigne being accepted Thus it is between God and us He forgiveth all the treasons of the flesh and accepteth of the obedience of the spirit God doth account that all the commands of the Law are fulfilled by us when that which is not done is pardoned Omnia tunc facta deputantur cum id quod non fit ignoscitur which is true in a sense in reference to sanctification as well as to justification And a spirituall man thus looking upon himselfe in the glasse of the covenant of grace doth know that he is a keeper of the Commandements of God and can say with the Psalmist Ps 119.10 With my whole heart I have sought thee O let me not wander from thy Commandements All his defects and imperfections with the committing of evil and omitting good in the flesh are done away and that which is good is accounted so by the law of God as it is presented unto him in this Covenant So speake ye and so doe as they that shall be judged by the law of liberty saith James Jam. 2.12 As God doth judge our persons by the law of liberty or the law of the new Covenant so he doth judg our actions and thus they are perfect And the law of the new Covenant is not only faith for justification but love for sanctification And thus this place is expounded by the learned Paraeus Arg. 14. Paul did not think himself to have fully apprehended or to be already perfect but strove forward Phil. 3.12 13. which cannot be said of the olde man but only of the new man for the old man doth not strive forward for the prize of the high calling Answ Though Paul had not attained to that perfection which he looked for at the resurrection Yet hee had attained to a perfection of parts which is opposed to sinfulnesse Which doth appear by what followeth in the 15. vers of the same Chap. where he doth acknowledg the Saints in this sence to be perfect with which verse I shall put a period to my answers to your objections As many as be perfect be thus minded if in any thing ye be otherwise minded God shall reveale even this unto you Vse 2. The lessons which God hath taught me from these meditations have beene very powerfull by his grace for the convincing mee of sin in a Gospel-way and for the humbling of my soule under his mighty hand by seeing the huge masse of corruption which is in the flesh that little quantity of pure gold which is in the Spirit It
away from grace and thus some have been too bold with me in this particular And when I have proved the law to be uselesse unto us in many particulars they have concluded that I did totally deny the use of the Law which hath been the ground of this groundlesse aspersion unto which I think it needlesse to give any larger answer Concerning the 3. other branches in this Article to wit that it is no rule for a Christian to walk by nor to examine his life by and that Christians are freee from the mandatory power of it I can either affirm or deny them all I doe acknowledge that in a sence we may be said to be under the rule and power of the Law and in a sence it is true that we are not under the rule and power of it which if it be well weighed by the ballance of right reason whether these who have charged me with this not stateing the question as I did when I delivered my judgment and suppressing my meaning in their Article may be justified in this action I leave it to any man truly rationall and unprejudiced concerning me yea to themselves when God shall awaken their consciences to judge Wherefore that the truth of God and my meaning may be more evident I shall present to the view of the Reader the distinctions which I made use of in the handling of this controversie The first distinction is this that the Law may be considered as delivered in Sinai Sion Gal. 4.24 As the covenant of Sinai or as a part of the covenant of Sion Isa 2.3 For out of Zion shall goe forth the Law and the word of the Lord from Jerusalem 2ly As 1. delivered by the hand of Moses 2. by the hand of Christ And though this distinction hath beene branded by some of the learned Teachers of our times in their Pulpits and Presses with the infamous mark of Antinomianisme yet I doe not doubt but that I shall easily prove it to be a Scripture distinction This is the meaning of that speech of John Joh. 1.17 The law was given by Moses but grace truth came by Jesus Christ By Moses that is by the hand of Moses As it is plain by Lev. 26.46 These are the laws which the Lord made between him and the Children of Israel in mount Sinai by the hand of Moses So grace and truth is given by the hand of Jesus Christ Christ is stiled the Mediator of the better Covenant Heb. 8.6 And as he is the Mediator of this better Covenant he doth give the law to the Saints by his hand in this Covenant This distinction is frequently used by Zanchius 4. Tom. operum delege Translata est lex a Mose ad Christum e manu Mosis in manum Christi veri mediatoris sicut et sacerdotium ab Aarone ad Christum verum aeternumque Pontificem translatum est Translato autem sacerdotio necesse est inquit Apostolus ut et legis translatio fiat The law saith hee is translated from Moses to Christ out of the hand of Moses into the hand of Christ the true Mediator as the Priest-hood is translated from Aaron to Christ the true and eternall high Priest For the Priest-hood being changed it is needfull saith the Apostle that there be a change of the Law And in the same booke he hath afterward these words Dicimus legem quatenus fuit in manu Mosis abrogatam jam esse per Christum fidelibus sed quatenus jam est in manu Christi confirmatam esse constabilitam We say that the Law as it was in the hand of Moses is now abrogated to believers by Christ but as it is in the hand of Christ it is confirmed and established Brethren give mee an answer in the spirit of love and meekenesse to this question why should you censure me to be an Antinomian for makeing use of this distinction seeing ye account Zanchius to be a sound and orthodox writer who maintaineth the same thing Having premised these distinctions I shall answer plainly to these severall branches and not be affraid to owne what I have delivered because I am still confident that it is the truth of Christ 1. The law as delivered by Moses is not the rule by which a believing Christian doth walk but as it is delivered unto him in the covenant of grace by the hand of the Lord Jesus I shall prove this by this argument A covenant of works is not the rule by which a believing Christian doth walk The law as delivered in Sinai by the hand of Moses is a Covenant of works Therefore the law as delivered in Sinai by the hand of Moses is not a rule by which a believing Christian doth walk I doe suppose that you will not deny the major proposition You will not say that a covenant of workes is the rule of a Christian for then a Christian should worke that hee might live whereas a true Christian doth work because he doth live and hath life without works If ye shall deny the minor or second proposition I shall prove it by these reasons which are drawn from Scripture Reas 1. The Apostle doth frequently oppose the righteousnesse of the law and the law to the righteousnesse of grace the covenant of grace which hee could not doe if the law were a covenant of grace 1. Hee opposeth the righteousnesse of the Law and Gospel Rom. 10.5.6 Moses describeth the righteousness which is of the Law that the man which doth those things shall live by them But the Gospel-righteousnesse is the righteousnesse of faith vers 6. Observe the Apostles words well he doth not say that the Law requireth doing and working for justification according to the false glosses and interpretations of the Pharisees as some Writers of late with the Papists of old have asserted But Moses describeth the righteousnesse of the law so 2 ly He opposeth the law and the Covenant of grace Rom. 6.14 Sin shall not have dominion over you because ye are not under the law but under grace What sence can you make of these words if ye shall assert the law to be a covenant of grace for then this will be the meaning of the words Sinne shall not have dominion over you because ye are not under the law or covenant of grace but under grace Reas 2. The Apostle doth affirme that no flesh shall be justified by the law because by the law is the knowledge of sinne Rom. 3.20 But if the law were a covenant of grace a man might be justified by it And therefore I conclude that it is not a covenant of grace Reas 3. The Apostle affirmeth that if righteousnessE come by the law then Christ is dead in vaine And shall wee say that that is the covenant of grace by which righteousnesse cannot come unto us Reas 4. The Apostle plainly saith that the law is not of faith but the man that doth them shall live in them Gal. 3.12
the whole law Cum sophista intelligit legem abrogari eamque ceremonialem tu potius intellige Paulum quemlibet Christianum universae legi abrogari Simplicitur mortuus sum legi hoc est nihil plane commercij est mihi cum lege Luth. I am dead to the law that is I have nothing to doe with the law Est autem mori legi lege non tencri sed liberum esse a lege et nescire eam To be dead unto the law is not to be held by the law but to be free from the law and not to know it Reas 4. If we preach consolation and doe exhort people to expect comfort from God we may bid them put away the law and their confidence of expecting comfort by it The law worketh wrath Rom. 7. and therefore it doth not worke joy The spirit of joy is not received by the workes of the law but by the hearing of faith We receive the promise of the spirit through faith Gal. 3.14 Res 5. Though the law requireth holiness yet it doth not make us holy A man that will be truely fanctified must not live under the Law but under the Gospel This is the argument of the Apostle Rom. 6.14 Sinne shall not have dominion over you because ye are not under the law but under grace Must not the law in some sense be put away that we may not be under it Let my arguments be well weighed and I am contented to be censured In the meane while I shall comfort my selfe in this that I am not the first of Saints who have been reproached and persecuted as an enemy to the law The false witnesses which were set up against the Proto-martyr Stephen did bring in this against him that he spake blasphemous words against the law Acts 6.13 And it is probable that some such thing was charged upon Paul by the Jewes as we may gather by his defence for himselfe before Festus where he professeth that hee had not offended against the law of the Jewes Acts 25.8 His proposing and clearing objections so frequently in his Epistles when he speaketh of the Law and Gospel lest hee should be traduced as an enemie to the law doth sufficiently prove what was in the hearts and tongues of men who were opposers of that doctrine of free grace which he preached I shall shut up my reply to this Artitle with the words of this chosen Vessell spoken by him in the like case Acts 24.14 This I confesse that after the way which they call heresie so worship I the God of my Fathers believing all things which are written in the law and the Prophets Sect. 3. The next Article which the Subscribers doe bring against me as matter of errour which they have received from the penne of the same witnesse is that horrid speech of mine as they were pleased to call it The law cuts off a mans legs and then bids him walke Reply When these Articles were brought against me it being demanded of me whether I would owne them as my tenents and opinions I doe well remember that I gave them this answer after I had read them over That I had made use of some phrases and expressions which were in that paper and that some things which were therein being understood in a right sense sano sensu might passe for the blessed truths of the Lord Jesus But as they lay in the paper which was given unto me so I did not own them as my tenents and opinions because those things which were in my Sermons and discourses which held forth light for the understanding of them were not conjoyned with them in that paper And that answer may more especially reach these particular words I am not ashamed to acknowledge that in a Sermon I did make use of these expressions speaking of the impossibility of our fulfilling the law for justification the irritating power of the law by which sinne is stirred up in us we by accident being made worse by it and while the law commandeth men who are under it to yeild personall and perfect obedience unto it though it giveth us no power to doe what it commandeth us And I doe not doubt but in the strength of grace I shall free the expressions from that horridnesse which the Subscribers following Mr. Gataker have put upon it or else I shall willingly acknowledg that it was a rash inconsiderate yea horrid expression which fell from me But before I come to defend the innocency of the expression I cannot but stand still a little and pause upon it wondering that so many men who by their profession are tyed and engaged to the study of the Scriptures should be so little acquainted with the language of the Scriptures that they should not be able to remember one Scripture expression among so many which are like unto it to free it from that horridnesse which they would put upon it Friends consider what you doe If ye censure my expressions as horrid which the holy Spirit will justifie by the like expressions of his owne in Scripture take heed that ye doe not censure the Spirit as well as me and strike at the truth through my sides It is the speech of Plutark The thick clouds do often darken the Sun and the cloud of passions the light of reason 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 And thus I am apt to think it is with you Your passions certainly are high or else how could you be so low in your reasons so unadvisedly to condemn that as an horrid speech which by warrant from Scripture I shall prove to be harmlesse But in the first place let us enquire where this horridnesse doth lie I am ready to believe that ye are not such enemies to the law to assert the latter part of the speech hath any thing horrid in it Yee will not say that it is horrid to say that the law bids men to walke The horrid treason then of the speech must lye in the former part of it 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 I have found I have found out the horridnesse of it It is horrid to affirme that the law doth cut off a mans legges Let us bring it to the bar of truth to be tryed and if it cannot bring speeches in Scripture like unto it where the Apostle is speaking of the same points which I handled when I delivered it let it be stil branded with the hot iron of the Subscribers and passe for an horrid errour 1. Let us compare this speech with that of Paul 2 Cor. 3.6 The letter kiâ—â—eth Which Expositors with one consent uno ore doe expound to be meant of the law and which the words following of the Apostle do so plainely prove that it is bootlesse and in vaine for any man to deny it wee shall take it therefore for granted That the law killeth and this is Pauls or rather Gods assertion who gave this law Now let the indifferent Reader judge whether it be more horrid to say
that the law killeth a man or cutteth off his legs Friends I am perswaded that some of you have experimentally found as I have done that the law killeth And when ye were slaine and killed by the law were you freed presently from the mandatory power of it I am perswaded that some of you can professe in truth with mee that ye were not The law then did command you to doe and walke What horridnesse is there more in this if I may make the comparison to affirme that the law cutteth off a mans legs and then biddeth him to walke then in this To affirme that the law killeth a man doth yet bid him to doe it and walke Object But some may say that Paul saith that the letter killeth because it giveth not strength to fulfill it Litera occidit nempe quia non consert vires ad praestandum Answ I spake it in this sense too and is it not lawfull for me to imitate Pauls expressions Unlesse the ignorant world must be made to believe that my speeches and exclamations are horrid and blasphemous I might multiply arguments from this Chapter if I should runne over all the expressions of the Apostle especially these where he calleth the law 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 A ministration of death a ministration of condemnation 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 a thing to be abolished or abolished and done away And whatsoever is spoken by any of the godly for the making good of these expressions I might make use of the same for the justifying of mine seeing I spake them in the same manner as Paul did But that it may appeare that I speake not this for the reproaching of you but the vindicating of wronged abused truth and knowing that a word is sufficient to a wise man when a thousand stripes will not enter into a foole I shall not insult over your weakenesse but rather cover it as farre as I may without injury to the truth Let mee only leave this word to your consideration which in this place is very seasonable to wit That it is the mind of God that we should be as favourable in interpreting the expressions of spirituall men in their writings and speakings now as in interpreting the expressions of those spirituall men who are now with the Lord knowing that they both speak by the same spirit which spirit doth retain his liberty to speake in us as it did in them 2. Compare this speech with that of the Apostle Rom. 7.5 The motions of sinne which were by the law which will sound as harsh as to affirme that the law doth cut off the legs of sinners But if some say this is only occasionally and accidentally men running the more into sinne by how much the more they are forbidden to commit sinne According to that of the Poet. Tendimus in vetitum wee have a tendency in us to that which is forbidden I answer that the same exposition will sufficiently qualifie my speech to take away from it the least appearance of evill The law doth cut off a mans legs occasionally and accidentally A man by reason of the corruption which is in him findeth by experience that he is of lesse strength to run in the wayes of God the more he doth endeavour to get strength by the law of workes Musculus compareth it in this respect to a chaste Matron in a Brothel-house which by her good advice doth prove an occasion to some impudent whores to be more bold and shamelesse in their impiety Had the spirit of love without which wee are nothing taught you something concerning this speech you would have been favourable in interpreting it and not rigidly censorious in condemning it Oh that you who seeme to he zealous for the law would consider that this commandement to wit that we should love our neighhour as our selves is one of the great Commandements upon which all the Law and Prophets doe hang Mat. 22.40 And then how would you dare to be so rigid and uncharitable in your censuring of your Brethren If indeed you have received the law from Moses may I not say as my Saviour did to the Jewes John 7.19 Did not Moses give you the law and yet none of you keepeth it And then remember what the Apostle saith Rom. 2.13 That not the hearers or preachers of the law are just before God but the doers of the law shall be justified Brethren I am not such an enemie to the law but I can with freedome of spirit make use of that pertinent portion of Scripture unto you Jam. 2.8 9. If yee fulfill the royall law according to the Scripture Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thy selfe yee doe well But if ye have respect to persons in your censuring judging them And the same thing in effect delivered by one man shall be accounted sound by you and shall be a horrid error if delivered by another man ye commit since and are convinced of the law as transgressors 3 dly Looke seriously upon those words of Paul Rom. 5.20 The law was given that the offence might abound And then tell me whether there be not the same figure in my expression which is in Pauls And why may I not make use of a figurative expression as well as Paul expounding my meaning more plainly afterwards as he doth which I also did in my discourse Calvin saith that by these words Paul doth simply signifie the encreasing of the knowledge and pervicacy Designatur hic simpliciter incrementum notitiae et pervicaciae And another saith that it it said that it aboundeth by the law because it aboundeth in our knowledge of it ut abundare agnoscetur And will not this which is usually spoken upon this place by Expositors make our speech passeable too And as Paul saith that the Commandement which was to life he found to be unto death Rom. 7.10 So may not I say that the law which was for holy walking I found to cut off my legs because being under it I was no more able to walke in the way of it than a man is able to walke without legs I leave it to the spirituall man who judgeth all things 1 Cor. 2.15 to judge of this thing betweene us And that you may not any farther to the dishonour of God and your profession the prejudicing of the worke of the Lord in my Ministery vent forth slanders and reproachas against me I do professe that I am not conscious to my selfe of denying the use of the law in any way in which it is held forth in the new Testament But know that the law is good if a man use it lawfully Knowing this that the law is not made for a righteous man but for the lawlesse disobedient for the ungodly and for sinners for the unholy and prophane for murtherers of fathers and for man-slayers for whoremongers for perjured persons and lyars and if there be any other thing that is contrary to sound
confirmation of the truth Give mee leave to give an answer to their arguments as I have already presented unto you answers to their objections Arg. 1. Paul was a regenerated man yet he confesseth that he was not able to performe that which is good Rom. 7.18 Therefore no regenerate man is able to performe that which is good Answ Paul doth give a sufficient answer to this objection in the preceding words of the same verse where he saith in me that is in my flesh dwelleth no good thing by which it is evident that he speaketh of himselfe in reference to his flesh And this is a truth which with all the faithfull I willingly subscribe unto But when he plainely speaketh of a man in the spirit freed from the clouds of temptations and power of the flesh in the last verse of the same Chapter he saith With the minde I my self serve the law of God but with the flesh the law of sin It is good to serve the law of God but Paul in the Spirit had attained unto this and therefore Paul was enabled to performe that which is good According to that of the Apostle Phil. 2.13 It is God who worketh in us to will and to doe of his owne good pleasure Arg. 2. There is none that doth good no not one Rom. 3.9 10 11. which is meant aswell of the regenerate as unregenerate as is evident by vers 23 24. because it is meant of all who are justified freely by his grace as appears further by the instances of Abraham and David which were regenerated Ch. 4.2.6 Therefore no workes of the regenerate are without sinne Answ It is plain that the Apostle speaketh here of a man under the law and of an unregenerate man by the things which are spoken of him Hee saith that none seeketh after God can you affirme this of a regenerated man when the same Prophet who in the 14. Psame doth give us a character of a wicked man out of which this is taken in the 24. Psalme doth give us this character of a man truly godly that hee is one of the generation of those who seeke God 2. The Apostle saith that there is none that understandeth But blessed be God the sonne of God is come and hath given us an understanding that we may know him 1 John 5.20 3. They are all gone out of the way But we can blesse God who through Jesus Christ hath brought us into the way of salvation 4. There is none that doth good no not one and there is none that is righteous But hearken unto the speech of John 1 John 3.7 Let no man deceive you hee that doth righteousness is righteous even as he is righteous I might runne over all the other particulars there laid downe but I shall content my selfe with what is spoken in the 17.18 it s said that the way of peace have they not known and there is no feare of God before their eyes Is a regenerate man an enemie to the way of peace and doe not they feare God to whom God hath sworne Jer. 32.40 That he will put his feare in their hearts that they shall not depart from him Again secondly you would prove it by this argument because hee speaketh of all those who are justified But let me tell you that we must distinguish of a man before and after his Justification Every man is such a man before Justification and in this respect he speaketh of all men but after justification there is a charge wrought in a man as I have formerly proved at large unto which I refer the Reader But thirdly you instance in David and Abraham who were regenerated men Answ Wee are not to forget that the Scriprure dosh acquaint us that there is a two-fold righteousnesse of a regenerate man The righteousnesse of Justification and the righteousnesse of sanctification Of the first of these the Prophet speaking saith that a man is blessed to whom sin is not imputed of the latter where hee saith of the same verse And in whose spirit there is no guile which the learned Zanchius doth apprehend to be spoken in reference to that sanctification which is in the unregenerated part understand the distinction rightly and you cannot want an answer to this Objection Arg. 3. Wee believe not so stedfastly nor love so perfectly as we ought therefore is our faith love imperfect and sinfull Ans 1. If we should grant the antecedent we may deny the consequence It is true that if a man doth not believe so stedfastly and love so perfectly as he ought that then the man doth sin consider him physically And this wee have alwayes granted but it doth not follow that his faith and love is sin but that which is in the flesh is sin which is the cause that he doth not believe so stedfastly and love so perfectly as he ought Amesius doth give a sufficient answer to this in answering an argument which Bellarmine doth bring against the Protestants to wit that sins doe not please God in Christ It is true saith he that sin doth not please God but the stain of sin being done away the good which remaineth is pleasing unto God Sane quidem certe sedpeccati maculâ in Christo deletâ bonum substratum placet Tom. 4. l. 6. c. 8. 2ly We say that a regenerate man looked upon in the new Covenant doth believe stedfastly and love perfectly His unbeliefe and hatred of God which is in the flesh being covered with the rich mantle of Gods grace and mercy as far as he doth believe truly he doth believe stedfastly and as far as he doth love he doth love perfectly Let not this offend any man that I say he doth love perfectly It is granted by most Protestant writers that a regenerate man hath a perfection of parts though not of degrees A childe may have an humane nature and the parts of a man as well as a man of forty yeares old A sparke of fire hath the true nature of fire a drop of water hath the nature of water in it as wel as all the water in the Sea So a sparke or drop of love hath the divine nature of love in it as well as that which burnes in the breasts of a Seraphim and therefore is not sin or sinfull And for this reason it is said that Abraham was not weak in faith though it is unquestionable that hee had his weaknesse in the flesh as well as other men and that hee staggered not at the promise of God through unbelief but was strong in faith giving glory to God Rom. 4. And this is the meaning likewise of Amesius in the place formerly cited where hee saith That the good works of the faithfull are not only good by the object of them but in reference to all the causes of them the efficient materiall formall and finall cause Opera fidelium non tantum sunt bona ex objecto sed etiam quoad omnes causas efficientem materiam
and all of you your rashnesse who have condemned me by your Censures When Constantius desired Liberius to subscribe to the Proscription and Excommunication of Athanasius he made him this answer O Emperour Ecclesiasticall censures are not to be passed without a great deale of justice O Imperator inquit judicia Ecclesiastica decet cum maximâ proferri justitiâ Trip. Hist l. 3. c. 17. Let me speake plainly unto you not to shame you but to convince you of your fault When I am most serious and free from all turbulency of passion I have apprehended that I should have found more justice in the High-Commission Court then among my Brethren The Civilians say that wee must not passe our judgement upon a law by one line of it De lege non judicandum ex solâ lineâ And Christian justice and equity will teach us not to censure Gospel-Sermons by one line maliciously or ignorantly taken out of it knowing that a spirituall man now as well as Paul formerly may have some things hard to be understood 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 which they who are unstable and unlearned may wrest as they doe the Scriptures to their owne destruction Secondly Give me leave to enquire of you whether spirituall prudence would teach you to be so violent against godly men who differ in some notions expressions and circumstantialls from you When there are so many Sepulchers wide open against you and them ready to devoure you both It was the policy of some barbarous people when Alexander came to contend with them for a Conquest as Curtius doth relate it to put an end of the wars and differences which were among themselves that so they might be strengthned against the common enemy And the like policy was used by the ancient Inhabitants of the Land when Caesar came to invade them whether Christian wisdome will make us lesse prudent and politicke for our own preservation I shall be willing that it may be determined by the man who liveth in the cleare light and liberty of the Gospel In the mean while I hope that you will not reject the Apostles caution Gal. 5.16 If yee bite one another take heed lest ye be devoured one of another 3 dly Let me tell you one thing which hath been revealed unto me by the Lord. If ye shall deal with tender-hearted Christians who cleave to Christ and are part of his mysticall body though they differ from you in some opinions in the way of Bonner and Canterbury leaving the example of Christ and his Apostles the Lord will blow upon you lay your honour credit and greatnesse in the dust while the heavens shall rejoyce saying Thou art righteous O Lord who hast judged thus 4 ly Let me beseech you not to suffer your uncharitable practises to give the lye to your zeale and professions for the maintaining the Law Walk not contrary to love professing your selves to be for the law because love is the fulfilling of the law Labour to be such as Ruffinus doth report Gregory Nazianzen was who did those things which hee taught and condemned not himselfe by doing things contrary to what he taught Qui fecit ea quae docuit seipsum minime condemnavit contraria agendo quam docebat Ruffin in vitâ Naz. Remember who they are who make a man an offender for a word and turn aside the just for a thing of nought Isa 29.21 And let none of you imagine evill against his brother in your heart Zech. 7.10 Be not so uncharitable towards me as you have been who doe assure you that I am able to speak it to the glory of Gods grace that though I may erre I shall never be an Heretique Errare possum haereticus esse nolo Endeavour not to perswade the world that I am a patron of Libertinisme for if you doe I hope that I shall be able by the power of grace to give you such an answer as an old man of Alexandria did to some who said that be was no Christian because he could work no miracles This saith hee doth prove mee a Christian That I am not moved with the injuries which ye have done unto me Hoc ipsum ut ijs quas insertis non moverer injurijs Cassian So I hope that the free spirit of Christ will so dwell in me that it will sufficiently prove that I am no patron of Libertinisme or looseness who at this present notwithstanding all the wrongs done unto me am able to subscribe my selfe Yours as far as you are for Christ his wayes and the liberty of his Saints JOHN SIMPSON Truth breaking forth through a mist and cloud of Slanders Section 1. THe first Errour which is charged upon me is this That the morall law is of no use at all to a believer no rule for him to walk by And that Christians are free from the mandatory power of it Delivered by Mr. Simpson witnesse Mr. Gataker This Article doth consist of four branches The first That the law is of no use at all to a believer Answ When some either through ignorance mis-apprehending or through malice mis-reporting what I had delivered in opening the Doctrine of the Law and Gospel had spread this abroad to wit that I denyed the use of the Law To stop the mouth of lying fame I preached at Algate where I was then an unworthy Steward of the mysteries of God upon these words of the Apostle 1 Tim. 1.8 Wee know that the Law is good if a man use it lawfully and did wholly disavow this tenet proving the usefulnesse of the Law and shewing what use Believers and the Preachers of the Gospel might make of it A believer is a creature spiritua ly intelligent and rationall and by the helps and light of grace can make a good use of every thing and so consequently a good use of the Law So that to my best remembrance I was never so much as tempted to think that the Law is of no use unto him And what I then delivered concerning the law the usefulnesse of it might have prevented this charge If my Father had not seen it good for me for a time to lye under a cloud of slanders reproaches that so I might be made conformable unto my head It is usual with ignorant and malicious hearers of the Gospel to draw wilde and loose conclusions from good premises and sound truths which they heare from the mouths of their teachers and then to fasten them upon them as though they were their own tenents Thus some did slanderously report concerning Paul that he affirmed that men should doe evill that good might come Rom. 3.8 And thus the Papists have charged the Protestants and first instruments which God did make use of to bring us from Popish and Antichristian darkenesse as men who opened a gap to all loosenesse and licentiousnesse of life and conversation because they asserted that Christians might be and ought to be assured of their salvation and denyed the falling
cary in his eye those distinctions and cautions which I have already laid down while we shall more largely prove that a believer is not under the mandatory power of the law of the olde Covenant but under the mandatory power of the law in the new Covenant of grace It is impossible that a believing Christian should live under the Covenant of grace as it is delivered unto us in the clear light of the Spirit and should at the same time be under the mandatory power of the law as it was delivered in Sinai It is impossible that a man should in the Spirit doe good works freely because hee is justified and yet doe good works that he may be justified But the law of Sinai doth command me to work that I may live and be justified and in the covenant of grace I am informed that I am freely justified therefore it is impossible that I should be under grace and under the mandatory power of the law as delivered in Sinai at the same time Again it is impossible that I should do good works because I see my self free from condemnation and doe good works for feare of condemnation But the law commandeth me to doe good works for feare of condemnation the Gospel because I am free from condemnation and therfore it is impossible that I should be under the Covenant of grace in spirit and under the mandatory power of the law as delivered in Sinai I shall draw the strength of these arguments into a few words Gods justified children are not under the commands of a Covenant of works But the commands of the law as delivered in Sinai are the commands of a Covenant of works Therfore they are not under the commands of the law as delivered in Sinai 2ly It is a contradiction to say that a man is under the commands of the law of Sinai but 〈◊〉 under it for justification or condemnation For the Law as it was there delivered doth 〈◊〉 command without promises of life to the 〈◊〉 and threatning of death to the disobedient 2 Cor. 3. for that it ceaseth to be the law 〈…〉 delivered if you take from it the proâ—â—â—â— threatnings 3ly Lawes are distinguished by their rewâ—â—â— and penalties And though the same 〈…〉 commanded in severall laws yet wee say 〈◊〉 are severall lawes because they have severall rewards penalties annexed to them Suppose the punishment of death which is due to thieves should be changed into the penalty of restoring of what he hath stollen foure-fold or working in a Gallyseven years We should say that the olde law is repealed and that there is a new law made concerning theft and hee that after all the Gospel-light which hath broken forth is not able to see a change of the rewards and penalties of the law of Sion from those of Sinai doth for his wilfull and affected ignorance deserve to be more blinded 4 ly The Covenant of which the Prophet prophesied Jer. 31.31 is new in reference to the commands of holinesse which appeareth by Heb. 8.10 And therefore Christians are not under the commands of the old covenant of Sinai as they were there delivered but under all Commandements as delivered in the new covenant of Sion Musculus and Zanchius doe both make use of this place for the proving of this point 5ly A believing Christian is commanded to doe all good workes in faith of his free justification But the law doth not command him to doe good workes in faith of his free justification And therefore a believing Christian is not commanded to do good workes by the law I suppose that the first proposition will passe without an exception For the second it is evident by Gal. 3.12 The law is not of faith but the man that doth them shall live in them 6 ly The Apostle plainly saith Gal. 3.18 That if wee be led of the Spirit wee are not under the law But if wee are under the mandatory power of the law as delivered in Sinai we are under it according to that of the Apostle Rom. 3.19 Wee know that whatsoever the law saith it saith to them who are under the law that every mouth may be stopped and all the world may become guilty before God Ye cannot put a man under the commanding power of the law as delivered in Sinai but ye must put him under the commanding power Reas 7. The approved distinction betweene legall and evangelicall obedience in point of sanctification will be sound unsound For all the obedience of the Saints which they yield unto God by their holy walking wil be by legal principles and not Evangelicall if we place them under the mandatory power of a covenant of works I hope by this time that the judicious and spirituall Reader doth begin to see that I am no enemy to the law by establishing it for justification by believing and sanctification by holy walking and that my expressions are justifiable by the Scripture of truth And if I am to be blamed for any thing it is because I have been so bold in these Anti-christian and Anti-scripturian dayes rather to keep close to Scripture-expressions than to tye my selfe up to the forme and methods of men in speaking of these covenants which I hope will further appeare by what shall be delivered in answer to the second article Sect. 2. The second thing which Mr. Gataker doth charge upon mee are these exclamations in the Pulpit Away with the law away with the law Is this such a strange and hereticall speech to one that professeth himselfe a Teacher in Israel that with all his learning and love hee cannot possibly make a favourable construction of it Might not love which thinketh no evill but beareth all things and hopeth all things 1 Cor. 13.7 have suggested this unto the spirit of a consciencious Christian that something which either preceded or followed it in my discourse had such an influence upon it to free it from the poyson and venome of false doctrine and heresie What an easie thing were it to gather many such speeches out of the bookes of Ancient and modern Writers which may sound as harsh to a tender eare as this doth and doe yet make a delightfull sound to the eare of Truth as they lye in their bookes To instance in a few Ambrose upon the 7. of the Romans hath these words Nec enim legis erit adulter sed Evangelij qui mortuà lege vinctus Evangelio post redit ad legem Mortua enim lex dicitur cum cessat ejus authoritas Hee is not an adulterer by the law but by the Gospel who being bound to the Gospel the law being dead doth return unto the law For the law is dead when its authority ceaseth And a little after this Mori legi Deo est vivere To dye to the Law is to live to God Luther upon the 5. chap. of the Galatians hath these words Habes pulcherimum et optimum librum omnium legum in corde tuo
Noneges ullo doctore hac in re tantum consule tuum proprium cor hoc satis abunde docebit te ita diligendum esse tuum proximum ut teipsum Thou hast the fairest and best booke of all lawes in thine owne heart thou needest no other teacher in this matter only take counsell of thine owne heart that will sufficiently teach thee that thou shouldst love thy neighbour asthy selfe And in the same booke upon the second Chapter Quod spectaculum valde jucundum est proponit producit legem velut furem aut latronem aliquem jam damnatum adjudicatum morti Pingit enim per Prosopopeiam legem captivam teneri cui jam manus pedes juncti sunt omnisque potestas adempta ita ut amplius non possit exercere tyrannidem suam hoc est non possit accusare et condemnare Et hac jucundissimâ dissimâ picturâ reddit eam contemptibilem in conscientîa ut credens in Christum jam ausit legi sanctâ quadam superbià insultare all hunc modum Ego sum peccator si quid potes contra me lex facito tantum abest ut credenti sit lex nunc formidabilis It is a pleasant sight to behold how he bringeth forth the law as a thiefe or a robber adjudged to death For he painteth forth the law by a Prosopopeia as a Captive whose hands and feet are bound and all its power taken away so that it cannot exercise its tyranny any more over us that is it cannot accuse and condemn And by this pleasant picture he maketh it contemptible in the conscience so that he that believeth in Christ doth now dare to insult over the law by an holy kind of pride after this manner I am a sinner if law thou canst doe any thing against mee doe it so far is the formidability of the law from a believer The like speech is that of Zanchius in his booke of the law of God Constat legem solis Judaeis datam fuisse non autem gentibus It is manifest that the law was given only to the Jewes and not to the Gentiles A parallell place to this we have in Musculus Legem Mosaicam literis comprehensam non inter Christianos duntaxaat qui ex Israele Christum filium dei ac salvatorem mundi credendo receperunt sed et inter Judaeos admodum de lege gloriantes reipsà abrogatam esse constat It is evident saith he that the law of Moses written with letters is abbrogated not among the Christians only who by faith have received the Sonne of God and Saviour of the world but among the Jewes who glory in the law I could likewise produce specches out of the Scripture which may sound harsh to some eares and may seeme to be very darke to some if they should be taken out of the places where they are set by the holy Spirit from which they receive light that they may be more easily and plainly understood by us But leaving this grant me liberty to prove by spirituall reason and Scripture that in some cases it may be lawfull for a Minister of the Gospel to make use of such an expression as this is Away with the Law c. Reas 1. If we speak of the law as it is faedus legale a legall Covenant so I speaking unto believing Christians may say Away with it Put not your selves under the Jewish Covenant The Apostle will justifie this expression by his owne Gal. 4.30 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Cast out saith he the bond woman Will you know what he meaneth by the bond-woman he himselfe will informe you and tell you that it is the Covenant of Sinai vers 24. which expression is most harsh to compare the Law or Covenant of Sinai to a bond-woman and to command us to cast her out or else to say Away with the law Reas 2. When wee speake of the law in opposition to the Covenant of grace as the Apostle doth Heb. 8. so I may say Away with the old Covenant that God may glorifie himselfe by revealing the new Covenant of grace unto you will not the word of truth likewise hold me guiltlesse in this expression if we consider what is spoken in the last verse of that chapter where the Apostle saith that it waxeth old is ready to vanish away From which words Mr. Dickson doth draw this conclusion that in the times of the Prophet Jeremiah the legall or Levitical Covenant was neare to death and vanishing away and by consequent after the comming of Christ under whom all things are become new it is expired Temporibus Jeremiae Prophetae prope erat ut moreretur evanesceret faedus legale seu Leviticum et per consequens post adventum Christi sub quo nova facta sunt omnia expiravit If I thus speake of the law Is there any greater absurdity to say Away with it than to say that it is vanished away Reas 3. When justification is preached and an experienced servant of Christ knowing that men naturally seeke righteousnesse by the law and the works of the law it is necessary for the Ministers of the Gospel to perswade their hearers not to looke to that law for Justification but to the grace of God in Jesus Christ Paul speaking of Saints saith that they are dead to the law by the body of Christ Rom. 7.4 May not a man bid people to put away the law in point of justification and salvation as well as to informe them that they must be dead unto it that they may live unto Christ Luther hath many expressions higher than mine in this point and yet you doe not looke upon him as an Heretique Will not the Spirit of God teach us to be as favourable to the living as dead servants of Christ in our Censures will not grace teach us to be as loving to those who are present with us as to those who are absent from us I shall for the satisfaction of the unpreingaged Reader set downe a few of his speeches Paulus est hic haereticus omnium haereticissimus estque haeresis ejus inaudita quia dicit mortuum legi vivere Deo Psuedo-apostoli docebant nisi vixeris legi non vixeris Deo Paul is here the most hereticall of all Hereticks his heresie is un-heard of heresie because he saith that he who is dead to the Law doth live to God The false Apostles taught unlesse ye live to the Law ye cannot live to God And afterwards If thou wilt live to God it behooveth thee to dye altogether to the law Reason and humane wisdome cannot receive this and therefore it alwayes teacheth the contrary unto it Si vis vivere Deo oportet te omnino mori legi Hanc doctrinam ratio et sapientia humana non capit ideo perpetuo contrarium docet Againe he hath these words When sophisters doe apprehend that the Ceremoniall law is only abrogated doe thou believe that Paul and every Christian is abrogated to
these there is nothing to be found in these availeable to justification Formes of government and Ordinances doe not make men Christians but a lively faith in the Lord Jesus When Caius Marius Victorinus told Simplicianus that he was turned from Heathenisme to Christianisme and he replyed that he would not beleeve him unlesse he saw him in the Congregation of Christians He wittily thus reprehended the rashnesse of his speech Ergone parietes faciunt Christianos Doe your walls then make Christians So to those that say men are of the world until they are under this or that forme of government and ordinance I may thus speak do these things make Christians Presbytery all government is nothing Independency is nothing dipping is nothing but faith which worketh by love The Apostle clearly proves this poynt Gal. 5.3 I testifie againe to every man that is circumcised that he is a debtor to do the whole Law Christ is become of none effect to you he shall profit you nothing Wee know that Paul circumcised Timothy after he was a preacher of the Gospel and submitted himselfe to many of the rites Ceremonies of the Jewes shaved his head put himselfe under a Jewish vow yet here he saith if a man be circumcised he is a debtor to the whole Law His meaning is this that if a man submit to circumcision as thinking it will any whit availe him to his justisication and salvation that man shall not be saved by Jesus Christ but he is a debtor to the whole Law he is not under grace but under the curse of the Law Act. 15.1 When some preached that there was a necessitie for men to be circumcised and keepe the Law of Moses that they might be justified see how the doctrine was disrellished by the Apostles Peter calleth it a tempting of God and laying a yoke upon the necks of the disciples which they nor their fathers were able to beare Paul though as a spiritual man he could become all things to all men to the Jew as a Jew to the Gentile as a Gentile 1 Cor. 9.20 21 22. That by all means he might save some yet how doth he thunder and lighten in the face of those that laid too much upon the practise of outward things denying unto them any salvation by Christ And as he said If yee be circumcised Christ shall profit you nothing so if any man be baptized I may say Christ shall profit him nothing If any man to satisfie his conscience desire one to dip him or joyne himselfe as a member to any Congregation thinking by pleasing God and Christ to further his salvation in this way he is a stranger to Christ and unacquainted with his Gospel Faith is inconsistent with any thing in this sense faith will not suffer any thing to be joyned with it in point of justification and if we will joyne any thing with faith for justification that faith is nothing worth at all If we will doe one thing that wee may be justified wee must doe every thing If thou wilt be a member of a Church as they speake that thou maist be comforted justified and saved thou art bound to fulfill the whole Law The Law is well compared by one to a chaine which is linked together and if we take one linck of it the weight of the whole chaine will be upon us So if wee doe any thing that wee may be justified wee lay our selves under all the bondage and slavery of the Law and are tyed to doe every thing in the Law that wee may be justified He that is circumcised is a debtor to doe the whole Law Gal. 5.3 But in Christ Jesus neither Circumcision availeth any thing nor uncircumcision but faith which worketh by love ver 6. By Circumcision he means all the outward priviledges of the Jewes these doe nothing availe to salvation and by uncircumeision the priviledges of the Gentiles Baptisme and the Supper All outward priviledges and prerogatives doe nothing availe to justification The kingdome of Heaven is not in these things not circumcision or uncircumcision or any outward Ordinances The Kingdome of Heaven is within you Another reason may be drawn from the consideration of the nature of Ordinances our submitting our selves to them There is not so much in that outward obedience that is given to outward Ordinances as in that obedience that is given to the morall precepts of the Law Mark 10.19 Our Saviour commends the Young man for acknowledging that obedience to God loving God and his neighbour were more then all burnt Offerings and Sacrifice There is more in internall obedience then in obedience to externall Ordinances From which Conclusion thus I argue If those things that are of a more excellent nature as love to God and love to our neighbour and relieving the poore be altogether unprofitable inefficatious and unavaileable to justification and salvation then these outward works of obedience in submitting to outward Ordinances are much lesse availeable This is an argument à majore ad minus from the greater to the lesse If the greatest works advantage nothing for justification and salvation then certainly the doing of inferiour works the suffering a man to dip mee and to make mee a member of his Church cannot advantage me These things are works in their own nature farre inferiour to the great works of the Law love to God and to the people of God and to the poore Saints of the Lord Jesus Christ Therefore if these works be altogether unavaileable if they can nothing further my justification nay if they hinder mee in point of justification if May any weight upon them then certainly these inferiour works can nothing further my justification and salvation And if a man doe not practise them according to the Command of Christ through ignorance it is no way prejudiciall to his justification and salvation It did not prejudice the thiefe that he dyed without Baptisme that he did not receive the Supper of the Lord that he was not admitted a member of a visible Church it did not prejudice him that he had no fellowship with the Saints A man may be justified and faved not onely without the works of the Law and works after conversion but he may be saved though he doe not submit himselfe to the practise of outward Ordinances Therefore if any say unto you you must be baptized or you cannot be saved I cannot look on you as a Saint except you be baptized you must be members of a Church or else you cannot be members of Christ I cannot acknowledge you as a brother rather pity their ignorance then yeeld to their exhortations What a sad thing is it for men to place Saintship and Religion in these things when the Scripture plainly and punctually in this respect overthroweth them Rom. 14.15 The Kingdome of God is not in meats and drinks concerning which there were many controversies and janglings in those times but in righteousnesse and peace and joy in the
9.20 O man who art thou that repliest against God who hath mercy on whom be will have mercy and whom he will he hardeneth And though men unacquainted with this truth may account this rather a shift or evasion then an answer to their carnall objections against election and reprobation yet I shall not be ashamed of my answer It is an excellent Speech of Augustine Christs great Champion against Antigratians in his time Absit ut pudeat nos hoc respondere quod respondisse videmus Apostolum Far be it from us to be ashamed to give the same answer which was given by the Apostle Who art thou that repliest against God c. In the next place wee are to consider that in Scripture salvation is taken either negatively or affirmatively And take salvation in either of these acceptions And it will be evident that wee are saved by grace In the first place if we take salvation negatively as it is a deliverance or freedome from all evill and in this sence wee are freed from evill onely by grace It is a true rule Gratiam Christi nihil praecedit humani Nothing in man doth precede or prevent the Grace of God The light and beames of Grace do dispell the clouds of our sins Not for our sakes but for his Name sake he covereth our sins It is Gods prerogative to free us from sin by Grace and to remove them far from us Psal 103.12 As far as the East is from the West so far he removed our transgressions from us He onely can remove sin against whom it is committed He onely can cast sin into the depths of the Sea who hath an Ocean of Grace in himselfe in which he swalloweth them up Micah is spiritually transported beyond himselfe in admiring this incommunicable prerogative of the God of Grace Micah 7.18 Who is a God like unto thee that pardoneth iniquity c And who can think that he will part with this priviledge which is his delight For so it followeth in the same verse He retaineth not his anger for ever because he delighteth in mercy Secondly If wee take salvation affirmatively for the instating of men into a condition and enjoyment of all happiness and felicity so wee are saved by grace Wee are made happy brought from a cursed condition into a blissfull condition from horror to joy from hell to heaven from the state of nature to the state of Glory onely by the grace of God It is onely by Grace that wee are what wee are By Grace our sins are pardoned by Grace wee have an inheritance with the Saints by Grace wee are the high born sonnes of the great King of heaven and earth by Grace wee are blessed and loaded with all spirituall and temporall blessings in Jesus Christ and are brought to the enjoyment of eternall felicity happinesse and blissfulnesse Thus wee are saved by grace and by grace alone One of the Ancients doth speake excellently to this purpose Nemo se palpet de suo Satanas est de deo beatus est quid est enim de suo nisi peccatum suum Let no man boast of himselfe for of a mans selfe he is a Devill by God a man is made happy What is a man of himselfe but sin Yee are saved by grace Againe salvation in Scripture is taken for salvation before God in the Court of heaven And it is taken for the saving of a partie in his own spirit and conscience if wee take it in the first sence a man is saved in the Court of heaven onely by grace What is the Reason that the accusing mouth of the Law being stopped no Bill no enditement can be brought against the Elect in the Court of Heaven Is it not this because God in his grace justifieth them This is the Apostles argument Rom. 8.33 Who shall lay any thing to the charge of Gods Elect It is God that justifieth them 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 who can implead or bring an action against them before God for breaking his Law He that is the Judge of the Elect is their justifier Grace hath cast out of Heaven the accuser of the Brethren which accused them before God night and day Rev. 12.10 The accuser can bring no enditement complaint or accusation against the Saints there There is no sin in our consciences that can be heard to accuse us in heaven because there is grace for our justification God beholds his Sonne Jesus Christ before his eye upon whom he hath laid all our sins The bloud of Christ doth with powerfull and undeniable arguments plead for those for whom it was shed The straying and stragling sheep which are within the reach of Gods eternall Grace cannot be condemned because the good Shepheard hath given his life for the sheep Joh. 10.11 God knoweth that he hath received satisfaction before hand for their sins by the hand of the Lord Jesus who is not now to pay any thing but hath already made payment for all their debts and is become the Mediator of the new Covenant of Grace which is sealed in his own bloud under which Covenant upon this consideration there can be no remembrance of sin Heb. 10.14 God beholding his Elect in their propitiation and alwayes hearing the sweet voice of their wrath-appeasing advocate making an heavenly melody in his eares And alwayes beholding our happinesse before himselfe in heaven lying wrapt up in his own grace doth acquaint us in his word of truth That wee are saved by grace Secondly If we take salvation in the other sence for salvation in our spirits and consciences and in this sence we are saved by grace There can be no salvation brought home to our hearts but by the sight of grace If wee had the sanctification of all the Saints which have lived since the fall of Man and should looke upon it all as ours to give comfort to our soules and to assure us that wee are in a state of salvation and should not looke above it to behold Gods grace and our sanctification in it and from it it would not give us any solid comfort or assurance of our falvation Nothing can shine in the heart to give it any comfort but what doth shine and give light in the light and beames of this grace Wee never come to see our selves in a condition of safety till wee see the grace of God Looke unto mee and be saved all the ends of the earth for I am God and there is none else Isaiah 45.22 None but God can save us and nothing but the sight of God can bring salvation to us Still wee have some objection or other against salvation and justification till God silence all objections by the sight of his own grace There is that onely in God and in Jesus Christ that will silence all objections If our conscience flie in our faces and tell us that wee have committed many thousands of sins more then wee can reckon or number up yet when God gives us a
of high Treason against the State the Law will condemne him for the Treason his good service not being availeable to make satisfaction to the justice of the Law for this Treason So if it were possible for us to keepe the Law for a time wee should be condemned if it can be proved that wee have broken it at any time Acts of obedience will not make satisfaction for acts of disobedience We cannot satisfie the justice of the Law by doing what the Law requires if we have once broken it If we could sometimes doe what the Law requires us we should not be able to free our selves from the guilt and punishment for doing that which it forbiddeth us at all times because it requireth obedience from us at all times And it is unreasonable to thinke that God if he deale with us as under the Law and not under Grace should give us a pardon of our disobedience in consideration of our obedience If a wife live honestly as becomes a wife some few yeares if her huband finde that she committed Adultery some yeares before the time of her honesty obedience the Law takes no notice at all that she hath lived in her latter time as became a wife but condemnes her she must be divourced from her husband for her adultrous act committed before her obedience So if it were possible that wee could keepe the Law and doe what is required in it and live under the obedience of it in every branch and point of it yet if we have once broken the Law the Law taking no notice of our obedience would condemne us for our disobedience What the Roman hystorian saith of the Roman Law that it is dura et inexorabilis severe and inexorable it is true of Gods Law The Law heareth no cry or begging for mercy No man shall finde favour or pardon from the Law by any acts of obedience to the Law who hath once disobeyed the Law The paying of a new debt will not make satisfaction to a man to whom an old debt is owing so if wee could pay the debt that the Law requires for the present it makes no satisfaction at all for our breaking it before for our old debt By this consideration in the first place it will be evident to every man who hath any spirituall knowledge of the purity and justice of the Law that it is impossible for sinfull man to finde out any way but the good old way of Grace to happinesse and salvation Secondly wee are justified by grace that God may have the glory of his grace Man fell by pride therefore God will not estate him in happinesse but by humbling him by bringing him upon his knees to the Throne of Grace that he may have the glory of his grace Naturally we are full of pride and would rise by that by which wee fell wee would be made happy by workes as wee are made unhappy by workes Every man that sees himselfe sees how that the whole streame of corrupt nature runs this way man will be doing working and acting that he may be justified But God will not suffer sinfull man to glory before him in his owne workes least he should loose the glory of grace Rom. 4.2 and therefore there is no salvation for us untill wee lie downe at the doore of grace If God enter into judgement no man living shall be justified in his sight Psal 143.2 God doth stop up all other waies to salvation but the way of grace that he may have the glory of his grace in justifing the objects and vessells of his grace God doth not so much intend mans salvation by grace as his owne glory and praise He formeth his people for himselfe that they may be happy in himselfe and with himselfe and they may shew forth his praise Psal 43.21 It is the minde and pleasure of God that every man should glory in himselfe therefore he justifies and saves us onely by that Grace which is in himselfe In the Lord shall all the seed of Israel be justified and shall glory And the Apostle when he had dicoursed of the grace of God in our election predestination and adoption doth sweetly acknowledge that grace doth streame forth unto us in all these particulars that it may be to the praise of the glory of his grace Ephes 1.5 6. He maketh us objects of grace that he may receive from us and wee be enabled to give unto him the glory of his grace All the Saints are brought forth standing before the Throne and singing forth this truth Rev. 7.10 Salvation to our God which sitteth upon the Throne and to the Lambe They ascribe salvation not to their owne workes merits deservings or worthynesse but to the grace of God and blood of the Lambe As earthly and grose bodies cannot mount up to Heaven which is a place of puritie and perfection but they fall downe by their owne weight to the earth unable to ascend thether So our works fall downe to the ground as unable to ascend up to the place of Gods purity and glory to justifie us in his sight that salvation may be attributed onely to his owne grace And he will not justifie us in the court of our owne consciences wee shall not read our names written in heaven till hee bring us from our owne workes righteousnesse performances and endeavours to rest upon the strong arme of his grace that we may give him the glory of his grace in our free justification and salvation Thirdly God saves us by Grace because if it were not by grace it had beene needlesse that the Lord Iesus Christ should have beene given to us If it had been possible for man to have wrought out his owne salvation by his own workes there had been no need that the Son of God should have disroabed himselfe of his glory and been made man like us Why should he have lived a life of sorrow and died a death of shame had it been possible for us to have gotten salvation by our own works Therefore the Apostle concludes that if righteousnesse had been by the Law then Christ had dyed in vaine And thus have I opened to you and shewed you the reasons why wee are saved by grace In aword now to make a little use of it and so I shall conclude for the present In the first place that which I have delivered concerning the eternall grace of God sufficiently confutes that error which is in the spirits of many men who thinke that workes and actings of the creature is the cause of Gods love to the creature God doth not love us because wee love him but we love God because he first loved us from eternity God doth not begin to love us when wee are made new creatures but God loveth us that we may be new creatures Faith is not the Antecedent cause but consequent of election Tit. 3.5 Not by workes of righteousnesse which wee have done but according to his mercy he
discovery and application of his grace unto our own souls As no rational man when he readeth those words of our Saviour to the woman who was diseased with an issue of blood Mat. 9.22 Daughter be of good comfort thy faith hath made thee whole would conclude that because our Saviour saith that her faith did make her whole that therefore she was not made whole by Jesus Christ as the principall cause So no spirituall man should conclude that we are not saved by grace as the principall cause because the Apostle saith wee are saved through faith Desireing therefore that that crowne may stand fast which God hath set upon the head of his owne grace I shall endeavour to shew you that wee are saved by faith or through faith Wee are not saved in a way of working but beleeving Thus God saved and justified the Father of the faithfull to teach his sonnes in what way they are to expect salvation God in a vision informeth Abraham that he was his shield and exceeding great reward Gen. 15.6 And he beleeved in the Lord and he counted it to him for righteousnesse This was the Oracle of truth which Habakkuk standing upon his watch received from the Lord Hab. 2.4 Behold his soule who is lifted up in him is not upright but the just shall live by faith It is by beleeving and not by working that wee are made just Fides justos ab injustis non operum sed ipsa fidei lege discernit Aug. Truth doth make a difference betwixt the just and the unjust not by the Law of workes but by the law of faith The naturall man knoweth no righteousnesse but what is by his own workes The spirituall man doth see himselfe righteous in beleeving Thus our Saviour directed the ignorant Jewes to the right way of righteousnesse when they asked him what they should do that they might work the works of God Io. 6.28 This is the work of God saith he that ye beleeve on him whom he hath sent If any enquire after salvation let him know it is not by works The plaine way to salvation and justification is only by beleeving Tit. 2. The grace of God bringeth salvation teaching us to deny all ungodlinesse wordly lusts He doth not say that grace in the first place teaches us to deny ungodlines worldly lusts but in the first place it brings justificatiō salvation through beleeving then secondarily the same grace teacheth us to deny ungodlines worldly lusts After we have believed for salvation the holy spirit is given Ephes 1.13 In beleeving we enter into our rest Heb. 4.3 keep the yeare of Iubile see our selves unstated in happines and keep a christian Sabbath It is only in beleeving that wee are brought to the enjoyment of that felicity which is by the grace of God in Jesus Christ The Apostles in their Epistles doe not hold forth any truth more frequently then this Gal 5.6 In Jesus Christ neither circumcision availeth any thing nor uncircumcision but faith which worketh by Love And Ro. 5.1 Being justified by faith we have peace with God through Jesus Christ our Lord. When the Keeper of the Prison asked Paul Silas what they should doe to be saved supposing salvation was only attainable by working they did at one discover unto him his error blindnesse acquainted him with the soul-saving truth of the Gospel assuring him that if he beleeved on the Lord Jesus he should be saved Acts 16.31 We find not rest in our spirits by the sight of our works love sincerity labours endeavours but by the sight of Gods grace in Christ Having by these places of Scripture confirmed to you this truth I shall now amplyfie it by shewing unto you more fully how it may be in truth affirmed that we are saved through faith In the first place it is by faith and by faith alone not by faith joyned with workes but by faith without workes I deny not but where true faith is workes will follow yet salvation is through faith without workes When wee are brought into the bosome of the Lord Iesus wee enter not into the bosome of his love by our love and faith together but by faith which produceth Love Our eyes are shut to the beholding all things in our selves and the eyes of our spirits are enlightned to behold what is in Gods Grace and the Lord Iesus Consonant to this is Pauls sweete and comfortable conclusion Rom. 3.28 Wee conclude that a man is justified by faith without the deeds of the Law Love to God and his people is a worke commanded by the Law but according to Pauls conclusion of truth wee are justified by faith without the deedes of the Law therefore we are justified by faith without love to God or his people When God discovers his Grace to a man for his justification hee shewes him that as his evill workes cannot bring damnation unto him so his good workes cannot bee availeable for his justification That assurance of Gods love which some professors have got by the sight of their owne workes being never illuminated in their understandings to behold Gods Grace in the light and beames of Grace is not the true assurance of the gospell but the deceit and lying divination of their owne spirits concerning their owne happinesse for salvation is by faith without workes God doth not require us to doe good workes for salvation in the conscience but doth positively and absolutely exclude them as things which have no influence at al upon that first assurance which he doth give unto his people of his love which is by a pure simple unmixed act of faith The spirit of Grace is never given to comfort us untill God hath stripped us of our owne righteousnesse workes and performances and hath brought us to the Throne of Grace to bee justified by free Grace without any thing in our selves that may make us fit for justification and salvation The Apostle doth lay downe this as a truth seconded by his owne experience and the experience of all true Saints Gal. 2.16 asserting that a man is not justified by the workes of the Law but by the faith of Iesus Christ even wee saith he have beleeved in Iesus Christ that we might bee justified by the faith of Christ and not by the workes of the Law for by the workes of the Law shall no flesh bee justified It is not as the Papists say that faith which hath love joyned with it which they make the forme of faith by which wee are justified but it is by faith without any workes at all by which wee are justified and have peace of conscience Augustine doth plainely lay downe his judgement in this point according to truth Noli presumere de operibus ante fidem quia peccatorem te fides invenit etsi te fides data facit justum impium invenit quem faceret justum Presume not upon thy workes done before faith because faith findeth thee a
sinner faith hath made thee just it found thee wicked whom it should make just The second reason why it is thus by faith alone is because it is by grace unlesse we were justified by faith we were not we could not be justified by Grace This reason the Apostle lays downe Rom. 4.16 Therefore it is of faith that it might bee by Grace As if he should have said unlesse you hold that there is a justification by faith alone without workes you deny Grace if you will bee justified by faith and workes conjoyned you destroy Grace Therefore it is by faith alone that it may be by Grace When we have a true sight of Grace wee see a sufficiency in that Grace to doe us good for our justification and salvation soe that there is nothing needfull necessary besides grace In which respect Luther saith that workes are not necessary to justification but pernitious to salvation the gospell requiring faith only according to that of the Apostle Gal. 3.12 The Law is not of faith the law hath nothing to doe with beleeving that doctrine which bids a man to beleeve that he may bee saved that is the doctrine of the gospell the law biddeth us not to beleeve but the man that doth it shall live in it The law bids us worke but the Gospell bids us beleeve not worke and beleive but beleive only We confound the Covenant of workes and the Covenant of Grace if wee presse an absolute necessity of doing good workes for justification This was the Divinity of the blood-sucker Bishop Bonner who in a Sermon propounding this quest How grace is to be applyed to us for justification doth answer by beleeving rightly and living uprightly joyning faith and holinesse for justification by grace whereas by the Scripture of truth it is manifest that faith alone doth lay hold of Christ and doth appropriate him unto us And that holinesse doth flow and streame from the apprehension of our free justification by grace through faith alone though faith is not alone but is accompanyed with other fruits of the Spirit which follow it This must be well understood or else we shall nullifie the grace of God wherefore God enableth true beleevers to see this truth plainly and clearly Vilesceret redemptio sanguinis Christi nec miserecordiae dei humanorum operum praerogativa succumberet si justificatio quae sit per gratiam meretis precedentibus deberetur Ambros Redemption by the blood of Christ would be vilified the prerogative of mans workes would not stoop to Gods mercy if justification which is by grace were due to preceding workes A man that truely beleives he sees not any holinesse or qualification in himselfe that makes him more worthy of salvation then another man he sees that he hath deserved damnation as well as any one who is now in the place of torment and yet hee sees that such is the Grace the unspeakeable grace of God to his poore souâ—â— that though he deserve to lye as low in hell as Iudas for his sin yet he shall be raised as high as heaven by the grace of the father made knowne to him in Iesus Christ Brethren if upon examination you finde that your joy comfort and assurance have in the first place proceeded from any workes which you have in your selves which make you conclude that you shall rather be saved then another man your assurance is not a right assurance But if your assurance be right it is by beleeving that which is reported concerning the grace of God that so salvation may be by grace It is possible for men to deceive themselves in obtaining an assurance of Gods love and their happinesse therefore I will a little digresse to open this to the ignorant It may be thou takest comfort to thy selfe by looking on workes wrought by thy selfe and not by looking on Christ it may be thou conceivest that thou lovest God and from thence concludest that God loveth thee though thou hast not seen his free love to sinners this is a bastardly assurance brought forth by thine owne lying spirit and not the true assurance of the Spirit of grace in beleeving In a true assurance by faith God hath the glory of his grace But in this kind of assurance God hath not the glory of his grace therefore it is not a true assurance Another deceiveth his soule and thinketh hee is in a good condition because he resteth upon a promise of God Christ saith Mat. 11.28 Come unto me all ye that labour and are heavy laden and I will give you rest A man doth apprehend himselfe to be heavy laden and from the sight of his burthen doth conclude hee hath rest and is in a good condition but hee deceiveth himselfe with a false perswasion for the promise is not made to the qualification of wearinesse but the promise is made to the commers to Jesus Christ Cain was heavy laden with his sin and it lay so heavy on him that he concluded that the punishment was greater then he was able to beare or else that his sin was greater then it could be forgiven and yet died miserable without mercy Wee find that the sin of Judas lay so heavy on him that he repented that he had shed innocent blood yet for all this hee went to his owne place Therefore if thy comfort and assurance come from a sight of what is in thy selfe and not from the discovery of grace as it is layd forth in the Spirit of grace thy assurance will not advantage thee in the day of wrath Though God hath convinced thee of sin and there may be some legall repentance reformetion wrought in thee and something which thou mayst miscall a true love to God thou canst not from the sight of these things rightly conclude that thou art in the love of God before a discovery of free love be made forth to thee a sinner For God doth not apply his grace or his Sonne to any man for justification but through beleeving that justification may evidently appeare to the sons of men to bee by his owne grace Which will appeare if in the third place we doe more fully consider that God doth save us through beleeving that hee may have the glory of his grace God as hee is glorious in his grace by which hee justifies sinners so he will be glorified in the hearts and consciences of those who are justified by grace that he may have the ful glory of his grace when he hath justified them Non est quò gratia intret ubi jam meritum occupavit Bern. There is no roome for the glory of Gods grace where the worthinesse of our workes hath filled up the place Where the creature may have glory in his owne workes there God loseth the glory of his grace Where God doth any thing for the creature by grace there it is not of our works otherwise grace is no more grace If it be of workes then it is no more of grace
otherwise work is no more work Rom. 11.6 Therefore God will not justifie us in doing the workes of the Law in giving us a sight of any thing that may make us more worthy of justification then other men but he makes knowne his grace to us in a way of beleeving The property of faith is to emptie the creature and to discover the fulnesse of the Creator Our owne workes they puff us up but faith empties us It wee could be justified and saved by that which we have done we might boast and rejoyce in it before God Rom. 4.2 But because God will humble us bring us low lay us upon our backs and tumble us in the dust that we may see our selves nothing and see his grace all in all to us for our justification therefore God justifies us onely in beleeving Faith layes the creature low and sets the grace of God on high that wee may goe to heaven admiring the grace of God to such sinners such base and vile wretches as wee are therefore God will not justifie and save us in the court of our owne Consciences by the sight of our owne workes but onely by the sight of his owne grace thus it is said of Abraham that he staggered not at the promise of God by unbeliefe but being strong in faith he gave glory to God Rom. 4.20 When God comes downe upon us and works faith in our hearts and wee stagger not at the promises of Grace by unbeliefe but give credit to what he hath spoken and promised God hath that glory from us that he will have from all those whom he intends to save Unbeleife robs man of his comfort God of his glory By faith the creature is comforted and the Creator exalted through faith man is emptied of selfe-confidences and filled with God and his praises therefore for this reason are wee saved through faith Againe Fourthly it is by faith because it is onely by beleeving that wee behold the grace that is in God by which he forgives sin Mans happinesse for the present doth not lye in the not having of sin but in the grace of God not imputing sin Nostra justicia est dei indulgentia Gods favour and indulgence is our righteousnesse Thus the Psalmist doth describe the Blessed man Psal 32 Blessed is the man whose iniquities are paraoned and whose sinnes are covered Hierome doth sweetly paraphrase't upon those words Quod tegitur non videtur quod non videtur non imputatur quod non imputatur non punietur that which is covered is not seen that which is not seen is not imputed that which is not imputed shall not be punished But by what is it that man beholdeth himselfe in this happinesse It is onely by beleeving and therefore wee are saved through faith Wee cannot see a nonimputation of sin by the grace of God but by the work of the spirit in an act of beleeving by which wee are assured that it shall goe well with our soules to all eternity And the great controversie is decided and determined in the spirit of a man whether he shall be saved or whether he shall be damned No other foundation can be laid then the grace of God in Jesus Christ our Lord 1 Cor. 3.11 And we cannot see this foundation that wee may be built upon it but by beleiving Moses by faith saw him that was invisible Abraham by faith saw the day of Christ and was glad As by the eye of the body wee see materiall objects so by the eye of faith wee see spirituall objects The Philosopher saith that prudence is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the eye of the Morall man so faith is the eye of the spirituall man By which alone God and the things of God are beheld 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Justin Martyr The Sun was not changed when the blinde man in the Gospel that never saw before received his sight and beheld it It was the same before and after his blindnesse so Jesus Christ the Sun of righteousnesse is the same yesterday and to day and for ever in himself and unchangeable in his love in reference unto us The change is onely in us by faith whom now we see though formerly wee beheld not his beauty and because the righteousnesse and salvation of God is revealed by faith Rom. 1.17 therefore wee are saved by faith Fiftly wee are saved by grace through a worke of beleeving because if it were not onely in an act of beleeving the people of God could not have that firme constant and unquestionable assurance of their salvation which now they enjoy in a way of beleeving When a man is to goe unto a place by many severall wayes which are not found out without some difficulty he doth often doubt whether he is in the right way or whether hee is out of his way but when he is to goe in one plaine way he is confident that he is not out of his way So when a man goeth by the way of the Law and workes for justification he is in doubt whether he is in his right way for justification the Law pointing out many wayes and requiring many duties of him that would be justified under it but the Gospel pointeth onely at Christ and faith in him for jusification so that those who walke in this way for justification are confident that they are in the right way The Apostle doth lay downe this plainly Rom. 4.16 where he saith it is by grace and that by faith to the end the promise might be sure to all the seed not to that onely which is of the Law but to that that is of the faith of Abraham the Father of us all God hath not made the promise of salvation to the seed under the Law or that doe any workes of the Law But he hath made the promise to be gracious to poore sinners in beleeving without the workes of the Law to the end the promise might be sure If there had been any thing else required beside faith the soule would be alwayes restlesse and unsatisfied If God should tie justification to workes men would be unsatisfied because they would doubt whether some workes were not undone and then they would doubt of their justification Therefore God hath not promised justification to any man who doth good workes or submitts to any outward Ordinance but onely unto him who closeth with his grace in a pure act of beleeving For God knowes that so long as there is any thing joyned with faith for justification wee shall be ready to question our justification wee may observe that such professors who are not acquainted with the Gospel are unsetled in their spirits when they doubt which is the true Government or externall Ordinances of the Lord Jesus If they doubt whether they are baptized in a right way or manner they doubt whether they are justified their comforts and assurance doe vanish away when they are not fully assured that they know and are obedient unto
that by Gods grace in the apprehension of it wee are made unblameable and holy before him in love which is all that I contend for I may adde this that if God had chosen us to love joy sanctification and the like which are sin and sinfull that then he had chosen us to sin or to something sinfull which conceit in my apprehension doth carry such an absurdity in the face of it that it needeth not a Confutation Object They are not sin in their morall nature as they ought to be done but they are so as done by us Answ God hath not chosen us unto them as they are considered onely in his command But he hath chosen us unto them as they are to be acted and done by us as it is plain by the words of the Text and therefore this objection hath no strength in it to weaken our argument Arg. 12. If the new creature were sinfull worke his sinful or sin it would nullifie Gods intention in our Justification who doth justifie us when we are unholy that he may make us holy Ephes 2.10 Wee are his workmanship created in Christ Jesus unto good workes which God bath before ordained that we should walke in them Wee are not ordained to walke in any thing which is sin or sinfull but to walke in good workes We are redeemed from sin that we might be purified unto himselfe a peculiar people And grace teacheth us to live soberly righteously and godly in this present world not sinfully but righteously God maketh us good trees by justification and then enables us to bring forth good fruit There must be a root before there can be fruit So God gives us a roote or seed of holinesse before wee can bring forth holy fruit and righteous actions And when the good seed is sown in good ground it cannot but bring forth good fruit Mat. 13.23 which place may give more light for the clearing of that objection where it was said that there could not bee good fruit though the seed were good because the ground is not good Arg. 13. God doth free us from the law of works and doth bring us under the covenant of grace that we may by grace be enabled to doe those works which we are not able to doe by vertue of morall commands The covenant of grace and Gospel-promises should be as ineffectuall for sanctification as the law if all that were wrought in us under that covenant were sin or sinfull And therefore it will follow that a man under grace hath a purity of sanctification in him God brings us from Moses who was the Law-giver and delivers us from the Covenant of works in giving us to Jesus Christ who is the giver of grace that he may make us holy in a gracious life and conversation The Apostle sets this forth unto us Rom. 7.6 But now wee are delivered from the law that being dead wherein we were held that we should serve in newnesse of spirit and not in the oldnesse of the letter We are freed from the service of God in the law of works under which wee serve as slaves till wee be brought to Christ that wee may serve as sonnes in obedience to all morall commands under the sweet gracious glorious government of the Lord Jesus Christ who is as well a Law-giver Isa 33.22 to write his lawes of faith and love in our hearts Hebr. 8. As a Saviour to save us from our sins And to cut off all objections against this argument wee may take notice that the fruits of the spirit are not onely called good and holy as they are in the promise or command but they are good and holy and called fruits of righteousnesse as they are wrought in us and by us with the omnipotent help and assistance of the holy Spirit We are called the trees of righteousnesse Isa 61.3 and feare and love are fruits of righteousness as wrought in us Jer. 31. Hebr. 8. The 14th Argument may be drawn from the oath of God If God should not performe this for the Saints God should be perjured which is blasphemy to speak The oath of God binds him God in his word which is the character of his mind hath discovered his hatred of perjury and false swearing we cannot think that God who hates perjury in others should forsweare himselfe but we have not only the promise but the oath of God for this so that unlesse we will say that God for-sweares himself we must subscribe to this truth to witt that God gives his Saints his Spirit and in the Spirit holinesse and righteousnesse I will give you a place for this Lu. 1.73 74. The oath which be sware to our Father Abraham What hath he sworne That he would grant unto us that we being delivered out of the hands of our enemies here is our Justification we are delivered out of the hands of sin death and the Devill But is this all No He hath delivered us out of the hands of our enemies that we might serve him without fear that is without slavish fear in holinesse and righteousnesse before him all the dayes of our life Some acknowledge that the people of God shall live holily and righteously to men-ward as they speake but that the righteousnesse of anctification is not to God-ward This place overthrowes this distinction he saith not that wee shall walk holily and righteously before men only as hypocrites may but he â—aith that we shall serve in holinesse and righteousnesse before him We shall not do such works which Luther and others have called vices vitia affirming that all the works of the regenerated man are vices nor such works which are sinfnl vitiata as some others speak buâ—uch workes which God who cannot lye cals righteous works nay righteousnesse in the abstract we shall serve him without feare in holinesse and righteousnesse not only in the sight of men for oft-times they look on good works as though they were bad but good in the sight of God they come from a sweet fountain therefore the water cannot be bitter or brackish from the fountaine of his owne Spirit in his Saints If the works of the Saints were nothing but sin or sinfull how could the Oath of God be fulfilled that they shall serve him in holinesse and righteousnesse all the dayes of our life Object Before him in this place as in other places doth meane under his protection Gen. 17.1 Answ Though it may be granted that sometimes before him may signifie under his protection yet it doth not appear that it should be the meaning of the holy Ghost in this place But he doth rather informe us how Saints doe approve themselves before God by sanctification As Paul laboured in godly sincerity to have his conscience void of offence towards God and towards men According to that speech of Hezekiah Isa 38.3 Remember O Lord how I have walked before thee in truth and with a perfect heart and have done that which is good in
it for the maintaining of the light thereof so we say that a Christian doth daily stand in need of spiritual oyle to be powred into his soule by Jesus Christ that he may shine forth in the light of truth Will you dare to say that the soules of the Just made perfect have no need of the teaching of Christ and that they have no dependance upon him because they are perfect Againe it is necessary in respect of the old man who is filled with hellish darknesse ignorance that Christ be looked upon as the great Prophet that wee may put off the ignorance which is in him may be more in the Spirit of Christ which will lead us into all truth It being the way of Gods working to shine into our dark hearts to enlighten them with the knowledge of his grace in Jesus Christ You may begin to see by what hath been delivered that this doctrine doth not overthrow the offices of Jesus Christ but doth sweetly to the glory of his Father confirm him in them Arg. 9. If the regenerate man work perfectly then is the wages reckoned unto him not of grace but of debt Rom. 4.4 But this cannot be that the wages either of the blessings of this life or the life to come should be of debt unto him and not of free grace seeing the Apostle testifieth that God of his free grace gives us his beloved Sonne and together with him all things Rom. 8.32 Answ This first place which is alleadged doth not reach the point in hand because the Apostle doth there speak of works done under the law for Justification and doth thence conclude that if a man be justified by those works which he doth under the law that then the reward is not of debt but grace because the law being not of faith Gal. 3.12 doth give nothing unto us in a way of grace But we are speaking of workes done and accepted under a Covenant of grace The principall cause of mens errour and mistake in this controversie is because they examine the new man and his workes by the law of works and not by the law of sanctification holinesse and love in the new Covenant of grace If wee did examine his workes by the law of holinesse which is in the new covenant we should plainly perceive that it is by the Spirit of grace that his workes are freely wrought in him and by this means all legall glorying and carnall boasting is taken away According to that of the Apostle 1 Cor. 4.7 Who maketh thee to differ from another And what hast thou that thou didst not receive Now if thou didst receive it why dost thou glory as if thou hadst not received it By which you may plainly see that the argument will not hold good to say that if a man work perfectly under a covenant of grace that his reward is not of grace but of debt I shal therefore give you a short answer to the first part of this argument by distinguishing of a two-fold working 1. under a law of works and there it is true that if a man worke perfectly his reward is of debt 2. Under a covenant of grace where a mans sin is freely forgiven him and by free grace he is enabled to worke righteously and there his reward is not of debt to speak properly but of grace Secondly Though we deny that God giveth any reward to a spirituall man as a debt due unto him for his merits and deservings yet wee affirme that God giveth rewards to a spirituall man who doth good works And therefore it is said that Christ commeth with his reward with him to give every man as his worke shall be Revel 22.12 And Mose esteemed the reproach of Christ greater riches than the treasures of Aegypt for he had respect unto the recompence of reward Hebr. 11.26 And this reward may be called a debt not in reference to mans merrit but in reference to Gods promise of grace as a man by his promise may make himself a debter to a beggar And therefore the Apostle speaking unto the Saints Hebr. 6.10 saith That God is not unrighteous to forget the worke of the Saints and labour of love And John exhorteth us that wee lose not those things which we have wrought but that we receive a full reward 2 John And in this sense something may be given unto us as a reward of that work of grace which is given unto us before it Our confidence in Gods grace may have a great reward in this respect According to that of the Apostle Heb. 10.35 Cast not away your confidence which hath great recompence of reward And this may be an answer to the second part of this argument Arg. 10. If the workes of the regenerate be not evill because the holy Ghost worketh them Then the works of the unregenerate as his love and obedience to his parents are not evill Answ There is a generall concurrence of God as the prime cause in the doing of some things by wicked men and thus God may concur to the doing of a thing yet the thing as done by the wicked man may be evill because not done in faith And it is no solid argument to conclude from hence God did concur in the doing of this thing and therefore it is not sin or sinfull 2ly There is a speciall concurrence of Gods grace and Spirit in the doing of a thing as hee is the principall agent in working good spiritually in the Saints who are under a covenant of grace And when God doth concur w th the speciall powerfull assistance of his grace for the effecting of a thing in a Saint it is safe to draw a conclusion to prove the goodnesse of the thing from the considering of the principall agent which did concurre in the doing of the thing As John doth in these words maintaining that a spirituall man considered as a spirituall man and acting as a spirituall man cannot sin because his seed remaineth in him By which distinction you may see the weakness of your argument with which you would prove the unsoundnesse of my arguing from God considered as the principal agent to the effect And the disparity of Gods working in the regenerate and unregenerate When God doth work in a spirituall man that which is spirituall it is not only good substantially and materially but formally and circumstantially by the grace of God as I have proved at large And therefore this argument is not strong enough to overthrow what hath beene delivered Arg. 11. Either the holy Ghost workes the works of the regenerate man wholly as the sole cause and then it is not wee but the holy Ghost that believes that loves that fears God that repents that prayes for the forgivenesse of his sin c. which were absurd to imagine or else we also work with him in some kind of causality to the producing of those workes that so the works may be said to be ours our loving our