incurreth for which day the husband maketh an acquittance supposing the receit of the rent for the said yeare last past and notwithstanding that acquittance his servant distraineth for the rent of half a yeare of the first year being behinde but though the last arrearages before the last terme were due to the feme dum sola fuit yet Harper and Dyer were of opinion that all the arrearages were discharged by the acquittance of the last terme because it is an antient principle That all the arrearages are discharged by the acquittance of the last terme and we ought not to deny principles Coke l. 10. f. 40. a. No man ought to dispute against recoveries the legall pillars of common assurances because we are not to dispute against principles and which St. Germins Doctor and Student c. 26. approveth to binde both in Law and conscience and by the Statute of 23. Eliz. C. 4. That for the avoyding of the dangers of assurances of Lands and the advancement of common recoveries it is provided that any common recovery shall not be avoided for any want of forme in words and not in matter of substance And Sir James Dyer then chiefe Justice did with great gravity and some bitternesse reprove an utter Barrister who rashly inveyed against common recoveries not knowing the reason and foundation of them and said that he was not worthy to be of the profession of the Law who durst speake against common recoveries which were the sinews of assurances and inheritances and founded upon great reason and authority Mary Portingtons Case vide ibidem â—lura Coke Com. f. 343. a. Principium est quasi primum caput a principle is as it were the first head from which many cases have their beginning which is so strong as it suffereth no contradiction and therefore is it said in our Books that ancient principles of the Law ought not to be disputed 11. H. 4. 9. 2. As that of every Land there is a fee-simple and that every Land in fee-simple may be charged in fee by one way or other Littleton ibidem Cessante statu primitivo cessat derivativus Coke l. 8. f. 34. a. The primitive state ceasing the derivative doth cease As if Tenant in taile maketh a lease for lives according to the Statute of 32. H. 8. c. 28. and then dyeth without issue the lease being derived out of the Estate taile shall not continue longer than the Estate taile against the opinion in 33. H. 8. 48. Dyer which was granted by the whole Court Derivativa potestas non potest esse major primitiva Noy max. f 4. A derivative power cannot be greater than it fâ—om which it is derived As the Attorny of one that is disseised cannot make claime of the Land it the disseisee durst have gone to the Land Littleton The Bayliff of a disseisor shall not say that the Plaintiff never had any thing in the Land for the Master himselfe shall not have that Plea because he is not Tenant of the Free-hold 28. Ass Pl. 4. The Servant shall be estopped to say the Free-hold is his Masters by recovery against his Master though the servant himselfe be a stranger to it for he shall not be in better condition tâ—an he whose right he claimeth 2. E. 4. 16. He that gaineth a thing on high shall neither have gaine nor losse thereby Noy Max. f. 11. As if one Joyn-tenant maketh a lease of his Joyntee and dyeth the heire which surviveth shall have the reversion of his Joynture but not the rent because he cometh in by the first Feoffor and not under his companion Dyer 187. So when the Husband is Lessee for years in the right of his wife reserving a rent if he dyeth the wife shall have the residue of the terme but not of the rent ibidem An executor recovereth and dieth intestate Administration of the goods of the Testator is committed to I. S. I. S. shall not sue execution upon this recovery Dower cannot be assigned reserving a rent or with a remainder over for shee is in from the husband and not from him who assigneth Dower Finch f. 13. Quod dignius est prius est minus digno The Law preferreth every thing according to its worthinesse Ployd f. 169. a. and therefore is every thing placed in Writs by the rule of the Register according to its dignity as the Messuage is placed before Lands the Land before Meadow and the Meadow before Pasture and the like and this dignity is taken from necessity for to have an house to inhabite and to defend his body from tempest and violence of weather is more necessary than to have Land to plow it for bread and also to have Land for bread is more necessary than to have Meadow for Hay to feed Cattell and likewise to have Meadow for Hay which will serve all the yeare is more necessary than Pasture c. ibidem And so in the Register the entire thing which is more worthy shall be demanded before the moyety part or parts As in a Replevin if it be of two beasts the one quick the other dead the living thing shall first be demanded Register Quod prius est verius est quod prius jure est potius est tempore Coke Com. f. 347. b. As in a remitter the Law preferreth the first and antient right before the latter and a sure right though it be little before a great estate by wrong which jumpeth with the rule of the Civill Law Quoties duplici jure defertur alicui successio repudiato novo jure quod ante defertur superest vetus Paulus 17. quest As if Tenant in taile discontinueth the taile and after disseiseth the discontinuee and so dyeth seised This is a remitter to the tenant in taile because the Law shall put and adjudge him to be in by force of the tayle which is his antient title for if he should be in by force of the descent then the discontinuee may have a writ of Entry sur disseissin in the per against him and recover the tenement and his damages but being in by force of the taile the title of the discontinuee is quite nullified Qualis causa talis effectus Ployd f. 292. a. Things are construed according to that which is the cause thereof as if an Executor assigne Auditors to one who was accountant to the Testator and the Auditors finde him in arrearages the Action of debt which the Executors shall have shall be in the detinet onely for the debt shall be in them as Executors and have respect to the foundation and cause 11. H. 6. f. 16. by Paston and Newton So if one have a villaine for years as Executor if the villaine purchase Land and the Executors enter the Land shall be to the use of the Testator and it shall be assets in his hands because the villain who was the cause of it was to that use Ibidem Pas 32. H. 8. E. villenage 146. Ployd f. 524. 525.
generall words imply no certainty and with that accordeth 21. E. 4. If a man be bound to be nonsued in all Actions that he hath against him in the Common Bench he may say that he hath no action therein otherwise if the condition be particular to wit that he shall be non-sued in a Formedon c. so as that it appeareth that generall words imply no certainty neither do they conclude any person to say that he hath nothing there vide ibidem plura Cok. lib. 8.78 a. Bospols Case In an arbitrament when the submission is generall of all Actions and Demands c. that may well stand with the generality of the words that there was but one cause depending in controversy between them For generall speeches imply no certainty and the awaâ—d for one is good notwithstanding the generality of the words for though there were many matters in controversy yet if one onely was made known to the Arbitrator he may make an award of it For the Arbitrator is in place of a Judge and his office is to determine secundum alligata probata the duty of the parties which are greived and know their particular greifes is to make known the causes of controversy to the Arbitrator for they are privy to them and the Arbitrator is a stranger and every one is to do that which lyeth in his knowledge but when the condition is in speciall and with a proviso and condition that an award shall be made of the premises or words which amount to so much there the Arbitrator ought to make Arbitrement of all or else the award is void Generalibus semper specialia derogant Reg. f. c. Derg 180. Quando charta continet generalem clausulam posteaque descenâ—it ad verba specialia quae clausulae generali sunt consentanea interpretanda est charta secundum verba specialia f. 134. b. in Edward Althams Case Which rule is almost word for word put and agreed of by both parties In. 7. E. 3. f. 10. Margery Mortimers Case to wit where a Deede speaketh by general words and then descendeth to special words if the words special agree with the words general the deed shall be understood according to the words speciall As if a man grant a rent in the mannor of P. to be taken in an hundred Acres of Land parcell of that Mannor with a clause of distresse in those hundred Acres the Rent shall issue out of the hundred Acres onely and the generall words shall be construed according to the words speciall so if a man grant a Rent and go no further those generall words shall create an estate for life but if the Habâ—ndum be for years that shall qualify the words generall 7. E. 3. So if a man give Lands to one and his Heirs Habendum to him and the Heirs of his body He shall have onely an estate tayle and no fee expectant for the Habendum qualifieth the generall words precedent Ployd f. 541. a. A man maketh a Feoffment by Deede to one to have and to hold to him and his Heirs and if it happen that the feoffee dyeth without heire of his body that then the Land shall revert The generality of that gift to him and his Heires shall be corrected by the speciall branch after so as the Donee shall have but an estate tayle 13. R. 2. in Formedon Dyer 261. b. A man seised in fee deviseth all his Lands in one village and in one of the two Hamlets by name and there were two Hamlets in the said Village The opinion of divers Justices was that none of the Lands in the other Hamlet should passe for it is intendable that the intent and meaning of the devisor was that nothing more should passe then what he had expressed A. acknowledgeth a fine of the mannor of P. with an advowson and regrants the mannor with the Appurtenances the advowson shall not passe Temp. E. 1. F. title grants Ployd 173. b. If I give or lease all my Lands to one and stay there he shall have all my Lands in England but if I say further in the manner of Dale there it is now restrained but if the specialty limiteth a thing which is void and so appeareth it is otherwise as if I lease to one all my Lands in Dale which I have by descent of the part of my mother and in truth I have no Lands in Dale which I have by descent of the part of my mother if the Lessor have other Lands in Dale he shall not have those Ployd 160. a. A man giveth Lands to two Habendum to one for life and after his decease to the other and his Heirs the one shall have the entierly for his life onely notwithstanding the Joynture given in the Premisses by the better opinion in terme M. 8. E 3.427 Generalibus sempâ—r specialia insunt Reg. f. c. Specialls are alwayes contained in the generals and the universalls allwayes comprehend the particularâ— Ployd f. 68. a. The plurall number containeth the singular and more and therefore was it resolved by all the Judges That a pretensed right and title was within the penalty of the Statute of 32. H. 8. for the buying of pretensed rights and titles for pretensed rights and titles in the plurall number did containe a pretensed right and title in the singular number And whereas the Statute of 5 R. 2. c. 5. forbiddeth that none make entry into any Lands or Tenements unlesse in case where entry is given by the Law yet if one enter into a Tenement he shall be punished though the Statute speaketh in the plurall number and likewise whereas the Statute of 1. H. 5. speaketh of false Deeds in the plural number yet if one bring but one false Deed he shall be punished by the Statute as it is holden in many Bookes Ployd f. 467. b. The Statute of Gloucester giveth an Action of Waste against him which holdeth for years which is spoken in the plural number yet may it be taken for him which holdeth for a year or half a yeare vide ibidem plura Generalis clausula non porrigitur ad ea quae sunt specialiter comprehenfa Coke l. 8. 118. b. It is a ground and maxime in the Law that a generall clause is not extended to those things which are specially comprehended Doctor Bonhams Case by the Statutes of 10 14. H. 8. it was enactd that no man should exercise the faculty of Physike within the City of London or within seven miles of the said City unlesse he be admitted thereunto by the President and Colledge of the faculty of Physike and there is another speciall clause contained in the said Acts that any who evilly and not well exercise the said faculty c. shall be punished by Fine and imprisonment c. and it was adjudged that the said generall clause that none should exercise the said faculty of Physike unlesse he be admitted c shall not be extended to the speciall clause
for the punishment of fine and imprisonment c. but that it specially shall be limitted to such onely as did offend only in not well executing and using the said faculty of Physike for a generall clâ—â—â—â— is not to bee extended to those things are specially comprehended so 34. Eliz. f. 120. ubi A. seised of the mannor of Stable in O. in the county of S in fee and also of other lands in the said O. in fee suffereth a common recovery of all and declareth the uses by Indenture that the recoveror shall stand seised of all the lands and tenements in O. to the use of him and his wife and the heires of his body and dieth and after his death the wife entreth into the said Mannor by form of the said generall wordes but it was adjudged that those generall wordâ— did not extend to the Mannor which was specially named Coke l. 4. f. 8â— b. Nokes case clausula generalis non refertur ad expressa a generall clause is not referred to those things are expressed as where the Assignee of a Lease shall have a Writ of Covenant upon those wordes demise and grant yet if there be an expresse covenant that the Lessee shall enjoy it without eviction of the Lessor or any claiming under him this expresse Covenant qualifieth the generallity of the covenant in Law and restraineth it by mutuall consent of both parties that it shall not extend to the assignee Clausula generalis non porrigitur ad ea quae antea sunt specialiter comprehensa Coke l. 4 131. l. 4. when the deed at the first containeth speciall wordes and then concludeth in words generall both the wordes as well generall as speciall shall stand as Lands given to one and the heires of his body Habendum to him and his heires hee hath an estate taile and a fee simple expectant for as Dier f. 56. b A deed by wordes subsequent may bee qualified and abridged but not destroyed Dolosus versatur in universalibus generalibus Coke l. 3. f. 8. a. Twins case it is one of the Ensignes of fraude in a Deed of gift if the gift is generall without the exceptions of his apparell or any thing of necessity for it is commonly said that the fraudulent is conversant in generalls Coke l. 3. f. 57. b. Specots case A Bishop ought not to shew a generall cause for the refusall of a Clark as that he is criminosus or non idoneus for they are too generall and the fraudulent is exercised in generalls and therefore so incertaine that no issue can be taken of them as 2. E. 3. f. 6. The heire ought to alledge some certaine cause of refusall whence issue may be taken Generalia sunt praeponenda singularibus it is a rule in the Register that in a Writ the generall shall bee put in demand or plaint before the speciall as the Mesuage before lands the Land before Meadow Meadow before Pasture and Pasture before Wood and Wood before Juncary F. a. b. f. 2. E. Ex verbo generali aliquid excipitur Coke com f. 47. a. An exception is part of the thing granted and in esse as exceptis salvo praeter and out of a generall a part may be excepted as out of a Mannor an acre but not a part out of a certainty as out of 20 Acres one Ployd f. 361. a. A Lease of all my Lands in D. except white acre is void for white acre and a gift of all my horses except my black horse is void for my black horse Coke l. 10. f. 101. b. quando verba statuti sunt specialia ratio autem generalis generaliter flatutum est intelligendum where the words of a statute are speciall and the reason generall the statute is generally to be understood as the reason of the statute of 23 H. 6. whereby it was ordeined that no Sheriff should take any obligation by colour of their office but onely to themselves and upon condition that the Prisoners appeare at the day contained in the writ was for the avoyding of extortion and oppression and therefore is to receive a benigne and favourable construction and that in equity not only a bond but an assumpsit is within the reason of that statute and so was it adjudged 27. Eliz. Trin. in the Kings Bench betweene Danhigh and Hothcot that if a Sheriff or Goaler for ease or enlargement of any who is in his custody doth take a promise of him to save him harmelesse that though the statute doth onely speake of an obligation yet it is in equall mischiefe otherwise as Wray chiefe Justice said the statute should serve for little or nothing Multa transeunt cum universitate quae per se non transeunt Coke com f. 142. a. If a man seised of land as heire of the part of his mother make a gift in taile or a Lease for life reserving a rent the heire of the part of the Mother shall have the reversion and the rent also as incident thereunto for many things passe with the generallity which by themselves doe not pass so if a man hath a rent-seck of the part of his mother and the Tenant of the Land grant a distresse to him and his heires and the Grantee dieth the distresse shall goe with the rent to the heire of part of the Mother as incident and appertenant to the rent for now is the rent-seck become a rent charge Singulare distributive sumptum e aquat plurali Dier 328. b. a singular distributively taken equalleth a plurall as in an assise the Plaint is of two Acres of Land the Tenant pleads two barrs severall for the two Acres at large and the Plaintiffe makes two severall titles at large to wit for every acre one the Tenant pleades let the assise come upon the title in the singular number and the assise found one title for the Plaintiff and the other for the Defendant against the Plaintiff and judgement was given that the Plaintiffe should recover for one Acre and be barred for the other Coke l. 10. Br. Lifiels case A Lease is for one yeare and that if they agree the Lessee shall have the Land for three yeares rendring during the said terme ten pounds yearely this reservation goeth to both termes Propria res est quae solius est sive uni soli convenit Tholoss Syntag. lib. 5. c. 1. A propriety is that which is one mans onely and appertaineth onely to one man Ploid f. 308. b God made man the Soveraigne over all living creatures and gave the rule of them all to man Terram dâ—dit filiis hominum and so men by the endowment of God were made Lords of the earth and possessors of all things in the earth but how much land or things upon the earth one man shall have and how much another God hath leased to man by lawes by them to bee made and provided and by such lawes in every Realme and Country they are provided and divided and every man
holdeth his Lands and things by the Lawes of the Land wherein hee liveth and this commonly called the law of proeprty Nihil dat quod non habet Arist nemo potest plus juris in alium transferre quam ipse habet Coke com f. 309. b it is a common erudition in the Law that no man can grant that hee hath not Perkins f 15. for that is requisite that he who by his contract shall make another possessor of any thing should bee the proâ—rietor of the thing it selfe otherwise his contract is void Ployd f. 432 b. as if I possessed of an horse sell the Horse upon condition to another that he pay to mee at the feast of Christmas forty shillings for it and before the said feast I sell the horse to another and after the feast the first Vendee failes of payment by which I reseise the horse the second Vendee shall not have the horse for at the time of the second contract I had neither interest nor property nor possession of the horse but onely a condition which is not sufficient to make me able to contract for the property and possession therefore it is meerely void Ployden So if a man grant a rent charge out of the Mannor of Dale and in truth he hath nothing in the Mannor of Dale and after purchaseth the Mannor of Dale yet hee shall hold it discharged Perkins H. 15. So if one not seised of Lands maketh a Lease to another it is a good Plea for the Lessee to say that the Lessor had nothing in the Tenements at the time of the Lease Litt. and the reason of this is for that in every contract there must be quid pro quo for contractus est quasi actus contra actum and therefore if the Lessor had nothing in the land the Lessee hath not quid pro quo nor any thing for which he should pay his Rent and in that case he may plead that the Lessor non dimisit Coke Com. ibidem f. 41. b. vide ibidem plura If the Conusee of a Fine before any Attornement bargaineth and selleth the Signiory to another the Bargainee shall not distraine because the Grantor could not distrain for no man can transfer more right to another then he himselfe hath Coke Com. 309. b. Coke l. 6. f. 57. b. He that hath no seisin in the Land charged cannot give seisin of Rent vide plura Bredimans for no man can give that he hath not The King pardoneth one for making a bridge this is onely good for the fine and he must make up the Bridge because the Kings Subjects have interest in it 37. H. 8.4 Da tua dum tua sunt post mortem tunc tua non sunt Ployd 280. a. when one hath property in goods the property cannot be in him no longer then he liveth for after his death the goods belong unto another Nemo videtur rem amittere cujus propria non fuit Reg. I. C. no man can loose that of which he hath no property and therefore in a Replevin if the Defendant claim property the Sheriff cannot proceed for it is a rule in Law the property ought to be tryed by writ and therefore in this case where the tryall is by plaint the Plaintiff may have a writ de proprietate probanda directed to the Sheriff to trye the property and if thereupon it be found for the Plaintiff the Sheriff shall make deliverance Coke Com. f. 145. b. F. n. b. f. 77. If A. endict B. for stealing of Horses or other goods he must say de bonis catallis cujusdam A. For if there were no property there could be no stealing or injury for nemini vim facere videtur qui suo non alieno utitur Reg. I. c. Nemo reditum invito domino percipere possidere potest Coke Com. 303. b. no man can receive or possesse another mans Rents against the will of the Lord as if one hold of me by Rent which is service ingrosse and another which hath no right claimeth the rent and receiveth it of my Tenant by coertion of distresse or otherwise yet by the payment of my Rent to a stranger I cannot be disseised or ousted without my will or election but that I may distrain my Tenant for the Rent or have an assize against the â—ernor Lit. for a man cannot be disseised of a a Rent-service in grosse Rent-charge or Rent-seck by Attornment or payment of Rent to a stranger but at his election for the rule of the Law is no man can receive or possesse an other mans rent against his will Coke ibidem Quod meum est id amplius meum esse non potest Coke Com. f. 49. b. And therfore if lessee for years enter he is in actuall possession and then Livery cannot e made to him that is in actual possession whereby the Franke-Tenement or fee may inure to him in the remainder for that which is once mine cannot be more mine ibidem Thirdly From the Anteprecedents Aequivocum and Univocum AEQuivocum denoteth words of ambiguous and many significations which as Boetius signifies nothing nisi ad quasque res secundum voluntatem significantis applicetur unlesse they be applyed to the thing according to the will of him that declareth or expoundeth them of which the Law taketh notice and giveth these grounds and maximes Nobiliores benigniores presumptiones in dubijs sunt praeferendae Reg. P. C. And Coke l. 4. f. 13. b. Benignior sententia in rebus generalibus dubijs est praeferenda In doubtfull speeches and sentences the more favorable presumption and opinion is to be perferred As if one doth charge another that he hath forsworne himselfe by the Law it is not actionable for it may be he hath forsworne himself in usuall conversation but an action is onely maintainable against him that hath forsworn himself in Court of Record so ibidem f. 21. An Action upon the case was brought for these wordes for my Lands in Dallinson they seek my life adjudged not actionable because he may seek his life upon just cause which are the more favorable constructions So verba accipienda sunt in meliori sensu Hub. f. 106. Coke l. 4. f. 13. Wordes are to be taken at the best for the speaker though some of them cannot stand with that construction As thou art a Theefe and hast stolen a Tree it shall be adjudged of a Tree standing not felled which is not actionable But as it is said there in Hubberd 106. This rule holdeth not in Deeds and Pleas for in those words are taken more strongly against the speaker of which this reason may be given because commonly words in common language proceed of a sudden from choler and heat whereas words in Deeds and Pleas are grounded upon mature deliberation and consideration and therfore in Deeds this is a general ground Ambiguum pactum contra venditorem interpretandum est Reg. I. C. and Ambigua verba contra
that he had not white Acre by descent but had it by purchase for the relation to the descent was in vaine in that certainty appeared before ibidem vide Coke l. 3. Doughtys case f. 18. Oportet quod certae personae certae terrae certi status comprehendantur in declaratione usuum Coke l. 9. f. 9. a. Every declaration of uses upon Recoveries Fines c. of Lands Tenements and Hereditaments ought to be certaine for otherwise there shall be no certainty of inheritances and that certainty ought to be principally in three things in persons to whom in Lands c. of whom and in estate by whom uses shall be limited and declared and if certainty faile in any of them the declaration is insufficient Certa debet esse intentio narratio Bractton lib. 2. All declarations ought to be certaine so as the Defendant may know to what thing he ought to answer Ployd 84. a. As 3. E. 4. f. 21. A man retained in husbandry brings an action of debt against a Prioresse for his salary and declares that he was retained with her Predecessor and doth not shew what person retained him and by the better opinion the count shall abate for the incertainty for that it might be that one that had no Warrant retained him And so is it in a Writ Ployd ib. vi a. 22. E. 4. f. 47. It was granted by Parliament that Ashby should have a writ with Proclamations out of the Chancery against one Griffeth to answer for diverse Trespasses which were contained in the Act of Parliament and the Writ by award was abated because he made no mention of the Trespasses in certaine and there it varied from the Act but that was a private Act and therefore the non-recitall of it makes the Writ naught and so should the mis-recitall but the recitall of a generall act or the mis-recitall of a generall Act is not material but the Judges are bound to take notice of it without the monstrance of the party Oportet ut res certa deducatur in judicium Coke l. 5. f. 321. a. Playters Case P. brought an action of Trespasse against W. Quare clausum suum fregit pisces suos cepit without shewing the number or nature of the Fishes and it was resolved that the count should have comprehended the Fishes in certaine that the Defendant might have a certaine answer and upon which a certaine judgment might be given as 4. H. 6. n. the writ was quare piscem cepit and counts of so many Pikes in certaine and though the writ was piscem in the singular number yet good because per se est nomen collectivum in which the plurall number is comprehended and great inconvenience otherwise would ensue for unlesse the issue hath certainty with which the Jury may be charged upon such a generall incertainty if they give a false verdict they may be charged in attaint and f. 38. a. Teyes case In a fine the same thing was granted and surrendred to severall persons and of severall estates and so repugnant and erroneous for a fine is like unto a Judgment for a Scire facias lyes to execute it as of a Judgment and oportet as Bracton saith quod certa res deducatur in Judicium Ployd Manhells Case f. 10. b. If three issues bring three severall Formedonâ— he whose writ is first returned shall have the Land for by it he hath first attached the possession in the hands of the tenant and the writ is not of Record before the returne but if all the three Writs be returned on the same day they shall all abate because it is incertain by the count if the Tenant confesse the actions to whom they shall award seisin because all their titles are alike and all returned on the same day and for that incertainty the writs shall abate as 21. R. 2. Fit avowry p. l. 262. In a Replegiare against two the one avows for Damage-feasant and the other avows that he had common in the Land and tooke the beasts as a commoner Damage-feasant and by the award of the Court both the avowrie was abated and the Plaintiff recovered damages against them because every of them could not have the returne and who should be preferred and who rejected would be incertaine to the Court vide Ployd f. 84. a. b. Partridges case In some cases the count and the writ may be generall without certainty as in assizes but there the certainty must be shewen by the replication and in some cases the writ the count and the replication also may be incertaine but the certainty shall appeare by verdict As in a Quare impedit the value of the Church doth not appeare in the count nor in the replication but it shall appeare by verdict for they shal assess double damages or damages for halfe a yeare according to the value of the Church as the case requireth so in a writ of Ward the Jury shal find if the heir be married or not and shall assesse daâ—â—ges for it and yet in the count and replication no such matter appeareth So in a detinue the valew of the goods appeareth by verdict and in many other cases So as the certainty allwayes must appeare to the Court and if it be requisite to be shewen in the count then it ought not to be left out or omitted in the count as Ployd f. 85. a. In decies tantum he must shew the certainty of the sum received because he shall recover ten times more and that he cannot unlesse he shew how much it is And in Trespasse if the Defendant pleade that it is his Frank-tenement and the Plaintiff intitles himselfe by a lease for years made by him and if the Defendant will shew that he made a Feoffment and that he entered for the forfeiture he must shew the name of the Feoffees and certainty of the Feoffment for in all cases the privy ought to shew the certainty and in case of forfeiture the Lessor in the reversion is privy to it So if the heire will pleade in bar in a writ of Dower the detainer of evidences he must shew the certainty of the evidencies for he is privy to them in that he affirmeth that they appertaine to him but if he say a bag ensealed with Charters that is good without shewing the certainty of them 18. H. 8. f. 1. B. Dower And if one be bound in an obligation to serve I. S. for seven years in mandatis omnibus suis licitis he shal pretend that he did serve him lawfully without shewing in what service or in what commandement for no servant can remember all 20. E. 4.13 So a man may aver a thing to be done by Covin without shewing how the Covin was for Covin is a secret thing contrived between two or three to the prejudice of another 4. E. 6. 46. And a man may pleade that he was chosen Knight for the Shrie by the greatest number without shewing the number for the
Laborne in his house being one of the Seriants of the City of London Frost cometh to Laborne with a Warrant from the Sheriffs to arrest the said â— upon the Capias Utlegatum which he utterly refuseth but suffereth him to goe at large upon an action of the case brought against the Sheriffs supposing that the Sheriffs arrested him and suffered him to goe at large the Defendants pleaded that they did not suffer him to goe at large and judgment was given for the Plaintiff and the verdict warranted well the count for in judgement of Law the Sheriff and his Serjeants are words equipollent amount to so much and is all one as if the Sheriffs had arrested the said B. vide ibidem plura A Writ is to the Sheriff and he returneth virtute praecepti he hath done well for it is equipollent virtute brevis 11. H 6. 16. In a Writ it is said quam clamat esse jus this equipolleth with a Fee-simple and therefore in the subsequent part of the Writ if he instanceth in a lesser estate as ex dono for life the Writ shall abare 39. H. 5. 38. Upon an Enditement for celebrating Masse contra formam Statuti 1. El I was holden that under this terme Minister a Preist was included because a Preist is bound to celebrate and minister the holy communion c. and also it was holden by all that the terme Clerk is sufficient to prove him a Preist or a Minister Dyer f. 203. b. Coke l. 5. f. 4. b. Verus antiquus redituus the true and antient rent is not to be understood of the quality incident to it but of the quantity of the rent for that is the effect and substance of the thing reserved as if the antient reservation was of rent to be paid in Gold and the novell reservation was to be paid in Silver or if a quarter of Corne was antiently reserved and now the lease is made rendring eight bushells of Corne it is all one for the Law respecteth not the formes of words or their quality but the substance and effect of the matter parum differunt qui re concordant and they differ little which agree and equipoll in substance If one maketh his Will and committeth the Administration to one by it he shall be Executor because it is all one in substance 3. H. 6. so by the grant of a Church the advowson shal passe 7. E. 3. 15. One granteth the nomination of an Advowson Habendum the advowson the Habendum is good for it is the same thing so one granteth the remainder whereas he had a reversion it is good enough to make the thing passe 6. E. 6. Ante 134. vide Ployd 157. b. If a man lease to one an acre of Land for life reserving to himselfe the herbage the reservation is void because he hath leased the same thing in substance and the profits of the Land and the Land it selfe are all one 38. H 6. 34. Words of substance and not usuall are equivalent to words of substance and usuall Ployd 140. b. As if tenant for life and his Lessor make a Feoffment in fee it is the Feoffment of the Lessee for life and the confirmation of the Lessor though there be not a word of a confirmation in it and if tenant for yeares and the Lessor make a Feoffment in fee it shall be the livery and Feoffment of the Lessor and the surrender of the Lessee and yet there was not one word of surrender And if a commoner maketh a deed to the tenant of the Land by which he renounceth the common unto him it shall enure as a release because the words are equivalent to a release So if Land be leased by Indenture for yeares and Covenants made to render and pay for the tenements such a summ it is all one as a reservation of a rent and if the Lessor say I wil have twenty pound rent and the Lessee agree or if the Lessee say I will give twenty shillings rent and the Lessor agree it is a good reservation of a rent so if a man be bound by Obligation to en feoffe I. S. and he maketh a lease for years and a release in fee he hath performed the condition because they are all one vide ibidem Yet words of art may not be supplyed by equivalent and equipollent words though they beare the same sense and substance as in an Enditement of murder voluntarie ex mulitia praecogitata interfecit is not sufficient but the word murder avit must be so in an Enditement quod quoddam tormentum in H. L. exoneravit dans eidem H.L. cum pelletto plumbeo predicto vulnus mortale Dans ei vulnus mortale c. is not sufficient but it should have been percussit which is the word of art Coke l. 5. f. 222. b. Longes case And the reason of this is given by Coke in his Preface to Littleton that words of art are so apt and significant to expresse the true sense of the Laws and so woven into the Laws themselves as it is in a manner impossible to change them neither ought legall termes to be changed SECT 4. From naturall Philosophy NExt to Logick by whose principles as by many hands we are conducted to the knowledge of the Lawes and other Sciences naturall philosophy is to be placed which is the prime and principall part of other Sciences for by the knowledge of naturall things we are instructed to observe the diversity of the actions and manners of men according to the difference of climats and various conditions of them of which any one ignorant wil be altogether unable to judge of civill and aeconomicall affaires and therefore as Mr Ployden Have the Philosophers searched so deeply into the law of nature in their lawes and writings and for the government of the people by them given precepts to follow the rule of nature and have taken nature to be as it were a foundation to all lawes Neither have the Founders of our lawes been remisse in searching out the law of nature neither were they void of the understanding of it for their lawes argue the contrary and shew that those who made them were of more great and profound judgement and as well learned in the law of nature as in all reason and in the Law of God also for nothing in our Law is ordeined contrary to nature or contrary to reason or contrary to the Law of God but according to them all Ployd 304. a. and b. And according to it hath the law established diverse grounds and maxims 1. Quae rerum natura prohibentur nulla lege confirmata sunt Reg. I. C. Marcellus Lawes which are contrary to the Law of nature lose their force and are no lawes at all Finch Nom. f. 75. Such was that of the Egyptians to turne women to Merchandise and Common wealth affaires and men to keep within doores and of the Thracians who counted idlenesse an honest thing and stealing
that be dissolved the dower ceaseth where the husband and wife are divorced a vinculo matrimonij as causa precontractus causa metus causa impotentiae seu frigiditatis causa affinitatis causa consanguinitatis and William Chadweth was divorced for that he did carnally know the Daughter before the marriage of the mother All these are causes of divorce preceding the marriage and dissolve the dower Coke Com. f. 32. a. 235. a. Yet it is said that if the assignement of dower ad ostium ecclesiae be specified to wit that notwithstanding any divorce shall happen yet that shee shall hold it for life that this is good ibidem but divorce a mensa thoro doth not dissolve the matrimony nor bar the feme of her dower Coke l. 7. f. 43. b. As it was adjudged T. 2. Jac. 18. 5. C. 23. S so well and Wilby dower Coke com f. 33. b. Yet if the wife elope from her husband and leave him and goeth away with the adulterer shee shall lose her dower untill her husband willingly without coertion ecclesiasticall be reconciled unto her and permit her to cohabite with him according to the vulgar verses Sponte virum mulier fugiens adultera facta Dote sua careat nisi sponsi sponte retracta And this is true although shee remaineth not continually with the adulterer or if shee tarrieth with him against her will or he turne her away or co-habiteth with her husband by censure of the Church in all these cases shee loseth her Dower Coke ibidem 32. b. yet though shee be barred of her dower shee may have an appeale and the reason is because the Statute of W. 2. c. 34. barreth her of her dower but not of her appeale Coke com f. 33. b. And for the abovesaid reasons dower is one of the three things are principally favoured in our Law and the Law by that name doth give her many freedomes for the very name Dos doth give her a freedome as according to the custome of the Kingdome mulieres viduae debem esse quietae de tallagijs Regist 142. 143. and tenant in dower shall not be distrained for the debt due to the King by the husband in his life time for the Lands which shee holdeth in dower of which Ockam yeeldeth this reason Doti ejus parcatur quia praemium pudoris est let her dower be spared because it is a reward of her chastity Coke com f. 31. a. By the Statutes of 1. E. 5. c. 2. 5. E. 6. c. 31. A wife shall not lose any title of dower which to her was accrued by the attainder of her husband by misprision of treason or any manner of murder or felony whatsoever but if the husband be attainted of high treason or petit treason shee shall be barred of her dower at this day so long as the attainder standeth in force which is more favourable to the woman then the common Law was Coke com f. 392. b. vide ibidem plura And a woman shall be endowed of a seisin in Law as where Lands or Tenements descend to the husband before entry he hath but a seisin in Law and yet the wife shall be endowed albeit it be not reduced to an actuall possession for it lyeth not in the power of the wife to bring it to an actuall possession as the husband may doe of his wifes Land when he is to be tenant by courtesy Coke com f. 31. a. If a man taketh a wife of the age of seven yeares and alieneth his Land and after she attaineth to the age of nine yeares the husband dyeth the wife shall be endowed for albeit shee was not absolutely dowable at the time of her marriage yet was she conditionably dowable to wit if she attained to the age of nine yeares before the death of her husband ibidem f. 33. a. An husband seised in fee of Lands giveth it in exchange and taketh others in exchange so as he was seised of both the wife shall not be endowed of both but she may take her election to be endowed of which she will Coke ibidem 31. If the wife be of the age of nine yeares and her husband dyeth she shall be endowed though her husband be but four years old ibidem or of what age soever the husband be quia non obstabit mulieri petenti dotem minor aetus viri because the inferior and lesser age of the man shall hinder the woman from demanding her dower and that albeit consensus non concubitus facit matrimonium and that a woman cannot consent before twelve nor a man before fourteen yet this inchoate and imperfect marriage from the which either of the parties at the age of consent may disagree after the death of the husband shall give dower to the wife and is accounted in Law legitimum matrimonium quo ad dotem a lawfull marriage in respect of her dower Coke com f. 33. a. If the husband alien his land and then the wife is attainted of felony now is she disabled but if she be pardoned before the death of her husband shee shall be indowed ibidem Dos de dote peti non debet Coke com f. 32. Dower ought not to be demanded of Dower as if there be Grandfather Father and Son and the Grandfather is of three acres of Land in fee and taketh wife and dyeth this Land descendeth to the Father who dyeth the wife of the Grandfather is endowed of one acre and dyeth the wife of the Father shall onely be endowed of two acres for dower must not be demanded of dower but otherwise it had been if the father had come to the Land by Feoffment from the Grandfather or by guift in taile the wife of the Father after the decease of the Grandfathers wife should have been endowed of that part assigned to the Grandmother for that the seisin that descended after the decease of the Grandfather is avoided by the indowment of the Grandmother whose title was consummated by the death of the Grandfather Non debent mulieribus assignari castra in dotem quae fuerunt virorum suorum quae de guerra existant Coke com f. 31. a. Castles ought not to be assigned to women for their dower which appertained to their husbands and which are for war and therefore of a Castle which is maintained for the necessary defence of the Realme a woman shall not be indowed because it ought not to be divided and the publick shall be preferred before the private but of a Castle which is onely for the use and private habitation of the owner a woman shall be endowed and that in the 7 th of Magna charta nisi domas illa sit castrum is taken for a Castle of publick defence De nullo quod est sua natura in divisibile divisionem non patitur nullam partem habebit uxor pro dote sua sed satisfaciat ei ad valentiam Bracton Coke com f. 32. Albeit of many Inheritances which be
entire and whereof no division can be made by metes and bounds a woman cannot be endowed of the thing it selfe yet the woman shall be endowed thereof in a speciall and certaine manner whereby shee may have satisfaction as of a Mill a woman shall not be endowed by metes and bounds nor in common with the heire but either shee may be endowed of the third tole-dish or of the whole Mill by every third moneth and so of a villaine either the third dayes worke or every third weeke or moneth So a man shall be endowed of the third part of the profits of stallage of the third part of the profits of a Faire or of the third part of the profits of the Marshalsey of the third part of the profits of keeping of a Park of the third part of the profits of a Dove-house and likewise of a third part of a Piscary by the third Fish or the third cast of the Net or the third Presentation to an advowson and a Writ of Dower lyeth for the third part of the profits issuing out of the custody of a Goale of the third part of the profits of Courts Fines and Heriots and a woman shall be endowed of tithes and the surest endowment of tithes is of the third sheafe for what Land shall be sowen is uncertaine Exception But in some cases of Lands and Tenements which are divisible and which the heire of the husband shall inherit the wife shall not be endowed as if the husband maketh a Lease for life of certaine Lands reserving a rent to him and his heires and after taketh a wife and dyeth the wife shall not be endowed neither of the reversion because there was no seisin in Deed or in Law of the free-hold or the rent because the husband had but a particular estate therein and no Fee-simple Coke com f. 32. a. vide ibidem plura Impossibile est unum corpus in duobus locis esse simul it is impossible for one body to be at two places at one and the same time Pop. Rep. 58. 3. 4. Eliz. As if a man make a lease of two Barnes rendring rent and for default of payment a re-entry if the tenant be at one of the Barnes to pay the rent and the Lessor at the other to demand the rent and no body be there to pay it yet the Lessor cannot enter for the condition broken because there was no default of the tenant he being at one Barne for it was not possible for him to be in two places together and Popbam Walmestâ— and Fenner said that also perhaps that the tenant had not money sufficient to pay it at either of the places but it is sufficient for him to have and provide one rent which cannot be at two places together ibidem Jura naturalia sunt immutabilia Bracton l. 9. c. 23. Coke l. 7. f. 15. b. The Laws of nature are unalterable as if a man have a ward by reason of a Signiory a signiory and is outlawed he forfeiteth his wardship to the King but if a man have the ward-ship of his own son or daughter which is heire apparent and is outlawed he doth not forfeit this ward-ship for nature hath annexed it to the person of the father 33. H. 6. 55. In the same manner maris faminae conjunctio est de jure naturae the conjunction of a man and a woman is of the law of nature as Bract. l. 1. c. 33. Dr. and Student c. 31. doe hold now if he that is attainted of felony or treason is slaine by one who hath no authority or executed by him who hath authority but pursueth not his warrant in this case his eldest son can have no appeale for he must bring his appeale as heire which being ex provisione hominis he loseth it by the attainder of his father but his wife if any he have shall have an appeal because she is to have her appeale as his wife which she retaineth notwithstanding the attainder because the conjunction of man and woman is by the law of nature and therefore it being to be intended of true and right matrimony is indissoluble and this is proved by the book 33. H. 6. f. 57. So if there bee mother and daughter and the daughter is attainted of felony now cannot she be heire to her mother for the cause aforesaid yet after her attainder if she killeth her mother this is parricide and petit treason for yet she remaineth her daughter for that is of nature All which accord with the rule of the civil law jura sanguinis nullo modo dirimi possunt the lawes of consanguinity and the lawes of blood can no way be broken and therefore the corruption of blood taketh away the privity of the heire which is nomen juris and not the privity of the son which is nomen naturae as if an attainted person be killed by his son this is petty treason for the privity of the son still remaineth but if a man attainted be murdered by a stranger the eldest son shall not have the appeale because the appeale is given to the heire for the youngest sons shall not have it 36. H. 6. 57. 58. 21. E. 3. 17. If the son be attainted and the father covenanteth in consideration of naturall love to stand seised of Land to his use this is a good consideration to raise an use because the privity of naturall affection remaineth So if a man attainted have a Charter of pardon and be returned on a jury betweene his son and I. S. the challenge remaineth for he may maintaine any suit of his son though the blood be corrupted If a villaine be attainted yet the Lord shall have the issues of the villaine borne before or after the attainder for the Lord hath them jure naturae as the increase of a flock Bacons Maxims f. 49. and 50. vide ibidem plura If the father be slaine the son shall have an appeale of it for it is a loss to the son to lose the father and the common law giveth the appeale to the son before any other for the earnest intent of revenge which the law supposeth to be in him against the offender for the killing of him and that the son by presumption had the more great love and affection Ployd ibid. f. 304. b. And from thence Bromly said that it was an ancient usage when a felon was found guilty in an appeale of murder that all those of the blood of him was murdered should draw the felon with a long cord to execution which was grounded upon the loss that all the blood had by the murder of one of them Ployd 406. b. Ed. 6. 3. The father being impleaded made a feoffment to his eldest son and heire apparent hanging the suit and the King brought a writ of Champerty against the father and son and by the opinion of most the action was not maintainable because by any law the son is to aide the father and
so long as he hath no understanding Lastly he that by his own vicious act for a time depriveth himselfe of his memory and understanding as he is that is drunk Coke com 147. a. Coke l. 4. 124. b. And for the three first sorts of mad men the Law is that they shall not lose their lives for felony or murder because they want reason and understand not what they doe neither can the punishment of a mad man who is deprived of reason and understanding be an example to others And therefore as Ployd f. 19. a. If a man of non sanae memoriae kill another although he hath broken the words of the Law yet he hath not broken the Law because he had not any memory nor understanding but meere ignorance which cometh unto him by the hand of God and therefore it is called unvoluntary ignorance to which the Law imputeth the act done because no default iâ— in him and therefore he shall be excused in that he is ignorant by compulsion and such an act is called and termed ex ignorantia to wit in that involuntary ignorance is the cause and God provided a speciall remedy that he who doth such a thing by such ignorance shall not be punished for it as Deut. 19. if a laborer be at labor with an hatchet and the head of the hatchet flyeth off and killeth another that such a laborer shall not be put to death because he did it by un-voluntary ignorance but if a man breake the Law by un-voluntary ignorance there he shall not be excused As if at man be drunk and kill another this is Felony and he shall be hanged for it and yet he did this by ignorance for when he was drunk he had neither memory nor understanding but because that ignorance came unto him by his own act and folly and he might resist this ignorance he shall not be priviledged by it because he is voluntarius daemon Coke com f. 247. and as Aristotle saith is worthy of double punishment because he hath dâ—ubly offended to wit in being drunke to the ill example of others and also in doing of the act and this act is called and said to be done ignoranter to wit that he is the cause of his owne ignorance and so there is a diversity of a thing done ex ignorantia ignoranter Ployd ibidem And Coke com f. 247. a. Omne crimen ebrietatis incendit detegit and what hurt or ill soever he doth in his drunkennesse doth aggravate it and that as well in case touching his life his Lands his Goods or any other thing concerneth him Coke l. 4. f. 125. Also for the same reason non compos mentis cannot commit petit treason as if a wife non compos mentis slay her husband as appeareth 12. H. 3. Tit. forfeiture 33. But in some cases non compos mentis may commit high Treason as if he slay or offer to slay the King this is high Treason for the King is caput Reipub the head and safety of the Common-wealth and from the head good health is conveyed to all and for this cause their persons are so sacred that none ought to offer them violence but he shall be reus laesae majestatis guilty of high Treason Coke l. 4. f. 124. b. And likewise for the same reason many are the priviledges which the Law giveth to one who is not compos mentis and his heires as if an idiot or non compos mentis maketh a Feoffment in person and dyeth his heire within age he shall not be in ward and if he dyeth without heire the Land shall not eschcate but if he make a Feoffment by Letter of Attorny although the Feoffor can never avoid it yet as to others in judgment of Law the State was void and therefore in such case if the heir be within age he shall be in ward and if he dyeth without heires the Land shall escheate and that is the true reason of the bookes in 7. H. 4. 5. and 7. H. 4. 12. And so is there a great diversity between an estate made by the person of a mad man and by his Attorny Coke l. 4. 125. Also an idiot in an action brought against him shall appeare in proper person and he that can plead best for him shall be admitted 33. H. 6. 18. otherwise it is of him who becometh non compos mentis for he shall appeare by his guardian if he be within age and by an Attorny if be be of full age Coke ibidem f. 124. b. So if a man of non sanae memoria â—ath cause to enter into tenements and a descent is had in his life during the time he was of non sana memoriae and then dyeth his heire may enter upon him is in by descent Littleton and though Littleton there saith that the Ancestor who had the same title could not enter during his life yet in case of a bar of his right he may As if a man of non compos mentis be disseised and the disseisor levieth a fine in this case at the common Law though the yeare and the day be passed yet he that was non compos mentis shall not be bound by it but that he might well enter Coke l. 4. f. 125. vide ibidem plura But if an Idiot or a non compos mentis by accident or qui lucidis gaudet intervallis maketh a Feoffment in fee he shall in pleading never avoid it by saying that he was an Idiot c. at the time of the Feoffment because it is a maxime in the common Law that no man of full age shall be received in any Plea by the Law to disable himselfe contrary to the opinion of some that he may avoid his own act by Entry or Plea and others that he may avoid it by Writ and not by Plea and others as Fitzherbert in his Writ of dum fuit non compos mentis that he may avoid either by Plea or by Writ but Littleton here is of opinion that neither by Plea Writ or otherwise he himselfe shall avoid it and herewith the greatest authorities of ouâ— Books doe agree and so was it resolved in Beverlyes case Coke l. 4. Though this Maxime holdeth not in criminall causes as before hath been said Coke com f. 247. Yet doth not the Law leave one who is non compos mentis destitute of remedy in this case but that upon an office found for the King the King shall avoid the Feoffment of him who is of non compos mentis for the benefit of him whose custody the Law giveth to the King and all that he hath for the King is bound by the Lawes to defend his Subjects and their Goods and Chattells Lands and Tenements as Fitzherbert saith N. B. 232. and therefore the King of right ought to have and to order him his Lands and Goods and this was by the common Law as appeareth by Britton f. 16. who writ in the fifth yeare of
Act in Law respecteth equity and will never charge any one with more or lesse then in reason and equity it ought For as Bracton saith jus respicit aequum If two four or more being severally seised in land joyn in a Recognizance all their lands must be equally extended An house that hath Copyhold and other lands usually occupyed with it is let for yeares with the lands appertaining yet the Copyholds passe not without speciall naming for then it were a forfeiture of them for the Law construeth all things according to equity and constraineth a generall Act if there be any mischief or inconvenience in it Finch Nomot f. 54. So a Corody granted to one and his Servants to sit at his Messe he cannot bring a Servant that hath some stinking and noisome disease And if Estovers be granted out of a Mannor the Grantee shall not cut down Fruit-trees So a Common granted to one for all his Beasts he shall not have Common for Goats and Geese nor other Beasts not Commonable Finch ibidem It is no Trespasse for a man to beat his Apprentice which is but reasonable correction for equity moderateth the strictnesse of the Law Finch Nomot f. 57. No more is it to carry away a mans Wife against his will to a lawfull end as to sue a divorce against her husband or to have the Peace of him before a Justice of Peace So if the Lessor commeth upon the ground it shall be intended that he came to see if Wast were done for equity turneth all to the best and maketh every Act to be lawfull when it is indifferent whether it be lawfull or not Finch Nomot f. 57. And if the Disseisee come it shall be taken that he meant to be remitted And in an Action of Trespasse if two Issues be joyned triable in two Counties as one in London and another in Middlesex without saying which of the Issues it should try this shall be taken to try the Issue in Middlesex onely for so the Venire facias is lawfull and not in both Counties which is against Law and therefore it is a discontinuance in the City of London and no discontinuance Finch ibidem And such a desire hath the Law to be ruled by equity as that it will feigne a thing in shew and colour whereby the reall right and equity of the thing may more certainly be found according to the ground Lex fingit ubi subsistit aequitas The Law faigneth where equity subsisteth Coke l. 10. f. 90. a. As the reason why the Law will give a colour in a Writ of Entry Sur-disseisin Writ of Entry in nature of Assise Trespass c. is that the Law which preferreth and favoureth certainty as the Mother of quiet and repose to the intent that either the Court shall adjudge upon it if the Plaintiff demurr or that a certaine Issue may be taken upon a certaine point requireth that the Defendant when he pleadeth such a speciall Plea that yet notwithstanding the Plaintiff may have right the Defendant shall give colour to the Plaintiff to the end that the plea shall not amount to the generall issue and so to leave all the matter at large to the Jurors which shall be full of multiplicity and perplexity of matter and though the colour be but a fiction yet the Law feigneth where equity subsisteth So f. 40. a. Common Recoveries are fictions in Law and for the equity that in them is transacted they are not onely allowed by the Common Law for the intended recompence but warranted by statutes for their equitable use And therefore the statute of 7 H. 8. c. 1. reciteth that divers as well Nobles as Commons have suffered Recoveries against them of divers of their Mannors for the performance of their Will for assurance of Joyntures to their Wives c. The same act in approbation of common recoveries giveth remedy to such recoveries in divers cases And in Dr. Student c. 26. it is determined that common recoveries do bind as well in conscience as in Law for semper in fictione legis subsistit aequitas And by the statute of 23 Eliz. c. 4. it is provided that for the avoiding of danger to common assurances in lands and for the advancement of common recoveries that not any common recovery shall be avoided by any want of form in words and not in matter of substance vide ibidem plura in Mary Portingtons case So Co. l. 11. f. 51. a. If one disseise me and during the Disseisin he cutteth down Trees Grass or the Corn and then I re-enter I shall have an Action of Trespasse against him vi armis for the Trees Grass and Corn for after my regresse the Law as to the Disseisor and his Servants supposeth that the Frank-tenement hath alwaies continued in me but if my Disseisor make a Feoffment in fee gift in tail lease for life or yeares and after I re-enter I shall not have trespasse vi armis against them who come in by Title for this fiction in Law that the Frank-tenement hath continued alwaies in me shall not have relation to make him that cometh in by Title to be a wrong doer vi armis for in a fiction of Law alwaies equity existeth vide ibidem plura And by these cases it appeareth that equity hath a vigorous use in the exposition of the Common Law But this bright Star more cleerly shineth and sheweth forth its lustre in the construction of Statutes for as Co. Comm. f. 24. b. equity is a construction made by the Judges what cases out of the letter of the Statute yet being within the same mischief or cause of the making of the same shall be within the same remedy that the statute provideth and the reason hereof is for that Law-makers could not possibly set down all cases in expresse termes and Co. Com. f. 271. b. when Lands and Tenements are conveyed upon confidences uses and trusts if any question groweth upon them they are to be ruled and decided by the Judges of the Law for they are within the intendment and construction of the Lawes of the Realm Rhet. l. 1. c. 3. And therefore Aristotle well adviseth Legislators and Makers of Lawes 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 to design and determine of things and to leave as little as may be to the descretion of the Judges But as Co. lib. 6 f. 40. b. Rerum progressus ostendâ—nt multa quae initio praecaveri provideri non possint The progresse and proceeding of things do declare and shew many things which at the beginning could not be heeded or provided for and therefore is equity required to replenish and fill up those chincks and deserts which seem to be in the letter of the Law which is therefore accordingly thus defined Aequitas est verborum legis directio sufficiens cum una res solummodo cavetur verbis ut omnis alia in aequali genere iisdem caveatur verbis Equity is a sufficient direction of the words
of the Law when one thing is provided for in the words that every other thing in the like kind shall be provided for in the same words And so when the words of a Statute enact one thing they enact all other things which are in the semblable degree As whereas the Statute of 9 E. 3. c 31. ordaineth that in an Action of Debt against Executors he that commeth in by distresse shall answer the said Act shall be extended by equity to Administrators for whosoever of them commeth in first by distress shall answer by the equity of the said Act because they are in the like degree So the Statute of 4 H. 4. c. 8. giveth an especiall Assise to him who is disseised and ousted of his land by force against the Disseisor and it is enacted that he shall recover against him double damages And so it is in an Assise of Nusance to turn the course of the water from the Mills of the Plaintiff with force it was adjudged that he should recover double damages and yet he was not put out of his land neither was there a disseisin but the Nusance was to the damage of his Frank-tenement and so by the equity of the said act the Plaintiff recovered double damages because the Nusance was in the like kind So the Statute of Gleucester giveth an Action of Wast c. against him who holdeth for life or for yeares and by the equity of it a man shall have an action of Wast against him who holdeth for a yeare or for twenty weeks and yet it is out of the words of the act because it is in the like degree and the cases which are of such degree in our Law are infinite Ployd f. 165. a. And there is another sort of equity which abridgeth and taketh from the letter and is a correction of the generall words Ethie 30. l. 10. and is defined by Aristotle to be 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 a correction of a Law wherein it is any way wanting because of the generality of it which also in our Law is of much use As when an act of Parliament is made that whosoever shall do such an act shall be a Felon and be put to death and yet a man non sarae memoriae or an Infant of tender age who hath no discretion doth it they shall not be Felons c. or if a Statute be made that all persons who shall receive or give meat or drink or other aid to one who shall do a felonious act shall be accessory to the Offence and be put to death yet if one doth such an act and commeth to his wife who knowing it receiveth him and giveth meat and drink unto him she shall not be accessory nor Felon for in the generality of the said words of the Law he of non sanae memoriae nor Infant nor a Wife shall not be included and so equity correcteth the generality of the Law in those cases and the words generall are by equity abridged so the Statute of Champerty W. 2. l. 49. Arti. super Chart. contra probatos men generally do receive Lands and Tenements while the thing is in plea yet M. 16. R. 2. accord it was said by the whole Court in a Writ of Champerty that if I bargaine any lands before any Writ brought and after the Writ purchased I deliver Seisin That the Writ of Champerty doth not lye because it shall not be intended that the Bargain was made for such cause and that by equity for when he bargained and promised the land upon just consideration before any action brought against him it was his act to perform it notwithstanding the action And Costle promoter of the King brought an action of Extortion H. 21. H. 7. 16. against an under-Sheriff grounded upon the Statute of 23 H. 6. c. 10. which ordaineth that neither the Sheriff Goaler or Ministers nor any of them by colour of their Office shall take any thing profit c. of any person for fine fee or ease of prison but for the Sheriff 20 d. the Bayliff 4 d. and the Goaler 4 d. supposing that he had taken 20 d. above the same limited upon the Statute and upon demurrer it appeared upon evidence to the Court that all under Sherifs of the same county have used from the time whereof memory doth not run to have of every prisoner in their ward for suspition of Felony when they are acquitted twenty pence called the Bar fee and the twenty pence supposed to be taken were taken from the person named in the count being acquitted for a Bar-fee and the opinion of the whole Court was that it was out of the raise of the Statute though it was within the words of the Statute for that the sum of a Bar-fee was assigned to the Sheriff at the beginning by the order and discretion of the Court in respect of his labour and charge he had with the prisoners and for his attendance and for his ministry when the prisoners are brought to their delivery and so that payment was with reason and good conscience which the intent of the makers of the act was not to take away and so equity did put an exception to the generality of that text of the Statute Law So the Statute of W. 2. c. 4. ordaineth that where a man rat or dog escapeth alive out of a Ship neither the Ship nor any thing that is within it shall be adjudged wrack but all the things shall be saved and kept by the view of the Sheriff c. in the hands of those of the Towne where the things were found so that if any one can prove that they are his within a yeare and a day they shall be restored to him and whosoever doth otherwise shall be awarded to prison and remaine at the will of the King and render damages yet if the goods within the Ship be such things as will not endure for a yeare and a day the Sheriff may sell them and deliver the mony taken for them to the Towne to answer for it and that by equity though it be against the words of the said Act. So the Act of 2. E. 6. c. 14. Which giveth to the King all Lands and Tenements by any assurance conveyance given assigned or limited to find any preacher to have continuance for ever c. if the words of that act should be taken generally they give to the King al the houses and glebe Lands of all Parsons and Vicars but equity putteth in that text the exception of Parsonages and Vicarages because it was not the intention of the makers of that Act Ployd f. 466. vide ibidem plura There is another excellent use of equity which consisteth in guiding the grounds and maxims of of things which seem to crosse and thwart one another for as Sir John Doderidge English Lawyer f. 209. it is scarcely possible to make any second rule of Law but that it shall faile in some particular
stranger tendreth them mony for the Land and they intending to sell it more deere defer the sale for two yeares and take the profits themselves the heire for the laches and long delay may enter and put them out of the Land 38. Ass Pl. 3. 39. Ass Pl. 3. A man indebted by specialty or upon an account determined tendreth the mony to the Debtee after the day in which it was due and payable and it is refused and after mony is embased it seemeth to many that the debtor shall beare the losse although he had made tender at the very day of payment because he must say vncor prist Dyer f. 83. Pl. 76. Caveat Emptor Coke Com. f. 102. a. Let the the buyer be vigilant and wary what he buyeth for though by the Civill Law every man is bound to warrant the thing that he selleth and conveyeth yet the Common Law bindeth him nor unlesse there be a warranty either in Deed or in Law Ibi. Coke l. 4. f. 26. a. A Copy-holder who is out of possession ought not to sell his Land untill he hath gained the possession and if any one will purchase any title he is not to be favored but in such case Caveat Emptor let the buyer take heed for if any one hath a pretended right and title to Copy-hold Land bargaine and sell it to another it is within the Statute of 32. H. 8. c. 5. vide ibidem plura If I take an horse of another mans and sell him and the owner taketh him againe I may have an action of debt for the mony for the bargaine was perfect by the delivery of the horse Caveat Emptor Nay Max f. 94. If I sell my Horse to another man for ten hundred pounds who taketh his horse againe I shall have all the mony Ibidem f. 95. Qui timent caveant vitent Offi. of Exe. 251. They who feare are wary to shun dangers as an Executors office is dangerous and therefore ought to feare what encombrances fall on him and to keep goods to pay all debts if any should be concealed Non temere credere nervus est sapientiae Coke l. 5. f. 114. b. Not hastely to beleive is the sinew of wisdome and therefore the Law hath appointed the last time in the day to pay mony upon a condition that both parties may certainly meet together which is founded on the experience of the sages least any of the parties should be constrained to make a Letter of Attorny or repose confidence or trust in any other to pay it for him when he will doe it for himselfe And it is wisdome not rashly to trust any Caveat actor Reg. I. C. Let the actor beware what he doth One entreth into Bond to A. that he and A. shall stand to the Arbitrement of I. S. If A. refuse he him-himselfe shall take the forfeiture of the Bond. If a man have a Chappell which is his donation by Letters Patents and he presenteth me his clerk to the Ordinary he shal not make collation afterwards If a Parson impropriate presenteth one to a Church it maketh it disappropriate If he who holdeth his Land by homage and fealty taketh his Land of the King by office found that he holdeth it by forty shillings per annum he shall pay the rent hereafter Abundans cautela non nocet Coke l. 11 f. 6. b. An abundance of circumspection doth not hurt vide ibi Qui sentit onus sentire debet commodum Coke l. 1. f. 99. a. He who beareth the burden and taketh the paines ought to receive the profit as if a Feoffment be upon condition that if the Feoffor or his Heirs pay the sum of 20 l. or to doe any act before a certain day that they shall re-enter in this case if the father dye before the day of paymenr and the daughter for the safe-gard of the inheritance pay the mony or satisfieth the condition in this case the Son after borne shall not devest it for if the daughter had not performed the condition the Land had been utterly lost and therefore in this case a good argument may be made that the daughter shall detaine the Land for Qui sentit onus sentire debet Commodum ibidem vide Hobart Rrep fo 4. in Youngs and Radfords case Ployd f. 514. Trevilian was Tenant in tail of Tenements and he being only seised of such an estate a common recovery was had against him and Avice his wife who vouched over according to the course of common recoveries and it was found that the wife had nothing in the Tenements the husband dyeth the wife shall have nothing of the intended recompence in the case because she had nothing in the Tenements and so could lose nothing If Tenant for life or in Dower do devise the Corn growing on the ground upon the land at the time of their death this is a good Devise and he in the reversion shall not have it 4 H. 3. Devise 26. And the Statute of Merton which saith Omnes viduae possunt legare sua blada is but an affirmation of the common Law which was used in the time of H. 3. 19 H. 6. 6. A man seised of land in see in right of his wife leaseth the land to a stranger and the Lessee soweth the land and after the wife dyeth the Corn being not ripe the Lessee may devise the corn and yet his estate is determined 7 E. 3. 67. A man seised of land in the right of his wife and soweth it and deviseth the Corn growing on the ground and dyeth before it is severed the Devisee shall have it and not the wife 7. Ass pl. 19. One seised of lands in fee hath Issue a Daughter and dyeth his wife Privement Ensaint with a Son the Daughter entereth and soweth the land and before the severance a Son is born and his next friend entereth yet the Daughter may devise the Corn growing on the land If a Mannor be put in execution upon a Statute-merchant and the Conusee sow the land he may well devise the Corn growing on the ground Perkins f. 100. vide ibidem plura Qui sentit commodum sentire debet onus Cok. l. 5. f. 24. He that feeleth or reapeth the profit must bear the burthen and the charges A man leaseth an house by Indenture for years and the Lessee covenanteth for him and his Executors to repaire the house at all times necessary The Lessee assigneth it over to H. who suffereth it to decay the Lessee bringeth an action of Covenant against the Assignee and it was adjudged the action did lye in that the Lessee had taken upon him to bear the charges of reparation the annuall rent was the less which trenched to the benefit of the Assignee and he that enjoyeth the profit must bear the burthen and charges vide ibidem plura Co. l. 5. f. 100. a. The Statutes will have all those which are in perill and which are to take comodity by the
Quare Impedit 54. but at this day it is remedied by the act 1 E. 3 c. 12. by which it is declared that because that many people may be grieved for it that Lands and Tenements held in chief of the King as all those which hold by grand Serjanty are and alien without leave have been held as forfeited hereafter in such case let a reasonable fine be taken So since that Statute at all times when Lands holden by grand Serjanty have been aliened without licence a fine hath been taken and no seisure ever made for the forfeiture and therefore no forfeiture to be taken for Custome is the best Interpreter of the Law vide etiam L. 10. f. 70. b. Consuctudo manerii est observanda Co. com f. 63. a. consuetudo loci est observanda Brac. l. 2. f. 76. l. 4. f. 28. The custome of the Mannor and the custome of the place is to be observed for there are different customes in many Mannors and places and the customes of one Mannor in some particulars commonly varieth from another And these diversities of customes have grown by reason of the severall Nations who have had government over this Kingdome Britans Romans Saxons Danes Normans which have left part of their Language and part of their usage which difference of usage and custome is to be observed in every place and Mannor for what a Copyholder may or ought to do or not to do the custome of the Mannor must direct it and if there be no custome to the contrary wast either premissive or voluntary of a Copyholder is a forfeiture of his Copyhold Co com f. 63. a. If a Copyholder for life surrender to another in fee it is no forfeiture for that passeth by surrender to the Lord and not by Livery And Copyhold Estates shall not have the collaterall qualities that the estates of the common Law have without especiall custome for the custome of the Mannor is to be observed Coke l. 1. f. 22. a. 23. a. vide ibidem plura f. 28. b. Coke l. 6. f. 67. a. In a common recovery which is had by agreement and consent of parties of acres of land the acres shall be accounted according to the customable and usuall measure of the Country and not according to the Statute De terris mensurandis made in the 33 of Ed. 1. Sir John Buntings case 1 Eliz. So if a man bargain and sell so many acres of wood they shall be measured according to the usage of the Country and that is according to twenty foot to the Rod and not according to the said act for the custome of tho place is to be observed 47 E. 3. 18. Coke l 10. 140. a in Kighleys case It was resolved cleerly that the severall Commissioners of Sewers throughout England are not bound to pursue the Lawes and Customes of Romney Marsh but in case where any particular place within their Commission have such Lawes and Customes as Romney Marsh hath there they may pursue them for the custome of the place is to be observed Consuetudo vincit communem legem coke l. 4. f. 21. Custome overcometh and mastereth the common Law and will not alwaies be ruled by its grounds for a custome and usage of time whereof the memory of man runneth not to the contrary may create and consolidate Inheritances Coke comm f. 185. b. If a man be seised of an house and possessed of divers Heir Looms that by custome have gone with the house from Heir to Heir and by his Will deviseth away the Heir-looms this devise is void for the Wil taketh effect after his death and by his death the Heir looms by ancient custome are vested in the Heir and the Law preferreth the custome before the devise 1 H 5 Executors 108. And so it is if the Lord ought to have an Heriot when his Tenant dieth and the Tenant deviseth all his goods yet the Lord â—â—all have his Heriot for the reason aforesaid And it hath been anciently said that an Heriot shall be paid before a Mortuary wherein the Lord is preferred because the Tenure is in him Co. ibidem Ployd f. 36. b. Whereas the Statute of 1 R. 2. c. 12. doth ordain that the Warden of the Fleet shall not suffer any one who is in execution to go out of Prison by main-prize bail or baston yet it is taken by equity of the said Statute thâ—t if any other Goaler who lets such a one in execution to go out of prison with mainprize bail or baston that it shall be said to be an escape But notwithstanding that it extendeth to all other Goalers so fully as though it had been expressed by plain words yet those of London use to let such go at large with baston in any place within their jurisdiction and shall not be judged an escape in them and the reason of that is not because the statute in equity doth not extend to them but the reason of it is their prescription in that point and all their customes and prescriptions are confirmed by the Statutes by which they may prescribe against the equity and words of the statute which are contrary to their customs and prescriptions as against the statute of Silva caedua and to hold Leet at other times then the statute appointeth and such others ibidem Obtemporandum est rationabili consuetudini tanquam legi coke l. 4. 38. b. Littleton Sect. 170. consuetudo ex certa causa ratienabili usitata privat communem legem We ought to obey a reasonable custom as a Law and a custom used upon a certain reasonable cause depriveth or over cometh the common Law but a custome introduced against reason is rather an usurpation then a custome coke comm f. 113. a. and it is a Maxime in our Law that all customs and prescriptions which be against reason are void coke comm f. 140. a. As if the Lord of a Mannor prescribe a custome in generall that every Tenant in his Mannor that marrieth his Daughter to any man without the licence of the Lord shall pay a fine and have paid a fine to the Lord for the time being this prescription is void for none in such case ought to pay fines but Villains vide ibidem plura So if the Lord of a Mannor do prescribe that for the time being he hath used to distraine Cattell were upon the demeans of his Mannor for Damage-feasant and the distresse to retain till fine were to him for damages at his will this prescription is void for it is a Maxime in Law Aliquis non potest esse judex in propria causa no man can be a Judge in his own case ibidem 141. a. And therefore a Fine levied before the Bayliffs of Salop was reversed because one of the Bayliffs was a party to the fine because he cannot be a Judge and a party coke ibidem So a custome that the Lord shall take for Heriot the beast of a stranger levant and couchant upon the
within a Mannor time out of minde of man used was to grant parcell of the said Mannar in Fee-simple and never any grant was made to the heir of his body for life or for yeares and the Lord of the said Mannor did grant to one by copy for life the remainder over to another and the heires of his body and was adjudged that the grant and remainder over was good because the Lord having a custome and interest withal might grant a lesser estate for in this custome which enableth him to doe the greater enableth him to doe the lesse Coke com f. 52. b. for omne majus continet in se minns and regularly it is true that where a man doth that which he ought to doe and more there it is good for that which is warranted and void for the rest Coke com 258. a. As if a Letter of Attorney be made to I. S. to make livery of seisin in white acre and he maketh livery in white acre and black acre there he doth idem aliud and therefore it is good for white acre that is according to his authority and void for black acre which is aliud from his authority Perk. 38. But otherwise it had been if the Letter of Attorny were to make livery of one acre and he maketh livery of two acres there it is void for both because it is not named in certaine in the Feoffment of which acre livery shall be made according to 4. H. 7. And so regularly it is true that where a man doth the same thing he is authorized to doe alio modo in another manner then the authority doth warrant there it is void for the whole Davis in case of tenures f. 21. As if I command a man to make a Feoffment in my name according to a copy shewed in Latine and he maketh a Feoffment to the same effect in English it is without warrant because he doth not pursue the authority in the same Mannor 10. H. 7. 9. So a Letter of Attorney is made to deliver seisin after the death of I. S. and the Attorney maketh seisin during the life of I. S. all is void 40. Ass 38. Authorities by Deed are to be pursued strictly and precisely both for matter and manner Davis ibidem f. 17. The Plaintiff did make a charter of Feoffment to the tenant and a Letter of Attorny to deliver livery of seisin the Attorney delivereth seisin upon condition this livery is void for the authority is not pursued in the same manner 12. Ass 24. 26. So on the contrary if the Letter of Attorney had been to deliver seisin upon condition and the Attorney maketh livery without condition this is void Co. Just 258. 11. H. 4. 3. So where an authority is given to enfeoff and he levieth a fine 10. H 7. 15. It is void Omne mandatum est temporaneum Reg. I. C. all commands are temporary and are extinguished by death which is the difference that the Civilians put between an authority and a command and that the commande is determined by the death of him that commandeth but not the authority as by these verses is signified Praeceptum non pracipitat mors praecipientis Mandatum mandatore cadente cadit But some hold opinion that they both expire by the death of him that commandeth or giveth authority which Fulbech saith is more agreeable to our Law especially in matters of Bailship of which notwithstanding these diversities may be observed A man deviseth all his lands to his Sister except one Mannor which he appointeth to pay his debts and he made two Executors and dieth the one Executor dieth yet the other may sell the Mannor and pay his debts Dyer 371. But if a Letter of Attorney be made to deliver Livery of Seisin after the death of the Feoffor the Letter of Attorney is void Coke com f. 52. b. And if a Mayor and Comminalty maketh a Charter of Feoffment and a Letter of Attorney to deliver Seisin the Livery and Seisin is good after the death of the Mayor because the Corporation dieth not But if the Lessor by his Deed licence the Lessee for life or for years to alien and the Lessor dieth before the Lessee doth alien yet is death no countermand of the licence but that he may alien for this licence was executed on the part of the lessor as much as may be M. 3. Jac. c. 23. And so if the King doth licence to alien in Mortmain and dieth the Licence may be executed afterward Coke ibidem There is a diversity between authorities created by the party for private uses and an authority created by Law for execution of Iustice As for example if a man deviseth that his two Executors shall sell his land if one of them dyes the Survivor shal not sell it but if he had devised his lands to his Executors to be sold there the Survivor shall sell it coke com f. 181. b. And if a man make a Letter of Attorney to two to do any Act if one of them dye the Survivor shall not do it But if a Venire facias be made to foure Coroners to impanell and return a Iury and one of them dye yet the other shall execute and return the same vide ibidem plura And if there be two joynt Attorneys to return Livery for another and livery of Seisin is made to one of them in the name of both this is void unless the Warrant be joyntly and severally Coke com f. 49. l. vide ibidem plura Mandata licita strictam recipiunt interpretationem sed illicita latam extensam Bacon Max. 60. lawfull Commands receive a strict interpretation but unlawfull large and extensive In committing of lawfull authority to another a man may limit it as strictly as he pleaseth and if the party authorised do transgress his authority though it be in circumstance expressed it shall be in most cases void in the whole act as hath before been demonstrated and distinguished But when a man is the Author and advisor to another to commit any unlawfull act then he shall not excuse himself by circumstances pursued Therefore if I make a Letter of Attorney to I. S. to deliver Livery and Seisin in the capitall Messuage and he doth it in another place of the land or between the hours of two and three and he doth it after or before in these cases the act of the Attorney as to execute the estate is void Or if I express the Seisin to be delivered to I.D. and my Attorney deliver it to I.B. it is void but if my Attorney maketh it to his Attorney it shall be intended for it is a Livery to him in Law But on the other side if I command I. S. to rob I. D. on Shooters-hill and he doth it on Gads-hill or to rob him such a day and he doth it not himself but procureth another to do it or to kill by poyson and he doth it by violence in all these cases he
affectum tribuit delinquendi minatur innocentes qui parcit nocentibus Coke l. 4. f. 45. a. Evil doings ought not to go unpunished because impunity ministreth a continuall affection of offending and he threatneth the innocent who spareth the Delinquent And Aristotle Pol. 7. Actiones justitiae sunt necessariae in civitate licet non eligibiles Though the actions of Justice that is the sentences and punishments of evill and condemned persons are not secundum se of their own nature eligible yet are they necessary in a City that the City may be the better ruled and saved for as Solon there are two things and tyes by which a Common-wealth is contained and preserved praemium poena reward and punishment and it is truly said Etsi meliores sunt quos ducit amor tamen plures sunt quos corrigit timor Thoughâ— they be the better persons whom the Love of goodness vertue draweth yet there are more whom the fear of punishment doth deter and correct and therefore the wisdome of our Law doth abhor that greater offences should pass unpunished So as that if a man be convict either of verdict or by confession upon an insufficient Indictment and no Judgment upon it given he may again be indicted and arraigned because his life was never in jeopardy and the Law wanteth his end which provideth that no evill Deeds should pass unpunished Coke l. 4. f. 45. a. for as Coke saith l. 5. f. 53 b. Oderunt peccare mali formidine penae The wicked to offend themselves refrain And from the same are scar'd for feare of pain And therefore by the Common Law is the offence of felony so severely punished and though the Judgment against such a Malefactor in that he shal be hanged by the neck untill he be dead yet implicitively he is punished First in his wife that she shall lose her Dower Secondly in his Children that they shall become base and ignoble Thirdly that he shall lose his Posterity for his blood is stained and corrupted that they cannot inherit to him or to any other Ancestor Fourthly that he shall forfeit all his Lands and Tenements which he hath in fee or in tail or for term of his life And fifthly all his Goods and Chattels And the reason was that men should fear to commit Feloâ—y ut poena ad paucos metus ad omnes perveniat that the punishment might be inflicted on few and the feare may come to all But some Acts of Parliament have altered the common Law in some of these points as by the Statute De donis conditionalibus lands in tail were not forfeited neither for Felony nor for Treason but for the life of Tenant in tail And this Law continued in force from the thirteenth year of Edward the first untill the twenty sixth year of Henry the eighth when by Act of Parliament Estates in tail are forfeited by attainder of high Treason but as for Felons the Statute De donis Conditionalibus doth still remain in force so as for attainder of Felony Lands and Tenements in tail are not forfeited but onely during the life of Tenant in tail but the Inheritance is preserved for the Issues but being attainted of high Treason or Petit treason the wife shall not be received to demand her Dower but in certain cases specially provided for Ployd f. 195. Coke com f. 392. a. b. And now the wife of a person attainted of misprision of Treason Murthâ—r or Felony is dowable by the Statute of 5 E. 6. c. 〈◊〉 c. in that case made and provided which is more favourable to the women then the Common Law was Coke ibidem Receditur a placitis Juris potius quam injuâ—iae delicta maneant impunita Bac. Max. f. 51. The Law will dispence with some grounds of the Law rather then crimes and wrongs should be unpunished quia salus populi suprema lex the safety of the people is the supream Law and the safety of the people is contained in the repressing of offences by punishment It is a positive ground that the accessory in Felony cannot be proceeded against untill the principall be tried yet if a man by subtility and malice set a mad man by some device to kill one and he doth so now forasmuch as the mad man is excused because he cannot have any will or malice the Law accounteth the Incitor as principall though he be absent rather then the Crime shall go unpunished 13 Eliz 1. So it is a ground in the Law that the appeal of Murther goeth not to the Heire where the party murthered hath a wife nor the younger brother where there is an elder yet if the wife murther the husband because she is the party Offendor the appeal leapeth over to the heire and so if the Son and Heir murther his Father it goeth to the second brother Ed. 4 M 28. 6. Stanf. l. 2 f. 60. But if the Rule be one of the higher sort of Maximes that are regulae rationales and not positivae then the Law will endure rather a particular Offence to escape without punishment then violate such a Rule As it is a Rule that penall Statutes shall not be taken by equity And the Statute of 1 E. 6. enacteth that those that are attainted for stealing of Horses shall not have their Clergy The Judge conceived that this should not extend to him that should steal but one horse and therefore procured a new act for it in 2 E. 6. c. 33. for it is not like the case upon the Statute of Gloucester that gâ—â—â—â—h an action of waste against him for term of life or years and yet if a man hold for a year he is within the Statute for penall Lawes are taken strictly and litterally onely in the point of defining and setting down the fact and punishment and in those clauses that concern them and not in generall words which are but circumstances and conveyances in the putting of the case and so note the diversity for if the Law be that for such an offence a man shall lose his right hand and the Offendor hath his right hand cut off in the Wars he shall not lose his left hand but the crime shall rather pass unpunished vide ibidem plura Nemo punitur pro alieno delicto Coke com f. 145. b. No man is punished for another mans fault And therefore the Defendant in a Replevin cannot claim property by his Bayliff or Servant and the reason is for that if the claim fall out to be false he shall be fined for his contempt which the Lord cannot be unless he maketh claim himself for no man shall be punished for anothers fault Dyer f. 66. pl. 14. It is the Law of God that every one shall bear his own burthen and receive judgment according to his proper fact and merit whether it be good or evill As whereas the Plaintiff chargeth the Defendants with an escape made and suffered by them they ought not to accuse
corrodit vistera textus a viperous exposition which should tear the bowels of the Text ibidem Coke l. 8. f. 1. 7. a. b. The better Expositors of all Letters Patents and Acts of Parliaments are the Letters Patents and Acts of Parliament themselves by construction and conference of all the parts of them together for optima Statuti interpretatrix est omnibus particulis ejusdem inspectis ipsum Statutum Injustum est nisi tota lege inspecta una aliqua particula proposita judicare vel respondere The best expounder of a statute is the statute it self all the parts of the same being looked into and it is an unjust thing One particular being propounded to judge and answer unless the whole Law be looked into ibidem in Dr. Bonhams case Coke l. 10. f. 24. b The better exposition of the Charter of the King is upon consideration of all the Charter to expound the Charter by the Charter it self and the Letters Patents in this case are the bowels of the Text and therefore all the parts of the Letters Patents should be considered and every part of it explained according to the true and genuine sense for verba chartae regi aeque portant suam expositionem For the words of the Kings Charter do equally carry their own exposition ibid. Divinatio non interpretatio est quae omnino recedit a littera Bac Max. f. 16. It is a divination and not an interpretation which leaveth the Letter As if I have a fee-farm Rent of ten shillings issuing out of White-acre and I reciting the same reservation do grant to I. S. the rent of five shillings to be received out of the aforesaid rent and out of all my Lands and Tenements in Dale with clause of distress Though there be an Attornment nothing passeth out of my former rent because for that it is against the words and the copulation of the words shew the taking of them in another sense but if I reciting that I seised of such a rent of ten shillings do grant five shillings to be received of the same rent it is good enough without attornment because percipiendum de to be received of may well be taken for parcella de parcell of without violence of the words but if it had been of the aforesaid rent it had been void vide ibidem But as Ployden saith f. 162. Exception Non est regula quin fallit There is no Rule but faileth and as hath been said the more reasonable and equitable rule is alwaies to be preferred when they encounter and meet in opposition as contrary to this is the rule of the Civilians Leges non verbis sed rebus esse impositas And Coke l. 11. 34. b. Qui haeret in littera haeret in cortice Lawes are not imposed upon words but upon things and he that sticketh in the letter sticketh in the bark or outside of the matter and not attaineth to the inside of the sense As by the statute of 27 E. 3. c. 1. It was provided that he that draweth one to the Court of Rome in a plea which was determined in the court of the King or of other things whereof judgment is given in the Court of the King c. to defeat the judgments given in the Court of the King shall have day containing the space of two moneths c. and if they come not within the meane time in proper person they shall be put out of protection c. and the question was moved in 30. E. 3. 11. If the Defendant appeareth pleadeth and be condemned whether he shall have the Judgement of a Praemunire given by the said Act but since in 39. E. 3. f. 7. Iudgement was given against the Bishop of Chicester who appeared although the letter of the Statute is that if they come not at the same day c. they shall be put out of protection and therefore a multo fortiori when the defendant in such case appeareth pleadeth and shall be found guilty he shall have Iudgement upon the said Statute 44. E. 3. 36. and yet it is out of the words of the Act which speake onely of a default for Qui haeret in littera c. So by the Statute of 25. E 3. the killing of his Master is adjudged Treason yet by construction is it extended to his Mistresse as it is holden in 19. H. 6. 47. And whereas by the Statute of 25. H. 8. house burners were deprived of Clergy and in the Statute of 5. 6. E. 6 there was no mention of that offence in particular but onely that the said Statute should stand in force concerning the tryall of offendors in another County yet by another sentence in the said Act that every clause and sentence in the said Act touching Clergy c. shall from henceforth concerning such offences remaine and be in full strength and virtue it was adjudged that the said clause should extend to all the Act of 25. H. 8. because by that construction such an hainous offence should not passe in effect without capitall impunity and that such Malefactors shall not be encouraged to burne not onely Houses but Villages and Cities And it is frequent in our Books that penall Statutes have been taken by intendement beside the letter to the end that they shall take effect according to the expresse intention of the makers of the Act to remedy the mischeife in advancement of Justice and suppression of hainous crimes Coke ibidem vide ibidem plura And though it is a Maxime that penall Lawes are to be taken it may be conceived of such as concerne inferior and not hainous offences Coke Com. 365. b. A man seised of Lands in fee levied a fine to the use of himselfe for life and after to the use of his wife and of the heire males of her body by him begotten for her Joynture und after he and his wife levied a fine and suffered a common recovery the husband and wife dyed and the issue male entered by force of the Statute of 11. H. 7. And it was holden that the entry of the issue male was lawfull and yet this case was out of the letter of the Statute for shee never levied a fine being sole or with any other after taken husband but is by her selfe with the husband that made the loynture but this case being in the same mischeife is therefore within the remedy of the Statute by the intendement of the makers of the same to avoid the dis-inherison of heires who were provided for by the said Ioynture and especially by the husband himselfe that made the Ioynture which as it was said was a stronger case then any set down in the Statute for Qui haeret in littera vide ibidem plura Coke com 241. a. If there be Lord Mesne and Tenant and the Mesne doth grant to the Tenant to acquit him against the Lord and his heires the Lord dyeth his wife hath the signiory assigned to her for the
the poor and the twenty pounds to the Queen and therefore doth the Statute of 3 Jac. c. 4. give a more speedy remedy for the said twelve pence yet shall they not be punished but upon one of them Yet when the latter affirmative Statute is contrary to the precedent Statute in matter the former abrogateth the latter as by the Statute of 33 H 8. c. 23 it is enacted that if any person being examined before the Councell of the King or three of them shall confess any Treason misprision of Treason or Murther or be to them vehemently suspected he shall be tried in any County where the King pleaseth by his Commission and after by the Statute of 1 2 P. M. c. 10. it was enacted That all trialls hereafter to be had for any Treason shall be had according to the course of the Common Law and not otherwise That latter act and though the latter words had not been had abrogated the first because they were contrary in matter But that doth not abrogate the Statute of 34 H. 8. c 2. of the triall of Treasons beyond the Seas notwithstanding the words are in the negative because it was not contrary in matter for it was not triable by the Common Law Dyer 132. Stanf. 89. 90. So the Statute of 1 E. 6. of Chanteries being in the affirmative doth alter the Statute of H. 2. c. 41. which giveth a Cessavit cantaria also in the affirmative for the one is contrary to the other in matter vide plura Coke l. 9. f. 63. a. But whensoever Lawes are contrary in quality that is where the first is a materiall or express affirmative and the latter an express or materiall negative and when the first is a materiall or express negative and latter affirmative there the latter Law doth abrogate the former As the Statute of 5 E. c 4. which prohibiteth every person to use or exercise any craft mystery or occupation unless he hath been an Apprentice for seven years doth alter the Common Law by which any one may in any manner worke in any lawfull Trade without any service precedent for without an Act of Parliament no man can be restrained to worke in any Trade Coke l 11. f. 54. a. in the Taylors of Ipsiches case And to conclude to this Argument with the generall ground given by Sir Edward Coke l. 1. 11. f. 67. a. That for that Acts of Parliament are established with such gravity and wisdome and the universall consent of all the Realme they ought not through any strained construction out of the generall and ambiguous words of a subsequent Act be abrogated as where the Statute of 16. R 23 c. 5. enacteth that all the Lands and Tenements of any one attainted in a Praemunire shall be forfeited to the King in the case of one Prudgion Pasch 21. Eliz. being tenant in taile of certaine Lands and Tenements who was attainted of a Praemunire the question before all the Judges of England was whether the estate taile was a bar or no and it was resolved by all the Justices that those generall words had not repealed the Statute de donis conditionalibus but that onely he shall forfeite them for his life and that the issue in taile should inherit vide ibidem plura Lex non patetur fractiones divisiones Statuum Coke l. 1. f 87. a. The Law will not suffer fractions and divisions of estates As if a man make a lease for life upon condition that if he doth not pay twenty pounds that another shall have the Land that future limitation is void Ployd f. 25. c. M. 18. H. 8. 3. And if after the Statute of 1. R. 3. before the Statute of 27. H. 8. A man had made a Feoffment to the use of one for life or in taile and after to the use of another for life or en-taile and after to the use of another in fee they in the Remainder might not make a Feoffment nor grant their estates by the generall words of that act for then there should be a fraction and division of estates which the Law will not suffer vide ibidem plura in Corbets case Coke l. 3. f. 32. b. If a man be seised of a Mannor to which a Leet waife or stray or any other hereditament which is not of any annuall value is appendant or appurtenant there by a devise of the Mannor with the appurtenances those shall passe as incidents to the Mannor for in that the Statute enableth him by expresse words to devise the Mannor by consequence it enableth him to devise the Mannor with all incidents and appendants to it and it was never the meaning or the intention of the makers of the Statute that when the Devisor hath power to devise the principall that he shall not have power to devise it that was incident and appendant to it but that the Mannor c. shall be dismembred and fractions made of things which by legall prescription have been united and annexed together Ibidem for the Law will not permit such factions in Estates Coke com f. 147. b. If a man hath a rent-charge issuing out of certaine Land and he purchaseth any part of the Land to him and his heires the whole rent-charge is extinct because the rent is entire and against common right and issuing out of every part of the Land and therefore by purchase of part is extinct in the whole and cannot be apportioned Coke com 309. b. If the reversion be granted of three acres and the Lessee agree to the said grant for one acre this is good for all three and so it is of an Attornement in Law if the reversion of three acres be granted and the Lessee surrender one of the Acres to the Grantee this Attornement shall be good for the whole Reversion of the three Acres according to the grant Apices juris non sunt jura Coke com f. 2 83. b. nimia subtilitas reprobatur in Lege Coke l. 4. 4â— b. The Law of England respecteth the effect and substance of the matter and not every nicity of forme or circumstance and too much subtility is reproved in the Law As it was alledged for an exception in the Enditement that the Enditement was taken before I. S. Coronatore in comitatu praedicto and not de comitatu praedicto or comitatus praedicti and every Coroner of one County is a Coroner in every County of England but not of every County but it was not allowed for the Coroner in the County c. shall in all reasonable intendement be taken for the Coroner of the County and so it is used in the Writ de coronatore elegendo ibidem vide plura Coke l. 5. f. 120. 122. It is a rule in Law that Enditements ought to be certaine but there are three manner of certainties the first is to a common intent and that sufficeth in Bars which are to defend the party and excuse him the second is to a generall
seised by word assigned Dower to the Feme which she accepteth yet was it adjudged that that refusall of the estate of inheritance and acceptance of her Dower in pais shall not devest the Frank-tenement out of her So 13 Ric. 2. Joynt-tenancy a Charter of Feoffment was made to foure and seisin delivered to three in the name of all and after the Seisin delivered the fourth commeth and vieweth the Deed and saith by word that he will have nothing in the Land and it was adjudged that that agreement by word in pais shall not devest the Frank-tenement out of him and Thorp 35 Ed. 3. Disclaimor said that in such a case the Tenement remained in all untill a disagreement in Court of Record So if there be Lord and Tenant by Deed enfeoffeth the Lord and a stranger and maketh Livery to the stranger in the name of both if the Lord by word disagreeth to the estate it is nothing worth but if he enter into the Land generally and take the profits that amounteth to an agreement to the Feoffment but if he enter into the Land and distrain for his Seignory that act amounteth to a disagreement of the Feoffment and shall devest the Frank tenement out of him 10 E. 4. 12. by all the Justices But if Lands be given to Baron and Feme and after by the Statute of 32 H 8. the Baron alieneth the Land to the use of him and his heires and after deviseth it to his wife for life the wife enters claiming by word the estate for life this is a good agreement to the estate for life and a good disagreement to the estate of inheritance Dyer 351. b. And if A. maketh an Obligation to B. and deliver it to C. to the use of B. this is presently the Deed of A. But if he offereth it to B and he refuseth it in pais by it the Obligation shall lose his force Dyer 167. The same Law is of the gift of goods and chattels and if the goods be delivered to the use of the Donee the goods were in him presently but he may refuse them in pais and by it the property shall be determined ibidem SECT III INclusio unius est exclusio alterius Coke l. 11. f. 50. a. b The inclusion of one thing is the exclusion of another As when an act of Parliament giveth a power and interest to one certain person by that expresse designation of one all others are excluded although such a statute be in the affirmative As where the statute of 31 E. 3. c. 12. it was provided that error in the Exchequer shall be corrected and amended before the Chancellor and Treasurer and therefore it could not be corrected before any other and the generall Rule is put that when any thing is to be done before any person certain by any statute it cannot be done before any other and yet the statute of 31 E. 3. is in the affirmative Ployd 106. b. in Stradlings case So whereas by the statute of 8 H. 6. c. 9. forcible Entry is designed to the Justice of Peace to make restitution by it others be excluded though the statute be in the affirmative and therefore neither Justices of Oyer or Terminor or of Goal-delivery c. shall do it Dallisan 3 Eliz vide ibid. plura And this is true in all acts which are the introduction of a novel Law as the above said acts are but where acts of Parliaments are no introductions of a new Law it is otherwise So the act of 35 Eliz. doth not exclude those to whom the Forfeitures are limited by the act of 23 Eliz because by it they are not given to a new person but to the same person to wit the Queen and is but an act of addition to give more speedy remedy As the statute of W. 2. c. 9. in a VVrit of Mesne giveth more speedy proces and in the end fore-judger whereas the proces at the Common Law was but Distresse infinite yet the Plaintiff may take which proces he will either at the Common Law or upon the statute because they are both in the affirmative Coke l. 11. f. 64. a. And also in many cases the designation of a novell person in a latter act of Parliament shall not exclude another person that was authorized to do the same thing by an act precedent As by the statute of 8 H. 6. c. 16. after Office found he who found himself grieved might within a moneth after traverse take the Tenements to farm that then the Chancellor Treasurer or other Officer shall demise to him to farm untill c. 13 E. 4. f. 8. and yet by the statute of 1 H. 8. c. 16. he hath liberty by the space of three monthes and after by the statute of 32 H. 8. c. 40. the Master of the Court of Wards by advice of own of his Councell is authorized to make a Lease of Land in VVard or an Ideot And though the latter act design another person yet it is not the first altogether taken away for before any Lease made by the Master of the VVards the Chancellor and Treasurer may do it and so e contrario as Stanf. holdeth Prerog f. 69. a. b. VVhere he maketh mention of this Rule â—eges posteriores priores contrarias abrogant vide ibidem plura Coke com f. 210. a. If the Condition upon a Mortgage be to pay to the Mortgagee or his heires the money and before the day of payment the Mortgagee dyeth the Lessor is not to pay the money to the Executors but to the Heire for in this case designatio unius personae est exclusio alterius Consensus tolliâ— errorem Coke com f. 37. a. Consent taketh away error As Dowment ad ostium Eclesiae ex assensu patris seem to be good albeit the wife be within the age of nine years But without question for the same reason a Joynture made to her under or above the age of nine years is good ibidem Coke com f. 125. b. a. If a Venire facias be awarded to the Coroners where it ought to be to the Sheriff or the Visne cometh out of the wrong place yet by assent of the parties and so entred of Record it shall stand for all consent taketh away error ibidem Coke l. 5. f. 36. b. Dyer 367. in Bainhams case Coke l. 5. f. 40. a. b. in Dormers case A common Recovery is not to be resembled to a judgement or proceeding at the common Law for by usage and custome it is become a common assurance and conveyance of Lands and because it is done by mutuall consent errors are not to be allowed for consensus tollit errorem If the Demandant and Tenant consent that two of the foure in a Writ of Right shall be Esquires where by the Law they ought to be Knights and well because by consent Tryall of Villenage was altered from the naturall tryall by consent Pleader of a Feoffment upon condition without deed and